An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 222–447 of 447. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
Others told us in fact it would happen in the election after the next. If we change the system and let Fianna Fáil back, Fine Gael would get in the election after next.
Comment on this
That was not said or should not have been said on the Third Amendment Bill.
Comment on this
There is another document in which you might be interested. It is "The 1970s with Fine Gael."
Comment on this
I think Senator FitzGerald started off by once again disputing my assertion which I proved that the proposal in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill will do no more in general than make the average rural vote of equal value in elections than the average urban vote. I hope this does not mean I am going to have to deal with this again and actually demonstrate how it is so. Even Senator FitzGerald should agree that the divergence it is proposed to insert into the Constitution through this Bill is a maximum divergence which can only be operated in particular circumstances. It must be quite clear then there will only be a minority of rural constituencies in which the divergence from the national average, in order to take account of such things as county boundaries, will approach this maximum of one-sixth.
It must also be obvious that in view of the requirement to pay the maximum possible regard to county boundaries there will also be some constituencies in which the number of population per Deputy will approach the national average and others in which, possibly, it will be over the national average. It must be clear, then, that the overall divergence from the national average in rural areas will be considerably less than the maximum of one-sixth, which is 16? per cent.
Comment on this
We will come to that and show the Senator's dishonesty, show his complete disregard of what I said and the context in which it was said. I will show the deliberate falsehood that the Senator tried to perpetrate here in regard to the alleged quotation with regard to what I said when dealing with Mayo.
Comment on this
I showed that if you take the percentage of the total population comprised of the electorate in the Dublin and Cork area and in the rest of the country and base representation strictly on parity of population, this will result in a vote in Cork and Dublin areas being 9 per cent more effective in electing a Deputy than a vote in the rest of the country and in view of the fact that, as I have said, it is obvious that the percentage divergence from the national average over the rural areas as a whole will be considerably less than 16?, it must be obvious to anybody that it is reasonably certain that it will do no more than, as I said, make the average rural vote equal to the average urban vote but I never maintained or in any way created the impression that it would make every rural vote equal to every other rural vote or every rural vote equal to every urban vote or every urban vote equal to every other urban vote. This would not be possible, particularly with the guidelines we are proposing to insert into the Constitution.
Comment on this
That would have to be investigated but if the Senators opposite have their way, if Senator Rooney has his way, the vote in Donegal will be 33? per cent less effective than the vote in Dublin North-West.
Comment on this
The Opposition are determined to have a system which will require only 10,206 votes to elect a Deputy in Dublin North-West as against 13,567 to elect a Deputy in Donegal South-West.
Comment on this
The Minister, without interruptions.
Comment on this
As I said, the object of this Bill was to avoid the injustice that had to be perpetrated on the people in many parts of the country as a result of the Fine Gael operation in the High Courts in 1961.
Comment on this
It was not a Fine Gael operation in the High Courts. It was not.
Comment on this
The objective was to avoid that injustice. No more than all the Deputies and Senators that I quoted as objecting to what had to happen in 1961 in demanding that the Constitution should be amended, no more than they at that time went to the trouble of finding out exactly what percentage of people suffered this injustice, I did not do it either.
Comment on this
That is the difference in approach between the ordinary Deputy or Senator and Senator FitzGerald.
Comment on this
The percentage is all that matters to Senator FitzGerald and if it was not a significant percentage that were moved that time and uprooted from their own counties and disfranchised, in the words of Opposition Deputies——
Comment on this
I did not quote any Fianna Fáil views on this. It was the Opposition who described it as savage dismemberment and the disfranchisement of the people concerned. Admittedly, it was not a lot of the people to whom this happened but these people who were uprooted from their own counties and constituencies in which they had voted for a long number of years on this occasion must in many cases now be moved off to somewhere else.
Comment on this
I believe, and every practical politician would agree, that this is undesirable, both from the point of view of the people themselves and from the point of view of their representatives and Party organisations.
Senator FitzGerald went on to allege that I turned down their proposal to avoid the breaching of county boundaries. Of course, that is not a fact. The fact is that their proposal would not provide the same scope to avoid the breaching of county boundaries as the proposal that is in the Bill and since the objective is to do that and since the amount of maximum permissible divergence we are asking is so low by international standards, I did not see any reason whatever for accepting the amendment of Senator FitzGerald.
Comment on this
It would be less satisfactory and, indeed, it would be a more obvious infringement of this alleged principle of absolute equality of every vote.
Comment on this
I have already argued that point with Senator FitzGerald; I have already showed him that the census figures are more reliable——
Comment on this
——and scientifically based and the fact that they are made at five-yearly intervals rather than every year is also an advantage.
Comment on this
I do not agree that it would be more satisfactory to base it on the register of electors rather than on the census figures, as has always been the case.
Comment on this
I did point out that the operation of this small maximum divergence from the national average on the basis of which constituencies have always been revised, that is, on the basis of the population, would not, in fact, result in conferring any differential voting power on the rural vote in general but the present position which the Opposition want to hang on to does, in fact, confer differential voting power on the urban vote in general.
With regard to this question of what I said when I was dealing with Mayo, Senator FitzGerald, I agree, did not appear to be paying any great attention to what I was saying but, apparently, he has gone to the trouble of looking it up and, if so, he must know that when I was dealing with individual counties and constituencies I was dealing with what would happen under the present position, not under the Bill. Senator FitzGerald, deliberately and with the intention of stating something which he knew to be untrue, got up and said that I was proposing to use this Bill for the specific purpose of breaching the boundaries of County Mayo whereas, in fact, I was dealing with what would be the position——
Comment on this
It is certainly not in order for anybody to be speaking when the Chair is endeavouring to speak. I am asking Senator FitzGerald is he making a point of order.
Comment on this
Is the Senator making a point of order?
Comment on this
With the deliberate purpose of saying something he knew to be false, Senator FitzGerald said that I had indicated I intended to use this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill in order to do what the Bill provides cannot be done. Of course, Senator FitzGerald knows that even if I did do that it could be challenged in the courts and shown to be unconstitutional. What I pointed out was that under the present system certain areas in the rural part of the country would have to unjustifiably lose representation and that if the present system was not changed, this representation which is not justified would be allocated to urban areas as against rural areas. I said that in those circumstances if the change we propose is not made—not if the change we propose is made— this Government would certainly try to minimise the number of representatives who would be taken from the rural areas.
Business suspended at 1.5 p.m. and resumed at 2.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I was pointing out that when I was speaking about what would happen in regard to County Mayo on the Second Stage, I was referring to what must happen if present circumstances continued in which such things as county boundaries—which the Opposition are so determined to retain —are irrelevant, circumstances in which representation is to be based closely on the actual population as disclosed in the latest edition of the census and in which county boundaries would not be a relevant consideration and, of course, neither will voters. I said that in these circumstances this Government would obviously be inclined to minimise the loss of overall representation which this requirement would involve for rural Ireland in general and that this operation would inevitably involve the breaching of county boundaries and that the boundary of County Mayo would be so involved but that this would be done under the circumstances in order that the maximum possible utilisation of the population in the rural areas would be ensured so as to avoid the unjust reduction of representation in those areas.
I pointed out that under the present constitutional requirements the Dublin area must get an increase of at least four seats, from the present 34 to 38, although an increase of only two is required by the actual number of voters and that the western area comprising Donegal, the province of Connacht and Clare must get a reduction on the present representation of 33 Deputies to 30, although a reduction of only one from 33 to 32 would be required by the actual number of voters in the area. Senator FitzGerald's approach as he disclosed here today would be further to downgrade the value of rural votes by allotting only 29 seats to the western area of Donegal, province of Connacht and Clare instead of the minimum of 30 to which it would be entitled even under present circumstances. You will get a different solution to the problem if your approach is on the basis on which Senator FitzGerald approached it. What I indicated was that our approach would be to minimise this unjust reduction in rural representation. I am not in the least surprised that the Fine Gael approach should be the opposite as demonstrated by Senator FitzGerald, that is, to maximise the reduction in representation.
It is quite clear—and on the Second Reading I made it clear—that it was under the present circumstances that boundaries have to be breached and that what I was doing when I went through the constituencies was showing what must happen if this Bill, the Third Amendment Bill, is not passed. I must say that I am grateful to Senator FitzGerald for his suggestions and his indications of the manner in which he would propose to deal with the situation——
Comment on this
If he has his way and the Third Amendment Bill is not accepted by the people, these will prove most useful. But we are proposing that in future the Constitution should require that so far as possible county boundaries shall not be breached. The Opposition are determined to retain the present position in which the ruling of the courts is that county boundaries are not relevant. It is natural that I should say that having a greater approximation to equality of votes as between the rural part of the country in general and the urban part in general is inherent in this Bill. This is the position and I showed it to be so.
Senator FitzGerald says that I have accepted that combinations of two counties are an acceptable manner of forming constituencies. Of course I have not accepted any such thing; what I have said is that combinations of two counties have been inevitable since the State was set up and since this ridiculous system of multi-member constituencies was first foisted on the country on the principle, as Fine Gael speakers have pointed out on a number of occasions, of trying it out on the dog. It has been inevitable but I have never said that it was desirable or acceptable to have these combinations of counties.
For instance, I do not, any more than Deputy Oliver Flanagan, consider the present combination of the two large counties of Laois and Offaly to be desirable. I can quite see the difficulty of a Deputy representing these two very large areas and I can see how defective representation is from the point of view of the people, and I can even understand how undesirable Deputy Flanagan considers the situation in which he has to collect votes all over those two large counties in order to bring in Deputy O'Higgins on his back. However, that is a consideration applying more to Deputy Flanagan and probably has something to do with the reason why he supports our proposals.
All I want to say is that although I agree that the joining of Laois and Offaly was inevitably required by the present electoral system for as long as I can remember, and possibly since the foundation of the State, I do not agree that it is an acceptable or a desirable solution and I am perfectly certain that the people of the two counties involved do not consider it desirable either and that they would consider this joining together of these two counties to be ridiculous.
The same applies in regard to Carlow-Kilkenny or Longford-Westmeath and certainly to portion of a county like Wexford being stuck on to the constituency that already comprises the two counties of Carlow and Kilkenny. But, of course, Senator FitzGerald does not see anything undesirable or objectionable in this. In his approach, he would detach Carlow from Kilkenny and add it on to Kildare where, of course, the junction between these two counties will provide only a narrow corridor as distinct from the comparatively extensive border that there is between Carlow and Kilkenny. It was in that context that I referred to the proposed joining of the counties of Monaghan and Cavan as not being a desirable solution of the problem there, even though the Fine Gael spokesman on this matter, Deputy Fitzpatrick, would welcome this because, as he said in the Dáil, it would suit him personally down to the ground.
It was typical of Senator FitzGerald's approach that he should allege that it was because of the fact that there was a certain non-Catholic community in both Cavan and Monaghan that I considered it undesirable that these two counties should be united. He knows that it was not in that context I was speaking at all. I was speaking in the context of the unworkability of very large constituencies and the practical impossibility of the Deputies giving the people the service they required under these circumstances.
I repeat now that it would not be a desirable thing and certainly not an improvement of the present situation to join the two counties of Cavan and Monaghan together in the one constituency. The result of it would be that the people would get bad service from their Deputies, even worse than at present when constituencies are larger than is appropriate. In present circumstances that is one of the things that happen, that the people get a raw deal in so far as representation by their Deputies is concerned.
Since Senator FitzGerald is concerned only with figures, he proposes with equanimity that, instead of the present position in which there are two comparatively large constituencies, constituencies difficult to travel round, in Donegal, the whole of Donegal should become one five-seat constituency, that Cavan and Monaghan should be joined together, and to form a new constituency consisting of the counties of Sligo and parts of——
Comment on this
(Longford): Did he not suggest that Sligo should be joined to Donegal despite the fact that it had not a frontier at all?
Comment on this
He did, but when I gave him a slight lesson in elementary geography he mended his hand here today and suggested that instead we should have a constituency composed of County Sligo, part of the county of Leitrim and part of the county of Donegal. Of course, these things are quite acceptable and reasonable to a person like Senator FitzGerald who deals with figures and figures only but forgets that the figures represent human beings and that those human beings have to be represented by other human beings in the form of Deputies, and that the work at election time has to be done by other human beings who are members of these political party organisations.
These things are irrelevant, according to Senator FitzGerald. All you need is the figures. When I was speaking about this in the Dáil I said all you needed in present circumstances was the figures and a map, but Senator FitzGerald does not even need a map and he is quite prepared to build up constituencies without even taking the care to see that the areas which he proposes to utilise to make up the required population in some constituencies are contiguous to the county to which he proposes to attach them.
In my reply on the Second Stage here, I dealt with each individual constituency. I put on the record of the House the actual figures for these areas. Dealing with each separately, I showed beyond any shadow of doubt that practically every county in the country must be breached in one way or the other unless the amendment being proposed is accepted by the people, must be breached either by the detachment from it of some of its population and its transference to some other county or be breached by the attachment to it of population from some other county. These figures are already on the record of the Seanad, and although I appreciate that Senator FitzGerald's main concern is to try to delay the passage of the Bill, I do not propose to repeat them. I do not think it is necessary.
Comment on this
I have not, of course, got the actual figures Senator FitzGerald gave here today, but I did count the number of counties that would be affected, and they number 20. His approach was to try to apply the principle of the non-breaching of county boundaries which is in the Bill to the present constitutional situation, although he is bitterly opposing the amendment of the Constitution which we are proposing so as to permit these things to be taken into consideration.
Senator FitzGerald was quick to see that a revision under the present interpretation of the Constitution, but also endeavouring to do what the High Court says is not relevant, to avoid county boundaries, would result in a further injustice to his pet aversion, that is, the western area of this country, Donegal, the province of Connacht and the county of Clare. He was quick to see that this would result in a reduction of the representation of that area from 33 to 29 as against 33 to 30 which is all that is inevitable in present circumstances, and as against the reduction from 33 to 32 which is all that would be required on the basis of voters and the present assumed permitted divergence from the national average of 5 per cent. It is of course indicative of the whole approach of his Party. When I describe it as "his Party", I am merely using his own phraseology. Apparently he has assumed some proprietorial rights over the Fine Gael Party. I detected the same attitude in the lower House when on a number of occasions Deputy Fitzpatrick, ex-Senator Fitzpatrick, indicated that he would leave some matters to be dealt with by the experts in the other House.
This is an indication of the Fine Gael Party's whole approach. It is obviously part of the effort that has been decided upon under, I believe, the influence of Senator FitzGerald, to practically eliminate the rural community by rearrangement of the land of Ireland on the basis of farms supporting a minimum of 400 cows each. Apparently the first step is to be a further downgrading of the value of the rural vote. Senator FitzGerald, on the basis of figures, and without any consideration for the needs or the desires of the people, put forward something which anyone could see was completely impracticable in regard to the revision or delineation of the constituencies.
Comment on this
——a much greater number. It ignored, for instance, the existing scheme of the constituencies. It bore no relation to the existing constituencies. Of course anyone with intelligence will admit that it could not possibly avoid the actual dismemberment of counties. If we were to go in to a greater degree for joining together two counties or groups of counties, if we were to go to extremes and go beyond the present maximum of five-seat constituencies, we could probably avoid breaching the county boundaries.
Comment on this
It is nonsense for Senator FitzGerald to say that only a small percentage would be disturbed since what is proposed is a complete recasting of the constituencies.
Comment on this
It ignores the fact that it would be a disadvantage to the people of Donegal to make the whole county one single five-seat constituency. To say that there is nothing involved in changing the county of Carlow from being attached to Kilkenny and attaching it to Kildare——
Comment on this
——well, I would not like to argue on those lines. The only other point made so far was made by my former colleague, Senator Rooney, who apparently alleges that the whole purpose of the Fine Gael approach to the High Court decision and the new revision of the constituencies which had to result in 1961, was to gerrymander the constituency of County Dublin so that in the struggle for the last seat out of the five Deputy Quinlan would be successful at Senator Rooney's expense.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to have it on the brain to such an extent that his name slipped out even in dealing with Dublin.
Comment on this
I would welcome him in County Dublin any time he likes to come. Apparently Senator Rooney is still brooding over the fact that in this thrilling struggle for the last seat in County Dublin, Deputy Clinton emerged the victor. The revision of the constituencies which took place in 1961 was, of course, called for because of the decision of the High Court.
If Senator Rooney would cast his mind back—if he is able to think back further than 1961—he would remember that the 1959 revision of the constituencies which his Party succeeded in having declared to be unconstitutional did in fact take the Ballyfermot area out of the constituency of County Dublin and in the rearrangement that was required by the High Court decision it was apparently found necessary to put Ballyfermot back into County Dublin. Apparently Senator Rooney alleges that not only was my predecessor, Deputy Blaney, so unscrupulous as to gerrymander that area in the interests of the Fianna Fáil Party, but that he also conspired with Deputy Clinton to gerrymander Senator Rooney out of the seat. He went on to imply that the area of Ballyfermot had been lost to Fianna Fáil. He based that on the local elections but Senator Rooney might like to be informed, since he does not appear to know, that neither myself, nor my gracious senior colleague, nor Deputy Foley, contested the local elections. The story will be completely different when we do.
Senator Rooney went on to ask if I could put forward a better scheme of constituencies than Senator FitzGerald. Of course if I could not do that I would resign, but I can do it, and I will, or the Commission will put forward a much better scheme of constituencies.
Comment on this
There will be 144 single-seat constituencies, 144 easily manageable single-seat constituencies, in which it will be a feasible proposition for the elected Deputies effectively to represent their constituents.
Comment on this
We are now dealing with the Schedule. It is difficult to know at what stage one should cease speaking——
Comment on this
——or indeed, whether one should begin to speak. In his performance here today and yesterday and last Friday, the Minister reminds me of the mother who has a troublesome baby she has just got to sleep. She is afraid of the slightest disturbance because the whole thing will start up again. There will be more whinging and the whole business will have to be gone through again until she gets the child settled down and asleep again. If we say anything here——
Comment on this
——that is the slightest bit controversial or with which the Minister does not agree immediately, he goes through the whole rigmarole again and we have to listen to his vapourings and his obsessional preoccupation with what has happened or what might happen. He defends the virtues of Fianna Fáil and pronounces upon the viciousness of Fine Gael and Labour.
Comment on this
There is no difficulty in being relevant, but it is difficult to know what points we should deal with and what points we should not, so as not to start the Minister unwinding again and again.
Comment on this
Could we discipline ourselves to avoid repetition?
Comment on this
I am trying to indicate my difficulty in ensuring that we shall not have further repetition of what the Minister has already repeated ad nauseam. This is the difficulty we are in. I think it is correct to say that the Minister certainly has not been guilty of repetition in this particular matter.
Comment on this
From 1959 or 1961 down to 1968, at no time has the Minister or any of his colleagues in the Government or any of the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party, or county councils, urban councils or any cumainn of Fianna Fáil or cumainn of Fine Gael, or anything else, complained about the 1961 constituencies. I have never heard Ministers get up, when visiting these areas, to declaim against the injustice that had been perpetrated against these people because they had been brought into a constituency that did not form part of their own administrative county.
Comment on this
There has been no indication from any Minister of the Government Party at any time that it was proposed, in the long years from 1961 to 1967, when they established this Constituency Commission, to review the whole of the Constitution. There was not an indication in the world that the people of these areas were suffering from what the Minister talks about, a gross and serious injustice. One would imagine that the presence of a Deputy in a particular area meant that the people, from then on, were happy. Because people had been transferred from one administrative county or joined up from a particular administrative county with another administrative county to form a constituency, one would not imagine they all went around with a sense of gievance wondering when the day of deliverance would come when they would be delivered from the serious and permanent injustice under which they were labouring. Our people are not as mad as that. They do not suffer from that sort of neurotic view of life and politics, as does the Minister. They do not value all that highly their Teachtaí Dála, from whatever Party they come, that they feel they are suffering from a serious injustice. It is just plain nonsense to describe it as an injustice.
The Minister says Senator Rooney, or some of us, cannot go back beyond 1961. Were there great and widespread complaints about the serious injustice that was done in 1935 when county after county was butchered, not because of a decision of the Supreme Court——
Comment on this
The constituencies were butchered in 1935 by Fianna Fáil because they got into power on the promise, among others—which time eventually falsified—that there was no need for more than 100 Deputies in Dáil Éireann and, in order to get only 100 Deputies in Dáil Éireann, it was necessary for them to switch two and three counties and bits of counties together so that there were hardly more than seven or eight counties in the country that did not have bits taken out of or put into them under the 1935 revision of constituencies—and there was no decision of any court on that— and the reason, the lame reason, then given by Deputy Seán Lemass——
Comment on this
It was not done under the compulsion of any court decision. It was done in the interests of expediency and because Fianna Fáil had promised the people they would reduce the number of seats from what it was before then—153 seats—to 100 seats. The best they could do to redeem their promise was to exceed the number of seats by 36 and they produced 136 seats after this butchering of the counties——
Comment on this
I do not know that it mattered a fiddle-de-dee to the people of these constituencies from 1935 to 1947. Two years after that, this operation—and it was a surgical operation—took place. We had a new Constitution. Fianna Fáil soldiered with these constituencies, cut up in the way in which they were, for a further ten years until 1947. They did not bother even with the provisions of the 1937 Constitution, and their then understanding of what those provisions meant, until the High Court declared what they were, what their understanding of what those provisions meant. They left those constituencies from 1937 to 1947 and then they made another change.
What all that adds up to is that, when the Minister and his Party say that an injustice is being done to people because they are taken from their particular county and joined on to another county, they do not mean a word of it, not a single word of it. In any event, there is no truth whatever in it. The people of these counties and constituencies are not as neurotic as the Minister fancies them to be.
The Minister then insists upon the half-truth. He insists upon parading that and on continuing to parade it well knowing—being the expert propagandist that he is—that the half-truth and the half-lie always stick and that it is very difficult to drag down the half-truth. He refers to the case taken by Dr. John O'Donovan on the Constitution in 1961 as being a case that was taken by the Fine Gael Party. That case was not taken by the Fine Gael Party or with any funds supplied by the Fine Gael Party. The costs of that action were borne entirely by Dr. John O'Donovan. Anybody who wants to ascertain whether or not that is so can find out from him. I know it to be so. Being a junior counsel in that case, I was paid my fees by Dr. John O'Donovan. Not one halfpenny was paid by the Fine Gael Party for the prosecution of that case. The Minister will still continue to say, in spite of my clear declaration as to what happened, that that case was brought by the Fine Gael Party—I do not say that, if they had wanted to bring it, they were not justified in doing so.
Comment on this
(Longford): Did Fine Gael not repudiate it?
Comment on this
Why? Dr. John O'Donovan availed himself of the right, which every citizen of this country enjoys, to go into court——
Comment on this
(Longford):——as a member of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
——being then a member of the Fine Gael Party. However, whether a person is a member of the Fine Gael Party or of the Communist Party, and so on, being a citizen of this country, he has a right to go into court to get a declaration as to whether or not a particular Act is constitutional. Is there anything wrong about that?
Comment on this
(Longford): Fine Gael could not take any action. It had to be taken by a person.
Comment on this
What is the complaint, then, that a citizen of this country availed of the provisions of the Constitution to go in to get a declaration as to what the Constitution means? Dr. John O'Donovan did that. All the High Court did was to pronounce on what was the meaning.
Comment on this
The Chair feels these matters have been fully thrashed out. They have been repeated and repeated. It is time to get away from them.
Comment on this
I want to dissent from the view of the Chair on that. I want to point out what has gone on and what the effect of the decision of the High Court was and is.
Comment on this
The Chair has no escape from the Standing Orders of the House. The Senator may not refer to these matters continuously.
Comment on this
We know well the extent to which the Minister can be influenced by the Chair.
Comment on this
I stopped dealing with the by-elections, although it is the subject I most like, the moment the Chair indicated he did not like me to deal with them—my favourite subject.
Comment on this
At least I have clarified one matter in relation to the origins of the challenging of the 1959 Act. It is wrong to say, as the Minister said here today, repeatedly, and no doubt will continue to repeat, that the courts have decided that no regard should be taken of administrative counties or anything of that kind. The High Court did not say that; the Supreme Court did not say it. What the Supreme Court did say, when the Electoral (Amendment) Act, 1961, was referred to it, was that all of these matters were matters to be taken into consideration by the Oireachtas.
Let me quote now from page 183 of the Irish Law Reports, 1961:
The sub-clause recognises that exact parity in the ratio between members and the population of each constituency is unlikely to be obtained and is not required. The decision as to what is practicable is within the jurisdiction of the Oireachtas. It may reasonably take into consideration a variety of factors, such as the desirability so far as possible to adhere to well-known boundaries such as those of counties, townlands and electoral divisions.
What the Minister says is in flagrant contradiction of what is contained in the Irish Reports in regard to the decision of the Supreme Court, that the country boundaries cannot be breached. Of course they have said these things can be taken into consideration and also indicated that a certain deviation from strict parity is possible. The deviation under the 1961 Act was of the order of five per cent of the national average and they said this was permissible, and perhaps if it had been eight per cent or nine or ten per cent, they could well have said that that was permissible too.
As I say, this Bill is produced on the basis that the people living in different constituencies have nothing better to do than to spend their time running to Deputies every day and that there is something wrong or unjust being done to a person who lives in a county other than that in which the Deputy resides, or if a person is attached to a county which forms the bulk of a particular constituency. I have never known that this gave rise to any difficulty. Of course there will be people who will complain, but in the long run what the people are concerned with is not whether their constituency falls between county boundaries or whether it is a one-seat or four-seat constituency, but with economic and social conditions, with educational and health services. They are not concerned with how accessible a Deputy is to them.
It is wrong to say that the people look upon their Deputies as aids to getting the kind of things to which by law they are entitled. The people want their Deputies, and in particular their Ministers, to devote their attention to the wellbeing of the community. They hope that in the general development of economic conditions every county and every part of every county will get its fair share of the prosperity. If a Deputy happens to belong to another county they have not got any neurotic ideas that they are going to suffer some injustice until the next revision of constituencies takes place.
It is an extraordinary fact that with all the talk that is going on, that even as matters stand there are upwards of a dozen towns that straddle two counties and I am satisfied that the people in these towns have no difficulty remaining in contact with their Deputies. I am sure the Minister will not be able to give any instance of people who have written from any of these towns saying that their town is divided into two parts, one lying in one county and the other lying in another.
We will start off with Athlone, part of which is in Roscommon, the other part being in Westmeath. It is what the latest census regards as a town. Then we come to the next town, Charlestown—what was it they said? "No one shouted stop"—part of which lies in Mayo and then across the railway bridge, part of it is in Sligo. It is represented by two sets of Deputies, Deputies from Mayo and Deputies from Sligo-Leitrim. I have not had the advantage of reading "No One Shouted Stop," or whatever the series of articles was called, to know whether that was one of the reasons decay set in in Charlestown. The next town is Dowra on the borders of Leitrim and Cavan. It is divided between two counties and these people continue to labour, according to the Minister, under this great injustice.
Comment on this
(Longford): There is only one publichouse in Dowra, on the Leitrim side. It is only a small village. Unless you are sure of what you are talking about——
Comment on this
I said it was a small town and if there is one thing worse than another, it is a "one pub" town because people have not got the opportunity of avoiding the company they dislike.
Comment on this
Can we get away from publichouses and concentrate on the Schedule?
Comment on this
Portarlington is divided between Counties Laois and Offaly and is also within the one constituency. Bunclody is divided between Wexford and Carlow and O'Brien's Bridge at Montpelier, between Limerick county and Clare. Clonmel is divided between Tipperary and Waterford and Bray, according to the last census, is divided between Dublin and County Wicklow. Finea straddles Cavan and Westmeath and Roosky straddles Leitrim and Roscommon. Birr straddles Offaly and Tipperary and Graiguenamanagh straddles Carlow and Kilkenny. Lanesboro, an expanding town, straddles Longford and Roscommon.
That is the way history and geography and the administration of the counties have ordained how these towns will be located in regard to their electoral location. Some of the towns are big; some of them are small. They are divided between two counties and I have yet to hear that that is a disadvantage, or to hear that these people suffer from any sense of grievance or injustice. One would imagine from the Minister's description of what has happened to date that these people were labouring under a sense of injustice. Let him apply the test in the case of these towns. No doubt the Minister will go through all of these points and we will have to listen to him from now until 5 o'clock—that is what is in store for us——
Comment on this
At any rate, these are the facts and the more the Minister continues to talk, the surer will people know that he has an extremely bad case. As we know, if you have a good case, it is very easy to present it shortly and simply but when you have a bad case——
Comment on this
That is why all the Senator's speeches are so long.
Comment on this
——you have to continue rambling and ranting and labouring along. All I want to say is it does not matter what the Minister will say or at how great a length, he will repeat himself notwithstanding the rules of order and so on. It does not matter what he has to say because nothing will convince the people that this Bill and the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill were not brought in for the sole purpose of protecting Fianna Fáil. In the words of the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, there will always be a Fianna Fáil Party and a Fianna Fáil Government but there was a danger, and this is the danger the Fianna Fáil Party foresee and against which they want to guard. It is for that reason they have introduced these Bills. I quote from the Irish Times of 29th March, 1968, when the Taoiseach spoke at the Tomas D'Arcy Fianna Fáil cumann in the Moira Hotel. On that famous occasion, Deputy Lemass said:
Under PR Fianna Fáil had become the predominant political force and would always remain so.
Comment on this
The former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass—I said that in the beginning. I said he was the former Taoiseach.
Comment on this
They were too apprehensive in their anxiety to know what the former Taoiseach had to say and their concentration was diverted for the time being. Deputy Lemass said:
Under PR the only issue was whether Fianna Fáil would have a working majority or carry on as a minority Government. The continuation of Fianna Fáil was never likely to be in danger. The only alternative under PR was another coalition which nobody wanted.
Comment on this
Is that not true? Does anybody in this House disagree with it?
Comment on this
I will come back to coalition on the PR Bill and I shall have something very interesting to say about it. I have quoted what Deputy Lemass said: we must always have Fianna Fáil and the only danger to the continuance in office of Fianna Fáil is that PR will continue; therefore, we must get rid of PR; therefore, these Bills have been introduced. That is the whole purpose.
Comment on this
I will not repeat. Senators can read it for themselves.
Comment on this
The bit the Senator read did not say that. There may be a bit on the next page.
Comment on this
"The continuation of Fianna Fáil was never likely to be in danger. The only alternative under PR was another coalition, which nobody wanted."
Comment on this
The only danger Deputy Lemass sees to the continuation in office of Fianna Fáil is the continuance of PR.
Comment on this
We will discuss the continuance of PR on this Bill. They are determined to keep this going.
Comment on this
The Minister can talk about it until 10 o'clock tonight. This Bill and the PR Bill are designed to ensure that Fianna Fáil remain in office always. PR is the threat to the security of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Of course it does and in the clearest possible way.
Comment on this
The Senator is being smoked out, to use one of Senator FitzGerald's phrases.
Comment on this
I repeat that is the reason why we have this Bill and, instead of the Minister for Local Government being concerned with housing and other matters, he will continue to waste more time here trying to ensure its passage.
Comment on this
All I regret is that the Government have not seen fit to do away with a written Constitution altogether. The Constitution should never have been written down. The British Government take good care not to have a written Constitution. The same position obtains in Northern Ireland: they have no written Constitution. What has happened here is that this written Constitution has created a lawyers' paradise.
Comment on this
Take the Solicitors Bill. I was Minister for Justice when it was introduced. I remember it well.
Comment on this
The Chair would ask the Senator to concentrate on the Third Amendment Bill.
Comment on this
If I am out of order, I will sit down. I thought we were amending the Constitution, or part of it, and I was saying it was a pity we are not amending it all. Is that in order?
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that we had this Solicitors Bill and we took every precaution to make sure that it complied with the written Constitution. Subsequently some solicitor misconducted himself. He was not actually struck off the register, but he appealed to the Supreme Court. Two judges took one view and two took another, and one of them found it hard to make up his mind, and we were then told that it was not constitutional to deal with a solicitor who had misbehaved himself. But the medical profession can do that and it is, apparently, quite constitutional. That is utter rubbish. I am sorry the Government have not done the right thing and done away altogether with a written Constitution. Let us have one or two principles and no more. So long as we have this written Constitution, we will have the lawyers fattening on it. That is all I have to say. I hope everybody understood. If the written Constitution is done away with, we will get somewhere.
Comment on this
Is Senator Boland forecasting the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution—to wipe it out?
Comment on this
Some points raised by Senator O'Quigley were, I suspect, merely raised for the purpose of delay. At the same time, I think I should deal with the points. He said that at no time since 1961 was there any complaint about what had happened in the 1961 revision of constituencies. He admits, apparently, that there were complaints in 1961. Senator O'Quigley must not make many visits to branches of his own Party's organisation in other parts of the country because, if he did, he would know that the uprooting of parts of the population from one county and their transference into another is still, in fact, resented in these areas. I admit that the complaints about what happened in 1961 are not so virulent now as they were in 1961, when this injustice was perpetrated on the people, and that is because the situation has now, of course, been established. Two general elections have been held on the basis of those grotesque constituencies and the position is now more or less accepted. But complaints were made from all sides of the House in 1961 and there were demands from both the Opposition Parties for an amendment of the Constitution, an amendment which could have been only on the lines we are proposing here. Once the situation was established and Deputies elected under the 1961 revision—presumably the Party organisations were adjusted to the new situation—we did not concede these demands. We did not comply with them and we did not move as we were requested for an amendment of the Constitution but the position is that now a further revision of constituencies is required by the position disclosed by the census figures of 1966 and that a demand has been made by members of the Opposition Parties for this revision to be carried out now. The Constitution says that this proportion of population per Deputy shall be the same as far as it is practicable at any time and if it is not the same now, we interpret that as indicating that a revision of constituencies is required now. It is quite clear that this would involve a further breaching of county boundaries, a further butchering or dismembering of constituencies, a further disfranchisement of large sections of the population in different parts of the country and obviously a further outcry against this ridiculous requirement. What is annoying the Opposition is that we did not go ahead and do this and give them the opportunity of moaning and groaning about it as they did in 1961. What annoys them is that we are complying with the demands made in 1961.
With regard to the suggestion that the 1935 revision of constituencies did not cause any complaints, of course that again is absolutely wrong. It did cause considerable resentment in the places where this type of thing happened in 1935. Of course, it did and not alone that, but the resentment still exists to the present day.
Comment on this
Where this had to happen, for instance as between Galway and Clare and Roscommon and Athlone. This resentment at what happened in those areas in 1935 exists to the present day. It has not happened there since but it has had to happen in other places and obviously would have to happen all over the country if a revision is made now. With regard to the statement by Senator O'Quigley, who was one of those involved in the action which required this to be done in 1961, that the action was not taken by the Fine Gael Party well if he says that I suppose we must accept it as true, that it is a pure coincidence that the person taking the action was a Senator of the Fine Gael Party, the solicitor was a Deputy of the Fine Gael Party, the junior counsel was a Senator of the Fine Gael Party and his senior counsel was a Deputy of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
And there were two other senior counsels who were not.
Comment on this
All I know is I was paid my fees by Dr. O'Donovan out of his pocket.
Comment on this
We know members of the Fine Gael Party who specialise in getting money out of the State on this kind of thing.
Senator O'Quigley went on to say that the High Court did not say that county boundaries could not be taken into account. I admit I would find it rather difficult to interpret what the High Court said in that judgment. I cannot say why they did not say it in so many words, lay down and specify what the position was. Instead of that, Budd J. took quite a number of pages of the Irish Reports in which to convey his decision. I can only take the advice tendered to me as to what the decision is. We have tried to interpret it because we have a practical job to do, to revise constituencies. We have interpreted it as indicating that these things are not relevant considerations but that a maximum divergence of about five per cent can be allowed. In fact eminent lawyers in the Fine Gael Party have not been able to agree as to exactly what is said.
Senator O'Quigley says here today that the High Court did not rule that county boundaries were irrelevant. Surely that means, in other words, that these things can be taken into account in delineating constituencies but the solicitor who instructed Senator O'Quigley in that famous case, Deputy Ryan—I believe "instructed" is the word—has a completely different view to Senator O'Quigley? On 28th May, 1968, volume 235, No. 1 of the Official Report, columns 42-43, Deputy Ryan said after I had interjected "That was because the court permitted the five per cent divergence":
The court allowed no such thing, and typical of the utterly false propaganda being advanced in support of this despicable proposal is the one that the courts have allowed a 5 per cent divergence. The courts have allowed no divergence from equality in so far as equality is practicable. The courts have said, because our Constitution says and because the people of Ireland said, equality should operate in the ratio between population and Deputy as far as it was practicable. In relation to the 1961 revision equality as far as it was practicable was operated. The courts have not said that a 5 per cent divergence is permissible. That is not what the courts said. That is not what the Constitution says. That is not what the law at the moment says and that is why I queried last week the ruling out of order of an amendment when the reason for ruling it out of order was supposed to be that the law at the moment allowed a 5 per cent divergence. The law allows no divergence whatsoever. It says it shall be equal as far as practicable.
As far as I can see, the position is quite clear from the Irish Reports and that is that such things as county boundaries may not be taken into consideration.
I quote from page 146 of the Irish Law Reports, 1961:
Here let me observe straight away that although a system in the main based on counties has in fact been adopted, there is nothing in the Constitution about constituencies being based on counties. The Constitution does not say that in forming the constituencies according to the required ratio, that shall be done so far as is practicable having regard to county boundaries. Even if it did, the Oireachtas or the appropriate Minister could alter county boundaries. No doubt it is convenient in many ways to use the existing administrative machinery: and there is nothing objectionable in a certain degree of adherence to the county basis of division provided that the dictates of the Constitution are observed.
Further down on the same page:
No doubt the Oireachtas would have to proceed on the basis of having regard to the areas for which census figures are available, but that is about the only limiting factor.
The only limiting factor is the amount of detail in which population figures are available in the census. I shall leave Senator O'Quigley and the other lawyer members of the Fine Gael Party to try to hammer this out between themselves because they have different views about it.
Comment on this
If the Minister understood us, he would know we both agree.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley says now that county boundaries may be taken into consideration. Other Deputies and Senators have said that they may not. I agree that there are certain cases of towns and villages straddling two counties as Senator O'Quigley has discovered. There are of course some cases in which a small part of one county could be added to another less objectionably than in other circumstances but unfortunately it is not always in these places that the constitutional need arises for these adjustments to be made and it is not always the case either that that would be a sufficient adjustment to make to comply with the requirements of the Constitution.
It is quite obvious from Senator O'Quigley's remarks that he, just as his colleague, would like the debate to be conducted on the basis of one side only. He said that no matter what I say he will not be convinced. I can assure him that I would not attempt for one moment to try to convince him or anybody else on the opposite side of the House. I appreciate that they have a closed mind on this matter, that their minds are made up and that this being a proposition put forward by Fianna Fáil, therefore, their duty is to oppose it. I agree with that but I am quite certain that the people will be convinced with the assistance of the fact that the Leader of the Fine Gael Party and the minority of his Party who have some confidence in the future of that Party are in favour of these proposals.
Comment on this
Very briefly on the Schedule, I rise to compliment Senator FitzGerald on the very excellent case he has made, and the excellent way in which he documented it. The figures are there and the inevitable conclusions to be drawn from them are drawn. This is only what you would expect from Senator FitzGerald and, indeed, it is only two weeks since the most senior member in the Government, next to the Taoiseach, Deputy Haughey, paid a very special compliment to Senator FitzGerald on the very careful analysis he had made of the Second Programme.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator will come to the Third Amendment.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied from the figures given that at most the breaching of six counties was all that was required and, indeed, that would restore much of what has been done up to this. In point of fact, the Minister deludes himself if he thinks the people down the country look upon these politicians as tin gods and that the whole welfare of the country is bound up with whether they have a TD or not. The Minister is not reading the signs right and from the way the Minister and his Party are rushing this——
Comment on this
——the public realise what is going on. The recent salary proposals have also contributed heavily to this. The case made by the Minister that he realises after 36 years that county boundaries can now be regarded as sacred is a very belated conversion and one that will not carry weight down the country because what is needed is a more efficient Government, more efficiency from the top so that the public can see that the Government are actually doing the job.
No person in his sane senses would trust the present Minister or any Minister with the discretionary powers that are asked for in this, being capable of bearing a tolerance from —?th to +?th so that 16,600 votes in one area can be equal to 23,300 in another or that three votes in one area can reckon as two in another. We would be prepared to give whatever tolerance was necessary provided we saw that would be carried out by an impartial body and provided there was provision in the present Bill for a Commission. That is given only in a package deal in connection with the Fourth Amendment where it is pretty well certain to be defeated.
The Minister has made no provision for any such Commission in conjunction with a system that would prevail after the referendum, where we will have the constituencies we have today and where the Minister seems to foreshadow some more Blackrocks being shifted from the parent region like Cork city, a totally unnecessary transfer especially when you see horns pushed out into the Cork constituency on the other end as far as Blarney and away up to the north end. That does not inspire confidence in giving discretionary powers and I would not be a party to giving these discretionary powers.
If the Minister has a case there is a duty on Telefís Éireann to enable this question to be resolved before the viewers. Let Senator FitzGerald's figures be shown. They cannot be contradicted because Senator FitzGerald would defy any panel to go on Telefís Éireann and take his figures one by one and examine them and their validity. Therefore, the new bogey raised about this breaching of county boundaries is shown to be totally absurd and unreal. The people will see it for that.
If the Minister wishes to submit it to an impartial inquiry, why not submit Senator FitzGerald's figures and his own figures to people whose profession it is to analyse such—in other words, to professors of political science. They are capable of analysing the figures of Senator FitzGerald and the Minister and giving the public the benefit of their impartial and considered judgment of these figures. I challenge the Minister to take that course because the public will have far greater reliance on figures produced by those distinguished and respected professors than they will have for figures handed out by the Minister. Let him take up that challenge and as a representative of the graduates of the university amongst whom we reckon the Minister, I challenge him to be a university graduate. Let the truth prevail and let him face a panel on TV against Senator FitzGerald and let the viewers see where the truth is and let Professors Chubb and Thorney play a part in the analysis. Until that is done, indeed it will be the height of folly to give the totally unnecessary tolerance that is asked for in the Bill.
Comment on this
I had not intended to intervene in this but one of the last Senators prompted me to do so when he said: "Let the truth prevail." I think it is a pity that the truth has not been let prevail by Senator Quinlan in his speech. He has suggested that if a tolerance is to be allowed in this Bill, discretion is to be given to the Minister to divide constituencies any way he likes. That is not true. There would have to be legislation and the legislation would be passed by both Houses of Parliament.
Comment on this
Surely no Minister and no political Party in introducing a Bill can be flagrantly in favour of one side or another? The whole basis of this discussion, unfortunately, has been what I said in my speech on Second Reading, that apparently the impression endeavoured to be given by the Opposition in this Parliament is that everybody, every Minister and every Deputy, is dishonest if he does not belong to one of the Opposition Parties. It is most degrading, most humiliating, and the people who make statements of that nature do not reflect great credit on themselves. The general intention in any electoral system is that in a broad way you should have a Deputy representing approximately the same number of people, but as well as representing the same number of the population in the country, he should also represent in a broad way the same number of the electorate. At the moment, we have a very grave discrepancy between parts of the rural areas and the cities because in so far as the electorate is concerned, it takes very many more votes in a rural area to elect a Deputy than it does in an urban or city area.
In every democratic country in the world there is a tolerance. The thing at issue is what is a reasonable tolerance. It must be reasonable at the time of each census because the Constitution says "at the time being". The population in various constituencies may increase. They may decrease as well. Are we going to have this chopping and changing around every five years or every eight years? Surely there should be some reasonable tolerance which will stay there for a rather indefinite length of time which would be fair and reasonable to everybody? I do not think anybody with any good sense can suggest that there should not be a reasonable tolerance. The only thing at issue is what is a reasonable tolerance. The tolerance suggested is one-sixth. Are we to consider that is unreasonable? Perhaps we could apply ourselves to other democracies. We do not hear Deputies in other democracies suggesting that because there is a greater tolerance, their Ministers and their Government are crooks and are dishonest people. The whole basis of this is to strike at the very root of democracy, to detract from the respect people should owe to any Government. I do not care what Party it is that is in power, I would not subscribe to that.
Comment on this
Provided it is not completely representative of Taca men.
Comment on this
I am not a member of Taca but there is nothing whatever to be ashamed of in Taca. Is it to be the suggestion that there is something to be ashamed of in being a member of a political Party? If that is the suggestion, why not say it?
Comment on this
Senator Nash, to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
I could not let that go unheeded. In this country politics has come to be a dirty word because of the tactics of certain people, who when they think they are looking through a window are looking in a mirror, and see themselves and not their neighbours. If I am going to suggest that somebody else's motives are dishonest without any evidence of it, I am judging his motives by what I might do in his place. Therefore, if I suggest dishonest motives to somebody else, it is because there is probably dishonesty in my own nature. I feel that it is striking at the very roots of democracy in this country that this scandalous attitude should be adopted towards political opponents.
Let the Opposition show, if they suggest a more reasonable tolerance than the one-sixth suggested, one example of where there is a smaller tolerance than one-sixth in any country in Europe. I consider it is a reasonable tolerance and that it is smaller than in most countries, and enables constituencies to be kept within county boundaries, which are already there for administrative and other purposes. I feel the people have a certain pride in their own county and that they would like to have the same relation between their counties and their constituencies as they already have between their county councillors and their Deputies.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator will explain what happened in Blackrock?
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan has had an opportunity to speak and will get another opportunity to speak later. Senator Quinlan must cease interrupting.
Comment on this
The Minister and the Fianna Fáil Senators have gone to great pains to blame the fixing of the constituencies the last time on the court action which has been mentioned here during the course of the day. This is just a red herring in order to divert the attention of the people from what is happening and so that the Minister will have an opportunity of fixing constituencies in the way he wishes. Take, for instance, the case outlined by Senator Quinlan in Cork where they moved portion of Cork city, Blackrock, into the middle of Cork for no other apparent reason than that it was the residential area of one of the most popular Fine Gael Deputies in that city. Again, if my memory serves me correct, we in the Fine Gael Party had a very promising Dáil candidate in Councillor Jim Bowe from Wexford. Before any time, he found himself and his area landed in Carlow.
Comment on this
I have not said a word about that but the area is 80 per cent Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
What happened to Councillor Bowe has happened all over the country. This was not confined to the constituency of that Fine Gael councillor alone. I think many Labour candidates found their constituencies moved as well. If the present Government get an opportunity, they certainly will rape the constituencies to a very fine degree. The Minister has not told us in any of his long speeches in this House whether any portion of the county boundaries will be regrouped. Will the portions of Meath and Westmeath which are with Kildare be restored to their administrative counties at the first opportunity? The Minister has said that those people have expressed disquiet on account of being with other counties but he has not given an assurance to the House that if he gets the chance, he will restore those people to where they were pre-1961. This entire problem is a major one and one which will affect practically every constituency and I would ask the Minister to show even at this late stage some change of heart in order to reassure the people that they will not find themselves facing a problem, as far as gerrymandering is concerned, such as they have in the North of Ireland.
Comment on this
There are two issues and a bit involved in debating this Schedule. We have tried to establish why it is needed. I have tried in speaking earlier to give the reason. I am merely summing up very briefly at this stage. There is the issue of fair representation. I suggest this is not in issue because we propose that an electoral basis, which the Minister thinks is fair, should be employed, but he voted that down yesterday. The Minister has rejected this proposal. He has rejected the proposal which would have given to the west of Ireland, including Kerry, which he seems to omit, 37 seats as against 34.1 as they are entitled to on the basis of population.
The second issue is county boundaries. He claimed in words which I quoted before that this would get much worse and what happened in 1961 would be as nothing to what must happen now, and that this would have to occur on such a much wider scale now if this Bill is not passed. These are the words he used. I have presented a possible way in which the constituencies could be divided which shows that not alone need this not be worse on this occasion, but better. Instead of taking pieces from seven constituencies, to take pieces from six would suffice. Instead of taking 56,000-odd people, 33,000-odd would suffice. In disturbing in their voting pattern 1.5 per cent of the people, the problem could be solved. Far from getting worse, this problem, if not aggravated by the desire to gerrymander at the expense of unnecessarily moving people around, might be resolved with very little disturbance.
It is not, therefore, a question of county boundaries. The Minister made this clear in his reference to Mayo where he said that under the present system—that is what I said, although I think he has misquoted me—he was prepared, and any government would be, to break up Mayo unnecessarily even though there was no need to do so and break up the county boundaries in order to produce unfair representation—something which certainly a Fine Gael Government would not do. We believe that county boundaries should be adhered to where possible and that representation should be fair, based on electorate or population, whatever is appropriate.
The grounds that the Minister put forward for the Bill were self-contradictory and were disproved out of his own mouth. I have challenged him with the figures I have put forward for the various constituencies and, speaking at great length and in his usual wandering manner, he has failed to come to grips with my figures and has not challenged them and, by default, has accepted that what I said was true. His claims that if the Bill does not go through, the country would have to be divided up far more extensively are disproved and, with respect to Senator Quinlan, I do not think it is necessary to establish any committee of inquiry to see whether these figures are correct or not. The fact that I have put them forward and that the Minister has failed to refute them is quite clear evidence that my figures stand and that his claims are false. On these grounds, we reject the Schedule.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan states that the Government are not reading the signs right. I imagine that the fact that we have continued to retain the confidence of the people over such a long period would indicate that we have a reasonable facility——
Comment on this
Senator Rooney should allow the Minister to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
I also thought that the main tenor of the debate was the allegation that we were too well able to read the signs, that we had too accurate an information service in regard to voting patterns and so on in the country. However, Senator Quinlan being, as he says himself, a rugged Independent, has, apparently, a different view from that of some of his colleagues.
With regard to Senator FitzGerald's scheme of constituencies, which Senator Quinlan naturally found so acceptable and so much deserving of compliments, I can only say that I dealt with each county on an individual basis, that I gave the figures from the census of population and I think Senator Quinlan would probably be capable of reading these. They are incontrovertible. I showed the number of counties whose boundaries would have to be breached. This cannot be contradicted.
Comment on this
These figures are on the record of the Seanad. I showed that a much wider breaching of county boundaries would be necessary now in order to do justice or to go as near as possible to doing justice to the people of rural areas under the present circumstances which the Opposition are trying to hang on to, that is requiring representation to be based on the population in the census irrespective of the number of voters in the constituency.
Senator FitzGerald's suggested scheme of the constituencies is, apparently, acceptable to Senator Quinlan but we know from past experience that it would not be acceptable to the people concerned or to their representatives but because these representatives have not been sufficiently interested to investigate the matter for themselves they have not come face to face with what is going to happen in their constituencies, of course, no objections have been raised yet but when this type of thing had to happen in 1961 the objections from the Opposition benches were very vehement indeed.
Apparently, Senator Quinlan's main purpose in rising was to repeat something which he knows to be a deliberate falsehood. With regard to this proposal to permit of a maximum divergence from the national average of population per Deputy of one-sixth in order to take account of certain very practical considerations, Senator Quinlan alleged, which he knew to be false, that this meant that it would take 16,000 odd votes in some constituencies, as against 23,000 odd votes in other constituencies, to elect a Deputy. Senator Quinlan knows that that is untrue and I suspect that his sole purpose in speaking was to repeat that deliberate falsehood.
Comment on this
He knows that, so far from that being true, the position is that these figures relate to total population and that the total population have not got votes, that, in fact, the position is that if the change that we propose is not made the situation that will continue will be that, for instance, in the area of Dublin North-West it will take 10,206 voters to elect a Deputy, not 23,000 odd as he alleged, and that in the area of Donegal South-West, it will take 13,567 voters to elect a Deputy, not 16,000 odd as Senator Quinlan alleged.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan also said that this proposal would give very wide discretionary powers to the Minister but he knows himself that, in fact, it will give much less discretionary powers to the Minister than now because the requirement will be to utilise this maximum permissible divergence from the national average of population per Deputy in order to avoid the breaching of county boundaries. So that, it will be much more restrictive on the Minister than the present position which Senator Quinlan wants to retain, the position in which the Minister will be required, whether he wants to or not, to make adjustments as between one county and another, and, of course, he will have the facility available to him of selecting the areas to be attached to one county and the areas to be detached from another in the many different ways this can be done. It is the situation now, and which Senator Quinlan wants to retain, which will give much greater discretionary powers to the Minister.
Senator Quinlan's argument against this is a dishonest one because he first of all decided what his attitude was to be, that his attitude was to be to oppose this, and it was only then that he searched around for arguments to use, instead of first of all examining the situation and then deciding, on the basis of the relevant considerations, what viewpoint he should take. He leads a very simple life and decides everything on the basis of one consideration and one consideration only and that is, if something is proposed by Fianna Fáil, he in his capacity, as he said himself, of rugged Independent, must oppose it.
Senator Quinlan, as well as everybody else here, knows that it is possible to put the provision for the Constituency Commission into one of these Bills only, since the two are being put before the people at the same time.
Comment on this
Every Senator knows that that is so. Senators also know that it was our intention originally to have only one proposal put before the people and that this provision for the Constituency Commission would be in the Bill. It was at their request, not as a result of any decision of ours, that these were segregated into two separate proposals and, that being done, it was necessary to decide into which of these Bills the provision for the Constituency Commission should be inserted. Surely, since all that is proposed in effect in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is a return to the circumstances that existed when the provision in the Constitution was interpreted by the people who drafted it, since that is all that is proposed and since there is a requirement to adhere as far as possible to county boundaries, only a minor revision of existing constituencies can take place. The whole scheme of constituencies is not to be disrupted. But if the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill is passed, there must be a completely new revision of constituencies.
If the information on which to gerrymander the country is available and if the Minister is as unscrupulous as Senators opposite say, then it is on the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill being passed that more scope is there for this unscrupulous activity to be carried out by the Minister. Obviously, if the provision of a Constituency Commission is in any sense a safeguard against gerrymandering, the more appropriate Bill to put it into, since it can only be put into one, is the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill.
But the discussion on this point is academic because we are proposing to the people that they should accept the two amendments of the Constitution and the Opposition are suggesting they should not accept either. Therefore, the likelihood is that we will either have both amendments accepted or neither. If neither is accepted the position will be as it is and we will be required to go ahead and butcher more constituencies. But there will be nothing to prevent a Constituency Commission being established to do that. It will not be a requirement of the Constitution, however. If, on the other hand, our advice and the advice of the Leader of the main Opposition Party, Deputy Cosgrave, is taken, then the two amendments of the Constitution will be passed by the people and the Constituency Commission will operate. The whole thing is quite simple and this is purely a bogus argument that is being made.
Senator McDonald wants to know whether or not the areas of Counties Meath and Westmeath and of other counties added on to other counties in 1961 will be restored. The Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill provides that it will be permissible to operate a maximum divergence of one-sixth from the national average for the purpose of avoiding the breaching of county boundaries. If this Bill is passed, it will be possible to restore in all cases these bits of counties added on to other counties. On this occasion also it will be possible to avoid doing it in any other case. On the other hand if the position Senator McDonald and the rest of his colleagues over there want to retain is retained, then it will not be possible to avoid doing these things
Comment on this
It will not. Even Senator FitzGerald admits it will have to happen in at least six cases, but I counted 20 counties when he was reading them out.
Comment on this
This cannot be avoided unless the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is accepted. Admittedly, if you are to approach it from the point of view of further decreasing the representation of the rural areas and further increasing the injustice that must be done if the change is not made, you can avoid a certain amount of this breaching. But, even on that basis, you cannot avoid it in every case on anything approaching it. A substantial amount will have to be done.
With regard to the loss of this prominent Fine Gael aspirant for the Dáil in County Wexford, I must say I do not know anything about that. But I do know Fine Gael have lost a prominent aspirant for the Dáil in the constituency of North-East Dublin lately, and this did not arise from any revision of the constituencies, gerrymandered or otherwise, carried out in 1961. It merely arose from the fact that we have this unnatural and disruptive electoral system of multi-member constituencies here. When this prominent aspirant of Fine Gael appeared and posed a threat to the two sitting Members for Fine Gael in the constituency, they took the action Senator Rooney regrets not taking in County Dublin. They kicked him out when they had the opportunity. Senator Rooney waited until it was too late and in the struggle for the last seat in County Dublin, he came a cropper. His colleagues in North-East Dublin knew what was going to happen and they got rid of this prominent aspirant. This is what is involved in the system of multi-member constituencies.
Comment on this
It happens at Fianna Fáil Conventions, too. The Minister knows it because he was rejected himself.
Comment on this
Senator FitzGerald still desires to prolong this discussion. Apparently, he was not able to do it himself and tried to provoke me into doing it. Once again he asked me why we are making this proposal. I explained it to him when introducing the Bill. I explained it again in reply to the Second Reading debate. Senator FitzGerald still wants to prolong this debate by asking me to do it again. I do not think I will oblige him. I think even he knows the reason by now.
Senator FitzGerald again takes me to task for having said that what happened in 1961 will be nothing compared to what will happen now. I have proved that by dealing with each constituency individually. The figures Senator FitzGerald quoted with regard to the disturbance involved in his proposed revision of constituencies are, of course, completely wrong. He ignores that in some cases he is actually disrupting the population of whole counties, detaching them from where they have been and attaching them to other counties. His proposal involves much more shifting of population than he himself has admitted.
All this is an operation with figures. The fact that you move people about every five years is of no concern. Nor is the fact that Dáil representatives are elected for a constituency this year and in two years time find that that constituency is changed and that now they have to adjust themselves to represent other areas for which they were not elected.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister has indicated he does not want to prolong the debate. I now formally propose that the question be put.
Comment on this
I am finished. You are precluding Senator FitzGerald from speaking again.
Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh an Sceideal mar Sceideal don Bhille."
Comment on this
Rinne an Coiste votáil: Tá, 29; Níl, 12.
Do you agree with this result?
There are matters with which we have dealt on Committee Stage, for instance, the Commission, which require amendment and which will have to be dealt with on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Have we a proposal as to when the Report Stage will be taken?
Comment on this
Tuesday. If Senator O'Quigley seriously intends to put down an amendment, we shall leave it over until next week but we shall take it on Tuesday.
Comment on this
Because the sooner the better. We want the whole week to discuss it, if necessary.
Comment on this
I do not intend that it should be a long debate. I want to ensure that the Members opposite will not have to suffer too long.
Comment on this
There is a tendency for the discussion as to when Stages of Bills should be taken to become somewhat disorderly. This should properly be handled by means of a straight proposition, with possible amendments. I take it the Leader of the House is proposing next Tuesday and that Senator O'Quigley is proposing next Wednesday, as an amendment. Any Senators who wish to speak once on the amendment are entitled to do so.
Comment on this
I think it desirable that we should, if at all possible, have the report of the Committee Stage debate available to us before the Report Stage. I wonder could the Leader of the House give a guarantee, if we agree to his proposal, that the report of the Committee Stage debates will be available by Tuesday.
Comment on this
It is desirable that it should be. We have been considerably handicapped as regards knowing what was said on the last Stage, the attitudes that have been adopted and the various nuances that have to be taken into consideration. In drafting suitable amendments for the Report Stage, it is very necessary to have the benefit of the report. From my experience, I cannot see it being available for Tuesday. I think we have gone a good distance to accommodate the Government in this debate and we are quite prepared to finish the debate on Wednesday.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any reason to alter what has been the procedure up to now.
Comment on this
Has the House anything to say before the questions are put?
Comment on this
In view of the length of time taken to debate this Stage of the Bill, practically an entire day, I think if we want to finish by the end of next week, it is essential we should sit as early as possible in the week.
Comment on this
There is only one speech from anyone on Report Stage.
Comment on this
There is a proposition to the effect that the Report Stage be taken next Tuesday and an amendment that it be taken on Wednesday.