We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille Um An gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: Coiste. Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–157 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 6 of 1968 ›

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before we enter into consideration of the Committee Stage of this Bill, the Chair suggests—

(1) In order to avoid duplication of debate that, as in the case of the Third Amendment Bill, consideration of sections 1 and 2 be postponed until the Schedule has been dealt with and that the sections be then passed formally.

(2) That the Schedule be dealt with on the lines followed in the case of the 1958 Bill, namely:

(a) Subsection 1º in Parts I and II be discussed together;

(b) Subsection 2º in Parts I and II be discussed together;

(c) Parts III and IV be discussed together;

(d) in Parts V and VI each section to be taken separately [i.e. section 3 Parts V and VI; section 4 in Parts V and VI; and so on], and

(e) When (a) to (d) have been disposed of, the question on the Schedule will be put formally and decided without debate.

There are two points on which the agreement of the House is necessary. No. 1, agreement is necessary or desirable for consideration of sections 1 and 2 to be postponed until the Schedule has been dealt with, and after that, sections 1 and 2 will be passed formally.

Agreed.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The second point on which agreement is necessary is the manner in which the Schedule itself shall be discussed. The suggestion from the Chair is that the various parts of the Schedule which are cognate will be discussed together, in other words, the Schedule will be broken up for the purpose of discussion, and when that discussion is concluded there will be no general debate on the Schedule as a whole. Is that clear?

Comment on this

Yes.

Agreed.

Cuireadh ar ath-1ó Altanna 1 agus 2.

Sections 1 and 2 postponed.

AN SCEIDEAL.

SCHEDULE.

Tairgeadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh fó-alt 1† i bPáirteanna I agus II ina chuid den Sceideal."

Comment on this

I am not entirely clear on what the position is. I take it that where you speak on the subsection you are speaking of subsection (1) of Part I and subsection (1) of Part II. Is that the position?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is. It is concerned with the principle of the single-member constituencies without reference to the manner of voting. We are taking both the Irish and the English versions at the same time.

Comment on this

While I have no particular desire to prolong the debate on this Bill any more than the debate on the previous Bill, I feel bound at the same time to draw attention to the fact that the provision contained in this subsection for single-seat constituencies rather than the present system of multi-seat constituencies is something for which there has been no demand up to 1959 or since 1959. I do not think the Minister or any member of the Government can point to any widespread demand for single-seat constituencies. As has been said already on the Second Stage of this Bill, the purpose of this provision is to enable the Government and the Fianna Fáil Party to entrench themselves in office with upwards of 90 seats. That figure is conceded on any calculation.

Comment on this

It is not conceded.

Comment on this

Having entrenched themselves with 90 seats, some of these Deputies, instead of spending their time attending to the needs of the nation, instead of directing their energies towards the formulation of national policy, instead of spending their time sitting in Dáil Éireann and making their contributions on the various measures and schemes and White Papers which appear before the Dáil from time to time, will spend their time going around every part of their small constituency cultivating it intensively in their own personal interest to ensure their return to the Dáil on the next occasion, to the neglect of their more serious parliamentary duties.

The purpose of electing a Member to Dáil Éireann is, first of all, to provide representation for the constituents and to represent the views of the people, and, perhaps, equally important to provide a Government that will govern. That can be achieved and has, in fact, been achieved over the past 46 years. No one can say that at any stage the people have been deprived of representation in the Dáil by reason of the fact that we elect representatives in multi-seat constituencies. A great advantage of the multi-seat constituency is that, not only can a person express his preference for a particular Party, but he can also express his preference for different members within political Parties. We all know of cases where the person chosen by the local organisation, and delegates at conventions, has been turned down, sometimes for good reasons, and sometimes for bad reasons, by Party headquarters and someone else implanted or imposed by Party headquarters. In a single-seat constituency what will happen in future is that if it is a safe seat, as it is known in Britain, the electorate will merely be asked to endorse and rubber-stamp the selection of the political Party which happen to have the largest number of supporters in that constituency. That, to my mind, is not democracy. It is political dictatorship. That would be one of the effects of substituting the single-member constituencies for the multi-member constituencies which we have known since 1922.

Apart altogether from that, the argument is being put forward by the Government that Deputies must be in touch with their constituents. Whether 90, 50, 70, 60 or 10 seats is the outcome of a particular election, there will be a large number of people in every constituency who will not have voted for the sitting Deputy. It is idle to think that in a case where a man not only did not vote for the sitting Deputy but campaigned actively against him, he will get from the elected Deputy the same kind of support as he would get from a member of his own Party elected in a multi-seat constituency. In a small constituency of 20,000 souls with an electorate of 10,000 or 11,000, perhaps, it would be very easy for the gauleiters to know who voted for whom, and the sitting Deputy, especially if he happened to be in a constituency with a comfortable majority, just will not bother his head when he is asked to make representations for someone who voted against him. I know that Senators on the other side will stand up and protest and say that when a man is elected he is elected to represent the constituency and he will work for everyone. That does not always happen.

Comment on this

If he has any sense he will.

Comment on this

What he will do is pretend. There are different ways of making representations. One can make energetic representations or merely write a letter.

Comment on this

Deputies are not barristers.

Comment on this

I do not know what that remark is intended to imply.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think Members should undertake not to hint that any Deputy is a parasite.

Comment on this

Very good, Sir: I was hinting in that direction.

Comment on this

There will be people, especially those who have worked actively against the only representative in the constituency, who will find that the representation they want to be made on their behalf will not be made or else will be made in a feeble or ineffective way. So far from giving that kind of person that service, the new single-member constituency will work against him.

I do not know how the new single-seat constituencies will be drawn up. That remains to be seen. I cannot see in, say, a place such as County Mayo, which I know perhaps better than any other, what advantage it will be to the population there to be put, say, in the four different constituencies consisting of Mayo North-West, Mayo North-East, Mayo South-West and Mayo South-East——

Comment on this

At least six.

Comment on this

What advantage will it be to a person to know he is in Mayo North-West compared with being in Mayo North, as at the present time? How will he know where his constituency begins and ends? For the life of me I cannot see how people will be any better off from the point of view of being in contact with their Deputy who may, indeed, be a Minister of State spending most of his time in Dublin——

Comment on this

——or a senior counsel.

Comment on this

——or two Ministers of State, as far as Mayo South is concerned, spending all their time in Dublin and now having transferred their families, as I understand it, to Dublin. I cannot see how the people can be better off or better served in a single-seat constituency than is the case at the present time. At least, at present, people have a choice of Deputies in a multi-seat constituency if they want to get a particular service. Under the new system, they will have to take Hobson's choice. If he happens to be an energetic Deputy, they may fare well. If he happens to be a Deputy who is an absentee, they may fare badly. They may have a Deputy in ill-health or a Deputy who is not able to do as much as would be necessary.

However, all of this talk about single-seat constituencies and the accessibility of Deputies is based upon the assumption that people must necessarily go to Deputies. I think that is a false assumption. If our public service were properly organised—and it merely means not more expenditure but more efficiency in the utilisation of existing staffs and existing services—there would be a great deal less need for the intervention of Deputies, Senators and county councillors than exists at present. However, the Government have made no effort whatever to bring these services to the people. At the last local elections, we proposed, as part of our policy for the future—and we shall pursue it—to establish citizens' advice centres so that people can go to these centres and find out the information they want. The Fianna Fáil Party have done nothing about that. There are some members of the Fianna Fáil Party who thought this a good idea. It is of interest to note that one of the leading young bright lights of the Dublin County Council, in the shape of a Fianna Fáil member, actually took over this suggestion at a recent meeting of the Dublin County Council and had it adopted, as far as my recollection of press reports goes. He, at least, being only a short time in public affairs, recognises the necessity for the kind of things we have been talking about for quite some time.

We all know that, if you want to get from any county council or any Government Department an answer to any question, the first thing you have to do is to fill in a form. As I said before, the forms the people have to fill in from time to time are couched in such language that even I, a barrister, trained and skilled in the interpretation of legal documents and documents of all kinds, have found it quite impossible, on occasions, when asked as a Senator to help people to fill in forms, to know what information the particular Government Department was looking for. It is because of that situation that people are thrown over on county councillors, Senators and Deputies from time to time. It is because people do not get from the public service the attention that their claims and requirements deserve and because they do not get clear-cut directions and clear-cut decisions that so much recourse has to be had to Deputies, Senators and members of local authorities.

It is a mistake to think it is necessary, because of that trend, to change our electoral system because as I say, the proper duties of all Deputies and Senators are not those of looking after these trivia in the daily life although these are things which keep people in office. It is not the looking after of these that helps to generate economic prosperity or to bring about further social advancement in this country. Rather it is the proper duty of Deputies and Senators to give detailed study to parliamentary matters in consultation with Ministers, when in Government, and with shadow Ministers, when in Opposition. These are the things which count. It does not matter whether the Deputies come from single-seat or multi-seat constituencies. If they are good Deputies and apply themselves to the matters to which they ought to apply themselves, we shall have a better Parliament and better administration at Government level.

I speak at very great length on this section, as we could speak at great length on every section of this Bill. However, I do not want to provoke the Minister for Local Government into another long harangue. I want to spare myself, my colleagues and the Members of the House opposite from another continuous, wearying, wearisome, use-less——

Comment on this

Very instructive, if you would learn.

Comment on this

——harangue that will have no effect whatever upon the ultimate decision of the people.

Comment on this

How does the Senator know what was in the Minister's speech? He was not here.

Comment on this

He was on his holidays.

Comment on this

The newspapers— not the Irish Press.

Comment on this

This is Seanad Éireann.

Comment on this

The Seanad Report has not yet appeared.

Comment on this

He is looking forward to reading it.

Comment on this

For all the Minister's seven hours of a reply, I did not read very much of it in the daily press. It was a wasted effort.

Comment on this

You will read it during the campaign——

Comment on this

If the Minister hopes to get all that kind of stuff across to the public, I think he is making a mistake.

Comment on this

——where appropriate.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley is hoping the truth will not get across.

Comment on this

Senator Yeats is very good at searching through old dusty files, but he will not be able to produce many resolutions from Fianna Fáil cumainn or public bodies or letters from members of the public since 1959 demanding the introduction of the single-seat constituency.

Comment on this

Of course, the last Ard Fheis.

Comment on this

The last Ard Fheis was a kind of Party performance.

Comment on this

That is what an Ard Fheis is for.

Comment on this

Everybody knows that at the last Ard Fheis, directions were sent out to put down these resolutions and——

Comment on this

The cumainn had them down.

Comment on this

I should like to know how many public bodies, who are always very hopeful when dealing with current and pressing evils, injustices as the Minister would call them, since 1959 demanded the introduction or put down resolutions seeking the introduction of the single-seat constituency.

Comment on this

They were minding their own business.

Comment on this

It is not like the public bodies to see grave injustices being perpetrated within the confines of their own boundaries and to allow them to pass without notice or not to form the subject of a resolution. There is not, there has not been and there will not be a demand for the single-seat constituency. As we said before and as we will continue to say, and as Deputy Lemass said on 29th March, 1968, "the only issue for the future is whether Fianna Fáil will have a working majority and can carry on as a minority Government".

Comment on this

That stopped in the middle of a sentence.

Comment on this

No, it is the full sentence as published in the Irish Times.

Comment on this

That is only part of what the Senator read before.

Comment on this

I am reading the middle of a paragraph, what Deputy Lemass said was the only issue——

Comment on this

"Or a Coalition Government."

Comment on this

The only issue under PR is whether——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The only issue is the single-seat constituency versus the multi-member constituency.

Comment on this

With respect, PR does not work very well in the single-seat constituency.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

As long as the Senator relates his remarks to the difference between the single-seat and the multi-seat constituency, it would be in order.

Comment on this

This proposal here is a very near neighbour of the proposal dealing with the relative majority system. The category into which this proposal falls is that this is the self-protective mechanism the Fianna Fáil Party are devising in order to ensure an unnatural prolongation of their political life.

Comment on this

The proposal here is to create 144 single-seat constituencies. Today the Minister spent a long time telling us that he wanted to bring in a system which would prevent the breaching of county boundaries and I am wondering how he is going to bring in 144 constituencies without breaching county boundaries as there are only 26 counties. He may in his reply show that this can be done and that we could have 144 constituencies located within county boundaries but in view of his arguments over so many hours I should like to have an assurance from him that he will not breach county boundaries, if and when the necessity for establishing 144 constituencies arises.

Comment on this

How can the Minister give an undertaking? It has nothing to do with him.

Comment on this

Do not forget that the ultimate power lies with the Dáil.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There should not be either interruptions or promptings in the course of this debate. Each Senator should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I do not know who is prompting me; I do not think it is Senator Ó Donnabháin.

Comment on this

He is provoking.

Comment on this

We have examined the figures for elections and we have examined the figures for the county council elections in which Fianna Fáil got a heavy beating. Compared with 1960, they are on the decline. Where Fine Gael went up by 75 seats Fianna Fáil went up one seat in the last county council elections. In spite of this remarkable forward stride by Fine Gael, so far as representation on the county councils is concerned, we have discovered that this proposed single-seat arrangement with a relative majority will work out in favour of Fianna Fáil. The reason for this is that the people who are very fair-minded believe in supporting various policies and various organisations such as the Labour Party, which is a very widespread and strong organisation, Fine Gael, which is an old national organisation, Sinn Féin which elected four Deputies in the second last general election, the farmers' organisations who sent 16 farmer Deputies to the Dáil in 1948.

Comment on this

And you eat them up.

Comment on this

They did not last long.

Comment on this

The people had the power to elect them. The people who wanted farmers' representatives voted for them and elected them.

Comment on this

Sixteen in 1948?

Comment on this

Approximately.

Comment on this

Seven.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before Senators go into too much detail, it would be desirable if Senator Rooney could relate this to the operation of the multi-seat system and the single-seat system. That is the issue which should be debated here, and no other.

Comment on this

The point I was making was that up to now you could have a Sinn Féin Deputy, a Labour Deputy, a Fianna Fáil Deputy and a farmers' Deputy from a five-seat constituency but now this constituency is to be divided up into single-seat constituencies and those five organisations could not possibly, for obvious reasons, put a representative into each area. The situation will be that you will have five areas and five candidates and only one candidate will be elected under the relative majority system, even if he only succeeds in getting one-quarter of the votes. We could have a situation then in which one-quarter of the people in an area could have a member in the Dáil representing them while three-quarters of the people would have no elected representative. The multi-seat constituency prevents that sort of situation because it enables the supporters of various political Parties and various policies to be represented in the Dáil. Democratic representation, therefore, will come to an end if there is a change to single-seat constituencies.

It has been said that, even though Fine Gael jumped by 75 seats in the local authority elections, gaining a great measure of support throughout the country, under this so-called relative majority system, the situation would be that the candidate with the largest number of votes, even though those votes may be in a minority, would be elected. Suppose threequarters of the people did not vote for a Fianna Fáil candidate and one quarter did and got their candidate elected and suppose the three-quarters wanted to have some matter raised or some question asked in the Dáil, who would table the motion or ask the question for them? Would the Government allow one of their Deputies to ask the Minister an embarrassing question? Would he be allowed to table an embarrassing motion in the interests of his constituents?

At the moment the interests of all constituents are well served because the various Parties are represented in the Dáil by Deputies from the different constituencies all over the country and they can table motions or ask questions. They can raise matters on the Adjournment if they are dissatisfied with the Minister's reply. Could there be any hope at all that a Fianna Fáil Deputy would raise a question on the Adjournment which might embarrass his own Government?

Comment on this

Nobody does that more than Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister mentioned him. I shall say no more. To come now to the preference arrangement in the multi-seat constituencies: there was a by-election in Waterford in which three or four candidates were involved.

Comment on this

Yes—three or four.

Comment on this

When the votes were counted and the candidate with the lowest number of votes was eliminated, his second preferences were transferred and that resulted eventually——

Comment on this

Just to clarify the position, I take it we can discuss the system of election on this?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I have repeatedly ruled that the question at issue is the choice between multi-member and single-member constituencies. Senator Rooney has recently started on a new line of argument and the Chair is awaiting his relating this to the debate.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling. I do not wish to widen the scope of the debate. I know the Minister will feel obliged to answer every point, however irrelevant.

Comment on this

Definitely.

Comment on this

They should not be irrelevant.

Comment on this

I intend to be relevant. Reputable statisticians have estimated that between 95 and 100 seats will go to Fianna Fáil in the first general election held, if this proposed arrangement is accepted. We would then have 144 Government Deputies representing 144 different areas and 44 areas with no Government Deputy representing them.

Comment on this

That is a total of 188.

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

This is still the system of election the Senator is talking about.

Comment on this

I am talking about the multi-seat versus the single-seat constituency.

Comment on this

The system of election.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Oh, yes. The Senator is making estimates, entirely false estimates, about the number of seats Fianna Fáil would get under the straight vote. That is the system of election and it has nothing to do with this section.

Comment on this

Then I will depart from the mention of 144 constituencies, though I felt it was relevant.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The mention of 144 seats was quite relevant.

Comment on this

But not the question of the straight vote.

Comment on this

I will not go through all the 144 constituencies, because the Minister might be tempted.

Comment on this

Deliver us from evil.

Comment on this

The people living in an area represented by a Government Deputy will have no voice in their constituency. Again, the constituency in which a non-Government Deputy has been elected will be ignored and neglected by the Government.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Oh, yes. Take County Louth, for instance. The people in County Louth are being punished by the Government and the Minister because the council there is Fine Gael. They have been threatened by the Minister that they need not expect facilities from him so far as schemes and grants of various kinds are concerned.

Comment on this

Look at the number of industries in the county. It is the best in Ireland.

Comment on this

Then, apparently, Fine Gael must get the credit. Even in a multi-seat constituency at the moment the Minister can say that, because there is a Fine Gael council, the people need not look to him for any kind of justice. I call it justice because it is something to which they are entitled, but the Minister says he is not interested in seeing they get justice. This will be the pattern in the non-Government areas if this change is made. On the other hand, the Government may penalise the people and force them into a position in which they may decide they had better support the Government because otherwise they will be left out in the cold; they cannot expect anything from the Government if they do not vote for them. The people will be compelled to vote for the Government candidate. There could be an area then represented by an Independent.

Comment on this

A rugged Independent.

Comment on this

A rugged Independent would be a good Independent. One could be sure of useful questions being asked and useful motions tabled, the latter in both the Dáil and Seanad, and, generally speaking, the people in the constituency could expect good service from the Deputy.

But what about the Government? It is doubtful that the Government would be interested in being useful to the people of that constituency and there again by penalising the people of that area, they would try of course to displace the Independent Deputy and to force the people into a situation where they would feel obliged to vote for a Government Deputy. So this system of single-seat constituencies certainly favours the Government of the time, whatever Government it might be. They will be able to exercise undue pressure. They will be able to create a feeling among the people that if they do not support the Government, they cannot expect what they are entitled to. I was going to mention some Independent representatives in the other House in the past but I do not intend to do so at this stage. However, you could have that situation under the single-seat constituency system.

Of course there would be no choice of personnel in a single-seat constituency. Whether people liked the Deputy or not, the Party would decide who the Deputy for an area should be. They would not have a choice of candidate. They could only protest to their Party headquarters but in the long run the Party would say: "Take it or leave it; your candidate, whether you like him or her, will be the person selected as the standard-bearer for the Party". At present the people have a choice of personnel, in addition to a choice of policy.

The final thing I want to mention is that this arrangement of single-seat areas would leave the Minister in a position to send up four Fianna Fáil Deputies from an area where there are 70,000 men, women and children and in an adjoining area, which would be a Fine Gael area, three Deputies only for 70,000 people, that is the one-sixth tolerance up or down from the average of 20,000 persons. That would be a very unfair arrangement. Fianna Fáil could elect four Deputies for 70,000 people and in another area there would be only three Fine Gael Deputies for 70,000 people.

Comment on this

Have some sense. How could they do that?

Comment on this

The Senator need not ask questions because he knows the differential is between 23,500 and 16,500.

Comment on this

It will be settled by the Commission.

Comment on this

If the Senator makes calculations, he will find the figures I am giving are correct.

Comment on this

The Minister will not arrange constituencies.

Comment on this

One area can have four Deputies and the other three, and the excuse the Minister will give is, "we do not want to cross the county boundary", and this 70,000 in one place where there are four Deputies are also inside the county boundary and the 70,000 represented by three Deputies are also inside a county boundary but they have only three Deputies because of course they are not Government supporters.

Comment on this

It is a judge of the Supreme Court who will arrange that.

Comment on this

It will be done by legislation, as the Senator knows.

Comment on this

The Chairman will be a judge of the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

It will not see the light of day until it suits Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

(Longford): That is the Senator's opinion of a Supreme Court judge.

Comment on this

That is my opinion of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Experience.

Comment on this

I shall not make any more points because I am sure the Minister has a lot more to say. Obviously the multi-seat constituency is more appropriate for the people of this country. They have become accustomed to contact with the Members of Parliament representing their own Party instead of going to a Member of Parliament who might not be a member of their own Party. Supposing we had a large block of single-seat constituencies in the centre of the country, you could have a Fine Gael supporter finding it necessary to travel from Monaghan down to Tipperary in order to contact a Fine Gael Deputy.

Comment on this

It would be that bad?

Comment on this

You will hardly be thrown out that far!

Comment on this

You might have a Fine Gael supporter having to travel from Mayo as far as County Meath——

Comment on this

Or Dublin where he has to come at present.

Comment on this

You must be losing support in Mayo. You have four out of seven at the moment.

Comment on this

I am giving an example of where you could have a large number of counties intervening between the representatives of any particular Party. You could have a whole county, for instance. You might have County Clare without a Fine Gael Deputy. That is quite possible.

Comment on this

Or a Fianna Fáil Deputy.

Comment on this

You know the state they are in there.

Comment on this

(Longford): Even Senator Garret FitzGerald could not divide Clare, whether into square or diamond shapes, in a way that would prevent Fianna Fáil from winning the seats.

Comment on this

Four out of four. That is the situation in County Clare.

Comment on this

That is what the people want.

Comment on this

They have not recovered yet in County Clare and it may take a long time for them to recover.

Comment on this

You are going to put me in bad humour.

Comment on this

I forgot about Senator McHugh, but that is the bad news I have for him in present circumstances. They are not going to have a Fine Gael representative and they are not going to have a Labour representative. That suits Fianna Fáil. Take County Donegal. Again they feel assured that they will win four out of four seats. At the moment there are two Fine Gael Deputies.

Comment on this

And one of them going to Dublin.

Comment on this

There will be 5½ in Donegal: you can have the half.

Comment on this

There you are. The Minister is now going to make Donegal into a five-seat constituency and we will have five Fianna Fáil Deputies for the County Donegal. At the moment Donegal has two Fine Gael Deputies and three Fianna Fáil Deputies, but the new arrangement will ensure that Donegal will have five——

Comment on this

And a half.

Comment on this

——Fianna Fáil Deputies and no other representation.

Comment on this

What about Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Harte?

Comment on this

I am assuming that Fianna Fáil know how to gerrymander areas and they will deal with Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Harte very effectively. I have just mentioned those two unfortunate constituencies. There are other areas possibly——

Comment on this

County Dublin?

Comment on this

No, we are quite happy there. In Dublin city and county, we are quite happy, but it is not so in some other areas.

Comment on this

We have a majority of two in Dublin and a majority of one in Connacht.

Comment on this

Dublin will deal with the Third Amendment and the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bills. They will speak for the rest of the country as far as these two Bills are concerned. We would like to hear from the rest of the country; we would like to hear them make a decision. We can rely on Dublin to do their part and do it more thoroughly than they did on the last occasion and more thoroughly than they dealt with the Presidential campaign in 1966. The people can rely on Dublin city and county all right. The Minister went home disgusted from Rathmines Town Hall at the 1966 Presidential election. That was followed up by the 1967 county council elections.

Comment on this

I was not disgusted.

Comment on this

I do not believe it at all: you were disgusted. The Irish people are a fair-minded people. They believe in fair play and in fair representation. They do not like a situation where a candidate who secures one-quarter of the votes can get a seat.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are not concerned with that question.

Comment on this

Then I shall leave it at that.

Comment on this

I have often heard it said that those who sit and listen also serve. Having listened to the acrimonious discussions over a week now, I feel relieved at Senator Rooney's speech here today, that we are at least getting pacific in our discussion. My speech will consist of about 12 sentences. Firstly, I think the people of Ireland should be grateful to the Fianna Fáil Government for bringing in this legislation, for bringing power to alter the system of election to the principal House of the Oireachtas, Dáil Éireann. I think it will save our people from a lot of the difficulties so obvious in the European situation. I saw recently in the papers that there was no Government in Belgium and I have not seen since that they have succeeded in forming a Government. The reason for that is the prevailing situation among the people of—I will not say coalition—multi-Party organisations.

The next point I should like to make is that the Opposition, namely, Fine Gael, should be grateful to the Government for bringing in this legislation. I am satisfied to say that after almost 50 years of efforts under multi-member constituencies, that is, under PR, they have never succeeded in beating Fianna Fáil and will never succeed in beating Fianna Fáil under PR while most of us are alive and our people are alive. It shows a lack of confidence in themselves now to pretend that the single-member constituency system of election will make the situation worse. I say that the best hope Fine Gael have of securing a majority in this country is under the single-seat system. Under PR which they have had for the most of 50 years, they have failed. The only occasions on which Fianna Fáil were not a Government in 50 years were two occasions when we had attempted Coalitions.

In 1919 the Government established was the Government for all Ireland. We had the 1916 Declaration of Independence and the 1919 election held over the 32 counties of Ireland, and a great majority, an overwhelming majority, accepted the 1916 Proclamation and a Government was established under the single-seat system. Unfortunately, the split came after the unfortunate Treaty and so the successors of the pro-Treaty people are now featuring as Fine Gael. It was in 1922 by direction of the British Government that the multi-member constituency was established to maintain the division in this country.

I said my speech would involve 12 sentences. I have reached that now and I will recap by saying that the people of Ireland should be thankful to the Fianna Fáil Government for introducing this legislation, and Fine Gael should be especially thankful, for it is the only hope they have of ever beating Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

What about the Labour Party?

Comment on this

I do not want to tell you anything about those. I would say that if the Labour Party have sense, they will become the principal Opposition.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Why should we be thankful for that in Fine Gael?

Comment on this

Stop your interruptions. I have only 12 sentences and I shall not answer any of your interruptions. We should be grateful to the Government for their achievements under PR and we are giving the Opposition, especially Fine Gael, the only opportunity they will ever have of beating Fianna Fáil because they will never beat us under PR or the multi-seat constituency.

Comment on this

In considering the single-seat versus the multi-seat, we have to look at and compare the position in England with our situation here. The first thing we must note is that the Member in England serves a constituency with a population at least four times as large as that of a Deputy here. They have 600 Deputies serving the present British population. That means in point of fact that the average English Member is serving as many as are served by three to four Deputies in any one of our constituencies here today. That enables a Deputy to keep at a certain distance from his constituents, a distance that enables him to discharge his more important function of legislator.

Here, unfortunately, we have gone too far in the other aspects of a Deputy's work, that is, of making representations. One would think from many of the speeches that one was electing, say, welfare officers and not Deputies. This tendency has grown apace over the past 15 to 20 years and new and more refined techniques are being used by Deputies of all Parties to encourage this and to make the people feel more dependent.

I am not saying it prevails in all Parties, but it does to some extent. The first essential, before bringing the Deputy any closer to the people, is to ensure that the people are educated into realising the real function of a Deputy, and his real function is that of legislator, and also into realising their rights as constituents. If they are entitled to an old age pension, if they have reached the age, they are entitled to it and there is no need whatever to call on any Deputy either to fill in the form or to make representations. We can sympathise at present with Deputies because all this unnecessary work is thrust on them. They have to do it if they are to stay in, but it is high time that a concerted effort was made by all Parties, spearheaded by the Government, to enlighten the people about what their rights are and so rid Deputies of this awful burden.

If we reduce the present level of representation, it will give a greater impetus to this type of what I would only call messenger-boy representation. That of course obviously is not for the good of the community. There are other and higher tasks required from Deputies. The State has taken steps, quite rightly, recently, to increase the salaries of Deputies so that they can concentrate on this work and they will be of a calibre that merits those salaries.

Again, in smaller constituencies of one seat, we have the situation where obviously only one can be elected. That means if a leading member of one Party, say, the Government Party, in his area is a candidate the Opposition have no choice in such a situation. They have either got to concede the seat to the man in possession or else they have got to get a really good candidate to, as it were, mark the member. It means that in such a constituency if we have one good candidate and say three Parties contest the election, we have three good candidates. There is no room for the mediocre candidate when there is one really good one in the field. Consequently it means that three candidates in the present situation of multi-member constituencies would be obvious for three seats and would form three excellent representatives. Now they are in competition with one another and only one can emerge. Much inferior candidates from other Parties will probably be elected due to the lack of competition.

When a swing goes against the Government, it is the ex-Ministers who very often are the people who suffer most. I am not saying this just solely from the point of view that it is hard on the ex-Ministers to find they are cut off and that they are not in Parliament. That is purely personal. What matters is that in a change of Government, we can be sure that the leading members of the previous Government and of the previous Government Party are available to lead an effective Opposition in Parliament and this means a healthy contribution in that respect. Therefore, any system of single-seat constituencies militates grievously against that, unless we resort, as across the Border, to the safe seat. We saw there in the last election only three out of every five seats were contested. Is that a situation we want to import here?

Again, we take the question of the lack of choice available. Our people at present are highly critical of the activities of Parliament and no amount of denial by Senator Nash or anybody else will get away from that fact. There is no point in whistling going past the graveyard. Politicians have only got to read the papers, see what the political commentators have to say and see what is said on Telefís Éireann to realise that people are highly critical of Party politics today. I admit a good deal of it is ill-informed criticism, but the fact is that the criticism is there.

The people have a certain distrust of what they call the Party bosses and the way the Parties are operated, especially at the inner caucus level. Consequently the people have valued down the years, and like to have the final say on who shall be elected. In a three-seat constituency, the people expect the Government in power to offer, say, three candidates, even though it expects to get one, or at the most two, candidates elected. That is only right and proper. The electorate assumes a very discriminatory function in putting those in the order of their choice.

This very often results in one man breaking through, as it were, the Party machine from being in the position of the reluctant third of the team. This is the choice of the Irish electors, and it is only right and proper that they should have this function because it means that they can exercise their choice of candidates which is made first at Party level and secondly, and most important, at the level of the voters. From that point of view, the people would be very unwise to make themselves simply cogs in the political machine where, if they wish to vote for the Government, they just simply have to put before whatever candidate the Government want, whereas at the moment they can vote for the Government if they wish, but have a choice of three candidates from which to exercise their preferences.

The single-seat constituencies make any idea of proportion impossible because it just simply means that one person is elected. It does not matter what system is operated under the transferable system, the person represents not just 50 per cent or one per cent of the electors. In other words, you have the rule of the 51 per cent. In a modern democracy where all reasonable shades of opinion should be taken into account, it is not only right but it is highly desirable that those shades of opinion should be expressed within the national Parliament. That cannot be achieved through the single-member constituency, especially in our set-up here where, by and large, the country is rather homogeneous. At least you have only two main divisions: the rural part and the urban part. Therefore, we cannot take it for granted that Parliament will be representative under the single-seat constituency system by the fact that one shade of opinion gets representation in one area and another shade gets representation in another area.

This is just like in England where you have certain areas where when it comes to a general election, they will return Conservatives and you have other areas where they will return Labour candidates, and you have the few Liberals who have their strongholds. We can see no such divisions here and therefore we cannot rely on any balancing up of our national representation in Parliament by this type of chance occurrence. It has been done very well in the past and very satisfactorily on the basis of our own version of proportional representation, that is, where the proportionality has been sharpened to give a bonus to the majority Party by keeping multi-member constituencies, with a majority of three-seat constituencies. That has worked well and we should be very slow to change from it.

Again, irrespective of whether a change is made or not, we must realise that we are now in the second half of the 20th century, that our parliamentary procedures, our parliamentary forms of representation, the work of the Deputy have not changed for 100 years. Consequently, we have got to get down to that. That is what we should be doing at the present time. It is what the people of the country are calling out for. They have been asked to modernise in everything they are doing. They have been asked to modernise in their work, to become more efficient. They have been asked to participate in all the recent advances of communication and otherwise. They are demanding that we here in Dáil Éireann and Seanad Éireann should modernise our approach, to set a lead rather than reluctantly be dragged on behind more progressive sections of our community.

For all these reasons, then, it would be very retrograde at this stage to depart from multi-member constituencies.

Comment on this

Opposition Senators are in a certain difficulty in discussing this particular proposal which is, of course, divorced from the question of the system of election, although I think it is reasonably obvious that in common with the public at large, the various Opposition speakers—and that includes Senator Quinlan—are clearly themselves basically in favour of the notion of a small, compact, single-seat constituency as compared with the sprawling multi-seat constituencies we have at present. They are merely trying to put up a certain fog of opposition because of their opposition to the voting proposals contained in this Bill.

I think nearly everybody, certainly, the vast majority of the public, would be in favour of the idea of these small single-seat constituencies, leaving the question of voting out of account. These constituencies, particularly in rural areas, would be very much smaller than the large constituencies we have at present. It is obvious that in certain cases—I quote Mayo which is well known to Senator O'Quigley—in certain parts of, say, Belmullet, they have nothing in common with people at the other end of the constituency.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They are all Irish.

Comment on this

Certainly, they are all Irish, but if the Senator knew anything about rural Ireland, he would realise that people 20, 30 and 40 miles away are somewhat far removed from you. There are people at the end of these big constituencies who are quite unknown to the majority of the local population. They feel that, while they are all Irish, they have relatively little in common with them except for that very obvious fact of common citizenship. I think the people themselves would prefer to be able to live in and work in, if they are interested in politics, and vote in a constituency which is small, which is known to them, the bulk of the area of which they would know very well and where they would know many of the people.

These advantages are so obvious that it is not very likely that anyone will seriously attempt to deny them. These constituencies, of course, will be much more easily managed than the existing ones. While I do not suggest that the interests of politicians should reign supreme in a matter of this kind, it is at least a factor that the various political Parties and various volunteer workers who have to help out at election time will find a much easier task in these smaller constituencies. By-elections, of which there are only too many—some 50 in the past 25 years— will clearly be much more easily managed and considerably cheaper not merely to the State but also to those who subscribe to political Party funds and the workers involved, I am sure, would be duly grateful for having a much smaller area to deal with.

More important than this, in these small areas the voters in general would have a personal knowledge of their Deputy. Not only that but, at election time, they would in most cases know all the candidates. In spite of suggestions made on Second Reading that it did not really matter, I am still unrepentant in my belief that it is an important matter in any democracy that the people, when they go in to vote on election day, should know for whom they are voting, that they should be faced with a ballot paper which consists of the names of candidates whom they know, whom they know about, know their form, their ancestry, what they do, what kind of people they are, what they represent. I may be astray on this, but I am as yet utterly unconvinced that this knowledge on the part of the voters is not a vital and essential part of a healthy democratic system. It seems to me utterly wrong that people should go to a polling station and be faced with a ballot paper on which they may know perhaps one or two names but have a great many more names that they have no personal knowledge of. If they are interested in politics, the voters concerned may have made themselves aware of the names, may have made sure as to what the names of all the candidates are and what Parties, if any, they represent, but they may not have this personal knowledge of the majority of the candidates which, to my mind, is a very necessary thing.

One of the greatest advantages, to me at any rate, of these small single-seat constituencies will be that you will have this personal knowledge of the candidates on the part of the ordinary voters, not merely those who are more politically conscious, but also the ordinary people, perhaps the majority of the people, who are not really so terribly interested in elections, but who are still, under the Constitution, given the power to decide on election day what the Government will be and who their representatives will be. It is very necessary that there should be this close personal knowledge of candidates and Deputies on the part of the electorate at large.

Looking at it the other way round, the Deputy elected in such a small constituency will know his own people well. I agree, on the whole, with, I think it was Senator O'Quigley, on this point that a Deputy should not be in the nature of a welfare officer. I agree that an awful lot of the work a Deputy does at present is unnecessary and wasteful and should be done by somebody else or is not needed at all, though, there is no doubt about it, in these multi-seat constituencies a great deal of the unnecessary work done by a Deputy is merely in competition with other Deputies for the same area, either in his own Party or in one of the other Parties or, perhaps, an Independent. There is no doubt about that at all. I am reasonably satisfied that in the single-seat constituencies some of that wasteful, unnecessary and undesirable competition will disappear.

But, at the same time, it is desirable that a Deputy should have a close personal knowledge of his people's needs and of their views on national and local affairs. In a small single-seat constituency, a compact area, a Deputy will be in a far better position than he is at present to know the views, the needs and the national and local aspirations, not merely of a section of his constituents but of all his constituents. That is a very great advantage of these small constituencies. At present, in in these multi-seat constituencies, a Deputy inevitably has to try to deal with the area nearest to him. There are many constituents at the far end of his constituency he never meets and has not much knowledge of or a great deal of interest in.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7.15 p.m.

Comment on this

I was speaking about the advantages, which I think are generally accepted on this side of the House and also outside it among the public, of the small single-seat constituencies as against the large constituencies we have now. A further advantage which I think is important is that in these small single-seat constituencies a Deputy could represent all his constituents in a way in which he does not do it at present. I know that in theory the Deputy represents all his constituents, not merely the supporters of his own Party but supporters of other Parties, and people who work against him and that many—probably all, in that case—are prepared to listen to people and help them in every possible way no matter what Party they may support. If only in his own interest a Deputy will do this, but there is at the same time a tendency, which I think is undesirable, for people who are seeking help from a Deputy or who wish him to take some action on their behalf, to go to a Deputy of their own Party. It is a much healthier and more satisfactory state of affairs where a Deputy can represent all the people who come to him for help, irrespective of what Party they support.

I dislike these divisive situations which tend to exist in multi-member constituencies where you have one section of the community looking to a Deputy of their own Party and another section looking to a Deputy of another Party. It is much more satisfactory to have a situation where one Deputy will represent all the people, as will be the case in the new constituencies. It is ridiculous to suggest, as has been suggested by a number of Senators, that a Deputy would ignore representations made to him by supporters of the Opposition. Clearly, this is not so. No Deputy interested in remaining a Deputy for a constituency would dream of doing such a thing because word would very soon go around and there is nothing more damaging to any public figure than for people to begin saying: "He was not interested in helping me because I was not a supporter of his Party", or something of that kind. Any Deputy interested in remaining a Deputy will certainly be willing to help in every way possible all the people of his constituency, no matter what their politics may be.

I suspect that most Deputies would go out of their way to seem to be particularly enthusiastic about helping members or supporters of the Opposition Parties, simply to avoid its being said about them that they were limiting their activities to one particular section of the public. We have an example of this in cities such as Dublin where the Lord Mayor is elected. He belongs to a particular Party or may be an Independent and he is recognised by the whole community as the Lord Mayor, no matter to which Party he belongs. In the same way, in these constituencies, the Deputy will be the Deputy for that area and will be looked up to as the public representative of the area and of all the people in the area, in the Dáil. There is no question, therefore, under this system of any difficulty such as has been suggested by the Opposition. Certainly, a Deputy who began saying to people: "I am not going to do anything for you because you did not work for me or vote for me" will not last very long.

The point has been made over and over again on various sections of the Bill that the institution of single-seat constituencies, no matter what the system of election is—that is another day's work—will result in there being a large number of safe seats, of Deputies being there and no matter what happens they could remain for ever and need never bother to carry out their duties as public representatives. This seems to me to be a somewhat irrational attitude, a misrepresentation, a misunderstanding of the situation which would arise under the new system of single-seat constituencies. It would be difficult to visualise a system of election more likely to create safe seats than PR in multi-member constituencies. There are many Members of the Dáil who are completely immune from swings of public opinion because they are the leading members of that Party for a particular constituency. Their Party may have two seats, one of which may be marginal. One of the Members will be elected, no matter what happens and his junior partner will come and go as public opinion ebbs and flows. You will have a considerable number of Deputies under the multi-seat constituency system who are there year in and year out and who are in the safest seats imaginable.

Under the single-seat arrangement, there will be considerably fewer of these safe seats, because every Deputy will become subject to the changes of public opinion in a way that most Deputies are not subject at the moment. The Deputy in a single-seat constituency will know that if the tide turns against his Party, he will be put out, no matter how good a Deputy he is, no matter how popular he is, and no matter how good a vote-getter he is. Therefore, every Deputy in the Dáil will be responsive to public opinion in a closer and in a more direct way than he is at the moment. Inevitably there will be some safe seats, but I do not think there is anything in the suggestion that safe seats will be created on a large scale.

It is quite clear that there is general agreement on this proposition that the single-seat constituency is far more suited to the needs of this country than the multi-seat constituency. I know some Senators, like Senator FitzGerald, are publicly in favour of the single-seat constituency, but I think there are others who may not have come out in this way but who if they were in a position to speak their minds as they would wish, would also support the single-seat constituency. I do not think it is likely leaving elections out of the count that anybody will come out to say he believes that multi-seat constituencies are more desirable than single-seat constituencies.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Senator Yeats has made, on the whole, a persuasive speech in favour of single-seat constituencies taken in isolation from the question of the consequences of such a system for the electoral system, for elections, for majorities in the Dáil, and so on. I think the case is quite strong for providing single-seat constituencies. It is not completely compelling; there are arguments in the other direction which I think will carry some weight with people. There is perhaps not so much force in the argument in regard to safe seats, because there would be quite a significant number of safe seats under this system. On any reasonable expectation of the share of the votes a Party is likely to get within the foreseeable future, in the sense that no seat is completely safe—at some future time there may be no such Party as Fianna Fáil in this country; the same could happen to Fine Gael or Labour—it is clear that there would be a significant number of safe seats. Take, for example, the figure of 35 per cent for the Fianna Fáil vote as a possible lower level for some years to come. I wonder would Senator Yeats challenge that. Does he feel that Fianna Fáil's share of the vote is likely to fall below 35 per cent in the foreseeable future because, if not, on that basis there would be for Fianna Fáil about 30 safe seats? The Fine Gael share of the votes at the moment is now around 35 per cent; it was about 34 per cent at the last election and it is, perhaps, 37 or 38 per cent in the light of the by-election and the local elections. On a similar calculation, Fine Gael are unlikely to fall much below 36 per cent, which would give them, perhaps, 20 or 25 safe seats. Labour, I suppose, might have about five safe seats.

Comment on this

They all have more safe seats than that at the moment.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Safe for whom? Not for the Deputy. The whole point of the argument about the multi-seat constituencies is that the seat is not safe for any particular Deputy. He can be ousted. This may be seen as good or bad. It happened, indeed, to Senator Rooney. It happens quite frequently. Whether that is a good or a bad thing is a matter of opinion. It will vary according to whether one is in the position of being the kicker-out, or the kickee-out, if there is such a thing. It may vary according to one's broad views, one's political philosophy, or one's Party views. The fact is that under the present system no one is safe other than someone like the Taoiseach, who has a very large personal vote, certain Ministers, and a few leaders of the Opposition, but the number of people who would be safe in the ordinary sense of the word, and by the same standards I am applying here, would be very few.

Under this system, despite the enormous instability about which I spoke, I hope as persuasively as Senator Yeats, there would, nevertheless, be something like 55 to 60 safe seats on any reasonable expectation of what Party votes might fall to in the foreseeable future. The question of whether these safe seats are a good or a bad thing is debatable. I am not saying they are necessarily bad. If, however, they are completely safe, so that even a grave dereliction of duty by a Deputy would be unlikely to shake his possession of the seat because of strong Party allegiance in the area, I think that would be bad, bad first of all because it would tempt the Opposition not to waste time and money in opposing seats—a temptation to which the opposition in Northern Ireland have succumbed. By the opposition I mean the opposition in the constituencies. It would also tempt the Government not to oppose Opposition candidates in certain places if such opposition was obviously a waste of time and money. It could lead then to unopposed returns.

Comment on this

Under what system of election?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The spot vote system of election.

Comment on this

I carefully refrained from discussing that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Under the alternative vote the argument would still have considerable force.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley made a great effort to be relevant. Now that is spoiled.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I do not think my relevance has been spoiled by the interruption by Senator Yeats.

Comment on this