An Bille Um An gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: Coiste. Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage.
Contributions 158–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1968 ›
I understood the debate to be about the spot vote in single-seat constituencies. I agree that this section deals with the single-seat aspect. I think it is reasonable for us to keep in mind the fact that, although we have no official knowledge at this point, we will shortly be debating the question of the spot vote. There are rumours to this effect. It is reasonable that we should have some regard to that in discussing this.
Comment on this
The argument is still valid in both cases. This question about the seats will arise with the alternative vote and the spot vote. I am quite prepared to go into that question. Let me recap: if you have the alternative vote in the single-seat constituency, the number of safe seats at 35 per cent is 15 per cent greater. On my calculation at 30 per cent for Fine Gael it is about 15 per cent greater, and for Labour about five per cent greater so, if you are talking about that, there are another 65 safe seats on top of the ones I have been talking about. Whether we talk of 60 or 125 safe seats is not terribly important. The point is that, whatever we do with the next section when we come to it, one way or another we will have a lot of safe seats. It will not be all loss because certainly all the Parties will endeavour to make some use of the safe seat system in order to put people into Parliament who at present cannot easily be got in and who they feel would be useful in Parliament.
It is quite possible that one consequence of the single seat would be the raising of the standard of Parliamentary representation. On the other hand, another consequence could be that there would be a lowering of the standard at the other end of the spectrum. As well as using some of the safe seats to put in people who would be an addition and an ornament to Parliament, and not by any means purely an ornament but an active addition to the work of Parliament, there would also be safe seats which would fall to people who are described by people outside politics as "Party hacks". We never meet any of these ourselves, but there are people who are so described by people outside politics.
Some of these safe seats would undoubtedly go to people who have rendered certain services to the Party, which could range from services in active support at by-elections to financial services in providing funds. Now there is a suspicion, unworthy no doubt, in certain quarters that some of the financial support which is coming to Fianna Fáil for this campaign arises in the hope that some of those financial supporters will be allocated some of the safe seats. Indeed, there is some resentment amongst some members of the Party at this prospect, if what one hears in the corridors and rooms of this House carries any weight. So, the safe seat, a by-product of the single-seat system, will yield, I am pretty certain, both good and bad results. How one weighs that up and where one comes down on the balance is a matter of personal preference. I would find it hard myself to come down very strongly on one side or the other. There are gains and losses and it is hard to weigh one against the other.
Most of what Senator Yeats had to say was soundly based and persuasive so far as it went, but it was not the whole story. There will be the problem of the unopposed seats in some areas, or a danger of it in any event. There will be the problem of some safe seats being used for people whom we would be better off without in Parliament, people who would neither add to the deliberations of Parliament nor be willing and able to provide the kind of services constituents want, people who cannot be elected under the present system because they are not prepared to work locally, people who would not, if elected through the safe seat system, do anything or add anything to the deliberations in the Dáil. We have to bear in mind that there is that loss to offset against the possible gain of some raising of the calibre of parliamentary representation at the other end of the spectrum.
Comment on this
That loss would not apply to certain constituencies in Waterford and places like that? The Senator is assuming that it is always the Party hacks.
Comment on this
I did not say anything of the kind. I said I believed all Parties would use this to bring in some good people who at present cannot readily get in or be got in. I said I believed it would also be used in other places for other purposes to get in Party hacks who are not even prepared to work for their constituents and who need a safe seat where they can get away with their laziness. I think both will happen. I do not deny that some good people will be brought in. I do not think we should necessarily assume that all the people brought in will be extremely worthy people who could not otherwise be elected and who will make great contributions. There are two sides to it and one is as likely to happen as the other. Both will happen in different places. Therefore, the argument on these grounds is one which has a certain validity. It is persuasive up to a point, but it is not totally compelling. I think it is open to anyone individually to come down on either side of that issue.
Secondly, there is the argument about the unrepresentative character of a Parliament in which all Deputies are elected in single-member constituencies and the fact that this eliminates to a large degree, and could eliminate totally in certain extreme circumstances, the proportionality of representation. This is an argument which I said on Second Stage should command respect. We should be slow to initiate a departure from proportionality and fairness and equity of representation. I do not think it is totally compelling in all circumstances to say that we should be tied always and at all times to achieving a maximum degree of proportionality even if this means we do not get more clear-cut majorities. The argument is a strong one but it is rebuttable if it can be shown that another system will yield slightly better majorities and will not undermine totally proportionality of representation and equity of representation. I think the case could be made for some other system. I do not say the present system is perfect.
There is another point which has been ignored in this House and pointedly ignored to the degree one cannot help noting as significant. I made the point on Second Stage that in the circumstances of this country's political geography this system will lead to very large majorities far beyond anything which arises under the British system with their political geography. These very large majorities will also be accompanied by great instability in parliamentary representation with as many as 30, 40 or even 50 seats in the Government Party changing hands at elections with the normal swing in votes which we experience at virtually all our elections. This is an aspect of the system on which the other side of the House have decided and I do not think they have honestly decided on it. I see some merits in the single-seat system but not compelling merits.
If one feels the need to move towards a system of election with a slightly larger bias in favour of clear-cut majorities and a slightly less proportionality, it is certainly open to one to examine other systems that might yield this result. What one is not, in honesty, free to do is to favour this system because one sees merits in single-seat representation and to ignore completely the Irish Party system, with the particularly homogeneous character of Irish political geography, with the absence of a great mass of seats which are held in all circumstances in other countries. There will be political seats here but not in the same circumstances. To vote for the 35 to 45 percentage vote range, within which the two leading Parties fall at the moment and are likely to fall under any situation for many years to come, with, in those circumstances, the instability of the system, the huge majorities which will yield a huge turnover of seats, is not something which I think is acceptable.
If one feels the present system is not perfect, if one feels it has serious defects, nevertheless one is not entitled to change it for a system which can be demonstrated to be one to produce results in the Irish context which are clearly undesirable. I am not arguing on the grounds that the fundamental system is wrong: it has undesirable features at any time but, in the circumstances of a country with a particular political geography, it can be so mitigated that the system may nevertheless be acceptable.
All systems, including proportional representation, have undesirable features. In this country, with our political geography, these undesirable features will not be mitigated or limited but exaggerated to a degree that does not exist in any other country. The reason this system does not operate outside of about three or four countries——
Comment on this
——is that it is unworkable, as a system yielding reasonable majorities and change-over in government, outside these countries with their peculiar and particular political geography.
We should be very unwise to adopt an electoral system which has not been adopted in or which has been abandoned by other countries, a system which has been shown to be unworkable in any country with a homogeneous political geography. We should be very unwise to adopt such a system when it can clearly be shown that, in the Irish context, it will yield majorrities totally disproportionate to the votes and with a turnover of seats at elections which would undermine the willingness of people to go into politics because the chance of their being defeated at each election would be so high, on the average—unless one gets a safe seat. If they get a safe seat, they may be happy and they may be lazy. On the other hand, there may be seats which are so unsafe that the chances are evens or more than evens at each election that they will be material to lose them. That would not be a happy situation. In a great many cases, the safe seats could be occupied by Party hacks and the other seats by people of a rather speculative turn of mind whose occupations are such that they can take a chance of being thrown out of the Dáil at the next election.
Comment on this
Senator O'Reilly has asked an apt and proper question which deserves a reply. There will be a certain number of seats— pretty small in number because of the extreme instability of the system, the extraordinarily high ratio of seats. There will be a certain number of people whose seats will not be safe but who, at the same time, will be reasonably safe.
Comment on this
Yes, marginally—you can use that word. They will represent, however, in the nature of the relationship between seats and votes under this system in the Irish context, a very small minority in a Parliament which will be divided almost totally as to 80, 85, 90 per cent either of people in safe seats or of people in very unstable seats—two categories into which I do not think it is good to divide our Parliamentary representation.
I accept most of what Senator Yeats said in good faith in the limited context within which he was speaking— the single seat, in isolation from the context——
Comment on this
(Longford): The Chair did indicate, in very strict terms, the limits. Senator Yeats was more than obedient to the rules as laid down by the Leas-Chathaoirleach.
Comment on this
If Senator Yeats is going to be more than obedient to the Chair, that is his funeral. My concern is to be obedient. If, in any way, I am disobedient to the Chair, I shall defer to its ruling when it is made. However, I do not think it is the function of the Minister to make such a ruling and I should not defer very much to it if he did make it.
Comment on this
While I accept what Senator Yeats said in good faith, I feel that this debate will not be valid on this section unless Senators come to grips with the point I am making—the point on avoidance which I made on the Second Stage. It is not enough to suggest they feel they have strong arguments to make against mine. The challenge is there before them. It is up to them to deal with the points I have made and not to talk at length about single seats in isolation from the composition of this Parliament and the consequences for the Parliament of this country if such a system were introduced here with the spot vote.
Comment on this
I think we can proceed on the basis, first of all, that Senator FitzGerald does not like safe seats. I think we can accept that as his first premise. Secondly, we can marvel at the absolutely definite and conclusive results that are based entirely on the exclusion of what I should call a fundamental element in life, the personality of the candidate. I have never met such conclusion arguments based on the exclusion of the personality of the candidate.
Senator FitzGerald took us on a tour and introduced figures at every nook and corner. It would be a very worthwhile exercise for Senator FitzGerald to go with us on the same tour when we might introduce him to personalities which would show him that all these ethereal notions that figures are the answer to all these problems will immediately be disproved. I take him as being a strong opponent of safe seats. It is fair to say that not less than 50 per cent, and probably more, in the Dáil at present occupy safe seats. There may be some who had had the unfortunate experience of Senator Rooney of finding his safe seat coveted by somebody——
Comment on this
Not less than 50 per cent of the membership of the Dáil occupy safe seats. I do not think we need to name the people who would be regarded as safe. I can give the names afterwards: I do not wish to put them on the record. But, where a Government Party are particularly strong in a four-seat constituency, there is no doubt in the world that two members occupy safe seats. It is a fact of the Irish political scene at present that, where a Fine Gael candidate has one of three or four seats, it is equally almost the unanimous experience that his is a safe seat. The electorate in their wisdom will probably confine Fine Gael to the same representation, that is, one out of three or four, and will hardly be so unkind as not to give them that representation. I am quite certain from the ordinary experience of the people involved in the Lower House that 50 per cent would be prepared to concede to Senator FitzGerald that they occupy safe seats. So much for the abstract notion of what the figures may tell.
It is hard to deal with anything at this stage in any sort of original fashion and if Senator FitzGerald is going to repeat the same arguments as before, it will be even more difficult. In any event, take the situation which Fianna Fáil at present experience more than any other other Party and which the other Parties must experience if they are going to achieve the political status they hope to achieve, the competition between Deputies of the same Party. This is something that the Labour Party have not experienced, nominating as they do one candidate for each constituency. Fine Gael have had a limited experience because their limited support does not warrant a situation whereby in most cases two members of their own Party are representatives for the same constituency. If the day comes to pass when they achieve that political status which they desire, they will realise that this competition is not at all desirable. Perhaps at the moment they have a little sympathy for Fianna Fáil Deputies who may be faced with this competition but in their time they will see that it is equally undesirable for Fine Gael and for Labour. This is the creature or the first child of the multi-seat constituency and it is certainly excluded from the single-seat constituency.
There is another matter which I want to mention and in this I will, despite the invitation of Senator FitzGerald, confine myself entirely to the balance of consideration between the single-seat constituency and the multi-seat constituency. In the single-seat constituency, the representative will have a smaller and more limited area and as Senator Yeats pointed out, he will be known for his achievement, for his status and he will be known in a more familiar way to the electorate than at present. This being so, representatives will be judged on the two aspects of their work. In many instances at present they are not being judged on both aspects. Where you have three or four representatives in a constituency, the electorate are quite satisfied if one or two of these devote their time to the main business, their legislative function, considering the legislation which comes before them, and if the other two devote themselves to the other business of looking after the personal problems of one sort or another. By and large they feel that the job is being done by different people in different ways.
All of us I am sure are anxious to see the day arrive when each man will as far as possible devote the major part of his time to what we all agree is the most important function, his legislative function. It is quite clear when one individual only represents a constituency, he will have to satisfy his electorate that he is doing this very important part of the work, that he is at national level, with which many of them at present are not concerned because other representatives are doing this for them, projecting the type of idea which the electorate want him to project. At the same time, he must not exclude himself from the personal problems in which so many of the electorate need to be assisted. I for one, having had as much experience as anybody in dealing with this type of problem, do not want to downgrade the experience one gets from coming in contact with people and their problems. In fact it would be a very salutary experience for many to see the type of problems dealt with at weekend sessions in the country and in the city. They would see personified before them the type of problem representatives are concerned to solve. It is a very salutary and in many cases a very trying experience and it certainly is a very profitable one.
I do not want to be taken as saying that in promoting what I regard as the first duty of a representative, he should ignore the other duties. The second aspect of the work confers as much benefit on him as on the people he may assist. Both can be achieved in conjunction and this work must be done with the realisation that the essential job must at all times be in the forefront. I suggest that the electorate in their discretion and in their knowledge would have considerable regard to this particular aspect of a representative's activities. Far from increasing the load of what in many cases is regarded as useless work—and there is some useless work involved—the single-seat constituency would clearly reduce that load. The competition both from one's own Party and from other Parties will automatically go and you can offer yourself to the electorate as the man you are, for the work you do, to be accepted or rejected in the next election.
Another suggestion has been that under the single-seat system the Party machine would move in. I cannot quote figures to support my argument, but I can point to a certain amount of experience and the attitude generally throughout the country is that where there is a man who is prominent in his community and who has proved that he has a significant contribution to make, then whatever Party may be involved would have a very difficult job over-riding his selection because he will be a well-known representative in a small area in comparison with the present extended area. If his achievement is such, no Party could overlook him and bring in some of the hacks about whom Senator FitzGerald is concerned. Therefore, with these limited constituencies it is obvious that one could see the emergence, not on any significant scale, where there are such individuals who may not be associated with any Party, of very prominent Independents. I do not see that this is at all impossible under this system and in such a limited constituency. Such Independents would be men of achievement and their contribution in the House would be very significant. What one should always have regard to in considering the single-seat constituency is the fact that we will be dealing with a quite limited area, an area in which each person will be fully aware of the ability of the man offering himself for selection and, on that basis, I think the man's ability will be a matter of most immediate concern.
Another matter which Senator FitzGerald and those who oppose this suggestion must be reminded of is the fact that this will give rise to a situation in which potentially effective representatives will be given an opportunity of standing for election in a single-seat constituency, whereas, under the present system, they could never get that opportunity because, human nature being what it is, one could not expect a sitting TD to support or promote a promising fellow candidate who might well become the sitting TD after the next election. Human nature being what it is, the sitting TD would, if anything, promote the weak candidate. The result might well be that weak candidates might be promoted and supported while strong and able candidates might be impeded. If we looked at our own personal experiences, we can all of us think of a few such candidates who, if we did have a single-seat constituency, would now be sitting in the Dáil and would be a significant addition to that House. Under the multi-seat constituency, potential members may never get that opportunity.
I do not want to be taken as condemning the multi-seat constituency out of hand. It has its advantages. Neither do I want to be taken as referring to any particular case, but I think each one of us must concede that what I have said are the facts of the situation. Far from being safe in a single-seat constituency, a representative must always be concerned with what the public reaction to his achievement is. This will keep him constantly on his toes in ensuring that the public do not become either tired of his image and antagonistic towards it, or determined to remove him from political activity. He will have to remain on his toes at every level of political life because he will be the only person on whom the electorate can focus their attention. Under PR there were four or five representatives. Under this proposed system, there will be only one and the electorate's attention will be devoted exclusively to him and to his achievement and on his maintaining his record, both inside and outside the House, will their continuing judgment and support for him be based. Whatever about the arguments in regard to the system of election, I should have thought that initially the whole House here would be in absolute agreement about the benefits to be derived from the single-seat constituency as compared with the multi-seat constituency. I am not at all surprised that Senator FitzGerald in his pretence of opposition to this notion could call on no better advocate in his favour to prove his position than these figures which are based entirely on the exclusion of the personality.
Comment on this
I made my position clear on the Second Reading; we are opposed to these Bills and the quicker they are booted out by the people the better we will like it. However, in case it might be assumed we have no views about this, I want to put them briefly now. May I say that, after listening to weeks of debate. I have come to wonder more and more why people cannot make their point briefly and sit down. That is what I shall do.
Having listened to the various views expressed on this, it is, I think, a fair comment that the single-seat constituency is good for the occupant but bad for the constituents and all the arguments I have heard so far convince me more and more on this point. We have been told about the evils of competition between Deputies of different political Parties, which is understandable, and also about competition between Deputies of the same Party sitting in the same constituency. We are told this is a bad thing. It may be uncomfortable for the occupants but I do not think it is necessarily a bad thing for the electorate and, surely, what we are concerned with is not the comfort of Deputies but the interests of the electorate, the people Deputies are supposed to represent in Parliament.
We are told that the single seat would make things more comfortable and easier for Deputies because they would have a smaller area to represent. Of course it would. A smaller area with no competition either in their own Party or from other Parties would make things much easier, but a Deputy elected in those circumstances would be the only public representative from that area and everybody would have to go to him. There would be no choice. This would not work with the ordinary Irish people. We tend to take our politics pretty seriously and I can well understand that people with strong political views or affiliations would not lightly or willingly go to a Deputy elected in a single-seat constituency if that Deputy comes from another Party. These are the facts of the situation. I know one can point to exceptions, but the general run of the people have strong political views and will not go to a Deputy who belongs to another Party. If this were to operate, they would have no choice, in which case they would probably not approach the Deputy at all.
Look at the position in Britain. Senator FitzGerald has made a point, which is not exactly comparable because there are differences. How does the system operate in Britain? I have spoken to Members of the British Parliament—most of us here have spoken to them on occasion—and the truth of the matter is that many of the Members representing constituencies in Britain have never been in their constituencies until they came to be chosen as candidates. That is quite different from the position here. A Deputy here ordinarily lives in his constituency, has contact with the people in his constituency, has to keep in touch with them; otherwise, he is in danger of losing his seat as a result of competition either within his own Party or from other political Parties. That is tough on him but it is good for his constituents.
In Britain, on the other hand, a Member of Parliament in many cases does not live in the area he represents and probably has never seen it until he comes to a selection conference, either nominated by a trade union or whatever the Conservative organisation is, and is vetted. I believe the fashion now is that not alone do they vet the prospective candidate but also his wife. It is at that stage in all probability he first sees the constituency and comes into contact with some of the people in that constituency and a very select group of people, maybe 20 or so, which is in complete contrast to the sort of selection conferences that operate here in the political Parties. He meets a very select group who vet him and his wife and on whatever basis they have select that person. He then is the candidate. If he is elected, he continues, in practically all cases—and I have checked this with people I know —to live outside his constituency. He makes occasional visits to the constituency but the work is done by a paid official, what they call, I think, a parliamentary agent. He is there in the constituency, but the Member does not live there and only occasionally visits it, perhaps for a general election, et cetera. That is the position in Britain. I do not think that position would be acceptable to the electorate of this country. As I said, this is probably a much more suitable arrangement, much more comfortable, for the occupant of the seat but not to the benefit of the constituency.
I come now to my last point. All this, of course, is a matter of opinion I express, a guess as to what the position would be here if this system operated. Equally, the people on the other side put forward their guesses as to what would happen if we adopted this change, if it were approved in the referendum. The whole point of my argument on this section and on the other sections is that there is no need to experiment. There is no need to take a risk on this matter. The present position of multi-seat constituencies is successful. It operates successfully. It has operated successfully in the life of the State. It has maintained parliamentary democracy in this country. We have no right to take a chance, to take a guess, to leap into the dark and say: "This, in my opinion, in my guess, is what the position would be in Ireland if we changed this." That, I think, is irresponsible.
Comment on this
The more I listen to this debate the more I am inclined to the belief that it would be a disadvantage to have only one TD representing a constituency. I believe that a sizeable majority of the electorate will vote "No" to this amendment of the Constitution when the opportunity presents itself for them to do so.
Much has been said about Deputies and the way they do or do not represent the public. I feel that the Irish people have placed a tremendous amount of trust in the public representatives down through the years. This stems, I think, from the tremendous work of eminent parliamentarians going back to O'Connell, Parnell, the Dillons, Davitt and a whole host of other eminent men. It is difficult for the Irish public to get the image of this type of parliamentarian out of their minds. People have commented here that Deputies were given too much of the wrong kind of work to do. This stems from the fact that before we were an independent State the ordinary man and woman had not that much trust in the Establishment as it was then and they relied on and placed their confidence in their elected representatives. I believe that the Deputies of all Parties have, by and large, down through the years served the public well.
I cannot forsee the ordinary voter throwing away the choice he now has of placing his case before any of three or five men who may be elected in his constituency and I think that this is a wise decision for him to take. As I see it, people approaching their TDs at the present time do not religiously go to a particular Party man. Each and every one of them has his own favourite choice, the one whom he feels will serve his particular case best. Ironically enough this man may not even be the person for whom he voted. I feel that the people will hold on to this position of having a number of people in each constituency from whom they know they will get this service and help and they will have one or other of them to champion their case. The position in this country in that regard is, perhaps, almost unique. The Deputies have given this great personal service and in many of the rural areas a Deputy knows, even in the larger constituencies, a tremendous number of people he represents.
Therefore, I feel that when the ordinary voter gets down to marking the paper he will realise that if he votes for this amendment most certainly it means that he will no longer have the trusted friends who have served him over, perhaps, a few Dáil terms. I think the people are no fools and despite things that have been said to the contrary they understand the present system very well and operate it excellently. A change in the voting system would not bring any benefits to the ordinary member of the public. On the contrary, he would lose his choice of Deputy. Under the present system the ordinary voter has only one day out of three or four years, election day, in which he has to pick out the candidate to whom he will give his No. 1. Many of them vote 1, 2 and 3 down the line religiously, wishing, perhaps, that they could have given No. 1 to more than one. When one is watching a count one sees that many people vote not for Parties so much as for individuals. They vote for the people whom they will approach if the occasion arises when they have problems. I think the Irish people will think twice before they make this change. They have done so before when there was a very attractive bit running alongside this proposition and when they get an opportunity this time they will in no uncertain terms register "No" against this proposal.
Comment on this
On this question of the single-seat versus the multi-seat constituency, I should like to make a few points. The Fianna Fáil Party are determined to get this question through, irrespective of whatever arguments are used against them. One must query their motives. Why there is this insistence? One could understand a Minister coming before the Oireachtas and saying: "This is a good idea, the single-seat constituencies". It depends on whether you agree with single-seat constituencies or not; but what is not understandable is the Minister and the Government coming before Parliament and saying: "We will have single-seat constituencies, irrespective of what the opinion of Parliament is. The Government have decided; we have the strength and that is the position that will obtain."
When you have that attitude, then you ask yourself what is the reason? The reason is obvious. Fianna Fáil are seeking to ensure that whatever happens after the next election, the result will be a Fianna Fáil majority. They are not concerned whether or not it will be a Fianna Fáil majority with multi- or single seats, but they believe that under the multi-seat system, they will not be able any longer to command the majority they had in the past and, therefore, their only chance now is for the single seat, in other words "go for broke". If we win, we do not care; if we lose, we are no worse than we were.
If one considers this position one finds it is at times amusing to listen to the Fianna Fáil Party put forward these arguments. They are utterly incapable of covering up their motives. They will use any argument, the first one that comes to their mind. People like myself who are backbenchers find it amusing to listen to the arguments with very little original thought at the end. You can see the trend right to the top. There is no original opinion. It would be amusing, as I say, to listen to all these except for the horrible thought that often strikes me. Fianna Fáil think the electors can be fooled. A more horrible thought than that is that Fianna Fáil believe it themselves at times. However, instead of being amused by these arguments, one is infuriated at the insistence of the same arguments, no matter how they are countered by intelligent argument from the other side. You seem to have this insistence that "We are right; our arguments are right" and nothing that can be said or done by the other side is of any use. This kind of thing is infuriating and would infuriate one intensely were it not amusing at times.
One asks what is the motive. The motive is to try to get a majority. When they are looking for this majority, one would imagine that they would be able to come before either House of the Oireachtas and say that there is a clamour and a demand for this change. Occasionally some of them, singly, occasionally some of them together, when they get into full cry after the Leader of the House will show you where the demand comes from and suddenly one sees that it comes from the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis, from the 1,500 delegates of the Árd Fheis.
I come from a constituency which is predominantly Fianna Fáil and I know something about what goes on at the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis just as I know the calibre of the Fine Gael Árd Fheis and the Labour Árd Fheis. This Árd Fheis, no matter what anybody says, is an annual outing. All the local branches of the cumann go and have their say and they go home satisfied. We all know that. That is what these things are designed for, particularly when you have a Party like Fianna Fáil. I know the delegates. Some of them are friends of mine and many of them we have entertained in this House after the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis. I know what brings them here. It is the same as brings my own friends. They have no thoughts about making decisions. They come out to enjoy themselves. Admittedly many of them are very sincere, but they come to Dublin to the Árd Fheis——
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator will leave the Árd Fheiseanna and come to the matter in the Bill.
Comment on this
We are told, a Chathaoirleach, that the decision and the clamour for the single-seat constituency, and against the single-seat constituency, if I am not wrong, was made at the Árd Fheis, not here. I think I am right in that, but you bring me back to my train of thought. I think the decision about the single-seat constituency was made at the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis. You are as well aware as I am about what went on there, more so perhaps. I cannot help thinking in looking at the demand for the single-seat constituency made at the Árd Fheis how the Holy Ghost descended on these 1,500 delegates and inspired them. Therefore, the decision is made. To the strains of the legion of the rearguard? That is what we are told happened. When the Leader of the House or a Fianna Fáil Senator has no constructive thought and just gets up and says something, it has to be accepted as gospel by this side of the House. I wonder have we as representatives of the people to accept everything Fianna Fáil say. I want to quote for the House.
Comment on this
I would quote you if you said anything worth quoting. I should like to quote from the Introduction to the Report of the Committee on the Constitution on page 4, paragraph 8, where they say:
Whatever may be said about subsidiary aspects of these provisions we are not aware of any public demand for a change in the basic structure of the Constitution.
They say here that there was no public demand for a change in the basic structure of the Constitution. Here we are spending weeks debating a change in the basic structure of the Constitution for which there is no demand.
Comment on this
I am about to finish. You can talk afterwards and say what is the basic structure of the Constitution. The people are being asked to alter the Constitution and as far as they are concerned this is altering the basic structure of the Constitution. Paragraph 8 goes on to say:
There appears to be general acceptance among the people at large of the institutions provided by the present Constitution.
I am sure that Senator O'Kennedy will hardly deny that PR is one of the things provided by the Constitution.
Comment on this
PR is enshrined in the Constitution. We are now asked to change it by the Fianna Fáil Party to ensure that they will have a majority in the next election. I know Senator O'Kennedy to be an intelligent man and, perhaps, he would like to tell the House what he thinks about that.
Comment on this
I must agree that for once some of the Senators opposite decided to be relevant to the question actually under discussion, that is, this particular subsection of Parts I and II. Of course, this approach was bound to collapse once Senator FitzGerald started to speak. Despite the very commendable effort Senator O'Quigley had made to confine himself to the subsection, needless to say Senator FitzGerald was, as usual, unable to make anything else except a Second Reading speech.
Comment on this
I think I will follow the example of Senator O'Quigley rather than that of Senator FitzGerald. I think I have adequately dealt with the more general aspects of the proposals we are making. Senator O'Quigley maintained that there was not any demand for single-seat constituencies. I dealt with the question as to whether or not there was a demand for the overall proposals we are making when replying to the Second Reading debate. I pointed to the clear indications there were after the last general election that there was a likelihood of proposals being put forward to provide ourselves with a more rational and a more justifiable system of election and representation.
With regard to the question of single seats as such, as has already been pointed out by other speakers from this side, a number of units of our organisation from different parts of the country had resolutions on the Clár of our annual Árd Fheis asking exactly this thing, that there should be single-seat constituencies established. Senator McHugh claims that the Ard Fheis consists of 1,500 people. I would have said that the total would have been nearer to 2,000.
Comment on this
I beg the Minister's pardon: I said the 1,500 was for this year.
Comment on this
It is quite true that the actual number of delegates at the Árd Fheis is limited. That is a necessary thing to do. It is a fact that they come from all over the country from isolated rural parishes, such as those people Senator McHugh has described as his friends. I have heard those people talking about Senator McHugh and they did not describe him as their friend.
Comment on this
Maybe they were. But I hope my friends never talk about me in the way they talk about Senator McHugh.
Comment on this
You should hear them. I shall tell you if you like.
Comment on this
The Árd Fheis is composed of people from all over the country—from urban areas, from rural areas and from all sections of society. Those are the people who are responsible for the fact that Fianna Fáil have been the major Party in this country almost since the day the Party was founded and who are responsible for the fact that we have so well interpreted the minds of the Irish people that we have been in government for 30 years out of the past 36 years.
Comment on this
It is because we have been keeping in contact with the people that we have been able to retain their support. I repeat that I do not know of any body of people in this country who are more representative of a cross-section of the community than those at the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis. There certainly is not any body of people that is more in contact with the people of the country as a whole than the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis, representing as it does every parish in the country from one end of it to the other. This Árd Fheis, this group of people, representative also of our organisation in the areas from which they were sent as delegates unanimously, as both myself and Senator Ó Maoláin believe, but if not absolutely unanimously, practically unanimously, requested this exact thing we are discussing, here, that is, that a system of parliamentary representation by means of single seats should be established.
I am not saying that that constituted a unanimous demand from the people of the country but it certainly indicated that a large section of the people wanted this. As I said, there were other indications also which arose out of the unedifying and discreditable evidence produced by the long recounts, producing different results every time the votes were counted, that there was something amounting to a general expectation that the people would be given an opportunity of ridding themselves of this system of election and representation. In view of that fact that we ourselves in Government and in the Fianna Fáil Party were already aware of the many advantages of single-seat constituencies and the many disadvantages and evils of multi-seat constituencies, we decided to accede to the demands made at our Árd Fheis and to the expectations of the public in general and put forward proposals for a system of representation based on single-seat constituencies.
I do not think I need deal with Senator O'Quigley's reference to the various projections that have been made by people who like to indulge in attempts to forecast the future with regard to the number of Deputies that Fianna Fáil may obtain under the system we propose. Senator O'Quigley described it as the obtaining of 90-odd Members. I think Senator FitzGerald was even more optimistic on our behalf. I will agree with both of these distinguished Senators that it is quite likely that Fianna Fáil will continue for some time in the future to retain the support of the majority in the country.
Comment on this
As to how many Deputies will be returned on behalf of Fianna Fáil, I do not know because, of course, it depends on so many things. It depends, for instance, as Senator O'Kennedy said, on the personalities that contest the various constituencies. Even one of the Opposition Senators admitted that the results would to a certain extent depend on the calibre of the different candidates that oppose one another in different constituencies.
Comment on this
Senator FitzGerald thinks that nothing matters only figures. Personalities, individuals, and so on do not enter into Senator FitzGerald's prognostications and that is why Senator FitzGerald is continuously making a fool of himself.
Comment on this
Both Senator Yeats and Senator O'Kennedy dealt reasonably comprehensively with the many advantages both for the people in regard to their representation and for the country as a whole in the final end product of a better Dáil and people able to give better attention to legislation, and so on, inherent in the system of single-seat constituencies and they also dealt adequately with the many disadvantages and evils of the system of multi-member constituencies and at this stage I do not propose to go into that in any great detail.
I would, however, like to make some further references to this question of safe seats. On this aspect, the Fine Gael Party display even more definitely than on some others their facility for taking two contrary viewpoints at the same time. We have had a number of Fine Gael Senators here taking the same attitude as nearly all the Fine Gael Deputies in the Dáil took—not all, but nearly all—that there would be a large number of these safe seats all over the country and at the same time, we had some Senators here, the same as we had a few Deputies in the Dáil, saying that this country was a different type of country, that we had a more homogeneous community here and these constituencies with definite traditional voting patterns did not exist here.
Comment on this
We had some Senators taking one attitude and some taking the other and the usual attitude of Senator FitzGerald of taking the two himself. He always manages to combine the two diametrically opposed views in the one statement. As I say, Senator Dooge and others maintained that this was not the position and at the same time, others of the Opposition based part of their case on the emergence of these safe seats all over the country. I pointed out before, and other Senators on this side who have spoken pointed out again here, that it is under the present system that safe seats develop.
Comment on this
It is possible to have safe seats where there are large constituencies, that where a comparatively small quota of votes can be gathered up and also where there is this extraordinary and unjustifiable provision for the allotting of votes to candidates for whom they were not cast at all. It is in these circumstances that Deputies can acquire, and have acquired, safe seats to the disadvantage of the electorate in the constituencies concerned. As I say, I do not want to attempt to compete with the eminent Senators on the Fine Gael Front Bench in forecasting what will happen.
Comment on this
Does the Minister really mean that we are eminent and distinguished or is he being sarcastic? He might mean it.
Comment on this
I do feel that it is safe to say that it is practically certain that there will be no uncontested seats in this country and I can definitely say that in so far as we are concerned our candidates are always selected by democratic local conventions.
Comment on this
Like you were the first time you were elected a Deputy.
Comment on this
This is a system that has served us well and we would not be so foolish as to change it. We have had allegations that these seats would be allocated by the Party gauleiters. We just have not got these people in our organisation.
Comment on this
We have not got what the Opposition have been describing as a system of Party bosses.
Comment on this
Our candidates are selected by democratically constituted conventions and I must say that this is an interesting insight that we have been given into the structure of the Fine Gael Party. Indeed, as Senator McHugh will be able to verify, we do not have to go further than the recent Clare by-election to know just exactly who determines who will be the Fine Gael candidates.
Comment on this
The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
In so far as Fine Gael are concerned, this is decided at Party headquarters but in so far as we are concerned, it is decided by democratically summoned and constituted local conventions. So we have this argument that is put forward by the Fine Gael Party, first of all, that we are a homogeneous society and that therefore there are not these strong areas where the people will continue to vote for the same Party. Secondly, we have the argument that there will be these safe seats to be allocated to Party hacks. As I say, the fact of the matter is that there will not be these safe seats and secondly, that so far as we are concerned our system would not permit of the allocation of seats in this way and, thirdly, we have not got that degree of contempt for the intelligence of the electorate that, even if it were possible to select candidates from Party headquarters, we would not do it because we know the electorate, quite apart from our own organisation, would have too much intelligence to accept that sort of imposition. If we had that degree of contempt for the people's intelligence, then, of course, we would have no more representation in the Dáil than the Fine Gael Party has. These safe seats just do not exist and, in my opinion, will not exist and, even if they do, in so far as we are concerned, at any rate——
Comment on this
The Senator went on to say that he does not know how the constituencies will be drawn up. Of course he does. If he read the Bill, he knows that it is provided in the Bill that they will be drawn up by the Constituency Commission. He maintains that our argument is based on the assumption that people must necessarily go to Deputies to obtain things which are theirs of right—conferred on them by legislation passed by the Oireachtas. Of course, we do not base our argument on any such assumption. It is quite clear that there will inevitably be much less of this type of activity under the system we propose. But in present circumstances in which Deputies are in competition, this will obviously tend to become even more common. This is because Deputies are in competition and any Deputy who wants to disabuse his constituents of this idea—I admit it exists among our people because it has been fostered by the system of multi-member constituencies—will find that his colleagues, and even possibly his colleagues in his own Party, will undermine any such attempt. But under the system of single-seat constituencies, it will be possible to disabuse the people of this belief.
In addition, because single-seat constituencies will be of more reasonable size, it will be possible for Deputies to really attend to local matters that require attention. There are such things but under the present system, when Deputies are cluttered up with a lot of things that do not really need attention and when the constituencies are too big to allow them keep in touch with them, the things that really require attention are perforce often deprived of proper attention from the local representatives and are not adequately dealt with by them. It is quite clear the people will gain in better representation from the system of single-seat constituencies.
In addition, it must be obvious that the Civil Service will become more efficient. First of all, a lot of unnecessary matters will not be the subject of representations at all. In regard to those on which representations are made, there will only be the one letter instead of three, four or five letters at present to Deputies and letters also to Senators and county councillors.
Senator Rooney asked me how I will ensure that county boundaries will not be breached under the system of single-seat constituencies. As Senator Rooney should know, this will not be a matter for me. It will be a matter for the Constituency Commission which is provided for in this Bill. In spite of the terrific effort made by the Opposition Parties to insert a second Commission in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, it is really amazing that they were able to ignore the fact there is provision in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill for a Commission. On the Bill where there is not a Constituency Commission, they were making all sorts of allegations about the necessity for it. But where there is provision for it they just ignore it and assume the Commission equals the Minister.
Comment on this
But you did not. You alleged, and your colleagues certainly alleged, that these constituencies were going to be drawn up by me. Senator FitzGerald and the other Senators who made the allegation, such as Senator Quinlan, should know, if they read the Bill, that there is provision in this Bill for a Constituency Commission.
Comment on this
It so impressed the Senators that they wanted two Commissions instead of one. But, when it is in, they assume it is of no consequence at all. Again, obviously they are merely repeating parrot-like the arguments they made the last time in 1959. But their attitude to the Constituency Commission in 1959 was quite different from the attitude they have taken up now. In 1959 they said there should not be any Commission at all and they put down an amendment proposing to delete the proposal for a Constituency Commission. Instead, they said the Minister should take the responsibility for it, that he should bring it into the Dáil, where it could be discussed in the open light of day with the press looking on.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, are we discussing the Commission on this section? I had not known that when I was speaking and I will have to reply to the Minister.
Comment on this
When the Minister embarked on this line, the Chair took it he was replying to the point made by Senator Rooney. I think the discussion, both in respect of what the Minister is saying and the interruptions, developed beyond that point.
Comment on this
But it was because of the interruptions, a Leas-Chathaoirleach.
To reply to Senator Rooney, it will not be my responsibility to try to avoid the breaching of county boundaries, but it will be the responsibility of the Commission. They will be required to do so by the provisions of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. Even the courts can be asked to rule on the situation and I have no doubt that the lawyer members of the Opposition, who specialise in constitutional wrangling, will make sure it will be done.
Senator Quinlan sympathised with Deputies because of all the unnecessary representations they have to make. Of course, he ignored the fact that this arises largely from the fact that they are Deputies in multi-member constituencies. He said that the calibre of Deputies should be improved. The system we are proposing of single-seat constituencies will gradually do that. Each Deputy will be isolated in his constituency and his constituents will be able to see him as the sole representative of the constituency. If he does not measure up to the required standards they will replace him if they are wise; and, if the Parties are wise, they will give the people suitable candidates from which to choose a better representative.
As far as I could interpret what Senator Quinlan said, he appeared to admit that this system was likely to produce good candidates from all Parties and that we were likely to have good candidates opposing one another. Although Senator Quinlan argued there was a need to improve the calibre of candidates, on the other hand, when he came down to saying we could have good candidates from different Parties opposing one another and only one could be elected, he also saw something objectionable in this. I would have thought it an obvious advantage of the system that each Party would find themselves compelled by the circumstances to put forward the best candidate in each constituency, to put forward the 144 best people they could find on the basis of selecting people appropriate to different constituencies, whereas in the present system that incentive obviously is not there. Senator Quinlan does not have to go outside his own Party of Fine Gael——
Comment on this
I would ask you to respect my Independent status.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon —the "rugged Independent" again. He does not have to go outside his colleagues in Fine Gael to see this built-in disincentive for the selection of the best candidates because of the multi-member constituencies. That is exemplified by what happened in the constituency of Dublin North-East, to which I referred already, where the two sitting Deputies found it necessary in response to the instinct of self-preservation to eliminate from their Party a potential danger, a person who was obviously a potential Deputy, but in the system we propose the potential Deputy would be the most desirable addition to any Party and there would not be this built-in incentive to eliminate such people. Rather they could be nurtured and encouraged in the hope that they would build up the Party to a greater number of seats.
Senator Quinlan apparently wants only one good candidate per constituency. I agree that if that situation did obtain we probably would arrive at the situation where we would have safe seats because people would have sufficient intelligence to choose the only one good candidate, if that is all there was. It is quite desirable on the other hand that all the candidates standing for election should be good candidates and that the people should be able to make a choice between them.
I come now to Senator FitzGerald and, as usual, it is hard to know what he is in favour of. He agreed that there were arguments in favour of the single-seat constituency and I was beginning to wonder was it possible that the two Leaders of the Fine Gael Party were outvoted at the famous all-night session; both Deputy Cosgrave who was in favour of our proposal and was known to be in favour of it and who is the titular Leader of the Party, as well as Senator FitzGerald who, during the debate here has been giving undertakings on behalf of his Party, as he describes it. Apparently, both of them were outvoted by the rank and file of the Party but apparently they are both still the Leader of the Party. I must say it is a rather peculiar position——
Comment on this
How anybody could be expected to accept Senator FitzGerald's undertaking on behalf of his Party when not even the Leader of the Party can speak for Fine Gael, I do not know. Apparently, both were outvoted, the official Leader and the power behind the throne, the drafter of such policies as the recent one for the elimination of the rural community. Senator FitzGerald went on to speak about "huge swings" and challenged comment on that. He suggested these are going to occur under the present system. That is another characteristic of the Senator. He makes statements without any substantiation——
Comment on this
——and he assumes that this is the actual fact that obtains. That is all right for Senator FitzGerald. I do not object to him assuming that something is so because he has said it is so but for everybody else to assume that because he says a thing is so, it is so, is too much. Much as I dislike to deflate his opinion of himself I must tell him that so far as we on this side of the House are concerned, so far from assuming that because Senator FitzGerald says such a thing is so, it is so, or more definitely still, so far from assuming that because he says something will be so, it will be so, we believe it is more likely to be wrong than right.
Comment on this
This suggestion of Senator FitzGerald's that despite the contention of his colleague Professor Dooge that there will not be safe seats, that these areas do not exist in this country, there will be these huge swings——
Comment on this
——is completely his unsubstantiated opinion. This is based on Senator Dooge's assumption that there will not be safe seats but the Senator goes on to argue that there will be safe seats.
Comment on this
He has an extraordinary facility for using diametrically opposed arguments because he followed on this assumption that there would be huge swings because of the non-existence of safe seats, by saying that there will be a liberal supply of safe seats for people whom he described as ornaments, for people who would be useful additions to the Dáil but who the people would not elect except for the existence of safe seats, and for people he described as political Party hacks and for a fourth category, substantial subscribers to Party funds. We are going to have this supply of safe seats and in addition we are going to have huge swings because of the non-existence of safe seats, according to Senator FitzGerald.
The Senator seemed to be affronted because I did not deal with this assertion of his that there would be these huge swings. I do not think this deserves any attention whatever because it is so completely illogical and so completely merely the product of the Senator's imagination. Senator Murphy——
Comment on this
That is all it deserves. The other points have been dealt with by Senators Yeats and O'Kennedy——
Comment on this
That is all the Senator is getting about this particular argument because that is all it deserves. It is based on an assumption which is quite logical to Senator FitzGerald but not to us, that is, that anything he says immediately he says it becomes a fact, becomes doctrine. So far as we are concerned we do not believe that at all. If he could only put himself in the position of people who have not the same regard for his unconsidered statements as he has himself——
Comment on this
——perhaps he could see why it is that we do not devote a long period of time to dealing with these statements of his.
Senator Murphy alleges that the whole idea behind this proposal of single-seat constituencies is the comfort of Deputies and the elimination of competition between Deputies of the same Party. The question of the comfort of Deputies does not arise at all although I do think, as did the British Royal Commission which considered the possibility of introducing this system into that country, that a strong argument against the present system is the disproportionate effort and expense and, as the commission says, the unnecessary electoral turmoil involved in by-elections. I think there is a disproportionate effort involved in covering large constituencies, in order to elect a fraction of the representation of these constituencies. For instance, in the recent by-election in East Limerick all parties tacitly agreed that the seat was a Limerick city seat, but despite that, we all found it necessary to go down and canvass the extensive constituency of East Limerick, including rural areas. And Senator FitzGerald found it necessary to organise the disruption of Fianna Fáil meetings and so on——
Comment on this
I want to make another routine protest against the Minister repeating something that I have denied, and a denial of which in a nominal form he has accepted having been instructed to accept it from the Chair previously.
Comment on this
Would Senator FitzGerald deny that instructions were given to Fine Gael students in Dublin to go down to County Limerick and disrupt Fianna Fáil meetings?
Comment on this
I said that no such instructions were given and if any such instructions had come to my notice I would have taken every step to countermand them. I could not say what everybody in the country did or did not do at that particular period. I am certainly not aware that any such instructions were given, nor am I aware that anything of the kind ever happened.
Comment on this
The only thing I am aware of is what happened in Limerick where one Fine Gael student was attacked and had his equipment stolen, and when he went to complain was beaten up in the main street in the presence of a Fianna Fáil TD to whom he protested.
Comment on this
The Minister, to continue on subsection (1) of Parts I and II.
Comment on this
On Senator Murphy's point about the comfort of Deputies, as I say, although this was a Limerick city seat, the whole constituency had to be involved in the election. You can take any other constituency you like in which there were by-elections. For instance, in the constituency of Clare, the whole constituency had to be canvassed, had to be brought to the polls, and all the necessary administrative arrangements over the whole constituency had to be made in order to elect one-quarter of the representation.
While as I say, the question of the comfort of Deputies is not the reason for bringing in this Bill, it is obvious that if in Clare only an area appropriate to the job in hands had to be covered, and that would be a quarter of the constituency, and, similarly in Wicklow, one-third of the constituency, then there would have been, for one thing, less disruption of the proceedings of the Dáil and Seanad and, for another thing, there would have been less demands on the stamina and fewer adverse effects on the health of Deputies, because a smaller number could have been employed and it would not be necessary to press people into service who possibly were not in a fit condition to undertake that kind of activity at the particular time.
The smaller area will result in better representation for the people and also better attention to local matters requiring attention. It will also provide a better opportunity to the elected representative of the people to attend responsibly to his fundamental duty as a Member of the Legislature.
I think it was Senator Murphy also who put forward the rather naive suggestion that people would not go to a Deputy of another Party. I wish Senator Murphy could see some of the files either of the Department of Local Government or of the Department of Social Welfare and he would see that not alone will they go to Deputies of other Parties but that they will go to every Deputy, to every Senator and possibly to every county councillor as well. He will see the vast amount of unnecessary work that is involved for the Civil Service in ensuring that these people who make representations get the exact same reply in the exact same terms and at the exact same time.
Far from people not being prepared to go to a Deputy of more than one Party, I remember the first week that I became Minister for Defence, I got a very gratifying type of letter from an individual who welcomed me to the Department. Although he was not from my own constituency, I was pleased that he had such a high opinion of me. He welcomed me back and welcomed the fact, in particular, that the "other crowd", as he referred to them, had been got rid of. Having dealt adequately with the merits of the Fianna Fáil Party down the years and the demerits of their opponents, he said that no doubt the pension of which he had been unjustly deprived for political reasons by my predecessor, General MacEoin, would now be awarded to him.
It was a fairly voluminous file, and I looked back to see just what exactly the case was and how General MacEoin had so maliciously deprived this man of his pension. I came on a letter with some date in 1954 where General MacEoin, having been addressed "Dear Seán"—I had been addressed "Dear Kevin"—had been welcomed back to the Department. The correspondent thanked God that the "other crowd" who, in this letter, were Fianna Fáil, had been got rid of. I leave it to the Senators opposite to imagine the disparaging references that he made, for instance, in respect of the Taoiseach who had been displaced in 1954, because they would be well able to supply this type of reference themselves.
Investigating the file further I found a similar letter addressed "Dear Oscar". It welcomed back the late Mr. Oscar Traynor as Minister for Justice, and described the appalling injustice that the late Deputy Dr. T.F. O'Higgins had inflicted on this individual by depriving him of a pension over the years. There were all the disparaging references to Blueshirts and so on, and now he was quite sure that justice was going to be done.
There was a similar letter in 1948 welcoming the eventual emergence of the only decent Party in the State, Fine Gael, and the fact that at last the iniquitous Fianna Fáil Party had been got rid of, and no doubt now the pension that this gentleman had been deprived of would eventually be received by him.
Comment on this
That is the position, that the majority of people who approach Deputies about unnecessary things will approach them all. The system that we are trying to get rid of encourages that type of thing, and I do not see much hope of disabusing the people of this idea except by the establishment of single-seat constituencies.
Comment on this
As I said, the file on practically every social welfare benefit and the file on practically every local government grant will disclose that in practically every case in which representations are made by a Deputy of one Party they are made by Deputies of every Party, and also as a general rule by Senators who happen to be located in the area, and in many cases also by the local county councillors.
I do not know that there is any need to refer, certainly in any great detail, to Senator McHugh's contribution. He alleges the Government have decided, by virtue of their majority, that they are going to have this system of single seats. We have not decided that at all, because we cannot decide it. What we have decided is that the people will be given an opportunity of providing for themselves this more normal and rational system of representation.
I have dealt already, and other Senators here have dealt already, with the suggestion that the purpose of this proposal to have single-seat constituencies is to perpetuate Fianna Fáil, and that that will be its inevitable effect. I have invited Senators opposite to explain just why this should perpetuate Fianna Fáil, just why it is that, although they continue to contend that their proposals for the conduct of the country's affairs are better than ours, and just why, in circumstances that we propose here of a clear confrontation in every constituency between the best candidates that each Party can get to put these proposals before the people, it should be that Fianna Fáil will be perpetuated in Government, circumstances in which, for instance, outstanding Fianna Fáil Deputies like the Taoiseach and Deputy Seán Lemass and my gracious colleague, Deputy P.J. Burke, will be able to elect themselves only and every Fianna Fáil candidate will have to stand on his own feet. Apparently this must result in the perpetuation in office of Fianna Fáil because in addition every Opposition candidate will have to stand on his own feet also. No doubt it is because of the fact that there are prominent members of the Fine Gael Party who do not stand on their own feet that people like the senior Deputy for Laois-Offaly are so definitely in favour of the proposals we are making.
Comment on this
I want to clear up one or two points. The first is in relation to the safe seats. What has been said can be summed up by saying that under the multi-seat system, which we have at present, seats are made safe by the excellence of the candidates concerned and by the contributions which they made in Government or in Opposition, but under the single-seat system, seats will be made safe largely by the voting strength of the Party at that period. No individual contribution will be nearly as significant as it is at present under the multi-seat system. Any member who has performed well in the outgoing Parliament is pretty certain to be re-elected under the multi-seat system.
The Minister twisted what I said about one candidate marking another. When we have an outgoing Government, Ministers will all be experienced and will be worthy of being representatives in Parliament, although they may not be fancied by everyone as Ministers. Practically all outgoing Ministers would be a considerable asset to a new Parliament. At present outgoing Ministers are pretty certain of re-election even if there is a strong swing against their Party. They will not be defeated, and quite rightly so. On the other hand, in a single-seat constituency the Opposition have got to decide either to give the Minister a walk-over or put up an outstanding man to oppose him if they think there is a chance of defeating him. The result is there are two good candidates in competition with each other. We need both in Parliament and only one can succeed.
In the vast majority of constituencies, there will be candidates competing who could not compete with either of the two I have mentioned. This is further aggravated by the television age when confrontations of Parties are becoming the rage of the time. In future if we have single seaters, we will have confrontations between those seeking election. Again a big man has to be put up to mark another big man. This will lead to great waste.
The Minister harked back to the long counts. I can assure the Minister that by next week I hope to be able to present to him with my compliments a fully operational electric computer that can carry out any count, whether it is for a Seanad Éireann election, a students' council election in the universities, the Labour Party executive election or any other election under the rational process of PR.
Comment on this
Whether counted by hand or by computer, PR is not in order at this stage.
Comment on this
The Minister argued the long counts against the multi-seat constituencies. This has been running through the debate in recent weeks. I can assure the Minister that there are good tidings in store for him and in future he can drop that argument. It will be like someone saying you cannot go to America because it is too far and the sailing ship takes 30 days—a person who never heard of the jet age or of jets going to America in five or six hours. We will have another system within ten years whether in the single-seat or the multi-seat system.
Senator O'Kennedy made a balanced speech but he appeared to me to attach too much weight to how the legislators will be judged as between dealing with constituency problems and legislative work. A legislator who spends his time legislating is pretty certain to be returned under the multi-seat system and the person who devotes his time to other questions also has a following. Therefore it gives a wider choice.
Senator O'Kennedy also suggested that a sitting TD at present promotes a weaker candidate, that is to say, that a TD who is selected to contest one area will have a very strong say in who will contest a neighbouring area. Are we to believe the Minister when he says that every single-seat constituency will be a republic in its own right? Are we to have republics within county boundaries and single-seat constituencies with inner republics and the local Party bosses, whoever they may be, making the choice unfettered and unlettered? We are generating into a series of mini republics and I do not think that is the way to progress. I do not believe that at the present stage of our development the electorate will give up the freedom and influence they exercise in selecting their representatives from candidates proposed to them by the Parties.
Comment on this
I wonder could the Minister give us an indication of what he proposes to do in the local authority elections? Are we to retain PR or are we to have the singleseaters? No reference has been made to that during this marathon debate.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan's purpose, apparently, in getting up was principally to re-state that, in his opinion, the single-seat system will give rise to safe seats. The Opposition can have it both ways and are insisting on having it both ways. Senator FitzGerald said there would not be safe seats. Senator FitzGerald maintained that the calibre of the Opposition will be reduced, on a change of Government, because Ministers are the most likely to be defeated. On the other hand, his colleague, Senator Quinlan, said Ministers could not be defeated in any circumstances under this system.
Comment on this
Senator FitzGerald definitely said the most likely people to be defeated on a change of Government under the system we propose would be Ministers who would be most closely identified——
Comment on this
It is another manifestation of Ministerial delusions.
Comment on this
Senator FitzGerald said that within the past hour. Senator Quinlan said Ministers could not be defeated under the system of the single-seat constituency unless an outstanding candidate was nominated to mark them.
Comment on this
——they insist on putting forward completely contrary arguments. Fine Gael say there will be safe seats and there will not be safe seats.
Comment on this
The Minister has developed that argument several times already.
Comment on this
The Minister has now replied to the point.
Comment on this
It certainly was. He went on to allege that one of the main arguments used in favour of this proposal is the fact that there were long recounts at the last general election. It is not the actual length of the recounts that I think proved so unedifying to the public as the obvious fact that each count could produce a different result. This undermined confidence in the system. It disclosed that the element of chance which arises from the random selection of votes for redistribution plays a very significant part in the result in circumstances where there is a close result and that, in fact, depending on where the group of votes for distribution is taken from, one candidate or another could be elected. It would be just as logical, just as justifiable, to toss a coin as to base the decision on a count carried out under this present system.
With regard to local authority elections, as Senator FitzGerald knows, the system of election to local authorities is not specified in the Constitution and that does not need a referendum to deal with it: it can be dealt with by legislation. In fact, at one stage, the Fianna Fáil Party had put legislation through the two Houses of the Oireachtas to establish a system of single-seat constituencies but fell for the gimmick that has been tried here, namely, accepted a minor amendment in the Seanad and a general election came and ensured that that did not happen. That seems to be the only hope the Opposition would have now, that they would succeed in getting an amendment accepted here which would delay the proposals so that it would be too near to the date of a general election to put them into operation.
Comment on this
Most of what the Minister said does not merit a reply but there seems to be confusion on what I said in relation to safe seats. The Minister may genuinely have misunderstood what was said on this point. Under the single-seat system, some seats will have a degree of safety which cannot attach to any seat under the multi-seat system. Therefore, for some seats, the degree of safety is enhanced. They become much safer for individuals than they could conceivably be under the multi-seat system under which, if a man does not work for his constituents and is not active in public life, he can be displaced by another colleague, which does not happen in the single-seat constituency.
In the Irish situation, where the number of safe seats will be less than in Britain because there is not the uneven distribution of political allegiances that there is in Britain, the swing in the range between 35 to 45 per cent of the vote will be far greater than in Britain. There is no contradiction whatever between these two statements. The number of safe seats will be much less than in Britain and therefore the swing will be much wider—but the safe seats will be much safer than is the case under the present system with the multi-seat constituency. No Deputy can feel completely safe under the multi-seat system.
Comment on this
I have pleasure in assuring the Minister and the House that this element of chance, which he has suddenly awakened to as being present in a very microscopic way in the present proportional representation elections, will totally be eliminated by the computer programme with which I hope to present him next week— another great argument gone, unfortunately, for the Minister. That, unfortunately, is the price the Minister has to pay for scientific progress. He has to keep his system up-to-date, too.
Comment on this
I think Senator FitzGerald has made a very lame attempt to justify his adopting two completely diametrically opposed assumptions in opposing this. He now says it is the degree of safety he is taking into account. I do not think there can be anything more safe than that some Deputies have retained their seats right from the institution of this Parliament up to the present day. If any seat could be safer than that under the system we propose, it would be a very safe seat indeed. It is absolutely clear that it is under the conditions of multi-seat constituencies that seats can in fact be safe. Needless to say, the number of safe seats will be fewer here. The total number of seats here is also much less than in Britain——
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan maintains that it is only in a microscopic way that this element of chance has influenced elections here. In practically every close result in which a surplus was distributed, this element of chance has entered into the final result. Senator Quinlan maintains that this will be eliminated by computer. In fact, the electoral system can be changed only by referendum. I do not think you can substitute a computer for a referendum, as I understand it. The system is described in the Constitution. If Senators opposite maintain that it is permissible to alter the actual rules for the single transferable vote, that could solve a lot of problems if you could do that without breach of the Constitution.
This would need to be done if the element of chance is to be eliminated whether by Senator Quinlan's computer or by any other means.
Comment on this
I propose that the motion be now put. A little therapeutic treatment may help to banish the delusions from which the Minister is now suffering.
Comment on this
That is a formal proposition and upon that basis, I move that the motion be now put. If it is not done we shall have a continuation of the same ranting and raving——
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley has informed the Chair that he wishes formally to move the closure of this debate. There can be no further debate until this matter is determined and it can be determined only by the Cathaoirleach.
An Cathaoirleach took the Chair.
Comment on this
The Chair understands that the motion is being made that the question be put. The Chair feels that the matter has been sufficiently debated and that the question should be put.
Comment on this
In order to leave no doubt about the position, now that you are in the Chair, Sir, I formally move that the question be now put.
Comment on this
The Chair is about to do so. The motion is: "That the question be now put".
Comment on this
I am not always wrong.
Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh fo-alt 1º i bPáirteanna I agus II in a chuid den Sceideal".
Comment on this
Do rinne an Coiste vó táil: Tá, 28; Níl, 16.
Do you agree with this result?