An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–176 of 512. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 6 of 1968 ›
We have now come to the consideration of subsection 2º of Part I and subsection 2º of Part II. The Chair wishes to point out that subsection 2º and amendment No. 1 will be discussed together. There will not be a discussion on the amendment and a subsequent separate discussion on subsection 2º.
Comment on this
The form of the amendment is to delete subsection 2º and replace it by a substitute subsection. If both section and amendment are discussed together, the question to be put at the end of that joint discussion will be: that subsection 2º stand part of the Schedule.
Comment on this
I understood that the amendment would be taken before the section.
Comment on this
The Senator should understand that, strictly speaking, the whole of the Schedule should be debated as one part of the Bill. The House is being convenienced by the splitting of the Schedule for debate purposes. This is an unusual procedure.
Comment on this
That was not mentioned when it was read out yesterday.
Comment on this
Is the House satisfied with this method of debate?
Comment on this
Subsection 2º and the amendment will be discussed together and at the conclusion of that debate, the question will be: "That the subsection proposed to be deleted stand part of the Schedule." If that is carried, the amendment will not be put. If that proposition is defeated, the amendment can then be moved and voted on.
AN SCEIDEAL.
SCHEDULE.
Comment on this
Tairgim leasú 1:
I gCuid I, fo-alt 2º a scriosadh agus an méid seo a leanas a chur ina ionad:
"2º Is do réir na hionadaidheachta cionmhaire agus ar mhodh an aon-ghotha ionaistrighthe a toghfar na comhaltaí.";
agus
I gCuid II, fo-alt 2º a scriosadh agus an méid seo a leanas a chur ina ionad:
"2º The members shall be elected on the system of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote."
I move amendment No. 1:
1. In Part I, to delete subsection 2º and substitute the following:
"2º Is do réir na hionadaidheachta cionmhaire agus ar mhodh an aon-ghotha ionaistrighthe a toghfar na comhaltaí.";
and
In Part II, to delete subsection 2º and substitute the following:
"2º The members shall be elected on the system of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote."
Our colleague on the university panel, Senator Stanford, has indicated his wish to have his name included with those of us who have tabled this amendment. It means then that the whole Independent panel here who have taken part in this debate are standing together on this amendment and I think in that case our view and our approach—I find it rather difficult with regard to Senator Cole, who is quizzing as to whether he should be included in the Independents or not; we will leave that to the House to decide——
Comment on this
(Longford): Is it fair for a Leader of a Party to canvass in the House? Is it in order to canvass new members for your Party within the House?
Comment on this
Is it in order for Senator Quinlan to inform us that a Senator who is absent supports this amendment?
Comment on this
It is in order. It is up to the Members of the House to accept it or not.
Comment on this
I am doing it at the request of Senator Stanford and I expect that he will be here to lend his support to this very desirable provision. In moving it, the House might reflect back to 1959 when the university panel moved together and issued a very strongly worded condemnation of what was then being done, and we like to feel they played a very big part in enlightening the public on the issue. Now we are coming together again to raise the present issue. The amendment seeks to ensure that the alternative to be put to the electorate will be that of the single-member transferable vote system. It is first the single-member constituency and then that the vote should be the single transferable vote, in other words, the by-election system as operated to date.
In moving this, speaking personally, I am not in any way abating one whit my support for the proportional representation system, and my advice to the electorate is to hold fast to the freedom they have and to hold fast to the system that has served them so well, but we are interpreting the public mind, in common with all the newspapers of the country, bar the Irish Press group, when we say that the only other system the public are interested in as an alternative to the present system of proportional representation is the by-election system, and, indeed, if the purpose of the Government were really to find out what the people wish and to be guided by them, they would have given the public a choice of three systems, the present one, the by-election system and the non-transferable or the “straight” vote system. They would have given a choice of all three and it is legal quibbling to suggest that they were held by the present legal position from doing so. No such restraint is provided in the Constitution.
The Constitution in Article 47, in dealing with the referendum, this very sacred and prized possession of any democracy, makes it possible for the Government to consult the people on any proposal. The only distinction made is if the proposal seeks to amend the Constitution, the course taken at present of actually presenting a Bill to the public has to be adopted. On the other hand, if the Government wished to say there are three possible systems, our present one, the by-election system and what is now called the "straight vote" system, they could have posed the question and ascertained the majority opinion. I believe there would have been agreement by all Parties and by all Independents with this course. There would have been an acceptance then that whatever clearly expressed preference emerged would be accepted by all and the necessary legislation at the stage of writing it into a Bill and presenting it for formal endorsement for changing the Constitution would be then treated as a formality.
That is the democratic way but unfortunately it has not been accepted. Therefore, we have to make the best of what we have got. The best of what we have got is that we have a Bill which will pose two systems to the people: the present system or another. It has been clearly demonstrated by all leaders of public opinion speaking on this, by the vast weight of public opinion in newspaper articles, by discussions and television interviews that the public do not want the choice presented to them in 1959 to be offered to them again on this occasion.
They have rejected the straight vote or the straitjacket vote. They do not want this right of preference taken from them. They are interested in and many have been impressed by arguments for better local representation by means of more manageable constituencies. Many are interested in that and I believe would vote for that if they had the transferable vote. Indeed, many commentators seem to hold that there would be a majority in favour of the by-election system.
Comment on this
I am in favour of proportional representation but I am sufficient of a democrat to believe that the people should have the choice they really want and that the referendum should not be perverted in the present way. If we are forced only to give a choice between two systems, we have to give the one we have and we should give the most likely to be accepted of the other. Indeed, if we were in doubt about that, surely the previous choice has been offered and rejected and rejected at a time when there was far more credence in it, when we had the personality of our President pleading for it, than now. Again, I repudiate any suggestion by the Minister or anyone else that at any time I yielded to anybody in my admiration for Mr. de Valera as a parliamentarian. Our best memory in this House has been of his conduct here as a parliamentarian. You can read the debates: you can read of his conduct on the Committee Stage debate here.
Comment on this
I challenge the Minister again that at any stage——
Comment on this
——any comment of mine could in any way be construed as unjustly critical.
Comment on this
I am talking about the election campaign. You have the hypocrisy to come in here and talk about esteem.
Comment on this
I am denying formally that I had any part in the last Presidential election campaign or in any Presidential election campaign. I expect the Minister to accept that.
Comment on this
The Senator has made a formal statement in regard to any action of his and this must be accepted by the Minister and by all Members of the House.
Comment on this
Thank you. We wish to give the people a choice that means something—in fact the two systems the people know. They know the system we have and how it operates. They also know the system that operates in by-elections. They are keen on comparing them. If we are to act here as interpreters of public opinion, we can say without fear of contradiction that this is the choice the people want. Indeed it would be very much in balance as to which they would choose. I hope they would choose the proportional representation system, but if they chose the other, I believe it could be made workable also because the essential feature of it is the transferable vote. This means that it would rule out all forms of back-stage deals. In other words, there would be no role any longer to be played by the blocker candidate who would just come in simply to prevent some candidate being elected.
In the single-seat constituency, if you have two Parties, say, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, or if we take a Fianna Fáil area where the candidate is in his home town, if a local Independent, or preferably an Independent with no leanings towards Fianna Fáil, were prevailed on by Fine Gael to go forward on his personality, he would probably get sufficient votes out of the home region of the Fianna Fáil candidate to prevent the election of that candidate. The final results might be say 8,000 votes for the Fine Gael candidate, 7,500 votes for the Fianna Fáil candidate and 2,500 votes for the blocker candidate.
Comment on this
If the blocker candidate were in the field, then you could examine his preferences but it is reasonable to expect that the majority of his votes would have gone to the candidate who had the greatest affinity, local affinity and a certain affinity of political outlook. Consequently that candidate would have been elected.
What is the alternative? The alternative is that the Party threatened would go to the candidate who is about to make a nuisance value of himself and there would be back-stage deals which would buy off this man and keep him from being a candidate, thereby securing the election of the Fianna Fáil candidate. That is not right or proper and it introduces an element of bargaining into political life which is all wrong. Of course, between political Parties with three Parties up, it would lead to the same type of deals. In other words, if you have one major Party like, say Fianna Fáil, with 40 per cent of the votes and the other two have 60 per cent between them, if those two Parties share a common feeling that the Government had been too long in power and that they should put them out, do you think this situation is not likely to breed certain local deeds?
All this would be obviated by having the ability to transfer votes. If the vote can transfer, one need not worry about a neighbour going up because he has his own personality against yours but you have your Party and there is the national question as to whether your Party should be the Government, against which he offers nothing. Consequently, you are away ahead at that stage. If the vote were transferable, you would welcome him in the field and let him run; there is no need to make any suggestion to him. He is entitled to run and try his strength. In the last analysis, if he does not get sufficient votes, the votes will be transferred and the final election will come down to a conclusion between the two. I like to think that in any Party convention—at which I have never so far had the pleasure of being present——
Comment on this
——in selecting a candidate for a by-election, we would have an announcement in the paper of the names of four or five people who are considered to be possible candidates—a couple of relatives and a couple of others. That is reasonable enough. That is democracy. If you are electing a captain of a hurling club, again, there is a difference of opinion as between three or four nominees. The supporters gauge their strength and, as in the American Presidential campaign, there is a tally as to the number of votes one's candidate is likely to get. As the convention date approaches there may be a feeling that one candidate may not make the grade and therefore it is decided to insist that there shall be one vote taken in the convention and no more. Six candidates have, therefore, to face the vote in the convention. One gets 25 votes out of 100, one gets 21, another 19, another 18, another 17, and another 15 and the man who gets the 25 votes is declared elected.
If you want a straight vote, non-transferable, then I challenge the Parties, whether Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour, to show that henceforth they will operate their conventions in the same manner and that the first past the post is the candidate that will be offered to the electorate in each constituency. Of course, they will not agree to that and I do not think they should because the 25 votes that a man gets when there are six in the field does not mean that he is the best candidate for the constituency.
Comment on this
Does the Senator favour having this system of selection of candidates in the Fianna Fáil Party in future?
Comment on this
If Fine Gael are going to have PR at their conventions in future, you will have some great fun. You will want your computer.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
The day that Senators can show me returns from a Party convention where the straight vote has been operated in selecting the candidates is the day they can say they are sincere in advocating the merits of the straight vote.
Comment on this
I do not take the system of proportional representation. I take the system of electing a person at any convention. The system is that the supporters of the various candidates gauge their strength. One finds that there are only 10 or 12 supporters for one candidate out of a hundred and, therefore, that he cannot be elected, and he withdraws. The voters then look around and are free to vote for someone else. That makes a field of five. Again the assessments go on until the fifth man drops out and so on until it is recognised that there is a front running candidate and when the vote is taken at the convention it is between two.
Comment on this
I am speaking of the single seat in a by-election. I am not speaking of what contortions go on in selecting candidates at present when you are selecting three or four.
Comment on this
I know how it operates in various connections. I have seen as many elections for chairman as Senator Yeats, or more——
Comment on this
The Senator said he had never been at a convention.
Comment on this
——not alone in this country but in America. In all cases this idea of six candidates going up for chairman and the top of the six being elected just because he got 25 out of, say, 100, just does not happen. There is no sense in that. There is the transferring that takes place, which is an ordinary human approach to the problem.
Comment on this
That transfer of votes is what is done under the transferable vote system except that the transferable vote calls for a more genuine and more honest assessment of the candidates than is available in the type of withdrawal that I have suggested because in the case of withdrawals the candidate withdraws but tries to drive a bargain as to how his votes will go and with his knowledge of how the others have voted he can assess who is likely to succeed and he can climb aboard the best rolling bandwagon. In the case of the transferable vote, the voter sits down in the privacy of the polling booth when he is filling out the form and considers genuinely and honestly what candidate he favours most, whom would he like to support and, if he is not available, which one of the others would he like to support. That is the ordinary democratic process. It is the process of living together. Consequently, that should be the choice offered to the people.
If we wanted to see the evils of the distorted results the non-transferable vote system gives, we had the classic example recently of the BGA elections which were conducted on the non-transferable vote system. In those elections one Party got about 70 per cent of the votes and the other, spearheaded by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, got 30 per cent.
Comment on this
Although they got 30 per cent of the votes, they got only six seats. Lo and behold, one of the shell-shocked survivors of that catastrophe has been so mute in the House since then that he has not yet come out of his fox-hole. I refer to Senator Willie Ryan, who succeeded. But even in his success, we had the distortion of a system which showed a success with 80 votes while poor, esteemed Deputy Corry with 420 votes could not make it. That is a providential warning to the Government Party as to how iniquitous this system can be.
Comment on this
You do not want these violent swings. That does not provide a Government with stability.
Business suspended at 1 p.m. and resumed at 2.30 p.m.
Comment on this
Before the adjournment, I was making a plea that, as the Government are insisting that only two choices can be given to the people, one of which must be our present system, the only second choice that makes sense is that of the by-election system. While I do not for a moment hold that that system is comparable with or preferable to PR as we have it with our three-seat constituencies, I still believe that the people are asking to be given this choice as expressed through their representatives or through the press. The clamour from the press for this has been very remarkable and has been expressed just as strongly by the provincial newspapers as by the dailies. It is unrealistic for the Minister to picture that all these are in one grand coalition against him and his Party. That is not so. All these papers, I think, would enthusiastically welcome the Minister's belated conversion to the transferable vote.
I think I got an admission before lunch that the political Parties, especially the Fianna Fáil Party, have no intention of using the straight vote technique to select candidates in single-member constituencies if that unfortunate position arises. They would not believe that in a situation where you have five or six candidates proposed, the candidate who got 25 out of 100 votes should be selected automatically. They go through the ordinary democratic process of selection just as we have gone through it in selecting the captain of a hurling team or the president of a graduates' association or any such selection of one person. We have always used a form of transferable vote. If you think back you will see that is what happens. You have been engaged at certain stages in these processes and you have talked about it and tried to get the candidate who got the greatest measure of agreement. I have never seen a report published from a Party convention selecting a candidate for a by-election where the candidate had not got a clear majority of the votes cast. I do not think it should be accepted here and I appeal to the Minister: if what you are trying to impose on the country you believe is not good enough for Party conventions, that is a sorry state of affairs.
Even at this stage the Minister would show himself worthy of his engineering training if he were to acknowledge the superior claim for inclusion in the ballot of the transferable vote. All political commentators believed that the Government would take this course and the redoubtable commentator, Backbencher——
Comment on this
——said, in his wisdom, that the Government would do a slight somersault in behind Fine Gael and the Labour Party and accept the by-election and would win the referendum based on that.
Comment on this
He has not acknowledged his mistakes. He is much less keen and anxious to acknowledge his mistakes than even the Minister and that is saying something. It is far too serious a national situation to continue on the present course which can only lead to catastrophe and a major catastrophe for the Government Party, especially for the Minister who is piloting this Bill.
Comment on this
That may have good effects because "out of evil cometh good", and if it does lead to a return of the Minister and his Party to democratic methods and an appreciation of democratic institutions and also an appreciation by them that no minority rule should be accepted in committee or in Government, then the long hours we have put in here may bear some fruit. At this stage I make one last 5 minutes to 12 appeal to the Minister——
Comment on this
I think 12 midnight is the hour of decision and at just two minutes to midnight——
Comment on this
——I appeal to the Minister to show some appreciation of the will of the people and give them the type of choice they desire or, perhaps better still, to withdraw the two Bills altogether and really go to the people in a proper referendum and give them the choice, 1, 2 and 3. I could then pledge my own support and I believe I could pledge the support of my party of Independents that whatever the will of the people would be we would accept it and endeavour to make it work.
The following referendum would be merely the rubberstamping of a decision that had been obtained from the people by proper and legitimate use of the referendum. If we cannot have that course, if it involves too much loss of face by the Minister, he should be prewarned and should give the people the choice they want and save his Party from the ruin that faces them.
Comment on this
I wish to support this amendment. I do not want to embarrass my colleague, Senator Quinlan, but I do not regard myself as being a member of any Party. A "party of Independents" is somewhat of a contradiction in terms. However, I am supporting the amendment and in doing so, I should not like to be taken as agreeing with Senator Quinlan's idea that this was a second best, that best of all, we should have proportional representation and worst of all, of course, the straight vote. I believe that if I were concerned in a debate in which I had all three systems to judge between, proportional representation, the transferable vote, and the so-called straight vote, I could see myself coming down in favour of the system that this amendment is set out to support.
I say that for two reasons: first of all, I think the average person is happier if he is not faced with an absolute, out-and-out choice. Most of us having to consider such questions have some doubts in our mind, and we would like to be able to express those in terms of preferences rather than as yeses or noes; in other words, shades of opinion rather than black and white. I think also there is substance in the argument that in a constituency where there is a multiplicity of interests, it would be very difficult to get a single person to represent all these. I am not talking about political interests in the sense of Party political interests; there are other types of interest to do with political advantage in the more general sense, in the sense of the good of the people, which must be pressed by different sections of the constituency and which one single person could not embrace in his own personal experience.
It would be better, of course, to have more than one person representing the constituency. If a voter has to look at a list and ask: "Which of these will represent my interests best?", then he should have a choice and be able to say: "If A cannot look after me, then perhaps B can do it. He belongs to a different party but he has the right kind of interests," and he expresses this in the form of a preference. For these reasons I feel myself strongly in support of this amendment.
Comment on this
If ever Senator Quinlan faced himself with a political miracle, he certainly did so today in proposing this amendment. Whatever might have been the possibilities for the Norton amendment in the Dáil, it is very clear that the Quinlan amendment in the Seanad has no prospect of success, not just because the Fine Gael Party are against it, not just because the Labour Party are against it, and not even because the Fianna Fáil Party are against it, but because, believe it or not, Senator Quinlan himself is against it. In the face of all that united opposition, it would take nothing short of a miracle to achieve the result which Senator Quinlan seeks here today.
If Senator Quinlan is serious that the Parties should adopt at their conventions the system of election which he favours for the country, then we can look forward to great confusion at political conventions from now on at Fianna Fáil level, at Fine Gael level, and even at Labour Party level, because they have now announced from now on they will put up at least two candidates wherever their prospects of securing one seat seem reasonable. So much for the Senator's consistency: if you believe in it for the convention, you must believe in it for the national system and vice versa. I am not aware that any Party uses PR for its conventions, and if there is any inconsistency, it lies with the Opposition Parties, according to Senator Quinlan's thesis, because they appear, on the one hand, to support PR, but on the other hand, at their conventions they do not adopt it. However, that is a matter that Senator Quinlan can work out with the Opposition Parties of whom he is so ruggedly independent.
This amendment refers to what is called the single transferable vote, and I think Senator Ryan, on the Second Stage of the Third Amendment Bill, pointed out this would be more properly referred to as the single partly transferable vote. We had a little dissertation this morning on emotional and evocative terms such as "straight vote", although I think it is equally fair and appropriate to say that this is not a transferable vote in the fullest sense of that word. It is partly transferable in that, as the Minister, Senator Ryan, and many other speakers have pointed out here, the only transfers that are effected are those of candidates who happen to be at the lower end of the poll. The supporters of the continuing candidate can have no chance under the system of effecting a second preference. As Senator Ryan pointed out also, those who are really in favour of the transferable vote system should also propose a system of evaluation of the preference votes for every candidate, not just for the lower ones, so that the votes of all the electorate and not a selected portion of the electorate would be taken into account. The same objection applies to the PR system of election. The transferable votes are again transferable in a very limited sense of the word. It is for that reason amongst others that I would oppose this system.
In my own particular view, a more cogent reason for opposing it is the firm belief that it would lead to a situation that the Opposition Parties for the time being, whoever they might be—and Fine Gael and Labour still cherish the hope that at some stage Fianna Fáil will hold that status—will join forces at each general election to defeat the Government Party. That is one of the facts of political activities. Their basic intention would be to get rid of the Government. We have seen this in by-elections and no blame to the Opposition for that intention. That is the reason they are there. The result would be that if at each general election we would have the Opposition Parties combining to defeat the Government and far from the stability which in many ways, possibly not absolutely, is a desirable virtue—there must be some degree of it—we would have constant changes of Government leading naturally to an interruption of Government policy after almost every election.
These are matters which should arouse our opposition to this measure, even that of those who think that to defeat the Government at some time is desirable, but it is equally desirable that for a reasonable period the Government should be allowed to formulate programmes, push them through, and be judged on them. I think this highly desirable situation would be in much greater jeopardy under the single-seat transferable vote system.
Apart from that, I should like to say to Senator Jessop that, while he made reasoned arguments in favour of consideration of this matter, one of the matters which apparently he is concerned about is the difficulty of getting one person to represent all the views in a constituency. I think Senator Jessop will agree that in the final analysis, after a candidate has been elected, he is still the only one to represent the wishes of a divided electorate. Whether the candidate is elected under the straight vote or the single seat transferable vote system, we still have the regrettable situation, so far as Senator Jessop is concerned, that one man with one mind and one personality represents what might be a divided electorate. This may or not be. What is true if this is one of the defects of the straight vote, if it is a defect which I do not accept, is equally true of the single-seat transferable vote system. Accordingly I join with Fine Gael, with Labour, with Fianna Fáil and even with Senator Quinlan in opposing this proposed amendment.
Comment on this
The point at issue is to allow the electorate to have a choice.
Comment on this
Is maith liom a thabhairt faoi deara go bhfuil na hóráideacha ag dul i ngiorracht agus tá fúmsa leanacht den dea-shampla. Sé an fá ar chuir mé m'ainm leis an leasú seo go mbraithim gurbh é an cuspóir is tábhachtaí atá rómhainn i leasú seo an Bhunreachta ná Dáil-cheantair aonair a chur ar fáil. Ceapann an tAire gur mó go mór an maitheas a thiocfadh as Dáil-cheantair aonair a chur ar fáil, is cuma cén sórt vótála a bheadh ag gabháil leis, ná as Dáil-cheantar ilTheachta. Mar sin, táimid ar aon intinn faoin méid sin. Agus más é sin atá uainn nach ceart dúinn gach dícheall a dhéanamh chun an cuspóir sin a bhaint amach agus chun a chinntiú go mbainfear amach é?
Ach má cheanglaítear an Dáil-cheantar aonair leis an vóta díreach, sé mo bharúil láidir go mbuafar ar an dtairiscint. Cuimhnimis go bhfuil breith tugtha ag pobal na hÉireann ar an dtairiscint chéanna seo 9 mbliain ó shin agus cén fhianaise atá ann go bhfuil pobal na hÉireann tagtha ar mhalairt intinne faoi ó shin i leith?
Táimid ag iarraidh orthu anois a rá agus a admháil go ndearna siad a mbotún 9 mbliana ó shin. Creidim féin nach féidir a bheith ag súil le haon fhreagra eile uathy an turas seo ach an freagra céanna a thug siad naoi mbliana ó shoin.
Ach tig linn rogha nua a chur chuchu an turas seo agus creidim féin go nglacfaí go réidh le tairiscint nua ina mbeadh an vóta ion-aistrithe á cheangal leis an Dáil-cheantar aonair. Anois ní hionann sin is a rá gur fearr nó gur cothraime liom an vóta ion-aistrithe ná an vóta díreach ach tríd an vóta ion-aistrithe a chur chuig na daoine is fearr go mór an seans go mbainfí amach an Dáil-cheantar aonair. Tá sé chomh símplí leis sin.
Leis an dtairiscint mar áta sí tá chuile sheans go bhfágfar muid leis an sean-chóras agus leis na hoilc agus na díombuanna ar fad atá ag roinnt leis. Níl a fhios ansin cén fhaid eile a fhágfar muid faoin gcóras sin mar is ar éigin a d'fhéadfadh Rialtas ar bith leasú ar an mbonn céanna a chur chuig na daoine nó a chur ós cómhair an phobail agus a rá gur diúltaíodh dó fé dhó taobh istigh de 10 mbliana. Má theipeann ar an iarracht seo beidh sin le rá—gur diúltaíodh don tairiscint seo faoi dhó taobh istigh de dheich mbliana. Ní bheadh sé de dhánaíocht ag Rialtas ar bith tairiscint den chinéal seo a chur arís faoi na toscaí sin. Mar sin, tá faitíos mór orm nach bhfuil á dhéanamh againn leis an dtairiscint seo sa riocht ina bhfuil sé ach ag buanú an tsean-chórais. Anois níl sé ró-dheireannach fós an t-athrú a dhéanamh agus ar mhaithe leis an aidhm is tábhachtaí a bhaint amach, sé sin, an Dáil-cheantar aonair a chur ar fáil, d'iarrfainn go dúthrachtach ar an Aire glacadh leis an leasú seo.
Comment on this
Senator O'Kennedy has achieved the impossible here today and has thrown his hat into the ring as the potential leader of a national Party. He has found himself in the position of being able to reconcile Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, Senator Quinlan, and everyone else. That is a great achievement and goes to show what can be done——
Comment on this
——when people set their minds to it. The difficulties of the Fianna Fáil Party, in trying to get rid of proportional representation, arise from the fact that history and the facts of the case are all against them. It is necessary, unfortunately, to repeat some facts which have been distorted, and which continue to be distorted, by spokesmen from the Government benches. It is quite clear that the Fianna Fáil Party suffer from some form of national inferiority complex which is not shared by a majority of people in this country. We had the Minister for Education, Deputy Lenihan, recently telling the Daily Telegraph that the revolution of 1916 was a mistake. We had a distinguished Member of this House, a former Minister of State, much respected by all and well loved by all of us, who yesterday wanted us to go the further distance of adopting the British system in relation to our constitutional position. He said we ought to get rid of our Constitution altogether, tear it up, throw it out, and not be bound by any Constitution. It is necessary to point out that, that way, lies anarchy and total power for any Government, without the courts intervening at any time to restrict the Government in arbitrary powers.
We have the further example of the national inferiority complex from which Fianna Fáil now suffer in that they want us to go over, holus bolus, to the British system of voting. They think that, because proportional representation was adopted by Arthur Griffith and put into our Constitution in 1922 by a committee of experts of the Provisional Government at that time who examined all the Constitutions of the world and took from them all that was best—because we did that in 1922 and because we did it again in 1937 — that is not good enough because it is not what the British have. Therefore, we are being urged to take what the British regard as best, that is, their system of elections, which I shall shortly demonstrate does not cure the evils to which Fianna Fáil say the present system of proportional representation gives rise.
Let it be said quite clearly again that the 1922 Constitution provided for the election of Members to Dáil Éireann upon principles of proportional representation. There was a variety of systems, any one of which might have been adopted.
Comment on this
The 1922 Constitution was not put before the people.
Comment on this
The people had no chance to consider it. It was put before them on the morning of the election.
Comment on this
The 1922 Constitution could have been rejected by the people——
Comment on this
Whatever deficiencies there might have been—and I do not admit there were—in the adoption of the 1922 Constitution——
Comment on this
They did not get a chance to read it at all. It was the same morning as the election. How could they reject it when they did not get a chance to study it? It is ridiculous talk by Senator O'Quigley.
Comment on this
And Fianna Fáil were not there because they preferred to go out. On a constitutional law debate, I shall not be drawn into the business of 1922 because I was not born then.
Comment on this
From 1922 until 1932, the 1922 Constitution was capable of being amended by ordinary legislation and——
Comment on this
It could have been amended by referendum, only you put an end to it.
Comment on this
——was, in fact, amended by ordinary legislation. Senator Yeats has been interrupting me. I am sure he will have an opportunity of speaking at a later time when he can make his contribution——
Comment on this
It could be and was, in fact, amended by Act. Senator Yeats and all Fianna Fáil will agree that it was amended to the extent of removing the Governor General and the Oath——
Comment on this
It was a perfectly harmless Oath which you were able to take and come in and say meant nothing. It was supposed to be an empty formula.
Comment on this
When Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932, and got an overall majority in 1933, they had the power then to amend the 1922 Constitutions by ordinary Act of the Oireachtas. They amended other sections, but they did not amend the provisions of Articles 26 nor did they then amend the Electoral Act of 1923 which provided for the particular form of proportional representation which was to be used in implementation of the procisions of Article 26 of the Constitution of 1922. No—there was nothing wrong with it in those days. A simple Act of Parliament could have changed that in the same way as a simple Act of Parliament abolished this Chamber, to suit the wishes of President de Valera in the 1930s.
Comment on this
There was nothing wrong with proportional representation up to that time. Then, when it came to 1937, President de Valera found nothing wrong with proportional representation. So far from finding anything wrong with it, he put it into the 1937 Constitution—and there is no doubt that that was not put in because of pressure from the British Government.
Comment on this
That particular Senator should keep his mouth shut. He is not a witness to facts. A Dublin jury did not believe him recently.
Comment on this
The Chair warned Senator O'Quigley before on this matter.
Comment on this
I trust I shall be permitted to make my speech. I ask for the protection of the Chair.
Comment on this
Might we now hear Senator O'Quigley, without interruption?
Comment on this
The 1937 Constitution was then framed, after careful consideration, by President de Valera. Not alone did he not leave it to the Oireachtas to decide from time to time the particular form of proportional representation which might be used but he solidified the position in the 1937 Constitution. He decided we would not have single-seat constituencies and said no constituency should have less than three seats. He then wrote into the 1937 Constitution that the system of proportional representation should be by means of the single transferable vote in multi-seat constituencies—and there was no British Government then with its gun to the head of the Irish nation to compel him, and the whole of the Fianna Fáil Party, to adopt proportional representation. That was done by a sovereign people who, as they say, in the noble Preamble to the Constitution "Do hereby adopt, enact, and give to ourselves this Constitution" for the regulation of their affairs as a sovereign people——
Comment on this
And you tried to make every Article a controversial one. You would like that one to be one, too.
Comment on this
——in examination of the provisions of the 1937 Constitution, as was our duty and our right. Eventually, that Constitution was put to the people and adopted by the people as the Constitution—for which I have every respect and every affection.
Comment on this
Might we hear Senator O'Quigley, please, without interruption?
Comment on this
I suppose that remark by the Minister is a perfectly pleasant and correct remark? That kind of remark brings no rebuke from anybody.
Comment on this
The 1937 Constitution was adopted by the people, having been recommended to them by the Fianna Fáil Party and Deputy de Valera, as he then was. On that occasion, Deputy de Valera, looking back over 15 turbulent years of the young State, had something to say of proportional representation—and it bears repetition. He said at column 1343 of Volume 67 of the Dáil Debates:
The system we have we know: the people know it. On the whole it has worked out pretty well. I think that we have a good deal to be thankful for in this country; we have to be very grateful that we have had the system of proportional representation here. It gives a certain amount of stability, and on the system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties.
He was not content to leave it at that and he went on to say:
I think we get, probably, in this country more than in any other country, better balanced results from the system we have. If you take countries where proportional representation exists, you get better balanced results than you get in the other countries.
We have heard a great deal about Hitler and Mussolini's Italy, and so on. He said that we get the benefits of PR in reasonably balanced legislation here, better than in any other country which he had read about or knew about. Do not forget that from the point of view of the Fianna Fáil Party, they have always claimed that Mr. De Valera was a statesman of international renown. When he was speaking in 1937, these were the words of an international statesman, a man of wide vision, great experience and great renown. These are the words which for Party political purposes they want to get rid of. If this was a communist country, they could rewrite the Dáil Debates and try to rewrite history as it was done after the deposition of Stalin and Khrushchev.
Comment on this
They tried to do it in the book "Facts About Ireland".
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator would continue with his speech on the amendment.
Comment on this
In 1935, and I do not want to be unnecessarily repeating——
Comment on this
You are very good at going back to 1925. In 1935 we had another renowned statesman, the ex-Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass and the former President and former Tánaiste, the late Mr. Seán T. O'Kelly, who in the debates on the 1935 Electoral Bill, were extolling the value of PR——
Comment on this
I should like to remind the Senator that these matters have been referred to and dealt with on the Second Reading.
Comment on this
I agree, but I am merely trying in this matter——
Comment on this
——to bring together in as terse a fashion as is possible with the numerous interruptions, all the arguments and facts relating to PR. However, I will go on to 1959 and leave Deputy Lemass and the late Mr. O'Kelly, then Minister for Local Government, extolling the virtues of proportional representation and saying that as long as we had it, there would never be gerrymandering. I take it that when you have single-seat constituencies, you can gerrymander whatever way you like. In 1959, after all this repeated affirmation of PR in 1937 by Fianna Fáil, by the international statesman, now the President, Mr. de Valera, this issue was put to the people and the people decided that PR was a system they knew and wanted to retain. What is the position in 1968?
Comment on this
Ten years later, when we have had PR for 46 years, there has been no demand except the organised demand in the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis but apart from that, there has been no spontaneous demand from the people for this change. The Minister has clearly told us that the whole press of the country is against Fianna Fáil and because of that we in Fine Gael, and I suppose the Labour Party, have been given a present, by the Minister, of the whole press except the Irish Press group, because they are now the coalition press. In some magical way according to the Minister, we have been able to control them and to get them to write editorials and to get political correspondents to write articles condemning the Government. This applies not only to the daily newspapers but to the weekly papers as well. The whole press is against them and the fact that they and all the organs of public opinion are against them is a fair indication that this proposal to abolish PR is brought before Parliament and is to be put to the people, not because there is any demand or any need for it but because it suits the particular difficulties of the Fianna Fáil Party at present.
It is well to recall that on the last occasion when a similar Bill came before Parliament, the great fear and the whole complaint was that the continuance of PR would breed minority Parties and give rise to coalition government, consequent instability and great difficulty in putting through programmes for economic expansion. This is what the present Taoiseach had to say when he was concluding the debate here in the Seanad when the Bill had already been defeated on the Report Stage and was about to be defeated on the final stages in 1959, at column 1667, volume 50 of the Seanad Debates:
I believe that this whole problem is bound up with our economic future. I am quite prepared to concede that PR, as it has evolved at the present period at any rate, has not hindered this Government in the slightest in implementing a broad programme of economic expansion. Not only has it not hindered the Government but the Government has given proof that they are carrying on with that programme. It is possible, however, that against the background to which I have referred and in the changing political scene in this country, we might in the years to come see a situation arising whereby many small groups representing minority interests will have a say in government far in excess of that to which they are entitled.
In that speech the Taoiseach was conceding the rights of minorities to have representation in Parliament but disputing their disproportionate say in government. At column 1668 he said:
We believe it is impossible for a Government to make progress under such conditions. We believe that is is not only possible but very probable that such a situation could develop here——
Small groups having a say in excess of that to which they are entitled——
and it is for that reason we ask the Seanad to restore these two provisions in the Bill which we will ultimately ask the people to adopt in their own interests....
We must pause here to consider what has happened since 1959. So far from there being a multiplicity of Parties and small groups and so far from the Government being hindered in putting through their programmes for economic expansion, the contrary has been the case. I do not think any member of the Government will say that the Government have been hindered, because of the existence of proportional representation, from putting through their First Programme for Economic Expansion and neither can they blame proportional representation for the breakdown of the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. They blame the latter upon external circumstances. It is not proportional representation that has caused difficulties. None of the difficulties which arose arose as a result of proportional representation. Proportional representation has not hindered the country's advance and, if the country's advance has been hindered, then that is due to the failure of Fianna Fáil to devise proper policies for the country.
That was the view in 1959 and I have not heard very much talk in the course of this campaign against proportional representation about the multiplicity of small Parties. The Minister for Local Government has devised a new set of excuses which have as little reality and as little to commend them as the set of excuses devised in 1959. So far from proportional representation creating a multiplicity of small Parties, the fact is that the small Parties we did have have gone out of existence.
Comment on this
We are neither the barbarians nor the cannibals that Fianna Fáil are. We do not eat up anybody.
Comment on this
Clann na Talmhan has gone out of existence. The National Labour Party and the Irish Labour Party mended their differences and have come together to form one Labour Party. Sinn Féin is no longer represented.
Comment on this
They did not take their seats. The Clann na Poblachta Party has gone out of existence.
Comment on this
——and, as often as the Senator repeats it, I shall have to reply that it is an ignorant statement. The facts produced in Appendix 11 of the Report of the Committee on the Constitution in 1967 show quite clearly that, under proportional representation, we have been left with three Parties—Fine Gael, Labour and Fianna Fáil. No matter what Fianna Fáil try to do and no matter what system of election is devised, there will always be three Parties—Labour, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, though the hope is, of course, that Labour will ultimately be eliminated.
Comment on this
Mark you, when the Labour Party jointed the inter-Party Government in 1947 to 1951 and in 1954 to 1957, they remained independent. They were not swallowed up. They are still independent and they always will be. The fact that people join in partnership for the benefit of the nation does not mean they are being swallowed up. In that context, what I find extraordinary about the present Fianna Fáil Government's condemnation of coalitions is the fact that, at the same time, this country is supposed to be seeking membership of the Common Market. What is the Common Market but the Grand Coalition of all time? The Council of Ministers in the Common Market countries will decide what laws we will pass here, irrespective of whether or not we like those laws. We are supposed to be trying to join the Common Market. That is a coalition and the Fianna Fáil Party by the constant condemnation of coalitions are certainly providing astute observes of the political scene here with plenty of ammunition to use against Fianna Fáil, if they are the people trying to get us into the Common Market; apparently they do not think it is possible for groups of people to work together in harmony. If they find it impossible to work in harmony with their own, how much more difficult will it be for them to work in harmony with groups of foreigners?
Comment on this
Which would Fine Gael rather have—their own Government or a Coalition?
Comment on this
Which would Fine Gael prefer—single-Party Government or Coalition?
Comment on this
I will not answer the question because the answer is perfectly obvious.
Comment on this
If the people do not choose to elect, though they have the power to do so, a Fine Gael Government, then I, for my part, will be quite happy to work with the Labour Party in an inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
Mark you, the present Taoiseach did not think so badly of inter-Party Governments in 1959 because he had this to say about such Governments. I am glad the Senators opposite have prompted me to read this. It is column 1668 of volume 50 of the Official Report of the Seanad:
I do not think they were disappointed so much with the performance of the inter-Party Government as with the manner in which they were able to break up and disintegrate from within.
There is criticism of the manner in which the inter-Party Government decided to go to the country. I do not withhold my ensure from them for that, but, mark you, the present Taoiseach thought well of the performance; he was then Minister for Industry and Commerce and he knew something about the strides that had been made in industry by the inter-Party Government. He thought well of the inter-Party Government.
As I say, the present system has not, in fact, produced a multiplicity of Parties. Neither has it produced a multiplicity of Independents. At the last general election, the Independents were practically wiped out by the electorate so that, at this stage in our political development and at this stage of our political maturity, the electorate themselves have found that they do not want small Parties, even under proportional representation, and they have decided that they do not want very many Independents. They have come down in favour of three political Parties and that is likely to be the pattern, although Fianna Fáil would like, under the straight vote system, to get rid of the Labour Party. It is only a very short hop from that to what they have in Soviet Russia and what they had in Nkrumha's Ghana. It is only a very short hop to the idea of just two Parties and another very short hop to the idea that one Party is obstructing the whole system of government. The argument then goes that it is a waste of time having an Opposition. Immediately the one-Party system evolves. It is a very short hop from two to one and, judging by the speech made by Deputy Lemass, which I read the other day, that seems to be his outlook too: there will always be only one Party in government and that will be Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
And, of course, a fortiori under the new system. It might be as well now to have a look at the British system of voting, a system so much beloved of the Fianna Fáil Party. Recent history has shown that it is neither a fair nor an equitable system. It does not necessarily produce stability. I do not know of any phrase in the English language which approximates to the long-standing phrase that we have in Irish “Cothrom na Féinne”, but the idea of “Cothrom na Féinne” is deeply-embodied in the Irish people and PR as it so turns out is the very thing that gives that fairness and that equity which has long since become a characteristic of our people. It seems to me to be wrong to say that at any time the government in power should be the products of the votes of a minority of the people. That seems to me to be essentially undemocratic. It may produce a Parliament which can work but it seems to me to be wrong to say that a minority of the voters can decide who will be the Government. That is the way the system that is organised in Britain operates.
One has only to look at the election results for 1964 and 1966 in England to see the position. These results I have taken from page 21313 of Keesings Contemporary Archives. We find that in 1964 the Labour Party got 317 seats with 44.2 of the votes. The Conservatives got 303 with 43.4 of the votes. The Liberals got 9 with 11.1 of the votes, which is a quarter of what the Labour Party got. Republican Labour got 1.3, and then there was the Speaker. In 1966, the Labour Party got 363 seats with 47.9 of the votes. Conservatives got 253 seats with 41.9 of the votes. Liberals got 12 seats with 8.5 and Republican Labour and others got 1.7. The interesting thing there is that a minority of the voters, 44 per cent in 1964, were able to return a Government. That may be a means of getting a Government but, to my mind, it is undemocratic that the minority should have the right to choose the Government.
The other interesting conclusion to be drawn from those figures is that, even with the straight vote or with the British system of election in 1964, they did not succeed in getting stable government or in getting a working majority, because out of a total of 630 seats, the Labour Party got 317 and the Conservatives and Liberals together got 312, that is to say, the Labour Party had a majority of five out of a Chamber of 630, which is much smaller than one seat out of 144 in this country. That is supposed to be the system that is designed to give stability but it was not a very stable government from 1964 to 1966 because it went out in 1966 and it then got its present majority.
Having done that, it is very interesting to see where further the straight vote leads. I do not know to what extent the Fianna Fáil Party will accept these findings I am going to give them, the findings from the recent Sunday Times poll which was reported in the Sunday Times of 21st July. They make very interesting reading. The Sunday Times poll was designed to find out from the people which of four alternative types of government the people interviewed would favour. These were the results: To continue with the present Government, 22 per cent; a Coalition Government, 30 per cent; Government under Mr. Heath, 15 per cent; Conservative Government with somebody other than Mr. Heath, 22 per cent.
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley knows very well what he wants and where he wants to go.
Comment on this
The interesting thing about this particular poll, to all intents and purposes the same as the straight vote system, is that in Britain with the British system of voting, having these fine swings from Labour to Conservative, the majority of those interviewed preferred Coalition Government.
Comment on this
I am using the basis that Fianna Fáil are proposing and on that basis the British people want Coalition Government.
Comment on this
Presumably Conservative and Labour Party.
That is the kind of product you get from the straight vote. The Minister for Local Government says: "That is not a majority". Of course it is not. That is the first past the post system: that is the straight vote result. Is anybody going to say that that is truly representative of the wishes of the British people at the present time? That is the kind of system the Fianna Fáil Party want foisted on the Irish electors.
Comment on this
I want to say something else about PR and I think that this is a matter to which the people of this country should give very serious consideration. Of course at the present time we have in France a system of election that gives strong government and it has given an overall majority to General de Gaulle and Monsieur Pompidou who has now been thrown out. However, people selected Monsieur Pompidou apparently and somebody else determined that he should not be there, that it should be somebody else. That is the way the French work it. They have a strong Government and we have seen the results of strong government there. Let there be no mistake about it—and I do not mind making this prophecy here—I have no doubt in my mind—this of course is based on two contingencies, one being that PR would be abolished—but if PR were abolished, I have no doubt that within a matter of ten or 15 years by reason of the fact that you will always have a majority of the people not voting for the Government Party, because that is the way the straight vote system would work, and by reason of our history, you will find disturbances similar to and perhaps much more violent than those which occurred in Paris. We had a lot of that in this country from 1922 to 1947. We got rid of it in 1947 when we took the last step on the road to complete independence as a sovereign people and got rid of the External Relations Act.
Comment on this
Would the Senator come back now to the amendment?
Comment on this
I want to say that the great merit PR has established in our history and in our circumstances is that, as I said on the Second Stage, and it bears repeating, whenever there is any group in this country dissatisfied with the state of affairs and that is when they ought to form a political Party, they have some chance of getting representation in Dáil Éireann under proportional representation. Under the other system, they will have no chance whatever. We did have here in the election of 1957 four Sinn Féin representatives elected in four different constituencies. They never took their seats in Parliament but they exercised their right and the people exercised their right to elect them, and once they did not function and the people saw it was useless electing them further, they elected no further Sinn Féin representatives. We have had no trouble to speak of from that element of our society since 1947. There has not been a shot fired at a policeman in this State since 1947 and since 1947, the Ministers of State can go around in State cars without detectives in cars before and behind them.