We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 177–341 of 512. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 6 of 1968 ›

It was hard to maintain it.

Comment on this

We completed the job; that is something that cannot be denied.

Comment on this

I emphatically deny you completed the job. You made a mess of it.

Comment on this

You sold the country.

Comment on this

That is the same sort of old cliché, the same sort of ignorant statement——

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley will continue with his review on amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

That is something proportional representation has brought and continues to bring, domestic peace and tranquillity to the country, which is the first purpose according to political theorists and indeed practical politicians for which the State exists. The most important service this country has, apart from the setting up of our courts, is that we have a police force and a defence force so that we can be protected without aggression and disturbance in our ordinary daily lives, and proportional representation is a system that enables dissident elements in this country to remain quiet.

You can always say to them: "If you have a point of view, put it to the people. You got four of your members in in 1947." Clann na Poblachta and Clann na Talún got in and eventually as time went on they faded away. I do not want to say any more on this particular amendment.

Comment on this

You did not say anything on it yet.

Comment on this

I have not spoken yet on the amendment. I can say that we have taken our stand for proportional representation in 1968 where we stood in 1959 and we believe that the best method of election in this country, the best system of election, now that we have had it for 46 years, is proportional representation under multi-seat constituencies and that being our view, we are not concerned with the second best.

Comment on this

I should like to intervene very briefly on this point, in relation to the amendment we are discussing. We must acknowledge the fact that the system proposed here would enable a Deputy to be elected by a majority of the people. He would not be elected unless he had secured some 50 per cent of the votes or unless he was the last candidate left, not having reached the quota. In the same way under proportional representation, a quota of votes is laid down and no candidate except the last can be elected or can secure election until he reaches that quota which in that regard is a majority.

That is the difference between the system of the straight vote and the system of proportional representation, or the single-seat constituency with the transferable vote. In the case of the single-seat constituency with the transferable vote or in the case of proportional representation a minimum target mut be reached before a Member of Parliament is elected. In the case of the single-seat constituency with a transferable vote, it takes at least 50 per cent of the votes and anybody who gets over 50 per cent of the votes in the process of counting must be regarded as a person having secured a majority of the votes.

The straight vote system would enable a person to be elected by a minority of the votes. I pointed out that in Great Britain, as would be the case here if this system were adopted, there are many Members of Parliament in the House of Commons elected with less than 33? per cent of the votes. That could not be regarded as a majority of the votes. Remember, in a straight vote system there is no quota or minimum number of votes to be secured in order to be elected. It is a case of whoever gets the largest number of votes, and it does not require that the largest number of votes should be a majority of the votes. Any system that requires majority decisions is a fair system. It is a democratic system and that is why the system of proportional representation or the single transferable vote is much fairer than the proposed system.

Irish people are fair-minded. They believe in majority decisions and at every club meeting up and down the country when matters have to be decided, it is by a majority of the club members. You would not have a situation in clubs—they would give up soon—in which any minority in that club were to get a decision in their favour if they were not a majority of the members voting. For that reason, and by reason of the fact that we have taken our stand in relation to the system of voting which we know at the present time, that is, the present system of proportional representation, that is the attitude of Fine Gael now. We have not closed our minds to the possibility of a better system of election but we are in favour of whatever system will ensure that majority decisions will be reached and that people who are elected will be elected either with a majority or with a pre-determined quota to ensure that they will have reached that particular level before being regarded as getting a decision, whether it be a decision of a club, as I have mentioned, or whether it be a decision in a constituency containing 30,000 or 40,000 men, women and children according to the area of the constituency concerned.

The new system proposes an average number of 20,000 persons. I have no objection to the number of people that might be decided on in a constituency, but what I do object to is that a minority of that community would have the power to send a representative instead of the majority of that same community.

Comment on this

Is dócha go bhfuil sé ar aigne ag daoine eile labhairt ar an leasú seo agus b'fhéidir go bhfuil sé ar aigne ag daoine labhairt mar do labhair an Seanadóir O'Quigley ar an mBille ar fad agus gan tagairt dá laighead a dhéanamh don leasú ach de réir deallraimh, sa treó sin atá an Seanad ag dul faoi láthair, sé sin, an díospóireacht a bheith ar an mBille ar fad in ionad an leasú a phlé. Ar eagla go ndearmadfar go bhfuil leasú ós ár gcomhair, tá mé ag ceapadh go bhfuil sé chomh maith dom tagairt a dhéanamh dó mar de réir deallraimh ní bheidh a thuille tagairt don leasú atá ós comhair an tSeanaid fé láthair. Is deacair freagra ceart a thabhairt ar an méid atá ráite cheanna féin mar do labhair cuid de na Seanadóirí ar an leasú agus labhair cuid eile acu, cosúil leis an Seanadóir O'Quigley, ar an mBille i gcoiteann.

Tugtar cead dom i dtosach tagairt a dhéanamh don mhéid adubhairt an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin. Mar is eól dó, aontaíom leis gurab é an rud is tábhachtaí atá in intinn an Rialtais, agus im intinn féin, go háirithe, ná na suíocháin aonair a chur ar fáil. Siad na mí-bhuntáistí a bhaineas leis an gcóras atá ann fé láthair an rud is tábhachtaí ar an leasú ar an mBunreacht dár liomsa. Ní hé sin le rá nach bhfuil tábhacht ag baint leis an gcóras toghacháin chomh maith. Ins an gcóras atá ann faoi láthair tugtar móran vótaí do dhaoine áirithe agus ní tugtar ach an t-aon vóta amháin do dhaoine eile. Ar chaoi ar bith, tá mé ar aon aigne leis an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin gurab é an suíochán aonair an rud is tábhachtaí. Dob é a bharúlsa gurab fhearr an dá rud a dheighilt ó chéile, sé sin, an córas ionadaíochta agus an córas vótála.

Conas d'fhéadfaí é sin a dhéanamh? Ní fheicimse slí ar bith chun é a dhéanamh. Tá an córas ionadaíochta agus an córas vótála leagtha síos sa Bhunreacht faoi láthair. Ní fheadar an bhfuil an Seanadóir ag moladh an dá rud a bhaint amach as an mBunreacht —gan ach córas an tsuíocháin aonair a chur isteach i dtosach agus gan rud ar bith a rá faoin gcóras vótála, sé sin, ligint don Oireachtas an cheist sin a réiteach nó b'fhéidir í a shocrú i Reifreann speisialta amach anso. Ní léir dom slí ar bith eile chun an rud atá ar aigne ag an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin a dhéanamh. Deir sé go bhfuil an córas atá molta sa leasú ag teastáil ona daoine ach níor theaspáin sé gur mar sin atá an scéal. Ní dóigh liom gur féidir é sin a theaspáint, go bhfuil fianaise ar bith ann gur mar sin atá an scéal.

Comment on this

Tá sé le léamh sna nuachtáin.

Comment on this

Tá ach ní scríobhann ach duine amháin na haltanna seo sna nuachtáin. Níl iontu ach daoine aonair, ní ionadaithe poiblí féin iad. Níor labhair ionadaí poiblí amháin i bhfábhar an chórais seo go dtí anois sa Seanad. Ní raibh duine ar bith sa Tigh eile, sa Dáil, i bhfábhar na tairiscinte atá ós ár gcomhair anseo. Tá sé fíor gur mhol an Teachta Ó Neachtain leasú ach dubhairt seisean nach raibh sé i bhfábhar an córais seo ach cheap sé go raibh seans níos fearr ann go gcuirfí na suíocháin aonair ar bun dá mbéadh an córas vótála seo sa tairiscint. D'admhaigh sé go raibh a fhios aige gurab é an vóta díreach an córas ab fhearr.

Comment on this

Sin é díreach a thárla.

Comment on this

Deir an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin gur dóigh leis go bhfuil sé seo ag teastáil óna daoine ach caithfidh sé a admháil nach bhfuil ansin ach a thuairim phearsanta féin. B'fhéidir go bhfuil an tuairim cheart aige. Nílim a rá nach bhfuil ach ní fheicim slí ar bith chun é sin a chruthú ach tré vótáil a dhéanamh. Ní féidir vótáil a chur ar siúl maidir leis an dá thairiscint seo, sé sin, idir suíocháin aonair agus an vóta díreach agus idir suíocháin aonair agus an vóta ion-aistrithe. Níl slí ar bith chun é sin a dhéanamh. Ní féidir ach rogha a dhéanamh idir dhá chóras, de réir mar a fheicimse é, idir an córas ionadaíochta agus an córas vótála a chéas sa tairiscint agus an córas ionadaíochta agus an córas vótála atá sa Bhunreacht faoi láthair. Níl a fhios agam an amhlaidh gur maith leis an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin, mar adúras, an dá rud a bhaint as an mBunreacht agus gan ach an córas ionadaíochta a chur ar ais, sé sin, nach mbéadh sa Bhunreacht ach go mbéadh Dáil-cheanntair ann in a dtoghfaí Teachta Dála amháin, gan tagairt ar bith a bheith sa Bhunreacht don chóras toghacháin.

Is dóca go bhféadfaí é sin a dhéanamh agus dá ndéanfaí amhlaidh, is dócha go mbéadh sé de chead ag an Oireachtas socrú a dhéanamh faoi an gcóras vótála nó d'fhéadfaí Reifreann eile a chur ar siúl ina dhiaidh sin ag tabhairt seans don phobal rogha a dhéanamh idir an vóta díreach agus an vóta ion-aistrithe.

Comment on this

Sin é an caoi is fearr.

Comment on this

B'fhéidir gurab é sin an caoi is fearr ach de réir mar a fheicimid é ó thárla go bhfuil an dá rud leagtha síos sa Bhunreacht fé láthair luíonn sé le nádúir go leagfaí an dá rud síos sa Bhunreacht arís sa Reifrinn. Ach más amhlaidh go nglacann muintear na tíre leis an dtairiscint seo ní fheicimse nach féidir seans a thabhairt dóibh rogha a dhéanamh idir an córas vótála, an vóta díreach, agus córas an vóta ion-aistrithe amach anseo tré Reifreann eile más gá é agus má theastaíonn sé Ó cuid mhaith de na daoine.

Níl aon fhianaise ann go nglacfaidh éinne leis an vóta seo ach cuid de na Seanadóirí go bhfuil an leasú á thairiscint acu. Níl siad uile i bhfábhar an chórais seo. Mar adúbhras níor labhair Teachta ar bith sa Dáil i bhfábhar an ruda seo. Tá a fhios agam go ndubhairt an Seanadóir Ó Conalláin gurbh é seo an rud a bhí ag teastáil óna daoine. Dá mb'fhíor é sin cheapfaí go mbeadh cuid de na Teachtaí ar aon chuma i bhfábhar an ruda seo. Dubhairt an Teachta Ó Neachtain féin sa Dáil go raibh sé i bhfábhar an tsuíocháin aonair. Dubhairt sé nach raibh sé i bhfábhar an leasuithe ach go raibh sé sásta glacadh leis chun córas an tsuíocháin aonair a fháil.

Mar is eol don Seanadóir Ó Conalláin, is é mo thuairim féin gurbh é an suíochán aonair an rud is tábhachtaí ach nuair nach bhfuaireamar aon treoir, cuirim i gcás, ón Coiste ar an mBunreacht faoin gcóras toghacháin seo ní h-ionadh go gcuirfí an córas ab eól dúinn a bheith ar an gcóras is fearr ós comhair an phobal.

Comment on this

Níor chuir sibh an cheist chucha.

Comment on this

Níl aon tslí ann chun trí rogha a chur ós comhair na ndaoine sa reifreann céana. Ní féidir ach Bille a rith agus a fhiafraí an bhfuiltear i bhfábhar an Bille nó nach bhfuiltear. Mar a dubhairt mé, má ritear an Bille seo, má ghlacann na daoine leis, is féidir seans a thabhairt i réifreann eile, más gá é, athrú a dhéanamh ar an gcóras vótála.

As I say, in replying to the debate so far there is a certain amount of difficulty because some Senators have dealt with the amendment, whereas others like Senator O'Quigley, have insisted on making Second Reading speeches. Before we get completely into a Second Reading debate, I thought I should at least deal with what had been said on the amendment which I understand is what is, in fact, before us.

Senator Quinlan puts himself forward as the great interpreter of the public mind and up to now has been saying that what we should be trying to do is interpreting the public mind and that we should act in accordance with what the public wish. He himself says that this is what the public wish, that they want single seats and what is called the transferable vote but still he says he is not in favour of it. According to his own words, he is not in favour of what the public want.

Comment on this

But I want to give the public a choice. I want to give them a proper choice. I am a democrat.

Comment on this

However, Senator Quinlan's computer has apparently told him that that is what the public wish.

Comment on this

All the newspaper editorials.

Comment on this

The peculiar thing is that not one public representative has said that he favours the transferable vote until, today, two Senators have expressed themselves as being in favour of this system—Senator Jessop and An Seanadóir Ó Conalláin. Senator Quinlan himself whose name is down to the amendment says he is not in favour of it.

Comment on this

Therefore, we now have on the record, of the two Houses of the Oireachtas, two people as being in favour of this system. I do not know how Senator Quinlan establishes, despite that, that the majority of the people want it. I cannot see any way of deducing that the majority of the people want this from the fact that only two Members have so far expressed themselves as being in favour of it. Senator Quinlan says that the people should have three choices, but the fact of the matter is that there is not any way in which the people can be given three choices. The people can only be asked at a referendum whether they are in favour of the proposals in the Bill and the Bill must surely propose to substitute for the present constitutional provisions in connection with the electoral system some other provisions and cannot propose to establish two separate systems of election and representation. The people can only be asked the question do they approve of the proposals in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill and the answer can only be "yes" or "no". There is not any way of choosing between three proposals on the basis of answering "yes" or "no".

Senator Quinlan suggested that the proposals could be submitted under Article 47 subsection (2) to the people, but these proposals are confined to Bills that come within Article 27, that is, Bills which the President cannot sign until there is what we call an ordinary referendum, that is, a referendum not dealing with an amendment of the Constitution. Article 47 subsection (2) cannot be used to ask the people to express preferences between hypothetical choices as a kind of gallup poll. When a Bill is the subject of a referendum under Article 47, if the people veto it it cannot be signed by the President, and if the people do not veto it the President signs it and it becomes law. It must be obvious that this machinery could not be used as Senator Quinlan suggests in order, as I said, to have something like a gallup poll.

There is not any way, then, of giving the people three choices. In any case, even if there were, the only possible result would be that it would split the vote of those who wanted the advantages of single seats and I am inclined to suspect that it would be in the hope of doing that that Senator Quinlan put his name to this amendment. He would like to have three different proposals so that the votes of those people who see the advantages of single-seat constituencies and the disadvantage of multi-member constituencies would be split between the two. In fact, it cannot be done.

The fact is quite clear when Senator Quinlan says that he is putting forward the suggestion because it would have a better chance of defeating the system that he is in favour of. I do not think that even Senator Quinlan could expect us to believe that——

Comment on this

That is democracy.

Comment on this

——that he wants the present system to continue; that he believes that our proposal has little or no chance of replacing the present system but, in order that the system that he says he wants retained would have a reasonable chance of being displaced, he wants this proposal to be put forward. I think the fact is clear that Senator Quinlan realises that the proposal we are making will be accepted and he would like to find some way of splitting the votes of the people in favour of single-seat constituencies and in the realisation that what we propose is going to be accepted he is making a last desperate effort at least to hang on to the system of voting which discriminates as between voters. I think his references to the election of a captain of a hurling club, to the selection of a candidate at a convention and so on, are just intended to be funny because, of course, there is no comparison whatever between that and electing the Dáil Deputies who represent different policies or, at least, pretend to represent different policies. There is no question of a different policy at the election of a candidate at a political Party convention or at the election of the captain of a hurling club or any of these other things.

I fully agree, as far as I am concerned, the obtaining of single-seat constituencies is the principal thing but that does not mean that there is no importance attached to the system of voting. I agree that the actual system of voting is relatively unimportant and personally, if I thought that the obtaining of single-seat constituencies would be impossible with the proposal for the straight vote but would be certain with the proposal for this system of voting —unfair, undemocratic and discriminatory as it is—then I would certainly be in favour of the course of action that would result in the advantages of the single-seat and would ensure getting rid of the evils and dangers of multi-member constituencies.

But I do not see that that is the position. I agree the main objective is to get the advantage of single-seat constituencies and get rid of the disadvantages of multi-member constituencies. Since this was a matter for the Government and since there was no indication given from any source, from the informal Committee studying the Constitution or any other source, we naturally put forward what we believe to be the best system of election. It is the only one that is democratic, which treats each voter in exactly the same way and which is fair to everybody, both to every voter and every candidate of a political Party.

The straight vote part of the proposal does something very important in itself. It proposes to establish for the first time here the democratic principle of one man, one vote. It proposes for the first time here that every voter should be treated in exactly the same way, that every voter should have the same consideration paid to his opinion as is paid to every other voter. This contrasts with the present system which discriminates in a completely arbitrary and unjustifiable way between voters. Without carrying out any intelligence test or any test of responsibility on the individual voter, it takes certain groups of voters and allocates to them multiple votes—as many votes as they want practically—the total number of votes being controlled only by the number of candidates who choose to offer themselves for election.

It encourages irresponsibility in the exercise of the franchise because a person can decide to vote for one candidate after another, even though that candidate has put forward no realistic proposals for the conduct of the nation's affairs. He can do this in the knowledge that the system is so rigged as to ensure that, whatever else happens, his vote is going to be continued to one of these candidates after another until eventually it is allocated to a candidate who is able to secure some reasonable amount of support for his proposals from the people. As I pointed out before, there is no justification whatever for this. This vote is finally allocated to a candidate, not on the basis that the voters decided he was the best candidate on offer, or that his policy was the best on offer, but many times it is allocated to him on the basis of an opinion that he is the second worst of all those on offer to the people.

Comment on this

He gets the quota.

Comment on this

What in the name of God is Senator Rooney talking about? What has quota got to do with it?

Comment on this

That is all the Minister knows about it.

Comment on this

I assure Senator O'Quigley I will deal with Senator Rooney's contribution to the debate. But the point is that the present system of the transferable vote discriminates between the voters on no democratic grounds. It may be that if there was some way of establishing the degree of intelligence or of responsibility of each individual voter, there might be some reason then for allocating differential voting power to different members of the community. But it is not practicable to do that. There is no way of finding these things out. Therefore, the only fair system that can be adopted is to give every person's vote the same value. This system does not do that. It discriminates against the majority. That, I have no doubt, is what led Deputy Dillon and other members of the Fine Gael Party to refer in such disparaging terms not only to the system but also to the people who devised it in the first instance.

Senator Quinlan says that this proposal was demanded by the people. I have pointed out that not one single public representative supported it until today when two Senators supported it, and Senator Quinlan was not one of them. It is not that public representatives did not get every opportunity of doing so. I agree that certain newspapers have been advocating this for some considerable time, but there is no evidence that the people asked for it through the press as Senator Quinlan said. Certainly, the public representatives got every opportunity. Admittedly, the proposal has been mooted in the papers since long before the Bill was actually introduced. As Senator Quinlan says, it has been strongly advocated in the papers. Any arguments in favour of it have been well and truly put. If the people wanted it, the public representatives have had reasonable opportunity of finding that out and complying with the wishes of the public.

In addition to the fact of its being mooted in the newspapers, there is also the fact that Deputy Norton's amendment was put down while the Second Stage debate was still proceeding in the Dáil. That debate dragged out for some considerable time. There was a period of time between the conclusion of the Second Stage and the start of the Committee Stage. Due to the delaying tactics of the Opposition, there was some considerable time before the amendment was actually reached in the Dáil. During that time these newspapers, these organs of public opinion, were representing to the people that Fianna Fáil were still open to accept this. Therefore, if there was any desire on the part of the Opposition to agree with what Senator Quinlan says is public opinion, they got ample opportunity of doing it. If there was any desire to obtain agreement, there was certainly plenty of time for that to be indicated.

But there was not any attempt. As far as we in Fianna Fáil are concerned, we made up our minds on this from the very outset. We put forward our proposals, and they were naturally the same as those we had in 1959. There was all this speculation throughout all that time and yet not one single public representative expressed any support for the proposal contained in this amendment. Senator Jessop and Senator Ó Conalláin argued for the system in principle. I recognise that that is a genuine expression of opinion, just as it is our opinion that the straight vote is the best system. These Senators must realise that they are the only two Members of either House to express this view and that even the proposer of the amendment here does not agree with it himself and neither did the proposer of the amendment in the Dáil agree with it.

I do not think there is any reason to believe that this is the choice of the people. There is no evidence of that. It is a system that discriminates in a completely unjust way against the majority and nobody has attempted to controvert what I said on the Second Stage and say why it is that some people whose candidate is not deemed to be elected should get a second, third, fourth, fifth and perhaps tenth vote for other candidates whereas other voters who voted for a candidate not deemed to be elected get one vote only. Nobody has attempted to explain what sin against democracy they committed that they should not have the same attention paid to their views as to those of others.

Comment on this

Are those the ones who were elected without a quota in the by-elections?

Comment on this

They are not. These are people whose candidates were deemed not to be elected but who, because they committed the crime of agreeing with more of their fellow constituents than any others, were given one vote only although others were given as many as five separate votes for different candidates or at least their votes were allocated to the candidate for whom they voted and to four or five other candidates also.

For instance, there was the Wicklow by-election. I appreciate there were six candidates and it may not be too easy for Senator Rooney to follow what happened in that case but I gave a simple example where there are three candidates and invited anybody to tell me why a certain number of voters should be selected and given two votes in that case. I showed that if every voter was treated in the same way, if their votes were treated in the same way, if the votes of the majority were not down-graded and treated as those of second-class citizens entitled only to one vote while others were entitled to multiple votes, that if the same consideration were given to everybody, it would very likely be established that there was a majority in favour of each of these three candidates. That would be an absurd result and you can get that because the assumption on which the whole process rests is absurd, that assumption being that a preference indicates the same degree of support as an actual vote. Of course it does not. It does not mean the same thing and Nos. 2, 3, 4 or 5 do not mean the same thing even for each voter who puts down the figures. Nobody knows what they mean. In some cases they mean absolutely nothing. It is a trick in order to allocate the votes that were cast for one particular candidate to another candidate. It does not establish that there was a majority in favour of any candidate and if a reasonably fair investigation is carried out it would be found that there was a majority in favour of more than one and that could not be. You get a silly result when you start off with a silly, unjustifiable assumption.

Comment on this

These defects were there when Mr. de Valera was there.

Comment on this

And he was an able mathematician. That is surprising.

Comment on this

I shall have to put these figures before Senator Quinlan again.

Comment on this

The child is crying again.

Comment on this

I am giving what is asked for.

Comment on this

If the Minister is prepared to debate it on Telefís Éireann, I can meet him there any time.

Comment on this

That is where we want it.

Comment on this
William Alexander Sheldon Acting Chairman (Mr. Sheldon) Independent

At the moment we are in the Seanad and not on television.

Comment on this

Let the Senators tell me why some people should get multiple votes and some should not. Let us take again the case of three candidates, A, B and C.

Comment on this

Surely this is repetition?

Comment on this

It is not. This is the first time I have said it.

Comment on this

The Minister himself said "again".

Comment on this

This is to deal with what Senator Quinlan said when proposing the amendment which he proposed but does not agree with. This deals with the system he suggested but does not agree with.

Comment on this

Are you using it in your own elections?

Comment on this

No, we are not. We are not mad.

Comment on this

You use the straight vote, I take it?

Comment on this

No, we are using a reasonably intelligent system of voting for the job that has to be done—to select out of a number of candidates, all of whom have the same policy, the man or woman the voters consider best.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If some Senators do not wish to listen to the Minister, they will have to leave the House because I am going to hear only one speaker.

Comment on this

It would make the proceedings shorter if they did, but I might not enjoy it as much. If candidate A gets 4,000 votes, B 3,500 and C 3,000, according to the rules of this system those who voted for candidate C are given a second vote and their votes were treated as if they were votes for somebody else. The division of the 3,000 votes could go 1,000 to candidate A and 2,000 to candidate B leaving candidate A with 5,000 votes and B with 5,500. The proponents of this system of the transferable votes now say: "It has been established that there is a majority in favour of one of the candidates, candidate B, because we have now given him 2,000 votes that were cast for C and the people have given him 3,500; whereas we have given candidate A 1,000 votes cast for candidate C and the people gave him 4,000, and this allocation of C's votes to A and B proves there is a majority in favour of B." Of course, it does not prove any such thing, but you get this ridiculous result because we make the ridiculous assumption that a preference vote of any degree is equivalent to an actual vote and because preferences are taken into account on a discriminatory basis.

As a result of this transaction, we now have the position that there are 4,000 unidentified, anonymous people who voted for candidate A and found themselves in the majority group in the constituency, and as a result of the machinations of this system, that candidate has been declared not to be elected and another candidate who got a smaller number of votes has been deemed to be elected. What I want Senators to explain to me is what sin against democracy these 4,000 people committed that they should be treated as second-class citizens and that their votes should not be entitled to equal consideration with the votes of the 3,000 who voted for candidate C? Is it not the same thing? Their candidate is deemed not to be elected.

Comment on this

Could I put a hypothetical case to the Minister?

Comment on this

I shall deal with this case first.

Comment on this

Let us assume that there are only two candidates A and B. What would the result be?

Comment on this

But there are not two; there are three and each is entitled to stand. What I want to show is that there is no reason to believe that would be the result but in any case there are three and each was entitled to go forward. Nobody is entitled artificially to reduce the number of candidates and give the people a choice between only A and B. They are equally entitled to have a choice between B and C or between A and C. If it was decided to give the same consideration to the votes of all members of the community it would be necessary to investigate the second preference of the 4,000 people who voted for candidate A who has now been "deemed" to be not elected and obviously these could go 1,500 to candidate B and 2,500 to candidate C so that we could get another result of 5,000 votes for B and 5,500 for C proving, according to the ridiculous rules of the system, that there is an overall majority in favour of B and that there is also an overall majority in favour of C, which of course is nonsense, and you get this nonsensical result because the assumption on which it is based is nonsense.

It might be said we have established that there are more people in favour of B than A, and that there are more people in favour of C than B; therefore there are more people in favour of C than A. Of course, that has not been established at all because only some of the people have only been given two choices. The 3,500 people who voted for B have been treated as second-class citizens. Their candidate has now been "deemed" not to be elected and their votes have not been given the same consideration as the votes of C and A, and if they were, it could happen that 1,500 of those votes would go to A and 2,000 to C, and we then have the third result of 5,500 being in favour of A and 5,000 being in favour of C. Therefore, we have established that there is a majority in favour of them all. As I said on the Second Stage, maybe these were three estimable candidates and the people did like them all and would like to have them all, but the Constitution says they can only have one. Therefore, there must be some way of deciding which one they may have and the only practical and fair way, the way that treats everybody the same, is the way we propose.

If you like to go on the assumption that it has been established there are more people in favour of B than A and more people in favour of C than B, we then find there are more people in favour of A than C. You could go round in circles like that forever. That, of course, arises out of the fact that the whole thing is based on the ridiculous assumption that a preference of any degree is equal, as an expression of support, to an actual vote, which is nonsense. Three candidates were entitled to stand. The people were entitled to choose one of them, and the only way in which they can choose between them is the way we propose. There is another possibility, of course; what they call the Borda system of attaching notional values to the preference votes and totalling them all up, but as I pointed out before the people just would not use that because they would see that by giving a preference vote to anybody else they would be voting against their own candidate.

The only practical question to ask the people at election time is: which of the candidates do you prefer? Count the votes and accept the result as the people express it. There is no way a returning officer and his staff can decide that there is an absolute majority in favour of one candidate if the people have already said that there is not. It is all right for Senator Rooney to say that there should be a majority in favour of one candidate before he is elected, but what can you do if there is not a majority, if the people insist there is not? This is not a theoretical thing at all. As I showed in the Wicklow by-election, there were 10,343 people discriminated against in this way, including 9,788 people who found themselves in the largest group of opinion in the constituency.

Because of the discrimination inherent in this system of the so-called transferable vote, these people who voted for a candidate who was not elected were given one vote only, whereas some of those who voted for candidates who were deemed not to be elected were given as many as five votes. That is discrimination, and it is not based on any democratic principle, because it is discrimination against the majority, whereas my understanding of democracy is that it is the majority view that should prevail. I pointed out from the results in the Wicklow by-election that if an effort were made to give the same treatment to all voters, to act in accordance with the fundamental principle of one man, one vote, that then it would have been established that, in addition to there being a majority for the Fine Gael candidate, there was also a majority for the Labour candidate.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Were there any complaints from Fine Gael or Labour about this?

Comment on this

In the by-election in East Limerick, of course, the same thing applied. Despite the maximum possible Coalition effort; despite the outside assistance of the two nonpolitical organisations that the Coalition Parties employed, the farming organisation and the anti-language organisation; despite the full-scale effort of the highly subsidised British Proportional Representation Society on their behalf, and despite the fact that, in addition to the two Coalition candidates, Labour and Fine Gael, there was also a candidate standing on behalf of a British political Party; despite all that, it was not possible, even with this discriminatory system, to secure the defeat of the candidate for whom the majority of the people voted.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

With a 17½ per cent swing.

Comment on this

They went fairly close to it, and after the election the Labour people had a complaint. Their complaint was that although they had done their work in the Coalition more thoroughly than Fine Gael, Fine Gael had let them down by not compelling their voters to transfer their votes to the Labour candidate.

I quite agree that there was no reason whatever why the votes of those who voted for the Labour Party candidate should not have been considered in the same way as the votes of those who voted for the Fine Gael candidate. The mere fact that there were a couple of hundred more of them was no reason why they should get less consideration than those who voted for the Fine Gael candidate or for the Liberal candidate; and if they were treated in the same way it might have been established that their work for the solidarity of the Coalition was more effective than that of Fine Gael, and fiddling around with the votes after the election in accordance with the rules of this system might have succeeded in allocating sufficient of the Labour Party candidate's votes to the Fine Gael candidate to elect him as they claim would have happened. I quite agree they were just as much entitled to that consideration as were the Fine Gael people. However, because this is a discriminatory system, because it only allocates this multiple voting power to a small section of the voters, this was not done, and so this charge of the Labour Party that they were more solid for the Coalition than Fine Gael cannot, in fact, be established.

Senator Rooney says it is essential that there should be a majority of the votes for the candidate to be elected, but if the people say there is not a majority, there is no way of establishing there is.

Those are all the Senators who dealt with the amendment. Senator O'Quigley made a Second Stage speech, in which he dealt with PR in general. He dealt with the 1937 Constitution. He dealt with the 1922 Constitution. He also dealt with the Civil War, with the establishment of the Border, and so on. I suppose Senator O'Quigley will be disappointed if I do not co-operate with him and go into all these things once again, but I know that certain Senators do not like to have these things refuted, and maybe for the time being, at any rate, and in view of the possibility that they will not be raised again, I shall postpone dealing with them, although this may offend Senator O'Quigley. If he wants to raise them again, or if he wants me to deal with the question of the 1937 Constitution, I will be only too happy to oblige.

Comment on this

Why not throw it in the wastepaper basket?

Comment on this

If he wants the 1922 Constitution to be dealt with, or if he or anyone else wants the question of whether this is the British system to be dealt with, I am quite prepared to deal with it. I will refrain from doing so at this stage although I must say I should like to, and we still have some time to go before teatime.

Comment on this

I want to give one very simple example of the machinations of the non-transferable vote. In passing, I want to remark that it was rather strange that in the 1959 campaign and debate, Mr. de Valera at no time invented or claimed any of the absurd discrimination in the PR system which the Minister ascribes to it. He said he wanted to change it. He gave his reasons, and they were solid but did not carry sufficient weight with the electorate. The Minister's absurdities discredit him and what he stands for.

I will go back to the simple little example I have worked out. We have here a Party convention selecting a candidate for a by-election. Of course, being committed as Fianna Fáil are to the non-transferable vote, or the straight vote, we would expect them to use the straight vote in selecting candidates in each constituency. That is the least the electorate might expect from them, so we proceed now to a constituency in which there are four candidates under general consideration. The Minister is good at algebra so I shall follow him. We have candidates A, B, C and D. In the days before the convention, when the canvassing is going on for votes, and there is talk about who will support whom, the agent of candidate B, who has a pretty good intelligence system, ticks off how the votes are likely to go at the convention and arrives at this estimate of the situation: A will top the poll with 30 votes out of a total of 100; B will be second with 25, C just behind him with 24, and D last with 21. They are all striving very hard to get the nomination, so what does B do? Remember this is the straight vote. B gets hold of a friend in A's area with rather similar interests to A and he gets him to go forward.

Comment on this

It is not a Fianna Fáil convention. The nominations are closed long ago.

Comment on this

B has calculated the vote which the stooge or straw candidate will get. He has to get seven votes from A and his own.

Comment on this

The nominations are closed long ago.

Comment on this

The result of this little manoeuvre, a slight little manoeuvre like the one used to keep rockets going around on course, and A is now down to 22, B has 25, C 24, D 21 and the stooge candidate E eight. B has now achieved his objective. The espionage of C is better and he learns of this little manoeuvre and he evaluates what is taking place. C sees his chance. A is finished. C has now got to jump ahead and he gets a real stooge candidate who can get only two votes and his own. So stooge candidate F goes forward, is proposed and seconded. He gets three votes and the final result is A 22, B 22, C 24, D 21, E eight and F three.

Comment on this

What about X and Y?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Perhaps the Senator would now come to the amendment.

Comment on this

If someone outside a political Party like myself can see how this could be done, one wonders if this happens in the green wood, what happens in the dry? This could also apply to the appointment of a rate collector. No sensible body of men would carry on like that. In a sensible body of men, the relative strength of the candidates is assessed and when a candidate sees he cannot hope to get enough backing, he retires. There are candidates retiring every day in the Presidential election in the United States and ultimately the selection of candidates will be between two and then one will be elected. That is the democratic process. We have all taken part in it, whether in Party conventions or in the election of a chairwoman in a local branch of the ICA— and Senator Ahern should know a considerable amount about that—or the election of the chairman of a branch of the NFA, or in an election in any group. We have taken part in elections to the university Senate. If three or four candidates were put up, unless one got a majority of the vote, the candidate with the lowest number of votes was eliminated and there was another vote between those remaining until ultimately one was elected.

Comment on this

That is not PR.

Comment on this

No amount of talk by the Minister about discrimination or thimble-rigging will convince the ordinary people that there is anything wrong with this approach. Up to now a person was asked: "If the person of your choice is not available, whom do you want to support?" That is the democratic process. That is the way it goes and the way it will go after the referendum. I make no apology here for insisting that the voters should be given a choice. I can see the position of the political Parties who are committed to the retention of PR. They are opposed to a system which is obviously unfair and unjust and could lead to rule by a 40 per cent minority. On the one hand, I should not like the Government to accept this amendment but, on the other hand, I have sufficient respect for the people to say that they should have been given a choice of all three.

Comment on this

Like everything else, you do not know what you want.

Comment on this

If we are going to be committed to two in this Bill, they should be given the two most likely at the present time and therefore the second choice should be the transferable vote. From my point of view, it has the merit of avoiding this type of thimble-rigging situation I have outlined; it has the merit of avoiding pacts, and so on. But it has not the proportionality and the respect for reasonable fractions of opinion that is ensured for us by proportional representation. I cannot claim to be a lawyer. Neither does the Minister.

Comment on this

Thank God.

Comment on this

We both, I think, got a sound engineering training. Therefore, we should consider that we should be able to make a reasonable layman's approach to interpretation of the written word. As it stands here, Article 46 of the Constitution, dealing with amendment of the Constitution, lays down that every proposal for an amendment of this Constitution shall be expressed to be "An Act to amend the Constitution". You must have an Act to amend the Constitution. On the other hand, Article 47 deals with any other proposal that is not a proposal to amend the Constitution.

There is nothing laid down in the Constitution as to the form in which this proposal must be submitted to the people. Indeed, it says at 4º: "Subject, as aforesaid, the Referendum shall be regulated by law". In other words, there is no obstacle whatsoever, except a sheer lack of democracy, that prevents the Minister and the Government from putting a simple question to the people in the following manner: "Mark, in the order of your preference, 1, 2, 3, the following electoral systems: 1, proportional representation and multi-seat constituencies; 2, the by-election system; 3, the straight vote system." There, you will be using just the simple 1, 2, 3, to enable you to decide, first, which system has the least support from the people and then you are down to a choice between the two remaining systems and that choice is decided by looking at what the people as a whole have said about their preferences between those two systems, and so you get your result.

If the Government had approached it in that way, I have not the slightest doubt that all political Parties would have agreed to accept the results, coming from such a question to the people, as binding. The resulting referendum, which would have to be, in other words, the findings of the people would have to be enshrined in a Bill and that Bill would then have to be put to the people for acceptance.

Comment on this

God help you.

Comment on this

The Parties would have accepted that as a formality. The people would have made known their wishes and this would merely be a formal carrying into action of their wishes. I invite the press and I invite all others studying this to look and examine Articles 46 and 47 of the Constitution to see whether these in any way inhibit the Government from putting the question as I have said it should be put and as everyone concerned with the maintenance of democracy and the strengthening of its greatest arm, that is, the referendum proposals, would wish the question to be put.

But, meantime, if we are to have a choice of two, the best and the second best, I do not see anything inconsistent in my saying I consider that the transferable vote in single-seat constituencies avoids some of the worst features of the non-transferable vote and, as such, is, in my view and in the view of all the leader-writers in both the weeklies and the national dailies— apart from the Irish Press group—the more desirable system to have. Consequently, I do not think there is any need to say any more except that I leave it to the House.

Comment on this

I was somewhat entertained, if a little startled, by Senator Quinlan's revelations as to the methods by which they elect the President of University College, Cork. I presume he was talking about——

Comment on this

No, Sir, I made no such suggestion but, in any appointment I ever took part in, no candidate was appointed unless he received the majority of the votes concerned and the lower candidate was eliminated.

Comment on this

Did he get a candidate from a local area to go up against him?

Comment on this

If Senator Quinlan was not talking about the election of a President of University College, Cork, he certainly was not describing anything that ever took place at a Fianna Fáil convention, or could. I note that Senator Garret FitzGerald is leaving the House. I hope he will not depart for any length of time because I propose to discuss his electoral statistics.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I shall remain within the precincts of the House.

Comment on this

Let him go off, for God's sake.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I shall stay, then, to hear the discussion on the statistics. I could not miss that.

Comment on this

Before discussing the statistics——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is not fair.

Comment on this

——I think it is only fair to say something about this amendment to which the names of five Senators have been put. I shall be brief because I am anxious to reach the topic of statistics as propounded by Senator FitzGerald. I see he is now leaving the House again.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Momentarily.

Comment on this

It seems to me that there is no advantage whatever in this suggestion of having what is called proportional representation in single-seat constituencies. In the first place, it is I think quite clear that, in a single-seat constituency, the transferable vote is not proportional at all. You can elect only one candidate in a constituency and the question of proportions simply does not arise. The question of minorities getting representation in Parliament in accordance with their political strength does not come into the matter. Indeed, the all-Party Committee on the Constitution accepted this point when one of the matters they referred to the Attorney General for his consideration was this question of the use of the term "proportional representation" in Presidential elections. They pointed out—I think rightly— that it is probably an error in the Constitution to describe this as proportional representation since, clearly, the question of proportional representation does not come into it: only one man can be elected. It is the transferable vote all right but not what we think of as proportional representation.

I think that, with one or two exceptions, we have heard here today all those who spoke for this amendment do so as the lesser of what they think of as two evils. They want single-seat constituencies and yet they have a sort of hankering after proportional representation or, as in the case of Deputy Norton, they are afraid the desirable prospect of single-seat constituencies might be lost if this compromise proposal were not put through. I do not think that anyone, with a few exceptions, looks upon this as particularly desirable. It might be no harm to point out that just as I am prepared to concede that there are people on the other side of the House who genuinely, sincerely and honestly believe in the advantages of PR, equally it might be admitted that we on this side of the House genuinely, sincerely and honestly believe that in the interests of the country the straight vote would be a more desirable form of election. I sincerely believe this and this debate would proceed with less bickering and backchat if this fact were recognised, just as we are prepared to recognise that there are on the other side those who are sincerely in favour of PR.

The great advantage to us of the straight vote is that it tends to create a two-Party system. You have a single-Party majority Government and sitting in the wings is an alternative Government in Opposition who can be brought into power when the electorate so decide. It does not necessarily always create a two-Party system. In the 1920s in England when the Labour Party were coming into power, it was gradually displacing the Liberal Party and you had three Parties competing with each other, but once the Labour Party displaced the Liberals, the Liberals disappeared and you had the two-Party system which is normally created under the straight vote system. That is a great advantage. You would lose that with the single-seat constituency with PR and you would have a permanent three-Party system and in time you might even have a four-Party system.

One of the main reasons why some people support this amendment is that they fear this suggestion that under the straight vote system, Fianna Fáil would get some 98 seats with, as happened in the last local elections, some 40 per cent of the poll. This suggestion was made in particular by Senator Dooge and Senator FitzGerald on the Second Reading of these Bills. To me this has always seemed an outrageous and ridiculous suggestion. I pointed out several times that in no straight vote country has it ever happened that a Party with only 40 per cent of the vote got the equivalent of 67 per cent or two-thirds of the seats in Parliament. It has not happened and it could not happen in the circumstances in this country.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think we are agreed on that.

Comment on this

Senator Dooge made some quite clear statements on Second Reading. He said that he had made a careful and scientific study of the last local election results and had tried to estimate what the results would have been, had it been a straight vote election. On that basis he worked out that Fianna Fáil would have got 98 seats. The other point is that the Fianna Fáil proportion of the total votes in the 1966 local elections was just under 40 per cent and therefore we have been told here and as everybody outside has been told——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Not by Senator Dooge or myself.

Comment on this

We have been told that with less than 40 per cent of the vote, Fianna Fáil would get 98 seats, and the suggestion has been made that Fianna Fáil are trying to cement themselves in power with a system of election to give them a vast majority even with a quite low proportion of the votes.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Twice I repudiated the suggestion that 40 per cent would give 98 seats.

Comment on this

The Senator did try to backtrack a little when I made the point. How did Senators FitzGerald and Dooge arrive at their figures? It is not merely a question of figures for the local elections or what might have happened if it had been a straight vote.

Senator FitzGerald on numerous occasions has referred to the fall in support for Fianna Fáil from one local election to another and from one general election to another. How did these figures originate? Basically, the Senators computed their figures simply by eliminating from their reckoning all the votes cast except those cast for Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour. Senator Dooge on the Second Reading, at column 1248, volume 65 said:

in the estimate I made I may say that rather than take all the votes which were cast in the local elections in any electoral area, in the vast majority of cases I only took the votes cast for the three major Parties.

I missed this when the Senator was speaking and when Senator FitzGerald was speaking I interrupted to say that this suggestion that Fianna Fáil would get 98 seats with 40 per cent of the vote was just ridiculous and I asked how did they arive at this conclusion. He said that all the votes for smaller Parties were to be forgotten about. I expressed amazement, not to say incredulity, and Senator FitzGerald said that the Independents would more or less cancel out. If that were true, it would be a reasonable policy to adopt, but of course anybody who has anything to do with elections knows that the usual practice is—and I am not talking now about the reasons for this or whether it is good or bad—the Fianna Fáil voters vote for Fianna Fáil candidates and not for anybody else.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

In local elections?

Comment on this

I am talking about general elections. I want to talk about the Senator's method which was applied in local elections but I am discussing general elections at the moment.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Senator will appreciate that the statement I made was that Senator Dooge's calculations had been based on the assumption that the Independent votes would divide in less proportion, in relation to local elections

Comment on this

This is as indicated in local elections as well as general elections.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That may be so.

Comment on this

Senator FitzGerald's statistics relate only to Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour. This method of computation might be justified if Independent votes go equally to both sides. If Senator FitzGerald is inexperienced in elections, he may not appreciate the facts with regard to Independent candidates, but he could have asked someone in his Party, with long experience, or he could have checked his facts. I do not know why he did not check—it seems an elementary precaution—before deciding on a fundamental point of this kind. He obviously did not check his facts or, if he did, he ignored the results.

I have done an investigation of the so-called Independent voters and the basic point is how his supporters would vote if the Independent candidate were not there. The method of computation is not completely reliable because the later preferences under proportional representation are not necessarily a very accurate representation of the voter's feelings. However, over a large number, the discrepancies probably work out very well and preferences can give a reasonably accurate idea of the feelings of the people who cast them. In the 1965 general election, of all the preferences handed on from various Independent candidates Fianna Fáil got 21.5 per cent, or one-fifth. This is a very consistent pattern. In the 1961 election Fianna Fáil got 24.6 per cent; in the 1957 election, Fianna Fáil got 22.6 per cent. The total number of electors involved was 168,965. It is a large number and it is a fairly accurate representation of the position. Surprisingly enough, in 1965 Fianna Fáil got more preferences proportionately from Labour candidates than they did from the other Parties' candidates—22.4 per cent instead of 21.5 per cent. In 1961 the discrepancy was even greater; Fianna Fáil got 35.5 per cent from Labour candidates as against 24.6 per cent from the other smaller Party candidates. If there were any rhyme or reason in this statistical exercise of Senator FitzGerald, he should have eliminated Labour candidates before he eliminated the other candidates.

These figures show quite conclusively that Fianna Fáil supporters in general vote for Fianna Fáil candidates but Opposition supporters may vote for Fine Gael or Labour or, from time to time, they may vote for some of the smaller Parties or for Independent candidates, as indeed they are encouraged to do by the existence of proportional representation; that is one of the purposes intended to be served by the system. People who support a particular group may vote for Independents or smaller Party candidates and hand on their votes to other candidates of the two bigger Opposition Parties, if they wish to do so. I can understand Senator FitzGerald and Senator Dooge omitting Independents on the specious ground that it all comes out in the wash and it comes to the same thing on both sides, but I cannot understand the justification for eliminating the smaller Parties. Why were Clann na Talmhan omitted from all reckoning? Clann na Poblachta? Sinn Féin? National Progressive Democrats?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What election is the Senator speaking about?

Comment on this

1957, 1961 and 1965. Senator FitzGerald has produced figures showing a curve. We talk about a trend; Senator FitzGerald talks about a curve.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I did not use that word in relation to this calculation.

Comment on this

Oh, yes. The Senator was telling the Minister why he was bringing in the straight vote; it was because of the disaster about to befall Fianna Fáil and the Senator described this curve from 1957 to 1961 to 1968. "Curve" is a great word.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I did not use it.

Comment on this

It is the sort of economic jargon——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The curve is related to the ratio of seats to votes—a quite simple calculation. The Senator is confused. There are no curves in the graph. It is a straight line. Fianna Fáil are falling in a straight line.

Comment on this

The Senator did use the word.

Comment on this

It is a straight downward line.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

And that describes Fianna Fáil—a very good description.

Comment on this

It is a graph; it is not a trend. It is a graph which proves itself almost before you have investigated it. However, for the purpose of this graph, curve, straight line, downward trend in the Fianna Fáil vote, in order to produce these figures, Senator FitzGerald not merely eliminated the Independents, who I have shown overwhelmingly hand on their preferences to Fine Gael or Labour, but he also eliminated all the smaller Parties in the last three general elections—Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta, Sinn Féin, National Progressive Democrats. There may be some others. These, apparently, become what can only be described as "non-Parties". Their candidates are "non-candidates". The people who vote for them are "non-people". They have simply ceased to exist, as far as Senator FitzGerald is concerned.

I do not want to impute motives unnecessarily but the result of this exercise is, of course, to increase the Opposition vote from election to election because these smaller Parties— Sinn Féin, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta and Independents — in 1957 got 16 per cent of the total vote, whereas, in the last general election, they got only 2.9 per cent of the vote. The result of that is, of course, that the acknowledged Opposition vote — Fine Gael and Labour—goes up and Fianna Fáil goes down, which was, I take it, the purpose of the exercise. One gets some quite clear results, however, when one remembers that the 16 per cent who voted for these small groups and Independents in 1957 still go on voting. They have not ceased to exist. According to Senator FitzGerald's statistics, they are non-people, but, for practical purposes, they are there. They vote for other Parties.

Take the situation in which the same candidates are involved from election to election, thought not always in the same Party or under the same ticket. I will give an example of the statistical complications that can arise in such a case. Take Deputy Seán Dunne, the Minister's colleague. In 1961 he stood as an Independent. Of course Independents are non-people, not recognised in Senator FitzGerald's statistical gallery. Therefore the votes cast for Independent Deputies in 1961 were not counted. They did not become part of the graph, curve, straight line, what have you. However, in 1965 Deputy Dunne stood again as a Labour candidate. That is a recognised Party and his votes are duly counted.

We have the opposite progress taking place in the case of Deputy Joseph Sheridan of Longford-Westmeath. In 1957 he stood unsuccessfully as a Fine Gael candidate. His votes were counted because Fine Gael are a recognised Party by Senator FitzGerald for statistical purposes. In 1961 he was elected as an Independent. He is now a non-person, a non-candidate; his votes cannot be counted. In 1965 he stood as a successful Independent. Once more his votes will not appear on the statistical record of Senator FitzGerald.

The next case we have is Alderman George Russell of East Limerick. In 1957 he stood as an Independent, a non-person. In 1961 he stood again as an Independent and again his votes cannot be counted. However, in 1965 he stood as a Fine Gael candidate. Now all is well. His votes are counted.

In the same city, we have Deputy Stephen Coughlan. He was unwise enough to stand first as a Clann na Poblachta candidate. That was a non-Party. His votes cannot be counted. However, he recovered and in 1961 and 1965 stood for the Labour Party and his votes were duly counted.

The late Deputy Donnellan was elected in 1957 and again in 1961 as a Clann na Talmhan candidate. Of course that was a non-Party and his votes could not be counted. However, in 1965, his son, John Donnellan, stood and was elected as a Fine Gael candidate and his votes appear on the graph.

Deputy Thomas O'Hara of North Mayo stood in 1957 and 1961 as Clann na Talmhan. That was a non-Party. His votes could not be counted. In 1965 he was elected for Fine Gael. This is all right so he had his votes counted.

I am sorry Senator McQuillan is not here at the moment because he might be interested to know that when he stood in 1957 as an Independent, his votes do not appear on Senator FitzGerald's graph. They were not legitimate votes: they could not be recognised. In 1961 he stood as a National Progressive Democrat candidate. This, I need hardly say, was a non-Party and the votes could not be counted. However, when he lost his seat in 1965 as a Labour candidate, his votes were duly counted.

Now the most hair-raising statistical complications of Senator FitzGerald arise in the case of Dr. Noel Browne. He has had a varied political career.

Comment on this

Yes, you would know; he was in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

He has had a varied political career but it is as nothing compared with the varied statistical complications he has caused Senator FitzGerald. He was elected in 1948 for Clann na Poblachta, a non-Party. His votes could not then be counted; they just did not exist. In 1951, he stood as an Independent, and once more the 8,000 votes he got just could not be counted. However, in 1954 he stood and lost his seat as a Member of the Fianna Fáil Party and it may be some consolation to him to know that on that occasion his votes could have appeared on any graph Senator FitzGerald would have been preparing. In 1957 he was once more elected as an Independent, but his supporters were non-people, his votes could not be counted. In 1961, he was elected for the National Progressive Democrats. This being a non-Party, his votes could not be recognised. In 1965, he lost his seat as a member of the Labour Party. It may be some consolation to him to know that his votes now may be counted.

This is a curious situation. Dr. Browne stood for election in all six different times. On four occasions he was elected and twice he was defeated. On each of the four occasions on which he was elected, Senator FitzGerald would not recognise his votes and on the two occasions when he was defeated, his votes are recognised and appear on the graph. This is statistics gone mad. This is the kind of way in which Senator FitzGerald and indeed, I am afraid, Senator Dooge, are able to prove that Fianna Fáil will get 98, 100 or 120 seats in straight vote elections.

The purpose of this exercise is curious. It is an almost incredible exercise, effectively to prove that black is white, to prove that water runs uphill and more specifically to prove by means of curves and graphs that an increase in the Fianna Fáil poll is in reality a decline. We had been given for example, several times during the course of this debate figures by Senator FitzGerald to the effect that the Fianna Fáil vote had declined between the general elections of 1961 and 1965 from 50 to 49 per cent. This is a swing of two per cent against Fianna Fáil. I do not expect anybody to take my figures so I go to the Appendix to the Report of the Committee on the Constitution and there of course find what we know already that in 1961 Fianna Fáil got 43.8 per cent of the total valid poll. In 1965, they got 47.7 per cent of the total valid poll; in other words, there was a swing to Fianna Fáil of eight per cent. By means of these graphs, these curious statistics which casually disregard all candidates who do not come within the holy of holies, the statistical canons of Senator FitzGerald, Senator FitzGerald is able to prove to his own satisfaction, and he hoped, to ours, that the swing to Fianna Fáil between those two elections of eight per cent was in reality a swing away from Fianna Fáil of two per cent.

Of course the same thing was done with regard to the figures he produced for the first time in my hearing yesterday for the last two local elections. He said that in the one before the last Fianna Fáil got 49½ per cent of the votes, and in 1966, only 45½ per cent, that is, a swing of eight per cent. Of course both those figures are wrong. In reality, of course, the Fianna Fáil proportion of the total poll at the last local elections increased, by some relatively small fraction, but none the less increased. However, this increase is transmuted by this statistical magic into an eight per cent swing against Fianna Fáil.

It is in this same kind of way that we get the totally false suggestion that Fianna Fáil at the recent local elections, if they were fought on the straight vote system, would have got 98 seats. The method of calculation is essentially the same. Independents, Clann na Poblachta, Sinn Féin and all the rest are non-people, just not recognised for statistical purposes and this estimate of the straight vote result is therefore on the basis that Fianna Fáil in that number of prospective single-seat constituencies would get a majority of 1,000 or 2,000, or whatever the figure may be, over the nearest candidate from Labour or Fine Gael.

Of course the distortion involved in this kind of exercise is increased when it comes to local elections because there are of course more independent candidates here. The number of votes cast for Independent and small Party candidates at the last local elections was 151,000. I take it there may be one, two or three cases in which candidates were recognised for those statistical purposes, but the vast majority, the great majority, of these 150,000 people who voted for independent candidates and the smaller parties simply became non-people and ceased to exist as far as Senator FitzGerald is concerned.

It will be clear, I think, that this is bound to make a fundamental difference in the situation as propounded by Senators Dooge and FitzGerald with regard to the 98 seats. The presence of such independent voters who would not be voting for independent candidates in a general election or a straight vote election of any kind would have the effect of reducing and in many cases eliminating the alleged Fianna Fáil majority in these areas. This is clear. The 98 seats are in fact vastly more than Fianna Fáil can possibly get in any election when they get as low as 40 per cent of the poll. It is certainly at least 50 per cent higher than the correct figure. I am talking about what would happen in a 40 per cent poll by Fianna Fáil. I would certainly anticipate that in any general election Fianna Fáil would get a much higher proportion than that.

I am dealing with the situation here of the 40 per cent poll and the allegation that Fianna Fáil would get 98 seats in such an event. That has been repeated and repeated and it is time something was said about it.

As Senator Dooge stated, in the vast majority of cases these Independent candidates and the candidates of the smaller Parties such as ratepayers, and so on, would not run in a general election and we have to consider, therefore, what the effects might be on the result under a straight vote election. I have a few cases here to show the type of situation which arises, and which were simply ignored by Senator Dooge, and I take it, also by Senator FitzGerald. I have one area where Fianna Fáil had 2,630 votes and the nearest party was Fine Gael with 2,583 under a straight vote, a majority of 47. That is one of the 98 seats, but there are also 1,029 of those non-recognised votes cast by non-people.

For practical purposes, whatever Senators Dooge or FitzGerald wish to do with statistics, they must recognise that these people do exist, and would be voting in a general election. We must also recognise, and the figures I have produced show, that the great majority of those 1,029 would vote for Fine Gael rather than Fianna Fáil, so that "majority" of 47 would disappear.

In a Cork city area, Fianna Fáil got 2,678 and the nearest Party, Fine Gael 2,657 under a straight vote, a majority of 21. There were, however, 1,507 for Independents, which have been ignored. There again, this so-called straight vote majority is an illusory one. There is another area, in which Fianna Fáil got 2,531 votes and Fine Gael 2,296, a suppositious majority of 235 but there are 1,735 unrecognised others also voting who must be considered.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Would the Senator indicate where he is talking about?

Comment on this

County Monaghan.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Which election? That is a particular area?

Comment on this

It is Monaghan area, the county of Monaghan. That is 1,735 votes which is more than enough to overwhelm this meagre imaginary straight vote majority. In Killarney area, County Kerry, here is an interesting one: Fianna Fáil 4,774, the nearest Fine Gael 4,356. That is a notional majority of 418 but there are 2,839 votes for Independents and other Parties. This is an interesting case because in this particular case the election showed that there would have been no Fianna Fáil majority, because they transferred in this case enough votes to Fine Gael to give them three seats as against two for Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

What is the point? This is a case where Fine Gael exceeded Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

No, this is where Fianna Fáil exceeded Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

This is Killarney, County Kerry. Last year's local elections figures are different. One of our figures are wrong. It may well be ours. My figures are different. There may be a misprint.

Comment on this

How many seats have you got in your figures?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Fine Gael three, Fianna Fáil two. The Senator's figures may be in error.

Comment on this

I would be surprised to know that in Killarney, County Kerry, Fine Gael got more votes than Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I understand that from Mr. Dennehy and Mr. O'Connor, for whom I worked, and I think my figures are correct with respect to the Senator.

Comment on this

I have my figures from the Irish Independent. Of course newspapers can make errors, even the Irish Independent. We cannot rely on them. There can be errors.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Could the Senator give the figures again for Monaghan?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil 2,531, Fine Gael 2,296, a majority of 235.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Statistical exchange across the floor is not normally the manner of debate.

Comment on this

I would not dream of anticipating the number of seats Fianna Fáil will get. Therefore, I think every last seat is not of vital importance.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I agree.

Comment on this

I am making a general point. Senator FitzGerald will say that there is a wider scope. I picked these areas out to make the point to show that it is utterly illusory to talk about a notional straight vote majority and ignore sometimes large numbers of Independent voters or votes of small Parties who would not be there in a general election, and who could eliminate that majority.

The next I get on to is Bray—Fianna Fáil 2,624, Labour 2,324, others 1,594 which is more than enough to give Labour a majority. There is a similar situation in Dublin in Area 11. Fianna Fáil 4,413, Fine Gael 4,393, a majority of 20 but there were 3,118 votes for other candidates. Those are only selected titbits, one might say, from the results. In fact, in no less than 61 areas there were votes for Independent candidates and other Parties, none of them recognised by Senator Garret FitzGerald's statistics, which exceeded in number the so-called straight vote majority of Fianna Fáil in these areas. Of those 61 cases, in no less than 36 cases the votes of the Independents were more than double this so-called straight vote majority. It is reasonable to suggest that in cases where the vote of the Independents was more than double the so-called straight vote majority of Fianna Fáil, it is highly probable that the majority would be wiped out altogether.

There were a further 25 cases where those votes amounted to more than three times the total of the so-called majority. In those cases we can be absolutely certain that there is no majority. I am not attempting a scientific assessment. I base those figures on returns from the newspapers. I would prefer to get the official return of the figures. If Senator FitzGerald says there are only, say, 23 areas where the Independent vote was three times the majority, I will accept that, but there is certainly a very large number of areas where beyond any possible shadow of doubt, there is no straight vote majority for Fianna Fáil and the straight vote majority alleged, originates entirely in an utterly faulty statistical analysis which omits 151,000 voters from the reckoning. They are simply people not counted in this extraordinary reckoning of Senator FitzGerald and Senator Dooge.

On those figures alone, so far from Fianna Fáil gaining 98 seats with 40 per cent of the poll, the most likely result would be that they would get somewhere in the 60s but there are other factors one ought to consider. One of those, of course, is the number of Labour candidates. I am not trying to do down the Labour candidates. I am trying to assess this in a realistic way. There are many cases in the local elections where Labour candidates stood who clearly would not stand in a general election. There are Labour candidates who got two per cent, three per cent or four per cent of the total poll and even up to ten per cent, and in such cases it would be futile to run under the straight vote in a general election.

Some of the people would vote for Fianna Fáil who had previously voted for Labour candidates but clearly the bulk of them would go against the Government and for Fine Gael. This would narrow the majorities and in some cases eliminate them altogether. Of course, the extent to which this factor would apply would depend on the co-operation between Fine Gael and Labour. It would be quite possible for them to co-operate quite closely so that Fine Gael would retire from contesting a constituency where Labour was much stronger and Labour would retire from a constituency where Fine Gael was much stronger. If they did this to any great extent, it would increase the number of seats where Fianna Fáil would fail to gain a majority. With 40 per cent of the poll, Fianna Fáil would probably get between 50 and 60 seats under the straight vote.

Comment on this

You are suggesting we would be a Party in the elections.

Comment on this

I do not want to be misunderstood. That is on the so-called calculation placed before us in this debate that with 40 per cent of the votes, Fianna Fáil would get 98 seats. I think I have proved that Fianna Fáil with 40 per cent of the votes, certainly in Irish conditions with the present relative strength of Fine Gael and Labour, would get something between 50 and 60 seats, depending on the amount of co-operation. I am certain that Fianna Fáil in a general election would get more than this.

Fianna Fáil, consistently during the past 40 years, have polled far less in local elections than in general elections. In a general election, I expect we would get 47 per cent, 48 per cent or 49 per cent of the total valid poll. I do not know about the number of seats. That would depend on the extent of the co-operation between the two main Opposition Parties. To get 98 seats in Irish conditions, bearing in mind the relative strength of Fine Gael and Labour, Fianna Fáil would need to win a much higher proportion of the total valid poll than they have ever won, or any Party has ever won in this country. It may be possible to get 98 seats but only on a vastly higher proportion of the total poll than Fianna Fáil have ever had. We got 52 per cent in 1938. In order to get 98 seats, you would need to get nearly 60 per cent of the votes. Certainly you would need to get well over 50 per cent. To say we would get 98 seats with 40 per cent of the poll is nonsense.

Comment on this

I do not know whether I should intervene between the two statisticians throwing figures across the House.

Comment on this

Give them time to cook up some more.

Comment on this

Between them the Labour Party would be squashed out. I am only going to deal with this point. Senator Yeats asked us to accept that all the people on this side sincerely believe it was in the interests of the country that the single-seat constituency system should operate and that we should have a two-Party system, the Government Party and an alternative Government. Let me say I am not prepared to accept that all the people on the other side are motivated by a sincere duty that what is proposed is good for the country. I believe quite a few on the other side, and quite a few Fianna Fáil Deputies, do not believe in what is proposed here, do not believe it is right that a second attempt to abolish proportional representation should be made.

This probably reflects the views of their supporters throughout the country. Equally, I believe there are people on the other side, including the Minister, who equate the good of the country with the good of the Fianna Fáil Party, that it is the same thing. They are motivated by this. I will accept Senator Yeats's word that he himself sincerely believes the two-Party system is good for the country. He spent a lot of time now disproving Senator Garret FitzGerald's figures and attempted to prove his own. It seems to boil down to this. He was arguing that Senator Garret FitzGerald's estimate of the 98 seats for Fianna Fáil was an exaggeration, that it was too many, and that in fact Fianna Fáil would not get so many seats, that Fine Gael would get quite a big share of the seats.

Comment on this

And Labour.

Comment on this

He forgot about Labour. Of course, this is the whole crunch of this issue. He said he believed in the two-Party system. I do not imagine even Senator Yeats is so sincere in his belief that he wants the two-Party system if that means eliminating Fianna Fáil. I do not believe that this would be the reason he has been trying to prove that Fianna Fáil will get so many seats, that in fact they will not get that many because Fine Gael will have a greater strength under the system than Senator Garret FitzGerald was saying, and Labour will be eliminated.

Comment on this

I did not say that, nor did I mean it.

Comment on this

We are refusing to be eliminated. The Senator did not say that but that is the tone of his argument, that Fine Gael would, in fact, get more than Senator FitzGerald suggested.

Comment on this

I said nothing about who would get them.

Comment on this

You want a two-Party system.

Comment on this

Yes, either Labour or Fine Gael.

Comment on this

And we, in order to balance this up, to make this a fine, workable system, should dissolve ourselves and go in with Fine Gael and that would give strength to Fine Gael to make them an alternative Government, that they would be in some way a balance to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

That is your argument, not mine.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil would probably get 70 or 80 seats and the Fine Gael Party then, if we dissolve ourselves and go in with Fine Gael, would get the balance—a nice, tidy arrangement. We are invited to do it by Senator Yeats.

Comment on this

By Fine Gael too.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

You are very welcome.

Comment on this

We have no intention of being eliminated by Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil. We fight this issue. We think it is quite undemocratic for any combination of a majority to take away the rights of a minority. That is a Nazi Germany sort of thing, that if you get a majority, you can take rights from a minority. We are a minority that have existed in this democratic State. We insist on our right to continue in existence and we will not accept the invitation of Senator Yeats or Fine Gael to eliminate ourselves.

Comment on this

Nobody can take it from you.

Comment on this

I am challenging this. I cannot see in a democracy that, in combination, a majority can, simply by being a majority, take the rights of a minority. That is not right. They cannot change the rules. To my thinking, that is not proper democracy, for example, simply because we have a majority of dark-haired people or people going bald, like myself, we cannot say to Senator Garret FitzGerald that we do not like his mop of hair, and decide simply by a majority to eliminate him because we think his hair is untidy. I do not mean this in a personal way. But the Labour Party is untidy, in this grand design of Senator Yeats and should be eliminated.

We are not going to be eliminated. We fight this issue. It is not right simply to say it will tidy up the situation and will be a grand thing to have a two-Party system, a Government Party and an alternative Government, that this is for the good of the country. It may be the Senator's idea of the good of the country but any such idea of eliminating a minority simply to tidy up the issue is an injustice. Perhaps this may be an exaggeration but the thinking behind it is the same thinking as Hitler's. He wanted to tidy up the general situation, to make them all nice people, to eliminate the Jews because they were Jews. It was untidy; they had no right; and he had a majority, and a very substantial majority, of the German people behind him but simply because he had a majority did not make it right. It was still an injustice. I say this is an exaggeration——

Comment on this

It surely is.

Comment on this

——but the thinking is the same. It is an exaggeration but the thinking is quite the same, that simply by some sort of combining and getting a majority, you can take the rights of a majority. That is wrong and an injustice. That is not what we understand as the function of a democratic State and what Fianna Fáil are after here is to try to tidy up the issue, eliminate the Labour Party and then we will all be nice. Fianna Fáil will be in power; Fine Gael will be sufficiently strong to provide a decent—conservative, maybe—Opposition and we will all carry on and it is too bad about these poor Labour people—they are gone; they are part of history.

Comment on this

I want to say about two words on this question. I hope Senator Murphy will take my word for it that in my remarks on this whole question of elections and what the results would be under the straight vote, and so on, I was interesting myself in the number of seats Fianna Fáil might get. I would not worry particularly who gets the other ones, whether Labour or Fine Gael or the others. I am not really terribly interested: perhaps I should be but I am not. However, I can assure Senator Murphy of one thing. I am not madly anxious to see the Labour Party or any Party eliminated. What I am anxious to ensure is that if the Labour Party want to nationalise the banks or dispossess widows from their farms or have any other policy of that kind, they are entitled to have that policy and to put it into force, if, and only if, they get a majority of the people to support them; but what I want to avoid, and I think all of us should want to avoid, is a situation where a minority of 15 or 20 per cent was able to force policies on a Government that the 80 per cent did not want. The Labour Party and Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil or any other Party are entitled to put any policies they like before the people and to put them into force if they can get majority backing for them but what is utterly undemocratic and what has led in other countries to dictatorships is the situation where a tiny minority, be it 3, 4, 5, 15 or 20 per cent, can force on a Government that they are backing in a coalition policies which the 80 per cent of the population do not want. That is all I am trying to avoid.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Senator Yeats has put forward some views which I have to deal with. I had not proposed to intervene at this stage but he will agree that it is proper that I should, as briefly as I can, not wishing to prolong the debate.

First of all, there appears to be some confusion between two bases of calculation. One is a graph which shows the Fianna Fáil share of the valid vote declining over a period. This is subject to some element of distortion in so far as the size of the non-Party vote, that is, outside the three main Parties, has varied and in so far as the distribution between the three main Parties, when these groups disappear, had they not been there at that time, would have been differentiated and not in proportion to the first preferences of the three Parties. This would not be taken into account and it is fair to treat Senator Yeats's remarks seriously.

There are two things I want to say. Senator Yeats made a statement— I did jot it down but I have lost the paper— that in the 1965 general election Fianna Fáil got 21.5 per cent of the preference votes of Independents. I should like to ask Senator Yeats a question which I am sure he will answer. In making this calculation, he was using the 1965 general election in which these preferences of candidates other than those of Fianna Fáil, Labour and Fine Gael are passed on. In all three cases could he tell me whether he included in these the votes passed on from Sherwin in Dublin and from Morahan in Mayo South?

Comment on this

Not Sherwin. What is the other?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Sherwin and Morahan. These were the Independents who were eliminated. Morahan was Clann na Poblachta. His votes passed on. Did he include them in his calculation?

Comment on this

I only included them in cases where the votes passed on at the time when both Fianna Fáil candidates and Labour or Fine Gael were in a position to receive them. In a couple of cases in which Fianna Fáil and a couple of cases in which Labour or Fine Gael were left alone—in neither case did I count them.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Senator Yeats confirms my view that in calculations of this kind he does endeavour to be fair but I simply cannot agree with his result. The figure I get on exactly the same calculation is that of the votes passing on to the three Parties, 35 per cent went to Fianna Fáil and not, as he said, 21.6 per cent. The only question is whether perhaps he is including votes passing on to Independents in his calculation. That would be double counting because those votes are again passed on when those second Independents are eliminated.

Comment on this

They might not be eliminated.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That possible error might account for the difference between us. If we are concerned with the share the Parties get, that would be appropriate.

Comment on this

We are getting into this fantastic detail of 1, 2 and 3. Will the Senator accept that his figures are grotesque——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Excuse me; follow my line of argument and make your own judgment. My calculation of the votes in the 1965 election, based on when Fianna Fáil. Fine Gael and Labour candidates are in the field, is that 35 per cent must pass on to Fianna Fáil. In 1965, the proportion of all votes going to Independents was 2.9 per cent. If, therefore, we compare the results on the assumption which I used in that graph, that the votes of the Independents are distributed proportionally between the three Parties, you take out these votes and divide the Party votes by the total of them. The answer you get is 49.1 per cent for Fianna Fáil, 39 per cent for Fine Gael and 15.9 per cent for Labour.

I accept Senator Yeats's point that there is some differential distribution of the votes of Independents. If you distribute them in proportion to the way they were distributed at that time, the answer you get is 47.7 per cent for Fianna Fáil, 35.5 per cent for Fine Gael and 16.1 per cent for Labour. The effect is to produce figures which, rounded to the nearest whole number, are identical with those in the graph. This would not necessarily have been so at earlier elections. I freely admit that. As regards the general election of 1965, the Independents' vote was so small that you could distribute it to high heaven and it would not make any difference to the final result. Therefore, the comparison made in the graph is not arguable in respect of 1965.

Business suspended at 6.5 p.m. and resumed at 7.30 p.m.

Comment on this