We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 342–512 of 512. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 6 of 1968 ›

Senator Quinlan made a further contribution to this debate and referred to what he described as the machinations of the non-transferable vote at Fianna Fáil conventions. Obviously, he has no idea of how a convention is conducted since what he describes could not happen. We have a better organisation than that. I notice that he made no attempt to show why some people should be discriminated against, in the manner I showed, and treated as second-class citizens, not entitled to the same consideration as is given to the votes of some of their colleagues. He describes the system we propose as being unfair and unjust but what it does is to treat every voter in exactly the same way and give every candidate and every political Party exactly the same chance. This is what the Opposition object to. This is the system which will require every candidate and Party to stand on their own feet, the system under which it will not be possible to continue the present practice of putting up candidates who cannot get any support from the electorate but are brought in on the surplus of other candidates who can.

In his quotation of Article 47, the Senator did not even quote the Constitution correctly. He omitted to say "...every proposal other than a proposal to amend the Constitution, which is submitted by referendum to the decision of the people shall for the purposes of Article 27 hereof be held to have been approved by the people unless vetoed by them in accordance with the provisions of the foregoing subsection of this section". He omitted the reference to "... for the purposes of Article 27 ..." I think the fact that he refuses even to quote the Constitution correctly is sufficient comment on his arguments.

Regarding Senator Murphy's allegations that Fianna Fáil Deputies are not in favour of this proposal, the fact is that there is 100 per cent unanimity in the Fianna Fáil Party in regard to this proposal. It may be that there were some who originally had doubts about the likelihood of its being passed, but, as time goes on and as we see the fears of the Fine Gael Party that their supporters and their members are gradually coming round to the views held by the Leader of the Party and those prominent members of the Party who still, despite all the reasons there are to the contrary, retain some confidence in the possibility that at some time in the future there may be sufficient backbone in the Party for them to have some future as a political Party under the clearer circumstances we propose to establish, we find that any of those in our Party who had some doubts about the likelihood of this proposal being successful at the outset are just the same as Fine Gael: they are beginning to appreciate that as time goes on it becomes more and more certain that the people will provide themselves with this electoral reform.

If Senator Murphy chooses to look on the role of the Labour Party as that of a permanent minority, that is his business. If he assumes that in these circumstances it is inconceivable that the Party should continue to exist, that is a matter for himself, but in that he is expressing an opinion contrary to the opinion expressed by the Leader of his Party and by others such as Deputy Dunne who claimed to believe, at any rate, that the Labour Party will continue to exist, irrespective of the electoral system.

Senator Yeats, I think, has shown that consideration of Senator FitzGerald's forecasts even on the basis on which he alleged these forecasts were made, are unjustified, but of course the basis itself is completely unrealistic. To attempt to make a forecast of what would happen under a system in which there would be 144 single-seat constituencies on the basis of results in electoral areas that bear no relation or cannot bear any relation to what the single-seat constituencies would be and which are greater in number than 144, is absolute nonsense, even if you ignore the fact that it takes no account whatever of the personalities who would be contesting these different single-seat constituencies.

In the county of Carlow, for instance, which could have, at most, two seats, there are four electoral areas and the population in these areas varies from 6,048 to 13,180. In Cavan, where there are three seats at present and where there cannot be any more than three seats, there are four electoral areas, varying in population from 10,390 to 16,644. In County Clare, where there are four seats, there are five electoral areas varying in population from 10,528 to 22,321. In Cork, where there are 12 seats, there are only seven electoral areas, and they vary in population from 18,412 to 38,502. In Donegal, where there are six seats, there are five electoral areas varying in population from 13,112 to 28,154. In County Dublin, where there would have to be at least ten seats, there are only six electoral areas, and these vary in population from 26,410 to 51,772. In Galway, where there are eight seats, these are only five electoral areas, and the population varies from 20,595 to 44,549.

In Kerry, where there are six seats there are four electoral areas, and the population varies from 19,402 to 37,923. In the county of Kildare, which could not have four seats without some addition, even under the Third Amendment of the Constitution proposals, there are four electoral areas, and the population varies from 12,397 to 19,860. In Kilkenny, where there would be three seats, there are four electoral areas varying in population from 11,594 to 21,718. In Laois, where there would be, at most, two seats, there are four electoral areas, and the population varies from 7,431 to 17,712. In Leitrim, where there is not sufficient population for two complete seats, even under the Third Amendment of the Constitution proposals, there are four electoral areas and they vary in population from 5,613 to 10,331. In Limerick County, where there would be at most four seats, there are five electoral areas and the population varies from 14,478 to 18,391. In Longford, where there would not be sufficient population for two seats, there are five electoral areas varying in population from 3,603 to 8,201.

In Louth, where there are three seats, there are five electoral areas and a variation in population from 5,497 to 23,424. In Mayo, where there are seven seats—there would not be sufficient population for seven seats—there are six electoral areas and the population varies from 14,667 to 26,857. In Meath, where there are three seats, there are five electoral areas and a variation in population from 10,701 to 17,695. In Monaghan, where again we could not justify three seats, there are four electoral areas and the population varies from 8,455 to 15,092.

In Offaly, where there could be at the most three seats, there are four electoral areas and the population varies from 10,371 to 16,522. In Roscommon, where there could be only three seats, there are four electoral areas and the populatiton varies from 10,521 to 20,183. In Sligo, where again three seats could not be justified, there are four electoral areas and the population varies from 7,446 to 21,040.

In Tipperary North Riding, where there are four electoral areas and where, at the most, there could be three seats, the population varies from 8,941 to 17,873. In Tipperary South Riding, there are five electoral areas and the population varies from 10,633 to 16,374. In Waterford county, which would justify at most two seats, there are four electoral areas and the population varies from 7,547 to 12,912. In Westmeath, where there is not sufficient for three seats, there are four electoral areas and a variation in population of from 8,020 to 19,379.

In Wexford, there are four electoral areas—this is the first county where the number of electoral areas equals the number of seats—and the population varies from 19,556 to 23,432. That appears to be the only county in which Senator FitzGerald's exercise would be in any way appropriate.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Minister has not listened to a description of the exercise.

Comment on this

In Wicklow, there are three seats, four electoral areas, and the population varies from 8,430 to 22,264. In Cork city, there are six electoral areas and there would probably be six seats, so that this is probably reasonably suitable also. In Dublin city, there are only 12 electoral areas, but three would have to be approximately 25 seats, so it is obvious that the whole operation that Senator FitzGerald went through——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is not the way we did it.

Comment on this

——is, in fact, ridiculous.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

This whole exercise is a waste of time. The Minister would know if he listened.

Comment on this

There is no deduction that can be made from the results in the local authority electoral areas that would be applicable, even if you ignored the fact that the issues are different, that the personalities contesting them are different, and so on, and even if you ignore considerations such as Senator Quinlan mentioned as to who is marking whom. These things are all relevant and Senator FitzGerald has no way of taking them into consideration. Certainly the electoral areas can bear no conceivable relationship to the single-seat constituencies which are likely to be formed except in a couple of instances. Any attempt to base forecasts on assumptions based on the results in the local electoral areas is ridiculous.

If Senator FitzGerald and his Party are happy in the belief that the local election results in Dublin city, when there was no question of the Government of the country involved and where personalities like the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Seán Lemass, Deputy MacEntee, Deputy Vivion de Valera, Deputy Noel Lemass and others were not involved, give some indication of the results of a general election I suppose it would be unkind to try to bring Senator FitzGerald back to a sense of reality. This reference is, of course, to his prognostications in regard to future results under PR. Similarly, his attempted forecast of what would happen in regard to the single seats, without having any knowledge whatever of the constituencies, or who is marking whom, or what candidates would be contesting individual constituencies, which is, of course, a very relevant factor, is equally ridiculous. Indeed, an attempt to do that is the height of folly and would not be expected from anyone except someone like Senator FitzGerald and Senator Quinlan whose contact with real life politics is minimal.

Senator Yeats has shown that, even ignoring these very relevant considerations and humouring Senator FitzGerald by considering his forecasts made on an inadequate basis, they are still not justified. Considering any comparison with what happens in Britain is equally irrelevant. There is a difference in the populations in the constituencies to the extent of 450 per cent there whereas here, even under the proposals made in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, the divergence from the national average cannot exceed one-sixth.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is the 450 per cent a divergence from the national average?

Comment on this

This operation which Senator FitzGerald and his colleagues have been going through may be very entertaining and I have no doubt it is a very stimulating mental exercise, but it has no reference to practicalities.

I still maintain, in regard to the amendment, that it is not democratic, if there are a number of candidates properly nominated, to rig the electoral system so as to arrange for an artificial and unjustifiable choice between one of the possible pairings of the candidates. If this is to be done the public are at least entitled to choose between each possible pairing and not one selected at random. Indeed, if this were done, it would show up the system for the farcical system it is.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I regret that I was late back after the tea interval, not because this involved the House in having the benefit of listening to the Minister but because of the apparent discourtesy of not being here to continue my speech.

Comment on this

I was only holding the fort.

Comment on this

The Minister is capable of some kindness.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I was dealing with points raised by Senator Yeats, points of criticism which are worthy of comment, because he was talking at a serious level. I think his points should be answered, and answered fully and fairly. I propose to recap on the system adopted by Senator Dooge in his calculation. As I mentioned earlier, I did not do the calculation in relation to the so-called straight vote. My calculation was confined to the alternative vote which cross-checked very closely with that of Senator Dooge, Professor Chubb and Dr. Thornley. I have no responsibility directly for the straight vote calculation beyond checking the manner in which it was carried out and, as is to be expected from someone of Senator Dooge's stature and academic standing, it was thorough and soundly based. The method adopted in dealing with the Independents has been oversimplified by Senator Yeats. This may, perhaps, be our fault for not explaining it more fully, although I thought Senator Dooge explained it fairly and fully in his introductory remarks. There were in the local elections something like 140,000 Independent votes. We seem to be a little bit at odds as to the precise number. Senator Yeats makes this 150,000.

Comment on this

All Parties.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

For all Parties other than Labour we got 138,000 and Senator Yeats got 153,000. Let us call it 140,000. The order of magnitude is agreed and, as I think Senator Yeats will agree, the precise figure is not vital for this purpose. What Senator Dooge did was to take one particular group in respect of which the preferences are well known and well established, where the bias towards Fine Gael is strong and where failure to take account of this could indeed be criticised. That is the rate-payers' group. Their votes were allocated with a very strong margin of preference for Fine Gael, giving a 40 per cent net advantage to Fine Gael. A similar operation was not carried out in respect of the votes from other Parties which did not go towards Fine Gael so we were being most careful not to bias the calculation in any way unfairly in the direction Senator Yeats is worried about.

Some further Independent votes were also taken into account because allowance is made for the election of several Independent TDs so that some of these votes are used in that way. The number of Independent votes which were not in fact used in the calculation —and which were not ignored in Senator Yeats's words—which he will agree is statistically the same thing as distributing them pro rata was about 105,000. What we are talking about— and the margin of error relates to this —is nine per cent of the total vote. I think the total vote was something under 1,150,000 and we are talking now of how we treated 105,000 of those votes, that is nine per cent. The simple answer, as Senator Yeats will appreciate on thinking it over, is that it almost would not matter what you did with nine per cent of the votes because, as each Party must get their share, the variation between the shares on such small amounts cannot be very great.

In fact what we did was to assume they would go pro rata to the Parties in the order of the magnitude of the Party vote. Senator Yeats argues that this was unfair and introduced a bias into the calculation. That is arguable. He may have a point. Let us consider it and see how big the bias is. I think it is arguable for this reason: while, in a general election there is an established pattern under which the Fianna Fáil share of the Independent preference is small, though not as small as Senator Yeats suggested—the figure was about 35 per cent in the general election in 1965 on a more accurate calculation—the Opposition Parties tend to get the major share. I would have thought, from my knowledge of the local elections, the position as regards Independents, and how their votes are distributed, that the bias against Fianna Fáil amongest the voters who support Independents is less marked in local elections than in general elections. There are many local candidates, the votes from whom are distributed pretty evenly between the Parties. There are also rather more, shall we call them, Fianna Fáil Independents—people who were not adopted possibly by the local Party. This happens in all elections but, in local elections, it is more liable to happen than in general elections.

I think that any study of preferences in local elections would show that the bias against Fianna Fáil, amongst the Independent voters' preferences passing on, is less marked than in a general election. However, for the sake of this argument, I would accept Senator Yeats's point and I would ignore that fact completely, giving full credit for these particular votes passing on, as they did in the general election of 1965.

Let us consider, now, what the outcome of this calculation is and the enormous difference it makes to the results of our calculations. We have, on my rough calculations, a starting point of the first preferences in the local elections roughly as follows, giving or taking a few thousand. I have rounded them off. There will be the odd error. We disagreed about the Killarney result before tea. A careful comparison of my figures with those of Senator Dooge shows that, from the typed figures I was supplied with, the Fianna Fáil candidate was wrongly allocated to Fine Gael. Senator Dooge's figures agreed with those of Senator Yeats. There are bound to be these errors. In local elections, there is the difficulty of establishing the Party affiliations and, in the tabulation, errors can occur. But, allowing for that, the totals I get are as follows, when they are rounded off: Fianna Fáil, 460,000; Fine Gael, 380,000; Labour, 165,000; Independents, 140,000; total, 1,145,000: we need not worry about some thousands either way.

When we take into account the distribution of the ratepayers' votes and the fact that we allowed about 10,000 Independent votes for the election of a couple of Independents, the distribution we get of the Party vote, allowing for that, before there is any arbitrary allocation, turns out roughly as follows: Fianna Fáil, 475,000; Fine Gael, 385,000; Labour, 170,000, with 105,000 votes which we allocated arbitrarily in the same proportion. With these 105,000 votes, when we allocate them arbitrarily in this proportion, the result we get is something like this: Fianna Fáil, 525,000; Fine Gael, 425,000; Labour, 187,000—call it 185,000. That, in other words, is the result we came up with, assuming that these votes of Independents were distributed pro rata to the Party strength and the Party vote. If Senator Yeats feels this is unfair, I would point out that I am accepting it for the sake of argument to see where it leads us. That gives Fianna Fáil 46 per cent; Fine Gael 37½ per cent and Labour 16½ per cent. That is the picture we came up with as a result of this calculation.

Senator Yeats holds that this is unfair. I suggest, therefore, we distribute these Independent votes in the same way as they were distributed in the general election of 1965, in the cases where they are distributed, where Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour candidates were standing in the 1965 general election. The distribution I got from that allocation is as follows: Fianna Fáil, 35 per cent of the Independent and small Party preferences passing on; Fine Gael, 43 per cent; Labour, 22 per cent. Let us distribute those votes in that proportion. We find that the answer is as follows: Fianna Fáil, 512,000; Fine Gael, 430,000 and Labour 193,000. That gives us the following percentages: Fianna Fáil, 45 per cent; Fine Gael, 38 per cent and Labour, 17 per cent.

In other words, the net result of the whole effort that Senator Yeats has put in, the net result of the bias he said we introduced — if it were true that Independent votes were distributed in a local election in the same way as in a general election—would be to introduce an error of one point in the percentage of the vote. This suggests that we have underestimated the decline in the Fianna Fáil support. We said that Fianna Fáil support fell, between the general election and the local elections, from 49 per cent to 45½ or 46 per cent. Senator Yeats said Fianna Fáil lost more votes, that they are down to 45 per cent. He may be right. That may be the result. I think he is a little unfair to Fianna Fáil if he thinks the swing from Fianna Fáil was nine per cent: I think it was seven per cent. Let us split the difference and reach eight per cent with a small tolerance of one-sixth.

Comment on this

You cannot compare local elections with general elections.

Comment on this

Even on your own basis, it was a fake.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I have now adjusted the comparison in accordance with Senator Yeats's prescription. It is changing the rules in the middle of the game to say that the comparison cannot be made.

Comment on this

It is no game.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Let us move on from the graph to what Senator Yeats had to say on the subject of the distortion this could introduce into our calculation that this share of the vote in a general election would yield Fianna Fáil 98 seats. The share of the vote giving Fianna Fáil, he thinks, 45 per cent of the Party vote which, if you allow for the fact that, in a general election, there are Independent votes, would mean their share of the total vote would be about 43½ per cent. We are saying that, with 43½ per cent of the Party vote—say, 44 per cent of the total vote—Fianna Fáil would get 90 to 100 seats. Senator Yeats challenges this. If Senator Yeats is right, and taking his figures fully and taking no account that Fianna Fáil may do better, we put down a bias of about 15 per cent of the Independent vote in the local elections. We put down Fianna Fáil as getting 45½ per cent and Fine Gael 38 per cent of the Independent preferences——

Comment on this

How many of the elected Independent councillors, half of whom you say were elected by Fianna Fáil votes, voted for the Fianna Fáil candidates for the chairmanship of the local authorities in this country? Would that be worth while finding out?

Comment on this

There is nothing relevant only what gives the required result. You start with the result.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I would not want to discourage Senator McGlinchey from this useful research, the results of which he might communicate to us in the next Session. My concern now is the performance of the voters rather than that of the votees. What the votees do, when elected, does not always satisfy the voters. It would be very interesting and perhaps Senator McGlinchey on some section on which it would be relevant, although I cannot imagine which, could give us the benefit of this research, or guesswork as the Minister would call it.

Comment on this

Not even that.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Do not be unfair to Senator McGlinchey in saying that it would not be even guesswork.

Comment on this

You start off with the result and then you work it out.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

This is about the 121st occasion on which the Minister has abused me. I think I am running a record. I will go back over the records and see how many score of such references there have been. The point I am trying to make here is that the bias we are said to have introduced is about 15 per cent. We were giving Fianna Fáil 7½ per cent margin and Fine Gael an 8 per cent margin—a 15 or 16 per cent difference.

The alleged bias is one of the order of 15 or 16 per cent and in order for this to affect the results, it would be necessary for the Independent vote to be six or seven times the size of the majority so that 15 or 16 per cent of it going as a net benefit to one Party rather than to another would distort the result, as Senator Yeats tried to tell us, if the vote were six or seven times the size of the majority. I have thus taken account of the maximum bias that might be introduced into this system.

I think I have cleared up any misunderstanding there may have been and answered the point. It is possible that there is some bias here; it could mean an over-estimation of Fianna Fail's share of the votes in a local election by one per cent but this is not a terrible offence and I am prepared to plead guilty to having committed that crime, in an effort to be fair. If that is the case, it could introduce distortion into the result and instead of Fianna Fáil getting 98 seats with that share, they would get something less. Senator Yeats will be able to tell us when his research discloses in how many cases the Independent votes were six or seven times as large as the majority.

Having dealt with that, fairly and justly, I hope, the House will agree that we have endeavoured to disclose the basis of our calculations and we have made no case which we are not prepared to back up with documentation and figures and, having done that, we can do no more. If that fails to persuade them, then we have done our duty, and if despite our efforts to persuade them from this project, for their own benefit, and if instead they are going ahead, I hope they will not complain if when the referendum is defeated, they find themselves facing a general election in a rather unhappy position. Certainly we will have very little sympathy for them at that stage, after all our warnings.

In conclusion, on the question of the alternative vote versus the straight vote, I have no doubt that the alternative vote is superior to the straight vote. The Minister's extraordinary argument about people not getting the opportunity to exercise preferences is one which is logic standing on its head. Let us take a Fianna Fáil convention, such as the one to which Senator Quinlan referred, and of which I have very little knowledge, but let us assume that the way the votes go is that the Colleyites get 40 per cent and the Haugheyites and the Bolandites might get 30 per cent each or 29 or 31 per cent and although the latter are in the overwhelming majority and although the Colleyite candidate's position in the Party is a minority one, they might let him in as a candidate if they both stand. If this was repeated throughout the country, think of the consequences for the Fianna Fáil Party. What do the Bolandites and the Haugheyites have to do? They either have to go ahead contesting these conventions on the straight vote and find the Colley candidates sweeping the country or do a deal and pull out. A very harsh choice for them to face. I do not think it is fair to put them in that position. Think of the consequences in Dublin NorthEast alone in these circumstances.

The truth is that what happens at Fianna Fáil conventions as far as I know and if I am wrong——

Comment on this

Were you ever at one?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

——the Senators will be able to correct me— is that if a candidate is not elected, someone at the bottom is eliminated and another ballot is held. Am I right? Is that the case? Or if somebody does get 40 per cent, do they simply accept him? Is that the way it is, that the simple straight vote ballot is used to select a single candidate for a by-election? I am waiting for an answer.

Comment on this

Make your own speech. We never interrupt.

Comment on this

Do not worry; the answer will come.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

They are not able to answer me. This is very distressing. Perhaps Fianna Fáil Senators are on a more elevated plane and are more removed from the hurly-burly of conventions than Fine Gael Senators are, or Labour Party Senators.

Comment on this

The Senator should address the Chair.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I have been addressing the Chair frequently.

Comment on this

The Senator should address himself to the subsection.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

I thought I was doing so with great effect and some humour.

Comment on this

What do Fine Gael do at their conventions?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

Fine Gael use this as the most convenient system. They use the system of the successive ballots, which I think is the best system. It is not a transferred vote but you have a series of ballots. The French have this system and it has advantages over the alternative vote but it does involve having a succession of elections. If you have six candidates, as you had in Wicklow, for a single seat, the eliminations could take a long time and you could have six elections in six weeks which would be worse even than the long counts about which the Minister told us. A system under which you might have election after election is a little inconvenient and for that reason the alternative vote has been adopted. It is imperfect but it is good enough for us.

The Minister was worried about the case where you have three candidates and the Fianna Fáil candidate is ahead but still has not got a majority of the votes. It does not enable Fianna Fáil supporters to say which of the two candidates they would prefer and this means that the man who is elected, whether he be Fine Gael or Labour, may not be the man whom the Fianna Fáil people would prefer to see elected. I quite agree there must be certain cases in which the difference between the Fine Gael and Labour candidate is so fine that, if the Fianna Fáil voters could, by the system Senator O'Kennedy proposes to us—an interesting but, perhaps, unduly complex one—express their preferences, they might push the lower of the two Opposition candidates above the highest candidate.

It is a pity the cumbersomeness of the system does not enable Fianna Fáil supporters to express this opinion and adjudicate between Fine Gael and Labour candidates. It is a pity this should happen. I can quite see that it bothers Fianna Fáil quite a lot. Any system that does that does bother them and, therefore, it is not fair. If Fianna Fáil voters could express their preferences, it might well be that they would put our candidate ahead of the Labour candidate. That might even have happened in Limerick, but we did not press for this. We are prepared to accept that, where we are without the benefit of the Fianna Fáil preferences, Labour may get ahead of us. Labour are not straining at the leash to get hold of these Fianna Fáil preferences to get ahead and we do not care if, on occasion, someone gets in who is not quite the person who should have got in if every preference were counted to the very end.

I do not think it is a national tragedy if, to the displeasure of Fianna Fáil voters, a Fine Gael man is elected instead of a Labour candidate. Nothing is perfect in this imperfect world. Indeed, the perfect may easily be the enemy of the good, and the Minister, in his search for perfection, is throwing out a system that is reasonably good and introducing a system which is demonstrably bad and a system which is demonstrably dangerous and we do not see why that should be done. That is what I feel about the alternative vote; it is demonstrably superior to the straight vote.

On the question of the amendment, the issue put before us by certain Independent Senators is that we should, in fact, prefer to either proportional representation or the single seat and spot vote, the single seat with the alternative vote. That is not a proposition which commands much support at the present time, for various reasons. It is clear none of the three Parties support it, I suspect for different reasons. It is a system which has certain merits and, if we had to choose between it and the single-seat spot vote, then we should not hesitate as to which we should choose because the bias it introduces into the ratio of seats to votes is much more moderate. It would have the effect of giving some clear majorities, but not the vast majorities the spot vote would be liable to give, and, for that reason, if we had to choose, most of us on this side of the House, including the Labour Party, would choose the alternative vote.

The choice happily is that we are able, with the help of the people, to hang on to the present system, a system which many think is preferable. I do not think—I have said this frequently—we should exclude the possibility of changing the system. I see certain merits in the transferable vote system: I have said so. I am disappointed the Minister has not researched the articles I wrote and tried to demolish the arguments. I will give him the references, if he likes. I have said there are certain theoretical merits in the system and it is worth considering, but such a change should not be made without the agreement of all Parties and, if one Party feels such a change would discriminate unfairly against it, then it is the duty of the other Parties, of Fianna Fáil as well as Fine Gael, not to indulge in an operation which is designed to benefit one Party at the expense of another. By all means let us reform the electoral system and change to another system, if it is a better system, and if it does not discriminate unfairly against another Party, but there is nothing in the present system so bad, so evil or so incapable of being worked satisfactorily that it forces us to change to another system which is not acceptable to all Parties.

Therefore, despite the siren temptations held out by the Minister, and despite the temptations of being in government on our own the second next time, which the Minister has promised us, with an assurance backed by forecasting I have never claimed, we remain unconvinced. I have some feeling as to what the result of the next election might be, but I am afraid I cannot follow the Minister in forecasting the second next with any certainty. I would like to feel the Minister was right, but I would much prefer the probability of Fine Gael being on their own after the next election, given the right system. I do not think we can accept the Minister's assurance, or necessarily accept his assurance, that his only consideration is giving Fine Gael the chance of becoming the Government. I think we are allowed to have some sceptical doubts in that connection. Accordingly, as this change is not agreed, and as its introduction would have the effect of preventing the people, by a reasonable swing, changing the Government at the next election, which they intend at present to do and I believe they will hold to that intention, and as the effect of this amendment would be to put Fianna Fáil into office for another term after 12 years of office, I am against it.

I am against it because I do not think any Government is much good after the first ten years, or so. I suspect the change of Government in 1932 was in many respects beneficial to the country. The people in office were becoming tired. They had carried the terrible burden of the Civil War, and after, and I believe the change of Government at that particular juncture will be viewed by historians as a good thing, though it was not regarded as a good thing by those who were defeated on that occasion, and they include my father. I believe the change in 1948 was a good thing. I believe it would have come much sooner but for the War. I am quite clear now that a change of Government at this juncture would be a good thing. I believe the effect of the proposed change in the electoral system would be to lower the percentage Fianna Fáil would need to get a majority and therefore the effect would be to put them back in office for a period of up to 17 years. That is something I am not prepared to contemplate.

I stand for the present system. This is not a good moment to change it. There may have been a case for changing in 1959 to the alternative vote. Had that been proposed and had it been agreed by Labour and Fine Gael, it might have been a useful change, but I am not prepared to make a change at this point in the country's history, when Fianna Fáil have been in power for 11 years. That approach would hold good, irrespective of what Government had been in office for the past 11 years. I am not prepared to make this change without the support of all Parties. Although I see some merits in the proposal of the five Independent Senators, for those reasons I am against it.

Comment on this

In my opinion, there is some justification for having the transferable vote in a multi-seat constituency, but not because of any intrinsic merit in such a system. There is a great deal to be said against it. For practical reasons, I think it would be difficult to manage the multi-seat constituency without the transferable vote and it is not, therefore, so objectionable in the present system. To bring this basically unsatisfactory and illogical vote—the transferable vote— into the single-seat constituency seems to me to be ridiculous. There is no justification whatsoever for it. It is an illogical system; it is unjust; it is unfair. Anybody who can see any justification for a system under which some get a second chance and others do not get a second chance must be deficient in some respect. It passes my comprehension how anybody could regard such a system as either a logical or a fair system of voting.

We have had the question of A, B and C so often that I do not propose to go over it all again, but it seems to me that Senator FitzGerald, speaking a short time ago, missed the real objection, or seemed not quite to understand the objections to the transferable vote because he gave as an example the fact that the system used in conventions was much the same system and, consequently, if you accepted that as being reasonably practical, you could not object to the transferable vote.

Of course the system used in conventions is completely different. It is different in a fundamental way and consequently it is not by any means as objectionable as the transferable vote, because if you take the situation where you have certain people voting for A, B, C and D and where A only has something less than half the votes, the point there is that the people who are supporting A, if they see how the voting is going and if they realise that A is not going to make it, on the second vote can change their vote. Therefore, they have a second choice and this fundamental objection to the transferable vote does not apply to the system which applies in conventions and so on where the last candidate is eliminated. The fundamental objection to the transferable vote which I have, and which most people have, is the fact that most of the voters do not have a second chance and the voters who are lucky enough and ill-judged enough to pick the last candidate have a second chance.

Nobody, to my mind, can justify that situation. If you are going to have a preference vote, a transferable vote, the only possible way in which it can be operated is to have the system where everybody's preferences are effective and you give a lower valuation to second, third and fourth preferences and add all the votes for all the candidates and find out who gets the highest total. This is a fair system. It might be a rather difficult system but at least it would be fair, and nobody would get less than a fair vote and neither the candidates nor the voters would be discriminated against in any way. There is no logical reason and I repeat, there is no logical reason, why under the present transferable vote system, the people who vote for the candidate who gets lowest on the list have a second chance and the people who vote for the person who gets the highest get no second chance. It is not logical: it cannot be justified on any grounds. It may be that people, for political reasons, feel that in the present political scene the transferable vote is best for them or best for their Party, but if we are discussing this purely objectively as an electoral system, there can be no justification for it.

Apart from the fact that we are discussing the system and that I have expressed my disagreement with the system as being basically unfair and illogical, I certainly think that the way this particular amendment is worded is quite ridiculous because we are talking about introducing proportional representation into a single-seat constituency. How can you have proportional representation in a single-seat constituency? When we think of PR, we think in terms of having, say, a five-seat constituency. We think in terms of, say, Fianna Fáil getting maybe 45 per cent of the votes, Labour perhaps 20 per cent, Fine Gael 20 per cent and Independents 15 per cent, and we think of Fianna Fáil getting two seats and each of the others getting one. This, in a rough way, represents proportional representation for the supporters of the various Parties in the constituency. When you have a single seat and if you presuppose for a moment that the voting is on the same pattern and you have 45 per cent of the people in the constituency who want Fianna Fáil, and roughly speaking 20 per cent who want the various other people and as a result of transfers you might find that a candidate who started perhaps with 20 per cent or even less gets the seat how can anybody suggest by any stretch of the imagination that this is PR?

Comment on this

The Constitution suggests it in the case of the President.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

The Constitution says in regard to the Presidency:

The voting shall be by secret ballot and on the system of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote.

We only elect one President at a time.

Comment on this

I am talking about the system in general. After all, we are changing the Constitution now. If the Constitution says that I think it is a bad way to describe it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

So do I.

Comment on this

The amendment is in line with the existing Constitution.

Comment on this

I would not be supporting this if I thought the Constitution was correct in every way. I think there are defects in the Constitution. There are the two we are dealing with and the fact that you can describe electing one person in a single-seat constituency as proportional representation. I think it just does not make sense. As I was saying, it could be that somebody who started with 20 per cent got the seat and the 45 per cent of the people who voted for somebody else are not represented at all. This could not be proportional representation. However, that is merely a question of definition which is not very important but it adds to the illogical aspect of the amendment we are dealing with.

Not only do I consider the transferable vote in a multi-seat constituency to be a bad one, I think in a single-seat constituency it is quite ridiculous to impose it in view of its various defects. However, I am not voting merely on the basis that I think the transferable vote is a bad one. I am voting on this on the basis that the "straight" vote is a good one and is the best one and the one which shows most clearly what candidate the people want in a constituency, particularly in a single-seat constituency.

One thing this system will force the elector to do is to really face up to reality, to face up to the facts of the election and to pick the candidate that he really wants and not to be laying long odds on on all kinds of other candidates, voting for a man because he is a favourite son, because he lives nearby, because he a good footballer, or something like that. We all know that at the moment people very often start off by saying: "Even though I want so-and-so to be elected I am going to give a vote to such-and-such a person. He will not be elected anyhow." He goes on down the list and probably gives his third and fourth preferences to the person he really wants to see elected.

This is obviously not facing up to reality. It is not genuinely making a decision. It is making several decisions. It is voting for people that you really do not think will be elected, that you do not want to be elected. It is going through this farce of giving first, second and third preferences to people you do not want to see elected. I think that if the person knows that there is going to be no second preference, no second choice, no question of eliminating people and distributing surpluses and all this kind of thing they will face up to the real issues in the election. They will face up to the real question of who is the best candidate in their particular constituency, who they really want to elect. They will have to make a much harder decision and a more realistic one. They will have to vote for the person they really want and not give votes to people just because they live nearby and so on.

I think it is an excellent system. I think it will ensure in a general election that there will be a good swing against a Government who have lost the favour of the people, lost the support of the people; that there will be a swing in favour of an Opposition that has shown itself capable of taking over government. It will give it a chance to become the Government, and become the Government with a decent majority, a chance to carry on and to form a strong Government, a Government who can really put their policy into operation. It is a healthy political situation and one worth having and much better than the kind of stalemate situation we have had in the past and certainly much better than the extraordinary and thoroughly unhealthy situation that has arisen in many continental countries that have PR, which have on many occasions for months not been able to form a Government because of the impossibility of transmitting public opinion into a definite strong Government.

I am very much in favour of this and in favour of the fact that there should be healthy swings one way or another, even if one of these swings puts Fianna Fáil out of office. No matter how good Fianna Fáil are, people will turn against them and if people put them out of office, I have no objection. I think it is a good thing, as Senator FitzGerald mentioned, that a Party should go out of office now and again to reappraise their policies and their personnel and have a new look at themselves outside government. I have no objection to that but I think the Government in power should be in a good healthy majority and realise when the time comes that it will go out with a bang as well as it came in.

It has been suggested by Fine Gael, in particular, that Fianna Fáil are in favour of this proposal because, and only because, it will benefit them. It will benefit Fianna Fáil and certainly having evaluated this system, they dealt with it purely as an electoral system and if they come to the conclusion that it is a good system in an objective way, the best system for the country, would it not be ridiculous for me to expect any Member or any Party to vote against it or not in favour of it? Would it not be ridiculous to be against it merely because it was against my own Party? I am not going to say I will vote because I think it will benefit my own Party. That would be illogical. I think it will be good for Fianna Fáil most of the time, not all the time, because sooner or later Fianna Fáil will go out with a swing but Fianna Fáil have faith in themselves as a Party. They have faith in their ability to form a Government and to govern. They have faith in their ability to get the support of the people most of the time and for that reason they are willing to accept the disadvantages as well as the advantages of this system.

Fine Gael are pretending they are against this system because they do not think it is a good system, because they say it is not in the interests of the country, because they say, among other things, that it might adversely affect the Labour Party and they would not stand for that kind of thing. Really I have not heard more hypocritical humbug in my life as I have heard from Fine Gael speakers over there crying about the fact that this may adversely affect the Labour Party. I do not think anybody in the country, least of all the Labour Party, is convinced by that hypocrisy. Fine Gael are against this proposal because they have not got the confidence in themselves that Fianna Fáil have. They have no confidence in their ability to form a Government at any time in the future. They do not believe that at any time in the future they will get the support of the people to enable them to form a Government. Consequently, they are in favour of PR because PR is a system that lets Parties down lightly, that lets Parties that are on the way down down lightly. It cushions the shock of inevitable decline. That is why Fine Gael are against the system. That is why they are waging this campaign because they have no hope that they will ever be in a position of taking advantage of the swing of the straight vote which would swing them into office. They are only looking forward to the decline of the Party and they want that cushioned as much as possible, and their whole campaign stems from this anxiety. They will not face up to the facts, because of the effects this will have on their Party and because of the fact that they want to take life easier and gradually decline under the PR system. If they face up to that by stating why they are against this, if they really state and admit it themselves, they may well conduct a more effective and more successful campaign against this proposal.

Comment on this

I should like to say that having listened to the debate and having raised the points that require to be raised on the single transferable vote, in order not to weaken the common effort against PR and in order not for any one moment to convey that I have any doubt or hesitation between them at this stage of the proceedings, I wish, by leave of the House, to withdraw the amendment standing in my name and to face the issue in the defence of freedom and the defence of the minority who have the right to exist in this country.

Comment on this

Before that, I think I am entitled to answer some of the ridiculous statements of Senator FitzGerald.

Comment on this

Is the House prepared to allow the amendment to be withdrawn?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

If the amendment is withdrawn, I take it the discussion will continue on the section.

Comment on this

The amendment would decide the vote on the subsection.

Comment on this

In that case it is not a matter for Senator Quinlan to decide that the debate will cease, in withdrawing the amendment.

Comment on this

The point at issue was not to be the subject of a separate decision but the main decision is the decision being taken on the section of decision.

Comment on this

The matter is one for the House. Is the House prepared to allow the amendment to be withdrawn?

Tarraingiodh siar an leasu faoi chead.

Comment on this

By arrangement subsection 2º is agreed; that is the understanding.

Comment on this

The understanding was that on conclusion of the debate the subsection would be put.

Comment on this

The understanding has been come to with certain responsible Members of the House that the two would be decided together.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

That means the section is withdrawn.

Comment on this

If the amendment is withdrawn, then the section is withdrawn.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. Garret FitzGerald Fine Gael

It must be put.

Comment on this

I understood that the procedure was that no separate decision would be taken and that we having moved the amendment, would be prepared to take a decision on the section but we certainly would not for one moment say that the decision on the amendment would prevent the putting of the section.

Comment on this

The amendment has been withdrawn. The Chair will now put the motion which is that subsection 2º be agreed.

Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh fó-alt 2º i 9 Codanna I agus II mar chuid den Sceideal".

Comment on this
Division

Rinne an Coiste votáil: Tá, 23; Níl, 16.

Tá 22
·
Níl 16
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Táimíd ag feabhsú. Tá biseach ag teacht ar an scéal.

CUID III AGUS CUID IV.

PARTS III AND IV.

Comment on this

Parts III and IV will be discussed together.

Tairgeadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh codanna III agus IV mar chodeana den Sceideal.

Comment on this

This is an improvement on the corresponding article in the existing Constitution and, accordingly, we have no objection to it, except that it is keeping bad company.

Cuireadh an cheist agus faisnéiseadh go rabhthas tar éis glacadh leis.

Comment on this

Is there not an amendment to section 5?

Comment on this

No; to section 6.

Comment on this

I wonder if one might have an indication at this stage as to what, in fact, we are now being asked to agree to. Is it the whole of Part V or is it the different sections of Part V?

Comment on this

The different sections, section by section in Parts V and VI.

Comment on this

It is time that was made clear.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 2.

Comment on this

Are we going through the different sections in Part V?

Comment on this

We have come to section 6 in Parts V and VI and we have come now to amendment No. 2.

Comment on this

Have we not got to amend Part V as well as Part VI? looks at Part V, page 8, section 6, subsection 2º, line 26.

Comment on this

If the Senator

Comment on this

Have we taken the different sections of Part V and Part VI? They have been called out without my hearing them and certainly without the House agreeing to them. However, if it is now in order to move amendment No. 2, I shall do so.

Tairgim leasú 2:

I gCuid V, leathanach 9, alt 6.2º, líne 26, "le tromlach dhá dtrian" a chur isteach i ndiaidh "rith"; agus i gCuid VI, leathanach 11, alt 6.2º, líne 41, "by two-thirds majority" a chur isteach i ndiaidh "passed".

I move amendment No. 2:

In Part V, page 8, section 6.2º, line 26, after "rith" to insert "le tromlach dhá dtrian"; and in Part VI, page 10, section 6.2º, line 41, after "passed" to insert "by a two-thirds majority".

This is an amendment to section 6.2º in Part V and to section 6.2º in Part VI of the English version. What we are proposing here is to provide that, where the Commission has made its report, whether that is the report of the entire Commission or the report of the chairman in default of agreement at the end of a period of three months, when the report is laid before Dáil Éireann it can only be amended by, not the simple majority that is contained in the Bill, but as is proposed in the amendment, by a two-thirds majority. In other words, what we believe is that if this Commission which is so much lauded by the Minister and which has much to commend it, makes its report and if it is not acceptable, it should not be subject to amendment by a simple majority of the Dáil; it should be subject to amendment by a two-thirds majority of the Dáil. I think in that we are following precedent because this is a rather special effort by a Constitutional Commission which is made up of six members of the Dáil who will have been chosen as to three by the Taoiseach and as to the other three, in such manner as may be determined by law, from the Opposition and it may well be that in default of agreement between the members of the Commission the Chairman, who will be a judge of the High Court or the Supreme Court will have to make up his own report.

For the purpose of annulling this report, we believe that it be not a simple majority, which is too easy and which means in effect that it would be very easy to amend the report of the Commission and, in effect, would mean that the ruling Party in the Dáil will be able to gerrymander, notwithstanding the fact that all the paraphernalia of a Commission has been provided by the people and has made its report. As the Bill is now framed and as it is proposed to amend the Constitution, it means that the work of this Commission, which is supposed to be independent, can be set at nought and the constituencies effectively and finally determined by a simple majority of Dáil Éireann. In effect, what that means is that if the Government of the day having a majority in Dáil Éireann do not like the way in which the Commission has drafted the constituency boundaries, the Commission's work is set at nought and a simple resolution of the Dáil amending the report can then determine the constituencies in a way in which they cannot be determined at the present time because even at the present time it requires a full Bill going through Second Stage, Committee Stage and Report Stage in Dáil Éireann and, let it be said, subject to review in Seanad Éireann, to determine the constituencies. So that the last position, which has been so well diagnosed by Senators on this side of the House, will be worse than the first, and, in fact, the constituencies for the future can be determined by a simple amendment to a report passed by a simple majority of Dáil Éireann.

It might seem to some people unreasonable to suggest that it should require a two-thirds majority of Dáil Éireann to annul the report of the Commission. In this context, it is of interest and I think of value of recall that in the proposal to amend the Constitution in 1959 it was provided that a similar resolution amending the report would require to be passed by not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting. If that was right and proper in 1959, there is nothing which has happened since then to say that it is wrong today.

Comment on this

Did you agree with it then?

Comment on this

That is an awkward question. His words are there, printed.

Comment on this

Did we agree with it then?

Comment on this

The two-thirds majority?

Comment on this

What we agreed with in the context in which this Bill was being presented to the people—we did not like this Commission at that time——

Comment on this

You like it now?

Comment on this

Wait now—what we believed was that it was better for Dáil Éireann to go through the process of a Second Stage, a minute examination on Committee Stage but we have no guarantee, knowing the way in which this particular Government operate, that any particular length of time will be allocated to the debating of this resolution. The Government may decide that they will allocate 12 hours, eight hours or one day or whatever they like. We believe that if the resolution is to be amended, it should require a two-thirds majority because, as it is now framed, what this Bill means is that a simple resolution of the Dáil can determine the constituencies for the next 12 years. To vest that power in Dáil Éireann, with no right of review by the Seanad, is, to my mind, handing over too much power to the Dáil in a matter so important as the framing of constituencies for Dáil elections. Accordingly, I commend the amendment to the House.

Comment on this

Senator O'Quigley mentioned the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958, which included a provision to the effect that the support of not less than two-thirds of the Members present and voting would be necessary to amend a resolution of the Constituency Commission. What he did not tell us was that this provision, just the same as the provision for a Constituency Commission itself, was strongly criticised by Opposition speakers in both Houses on the grounds that it gave virtually absolute power to the Commission and effectively left the Dáil with no say in the matter. We are being criticised because, as is being alleged, we made no effort to obtain agreement. I have been pointing out all the time in these debates that it is not possible to interpret the minds of the Opposition Parties and bring in any proposal to coincide with their viewpoint as interpreted by their previously known attitude. Of course, their previous attitude is not relevant. All that is relevant is that everything brought in by Fianna Fáil must be opposed. The only measuring stick they apply to anything brought in is that, if it is proposed by Fianna Fáil, it must be opposed by them.

In 1958, when the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill was being debated, they did not want the Commission at all. They objected to it and put down an amendment to remove it from the Bill. But, if there was to be a Commission, then they wanted the Commission's decision to be amended by a simple majority of the Dáil. Unlike some other things, we did not try to meet their viewpoint completely, as far as it was known. We decided a Commission was desirable in these circumstances when there was going to be a complete recasting of constituencies, when there was going to be a system of 144 single-seat constituencies instead of the present 38 multi-member constituencies. We decided it was only reasonable and fair that there should be an impartial Commission set up to delineate these constituencies. We decided, whether the Opposition liked it or not, we would propose the establishment of a Commission and that this should be inserted into the Constitution.

On the other hand, we decided we would go part of the way with the Opposition and that this time we would concede their demand that the Constituency Commission's decision could be amended by a simple majority of the Dáil. Of course, we pleased them with neither thing. This time, however, contrary to all expectations, instead of wanting no Commission, when they succeeded in getting the fairly simple proposal split into two separate proposals, they wanted two separate Commissions and separate provision made in the Constitution——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister is now going somewhat wide of the amendment, which is concerned about what happens to the Commission's Report when it goes back to the Dáil.

Comment on this

I have made my point. We did not succeed in interpreting their minds correctly and, lo and behold, we were not correct in the other change either. They have to oppose this because it is introduced by Fianna Fáil. Although last time they wanted the Commission's decision to be amended by a simple majority at a time when we proposed it should be amended by a two-thirds majority, this time when we concede their point to them and suggest a simple majority, they want a two-thirds majority. Senator O'Quigley was one of those who in 1959 argued in the following terms. I think he has the Seanad Debates there and he will find this in volume 50 at columns 406, 407 and 410. He said that the people:

... will be deprived fairly effectively of any opportunity to express their view in Dáil Éireann because the report of the Commission can be set aside or modified only by a two-thirds majority of the Dáil.

He went on to say:

The Commission I want set up is a Commission that will inform and recommend, not a tribunal that will decide.

In other words, he wanted the decision to be made, in effect, by the Dáil. In the Dáil also Deputy T. F. O'Higgins, who was one of the Deputies who sponsored the amendment proposing the removal of the Constituency Commission altogether, also advocated that the Commission's decision could be set aside by a simple majority of the Dáil. As I pointed out before, it is completely futile for the Government or anybody else to try to interpret the minds of the Opposition Parties on any subject under the sun. We took their views into account and complied with them in so far as we felt it was reasonable to do so. Now we find that they have decided to change their opinion. They are not satisfied yet.

Comment on this

We are always a step ahead.

Comment on this

The funny thing is that these Parties who change their minds overnight, in accordance with whether a proposal is favoured by Fianna Fáil or not, still argue that it is unreasonable to expect that the electorate could possibly have changed their minds in the short space of nine years, although they have had much more experience of the evils and dangers of the present system and have seen how similar systems have resulted in the inability of countries in Europe to form a Government at all. It is unreasonable apparently to think that the ordinary people who do not take an active part in politics could have changed their minds in view of these things, but Fine Gael can change their minds overnight in accordance with whether a proposal is favoured by Fianna Fáil or not and without any reference to the merits of the proposal.

There is no point in trying to reach agreement with the Fine Gael Party. It is quite obvious the whole objective is to try and get a minor amendment— I agree this would be only a minor amendment—accepted in the Seanad for the sole purpose of trying to postpone this for another while in the hope it will come so near to the last date for a general election that it will not be practicable to have the Referendum before the general election at all and so give Labour and Fine Gael one last opportunity of forming a Coalition behind the backs of the people.

Comment on this

We all realise by now that the Minister has the great advantage of having a Civil Service behind him——

Comment on this

He has a memory.

Comment on this

——which he as Minister directs to go around and look up every quotation ever made by everybody about anything. I suppose he finds that entertaining.

Comment on this

No, it is Senator Yeats who does that, not the Civil Service.

Comment on this

He is living in the Celtic Twilight. The Minister conveniently forgets——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Chair is intrigued by the fact that voices have been coming from all quarters of the House in the last few moments. Could we have Senator O'Quigley on the amendment?

Comment on this

Hearing strange voices in the same way as the Minister has been seeing and hearing strange things, things that Senator FitzGerald never said. The truth is that in 1959 we did not want the proposal to abolish PR or the Commission and this House did not have either of them because they threw out both.

Comment on this

We had a majority.

Comment on this

But now our duty, as we see it at present and in the light of the very valuable report—in spots— of the all-Party Committee on the Constitution which reviewed the whole of the Constitution, is to establish that it is desirable to establish a Commission and, if it is to be the type of Commission we believe it should be, the precedent for that Commission should be set out in this Bill in a proper way. We know this Bill will be defeated but that is not a reason for not trying to amend it. If Fianna Fáil were right in 1959 I do not understand why the Minister is complaining if we think as we do now on this particular aspect of the matter.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the amendment pressed?

Comment on this

Yes.

Cuireadh an Cheist: "Go gcuirfear isteach na focail a tairgeadh" agus faisnéiseadh go rabhthas tar éis diúltú leis.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The question now is: "That section 6 in Parts V and VI stand part of the Schedule."

Comment on this

On this I must take issue on what has gone on before. I do not know what the Chair was putting to the House, whether the Chair put subsections 1º, 2º, 3º, 4º and 5º of Part VI beginning on page 8 of the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

At the commencement of the Committee Stage the Chair read out the course which it was proposed would be followed. An interval was allowed for consideration of this and then the House agreed to a certain course of action. It is acknowledged that the procedure was an unusual one and the Chair has throughout the debate tried to facilitate Senators in every way possible. The order of the House in regard to the manner of discussion still stands.

Comment on this

I do not know what that is intended to mean but I want to say this. When the vote finished here this evening there was unruliness and disorder on the opposite side of the House to the extent that the Chair had to sound the gong and call for order.

Comment on this

Not on this side.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the Senator raising a point of order?

Comment on this

I am raising a point of order to know where we stand.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

On section 6 of Parts V and VI.

Comment on this

I want to take issue on that and to say that we were afforded no opportunity of dealing with sections 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of Part VI contained in the Bill. There was a number of points I wished to raise in regard to the Commission.

Comment on this

Does the Senator want to go backwards?

Comment on this

The Minister should try to conduct himself now and again.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator is complaining about sections 1 and 2 of Part V which do not appear to exist.

Comment on this

I am talking about sections 1 and 2 of Part VI and there are sections 1 and 2 of Part V. They do exist. That is the Irish version. I admit it is very difficult to follow this Bill but despite that we must do the best we can.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The position is that Parts V and VI start with section 3.

Comment on this

And the Senator wants to deal with sections 1 and 2.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

There are no sections 1 and 2 in Parts V and VI.

Comment on this

I do not understand this business at all because, as I understand the Constitution, it consists of articles and sub-articles and when you begin to talk to me of sections you are introducing terminology that is foreign to the matter. The Constitution is made up of a number of articles and sub-articles and therefore it is irrelevant and wrong to refer to them as sections or sub-sections. That is where I misunderstood the situation, that is if these sections were ever put.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

So far as the Chair is concerned sections 3, 4 and 5 have been put to the House and agreed to.

Comment on this

In my respectful submission they have not been put to the House. I did not assent to them or dissent to their passing and they certainly were not put ordinarily.

Comment on this

The Senator said they were an improvement.

Comment on this

No, I said Part IV is an improvement, which it is. I said that, as compared with the corresponding section in the Constitution, it was an improvement. But I also said it was in bad company.

Comment on this

Could the Chair help the House by re-reading what we agreed to? My recollection is that we agreed to take Parts V and VI together. Part V commences towards the bottom of page 6 and Part VI commences towards the bottom of page 8. That is what we are now dealing with. We take them as a whole and not in paragraphs.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

In fact what was read out at the commencement of the Committee Stage said in regard to the other Parts, for example in regard to Parts III and IV, that they would be discussed together but in the case of Parts V and VI each section would be taken separately.

Comment on this

The sections were not put to the House.

Comment on this

Yes, they were; 3 and 4 were put.

Comment on this

They were not.

Comment on this

That is a reflection on the Chair.

Comment on this

Is it not the normal procedure when dealing with an amendment, whether it is a subsection of a Bill or not, that you take the amendment first and that if we are dealing with Parts V and VI, we take amendments to Parts V and VI? I was at pains, when the debate started on this section, to point out that there was an amendment to Parts V and VI and the record, I trust, will show that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The amendment was to section 6 of Parts V and VI and, accordingly, the Chair disposed of sections 3, 4 and 5 before calling the amendment on section 6.

Comment on this

That is the standing procedure. That was not done. I called the attention of the Chair to the fact that there was an amendment to Parts V and VI.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the House feels there was a misunderstanding here which is obstructing the debate and if the House decides that a discussion might now take place on the sections 3, 4 and 5, the Chair will not stand in the way of the decision of the House.

Comment on this

I do not think it was envisaged that there should be a separate vote on each section but, as I understand it, that each section could be debated separately and that if, as has happened, nobody raised anything on sections 3, 4 or 5 and as the mover of the amendment to section 6 stood up to move that, I think it was taken, whether formally put to the House or not, that nobody wished to say anything on 3, 4 or 5. The misunderstanding has arisen, I think, in that Senator O'Quigley understood that the amendment would be taken and following the amendment, that there would be discussion on Parts V and VI as they stand. When moving the amendment he did not appreciate that any sections of Parts V and VI were disposed of.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Chair is concerned to keep order in debate but also to facilitate Senators and if the House now wishes—otherwise, the only remedy open to Senator O'Quigley would be to put down amendments to those sections on Report Stage and discuss them then— there could be a debate now on Parts V and VI as a whole. This would be a variation of the earlier order that they be taken separately.

Comment on this

I would have long since finished and the Minister would have disposed of the two or three small points I want to raise.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the House agreeable that, having disposed of the sections, we now vary the procedure and debate Parts V and VI as a whole and at the conclusion of this debate, a single question will be put that Parts V and VI stand part of the Schedule?

Comment on this

No. That is not the way the rest of it was done.

Comment on this

That would open the whole discussion on it again. We could be here for another fortnight.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If we proceed the way we were proceeding, there would be a discussion on sections 6, 7 and 8.

Comment on this

The same could have been done on Parts I and II. I refrained from replying when Senator Quinlan wanted to withdraw his amendment—although it was not his amendment, as there were other Senators associated with it—in order to convenience Senator Quinlan. If we are going to go back in order to convenience Senator O'Quigley, we should also go back to Parts I and II to convenience me.

Comment on this

Heaven forfend. I would agree to anything rather than subject myself and everybody else to that.

Comment on this

We made this arrangement earlier and I think we should stick to it. If Senator O'Quigley really wants to raise something on one of the earlier sections, I certainly would not object to it if you, a Leas-Chathaoirleach, are willing to rule in his favour.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

In the interests of expedition, the Leas-Chathaoirleach will call on Senator O'Quigley and will probably not listen to him too carefully for the first three minutes. First of all, we shall dispose of sections 6, 7 and 8.

Cuireadh agus d'aontíodh Altanna 6, 7 agus 8 i gCodanna V agus VI.

Comment on this

I do not want to detain the House except to make two or three small points which I think are of some importance. In the first part of Part VI, that is, the provision dealing with the Constituency Commission, we provide for the appointment of a chairman and the selection of six members, three to be appointed by the Taoiseach and three to be determined by law from among the Opposition. What I am concerned about in this— and I think this is of crucial importance in the operation of this Commission—is that nowhere in this article or elsewhere in the whole of Part VI will one find any provision that the expenses of the Commission shall be determined by law. There is nowhere any provision to the effect that the Commission will have its own independent staff or that it will have any staff to enable it to do its work in drawing up the constituencies. I would be anxious to know what will be the position, whether it will be short staffed or not staffed at all; and, if it is not going to be staffed, whether it will have some say in the selection of the staff or will have to take the staff which is given to it. If the Commission is to operate independently, effectively and efficiently, it ought to be able to have the staff which will have the confidence of everybody concerned, not least of the Commission itself.

Secondly, in regard to the members of the Commission, I observe that any member of the constituency commission may resign his office by placing his resignation in the hands of the chairman of Dáil Éireann. But it is always proper form in legislation to provide that in such a situation the vacancy may be filled by co-option. I do not find any such provision in this Constituency Commission. If the interesting situation develops where a judge who was the chairman of the Commission said: "A plague upon both your houses; I cannot do anything with you", and resigns his office, I do not see any provision here that a successor can be appointed forthwith, In that event will there be a lengthening of the time; will he have his three months and one month to resign, or what happens if he dies while he is Chairman of the Commission?

These are matters which should be provided for when we are amending the Constitution. If these are minutiäe which cannot be dealt with in a general document such as the Constitution, the Constitution should enable these matters, which are substantive matters, to be determined by law. Those are the few matters I should like to have dealt with, and perhaps the Minister would give his views on them.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister, on Parts V and VI.

Comment on this

It is quite true we have not provided, and are not proposing to provide, in the Constitution the manner in which the expenses of the Constituency Commission will be dealt with. I think that most Members of the House will agree that we would have a very peculiar Constitution if we were to insert in it matters of detail about the staffing of various bodies. Of course, all matters concerning the Commission can be dealt with by law and the law cannot be enacted except by going through the two Houses of the Oireachtas. There will have to be a Bill brought into the Dáil and brought from the Dáil to the Seanad in regard to the Constituency Commission. Similarly, with regard to the resignation of members, it would seem to be ridiculous to insert details like that in the Constitution. The law will provide that where a member resigns he will be replaced by somebody who will be selected in the same way. If it is the chairman, he will be selected in the way in which it is provided that the chairman will be appointed, if it is one of the Government members, he will be replaced on the nomination of the Taoiseach; and if it is one of the Opposition members, he will be replaced in the way in which it is provided Opposition members will be appointed. I think any normal person will accept that and will say it would be ridiculous to insert all these things in the Constitution.

We were warned on the last occasion by no less a person than Deputy John A. Costello of the undesirability of cluttering up the Constitution with too much detail. In attempting to interpret the mind of the Fine Gael Party in regard to the desirability or undesirability of cluttering up the Constitution with too much detail, I do not think it would be unreasonable if we accepted what Deputy J. A. Costello said as being their view in regard to this matter. It is ridiculous to suggest that all these details should actually be inserted in the Constitution. A law will have to be passed with regard to the setting up of the commission on the constituencies.

Comment on this

I suppose the Minister will in time learn something about the Fine Gael mind.

Comment on this

I doubt it.

Comment on this

He seems to find great difficulty in interpreting it.

Comment on this

I do not intend to try.

Comment on this

Ah, do try.

Comment on this

There is not any such thing.

Comment on this

If there is not any such thing, why refer to it?

Comment on this

I was assuming there was. Obviously there is not any such animal.

Comment on this

The Minister of course does not know——

Comment on this

See section 7.

Comment on this

——the provisions of the Constitution as well, perhaps, as some people who were not around when it was drafted. He will find in the present Constitution that the President "shall receive such emoluments and allowances as may be determined by law". That is Article 12, sub-article 11.

Comment on this

There is nothing about clerical officers.

Comment on this

So it is proposed to appoint clerical officers only to the staff of the commission.

Comment on this

Nor departmental secretaries.

Comment on this

It is provided in the Constitution in relation to the very transient commission known as the Presidential Commission that it can aot in the absence of the President. That is Article 14 of this ridiculous Constitution to which the Minister refers. There is provision for what is to happen in the event of the chief justice being unable to act, and in the event of the Deputy Chairman of Dáil Éireann and the Chairman of Seanad Éireann being unable to act. It may be ridiculous to have put these things in the Constitution but they are there, and it seems to me that if you want the commission to be independent we should put in a general provision that matters relating to staff and the filling of vacancies, and so on, should be determined by law, so that if something arises there is provision to fill the gap created by such things as deaths. I am glad the Minister can be lighthearted about some things but I believe this is a legal requirement and it is necessary in the section.

Comment on this

I suppose it is only natural that lawyers who have discovered the potential of the Constitution with only 50 Articles as a source of income would like to see the scope in this direction still further increased. May I direct the attention of Senator O'Quigley to the fact that section 3, subsection 2º of Part VI provides that a Constituency Commission shall consist of seven members appointed by Dáil Éireann and its form and manner are described there. The next section we shall be discussing, section 7, provides that any matter whatsoever relating to Constituency Commissions or constituencies may be provided for by law.

Comment on this

It does not provide for the filling of vacancies.

Comment on this

We did not include the law about the Constituency Commission in the Bill but the Bill provides that such a law shall be enacted.

Comment on this

"Subject to the provisions of this Article, any matter whatsoever relating to Constituency Commissions or constituencies may be provided for by law."

Comment on this

That is what I asked the Minister to point out earlier. He did not know.

Comment on this

I did. The Senator wanted to go backwards instead of forwards.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know what is in his own Bill.

Comment on this

Senator Ó Donnabháin found it.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Are there any points which Senators wish to raise on Parts V or VI?

Cuireadh agus d'aontaíodh an cheist.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is now necessary to put the question formally:

"That the Schedule be the Schedule to the Bill."

Cuireadh an cheist: "Gurb é an Sceideal is Sceideal don Bhille."

Comment on this
Division

Do rinne an Coiste vótáil.

Tá 24
·
Níl 11
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

In accordance with the procedure previously agreed to, it is now necessary formally to pass sections 1 and 2.

Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh alt 1 in a chuid den Bhille" agus faisnéiseadh go rabhthas taréis glacadh leis an cheist.

Comment on this