Appropriation Bill, 1969: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–178 of 362. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1969 ›
Before the adjournment last night I paid tribute to the Minister for Education and also to the Minister for Finance and the Government generally for the massive investment in education. I pointed out that the Vote for Education had increased from £15½ million in the year 1959/60 to £58½ million in the year 1968/69. This is a massive investment in education, a massive investment in people and in the development of our country. This occasion should not be allowed to pass without putting that on record.
I referred also to the creation of more opportunity for education for a greater number of people. People who in the past could not avail themselves of post-primary education can now do so. I referred also to the rationalisation of the schools situation throughout the country by the elimination of the very small schools and also to the schemes of improvement in schools throughout the country. More than 1,000 schemes of improvement and reconstruction have been put in hand since 1967. I referred also to the very significant development in special education for mentally and physically handicapped.
I regretted to have to refer to a vicious campaign which has been carried on inside and outside this country against the teaching profession. It is very embarrassing for anybody to have to stand here before intelligent people to take a stand against this campaign. It has been triggered off by a small group of people who avail themselves of the various media to denigrate the teaching profession.
It would not be reasonable to resent reasonable criticism but one must strongly resent complete distortion and exaggeration. This is bad enough inside our own country but people have seen fit to go outside the country and use the television medium in the United States with a viewing audience of 35 million people, and portray the Irish people as a nation of savages. These words are not mine, they are words used by a member of the medical profession—and I must say that some of the people engaged in this campaign are members of the medical profession, a very small group who do not represent at all the magnificent profession of medicine in this country——
Comment on this
Has the Senator seen the film he is talking about?
Comment on this
A Chathaoirleach, would you tell this man to desist from ignorant and ill-mannered interruptions?
Comment on this
The Senator should not refer to another Senator in that fashion.
Comment on this
I did not say he was ill-mannered. I said his interruption was.
Comment on this
All interruptions are disorderly. Senator Brosnahan on the Bill.
Comment on this
I shall refer to the film if it will satisfy the Senator. I said that the words I have used, that we are a nation of savages, were used by a member of the medical profession in this film. The same person went on further to describe how regulations prevent the slaughtering of a pig in the presence of other pigs but that children can be beaten and slaughtered in Irish schools in the presence of other children and that we should come abreast of pig psychology. This is the presentation that has been made of the Irish people to 35 million people in the United States.
Comment on this
I shall come to that too. Thousands of letters have poured into this country and many of them have come to our office and also to the Department of Education, seeking an explanation. Irish people and Irish-Americans have been gravely disturbed by what they have seen and have asked how could Irish people contribute to the creation of this image. One of the persons who contributed to the film, the person who used the words I have just used, has been described in today's paper as a person who calmly presents the case against corporal punishment.
The question of corporal punishment is not being discussed at all. We are discussing a campaign which tries to pin the charge of brutality on Irish teachers, on Irish schools and on the Irish system. They are the words used by what is considered a responsible Sunday paper—the strange story of brutality in Irish schools—not brutality, not discipline, not even beating but police brutality, teacher brutality and parent brutality.
This is the line that is being put out leading to the same situation as exists in the place where the film was shown. We see the results in the United States of the dropping of discipline in schools. People are trying to reintroduce it into the schools in New York where you have a blackboard jungle, where a teacher cannot turn his back on a class, where teachers had to go on strike because they could not get police protection in the schools, where in Chicago an armed policeman has to stand guard in the corridors of certain classes. If one read Time magazine a fortnight ago one would have seen that statement.
Those are the lessons to be learned from abandoning all discipline in schools; I am not making a case here on behalf of corporal punishment but I shall nail this charge of brutality against Irish teachers. The NBC team arrived in Ireland and they got a number of people to make statements. I was approached at the end after several people had spoken. A phone call came to my office asking me if I would answer some questions on the Irish school situation.
I agreed because this is a new dimension in any position in which people have to deal with the public—if one is asked to give an interview, one cannot say no. A team arrived at the office by appointment, with cameras and lighting equipment. I was asked a series of questions on the Irish school situation: what were the advantages of our system, the disadvantages, the problems and so forth, and then at the end I was asked about discipline in the schools. Incidentally, I considered the person who interviewed me to be a rather shifty-looking character; he did not seem too happy and he fluffed several of his questions. I have been interviewed by at least ten interviewers from RTE and I have never had the experience of an interviewer fluffing his questions before. I feel I must mention this if I am to comment on the film later on. I felt that this was a strange performance from an NBC interviewer——
Comment on this
He was not frightened, but as an explanation one of his colleagues said he had a bad night the night before and we know with whom.
Comment on this
If this is supposed to be a reference to me it is not true.
Comment on this
Senator Sheehy Skeffington has been told it is not in order to interrupt. Is there to be one law for him and another for the rest of us?
Comment on this
I told him that we had not got blackboard jungles here, that if he wished to see one he should go back to his own country. Corporal punishment was allowed; it was disappearing from the educational scene for certain reasons, which I gave —the abandonment of the results system on which a teacher's pay depended on the answers given by the children, the abandonment of the rating system where teachers were under pressure to produce high standards and these high standards were produced by a question and answer performance by the teacher and the children, the abandonment of the scholarship scheme under which children were pressured to perform beyond their capacities in examinations, the abandonment of the primary certificate examination, the introduction of a new curriculum on a child-centred principle rather than a programme-centred curriculum—I said all these things have led to an easing of corporal punishment. Any teacher who inflicts corporal punishment now for failure at lessons should have his head examined. There is no need for this and it has practically disappeared, yet in that situation this small group of people sought to go outside the country and drag the good name of the Irish people in the mud.
The man who has been described as calmly presenting the case against corporal punishment—I shall not name him because I do not want to take unfair advantage of anybody within the protection of this House—was described by a doctor living in Arizona writing to his sister in Ireland as a garrulous buffoon who destroyed his own case by exaggeration. Dr. Sheehy Skeffington is described in it too; to give credit where it is due, he is described as speaking well but he was also described as having very heavily attacked nuns and brothers. This is all in the film which I hope will be seen here. We are asking that it should be seen so that the Irish people should know what was said about them.
Comment on this
And by whom. The country in which this film has been shown is a country where in some States there is corporal punishment and in other States there is not —it even varies from city to city— but in the places where children are protected against their teachers they are fed with the portrayal of violence and much of it can be seen in this country on television at the present time—stabbing, booting, shooting, and strangulation. This presentation of violence appears on television in America, yet these children are being protected by psychiatrists, psychologists and so on. I do not want to make a case against the American situation—there is nobody who has a higher admiration for the American nation than I—but it is a complete distortion of the truth to bring a film portraying an unreal situation in this country into an atmosphere of that kind. The only people in America who were shocked were the Irish and the Anglo-Irish. Anything they saw in the film could not shock the native Americans as they see violence all around them.
As a follow-up to that film, the group which organised it wrote to a firm of lawyers in Philadelphia asking for their support in a fund-raising campaign to stamp out brutality among the Irish. I think the Department of External Affairs, the Department of Education, the Government and the people of this country should know exactly what is being said on their behalf. I think it should go on the record of this House what is being said about the Irish people so that we will be in a position to say to the people who write to us about the Irish school situation that what has been portrayed is an unreal and distorted picture. This is a letter to a firm of lawyers in Philadelphia:
Quite some time ago, you and I met in the Gresham Hotel, Dublin, and had a long chat in the lounge with our mutual friend, Raphael Siev. I showed you some pictures and implements of punishment and gave you some accounts of the awful conditions in some of our schools. You gave me your card and offered your help. If the offer still holds, I would like to ask a great favour of you.
Perhaps you saw the big exposé in the September issue of N.B.C.'s television program "First Tuesday"? Well, this program has done a great deal to put pressure on the Establishment (Church and State) to introduce new regulations stopping the terrible beating of defenceless Irish school-kids. (The parents belong to one of three "camps"—(a) they don't give a damn, (b) they actually want their children beaten at school, or (c) they are afraid to open their mouths.)
You parents fall into one of these categories. You have no option. You don't care a damn, you actually want your children to be beaten or you are afraid to open your mouths. The letter continued:
At last we seem to be "getting places". However, the battle is not yet over. The teachers, the Department of Education, the Catholic Church Authorities, and indeed a large number of parents, are all bitterly opposed to us. Foreign exposure is the thing that really "makes the shoe pinch". N.B.C. has promised to send us the film of the T.V. program. I don't think Irish Television would allow it to be shown here. Maybe B.B.C. in London might be very interested. We will "shop around" when the film arrives.
The entire "REFORM" crusade has been a tremendous effort on the part of a small number of people. We have given of our free time, and money, in fullest measure. We really do need financial aid to keep up the battle. We are writing letters of appeal for funds to the leading American newspapers. We hope that the people who saw this television program will feel strongly enough to send us a donation. (N.B.C. reckon that about 35 million people saw it in colour.)
We wonder,..., would you agree to become our American fund agent? Could we mention your name and address in our letters to the leading newspapers —New York Times etc? We feel that those thinking of donating to a remote and little-known organisation might feel “happier” sending money to a highly-respected American firm of lawyers. In that way REFORM's “bona-fide” would be established in their eyes.
We, the committee, realise of course, that you may not be in a position to undertake the task we ask of you. There may be many reasons why you could not do this particular favour for us in REFORM.
Anyhow, we thought that it would not do any harm to ask you to help us in this rather special way. Unfortunately, time is running out on us and we must get these letters off to the American newspapers as quickly as possible. However, we must "hold fire" until we hear from you. Naturally, we would be most grateful (Mr. X) if you could let us have a "yes" or "no" answer as soon as you possibly can.
We had a committee meeting last night and I was asked to write to you without delay. Our letter of appeal should have been attended to long before now, but we were held up by NBC. Anyway, better late than never! Time magazine may do an article on this subject soon—the title being “Mutiny on the Blarney”. This would be great because it would “freshen up” the whole thing in American minds again. However, we cannot be certain that it will appear and we must forge ahead anyway, with or without this additional publicity.
I look forward,... etc.
A postscript said:
I enclose a final draft of the letter of appeal. It cannot be mailed until we hear from you. Enclosed also is a copy of our memorandum which will give you more information about us.
Comment on this
On a point of order, could we have the signature to this letter? It is only fair that the Senator should tell us who wrote the letter.
Comment on this
It was written by Dick Clear, President of REFORM. I have already said that I did not intend using names.
Comment on this
It is important that we know the source.
Comment on this
I am not doubting the Senator but just asking for the signature to the letter.
Comment on this
This is the final draft of the letter to American newspapers:
...Many millions of civilised Americans saw the September NBC "First Tuesday" television documentary on the beating of children in Irish schools.
Note "civilised Americans". Who were excluded? —the Red Indians?
To those of you who were shocked by what you saw, we, the committee of REFORM, appeal for your help.
Our association was founded in 1967 and has sought unceasingly to put a stop to the almost incredibly harsh and primitive methods still used in many schools in Ireland. Protests, over the years, have been virtually ignored by the authorities. The only effective weapon we have which can force the Government to take positive remedial action is publicity, bringing the true facts about corporal punishment in Irish schools before the eyes of the world.
The "David Moore" court case——
This is the case of a child who was beaten on the posterior and a coloured photograph of this appeared in a certain shop window in the city and it also appeared in colour in the film. It was an isolated case but it was enough to drag the good name of the Irish people into the mud of certain television systems.
Comment on this
Damages to the extent of one shilling were given by the court.
Comment on this
That is the responsibility of the court. The draft continues:
——which you learned about in the television program is only one of the many instances in which REFORM's aid is vitally needed. But REFORM needs your support, financially, to carry the campaign forward to final success.
We are an entirely independent association and our only funds are the voluntary contributions of our members. It is another sad fact about Ireland today that many of her people are apathetic to this appalling situation in our schools, adopting the attitude that "what was good enough in grandfather's time is good enough for us", or— if they are more enlightened—they are afraid to oppose the Establishment. Consequently, the number and resources of our supporters are limited. That is why we so urgently need your help.
The name of the firm of solicitors was then given. The principal of this firm, the letter continued, brought back with him
first-hand information about conditions in certain Irish schools. He has, very kindly, agreed to act as our American fund agent.
This is the draft before the man had ever replied:
Receipts will be sent to all persons who donate money to REFORM's fund.
The Government of the Republic of Ireland is acutely sensitive to criticism from overseas, particularly from the United States. By writing to Irish newspapers, expressing your horror of what you saw on the N.B.C program, many of you have already helped our cause more than you probably realise, and we want to thank you.
But, please don't forget to send something to ... to speed the work of REFORM in bringing humanity and enlightenment into the educational system in Ireland.
Comment on this
Yes, Mr. William J. Brickley, the head of a very large firm of solicitors on John F. Kennedy Blvd., Philadelphia. I shall now read the letter he sent back, and he sent the entire correspondence to members of our organisation. He, like several other Irish-Americans, was appalled by what he saw of the presentation. They would not have been appalled at the real presentation but they were appalled at something they knew was totally false. Maybe the people who did contribute to making the film were misled and maybe when the negatives were brought back to the television station in America they were edited in such a way that they did present a false picture. In situations like this the Secretary of the Department of Education would be asked a question about the protection of children. He would give an answer and something else would be put in to contradict it. This went on all the time. A person speaking in good faith would say something and the next thing something else would come on. This is the type of presentation which was presented Everybody realised it was a complete fabrication.
Mr. Richard Clear, President, Reform.
Dear Mr. Clear.
I thank you for your kind letter of October 9, 1969 which was flattering to me to say the least. Subsequent to the conversation that I had with you in Dublin last year, I investigated the overall question by conversations with individuals who are intimately connected with the educational systems in the schools of the Republic of Ireland. On the basis of this inquiry, I have reached the conclusion that extreme problems of corporal punishment do not generally exist within the Irish School Systems, but isolated instances of cruelty exist and take place in your schools as they do in almost any school system, when human beings, in the name of education, take the place of the parents, and mete out unjust discipline to their students.
However, in good conscience, I cannot lend my name to the overall indictment of the entire Irish school system, strictly on the basis of isolated cases of corporal punishment being meted out in excess by logical disciplinary needs.
We have too many instances in today's world where many good meaning individuals engage in the fallacious reasoning of going from the particular to the universal. As a matter of fact, in the United States, the greatest problem that we experience in our public school systems is the inability of the teacher to maintain any discipline whatsoever, even justifiable minimum corporal punishment. If corporal punishment meted out in excess of normal requirements were in fact a policy of any school system, I would oppose it on purely intellectual grounds.
Comment on this
The letter went on:
However, my investigation leads me to believe that your organisation has established a straw man and is attacking an alleged policy which is de facto non-existent.
Comment on this
I will continue:
If your organisation's aim was merely to lend its support to the elimination of individual cases of extreme cruelty, I would be the first one to lend my support to such a case. However, I cannot in good conscience lend my support to any group which is bent on attacking the entire system without any proof whatsoever that the said system actively engages in the policy, or better stated, the alleged policy, of extreme corporal punishment.
I will defend your right to the death in undertaking your campaign, but I cannot go contrary to my own conscience when I disagree with the major premise, and real target of your group.
What might be "the real target of your group"? That is the situation which has been created by an irresponsible group of people speaking on behalf of the Irish people. That is the type of correspondence that would have appeared in the leading American newspapers. The correspondence has already done immense damage to Irish prestige abroad. I would be failing in my duty to the people of this country and to this House if I did not put this correspondence on record. It is a disgraceful situation. I do not know what we can do to repair the damage this campaign has done.
Comment on this
I should like to tell Senator Sheehy Skeffington, Reform and any other group of people who try to tell the teachers of this country how to maintain discipline in our schools that they are only wasting their time. I do not know whether you read it or not but recently there appeared the story of the INTO over 100 years. It is a story of struggle against pressure groups, against authoritarianism, down the line. It is a proud record which we have. We have always defended the child. We have sought a better system of education for the child. We were the first to highlight the plight of mentally handicapped children. Not alone that, but we have contributed from our funds through the distribution of hints to parents of mentally handicapped and physically handicapped children. We have issued pamphlets on mongolism and various other aspects to help parents to realise the difficulties of dealing with the handicapped child situation and by negotiation with the Department of Education we have created special schools and special classes and have endeavoured to improve the lot of the child generally.
I would personally deplore, and I know every reasonable teacher would deplore a situation where any child would be ill-treated but not for one second, however, I repeat, will we abandon our responsibility as teachers and allow a blackboard jungle situation to develop. Not for one second, and I say this deliberately to any group of people in this country, will we abandon our responsibility. Other children have rights and other parents have rights too. You take a class of 50, which is far too large——
Comment on this
——or 45 or 40 and where you have two or three blackguards who want to disrupt the whole situation and the whole order in the school, and the other 43 or 47 children want to be taught in an orderly, disciplined manner——
Comment on this
There should not be classes of that size.
Comment on this
The Senator has already spoken and he should allow Senator Brosnahan to make his speech.
Comment on this
Where parents want their children to be taught in an orderly, disciplined manner and where the children themselves want to be taught in an orderly, disciplined manner we will not abandon those people's rights just to cater for the point of view of a small group of mischiefmakers. The mischief they have done on this occasion has been tremendous and we will all pay for it as a nation. This calm person who has been presenting the case against corporal punishment has written to the New York Times and other American papers —a copy of his letter appeared in an edition of the Sunday Press— advising American bunsinessmen to think twice before coming to Ireland because if they came they would expose their children to the savage brutality of Irish schools. In other words, those people were prepared to go so far, having smeared the Irish nation abroad and the teaching profession, as to damage the economy by advising business people not to come to Ireland as business executives or as people who might be willing to set up business here and invite over trained personnel.
They were prepared to go that far to damage the economy to a certain extent by advising people not to come into the country because their children would be beaten up at school. I should like to re-emphasise the point I made. We are only one teachers' organisation in this country. There are others, religious and so on, and we are not speaking on our own behalf here. I should like to emphasise, in respect of one teachers' group, that we will not abandon our right to maintain discipline in our schools within the rules of the Department of Education. We think that the rule set in the Departmental code is an excellent and wise one.
Comment on this
We will not abandon our right within the rules to maintain discipline no matter what pressure is brought to bear on us, because we think that it would be irresponsible to get back into the situation which exists in certain countries at the present time. There is a great similarity between our school system here and the school system in Scotland, and as recently as two years ago the Scots set up an independent group of people completely outside teaching to investigate this question of school discipline. Strangely, their thinking on it was very much the same as we had in the teachers' organisation, that we would welcome a time when it would not be at all necessary to use corporal punishment in the schools. That time has not yet come, but with improved school systems and improved curricula, improved school buildings and better pupil-teacher ratios, the time would come when it could be phased out in various standards.
Comment on this
But it will never be phased out under pressure from any group as far as we are concerned.
Comment on this
Never, as far as we are concerned, but we would welcome a situation like they have in Scotland when an ideal milieu can be created within the school whereby corporal punishment would not be necessary.
Comment on this
But we are giving away to no pressures. I had a number of other things to say with regard to our educational system. Our organisation have sought for many years a university-teacher training college link. This has been a request which has been made as far back as 1902, repeated in 1908, 1923, 1953 and at various teachers' congresses since. We think that there is only one art of teaching and there should be one common qualification in the art of teaching. The principles of the imparting of knowledge and cognition are well and truly established. No matter what level the teacher is teaching he uses those principles established over the centuries by trial and error. We think that there should be one qualification in the art of teaching no matter what level one teaches, for the principles are still the same. There is just a variation of techniques.
When one is teaching the lower classes one must adopt various techniques of presentation—colour, illustration, change of voice and so on—in order to establish involuntary attention, because little children are incapable of paying attention and the teaching must be such as to compel, as involuntary attention. Then as the child grows older this appeal to involuntary attention eases off and the teacher has to rely upon acts of the will. The child must agree to learn. This is more or less voluntary attention. The teacher here has to again change his techniques, until one finally reaches the state of lecturing adult pupils who because of their dedication or necessity to qualify at the end of the course do pay attention. It is still the same art of teaching that operates at different age levels.
We think that there is unnecessary duplication in the giving of qualifications to a teacher. In the secondary schools the Higher Diploma in Education is required. In the secondary schools a two-year course of training is required. There is unnecessary duplication here, and if there was a common qualification people would opt to go into the area of teaching where they would feel happiest and because of that teaching would then find their level, and we would not have teachers who would make excellent secondary teachers teaching at primary level, or, similarly, hopeless secondary teachers might be much happier dealing with a primary school situation.
There would be freedom of movement within the profession and the profession would find its level. We think, therefore, that it is important that this university-teacher training college link should be established. This does not mean that all should be brought within the training college-building complex. Cadets from the Curragh can now get a university degree from Galway University by an external link with the university. Therefore, the training colleges at the present time can be reorganised to provide a course of sufficient length and depth to qualify for what would be the level of a university degree. Not that I find university degrees anything sacrosanct, or something to be chased after, because I have had experience after training college of spending a number of years in the university taking different degrees and diplomas.
As far as I am concerned a university degree has no magic at all compared with the training one gets in a training college, but we live in a type of society where one does not seem to have the status sought for by society if one has not a university degree. This is the type of situation which is abroad in people's minds and they are inclined to, in a snobbish way, look down on people who hold qualifications which are not of university level.
With regard to the school leaving age, this matter has come up in the Dáil very often—the age of transfer from primary to secondary education. I should like to say that here from experience we do consider that the age which has been established by the Department of Education is the correct age and has been approved in many countries in which research into this problem of transfer from primary to secondary has been examined. We think that it would be damaging to a child to transfer him or her at an earlier age than 12. There are certain children who can gallop along at a much faster pace and unfortunately for that small group they are held up by this 12 bar, but the people who are making the case for an earlier transfer are people who are interested in children who are attending private schools and now want to bring them into the secondary sector so that they can qualify for grants. We think that the Department of Education should not at all consider giving away to this suggestion. I know that there are parents concerned that their children cannot be placed in secondary schools earlier, but taking the situation by and large it would be a very retrograde step to reduce the age of transfer into post-primary schools.
I should like to suggest to the Department of Education that they should set up a national council for educational research. Such councils exist in Scotland since 1928 and year after year they present reports upon the projects on which research has been made. It would be a very useful council in this country because no amount of educational work has been done in this particular activity of research. There are researchers in various departments of education in the universities and in the teacher training colleges but we think that the time has come when the Department seriously should consider a national council.
I should like to emphasise something to which I referred here before, and that is the setting up of a system of career guidance in order to create a harmonious society in which the number of misfits in positions can be reasonably reduced. We feel that children should be advised, particularly at the primary school leaving stage, as to their aptitudes. This does not mean that a child should be advised or forced into an occupation. That would be wrong, but through a series of aptitude and ability tests over the years it would be clear to the career master in the school that a child would be suited to positions within a certain range. He would not be told to become a civil servant, a doctor, a teacher, a lawyer or a carpenter and advice would be given to the child and to the parents that this child would do well within this range of occupations.
Follow-up surveys in various countries show that where children have been advised they are much happier in their occupations in the long term. Entry into work in Ireland is haphazard and entirely fortuitous. The father meets somebody who has a vacancy in his firm or business and suggests that the child should be sent along. The child spends a couple of years there doing work in which he has no interest and for which he has no aptitude. After a while he abandons his position and tries something else. Then he tries something else and finally he emigrates. In other words, he is entering dead-end situations all the time until, having experimented with various occupations at home, he has to go abroad. This is a deplorable situation where children walk out into life in an aimless way like this and finally are forced to emigrate. I feel it would stem emigration considerably if children were advised as to the occupations for which they would be suited by their aptitudes.
I had a number of things I wished to say but I will not take up the time of the House because I had to spend a considerable time on one item. We must pay tribute to the Minister for Finance and the Government for the creation of a widows' and orphans' pensions scheme for people in the public service and also for the setting up of a system of ex gratia payments to widows of public servants and also for the acceptance of the principle of parity of pensions whereby pensions will be based on current salary. If salaries have to be increased to meet the rise in the cost of living it is logical to assume that pensions must be equally improved because the pensioners have to live in the same society and suffer the attacks which are made on their incomes by rising costs and depreciation of money values.
Therefore, pensioners should be protected and we are glad that the Government have accepted the principle of parity of pensions. They have not fully implemented this principle yet but they have promised to do so. They have improved the situation by basing pensions on the levels of salary which were paid to public servants on 1st February, 1964. We should not let this occasion pass without thanking the Minister for Finance for his generous treatment of the widows and orphans of persons in the public service or persons who had given service to the public.
Comment on this
I can sympathise with much of what Senator Brosnahan has said relating to schoolchildren and the difficulties of teachers in maintaining discipline in classes where some poor children attending those classes have not had proper advantages, have come from broken homes and therefore are not readily amenable to discipline. That is inevitable and undoubtedly teachers in this situation must exercise a certain amount of discipline. One can readily appreciate how this will happen in such circumstances with children with an unhappy background when one finds on the front page of the Irish Times of Thursday, 4th December, 1969, an account of a professor being assaulted at Trinity College. I quote:
A professor was manhandled, his clothing torn and a lecture abandoned yesterday afternoon in Trinity College when left-wing students continued their protest.
It goes on to state that during the melée the professor had his coat ripped and he himself was knocked to the floor. Surely if things like that can happen at university level where one would expect a certain standard of behaviour from students whose education to a great extent is being subsidised by the taxpayers of the country, one must assume that in the national school there will on occasion be a certain lack of discipline.
We in Ireland at the moment are heartened and encouraged and facing a challenge by the fact that in the next six or eight months negotiations will open for our entry into the Common Market. This will be a challenge for all our people—our farmers, our workers, our industrialists —and in approaching that challenge we must make up our minds what exactly our priorities are.
Are we to stress economics only or are we to consider that in the progress of a nation there are some things more important than mere money? We must consider also whether there is really a conflict. Do we want to maintain at one and the same time the American standard of living and the Irish way of life? Do we consider that those two things are possible? Do we feel that if they are not possible there there are certain priorities?
In this regard I may say go bhfuilim ar aon eagna leis an méad atá ráite cheana ag an Seanadóir Cranitch. He impressed on us that if we are to make progress in the real sense that while having a certain standard of living we must also be proud of ourselves, of our language, of our tradition, and that pride will probably lead us to further economic advances because no family and no nation will really make the same progress or have the same vitality unless it has pride in itself.
Those people who purport to decry the Irish language and to suggest that it interferes with economic progress in the west or any other part of Ireland might perhaps look to the Celtic nation which is nearest to us, Wales. Of the minority Celtic communities which were formerly associated with Britain—Wales, Scotland, Ireland— Wales is perhaps the country which was at all times militarily least strong and historically most easily subdued, but though Wales never had the victory of a Bannockburn neither did it ever have the defeat of a Culloden. In contrast with Wales, Scotland always has presented its case in a most extrovert manner with a technique, a facility, a fluency which would have done credit to the most progressive advertising agency. Yet if one compares the progress of Scotland and Wales one will find the benefit lies with Wales. Today, Wales is the Celtic country which is proudest of its traditions. It is the Celtic country which has adhered most closely to its own language and it is the Celtic country, in contrast to the others, which has done best.
Let us contrast the 140 years from 1821 to 1961. In 1821 Wales had 5 per cent of the total population of Great Britain; in 1961 it still had 5 per cent of the total population despite the large centering of finance and capital in London and in other parts of the country. In 1821 Scotland had 13.5 per cent of the total population of Great Britain but in 1961 it had only 10 per cent and that despite the centring of very considerable amounts of capital in the lowlands of Scotland. If we contrast this with that part of our little island, with which we hope one day to be associated, we see that in 1821, Northern Ireland—which had forgotten its language and which no longer took pride in its traditions— had 9 per cent of the total population of Great Britain but in 1961 it had only 2.7 per cent: it had depreciated to almost one-fifieth. In other words the depreciation in population was almost in direct proportion to the pride and interest which each of those three Celtic minority groups had in their language, their habits and in their people, and this is one point that we in Ireland should remember on the eve of our advent, as we hope, into the Common Market. There is much we can add to it, there is much we can do, but if we once feel the highest function in our life is merely to imitate other people and another country we shall sink into the backwater.
During the debate some people laid stress on the commission being set up to investigate the rights of women. I should like to make a few practical suggestions in that regard which perhaps might be useful. It is only in recent times by the Succession Act that the Irish wife had any security whatsoever. Prior to that many of us know of the saddest of cases where the man died, willed his property elsewhere, his wife was left practically destitute, or a life tenant, which is merely an unpaid servant, to keep the lands and estate for the benefit of nephews or other relatives. Therefore, the Succession Act was the first really practical step towards helping Irish married women. There are, however, many steps yet to be taken.
If a man is a drunkard, is dissipated, is cruel to his wife and children, the father of a family who inevitably must grow up under severe handicaps, relatively little can be done. In a summary manner the only protection or assistance the wife can get is if there is legal desertion. In those circumstances she gets at present a maximum of £4 a week which, of course, is completely inadequate.
However, let us remember the circumstances of the man, the wife and children living in a home where the wife has no assets, where no matter how cruel he is she cannot leave. She cannot, therefore, prove legal desertion and there should be a remedy in law to save that woman and her children. It should be possible in such cases to apply to the court to ensure if necessary that the man is denied access to the house, provided cruelty is proved. It should be possible for women in such circumstances to get a realistic figure towards their support and that of their children. Where a man earns £20 to £30 a week and gives his wife the paltry sum of £4, that situation is a social disgrace.
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Senator, but much of what he has said would involve legislation and it cannot be debated on this Bill.
Comment on this
This Bill involves the appropriation of money towards various Departments of State including the Department of Justice and it is on that basis that I was approaching the matter. But if you consider I should not follow it I bow to your ruling.
Comment on this
The Senator is in order in discussing the administration of the Department of Justice but he may not advocate fresh legislation.
Comment on this
A further matter the Department of Justice might possibly consider here is what could be done more effectively to deal with the rights and protection of women: whether the home of the husband, wife and child should not be treated as a family asset in which the wife and the children under age have a vested interest. It is sad at times to see a man who is an alcoholic or a compulsive gambler, dissipate the assets because he happens to own them even though perhaps the wife, by her own earnings, had contributed to those assets. I believe in any home the assets should be joint ones, the wife should have a definite legal right and she should be entitled to prevent the dissipation of those assets which would be detrimental to her children and to herself.
If the Department of Justice took practical steps in regard to the points I have mentioned, we would have far fewer problem children than we have at the moment. Little children in their early years should have their happiest time of life but what standard of happiness can they look forward to if there are rows, drunkenness and absence of security.
One matter which has contributed considerably to the industrial progress that we have made in this country in recent years is the assistance which has been given by the Department of Industry and Commerce to small industries. It is only by the initiative of the people that we can hope to have expansion in the rural areas where people can get off-the-land employment. However, a strange feature of all our social welfare legislation is that there is no provision for the self-employed man—the smithy who is running his own forge, the carpenter who starts his own little business or the shoemaker who expands his business and puts in machinery in his shoemaking shop. Under social welfare legislation as it exists at the present, this category of people has no protection whatever.
I recommend that consideration be given to them and that the man who starts his own business and whose income is less than that allowed for entitlement to benefit in the case of an employed person—up to £1,200 a year —should be entitled to partake of our social welfare legislation. At the moment he is practically a second-class citizen. If he dies his wife is not entitled to a contributory widow's pension and if he dies at a comparatively early age he is usually not very well off because any little capital he had has been put towards the purchase of whatever few machines he may have.
A fillip would be given to young men of initiative if some provision could be made for them under social welfare legislation. We have here the Parliamentary Secretary primarily responsible in that regard and I respectfully submit these matters to him for his consideration.
Despite all the criticism that has been made from time to time, by and large the progress made in this country during the past six or seven years has been practically phenomenal and has been due to the fact that each Department have approached their job in a businesslike way. They have not attempted to do anything spectacular because doing things in a spectacular manner is often the surest way to regret them. They have endeavoured to close the technical gap between the impact of new technology by the developments and encouragement of schools where that technology is taught. They have encouraged a high rate of investment and they have succeeded in their monetary system and policy by accelerating expansion while, at the same time, avoiding the overheating of the economy. Despite all that is said about our taxation system and while we, for the most part, consider that we are heavily taxed, they have so framed the taxation system as not to curb industrial investment or damage personal incentives. Those are factors of which any government might be proud.
The Government's realistic approach has been one of commonsense and practical good sense. There are many things that we would yet like to see being accomplished and we can confidently look forward to their being accomplished as time progresses.
Comment on this
As the nominee of the Irish Creamery Managers' Association I cannot but be primarily interested in agriculture. Accordingly I wish to make a few brief points and I will confine myself to the agricultural scene.
Nobody will pretend that there are not major problems in agriculture, yet the Department of Agriculture have no readymade means of consultation with the various interests in agriculture. We saw the result of the absence of proper consultative machinery in the recent past when a reversal of policy was introduced by the Minister for Agriculture. I am not here to deal with the merits or demerits of the new policy but I wish to emphasise that absence of consultation with those immediately concerned aggravated the insecurity and uneasiness which necessarily flow from a radical departure from previous Government plans.
It seems all too evident in the scheme for sealing down milk price allowances that insufficient consideration has been given to the technical and practical aspects of the application of the scheme at a time when people everywhere are expecting involvement in all matters which concern their lives. It should hardly be necessary to argue for a properly constituted, consultative committee or council which at least could contribute handsomely to the evolution of planning for agriculture and still have full regard to the overall agricultural policy.
Another area where the absence of Government consultation involves the whole agricultural community at the present time is the matter of the Anglo Irish Free Trade Area Agreement. I take the view that that Agreement, in so far as agriculture is concerned, was heavily in Britain's favour. I suggest with the weight of public opinion behind it and with a generally long term policy on agriculture worked out the Government could strike a considerably better bargain or agreement with our neighbours in Britain, which has increasingly found Ireland to be an extremely important and valuable market. This concept of course hinges on the preparedness of the Minister for Agriculture to take all interests into his confidence and to recognise that he, the Department of Agriculture and the different interests in agriculture throughout the country should be working together towards a common end.
At the moment, few will deny that the Anglo Irish Free Trade Agreement needs revision so far as quotas for agricultural produce are concerned. Our export marketing operations are severely and I would submit unfairly circumscribed by the terms of the Agreement. The Minister and the Government in the light of Britain's unilateral action to protect her own economy and her own interests are imposing on the Irish taxpayers an usually heavy burden. They should negotiate an agreement to get a better deal for farm produce. I suggest in such negotiation the Irish hands would be considerably strengthened if the role of the agricultural sphere has prior involvement with the Minister through proper consultative machinery.
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words about the vote for Agriculture and in particular about the subsidies for milk approaching £27 million. There are of course other support prices for agriculture which need serious consideration but I want to deal for a short time with the one relating to milk. This is something in the region of £27 million this year. It has increased fairly steadily through the years. In spite of the fact it has now reached this very high figure, a figure which is a very heavy burden on the taxpayer, nevertheless the farm organisations have said again and again it is not enough, that the farmer is not getting enough for his milk, and that the farmers' income is not sufficient.
I do not accept the criticism by some of the farm organisations regarding the price for milk or their complaint about the price necessarily represents the real view of the farmers. I believe the average farmer is reasonably well satisfied with the price he is now getting for his milk.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, it is a fact, as a recent survey has shown, that the income of the farming community today as compared with that of the rest of the community does not compare favourably with other sectors and whereas the price of milk at the moment and the price of farm products may be reasonably good it certainly cannot be said that farmers are getting too much. If the present trend continues it would mean that this subsidy for milk would have to increase almost every year and this is something which I think we view with any composure because it is something which would certainly lead to a very serious financial crisis in the future. Therefore, we have to consider not merely the claims of farmers but also the claims of the taxpayers who have to pay this money.
We have to consider also the very unusual position we have in this country in regard to the relative number of farmers as compared with the remainder of the population and to realise that this is extremely high as compared with most other European countries. At the end of 1968, which is the last figure I can lay my hands on, the farming community represented something over 31 per cent of the community. This compared with three per cent of the community in Great Britain and compared with considerably less than half of 30 per cent in most other European countries. Just to give you a few examples, in Belgium it is 5.8 per cent, in France 16 per cent, in Germany 10 per cent, in Italy, the only one which compares with Ireland, 24 per cent, in Luxemburg 12 per cent and in the Netherlands eight per cent. It is quite obvious that the subsidisation of farm prices may be feasible in some countries where the farming community represent a relatively low proportion of the entire community. It is quite obvious in Great Britain where the farming community are only three per cent of the entire community that it would be easy, and is in fact easy, for them to subsidise farmers. In fact, the Government could give a pension to every farmer in the country and tell him not to bother farming at all and it would not be an insupportable burden on the community. Where you have 31 per cent of the community needing subsidisation from the community in general and from those in particular who are not members of the farming community then this is a very heavy burden and one which has to be considered and examined in the closest possible way. The position is that we in this country, the community generally, because of the high proportion of those engaged in agriculture, have to find far more than almost any other European country with the exception of Spain, Portugal and Greece, and on the other hand because of their high proportion there are fewer resources, fewer people, to find the heavy sums which are necessary to provide these subsidies.
There are a number of solutions, of measures which can be taken to try and deal with this situation. It is, of course, essential that new and more profitable markets should be found for milk products, and in this regard Bord Bainne have made remarkable progress, have taken remarkable measures to try to find new and more profitable markets, and have taken many measures to diversify the products which can be made from milk. They have shown great imagination and initiative in these respects even in taking a partnership in new industries which could use milk in such faraway places as Trinidad and the Far East. Certainly what they have done has eased the problem of finding a profitable outlet for milk, and I have no doubt that everything that can be done in this respect is being done and will be done in the future. But on the other hand what they can do and what they have been doing will not be a complete solution to this problem.
A second way of dealing with this problem is to endeavour as far as possible to send less milk to the creameries or other factories but to use more milk on the farm for feeding. I do not profess to be an expert on farming and I will not say anything more about this aspect of the situation except that some progress is being made in this regard and I hope it will be possible to make more progress in this regard. But again this way of combating this problem is only a marginal one and cannot do more, I think, than ease the problem as time goes on.
The EEC have certain proposals for cutting down the output of milk even by subsidising the slaughter of cows so as to cut down the total population of cows, and of course this will certainly, again, be of some help, but it is unlikely to have more than a marginal effect on the situation. In Ireland at the end of 1968 we had 1.6 million cows, which was a record number, and our milk in that year had gone up by some eight per cent on the previous year, so it can be seen that our problem is not merely to reduce the number of cows at the moment. Our problem is to stabilise it, and if we can do this we will be making a great contribution to the problem. Even holding the number of cows at the present number, it is quite obvious that as more scientific methods of breeding and so on take place the yield from those cows is going to increase and we are going to find with the same number of cows an ever-increasing amount of milk being produced and an ever-increasing problem to contend with.
Up to recently, up to three or four years ago, this problem was not considered to be quite so serious as it might be because it was said that if and when we became members of the European Community then the problem would be very much eased. Certainly if we had become members of the European Community in 1963 the problem of disposing of milk, and disposing of it at a profitable price, would have been met by membership of the European Community. But unfortunately the problem of surplus milk has overtaken the European Community just as it has overtaken the United States and almost every part of the western world, and even if we become members of the European Community now, although the problem may be for this country to some extent eased, nevertheless we will be becoming members of a community which have their own problems of milk surpluses and which during the last year probably had its most serious crisis since the setting up of the Community on the basis of prices for farm surpluses and in particular the price of milk and the surplus of milk. So we can no longer look to membership of the European Community as an answer to this problem of milk surpluses.
There is no complete solution, as I have said, in this country, and in spite of the amount of examination and study which has gone into the problem in the European Community there is no complete solution there either. There is the Mansholt Plan which has been introduced in an effort to deal with the problem, but that plan is based primarily on the re-structuring of farms, having bigger farms, having more economic units, and dealing with the problem to some extent in that way. This again is a plan which has given rise to very great opposition and a great deal of controversy. It is going to have a fundamental effect on the whole structure of farms and the farming community in the European Community if it is introduced. It is by no means certain that it will be accepted and it is by no means certain even if it is accepted and introduced that it will be a final or complete solution to the problem of milk surpluses.
Nevertheless, I feel that it will play a significant part in dealing with this problem. The fact that this plan may be an answer or a partial answer to the problem in the European Community does not necessarily mean that it would be, if we remained outside the Community, a solution to our problem or that any adaptation of it would be a solution to our problem. Nevertheless, it should be studied in this country to see to what extent if any, this kind of approach to the problem would play a part in solving it.
It should be studied whether we go into the Community or not because of course if we go into the Community we may have to accept it whether we fully agree with it or not. This is one of the solutions and we can of course endeavour and must endeavour to examine every possible solution to this problem because it is something which is becoming a larger and larger one.
I want to make it clear that I am not suggesting that the problem should be met or dealt with on the basis of merely cutting down that subsidy without any regard to the claims of the farmers or any question of tying that subsidy to a particular figure without any regard to the claims of the farmers. The farmers must be considered and very carefully considered in this problem but there is a limit to what can be found to deal with this problem. It must be realised that it cannot merely be dealt with by continuing to give larger and larger amounts. If that was the way to approach it it would be just a matter of finding larger and larger amounts every year and it would be merely a financial problem. The point I want to make is that it is already a financial problem, it is already a very large financial burden. What I am advocating is that every effort should be made to see whether this problem can be dealt with in other ways so as to limit the extent to which it is met merely by providing more and more finance.
Comment on this
One of the greatest problems affecting the country at present is the threat of a recurrence of the Garda flu. This is something which is causing the public a great deal of uneasiness. I should like to say that the most effective way of dealing with this is to have in the shortest possible time a very rapid infusion of recruits into the Garda force. In practically every station in the country our gardaí, who are doing excellent work, are grossly overworked. During the Seanad election campaign this year I stayed overnight in Bundoran. It was the week a young garda was thrown over the cliff. I was told there were only five gardaí there to look after something like 20,000 people at the height of the tourist season.
Surely the Minister does not expect these young men to be supermen? It is grossly unfair to expose them, they are all family men, to the dangers of having to police large numbers of people in riotous mood, sometimes with such sparse numbers. Recently many of them have been transferred on temporary duty to the Border and in the Dublin area and even in large towns, the principal towns in many counties, the effective strength of the force is reduced to four or five men with perhaps somebody on sick leave and a barrack orderly.
These men are forced to work six days per week and four or five hours on Sunday when practically every other sector of the community has a five-day week. Their work is difficult and they should at least have the force brought up to strength. Indeed the normal strength of the force should be reviewed with a view to having adequate numbers to ensure that law and order will be maintained. It is bad for the morale of the force to force them into the position of having to take drastic action like falling sick. This is something that disturbs many peaceloving citizens.
I should like to mention the decline in the progress of the group water schemes. One of the worst tasks is to be forever a hewer of wood and a drawer of water. It is pathetic to see children in rural Ireland having to carry buckets of water half a mile or more. The group water supply schemes have been very effective, but with rising costs the grants are not adequate to cover nearly the same proportion of the overall cost as they did originally. In the absence of any increase in the grants, I should like to ask the Government if it would be possible to introduce a special grant towards the cost of providing the head-works, the reservoirs. With that expenditure taken off the backs of the groups, it would perhaps be feasible to continue with those schemes for another few years.
The extraordinary thing about these co-operative water supply schemes is that it is possible to instal or to lay a piped water supply scheme for about half of what it would cost a local authority. If we are going to reach the stage when we have those facilities in all the small towns and villages of the country up to a desirable standard then the cheapest way will of course be the only way open to us, namely, through co-operative schemes which have by and large worked very well. There were many difficulties in many of the areas but we must stick with this idea of co-operative effort, and as the years go on some effort should be made to correct the failings of the present schemes.
Up to last year one of the Department's main forces behind the scheme is a gentleman named Burke who, I think, has now gone to the National Building Agency. I do not know if this man's post has yet been filled but the number of engineers the Department have engaged on water supply schemes is not nearly sufficient. There is a great time-lag between the date a scheme is costed and when the work is carried out, and the unfortunate trustees of the schemes must go back to their members, not only once but perhaps twice, for increased contributions. This is never popular and I think a strong effort should be made to have these schemes got off the ground as quickly as possible.
It should not be beyond the capacity of the Department of Local Government to provide some definite aid for the organisers of these group schemes, some of which cost between £40,000 and £50,000. The administrative work is left on the shoulders of some local person who works in a voluntary and indeed thankless capacity of organiser for his neighbours. The administrative work is altogether too much for one person to take on and the Department should provide some kind of filing system, something perhaps on the lines of an account book which would include all the data that an organiser would need. After nine years of operation it should be possible to streamline this excellent scheme and enable the work to progress more rapidly.
I have listened with interest to this debate and there is one topic on which I feel I should speak—agriculture. There is no aspect of Irish life in which a clear statement of long-term Government policy is more urgently needed than in agriculture and I feel that the failure of successive Fianna Fáil Governments and Ministers for Agriculture to formulate such a policy has meant the extraordinary position we have at the moment where sectors of the agricultural industry are presently faced with a declining and reduced income.
Senator Keery yesterday, or perhaps the day before, spoke of the visions he had when reading the Third Programme for Economic Expansion. I should like to remind him if there is any ghost in this area it could surely be the ghost of the Second Programme for Economic Expansion to which the Government gave such an indecent and hasty burial.
I would remind the House that of the targets set out in 1964 in the Second Programme the only one achieved was the one set of 550 million gallons of milk to be produced by 1970. This year the Irish farmers will produce somewhere in the region of about 530 million gallons. Senator Keery spoke of and praised the MOVE effort. I think that organisation——
Comment on this
On a point of fact I did not say that. I said that no one could claim that the MOVE effort has been an unqualified success. I praised the public relations idea and intention behind it.
Comment on this
I was about to say that this organisation deserved greater success but I submit that the only sector that met the targets set out in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion are now faced with a drastic and definite reduction in their income for the coming year. There is no use in drawing up a Third Programme and setting out targets when the people who achieved the targets are rewarded by a reduction in their incomes as a result of their efforts.
The price of milk, as Senator Ryan said, is not an easy problem. Last autumn the price of milk paid to our farmers was reduced by five-eighths of a penny and last April a further reduction of one penny per gallon was made to Bord Bainne out of milk produced by farmers. The Minister now proposes to give one penny back on all milk sent in by the farmers in May, June, July and August, but this is not to exceed one penny per gallon up to 1,000 gallons. The most a farmer could hope to gain by this one penny per gallon increase would be £16 13s 4d and this would only replace the one penny deducted last April and not take into consideration any increase in costs which have been considerable over the past year. Very few farmers have been paid this sum this year even though the Minister promised that payment would be made before November. Regarding the question of payment by the Minister I should like to mention that payment of the money held over after the wheat harvest in respect of the levy has not been paid out to most of the farmers to date. I hope that both these payments will be made immediately so that farmers might have something to spend before Christmas.
Under this new price scheme for milk, which is so very complicated, the Minister has introduced the new milk year which commenced on 1st September, 1969, and will end on the 31st August, 1970. He has set out the milk prices for this period. I have assessed them and I hope I am correct in thinking they are right, but the entire price structure is so complicated that I do not think very many people understand or are able to make it out.
A farmer sending in 7,000 gallons of milk in any year will receive the full subsidy which, I think, is 9d. To arrive at what the farmer gets, the Minister gave an increase of 1d per gallon, which was paid every three months by the creameries. Under the new scheme the farmer would still get the same 1d, plus the additional 1d in respect of the scheme under 7,000 gallons. The most the average farmer who produces 4,000 to 5,000 gallons can hope to gain for the next 12 months in respect of this 1d on the first 7,000 gallons will be £16 13s 4d—something equivalent to 6s 4d per week or 9½d per day. This is a very small increase which I think would not be tolerated by any other sector of the community.
The difficulty about this scheme is that a man who sends in more than 7,000 gallons and less than 8,000 would receive an increase in his income of £25 a year and those who supply between 8,000 and 9,000 gallons per year will be blessed with £20 16s 8d per year—the more you produce the less you get. For those who produce between 9,000 and 10,000 gallons the increase will be £16 13s 4d; for those who produce 10,000 gallons and less than 11,000 gallons an additional £12 10s will be paid. Those who produce 11,000 gallons and less than 12,000 gallons will receive £8 6s 8d per year by way of increase and those in the 12,000 to 13,000 gallon bracket will get an increase of £4 3s 4d per year. For those who produce 14,000 gallons, the price for next year will remain the same as for the current year. The same applies to those in the 14,000 to 20,000 gallon category.
This is extraordinary when we consider the Government's very determined effort to increase milk production in line with their Second Programme for Economic Expansion. Those who supply between 21,000 and 30,000 gallons will lose 3d per gallon in the same period next year and for those in the 31,000 to 40,000 gallon category, the loss will be 4d per gallon. For those in the 41,000 and not more than 50,000 gallon categories there will be a loss of 5d per gallon and for the 51,000 gallons and not more than 60,000 gallon categories the price will be down 6d per gallon, and for the 61,000 and not more than 70,000 gallon producer, there will be a cut of 7d per gallon. After that, no subsidies will be paid so that the farmer will be at a loss of about 9d per gallon.
This is an extraordinary price structure for any commission and it is unfortunate that so many people have not been able to come to grips with it. In the Second Programme for Economic Expansion a very high target was set—550 million gallons by 1970. This target was backed up by a very virile and active campaign by the Government. The county committees of agriculture were advised by the Department to launch intensive campaigns not only for clean milk but for greater quantities of milk.
The position that members of county committees of agriculture now face is that during the past four years they have directed their instructors to put in motion the greatest sales effort ever in this country. Not only did they vastly increase the output of milk, but they brought the number of farmers who qualified for the clean milk bonus scheme in my county from nine per cent of the farmers in 1964 to over 80 per cent in the current year. This was a tremendous effort and it demonstrated in no uncertain manner the attitude the farmers adopt towards the advice given by the Government and the fact that they played a full role in endeavouring to help the national economy by reaching the targets set out in the Second Programme.
However, after that Trojan effort they have been rewarded by a cutback in income. I should like to remind the House that the man supplying 61,000 gallons and less than 70,000 gallons of milk who next year will face a loss of 7d per gallon will actually have a reduction in his income of £1,200 or £1,300.
From the demands already in, I can see that our rates will sky-rocket. There is a widely accepted myth in this country that farmers pay no rates but I must remind you that in my experience of the 4,000 odd farmers in my county, 1,800 of these are over the £33 valuation and between them they pay £452,000 net in rates. The remainder of the small farmers who pay portion of the rates include the people who are within the £20 and £33 valuations; and all the others who pay full rates on buildings, plus the rest of the entire community, between them, pay only £432,000. Therefore, a small number of farmers who are being faced with a reduction in their incomes will pay their fair share of taxation but this is not generally realised and people refuse to accept it. As well as that, we all know that with the taxation structure being what it is at the present time, everyone is paying a certain amount of indirect taxation because of turnover tax.
Comment on this
On a point of information, it is difficult to follow those figures. Do I understand that the farmers paying rates in this county pay, on an average, less than £30 per year in rates? That is just a rapid calculation.
Comment on this
What I said was that 1,800 farmers in my county whose holdings are more than £33 valuation collectively pay £452,000 in rates and the rest of the community, which includes farmers with valuations of up to £20 and who only pay rates on the farm buildings, plus the 1,100 farmers with a valuation in excess of £20 and less than £33 who pay on the farm buildings, plus a lesser amount on the land, together with the rest of the rate paying population in the towns and villages, collectively pay only £432,000. Therefore, farmers, and especially those in the more than 50-acre class, are paying rates and taxes at a very high rate and I submit that in proportion to their incomes they are more heavily taxed than any other sector of the community or any other individual in the community.
There is also the fact that it is reasonable to expect that a man having 200 acres of land would be producing between 60,000 and 70,000 gallons of milk and that man will be faced with a reduction of something in the region of £1,300 next year.
Comment on this
How much will they qualify for by way of subsidy?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senators could either agree on a price or else allow Senator McDonald to continue.
Comment on this
A figure of 9d, including 2d clean milk bonus, would not be very far out. Perhaps the Government might have a second look at this very difficult problem. The cost of production in every aspect of farming has gone up and I should like to comment on the manner in which the Minister for Industry and Commerce allows fertiliser manufacturers to increase the price of fertilisers each month. They get away with this in an inverted way and they of course penalise the small farmers every time because the wealthier people can afford to put on greater quantities of manure in what we might call the off-season. I feel that like every other commodity the price for manure should be stabilised and rationalised.
Comment on this
For the last couple of years the factories have been getting away with increasing the price month by month and I think this system of having a sort of sale bargain which helps the wealthier farmer is only creating greater difficulties. Senator Ryan mentioned the Mansholt Plan and I did not quite follow whether he was in favour of it, but I do not think the present milk price scheme could be said to be in line with Mansholt's ideas because it very definitely penalises not alone the large farmer but the people in the 30 to 50 acres category. As you all know, in any farm now with an acreage of less than 75 it is doubtful whether it is an economic one. Up to a couple of years ago the farm with 50 acres was considered to be economic. Surely that acreage should now be increased and something in the region of 75 acres should be considered as a viable holding.
Senator Ryan also wondered whether more milk could be utilised on farms. The difficulty about this problem is the fact that we have not got a guaranteed price for beef, and to that extent the cost of rearing beef on milk would possibly be a little too expensive. I would prefer to see the Minister for Education and the Minister for Agriculture coming together and instead of sending our butter abroad where in some places I have been told we are getting as little as 1/- a lb. for it, we could devote some of this subsidy, which is included in the £27 million mentioned by Senator Ryan, to introduce a scheme whereby all our school-going children might be given a pint of milk every day at the midday break. I do not know what this would cost. I suppose there would be some administrative costs attached to it but at least if the Irish taxpayer was subsidising the disposal of milk instead of turning surplus milk into butter, a considerably higher gallonage of milk per day could be used by giving the milk free to all our school children. In that way very many of our children, whose parents perhaps cannot afford to buy sufficient milk for them would get the benefit of the subsidy provided by the ratepayer.
Comment on this
You would probably get another film group from America showing milk being given to all the starving people here.
Comment on this
If we are ever going to find a way out of this difficult problem it will be necessary to find more than one method of trying to use up the surplus of milk. Again as the production of beef is so closely related to the production of milk, if we are to continue producing beef we will always have this milk problem. Therefore, it is of the utmost importance that the Government policy should be a long-term one and that farmers should have some guarantees in the long term before they are asked to invest the reasonably large amounts of money now required to change from one type of farm husbandry to another. The difficulties of changing from milk at the present time, after everybody has gone into it, are many.
There are grave uncertainties with regard to the growing of wheat. This year the farmers were quite lucky regarding the crop because the acreage was not too high, but you must remember that the growing of malting barley in this country is a closed shop. It is impossible for a young fellow coming along now, if his father did not have a malting barley contract, to get one. Usually it happens he cannot get one at all. Similarly, the Sugar Company are getting very sticky. Not only will they not give out contracts but they do their damnedest to take the contracts on the pretext that farmers have not a healthy crop or that they did not produce a sufficient quantity per acre in the previous year.
The Government must step in with an overall long-term farm plan which will give, especially to young men who now have the advantage of attending agricultural colleges and winter farm schools and have readily available free access to the advisory service in each county, a good living. If they do not do so those people will think twice either before they invest their own money, if they have it, in agriculture, or borrow it to embark on any special agricultural expansion.
During the course of his speech Senator Ryan spoke of the rather large amounts of money being spent on agriculture. I certainly agree that the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture is now quite a generous one. It is difficult to meet all the problems but the Senator mentioned the fact that the percentage, compared with the population, of farmers in the country is high compared with other countries. I am at a loss to know why this year the Minister for Agriculture thought it advisable to reduce the incentive bonuses and the grants payable on the farrowed sow scheme by £90,000 when we are not producing sufficient bacon and pork to meet our export quotas and at a time when the Government are turning a blind eye to the mass smuggling of pigs across the Border.
Comment on this
It is not fair for the Senator to say the Government are turning a blind eye on smuggling across the Border.
Comment on this
The amount of money allocated last year was not used by the various county committees of agriculture.
Comment on this
I am not concerned about this rumour. The Revenue Commissioners and their officers are doing everything in their power, but this is a very difficult situation to deal with. If they have not succeeded it is not because of any lack of effort on their part. The Senator knows full well that to get evidence on which to base a prosecution with regard to smuggling is probably a most difficult thing.
Comment on this
I do not think that it is going on to the extent to which we hear it is.
Comment on this
I do not think so either, but what I was concerned about is that Senator McDonald said that the Government were turning a blind eye and this is just not true.
Comment on this
If the Six County pig was orange and the Republic pig green they could easily be stopped, but unfortunately they are all the same colour.
Comment on this
Senator McDonald on the Bill. Will the two Senators kindly desist and let us hear Senator McDonald on the Bill?
Comment on this
Another point about this pig smuggling is that the pigs being smuggled are only second-class pigs. They are not grade A. The bacon that we export must be grade A special or grade A and the lower standard pig must be foisted on the home market. Everybody must agree that nobody wants fat bacon at the present time, but the extraordinary thing is that the price structure for bacon pigs is such that it is possible now to get up to £20 for a fat pig that the housewife does not want whereas if you are sending your pig to a factory the most you can get would be somewhere in the region of £18 or £18 10s for grade A special. This is something that I think the Minister for Agriculture might give some thought to. Nevertheless, I think it alarming that at a time when there is a grave need to increase our pig population, to encourage our farmers to keep more sows for breeding purposes, the grant in aid here under K 24 for the scheme for farrowed sows has been reduced this year by £90,000. I think too that the subsidy of £5 per sow was hardly generous enough. As you know, this particular aspect of farming with sows and bonhams calls for a reasonable amount of milk in the diet, and if we had a more generous allowance there it might be possible to divert some of our milk in that direction.
Comment on this
Does the Senator say that we are not paying enough for pigs?
Comment on this
I am saying that your scheme for farrowed sows is not attractive enough or we would have had more of them in the last year.
Comment on this
Because of the scarcity of pigs in the country. After all they are paying £4 per head more for them on this side of the Border. The fact is that we would not have to smuggle pigs if they were readily available on the home market, which they are not. The factories are buying smuggled pigs. They know very well they are smuggled, because if a fellow comes in with a load of pigs in a lorry at 6 o'clock in the morning the factory must know that they are not coming from an Irish farm. Maybe the Donegal farmers get up earlier, but I do not get up until 7 or 7.30.
Comment on this
How does this tally with your talk about greater productivity?
Comment on this
The productivity is there, and the Government are now going into reverse to try and discourage people from producing. The same applies to the production of wheat. If you produce too much wheat you are penalised. We have to pay 8/3d per barrel this year because we overproduced and next year this can go up to 15/- a barrel. It depends on what acreage is sown. The incentives for the farmers work in the opposite direction to industry—the more you produce on the land the less you get.
Comment on this
I am glad that Senator McGlinchey mentioned that, because the fact that a large quantity of wheat has been smuggled in has meant that the Irish farmer has had to suffer a payment of a higher wheat levy this year. I put it to the Minister that were it not for the fact that a large quantity of wheat was smuggled from Northern Ireland the Irish farmer would not have had to pay a levy as high as 8/3. This is a disgraceful situation. If the present facilities or powers that the customs authorities have for dealing with these offences are not adequate some steps will have to be taken to combat them, because with the farmers' share of the national income it would not be too bad if it remained static but it is declining. I cannot see how any Government can accept this and expect to have in rural Ireland a docile and peaceful community. It is just not possible.
We have had during the last two or three years a difficult phase in Government farmer relations which I do not want to go into, but surely if we have a situation now where people find that they are worse off this year than two or three years ago this is not going to call for harmony and peace. We will have this trouble starting all over again. During the past few months the price of ordinary store cattle has fallen by almost £2 per cwt. This surely represents a loss in farm incomes. The trouble with the urban population at present is that they cannot accept that anyone would work for the income that the average Irish farmer is working for. I defy the Minister to challenge the fact that the average family farm income of 70 per cent of our Irish farmers, taking into account the amount of hours that the farmer's wife and children put into it as well, in the last year has been less than the agricultural wages obtaining in the country. This is a deplorable indictment of the Government's agricultural policy. Nevertheless, a thing I cannot understand is that in the recent election so many farmers voted for that policy.
Comment on this
One can do anything with figures and An Foras Talúntais certainly do.
Comment on this
I have a high regard for An Foras Talúntais but if they bring up a figure that is unfavourable to the Government they are cold-shouldered. I do not think this is right. The findings of their projects should be published whether they favour the Government's policy or not and they should not be suppressed.
Comment on this
I want to make it quite clear that there is no question of any Government interference with what An Foras Talúntais publish or do not publish, none at all. I am sure Senator McDonald will accept that the Government have not at any time interfered with the publication of any report.
Comment on this
Senator Farrell is quite right. The Minister for Finance did marvellous things with figures in the last election campaign.
Comment on this
I do not know who this Senator is but I would ask Senator McDonald to accept that the Government have not at any time interfered.
Comment on this
The figures that count are the last election figures.
Comment on this
Farm incomes have not increased.
Business suspended at 1.5 p.m. and resumed at 2.30 p.m.
Comment on this
Before the luncheon adjournment Senator Mrs. Farrell mentioned the figures of the Agricultural Institute. I should like to put it firmly on record that this very excellent Institute—which has been blessed with an outstanding team of graduates— produces figures as a result of their various trials and experiments on a set basis. If somebody wishes to dispute those figures it is up to them to indicate in a positive manner where the discrepancy, if any, lies. In the years since it has been established the Institute has played a very significant role in Irish agriculture. The pity is that so much of their valuable work is not channelled quickly enough to the advisory services. This is where the Government policy presently differs from the Fine Gael policy on agriculture. We believe we should have a rural authority established which would co-ordinate more effectively and actively the various agencies who are presently working in their own particular way to helping agriculture and I think that Senator Mrs. O'Farrell was on this point when she was speaking on this debate. We must have co-ordination of effort if we wish to be efficient. To coin a phrase introduced by Senator Keery, we would visualise a new organisation replacing the present county committees of agriculture which would embrace and control the activities not only of the advisory services but also the Land Project organisation, the Bovine Tuberculosis Eradication Scheme, the Agricultural Credit Corporation and all the agencies presently working in their various and several ways in agriculture.
If a farmer wants a farm building grant it could be dealt with more speedily if he could make the application to a central office in his own county and have the one team of advisers or personnel to inspect and advise and it should not be necessary to have the proposal vetted by several persons. At the moment if somebody wants to secure a loan from the Agricultural Credit Corporation we all know that the ACC send down a graduate to inspect the man's holding in addition to the man having prepared, in conjunction with his own adviser, a farm plan indicating the project. This I consider wastage of valuable personnel in both these services. We all know that unfortunately there is a scarcity of agricultural adviser graduates in the advisory services—practically every county are a few advisers short and this is a matter that is causing worry to many people at the moment In my own county we were five people short earlier this year——
Comment on this
You could not expect anything else considering there is not a Fianna Fáil man on the County Committee of Agriculture in Offaly.
Comment on this
Indeed there are. I do not know exactly what is the composition of the committee but I know that all the men, irrespective of whether they are Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour, are excellent in the county of Offaly which is indeed a very progressive county from the advisory point of view. I cannot understand why the Senator should mention that county. There are many counties who have experienced difficulty in getting permanent officers appointed. The system is certainly wrong and leaves much to be desired because the tendency is for many of the advisers to move eastwards to the counties of Dublin, Kildare, Wicklow and Meath and the rest of the country is then at a decided disadvantage. On the other hand, with the way the agricultural industry in general has increased output during the past three years, the Government may think that farmers have already received official advice and perhaps they might like to slow down the practice by not providing official instructors to continue their good work.
Finally on that matter, I should like to compliment the Agricultural Institute on the successful work that they have been doing. I should like to see greater and closer liaison between the Institute and the Department. Once the Institute submit a report of their findings, that report should be readily accepted by all people in the Department as being very factual. Their experiments are very open and very intensive and they have clearly indicated the scope for expansion in the Irish agricultural industry.
The one great difficulty I see for the future of Irish agriculture is in the marketing field. There must be greater emphasis on orderly marketing and this can only be achieved if the farmers are guided by a modern and sound agricultural policy. A better tie-up is needed. It is not sufficient for the agricultural industry to be depending on either the smuggling of pigs to keep the factories going or on the smuggling of wheat to keep the mills going. We must be able to provide an outlet for the amount of produce that our farmers can produce.
I also regret that in the Estimates for the current year for the erection of glass houses there has been a reduction of some £300,000. This is surprising when one considers the import figures for the commodities that are usually grown in these glasshouses. I thought it would have been good policy on the part of the Government to continue that scheme.
Similarly, the lime and fertiliser subsidy scheme has been reduced by almost £1 million in the present year. This will have an adverse effect on production. All of these things show clearly that the Government obviously assume that if they continue to highlight the use of fertilisers and to promote these advantages but reduce these subsidies they will slow down production in a backhand way. Fertilisers will cost more in a year when farmers' incomes will be already reduced by the reduction in the income from milk and cattle which are already showing signs of decline.
Comment on this
It looks as if the Senator is hoping there will be a decline. There will always be ups and downs.
Comment on this
It is taken for granted that farmers' incomes in the cattle industry must fluctuate the same as in the pig industry. Were it not for the fact that so many pigs are being smuggled over the Border, the Irish farmers would be getting much more for them than they are getting, and even since the NFA put viligante groups on the Border the prices have significantly increased. Great credit must go to the public spirit of these people in taking time off to do this type of work which should not be necessary.
We in Fine Gael believe a healthy agricultural industry in the 1970s can only be achieved by adopting a courageous new agricultural policy. Agriculture has suffered for some years from the present Government's failure to produce a long-term agricultural policy. In consequence large sections of our rural community now face collapse. We believe that with a target and good leadership this set-up can be reversed and a prosperous rural community can find its place in the Ireland of the 1970s.
Comment on this
I have been listening attentively to the debate in this House during the past three days. My first reaction would be to say a word of appreciation to the Senators on both sides of the House for the very positive contributions they have made and their realistic approach to an examination of the problems of the country at the present time and looking to the future. I enjoyed every minute of the debate. I had no intention of doing anything else except continuing to enjoy myself until I realised last evening that there was a certain bias in the debate away from the West of Ireland and a bias away from consideration of some of the problems of the West of Ireland.
I remember one time during my career as county engineer for Mayo we had a vacancy for county manager. The first county manager died and an Assistant Secretary of the Department of Local Government was sent to Mayo to act as temporary county manager pending a new appointment. He remained with us for nine months, every month and every day of which we enjoyed. He was a tremendously good manager, sympathetic and well trained. At the end of his nine months' period we had a little farewell party and during that party this Assistant Secretary to the Department of Local Government said he had been 35 years in the Department and he further said: "Now I have been nine months acting as county manager in Mayo and I have learned more about local government administration in nine months in Mayo than I did in 35 years in the Department of Local Government".
That was brought to my mind when some time after nine o'clock last night I was thinking back on the contributions which had been made to the debate and from the Opposition side of the House I jotted down the names of Senators O'Higgins, Alexis FitzGerald, Kelly, Dunne, Sheehy Skeffington, Miss Owens, Horgan, Jessop, Dr. Belton, Miss Burke; and then Senator Brosnahan was speaking, everyone of them living in Dublin, everyone of them with a city bias in regard to rural Ireland.
Comment on this
Yes, by birth. The only Senators living in the country who spoke were Senators Quinlan and Russell, so I thought it might be well for me to get up and say something, not exactly on the big question of Government policy, but rather something in connection with the implication, the results and the difficulties of implementing various Government decisions. It is true, of course, that Dublin city comprises approximately 25 per cent of the population of Ireland and I thought possibly something might be said on behalf of the remaining 75 per cent. Today, I admit the position has been different because we had Senator Butler and Senator McDonald from the country speaking from the Opposition side.
The first point I should like to make is in connection with a very important matter affecting not alone the west of Ireland but anywhere in which the Board of Works have been operating very important drainage schemes. The Board of Works are particularly well equipped for the purpose of carrying out those drainage schemes. The present intention is once drainage schemes are carried out the after-maintenance becomes the responsibility of the local authority. I want to say this might be all right in theory but in practice it will not work out. I should like to put before the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance the need for a re-thinking on this matter. County councils have not the trained personnel, they have not got the equipment and they are not really geared to carrying out major drainage work for which the work force of the Office of Public Works is most adequately equipped and adapted to.
I want to make a suggestion that as far as the after-maintenance of major drainage projects is concerned the ideal solution would be for the Central Fund to accept full responsibility for the maintenance of the main rivers and the main tributaries. It would be reasonable to expect county councils to accept responsibility for minor rivers and feeder drains; and the benefiting riparian owners might be expected to contribute for the maintenance of field drains and land drains. No matter what work is in progress, no matter how industrious a farmer is, no matter how intent he is on improvement and development of his land arising out of the drainage scheme, unless each other body lower down than him carries out effective drainage the work he is going to do on his land will be ineffective.
The second point I want to make is that I was deeply interested in the very enlightened discussion in connection with education. Senator Brosnahan indicated that between 1958 and 1959 a sum of £15½ million was available for education and in 1969-70 £58 million is being provided. This is a tremendous breakthrough as far as education is concerned. It is certainly a tremendous breakthrough as far as financing education is concerned but I am one of the people who feel that unfortunately we have not got and we are not getting the full benefit of that expansion in outlay and expenditure.
I feel our education scheme was rushed. I feel even at the present time we are not equipped for the expenditure of all that money and that we are in fact not getting value for it. It is of no benefit to spend money on education or anything else unless you have down the line the building, the trained people and the dedication which will ensure that the expenditure of that money is to the best advantage.
Looking at it from that point of view, the first and most necessary thing to ensure the best results from that expenditure was to see that we had sufficient qualified fully-trained teachers and in the second place adequate school buildings. I would ask the authorities to consider what proportion of teachers in various schools at various levels, primary, secondary and vocational—I do not know about university but I will deal with that later on—are fully qualified, fully-trained teachers and within the age group in which they are capable of giving fully adequate value for the money they are receiving as teachers.
I am afraid that if an examination was carried out it would be found that there are two things wrong at the present time. One of them was dealt with here, and that was the size of the classes, but I would also think that there is a noticeable percentage of cases in which the teachers are not fully qualified, fully trained and in a position to give, as I said, full value for money. There is a grave necessity to look into the appointment of teachers.
At university level I speak about the National University. Senator Sheehy Skeffington will know more about Trinity, but so far as the National University is concerned the present system of appointing professors to the National University is absolutely grotesque. I have been a member of the Governing Body of the National University——
Comment on this
Is this a matter of Government administration?
Comment on this
The Government are contributing very extensively to the upkeep of the university.
Comment on this
I think that the University has a certain amount of autonomy in regulating its own affairs and I do not think that the appointment of professors should be dealt with.
Comment on this
It would be very difficult to put the responsibility on one particular Minister for the appointment of a professor.
Comment on this
Right. At primary level the classes are too large if you have in all our schools in towns of 5,000 or 6,000 population—my own town comes within that range and I understand that the classes at primary level run from 60 to 80 pupils in a class. No teacher no matter how qualified, no matter how dedicated, can possibly control 60 or 80 pupils in a class, and I have evidence of this. I know this to happen, that if you take a class of that size you have a reasonable percentage of up to 25 per cent of the children who are of high intelligence, and they are entitled to get the benefit of their aptitude, they are entitled to benefit from their IQ, but they are held back by the 50 per cent of the pupils in the class who are of average intelligence.
The brilliant pupils are kept back to the level of the average, and the 25 per cent who are below average are completely and entirely neglected. I have seen children leaving the national school at 12 years of age who were not able to write the names on a show-board in the town of Castlebar, and if they were sent to post a letter in the post office you had to say "There are seven letters," and spell out LETTERS and count "one, two, three, four, five, six, seven." I do not say that those children were good in their attendances. Probably they were not, but at the same time bad and all as they were they were entitled to special consideration if they were special cases.
There is another practice which I think is to be deplored, and that is the practice of married people going back as teachers in various categories of schools, people who have already reared their families, have sent their children to the universities, have children qualified at the universities, and go back to get positions as teachers in secondary, primary and vocational schools. If those married people are getting employment in that way, sometimes I feel with a certain amount of preference, it is militating against employment for our young qualified teachers and even contributing to a certain extent to emigration. This is a matter I would like to see closely investigated.
Comment on this
If we are short of teachers you are not going to improve the position by putting back into the schools people who are not qualified to teach or are no longer able to teach.
Comment on this
They make very good teachers, most of them.
Comment on this
There was a lot of discussion here in connection with Radio Telefís Éireann. Their merits in connection with that are outside discussion. I accept the statements that were made here last night by Senator Brugha. Senator Brugha speaking from personal knowledge and experience paid a tribute, probably a well-deserved tribute, to the honesty, fairness and dedication of the members of the executive working for the Radio Telefís Éireann Authority. Accepting that without question, I have to ask myself whether the executive of the Authority is really in charge. Does the executive control and accept full responsibility for the programmes that are being put over?
During Senator Brugha's very excellent speech yesterday he mentioned the fact that the licence fee was £5. For once I erred. I said "it is not worth it". I plead guilty but I am guilty through conviction. I am perfectly satisfied that Senator Brugha was speaking because as he said one-third of the people of this country had at least two other channels open to them, but if he was confined to the one channel possibly he might agree with me.
Comment on this
There was a certain amount of novelty in 1963 which has worn off. People are now beginning to be a little more sophisticated and expect something better for their money. Afterwards Senator Quinlan dealt very extensively with Radio Telefís Éireann. Sometimes when I feel that I may be going to say something I jot down some notes, and I am perfectly satisfied, and I have confirmed this since, that Senator Quinlan was one of the people who agreed with me or at least went as far as to say that the present fee was reasonable and adequate, but he did criticise the lavish entertainment and the unjustified expenditure which is a feature of the preparation of RTE programmes. I will not quote him verbatim, but he said that RTE were not entitled to send representatives to the ends of the earth for the purpose of gathering a five-minute episode which may be of little interest to the majority of the people of this country.
I feel that our television programmes should be as varied as possible and that a reasonable expenditure possibly for the purpose of getting interesting programmes and features is justified, but neither I nor any other person will agree with the lavish expenditure which takes place in connection with putting certain programmes on the air before people which should never be put before the people. I am quite sure that when the representatives of RTE went to Lisbon on their way to Vietnam the people must have been relieved, or at least now will feel relieved, that they were not allowed to continue their journey, because without going very far, without leaving this country, programmes have been put on the air recently which were a disgrace to the authority.
I was listening in to the news a few mornings ago, and before the 9 o'clock news a person was interviewed on Radio Éireann. The interview was referring to a march which was to take place I think two days later. As far as I remember this programme was on Friday morning and the march was to take place on Saturday morning from the Parnell Monument to the American Embassy as a protest against the American war in Vietnam. If a business person wants to get a minute's publicity it costs him several hundreds of pounds but this morning an interviewer on behalf of RTE spent at least five minutes interviewing a lady who was interested in the promotion of this march, inquiring where it was to start, where it was to end, how many were to take part and giving it the widest possible publicity for nothing. It is a tribute to the good sense of the people of Dublin that notwithstanding all this publicity the number who took part did not exceed one thousand people.
I saw a Seven Days programme a few nights ago. Between one activity and another I get very little time for looking at television but I am usually anxious to see Seven Days. I was shocked. We all know that conditions in regard to housing people are difficult. We all know that unfortunately there are still people in unsuitable, insanitary houses. We all know that among those people there are problem cases, not typical cases. If one wants to elucidate a point one would be expected to take a typical case rather than an isolated one where neither the local authority nor the charitable institutions of the city could be held to be responsible for particular types.
This programme was intended to set out the difficulty of getting proper housing experienced by a couple who got married. The man was supposed to have been married at 18 years of age. His wife was in hospital after a confinement. The interviewer brought his cameras to the hospital. He asked the woman: "Is it a fact that your baby is not yet an hour old? Is it a fact that your husband has not yet come to the hospital to see you or the child?" The husband had not come but the Telefís Éireann cameras were there.
I remember the whole television outfit coming to Castlebar on one occasion. They were at least two days in the town setting up their equipment. I am just wondering whether the interviewer in this case even allowed the unfortunate woman to be left alone while her baby was being born. It is a fact that in order to give a certain bias to the difficult housing position in this city that unfortunate woman was quizzed for at least three or four minutes about her marriage, her other children, the second of whom had died, about whether her husband had come to see her. The whole sordid thing was there before the public. Many people must have felt that if this is the type of thing put forward by Telefís Éireann it is dear at any price.
Comment on this
In connection with Radio Telefís Éireann I have no enmity. I admire that interviewer. I do not know him, but on that occasion my wife and I were completely disgusted, as I am sure were many others.
I suggest that a re-arrangement of programmes should be made on Saturday night and Sunday night when people in the country can sit down and look at television there should be more entertaining, more elevating programmes. We have had enough of 30 years old canned musicals. A few nights ago we had a 27 year old film —Yankee Doodle Dandy. If we can get only canned programmes could we not get some of the better BBC and ITV programmes. We should take some of their better programmes, some of the educational programmes, some enlightening and debatable programmes as well as some of their sporting items——
Comment on this
Again, the lavish expenditure is illustrated. Some time ago we had a programme called Quick Silver and now a programme called Cé Hé and the amounts paid out during half an hour are really unjustified and unjustifiable. However, I shall leave it at that.
I should like to say a few words in connection with traffic—the dangers of traffic and the methods being used in order to try to control traffic and to make it safer for people on the roads. I will not criticise the gardaí. I have always been on the most friendly terms with the gardaí and I admire them as being completely impartial and adequate for their duties, but it really does not show up the gardaí in a good light when so many prosecutions take place for driving offences where the gardaí in the squad car find it difficult to pass out somebody on the road. I travel 153 miles from Castlebar to Dublin fairly regularly, on my visits to the Seanad and for other duties, and I scarcely ever meet a garda on the road. During that four hours travel I seldom see one but the moment I come into town and park my car there is a gentleman with a yellow band, notebook in hand and a threatening look in his eye.
Unfortunately there are still very serious regrettable accidents on the road—mostly in connection with very heavy lorries. I think an improvement might be made, though I realise that this is a difficult situation. Many people use the roads only occasionally, for pleasure purposes or for short trips— I am referring now to farmers who go into town probably to do shopping, who go to Mass and so forth. They are not quite well up in traffic regulations.
Something must be done quickly, clearly to identify very heavy vehicles, particularly vehicles described as matadors, two-truck vehicles. Many accidents are caused when cars pass out the first vehicle and they do not realise there is a second truck on tow. Several years ago during a short trip to Germany I saw quite a number of those on the autobahns and they were clearly distinguished by a set of lights not alone at road level but on the top of cabs. This, of course, is all right for people in Germany but many of our people do not realise the significance of this lighting and something should be done to light the second vehicle on tow with a white light at the front and possibly two or three reflectors on the side.
Another serious cause of trouble is people running into parked vehicles. There is a regulation when a truck is stationary that it must bear parking lights and in addition have a triangular plate. Anyone who travels the road will realise that the way in which the triangle is placed, its size, is completely useless as far as giving a warning to oncoming traffic is concerned. I suggest that the Minister for Local Government would think about issuing new regulations in connection with this. The triangle should not be placed on the road level—it should be at least 2½ feet above the level of the road. The triangle should be on a tripod. Otherwise it is completely and entirely ineffective. One sees time and again that an effort is just made to satisfy the regulations but it is not sufficient to guard against accidents.
Very heavy lorries never keep as close as possible to the side of the road —for the good reason perhaps that they are heavily laden—but then keep as close as possible to the central line and when there is a hold-up of traffic they pile up. A passing car has no chance of leapfrogging between one heavy vehicle and another. There should be a regulation that in slow traffic a clear space of 40 or 50 yards would be maintained between one heavy vehicle and another so that people coming along, sometimes without knowing exactly what is happening, pass out the first vehicle and find themselves then in a string of traffic.
In connection with local government, there is a complete lack of uniformity as regards planning decisions. This is a matter in which I have no professional interest: having resigned my professional work of engineering I became a Member of this House. However, I am often called on by people who feel they have had a bad decision in connection with planning applications and sometimes I feel that is so.
One can see along some parts of the west coast of Ireland one local authority who select a spot on the side of a lake near Crossmolina or near Ballyroe or Cushla. They will pick out an area on the lake shore for a car park and parking for caravans. I do not see any objection to this, I think it is quite right, but then another man wants to build say five or six chalets on the side of the lake—permanent up-to-date buildings—which will help to bring tourists into the area. It is very difficult to understand how it is possible to have parking facilities on the lake shore and another person is prevented from building chalets. I think what happens is that county councils make an omnibus decision saying they will allow no building on the side of the lake between the road and the lake and then the next thing that happens is that the Land Commission put up a house and there is nothing more about it.
There is an old regulation in connection with local government regarding road grants and that is that they have to have a certain labour content. I am sorry that has been waived in recent years—of course the whole system has changed with the advent of machinery—but I think in the interest of giving some employment in the rural areas a regulation should be imposed in the making of road grants that there should be a certain minimum amount of labour content. The Minister has been criticised for dispensing with the Christmas relief scheme. I am rather glad; I had to administer that scheme. Everybody who has had to deal with labour knows that in the Register of Unemployed there are thousands of unemployables, people physically unable to work who have never worked and who never will be able to work. Instead of imposing hardship on these people by bringing them out to work, it would be much better if a more charitable scheme could be brought in to assist them at Christmas by either increasing their dole or allowances or by helping a charitable institution like St. Vincent de Paul Society. He must not put an unfortunate fellow out to work who has not handled a pick or shovel for possibly 12 months and who may not even have an overcoat to protect him and if he has an overcoat he is barely able to keep it on. It is simply cruel to expect these people to work.
Another matter I wish to mention, and on this I will be a little critical of ourselves, and that is in relation to the West of Ireland. Some effort should be made to encourage the better utilisation of the facilities we have in the west. On my journeys to Dublin I meet lorries going from Lanesboro' to Mayo with loads of turf briquettes. I remember the time during the emergency when we sent almost 300,000 tons of turf out of the country to help to keep industry going and to help to provide fuel for the people of Dublin.
I cannot understand why we should get away completely from encouraging our people to produce sufficient fuel for the purpose of satisfying hospital requirements, institutional requirements and factory requirements in our own country. It seems to me to be wrong to come up to the midlands, where the fuel is produced by machinery which means the minimum amount of employment, and bring it down to the west.
Something should also be done about the utilisation of land in the west. Again, it is regrettable that most of the vegetables and practically all potatoes now consumed in the West of Ireland are bought on the Dublin market. I do not know what would be the remedy but to some extent, I would suggest co-operative farming. People are no longer prepared to cultivate their land by manual labour but if a number of farmers could be convinced to buy machines co-operatively it would be a great help. It might also be possible to have some factory for the purpose of processing the material and that would be a help towards keeping people on the land.
Another matter, but I will only touch on it, is hospital medical services. Senator Belton dealt with the difficulties of dispensary doctors but this is a different matter. The time has come when we must realise that professional men, surgeons, physicians and others are entitled to be paid adequately and, for God's sake, cut out private beds in public institutions. It would be much better for the people and much more satisfying if the doctor was paid a generous and adequate salary.
Comment on this
In that way, equal care and attention would be given to every person. I would go along to some extent with collecting fees for hospital maintenance from people who could afford to pay provided that if the rule is made it will be carried out and that everybody who can afford to pay will be compelled to pay.
In talking about dispensary doctors, Senator Belton offered two suggestions. One was that the assistant medical officer of health might be available for weekend duties. I have been thinking about my own county and from what I can recollect, without having any documents before me, there are between 28 and 30 dispensary districts in the county. We have one assistant county medical officer of health so it is obvious that he would be able to do relief duty for a doctor only about twice in a year. The dispensary doctors want every weekend. Up to now they have been able to make arrangements between themselves for dispensary duties. They must have time off to attend certain functions and to have some recreation and they must also be able to attend court cases arising out of their practice. The fact is that dispensary doctors are on call 24 hours a day for seven days of the week. Something must be done about the position but certainly it will not be sufficient to say that the assistant county medical officer will be able to relieve these doctors nor will the appointment of one additional doctor meet the case.
Senator Brosnahan also mentioned the engineers. It is unfortunate that there is disagreement at the moment between local authority engineers and the Department of Local Government. Again, I can only repeat what has already been said in this House, that is that local authority engineers have not up to now been adequately paid— that if they were in posts in the private sector they would be much better paid. It is regrettable that any difference should arise because I know from working with them for many years that they are a dedicated body. They are people who have been called in many times in the interest of the State and of the country. From the very early days they were called in to solve the terrible problem of unemployment when we had three times as many labourers as we have at the present time and when people were very badly in need so that we had to rotate work for two, three or four days in the week.
They were called in again in connection with turf production and they worked late into the night in helping to get the turf away to Dublin by wagon. They amount of work that they did at the time was appreciated and they received a personal letter of thanks from the then President. We should not forget all that. We should not forget that if they are paid satisfactorily they have wonderful potential in the interests of the people of the country generally. If a public official is satisfied, he can give tremendous service and this applies to all people who are members of public bodies.
I agree with most of what has been said during this debate and, as I said at the beginning, I have been edified by the standard of the debate and I hope that that standard will continue to be a feature of the debates in this House. One feature of the debate has been contructive criticism and contributions in this House should be constructive and along the lines of doing the best for the people of the country.
Comment on this
I listened with great interest to Senator Flanagan, he being from the West of Ireland, and I can agree with most of what he said with the exception of his references to the question of heavy lorries on the road and of our articulated lorries. I find it necessary to drive one of these lorries and, God knows, I want to say to this House, for people who never had that experience, it is the greatest hardship which can befall anybody to try to drive a lorry with 20 tons of stuff. A person driving a car will often come along and say that a lorry-driver did not keep in far enough to let him pass.
I want to impress on this House the hardship it is on lorry drivers when they want to pull in. Most of those lorries are carrying 20 tons and when the driver pulls in he goes down slightly on the road and the whole weight comes over on that side. People driving along the roads in rural Ireland or near the city have often seen a lorry and trailer tipped over. This is caused by the driver trying to keep in to let a car pass. I often ask myself, with my experience of this matter, if people driving cars drive them carefully enough.
Senator Flanagan mentioned the triangle which must be displayed in front of a lorry in the event of a breakdown or a burst tyre. A motorist drives along probably between two lights at about 50 miles an hour. He does not see anything until he hits the lorry and immediately the unfortunate lorry driver and the lorry proprietor are blamed for the situation. I certainly could not agree that the whole fault is with the lorry driver. A big percentage of the fault lies with the car drivers and with carelessness. In my opinion the greatest number of those accidents are brought about by speed. I wanted to mention that at this stage because I feel Senator Flanagan and most other Members of this House will never be compelled to drive those lorries.
In this debate Senators, I am sure, spoke on the problem nearest to themselves. Some people who were quite capable of doing so dealt with education and others dealt with Health and some Senators mentioned the TV service. Others dealt with agriculture and I should like to deal with a few problems which are nearest to my heart and which are very hard problems to solve in the West of Ireland.
As was mentioned earlier on by Senator Belton, and more recently by Senator Flanagan the question of dispensary doctors is a great problem. There are a number of dispensary doctor vacancies particularly in Counties Leitrim, Roscommon and Sligo at the moment. These posts are very often advertised but no doctor applies for them. The unfortunate people living within that dispensary district have no service other than the service they are getting from the dispensary doctors in the neighbouring dispensaries.
At the present moment we have a situation in Leitrim where there is a vacancy for one dispensary doctor but no doctor will apply for it. The doctor who is carry out work in that dispensary area has since become ill, which means that there is one doctor trying to do the work of three dispensary doctors. That is all right for some of us who are blessed with enough of the worldly goods so that if we get sick or our wives or any members of the families get sick we are able to put our hand in our pocket and pay for a doctor.
However, there is a large number of people in that area who have medical cards and who cannot pay for any service. It is a great hardship on them now that there is no dispensary doctor there. I admit that somebody might easily ask how we are going to solve this. The only way this can be solved is by increasing the salary which dispensary doctors receive. I think the maximum of the scale in rural Ireland at the moment is £2,300. It will have to be shoved up substantially if we are to give a service to the people living in rural Ireland.
I was rather amused on looking back at the local paper, the Roscommon Herald, when I saw that the Minister for Education at the time, Deputy Brian Lenihan, made a statement during the general election campaign. He referred to Roscommon County Hospital and to the health services generally and this is what he said:
As far as health is concerned we have changed the system and now a patient may have his own choice of doctor.
That statement referred entirely to people in the lower income group. He did not say that he was playing politics where one would expect him to play them because the people in the other income groups could afford to pay for the service. I want to ask the Minister who replies to this debate since when did the Government give free choice of doctor to people who are holders of medical cards? If they did in which counties are they being given free choice of doctor?
Comment on this
Surely the Minister was anticipating the legislation which will be coming before the Seanad shortly.
Comment on this
Those are the words which were used. Perhaps he was saying this to try to fool the people in that area who did not know him as well as I do. If you look at the figures in that particular constituency you will find they are beginning to know the Minister.
Another problem very near to my heart is the question of mentally handicapped children. I admit both the Central Health Authority in the Department of Health and the county councils are doing tremendous work in this field but there still remains a lot of work to be done here. As one who takes an interest in this problem and realises the hardships which are involved, I know the problem which confronts the Department of Health. There is the question that if you build institutions it is very hard to get people to teach there. We all know that those unfortunate children, unless they are only mildly handicapped, once they go into institutions remain there until the Lord calls them. This means there are no vacancies to let others in.
I admit we have an increased number of beds and the accommodation available has doubled during the past couple of years but in my opinion it should be a first priority of not alone the Department of Health but of the entire Government to provide accommodation for all those unfortunate children. I had the experience quite recently where a man came to me with a child who was what you would say a degree above mildly mentally handicapped and that man was most anxious to get the child into a mental hospital. God knows we all know that is no place to send an unfortunate child like that. I often wonder if the Government's conscience is clear on it. I wonder if our consciences as members of local authorities are clear on it and if we could satisfy ourselves that we have done enough for this particular problem. I do not think that we have and there ought to be very much more done.
I was delighted also to hear Senator Flanagan speaking today about no private beds in any of our hospitals. I was wondering to myself if he had got a look at the "Just Society" which was being read here all morning by Senator Keery, the policy which was prepared by the Fine Gael Party and which was brought up to date prior to the last general election. In that policy we clearly conveyed that, and we told the electorate about that policy that we would all go to the door at the one level and only that.
Comment on this
They had a right to but I will quote further from it where another Minister used it. The people did not accept it due to the propaganda that was used by the Government Party, but if we are sincere about giving people a health service in the lower income group and doing away with private beds in these hospitals the only way to do it is by adopting the Fine Gael health policy, and let us all go to the dispensary door at the one level.
We have another very serious problem in the West of Ireland, and that is regarding the housing of old on elderly people. There are a number of people—in some cases widows who live alone, in other cases widowers and in some cases man and wife in receipt of old age pensions—and these people would be quite prepared to move into a town centre and probably sell their land to neighbours, which would help to solve this problem of congestion in the West of Ireland.
In my county the local St. Vincent de Paul Society a year ago bought three old houses and re-constructed them at a total cost of £2,500. The county council gave them a grant of £800 and the Department of Local Government gave a grant of £800. It was the county MOH and the manager who appointed the three people who would occupy these houses. One of them is an old age pensioner who is paying 5/-a week, another is also an old age pensioner a little bit better off and her rent is 8/2d. The third is a man who sold his farm and got £500 for his land and he is paying 20/- per week. Now that gives a total income of 33/-per week for the three houses. Those three houses will have to be kept and maintained from this income. There is no other means of keeping or maintaining them. I am sure that any Senators here who are members of the St. Vincent de Paul Society or know the work the Society does have found that the day-to-day demands on them leave them with no money whatsoever for capital development. I certainly think that in cases like these these grants should be substantially increased, because the local St. Vincent de Paul Society Conferences are doing enough of work in their own way by means of contributions, by looking after these people, sometimes having to buy clothes for them—bedclothes and the clothes that they wear, boots, shoes and so on—and I certainly think that there is an obligation on the Central Fund to increase these grants.
Quite recently we have sent a further scheme to the Department of Local Government which is going to cost £25,000. This scheme includes five double houses which will house ten people, twelve single houses which will house 12 people, with a community centre, TV in it, kitchen and laundry. The local contribution will be £4,000 and we are finding it very difficult to get enough money by means of grant from any Department to cover the balance. These people can be kept much cheaper by the St. Vincent de Paul Society than they will be kept in any county home in Ireland. Most people will admit that even at this stage a certain stigma attaches to the county home and people are not prepared to move into it, so it would serve a twofold purpose to take those people into the centres such as I have mentioned. It would serve the purpose that more land would be available to sell to their neighbours, and ease congestion, and it would be taking them in where they would be nearer whatever church they wanted to go to, nearer to doctors for medical attention, nearer to shops when they would purchase goods they required to keep the human life together I hope that the Minister for Finance will take particular notice of that and give substantially increased grants to societies doing this work.
I would like to make some reference to the FitzGerald Report on hospitals In doing so I would like to mention at the outset that the makeup of the people who issued this report is ten people from the City of Dublin, one comes from Castlebar, two from Galway, one from Cork, one from Limerick, and one from Sligo, and it is rather funny in looking at this and at the make up of the personnel of the board that in each one of the areas where a representative comes from it is recommended within this report that there should be a central hospital Maybe it is coincidental. I do not know, but it struck me as most peculiar when I read it. The report talks of the community centres and explains on page 31 what is meant by a community health centre. It says that county hospitals not selected for development as general hospitals should become community health centres providing in-patient services similar to those in district nursing homes but backed by somewhat increased diagnostic facilities and a more comprehensive consultant outpatient organisation.
I find also that on page 97 of this report reference is made to the Roscommon County Hospital. I mention this solely for the purpose of conveying to the House the situation in this hospital. The Report says:
Hospitals are at present functioning in Roscommon (County Hospital), in Ballinasloe, (Portiuncula Hospital) and in Ballyshannon (Sheil Hospital). The re-organised service envisaged in this report, involving a more centralised hospital service with larger and fewer hospital centres, makes it impracticable in the long term to continue to use these hospitals for acute medical and surgical services. In the short-term, while the main centres are being developed to acceptable standards, the hospitals at Roscommon, Ballinasloe and Ballyshannon will continue, as at present, to provide a necessary service for their immediate surroundings. Close ties should be developed between these hospitals and the main centres. In the case of Portiuncula Hospital and Roscommon County Hospital these ties should be with the Regional Hospital in Galway while the Sheil Hospital should be linked to the General Hospital in Sligo. With the implementation of the programme aimed at having all acute work dealt with in these centres, a new role must be found for these three hospitals, one or more of which might have become Community Health Centres. This might be determined in the light of experience by the Regional Hospital Board. A new role must be found for these three hospitals one of which might become a community health centre. This might be determined in the light of the experience of the regional hospital board.
That is what the report said about the Roscommon County Hospital. Roscommon County Council took a poor view of the report naturally, first of all because of the amount of money that has been spent on that hospital. It was built in 1941 and it cost £138,000, £46,000 of a loan which was borrowed by the county council and which is being paid back at the normal rate of interest at that time. The grant received was £92,000.
The county council had to pay the £46,000. There was an extension built in 1953 which cost £68,286. Of this £14,426 was a grant and £53,000 had to be found by the council, again by means of borrowing. Everybody knows that the ratepayers contributed a very substantial amount. In 1968 there was another reconstruction job done which cost £104,000, £52,000 of a grant and £52,000 of a loan. Last year a new laboratory was built which cost £3,000. This was paid for by the county council. The total amount spent on the hospital since 1941, including the erection, extensions and everything is £313,276 and the amount of money received by way of grants is £158,426 and the amount contributed by the ratepayers of Roscommon is £154,850.
This hospital has given tremendous service to the people of County Roscommon and some of the adjoining counties, particularly the southern part of Leitrim around Carrick-on-Shannon. These people feel very aggravated that there should be any suggestion, even in the FitzGerald Report, of closing down this hospital. As a matter of interest the work that was done in that hospital in the year 1967 was: Admissions 3,423; Operations 1,246; Births within the hospital 411—the total number of births in the county was 830 so approximately 50 per cent of the children born in Roscommon in that year were born in the hospital— Laboratory tests 6,082; People who attended specialist clinics 2,371. I do not think it is fair to deprive these people of that service within their own county.
I want to quote a statement that was made on the very same day that the Taoiseach let himself loose around the country during the general election campaign. The heading in the Roscommon Herald was: County Hospital to be Retained and Expanded. Taoiseach addresses Public Meeting in Roscommon. The then Minister for Education, now Minister for Transport and Power, was there to greet the Taoiseach. On that evening he had got in touch by phone with two local newspapers that I know of and I do not know how many more. He asked them to hold some space for a prepared script he had with regard to the hospital. Naturally the papers did as as they were told and the script duly arrived. It is interesting to read it at this stage. I quote from the Roscommon Herald:
The County Hospital will be retained. I want to tell you this because a lot of talk was due to people from the Opposition who were using this for political purposes. There will be no downgrading. The hospital will be retained and expanded and further expansion will be taking place and at present I can tell you that there are plans in the Department.
I did not believe this but many people in Roscommon believed it. A few days ago when this was being debated in the Dáil after the Deputies who now represent that constituency had pleaded with the Minister, here is what the Minister said and there is no word about plans in it:
As regards the closing of a hospital I propose that we repeat the section of the 1947 Act so as to prove that the Minister must hold a local inquiry before directing the closing of a hospital or institution. I hope that will satisfy the House.
That satisfied the House but I wonder will it satisfy the people of Roscommon who were completely misled by the Minister for Transport and Power. I do not know what the future of the Roscommon hospital will be. I certainly felt bound to make the plea that I have made on behalf of the people who were not fooled by the promises made by the Minister.
I should like to deal briefly with the comments that have been made by Deputy Flanagan, Minister for Lands, in his reply to the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Lands.
Comment on this
It would help if the Senator would quote the volume and column number.
Comment on this
I quote from Volume 242, No. 9, column 1426:
Then I come to the question raised as to whether the Department of Lands as such should be a separate Ministry or should be amalgamated, as suggested in the Devlin Report, with the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, and the other question as to whether the forestry service should be reconstituted as a semi-State body. My view is that the forestry service as it is is extremely successful and that, if the Department of Lands were to be abolished and the amended functions of the Department put under the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, this should not include the Forestry Division. In those circumstances it would possibly be preferable to set up a commercial, semi-State body, say, on the lines of Bord na Móna, and that that body would be responsible not merely for the implementation of our forestry programme but also for all aspects of timber and all the allied industrial undertakings associated with the by-products of trees.
I am certainly not going to involve myself in a row between Deputy Flanagan, the Minister for Lands, and Deputy Moran, the Minister for Justice, as to whether the Department of Lands are to go to Castlebar, but I wish to make this reference——
Comment on this
As I have said before, I do not wish to involve myself in any rows between Ministers, but I should like to quote our policy relating to the Department of Lands. I am sure the Senator who began this morning must have read it in our Just Society: if not he will find it there:
The Department of Lands will be abolished and most of its functions will be taken over by an authority. The possibility of placing the afforestation programme, which is essentially a commercial type activity, under a new State company will be examined closely.
I wonder if Deputy Flanagan was, as he said, reading the Devlin Report. I believe that some time previously he had read the Just Society and this gave him the idea.
Again at column 1421 of volume 242 Deputy Flanagan referred to people, small farmers, who will not accept land, and I quote:
At least two or three Deputies mentioned that it was more economic for people in congested areas to refuse land than to accept it and this applies even where the 50 per cent annuity operates. This point is valid and reinforces my view that we would be adopting a sounder policy if we were to provide employment for as many people as possible leaving them with their 15 or 20 acre farms as a sideline. That represents a very considerable change in the system particularly for the West of Ireland and I shall await with interest the public reaction to this statement.
I think the reason people refused this is because the 50 per cent annuity is too high and small farmers nowadays are just able to make ends meet. If they receive further lands to add to their holdings, and they are being asked to pay 50 per cent of the annuity, they do not seem to be able to pay it. This question of refusing land never happened until the annuity was substantially increased a few years ago and for that reason I think the Minister for Lands would be better engaged if he looked at the possibility of giving a further reduction in this annuity.
I now come to his reference to the county I was born and reared in. At column 1413 of the same volume, the Minister for Lands out of the blue said:
I have plans for certain areas which I regard as being particularly suitable for forestry. I refer in particular to County Leitrim and I should like to inform the House that I have directed the Forestry Division to make an all-out drive to acquire land in County Leitrim, to plant it and thereby give employment to as many people as possible in that area. This perhaps involves acceptance of the fact that most of the land of Leitrim is not suitable for development in agriculture. It is as well to face realities in regard to matters like this and to abandon the effort of making a living where a living is not to be got. There are other questions with regard to forestry to which I shall return later.
One reads that and one reads the earlier passage where he referred to industries for Leitrim. That is not the first time the people of Leitrim were promised industries, but unlike the people of Roscommon, they did not believe it. However, they paid a rather severe price for not believing the Government, when their county was divided into three parts for election purposes, and this was done for no other reason other than they did not believe the Government.
Comment on this
The Senator abused the facilities of this House yesterday to attack a colleague who was not here to defend himself, but it is typical of him.
Comment on this
It is not my fault that the Minister was not here. The Minister knows perfectly well that in this debate all Departments are under examination.
Comment on this
It was a personal attack on the Minister who was not here to defend himself. It was typical of the Senator; he is unfit to be a professor in the university.