Appropriation Bill, 1969: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 179–362 of 362. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1969 ›
The Chair wishes to point out that these proceedings are completely disorderly and cannot be tolerated. The Members and the Minister present must obey the order of the Chair. The bell has been rung three times in the last few minutes and still the disorder continued. It must be pointed out that all these interruptions, and the interruptions of the interruptions, cannot possibly be tolerated. I would ask Senator Reynolds to resume on the Appropriation Bill and I would ask all others to refrain from interrupting.
Comment on this
In 1937 Fianna Fáil had two seats out of three—Leitrim was then a single constituency. During that election campaign I remember one morning waiting to address a meeting after the Fianna Fáil speaker in the town of Carrick-on-Shannon had pointed up to the old jail and said: "In the next few months we will have a shirt factory there". I am coming to the point of industries for Leitrim. The old jail is still there but the shirt factory is not. Again we are being promised here further industries. In the election of 1957 it was quite noticeable that the electorate of Leitrim was no longer believing the Government Party and the votes switched from them. In the 1961 election that county was divided into parts; portion went to Roscommon and portion went to Sligo and it resulted in two Fine Gael Deputies in County Leitrim, Deputy Joe McLaughlin and I.
In the 1967 local elections which followed, the Fine Gael representatives went from five to 12 which clearly indicated that the Fianna Fáil Party were in serious trouble in that county. Last year it was divided into three parts and it gave the result of one Fine Gael TD only, after Fianna Fáil had shufflled an extra seat out of it through the kind of promises I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I have great admiration for Senator Reynolds and I am sorry that he is not in the other House any more, but allowing for all the latitude that is granted on the occasion of this debate, is he not going a bit too wide?
Comment on this
The Chair was possibly within 60 seconds of warning Senator Reynolds that he was out of order.
Comment on this
In a discussion of this type it is essential to relate these remarks to the Bill under discussion and it is clear to see that the Senator has been dwelling on this point, which is without direct reference to the Appropriation Bill.
Comment on this
The reference I quoted was in relation to a statement from the Minister for Lands when he said that Leitrim will be planted. I bow to the ruling of the Chair but I wonder how much I am out of order. When one is examining this whole situation and particularly with regard to the problems of the present, one will see that there is a drop of 27 per cent of the total population.
Comment on this
I compliment the various Senators from all sides of the House on their contributions but I think it is beyond a joke when a Senator stands up and reprimands the Taoiseach and the Cabinet for the attitude they adopted during the recent Northern Ireland crisis. I wish to compliment the Taoiseach and his Cabinet very sincerely and I am sure that I speak for at least 95 per cent if not 99 per cent of the people of Ireland who have already voiced their opinions by various means in thanking the Taoiseach for the stand he took during that time.
I should also like to compliment the Minister for External Affairs on what I thought was a most enlightening address to the UN on the Northern Ireland question. It proved without any doubt that the various Ministers of Fianna Fáil have been accepted as being second to none in their various positions throughout the world. However. I may forgive Senator Kelly. He is a comparatively young man but he made a vicious attack during his speech on the Taoiseach and the Cabinet for their handling of that situation of course, I accept that Senator Kelly was expressing only his own opinion because there is no indication from questions put and reports received from the people of Ireland that they did not accept the stand taken by the Taoiseach and his colleagues.
Certainly, we all want to find out what is the root of the trouble in Northern Ireland. We know where it lies and some of us are old enough to remember the time when a leader of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government came back with £5 million and said: "We have a good bargain". The root of the trouble in Northern Ireland lies in the boundary that was instigated, founded and accepted by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.
Comment on this
The cry from Fine Gael on the situation in Northern Ireland is accepted as being a bit belated. We all have good reason to accept that. I should like to refer to a body governed by the Minister for Finance—the Board of Works—and to point out that in some of the large drainage schemes that have taken place throughout the country and especially in the western areas there are certain rivers and drains that have not yet been completed. That may be all right in the eastern side of the country where land is not as valuable to the owner as it is in the West of Ireland. One can imagine a small farmer with ten or 12 acres of land trying to eke out a living for his family, but as a result of the drainage not being completed, four or five acres of that man's land are flooded at certain times of the year. Those four or five acres mean as much to that man as, possibly, 30 or 40 acres to a man on the eastern side of the country who probably had a farm of 150 or 200 acres.
I should like to impress on the Minister and on his Parliamentary Secretary that if they could do anything to ensure that those unfinished rivers and drains are completed before the machinery leaves the areas in which it is operating, it would mean a lot to the people concerned. The drainage of 90 or 100 acres of land may be the difference between existence or extinction of the farmers of a particular area. Of course, I do not mean that one farmer would have 90 or 100 acres—several farmers would be involved in that amount of land.
Speaking about the west, I should also like to mention small industries and in speaking about them one must bring in small holdings of land because one is complementary to the other. It is reputed and accepted that the largest families in Ireland come from homes along the western seaboard but we must accept that only one of these people, a son or a daughter, can remain on a small holding. The remaining six or seven, and sometimes ten or 12 children, must find employment away from home, be it in Dublin. Birmingham or London. These small holdings cannot support a man, his wife and ten or 13 children.
I should like to see more small industries coming to the West of Ireland in the very near future. If this does not happen, whether the Opposition like it or not, there will be no referendum but there will be only a one-seat constituency in Mayo because that is all the population will be able to elect. We want to see those small industries coming to the West of Ireland where families can be employed. Those who had to leave can then return to their homes and in this way they can supplement the farm incomes on those small farms.
In my own area I have experience of this type of work because we have in the Crossmolina area Bord na Móna works and an ESB peat station and we have seen small farmers' incomes supplemented by the incomes of their families who they worked on those projects. Those farms are now thriving instead of being downtrodden. We have seen how some of those poor farms can look in spring when the land is very wet and in need of fertilisers and manure. Now, with the increased income coming in from small industries, those lands become green fields with cows grazing in them.
Some of the younger children living on those farms are receiving a good secondary education and some of them are going to the vocational schools. They will not be forced to go out to work at an early age or go to the fields of Scotland and England picking potatoes before they are even school leaving age. As I said, I have seen what has happened in the Crossmolina area and I should like to see this spread to the eastern and northern parts of County Mayo as well as in further areas of the west part of the county.
I do not believe that planting a huge industry in a particular large town in Mayo or any other part of the West of Ireland will be the means of saving the West. I am sick, tired and fed up listening to the slogan: "Save the West". If we had the opportunity of demanding it as a God given right, we would save it ourselves and we do not want people coming in and doing it for us. We are quite capable, if we get the opportunity of doing so, of going out and finding industries which will come in there. I am sure many of them would be very happy to come in and start industries in the West of Ireland.
I have heard references to education and I heard one Senator saying that in the next few years the number of students attending universities will be something like 18,000. I believe, although our children are entitled to higher education, if an industrial drive began in rural areas instead of all the young children and their parents being anxious to have them get four to five honours in the Leaving Certificate, and attend university, they would be quite happy, and more than content, to have those children attend the local vocational school and eventually fit them out to take their place in industry, where they would be able to take over technician places. I may say, without fear of contradiction, that the young men I have seen going to the technical school in my locality have obtained very good technician posts and, without mentioning names, there has been one man, whose name appeared in the papers some months ago, who is one of the leading technicians of a big radio and television company in Dublin. He also lectures. He is a past pupil of the vocational school and he never in his life saw the inside of a secondary school.
I also know young men of the present generation who learned the carpentry trade in the vocational school in my locality and some of them are now employed in Dublin, while others are in England as agents for contractors and huge building firms. I believe if the industrial projects spread throughout the country and we can educate our young boys and girls in proper career guidance and direct them to the vocational schools, where they would become masters in art and industry, we would not have the clamour and sanctity attached to the university and the secondary schools. This is one of the finest cures and methods of reducing this egoism about attending a university. There are technicians working throughout the length and breadth of Ireland who are equal to if not better than some of the qualified men who come out of the various universities.
I have heard criticism from the other side of the Chamber that the Government are making no effort, or have made no effort, to educate our people for entry into the Common Market. When the Minister for Agriculture recently tried to educate people to prepare themselves for entry into the Common Market he was castigated by every speaker of the Opposition Parties in Dáil Éireann, and also in this House during this debate. He endeavoured to educate people to the fact that over-production of milk is a detriment to this country at the present time. All the EEC countries are now trying to reduce the production of milk. Despite this we now hear a clamour for more bonuses and subsidies to be paid to men who produce 28,000 to 40,000 gallons of milk per year.
The Minister for Agriculture has paid a subsidy to try to increase the production of beef. I do not see the gentlemen who are complaining being consistent in their argument. The people in the Twenty-six Counties have told them recently what they think of their arguments of the past 50 years. I should like those people to be consistent and to give any Minister credit who endeavours to educate the community and to prepare them for entry into the Common Market.
When he is doing that, I should like him to be appreciated and not castigated. This type of work is wrong, and they would get a far better hearing from the general public if they had the manliness and the common sense to stand up and to say that the Minister is putting us on a sound basis, that we know where we are going and that when we enter the Common Market we can get down and try to do it. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Finance, the Government and everybody else have been trying to educate our industrialists to reach the level of production that is operating on the continent so that when we do get into the Common Market we will be able to meet competition and to deal with our competitors on a very good scale.
I have also heard Senator McDonald saying that the Estimate for the pig farrowing scheme has been reduced by £90,000. I do not wonder at all at the estimate being reduced by £90,000. I happen to be a member of Mayo Committee of Agriculture, and we operate that scheme on behalf of the Minister for Agriculture, and last year we fell short by 200 applications. We could not get rid of this money that the Minister put at our disposal to increase the pig population. There was nothing we could do about it, although recently on the British market Irish bacon has come up in price to the second highest of all cured bacon entering into the British market, within 10/- per cwt. of the Danish price, which we have not reached for many many years.
If the money estimated by the Department is not used by the community I do not think that anybody can blame the Minister for reducing it by that amount the following year. I am sure that Senator McDonald and interested people who enter into this pig farrowing scheme will have no difficulty at all in getting the Minister to have a supplementary Estimate for more money, but until he is able to convince me of that fact I do not think it is up to the Minister to allot more money on that basis.
I should like to speak on the Department of Local Government and the housing programme, which is a very sore fact in my area and I believe in a lot of other areas. I am not blaming the Department of Local Government for not putting funds and everything else available. I know that they are there. I know that we can get them and use them. We had an experience back in one period which was a detrimental period in the middle fifties where we owed £750,000 from Mayo County Council and could not get it but the advent of Fianna Fáil within six months enabled us to wipe out our backlog. There is no shortage of money as regards housing at the present time in any county council that has adopted a supplementary housing scheme. There is plenty of them available, but what I would like the Department of Local Government to do would be to cut out a lot of the red tape that is concerned with the acquisition of sites and tendering for houses.
I speak with some authority on this we have especially a county engineer who wishes to dominate and dictate the smallest particle of policy to his engineers and will not allow them to use their own intelligence and their own initiative to adopt a scheme and implement it, for he has to come and examine every single detail, see all the applications; and if the Department of Local Government allows him to do that he holds up those housing schemes and I am afraid that the housing programme will be long delayed. What I would like the Department to do would be to cut through this red tape and get on with the building of houses and stop this monkey-doodling business, as I call it, of the engineers — I do not say all of them but some of them. I do not suppose it is happening in every county but it is happening in some counties. I would like if we could cut the red tape and get on with the housing.
Planning is another very sore item in the West of Ireland, but I believe there is going to be a new Department of Planning set up and owing to the fact that I believe this will be in the very near future I think I will reserve my remarks about planning until such time as that happens.
Comment on this
I take it that we will continue until we finish the Appropriation Bill, and I would suggest that the Minister might get in to conclude not later than 5.30 if that will meet with agreement.
Comment on this
I do not think that they will last any length of time, but I do not think it would be prudent to set a time.
Comment on this
It is no use trying to set a time. I had not intended to take part in this debate, since we have a number of new Senators whom we have heard in excellent talking form on both sides of the House and I must compliment those who made their first speeches here. Most of them were excellent and most of them made an effort to address themselves to the business in hand. I was terribly disappointed to find in particular the speech of Senator Kelly across the way, about whom I have heard quite a lot, but whom I did not realise was so poisonous in his attitude.
Comment on this
The Senator should not speak of another Senator in that fashion.
Comment on this
Then should I say that the Senator was obscurantist in his attitude in regard to those with whom he found himself in disagreement. The Senator, as far as I can gather from his work in the newspapers, his attendance at Fine Gael Party meetings, and his activities generally outside the House and his attendance in here does not leave himself much time, apparently, for his business of professing. What strikes me most is that whatever he does profess in his academic capacity, if you can describe it as such, must have a very jaundiced view in view of the jaundiced picture portrayed here today and in view of the fact that he must — he is surely old enough — know what happened in this country in the last 50 years, and he must have read some Irish history apart from this Just Society that those people are talking about. He must have read some Irish history apart from anything else.
Comment on this
I read this document this morning and there is no reference in it whatsoever to the North of Ireland so how could he know anything about it?
Comment on this
Well he should have known something about the history of Ireland from what he has read. In that case I would not have shouted across to interrupt other people that the statement was untrue, with regard to the situation in the North, that the Senator here stated that the Fine Gael Party have more or less sold the people of the North for a mess of pottage. You may recall a few long contributions we had yesterday——
Comment on this
Before the Senator goes any further on these lines might I remind him that this is the Appropriation Bill and historical matters do not really come into it.
Comment on this
I am not going into detailed history, but I just want to deal with the accusation that the Taoiseach did not handle the situation in the North well and that the country was not satisfied with the way he handled it. He tried to insinuate that the Taoiseach really did not act for the country in a fit and proper manner. I am trying to point out that he represents a party which on four occasions sold the Six Counties of the North, whether for a mess of pottage or pride or ineptitude or not, I do not know.
Comment on this
I am told it is nonsense now — 1921, March 1922, December 1925 and February 1949. You will find it all in the history books if you read them. Senator Kelly ought to have a little more sense than to attempt to put that across to people who have read their history, helped to make their country's history and continue to read their history. He will find that he will do a lot better in the Seanad, which is not a House like the Dáil — we have tried to make it a House of reasoned debate in which people put their point of view without interruption and I do not think anybody can allege that I interrupted or was in any way unco-operative during the last three days — we have tried to make this a House in which even Senator Sheehy Skeffington is allowed to speak.
Comment on this
If Senator Kelly plays ball in that direction he will find that he will be listened to but if he does not play ball and if he does not attempt to observe the decencies by conducting himself in the fashion of a gentleman then I am afraid he will get possibly a little more than he might expect.
With regard to Senator Sheehy Skeffington I am reminded of a suggestion which unfortunately cannot be considered under this Bill since we cannot advocate new legislation, but possibly we could advocate the amendment of existing legislation?
Comment on this
On the section of the Bill dealing with the Estimate for the Department of Defence then. We vote a lot of money for Defence and we fall short in regard to our defensive measures under the existing provisions by not having provision in the Bill and in the power of the Minister for the defence of the realm against poisonous, slanderous tongues, operations and campaigns inside and outside this country. Senator Sheehy Skeffington connived at one of these campaigns and in any remotely democratically organised society a person who tries to undermine that society would be dealt with as an enemy of the people and of the society——
Comment on this
——and would find himself facing trial by jury of his peers. Unfortunately, I do not know of any legislation that exists here at the disposal of the Department of Defence to deal with Senator Sheehy Skeffington, Dr. Cvril Daly, Mr. Cleer, Constance O'Connell and all these other "weirdies" who have caused this campaign of which Senator Brosnahan spoke this morning. If there was such an Act I certainly would be the first to turn public informer on Senator Sheehy Skeffington and the others concerned.
Comment on this
Would the Senator come back to the Appropriation Bill?
Comment on this
Yes, I was dealing with the Department of Defence. I have great respect and esteem for Senator Jimmy Dunne, whose honesty and integrity I rate very highly. I was interested to see that he is anxious that we should restructure our society on the basis of some type of prices and incomes policy which would commend itself to the trade union movement which would then be prepared to cooperate to give it effect. Faith without good works is dead and when a fellow has bought a pig in a poke a few times he likes to see some evidence in advance of buying the pig again. I am very much afraid the these statements about the trade union movement cooperating are a little bit woolly.
Four or five years ago when the TUC met in Cork with Senator Dominick Murphy presiding I made a speech here on the fourth day of the Trade Union Congress discussion on the rationalisation of its own structure and on the need to deal with these mustang wild cat strikes that were occurring at the time. Just at that time also one of the first of the big breakaway groups formed a union and the TUC found itself unable to deal with that. Since then we have had many strikes, some of them very serious, some of them nationally dangerous, and all of them damaging to the endeavour to put Irish industry in such a position on the export market that when the EEC situation arrived we would find ourselves in fighting trim and able to meet any competition. These official strikes developed into a further phase of unofficial strikes so that now we have a system as far as I can judge, whereby the union will repudiate a group who go on strike and that group will describe itself as an unofficial strike. They will put on a picket and then the new religion about which I spoke four or five years ago with its first commandment: "Thou shalt not pass the picket" frightens the wit out of everybody in the town or anyone who goes next or near the edifice around which the picket is stationed and the unofficial strike continues and nobody can do anything about it. They tell the union bosses and everybody else to go to hell and they carry on their merry way. In due course a settlement is arirved at. Possibly the employers are bludgeoned into giving in but anyway they give in. Then the men go back to work. The union is quite happy and that is recognised then although it is breaking an agreement perhaps six months before the termination of the period for which the agreement was supposed to operate. It is now recognised as the norm by which all the other workers in that industry are to claim increases. The Trade Union Congress apparently can do nothing about it because they appear to have lost control completely over their members in the various unions.
It was appalling and deplorable to me, who have always regarded trade unions as a very vital and essential part of a democratic State, to hear Mr. Rory Roberts on television the other night, when questioned by one of those brilliant interviewers they have in Telefís Éireann, admitting that although the Congress had made a certain decision with regard to the visit of the Springbok team to Ireland it could not enforce that decision on the unions and that in fact one union had gone far ahead of the decision Congress had taken. This shows that before anything could happen in the line of co-operation by the trade union movement as such the Trade Union Congress must control the movement and must be in a position to enforce discipline among the units that make up that movement and——
Comment on this
——and must be in a position to make good a bargain which it makes with anybody else. I do not want to develop that any further in view of the possibility of legislation but I would say to all who are interested and who have any influence that the time has come when unions should catch on to themselves and realise that the great damage they are likely to do in this country, is not to the boss class which does not exist any more in the Marxism phraseology, or not to the Government or not to any inanimate thing but to the workers themselves. If they so cripple the economic position here so as to make it impossible for us to have a viable community, they should remember that the days of isolation of industry throughout Europe are ending and that we shall not be able to stand up but shall go to the wall and they will suffer most. Therefore all men of goodwill should bend their efforts to that end.
A couple of years ago I made a plea here which has been referred to by Senator Kelly — that is the question of buying Irish goods at Christmas. That is rubbish because we should buy them all the year round. The shops were filled with Irish goods — and I use the past tense here — but we now find that the shops are mainly filled with English goods, particularly women's goods, ladies' fashions, hose, hats, coats and so on.
We had the extraordinary warning from a fashion show, or at least a fashion debate in the Intercontinental Hotel the other night, that by 1975 most of our fashion goods will be in open competition with British manufactured goods and with tariffs so low that there is practically free trade and the importation of British goods will be at least two or three times the value they are now, and this only applies to ladies' clothing.
The figure was down to about £500,000, it crept up to £1 million and within the next 12 months it will have gone up by another million. It is the teenagers particularly and young ladies who buy British goods. They are the wives, the daughters and the sisters of trade union members, of the half million men who are registered in the trade union movement in this country and surely it is the first duty of the Trade Union Congress to see to it that concrete action is taken. Apart altogether from trying to worry about trade union structure and strikes, here is a concrete case where we can do something to preserve the jobs of thousands of Irish workers and to produce jobs for thousands more.
If you go into any shop at the present moment you will find it very difficulty to find Irish goods on sale. My information on this, and I have contacted very reliable people, is that very little effort is made by salesgirls in these shops to produce the Irish-manufactured goods to push them, to say these are better not because they are Irish but because they are manufactured from better material. The same situation applies to the sale of liquor and I find that barmen in this city are very guilty in regard to the sale of Irish drinks. I have gone into public bars and hotels, though I think this applies particularly to hotels, and if one does not specifically ask for an Irish whiskey, be it Paddy or Jameson, you will be served with Scotch. The same applies to beer — you will get Carlsberg from Denmark or Skol or ZHB. This is a sector in which we could make a more determined effort to buy Irish.
I should like to compliment the Minister for Finance on a couple of very imaginative Budgets in which original steps were taken on behalf of people who have been forgotten and on behalf of IRA veterans and the small farmers. I am satisfied with these activities in that direction and I think he deserves a word of praise. I should also like to praise whoever is responsible for the fact that we will have an Irish exhibit at Expo 70 in Osaka next year. Twelve months ago I appealed in this House to the responsible authorities to take advantage of the fact that in Expo 70 we will have one of the greatest trade fairs ever seen in the modern world, held in the neighbouring city to the capital of the fastest growing industrial democracy in the world, where wages are now reaching peak point and where the standard of living is as great as in the seaboard States of the US and as in the motor industry areas of Detroit and Michigan.
I refer of course to Japan where there is a tremendous market for manufactured goods in which we have not got our share yet. We are only selling about £1½ million as compared with the £6 million we buy from them. There is a big market there and anyone who has seen any of the recent films on UTV or BBC — I do not think I have seen them on RTE, they are too busy otherwise — those films dealt with the situation in the Far East from the trade point of view and may have our tongues hanging out when they hear that the price of a bottle of Scotch in Tokyo is £12. If they can sell Scotch at £12 in Tokyo we should be able to sell our far superior product for £15 to £20 but even £12 would be quite satisfactory. However the Irish distillers do not appear to be making an effort to put their product on the market. Perhaps here the Minister for Finance might be able to impose an extra tax for laziness in not trying to export our products eastwards. A measure such as this might help to remedy the situation.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied with Harp.
There are some other matters I should like to deal with. There is the question which our education brains trust here have been tub-thumping for quite a long time — we have a brains trust here, let the minions in the Lower House take note, this is certainly a citadel of education, higher, middle and lower. We have heard much of the new curricula in the national schools. I have not seen it but I have heard about it and I shall stick my neck out, possibly I shall be the only one in the Seanad to do so, by going on record as having grave doubts about this false philosophy of child-centred education about which the professors and the intelligentsia have been waxing so eloquent. As far as I can make out from reading this concept was the invention of Dr. Spock and was also conceived by a gentleman named Dewey. As far as my reading tells me, Deweyism became known as the curse of Columbia and has now become known as the curse of Ireland, if I can judge by the results of this child-centred education. Dr. Spock has now got such an eyeful of what the produce of his philosophy have been in the United States, in gangsters, killings and all the rest of it, that he is having second thoughts and is on the verge of requiting most of what he has put across to the rest of the world. Unfortunately, his ideas have been put across to us here and if they continue to be adopted to the same extent as they were adopted in the United States I do not know what the outcome will be.
This permissive society and the whole philosophy of Dewey which has been experimented with here has brought about a situation which, to say the least of it, is alarming, a situation in which we find not very far from a church in the centre of Dublin a number of beautiful little houses built for old people but in which the windows of every one of them have been broken and have had to be boarded up with the result that the old people inside are deprived of light. The kids continue to enjoy themselves and nobody is inclined to do anything about the situation.
There is something very sadly missing when we have a situation like this and I ask the Minister for Education and the Government to take another look at this whole question and to take a look also at the question of mental handicap which to my mind is being clouded with a lot of woolly thinking.
Comment on this
This new curriculum is only coming in this year and I fail to see how it can have influenced the activities of children up to this.
Comment on this
On a point of correction, this is a working document which will be used in pilot schemes in six schools.
Comment on this
I would be delighted to continue, a Chathaoirleach, but when people prevent me from doing so I have to sit down. With regard to this question of mental handicap we have been looking westwards for a long time to developments in that part of the world whereas there are great developments eastwards about which we know very little. I suggest, therefore, that the Department of Education and other Departments might look eastwards. For instance, our Department of Health might look to the East, in particular, to Japan where, from what I have read and learned, there is progress in surgery and medicine about which we have not had the slightest idea. In fact, they are far ahead of the best in England in this field.
We might also look to Moscow where there was a test held by Dr. Luria in regard to mental handicap and where, according to claims made by this statistical academic of the USSR, mental handicap accounts for only one per cent of the children. This vast semi-continent where, less than 70 years ago, the majority of the people were illiterate has now grown into a great country of modern progress with only one per cent of its children suffering from mental handicap and they are now about to give a blueprint of how to treat the situation. One of the things about the treatment is the fact that in the early formative years in infant classes there is no segregation of what are called here slow learners or dull children into separated classes and there would not be a boy or girl whom we would call a dunce at the end of the class. They have a different method and perhaps our Department might look a little towards Russia in these matters instead of always looking westwards so that we might learn something to our advantage.
One of the other matters mentioned during this debate was the ever-recurring Telefís Éireann. I think it was Senator Horgan who said that they would have to get a new definition of impartiality. They certainly would. If all their programmes — documentaries, sport and so on — were put together over a period of a year one would find it very difficult to pick out three or four normal people from the lot. The same faces seem to recur all the time and this is true in particular, of the "Late Late Show". Speaking of the "Late Late Show" reminds me that I must support Senator Brosnahan in his denunciation of the campaign that was organised on the basis of the NBC film made here with the connivance of certain well-known gentlemen inside and outside the Seanad.
Comment on this
The type of individual in Ireland who disgraces public life by conniving at a thing like that——
Comment on this
He is prepared to produce the evidence he has on file from the people in the United States. Before I was so rudely interrupted by the Senator who is so irresponsible that he does not like truth and cannot be kept quiet, I was speaking about the "Late Late Show". Some of the most horrible looking things that I have seen in a long time appeared on that show alleging to have been used by teachers in primary schools in this country.
Comment on this
If the Professor of Political Science, the dissident priest, Fr. Fergal O'Connor, saw some of the instruments——
Comment on this
Persons outside the House should not be criticised.
Comment on this
I was just saying that if Fr. Fergal O'Connor saw the instruments on that Late Late Show — he probably did not see it — God knows what he would have made of it. Bad and all as the film is, God knows what he would have made out of it because he is a teacher of political science.
I can relate that now to the subject under discussion because it has occurred to me that we are voting money here in this Bill for the universities and I do not think any man who conducts himself in the way a certain professor does — if I cannot mention his name, you know whom I am talking about — on Telefís Éireann, I do not think he is a fit or proper person to teach political science to Irish students. He will poison the minds of a whole generation of students if his attitude is that shown by him on Telefís Éireann.
I want to say to the Minister for Finance that I hope he will take note of this. If I were Minister for Finance I would, as a measure of disapproval, deduct from the university grant, the amount of salary, emoluments, fees or whatever is paid to this reverend gentleman who described St. Francis of Assisi on one of the Late Late Show programmes as the first of the hippies. He made a case for the hippies on the basis that St. Francis was the first of them and he described himself, I think, as a Christian Marxist priest. If university education is to be on that basis, then the sooner we do away with those university dons from the clerical end the better and get lay lecturers who will not have any inhibitions one way or the other.
The situation with regard to the merger is one on which we should like to hear a little bit of encouraging information — that the matter is under active arrangement, that it is being speeded up and that we will see a merger of those two famous institutions here in Dublin. I think apart from anything else it would do a lot of good to rid the academic life of Ireland possibly of some of the weirdies we have running it because maybe under a merged institution in Dublin there would be a selection board which would have more sense than to pick people who will do more damage to education than all the American gangster films we hear so much talk about on Telefís Éireann.
The last thing I want to say is that I am quite satisfied to vote this money in the Appropriation Bill. It is money which is being given to people who are spending it properly and rightly and it will pay good dividends in social, economic and political progress for this country.
Comment on this
This debate could best be described as a bumper one and some of the Members may know that a bumper is a good place for trying out the novices. Some of the contributions I have listened to in the last two or three days were very good and I am looking forward to the debates when the classics come up. I have just a few things I want to say on this Bill but before I do I should like to comment on something which the Leader of the House said towards the close of his remarks. Senator Ó Maoláin is one of those extremely keen debaters who never pull punches, but he is always fair. However, I think he departed from that in his reference to a reverend gentleman and I think it was quite uncalled for.
The contributions I have to make are under three short headings. One of them relates to the sphere of agriculture which has been covered rather fully by various speakers, but as far as I know no reference was made to sheep. We see in the booklet which was issued by the Department of Agriculture on the main activities of the Department that the sheep population in the country has been declining steadily. The most recent year quoted is 1968 but I think 1969 will show a further decline.
The Minister for Finance, as a former Minister for Agriculture, will realise the importance of the sheep industry in this country. He and his successor have made certain efforts to increase the sheep population in particular with the sheep grants given. They have nevertheless been unsuccessful in stemming the reduction in the numbers and some of those grants are wide open to abuse. They should be extended to include the lowland farmers.
Our entry into the EEC has been mentioned here by a number of speakers and I have noted in the papers that 1972 or 1973 will be the probable year of entry. While I do not know what the position will be in the British market regarding Commonwealth preference such as New Zealand for the importation of mutton and lamb they will find themselves in considerable difficulty and it will leave us with an extremely lucrative market. In the next two or three years, between now and our entry into the Common Market we have a great opportunity to build up our numbers of sheep and lamb and to avail of that market not to mention the even wider market on the continent of Europe a market which to take France for instance fluctuates during the season. When it is open there is a very spectacular rise in the price of lamb and when it closes the price drops considerably. But when the Common Market is extended that market will be there all the time. I would hope that the Minister for Finance would make a big effort to assist his colleagues in agriculture to vastly expand the sheep population so that we may be ready to avail of that.
There is another aspect of the sheep trade, namely that of wool. At the present time in a town in my own county, Newbridge, County Kildare, a very large factory is being built which will process the entire wool clip of this country. Not alone will it use the entire wool clip of the country but it will still have to import 80 per cent of its raw material. I do not know what the comparison would be of the increase in the export of wool as compared with whatever their final product is going to be for export and whether we would benefit in wool prices in that respect, but there is an aspect to be considered, namely that of the employment which will be given.
Despite the fact that it will be one of the most highly automated factories in Europe it will employ possibly in the region of 200 who I imagine will be very highly skilled operators and consequently will be in the very high income bracket, or should be. That is another thing to keep in mind when we are talking about the decline in the sheep population, to make sure that the decline is resisted, and it can be done with sheep in a much shorter time to bring them up to higher numbers than in the case of cattle.
I pass from that to a very brief reference about housing. I have every sympathy — indeed I am sure everybody in the House has — with the idea of better houses for old people. I think that they should if possible be brought into community centres into the towns and villages from outlying areas, but if you were to take my county where old people are living in vested houses they cannot leave them, but would have to dispose of their houses and would then not qualify for a house. I think that something could be done to enable them to so dispose of their houses and still qualify for a local authority small dwelling in a community centre where they would be near churches, shops, and so on, and not have them living in isolation, with the terrible loneliness that goes with that, not to mention in old age in particular.
The housing programme of the Government has been criticised. We in Kildare are making tremendous efforts and indeed I can claim tremendous strides in house building, but we have come up against a very severe problem, namely that of the small dwelling loans. Recently we have had so many people building houses in the country that in order to distribute all the money that is available to us for the loans we have had to confine it to people within the county. A certain individual who was building speculatively in one part of the county recently had his agent appear in a supplement to the Irish Independent. He criticised the Kildare County Council for doing this. He criticised the council for reserving this money given to us by the Department of Local Government for the Kildare people, and suggested that it should have been left wide open. If we convey his remarks to the Minister for Local Government or the Minister for Finance I am sure that they would try to meet the situation.
I move from that to the final item, namely, tourism. Tourism to my mind is one of our great assets. It is the goose that lays the golden egg but, alas, we are rapidly killing the goose. While a Senator on the far side yesterday evening almost referred to overcharging, he suggested that prices should be put up outside hotels and restaurants to show the people what the prices are inside. That to my mind is not the answer. We hear so much criticism from tourists — and I have heard it myself here in the country — referring to the prices being charged not just for bed and breakfast but for drink, tobacco, petrol and what have you, with the result that the great pool of tourists who cross the channel are to my mind turning from Ireland to the continent where they can have cheap holidays.
I cannot see anything wrong, instead of spending huge amounts of money in selling tourism here, in devising some system of giving cheaper petrol, cheaper drink, cheaper tobacco and so on and so encourage a huge influx of people into the country. The influx last year seemed to die down probably because of the disturbances in the North which may have kept some away, but nevertheless I think that when the figures come it will prove to have been a pretty good year. But it would increase the numbers coming in, and instead of having to sell it to people coming here the people would sell it for us and we would have them for many years spreading over the continent, over America, all over the world, that the place to go for a good and cheap holiday will be Ireland. That I am sorry to say is not the position at the moment, but I am sure that the powers that be will take note of that, and that when the Minister is drawing up his next legislation he will keep in mind that if he has to fall back on the hardy annuals he is going to do the economy a tremendous amount of harm.
Comment on this
During the last few days the voices of Munster, Leinster and Connacht have contributed to this debate, and I feel that it is only appropriate that at least one voice from Ulster should say a few words before the debate concludes. In referring to myself as a northerner and as an Ulsterman I would like to protest at the attempts made by many people not only in England, not only in the Six Counties but also here on this side of the Border, to deprive the people in the counties of Monaghan, Cavan and Donegal of their provincial status. One would get the impression from many people that they believe that Ulster is confined to the Six Counties of the north-eastern portion of this country. Indeed I consider it an act of impertinence on the part of the British Government to introduce into Westminster legislation referring to the new so-called defence corps as the "Ulster Defence Corps".
The trouble in the Six Counties did not begin on the 12th August of this year or the 4th October of last year. It did not, indeed, begin with the Boundary Commission in 1925, the Treaty in 1921 or indeed with the Battle of the Boyne. To my mind the current trouble in the Six Counties could go back as far as the defeat of O'Neill and O'Donnell at Kinsale. They returned to Ulster and after four years they were dejected and dispirited and in company with 90 others they left this country. In doing so they left Ulster defenceless and provided the British Government with the opportunity of curing for all time Ireland's chief trouble spot. The land was the source of wealth and the basis of power, and in removing Irish Catholics from the land in Ulster and replacing them by Protestant immigrants the British Government felt that in a very short time they would yield to their power — and so the Plantation of Ulster took place. We found in Ulster then a Protestant community riddled with Irish Catholics.
Comment on this
If we would replant Ulster under the Department of External Affairs I think we could solve the problem.
Comment on this
Senator McGlinchey to continue on the Appropriation Bill.
Comment on this
We found that the Protestant community in Ulster was riddled with Irish Catholics who were degraded and embittered and who remained there hoping that some day they would have a chance to fight again. Today, 360 years later, those Irish Catholics are still degraded, they are still embittered and they are still waiting on the chance to fight again.
I referred to the Plantation of Ulster because I feel that today in many ways history is repeating itself. We have not got a Flight of the Earls from Ulster at the moment but I believe that we have a flight of Irish nationalism, thanks to many doctrines — the Hume doctrine and the Cooper doctrine and many others and the "middle-of-the-road" doctrine which was referred to yesterday. I believe that the people who consider themselves "middle-of-the-road" are those who once again place their trust in British promises to Ireland and if we study our history we should know that British promises to Ireland were broken on many occasions. They were broken in the 17th century, in 1625 by King Charles, in 1685 when they were promised Catholic judges, Catholic privy councillors, Catholic employment in Ulster and they got them for a while but a few years later they got William of Orange. The Treaty of Limerick was broken before the parchment was dry and only 50 years ago the 1921 Treaty and the Boundary Commission to my mind was broken in the sense that the geographic and economic conditions were not taken into consideration as was promised and my county in particular has suffered considerably as a result. There is a grave tendency, in order to placate the Unionist Government in Stormont, in order that we may not rock the boat, that many people on this side of the Border are prepared to forgo all the principles that Irish people have stood for for so long. We should never allow ourselves to forget that when it suits the British Government they will reject the Irish petitions as they have done so many times in the past.
Only recently we had Mr. Quentin Hogg visiting the north-eastern part of Ireland. We heard him tell a Conservative Party conference of the tears he shed at the discrimination he witnessed. Perhaps he should have told us where those tears have been for the last 50 years. When Mr. Hogg expressed his dislike and his hatred for the Irish National Anthem he should remember that good Irishmen died so that we could play that Anthem and if necessary good Irishmen will die again if he or his ilk should attempt to take it from us.
Another popular theory at the moment is that the future of the Six Counties should be determined by the people of the Six Counties themselves. For reasons that suited themselves this particular section of Ulster was chosen to include the Six Counties and it would be a very simple matter for the British to ask those children to determine their future but I feel that as a Donegal man and an Irishman——
Comment on this
——I have as much right to express my views in a plebiscite as anyone in Derry, Tyrone or Fermanagh. I have as much right to express in a plebiscite whether or not I want my car examined by British customs on the way to Dublin, whether my car should be stopped by British Tommies on the way back and this right not only applies to the people of my county but to the people of any county in this country. No matter what views we may hold, no Irishman at any stage should forgo the principles that our people have died for throughout the centuries of long struggle aginst the British Government.
While our people naturally have different views on the subject as to whether the partition of Ireland can be solved by peaceful means or otherwise, I can only say that when I drive across the Border tonight and when the British Tommies surround my car, when their guns are stuck into my car, then I hope and pray that some day the Irish people will drive the British from this country, whether by foul means or fair, by hook or by crook——
Comment on this
I have a perfect right to have my views on the Six Counties. I am not surprised that I am interrupted by members of the Fine Gael Party because my county is cut off from the rest of Ireland because the members of the Fine Gael——
Comment on this
Because Fine Gael repudiates the use of force to solve this problem more unequivocally apparently that your party do.
Comment on this
The Chair will not allow interruptions on the Bill.
Comment on this
We should strengthen ourselves and take all steps to ensure that any threats from across the Border would be counteracted. Only yesterday we read of the boast of the UVF that they would even the score so far as we were concerned. This is a serious threat particularly to border counties. In order to protect ourselves I think our Army must be greatly strengthened.
Comment on this
Hugh O'Neill had more soldiers under his command in County Tyrone in 1601 than the Irish Army has today.
Comment on this
Perhaps Senators FitzGerald and Sheehy Skeffington would have been satisfied had the UVF succeeded in blowing up the power station at Ballyshannon.
Comment on this
Judging by their interruptions one would assume they do not want installations of this kind protected.
Comment on this
We must remember that were it not for the fact that that transformer station was slightly different to others in the North and South of the country — there was one extra cable that the gentleman who carried out the operation did not know about — he would have succeeded in his work.
Comment on this
That would have been by foul means and that is what the Senator is advocating.
Comment on this
As far as I am concerned about the British so long as we get them out of Ireland I would not be concerned by what means.
Comment on this
What about the Free Trade Agreement?
Comment on this
Had that third cable not existed the town of Ballyshannon would have been blown to smithereens. Because of this and many other threats it is imperative that the people along the border counties are protected with a military force. Had this outrage succeeded at Ballyshannon, then possibly the views of Senator FitzGerald and Senator Sheehy Skeffington might be different today. We all have our own view on the subject but of all the counties in Ireland that have suffered as a result of the partition of this country I think my county has suffered most.
Comment on this
They seem to be putting up with it all right. On the Ballyshannon case I would ask the Minister for Finance to consider that the ESB have lodged a malicious damage claim on Donegal County Council. I think it is wrong that under the present legal process Donegal County Council is the only body on whom this claim can be served and, while the amount is small, it is the principle that is involved and damage of this kind should be made a national charge. If the situation is going to obtain that the UVF cross into Donegal now and then and create damage that must be paid for by the people of Donegal alone that would be a most unfortunate state of affairs. Therefore, I would ask the Minister to look into the matter and see if anything could be done to make it a national charge.
Comment on this
May I remind the Senator that this would involve legislation and therefore is not appropriate under this Bill.
Comment on this
I have made my point. We all have our views on the partition of Ireland. I have mine and I make no secret of the fact that I believe the partition of Ireland is more permanent today than it ever has been and while I do not advocate that we cross the Border tomorrow morning my only reason is that I do not believe we are in a position to win. If I felt for one moment we could win then I would certainly be in favour of trying.
Comment on this
As a new Member of this House — indeed I have been here for such a short period that the Minister did not know my name — I speak with some apprehension. However in view of the contribution of the last speaker and the latitude shown to him by the Chair, I feel some remark would be appropriate on the matter. It seems to me that the remarks from people like Senator McGlinchey, made in the way they have been, can only exacerbate a situation already troubled and inflamed. All of us in this part of the country deplore the recent incidents in Northern Ireland. All of us here are people in public life, some of us for a longer period than others, but it would seem that length of time does not always guarantee political wisdom.
People in public life are often inclined to make statements about affairs of national interest at the first available opportunity but it seems to many of us that the best contribution which can be made, certainly by Members of either House of the Oireachtas, is the contribution of silence. To speak out in terms such as those used by Senator McGlinchey can only add fuel to the fire and provide ammunition for those who are enemies of the State. I hesitate to say this, but it must be said, that it is just as likely were it not for the accident of birth and religion that Senator McGlinchey might have been a member of one of the organisations which supports the British Crown so actively and certainly the remarks he made, had they been looked at in that light, would not have been inappropriate to a member of the UVF. I hope further speakers on all sides of the House will endeavour to help the situation with silence.
Turning my remarks to the Appropriation Bill, in company with several of the younger members of the House I am concerned about the actual spending of money and the whole aspect of Irish living which necessarily is influenced by the manner in which this money is to be spent. There has been much good talk of development progress but sometimes it seems to me that we can become carried away by viewing the material prosperity of other countries while forgetting our national heritage and our national culture. A Minister who has, in many respects, as the Minister here has, shown himself to be a liberal thinker might devote his mind to ensuring that the national culture and heritage of this country are involved in the development of the resources of the country, people and material, so that instead of just becoming the poor carbon copy of society abroad we develop ourselves as an ethnic unit.
I recently read a booklet which gave some of the thoughts of one of the people who helped to found this State and who had the reputation of being more of a miltary man than a politician or administrator, but he put forward some rather interesting views in this regard.
Comment on this
Not wishing to interrupt the Senator, I should like to know if Senators wish to adjourn for tea or to continue until the debate is concluded?
Comment on this
I will endeavour to be brief. The Minister has been patient with the House. Michael Collins, writing in 1922 about the development of our resources said:
In the ancient days of Gaelic civilisation the people were prosperous and they were not materialists. They were one of the most spiritual and one of the most intellectual peoples in Europe. When Ireland was swept by destitution and famine the spirit of the Irish people came most clearly to extinction.
He went on to deal with this culture which we have and continues:
What we must aim at is the building up of a sound economic life in which great discrepancies cannot occur. We must not have the destitution of poverty at one end, and at the other an excess of riches in the possession of a few individuals, beyond what they can spend with satisfaction and justification.
I wonder if we might just devote our thoughts for a few moments to that paragraph alone which was written more than 50 years ago and if we could say that this is a country where these discrepancies do not occur? To quote again from this booklet entitled The Path to Freedom:
The growing wealth of Ireland will, we hope, be diffused to all our people, all sharing in the growing prosperity, each receiving according to what each contributes in the making of that prosperity, so that the wealth of all is assured.... The keynote to the economic revival must be development of Irish resources by Irish capital for the benefit of the Irish consumer in such a way that the people have steady work at just remuneration and their own share of control.
These are the kind of thoughts to which a Minister of any Government in suggesting how moneys should be spent should direct his attention.
Comment on this
I would not be prepared to accept that each receives according to what each contributes.
Comment on this
It would appear from that that the people who can contribute nothing will get nothing.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I worry the Minister about the suggestion that one should get in relation to what one contributes.
Comment on this
I am quoting from a book written by Michael Collins. I turn now to the operation of some of the Departments. Some of the things that I have to say are laudatory and others might not be accepted quite so well by Members on the other side of the House but I might begin by praising the Minister for Finance on his decision to make the ex gratia payment to widows of civil servants who died prior to the date of the implementation of the present scheme. I had a particular interest in this and I know just how much pressure was brought to bear on the Minister and I know, of course, how much work he himself initiated in order to make this payment possible. It is something for which we must sincerely thank the Minister.
However, on the other side I might point to the interesting example which exists still in our democracy, and that is that a group of widows who, one will agree, are one of the weakest sections of the community, used effective methods to bring light to bear on their problem. The result is 50 per cent satisfactory.
While speaking on this problem, perhaps I should suggest that all our Departments should at all times go out of their way to assist widows. I must admit to having a personal interest in this regard which, I think, is also shared by the Minister. When a woman's husband dies and she is left with a young family she almost invariably becomes endowed with some extra qualities which strengthen her and give her energy and vitality to provide all she possibly can to raise her children. I was very shocked to discover only yesterday that Dublin Corporation, when letting off some temporary staff, turn first to the widows and dismiss them some few weeks before Christmas. I am sure that opportunities are available in many Departments for temporary work at various times of the year and when such work is available preference should be given to widows at all times. I do not suppose that any Member of the House would quibble with this suggestion.
The Minister has also endeared himself to many people by the tax relief he is giving to the Arts. This is the sort of enlightened attitude which helps to bring this country into greater repute throughout the world and is certainly an incentive to helping the development of and expansion of our national culture and heritage, which I referred to some moments ago. Those remarks might now be a little clearer to the Minister. I believe there is an urgent need to review the income tax code and the scale of allowances.
Comment on this
If I may interrupt the Senator, a passing reference to legislation is in order, but not any sort of detailed discussion, on this Bill. It would be more appropriate on the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
I appreciate the ruling of the Chair and I will leave it at that. Again, on a topic which concerns the Department of Finance mainly, in the Third Programme, about which we had such a lengthy contribution from Senator Keery on Tuesday, there is a suggestion that the level of public investment will jump very sharply in the first year and tend to level out in the remaining years. One wonders how realistic this suggestion is. Since 1957 our national debt has almost trebled, from £328 million in that year to £937 million in the present year. Government borrowing has amounted to £550 million and turnover tax and wholesale tax yielded over £80 million. Even the prize bonds scheme, which was criticised so strongly when it was originally introduced, has roped in some £30 million to the Exchequer.
One wonders sometimes where exactly all this money is employed? What return have we to show for it? One thinks of the situation in regard to housing and the difficulties which seem to abound in the matter of financing housing to a sufficient degree to meet the needs of our people both in the public and private sectors of housing. The fact is there are some 100,000 fewer people in employment than there were in 1956. In that same period more than 400,000 people have emigrated and the burden of taxation is becoming more pressing on a smaller number. The load should be spread more evenly.
I want to quote from a contribution made by a former member of the Fianna Fáil Party, reported in the Dáil Debates for 20th March, 1956. Mr. MacEntee, speaking to a motion by the Minister for Finance, was referring to farmers and he said:
What does the Minister propose to do for them? Rates are rising, costs are rising and taxes are certainly not coming down. How does the Minister intend to put the farmers of Ireland in a position to export more in the face of increasing competition? What about the country shopkeepers? Their shops have been empty and trade has been stagnant over the past month.
Further on he said:
Every day the real value of the incomes of these unprotected classes is declining. Every day they find it harder and harder to keep body and soul together. Every day they have less and less to spend. What does the Minister propose to do about their problem?
Later on he said:
A halt will have to be called. If it is not, we will head for a crisis which will require, indeed, extraordinary efforts and sacrifices to overcome. Somehow responsibility will have to begin to reign in the councils of the Government of this country. We cannot go on spending and spending until, as I have said, the primary producers of this country, the people who are bearing the whole burden, are crushed closer and closer to the earth.
I do not think it would be inappropriate if the present Minister for Finance were asked those same questions today. I am sure if Mr. MacEntee were still a Member of the other House, or a Member of this House, he would have at some stage during the past few months directed those questions to the Minister for Finance.
I agree with Senator Horgan and Senator Miss Bourke regarding what they said about the whole purpose and function of the Seanad. It is time for the Members of the Seanad and the members of the Government to decide what is the purpose of this body? What is its function? If, having decided that it fulfilled some useful function or that it could more usefully be employed some other way, then by all means let us go ahead and devote ourselves in a workmanlike way to carrying out this task. If, on the other hand, it is felt that this House of the Oireachtas is surplus to requirement, and mind you I do not know if I would particularly agree with that suggestion, let us face up to the fact and say that we do not need the Seanad.
It is perhaps, especially for new Members, a little frustrating to come in here in the first few months and to find that I am speaking now on the fifth day which the Seanad met since the election took place in August. One wonders when one finds the method in which the Seanad meets, perhaps next week or perhaps not for a fortnight, if there is any need at all to have this legislative Assembly. If we have not got great pressure of business this is something we might have a discussion about in this House at some stage during the present session.
I welcome, in company with other Members who have spoken, the decision of the Government to set up a commission on the status of women in our society. I am sure this commission will be welcomed by everybody in the community, especially by women, but also by the male sex. Senator Keery referred to the small print in the Third Programme. My only remark on this, having read the document some time ago and just this morning having re-read the review of it, is that it suggests that if they are phrases designed by the same people who designed the Second Programme perhaps they will have within a few years a very hollow ring.
Senator Keery referred at length to the various reports and investigations which have been carried out at the instigation of the Government. I agree it is a very good thing that we should have so many learned groups sitting on so many topics, but there is a danger that the solution to all the ills in our society will be seen as the setting up of a commission or the commissioning of a report. We must remember when those reports arrive on the tables of those who are charged with implementing the policies of the Government they must decide what decision is to be made and when.
A White Paper languishing for years in some Government Department will merely become a dirty yellow paper and it will not solve the problem. We are all quite prepared when there is some problem which the Government sets about investigating to await the arrival of the report or the findings of the commission in question; but all of us expect, and reasonably expect, that there should be some action taken when this commission or inquiry board provides its report. I do not think that this has always happened in the past, and I believe that very many groups such as those which have been set up in the past few years and which were detailed very extensively by Senator Keery have cost the taxpayer a very considerable amount of money. I wonder whether we have gained all we usefully could have from the information and suggestions put forward to us in these various publications.
I want to refer to an organisation or a body known as MOVE which Senator Keery spoke about at some length some days ago. I am not sure which is the Department responsible for having initiated the idea of MOVE but I wonder whether they or Members of this House have seen the article in the Irish Times dated the 7th January, 1969, by Hugh Monroe which is most critical of this organisation and is headed “MOVE shows lofty arrogance over £90,000 PR campaign”— PR meaning public relations. He speaks of it as giving an example of muddled economic thinking, and goes on at great length to dissect the report put forward by this body as to why it was set up and what its aims were. I do not propose to quote extensively from it but just to say that the gentleman in question is a well-known writer in the Irish Times and in other journals, and he concludes by saying:
MOVE should not be quietly discredited: it should be publicly disowned. The politicians and the people have a joint interest in firmly stating that where questions of choice in public policy arise, these questions are solved through the politicians, for the politicians are the only group who are chosen by the people and who have to take the responsibility for public choices. A situation where the State allots £90,000 to a body carrying no sort of responsibility and which then takes it on itself to "direct our national aspirations", is one which cannot be allowed to continue.
There were very many more remarks such as this in the course of this article, and I think that the Minister might well make some answer in this House to the sort of accusation which was made in this article against this body. If they are true, or even true in part, they are very serious, and certainly charge that there has been a waste of public funds on a large scale. One finds this somewhat hard to accept, and I hope that the Minister may be able to enlighten us to some degree in this matter.
Mr. Monroe says in one part:
MOVE talks for instance of the need for "radical and basic changes" without once saying what these changes should be. There is an empty, casual irresponsibility about this kind of thing; just what is the point of saying that groups must reform in some way you cannot specify, unless it is to demoralise those groups?
I just pick two paragraphs at random to quote to the House, but there are perhaps 30 or 40 paragraphs along these lines suggesting that an organisation set up by the Government to encourage national aspirations, as they themselves apparently say they were, was no more than a waste of public funds, and it would be very appropriate if the Minister could make some comment on the matter when he replies.
There are a group of public servants in this country who play a very important part quietly in our everyday life. I refer to the gardaí. I believe that we have here a group of highly disciplined and well conducted men who have served this State well since its inception. It does not seem as if their remuneration or their conditions of work can be justified in the Ireland of 1969. Certainly the comparison which the Garda Representative Body has made between the salary of the ordinary garda and other people engaged in the public sector or in fields of security shows the ordinary guard to be very poorly underpaid and to be expected to work for very long hours without any overtime or extra facilities. They quote for instance that:
A recent award gave to Dublin firemen a pay scale starting at a higher point (£16 1s 6d) than the guard's entry point, higher indeed than a guard's pay on completion of his initial period of training. Moreover the fireman's pay scale has a similar maximum to that of a guard's (£22 2s 3d) but in the case of the fireman this maximum is reached after six years, while in the case of the guards it is not attained until after about 10½ years.
We will see that the ordinary pay of a garda at his maximum is £22. For this he can be expected to work many long hours at a time. I think that there are gardaí both in the metropolitan area and outside it who have in certain circumstances and on occasions had to serve for over 24 hours at a time, and this without receiving any overtime and very often without receiving any time off in lieu of this very long continuous period of service. I realise that there is one of the commissions which I referred to some minutes ago investigating the whole problem of the salary and conditions of the gardaí. I would hope that this commission will report in the very near future and that we will have prompt action on those findings to bring the standards and conditions of the gardaí up to an acceptable level.
There have in relation to the Department of Justice been in the recent past rumblings as to the manner in which cases have been presented by the State, and in various courts in the country. I think again that this is a matter which requires clarification from the Government. It is a matter of grave public concern if people feel that cases are not being pressed or presented in a proper way. I think it requires a definite statement from the Government in this regard. There have in the recent past, as many members know, been some very serious allegations made concerning the Minister for Justice.
The Minister present here today made it very clear that he resented these allegations being made in this House last night when the Minister for Justice was not present. As I am a newcomer here I am not sure whether the discussion of the spending of money and activity of a Government Department extends to discussing the activities of its Minister. It would seem to me that it does. If so, the Senator in question was quite entitled to pass comment and give his opinion on how the Minister is conducting himself in high office. If it is not, as the Minister said the tradition of this House to criticise a person while he is not here then the remarks of the Leader of the House concerning Fr. Fergal O'Connor are very out of place and inappropriate because the reverend gentleman, any more than Mr. Ó Moráin, is not here to defend himself.
Comment on this
The Chair will rule on matters of order as they arise.
Comment on this
I appreciate the feelings of the Chair in this regard. May I say that if there is any basis in fact for the allegations made that a Member of the Government is continuing to act in his private capacity while retaining a position in the Government in view of the Taoiseach's statement to the contrary three weeks ago it would seem to me to require definite and immediate action on the part of the Taoiseach. The Dáil and the country were assured by the Taoiseach that no Member of his Government held any other position.
Comment on this
The Senator will appreciate that the Minister in question has denied the charge and it is usual in this House when a charge has been made and denied for the matter to be dropped.
Comment on this
I appreciate the ruling of the Chair although charges which were denied initially subsequently led to the setting up of a judicial inquiry.
I should like to refer to the conditions obtaining in reformatories, in the training of prisoners to take up an active occupation when they secure release from their term of imprisonment. There is much we could do to improve the situation and I would ask that it should be looked into by the Minister for Justice.
May I turn to the Department of Defence? It seems to me that there are certain basic questions which we must ask ourselves about our Army. I do not think they are unfair questions; they are questions which have been put to me by many high-ranking officers in recent weeks. The Government and the country must decide what do we want an Army for, what is the purpose of the Army, what is its function? If they decide that it is necessary to have an Army in its present form they must then decide how large an Army we need, how many battalions, how many men, the ratio between officers and non-commissioned men. They must decide that on the basis of what we need that Army for. The feeling seems to exist in the ranks of the Army at present that they are going from day to day without realising what they are there for and without any clear sense of purpose or direction.
Comment on this
The Minister has some experience of service in a branch of the Army. I have not had that experience so he is probably more expert on this matter.
Comment on this
No doubt Caesar's legions often asked: "What the hell are we doing or where are we going?"
Comment on this
The question has has been asked why we have decided to recruit a certain number of extra men, 800 I think, for active service. The suggestion has been made that the basis for deciding on 800 was the basis of cost and cost alone. The suggestion has been made that we could have a more useful and more productive operation by having some form of a security force based on highly-trained, highly-paid men, a relatively small number who could, in the event of a national emergency, become the high-ranking officers of a larger group which would constitute the reserve in normal times. There is great resentment in certain sections of our Army at present in regard to the method in which they go on from one day to the next and not really knowing what they are there for. Indeed there is resentment, and I am sure the Minister will tell me that this has always existed, about the very large number of civil servants it takes to administer the relatively small number of men on active service.
Nobody would question, however, that whatever resentment there is in the Army it could not possibly equal the resentment or frustration felt by those on active service in our Naval Service and we are being charitable when we refer to it as a Naval Service. That political football, Radio Telefís Éireann, carried a programme within the last fortnight on our Naval Service. According to RTE — I do not know whether these facts will be questioned but I will be surprised if they are not, considering the body they emanated from — there is one of our three corvettes on active service and conditions for seamen serving on this corvette are dreadfully bad whenever the sea gets any worse than a plateglass surface. They also suggest that in the last 18 months, three times the original purchase price of that corvette has been spent in providing replacements for it. The Minister — come to think of it, he is a man with experience in many fields — has experience in the field of accountancy also.
Comment on this
I thought the Senator was going to say in sailing. I sailed in a force 10 gale. That is more than Dick Belton ever did.
Comment on this
The Minister has had some rough passages. The Minister's experience in the field of accountancy would tell him that when any piece of machinery reaches the stage where one spends within a year the equivalent of its purchase price it is obsolescent but when the figure is three times the purchase price in the period of 18 months the person controlling the procedure is himself obsolescent or using obsolescent procedures. The need to provide adequate fishery protection for our fishermen which I think would be the prime purpose of our naval service is very great.
I do not think that we can in all conscience and sincerity suggest that we should in the foreseeable future provide a navy or a naval service which would protect the entire coast of this country in the event of an armed attack by a large invading force. It would seem that the duties of the naval service would, in the first instance, extend mainly to the protection of our fishing grounds and to carrying out a survey of the waters off the coast of this country. If one is to believe RTE, — I believe that approximately 50 per cent of the people here believe nothing which emanates from that body, but I shall speak momentarily to the other 50 per cent — one corvette cannot protect even one small sector of coast, never mind the entire coast. I shall leave that matter in the capable hands of the expert sailor from Howth.
Turning to the Department of Education, I suggest one of the founders of our State who wrote in strong terms about the murder machine might have looked with raised eyebrows at the recent incidents in Montpelier and O'Brien's Bridge; he might have looked with raised eyebrows at the strike of the secondary teachers last year; at the amount of control given to civil servants in the compiling of policy in regard to educational matters. Senator Keery suggested that having gone so far in the educational field, the Minister for Education should stop and have a look at the situation and think about consolidation——
Comment on this
I do not think I am being unfair in saying that this is a stock-in-trade remark which comes from the Government Party when they indicate that all the political milk has been taken from one particular aspect of our services and that we are now going to leave it and move on to some other more lucrative field.
Comment on this
Or a few votes to be obtained. I hope this is not the case because it is evident, especially to those who have a particular interest in the field of education, that there are many ways in which we could improve our services, improve the minds and consequently the future of our children.
Comment on this
It seems to me that we talk about economic crisis very often or perhaps the need to invest money, to attract foreign capital, but I have for some time felt that the greatest investment which can be made in any country is education. If I might make so bold as to suggest no money no matter how great spent on education could be described as a non-productive investment. I sincerely hope that the lecturers in economics who lectured to Senator Brosnahan in that fashion in UCD some years ago had long departed that august establishment before I arrived on the scene because I should be very upset to think my mind might be influenced in this matter. Investment in education is long-term but productive and anyone who says otherwise——
Comment on this
I understood the Leader of the House was suggesting that Fr. Fergal O'Connor was preaching Fianna Fáil were not a productive unit.
Comment on this
You misunderstood me, I was suggesting he was destroying the minds of generations of students.
Comment on this
References to people outside the House are to be deprecated.
Comment on this
The Senator should not allow himself to be drawn in.
Comment on this
I am very grateful to the Chair for having clarified that query. It would seem in the matter of External Affairs, as I said at the outset, comments on the troubled situation in one part of our country are not helpful in any way. I shall say no more on that topic except to remind Senator McGlinchey that people of one particular religion have not got a monopoly of Irish nationalism or patriotism. In his long speech in which he gave his views of the history of the country from the point of view of the Fianna Fáil Party, he omitted to refer to the Young Ireland Movement which more or less originated in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
If Mr. McGlinchey had skipped all the centuries I should have been finished by now. I shall refer to the report of the RTE Authority for the year 31st March, 1969. The members of the Authority, for the information of the House, were C. S. Andrews, Chairman; Ruairí Brugha, whom we have here now; James I. Fanning; Fintan Kennedy, who is also a Member of this House; T. W. Moody; Michael Noonan; Michael O'Callaghan; Phillis, Bean Uí Cheallaigh; and Dónal Ó Moráin; Director General was Thomas P. Hardiman. This was hardly a group of people who could be said to be politically opposed to the Government, as far as the majority were concerned.
In the review of the year they said:
Current Affairs programmes have been steadily developed and the distinction between news, news-analysis and news-comment programmes has been publicly identified in broadcasting practice.
A broadcasting service that seeks to be comprehensive must give considerable weight and effort to programmes in the field of information and public affairs, and such programmes are now part of the public expectation from broadcasting in this country. It is the Authority's policy that its public affairs programmes should be informed by a sense of the importance of broadcasting among the communications media, and guided throughout by an understanding of the responsibility for impartiality required of RTE by the Broadcasting Authority Act, 1960.
This is an interesting comment from a Board which I think it is fair to say is composed in the main of supporters of the Government. The comments would be welcome from all responsible sections of the community. They stated the division of RTE which dealt with news and public affairs was being extended and reporting in depth was being initiated and that they would go out of their way to ensure that impartial fair programmes were presented. However, there was a reminder in an oblique way that the Broadcasting Act, 1960, is there and if the Government had any grievance about the operations of RTE in any shape or form there are clear-cut procedures laid down whereby the Government could communicate its displeasure to the RTE Authority. I would hope that this would be remembered at all times when the Government have displeasure towards Radio Telefís Éireann.
I wish to refer briefly to the problem of water pollution which has been causing such great concern of late and I would point out that in the OECD Observer for October, 1969, there is an article which deals with the need to ensure water conservation. The article says that the problems of water research have been under study since 1961; water, both as to quantity and quality, has become a potential inhibitor of economic growth.
I realise that there are difficulties in dealing with this problem but when a body such as OECD suggest that the quantity and quality of water could become an inhibiting factor to economic growth and advancement the Minister for Finance might have a look at the problem. The article goes on at length to show the way in which lack of water or water pollution held up development in certain areas in many continental countries. I am sure the Minister would not like to see this happen here and that he will devote some of his time and talents to ensuring that some solution can be devised to this problem.
Comment on this
The Minister will not rush me. With regard to the Department of Local Government, Senator Garrett explained to us at some length that there was no lack of money for housing and rather than interrupt the Senator I decided to wait until I was speaking myself to ask if there is no lack of money why applicants for SDA loans to Dublin Corporation and Dublin County Council have been told that these cannot be sanctioned. Why did the City Manager for Dublin, who was the County Manager for Dublin announce some time ago that the worst that these people can be told is that they may have to wait 18 months for their application to be sanctioned?
These remarks hardly fit in with the suggestion of Senator Garrett that there is no shortage of money for housing. I suggest to him and to the House that the number of houses provided in the State in any year in the public sector is controlled completely from Central Government. The blame is often laid on the doorstep of the local authority concerned, but it is well to remember that before that local authority can proceed it must first notify the Department of Local Government as to the number of houses which it is envisaged to build in any one year. Having done that, and received sanction they must forward plans to be approved by the Department and then they must advertise for a tender. Having decided on a tenderer they must send that to the Department again for their approval. All these things take a considerable length of time and very often documents of tender may lie in the Department for six months or even longer. Therefore, the Department of Local Government have effective control as to the number of houses built by local authorities in any year. This situation should be explained to the general public by the relevant Minister when he speaks on the topic.
Only yesterday the Minister for Finance answered a question as to the value of the pound sterling in various years. He told us that the pound today is worth 9s 2d in 1948 terms.
With regard to the State grant to purchasers of new houses of less than 1,500 square feet, I must point out that an enlightened Government raised the figure to £275 in 1948 and that it still remains at £275 in 1969: £275 in 1969 is worth less than half of what it was worth in 1948.
Comment on this
The Senator will appreciate that legislation would be required to change that.
Comment on this
The figures have changed. There has been a complete revamping of the figures for house grants.
Comment on this
There are many people in County Dublin who in recent months received only £275. Is the Minister suggesting that I should advise them that the figure has been increased?
Comment on this
The Senator will appreciate that house administration is not the administration of Local Government. The house grant figures are laid down by legislation and are not a matter of administration.
Comment on this
It depends on the floor area of the house, but the grants have changed considerably.
Comment on this
Yes, in an effort to concentrate house building on the cheaper-type, smaller houses.
Comment on this
On Monday afternoon the officials administering the scheme in Dublin Corporation understood that grants of £275 applied to houses of less than 1,500 square feet. I am delighted to hear that since Monday afternoon the Minister for Local Government, presumably in conjunction with the Minister for Finance, has decided to increase these grants and I am sure the people will welcome this.
There are 200 families squatting in houses belonging to Dublin Corporation. According to information compiled in relation to the 1966 census, 44 per cent of the corporation tenants in Dublin were sub-letting their houses. It is obvious to all Members here that they are not subletting by choice but that in fact almost all of them are subletting to sons or daughters who have got married, and for whom houses are not available. In 1967 4.1 per cent of the gross national product of this country was spent on housing. This places us third bottom of the list of European countries in this regard. We only managed to excel Norway and Britain in this matter. I am sure it pleases Senator Keery that we excelled Britain.
I was surprised at Senator Garrett telling us that the new Department to handle planning was to be set up soon because this seems to be directly in conflict with the statement of the Taoiseach within the last two days that he has for the moment shelved the idea of setting up a Department for Housing and Physical Planning pending examination of the Devlin Report. Again we are getting such instant Government now in the matter of housing grants, setting up Departments and taking away Departments that it is rather difficult to keep right up to date.
Comment on this
It is the progress of doing nothing. I would ask the Minister to seriously devote himself to the matter, unless this has been changed also, of the income ceiling for applicants for house purchase loans, which stands at £1,200. This was the ceiling which was set some years ago and as many Members of the House will know a person going to a building society or an insurance company has not got very much chance of securing a loan to purchase a house unless he has an income of at least £1,500.
There are many young people who want to get married and who fall into the income category somewhere between £1,200 and £1,500 but they are ineligible for county council loans and corporation loans. They have not got sufficient income to secure a loan from a building society. This is a problem which is growing every month and one which should receive the urgent attention of the Government. Surely the maximum for SDA loans should be at least the equivalent of the minimum income for loans from building societies. I suppose it is too much, although I do not think it would require bringing in new legislation, to suggest to the Minister that he might use his good offices with his colleague the Minister for Local Government to reestablish and reconstitute the Corporation of Dublin.
In relation to the Department of Local Government, the activities of local authorities and the whole matter generally of local administration it seems we now have a system still operating in 1969 which has far outlived its usefulness. It is a system which was devised some hundreds of years ago which seems to many members of local authorities to be creaking at every joint. It seems there is an urgent need for an overhaul of the system of local administration throughout the country, if we are to bring it into line with modern business standards and with modern systems of communications and development.
I should like to comment on the activities of the Departments of Health and Social Welfare because I feel the Department of Social Welfare is one Department which could be said to be surplus to requirements. It seems to act now as no more than a paying agency and to look at a Department which by its title implies it is dealing with the welfare of our people and to realise it has not got even one trained social worker on its staff leaves grave doubts as to the worth or merit of the particular Department. It would seem as if the functions of that Department could well be taken over in the main by the Department of Health and in some aspects by the Department of Labour. It would in addition have the great benefit that it would remove some of the burden from the gentleman who at present holds ministerial office for that Department and allow him to devote some more of his time to the job as acting as a responsible Minister for Local Government. However, in view of the lateness of the hour, the long time this discussion has gone on and the fact that I know Senator Walsh is most anxious to speak, I will not go into this matter in any greater detail.
Comment on this
I appreciate the fact that we now have spent more than three days discussing this Bill and I do not intend to detain the House very long. However, I should like to make some contribution to the Bill but before I do so I should like to make some brief reference to Senator Boland's remarks. As a newcomer to the House I do not believe in engaging in any form of heckling and cross talk but I should like to remind the Senator, and I think Senator Belton would wish to be fair on this and would agree with me, because we want to be fair on this matter, with regard to what the Senator said about there being no loans available from Dublin County Council. I agree with the first part of the Senator's statement. Unfortunately Senator Boland did not state everything he should have and did not say everything he was told by the city and county manager, Mr. Macken, when he had a special meeting of Dublin County Council to deal with this matter.
Senator J. Boland is a very good man for figures, I grant him that, and it is quite possible he may have them in his possession. On that occasion we had a very long, and sometimes very heated, discussion with regard to the availability of loans for people anxious to purchase houses. He was informed on that occasion that there was far more money allotted to Dublin County Council this year than ever before. During the month of July it became apparent to the City and County Manager, Mr. Macken, that the number of applicants had increased considerably this year. We then approached the Minister for Local Government and an extra allocation was made available to him to meet the thousands of people looking for loans. I may be wrong but I think I am correct in saying that roughly an additional £250,000 was made available to Mr. Macken. I am not denying that the city and county manager said he could not guarantee the sanctioning of loans from 1st September. I would not like to have included every statement that was given at that meeting by the city and county manager.
Comment on this
Just a second. I did not interrupt the Senator. I am a newcomer to the House and during the past three days I have listened to some very worthwhile contributions by speakers from both sides of the House. Many tributes were paid to the Minister for Finance in his capacity as Minister and many tributes were paid to him for his interest in education and the amount of money he has channelled in that direction. I should like to add my voice to one of those tributes also. There is no doubt we have heard different views as to the manner in which the Department of Education should be worked and so on but there is one thing I am very pleased about and that is that education is made available to all our children, no matter who they may be.
I have no doubt that in years to come, when the present day school-going children have finished school and set out into the world with the education they will have received they will be fully and properly equipped to meet whatever challenge lies ahead of them. Should they decide to move to other countries I have no doubt that they will be properly equipped to counteract the charges which we have heard so much about, which were made known in a special film of which we have heard so much today, and to which we have heard that some people in the House have made some contribution.
I was very pleased when Senator Ó Maoláin spoke at great length on this matter. No matter what side of the House, no matter what political beliefs we may hold, at least we should have the honour and the decency to come and speak and when something worthwhile is being done at least we should express our appreciation for that. I am a member of the Fianna Fáil Party. From time to time we had a Coalition Government. I know that the amount of legislation they introduced was very small, but once or twice I remember they did introduce some legislation which I have some admiration for and I never failed to give them credit for that.
Comment on this
Do not worry about that at all. We are well able for it.
There was one thing I admired the Minister for, and that was for having made an allocation of money for the development of recreational facilities for the young. We hear quite a lot about the slogan "The youth of today are the men of tomorrow." I appreciate very much the Minister's interest in that field. Apart from the fact that he has made this allocation of money for this development he has encouraged the people associated with this, for this is a recognition of their work. I hope that some of the money that has been allocated will be devoted to work for boys' clubs. The firm with which I am connected has employees some of whom are involved in this work, and it is only when one has discussions about their activities in this field that one realises the part that they are playing for the welfare of youth. I appreciate very much the Minister's attitude and thinking on these lines.
Three or four weeks ago on the first occasion when the House met we passed the final stages of the Bill to increase the borrowing power of the National Building Agency. This is something which I appreciate very much also. The National Building Agency is playing a very important part in the building industry today. As I said on that occasion, as a member of a local authority I have always been very impressed by the manner in which the National Building Agency operates, the speed with which it can get work started. This is something which is of great importance and something which we in the local authority are very grateful for. I would like to compliment the National Building Agency on its work.
I do not know if this is the responsibility of the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Local Government, but I would ask the Minister responsible that some time he would have a look at the manner in which the building societies operate. There is no doubt that there is a great interest in this at the present moment. The loan conditions certainly make it impossible for any ordinary worker to meet the repayments to these societies, and it would be very much appreciated by all sides of the House and by everybody concerned if we could possibly hear something from the Minister in this field.
I am not going to delay very long, but I was listening to some of the speeches today and Senator McDonald spoke at great length of the Department of Agriculture. He made some references to why and where the Fine Gael policy differed from Fianna Fáil policy in agriculture. As I have said I am not going to engage in cross talk but I would like to ask him which Fine Gael policy on agriculture, because I am sure it is clear to everybody that over the past ten years we have had a number of by-elections and a general election and on every occasion the Fine Gael Party came out with some different policy on agriculture. When the by-election was lost by them and another one came along we still heard something new on agriculture, and I intended to ask Senator McDonald which agricultural policy he had in mind — was it the one introduced in 1963, or the one in 1964, or so on?
We have heard a lot also about Telefís Éireann, and I am not going to make much reference to that, but I would like to refer to a speaker yesterday, Senator Quinlan. When he was speaking about this he mentioned the fact that he hoped that the Government would not give way to the request of Telefís Éireann to increase the licence fee. Listening to the radio last night and this morning he was quoted in a very different way. Possibly this could be a mistake, but it is quite possible that his speech could have been distorted more or less to suit themselves. He was quoted as expressing the hope that the Government would give way to this appeal. I would like to make matters very clear. I certainly hope that the Government and the Minister concerned will not give way to this request.
I do not intend to delay the House any longer. Thank you very much.
Comment on this
May I at the outset and on the occasion of my first appearance in the Seanad since you have been elected to the Chair offer you, Sir, my congratulations on your elevation to this office of great importance and responsibility. It is still for me personally a pleasure, and indeed very instructive, to go back over the records of this House and read the contributions which were made by your illustrious father. That you will now be carrying on a family tradition of service to the Seanad as its Cathaoirleach is something in which I think all of us take a great pride.
In mentioning your father may I hope that in regard to your occupancy of the Chair you shall have some peace there. I hope that there will not be many occasions for you to observe that midnight's all a glimmer whatever about noon occasionally being a purple glow. Finally may I express the hope that during your time here in the Seanad the Seanad will be a place where nobody gets old and bitter of tongue.
There was some talk here about productivity in the House. I feel that many of those who spoke about productivity proceeded with subsequent behaviour in a manner which could hardly have been described as productive. I, as a Minister coming here to the Seanad, would greatly welcome productive and constructive debate, because I think that the Seanad can make a very useful contribution to the issues of the day, and I feel that in the membership of the Seanad we have people who are capable of being of considerable assistance to the Government in grappling with the issues and problems which confront it.
I would not think, however, that on this particular occasion the Seanad has fully availed itself of the opportunity presented to it by the debate on the Appropriation Bill and I think that perhaps the speeches have covered far too wide a field. Certainly, for my part, I have been bemused by so many different subjects and topics that whatever few coherent thoughts I began with when I came in here have more or less evaporated by now. I regret that a number of Senators could not apparently resist the opportunity to engage in party politics and personal attack. I have become increasingly intrigued in recent years to observe how the academics who come among us here in the Seanad seem to concentrate mainly on this personality type of political debate. One would imagine that if we are to get impartial and objective discussion and examination of issues in a broad way that we would get it from the academics. Unfortunately, that is just not so. It would be interesting to probe the reason why this should be, it may be something inherent in their way of life. However, it is something which the rest of us continually observe with interest.
I want to assure the House that a great deal of the matters which have been raised here are being actively considered by the Government. In regard to some of them, decisions have already been taken although they may not have been announced so that if I do not deal with a particular topic or aspect I hope the Senator who raised it will accept that I am not ignoring it. There are other matters which are the particular responsibility of particular Ministers and because of their fundamental importance in the policy of the particular Minister it is not really proper that I should make more than a passing reference to them because I would only, at the best, be dealing at second hand with something that is of very considerable importance.
One of the points that was raised early in the debate was the question of giving more State aid for bodies which are assisting our emigrants in Britain. The Government, as the House knows, have provided a sum of £10,000 to the Department of Labour to assist the voluntary organisations which are working in this field. The Minister for Labour has set up a fairly widely representative committee to advise him on how this money and any further moneys which would be made available for his purpose should be disposed if. This committee will help the National Manpower Service here also in its work and I feel that there is a great deal that can be done immediately in getting our people back from Britain to this country. There are many areas of this country where there is a shortage of labour generally or a small shortage of a particular type of labour. I know that the Department of Labour propose to enter into this field of advising our people in Britain who have particular skills of opportunities which are available to them here and we hope that as time goes on there will be perhaps a continuing flow of migration back to this country.
Somebody mentioned legal aid. I should like to deal with this because I was the Minister for Justice who introduced legal aid. At present of course it is only available in criminal cases and I have no recent information as to how it is working out in that area as a scheme. The question of extending it to civil cases will be a major one. It would, I believe — apart from any question of principle as to whether it would be a good thing or not or whether it would encourage vexatious litigation — be quite costly and perhaps the Department of Justice have other priorities though I would feel that the ultimate objective must be an extension of free legal aid in a limited, sensible and rational way into the civil field.
A number of Senators spoke about the situation of widows and asked some particular questions about the present position. In so far as civil servants who became members of the new scheme for widows in the public service are concerned the grants are being made in the normal way as the claims arise. With regard to the ex gratia scheme which applies to the widows of civil servants whose husbands were never in a position to qualify for the new scheme the position is that we have decided to make these ex gratia payments available or to give effect to that as from 1st October, 1969. We are working diligently on getting these payments made and I am sure Senators will appreciate that this is a fairly difficult task. Many of these people died many, many years ago and it is difficult to trace them and to verify them. It may be some time before every case is cleared up but we are doing everything we can to get it into full operation as quickly as possible. Indeed if any Senator is aware of a particular case I would welcome information from him about it and help to get it cleared up.
Somebody asked about the extension of this scheme to the widows of teachers. This has, in fact, already been done. A separate scheme, but similar, has been arranged for national and secondary teachers. Vocational teachers are, of course, included in the general scheme for local authority officers which was authorised by the Minister for Local Government last month.
There has been a considerable amount of discussion here during the last few days on education. Education is such a specialised field that I am sure the Seanad would not expect me to do much more than co-relate all the various points of view that have been brought forward and transmit them to my colleague, the Minister for Education, for his consideration.
Perhaps I might mention one particular matter that has been raised, that is the merger. I could say a great deal on this subject but I want to point out that it is a pretty fundamental part of educational policy and therefore better dealt with on some suitable occasion by the Minister for Education himself. I do want to endorse very much what Senator Farrell said at an early stage. I thought it was a very commonsense comment though Senator Sheehy Skeffington sought to confuse the issue later. Senator Farrell said that what the ordinary person really wanted was to get value for money in our university education system. I submit that is the primary community requirement.
Every Senator in this House knows that the expanding demands which are being made on our resources throughout the whole spectrum of Government activity will take us all our time to meet. Having to set aside every year increasing resources in practically every direction that Senators consider desirable — health, education, hospitals, schools, industrial development, agriculture and so on — the total of our annual capital programme now is quite intimidating and it is making very considerable inroads on our resources to keep financing that capital programme. In that situation we cannot afford any wasteful allocation of our resources. We must make sure that we get the best possible value for the capital we are prepared to invest in our development. To my mind that is at the nub of the development of university education. We are not wealthy enough to afford the unnecessary duplication of facilities and that must be the paramount question we keep before our minds when looking at the problem of development of our universities and the question of the merger.
Quite frankly, I was a little disappointed to see the reaction of a very considerable number of people in our academic life to the question of the merger. There are many in this community who believe that the Irish universities have not made the contributions they should have to the building up of our nation, who believe that when we were endeavouring to pull ourselves up by our own bootstraps the universities did not play the part we might have expected of them.
The bringing forward of this great new concept will provide the Irish universities with an opportunity once and for all to dispel that feeling, if there is any validity in it. I would have expected them to approach the problem in a forward-looking way, with magnanimity and generosity, but I fear that the ordinary man-in-the-street thinks he has been let down by the academics in this matter. Instead of the sort of approach he was entitled to expect, there seemed to be a rush to man the particular academic barricades and in many directions there seemed to be a desire to defend a particular piece of academic real estate, status and prestige in different sections. I may be wrong about this but it is a view I hold, which I hope events may prove wrong. Perhaps I could not have got a better illustration of what I think about this than the fact that Senator Sheehy Skeffington in this House was prepared to offer us, as an example of something tremendous, the two particular faculties that had been swapping extern examiners for a number of years.
I listened to Senator Dunne with interest and respect. He mentioned his personal dilemma; I want to assure him, if it is any help to him, that in my eyes he will always be a sturdy and courageous trade union leader rather than a mere member of the Labour Party. Any time I sat around a table with him I never had any difficulty in finding a great deal of common ground but I would have hoped for perhaps a different emphasis in his approach on this occasion. It is not very realistic for us in this House to talk in terms of trade unions defending themselves and of attacks on the trade unions, I do not think that is a matter of realistic politics today. Most of us know that over large areas unions or individual groups decide the level of their own remuneration. I should have preferred, perhaps optimistically, if we spoke today about the lower-paid worker and the weaker sections of the community, as it is with this area we must concern ourselves more in the future. I want to make this point as firmly as I can — every time a strong, well-organised group of workers or trade unionists demands and gets an increase in income which is totally out of line with national production then it is the poorer section that slips down the line with less prospect of ever getting its rightful place in the sun.
I had really hoped that this year we would have been able to achieve something significant in this respect. We began the early part of the year with discussions which centred very much on the problem of the lower-paid workers and the weaker sections of the community. We spoke, in fact, of making 1969 the year of the lower-paid worker. In finalising the public service agreement and, indeed, the budget, the strategy of which was closely related to that public service pay agreement, we set a very useful headline. I am afraid that the effort has petered out and I would not be surprised if the statisticians were able to tell us at the end of 1969 that the lower-paid worker is relatively worse off than he was at the start. I am not sure of this but I am very much afraid this is the case. I would suggest to Senator Dunne and his colleagues in Congress, who I know are concerned about this problem, that there is, perhaps, scope for further consideration and co-operation between Congress and the Government on this issue and that what we failed to do in 1969 we might be able to do in 1970, or at least to make a significant contribution towards a real improvement in the conditions of the lower-paid workers. I want, through Senator Dunne, to assure Congress that the Government stand ready to enter into constructive and meaningful discussions on this subject.
Reference was made to the status of women in Irish life and I wish to assure the Senators who spoke on this that there is no need to harry the Government on this issue. In recent years the Government has been directing increasing attention to this aspect of our community life and I think I can fairly claim we have been approaching it in a humanitarian and sympathetic way. I believe we are about to take a really historic step forward in the establishment of this commission, which will go into the question in a fundamental way.
I was a little disappointed by the Senator who spoke about the commission being discredited. It has not yet been established; its terms of reference have not been set; the personnel who will act on it have not been decided and I really think that a comment of this sort is, to say the least, premature. Reference was made to a reply I gave in the Dáil in this matter. That reply was very carefully framed; I indicated quite clearly that, while equal pay for equal work was no doubt a matter the commission would have to deal with, the establishment of the commission in no way prevented a continuation of the principle of public service negotiations which we inaugurated last year whereby no differentiation was made in the increases granted.
I think this commission will be vital for the future of Irishwomen and I hope it may be given every chance to work and that no attempt will be made to cut the ground from under its feet before it starts. Of course it will have to concern itself with the question of equal pay but it will also have to concern itself with other matters and there will be many women who will regard other things as being of much greater importance than equal pay because there are a great number of women to whom equal pay does not matter. Let us not have any confusion of issues at this stage.
With regard to getting this commission set up we should all try to make sure that it is successful and that as a result of its efforts a significant contribution will be made not just to the status of women in society but to the betterment of Irish society as a whole. Nobody should be under any illusions about equal pay or should try to be glib about it. It is a major issue and of very considerable economic significance. Nobody in the Government is in any way opposed to equal pay in principle. It is simply a question of practicality.
Allied, perhaps, to the question of the status of women in our society is the question of old people which was raised by Senator Gallanagh and others. We have been making progress in this field and in my own constituency I see many encouraging things happening. For instance, I see quite a number of very pleasant little community centres where old people can live not only in great comfort but in great dignity. I am aware that there is a great deal of splendid voluntary effort by way of Meals on Wheels and so on and there are a lot of dedicated volunteers working in this field.
I am sure the Senators will also admit that we in the various Departments of Government have been generally developing a human and humanitarian philosophy in our approach to this aspect of our community life. I said recently that I think it is possible for a small nation to be great in the way that it provides solutions for its community problems. The value or standing of a nation should not be judged by the size of its gross national product. It can show greatness in other ways and I would like to see us regarded as, perhaps, to a great degree, civilised in the humanity and compassion with which we treat the weaker sections of our community and especially the old because, whatever we may say, practically every other section has the hope and the opportunity of bettering itself perhaps through its own efforts but the old must rely on us.
Much has been made of the Devlin Report and I have not much more to add to what I have been saying in response to questions in the Dáil. This is a splendid report. It is one of the most searching and careful reports we have had for a long time and I am happy to take this opportunity to pay tribute to those who compiled it. However, it is a very serious fundamental document and the changes which it suggests are of a very far-reaching nature indeed. It consists in practically turning our existing civil service machinery upside-down and we cannot, as a Government, even if we wished to, rush into decisions on this report.
Perhaps we are not even equipped as we stand to take the decisions on the report. We may have to develop our civil service techniques further before we can validly test some of the recommendations which have been put forward by that report. The report would require careful and accurate scrutiny by the Government and by senior members of the public service but we are looking on it as one of the major tasks confronting the present Government.
Strangely enough, there has not been a great deal of discussion on the general economic situation although Senators have adverted to different aspects of it. We must, of course, at this time look at our economic situation in the light of what is happening abroad. I am not sure if it has yet been announced that some of my colleagues and I will be going to London to have discussions on the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement with our British counterparts. We will be examining the workings of the Agreement in great detail and our discussions will have to be in the light of the recent developments in regard to the European Economic Community. At the present time, we must look on our own particular economic situation both from the internal and from the external point of view.
Perhaps the most important aspect of our internal situation is the problem of inflation. As Senators know, I have given the figure of 8 per cent as the inflation we had in the 12 months to August last. That is a very serious figure and one which must give everyone in the community who has responsibility in any area serious food for thought. I know that we are in a worldwide inflationary situation and that we are importing a great deal of our inflation but there is nothing we can do about that.
Nevertheless, we must make a real effort to get this situation under control and there is no point in anyone blaming anybody else or accusing others of being responsible for it. In every sphere we must try to bring about a situation where incomes do not go so far ahead of national production that inflation is inevitable. That is a spiral which if we once get into it there is no knowing where it will end. I believe there is not yet somehow a sufficient realisation among the ordinary workers that a wage increase or an income increase, no matter how large or how attractive it may be in money terms, if it is more than the community can afford it is only an illusion in the long term and that we will have a situation where everybody will be trying to insure themselves against mounting inflation.
Of course, that ultimately leads to complete chaos and collapse and a collapse brought about by working under inflationary pressure. It is the workers and the poorer sections who suffer most. Perhaps it is regrettable but it is true that the capitalist can always find some way of protecting his interests in that sort of situation. It is terribly important that whatever any of us can do at the present time should be done to try and get this fundamental truth established that we in the community can only take out of it what in effect we put in it.
In my Department every year we are prepared at the beginning of the year to state clearly and categorically what our estimate of the national growth for the year ahead will be. It is only reasonable that everybody should base their income and their expectations of income demand on the basis of actual growth and on nothing else. In so far as anybody takes more out of the pool than is justified then in effect they are, as I said at the beginning, really only hurting those who cannot fight as vigorously for their share.
I want to pay a tribute to the public service for their very enlightened approach to this matter last year when the agreement was entered into and I would hope the headline which they set on that occasion could be followed throughout the community because it would bring splendid results in growth, more in employment and increasing prosperity; I also want to pay tribute to the public service committee of congress for the initiative they took.
Allied, of course, to our inflationary situation — and perhaps a direct reflection of it — is the balance of payments deficit which we are encountering at the present time. I am sure the Senators by now are very familiar with the figures but, if not, I will repeat them.
In deciding on our general plan for this year, 1969, we anticipated a balance of payments deficit of £55 million and we said: "That is a pretty considerable balance of payments deficit. It is not one we would be prepared to tolerate indefinitely year after year but in the circumstances in this particular year we are prepared to live with it." Fortunately all the indications are that it will turn out to have been what we projected. There may have to be an adjustment of about £4½ million in respect of the sale of aircraft. That is only a technical adjustment and is of no particular economic significance. So, in fact, 1969 will have almost worked out in this regard very much as we anticipated and planned for; but what is disturbing is that whereas £55 million could be accepted as a tolerable figure for one year it looks now as if it may project itself, and perhaps even be increased, in 1970.
This is something to which we must again direct the most careful attention and which must influence us very much in our approach to all our economic affairs in the coming year. Again, if 1970 sees, on a broad scale, income increases of the nature we experienced in 1969 then undoubtedly we will have a balance of payments deficit bigger than that in 1969 and undoubtedly much larger than we could with any satisfaction contemplate. That is the situation we find facing us now in the closing weeks of 1969. It was a good year, economically. We kept up a a fairly steady rate of growth, four per cent or four and a half per cent. It is difficult to know precisely yet.
We continued to export very satisfactorily indeed. One of the really redeeming features about our whole situation is a continuing rise in our export potential. As I say our exports continued to rise in 1969 at a satisfactory rate but, unfortunately, we have this inflationary pressure at home, excessive consumption leading to the continuing and unhealthy deficit in our balance of payments. Fortunately, of course, the balance of payments does not bring itself so brutally to our notice because we still have a very satisfactory inflow of capital into the country which enables us to ride out those balance of payments deficits. Nevertheless, all of us must get down during 1970 to see what we can do to ensure that the inflationary spiral inside the country is halted and that our balance of payments is brought back to tolerable limits.
I want to assure Senator Boland, after the excellent contribution which he made here this afternoon, that I will remember his name for the rest of this Seanad. I apologise if I cannot deal with all the various points he made but I assure him and all the other Senators likewise, in so far as they have made particular points in relation to the activities of particular Departments, that I will convey those to my colleagues for their consideration and hopefully for suitable and appropriate action.