Finance Bill, 1971 (Certified Money Bill): Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–120 of 239. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1971 ›
In this Finance Bill the Minister has been unfair to the lower paid workers by virtue of section 2. This is the only occasion during the last ten years when the Seanad have had an opportunity of amending the Finance Bill, because we have it at least a week or a fortnight before the other House adjourns for the summer recess. Therefore, I look forward to the Minister meeting some of the points we raise.
With the present rate of inflation it is unfortunate that the Minister has seen fit to remove the concession that the people who are just within the income tax net enjoyed heretofore. I wonder would the Minister consider reverting to the position that obtained prior to the introduction of this Bill.
The category of workers that this will affect are the manual workers, especially those in areas where employment is difficult to be found. The people who will be most adversely affected by this section are those we see cycling many miles to work to such places as Bord na Móna or other hard manual employment. If the Minister was seeking to collect a certain amount of money it would have been more equitable had he sought to get it at the other end of the income scale.
Comment on this
This section is the one that seeks to abolish the concession of having the first £100 of income charged at a lesser rate of tax. The amazing thing about it is that section 2 of the Finance Bill, 1971, is seeking to abolish section 2 of the Finance Act, 1970. Here was a provision that was introduced with a great fanfare of trumpets by the then Minister. He, much more eloquently than I could, pointed out what a good provision this was and how much it would benefit the lower income groups because the first £100 of their income would be charged at so much lower a rate.
Just a year later his successor comes along and takes away what was given last year. One can be forgiven for wondering what section of the Finance Bill, 1971, will be cancelled by a similar section to this in the Finance Bill, 1972. It is an amazing way to run a Government, or to balance a Budget, or to produce the yearly main Finance Bill, to introduce a concession which was generally acclaimed one year and to remove it the following year and to justify the removal of it by pointing out that it was necessary in order to give the concessions that were given in the Budget.
The fact remains that we are removing a concession of last year's Budget. This does not seem to be a very efficient way to try to produce the annual Budget. I should like the Minister to let us know how much money he estimates will be netted because of the cancelling of section 2 of the Finance Act, 1970; in other words, how much money will the Exchequer get by taking away the concession of charging the first £100 at the rate of 4s. in the £ tax.
The physical task of re-gearing the system last year and the administrative cost of charging the first £100 of income at 4s must have been quite a considerable one, because the existing system was being changed to allow for this new provision. Whatever that cost was, we surely will get at least an equivalent cost by removing it again and reverting to the old system. I wonder if the Minister can, first of all, give us his estimate of how much money the implementation of section 2 will net for him, and secondly, if he could put any estimate on the administrative cost of introducing a concession last year, operating it for a year and cancelling it this year.
Comment on this
First of all, let me make it clear that in the preparation of any Budget, there is no law, no moral obligation or no tradition or custom which inhibits the Minister for Finance from taking such action in relation to changes in the rate of taxation as appear to him to be the most appropriate in the light of the economic circumstances with which he is dealing.
Secondly, I have referred to the fact that the Budget this year was framed in a context in which it was necessary to reduce the rate of increase in Government expenditure to ensure that no action taken in the Budget would have any effect on the operation of the National Pay Agreement, and, at the same time, to provide reliefs in the sum of approximately £9 million. Faced with this situation and having examined the various possibilities, it seemed to me that the most effective and appropriate way in which a substantial portion of that £9 million available and required for redistribution could be raised was as indicated in section 2 of this Bill. Allowing for the concessions which were also introduced and which are dealt with in later sections, the net effect of section 2 and the other sections giving the concessions, will be to yield £5 million in the current year. This is, of course, a substantial portion of the £9 million which is being redistributed.
For the reasons which I have indicated, it was not possible to raise this money by means of indirect taxation. It would have been possible to raise it by increasing the standard rate of income tax but there were a number of objections to this. One of these was that this would, of course, apply to companies whose rate of tax had already been increased last autumn from 50 per cent to 58 per cent. Weighing all the circumstances together, this appeared to me to be the most appropriate way in which to do it. I would remind the House that the impact of section 2 will be less than £12 per annum in the case of any taxpayer. Furthermore, it must be weighed in conjunction with the other concessions the effect of which is to remove from the tax net approximately 20,000 taxpayers and to reduce the income tax paid by approximately 40,000 taxpayers. I do not think it can be said, taking these sections together, which one must do to get the financial picture, that there is any great hardship being imposed on anybody. Nevertheless, it provides for us the bulk of the revenue necessary for the various concessions announced in the Budget.
To suggest that it could have been raised simply by increasing the rate of tax for people in the higher income group is quite unrealistic. Unfortunately, we do not have enough people in the higher income group to make it possible to get that kind of money without an absolutely penal increase in the rate of tax which they pay, the effect of which would be to ensure that the yield went down instead of up. Having regard to the constraints which I have mentioned, this was the only way open to us, but, as I say, it has not operated to create any real hardship for anybody. In those circumstances, I feel the section is deserving of the support of the Seanad.
As anticipated by Senator Boland, I do not have a figure for the estimate of the cost of the administrative arrangements which were necessary. I would remind Senator Boland again that the net yield estimated in the current year from this and the concessions being given in other sections, is £5 million.
Comment on this
It is amazing when one remembers the arguments which were adduced last year by the Government for granting this concession, to hear the same Government now adducing arguments why the concession that was given last year should be abolished. There is obviously a great inconsistency in the arguments coming from the Government. Last year the rate on the first £100 of taxable income was reduced from 7s to 4s., the Minister said £5 million would be collected. In the Dáil he said £5½ million.
Comment on this
£5½ million was the figure given in the Dáil. I do not understand why within one year, there should be a complete change of attitude, a complete change of arguments. According to his statement, the Minister is raising £5½ million, not £5 million. In spite of what he states, the first £100 of taxable income affects the lower income group mostly. The concession made last year was probably welcomed by most wage-earners. The Minister has stated how valid his arguments are. I do not know if this is the best way to raise the money he is looking for; it may be the easiest way; it may require less administration; it may be less expensive to collect the money this way, but I am very dubious as to whether it is the most equitable way.
Comment on this
I think section 2 of this Bill is the most disappointing section in a disappointing Bill. As other speakers have pointed out, it takes away a relief which was given only 12 months ago by another Minister for Finance. If one went back on the record of the debates both in Dáil Éireann and in Seanad Éireann, one would find that there was quite an amount of backslapping and of congratulating the Minister who had given this relief on the first £100. This section is relieving the lower income group of £12 per year which to the Minister, from his remarks a moment ago, appears to be a very small sum indeed. We heard mention of "it is only the cost of a packet of cigarettes per week." But the cost of a packet of cigarettes per week means something in a pay packet. What is the value of discussing the rights, wrongs, merits and demerits of this particular section when the people we are talking about are already having these deductions made from their pay packet under PAYE? It is a mean provision to seek from the hardest working and lowest paid section of the community the £9 million that the Minister required to balance his Budget and to enable him to give the reliefs that were given can be described as going back on a promise made 12 months ago. Surely there must have been some other way of doing it.
Comment on this
The Minister was not the architect of the Finance Act, 1970, but a word with the then Minister would perhaps have elicited how it could have been done and how he could avoid, having given this concession to those people 12 months ago, taking it back now because he could not find another way of reimbursing the Exchequer.
Comment on this
It is significant that the only suggestion we had as to how this money might have been raised was a casual remark by one Senator that it should have been raised from people in the higher income group. I have already dealt with the unreality of that. Senators deliberately chose to ignore the circumstances in which this year's Budget was prepared and in which it was essential to avoid anything that would endanger the National Pay Agreement; that we succeeded in doing that in this year's Budget and, at the same time, we gave reasonable reliefs to the most necessitous members of the community. One would think, listening to Senator J. Fitzgerald, that this concession was related solely to the lower paid. It was not, of course; it relates to all taxpayers.
Senator Belton referred to a statement I made in Dáil Éireann when I said the yield would be £5½ million. That is in a full year, but in the current year I said it was £5 million.
Comment on this
I should also like to say that the considerations which operated in the Budget, and which I have outlined, were and are vitally important to the whole economic future of this country and of every person in it, to both the lower and the higher paid but, particularly, to the lower paid. The signs are that the policy we are pursuing is beginning to pay off. We need not have any sense of complacency about it, but the signs are there showing that we are on the right road. One of the very important factors in this is that this Budget did not interfere with the National Pay Agreement. This is far more important, particularly to the lower paid workers, than the fact that they will have to pay an additional tax of, in many cases, something under £12 a year. It is more important to them that we should manage to win the battle against inflation than that they should have to pay less than £12 a year additional taxation. In these circumstances, I suggest that anybody who gives any thought to this, and who tries to come up with an alternative method of raising this amount of money, will find straightaway that he is coming up against the problem I have outlined: whatever he suggests is either not going to yield the money or it will have repercussions, particularly on the National Pay Agreement, which could be far more costly than any additional tax imposition on the amount of money raised by the Exchequer as a result of section 2.
Comment on this
I am in the same difficulty this afternoon as I was in this morning because I have risen only very slightly from the abysmal depths of my ignorance on financial matters having listened to the Minister and his colleagues speaking on the Central Bank Bill. I wonder if the Minister would explain to the House what were the provisions which operated heretofore in relation to situations such as this.
Comment on this
It will be noted that the provisions of this section are confined to cessations occurring on or after the 6th April, 1972. That is the first thing to note. This is an anti-avoidance measure. At the moment, on the cessation of a trade or business, the last year and previous year of business are brought into account and the Revenue Commissioners may assess tax on the basis of the actual profits earned in those two years. There are methods by which, under the existing law, certain arrangements can be contrived to bring a business to an end when there has been in one year a particularly large profit. Arrangements can be so contrived as, in effect, to pay very much less tax than would normally be payable. The purpose of this section is to extend for another year the period over which the Revenue Commissioners may have a look at what the actual profits were and, if necessary, assess tax on the basis of the actual profits in those years. The effect of this will be to make it more difficult at least to contrive a situation in which one avails of this to evade tax. The fact that it brings in the additional year makes it less easy for somebody to contrive this situation. They may, of course, have the situation brought about purely by chance and one cannot object to that. What we are trying to get at is the situation in which this was contrived. We believe that adding on another year will make it far more difficult to contrive this form of avoidance.
Comment on this
I merely wondered whether it would be possible that, where a trade or profession ceased because they were not operating successfully and perhaps had returned a small profit in the last year of trading, by this adjustment the provisions would turn out to be more than had applied heretofore. What I envisaged was a situation in which the owner might have been in serious financial difficulties anyway and this was one of the reasons for ceasing and then he would find the tax demand completely inordinate. Is it possible for such a thing to happen if the Revenue Commissioners want to operate it that way?
Comment on this
I would not think so. In circumstances in which a business is closing down because of financial difficulties one may take it that the profit is either non-existent or very small. Of course, the Revenue Commissioners cannot charge tax on profits which have not been earned. Therefore, the kind of situation which Senator Boland envisages cannot bring about a situation in which inordinate demands of tax are made because the tax must be related to the actual profit earned. I will not go into all the details, unless the House wishes me, because it is rather complex but I will give a few figures which might illustrate what can happen. If we assume that a man who is trading on his own earns profits as follows: for the year ended 30th April, 1967: £2,400; 30th April, 1968: £3,000; 30th April, 1969: £12,000; 30th April, 1970: £3,000. In that case, under the existing law, the tax which he would pay on those profits would total £6,400 whereas under this proposal the tax he would pay would be £15,250.
In each case the tax is related to the actual profit. In neither case would he be charged tax on profits which he did not earn but because of this contrivance which relates to the date of cessation, the end of an income tax year, it happens in those circumstances, which I have outlined, that under existing law that instead of paying tax at the rate of £15,250, which is the correct rate of taxation on actual profits earned, he would pay only £6,400. As I say, unless the House wishes me to I will not go into the actual details of how this works out.
Comment on this
The Minister is oversimplifying it. Really what he is doing is allowing himself provision to look back over a longer period.
Comment on this
This is the section which is designed to catch those who are operating overdrafts outside the State and evading tax both within the State and in whichever country they are operating. There are two questions which I want to ask the Minister. He probably has not got the answer to the first here. How many people does he envisage, or how many companies would he envisage would be affected by this and what amount does he expect the implementation of this section would produce in any one year? Secondly, when one appreciates that what the person has been doing is deliberately and consciously to evade payment of income tax in quite a legal way, does the Minister feel that the allowance of a period of 12 months, up to 6th April, 1972, is not perhaps inordinately long?
Comment on this
On the first question raised by Senator Boland, it is not possible to estimate how much this will yield. I should say, of course, that it applies only to individuals and not to companies. If I may quote something I said in the Dáil debate it sums up pretty accurately all I can say about the estimated yield. It is from Volume 253, column 770. In response to a question on this point I said:
It is difficult to estimate it accurately, as the Deputy will understand, because all the cases have not come to light. However, we do estimate at least £20,000 to £25,000 a year is involved in tax. It may well be substantially more, but we are pretty sure it is at least that.
In fact, something I have heard suggests to me that it may well be substantially more. We do not know because since it was not liable to tax it is not possible for us really to estimate it.
The position is that the extension to which Senator Boland referred is not unduly long because anything else could only be regarded as retrospective. We did consider that section 4 should not operate in a case in which a debt was incurred in 1971-72 before the legislation was foreshadowed in the Budget speech if the foreign income is applied during the year 1971-72 in satisfaction of the debt but any debt incurred in this way after the date of the Budget speech would be caught. To go further than that would be retrospective and would be unfair. As the Senator pointed out somebody doing this was acting within the law so that it would be unfair to make it retrospective.
Comment on this
I have no time for all this talk about "retrospective". Ministers have certain devices which they use to suit their own ends. It is rather like this interpretation of "may" and "shall". One can always take it that it will be a "may" interpreted in whichever way the Minister wants it to be and whichever way the Opposition do not think it should. In the very same way when any Minister wants to make a case retrospective action in legislation is wrong and when he wants to make another case retrospective action is necessary and in the common good. There are a lot of unfortunate people operating quite legitimately within the law who were pretty shocked when the Minister arrived with his autumn Budget last year, which he has referred to here already, and introduced quite a retrospective element of taxation far as companies operating quite legitimately were concerned.
Here we have a situation where a number of people—we do not know how many—were operating and using a loophole within the taxation code and were doing that to evade payment of taxation. The Minister, quite rightly, wants to close that loophole. In fairness, anybody operating or endeavouring to use one of these loopholes will have to say to himself: "OK, fair game, I got away with it for so long but he announced in the Budget today that it is stopped and that is it." To announce that it is stopped but that you are going to give him 12 months to make up for his legal sins of the past is being an overcharitable confessor especially when we see where under other sections people of much more modest means, as in section 2, will be asked to pay it immediately. Unfortunately, because it was not implemented immediately, we are asked to pay quite a lump sum in one particular month. That has more or less been got over now, but the sort of person who would be operating this legal loophole would be in quite a different category, probably in the category of a person who would be paying the wealth tax, which the Minister does not want to produce. To allow them 12 months to remedy their legal sins of the past seems to be just a little bit too generous. It is, perhaps, something which the Minister might consider in the future. We all know that in every Finance Bill a certain number of legal loopholes will be closed, and just as soon as they are closed a bevy of gentlemen will leave here to consult the best financial brains in London to see what other ones they can open and which ones they still have available to them, and some of those will be closed in the following year's Bill and so this never ending battle will go on.
I suggest that when we are closing some of the financial loopholes in the future we accept the fact that we will make people pay tax, which they should have been paying anyway, and which they have been evading. They ought to start paying it right from the day the closing of the loophole is announced. Admittedly, in this case that would have been unfair, but to allow a whole year is being over-generous.
Comment on this
I could not find myself at all in agreement with those sentiments. There is no use saying that people should have been paying tax. Surely people must only pay tax that is due and payable by them. If there is not tax due and payable it should not be paid nor should the payment be made retrospective because the Minister for Finance sees a method of getting further tax. This is entirely wrong and it is contrary to the ordinary principles of justice and I would not agree with it.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that there should have been any element of retrospection, I am merely saying the period of grace which the Minister has allowed, which is a year, is over generous.
Comment on this
Subsection (5) says:
This section shall not have effect in relation to income applied in or towards satisfaction of a debt for money lent before the 28th day of April, 1971, or of a debt incurred for satisfying in whole or in part any such debt, unless it is so applied after the end of the year 1971-72.
Comment on this
I could not accept any element of retrospection in a matter like this. I think Senator Nash is perfectly right that anything that was done in this case, or in similar situations, which was legal, is not something for which one is entitled to penalise people. One can close the loophole all right. While I do not want to get involved in going back over the old ground about the company taxation, I want to say again, for the record, that in my view there was no retrospection involved in that. It was passed in the autumn and no tax was payable under that provision before the 1st January of this year. Taking it on a straightforward basis, you cannot say that that is retrospective. I do not want to get involved in that argument, but I accept the principle.
Comment on this
You cannot apply retrospection in a case like this. I was delighted to hear what the Senator had to say about people who had not been paying tax and their liability to pay it, especially having regard to those who do pay their taxes. A great deal of this Bill is concerned with people who have a clear liability, not availing of a loophole, but under the law as it stands have not been paying their taxes or have not been paying them promptly. This is designed to get after them and move them. I trust that we have the full support of Senator Boland on those issues.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give the House any indication of the percentage of taxpayers who either do not pay or are slow in paying, or of the amount of money involved in the last financial year?
Comment on this
I could not do that, but I think I can say it is expected, as a result of the various provisions in this Bill designed to speed up and improve collection, that that will yield an additional £2 million.
Comment on this
I suppose we cannot be too hard on these people when we see what the Comptroller and Auditor General had to say about the Appropriation Act of 1969.
Comment on this
What he has to say is his business. It is not necessarily the view of a constitutional lawyer.
Comment on this
Will the question arise in the future if and when we become a member of the Common Market? Will it affect any type of taxation such as this?
Comment on this
Not directly, but in the longer term there will be a harmonisation of different kinds of tax which will alter the basis of our tax structure. It will not immediately direct our ordinary taxes.
Comment on this
It will not happen for some years? What I was really trying to get at was, was the time wasted in bringing in this measure? If the harmonisation is to occur in the immediate future. It might be a waste of time.
Comment on this
It is a very small item but it is an anomaly which has been found to exist. The cost of the registration of a patent, say, is chargeable, but it was found that there was this anomaly that the cost of registration of a trademark was not allowable as a deduction. It is simply remedying that anomaly and there is very little involved in it either for the Exchequer or for the people concerned. It is just an anomaly that has come to light and this is remedying it.
Comment on this
This is the section that allows for an increase in the earned income for single people and widows from £125 to £150 and for married persons from £225 to £250. Could the Minister give us any idea of how much the provisions in this section will cost? Another point on which I should like the Minister to elaborate is this: Could the Minister say how long the existing figures for minimum earned income relief have been in force?
Comment on this
This figure was brought into existence last year. I do not have a breakdown for this but the estimated cost to the Exchequer of this, plus the other two reliefs which are coming up, is £1 million, in this year.
Comment on this
Is this the one that the Minister is fumbling by stealing back the £5½ million on the first £100? The Minister is making a case that he is giving concessions and so he will have to take back this £5½ million. Is this one of the concessions that he says was directed——
Comment on this
No. I think perhaps the Budget passed the Senator by. That was not what I was saying. I was saying that the net yield from section 2, less this and the other reliefs that are coming up in the Bill, would be £5 million in this year and in a full year £5,500,000. The cost of these income tax reliefs in this year is £1 million but the net yield, taking what is coming in under section and what is going out under these reliefs, in this year is £5 million.
Comment on this
It will take in £6 million under section 2 this year?
Comment on this
Yes. The concessions in section 2 were the concessions made in the Budget to people in receipt of social welfare, to agriculture, and to various other people such as Old IRA people, public service pensions, widows of Old IRA men and all the other categories of people who benefited under the Budget. They were the concessions to which I was referring. The money required under section 2 is required to pay for those concessions.
Comment on this
But sections 6 to 12 rely partly on section 2.
Comment on this
If some of the Senators on the opposite side are objecting to section 2 then surely they should be objecting to sections 6 to 12 as well.
Comment on this
I am delighted to get an opportunity of speaking on section 9 for the very simple reason that it is virtually a carbon copy of a similar section in the earlier Finance Act which allowed a widowed person a housekeeper allowance. I must admit that it is some time since I read that earlier section but I think this section is more or less modelled on it.
Section 9 intends to allow a housekeeper allowance to an unmarried mother who is engaged in a full-time occupation. That housekeeper allowance would be paid in respect of a family relative whom she has working for her. If she can prove that there is no such relative available, or prepared to live with her, she can claim a housekeeper allowance in respect of some person whom she employs to look after her child. The same provision applies to a widower who has to employ a person to look after his children while he is at work.
I want to crave the indulgence of the Chair and the ear of the Minister to make the point that it is quite difficult for a widower to find a suitable person, who has no other source of income, to look after his children. I have come across a case where, apparently, the Revenue Commissioners are insisting that because the widower employs a married woman he is not entitled to claim a housekeeper allowance for her because her husband is already claiming for her in his allowances. This man cannot get a single person to mind his children. If he could he might not want to do so because ideally the best person to mind the children is someone who is a mother herself. The Chair has been very good in allowing me to make a case on an Act that has been in force for some years. I hope the Minister will take heed of it.
Comment on this
The Chair is very trusting. A very similar situation will probably develop in this case. Let us look at the situation quite seriously. If an unmarried mother with a child has to go out to work, as most unmarried mothers have to, she could probably not afford to pay very much to some person to look after her child. It is most likely in such a case that she will not have a female relative living with her who does not have any other source of income. More than likely she will have to employ a person to come into her home or flat to take care of the child or else she will have to board out the child in a créche or a nursery.
In my opinion if an unmarried mother was to put her child into a day school or nursery she would not be entitled to claim a housekeeper allowance. If she would be entitled to claim such an allowance I would be delighted to hear so from the Minister. If she boards out her child to some person in the locality who will mind the child in her home it is almost certain that that person will be a married person whose husband has already claimed for her. While the intention of section 9 is good and admirable—as good and admirable as the intention of the original section in relation to widowers—I am afraid that the 1967 section has produced a lot of difficulties. I imagine this section, from the point of view of the unmarried mother, will be an even more difficult one under which to claim.
Both of these categories of people are people who suffer a fair amount of hardship. Perhaps the Minister would consider relaxing this restriction about female relatives and about a person being claimed for twice, if the person happens to be a married person, in these cases.
Comment on this
I, too, should like to welcome this section and also section 11. It denotes an awakening of the Government's social conscience. I should like strongly to support Senator Boland's plea that the Minister should go that little bit further and relax this restriction. Experience has shown that there are quite a small number of people involved under this provision.
Comment on this
Senator Boland is correct in thinking that what is involved here is simply an extension of section 139 of the 1967 Income Tax Act which provided the housekeeper allowance for a widower, a widow, a married man, whose wife has deserted him, or a woman, whose husband has deserted her. This is an extension of that provision to an unmarried mother, who is engaged in full-time employment or who is engaged full-time in a trade or profession, and who secures the services of a housekeeper to look after her child.
The situation envisaged by Senator Boland, where the unmarried mother boards out her child during the day with a neighbour, and pays the neighbour to look after the child, is one in which the unmarried mother would be allowed that expense as a claim under this section. It is true to say that the married woman neighbour in receipt of this money would have to account for that money. I think the situation Senator Boland was talking about arises only where a female relative of the applicant is involved. As he said, whatever about the other cases, it is not very likely in the case of an unmarried mother that the female relative problem will arise. The problem to which he referred arises more frequently in the other cases under the 1967 Act. It is unlikely to arise in this case.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think that most unmarried mothers will board out their child by day to a married neighbour? It will not be worth the neighbour's while to take the child, if she has to pay tax on the money she gets. It is a vicious circle.
If the unmarried mother gets her housekeeper allowance, and then the other person has to pay tax, it will not induce her to take the child. It had been my understanding that as it operated under the 1967 Act in respect of widowers, the allowance would not be paid where the person involved—the person with whom the child was boarded out—was already being claimed for in respect of her husband, or whoever was responsible for her. In that case the allowance was being refused to the widower and I assume that with the marvellous consistency of the Revenue Commissioners, it would in turn be refused to an unmarried mother in the same sort of situation.
Comment on this
That arises in the case of a female relative only. It does not arise in any other case.
Comment on this
In the particular case which I recall it was in relation to a person who I am virtually certain was not in any way related to the widower concerned. She agreed to come to the widower's house each day to look after his children and provide a meal for them during the day. He was informed by the Revenue Commissioners that he would not be allowed a housekeeper's allowance in respect of her because her husband was already claiming for her. She was in no way related to the widower. Would the same situation not arise in relation to the operation of this section?
Comment on this
I am advised that that should not arise if the person concerned was not a female relative. If the circumstances are as outlined by the Senator, perhaps, he would have another look at this on the basis that if it is not a female relative, then that situation should not have arisen in that case. I should like to point out that in the case we envisage of the unmarried mother boarding out the child during the day with a married neighbour, the married neighbour would have an allowance of £99 per annum free of tax, earned income relief. However, we cannot take the view that income derived in this way should be completely exempt from tax. It is the only way that we could meet the point being made by Senator Boland.
Comment on this
It is a difficult problem. It is more complicated in its operation and more difficulties arise in its operation than, perhaps, are envisaged by the Minister.
Comment on this
We all agree with the principle here. However, I cannot understand why the Minister would not put in a simple section, giving the idea that we do not have to have this type of amendment, year after year, in the Finance Bill. Surely we all agree that if the old age pensioner gets an increase of 40 new pence or 50 new pence it should not be taken off by the tax collector. While we all agree with this, would it not be easier to delete the figures altogether, and just replace that section with the general principle? I envisage something like what is contained in the latter half of the explanatory memorandum. In this way we should not waste the time of the Oireachtas by bringing in these types of amendments, especially when we all agree with the principle and support the section as it stands.
Comment on this
The case was very validly made in the other House. Contrary to all the beliefs of the Department of Social Welfare, there exist a number of contributory old age pensioners for whom the old age pension is the only income they have. Of course, I appreciate that a person could have quite a considerable income and still qualify for a contributory old age pension. The case was made to the Minister in the other House more or less in passing, and it is worth re-emphasising here. It would be well worth while, if there could be included by way of amendment of section 142 of the 1967 Act, provision for a dependent relative allowance to cover the contributory old age pension as well, where it could be shown that that pension was the only income of which the dependent relative was in receipt.
Comment on this
On the point raised by Senator McDonald, while it is true that this relief applies to all categories, nevertheless, the section could be so drafted as to relate, without figures, to whatever the current rate for noncontributory pension was. I will consider that for the next Finance Bill and draft it in that way. I think it would simplify it.
I shall now refer to the other point about relating it to the level of the contributory pension. As I explained in the other House, there are a number of reasons why I found it impossible to accept it. One was the cost and others were reasons of principle. One must remember that since there is no means test in relation to the contributory pension, we would be departing completely from the basis of this, which is related to means. We could well find ourselves giving the benefit to people who did not require it, thereby depriving people who would be much more in need of that benefit. On the whole, for practical reasons and for reasons of principle, we should adhere to the practice we have been following, that is, to relate it to the level of the noncontributory old age pension.
Comment on this
This is to provide a deduction in assessable income to persons. Does this refer to persons in receipt of a blind pension? How is one to satisfy the Revenue Commissioners that the degree of blindness exists?
Comment on this
No, it is not related here to the receipt of a blind pension but rather to the production of a certificate by an ophthalmic surgeon as to the degree of blindness. The degree required would be that if a person cannot, with correcting lenses, read the largest letter on the standard chart at six metres, then his central visual acuity would be said not to exceed 6/10. The reference to a limitation in the field of vision means that looking at a central point on a chart used for the internationally recognised Snellan Test, the field of vision is limited on either side of the central point to the degree stated in the section. This definition is taken from an American statutory definition in relation to a similar kind of thing. I am advised that it is a fairly generous approach to it.
Comment on this
I am rather surprised that there are not several special sections in the Bill to enable the Exchequer to finance any activity that McKinsey and the Public Service may feel like.
Comment on this
The purpose of this section is to ensure that that part of the contributions under the Social Welfare Acts which is referable to the new death grant and retirement pension which were introduced by the Social Welfare Act, 1970, shall be allowed as a deduction for income tax in the same manner as the contributions referable to the other contributory benefits mentioned in section 224 of the Income Tax Act, 1967.
Comment on this
In other words, this provides that the actual social welfare contributions which a person pays each week may be deducted before making income tax assessment?
Comment on this
The Minister is probably aware that the Minister for Health has visited this House recently and also the other House and has, by dint of numerical strength rather than by logic, taken through these Houses legislative measures which will mean that the same persons who will pay these social welfare contributions will be made to provide £5 million extra to the Exchequer through the health contributions. They will have to start paying those fairly soon.
I am a little bit surprised that if the Minister should allow the social welfare contributions to be deductible before tax is assessed why will he not allow the Health Contributions Act contributions to be deductible also? After all, in equity or even in logic, as the Minister was mentioning the unfortunate people in the limited eligibility health category, they will be saved £700,000 a year and for that privilege they will have to pay £5 million by way of weekly contributions or other means——
Comment on this
And receive services which they are already in receipt of and entitled to. I know the Minister would prefer not to go into the field of health because he is probably anxious to get through as many sections as possible today. Does the Minister not feel that the health contributions ought also to have been included here and if he does would he consider including them? If he does not, would he say why not?
Comment on this
In response to a question by Senator Boland when he asked "Does that mean the social welfare stamp is being allowed as a deduction", I said "In effect." I do not want there to be any misunderstanding about it. It does not mean that the whole of the social welfare contributions are allowed but the portion that I mentioned in reply. This section provides for additional items that may be deducted, that is, the contribution referable to the death grant and retirement pension.
I do not know how Senator Boland arrived at the conclusion that health contributions will not be allowed because these health contributions do not exist yet. When they do, then the matter can be dealt with. We cannot be making provision for them when they do not yet exist.
Comment on this
Take the ordinary Joe Soap who will pay for his health services by way of taxation, by way now of a weekly health contribution. Surely it is the final indignity if the Minister will allow a situation to exist for a year when he will be doubly taxed because he is taxed on the health contributions which he is obliged to make under the Health Contributions Act. In all fairness, it seems to be stretching the tolerance of the middle income group or the limited eligibility category, as they are referred to in the Health Contributions Act, a little bit too far. In effect, it would amount to £5 million. Even if the Minister did include it in the Finance Bill, 1972, it would have meant somewhere around £3 million between now and then to the Exchequer. We are getting it once and also getting the tax on it.
Comment on this
I, of course, support the idea in the section which specifically exempts road vehicles. I wonder if the Minister would consider giving a special concession to firms who would propose to purchase intercontinental road transporters for the purpose of exporting directly to continental Europe or, indeed, to Britain on the ferry.
Carriers operating cross-Channel or to Europe have a monopoly on our roads here. This is a type of activity that our own carriers or even CIE should get into. Especially if we are going into Europe, Irish companies should be seen to take our goods. Our lamb trade should increase to France and our frozen meat to most of the EEC countries. If this concession were given, even for a few years, to allow any of our carriers to enter this line of business, the Government would be encouraging expansion. After all, it is a business and does it really matter what it is as long as our people are employed? It is of paramount importance that lorries with Irish markings should be seen to carry our goods abroad. I come through County Kildare every day and all the lorries that I see that are taking frozen meat from the chilling factory in Kildare are all foreign owned.
Comment on this
This is section 13 which, according to the explanatory memorandum, applies to capital expenditure on new machinery or plant other than road vehicles.
Comment on this
It exempts road vehicles and I was asking the Minister if he would include road vehicles which are purchased specifically for the export trade. This type of vehicle is not available here because the continental lorries that I see here have sleeping accommodation and are a very expensive type of lorry. If our Irish hauliers were to purchase them with the 35 per cent import duty or levy that applies to them, it would place them in a position of not being able to compete with the European or, indeed, the British or Northern Ireland hauliers. I see no reason why CIE and some of our more progressive private hauliers should not be encouraged to tackle this trade and to have lorries travelling to Britain and Europe with Irish markings and proudly portraying an Irish image abroad.
This is very important especially if we are really going after the fresh lamb trade to France. We are at present exporting a relatively small amount of this commodity to France despite a 20 per cent import tariff there. If we enter the EEC, there are good prospects for this trade. Why does the Minister not encourage our hauliers to be on the ball there and to get across with our agricultural exports and not to depend on European carriers to do it for us?
Comment on this
I agree with many of the points made by Senator McDonald. Before supporting his argument, I should like to hear the Minister speak on this. There are many reasons why what Senator McDonald said should be done in this case might be done. As against that, one could give reasons as to why it should not be done. I should like to know what the Minister has in mind when a 60 per cent allowance can be made for new machinery or plant other than road vehicles. We all know that in many factories there is total dependence on a certain type of road vehicle. I am thinking of bulk loaders for cement, for flour, ready-mixed cement, et cetera. I should like to get the Minister's views on this. Is this specialised type of carrier included in the 60 per cent?
Comment on this
These kinds of vehicles were never included in the initial allowance and, as Senators have seen from the Bill, I do not propose to include them now. The principal reason for this is that the cost to the Exchequer would be prohibitive. If one were to confine it, as suggested by Senator McDonald, obviously the cost would not be so great but it would become impossible to resist claims for similar treatment for different kinds of passenger vehicles. It is surprising how ingenious people can be. Once an extension like this is granted, a logical case can be made for a further extension and I would be much afraid that the Exchequer could not afford it. I certainly could not contemplate this in the present financial year, whatever might be the position in the future.
Comment on this
Surely for a start the Minister could confine it to the meat trade only. Those special containers or lorries are really plant because they are very expensive items of equipment and even the lorry cabs are a special job. I remember at the Derby in the Curragh some of those foreign lorries going to the chilling factory in Kildare and one would think the race was taking place in France.
Comment on this
If we are to be able to sell our Irish meat, the packaging is important. The stock which rolls on and off our ferries should be Irish lorries and Irish registered vehicles. I should think a dozen applications would be the maximum the Minister would receive because we have only a handful of factories and I do not think all of them will be in the export trade. Would the Minister then give a concession to the meat trade especially since the export of Irish lamb is so important to the Irish farmers? The Minister may not be aware that lamb prices this year have taken a drastic nose-dive and it is very important to the Irish agricultural economy that we should boost in every way possible the export of lamb.
If we had our own vehicles they would be a type of advertisement on the road down to Paris or wherever they might go. Since the numbers of vehicles will not be great whether it be CIE who take on the service or some of the more progressive carriers that we have who take it on, why leave this type of business entirely to continentals?
Comment on this
I do not want to argue against what Senator McDonald has said but if I were the Minister I could make a good argument against it. What I mean by plant is having a type of truck that carries ready-mixed cement. It carries bulk cement. It is on the road for one purpose only. You cannot remove the back of it and have a lorry, as you can with a container. You put a container on a lorry and you take it to the port and your lorry may be used for anything else after. You cannot use containers for ready-mixed or bulk cement for any other purpose. They are part and parcel of the plant and a good case should be made for the reduction of the 60 per cent. If the Minister could see his way to do what Senator McDonald has asked in the case of the meat containers that is very good if it will help the export of lamb or any other commodity, but I feel that the lorries to which I am referring are geared for one purpose only and I do not think anybody could try to drive a coach and four through any regulation the Minister might make in that respect.
Comment on this
On a point of clarification, the vehicles I am speaking about are also just single-purpose vehicles equipped with deep freezes for meat without removable bodies.
Comment on this
The fellow with the ice cream van will look for the same concession.
Comment on this
There is no evidence at all to suggest that the export of lamb would be inhibited in any way by the absence of Irish lorries to transport the lamb. Regarding the suggestion by Senator Fitzgerald, if the people concerned want to make a submission about it to me or to the Revenue Commissioners on the lines made by Senator Fitzgerald, I would be prepared to consider it but not in the current Finance Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to ask why an exception is made in relation to hotels, holiday camps, registered holiday cottages, market garden buildings. What was the purpose of excluding them from this remission?
Comment on this
Hotels, market garden buildings and registered holiday cottages get another form of allowance which is better than this as a kind of compensation for the fact that they do not get the export tax relief.
Comment on this
This is another anti-avoidance measure. The existing law provides that where in consequence of a settlement income is paid during the life of the settler to or for the benefit of a child of the settler in any income tax year at the commencement of which the child is an infant and unmarried, then the income is to be treated as the income of the settler for tax purposes. In the case of a child born after the 6th April in any year of assessment the parent can, in that year, divert his income by way of a settlement in favour of the child and since the child was not an infant and unmarried on the 6th April that year, the income cannot, under the existing law, be treated as part of the parents' income although for subsequent years it will be. This section allows a taxpayer, if he wants to arrange his affairs in that way to do so but if the child was born at any time during the income tax year, then the existing law would operate in respect of it.
The device has been used fairly frequently for income tax avoidance and a substantial amount of income tax and surtax could well be avoided in the year of the child's birth by virtue of it. That is why we propose to close the loophole. Under this section the test will be not whether the child is an infant and unmarried at the beginning of the year but whether the child is an infant and unmarried at the time the payment under the settlement is made.
Comment on this
In this instance the Minister is, perhaps, going that small bit too far. I have had more time to study the explanatory memorandum since Tuesday last. Nevertheless in the case of an individual who finds that he has been engaged in an activity which is liable to income tax through no fault of his own this 9 per cent will be a penal imposition on him, more especially if he finds he was liable for tax for two to five years back. I do not know if this is possible but it might happen. At 9 per cent it would not take more than six or seven years for the demand to be doubled with compound interest. The 9 per cent is, indeed, a penal interest because even if a taxpayer wishes to avoid paying tax on the nail and invests at 9 per cent, his net tax-free interest will not be 9 per cent. He will be lucky if it is 4 per cent. The Minister has said that this was to discourage people from investing at a high rate of interest. This argument does not hold because it is impossible, especially with inflation, to get a net interest rate of 9 per cent. The amount that the Minister will gain by this will be negligible. On the other hand, the Bill will be prohibitive to a number of people who are caught up in the tax net, especially if they are assessed with tax on some other activity, the liabilities for which they were unaware of, for a few years back. I would ask the Minister to have a look at this. Nine per cent is altogether too high. As the tax would form part of the taxable income at the interest of 9 per cent, if a person were lucky enough to get a net interest rate of 9 per cent from an investment it would be compounded. I feel that the Minister is going a little too hard. In addition, it is proposed to reduce the period of grace from three to two months. I would remind the Minister again that this year is the first year in a long time that the Seanad will be able to effect an amendment to this Bill by virtue of the fact that the Dáil is still in session. It will be possible for him to go back there next week or the week after with any amendment that he may accept here.
Comment on this
This is one of the sections on which I expect the full support of Senator Boland in view of what he said earlier.
Comment on this
The Minister has great expectations, but I doubt if I will be able to live up to them. One of the difficulties I find in speaking on the Finance Bill is that as far as the Seanad is concerned we are this afternoon like political eunuchs. No matter how much we may disagree with any provisions of the Bill we are inhibited from expressing that disagreement in terms of voting.
Comment on this
The idea of reducing from three months to two the period of grace for payment and at the same time of increasing by 50 per cent the amount of interest payable from the due date of assessment seems to be unduly penal. I would envisage a situation whereby people might have to liquidate assets in order to meet the tax demands in these cases. There was already provision whereby the commissioner could direct that a certain amount of money could be paid pending the termination of an appeal. I wonder if the Minister would explain to the House why it has suddenly been decided that this provision is no longer effective.
As Senator McDonald has said, at 9 per cent the rate of tax is virtually a commercial rate. I do not think the Minister will catch too many people who could, as he said, have invested their money and be earning fat interest while awaiting the determination of an appeal. Rather will he unduly harass many small business people who are already up to their ears in trouble because they have got as far as the appeals section, the Revenue Commissioner. If they are also expected to pay 9 per cent interest on whatever amount is eventually decided is due, it could, indeed, be the financial straw that would break many a small man's back. I do not like this provision either whereby, as the explanatory memorandum states:
...tax charged by the assessment will carry interest from the date on which it would have been due if there had been no appeal. Interest will not, however, be charged in such cases if an agreed payment on account has been made within two months from the due date and if any balance of tax found to be due on determination of the appeal is paid within two months of such determination. Neither will interest be charged where a payment which is made without agreement within two months of the due date proves to be not less than 80 per cent of the tax found to be chargeable on the determination of the appeal and where any balance of tax is paid within two months of the determination.
It is surely very much a case of a reversal of all that has applied in our courts, in our taxation system and elsewhere. It is the idea that a man is innocent until found guilty. The effect of section 7 is very definitely that one is guilty unless it happens that the appeal finds one innocent. Because we have decided a person is guilty the only way he may get any partial remission of this penal interest rate is by paying quite a large sum of money immediately. If the appeal rules that he has paid too much it will be given back. This does not seem to me to be operating in a very enlightened manner. I can quite understand why the appeals commissioners would be anxious to see that people of large incomes, who had been evading tax for a considerable length of time and who had well within their resources the wherewithal to meet the demand, ought be made pay that as quickly as possible. However, I would suggest to the Minister that the majority of appeal cases which go before the appeals commissioners more often than not concern a small business person who through his own folly or otherwise has not paid this tax, has not paid it for some considerable length of time, perhaps, because he was not aware that he was liable for tax in this regard. Suddenly this person is faced not only with a taxation demand which makes him blench but also with a demand to pay what is virtually commercial interest rates on that figure. The Minister ought to take a very close look at this. It could turn out to be one of the harshest impositions that has come before us in any section in any Bill in recent years.
Comment on this
The Minister may be able to defend himself in what he says here, but from what I see year in and year out the income tax code is becoming more complex. One could nearly devote one's whole education to understanding the income tax code and to advising other people on it. The more complex a code like this income tax code becomes the harsher the burden will fall upon those who have to pay smaller sums in income tax. Those companies or persons who have to pay large sums of income tax will, of course, have income tax consultants that the smaller business people cannot afford to pay. It is the smaller business people or maybe smaller companies which will be caught in the net that is being provided under this section. That is a point which I would like the Minister to examine. It may be through ignorance that income tax is not paid.
Even to a man in business who is reasonably well educated the complexities of the income tax code are like cross-word puzzles. Wealthy companies, companies from whom the Minister is expecting large sums in income tax, can employ special income tax advisers to advise them as to what they should do. The income tax advisers will know the legislation on income tax and will advise these people, but the people who pay small sums in income tax cannot afford to have these income tax advisers and may be caught in this net that is primarily designed. I presume, to catch large sums of money. It will not catch the large sums of money. it may get money by the imposition of the 9 per cent after two months from the date of assessment. That 9 per cent which has been explained will, of course, be compounded because it will be taxing tax all along the line, month by month, not year by year.
That is the point I want to make about this. It does not apply to this provision that is being brought in this year by the Minister. It applies generally throughout the code and through many other codes of taxation. Wealthy companies can afford to employ consultants either to enable them to keep within the law, but only just, or to save them money in certain ways, but a person who is paying income tax at a lower rate or without surtax cannot avoid payment because he will not have that expert advice.
This is a point which I should like the Minister to look at in this. All this legislation here is only making money for the boys. Certain types of legislation that is not consolidating legislation makes money for barristers and counsel. The same thing is happening here.
Comment on this
I appreciate the hardships which Senators have referred to, but the situation is simply this. To balance the Budget an extra £2 million is required. This £2 million is lost because some people will not pay their income tax in time. It may be a hardship on them to have to pay interest on it, but it is a question of balancing the hardship. If they do not pay it, somebody else has got to pay it, and it is subsequently paid by the man who is paying his income tax in time. You have got to pay more tax to make up for it. Which is the greater hardship? Who should pay in those circumstances? Obviously it is the man who does not pay in time.
It would be completely unfair to put a greater load on the man who pays his tax in time and to say to him: "In addition, because some people do not pay their tax in time, you must pay an extra six pence or an extra three pence, as the case may be, in your income tax to make up for them." People who are earning salaries and wages are really paying their tax in advance. They are paying every week, every month or every quarter, as the case may be, according as their wages or salaries are paid, in advance before they have got their full year's earnings. The other person is paying in arrears. He is assessed on the previous year's earnings. For both those reasons, while I sympathise with what has been said, I think if there is to be a hardship it should be on the man who has not paid in time.