Finance Bill, 1971 (Certified Money Bill): Committee Stage.
Contributions 121–239 of 239. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1971 ›
I think Senator Nash has put very lucidly some of the issues involved here. I do not think anybody could quarrel with the principles which he has enunciated. There are one or two other points which I want to mention. First, I think it was Senator Boland who mentioned the power under the existing law for an appeal commissioner to direct a payment. The problem that arises there is, first of all, that this is a matter for the commissioner himself; it is not a matter which will be controlled by the Minister for Finance. Secondly, the commissioner finds himself in the position that in many cases there are no accounts and he is not in a position to say what the amount of the payment should be if he has no figures on which to work. It is for that reason that it is necessary to supplement that power that exists.
I would regard this section and similar sections later as being very important in this whole Bill. For reasons of justice as between one taxpayer and another, as far as we can reach that outlined by Senator Nash, and equitable treatment as far as we can reach it as between one taxpayer and another, and also from the point of view of the Exchequer itself, it is important. For every day that tax which is properly due is not paid there is a cost to the Exchequer. When this is added up, over all the amounts due and not paid, it becomes quite a substantial burden which, as Senator Nash has pointed out, is borne by people who are paying their tax, and maybe by all the people who are paying their tax by deduction and paying in advance. It seems to me that the principle involved in this is one that all Members of the Oireachtas must support.
It is not unduly restrictive on a taxpayer in the sense that he has two months to pay and if he is disputing the amount he can either make an arrangement with the Revenue Commissioners, which will exempt him from liability to interest until the determination of the appeal, and then he had another two months in which to pay, or if he disagrees with the amount being suggested by the Revenue Commissioners he can make his own assessment. If he pays a sum which turns out to be 80 per cent of what was due, then he does not become liable for any interest and he has another two months from the date of determination of the appeal to pay the amount actually found to be due.
This is fair treatment for any taxpayer. Add to that the fact that if he overpays he gets back the overpayment plus interest at what Senator Boland has described as virtually a commercial rate. This is not unfair to any taxpayer. Somebody mentioned—I think it was Senator McDonald—the question of the possibility of going back over three or four years and charging interest at 9 per cent on that. That cannot arise because either the person has already been assessed and should have paid his tax before now, in which case he will be liable to 4 per cent up to the date of operation of this section and 9 per cent thereafter, or, if he has not yet been assessed but the Revenue Commissioners have come across him now and proceed to assess him in the next few months over the last three or four years, he is only liable for interest from the date of assessment. In that way the kind of situation that has been envisaged will not arise.
By and large, I do not think that any fault can be found with this provision on the basis of equity or on the basis of the interest of the Revenue Commissioners balanced against the interest of the individual taxpayer and the general taxpayer who is paying his tax and paying it promptly. The primary purpose in this section and in the other similar sections is twofold; it is, on the one hand, to ensure prompt payment of tax in the interest not only of the Exchequer but of all taxpayers, and secondly to ensure as far as we can equitable treatment as between one taxpayer and another. When one considers the situation of a taxpayer who is paying his tax by way of PAYE and compares that with the kind of case we are dealing with here, it can only be agreed that the kind of case we are dealing with here is being very fair and everybody is being generously treated.
Comment on this
I certainly should not like to be put down as speaking on behalf of people who do not want to pay their fair share of taxes. Nevertheless, I often wonder if the Revenue Commissioners, who look to be nice ordinary people, are getting a percentage "rakeoff" of the total proceeds or whether they are paid salaries in the ordinary way. I think the 9 per cent interest rate is punitive and I should prefer if such figures were not written into the Bill.
The bank interest rate is a variable figure; it goes up a half per cent one year, or down three quarters per cent another year, and I would prefer to see this section without the figure put in, or that the Minister could relate the figure to the prevailing interest rates. It may happen that in a year or some time in the future the Minister's 9 per cent may very well be 2 or 3 per cent higher than the prevailing interest rate. Any of these things can happen if the present rate of inflation continues. I consider legislation to be bad legislation when we start inserting figures that may be unfair or meaningless in a few years time. I do not remember if the Minister mentioned what percentage of the taxpayers would be involved in this or what percentage of the taxpayers were asked to pay the 4 per cent interest rate last year.
Senator Nash dealt, in some degree, with those people who are subject to PAYE. He made a case for them and I certainly would agree with the case he made. What about the company or the private concern who collected, free of charge and almost without thanks, the PAYE on behalf of the Government? If, through some clerical error or oversight, that money is not passed on by a company on the appropriate date is it fair to ask that company to pay 9 per cent interest because of this? Commercial life and business people in this country have saved the Exchequer and the Revenue Commissioners hundreds of thousands of pounds by the work they have put into collecting taxes since the introduction of PAYE. Indeed, they are getting scant recognition for their efforts and very little thanks.
I consider this section will place an added imposition on those companies, especially on companies with a high rate of company taxation. This point has been completely overlooked. I do not have to remind Senator Nash of this fact because as a businessman with considerable experience he knows all the pitfalls and difficulties in this regard. Whether those people be large or small employers we should not forget the valuable contribution they have made in saving the Revenue Commissioners many hundreds of thousands of pounds through their collection of the PAYE tax throughout the years.
In view of the fact that the bank interest rate is a variable figure I would ask the Minister to substitute for the 9 per cent some figure in proportion to the bank rate of the day. Each year the bank rate goes either up or down 1 per cent or 2 per cent. I can see the situation now whereby the bank rate should be reduced and those borrowing from banks would be very grateful if it did. The Minister is making a tremendous profit at the expense of people who, through no fault of their own, will be called upon to pay this rather punitive interest rate of 9 per cent. It is altogether too high, especially when we consider that any tax that may accrue from this money not being paid promptly will itself be subject to income tax. I think the Minister is trying to get it on the double. In his efforts to get people to pay their taxes more promptly—we would all like to see that—he seems to be coming down too hard on a minority of cases. We should endeavour, when dealing with legislation of this kind, to ensure that no section of the community will be put to the wall by virtue of a rather heavy imposition of the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
The case made by Senator McDonald was that it costs many companies a good deal of money to collect the PAYE tax. From practical experience it has been found that it takes one expert book-keeper an entire day per 100 employees to calculate the tax, prepare the tax slips, get it deducted and make out the net balance each week. Senator McDonald contends that in those circumstances the tax which is deducted must be sent on at the end of the month to the Revenue Commissioners. If that tax is not paid by the end of the month it carries an interest rate of 9 per cent. He feels that that is rather penal in the circumstances because, through illness on the part of one of the office staff or the accountant, through oversight or otherwise, it might easily be overlooked. He, therefore, considers it as a penal tax.
I am inclined to agree with him in that respect. PAYE must be met and you get no leeway. If you fill in the wrong amount because the bookkeeper is ill, three or four months later you will get the additional assessment with its extra 9 per cent. Considering this tax is paid in advance there should not be a penal interest like this if it can be established that it was a genuine mistake and that there was justification or an explanation for it. I can quite appreciate the difficulty of legislating especially for such matters.
There is no doubt that there would have to be a fixed rate of interest and the fixed rate of interest must correspond, more or less, with the rate the Government have to pay on national loans which at present is about 9 per cent. Next year, if we are fortunate enough to be able to borrow at 6 per cent, one would expect this rate of interest to come down in next year's Finance Act. I can appreciate that if 9 per cent is the borrowing rate, you would have to have a fixed rate of interest. The Minister was absent during portion of Senator McDonald's speech and I have taken the liberty of reiterating what he said, so that the Minister can explain his outlook on it.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister several questions on this section. I am sure that the Minister knows very well, from his present position and from his former heights of glory in the legal profession, that very often there can be a genuine disagreement between the tax inspector and the person concerned as to how much is actually owed. Under the provisions of this section, even in a case like this where genuine disagreement exists, the only way whereby a person can escape paying this punitive rate of interest is if he pays a figure which subsequently turns out to be 80 per cent of the decided amount after the appeal.
I should like the House to consider the case of a small shopkeeper, or indeed the case of a small door-to-door van salesman whom I heard about only a few days ago. He thought that he had settled his affairs with God and the Revenue Commissioners—sometimes I am not too sure who comes first; we know who comes last because in these cases they affect one in the land of the living and in the hereafter—and was suddenly asked to pay £85. Can one picture where a door-to-door van salesman, operating on a daily basis, making cash purchases and selling each day at doors, was going to find £85? If that man had a genuine disagreement with an inspector and he went on appeal, apparently the only way whereby he could escape paying 9 per cent interest rate on whatever figure the appeals commissioners finally decide is if he pays a figure which amounted to 80 per cent of £85. My financial adviser, Senator Belton, tells me that is £68. This would be quite beyond his means. Can the Minister say if this is a fair enactment in cases where there is genuine disagreement? Can he say if it is envisaged that there will be a minimum figure below which interest will not be charged, or if so that it will not be charged at this rate?
Let us take a figure of £1,000. Those who owed something below that figure and were disputing it and going to the appeals commissioner were probably again those least able to pay out immediately the figure involved. I suggest to the Minister that the section would have been far more acceptable had a minimum figure been included, below which the interest payments would not have been as harsh as those now envisaged. Perhaps the Minister would explain the position to us, first of all, in relation to the genuine disagreement, and, secondly, in relation to the apparent absence of a minimum figure. As we so often compare ourselves to Britain, I am interested to know what rate of interest is charged there? In addition, would the Minister consider the case of a trading company who could be placed in serious financial embarrassment because of the provision? Would he explain what the equivalent tax allowable interest rate would be for a trading company on a figure of 9 per cent interest?
Comment on this
If one takes the case of a trading company operating with certain allowances and making their normal returns, say, in the current financial year but the returns of the previous financial year are in dispute. Because they are in dispute, they go to the appeals commissioner; and with all the complicated procedures set out in section 17, they end up paying 9 per cent on whatever the final determined figure is. That 9 per cent is money which they are taking out of the current year's trading figures and out of the current year's operation. Consequently, it affects the current year's operation also to a greater degree. Would it be something which could be deductible in the current year's figures?
Comment on this
There is one thing which strikes me about Senator McDonald's suggestion to have a current rate. If the Minister accepted that, it would not be very popular in the country as current banking rates are slightly higher than the 9 per cent.
Comment on this
I mentioned to tie it to it, so that if the banking rate goes down this also goes down.
Comment on this
We also have a Finance Act every year. If the Minister considered that the 9 per cent was too high, I should hope that he would naturally bring the interest down to the bank interest rate if that was 6 per cent or 7 per cent. He must keep it almost in line with banking rates, because otherwise it would only encourage people to appeal every income tax claim and keep delaying it. It would be easier to pay, say, 6 per cent or 7 per cent interest to the Revenue Commissioners than to pay a high rate of bank interest on an overdraft.
Comment on this
That is the reason why he must bring the interest rate up to a realistic level. The Finance Bill is the one Bill that must be renewed every year. I know that the Minister and the Revenue Commissioners examine the records before the annual Budget, in order to keep an eye on who is escaping through the net and to try to prevent it.
Even if Senator Boland's door-to-door salesman had such a row with the inspector of taxes he was always at liberty to go to his solicitor or to an income tax consultant, or he could go to a public representative like the Minister. Between the three he might have been able to get some satisfaction. The Revenue Commissioners can be human at times. The Minister has been realistic in this figure because people were using it as another way of securing overdraft accommodation.
Comment on this
It should be clear that there must be a fixed rate of interest. If the taxpayer did not know what rate of interest he was liable to this would be a very unsatisfactory position. As has been pointed out it is reasonable to assume that in the event of a drop in interest rates with a Finance Bill coming in at least once a year there would be every opportunity to reduce the rate of interest in this corresponding to the drop in the going rate. If the Minister did not initiate such a change I am quite sure his memory would be jogged in either or both Houses of the Oireachtas. The only statutory exemption at the moment as regards an amount of tax due not being liable for interest is that interest is not chargeable on an amount of tax not exceeding £1. That is in relation to a point that was made by Senator Boland.
I do not think that there should be an approach on the basis that, if the amount due is below a certain figure, what might be regarded as a fairly reasonable figure, either no interest or a smaller rate of interest should be payable. I am reminding the House again of the fact that we are trying to achieve, as far as we can, equity between one taxpayer and another. Many taxpayers are paying, as has been pointed out, by deduction in advance. If one wants to get some kind of reasonable correspondence then those who have the advantage of paying in arrears should certainly not be given the further advantage of either paying no interest, if it is overdue, or a reduced rate of interest.
I understand that the rate of interest charged on unpaid tax in Britain is 6 per cent. It may be that arising out of this Bill they may change their minds on that, but that is their business. As far as I am concerned the going rate here is very close to 9 per cent. The Government actually pay a bit more than that at the moment and therefore the figure has to be at that level. I would say, in regard to the case referred to, that if there is genuine disagreement, which is justified, then the taxpayer would be found not to be liable for the tax and would not have to pay any interest. If, however, there is genuine disagreement but he is liable for the tax, then the fact that he has had a long period during the appeal in which he did not have to pay, it should not be available to him to avoid paying the tax and paying the interest on it, again comparing him with the person who has to pay in advance.
Comment on this
The position is that there are many appeals taken at the moment which are not bona fide and which are dropped at the door of the court. The whole object is to delay payment and thereby become liable only to the existing rate which is 4 per cent and thereby save money. It is well worth people's while to do this. We cannot allow this to continue by having a built-in inducement to do it. It is not in the interests of the general taxpayers that this should be allowed to continue.
The question was raised if interest paid in this way is allowable as a business expense deductible by a company. It is not and I do not think it should be. Their interest is payable in this way. It is payable because the company concerned were liable for tax and did not pay it in the due time. It would defeat the whole object of the exercise if one were to allow this to be a deductible tax expense. It would effectively reduce the rate of interest very substantially and it would give an advantage to a trading company not available to other taxpayers. This is intended to be in the nature of a penalty for non-payment of tax on the due date and thereby to induce prompt payment of tax. To allow it as a tax expense deduction would defeat the whole object of this section.
Reference was made by Senator Boland to the door-to-door salesman. I was reminded, when he was talking about it, of something that often comes to my mind. Whenever there is any talk of restraining dividends one is led to believe that all dividends are paid to widows with large families who are completely dependent on the dividends. One never hears of anybody else receiving dividends. Similarly, in this case, one might be tempted to think that all of the people concerned by this will be the small hard hit people. Of course, some such will be affected but most of them are not in that category at all.
Comment on this
Let us take the hard case, which as we know makes bad law, and examine it. In that situation this man got a demand for £85. Either he owed that money or he did not. Either it was due for tax or it was not. If it was not properly due, it was open to him to appeal and to establish that it was not due, in which case he did not have to pay that or the interest on it; but, if it was due, then it was due on profits which he had already earned. Although he may not have been well off there are plenty of other people paying tax who are less well off and they have to pay on the dot. I see no reason why he ought to get special treatment as compared with other taxpayers who are not as well off as he is.
It may be that he would have difficulty in paying this money. I would suggest that in such a case he would have to come to an arrangement with the Revenue Commissioners for payment of the money by instalments. He would, of course, have to pay interest on the money outstanding. He is already getting a privilege as compared with many other taxpayers who are not as well off as he is. Although that case may seem hard on the face of it, when it has been examined it does not seem that there is any particular injustice being done to that taxpayer as compared with many others.
Comment on this
Since a man gets no allowances for business expenses on the 9 per cent if he underpays, may it be assumed that, if he is overassessed, pays too much tax and gets the 9 per cent back from the Revenue Commissioners, he will not have to pay income tax on that?
Comment on this
I am still not convinced by the Minister's argument. In section 17 the 9 per cent should not be as definite as it is. I am not 100 per cent familiar with the paying over of the PAYE but I understand that there is a certain date of every month by which the previous month's tax must be sent in. The smaller the company, the more they will feel the pinch. Even a bank holiday can knock out some companies' schedule or if a bookkeeper falls ill or in the event of a strike, is it fair to clap on 9 per cent on a month's PAYE on companies when it is clearly not their wish that it had not been paid or it was outside their control?
If this section remains as it is it will be mandatory on the Revenue Commissioners to collect 9 per cent. Surely it is possible to amend this section in some way so that people who endeavour at all times to meet their obligations and are caught out by an industrial strike or even a bank holiday or illness of a person who deals with PAYE will not be penalised? The Minister must take into consideration situations of this kind because 9 per cent is a fairly heavy burden no matter how much PAYE is being paid. Would the Minister not have a clause in this Bill that would be enforced only where people consistently endeavour to evade paying? I cannot see that that would complicate matters very much.
All these companies are unpaid tax gatherers and I doubt very much if the Revenue Commissioners give any free time to this problem. Each company have to employ, at their own expense, people to send in the cheque in respect of PAYE each month. It is a mounting bill in practically all cases and is becoming more complicated with each Finance Bill. It is a pity the Minister cannot see his way to meet people who, through no fault of theirs, are unable to meet a deadline perhaps one month in the 12.
On the other hand, as Senator Crinion said, we have a Finance Bill here each year. I am here for about 11 years and this is the first year that the Minister came before the Seanad in a period when the Dáil was still in session. The cry then was, "We cannot attempt to amend this because the Dáil is not sitting." This year we have two weeks before the Dáil goes into recess and it is possible to put in an amendment. Otherwise there is no point in discussing an annual Finance Bill. The Finance Bill is never amended in the Seanad and hardly ever amended in the Dáil either.
I emphasise that 9 per cent is a very high figure and I refute the idea of having a definite figure. That is bad. It should be related in some way to the prevailing bank interest if it must be there at all. Perhaps the Minister might tell us how many people paid the 4 per cent in the last financial year. If the Minister is basing so much hope on increasing the revenue by jacking up the 4 per cent to 9 per cent he will be aware of how many people were called on to pay interest at the rate of 4 per cent and the total amount that this figure realised.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a question in relation to what Senator McDonald has said. He has mentioned the case of PAYE being stopped at source. The Minister, by way of answer to his question, said that it had to be in by the 5th day of the following month. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Nine days? In the event of it, not being in, for example, until 14 days or perhaps 21 days, has interest been charged?
Comment on this
Has it so happened? Has it been rigidly enforced? I know it has not been enforced in the case of turnover tax. I know the penalty is there.
Comment on this
The Minister appreciates that very often it takes time to fix up the affairs of the estate of a deceased. I envisage that among other hardships that this section might bring about you could have a situation whereby, because of the delay in taking out letters of administration, the executors would end up by being obliged to pay this interest rate also. Is that possible?
Comment on this
I want to correct something I said earlier where I referred to the existing rate as 4 per cent. I am afraid I was thinking of the estate duty section rather than income tax. The existing rate is, in fact, 6 per cent.
Comment on this
I would point out also in relation to the case about non-payment of PAYE that this is money which does not belong to the employer concerned but is tax deducted from his employees, and the employer has the use of that money which is not his. This is some compensation for the expense incurred. Senator Nash made a case earlier where there is a genuine mistake occurring. He went on to say that, while he felt this was a case that deserved consideration, he recognised there was considerable difficulty in legislating for it. There is. Senators will see that if they think about it. All I can say in that regard is that I will have a look at this and if I think something can be done about it I will bear it in mind for the next Finance Bill. Without having examined it, it appears to be almost impossible to frame a provision that will cover that case and will not lead to loopholes.
On the question raised as to what happens when tax is due and the taxpayer dies and there is a delay in taking out the probate or letters of administration, I am advised that when a taxpayer dies during the period of grace, that is, when interest has not begun to run, it is the practice to allow a similar period of grace from the date of extracting the probate or the letters of administration. During that period the tax may be paid without attracting interest. But where the taxpayer dies after the period of grace, that is when interest has already begun to run, then the interest charge is maintained up to the date of payment on the basis that the tax should have been paid prior to the taxpayer's death.
Comment on this
Yes. In the case where it was not due at the date of death, then allowance is made for the period of taking out the probate. This seems to me to be the fair and only possible approach to it, because the tax was due before the taxpayer's died anyway.
Comment on this
It would seem to me that if you began to charge interest from the date of probate and in addition charged interest for whatever period had elapsed from the time interest became payable up to the time of the death, that that would be fair, but I cannot see the fairness of including the period from death to letters of administration being granted.
Comment on this
It seems to me there are sufficient delays in the matter of administration of estates without building in another inducement for further delay.
Comment on this
That is a case I had not thought of but I can imagine in a case like that if a person were dying or if his death were expected his affairs would not usually run too smoothly around that period. If it were outside the period of grace, when interest was incurred, I know that there would be a number of cases where the executors may not have the power to make a payment to cover the tax without taking out letters of administration or probate. Anybody who has had the experience of taking out probate or even administration knows the great difficulties.
I would imagine that some arrangement could be made with the Revenue Commissioners because they will eventually get estate duty and probably death duty. If administration could be taken out in a week, a month or two months, I could see some sense in it, but sometimes this laborious business may run into a year and it would be a very heavy imposition on a small estate. It is not just a question of a person dying and executors having to take out probate. Nobody has the freedom to liquidate the debt with the Revenue Commissioners because they have not the authority to do so.
I do not know the solution to this problem but there is a very serious injustice built into the idea that if a person has tax outstanding at the time of his death he is outside the period of grace. This poor man is dead and it is the people who have to deal with his affairs who have the responsibility. You cannot write a letter to somebody and get probate the following day.
People who have a small estate could suffer a great hardship.
Comment on this
Senator Honan is quite right in this regard. The big trouble arises again in the estate duty section. We all know that if an estate is fairly substantial it sometimes takes six or eight months to clear it through the Estate Duty Office. Before you can do anything else you will be charged income tax, if it is due, plus 9 per cent. You will also have to pay estate duty plus 9 per cent.
Comment on this
Sorry, but you will not be charged the interest on the estate duty while the case is in the Estate Duty Office.
Comment on this
All right. Sometimes a businessman dies, then his auditors come along, take stock, get an up-to-date balance sheet and profit and loss account up to the date of his death. From my experience, if you can get them to do that within five or six months you are doing very well. You are allowed two or three months according to this Bill. There is no personal allowance whatsoever when you come to pay income tax on that estate before it is distributed. It will take 12 to 18 months before you can distribute it. You distribute it very quickly if you do it in 12 months. There is no personal allowance despite the fact that that man may have willed his estate to a son, daughter or somebody else. The executor is assessed with income tax on the estate without a personal allowance. The interest paid on estate duty is not allowable as an expense nor is the interest paid on the income tax.
If during the year the business makes a profit of £600 you pay income tax on the £600 without any personal allowance. If you have also paid as interest on estate duty of £100 you cannot set off that £100 against the £600. If you could it would help to balance things out. Likewise, if you could set it off as an expense in the case of a deceased person I think it would help. I realise the difficulty in drafting for all this. The Revenue Commissioners on their own initiative, with the consent of the Ministers representing Parliament, could make such an allowance.
I have found some cases of great hardship. If something like this could be cone, the executor could go along on his own initiative very often. He could borrow the money from the bank. He will pay the bank interest. He is not allowed to set off the bank interest. That is the trouble. If there could be some way whereby the interest on the estate duty and the interest on the tax, where tax is due, could be set off as an expense against the income from the estate and tax were then chargeable for the year after that on the net income of the estate, it would be much more equitable. I do not know if it is practicable. I should not like to be asked how you could draft legislation for it. If the Revenue Commissioners could do it on their own initiative it would avoid tremendous hardship. Perhaps the Minister would have a look at that.
Comment on this
I am genuinely surprised to think that the interest would be paid from the period of death to the time of taking out probate. It is really unfair.
Comment on this
I will have a look at the suggestion made by Senator Nash although we should remember that in some cases, maybe not in all, the estate is earning interest until the probate is taken out and the estate is distributed. I should also like to say in regard to a point raised by Senator Nash that the beneficiary under an estate, if he is the beneficiary of the income on the estate, on receipt of the income, can go back and claim the allowances. A sole beneficiary is normally regarded as being entitled to the allowances as from the date of death. I will examine this point. Again, I would remind the House that there is the other side of the coin that interest may be earned during this period when probate has not been taken out.
Comment on this
This is the section whereby when the appeal commissioners eventually decide that the unfortunate applicant was right all along and that the inspector was demanding too much tax from him, he will be entitled to get back the money in the event of his having already overpaid. May we just confirm the point made by Senator Nash that in that event the interest which is to be payable to him would not be taxed in that year?
Comment on this
In this section you are giving the poor innocent back something which you have already taken from him.
Comment on this
This is the section which raised quite an amount of contention in the other House because of the decision of the Minister to ally in one section the words "neglect" and "fraud." Certain people seemed to feel that cases of neglect, as defined, ought not to be included in the same section and be liable to the same sort of penalty as cases of fraud. There was quite a lengthy debate on it in the other House. Perhaps the Minister would again outline why it is equitable to equate fraud with neglect.
Comment on this
Of course the question of equating fraud and neglect is only superficially true. It is equating them for the purpose of section 5 but they are not equated for the purpose of the penalties which follow from fraud and the penalties which follow from neglect. In relation to other provisions of the law, one becomes liable for much greater penalties for fraud than one does for neglect. That is the first point I would make.
The second point is that neglect in the sense meant in this section is different from what is regarded as neglect by the layman. It does not comprehend what would be regarded as a genuine mistake made by the taxpayer. This point was raised some years ago when a somewhat similar provision was being made although, in a way, a more penal one in relation to the power of the Revenue Commissioners to go back over the taxpayer's affairs for an unlimited number of years where there has been fraud or neglect. On that occasion the late Deputy Sweetman raised this point in Dáil Éireann. In the course of the debate on it he asked the then Minister for Finance, my predecessor, to give an undertaking in his corporate capacity that if it should be held that a case of genuine mistake were to come within this definition of neglect, action would be taken to amend that position in legislation. My predecessor, in his corporate capacity, gave that undertaking. I repeated it in Dáil Éireann on this Bill and I am now repeating it here in this House. I am advised that no such interpretation has arisen but if it should arise I am repeating that undertaking in my corporate capacity.
Comment on this
We all agree as far as fraud goes but how far does neglect enter into it? Exactly what is meant by neglect?
Comment on this
This is the statutory definition of neglect which is incorporated in this Bill taken from section 186 2 (d) of the Income Tax Act, 1967:
In this subsection "neglect" means negligence or a failure to give any notice, to make any return, statement or declaration or to produce or furnish any list, document, or other information required by or under the Income Tax Act provided that a person shall be deemed not to have failed to do anything required to be done within a limited time if he gives it within such further time, if any, as the Revenue Commissioners' officer concerned may have allowed, and where a person has a reasonable excuse for not doing anything required to be done he shall be deemed not to have failed to do it if he did it without unreasonable delay after the excuse had ceased.
Comment on this
I accept that is fair. I would not be so perturbed as some of the people in the other House seem to have been. The point was made there, and I do not think answered very adequately by the Minister, that where somebody files returns for a tax year and through neglect in the office of the tax inspector, through the forms being overlooked and nothing further emanating from the tax office to the person concerned, it would be very fair on the part of that individual to decide that he would wait until the tax inspector contacted him. He should not have to contact the tax inspector and find out how much the tax inspector had decided he had to pay. At the same time, might he not fall into this category, assuming the tax inspector eventually finds his forms—this can happen because I know of a particular case— and might he not under this definition subsequently be found guilty of neglect by omission when in fact the neglect was really because of administrative error in the tax office?
Comment on this
No, I could not see such a case arising at all. Assuming that the taxpayer concerned has made such returns and accounts as are required and that the delay then occurs in the office of the inspector of taxes, the position then is that until the inspector of taxes has disposed of the matter and made an assessment, the man is not liable to pay tax and therefore he is not liable to pay interest on it. That is assuming the delay is solely due to a hold-up in the office of inspector of taxes. If, of course, the delay is due to the failure of the person concerned to make the return or if he has made an inaccurate return, then this question of neglect as defined here comes into play. One would have to examine each case on its merits.
Comment on this
Could I put it to the Minister another way? Supposing the tax inspector is not aware the person is working in the country—let us say he is employed by a British company and the tax is not being deducted by the British employer—the tax inspector is not aware of the existence of the person concerned but the person involved eventually contacts the tax inspector himself and says: "Look, I am here, in existence, earning money and I should be paying income tax but nobody has ever sent me a form to fill up so I have done nothing about it."
What is the situation now? They sit down together and they get details of his income over the past number of years while he has been in employment. Is he then immediately liable to the 9 per cent interest on foot of the definition of "neglect"? Let us take a second example where the same person contacts his tax inspector and says: "I am in existence. I am earning money, will you contact me." He hears nothing from the tax inspector for perhaps six months and at that stage files his returns for the previous two or three years and again hears nothing more from the tax inspector for six months. In each case there is some element of neglect, whether the man is coming within the legal definition as defined by the Minister or not, in the case of the person involved. There is also an element of neglect, at least to an equivalent extent, in the case of the tax inspector.
Comment on this
In neither of such cases would the Revenue Commissioners try to invoke this section.
Comment on this
As we are on this section, the Minister forgot to answer a question of mine on an earlier section but it is also applicable here. Here the rate of tax will be .75 per cent per month. When we were on section 17 I asked the Minister what the British equivalent was.
Comment on this
I did not reply to that; it is six per cent. I also said at the same time by mistake that ours was 4 per cent and I subsequently corrected that to 6 per cent. Our existing rate is 6 per cent and so is the British rate. The Senator may perhaps remember that I said that, arising out of this Bill, I might take a new approach to it.
Comment on this
I was complaining earlier on that the 9 per cent interest was rather punitive. Surely here we have a 12 per cent interest rate. I wonder what is the necessity for this abnormally high rate of interest? Is there any particular reason why it is necessary to penalise the local authorities to this extent, seeing that the Minister for Local Government is looking for low-cost housing?
Comment on this
Of course, no well-run local authority would become liable to this rate. What is involved here is the same rate which applies in the case of PAYE, wholesale tax and turnover tax. The reason that it is 12 per cent is that it is dealing with other people's money. It is not their money and if they hold on to it they have an additional advantage. That is the reason why the rate is at 12 per cent. I am quite sure no well-run local authority will become liable to this interest charge.
Comment on this
It was section 17 of the Finance Act, 1970, which gave rise to a big discussion here at that time. The Minister has said that no well-run local authority will be caught up in this.
Comment on this
The Minister will agree that it is the way in which it was interpreted by the Revenue Commissioners since 5th April. It is quite on the cards that a number of local authorities will be caught, because there were people working for local authorities who could be described as subcontractors who would have been caught up if representations had not been made and a different interpretation put on it from the one which is being put on it by the Revenue Commissioners. Would that be correct?
Comment on this
No, I do not think that is correct. The misinterpretation was by the local authorities, not by the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Perhaps that is what happened, but the subcontractor in that particular case was the victim of the misinterpretation of the local authority. I should like to see the correspondence from the Revenue Commissioners on their demand notes in that connection because they might be partly responsible for the misinterpretation by the local authority.
When we were discussing this here 12 months ago we were dealing with the subcontractor on the building site. At that time I prophesied that there would perhaps be a reduction in the output on the building sites, because these people would be inhibited in carrying on in the way in which they were. They were going to be caught up in the tax net. A very good case has been made by many Senators and by the Minister, with which we agreed, that a number of these people were not paying social welfare contributions, and in many cases, as a result of illness or perhaps death, the families of employees suffered.
The introduction of section 17 at that time has meant that perhaps some of the best workers who were engaged in the building industry are not in it any more. I have some experience of this and no matter how you try to encourage these people to pay their social welfare contributions or to make income tax returns they are not prepared to do it. A great many of them have left the country and the building trade and housing output have lost out as a result.
Comment on this
Does the Senator suggest that special preference should be given to these tax dodgers?
Comment on this
I should like to say, first, that I have not got here the correspondence from the Revenue Commissioners to local authorities but I have seen it in another connection. I think the fact that only a certain number of local authorities had difficulties, whereas most of them had not, is evidence enough that the difficulties arose on the part of some local authorities and they are being sorted out now. Those that could be sorted out before were those that could not have been sorted out in this section. On the remarks made by Senator Jack Fitzgerald I should like to say that I do not know how many of the "lumpers" have left the country as a result of this section. I doubt if anybody does. I suspect that it may not be very large because there are similar provisions operating across the water.
What I do know is that very many thousands of these men, especially in cities like Dublin, Cork, and Limerick who were out of the PAYE system simply as a tax dodge, have gone back into it, where they really should have been. By going back not alone are they, as touched on by Senator Jack Fitzgerald, paying tax, but they are paying their social welfare contributions and the very difficult situations that had arisen before, when there was illness or injury and they were not paying social welfare contributions, are being avoided. So far as I am concerned the operation of this particular section of the 1970 Act has been very successful in achieving the object we had in mind, despite the forecasts by some people in this House and in Dáil Éireann that we were wasting our time and it could not be done. I want to say that it is being done.
Comment on this
What evidence has the Minister that it is being done? How many of these people registered, as they were asked to do?
Comment on this
Some did, but what is more important is that the people who could not register as they were not genuine subcontractors have mostly gone back as employees paying PAYE, which is what they were originally and what they really should be.
Comment on this
But these people could not register because they had not a recognised place of business. As I pointed out 12 months ago, these were people who carried a hammer and trowel, had an old car or an old van and they performed the work of block-laying of a house or the foundations for the walls. This was their job and sometimes they worked 16 hours a day. Why were they not allowed to register from their own place of residence? Somebody was the boss of this little outfit; somebody was in control of it. There may have been three or four of them in it.
Comment on this
Why was no provision made for these people to register? Why was it only the people with the plush office who could register?
Comment on this
One of the reasons why the Revenue Commissioners were a bit strict on them was that they had been used to PAYE and they had been working satisfactorily. At one stage they worked for what they got out of it, out now that they are coming into the tax net the first time they will get a tax assessment on 1st January next when they will get a bill for quite a substantial amount. They will probably not be able to meet that bill because they will not have saved up to meet it. We had this situation in the mid-fifties, before PAYE, where young people at that time got bills on 1st January for £50 or £60 and they had no hope of meeting such high bills. In some cases they paid the tax by the week but, in most cases, it was a case of hopping across the water. Having had that experience, the Revenue Commissioners felt that, if an employee had not an established contractor, they would have the same trouble arising again.
My own experience has been that, where a contractor came up with a genuine case, and where he intended to meet his tax commitments, provided he had a letter from his auditor, the Revenue Commissioners accepted the explanation. The person must make a genuine case to show that he intends to pay the tax. In quite a number of cases contractors have dodged paying tax and they felt apparently that, if they could get registered, that would provide another way of dodging tax for another few years. The Revenue Commissioners need to be assured that the man intends to pay his tax commitments.
Comment on this
I think it is wrong of the Minister to bring into the net local authorities building houses by direct labour. As the Minister well knows these houses are mainly built by direct Government subsidy or Government grant. We have the constant difficulty of getting payment of such grants and loans from the Department of Local Government and it can very often happen that a lumper, or one of these small subcontractors, may be pressing the local authority very hard for payment for work done. It often happens that the county council may, in view of the pressures brought to bear on them, pay off some of these subcontractors out of other funds. It is unfair, therefore, to charge them 12 per cent on the moneys they would be deducting from these subcontractors or lumpers because the delay is caused by the Department of Local Government which has not received the money from the Department of Finance for the housing subsidies in question. It is a vicious circle and I think it is wrong; it adds an additional percentage, although the percentage may be small, to the unit costs of houses.
Surely in the case of local authorities and, indeed, in the case of voluntary building agencies, this 12 per cent could well be waived or dated at least from the date of payment of the grants or housing subsidies. This is a genuine difficulty. Some of these people may very well have to give in to pressure to pay a small subcontractor many months before the Department of Local Government transmits the housing subsidies or housing grants to the local authority. We, on local authorities, have this experience every year; we have difficulty in getting grants. If the houses are not completed until after Christmas we may very well have to wait until the beginning of the new financial year in April to receive our grants or payments. This is something that the Revenue Commissioners have overlooked. Seeing that it is all public money I see no reason why this imposition should be levied. The present trend seems to be—I think the Minister for Local Government has made a policy point of it— that the Department gives sanction more quickly to low unit cost housing than to the traditional type of houses councils built up to this. There is an anomaly here and the Minister should look again at this 12 per cent interest charge.
Comment on this
The interest should be due only after the payment of the State grants. This would hold good for the building societies as well. Both the voluntary housing societies and the local authorities are very dependent on the two-third State subsidy from the Department of Local Government. As the Minister knows, his own Department holds up the payment of these grants. This causes great difficulties in the local authorities and surely this is a case where the 12 per cent could be waived or at least backdated until the day of the payment of the grant or subsidy to the council.
Comment on this
I do not know what Senator McDonald has in mind. I do not intend to follow him up the alley of payments to local authorities by the Department of Local Government and sanctioned by my Department. We could argue for a long time on that point. The facts of the matter are that, if this provision for deduction was not there, the local authority would have to pay £100 to a subcontractor. Because of this provision the local authority will have to pay only £65. Whatever way you look at it, the local authority is paying less than it would otherwise pay if this provision were not there. Leaving aside all the extraneous matters, the effect of this will be that the local authority will pay less at the moment out of their allegedly strained resources than they would otherwise be paying.
Comment on this
The Minister is obviously basing his argument on the fact that there is £100 due to a lumper or subcontractor, and the local authority, because of pressure, pays off the contractor. They may not have the money to do so but sometimes, if the council makes a good case and the figure is not too high, a small contractor can get paid perhaps an instalment on his money. This money may not be out of the appropriate grant.
Comment on this
But if this were not here they would be paying him £100. Because of this compulsory deduction they pay him only £65.
Comment on this
Yes, but the Minister, by virtue of this section, is putting the onus on the council to pay the remainder of the £100 direct to the Revenue Commissioners before they get it from the Minister's Department. The Minister is the fly in the ointment.
Comment on this
I am in favour of the section up to a point. I am in favour of the section if the Minister would agree to waive the 12 per cent interest rate in respect of local authority and voluntary housing societies. The local authority cannot pay out 100 per cent of the cost until the Department of Finance and the Department of Local Government, between them, make up their minds to pay the housing subsidy which amounts to 75 per cent of the cost, in my county anyway, to the local authority. Sometimes we wait for six to nine months, perhaps a year, for payment. Is it fair to ask a subcontractor to wait that length of time, until the Department of Finance condescend to allow the Department of Local Government to pay the housing subsidy? It is possible, and in many cases a point can be stretched, to give the subcontractor his 65 per cent. We would all be agreeable to that. Would the Minister not give us the concession of not having to pay the 35 per cent until such time as the grants come through from the Department of Local Government? This is a very reasonable request Otherwise, he is going to inflate the estimates. When you start a housing scheme it is impossible to estimate the exact date on which the grants will come through, especially if the houses are completed in, say, the months of December, January or February. In those cases, it is most likely that the housing subsidy will not come through until the beginning of the next financial year. Any Member of the House who has any knowledge of local authorities knows that. This section is designed to inflate the cost of local authority housing, despite the fact that we are making every effort, at the direction of the Minister for Local Government, to contain the unit cost of local authority housing.
Comment on this
My experience of local authorities is that if the contractor who is dealing with a local authority mentions to the Revenue Commissioners the amount of work that he is doing and produces a letter from an auditor, he will have no trouble in getting registered. I know of quite a few. They were caught in the month of May and I think every one of them has since been registered. Normally, they are contractors of standing. In regard to the subsidy, my experience has been that the local authority is never allowed to go ahead until the loan is sanctioned for the houses.
Comment on this
I am glad that the Senator made that point, because I did not want to be solely defending my Department. However, this is the basic point in the whole argument.
Comment on this
That more or less covers the point, because they cannot go ahead until the loan is sanctioned.
Comment on this
I can see Senator McDonald's point. The loan is sanctioned. I have acted for contractors many times in this connection. However, it is one thing to sanction a loan and another thing to collect it. Frequently, the local authority will not collect its loan until six or eight months after it is due and the unfortunate contractor is out of his money. Senator McDonald's point is as follows: let us assume that a contractor at that stage, as many of them are "lumpers", is due £1,000. For one reason or another, he has not registered; he is careless and is usually one of those fellows who carries his books in his head. If in that case before the local authority get the subsidy, in order to help him out, they borrow £650 from a bank and give it to him on account, they should not have to borrow a further £350 to give to the Revenue Commissioners. In other words, their liability to the Revenue Commissioners should not arise until such time as they get the money from the Department.
Comment on this
It does arise. The subcontractor has done his job. They enter into a contract with him and their liability is to him. It is no part of the contract that he is not going to be paid unless and until they get the subsidy. The contractor is due his money. One of the reasons why local authorities at the moment find it so very hard to get contracts at a reasonable price is because they are so slow to pay.
Comment on this
There are a vast number of small contractors doing work for local authorities at the moment. They are gravely embarrassed and I have heard many of them say that they will never again touch a contract for a local authority. Some local authorities realise this, and before they get the subsidy they borrow money from the bank and make a payment on account to him. Senator McDonald's point is that they are making this man a payment on account of half or two-thirds of what is due to him. If they pay only the £500, they should not right away have to pay another £250 or £300 at that point. In other words, they should not be liable to pay the tax until they get the subsidy.
Comment on this
Yes. They will not get that until six months after a contract is finished.
Comment on this
But surely the contract provides that the full payment is due to the contractor at a time which relates it to the payment of the subsidy, because his work has to be inspected and passed.
Comment on this
The contract provides as follows: periodically his work is inspected by the engineer. A certificate will be passed to him for 90 per cent of the work done. Therefore, when he has his work done, when his houses are ready for occupation, he calls on the engineer to inspect them. The engineer inspects them and passes them at that stage. Then there is usually 10 per cent or 5 per cent left over for six months, in order to ensure that there are no defects. He is entitled to his money then. In 19 cases out of 20, the unfortunate man will have to wait for a further six to eight months for the subsidy. Every member of a local authority, including Senator Crinion, will admit that. This is one grave defect in local authority housing and it is pushing up the cost of it.
Comment on this
The inspection has been carried out. The money is not available.
Comment on this
I think that we have gone completely away from the section and I hope that I was not responsible for that, because it was Senator McDonald, Senator Boland and I who initially raised the question. There has been talk about county council "lumpers" or subcontractors. As discussion developed, I find that the subcontractor in this context is a housing contractor who submits a tender in reply to advertisements in a local paper for the building of local authority houses. He is a contractor and is not a "lumper" or subcontractor.
Comment on this
Therefore, I submit that we are dealing with two different things. I was amazed when I heard my colleague, Senator Crinion, trying to confuse the genuine contractor who has a place of residence with the lumper who the Minister submits, has not a place of residence.
I should like to refer to a point raised by Senator Nash. I do not know if Senator Nash is a member of a local authority. I am a member of one, and in fairness to local authorities, I do not agree that there is any hesitancy on the part of contractors to tender for work of the local authorities because they are slow to pay. Those of us who are members of local authorities will agree that every effort is made by way of payment to induce contractors to proceed and finish the contracts which they have tendered for. It is unfortunate that so many contractors have so much other work apart from local authority work so that the local authority comes second in many cases.
Senator Ó Maoláin passed a remark that I was making a case for those tax dodgers. I was not making a case for those people described by the Leader of the House as tax dodgers. I was making a case for their right to register and go to McInerneys, Walls or any of the other big contractors and take a site for houses from them to build by subcontract from the foundations to the wall-papering or to do any other work that they wish to do by subcontract. They should be entitled to register as such. They should not have to have registered offices. In that way they would have to pay their taxes because the contractor who had employed them would be liable under PAYE for their income tax. That is the way I understand the section. If I am not correct perhaps the Minister will tell me so.
Comment on this
First of all, on the suggestion made in relation to this section, I cannot accept it for a number of reasons. I do not wish to enlarge the scope of the debate but let me point out that, if it were accepted, within a few weeks of the payment being made by the local authority to the subcontractor that subcontractor would be demanding from the Revenue Commissioners a refund of the sum retained by the local authority which would not have been paid by the local authority to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Would the local authority have to supply it themselves if they did not submit it to the Revenue Commissioners?
Comment on this
It is the only relevant point that arises.
Comment on this
I would also like to say that, as far as I know, the cases about which Senator Crinion was speaking were, in fact, genuine subcontractors or lumpers because if they were not the problem would not have arisen. It was that precise problem which Senator Fitzgerald spoke about, registration, and it was the registration which Senator Crinion had come up against and had dealt with. Perhaps I might be allowed to indicate what the broad policy is as it has been operated. It has been to refuse certificates to labour only subcontractors who, in general, are not more than itinerant tradesmen operating from their homes or lodgings who frequently move from place to place with no established place of business. These are the cases in which there has been widespread evasion of tax in the past. In some cases of labour only, subcontractors certificates have been issued where the circumstances were exceptional. These would be, for instance, where the subcontractor has been charged to tax under Schedule D on the basis of regular returns and accounts or where the business was on such a scale that it could clearly be said to be an established place of business. This was indicated in the Bill and the regulations connected with it. It has operated as envisaged and it has operated very successfully. If I may return to the section. I repeat that the effect of the suggestion being made would be that the Revenue Commissioners would be asked to pay refund tax which in fact they had not received.