We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971 ( Certified Money Bill ) : Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–207 of 614. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971
Enacted

No. 30 of 1971 ›

Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The interpretation section omits to give interpretations in respect of a number of matters which are referred to in different sections throughout the Bill. For example, "be appointed today for the purposes of keeping the register" is not interpreted in this section. There is no definition of "delivery"; this is defined in section 3. There is no definition of "the rendering of services"; this is defined in section 5. There is no definition of "stock-in-trade". None of this may be thought important until you consider that "an accountable person" is defined in section 1 as "a person who is an accountable person in accordance with section 8". Yet you find in section 4 (5) (a) that "a person shall ... be deemed to be an accountable person".

Turning to section 16, there is an obligation on keeping records and the question arises whether the person referred to in section 4 (5) (a) who is deemed to be an accountable person is an accountable person by virtue of the failure of section 1 to include "deemed an accountable person" for the purposes of the Bill. This is important because persons who are given the duty of keeping records are subject to penalties if they do not.

With regard to the definition of "stock-in-trade" which is found in section 34 and not in section 1, the definition in section 34 is for the purposes of section 34 only and is not for the purposes of any other section in the Bill.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister a question regarding the definitions in section 1. There is a definition of livestock in section 1, namely, "‘livestock' means live cattle, sheep, pigs and horses". If horses are included, why not include ponies, donkeys and greyhounds? Are these livestock within the meaning of this Bill? If sheep are included, why not include goats? There are some possibilities in the breeding of special purpose goats.

Comment on this

I should also like to ask about the definition of "livestock". "‘Livestock' means live cattle, sheep, pigs and horses". In section 8 it will be found that poultry farmers are deemed to be accountable people. There is no reference to this except in Schedule I where it states "live animals". It is stretching the imagination to call a chicken an animal. Zoologically speaking, you might say the animal kingdom is divided into three, but if you speak on poultry and eggs you should mention the source from which they come.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister about one or two matters? Why, in section 1, is the term "promotion of dances" used? Can it not refer to the promotion of any other activity, or is there a special reason for singling out dances in this section?

With regard to the reference to customs-free airport, does that mean that the country will continue to have only one customs-free airport? Can this apply to an airport other than a customs-free airport, such as Dublin Airport? The interpretation of the word "established" in the section means having a permanent establishment. Could the Minister elaborate on that? Would a permanent establishment include, say, a mobile home?

Comment on this
George Colley Minister for Finance (Mr. Colley) Fianna Fáil

With regard to the definition of "livestock", the reason for the limitation of this definition to live cattle, sheep, pigs and horses, is that these are the animals which are sold through marts. There are special provisions later in the Bill which cover these sales.

With regard to the promotion of dances, there is a special rate provided in the Bill which substitutes for the existing tax on dances. It is the only item to which this rate applies.

With regard to the customs-free airport the definition refers to the only existing customs-free airport. If another customs-free airport were to be established the legislation establishing it would presumably include a provision including the customs-free zone under this definition section.

On the point raised by Senator Farrell, the position is that a person who operates a poultry farm on a commercial scale is entitled to adopt the special arrangements for unregistered farmers, provided his sales do not exceed £1,000 per two-month taxable period. That would be £6,000 per annum. Such a person may opt for registration if he so wishes. It would be in his interests to do so if he was likely to incur heavy capital expenditure on buildings or equipment and a substantial proportion of his produce was either exported or sold to registered persons within the State. A poultry farmer whose sales exceed £1,000 per taxable period is required to register and will be treated for tax purposes as an ordinary trader. He will not, however, lose by this requirement because he will obtain full credit for tax suffered on his inputs, for example, buildings, equipment and fuel and he can pass on a tax credit to his registered customers.

Day-old chicks are regarded as live animals for tax purposes and, consequently, the rate of tax chargeable on these when sold by a registered person will be the lower rate of 5.26 per cent. Larger customers are likely to be registered for tax and they can get full credit for any tax suffered on their purchases. Sales between unregistered farmers will not be liable to tax. The larger poultry farmers who are required to register for tax are unlikely to be prejudiced by competition from smaller unregistered producers. The reason for this is that unregistered producers will suffer tax on their inputs. The tax credit which they will be able to pass on to registered customers will be limited to 1 per cent of their sales to such customers, as compared with the credit of 5.26 per cent which registered poultry farmers will be able to pass on.

Comment on this

I should like to raise this point again under section 8. We are only dealing with the livestock end of it now.

Comment on this

My question is much the same. Can I take it that the £1,000 per taxable period will be the governing feature of a poultry farm? I am thinking of poultry farms which are integrated with an ordinary farm supplying eggs to a hatchery or broiler breeder units which would be part of a bigger farm. How would they be affected?

Comment on this

Arising from the Minister's reply on the definition of "livestock" as animals going through a mart, do horses passing through the RDS sales ring come under this definition?

Comment on this

They will be treated the same way.

Comment on this

How about greyhound sales? They are sold in similar circumstances at Shelbourne Park. At the Connemara pony sales, would a pony qualify as a horse in this definition?

Comment on this

The greyhounds would be liable at 5.26 per cent. I understand horses include ponies.

Comment on this

And donkeys?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Where do we draw the line?

Comment on this

The animals normally sold in the mart. In reply to Senator Crinion's query, the operation of the poultry farm would be treated as part of the whole of the operation. The figure of £1,000 per taxable period would relate to the poultry farm operation.

Comment on this

I should like to raise a point on this section. It states "value-added tax on goods imported into the State". I raised this point on Second Reading but I was unable to follow it through. What is the situation with regard to tax on goods imported into the State? Let us take the example of clothing made in England as compared with the similar clothing made here. If the clothing is made here and sold on the Irish market it has to carry the full value-added tax. If similar clothing is made in England and arrives here in a finished condition, will it have to carry the same tax as it would carry if it had been manufactured here?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I was worried about that point in case the imported articles would have an advantage.

Comment on this

There is no advantage.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The transfer of ownership in paragraph (d) takes in the case of an acquisition by the State and also the seizure by a person acting under statutory authority. It does not appear to take in the case of the property being passed by judicial order where there is no agreement between the parties.

Comment on this

Could the Senator elaborate a little on what he has in mind?

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Only what I have said. It might be the result of a dispute. It might be a "got together" dispute when you have such things under which the property is effectively passed by virtue of the judge's order. There is no seizure. The person who has argued the case apparently badly and has got the judgment which he expected against him allows the property to pass by virtue of the judicial order without the intervention of any seizure process. It seems to me that you would want to catch that transaction as a delivery.

Comment on this

I am trying to visualise the situation in which there is an actual transfer solely by virtue of the court order and no other instrument. The Senator is more in touch with these matters than I am now but I take it that such a thing is possible?

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

It has been thought of as a method in relation to other tax and statutes.

Comment on this

In the event of a compulsory purchase order by a local authority where they require a good deal of land for building, will the individual have to pay tax on it? A farmer or a person who owns a house which is compulsorily acquired would take a very poor view of this compulsory acquisition and then have a tax also.

Comment on this

It would be so liable because, if it were not, there would be two values for land—one in the case of land which was not subject to the tax and one case in which it was subject. The whole object of this bill, as far as possible, is to achieve neutrality in all these transactions—to ensure that no advantage accrues to one particular class as against another. For that reason, it is necessary to ensure that tax would apply in all those circumstances.

In regard to the point raised by Senator FitzGerald, I am not sure whether the kind of transfer he has in mind solely under court order is, in fact, covered. This is a matter I will have to examine.

Regarding the point raised by Senator Crinion, the question of liability to tax arising in a compulsory purchase order case would, of course, only apply where there had been work done by way of development of the land. In the ordinary course of acquisition of land for development by a local authority, it would not be developed land within the meaning of the Bill and, therefore, the tax would not arise.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

One question for clarification. With regard to paragraph (f), I take it this is to catch within the tax net an accountable person—for example, a person who brings home his own goods and uses them for his own purpose? It would also mean that accountable persons would be caught within the tax net in respect of their charitable gifts if they decided to give groceries or old clothes to the St. Vincent de Paul Society. Strictly speaking, I take it they would be caught?

Comment on this

They would be caught.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is there any power taken anywhere in the code to give the Revenue Commissioners a right to exempt such transactions?

Comment on this

There is power given in the Bill—not to the Revenue Commissioners but to the Minister—to order a repayment in certain circumstances where it is clear that it would not have been the intention that the person would have been subject to tax; but to provide an exemption would create all sorts of difficulties and anomalies. Theoretically, it would be possible for the Minister in the circumstances described by Senator FitzGerald to provide that tax would not be payable. I do not want to give the impression that such an order would be made because it could certainly be open to abuse.

Comment on this

Following the Minister's reply to Senator FitzGerald, how would the amount of tax be assessed? On what sum? How would you value a gift?

Comment on this

The cost price to the trader concerned.

Comment on this

If it is a question of a charitable bequest or gift, how would you assess the value of the gift?

Comment on this

For instance, if a shopkeeper were to make such a gift, then the basis of value would be what it cost him.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The value added would be ignored. There would be no value-added tax here.

Comment on this

For the purpose of assessing the tax it would be the cost to him.

Comment on this

There are certain homes for elderly people in Limerick city and elsewhere where traders each week give a free gift of goods or foodstuffs. Would they be liable for tax on these and would they have to re-claim it, or would the institution itself be liable? There is an old men's home in Limerick run by the St. Vincent de Paul Society and a number of traders donate foodstuffs each week. Is the home liable for tax?

Comment on this

The traders would be liable, as they are liable at the moment to turnover tax.

Comment on this

How would the recoupment take place? Would the institution be liable for tax on the cost price of the goods, even though the goods were given free?

Comment on this

The trader would be liable. Let us suppose he furnishes some item to the home. He purchases this. It costs him a certain amount and he has to pay turnover tax on that item at the moment. The position in practice from his point of view would be exactly the same under value-added tax.

Comment on this

The institution would not be liable for any tax?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Under this section, there is the question of delivery. It says in section 3 (1) (b):

the handing over of the goods to a person pursuant to an agreement which provides for the renting of the goods for a certain period subject to a condition that ownership of the goods shall be transferred to the person on a date not later than the date of payment of the final sum under the agreement,

Does this cover hire purchase transactions or sales of houses under a loan, in which case the delivery would not take place until the final payment possibly 25 years after the original transaction was made? Am I misreading the section or is that the intention?

Comment on this

It is intended that the section would apply to hire purchase transactions, but the housing situation is dealt with under section 4.

Comment on this

What about hire purchase transactions, say, in motor cars?

Comment on this

Yes, that would come under this section.

Comment on this

Effectively, that would not take place until three years after. Is that correct?

Comment on this

In the case visualised by the Senator, the delivery would take place at the commencement of the hire purchase agreement because the goods would have been handed over at that point.

Comment on this

Maybe I am misreading it. The last two lines of that subsection state:

Not later than the date of payment of the final sums under the agreement.

Comment on this

Subsection (i) provides:

In this Act "delivery", in relation to goods, shall include—

(b) the handing over of the goods to a person.

That is the operative part. It continues:

... pursuant to an agreement ...

It goes on to describe the kind of agreement. The kind of agreement envisaged here is one in which the legal ownership does not transfer until, say, three years, as the Senator visualises in the hire purchase of a car. For the purpose of value-added tax, the delivery takes place on the handing over of the goods.

Comment on this

So it is liable to tax, the same as if it were a cash transaction?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Subsection (3) deals with the auction of goods. There are charities which hold draws and auctions to which people send in goods either to be raffled or auctioned. Would these be taxed? The ICA have country markets where members sell their produce to customers. This is a completely voluntary body. Would these also be liable to tax?

Comment on this

Liability arises only where sales are made in the course of trade, so the kind of auction which the Senator visualises would not be in the course of trade and therefore would not attract tax. A raffle is specifically excluded. Jumble sales are also excluded. The ICA sales to which the Senator referred would be excluded on the grounds that they are not in the course of trade. It may be that in certain circumstances it could be said that some of these operations amount to operations in the course of trade. In that event they could become liable to tax. The test would be whether it was in the course of trade.

Comment on this

These country markets are part of the activities of the ICA. They are a charitable organisation and as such cannot trade. This is a voluntary organisation; a type of small co-operative where the producers of the locality get together as a co-operative body and sell their goods on a particular day of the week. The Kilternan market is a well-known market in the Dublin mountains.

Comment on this

Does the Senator know whether they are liable to turnover tax?

Comment on this

I do not think they are liable to turnover tax. Under this rule about a producer of agricultural goods—the one the Minister quoted of £1,000—they might well be exempt because the amount of money taken in by any individual producer in such a market would be very small. It would only be a few pounds per week for any producer. They certainly would not produce £1,000 worth per annum.

Comment on this

I think Senator Farrell is right in so far as they would come in under the course of trade and they would go out again because of the level of business transacted. If it amounted to less than £6,000 per year they would not be liable for tax. I would assume that it is on this basis that they are not liable to turnover tax also because the exemptions are approximately the same.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think I understand the purpose of subsection (5) of this section, which provides that the transfer of ownership as security or in connection with the transfer of a business shall be deemed not to be a delivery. I do not understand—perhaps the Minister will explain it to me —why the Fourth Schedule goods are excluded. If Fourth Schedule goods are subject to this high rate of tax, are they to be treated, in principle, in a different way from the way in which the 16.37 per cent goods or the 5.26 per cent goods are treated. Is there a loophole which needs to be covered?

Comment on this

No. This is intentional. If part of the stocks of a manufacturer of these goods which are liable at a very high rate were transferred to a retailer, we think it would be desirable that the tax at the 30.26 per cent rate should be charged at that point, leaving the subsequent sale by the retailer at only 5.26 per cent which is the same rate as nearly all the other groups he is handling. It is a special situation in relation to these goods in the Fourth Schedule only.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is it the same with the 16 per cent ones?

Comment on this

No. It is not the same position there, where it is the whole which is passed on. What is happening in the high rate goods is that only the 5.26 per cent is passed on. In other words, apart from the 5.26 per cent, the rest of the tax is paid at the early stage and thereafter these goods are treated in the same way as those in the low rate. It simplifies operations for retailers, in particular, and for everybody concerned.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think I understand.

Comment on this

In subsection (5) (ii) it is provided: "where goods are held as security for a loan or a debt, upon repayment of the loan or debt...." Is tax charged on the actual goods? If a person owed money to a garage proprietor and left his car in for repair, the garage owner would not release it until the full debt was paid and if it was held for a period of time, would he have to pay tax on the car or on the actual loan?

Comment on this

In the case described by the Senator, there would not be a transfer of ownership. The type of case envisaged here is a deal with a pawnbroker.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like to raise one or two points on this section. The question of interest is defined in paragraph (d) of subsection (1) where a mortgage is excluded. What is there to prevent somebody who wants to, passing the interest by creating a mortgage for a sum very substantially in excess of the value of the immovable property in question and then transferring the benefit of the mortgage? The mortgage itself is not an interest. Ten times nothing is still nothing, and the transfer of what is not an interest could not be an interest.

It is not a question of being unable to see the wood for the trees in this Bill but there are so many leaves I do not even know what tree I am looking at very often.

Comment on this

I do not blame the Senator.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The second question I wish to ask is what is there to prevent—this may well have been contemplated—someone who wants to transfer immovable goods taking advantage of the exempted activity provision and transferring the shares in the company who hold the immovable goods so that the immovable goods never transfer at all and still remain the property of the original owner and all that is passed is something which is exempted from taxation by virtue of being an exempted activity? I know this will get caught for other purposes but it seems to me that it will not be subject to wholesale tax. If you have a straight sale of developed property which is subject to wholesale tax and a type of operation whereby you can transfer the interest without exposing it to wholesale tax, it would seem that people will opt for the type of operation which will leave it outside the wholesale tax.

Comment on this

First of all, in the situation envisaged by Senator FitzGerald of the transfer, for example, of shares in a company so that the actual ownership does not pass but remains in the company, this was considered, but it was decided not to provide against it because, on the one hand, to provide for it would involve very complex provisions somewhat analogous to the rather complex provisions we have in connection with liability to other taxes. The Bill is already complex enough. Secondly, it was felt that in most cases any transfer would be between accountable persons, in which event making them liable to tax would not make any real difference in the long run. Anybody so becoming liable could pass it on. It may be that some transactions will get through the net but, in so far as they do, we will have a similar situation to that envisaged by Senator FitzGerald.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

You will see the fish as they are coming.

Comment on this

The transfer of a mortgage as distinct from the actual execution of a mortgage could well be exempt. The Senator is right. It could be exempt. I am not trying to pronounce on this authoritatively, but it could well be outside the net. We think that in most such cases the transactions would be between accountable persons and, therefore, it would not make any difference. If, however, we see the fish coming—as the Senator said—and a few getting through to the extent that it would indicate that this was a loophole which was being availed of to defeat the purposes of the Bill, there is always the possibility of amending legislation.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

To help the Minister in his amending legislation, I wonder whether subsection (2) which deals with the disposal of an interest which is defined in the previous subsection, which derives therefrom, would take care of the case where it is only a part of the interest which is transferred, where, for example, a person having sole ownership decides to reduce his fractional interest to a 1000th part and to transfer 999 parts to someone who pays him for it?

Comment on this

Yes, that would be caught. Subsection (2) refers to "goods to which this section applies disposes, as regards the whole or any part of those goods, of that interest or of an interest which derives therefrom". That would cover the situation envisaged by Senator FitzGerald.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I do not think it would because the interest itself alone will be divided. It will be an interest in the whole of the goods and it will not be a derivative interest from the interest in the goods.

Comment on this

This form of wording has been used and operated in another code but it may be that the Senator has something in mind which I have misunderstood. In that event, I will examine it further with a view to possible amending legislation.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Thank you. Could I get complete clarification as to what is intended here? It is only intended to catch within the net of the value-added taxation, sales or transactions in property which is developed. The ordinary sale of property is not within the wholesale net if there is no development within the definition in the Act?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

So those of us who have to operate this code have really only to concern ourselves where we are dealing with a developed property?

Comment on this

And development which takes place after the commencement of the tax.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

After the specified date?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I notice the use of the words, in subsection (5), of "other than transport services". Is it absolutely clear what is taken in by "transport services"? Can we look to the transport code for a definition in that regard?

Comment on this

The term is not defined in the Bill. What is envisaged is the carriage of goods.

Comment on this

What about taxis?

Comment on this

No. We are dealing here with goods. Passenger transport is exempt. On that basis I presume that taxis, unless they were carrying goods, would be exempt but this raises a different——

Comment on this

Only goods?

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is the word "services" included? That would take in that type of transport?

Comment on this

There is provision in regard to passenger transport.

Comment on this

Is it resale? Does it apply to secondhand goods?

Comment on this

Effectively, the position is that the sale of secondhand goods will be the same under the value-added tax as it is at present under turnover tax. There are certain circumstances in which they are liable, and certain circumstances in which they might not be liable. But it would be the same position under value-added tax. Substantially the answer is: "Yes, they are liable."

Comment on this

Would it include the sale of property of any kind?

Comment on this

It depends on what the Senator means by "property". Does he mean fixed property such as land, buildings?

Comment on this

Houses were referred to on the last section.

Comment on this

They must be developed since the commencement of the operation of the Bill to become liable to value-added tax.

Comment on this

Every time they are sold after that, they will have a value-added tax on them?

Comment on this

So far as they have been developed. It applies only in the case of a sale in the course of business. A private sale of a house from one private person to another private person, neither of whom is in the business of buying and selling houses, does not attract value-added tax.

Comment on this

Even though there is a difference in the price?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In the case of new cars would the Revenue Commissioners agree to a tax so that the garage can advertise a car at a list price, which will include taxes? We had that in the first tax. The price list of new cars includes turnover tax. Is there a provision in this that they can do the same with the value-added tax?

Comment on this

They can do it, but there is no provision in the Bill to compel them to do it.

Comment on this

But there is provision——

Comment on this

There is nothing to stop them from doing it.

Comment on this

Am I right in thinking that this section deals with all types of services? It is headed "Rendering of services". Does it include services not specifically set out in the section, such as advisory services, consultative services, domestic employment agencies? Are they all included under that section?

Comment on this

It includes all that are not exempted.

Comment on this

How would the value-added tax operate in, say, a domestic service agency? Who would be liable for it in the final stage? Is the person who engaged the employee liable, or is the employee himself liable? Who, in fact, would pay it?

Comment on this

The agency would be liable to account for it to the Revenue Commissioners. Presumably in those circumstances they would make provision for this in their charges.

Comment on this

Would the sale of a business come under the value-added tax?

Comment on this

I have to refer the Senator back to section 3, subsection (5) (b) (iii) which reads:

...in connection with the transfer of a business or part thereof to another accountable person...

That is excluded from liability.

Comment on this

Subsection (1) of section 6 provides:

Tax shall not be chargeable in respect of any exempted activity.

The Minister may by order declare the delivery of goods of any kind or the rendering of a service of any kind to be an exempted activity.

If the Minister declares the delivery of goods or some service to be exempted, does that mean they are exempted from all taxes at the different stages of which the value-added tax would apply or does it mean that they are only exempted at a certain stage? I am not quite clear what the effect of making an exemption order would be. Perhaps if the Minister would elaborate on this, it might eliminate the necessity for any further question in the matter. As of now I do not quite understand what the effects would be. I know that a person would be exempted in the sense that he would not be liable for value-added tax. At the same time, he would not be able to recoup any tax——

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

The stage at which he had made the order—is that correct?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Minister that in this section—I suppose it is too late to do it now but, obviously, when this Bill is enacted and has been in operation for some time, the Minister will see the need for some adjustments—it would be advisable for him to take power to ensure that certain services or deliveries are zero rated? As I understand it, under this section he can only grant an exemption order. He cannot grant non-liability for all taxes, or the right to recoup taxes, by making a service or a delivery of goods zero rated. Would it not be advisable at this juncture to provide for that power in the Bill?

Comment on this

The power to which the Senator refers is provided in section 10 (8). All that is dealt with in this section is the power to exempt. The Senator is quite correct in what he says. Exemption means non-liability for value-added tax, and it means non-liability at all stages, and for all of the value-added tax. It also means, as the Senator said, that there is no right to claim a credit for tax suffered on other activities in the course of the business, or in the rendering of the service.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like to ask one other question. Has the Minister power anywhere in this— and if he has not, should he not have —to remove an exemption? If we are moving towards full harmonisation, have we that under section 11, subsection (8) (ii)?

Comment on this

That cannot be done. We have the power under section 6 (ii) (b)—

the Minister may, by order, amend or revoke an order under this subsection, including an order under this paragraph.

The effect of that is that the granting of an exemption by order may be cancelled. Where exemptions are given under the Bill they cannot be withdrawn by ministerial order. I can see the reasons why one might think it advisable to do this but, on the other hand, I am sure Senator FitzGerald will agree with me that it is not the kind of practice that would be considered desirable—that, where the Bill specifically provides an exemption, the Minister could cancel it.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

If you are moving towards full harmonisation, where the exemption from taxation of exports may go, will you not want to be able to do that without coming back to the two Houses of Parliament? If my understanding of what is involved in full harmonisation is correct, it may not be necessary.

Comment on this

I must say that no knowledge I have of the operations in this regard within the EEC would suggest to me that harmonisation would involve abolition of zero rating on exports in the near future. I am not aware of any developments that would suggest that this is likely to disappear under harmonisation procedure. It is most unlikely because it is regarded as an essential element in ensuring equality of treatment. If such a thing were to come about, it ought to come before both Houses by way of legislation. I would be slow to depart from the idea that, while exemptions or zero rates given by ministerial order could be revoked by ministerial order, those given specifically by the actual legislation in the terms of the Bill could only be altered by way of a specific amendment. This is a reasonable safeguard.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I was surprised to find that I had to turn back to the general section dealing with regulations to find the power to make regulations under section 7 with regard to the manner in which exemption may be waived and to discover that these regualtions may provide for:

the manner in which exemption in respect of certain services may be waived under section 7 and any such waiver may be cancelled, and the adjustments, including a charge of tax, which may be made as a condition of such cancellation:

We find provisions for regulations of a particular kind in section 7 itself and then we have to turn for the power to make other regulations with regard to the exemption itself to section 32. Why have they divided them up? However, do not let us delay the House on it.

Comment on this

It was thought advisable to bring together in this section, which deals with the waiver of exemption, but provisions relating to regulations concerning the waiver of exemption; but the provisions in relation to regulations under section 32 relate to all of the possible matters in regard to which regulations could be made, quite apart from the question of waiver of exemption. It is a matter largely of determining which one thinks is the most appropriate.

Comment on this

Surely the position is that section 7 is merely enabling; it is the law which allows this to happen. Provisions may be made by regulation and section 32 gives the authority for the regulations.

Comment on this

That is true, but as it specifically refers to section 7——

Comment on this

Section 32 sets out the manner in which the regulations shall be made or framed. Section 7 is merely the provision which enables; section 32 provides for the way in which it is to be done.

Comment on this

This is true, but the Senator will see that, apart from doing what he says, section 32 also provides for regulations in regard to many other matters other than waiver of exemption. What the Senator says is correct. It is the one that lays down the manner in which this is to be done.

Comment on this

Does section 8 mean that a trader, who has a turnover of £1,000 a year and who did not have to make any return to the Department under the turnover tax, will now have to make a return on £500 due to added-value tax?

Comment on this

The accountable period under turnover tax is one month; under added-value tax it will be two months. The limits which are being set are the same as under the present taxes subject to the fact that one is on a tax inclusive and one is on a tax exclusive basis. Leaving that aside, the limits are the same as under the present system.

Comment on this

I want to raise again the question of the commercial production of poultry and eggs. What type of eggs are referred to in subsection (1) (b)? I want to talk to the Minister, for his benefit and the benefit of his advisers, about eggs. There are eggs for commercial purposes, which would be in the First Schedule under food. There are also hatching eggs for the production of chickens, ducks and turkeys and are not regarded as an item of food.

They are considerably more expensive than a commercial egg. If I may talk in terms of "old money", the price of commercial eggs to the general farmer is usually about half-a-crown a dozen. The price of a dozen hatching eggs can run from 7s 10d to 8s 6d for hen eggs. Turkey eggs cost about 4s 6d each.

I can understand the reference to nursery gardens in this Bill. There is just one process involved in market farming and one process involved in fish farming. In the case of poultry it is a question of whether the chicken or the egg came first. I ask the Chair's indulgence while I go into this.

Comment on this
Charles B. McDonald Acting Chairman (Mr. McDonald) Fine Gael

The Senator is quite in order.

Comment on this

The grandparent stock are there for the production of the parent stock. The grandparent stock produce day-old chicks for sale to registered supply farms, for laying breeders or for broiler breeders. These chickens will be subject to 5.26 per cent tax. A lot of medication is used before these birds are sent out and this is an added expense. On the farm the grandparents are put out as day-old chicks for 26 to 27 weeks before they start to lay. In that time 100 pullets would consume nearly one ton of food. It is from these eggs the parent stock is sold.

They continue to need food and this food will be charged at 5.26 per cent. The chickens are then sold to a registered supply farm. I take it that the grandparent stock farm is an "accountable person". The supply farm where these chickens are sent, because it is usually part of another farm, may or may not be an "accountable person". The volume of trade must be taken into account. The chickens will be on the supply farm for 27 weeks before they start to lay. The eggs will be sold to a licensed commercial hatchery for the production of chickens. This is bound to escalate and put up the price of the finished poultry. Where and how is the cost of all this food to be recovered? I am speaking about the food used in producing these birds to the point of laying.

The commercial hatchery will be accountable so they will be charging 5.26 per cent. A grower may or may not be an accountable person. Most of the chicken growers have this enterprise as an adjunct to their farms and may elect not to be accountable persons. The grown chickens go to a processor who will be an accountable person. There is another snag here. Hatching eggs are exported, from both grandparent and parent stock. Finished broilers are also exported but nobody knows what proportion of the chickens coming from the eggs they produce will eventually become an export.

This is a very complicated business. It is bound to lead to an increase in the price of finished chickens. There should be only one accountability there and that should be on the final process between the grower and the processor or between the processor and his retail sale. Only the processor knows what percentage of the chickens will be exported in any one week.

If it were a simple thing like a nursery garden, it would be easy, but poultry farming is a complicated subject and should be looked into again. This applies not only to broiler chickens but to turkeys and laying stock.

Comment on this

There are a number of turkeys being exported and the supply farmer will never know whether they came from the eggs produced on his farm. Eggs for export should have a zero rating but how can they be distinguished?

Comment on this

I should like to raise a few points on this important section. Section 8 (1) sets out the farming business or fishing enterprises which are "accountable persons". They are not included in the general omnibus reference to farming and fish business. Are pig or cattle-fattening stations, whether co-operatively or individually owned, accountable persons or non-accountable persons? They are not specifically mentioned in this subsection. There is mention of commercial production of poultry eggs. Is game shooting an accountable operation?

Comment on this

Game shooting?

Comment on this

Yes. The shooting of game birds such as pheasants.

Comment on this

If you use a punt gun for duck?

Comment on this

The business of game shooting and selling the game is actively engaged in in some parts of the country. Is that accountable for VAT?

Comment on this

Where does the game hatchery and the commercial production of game come in here? There are hatcheries for the production of game.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Let us take one bird at a time.

Comment on this

I am talking about people who engage in the activity of shooting birds and who sell them to poulterers. Is that activity liable to VAT? Are groups of farmers operating co-operative pig-fattening stations accountable persons within the meaning of this section? Section 8, subsection (3) (a) (iv) states:

deliveries of goods and rendering of services other than those referred to in subparagraphs (i) to (iii) the total consideration for which has not exceeded and is not likely to exceed £1,800 in any period consisting of six consecutive taxable periods;

How, in a Bill such as this, can the Minister say a thing is not likely to exceed a stated figure having regard to the continuing effects of inflation? In the case of farmers a substantial increase in the cost of all feedingstuffs is just around the corner because of our impending entry into the EEC. At present the prices of feedingstuffs here are substantially lower than on the Continent. The figures which the Minister has written into the Bill may be substantially increased under EEC conditions. Subparagraph (iv) of section 8 appears to assume that the figure is not likely to exceed £1,800 in any period. Some provision should be made for increasing that figure; this will undoubtedly be necessary in the years ahead.

I should like to raise a point on somewhat similar lines in regard to the exemption given to small traders of £1,000 in every two-monthly period or £6,000 per annum. Is that a realistic figure? It appears to me to be analogous to the old figure under turnover tax requirements. That came into operation in 1964 or 1966. It has been quite a long time in operation now and the price of every item a small shopkeeper sells has substantially increased since then. Consideration should be given to the changing values of money over the intervening years. Has the Minister power in the Bill to waive those figures? Perhaps he has this power but it is not apparent in this section. The Minister should reconsider the exemption limit of £6,000 per annum because it is no longer realistic. It may have been realistic five or six years ago.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would the Minister like to answer some of the points raised?

Comment on this

I will try to answer some of the points raised. The limits set out here approximate to the existing limits under turnover tax. There is no provision in the Bill to enable these to be altered by regulation. Any alteration would require legislation. Our experience has been that they work reasonably well in the way they were intended. The reference "not likely to exceed £1,800 in any period consisting of six consecutive taxable periods" is intended as a relief for a small shopkeeper with a farm. If it were not worded in this way they would have to prove that they did not have to come in under the system. As it is worded, they can stay out unless they operate on quite a big scale, in which event the Revenue Commissioners could show that it was not likely they would not exceed that figure. It is designed to make life easier for small shopkeepers with a bit of land rather than as an advantage to the Revenue Commissioners.

Points were raised on various topics such as game shooting. The position is that, if the particular activity is done in the course of business, then it becomes liable. Under the exemption provisions corresponding to the existing provisions under the turnover tax, unless work done in the course of business is of a scale which exceeds these provisions, it will not come into the net. That is the general principle which applies.

With regard to the points raised by Senator Farrell, I am not sure I follow all the intricacies of the operations she described. I know she is very familiar with them. I am not sure the position is quite as complex as she seems to think it is because of her knowledge of the problems concerned. Anyone who becomes liable to the value-added tax in the course of his business will be able to recover in full whatever tax he suffers either by deducting it from his own liability or his sales or, in certain circumstances, from the Revenue Commissioners. If his liability for tax in an accountable period exceeds the amount he should account for he can get a refund. I would assume that the people involved in the various chains of production described by Senator Farrell were engaged in these operations in the course of business and that they would be engaged to an extent higher than the limits mentioned here. If, for instance, they were engaged on a smaller scale, and if it suited them, they could opt in. This provision enables them to opt out. Such a person should not suffer as a result of coming within the tax net if he wishes to do so.

The question of whether or not their produce is to be exported is introducing an unnecessary complication. It is the person who is doing the exporting who is concerned. I cannot remember the exact words used by Senator Farrell to describe the person concerned. I think she referred to a person who would not know which eggs were going to be exported must not be exporting eggs himself. In that case the problem does not arise. If he is exporting them himself he knows what he exports. I may be missing the point, but I cannot see a problem arising there.

Comment on this

I am not with the Minister on this and he is not with me. The way I look at it is that there is a whole unnecessary complicated system being set up in an already complicated business, whereas by rating everything up to the time that the purchaser gets the chickens as zero and then putting on 5.26 per cent you would achieve exactly the same thing plus the fact that it will mean that all the people along the line will have to find far more capital at every stage. All right, they will get the tax back—perhaps. I still contend that no grandparent stock farmer or no supply farmer can get back the tax on the food fed to the chickens from the time they are a day old. Where will the farmer recover it?

Comment on this

Where will these farmers sell their produce?

Comment on this

The grandparent stock farmer will sell to the supply farmer, but he will then be blowing the price of the chickens up to get money back again. Perhaps, I am wrong. But let us assume that 100 pullets up to the point of laying will consume three-quaters of a ton of food. Multiply that by 50, because usually about 5,000 pullets are run. How will that be shown on the sale of the subsequent day-old chicks? It is not the food which the birds are eating up to the time the eggs were produced that produced those chickens. I thought it was complicated but——

Comment on this

I wonder is the Senator complicating the thing unnecessarily. Could I interrupt her just for a moment?

Comment on this

I do not think so. When a bird is 27 weeks old it starts to lay. Up to that time it has incurred a certain amount of tax on food. The bird continues to eat taxable food every week, so it has to get not alone the back tax but it also has to get the tax off the week the egg was laid. In this connection it would be far easier for everybody concerned to bring in a zero rating except while at the actual production of the chicken or the egg that will be sold to the consumer and let the processor or the egg wholesaler put on the 5.26 per cent and eliminate everything else. You have medication at 5.26 as well and you have the 5.26 tax on the livestock. There is a tremendous amount of tax involved. There is tax on food and medication and tax on live animals. There are three different taxes on one unfortunate little chicken's head.

Comment on this

I am now convinced that Senator Farrell is making this more complicated than it is. The business is complicated but the tax is not as complicated as the business of chick hatcheries. The first thing to be clear on is that it does not matter what tax is going on at the intermediate stages. As far as the ultimate price to the consumer is concerned, the tax being imposed is 5.26 per cent which is exactly the tax being paid today as turnover tax. No matter what happens at the earlier stages, that is the result to the consumer. It does not matter whether a certain amount of food is given to the chicken up to the day the first egg is laid and then food continues to be given thereafter and all of it is subject to tax. That does not affect the issue at all because the trader concerned at the end of each accounting period has made up accounts which show that he received in through the proceeds of sale £X, and he paid out £X as expenses of which £Y consisted of tax that he had paid on the various items mentioned. It does not matter whether it was before or after the chicken laid the egg. It was during the accountable period. He deducts the liability for tax which he suffered on all of these items, from the tax on the amount that he receives on his sales. He is only liable for the difference.

If it happens that the tax which he suffered exceeds the tax on the amount of money received for what he sold, he can then recover the difference from the Revenue Commissioners. Normally, this will not be the case, but whatever tax he pays on feed or anything else and whether it was administered at a particular stage in the bird's life or not does not matter. It may be a complication from the point of view of his business but it is not a complication from the point of view of tax.

Comment on this

I do not know how anyone is going to estimate this.

Comment on this

Why estimate? Why not take the actual figures?

Comment on this

How can one put on 5.26 per cent tax on a ton of food over a certain number of chickens?

Comment on this

One calculates in an accounting period how much tax one pays and how much tax is due on the money one gets in.

Comment on this

This is what I am saying.

Comment on this

How do you apportion the tax when you are selling the chickens either in dozens or singly?

Comment on this

You do not have to.

Comment on this

Does that mean you are passing it on?

Comment on this

What you do is you calculate the tax. For simplicity sake, let us take the 5 per cent rate payable at the moment. It is exactly the same as the 5.26 per cent. If you are selling a dozen or a thousand dozen and the price is so much, the tax on that would be 5 per cent on that figure. There is no question of apportionment here. It is simply on the basis of the price.

Comment on this

It is part of the cost.

Comment on this

That is what determines the tax. Supposing you sell a thousand dozen and that by doing this calculation, you find your tax liability is £500. That is the amount of tax which you are liable to hand over to the Revenue Commissioners in theory but, in fact, you deduct from that all the tax which you have paid out during that period on food, medicines or any other items you have to buy for the purpose of your business. If that tax came to £400, your tax liability then is £100— the difference between £500 and £400. All these calculations can be done without any reference to apportionment between the birds you are selling or the point in the bird's life at which you administered food or medicine. This does not enter into it.

Comment on this

It is a continuous process. You are purchasing food continually month by month and selling month by month. At the end of every two months you add up all the purchases and subtract your sales, find out how much your liability is and deduct what tax you have paid on what you have purchased. It is an on-going process. It does not matter whether the chickens lay today, tomorrow or——

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this. If I am selling 10,000 chickens this week—I am referring to the grandparent stock not to the commercial hatchery stage which is a relatively simple matter—and 10,000 chickens next week, is the 5.26 per cent tax added on to all that? I add on £52.60

Comment on this

Where you are charging the price to the person?

Comment on this

Yes. You would give an invoice which would show the cost of the 10,000 chicks plus tax calculated on the price.

Comment on this

I will have to pay tax for 27 weeks, buying food before I get any money.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

You must feed a bird for 27 weeks before it begins to lay and during that time you are not making any sale.

Comment on this

What the Senator is describing is the situation in which somebody is starting out in business. Even then what she has described is not true. What Senator Norton said is true—you have a continuing operation, or you should have, if you are in business.

Comment on this

You have a cycle.

Comment on this

You may have, but you are in business over a period of months. The accounting period is two months. In that two-monthly period, a person is entitled to set off against his liability for tax any tax paid, including the tax on the feeding of these birds for that period, even though he is not going to sell them for another two months. If it happens at that point that you have paid out more in tax than you are liable for on the basis of what you will be receiving on sales in that period, you can recover the difference from the Revenue Commissioners. It is related to the accounting period of two months, not to the date on which you sell the birds and the length of time for which you were feeding them. It is only related to the accounting period of two months. Any tax suffered in that period can be charged.

Comment on this

Thank you. I understand the position now. If you are using food which is taxed, and you are going to get a refund on it, you can claim a refund every two months, for the first accounting period, before the hens start laying.

Comment on this

Would the Senator explain this?

Comment on this

This food tax is only there in order to be written off.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Then my contention is why charge it in the first place?

Comment on this

I knew the Senator would say that. Most of the food in question is zero rated. It comes in under the Second Schedule where there is reference to processed animal feedingstuffs.

Comment on this

I see in the Bill "Goods Chargeable" at the rate of 5.26 per cent. This is stated in the Third Schedule, Part I.

Comment on this

Would the Senator look at page 42?

(vii) any feeding stuff (within the meaning of the Fertilisers, Feeding Stuffs and Mineral Mixtures Act, 1955), compound feeding stuff (within the meaning of the said Act) or mineral mixture (within the meaning of the said Act)——

It has certain provisions about being delivered in certain quantities, and so on. This will cover most of the food which the Senator is talking about, and it is zero rated.

Comment on this

Where is the medicine to come in?

Comment on this

That is not zero rated.

Comment on this

Through the Chair, may I say to the Minister I am sorry if I have confused him in any way, but I think a lot has been learned here today about poultry. When I am in difficulty I will come to the Minister's advisers.

Comment on this

The fact that an item is zero rated still leaves an obligation at the various stages to charge a tax and then look for recovery.

Comment on this

Yes, it comes into the system.

Comment on this

I should like to refer again to the question of the exemption ceiling for the smaller trader of £6,000 per annum or £1,000 per two-monthly period of accountability. Does the Minister not agree that this should be raised? It is eight years since it was brought into effect. In that period of eight years, costs have gone up by 50 to 70 per cent. Would a more realistic level not be at least 50 per cent higher than that figure, if not double that figure?

Comment on this

We have not had any substantial volume of complaint about these levels. They have worked out reasonably well. One of the things we have tried to do in value-added tax, as far as it was humanly possible, was to change over from the existing turnover and wholesale tax to value-added tax with the minimum of change. It is for this reason that we have the peculiar looking rates of 5.26 per cent and so on. That is the exact equivalent of the existing 5 per cent turnover tax.

We are taking away turnover tax and wholesale tax and substituting value-added tax for them. I am trying to ensure, as far as possible, that we do not change from the existing system in doing this. On that principle alone, I do not want to depart any more than I have to from the existing limits. We have tried to write in, in value-added tax terms, the equivalent, more or less, of the existing exemptions in turnover tax terms.

A grocer dealing in the 5.26 per cent. region must be registered if his turnover is £12,000 per annum. For very many small traders which this is intended to cover, this is not an unreasonable figure. Certainly people who are in any volume of business ought to be included in this. There are advantages for traders to be included, particularly for retailers. It may be that for the very small trader the advantages will not outweigh the disadvantages, but for most retailers there are two advantages in being registered under the value-added tax system as against the present turnover and wholesale tax systems. They are, first, that the trader will now be able to recover tax paid on items such as weighing scales, other equipment for shops, wrapping paper and all equipment and materials required in the course of his business which at present are subject to tax. Under the value-added system, he will be able to recover the tax in the way I have described to Senator Farrell concerning chickens. That is one advantage over the present system.

The other advantage is that because of the increased accounting period from one month to two months a big majority of retailers will be substantially better off from the point of view of liquidity than they are under the present system. There are advantages for retailers in the value-added tax system and it is only to people in a very small way of business that the advantages will not be too attractive. The limits we are setting are substantially the same as the limits we have at present. As I have already said, we do not want to change the system any more than is absolutely necessary on the change-over to value-added tax.

Comment on this

I accept the points made by the Minister. I think they are quite valid, but the Minister will recall that when these exemption limits were brought in they were brought in for a very valid reason which I think is still valid now, and that was to answer the case put up at the time that small traders have not got the facilities to engage in the book-keeping and record-keeping which was necessitated when the turnover tax was first brought in. It was to avoid those troubles and difficulties that it was decided to give the small trader a break. That argument was accepted by the Minister at that time. That argument is still valid today. I know there are advantages in registering; the small trader can recover tax on shop equipment but he will only have to buy that type of equipment once in ten years, so that will not make much difference to him.

It is an accepted practice, in tax law of every description—and it is certainly accepted in agreements covering wages and in legislation covering income tax exemptions—that decreases in the value of money and inflation are taken into consideration. Every time a Minister for Finance brings in a budget he recognises the fact that people have gone into higher income brackets and makes adjustments accordingly. If £6,000 a year was valid eight years ago, I suggest to the Minister, for the reasons that induced the then Minister for Finance to bring in the exemption which excluded small traders from the bother of keeping accounts and returns, that he should give serious consideration to increasing that ceiling.

I think the Minister said earlier that there has been no great demand for this change but in the intervening years more small shopkeepers have gone over the £6,000 limit and have gone into the £8,000, £10,000 or perhaps £12,000 bracket or perhaps they have not gone to the trouble of registering under the far stricter conditions which will prevail when VAT comes into operation. There is a very strong case to be made for increasing that limit and I would ask the Minister to have another look at it. I am sure he will agree with me when I say that we should do all we can to assist the small shopkeeper and trader. He is having a rough passage today and anything we can do to alleviate his hardship, while at the same time not depriving the State of any substanial figure of tax, should be done. I would strongly urge the Minister to have another look at those exemptions which are now very much out-of-date due to the changed money values and the increased cost of everything over the last eight years.

Comment on this

I should like to support Senator Russell on this point. In the average small business, run by a husband and wife with the help of some of their children, the wife usually looks after the turnover tax. If the wife falls ill the accounts fall into arrears and the Revenue Commissioners come down on them like a ton of bricks and look for 9 per cent interest on the money outstanding. It is not, in my opinion, practical to talk of a turnover of £6,000 a year in a small family business which usually is the sole support of the family. Senator Russell has made a good case for those people and I do not wish to elaborate on it further but it is not good enough to say to a small shopkeeper: "You must provide the Revenue Commissioners with accounts and you must pay on the nail. If you do not pay on the nail you will be charged 9 per cent interest on the sum outstanding."

I know of cases where decrees were lodged with the sheriff and proceedings were taken against some shopkeepers because their tax fell into arrears while people, living beside them, with a bigger turnover than they who are not registered at all pay through direct sales. The items they purchase are given to them with the cash added. We have one person on one side who has not to do any accountancy at all while, on the other side, we have another person who is obliged to do it. The people who have not got to keep accounts are immune from the terrors of the Revenue Commissioners while the other people have to dance to their tune. As Senator Russell has said, the ceiling should be looked at again because it would be easier from the Revenue Commissioners' point of view to have the tax paid directly by the firms who supply the goods. I know of cases where some member of the shop-keeper's family became ill and they were not able to keep their accounts up to date and the sheriff's minions issued them with a threat of seizure for very small amounts of money and without inquiring into the reasons for the arrears. I would ask the Minister to have another look at the matter.

Comment on this

Before the Chair puts the question, I should like to ask if any alteration will be made with regard to the commercial production of poultry or eggs? There is a difference between hatching eggs and eggs for human consumption.

Comment on this

They will all be liable to 5.26 per cent.

Comment on this

The Minister has missed Senator Farrell's point. She was attempting to differentiate between eggs as a food product and eggs as a farm input. This is a point that needs clarification. In relation to accountable persons, could I ask the Minister a question regarding subsection (3) (a) (iii)? If a small agricultural contractor who shall not be an accountable person tries out some work for a small farmer, who again would not need to be an accountable person, are the activities of such people exempted from VAT?

Comment on this

Yes. Such persons, unless they opt otherwise, will be treated as ordinary farmers, in exactly the same way as ordinary farming operations are treated under the Bill.

Comment on this

That is, no tax transactions?

Comment on this

Yes, in effect. There is a complex arrangement but the result is simple. The effect of it is that they are not involved as accountable persons. The kind of persons mentioned by Senator McDonald would be treated in that way.

Comment on this

I have been following the debate for the past couple of weeks and there has not been much reference to the position of farmers. Referring to subsection (3), if a farmer in any one year, had an excess of £1,800 worth of produce—be it animals or any other type of produce—would he have to be an accountable person?

Comment on this

No; that is not so. Ordinary farming activities are not subject to this limitation. These limitations to which the Senator refers apply only to the kinds of services which are referred to in the subsection. If the Senator examines them, he will see them. For instance:

deliveries of machinery, plant or other equipment which has been used by him in the course of a farming or a fishing business,

rendering of cultivating, fertilising, sowing, harvesting or similar agricultural services,

This is from one person to another. It is not describing the activities of an ordinary farmer on his own farm. There are no limits as far as that is concerned. These limits apply only to these services being rendered over and above what we would understand by the ordinary farming occupation.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Minister did not clarify this a little more in the Bill. In subsection (1) the Minister does not include the operations of poultry and egg production. I do not know why; perhaps it is because the prospects for this business are not too good. There is no mention at all of the pig units and the co-operative pig projects that are becoming quite popular. There appears to be quite a big impetus and development in this field, mainly because the policy of the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries offers attractive stimuli to boost production.

I should like to ask the Minister where exactly an ordinary farmer with such a unit stands. I wish to refer again to the man who is producing, say, bonhams or piglets of up to 70lbs weight, who would be either selling them to a co-operative or to a farmer with a unit. These would be agricultural inputs. Where does he stand? I should like to cite the pig factor who would perhaps be selling, under contract to one of the processing factories, about £500 or £1,000 worth each week. Presuming that these are not accountable persons, what exactly are their liabilities and how much tax will they be called on to pay?

Comment on this

The reason that the types of operation described by Senator McDonald are not included in subsection (1) is that these operations mentioned in subsection (1) are being brought into tax in the ordinary way as ordinary business. I do not think the Senator is urging me to include pig fattening, and so on in that way. That is the reason they are not in: because we do not want to have them in in that way. The kind of operation described by Senator McDonald, through the various processes through which it goes, would not be subject to tax at all, except at the last stage where there is a special 1 per cent added on to compensate for the farming inputs that would suffer tax. It may not be appropriate for me at this stage to explain why this is so. I referred to it earlier in one of the Schedules, where a great deal of feeding stuffs, fertilisers, et cetera, will not be subject to tax at all. The estimate of the amount of tax which will be suffered by farmers as distinct from pig farmers, is 1 per cent. They will recover that at the last stage of the chain of production, and will be included in the system thereafter. They need not be registered nor have they to do any accounting of that kind to get this.

Comment on this

Irrespective of the size?

Comment on this

Yes, irrespective of the size. The kind of operations described by the Senator would be in that category. They are treated as farming operations in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

Can any tax be recovered by, say, a pig fattening or a poultry producing enterprise in relation to the ingredients in compound feeding stuffs that suffer tax? The Minister may know that some ingredients suffer tax, such as antibiotics. Some of the ingredients in feeding stuffs would be liable to tax. There is a value-added tax compound in the price charged to the pig fattening station or to the poultry production station. Is that recoverable in any way?

Comment on this

These feeding stuffs have now been zero rated, so that there will be no tax element in the cost to a farmer. There is no question of recovering tax because he will not be paying it.

Comment on this

No, but the manufacturer of the feeding stuffs will presumably have paid some tax on items or ingredients liable to value-added tax. They will become a part of his cost. I presume that that will not be recoverable.

Comment on this

If this should arise, the manufacturer would be able to recover the tax he had suffered on those elements in the production.

Comment on this

I should like to refer to those whom the Senator described as contractors, people who may not have farms but who may offer to the agricultural community a service, such as supplying machinery. Are they eligible if they offer a service?

Comment on this

They can be treated as ordinary farmers for the purpose of tax. They do not have to get involved in the system, except to the extent I have described. They can opt in if they wish. It might suit them better to do so.

Comment on this

Within that there are two types. First there is the syndicate, a group of farmers who probably hire a man amongst themselves to do the work and pay him the same price as they would pay a contractor, but they have him for different jobs on the days they require him. It would be hard to differentiate between the two.

Comment on this

There will be no difference in the treatment of either category.

Comment on this