Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971 ( Certified Money Bill ) : Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 208–408 of 614. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 30 of 1971 ›
One of them would be a farmer, and the other would not be a farmer but would be offering a service.
Comment on this
Yes, but they will all be treated as farmers for the purpose of the tax, unless they opt to be treated otherwise.
Comment on this
If they opted to be treated otherwise, they would not get a rebate on fuel and so on for their machines?
Comment on this
If they opted it would be because the amount was so substantial in their business that it would be worth their while. I think that is the only reason they would opt.
Comment on this
I would like to refer the Minister back to the statement he made about pig farming. He said that it was justified to have one tax on that at the end and this is why pig farming was not included.
Comment on this
It sounded like that to me and I wondered why poultry farming could not have been done the same way?
Comment on this
What you have said is that if they do not opt in, the terms that apply at the moment would not necessarily apply then—the tax free allowance on oil and so on. Is it tax-free or subsidisation by the State?
Comment on this
At the moment the agricultural contractor has an excise exemption. That will continue. He also has a benefit which will continue but not on the face of it. Hydrocarbon oils and so on are not subject to turnover tax at the moment. They will become subject to value-added tax at 5.26 per cent. To that extent the tax will go on to input which this contractor has, which he does not pay at the moment. A contractor who is simply selling his services will be entitled to add on 1 per cent to the cost of his services. It will work out on average that he will recover what he has paid out in tax. In turn the farmer can add that 1 per cent on to the cost of the produce he sells. That recovers it to the farmer. There is a special arrangement in regard to pigs. The content of tax paid on foodstuffs for fattening pigs is much higher than on most other things. There is a special arrangement whereby farmers can recover their inputs on that through the tax they suffer on them. With regard to the contractors as described by Senator Killilea, some of the things which are not subject to turnover tax at the moment will become subject to value-added tax, but they will recover that by adding 1 per cent on to their contract price.
Comment on this
In the case of a syndicate, which is a limited group, a contractor, who is a land owner, does an amount of work for a group of farmers in his area. He is not offering his services. He is hired within the group itself. For example ten people might say: "We will get our work done this way and hire A to do it for us. We will give him the same price as we would give to a normal contractor." He is a landowner and some of those people may go out to work as is happening now. What happens in that case?
Comment on this
That is debatable. The contractor has an alternative, but this man is giving a service for which he has no alternative. He is not going outside the scope of the agreement with people to do it this way. While working elsewhere he is rendering the same service as he would if he were working on his own farm. The group is giving a service to itself.
Comment on this
As regards subsecsection (1), is there any danger that the Revenue Commissioners will mix up a farmer and a market gardener? Is there any chance of a farmer who supplies vegetables under contract to Erin Foods being classified as a market gardener? In the case of farmers who produce any of the profitable line of vegetables and attempt to sell a few dozen heads of cabbage retail in a local village, they will have to pass on some tax or will the effect of this Bill be that unless people are careful they will be acting against the law? In a village where a person sells a few heads of cabbage it is doubtful if 99.9 per cent of those people would think of paying tax. It is unrealistic to expect people to observe a law like that.
Comment on this
The question of distinguishing between a market gardener and a farmer who is growing vegetables is not a new problem. It has been dealt with before in connection with income tax and should not be too difficult. If Senator McDonald thinks about this question he will find it will work because the person who wants to recover tax, either by way of set-off against his own liability or by a refund from the Revenue Commissioners, will ensure he gets an invoice setting out what tax he paid. It is in his interest to do this and he will do it.
Comment on this
Again on poultry, I do not see any mention in the Third Schedule, Part I, of the number of eggs supplied to a hatchery. It is mentioned in subsection (b). Should it not also be in the Schedule?
Comment on this
The Third Schedule, Part I, refers to "animal produce in an unprocessed state". I understand that will cover it.
Comment on this
I presume the Revenue Commissioners would not categorise people who grow in bulk for, say, food factories as market gardeners?
Comment on this
If Senator Killilea is aware of any such people being asked to pay income tax, he can start worrying. The same distinction is being made.
Comment on this
Now that chickens are animals, I should not be asking a question like this, but in this Schedule, there is reference to "animal and vegetable produce in an unprocessed state, such as wool, horsehair, bristles, feathers, hides, skins, carcases, roots, plants and cereals". Is the Minister seriously telling us that he is putting hatching eggs into this category?
Comment on this
Subsection (7) of section 8 relates to goods or services supplied by a club. The First Schedule excludes sporting events. Does the reference to services in subsection (7) (b) cover the charges made by various sporting clubs, such as annual and entrance charges, and so on?
Comment on this
This would cover all sporting organisations?
Comment on this
Yes. It relates to the services provided but not membership subscriptions, and it follows the corresponding provisions regarding turnover tax.
Comment on this
Is the Minister agreeable to having a look at this non-accountability limit of £6,000 for a small shopkeeper?
Comment on this
It will be one of the matters to come under review from time to time. As I have explained to the Senator, I did not wish to make any unnecessary changes on the switch-over to value-added tax.
Comment on this
I should like to support Senator Russell. This section is extremely complicated and when the Minister is bringing in something by way of amending legislation he could make it more readable.
Comment on this
I should like to grant Senator McDonald his wish. I look upon this as the most complex Bill as regards terminology I have ever seen.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) of section 9 states:
Every person who on the appointed day or on any day thereafter would be an accountable person if tax were chargeable with effect as on and from the appointed day shall, within the period of thirty days beginning on the appointed day...
Does the Minister consider this period to be adequate? This is a tax situation coming into being for the first time. I am thinking of the shall shopkeepers and traders who did not register under the old turnover tax system. They may not take notice of the appointed day. Would the Minister consider extending the date, at least in the early stages of the value-added tax system? A great many shopkeepers in rural areas will not read these Acts or Bills. Could some additional days of grace be allowed beyond the period of thirty days which, presumably, includes Church holidays?
Comment on this
I support Senator Russell. I should like to ask the Minister if there is a chance his Department might issue a booklet setting out in an unbiased way the pros and cons of how to opt to be an accountable person or otherwise. This would not cost a lot and would help the public to decide how they would derive the most benefit.
Comment on this
If I might deal with the last point, there will be a guide to the value-added tax published by the Revenue Commissioners as soon as the legislation is enacted. It will include the information suggested by Senator McDonald up to a point. I do not feel one could expect the Revenue Commissioners to go into a lot of detail in a publication to tell somebody, whose decision must be a personal one relating to the circumstances of his business, what will happen if he opts one way or another. They can tell him what the consequences of opting are but he must apply this information to his own business. We cannot do better than that. The Senator will find that the guide, various forms and ready reckoners which will be issued are designed to make life as simple as possible for small shopkeepers.
The Senator will also find that the Revenue Commissioners will not be unreasonable in regard to the introduction of value-added tax. The change-over will not be noticeable as far as the consumer is concerned. As far as many shopkeepers are concerned the change-over will only have minor effects. For some wholesalers and for manufacturers the change-over is substantial. The House will be aware that I propose to appoint a committee representative of the various trading interests to work in conjunction with the Revenue Commissioners to advise on the teething problems that will be seen to arise in the three-month period before the operation of the tax and the three months following its introduction. Our general approach is to make the change-over as smooth as possible. There will be no question of hounding people for inadvertent mistakes.
On the question of the number of days provided in subsection (2), the fact is that this provision was originally nine days. I did agree in the other House to its extension to 30 days having regard to the fact that we have doubled the accounting period. In my view, that period is reasonable when one considers that the vast majority of the people who will be registered under value-added tax will be registered automatically because they are already registered under turnover tax. We are only concerned with a relatively small number of people, who will be notified.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Minister if he can assure the House that there will be adequate advertising coverage in the newspapers and on television prior to the first of the 30 days?
Comment on this
I am not clear whether the appointed day has got to be a day before or after the specified day.
Comment on this
I see. My other point relates to the person who is deemed to be accountable and whose land is developed by someone else. Will he be in the position of being obliged to furnish all the necessary particulars to get on the register? If so, when? What will be the consequences if he does not?
Comment on this
He will have the 30 days the same as everybody else. As regards the consequences if he does not, there is a penalty clause in the Bill in connection with failure to register in these circumstances. The practice in these cases is not to invoke the penalty unless the failure to register is also accompanied by evasion of tax.
Comment on this
Yes. Section 5 (4) will catch people who may be entirely innocent of any such intent.
Comment on this
The Senator may rest assured that in such cases no penalty will be invoked against such people.
Comment on this
Must people apply for registration for a definite period of two or six months or a year? Can they not get on the register and, if they are not doing too well, apply to get off it? Could the Minister state the exact procedure in a case such as this?
Comment on this
The circumstance described by the Senator is correct. It is only if they wish to come off the register that they must make another application. There are provisions covering those cases.
Comment on this
Once a person elects under section 8 (3) he is registered. He would remain registered unless he applies to be taken off the register. In the event of his wishing to become unregistered one of the important things to be determined is whether by doing this a person is evading liability for tax. There are provisions to ensure that he pays tax up to a level that would put him back as though he had not been registered.
Comment on this
I would like to know how the wholesale tax is going to be assessed in the case of sale of immovable property which I take it includes any house which has been the subject of a development as defined in section 1. This is an entirely new and important tax which will affect the price of every house which has been altered subsequent to the specified date or which is itself a development of the land. If the alteration is made, say, at the end of 1972, after the specified date, and the house is not sold until 1990 and there is a tremendous increase in the monetary value of the house because of inflation, I would like to be clear as to the basis of the assessment of the tax and the position of the person who, say, altered his garage to a bedroom, or did something to it which amounted to a development. Must he keep all his records showing his expenditure and if that expenditure has become irrelevant in terms of the price which he gets for the house eventually, how is a just tax assessed on him in relation to that particular transaction?
I think I am correct in saying that this is not a case of bringing in the value-added tax as a substitute for the wholesale or turnover tax. This is a new tax, a tax imposed on a new item offered for sale, or liable to be sold by someone who is a developer or who is caught for tax under the Act, though it may be that the ordinary man who carries out the alteration to his house is not such a person. I should like to know how sure is his position. Maybe the Minister would direct me to the relevant sections on the point.
I take it that if a man conducts a development, builds a lot of houses and then sells them off in the ordinary way, that in so far as he will have put into the development value-added taxed goods in the course of the development, it is reasonably clear how the value-added tax will be established in his case. Very often there is a case whereby a man effects a development and perhaps keeps a house for himself on the estate on which he develops. What is his position in relation to that vis-à-vis wholesale tax if 15 to 20 years later he effects a sale in relation to it?
Comment on this
The first thing to remember here is that the value-added tax will arise in the case of the sale of houses only in the case of a sale between accountable persons. Therefore, in the case of the normal sale of a house from one private person to another, this question will not arise. Where it arises the tax to be charged will be at 5.26 per cent on 60 per cent of the consideration. That consideration can include the value of any rents subsequently created after the development work has taken place. The effective target is to charge an effective rate of about 3.1 per cent.
The reason for this is that at present the tax payable on a house, if you take into account the amount of tax paid by way of wholesale or turnover tax, and taking into account certain items which are not subject to tax, on average it works out at 3 per cent of the selling price of a house. That is how this arrangement—5.26 per cent of 60 per cent of the consideration came about. The tax being charged under value-added tax is as near as we can make it to the existing tax.
If somebody adds a bedroom to his house and in 20 years time sells that house normally no question of value-added tax will arise because he will be a private person doing this for his own purposes and then selling his house in the normal way to another private person. If, however, this becomes a transaction in the course of business between accountable persons, tax would be levied at the effective rate of just over 3 per cent on the consideration passing, which is the equivalent of what is being charged at the moment. I do not know if that answers the questions put by Senator FitzGerald but if not, and if he elaborates, I will reply further.
Comment on this
I think to some extent it does, in so far as it makes clear that the only person liable for taxation is somebody who is an accountable person under section 8. What I have difficulty in understanding is why this liability arises only if it is a transaction between one accountable person and another. If I buy a joint from my butcher I am not an accountable person. I pay for the joint. My payment to him renders him liable for value-added tax on the value he has added to the joint between his buying it and selling it to me. Where is the distinction between the butcher, in such a case, and the accountable person from whom I buy the new house?
What the Minister has said has allayed considerable anxiety with regard to the position of a non-accountable person so I should like to see where the distinction is to be drawn and from whence it is derived.
Comment on this
I may have put the Senator on the wrong track by one phrase I used, which was: "A sale between two accountable persons." I should have said: "A sale in which the seller is an accountable person" irrespective of whether or not the purchaser is accountable. In that case the seller becomes liable for the tax. Perhaps that makes it clear, that there is no distinction between that and the case of a person going to the butcher —the butcher being the accountable person, the customer not being accountable.
The principle involved here really is, as far as sales and shops are concerned, or even sales of new houses, that it is the ultimate consumer who becomes liable to pay the tax on the price he pays. The tax is at whatever the appropriate rate is, say, 5.26 per cent. It is the accountable person who has to account to the Revenue Commissioners. We may safely assume that in all the cases we can think of, the price paid by the non-accountable person—the ultimate consumer—will include the tax.
In the case of a person buying a new house after the commencement of this Bill, or it may even be a building contract for the actual work although he may be the owner of the plot, in the more usual case he will be buying the house on the land as it stands from the builder. In either case he will be liable for the tax in the manner I have described which amounts to an effective rate of just more than 3 per cent on the consideration and that is the same amount of tax as he is paying at the moment under turnover and wholesale taxes.
There may be some other aspects but if we can eliminate the difficulties as we go along it may be clearer and quicker in the long run.
Comment on this
One thing which seems to emerge from what the Minister is saying is that the buyer of the house is under no greater liability to see that the value-added tax is paid by the seller than is the buyer of the joint from the butcher.
Comment on this
To take the case I mentioned in which you have someone who builds a series of houses and converts them into flats but does not sell them immediately—this operation may run throughout his whole lifetime. Is he simply taking the risk that if inflation inflates the ultimate price at which he sells, that the value-added tax will capture—as value added—what has been conferred by inflation in the time between his original building, or reconstruction, as the case may be, and his final sale, whether it be by means of a direct sale or a sale by lease, or whatever way he chooses to have the deed carried out? If so, he is in the position of having to pay a figure of 3.156 per cent on the value added. If he is engaged in this operation he is a taxable person and if he pays this addition, will it be an allowance for determination of what is his net profit for the purposes of income tax and corporation profits tax?
Comment on this
That would be so. It would be allowable but there is a point in what Senator FitzGerald said on which we should be clear. He becomes liable to the value-added tax when he parts with possession of the house. I am not quite clear what the Senator had in mind when he talked of somebody building a series of houses over, say, a period of 20 years.
Comment on this
Take the simple case of somebody who likes to invest his money in buying old properties and converting them into flats. When does he become liable?
Comment on this
In the circumstances described by Senator FitzGerald the person becomes liable to the tax regardless of whether he makes a lease longer than ten years. If he makes a lease of ten years or more it is a delivery of the property within the meaning of the section. If, however, he gives a monthly tenancy this is treated as being "a self-delivery" and he becomes liable at that point.
Comment on this
Let me put it this way: the only circumstances in which he would not become liable would be if he simply left the property unoccupied and did nothing with it. If he parts with possession, even on a short-term lease, he becomes liable at that point.
Comment on this
That may be going a little far. He must be in business before this arises at all. He would not be an accountable person if the transaction were not in the course of business
Comment on this
I do not wish to spell out precisely the circumstances and then say that these are the only circumstances in which the liability would arise. This would be unwise on my part. I am trying to give the general principles behind the liability for tax in these cases. One must bear in mind all the time that liability arises only where the person is an accountable person which means—as Senator Brugha said—that he is in business.
Comment on this
I wish to direct the Minister's attention to the definition of "business". It is more extensive than the ordinary man would think was required of him to be in business. If I bought a house and did something to it I could be deemed to be in business, even though I only did that one transaction, because I had engaged in a venture in the nature of trade or commerce. Therefore, anybody who does anything with a view to turning the operation to gain will be in business under the Bill, as I understand it, and will be an accountable person and will be liable to value-added tax on the value which he has added. I am wholly out of my depth when I come to deal with the short distinction between monthly lettings and the effect of the monthly lettings as distinct from the ten-year term.
Comment on this
The practical effect, so far as liability is concerned, is no different because the liability will arise. On the question of the definition of "business" it operates on the same basis as operates at present under income tax on land development which, in very rough layman's terms, amounts to the situation where if a man does it once it is all right but if he does it more than once he is deemed to be doing it in the course of business. That is a very rough interpretation. It is the same kind of interpretation in default that would be operated in this connection under value-added tax as is operated at present.
Comment on this
Will the people undertaking big developments and only letting their buildings for five years, or renewing their rents every five years be exempt on account of the short leases?
Comment on this
It is a little difficult to answer that question precisely because it would depend on the terms of the lease. If it was a long lease subject, at intervals, to a right of surrender with, perhaps, increased rents being exercised, or if it is a five-year lease, subject to a new five-year lease being granted, it would become liable to tax on the second lease. I cannot answer the question precisely because it would depend on the terms of the lease in each particular case.
Comment on this
Let us take the case of a widow whose husband had a large house. After he dies the house is much too large for her and, in any event, she has not got the income to keep it going so she converts seven or eight rooms into bedsitters. This to her is a business. She sets the bedsitters to eight separate tenants. Is she liable to value-added tax on those bedsitters?
Comment on this
No, except in so far as she would be liable as at present for the tax element in the work done in converting the house.
Comment on this
She would pay that in the same way as she pays it at present and that would be the end of her liability.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister to look at subsection (7). I am not at all clear what exactly is meant by it. Subsection (7) states:
The amount on which tax is chargeable by virtue of section 2 (1) (a) on the delivery of livestock shall be 19.20 per cent of the total consideration referred to in subsection (1).
In the definition section we read that "livestock" means live cattle, sheep, pigs and horses. Presumably, that means live cattle, live sheep, live pigs and live horses but would there be a difference if, say, I wished to dispose of my stock deadweight? If a farmer sells his cattle, sheep or pigs liveweight to a fellow farmer there would be no tax transactions, or if a farmer sells to a fellow farmer via the mart there would be a 1 per cent charge, but if a farmer sells deadweight to a factory will he be charged 5.26 per cent on 19.20 per cent of the total price? Have the Revenue Commissioners differentiated between selling farm animals on the hoof liveweight or selling them deadweight? Both of them are quite common methods of transactions.
Comment on this
In the case of a deadweight sale the rate of tax would be 5.26 per cent on the current price but that is only relevant in a sale by a registered person. The ordinary farmer the Senator has in mind would not be a registered person so that the question will not arise as far as he is concerned. In the case of the sale of live cattle, sheep, pigs and horses the method adopted here may appear complex but, in effect, it is producing a 1 per cent rate on the tax-inclusive price. You get that by charging the tax at 5.26 per cent on 19.20 per cent of the value excluding the tax. The object of this is to enable the marts to operate with a single rate of 1 per cent on all livestock. Without this it would be impossible for them to operate. It achieves the same situation for both registered and unregistered persons selling through the mart and for those who are selling otherwise. The ultimate result is the same, so that the value-added tax is not going to affect the price or the competition as regards live animals. There is a difference in approach as regards the sale of carcases on a deadweight basis but this will only affect somebody who is a registered person under the Act.
Comment on this
I am still not clear although I accept what the Minister says. If I sell cattle, sheep or pigs deadweight to a factory, who will be a registered and accountable person? That will be the end of the road for this particular animal, whereas by sending it to the market it may have two, three or more owners before it eventually reaches the factory. Therefore, the collection of tax will not be the same on every beast. Some of them will yield 300 or 400 per cent tax, whereas pigs, in the main, will possibly have a once-only tax. There is a difference here.
Comment on this
It is not clear from the text how he is going to avoid it. Very little has been said on this so far.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned a few minutes ago that most farmers would not be registered. Anyone selling perhaps 50 or 60 cattle will be over the £6,000. Any dealer dealing with over 50 or 60 cattle a year would naturally have to be registered.
Comment on this
No. If he is a farmer, he does not have to register at all, no matter what his output is.
Comment on this
In response to what Senator McDonald said, perhaps I should go a little further. I shall take the case of an ordinary farmer whom we can assume to be unregistered, selling on a deadweight basis to a factory. First of all, because he is unregistered he will be entitled to add 1 per cent to the price and so will recover the amount of tax that he has paid on feeding stuffs and so on. If he happens to be a registered person he would put on 5.26 per cent and the factory would deduct 5.26 per cent. He would be deducting on the basis of the tax, if any, he had paid on the items he was feeding the animals with. It would not be a flat deduction. It would be related to what he had actually paid out and he would have to produce the accounts, as a registered person.
There will not be very many farmers in this position. A farmer in this position would be in exactly the same position as any other kind of trader. The vast bulk of farmers would be unregistered. They would simply add on 1 per cent and that would compensate them for the tax they had paid on farm requisites and other items. That is the end of it as far as they are concerned.
Regarding the question of tax being charged a number of times along the line and thereby reaching, as Senator McDonald has said, 300 or 400 per cent, this will not happen. I shall take an example. An unregistered farmer sells a product to a factory. The factory do a certain amount of processing on it. When they sell in the next stage of the processing they will charge 5.26 per cent on the price at which they are selling. However, they will be entitled to set off against that, or, if necessary, if the figure is too big to get a refund from the Revenue Commissioners, all the tax that they have paid. For example, if they were selling £100 worth with £5.26 tax, the next person in the line will have bought from them at £105.26. Let us assume that he sells at £120, when he comes to sell he can deduct from his liability for tax on the £120 the £5.26 that he has already paid out. This goes on and on in the chain. The net effect is that all the Revenue Commissioners get out of the transaction at the end of the day is £5.26. That is also the amount paid by the ultimate consumer. In fact, it does not really matter theoretically, in the intermediate stages, if somebody charges too much tax or too little. It evens itself out along the way and the ultimate result is still the same. The Revenue Commissioners will get, and the ultimate consumer will pay, tax at the 5.26 per cent rate. That is where we are dealing with goods subject to that rate, which is exactly what is paid at the moment —5 per cent turnover tax.
I know this concept is a little difficult to grasp, if you have not gone through an example in your mind and worked it out. If you do, you will find that this is so. There is no question of tax doubling up all along the way. The whole point of the value-added tax system is to avoid this kind of cascading of tax and to ensure, no matter how many transactions are gone through along the chain of production and distribution, that in the end the amount of tax received by the Revenue Commissioners and the amount of tax paid by the consumer is the figure laid down in this Bill, appropriate to the particular commodity.
Comment on this
What happens in the case, say, of a factory that carry a considerable amount of raw material? Perhaps they have £100,000 worth of raw stock on hands on 1st November. They manufacture that and sell it. More raw materials are got in after 1st November.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. I shall wait until we come to that.
Comment on this
I should like to ask one other question regarding cattle. In the cattle trade there are a number of dealers who do not own any land. Have they to become registered or will they be liable for tax under this? Will they be exempted in the same way as a farmer?
Comment on this
No. A cattle dealer or a mart will be treated in the same way as a farmer. They do not have to register.
Comment on this
In connection with the sale of cattle, what is the position of a person who is registered as a business person and farmer combined?
Comment on this
This is where the provisions to which we have referred earlier in section 8 come in. I said that this was intended to cover a case, say, of a man with a shop and a small farm. Where he has a business which is registered and he also carries on farming activities which normally would not be registered, if his farming activities exceed the figures laid down in section 8, subsection (3), then he would have to register for the whole business, that is, farming plus the other business. However, if his non-farming business does not exceed those figures then the business can be treated in the same way as any other farmer.
Comment on this
I want to refer to immovable goods. As Senator Nash mentioned, if we have a case of a widow who has a gratuity to invest and she invests it in converting an old house into flats, it is probable that she would be in the business of engaging in that enterprise and then making sublettings. Therefore, she would be an accountable person and have the responsibilities of such under the Act.
If she sells the house or gives more than a ten year lease, that is a disposal and delivery and she is liable for value-added tax from the value added in relation to that. Short leases are regarded as equivalent to the shopkeeper taking home the stock of goods. The value of that is regarded as part of the groceries that the shopkeeper took home, in assessing her value-added tax. If she elects to be taxed on the rents arising from these short lettings, then she is exempt from value-added tax, if she pays tax on the rent. She is then engaging in an activity which is exempted from value-added tax, but pays tax on the rent in the ordinary way.
If she does this for ten to 15 years and then sells the house at this point there is a disposal and delivery of goods, the value-added tax liability arises and the exemption ends. On what basis is it then determined as to what value she has added by her exercises of the property during the period of buying, reconstructing, and so on? How do they treat the old house which she acquired from somebody who was not a taxable person because there was no tax included in the price she paid for the house? She expends a great deal of money on builders, who are taxable and accountable persons, and she is allowed that money. How is part of the money which she paid on the original property treated for value-added tax purposes when there is no tax repayment to be made to her in relation to it? Does she, in fact, pay value-added tax on the difference between the original cost, whether it includes the cost of the building, before reconstruction or after reconstruction, and includes the entire inflationary difference?
Comment on this
In such circumstances a woman would be taxed on 60 per cent of the full selling price at the rate of 5.26 per cent. It works out at a little over 3 per cent. It could include, if she had created rents, the value of the rents. Presumably, if she sold the rents coming in, then it would include that.
In the circumstances described by Senator FitzGerald I am not sure whether she would become liable at all, or if she would come in as a registered person with the advantages and disadvantages that apply to that. I am giving that answer on the assumption that she would. The treatment of rents is a rather complex business. Rents are exempt from tax under the First Schedule, unless a landlord specifically waives, under section 7, his right to exemption. He might elect to pay tax at 5.26 per cent on his rents if the property was let to a registered person —a shop or factory—and if it was desired to pass on to a registered person's tenant the entitlement to credit for all the prior stage taxes. Normally a landlord who has not waived his right to exemption will not be registered and therefore will not be entitled to any credit or refund for the tax element included in the price of the property purchased by him, or in the charge made by a builder for any property constructed for him. Thus, nearly all property acquired by him, which is constructed after value-added tax commences, will have a value-added tax element of 3.16 per cent, included in the cost, either at that stage —or, if the acquistion is exempt, because it is a second-hand sale—at some previous stage. This continues, almost exactly, the present system under which the element of turnover and wholesale tax represents approximately 3 per cent of the cost price of a building.
A registered person who buys property, or who has a premises constructed for him for the purpose of a taxable business, will be entitled to full credit for the value-added tax included in the price. Having obtained this credit he will be in the same position as if he had acquired the property tax free. This is within the intention of the Bill, so long as the property continues to be used for the business activities which are taxable.
A difficulty arises if a person, who has got a full tax credit in respect of property, subsequently decides to let the property, but does not waive his right to exemption on the rent received. If no adjustments were made in these circumstances, he would have an advantage over an unregistered landlord since the capital cost of property let by the unregistered landlord would include a tax element of 3.16 per cent, whereas the capital cost of the property let by the registered person, would not include any tax element. There would also be the advantage over property built before the commencement of value-added tax, since such property will have an element of turnover and wholesale tax in its original cost. In order to ensure equality of treatment, it is necessary to withdraw the tax credit which the registered person obtained in respect of the property. This is done under section 4, subsection (3).
Any landlord may elect to be accountable for tax on rents receivable by waiving his right to exemption, but there would not be any advantage for him in making this kind of election unless he had been charged value-added tax for which he could claim credit and unless his tenant was a registered person who could obtain credit for the tax element in the rent.
In the case of ordinary residential property, if a tenant is not registered the landlord would almost certainly prefer to retain his right to exemption, that is to bear value-added tax at 3.16 per cent on the cost of the property and to be exempt on the rent. He would almost certainly prefer that course rather than to obtain credit for the tax on the property but to pay value-added tax at 5.26 per cent on the rent. If he took the latter course, not only would the rate of tax be higher—that is 5.26 per cent as against 3.16 per cent—but over the period of the lease the rent would be greater since it would include an element for the landlord's gross profit in addition to an element for the capital cost of the house. I am trying to assure the House that the danger of rents of residential property being affected by value-added tax is extremely remote.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a question regarding section 10 (1). This section describes the amount on which tax is chargeable. I quote:
...the total consideration... including all taxes, commissions, costs and charges whatsoever, but not including value-added tax chargeable in respect of the transaction.
Does that definition apply to all goods and services?
Comment on this
That is the basic element on which all value-added tax is levied. I should like to ask the Minister what taxes are included in this? "Including all taxes" would cover income tax and taxes on property and qualifications. Is this correct?
Comment on this
I cannot either. The definition includes all taxes. It is a very embracing term. Would I be right in saying it relates to all tax except taxes on income?
Comment on this
It relates to taxes which can be identified as a cost element. Stamp duty is a good example. You could determine precisely how much that was.
Comment on this
Is the Senator's point not a valid one? If it states "including all taxes" does that not mean all taxes of every description?
Comment on this
Yes, in so far as you can apply them, but there would have to be an identifiable amount. I do not know how you could identify the proportion of income tax involved in the cost of the item concerned.
Comment on this
It would not be included in the cost of the service or the goods in question. It goes on to say "but not including value-added tax chargeable in respect of the transaction". Does that mean the value-added tax that would be charged to the consumer on a delivery or does it exclude taxes incurred up to that stage? Say there is a three-stage tax right through manufacturer, wholesaler, and retailer, the retailer delivers to a customer, and at that point he has incurred the manufacturer's and the wholesaler's tax with the deductions in between. For the purpose of assessing the amount which is chargeable, the final tax is not added on but is the net charge for the other two taxes included in the price of the goods?
Comment on this
The reason for the wording "not including value-added tax chargeable in respect of the transaction" is, as I have mentioned in speaking on an earlier section, that goods specified in the Fourth Schedule are those subject at the moment to the highest rate of wholesale tax plus turnover tax. There is a special arrangement regarding these goods whereby they become liable at 30.26 per cent, but only the 5.26 per cent passes on from the manufacturer or assembler down the line. The remainder is retained. This is a special arrangement regarding this limited range of goods.
Without this wording we would run into trouble in regard to those transactions. That is why it states: "not including value-added tax chargeable in respect of the transactions." In effect, what happens is that everything is included other than the value-added tax in respect of the particular transaction which may be 5.26 per cent or 16.37 per cent or 30.26 per cent, depending on the goods concerned or the services concerned and which Schedule they come under.
In the case of motor cars and television sets, which come into the highest range, there can be included an element of value-added tax which would be 25 per cent. In all other goods, the value-added tax would not be included. The tax appropriate to that transaction would be added on after everything else was added up to determine the price.
Comment on this
That is reasonably clear. I am taking the case of a trader making out an invoice on which he will be assessed for value-added tax. He takes into consideration all taxes, commissions, costs and charges, including charges for delivery. At that stage, he could have paid some measure of value-added tax because if he bought from a manufacturer through a wholesaler, the manufacturer and the wholesaler would add on their percentages and the wholesaler would deduct the manufacturer's tax. Then it would come to the retailer who would normally add on the retail proportion and deduct the wholesale proportion. This would get to the final figure. At this stage, there would already be some tax paid in most instances. It would not be free of value-added tax.
Comment on this
At that stage a retail trader would have paid the taxes along the line, making the appropriate deductions. Then he would be faced with the final delivery to a housewife. The final charge would surely include the value-added tax up to that final stage.
Comment on this
No. If we exclude the items mentioned in the Fourth Schedule, where there is a special arrangement, there would be no element of value-added tax paid at the point where the retailer comes in. It would have been paid but it would have been fully credited. So far as the Revenue Commissioners are concerned, no tax whatever would have been paid at that point. If it were an item liable to 5.26 per cent the retailer would charge that 5.26 per cent on the cost. That is the only amount of tax payable on that particular transaction.
All the other tax paid previously at different stages as described by Senator Russell would have been fully credited to the person who paid it. The only exception to this is the special arrangement in regard to the limited range of goods which I mentioned under the Fourth Schedule, that is, where 25 per cent of the tax would have been paid at the manufacturing or assembly stage, would be included in the price all the way down and would not be credited further along the line. In all other cases, all of the tax paid would have been fully credited to whoever had suffered it.
Comment on this
What is the tax referred to in subsections (5) and (6) —"excluding tax"? It is clear enough in subsection (4) that tax has been excluded.
Comment on this
In the definitions in section 1 "tax" means value-added tax chargeable by virtue of this Bill. Does that help the Senator?
Comment on this
In other words, the reference to "tax" in subsections (5) and (6) is to value-added tax?
Comment on this
There are just two questions. Section 10 (3) (a) states:
if for any non-business reason the actual consideration in relation to the delivery of any goods or the rendering of any services is less than that which might reasonably be expected to be received if the consideration were an amount equal to the open market price or there is no consideration, the amount on which tax is chargeable shall be the open market price,
Could the Minister indicate what is a non-business reason? What is the open market price and who decides it? It is possible that the market price in the sale of some commodities may be very variable? How is the tax collector going to assess that? What are the mechanics and how is it going to operate? It is grand in theory and looks lovely in print but there are markets where prices can change quite suddenly.
Comment on this
Even at that, what formula is there for assessing the open market price and who will be the assessor? I should be interested in how it is to work. It seems to be unworkable.
Comment on this
The open market price is defined in subsection (9) (b) as follows:
"the open market price", in relation to the delivery of any goods or the rendering of any services, means the price, excluding tax, which the goods might reasonably be expected to fetch or which might reasonably be expected to be charged for the services if sold or rendered in the open market at the time of the event in question.
The question of who determines this would be a matter for the taxpayer in the first instance, then for the Revenue Commissioners. There is a right of appeal provided later on against any such decision if a person feels aggrieved by that decision.
Perhaps I should mention the thinking behind all this. Where goods are given away free or at an artificially low price we want to provide that tax shall be payable by reference to the open market value except in the case of genuine trade offers. Provision is made in subsection (3) (b) that where the amount actually received exceeds the consideration referable to a particular contract, a tax shall be payable on the amount received. The purpose of this paragraph is to prevent any attempt at evasion through issuing a false invoice or through understating the consideration in the original agreement.
Paragraph (c) provides for the granting of relief where the amount received is less than the full consideration and there is a genuine business reason such as discount allowed or bad debts. Its operation will be very similar to the present system of operation. The Revenue Commissioners will take account of the practices to which ordinary business people are subjected. This is designed simply to catch people who are trying to evade liability for tax. The idea that the Revenue Commissioners would question the normal transactions of retailers who are selling items at a particularly low price for the purpose of attracting business would not be practicable. While the intention is to catch people who are trying to evade their tax liabilities, we are trying to provide a saver to cover the normal business practices followed by, but not confined to, retailers.
Comment on this
It seems to me that is a good definition of the open market price. I agree it is not an easy matter to define. I do not think it meets the kind of situation referred to by Senator Russell. This definition is perfectly sound where you are dealing with a consistent market but if you are dealing in the kind of market where there can be substantial variations even in the course of the same day, then it would fall. There should be some guideline by referring to the average open market price which would be expected in such circumstances. While I am not suggesting they would do it, under this it would be open to the Revenue Commissioners all the time in the case of variations in market prices on the same day to go for the highest rather than the lowest price. There is no guideline to tell them that they should go for the average.
Comment on this
I would say that the only real guide to the market price of an article is when you have sold it.
Comment on this
What we accept as a basis at the moment is the cost price to the trader which is a fixed figure that one can determine. We might not question even a value below that, given particular circumstances. It is when the figure goes below that that the matter of whether any question should be raised arises. It is fair enough if we accept the cost price to the trader without question—in such circumstances the kind of difficulty visualised by Senator O'Higgins would not arise. I admit it could happen if you were thinking about the selling price, but if you go on the basis of accepting the cost price I do not think the question arises.
Comment on this
You could have things like carpet auctions where people get hold of a big quantity of surplus carpets. They sell them off at substantially below the open market price, because they happen to pick them up quite cheaply. They could be assessed for the difference between the market price and the actual selling price. But, as the Minister says, if the cost price is brought into consideration, that would probably cover this point. Subsection (5) states that the amount on which tax is charged in respect of the rendering of services referred to in section 5 (2) shall be the cost, excluding tax, of providing the services. Take the veterinary service. I am just wondering what the word "cost" means. Is it a cost to the supplier or the cost to the customer?
Comment on this
What is intended here is the cost to the taxpayer. In section 5 (2) we are dealing with transactions in which a liability will not arise unless regulations are made to that effect. Such regulations will not be made unless it transpires that it should be necessary to do this. Subsection (5) in effect provides that in the case of a self-rendering of a service for business purposes, if such self-rendering becomes liable under section 5 (2), then the consideration for which the tax is payable will be the cost excluding tax of providing the service. Liability for tax in circumstances such as this is a fairly remote prospect. It is only if we find, for example, that there is a definite attempt to evade liability for value-added tax by way of these kind of transactions that it would be intended to make the regulations that would apply liability to these transactions.
Comment on this
I always understood that the cost price would be the cost to the person who supplies the goods. The sale price is the price which the purchaser pays.
Comment on this
Arising from what the Minister has just said, I had hoped that this Bill contemplated that everybody who rendered services other than persons who fall within the description of "exempted activities" would become liable, if they are in business, as accountable persons for value-added tax in respect of the value of the services they render or as subsection (5), to which reference is being made, describes it, the cost of providing the services in question. If you look at the list of exempted activities you find that, while a number of professional services are clearly stated to be exempt, a number of others are not in that list of exemptions which one would have expected—like architects, engineers and quantity surveyors, to mention but three. My understanding of what the Minister has just said is that, although these people are not listed in respect of their activities within the First Schedule, they are in some way not to become liable until a regulation is made under the earlier section to which the Minister referred, section 2. If a quantity surveyor is liable for wholesale tax, on what basis is he liable? Is it for the total receipts he gets for his services?
Comment on this
Does this subsection, for example, deal with all renderers of service whose activities are not exempt in the Schedule for exempted activities?
Comment on this
In case we get into more confusion, section 10 (1) deals with the services which are not declared to be exempt. Subsection (5) refers to services of a type covered by section 5 (2) which reads:
The rendering of a service by a person for the purposes of any business activity in which he engages shall, subject to regulations, be deemed, for the purposes of this Act, to be the rendering of a service in the course of business.
That is the special kind of self-rendering of a service to which I was referring. It will not become liable at all to tax unless a regulation is made bringing it into liability. I mentioned already the circumstances in which that could arise. The ordinary services, other than those which are exempted, are dealt with in subsection (1) of this section.
Comment on this
No. At present this is not workable. There is at present an exclusion from liability for tax on dances where the number admitted does not exceed 100 and the price of admission does not exceed 20p. That would continue, but otherwise dances would be liable to the 11.11 per cent rate. The existing position will be continued in relation to dances.
Comment on this
Am I correct in understanding this section as signifying that the Minister is not reserving any power to use the value-added tax as an economic regulator, in so far as he is to be given the power under subsection (8) to reduce the rates—that he is not taking any power to increase the rates?
Comment on this
This is quite different from the United Kingdom where there is a leeway in both directions of 2½ per cent.
Comment on this
What the Senator says is true. There are two factors involved which should be taken into consideration. The first one is that it is very difficult to compare our situation in relation to value-added tax to that of Britain. Our circumstances are quite different. Our existing sales taxes are far closer to value-added tax than those in Britain. Their transition is far more difficult because they are so far removed from value-added tax at the moment. There are a number of other differing conditions applying but that is the main one.
The other point is that in general our approach in the past has been that the question of increasing taxes should not be made too tasy for the Government of the day without having to come before the Houses of the Oireachtas and justify their action. From the point of view of an economic regulator, if any Government wish to increase particular rates of value-added tax, it is not impossible for them to come before the Houses of the Oireachtas and argue their case.
Although I might be tempted as a Minister for Finance to look for the ease of movement in these rates, as given by the leeway of 2½ per cent or more, up or down, on balance I believe it would probably be better if we did not do this at present. I should like to make it quite clear that there is no question of increasing the rates of tax as soon as the Bill has been passed. We cannot do this under the Bill. In order to increase the rates of tax new legislation would have to be brought before both Houses of the Oireachtas.
As far as we can we are trying to maintain the existing rate of tax under the value-added tax system. It is not open to us to change that rate of tax after the enactment of legislation without coming back to the Oireachtas to do so.
Comment on this
Speaking for myself I do not dissent from the decision of the Government on this matter but I thought it was an important question of policy and it would be useful to get a definite statement on it which had not been made previously.
Comment on this
There are some building materials which were exempt under turnover tax which are to be subject to value-added tax at the rate of 5.26 per cent. These are blocks, lime, mortar, plaster, bricks, damp-proof courses, roofing felts.
Comment on this
Senator Reynolds is right in saying that some items of this kind are becoming liable to tax which were not previously. Similarly, there are a number of items, for instance, timber and glass, which are at present liable to both wholesale and turnover tax. Under value-added tax they will only be liable to the equivalent of turnover tax. The effect of the arrangements in the Bill is to give us the same position as we have had before—that the average amount of tax paid on a new house will still be in the region of 3 per cent.
Comment on this
I do not know where the Minister got this figure but it will certainly be much higher than 3 per cent. One can think of the materials used in the building of houses which were exempt, as against those which were liable to 5 per cent turnover tax, wholesale tax or both, particularly, cement, gravel, plaster, unless they were imported. Heretofore they were free. Now they will cost considerably more.
Comment on this
I do not wish to delay the House on this point but I must explain something which may not be clear to Senator Reynolds. By making all of these items subject to 5.26 per cent we are enabling people to recover the tax which they will pay on them. At the moment they cannot do this. As far as the ultimate consumers are concerned, what they will pay will be just more than 3 per cent because it is 5.26 per cent of 60 per cent of the consideration. This works out at just more than 3 per cent. It will not affect the ultimate price to the consumer because the tax he will pay will be 5.26 per cent of 60 per cent, just more than 3 per cent, irrespective of the level of tax on the component items which it contains. They are only valuable for the purpose of the intermediate transactions for builders providers and builders so as to determine what they should be paid and what they can claim.
Comment on this
To break this down simply so that people who are not in the business will understand it, heretofore, if a man went to build a hayshed, the pillars in the hayshed were exempt, the concrete used for holding the pillars was exempt, the galvanised iron which made the hayshed was exempt.
The only item which was taxable was the timber. Timber was taxable at the full rate. I regret I have not got the figures here to prove that. Everybody knows the amount of timber required to build a hayshed is very small but I can guarantee that the price of building a hayshed from now on will increase by much more than 3 per cent or 4 per cent and it would not surprise me if it increases to 5 per cent.
Comment on this
As far as the farmer is concerned—he would be the man concerned with building a hayshed— whatever tax he pays in the building of a hayshed or farm buildings needed for his business he can recover from the Revenue Commissioners so that the price will not go up as far as he is concerned. As regards houses, the amount of tax is worked out on a mathematical formula of 5.26 per cent of 60 per cent of the purchase price which works out at just over 3 per cent.
Comment on this
Why introduce this complicated mathematical problem of 5.26 per cent of 60 per cent? Is it to give a future Minister for Finance an opportunity of raising the tax to 5.26 per cent of 100 per cent? Would it not have been handier to charge, say, 3 per cent on those commodities and have a Sixth Schedule to the Bill rather than have these complicated decimals?
Comment on this
If we did that it would drive the shopkeepers off their heads. I can assure Senator McDonald that if we gave them three or four rates of tax to handle they really would go on strike. The 5.26 per cent is the rate that applies across the board on most commodities. We kept that rate and then we asked ourselves: "What percentage of the consideration, worked out at 5.26 per cent, would give you what people are paying at the moment, which is just 3 per cent?" It worked out at 60 per cent. That is how the figure was arrived at.
Comment on this
On the question of the various tax rates, the Minister went to considerable pains to explain to Members of the Dáil the reasons why it must be an odd amount, such as 5.26 per cent instead of an even 5 per cent, which would have been so much easier to calculate. Basically the reason is that under the present wholesale and turnover tax system there is no provision made for tax rebate while under this system we will have provision for rebate. The 5.26 per cent under this system equals the 5 per cent under the old system. I think that is roughly the situation.
Comment on this
If I may interrupt the Senator, one is tax-exclusive and one is tax-inclusive but mathematically the 5.26 per cent is precisely the same as the existing 5 per cent turnover tax.
Comment on this
That is what I was trying to say. Notwithstanding that fact, and having regard to the difficulties which this will create, particularly for the smaller shopkeeper, and the fact that it will not make any difference ultimately to the selling price, I think it will have disadvantages. The Minister made the point that if you bring the tax down by 0.26 per cent you will not have a 0.26 per cent reduction in the price of goods. That would be an impossibility but it would, from another point of view, have advantages. It will take some time for people to sit down and do calculations, and time is money nowadays. It would be of considerable help, particularly to the small shopkeeper who will not have the benefit of computers or calculating machines, if those amounts could have been evened off. I do not think the Minister would lose any revenue in consequence.
I know the Minister is basing this system on the present system of wholesale and turnover taxes but I am sure he would be the first to agree that costs, and consequently sale prices, are not going to remain static. We will have continuing inflation and any marginal loss by a rounding off of these figures would be recovered very quickly by increased prices in the years ahead. Having regard to the fact that he is not prepared to increase the exemption limit of £6,000 per year, which is the current figure, calculating these odd tax charges will mean quite an amount of trouble for the shopkeepers. I think the Minister said in the Dáil that a booklet will be produced and supplied to shopkeepers but most of us who have had occasion to buy items such as newspapers, sweets and cigarettes in small shops will agree that they provide a very useful service particularly at night when most of the larger shops and supermarkets are closed. Anything we can do to ease their burden in regard to the operation of this new system should be done. For that reason I would urge the Minister to round off these figures.
If he cannot do so under this Bill— and I imagine he cannot because time is running out for bringing it into operation—he should take powers to adjust the rates at the earliest possible date. These rates will cause a good deal of confusion. Schemes such as these that are devised by experts in the Minister's Department may look very well on paper but in practice they can cause a great deal of confusion particularly to people who are in a small way of business. I can appreciate the Minister's difficulties in this regard. He does not want to take any action that will increase charges or costs, particularly of the necessaries of life, but if he undertook to round off the figures it would help greatly to ease the operation of this complex system.
I think I am correct in saying that the system we have evolved is more complex than the system generally in use in other EEC countries. In England there is only one flat rate of tax of 10 per cent. Of course that may not be feasible here for reasons better known to the Minister than myself. In another small European country there are only two rounded-off rates of tax and I am wondering why we could not do likewise here.
I do not want to open up a discussion which has already had a good deal of mileage in the other House but it is a pity that the Minister could not find some means of excluding at least an agreed list of necessary foodstuffs. I know he made the argument in the Dáil that you cannot exclude a limited range of foodstuffs, you must either go the whole hog or nothing. The Minister may come back and say: "If I do that it means I will drop £15 million or £17 million in revenue. How will that sum be made up except I put it on items other than food." They might be regarded as necessaries of life. I am fully conscious of these difficulties and I accept that food is the basic necessity of life. The housewife purchases daily or weekly at least ten items which I am sure the Minister is anxious to keep at a low cost. It is unfortunate that we could not exclude food. From the point of view of controlling prices, and thereby costs and inflation, the basic thing to start with is the cost of food. I am sure the Minister would agree with me in that regard.
I am sure the Minister does not want to go over old ground again, but while it is not practicable to round up these figures, or to cut down the number of rates to, perhaps two, perhaps we could have a simple single rate such as exists in Great Britain? I should be grateful if he would give us his views on that.
Comment on this
On the question of zero rating food I would certainly agree with Senator Russell that this would be very desirable if it could be done. However, he did quote me correctly as saying that if one wants to do this one has to do it across the board. Anybody who goes into the problem discovers this very quickly, as a Deputy in the Senator's party discovered, when he went about it. That was one thing on which we were agreed: that if it were to be done at all it would have to be done across the board.
That brings in all sorts of problems. You are then zero rating quite a number of items which most people would not regard as being of an essential nature whatsoever, and indeed might well regard as being the ultimate in luxury. I shall not proceed with that in detail; I merely want to point out that that is one difficulty we are up against. If you do this, there is the problem of how to ensure that you will get the benefit in corresponding reductions in the price of essential foods. There is no guarantee that this can be done. At the same time, to do it you are increasing the price of many items which many people would regard, if not essential, almost as essential as food. For instance, you increase the price of new houses and all the furnishings and fittings for houses, clothes and footwear, et cetera. On balance, when you weight it up as I did — having started out on the basis of wanting to take tax off food —you will come ultimately to the conclusion that if you really want to do something worthwhile for the poorer sections of our community, the only effective way to do it is through the social welfare system and an amended children's allowances scheme.
On the question of the rounded rates, clearly life would have been a lot easier for me if I came here with figures such as 5 per cent, 15 per cent, 30 per cent off. I did not lightly approach both Houses of the Oireachtas with rates such as 5.26 per cent and 16.37 per cent. I gave a great deal of thought to it and eventually I concluded that if we were to do our part, not alone in not increasing the cost of various commodities, but in not providing an excuse for people to increase them, then what we ought to do as far as was humanly possible was to maintain the existing rate of tax. The whole system would be a value-added tax system but as far as the consumer was concerned the actual cost of the taxing would be the same as under the turnover and wholesale taxes. That is the reason why we have held on to these peculiar rates which are as near as we can get to the mathematical equivalent of the present rates of tax.
It means that for the consumer the consequence should be nil, in practically all cases, because the amount of tax will be exactly the same as it is today. As far as the retailer is concerned—and most people are concerned with the effect on the small retailer—the position is that no retailer will have to handle more than two rates of tax. When we talk about his calculating 5.26 or 16.37 per cent, I must admit this sounds like a most formidable undertaking. For instance, if somebody asked me to work out 16.37 per cent of £54.35, I would have to get a pencil and paper and do a lot of work on it. If this is the way we visualise the shopkeepers doing it, we could not expect them to do this.
In practice, that is not what they will be doing. First, they will be issued with ready reckoners and it is a question of looking up in the ready reckoner what is the correct tax, at 5.26, or 16.37 per cent on whatever figure they are looking up. Furthermore, most shopkeepers have a range of commodities, but these do not change very much. At the moment they know the price of these commodities without having to look up invoices and, in a very short time, they will know the amount of tax on these items without having to look up the ready reckoner.
Whatever trouble may be involved, it is not that of doing out a sum such as this on each transaction. If that were the problem, they could not do it. It will be a question of using the ready reckoner to get the precise amount on a particular figure. If they decide to do it on the basis of including the tax in the shelf price, then they have only to do it for each item. On the other hand, if they do it at the check-out point then they will do it on the total sum involved. It will be the one sum—"calculating" is the wrong word. I should prefer not to have these peculiar looking rates but when one examines the reasons for it, one must agree that there are compelling arguments why we should have them, to substitute as accurately as possible for the present rate of tax. When one analyses the problems that are involved for retailers, they are not nearly as great as they might appear to be at first sight.
Comment on this
I accept what the Minister is trying to do. It is more or less a conversion to a value-added system the effects of our existing sales tax. Would he not agree that it was made apparent to us the bewildering number of different effects in our existing system? If my calculations are correct, this Bill, in relation to different transactions and to different goods and different services, will apply no less than ten different rates. There is the zero rate, which is simple; the 11.11 rate for dances; the 5.26 rate; the 16.37 rate; the 30.26 rate and the rate applicable to livestock, which I work out as 1.00992, without the aid of a ready reckoner and in the case of subsection (8) of section 10, according to which of the rates is applicable, 60 per cent is applied; in the case of the 5.26 rate we have 3.156; in the case of the 16.37 rate we have 9.822; in the case of 30.26, we have 18.156 and, finally, in section 40 we have a tax on betting of 15 per cent.
That should make us pause as to whether we were wise in trying to avoid all the difficulty of bringing these different rates closer together, having regard to the fact that by 1974 the tax systems in the EEC will have to be harmonised and that certain other countries have one and two rates. What are we going to do the day we have to reduce ten of them? How are we going to do it when they are separated by 30.26 per cent to zero?
Comment on this
Is the Minister serious in making an assertion that it would not be possible to guarantee that if food had a zero rating the benefit of the reduction would be passed on to the consumer? If that is the stance the Minister is taking with regard to this question, it seems to be an admission of utter failure by the Government with regard to the question of price control. It shows a complete lack of self-confidence on the part of the Government in tackling the question of any method of price control. If it were decided to zero rate food and if there was to be a consequential reduction of 5 per cent, or one of the other percentages that Senator FitzGerald referred to, it should be well within the competence of any government to ensure that that reduction would be passed on for the benefit of the consumer.
Comment on this
I meant precisely what I said, namely, it could not be guaranteed that any reduction would be passed on to the consumer. This is not a confession of inability, incompetence or anything else, as Senator O'Higgins may think — it is a statement of fact. Senator O'Higgins should know that, with one or two exceptions, there is no price control at retail level. I am sure he knows why that is so. To be in a position to guarantee that a reduction of 5 per cent on the tax on food would be passed on to the consumer one would have to have a system of price control at retail level enforced by a huge army of inspectors and even with a huge army of inspectors it would not work.
Can anybody tell me of anywhere in the world where there is effective control of prices at retail level? Without such control you cannot guarantee that the reduction will be passed on to the consumer in whole or in part. If there is not such a system in existence, you cannot guarantee that this reduction will be passed on to the consumer. That is why I made that statement and it is why I meant what I said.
Comment on this
No later than yesterday evening we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the House with the Prices Bill and he told us that prices are going to be controlled. Another Minister comes in this evening and asks us if there is any other country in the world where this is operating?
Comment on this
No, I did not say price control. Of course it operates here. I said price control at retail level.
Comment on this
If it does not work at retail level then it does not work at all. There is no point in splitting words. I certainly felt obliged to make reference to the Minister's last statement about food. The Minister said that people in the retail business will only have two different taxes—5.26 per cent and 16.37 per cent. In my own business we will be dealing with some exempted goods, with goods at a zero rate, and with the other two rates. If we have not to collect the money, I am sure we will have to fill up some type of form indicating the exempted goods which we sold, or the goods sold at zero rate. The calculations will have to be made for the other percentage taxes.
It is an easy thing for somebody who does not know anything about business to say that ready reckoners will be available and it will work itself out. The costings will have to be included. If we buy articles in Dublin and transport them down the country with our own transport, we have to put a cost in against that. Then we have to put a cost in against the tax. I can see prices soaring here, because we all know what happened when turnover tax was introduced. There is no point in the public blaming the business people for turnover tax. The business people did their best not to have it introduced. They walked the streets of this city and of every town in the country protesting against it. Prices are automatically rounded off and this is the danger. We had that experience with the change of currency and I can see the same thing happening. I can see the price of houses going sky-high because there is a tax on building materials. It will be much nearer to 5 per cent than 3 per cent if not more than that amount. This Bill is dangerous as far as increases in costs are concerned unless the Minister for Industry and Commerce can control prices. Prices must be controlled at retail level.
Comment on this
To talk about what happened when turnover tax came in is irrelevant. When turnover tax was introduced, there was a new additional tax being imposed and obviously prices had to go up to cover this. I have gone to some pains to explain why we are keeping these odd rates, that is, not increasing the tax. The 5.26 rate is precisely the same as the 5 per cent turnover tax. We are not increasing the tax and, consequently, it is not a comparable situation. When this comes into operation, I think Senator Reynolds will find that he is mistaken in what he thinks is going to happen in his own business as regards the number of items coming under different rates. Despite what he said, the operation of tax with regard to the price of houses cannot be any more than just over 3 per cent, because it is to be calculated at 5.26 per cent on 60 per cent of the purchase price. However you work it out that cannot be 4 per cent or 5 per cent. It is just over 3 per cent.
Comment on this
I am talking about the tax which the Revenue Commissioners will collect. This is laid down in the Bill and they cannot collect any more on a transaction like that. The danger referred to by the Senator does not arise in the case of houses because the amount of money is substantial. There is a danger in regard to small items in retail shops and that is precisely why I am sticking to the 5.26 per cent. I do not wish to give the slightest excuse to anybody to say that because there is a slight change in the rate, he can change the price.
Comment on this
The Minister is being most helpful but there is a tendency to oversimplify the matter. As Senator Reynolds said, more services are being brought under value-added tax than there were in the case of either wholesale tax or turnover tax. The Minister cannot get away from this.
Looking at subsection (1) (e), which deals with services, I think there are difficulties in regard to new services which are subject to tax for the first time. I have in mind the co-ops which provide the AI service, for instance. To date this service has not been subject to turnover tax or wholesale tax. Yet, under the terms of section 11 it would appear that it now comes in at the rate of 16.37 per cent. That is, I presume, 16.37 per cent of the entire cost of the service. This is paid at the time the service is given. What becomes of the old custom: "no foal, no fee"? Will there not be great difficulty and much red tape involved in reclaiming this tax which they will have paid several months in advance? I think the whole thing will be completely unworkable.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister. There is no method of effective price control at retail level. In my experience, as a businessman and as a public representative, I have never seen it work effectively unless there are emergency conditions with limited supplies where goods can be controlled from the supplier through the whole manufacturing and distribution system. The best system is to encourage active competition in free conditions. Everything that can be done to encourage competition should be done. I do not accept the Minister's surmise that, even if we took the value-added tax off food, there would be no guarantee that it would be passed on to the consumer. I believe it would be used as a sales gimmick. We have evidence of this from the large advertisements we see in the daily newspapers in which every advantage is taken by some of the larger operators to cut prices and make special offers to the housewife. The abolition of value-added tax on food items would have an automatic repercussion on the lowering of prices generally.
We must accept the fact that if the Minister does that, there must be a quid pro quo, and he would have to find another £15 million or £17 million by some other means. The Minister has turned his face against increases in other costs but it is unfortunate that we could not find some system of not taxing the necessities of life such as food. This would have a steadying influence on the question of price inflation. It would be a help to people who do not come into the children's allowance class, such as old people living alone, et cetera. Turnover tax on food started off at 2½ per cent and there was an assurance that it could not be increased. It was doubled by just a stroke of a pen some years ago. The Minister has made provision whereby the value-added tax on food and similar items cannot be increased. There is no guarantee that his successor will not do this. Once a precedent is created, there is always a danger that some future Minister for Finance who is stuck for £15 million or £20 million will decide that the easiest way out is to increase the rate of value-added tax on food and similar items.
Comment on this
In reply to Senator Reynolds the Minister stated that he is only interested in collecting roughly the same amount of tax from the same amount of goods. Under this section and in the Third Schedule animal medicines are being taxed at the rate of 5.26 per cent. This has not happened before. The 5.26 per cent will be on 60 per cent of the cost. It will be helpful to all concerned to have these mattes clarified in writing as a guide for those who must live with this Bill when it is enacted later this year. Regarding the cost of animal medicines, is it 5.26 per cent of the full cost or is it 5.26 per cent of 60 per cent of the cost?
Comment on this
It is 5.26 per cent on the full cost of animal medicines. The whole basis of value-added tax is that people engaged in business suffer tax on the various items they use in the course of their business, but recover that tax in full. Farmers using these various items in the course of their business will pay tax on them but they will also recover the tax. The farmer will not be any worse off. It is necessary to do this in order to make the value-added system work. It must be spread across the board on as wide a basis as possible.
There are a number of reasons for a value-added tax system. One is to make it more difficult for people to evade their liability to tax which they find it rather more easy to do than I would wish at present under the turnover and wholesale taxes which are stretched almost beyond their limit. They were not designed for the level at which they operate today. To cut down on the size of the net operated under the value-added tax system would defeat this objective. Farmers, like other people in trade or business, who suffer tax will recover it. Their position will not be disimproved as a result of value-added tax.
Comment on this
Does it mean that farmers will get a refund of 1 per cent on medicines? Medicines for cattle were exempt under the turnover tax. In the Second Schedule they seem to carry a tax of 5 to 6 per cent. Does it mean that the farmer will have to pay a higher rate for his medicines due to the value-added tax?
Comment on this
There are two aspects of recovery of tax so far as the farmer is concerned. He can recover in full the amount of tax which he pays on farm buildings from the Revenue Commissioners. He can, also, add 1 per cent on to the price at which he sells his produce. If he adds 1 per cent on to the price of a cow——