We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971 ( Certified Money Bill ) : Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 409–614 of 614. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Value-Added Tax Bill, 1971
Enacted

No. 30 of 1971 ›

——he is covering a lot more than the tax he paid on the animal medicines. Allowing for the items which are being zero rated this figure of 1 per cent has been worked out as being the amount of tax which a farmer on average would suffer on his inputs other than on the farm buildings. That is what he gets back. He will be no worse off than he was before. Even if certain items are now becoming subject to tax, which were not subject to it before, he is in a position to recover tax in one of the ways I have mentioned, which he was not in a position to do before.

Comment on this

Could I ask the leader of the House a question? I am raising it from the point of view of the staff. The intention was to continue the debate until we had finished all Stages of this Bill. Is that still the intention?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

It will take us ten hours at the rate at which we are going.

Comment on this

We have been dealing with the most difficult sections. The remaining sections are much simpler and we should go very fast.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Not if there are difficult Senators.

Comment on this

I am not objecting. I simply wanted clarification.

Comment on this

Is there any reason why we must? Surely another day will not make that much difference. We have not dealt with the main agricultural sections yet. When anything dealling with agriculture comes up here we have to burn the midnight oil. There was a prolonged debate in the Dáil on section 13 on one word. I am not happy about the position. I do not wish to be here until 2 a.m.

Comment on this

I do not think the Senator is correct in saying that any one section of this Bill was dealt with in one word in the Dáil. Perhaps he is referring to the last Stage.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Every year the Seanad is stuck here in August. We have all had an ambition to get out of here at the same time as the Dáil. Year after year we were not able to manage it. This year there is a glorious opportunity of doing so. Last Thursday when the House adjourned I indicated that it was our desire to get the business completed quickly this week and to adjourn for the summer recess. Yesterday I indicated that we would complete the Value-Added Tax Bill today. To facilitate Senator FitzGerald we started today at 3 p.m. instead of 10.30 a.m. in the hope that we would complete all Stages of the Bill. As the Minister has said, a lot of detailed explanations had to be given. Perhaps there may not be so many detailed explanations needed in the remaining sections of the Bill and we might proceed quicker. Senators on the other side are young, fresh and well fed and there is no reason why they cannot put in more work.

Comment on this

I agree that we should go on until 10.30 p.m. and consider the situation then.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister for clarification of certain of the services included under the First Schedule. Let me give three examples so that my question becomes a concrete one. I am interested in a service listed under the First Schedule, for example an educational or medical service with a subsidiary activity. If the educational activities of a school are exempt under the First Schedule what is the position of the school tuck shop? That is a very small item and probably the tax would be negligible. In the case of a hospital whose medical services would be exempt under the First Schedule, what is the position in regard to a hospital cafeteria which might be used by members of the public visiting patients and by the medical staff? What would be the position of a cafeteria in a training college, university or technical college where the educational services were exempt?

Comment on this

These subsidiary services do not affect the liability or non-liability of the major service to which they are ancillary. As far as they themselves are concerned, the question of their liability depends on (a) whether their operations come within taxable activities as set out in the Bill, or (b) whether the size of their turnover is above the limits of exemption provided in the Bill. If they are engaged in taxable activities, or the sale of taxable goods, and if the level of their turnover is above the limits set out in the Bill, they are treated as a business and their liability for tax does not affect the liability or non-liability of the main business to which they are ancillary.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

As Senator West has raised the point, could I ask the Minister if the activities of the Seanad are exempted activities? The First Schedule gives a list of service renderers whose activities are free from value-added tax. The only possible heading under which the remuneration of Deputies and Senators and Ministers could be treated would be under paragraph (vii) where the service is given in return for wages and salaries. We do not get wages and salaries and it would seem to me——

Comment on this

What about paragraph (xxii)?

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Of the schedule? Do we come in under that?

Comment on this

We will if we go on much longer.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

It is a serious matter. It seems to me we are rendering the activities because we are within the definition of a business in so far as each one of us is pursuing a profession. The same thing would apply to director's fees which do not seem to get listed at all and seem to be subject to value-added tax.

Comment on this

When Senator FitzGerald stated that we are not paid wages or a salary he was thinking of some years ago. That position changed some years ago. The remuneration paid to Senators, Deputies and Ministers is subject to tax under Schedule E as are the fees paid to directors and, on that basis, they would not be subject to value-added tax.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is it only wages and salaries which are exempted if they are taxed under Schedule E? not all those different types of remuneration other than wages and salaries which are taxed under Schedule E are exempted.

Comment on this

If I may intervene for a moment, this arises under the First Schedule.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

It arises on the question of the rates, does it not?

Comment on this

If the Senator can convince me of that, yes. At the moment I do not think it arises on section 11. It may do so, but I am unable to find it.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I intended to raise the point on the First Schedule, but if the Chair rules it out of order, all right.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I have only two points to raise on this. Under subsection (2) it is not stated when the excess is to be paid. Is there any time within which it should be repaid? If there is delay in paying it, there is interest borne by the sum which is in arrear on a repayment.

The second point is a question of principle. Why have the Government decided to exclude motor vehicles and petrol from this provision for deduction of tax? This is not universal and, indeed, as I said on Second Reading, under the Danish system of value-added tax, there is a deduction for these items wholly if they are used for business purposes and a percentage if they are only partly used.

Comment on this

On the second question first, it is quite true to say that our treatment in this regard, of motor cars and petrol, is not universal. It is also true that there are a number of countries with the value-added tax system who adopt the same approach as we do. It is equally true to say that some of the countries who allow cars and/or petrol as a deduction in whole or in part are at present contemplating changing their position because it seems to be a provision which is very much open to abuse and very difficult to control. That is primarily why we did not make provision for these deductions.

Regarding the first question raised by Senator FitzGerald, speaking from recollection, I think we have a provision in the Bill which deals with this. I will check in a moment.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I could not find it, but no doubt it is there.

Comment on this

I was wrong in my recollection of this. I was thinking of another point. The position as regards the time within which a refund would be made is that in the normal case it would be made within three weeks, that is where the taxpayer furnishes the necessary details. But there can be situations in which the necessary details are not furnished, or in which there is some particularly good reason why a further examination would be necessary by the Revenue Commissioners. For that reason, I cannot put an absolute time limit on all cases. It is not proposed to pay interest on the money due to a taxpayer except in so far as the taxpayer might have paid interest to the Revenue Commissioners on the sum involved. In such case they would have to give back the interest, but that would be the only repayment of interest involved.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

This deals with special provisions for tax invoiced by farmers and fishermen. Could the Minister explain paragraph (a) of subsection (3)?

Comment on this

This relates to the 1 per cent which may be added on by an unregistered farmer in order to recover the tax he has suffered on his various transactions. As I mentioned earlier, this is calculated on the basis of what will happen under the value-added tax as set out in the Bill. Originally, as drafted, that figure was 3 per cent because there were items such as fertilisers and processed feeding stuffs and so on, which were originally to be subject to tax, but subsequently I discovered that it was possible to exempt them and, as a consequence, we were able to reduce the flat rate figure necessary to compensate the farmer.

I mention that as a background because it is conceivable that, with changes in prices, or even changes in the kinds of commodities used by farmers, this flat rate calculation would alter and that is the reason why we are providing here that, if circumstances alter, we can, by order, change the amount of that flat rate. If such an order were made it would, of course, have to be brought before the Oireachtas. It is designed to give some degree of flexibility to the amount of flat rate relief.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Up or down?

Comment on this

Up or down, yes.

Comment on this

This section relates to the rates of tax applicable to imports under the various Schedules. Under the British system there will be one flat 10 per cent rate. I should like to ask the Minister if this is likely to raise any complications. We will be applying three grades of taxation to imports from Britain and Northern Ireland. They will be applying a flat rate of 10 per cent on imports from this country into Britain. Is this likely to raise complications having regard to the close trading relationship between the two countries and to the EEC objective to rationalise taxation between countries? Should we not now prepare for the day when there will be rationalisation of taxes? Is the Minister making trouble for himself, or his successor in future years, by having these three categories of taxes whereas Great Britain has only one? I do not think any other country has the same number of import taxes as we have.

Comment on this

Speaking from recollection, there is one country at least which has four rates. Effectively, our higher rate, because of the special arrangement I described earlier, in regard to 25 per cent of it, it operates only at the manufacturing or assembly stage and thereafter it is the same as our ordinary rate of 5.26 per cent. The purpose of this provision is to ensure that we apply the same rates to the same goods which are imported as we apply to those which are delivered within the State. If we did not do this there would be a competitive advantage for imports and we could not have this.

Comment on this

I see the reason.

Comment on this

That is why we have to do it. I do not think it will present any problems. We are operating the same system at present under the existing sales taxes. Registered persons will be able, as at present, to import these goods without paying the rates of tax. I would only be an unregistered person who at the importation stage would have to pay the appropriate rate of tax. We need not anticipate any difficulty in the operation of this. It is essential in order not to give a competitive advantage to imports.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I know nothing can be done at this stage but I am concerned about the kind of situation with which we are familiar in relation to people who have property. Let us frankly state the position of many people at present with regard to the possibility of their liability for income tax if they should dispose of their property. They are uncertain about the matter and will get conflicting advice and different opinions. It turns upon delicate issues of fact as to whether or not a court would finally hold them liable.

Such persons might finally be held to be engaged in a business defined in the first section and become persons who are deemed under section 4 (5) as an accountable person in relation to that part of the land which, for example, they allow somebody else to develop. They might allow this development to continue for them and finally become liable for income tax, surtax, corporation profits tax and so on and finally pay whatever is due.

Under this Bill, they might be found not merely liable for wholesale tax but, under the language used in this section, without the savers which ought to exist, and failing to have kept the proper records and to have entered their names on registers, liable to penalties which are quite extensive. This could prove very worrying and serious for these people. This is something which ought to be clarified by an amendment at some future date. It is not clear at the moment; just as it is not clear whether such a person is at present liable for income tax it is equally unclear whether they will ever be found liable for wholesale tax.

Comment on this

I think this is a completely unnecessary section and I regret that it should be foisted on the public at the present time. Over the years the Revenue Commissioners have got off lightly by having turnover tax collected for them gratis. They will now operate the same system with this tax. This will cause great hardship on those who must collect and keep accounts for the Revenue Commissioners.

I think subsection (2) of this section takes the biscuit altogether. As far as the farming community are concerned, it is completely unpractical. It cannot possibly work.

I should like to ask the Minister how he expects the vast majority of the farming community who, in the main, do not keep any records and have not even the simplest from of a filing system, to accumulate records, invoices, receipts, accounts, vouchers, bank statements and other documents which relate to the delivery of goods of any kind by any person.

Comment on this

I do not expect them.

Comment on this

How does he expect ordinary people to keep these records for six years?

Comment on this

They will not be registered persons and therefore will not have to keep records.

Comment on this

What about a person other than an accountable person? The people who are not accountable persons are being asked to keep these accounts for six years. This takes in at least 200,000 large and small farmers. I would remind the Minister that at least 70 per cent of those 200,000 persons are farmers with less than 20 acres. They are people in the very low income group. These people, heretofore, have not kept an accounting system. In any one county, the people who keep formal accounts can be counted on the fingers of one hand. In my own county there are only two groups who have responded to the efforts by the advisory services to introduce some type of accounting system for farmers. In the whole county there are less than 30 students out of 5,000 farmers. That does not mean that only 30 people keep accounts but nevertheless the Minister is setting himself an extraordinarily difficult task.

When one looks at the penalty meted out under section 26 one will realise that we are going too far altogether. If the Minister expects co-operation on the grand scale he is laying down in this legislation he is completely misjudging the situation. It is unfair and unjust in the extreme to expect elderly farmers to keep accounts. If the Minister looks at the figures of the last census of population issued by the Central Statistics Office he will observe that a high percentage of farmers consist of elderly and bachelor farmers. Most of them are over 55 or 60 years of age. How can we tell people at that age to introduce a book-keeping system and to keep files and store them for six years? It is an impractical suggestion.

When one looks at section 26 one observes that the penalty is £26 a day for each day that accounts are not kept. Every person in public life, whether he be a Member of the Oireachtas or of a local authority, knows that if one is asked to assist a farmer in filling in an ordinary form for an agricultural grant the farmer usually cannot lay hands on the latest rates demand notice which may be only a couple of months old. The keeping of documents, invoices and receipts has not been a tradition in rural Ireland. By imposing a penalty under this section the Minister is doing a grave injustice to those people. He will not be able to bulldoze the farming community overnight into a state of efficiency. I would like to see the farming community keeping exact records because it would help them to become more efficient but I deplore the fact that the Minister is compelling them to do so with the big stick of severe penalties.

Comment on this

I think Senator McDonald made a very valid point but he could have cast his net a bit wider to bring in the trading community, which I have mentioned on more than one occasion. I am concerned about the small shopkeeper who sells around £6,000 worth of goods per year, which is a little over £100 a week, and whose business cannot be regarded as anything more than a huckster shop. According to this section:

every accountable person must keep such books, invoice, credit note, debit note, receipt, account, voucher or other document which has been issued by the person to another person. Any copy therefore which is in the power, possession or procurement of the person shall be retained in his power, possession or procurement for a period of six years from the date of the latest transaction to which the records or invoices or any of the other documents relate.

That is the accountable person. Then the non-accountable persons such as farmers, fishermen and shopkeepers selling under £6,000 worth of goods a year must keep all invoices issued to them in connection with the delivery of goods.

Apart from the impossibility of the farmer or the shopkeeper complying with that regulation, the next step taken against them is the likelihood of inspection. This gives an authorised officer of the Minister's Department very wide powers and the only comparison would be a police officer with a search warrant. The authorised officer can go right through the person's shop or dwellinghouse and look for receipts, inspect books, bank statements, invoices, credit notes, debit notes and every other document connected with the business. According to section 18 the shopkeeper or farmer concerned must co-operate; if he does not co-operate he will suffer very severe penalties.

The real problem in this section is, as Senator McDonald said, that the keeping of books by the farming community is almost completely unknown except in the case of the larger farmers. It is equally unknown to the small shopkeeper whose accounting system, as the Minister probably knows, consists of putting the invoices on one hook and the receipts on another hook. That is usually the book-keeping system of many small shopkeepers. I believe it would be impossible for them to work this section and I hope the Minister will find some means of modifying it to make it workable.

Comment on this

Small shopkeepers will come under this if they have a turnover of £6,000 a year, which is approximately £100 a week. They are not voluntarily going into the scheme; they will be compelled by the Act itself. As Senator Russell has pointed out, their book-keeping system is very limited. Those people will have difficulty in making available to an inspector of the Revenue Commissioners any books, credit notes, debit notes, receipts, accounts, vouchers, bank statements or other documents. Even in bigger businesses which keep such records the question is: where will they get storage space for those documents for six years? It will create quite a problem for them. At the moment they are obliged to keep their documents, under the turnover tax system, for a five-year period. Those people know that they could use the space taken up in storing these documents for other equipment connected with their business but they are compelled by law to hold the documents for inspection. I would suggest that that period should be reduced substantially. I cannot see the reason why, unless the Minister in his reply can convince to the contrary, it is necessary to hold such documents for six years.

Comment on this

The Minister intervened very briefly and, I am quite sure, bona fide to reassure Senator McDonald that it was not intended that farmers should have to keep these records. I looked down the section to see how that could be and because it seems to be clear that this section, as it stands, applies first under subsection (1) to accountable persons and, secondly, to everyone else who is not an accountable person as defined by the Bill under subsection (2). The only possibility for excluding from the operation of this section the categories to which Senator McDonald and Senator Russell referred would be by bringing into play the machinery provided in the second paragraph of subsection (3). That would be an immense task. The paragraph I am referring to reads:

Provided that this section shall not require the retention of records... in respect of which the Revenue Commissioners notify the person concerned that retention is not required.

It appears to be an immense task to bring that particular portion of subsection (3) into operation because it does not apply to classes or categories of persons: it applies to individual persons. These individuals must be notified, as individuals, by the Revenue Commissioners that in their case it is not necessary to keep this record, that book, or such and such an invoice. In other words, as I interpret it—I may be wrong in this—there must be individual notification by the Revenue Commissioners to the persons concerned. I could see that if the situation were that, under subsection (3), the Revenue Commissioners could, by announcement directed to particular classes, exempt from the obligations of keeping records, the thing might be workable. As it stands, unless I am reading the section completely incorrectly, it seems that the net is so wide as to cover everyone. The consequences of that are exactly what Senator McDonald has said: if the farmer, whether big or small, or the small shopkeeper to whom Senator Russell referred, falls down on the job of keeping the records required to be kept under section 16, of keeping the invoices, the accounts and statements, et cetera, for a period of six years, he automatically becomes liable to have the penalties provided in section 26 imposed on him. The penalties are no mean penalties. As Senator McDonald has pointed out, they start off with an initial penalty of £20 and after that a daily penalty of £20, as long as the omission continues. In the light of the remarks made by Senator McDonald and Senator Russell, anyone trying to look at the matter objectively and from an independent viewpoint would feel that what Senator McDonald and Senator Russell have said is quite right and, if this section goes through as it stands, it would be quite unworkable. It is not the business of the Oireachtas to pass legislation which is unworkable.

Comment on this

When I interjected during the course of Senator McDonald's remarks I said I did not expect the farmers, large or small, to produce, keep and maintain for six years accounts of their business. The remarks of Senator McDonald, and subsequently those of Senator O'Higgins, appear to suggest that they are under the impression that that is what this section requires. Of course it does not. I noted some of the phrases used by Senator McDonald. In relation to non-registered farmers, he talked about accounts, a book-keeping system and exhaustive files. Looking at the actual section it can be seen that the requirement in relation to such persons is only that they "shall keep all invoices issued to them in connection with the delivery of goods or of the rendering of services for the purpose of such business". In other words, if somebody issues them with an invoice, they are to keep it. They can put it on a hook—just keep it. That is all they are being required to do. They are not required to keep accounts or exhaustive files. That is all the section requires them to do.

The same requirement applies to unregistered small shopkeepers to whom Senator Russell referred. The reason for this requirement is very simple. If we did not have this requirement people could escape liability simply by refusing to keep any records. It would be completely open to abuse. They did not keep any records, they had no liability and they would be committing no offence by not keeping any records. It is as simple as that. The requirement in relation to unregistered shopkeepers or unregistered farmers is merely to keep the invoices which have been given to them.

Comment on this

For how long?

Comment on this

Up to six years.

Comment on this

Then subsection (3) relates to subsection (2) of the period of six years, because subsection (2) says nothing about six years.

Comment on this

I do not understand the Senator's point.

Comment on this

I took it that the Minister is making the point that the only subsection that applies to the small farmers or small shopkeepers is subsection (2), which requires merely the keeping of an invoice.

Comment on this

What I said was that the only requirement imposed on an unregistered farmer or shopkeeper was the one of keeping invoices issued to him. At one stage Senator McDonald made this point, that in subsection (2) this was where the requirement in relation to an non-accountable person existed. The requirements imposed on an accountable person are mentioned in subsection (1), and indirectly in subsection (3). The fact that the six years could apply to the non-accountable persons does not impose an obligation on them, additionally, to keep any records other than the invoices issued to them. That is the only obligation on them.

As far as farmers are concerned, many of them—indeed it may well be the majority of them—will in the course of their business be erecting farm buildings and will become subject to tax on the elements involved in that. They will be entitled to get a refund of the total amount of tax they have suffered in the farm buildings. In order to get it they will, of course, have to apply and, if they apply, they will have to produce their invoices to show the amount of tax they have suffered. Therefore, it is in their interests to keep accounts. If it is just a case of leaving a hook on the wall and shoving every invoice they get in connection with value-added tax on to that hook, that does not seem to me to be an undue imposition on anybody, be he a farmer or a small shopkeeper. It does not require him to produce an elaborate accounting system or book-keeping. It just asks him to hold on——

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

It will add to the number of hooks in the country.

Comment on this

I think Senator FitzGerald is getting the idea. In regard to the requirements of registered persons, they are somewhat more onerous, as one would expect. By being registered, these people are enabled to recover in full any tax which they have suffered. It is necessary therefore to have an accurate record of what tax they did suffer and what tax they should be allowed, either by refund from the Revenue Commissioners or by way of set-off against their liability. Under subsection (1), they are required to keep full and true records of all transactions which affect or may affect their liability to tax.

In regard to subsection (3) it might be thought on a first reading that they are required to keep all of the items mentioned. That is not what it says. What it says is:

Records and invoices kept by a person pursuant to this section and any books, credit notes,

and so on with that list, which are kept by him—

...and are in the power, possession or procurement of the person...

In other words, the only specific requirement is——

Comment on this

It says:

any books... whatsoever relate to the delivery.

Comment on this

Yes, but if they do not have them or do not have power of control in their possession, it does not impose on them an obligation to have all the things that are listed here. The only obligation imposed on them as regards the kind of record they keep, is contained in the following:

such records as will give a full and true record of all transactions which affect, or may affect their liability to tax.

Under subsection (3) all kinds of documents are listed which may be in existence, or which the person may have, or which are in his possession, power or procurement. In relation to those, he has got to make them available for inspection. It does not say that he is obliged to keep records of this kind. If he complies with subsection (1) that is his obligation as regards the kind of records he has to keep. It will be seen that the obligations on a registered person are not as onerous as might appear and are similar to those at present imposed on people under turnover and wholesale tax. As regards non-registered persons, the only requirement is to hold on to the invoices which are issued to him.

As regards the time involved, at the moment there is a requirement to keep them for six years. The provision in the second paragraph of subsection (3) is for businesses for whom it would be impossible to hold on to records for six years. On application to the Revenue Commissioners they can be given permission to keep their records for less than six years. It is not a question of the Revenue Commissioners issuing word to a particular group or class of people but if people applied to them the Revenue Commissioners would have power to modify this requirement.

Comment on this

Why six years? That seems a long period.

Comment on this

It is the existing period. If anybody finds difficulty in complying with this requirement he will find the Revenue Commissioners prepared to facilitate him, provided he is acting bona fide. If he is not acting bona fide he will not find the Revenue Commissioners co-operative. The vast majority of taxpayers are bona fide and we should not forget that. It is because the majority of taxpayers are bona fide that we have all the greater obligation to ensure that the minority who are not do not evade tax.

Comment on this

You are asking the vast majority, 95 per cent, to facilitate the 5 per cent who are not complying at present.

Comment on this

Anybody who has a particular problem will be able to get accommodation from the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Could I ask the Minister to clarify this? The Minister obviously knows what is intended under this section. I have no doubt his interpretation is correct. After listening to Senator McDonald and Senator Russell, I believed the points they raised were valid. The Minister has eased my anxiety, to some extent, by spelling out what is required in subsection (2), but I am still a bit uncertain as to what is required under subsection (3) of this section. It is clear what the requirement under subsection (2) is. It is for:

every person, other than an accountable person, who delivers goods in the course of business or renders services...

The requirement there is to keep all invoices issued to him. There is no dispute about that. I understood the Minister was making the case that the list of documents which are set out in subsection (3) has nothing to do with that and that all that was required was a "hook" long enough to take invoices for a period of six years and that you then complied with section 16. Subsection (3) reads:

...records and invoices kept by a person, pursuant to this section....

That seems to me to apply either to a person who keeps records under subsection (1) or who keeps invoices under subsection (2). The subsection reads:

...records and invoices kept by a person, pursuant to this section and any books, credit notes, debit notes, receipts, accounts, vouchers, bank statements or other documents whatsoever which relate to the delivery of goods by the person.

Is there any reason why that does not apply to the person who delivers goods referred to in subsection (2)? I would have assumed that the reference here to the delivery of goods by the person is equally applicable to the person who has delivered goods and obtained an invoice under subsection (2). It seems to me that Senator McDonald and Senator Russell are correct in thinking that the small farmer or small shopkeeper has an obligation under subsection (3):

...to retain any books, credit notes, debit notes, receipts, accounts...

Comment on this

Excuse me, that is not the case Senator McDonald made. I do not want to deflect the Senator, but he will recall that Senator McDonald made the case that small farmers were obliged to keep accounts, a book-keeping system and exhaustive files. That is not the case Senator O'Higgins is making, or is it?

Comment on this

No, this may clarify the position for me. There is no mention of an accounting system here. Am I right in thinking that any of these other documents, whether by a credit note, debit note or an account, must be kept for six years, and that copies must be kept in certain cases? To me it is not an excuse to say "possession of procurement was in my power but it no longer is", because the period of six years commences from the moment possession of procurement comes into a person's power. The period of six years starts from then, so that getting rid of one of the documents does not help a person.

Comment on this

It is quite clear from section 16 (1) that a set of accounts must be kept.

Comment on this

By an accountable person.

Comment on this

Yes, they must keep records. The books and so on itemised in section 3 would exclude some of the books normally kept in the accounting system. We should face up to the issue that an accountable person must keep an adequate set of accounts or books in conjunction with his business. There is no question of his doing away with a credit ledger or debtors' ledger or a bank lodgment book. He must keep a set of books. It would be misleading to say that he need not keep certain books. If he keeps a set of books, as understood by any accountancy practice, he must keep a complete set for inspection for six years unless he gets permission from the Revenue Commissioners to destroy them after four or five years.

An accountable person in the case of a shopkeeper is one who sells £6,001 worth of goods and over per year. Many of those people are not in a position to keep books. Many of them are what we call "man and wife" shops or shops run by one person. It could be a severe strain on these people, but under that section there is no way out of it. I suggested earlier to raise the limit to exclude a greater number of these people from the necessity of keeping what can, for a small trader, be quite difficult records.

Comment on this

I take the Minister's point that small farmers and shopkeepers have only to keep the receipts involved. For a large section of the farming community whom I know, this will be a new departure. I suggest to the Minister when this tax is launched he should simultaneously, or some time before, launch a campaign to explain this vital point to the community especially to those who are not used to keeping full records. In doing this, some of the other difficulties involved could also be explained.

Comment on this

I accept the spirit in which the Minister looks at this. When some unfortunate person, whether a shopkeeper or farmer, finds himself standing before a Circuit Court judge, will his lordship look up the spoken record of what was stated by the Minister here tonight or will he be guided by what is in the Act before him? It is likely he will be guided by the Act and so it is a pity the Minister did not state exactly——

Comment on this

It states it precisely that he must keep all invoices issued to him.

Comment on this

If what the Minister states is true, why did the draftsman not write into subsection (3) "records and invoices kept by a person pursuant to subsection (1) of this section"? He included the entire section. It can be read either way and there is a danger there. The Minister over-simplified it. It is not just a matter of getting one "hook". If he were to take that attitude he would need at least six "hooks", one for each year.

Comment on this

That would be an undue imposition over the six-year period.

Comment on this

The Minister has told the House that every item will come under value-added tax. For the least purchase the consumer can expect to have an invoice or receipt, and I should imagine a billhead will go with it. The amount of material will be great. These things will not last for six years, they will blow all over the place. I would be happy if the Minister would remove this section from the influence of section 26. A Circuit Court judge would have no option but to impose the penalties as set out in section 26.

Comment on this

Regarding Senator West's point, there will be publicity given to this and other appropriate matters arising out of this Bill after its enactment. Senator McDonald is mistaken in thinking that the penalties would apply automatically. They would have to be sued for, and liability established in court. It is not a question of a penalty being applied because the Revenue Commissioners "are of opinion".

Comment on this

This section is quite clear.

Comment on this

Which section?

Comment on this

Section 26 stipulates the actual sections and penalties. If a person cannot produce the invoices there is a definite case against him in the sixth year.

Comment on this

This would be a question for the courts and not the Revenue Commissioners, as to whether a person was guilty of an offence under this section. This brings in factors other than the mere presence or absence of records. At this stage I will not pursue that aspect of the matter. Subsection (2) is quite clear regarding the onus it puts on non-accountable persons such as small farmers and small shopkeepers who are not registered. It reads: "They shall keep all invoices issued to them."

The provisions in subsection (3), and many of the things listed, could not under any circumstances be deemed to be invoices or part of invoices. I read subsection (3) as meaning that in the case of either a registered or a non-registered person, if he happens to have any of these things mentioned, he has the obligation to produce them. There is no obligation imposed under this section on anybody to keep records of the kind mentioned in subsection (3). The obligation in the case of non-registered persons is to keep all invoices issued to them. In the case of registered persons, it is to keep full and true records of all transactions which affect or may affect their liability to tax. This means for many small shopkeepers a record of their sales and purchases, and very little else. This is a precautionary measure and is so for the simple reason, as I mentioned earlier, that without this provision people could evade all liability by refusing to keep records.

Comment on this

Even though the Minister states this is a precautionary measure, we all foresee difficulties at the time of the introduction of value-added tax. Even with a campaign to educate the general public there will be problems in the operation of this tax. I hope the Revenue Commissioners and the Minister will look leniently on the people, at least in the early stages in their compliance with these sections. Education at that early stage is much more important than the imposition of penalties on certain unfortunate people who may be caught by bad luck.

Comment on this

I can give complete and unreserved assurance to that effect.

Comment on this

Does section 17 (5) clearly indicate that tax must be added on when the invoice is being issued?

Comment on this

Would the Senator elaborate on that point?

Comment on this

To develop the point, let us suppose a person enters a retail shop, purchases some item that is carrying tax at the rate of 5.26 per cent to the value of £100, is it sufficient to add 5.26 per cent on the invoice? Can he embody it in the costings?

Comment on this

In each of the separate items? I understand what the Senator means.

Comment on this

If the answer is yes, it will present an awful problem.

Comment on this

The position is that it is open to the trader to do it either on the total or in relation to each separate item of the invoice. I am not sure if this is relevant to the point raised by the Senator.

Comment on this

I do not wish to interrupt, but I should like to simplify the point. Whether one, two or three items are involved, must the tax be kept separately on the invoice for each item?

Comment on this

No. It can be done either way.

Comment on this

The tax cannot be embodied in the costing?

Comment on this

Does the Senator mean: can an invoice be issued for a particular sum which is the total amount the person is going to pay because it includes the tax?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This can be done in the case of an unregistered person, but in the case of a registered person an invoice issued to him must show the tax separately.

Comment on this

Ninety per cent of the people in rural areas embodied the wholesale and turnover taxes at the costing. Where an item was carrying 5 per cent TOT and cost £5, they added 5 per cent to that figure to get their costing. What will the position of that merchant be when value-added tax is introduced?

Comment on this

Exactly the same as at present, if he wishes it to be.

Comment on this

That cannot be, because he has to give invoices for other people to get refunds.

Comment on this

Is the Senator speaking about the shelf price, or what he shows in his accounts?

Comment on this

It is the same price.

Comment on this

No. He can show the shelf price if he wishes, including the tax. He may well be compelled to do so, not under this legislation but under the Prices Bill. The question of claiming a refund is a separate matter. It has nothing to do with the customer. That is one of the reasons why the invoice he receives has to show the tax involved separately. When he claims a refund of tax, he produces this invoice and knows immediately how much tax he has paid on those goods.

Comment on this

But if he sells building materials to a farmer who will be applying to the Revenue Commissioners for a refund under a farm building scheme, he must show the tax on the various items.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

In that case, what will happen at the change-over period? For example, nails carry both taxes and he has them costed in as carrying both taxes. He then retails them at a given price and has to add the value-added tax.

Comment on this

Is the Senator speaking about the actual stocks on hand?

Comment on this

Yes, this is the danger.

Comment on this

That arises under section 34 of the Bill. He will be able to get a refund of the tax he has paid.

Comment on this

It will arise anyway and is going to create an awkward situation.

Comment on this

No, it is all worked out.

Comment on this

Section 18 (1) states:

An authorised officer may, for the purpose of making any inquiry which he considers necessary in relation to liability to tax of any person, enter any premises in which the officer has reason to believe that such person is carrying on business and the officer may request the production of, search for and inspect any books, invoices, credit notes, debit notes, receipts, accounts, bank statements, vouchers or other documents whatsoever relating to the delivery of goods or the rendering of services and may remove and retain any such books, invoices, credit notes, debit notes, receipts, accounts, vouchers, bank statements or other documents for such period as may be reasonable for their examination or for the purpose of proceedings for the recovery of a penalty under this Act.

Can the Minister give the same assurance in regard to this section as he did in relation to section 16 (3) where the small business person or small farmer is concerned? The two sections are similar. This section also carries a penalty.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Even more important is the fact that every Irish-man's home is his castle. It is not even limited to an accountable person. It refers to every person, accountable or not, who is carrying on a business.

Comment on this

A business as defined in section 1——

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The whole of Éire is open to the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

It is true it is not limited to accountable persons. This is necessary. It might well be necessary to establish whether or not a person was accountable. I could not do this without the necessary information. I can give an undertaking that the powers involved in this section will not be used by the Revenue Commissioners in cases where it is clear to them that any problems that have arisen are due to simply a lack of knowledge on the part of the people concerned and that it does not arise out of lack of good faith on the part of such persons. There is a considerable difference between this section and section 16.

I would assume that in the main section 18 would not be operated at all except in cases in which the Revenue Commissioners had good reason to believe that they were matters which required investigation by them and, in order to be investigated, required them to enter on premises, make inspection and if necessary take away certain records. There is a difference between the two sections and, subject to that difference and on the basis which I have outlined, I can give the undertaking mentioned.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

To ensure that all his successors will comply with it, can the Minister have it amended to limit it to accountable persons?

Comment on this

No. It would leave loopholes.

Comment on this

If, as the Minister told us, subsection (3) applies only to accountable persons, then how does subsection (1) apply to persons who are not accountable? It is the same list of books, invoices, credit notes and so on, in the main, that are concerned.

Comment on this

Section 18 involves action by the Revenue Commissioners. Section 16 involves the retention of records by taxpayers. There is quite a difference.

Comment on this

The Minister said when dealing with section 16 that subsection (3) did not apply to persons who are not accountable persons.

Comment on this

That is not what I said.

Comment on this

An officer of the Revenue Commissioners can come in and request production of these things specified in subsection (3). If they are not forthcoming, they can go in and search for them. The two are not compatible.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

When is an invoice to be issued? Fortunately, I was not here for the debate on section 17, but as I read it I do not see any provision for a time of issue. If there is not a time of issue, what is issued in due time and when is it that that invoice should have been issued?

Comment on this

It is intended to prescribe by regulation that this will be within ten days after the end of the month during which the delivery took place.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

That is provided for in section 32 (1) paragraph 5.

Comment on this

Yes, that is correct.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The section says that the Revenue Commissioners may refund the excess. Should they not be obliged to refund the excess and to include in the excess any interest paid? My second point is, while I am entirely satisfied and approve of the provisions with regard to the blind, why is this limited to the blind? There are lots of other disabled persons who could be beneficiaries of the subsection. Perhaps that is for future legislation.

Comment on this

They can be dealt with under ministerial orders. In reply to Senator FitzGerald's first question, I am advised that "may" means "shall" in this context.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

At this time of night I am inclined to believe the Minister.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister here about the refund of taxes. It says that the Revenue Commissioners may include any interest which has been paid under section 21 in the amount refunded. Will the Minister agree to pay in cases where the Revenue Commissioners are rather slow to agree to pay? Are the Commissioners empowered to include in their refund a similar amount in interest, that is, 1 per cent for each month that they delay in paying the refund back to the taxpayer?

Comment on this

No. The only provision is for refund of interest which might have been paid by the taxpayer. There are provisions of the kind mentioned by the Senator in regard to income tax and sur-tax, but the considerations involved are different and lead to a situation where we do not provide for interest or payments of that kind in regard to value-added tax.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is the interest here, if payable, deductible as a matter of expense in the other tax returns of the taxpayer?

Comment on this

Yes, it is.

Comment on this

I think that the penalties here as set out in this section are altogether too harsh, especially regarding the penalty of £20 for each day on which there is a continuity of the offence being committed. In cases where persons are just unable to find the invoices or the documents concerned that this is too severe. The Minister is not making any allowance for people on the lower rungs of the ladder who may find themselves in conflict with the law through indolence or ignorance. I should like to see a less severe section, or to have the penalty subsection deleted altogether.

Comment on this

I wish to support Senator McDonald. I should like to ask the Minister about the phrase, in subsection (1), which stipulates a £20 penalty together with, in the case of continuing non-compliance, a penalty of a like amount for every day for which the non-compliance continues.

I presume that if a farmer loses an invoice he is liable to a penalty for losing that invoice but the penalty is for that time only. If this invoice turns up some months later would it make him liable, at most, for a penalty of £20 and for no other day in the period? Also if a farmer loses two invoices on two separate days, as far as I understand it, he is liable for a penalty of £40 but nothing for the intervening period.

I do not know if we have much legislation which penalises somebody for losing something; therefore, I am not sure if this type of clause has come up in a case before the courts. I should like the Minister to say how this will be applied.

Comment on this

I should like to speak against what Senator McDonald has said in that the penalty is too heavy. This Bill must be given some teeth. From our experience in the courts, how rarely does a first or second offender get anything near the maximum penalty for which a Bill provides? This penalty is intended for the persons who is consistently failing to keep records.

Comment on this

Just to add to what Senator Crinion has said, there is no point in having all these elaborate provisions if you do not have some penalty to deal with people who are trying to avoid their obligations. To imagine that somebody who inadvertently loses an invoice will, in the first place, be prosecuted at the instance of the Revenue Commissioners and in the second place be subjected to the maximum fine under this section by the courts, is stretching the imagination too far. I would expect any court, on being satisfied that there had been a breach of one of these sections, but that there was no real intention to defraud the Revenue, would be inclined to apply the Probation Act.

The Revenue Commissioners are not going to waste their own time and the taxpayers' money by prosecuting people frivolously under this section. The only kind of situation in which there would be a prosecution would be where it appeared to the Revenue Commissioners that there is a deliberate attempt to evade liability or to aid and abet in its evasion. It is a matter for the court to decide whether it is of this nature. If the court is not so satisfied, the Probation Act would be applied.

Comment on this

Listening to the Minister one would think that the Revenue Commissioners were all saints complete with haloes. When one picks up the local papers week after week and finds the Revenue Commissioners prosecuting farmers for using marked diesel in tractors taxed at the rate of £2.50, despite the fact that that seems to be the law, I cannot see from where all these reasonable Revenue Commissioners come.

Comment on this

Surely the Senator is not suggesting that these people should not be prosecuted? If they are not prosecuted why should any of the rest of us use anything other than red diesel?

Comment on this

I mean using red diesel in tractors taxed for agricultural purposes. They are doing this in several counties. It all depends on what county you live in as to whether you will be able to do this.

Comment on this

It is the Land Rovers that are evading the tax. They should be paying a higher rate.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to explain subsection (2) for me.

Comment on this

This subsection provides a penalty for an unregistered person who issues an invoice showing tax in such a way that the receipient would be entitled to claim tax either by credit or refund.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I am concerned about the responsibility of a personal representative under subsection (3) of this section. Has the duty of a personal representative become so enlarged that he must infer correctly with regard to whether invoices are correct or not? Is he then in trouble if he makes the wrong inference? What is the obligation of the personal representative on such a matter?

Comment on this

It does not impose an obligation on the personal representative. It only says that: "If it comes to his notice" then there is an obligation. I cannot believe that any court would interpret that phrase as meaning that the personal representative should have found the error in the documents. I could not believe that any court could interpret that as meaning: "The documents were there and you should have known it."

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I hope the Minister is right.

Comment on this

I would assume on the normal interpretation of statutes of this kind that, in effect, the onus would be to show that there was something far more active than simply that the information was there but that it actually came to the notice of the personal representative.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Does this mean that someone who, for example, types out an invoice which is incorrect is liable to a penalty of £500? It would be the price of her job if she tried to do anything about it.

Comment on this

I do not believe that a typist in such circumstances would be liable under this section but, as the Senator knows very well, this would also be a matter for interpretation by the courts. I would assume that the courts would require some degree of active complicity before there would be any question of conviction in a case of this kind but I cannot purport to give any authoritative interpretation of this section.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I take it that these regulations must all be made before the specified date?

Comment on this

There is a continuing power to make regulations.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

But they would be concerning those appropriate persons?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Could the Minister give a short summary of the position of stock which is held by various people in relation to wholesale and turnover taxes paid on it?

Comment on this

The stock-in-trade held on the specified day will be chargeable with value-added tax on delivery and there would be double taxation if it had already borne turnover tax or wholesale tax on purchase by the person accountable. A claim for the appropriate relief must be made and the necessary adjustment will be made in the second and third taxable periods. The persons entitled to credit or repayment will be, generally speaking, retailers registered for turnover tax whose stock-in-trade includes goods which they bought at prices including wholesale tax. Secondly, persons such as building contractors who are not required to register for turnover tax or wholesale tax but who will be registered for value-added tax and who hold stock on which turnover tax and wholesale tax has been paid will also be entitled to credit or repayment. The relief will cover goods in stock for resale, work in progress, materials held for incorporation in the manufacture of finished goods for resale and consumable materials held for use in constructing, repairing or decorating premises.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say what the position is on stock held to which wholesale tax did not apply?

Comment on this

Does the Senator mean stock which would have been liable, in the normal way, to wholesale tax?

Comment on this

No, it would not be. This is at the appointed day. You will have huge stocks all over the country in different firms.

Comment on this

Stocks of what kind?

Comment on this

Which would not have a value-added tax. Now you are going to have a 5.26 per cent value-added tax coming forward.

Comment on this

I do not follow. Could the Senator give me an example of the kind of situation he envisages?

Comment on this

Value-added tax on any commodity which is not subject to turnover tax, on a whole range of goods which does not necessarily carry wholesale tax. Under value-added tax, as it will be applied, the 5.26 value-added tax will come in gradually. It will not be a turnover tax. It seems that there will be concerns carrying very large quantities of stock to which value-added tax cannot have applied up to date and to which turnover tax would apply normally. Are they subject to any form of value-added tax or will the Revenue Commissioners allow the normal turnover tax system in a value-added tax of 5.26 per cent on sales?

Comment on this

These would be goods which, on the appointed day, had not been subject——

Comment on this

——and had not been subjected to any tax. Thereafter, in the course of sale, they would normally be liable to 5.26 per cent.

Comment on this

When sold, yes.

Comment on this

I cannot see what is wrong with that situation that they would continue——

Comment on this

Let us take two years after the appointed day. By that time tax will have been paid from the manufacturing process through and collected back if necessary. Are the Revenue Commissioners going to take the view that the tax should have been paid on stocks?

Comment on this

No. I see what the Senator means.

Comment on this

It is only a technical point because the tax could be reclaimed.

Comment on this

They would only be liable to the 5.26 per cent. There would be no question of going back retrospectively and making them liable to the earlier levels.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Is it not odd to include betting tax?

Comment on this

I agree. It arises because we must increase excise duty from 10 to 15 per cent. We are abolishing turnover tax, for which the value-added tax is substituted.

Comment on this

Betting can be classed as a luxury.

Comment on this

I do not think Senator FitzGerald is objecting to it.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister whether a case cannot be made in respect of particular educational charities. I believe that in Britain there have been concessions to charities in the British value-added tax system, such as allowing the charities to spring up into their separate organisations for the purposes of reducing the level of taxation. I ask the Minister to consider transferring section 10 and the services listed under section 9, hospitals, nursing-homes, schools and similar establishments, from being exempted activities to the Second Schedule and, thereby, a zero rating. Under this First Schedule they will suffer certain disabilities which they do not suffer at the moment and they would be considerably better off coming under the Second Schedule.

Comment on this

What kind of disabilities does the Senator think they will suffer from which they do not suffer at the moment?

Comment on this

I have not worked this out in detail. However, I believe in the case of schools, colleges and universities they have exemptions on other items, rather than just the basic services which are mentioned in section 9. The actual example I have involves the purchase of scientific equipment for research which comes in the Third Schedule. Equipment which schools or universities buy for laboratories for scientific research is not mentioned in any of these schedules. Therefore, it is taxable at the rate of 16 per cent. I should like to have it reduced and to have it included in the Third Schedule. This is not actually the point I am making on this First Schedule. I should like the Minister to examine the case of educational charities and their position in the First Schedule.

Comment on this

The liability under value-added tax would be the same as the liability under the existing turnover and wholesale taxes. As I said earlier, I do not wish to change from that where I can avoid it, for the reasons I set out earlier.

Comment on this

But equipment of that nature was exempt from wholesale tax — if it was for research purposes.

Comment on this

There is no exemption of that kind from wholesale tax.

Comment on this

Some of the equipment I am referring to is mentioned in the Third Schedule, paragraph (e) of clause (xvii). The equipment mentioned there, coming under the 5.26 rate, is:

... of a kind used solely in professional practice either to make a diagnosis or to prevent or treat an illness or to operate.

I had hoped that equipment used for research of this nature would be included at the 5.26 rate in the Third Schedule.

Comment on this

The equipment to which the Senator is referring is not being changed as regards liability for tax under the value-added tax system. Therefore, I could not agree to a change. It might be possible at some future time but not on the introduction of value-added tax.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, I have not got the exact details that I would wish to have. If I find an anomaly I will write to the Minister and let him know what it is.

Comment on this

Regarding subsection (vii), I am not clear what the rate of tax is on feeding stuffs:"... designated for the use of dogs, cats, cage birds or domestic pets."

Comment on this

The pet foods are at the rate of 16.37 per cent.

Comment on this

In a certain size packet. Subsection (vii) (a) states:

which is delivered in units of not less than 10 kilograms and is not packaged, sold or otherwise designated for the use of dogs, cats, cage birds or domestic pets.

Comment on this

I think the Senator is referring to animal feeding stuffs, which are non-pet foods. The animal feeding stuffs which are sold in sizes at or exceeding those specified in the Schedule are zero rated. Animal feeding stuffs sold in smaller quantities are subject to the 5.26 per cent rate. Pet foods are subject to the 16.37 per cent rate.

Comment on this

In this connection I want to refer to tar, asphalt, bitumen and pitch. For road making and surface dressing, at the moment, an additive is added to enable materials to be used in damp or wet weather. That additive is generally imported from Sweden or France and used by the local authorities if they are manufacturing their own surface dressing materials, or otherwise used by some of the bigger companies who do surface dressing by contract. At the moment the additive is subject to wholesale and turnover tax. It is listed in the Third Schedule at 5.26 per cent. What rate will it be liable to?

Comment on this

The additive would be liable to 16.37 per cent, which is lower than wholesale tax plus turnover tax. However, I should point out that a local authority are entitled to recover all of the tax they suffer including this tax on the additive used in road making.

Comment on this

Have they not got this facility at the moment?

Comment on this

No. this will be one of their advantages from value-added tax.

Comment on this

I would like to ask a question about clothing. Up to now, manufacturers of clothing were not subject to wholesale tax. Now clothing, fabric and yarn are subject to value-added tax. Can that tax be passed along by getting the same rebate as others can get?

Comment on this

I would like to make it clear that there is no change in the incidence of the taxation. Where turnover tax only applies at the moment in this field, 5.26 per cent value-added tax will apply; where the lower wholesale tax, which is 10 per cent plus turnover tax at 5 per cent, applies at the moment, 16.36 value-added tax will apply. There is no change there.

In so far as it applies, a credit passed on may be claimed against liability or, if necessary, if the amount that a person claims for credit exceeds the liability, there can be a refund from the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister a few questions. I am disappointed that wool is included in the Third Schedule because wool has been at a bad price for the last few years. The entire wool industry is finding it difficult to cope because of competition from the synthetic fibres.

I regret that newspapers and school books were not included in the Second Schedule. I would be greateful if the Minister would clarify the position regarding medicines. Where is the dividing line between those charged at 5.26 per cent and those charged at 16.37 per cent? In this particular field there will be difficulties for retail chemists. The Minister might be able to elaborate on the dividing line.

Comment on this

We are not changing the incidence of taxation on wool or medicines. There is a marginal change being made whereby items such as insecticides, medicated detergents, shampoos and so on will be rated at 16.37 per cent. At the moment they are liable only for turnover tax and this has presented a number of problems, because as the Senator said, where does one draw the line. This is not a complete answer to the problem. There is no ideal answer but this will be a more rational approach in so far as these particular kinds of items would appear to be more appropriate to goods which are liable to turnover tax and the lower wholesale rate rather than to medicines subject only to turnover tax.

One change we are making here is to reduce the incidence of taxation on newspapers and periodicals, effectively taking the wholesale tax off and leaving them liable only to turnover tax. That is the effect of that is being done in value-added tax terms.

Comment on this

I welcome this change for newspapers and periodicals from 16.37 per cent to 5.26 per cent, but I am disappointed that the Minister was not bolder and that he did not go the whole hog and zero rate printed books, booklets, newspapers and periodicals. So far as books are concerned, this has been done in other EEC countries. I hope we will get around to getting them a zero rating in the near future.

I would like to ask the Minister about one difficult point which I raised previously in connection with wholesale tax or turnover tax. This concerns material of a printed and scientific nature coming in by exchange.

The specific example I have in mind is that of the Royal Irish Academy who produce a journal which is well known and circulated all over the world and in exchange for that journal they receive the proceedings of other societies from the entire academic world. We would not be able to purchase one-tenth of these. We get them by exchange and I hope the Minister will ensure that these journals and similar ones coming in by exchange are exempted from any further tax. It seems ridiculous that something which comes in by exchange for something we send out should be taxed.

Comment on this

It is necessary for administrative reasons to apply tax at importation. I have made arrangements whereby this tax can be recovered. I have gone as far as I can without creating a number of problems particularly for people whose livelihood is dependent on ensuring there is not an advantage for imported books as against those produced at home. I also have regard to the other desirable aspects of facilitating the importations of the kind mentioned by Senator West. The arrangements which I announced some time ago are as far as I can go.

I should like to assure Senator West that while I am Minister for Finance there will be no situation arising in which newspapers and periodicals are zero rated while essential foodstuffs are subject to 5.26 per cent.

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Minister has made concessions as far as the special importation I described arises. Do I understand him correctly in that the arrangements that now apply under the turnover tax will apply similarly to these items coming in so far as recovery of tax is concerned?

Comment on this

Under value-added tax? Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister has made the case that since we must tax foodstuffs, why should periodicals and newspapers be exempt? Provincial newspapers will go by the board if the Minister insists on applying value-added tax. It is not a good argument to say if we must tax foodstuffs, we must also tax newspapers. In my view, this is a tax on education.

Comment on this

The position of newspapers and periodicals is being improved substantially under value-added tax. The wholesale tax is being taken off. Under no circumstances would I, as Minister for Finance, attempt to justify taking tax off newspapers and periodicals while, at the same time, taxing essential foodstuffs.

Comment on this

The Minister should tax those and take it off foodstuffs.

Comment on this

We dealt with that earlier.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Are cassettes and tapes included here?

Comment on this

It does not include either of these. They would be at the 16.37 rate.

Comment on this

I should like to compliment the Minister. He had a difficult session in the other House and has had a number of important duties to attend to as a Minister of State, both inside and outside the country. We should not finish without thanking him for the manner in which he received the various points raised here tonight. He did not give us complete satisfaction but that would be asking too much.

It is proposed to bring the Act into effect on the 1st November next. It was suggested in the Dáil that it should be postponed again but the Minister has resisted that suggestion. I ask him to reconsider it. November 1st is a most inappropriate time to bring in a Bill of this kind. It is the pre-stocking up period for stores and business premises for the Christmas trade. It will present the commercial and business community with another problem on top of the many other problems with which they must contend.

Our friends in Great Britain are not introducing value-added tax until April, 1973, I think. A more appropriate time for us would be after the busy Christmas period when the business community will have more time to devote to complicated legislation of this kind. The Minister and his advisers may think the small shopkeepers and farmers will have no trouble in applying these laws, but I can assure him, speaking as one with some knowledge of the business world, there will be difficulties. I would ask the Minister to defer it until the new year when business would be slacker and the business community would have a better opportunity to become accustomed to this new legislation.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I should like to make one general remark on this Bill. The parliamentary draftsman should study closely the report of today's proceedings in the Seanad. I would suggest that in future when he is drafting a Bill he should put the most difficult sections at the end. We are all feeling tired and might be here for breakfast.

Comment on this

I do not wish to delay the House but in regard to the question of the date, If it is not 1st November this year it will have to be 1st March, 1973. I do not wish to accept that for a number of reasons. I would remind the House that the longer we delay putting the Bill into operation the longer we delay the benefits for the newspapers and periodicals and for retailers who stand to gain in two ways under value-added tax, first, by getting credit for tax on items which they use in the course of their business and, secondly, by increasing their liquidity substantially. That is why I am not anxious to delay the operation of the Bill. It can operate from 1st November without disruption to the Christmas trade. Any time later would create disruption. Finally, I should like to thank Senator Russell for his kind remarks which I very much appreciate.

Comment on this

Sula chuirim an Seanad ar athló ba mhaith liom an méid seo a rá: tá súil agam go mbeidh saoire taithneamhacha ag na Seanadoírí uilig agus ag oifigí na Tí.

I should like to wish Senators and officers of the House a very pleasant holiday.

The Seanad adjourned at 12 midnight sine die.

Comment on this