We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Appropriation Act, 1972: Motion.

Contributions 1–111 of 222. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I move:

That Seanad Éireann notes the supply services and purposes to which sums have been appropriated in the Appropriation Act, 1972.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Would the Minister like to assist our thought processes by coming in at this stage?

Comment on this
George Colley Minister for Finance (Mr. Colley) Fianna Fáil

This motion provides the Seanad with an opportunity of debating the expenditure provided for in the supply services Estimate and to discuss expenditure and financial policies in general. It is not usual for the Minister for Finance to make a lengthy opening statement on this general debate and I do not propose to depart from that procedure. However, I hope at the end of the debate that I will be able to reply as fully as possible to the various points which will be raised by Senators in the course of the debate.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

In considering as we must the manner of the administration of the sums which are the subject of the Appropriation Act it is not inappropriate for me in opening the debate to say something about the approach I would have to the object of the expenditure, to describe the kind of society we ought to be concerned to establish and to examine the defects which can be seen to exist in society. My approach, and that of my party, is obviously that of a party which are concerned to evolve something better than something that may be partly good and partly defective— not to swallow all the pseudo-solutions of revolution or accept any intellectual menace from the bloody-minded leap in the dark, of which a revolution consists.

In thinking about our problems, we should start with the realisation that the present situation is historically determined and capable of being improved and evolved through our conduct of the days that are left to us. We can look back over the period of our self-government and ask ourselves have we shaped a society to our own satisfaction, our own pride and the world's admiration. Although there has been achievement, and I am willing to say that and to repeat it, the society is not to our satisfaction.

I should like to say a word about our achievement. Only Finland—a special case—and Ireland, of all the countries which achieved freedom after the 1914-18 war, still retain it. We had a civil war with a peaceful end, thank God, and there was a subsequent transference of power which represented a triumph of character for the persons involved on both sides, and a triumph, too, of ideas. Alas, in our public debates very often truth gets injured and it is not in the way of public people to speak about unpopular truths. It is right to say that in respect of the ideas that have made possible the evolution that we have had we owe much to the liberal parliamentary achievements of Britain. There is much more that could be said about our achievement but that is sufficient for the moment.

Let us look at some areas of our affairs about which we might ask some questions. With regard to Northern Ireland, I think it is possible to say that our problems there—and they are our problems—derived from the fact that at once we accepted insufficiently our own history, and, in a sense, accepted Partition too completely. We accepted Partition too completely because instinctively the thoughtful people knew that in the terms of our own demands the problem was insoluble. It is the case once more of the best being the enemy of the good. We did not aim for the attainable but the unattainable. We must be truthful and it has lessened this factor very much through the impact of appalling events: we are too concerned with the persons within the State of this Republic, too little concerned with the people lying outside its jurisdiction. We did not see this problem, as I think it must be seen, as not merely a national problem—though it is that—but also a problem affecting the whole conduct of our foreign affairs, the whole question of the peace of these two islands. In accordance with our political thought, we should place this problem more clearly in that larger context. Reality has broken through to us all and, despite all the pain and suffering, I believe that there is a considerable degree of agreement in this House and in the other House as to the sort of approach which must prevail in the future.

I should like to mention something about our performance in regard to the whole affair of parliamentary democracy. There has been too ready an acceptance on the one party or the other that each or that any given speaker or thinker was a member of a more worthy, more moral or more patriotic tradition and sometimes the two conflicted. This has been bad for us and led us, in Parliament and in public life generally, to use words in a sense in which they ought not to be used, to attribute attitudes to other people that we know are not theirs. Indeed, for a party in Government in relation to the fruits of public expenditure, to behave in a true Santa Claus fashion—that genial, jolly, generous donor of gifts of which he is not the owner—has been bad for the country.

With regard to the whole movement towards the realities of self-government, as the parties succeeded each other in office each became more aware of these realities. They became aware that the voices from the past were sending us very often wrong messages. The songs were against those with the burden of government from time to time. I mention this particularly because it has an immediate relevancy arising out of some of the Taoiseach's experiences, as seen and described recently in America. An area of our foreign policy that we have not sufficiently listed as a high objective is the establishment of good realistic relations with our diaspora— with the Irish emigrants, who listen all too much to the voices of the past and know too little about the problems of self-government for ourselves. The Irish diaspora relative to Irish affairs is infinitely more significant than that of the diaspora of any other country except obviously the Jews.

I should like to mention a few general points arising particularly in relation to administration. We are now well into the month of January, and have not yet got the four-year plan which concerns the administration of the affairs of this country from 1st January last. That seems to be a bad mark, seems to be a failure. The first Devlin Report about recruitment to the public service and about the establishment of policy-making was published in 1969, almost four years ago, and early in 1970 it was accepted in principal by the Government. We are in 1973 now and a Bill has not yet been published. Why are there no improvements? What has happened to the plans for the decentralisation of government? These are matters for parliamentary consideration. Why were announcements made which, apparently, were never followed up? What progress has been made or what policy has been formulated in elaborating a structure for the proper public control of semi-State bodies?

Members of the Seanad and Dáil get reports every month from these bodies. How many of us study them? How many of us have the expertise to make worthwhile judgments on them? I have had a favourite idea for many years which I have expressed in this House, and that is that a holding company should be formed to hold the shares in these different semi-State bodies which would provide more apt control, have the management skills organised in a central way and give these bodies greater freedom.

We have had in particular two splendid appointments and the Government are to be commended on them. They did not come from any ranks that are remotely associated with the Government but they were splendid judicial appointments. It gave great heart to the whole profession for no other reason than the high quality of the appointments. Without naming them I could go on to say that there would be a general sharing of this view about the other appointments made to the Bench. However, is sufficient consideration given whether the range, in which selection is made for appointments to these boards, is wide enough? It stretches down in terms of age to a young enough age.

In regard to participation in the Government by persons affected by governmental policy, it is appropriate to say that various State Departments have much to learn from the practices of the European Commission who are not shy about sending out drafts of their proposals and widely circulating them to get the views of persons with real experience in the areas to be affected by the proposals. I hope that some of the funds to be appropriated by the Appropriation Act will be spent in that type of development. It is delusion to accept the idea that because civil servants have access to unpublished information they necessarily know everything about it, or even more than many people who have access to a lot of other information. There is much benefit to be got from an exchange of ideas between informed and confidential administrators and people whose lives give them different types of experience.

What is the position in regard to regional policy? Ten years ago the Committee on Industrial Organisation recommended unanimously on proposals for the development of growth centres outside Dublin. Their recommendations were supported by a further committee and in 1968 Buchanan reported. Five years later we have only the watered-down Buchanan Report of an industrial development policy produced by the Industrial Development Authority which only deals with industrial development. There is more to regional policy than that.

With regard to social policy, insufficient realisation seems to exist of the principle that what can be done by a subsidiary body can be done by that body better and cheaper and less bureaucratically than if it were done by a central authority. A most unfortunate decision was made on the advice of the Revenue Commissioners, which abolished the general principle that a covenant in favour of charities is an allowable reduction for tax and I would ask the Minister to open his mind to that. There has been a breach of the principle in recent years in so far as certain kinds of covenants are concerned and particular kinds of exercises and scientific research in that field are allowable deductions. There is a whole area of extended knowledge of social problems which could be well mapped and the solution to the problems propounded more rapidly if the people concerned were properly financed.

Housing is the most acute of our social problems. If a person tells me that it cannot be solved without creating a burden which would hold back economic growth, I say it would be better to hold back economic growth because economic growth is a pseudo development if it leaves that kind of social evil unsolved. In this field we should break away from British and Continental thinking and recognise it as a burden on Christian conscience to see that the resources are applied in a radical way to the solution of that problem. In housing one of the big problems is the actual cost of the site. The Minister should examine some of the factors operative in regard to the cost of sites, in particular, in the Dublin area. There is, first of all, the inflationary effect of the gentleman's agreement with the insurance companies to invest up to 80 per cent of their premium income in Ireland. Having regard to the nature of the Irish Stock Exchange, this has actually had the effect of transferring additional demand for development land in Dublin city, to mention just one area. The impact on the cost and price of houses of the existing subsidy system is worthy of very close examination. I have very little doubt this is merely adding to an existing demand and pushing up the price of what is bought. Where wealth and value are being conferred on property owners, by the mere fact of property ownership, in a situation of economic and population growth, there is ample justification for a taxation of these additional values. Consideration of the supply and demand side of this problem is urgently necessary and, associated with supply, is the question of the direction of resources into making land available for building.

I come now to inflation. Inflation is viciously anti-social; it leads to the transfer of resources into non-productive purposes. It leads to taxation of the thrifty, of pensioners and of those on fixed incomes. This, proceeding at a lower rate, as far as I know, in Britain, has led to a major crisis there. The figures I have show that the price rise in Britain between 1968 and 1972 was 27½ per cent and, during the same period in Ireland, it was almost one-third more. Yet, we have still no incomes and prices policy.

According to the October publication of the Economic and Social Research Institute, the rise in food prices was of the order of 14 per cent up to that month. Yet, with such a rise in food prices, we go ahead with value-added tax. The Financial Times stated yesterday that people were now talking seriously in Britain about a negative value-added tax on food. What steps have been taken or are proposed to provide protection and information for consumers, or to consider the formulation of laws which would ensure they were given full details of the contents of packaged goods?

Now, as to our employment situation, the Industrial Development Authority in March, 1972, reported 7,700 new jobs but during that period 11,600 were laid off, a loss of 3,900 jobs. There may be more recent figures, but these are the most recent I have seen. For March, 1973, there were 8,000 new jobs with a redundancy of 10,000 during that period. Even allowing for the estimated disappearance of emigration in 1972, this is an acutely embarrassing position. Facts which are there, in alleviation of our problems, and which should be noted, are that the terms of trade shifted in our favour and it was estimated in 1971 that the effect of the improved price of exports relative to the price of imports was to give us an additional £12 million resources and, in the following year, to give us an additional £20 million resources.

I am in favour of the free system of government and the free type of society. I am for the saver retaining the fruits of his thrift and his work. I do not believe egalitarianism is right or that there is anything wrong in property-owning. Indeed, there is a great deal to be said for it but the free system must justify itself by its performance and demonstrate its superiority.

Is our society just in tolerating a wretched housing situation, a higher rate of inflation than exists in Britain, in not providing a solution to the unemployment problem and in leaving unchanged a taxation system with many defects? I will pass charitably over the very bad mistake made by the Minister, when he first became Minister, in raising corporation profits tax. This was later reversed. We should learn from that mistake. Taxation on retained company profits is taxation on employment. It is a tax on demand for labour and, in the future formulation of company tax policy, this fact must be recognised.

The personal allowances, where they apply to the lower range of taxed incomes, are quite inadequate and often involve the ridiculous position that that same individual may be paying tax and getting social welfare relief at the same time. Taxation of earned income, when it reaches a certain level, is both excessive and stupid because one of the things we need here is management skill. That is one of the things we must attract if we are to make this country that which it should be. The Americans cannot afford to tax earned income at more than 50 per cent and they are a great deal better able to afford things than we are. Until that nettle is grasped a great deal of worthwhile progress will be retarded.

Reforms in local finance are long overdue. The high rates are inequitably spread and have no regard, as we all know, to the incomes of the payers. They are effectively regressive. There is only one solution and that is to take the health cost off local finance and find the money for it some other way.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

And malicious injury payments.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

With regard to savings, the effects of inflation on these should be faced. I know the Minister has designed schemes which encourage private savings. These schemes are good but they are of use only to savers who are prepared to put their savings into public funds. Our taxation system should encourage worthwhile development like, for example, employee share schemes. So far as industrial democracy is concerned, there is no energetic plan to bring that about. Certainly there is no plan that I know of. Why have we, as a community, done nothing to encourage workers to participate in enterprises? There is a participation of which they are insufficiently aware through the employment of pension funds and so on.

With regard to law reform, what have we had in the lifetime of this Parliament? Elsewhere there has been considerable progress. About ten years ago we were told about a series of measures of law reform; we had two. Then there was a great silence. To highlight the weakness of performance, let us take one single area. In March, 1971, the Minister for Justice announced that he proposed to amend the landlord and tenant law; two years have elapsed and we have not yet seen the amending Bill. A decision must then have been made. This leaves people with problems of tenant right or landlord right of property interest in a state of great doubt as to what their position is in a whole host of situations.

In education we have had the occult formation of largely imitative policy. Where is the appreciation of standards, the awareness of criticism, the encouragement to open debate? In the administration of educational policy no regard is shown for the value of old institutions, the importance of old loyalties or a recognition that they are, in fact, carriers of culture. If we take the field of planning, in which vast values are now involved, we will find it is inadequately staffed and badly structured. There should be a special planning body divorced from the Minister.

I do not want to make too much of any of the things I have said. Another man might make much more of them. I will content myself with the general proposition that small mistakes in government can be writ large in the lives of people and it is a sort of corruption for any of us to tolerate remediable ills. Surveying Ireland, I certainly am not a bit ashamed to be here, nor before I was here, to be doing what I was doing in relation to politics. The heaviest weight of responsibility for our situation lies on those who ought to, but are not, playing their part. Again, in relation to all I have been saying, at another time we could have had great trouble in Ireland and it is worth asking ourselves, with that sort of record, why have we not had trouble? It is a classical example, I think, of foreign distractions permitting a degree of domestic dereliction of duty. Putting it brutally, if we had not had the trouble in the North we would have had a great deal more social trouble here; and we should anticipate that by a renewed sense of purpose to change and improve the situation.

At the end of what I have had to say, I come back again to the beginning and ask what is our purpose? It has been a cliché used by people on this side of the House that we want a just society. I would rather like to take that phrase out of the hot context of politics in so far as it may suggest that other Members do not. In terms of the world that is, I should like to put this in a slightly different form: we have, economically speaking, capitalism here and we should, I think, stand for the realisation of a reformed capitalism. Do we give our people sufficient reasons for work and study and dedication? Is our concern for truth and justice completely unreserved?

We are at a difficult historical moment. One empire has dissolved and left in its trail a people deeply shaken in their self-confidence, a society sick with a sickness which is infectious. There is a widespread anti-Americanism based, to a considerable degree, upon a resentment by the British of the American imperialism which has succeeded the British. It emphasises, I fear, our colonial situation in the extent to which we find that anti-Americanism here. At this point of time, at which one empire has succeeded another, that second empire, the American, may be having its Boer War in Vietnam shaking its own confidence. Anti-Americanism is not a propos our situation. World power blocs are an inescapable fact and, if we cannot have a Roman peace, the only peace we can have is one resulting from a balance of world powers. Materialism has been all that we have tolerated. Without it being positively offered, it is still there. But materialism is no answer; its satisfactions are meagre, transient, delusive and insufficient.

Nationalism of the narrow, introverted type—which, alas, ours has become—will not cope with our needs. I have a hope that in this year the focus of our loyalties may be shifting and the horizons of our imaginations may be extending. I do not think, even if it be rhetoric, even if it is what is sometimes described as windy rhetoric, it is wrong to speak of the free world, because there is a free world, a world in which men are not imprisoned or punished by authority for speaking the truth. In this month, it seems right for me to say that I think our traditions are wholly reconcilable with those of Europe and our ambitions achievable within it. We could - there find the stimulus for and the liberation of our energies, a society capable of being shaped to the likeness of the image which has been our best inspiration, an image faithful to tradition, Christian and free, an image worthy of the devotion and loyalty of all our people.

Comment on this

I listened with considerable interest to what Senator FitzGerald had to say. There was, if I may say so, an air of resignation in the tone with which he delivered his remarks. Indeed, it was something of a surprise to find that on the Fine Gael side of the House the debate was opened by Senator Alexis FitzGerald and not by our familiar debator, Senator O'Higgins. Perhaps it is this air of resignation that I detected and the fact that Senator Michael O'Higgins, who was in the Chamber, did not open the debate that underlines more than anything else the great change in the political climate in which we are debating this motion.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Has the Senator the faintest idea of where Senator O'Higgins is or what he is doing? Why, therefore, draw conclusions about his absence?

Comment on this

I am about to draw an important conclusion from his absence. On previous occasions Senator O'Higgins has been present and has taken great delight, in almost every Appropriation Bill debate, in producing the election manifesto of the Fianna Fáil Party and in reading out one particular sentence in that manifesto.

Comment on this

I wish to intervene for a moment. I know the Senator has a point to make, but it is hardly relevant to the Acht Leithreasa, 1972. I would like the Senator to return as soon as possible to the Appropriation Act.

Comment on this

The point I am about to make does not depend on the presence, in any part of the building or elsewhere, of Senator O'Higgins. However, in previous debates of this kind he has placed repeatedly on the record of the House a quotation from the manifesto of the Fianna Fáil Party at the last general election. That sentence reads: "Only a united Government vigorously and resolutely pursuing clearly defined policies endorsed by the people and supported by a secure majority in Dáil Éireann can face these problems and overcome these difficulties." In previous debates Senator O'Higgins has tried, and perhaps people have felt that there was some evidence for his suggestions, to raise the point that perhaps there was not a united Government, perhaps there was not a Government vigorously and resolutely pursuing clearly defined policy and he queried the future of that Government in office. He has not been here to make that claim on this occasion. He has not opened the debate and that is definitely significant. There is an air of resignation on the other side of this House.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

He would give a loud laugh if he could hear that. He will be back yet and I hope the Senator will be here to listen to him.

Comment on this

I will. Many of the points made by Senator FitzGerald I intend to repeat in a rather different way because, like Senator FitzGerald, I tend to regard this debate on the Appropriation motion as a time for looking back, a time for assessing one's position, a time for making general views known about how one should advance to face the problems ahead. This country is now in a position where the Government of the day, which went through certain difficulties reflecting the stresses and strains felt in the community in general by way of reaction to the serious situation in Northern Ireland, have faced up to those difficulties, dealt with them and now stand as a united Government vigorously and resolutely pursuing clearly defined policies. They stand in a position where, following the uneasy situation that followed the last general election, we have had the implied mandate of referenda decisions and particularly of the by-election in mid-Cork. Although Senator O'Higgins or Senator Kelly may feel it fair and factual to say that the majority of the Fianna Fáil Party in Dáil Éireann did not look too secure we, in Fianna Fáil, would not quibble with that at all. We would be quite happy, at any time and at any moment, to put this question to the test of a general election.

I would like to suggest that it might be timely, now that we are facing an election year, to look at the work in hand and to see the attitude that the Government, backed by the Fianna Fáil Party, can bring to the problems that lie ahead.

First of all, I thought it interesting that in his review of the present situation Senator FitzGerald did not query the basic economic soundness and health of our present position. The points he made about the structure of our taxation system and other matters were of interest and his approach to the matter of detail, as always, were well worth consideration. However, it must be stressed that our economy is in a basically sound state and commentators are looking to an upturn in the indications of progress and prosperity in a modern economy. Their optimism, in this regard, relates to the fact that we are now members of the enlarged European Economic Community and stems from the massive endorsement of our membership by the people.

I have already dealt with the political climate but I would like to underline that the people, if asked for their views on the matter, would say resoundingly that the only party capable of offering united and vigorous Government is the Fianna Fáil Party, led by An Taoiseach, Jack Lynch. I am sure the people would state that this is the time for a major advance in a number of important policy areas. At this time, when we have all been disturbed by the serious, sad and tragic events in the North and when we have had a time of questioning and self-analysis, the people are looking for a new spirit and new attitudes in which to approach the problems we all acknowledge exist. This is the time for an outward looking and generous spirit to be demonstrated to the world and to our neighbours on this island. It is also a time for trying to achieve a community approach to the human problems which beset many of our people. It is vital that this new spirit and attitude should not be shattered in any way by the inadequacy or inflexibility of any of our institutions essential for progress and development.

There were a number of occasions on which Senator FitzGerald may have been slightly unfair or misleading on some of the points he made and in talking about the importance of the institutions of our public service and their need for development he mentioned that, following the publication of the first Devlin Report, no Bill had even been published. This is not the case. The Ministers and Secretaries Bill has been published and circulated. From time to time, I have indicated that I would like to see it processed by the Houses of the Oireachtas but it is not correct to say that no Bill was published following the publication of that report. Neither is it correct to give the impression that nothing has happened since the publication of that report because major steps in the framing of the new Public Services Department, which is the key to the implementation of the Devlin proposals, have been taken. I am sure the Minister will deal with this point later on but the Minister has indicated that in certain chosen Departments steps have already been taken to re-organise the work of those Departments on the Aireacht principle which is fundamental to the Devlin proposals.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

There has been a motion in connection with the Devlin Report on the Order Paper for three years, so it does not seem that the Government want this House to——

Comment on this

I do not want to allow myself to be diverted by interruptions; I respect and participate as much as I can in the debates that take place in this House on motions. To say that a motion has not been taken is no index whatsoever of a lack of action by any Department of State.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

It is some index, not a great one.

Comment on this

I should like to proceed to a selected number of topics in the light of the spirit and attitudes which should inspire our approach to certain problems and certain policy areas, particularly in the next 12 months. First of all, I should like to say something about the work handled by our Department of Foreign Affairs. I hope my comments may be helpful at a time when our new Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Brian Lenihan has taken up his office with great élan. This was evident at the meeting of the Council of Ministers and was very encouraging.

In discussing matters of foreign affairs and international relations, particularly after the campaign on the European Economic Community and its enlargement, the Government should make sure that no one is under the impression that Europe is the world or that the Communities are the world. Our people should realise that. There is a great deal more to our place in the world and our attitudes towards international relations than our business with and membership of the enlarged European Economic Community. This is something we will see in great measure this year as the Community itself tackles the major questions of its external relations, its trading partnership with the United States and its contribution, through the member states, to the forthcoming European conference on security and co-operation. We will also see it in the attitude of the Community towards the developing world which will increasingly become a matter for major debate.

It is extremely important—particularly as we in Ireland have distinctive views on a number of those topics and in the area of European security—that our attitude on such topics should be extremely well thought out and we should constantly ask ourselves if we are giving an adequate proportion of our resources and manpower to consideration of an work on those topics. It will be very difficult for Ireland's voice to be heard effectively on any of the major international issues unless first of all our Government, and, secondly, our people, are adequately informed on the issues involved.

I should like to give one practical example: during the negotiations leading up to the enlargement of the European Community Ireland was represented, with the applicant countries, on what is known as the d'Avignon Committee, which was a committee set up by the Council of Ministers to consider questions in the foreign policy field. That committee set up subcommittees to examine matters like the situation in the Middle East and problems connected with the Mediterranean, and so on. It must be extremely difficult for our Department of Foreign Affairs to make a worthwhile contribution to those important debates and studies. Though they may seem remote, nevertheless they may be greatly to our interest. In our particular case, as a country with a firm commitment to peace, with no colonial tradition and with a history of respect for the United Nations and its Charter, it is important that we should make as active a contribution to such discussions and debates as we possibly can.

If there is anything that needs to be examined, whether it is about the location and distribution of our embassies, or about recruitment of specialist staff for the Department of Foreign Affairs —and there must be many other examples of new stresses and strains on that Department at this time—it is very important that such improvements and such reviews should take place as soon as possible. We are in a stage where many things will be happening very quickly. Events happen always after a period such as the enlargement of the European Economic Community, while everybody is looking at a new situation. It is very important that Ireland's voice should play a key part in this time of change.

I am spending a little time talking about this, because, generally speaking, there is not a great deal of public interest in foreign affairs or in the work of our Department of Foreign Affairs. There is much glib analysis in the newspapers of the role of our embassies: the suggestion is made that embassies are luxuries, that they should concentrate on trade matters and so on. Certainly, trade is important, and Ireland's role as a trader to the Community and to the world is extremely important. However, ultimately our whole future depends on the peace and stability of this globe on which we live. If, by our voice in international relations we can do anything to help promote the continuance of that peace and stability, it will be absolutely invaluable.

I am aware of the cost of establishing new embassies in different countries. Perhaps we could avail of the information services of such neutral powers as, say, Switzerland and Sweden, who have embassies all over the globe. Such embassies would have reports regarding certain world problems which would help to make sure that we were informed about the crises that mean so much—and will mean so much—in a Community in which countries such as France, Germany and Britain have major overseas commitments. There must be some way of ensuring that our sources of information are up to equal participation— and we are equals in political discussions—in that enlarged Community and this would be worth considering.

I should now like to refer to a topic that has already been mentioned, the situation in the North. The words I have already used about spirit and attitudes are absolutely crucial here. If there is to be any advance at all in human relations on this island, it is absolutely vital that the people of the Republic should come to understand what real generosity is and what the essential spirit of compromise must be. The understanding must be there if one is to become reconciled in peace with people whom it must be conceded have very different views on some topics. They have entrenched hardened attitudes on many matters in which they would differ vastly from the great majority of people in the Republic. It is absolutely vital that we generate an understanding of what real generosity is. We should also generate a spirit in which people may be prepared to accept changes which, if they were to act exclusively in their own interest, they might find in some way repugnant. That is what real, human progress is in terms of reconciliation: it is to be prepared to give to a fellowman something that one would not necessarily ask for oneself.

I should like to refer to two things which deter people from advancing towards these attitudes of generosity and compromise or mutual understanding. First of all, because future relations between North and South are so often stated in economic terms and in terms of bridging the social welfare gap, and because people tend to feel that this is not just possible in material terms, they tend to be discouraged. They are inclined to say: "No matter what we feel about it, it will be impossible to persuade the people of the North to come into any close partnership with us, if it will mean they will be hit in the pocket or that they will lose out in some way." As far back as 1959 in his speech at the Oxford Union, Seán Lemass said quite clearly—and I am often interested to see how many current speeches on the North reflect the wisdom which Seán Lemass showed at that time— that he felt it would be possible to maintain separate levels of social welfare benefit for a lengthy period, if necessary, in both parts of this island. He felt that would be politically acceptable in the interests of progress towards the reunification of this island. In addition, when we are discussing the question of different social welfare benefits between North and South—and the gap has been narrowed since Seán Lemass made that speech—we tend to leave out of account the British contribution to the North.

At present the British and Irish Governments have a common interest in stability in these islands. Seeing the amount of money the British Government pour into the disastrous tragedy in the North she is extremely anxious to find a solution to the difficulties which face us all even at considerable financial outlay and I think that given any possibility of a lengthy period of stability in conventional terms in the North, some return to—I do not like to use the word "return" because the situation was abnormal and we do not want to get back to an abnormal situation—any kind of conventional peace in the North, the British Government would be prepared to continue its massive expenditure in Northern Ireland.

In times of peace that investment would be worth far more to Britain than at a time when the transfer of resources is bringing and meaning nothing but trouble to the British people. Stability means one thing to Britain: that is the possibility of trade and friendly relations. It also means an end to the peculiar fear which Britain has because she is in many ways still an imperial power, this fear that insecurity in the western part of the islands of which Britain sees herself as the centre, is, in some way, a threat to her security in the global sense. The cost to Britain at the moment and the possibility of future improved trade and better relations which real understanding between all parties in these islands would mean, all these considerations for Britain underline the real probability that Britain will be prepared to make a major contribution for a long time to come which would be of assistance not only to the North but to the whole island and its future.

I have said this to try to combat the feeling of helplessness which people often develop when looking at the North and trying to tackle this economic argument which is so readily bandied about.

We must try to lead all the people of the Republic to a situation in which they will have a real attitude of generosity and understanding towards their fellow Irishmen in the North. I do not underestimate the difficulties of this. If one wants examples one need only think of what the attitudes of the people must be in our border towns when faced with some terrible recent murders in their midst. This is an important role for political leadership. It can be a particularly important role for the Fianna Fáil Party, a party who now know what it has meant for people to have different views on the best approach to the situation in the North. Now, in a united sense this party have their firm commitment to a peaceful solution of the problems and they must move on further and quickly to spread, throughout their ranks, a real understanding of what generosity and change mean in a situation where we must now move as rapidly as we can to reconciliation of people.

I want to say a few words in relation to the economy. Senator FitzGerald referred to inflation and particularly to the problem of prices. This theme for a Community approach to the problem is apt where the problems of inflation and prices are concerned. We are living in an unusual situation and I do not think that Senator FitzGerald's view that people would be more concerned about problems of this kind here if it were not for the distraction of the situation in the North is a fair comment. The attitude taken and the patience displayed by our consuming public in the face of rising prices is not due to a distraction but to a wide understanding that there have been a number of different factors in inflation here compared with the situation facing the people in Britain.

One of the big advantages of our EEC referendum campaign was that our people are better educated and have a better grasp of what the EEC means than the people of Britain and though an effort was made at the time when much publicity was given to the inquiry set up by the British Government into beef prices, comparable efforts to creat some kind of a stampede here did not succeed—for obvious reasons. The average man in the street already knew what it took this public relations commission set up by Edward Heath three days to find out. The average Irishman knew the factors which had led to an increase in the price of beef because he understood what agriculture is about and how it works; he understood something about the EEC and how it would affect the situation and he did not need any commission to say that we were in a position in which it is difficult to do anything more than describe the situation. That is one reason why we did not have the type of clamour about beef prices here that occurred in Britain, a clamour which, to my mind, led to this ridiculous piece of showmanship by the British Government: the setting up of an inquiry which they must have known could not produce any change in the situation.

Another major achievement for which all our people must take credit is the fact that we are in our second negotiated national wage agreement. I should like to pay great tribute to both sides of industry on reaching this agreement, an agreement endorsed by consultation among their members. Consultation means education. When certain percentages have been negotiated for the work force, and have been phased in a certain way, this helps to give a common-sense understanding that there is a relationship between wages and prices. We in this House are as aware of rising prices as the man in the street and of what it means to pay more for the groceries. Another factor which helps us to accept this is that we have all experienced real improvements in our standard of living.

I should like to applaud the work of the National Prices Commission in this connection. This body, set up towards the end of 1971, unlike so many other bodies, each month produce a report stating exactly what they are doing, where they are going, what their recommendations are and, if action is being delayed on the comments made in one report, they state this in the next report. It is unfortunate that space does not permit the printing of these reports in full in the Press each month. In addition to the specific recommendations made by them, they often do an excellent background analysis of the reasons for price increases which they have had to recommend for acceptance in the previous months.

If this leads to a community understanding of what inflation means it is invaluable. The problem of rising prices and inflation can only be met by community understanding, by an appreciation that we all have a part to play by prudent spending, by critical purchasing and by having an interest in the best consumer standards. If we work collectively we can do something to contain this process of inflation. I should like to see the idea put forward by the National Prices Commission, of the establishment of local prices committees, catching on in a major way. This would be community involvement at its best. Local prices committees who follow the functions outlined by the National Prices Commission in their monthly report No. 6 of April, 1972, could have a big impact. Local communities throughout the country which would collect and collate information on retail prices, and generate an interest in price comparisons, and make consumers more aware of their role in seeking value for money, and insist on proper consumer standards, could do a great deal to curb inflation.

From time to time among certain bodies, some of which are State-sponsored and have been refused applications for price increases by the National Prices Commission, I have detected attempts to brow-beat the National Prices Commission into saying: "You are quite wrong. You have not examined this enough. What do you know about it?" I intend to take a particular interest in this subject. We should all do what we can to back up the National Prices Commission in their work month by month. They have been proved to be a hard-working body of integrity, anxious to get to the bottom of every question which faces them. They have no axe to grind. They are representative of all sections; workers, employees, industry and the consumer.

I should like to say something about the underprivileged in our society. Senator FitzGerald asked us to accept as a fact the existence of some appalling housing conditions. We accept that fact, although on this side of the House we have put it on record that we are ahead of our projections for house building. These projections were endorsed by the people in the 1969 general election. The White Paper on housing in the 1970s was published shortly before that. We are ahead of the projected figures for house building in that White Paper. The problem still exists and more work must be done. As much of our resources as possible should go into housing. Bad housing is a major cause of many of the social ills of family life.

There has been a great deal of debate on the problems of underprivileged children and the problems of women trying to face up to unusual domestic difficulties, stresses and strains and legal disadvantages under which, to my regret, they still labour in our society. I hope we will not have to wait too long for the report of the Commission on the Status of Women and that these matters will be dealt with as a matter of urgency.

The problems facing underprivileged children, which are of particular interest to women, and problems of health and welfare generally, have been under examination by researchers, pressure groups, the Hierarchy and various other interested bodies. When one reads about particular cases one wishes that there was sufficient money available to go around. One wishes there was not the problem of establishing priorities. As things stand at the moment, much could be done, even without greater resources, if we had a great deal more flexibility in our institutional arrangements for dealing with the problems of the underprivileged. I am speaking about attitudes, understanding and compassion.

I do not wish to be critical of public servants, servants of local authorities and Government Departments, because I know they have an unenviable task at times with limited resources. There may be occasions when they would dearly like to express criticism, if they were permitted to do so, of the politicians who so readily point to what needs to be done. As politicians we can give leadership. I should like to see a much more constructive and outward looking spirit throughout our public services and local authority services. At times I fear matters of red tape and bureaucracy impinge in an inhuman way on many cases of hardship and underprivilege. Politicians, particularly those with a constituency interest, may see this more than others.

People sitting behind desks who send out abrupt and curt notes to a person in distress cannot be aware of the impact of that note on the person who receives it. It is a further thorn in the flesh at a time of serious hardship. I should like to give one specific example which, to my mind, needs urgent attention.

It is possible at the moment for a wife living with her family in the Republic to be deserted by her husband. He can then go to Britain, gain a divorce and live there with another wife and family. In that situation the deserted wife is not entitled to a deserted wife's allowance. The fact of divorce, even though it is not recognised by our Constitution, is sufficient as things stand to rule out her application for an allowance as a deserted wife. May I say at this point that I very much welcome the allowance for deserted wives which was brought in by the Government? I have experience of one case, which is with the Minister for Social Welfare at the moment, where a wife was deserted by her husband and received no deserted wife's allowance because her husband had divorced her and was living in Britain. When that man died, she applied for a widow's pension and, when at last it seemed she was in striking distance of at least a regular weekly payment as of right, without going to the local home assistance officer, she received in reply to her application for a widow's pension a letter which said she had not shown conclusively that she was a widow.

Bureaucracy or the letter of the law can lead to a situation where a woman whose husband has died is told that she has not shown that she is a widow and is thereby deprived of a pension for herself and her children. That is nonsense and, in my view, it should be dealt with by a stroke of a pen if it can be dealt with at all. Finance does not enter into it. It is a matter of an administrative difficulty. There must be many examples of this kind. We have seen them in the recent first-class case study reports by bodies like the AIM organisation and the CARE group with an interest in children, and the reports of the free legal advice centre. Even if we feel we cannot face up to the basic question of how we divided the national cake, there must be many problems which could be eased either by the stroke of a pen or by making some small administrative change, or else which could be greatly alleviated by all the parties involved, such as administrative people who never see their clients, or by hard-pressed and, indeed, overworked social workers, or by politicians. I hope that in this year of 1973 we would all have a look around us and see what we can do by way of flexibility and genuine community spirit to ease the lot of the underprivileged. I make that plea quite apart from my plea to the Government to make sure constantly that their allocation of resources in matters of social welfare is the most that can be given at one time.

The future of all the people on this island depends on our own human attitudes and our approach to the problems which face us, whether they are inflation, our position within the European Economic Community, or our work for the underprivileged. In almost every case it gets down to community effort, and how we go about helping ourselves and make sure that we achieve the goals we set ourselves, whether they are higher productivity, better export results, or merely encouraging our people to make the best use of the educational facilities available to them. I should like to end on that note at a time when we are discussing collective responsibility for matters of administration. While expressing general satisfaction with the overall job of administration I, for one, should like to underline the continuing need for the involvement and effort of every individual citizen of our State. I should like to underline the continuing need for the involvement and effort of every citizen.

Comment on this

Senator Alexis FitzGerald said that this debate presents us all with an opportunity of indicating the type of just society in which we would like to live. I am not in a position at present to outline briefly my conception of the just society. I can, however, say briefly what type of society I do not want and what type of society the vast majority of our people do not want. This may be regarded as a negative attitude but I firmly believe that it is only by recognising inequities and injustices that we can hope to discard them and plan for a progressive and equitable future for all our people.

Basically the type of society I reject is one in which more than two-thirds of the wealth of the nation is owned by only 5.1 per cent of the population. That is the type of society in which we live today. This is revealed in the elaborate survey carried out by Professor Lyons of Trinity College. In the preface he thanks the Minister for Finance for according him so many facilities to check on statistics of the Revenue authorities, and so on. If we started on this basis and rejected that form of society we might make some progress. Springing from that essential fact there are many more injustices and inequities. Senator Keery referred to the fact that in the past 12 months in this small country, more than 3,000 people have been declared redundant, most of them having spent a lifetime in a particular employment. They did not receive adequate compensation and in many cases no notice was given.

During the past 12 months many thousands of our people have had to emigrate and thousands more are unemployed with no possibility of obtaining work. In a vast number of cases wages are inadequate to keep pace with the ever-rising cost of living. Senator Keery referred to this in detail. There is a lack of housing accommodation. Most important of all, our social welfare and educational services are inadequate. In this connection I should like to refer to some statistics produced by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions.

Between 1963 and 1971, the gross national product in money terms rose by £1,082 million. Of this increase, £268 million was spent by public authorities on social and community services. Accordingly, only £1 in £4 of the increase in the GNP went to public spending on our social services. Over this eight-year period, when public spending on social services went up by £268 million, expenditure on alcohol rose by £92 million, on tobacco by £31 million, and on motor cars by £27 million. This means that for every £1 extra spent on social services, 56 new pence was spent on drink, tobacco and motor cars. The increase of £92 million on alcohol compares over the same period with an increase of only £97 million in respect of all social welfare services. The increase, not the amount itself, in drink expenditure over that eight-year period almost equalled the extra amount spent in respect of all social services.

I am not suggesting that the Minister or the Government should take steps in regard to the increase in drink and tobacco expenditure but I suggest, in a situation in which we are spending very little on social services compared with other countries, and particularly compared with other EEC countries, that some kind of inquiry should be made into our rather excessive expenditure on items which are not essential to our well-being and to our progress.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator mean to compel workers not to drink, smoke or buy cars?

Comment on this

I have just said that I am not suggesting any remedy other than an inquiry into expenditure on these items related to expenditure on social services. It has been stated on many occasions both inside and outside this House that a major factor, if not the principal one, in improving relations between the Republic and Northern Ireland is the desirability of implementing a citizens' rights charter in respect of all citizens in both parts of the country. Allied with this is the desirability and the promise that we should at least equate our social services and other legislation with those operating in Northern Ireland.

Another major factor based on promises in the past is for both Southern and Northern Ireland to bring into line with other EEC countries their social welfare services and expenditure. At present the Republic falls far short of Northern Ireland, and both the Republic and Northern Ireland are much below and inferior to EEC social services. The social services of the Republic and of Northern Ireland are much inferior to those within the EEC. Therefore, just at the point of formally having entered the EEC, if this country is to make progress, we must ensure that along with suffering the disabilities of entry into the Common Market, such as price increases on food products, which have been pointed out many times and disregarded, we must also ensure that we gain the benefits of entry. That means in the first instance greatly increased social welfare services.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I am sorry that Senator Keery has left the House. I shall not draw any conclusions from his absence but the extremely cantankerous opening sentences in his speech, had they come from this side of the House, would have reduced the people on our side to fury. Incidentally, it gives me a very appropriate platform from which to launch the remarks which I have to make to the House today.

With a good deal of irony, he invited the House to draw conclusions from the absence of Senator O'Higgins, who in previous years he said—though it must have lodged deep and painfully with him because I have no recollection of this myself—had quoted from the Fianna Fáil election manifesto and had quoted with particular glee that part of the manifesto in which the Fianna Fáil Party invited the country to return them to power, because the country needed a Government with clearly defined policies.

I had forgotten all about that manifesto, if I ever read it. If I can take Senator Keery's word for it that that was the Fianna Fáil election manifesto when they last went to the country, I have to ask myself in relation to what I want to talk about today, and I shall deal with one theme only, a theme which the House has heard me on before, that is, how far these policies can be described as existing at all, let alone having a clearly defined existence. This debate will not go through without mention of Northern Ireland being made in one shape or form by most Members. My speech at this time last year was entirely devoted to the subject and we may do the same thing this year.

I have watched with a great deal of dismay the way in which the Government have handled the problem of the North over the last three or four years, and particularly over the last year. It is true that the last 12 months have not seen the same convulsions and the same scandals that disfigured the year 1970. However, I watch the way in which the Dublin Government are exerting what ought to be a very considerable influence, and a very great influence for good, on the course of events. I watch in particular the behaviour of the Taoiseach and I must confess—and I make a present of this to gentlemen on the far side—that I am despondent when I find the relative degree of complacent acceptance which the media, editorial writers and so forth, accept that the Government here are doing their best in this regard.

I have never accused Deputy Lynch's Government of wishing to foment bloodshed or disorder; I know that that is not in their minds, and I know that perhaps it was never in the minds of most of them. I am not making that charge, and Members here will know that I never have made it. I say that because of local political exigencies, because of ignorance, because of neglect stretching back over generations, the Northern situation is being mishandled in a way which would be difficult to describe adequately, because it is so muddled and so much a scene of contradiction and of conflict.

It is extremely important that the policy of this Government, or of any Government who happen to be in office this year, in regard to the North of Ireland should be defined clearly and understood. It is not enough to talk in generalities. Everybody in the southern part of this country was brought up to believe that the people from the North —of whichever persuasion, but particularly what in the North is the majority persuasion—were hardheaded people who, whatever their other failings might be, wanted to hear "Yes" when a man meant "Yes" and wanted to hear "No" when he meant "No". It was also held out—I suppose as part of the legend about them—that they had no time for evasions and had no time for the kind of "sloothering" associated with the worst type of person who in their legend the southern majority to a large extent consisted of. Faced wth a Northern majority of that kind the necessity to be clear, to be unambiguous and to say exactly what you mean and not to leave room for misunderstanding or doubt, is absolutely paramount.

I have here a collection of speeches made by the Taoiseach between August, 1969 and October, 1971. Every Senator received this booklet. A few of those speeches made in the late 1969 and early 1970 were being made—I do not mean to offend gentlemen on the far side who perhaps were not privy to this; neither do I want to rake up old sores—at a time when one of their own former Ministers said there was deliberate effort on the part of some members of that Government to supply the IRA in the North of Ireland with guns.

I shall not beat that drum any longer: I think it has been beaten too much by the Opposition. I believe that any Government in office in 1969 faced with the Northern explosion would have been subject to pretty much the same kind of pressures as the Government here were subject to. I believe that a Fine Gael Government would have stood up to them better, but I confess that they would have been faced with pressures of a similar kind and would have been faced with the same emotional difficulties of reconciling what they knew to be right with what, perhaps, some of us in our hearts would have liked to do.

I admit that the minority in Belfast in 1969 and in the rest of Northern Ireland were in a situation where it looked as though they were on the point of being massacred. I can well imagine the strains and the stresses which people of responsibility here underwent when faced with a population who were appealing to them for help to save their very lives. Therefore, I do not want to make too much of this.

However looking at it from the point of view of the Northern majority, the people we are trying to sell something to know that, for whichever reasons and however good the emotional excuse might be, the Government here knew—even the Taoiseach himself— that help was being given to people over whom no control could be exercised. If the Government here had sent in the Army it would have been a lunatic thing to do, militarily, nationally and every other way, but at least it would have been open and above board and at least the men sent to their deaths over the Border would have been people disciplined in the use of force and accustomed to taking orders and obeying them.

But once you have put a gun into somebody's hand over whom you have no control, then, as has been seen, there is no end to the violence and there is no bottom to the savagery. That is a bitter lesson for us to have learned. I do not go to the same length as some of my party or some of the Opposition go in blaming the Fianna Fáil Government for their neglect in this matter—I blame them, certainly—but I can imagine that there were dimensions of anguish in making the decisions they made, which probably we would have experienced had we been in office.

Nonetheless, that history makes it essential that no member of the Northern majority should be in the slightest doubt about the position of the Government here. If we look at many parts of the Government's position here it leaves room for an honest doubt and an honest bewilderment as to what exactly is in Deputy Lynch's mind.

I have made all the concessions I can make; I tried to approach this in a fair way; I have made concessions in the last ten minutes that you have not heard from my side of the House before. The Taoiseach's contribution in the last year or so has been terribly feeble. The contributions made by most of the Ministers behind him have been nil. I suspect that many of them have never opened their mouths to give a moral lead to the people on issues of death and violence because they were afraid it might shave away a few votes from a quota or the double quota which they have in the constituencies to which they belong. I should like to be wrong about that. It is being left to the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste, to Deputy Colley and one or two others to carry a burden which ought to have been carried shoulder to shoulder by a whole Government, as it was in William Cosgrave's time, and as it will be again when the present Government go out.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

When?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I want to say positively now that apart from the Taoiseach and about three of his Ministers who had tried to give a lead and who mean and believe what they say, the rest of the Ministers have sung dumb. What conclusion would you draw from that if you were a Northern Unionist? What conclusion would you draw from it when you find, looking over the Border, that Mr. Faulkner has never said a word on the subject—I mention him because you could run into him as soon as you cross the Border coming towards Dublin—has never opened his mouth on this question? Neither Deputy Lalor nor Deputy Molloy has ever opened his mouth on it. The Parliamentary Secretary now in the House, or the Parliamentary Secretary across the border in West Galway, has never opened his mouth on it, and a whole string of others have never opened their mouths on it.

Comment on this

Nobody but Gerry L'Estrange——

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

There were some on our side who thought Deputy Gerry L'Estrange was going too far but he turned out to be right in the end. Who was right in the end, as between Deputy Gerry L'Estrange and the people on the other side who shouted him down? Who was the man who was right when he said we were slipping towards anarchy and that there were bloodshed and violence looming ahead for lack of a decent Government? He was right, and the people who were laughing at him were wrong, and nothing has shown that more clearly than the history of the last 12 or 15 months. I am proud to have Gerry L'Estrange in the same party as myself.

Comment on this

Not in Christmas week.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Who was right?

Comment on this

The history of Easter Week—has the Senator forgotten it?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The majority in Northern Ireland need to be told clearly what exactly we are up to. I am afraid that that is something which has not happened. If I were an open minded and fair minded member of that majority I would not know what to make of the repeated statements which I find attributed to the Taoiseach. I do not believe the Taoiseach has ill will about this matter, I believe he does not want bloodshed or savagery, but I think he is incompetent and that he is incompetently advised. I also suspect that his speeches are written for him by two or three script writers. I do not fault him for having speeches written for him. I will not be drawn by Senator Garrett.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I cannot hear Senator Garret and talk at the same time. If you want me to stay here all night, keep on interrupting. I do not resent it a bit. I do not fault a Minister for having speeches written for him because he has so much to do that on the ordinary occasions, opening bun fights and so on, he needs a script, nor do I fault a Taoiseach for having speeches drafted for him on important issues, but I fault him if he does not take the trouble to read these scripts through critically before he delivers them and I fault him if he delivers statements within a speech of a few weeks or a couple of months together, which even to the inexperienced eye of an only moderately logical layman, do not hang together and cannot be reconciled with one another. However well it may fit the Irish character, which is said to prefer prevarication to straight talk, it has done nothing to improve our position with the Northern majority. All through there is nothing but muddle and contradiction. There was an article which the Taoiseach contributed to an American paper called Foreign Affairs which was reprinted in the Irish newspapers last June. In this Deputy Lynch stated:

I consider that the only solution is an Ireland united by agreement. It is a solution that I would and the Senators on the other side of the House would like to see, but is it the only solution? A man who is dealing with a situation where people are losing their lives every day has no right to set up as a prophet.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is he not entitled to his view?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

He is entitled to his view but what the Taoiseach says will be broadcast all over the world. What he says will be analysed in Lurgan, Ballymena and Coleraine. That is very important. What Senator Garrett or I say may not be very important. Who will pay much attention to us?

Comment on this

The Senator is afraid of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I am not afraid of the Taoiseach. He is perfectly entitled, under the Orders of this House, to come here and sit where the Parliamentary Secretary is sitting. The other day I read some figures about what Mr. de Valera did in the Seanad in the thirties. He appeared in the Seanad about four times a year during the last three years of the old Seanad's existence, when he was Taoiseach. I would be delighted to see the Taoiseach here. I hope I will conduct myself as well towards him as Senators opposite conduct themselves towards people on our front bench. I am not afraid of him or of anybody on the other side.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Good man, we will not harm you.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I will say what I came here to say. If you give me a chance I will finish before the tea break, if you do not I will be still on my feet at 7.30 p.m.

Comment on this

I am enjoying——

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I do not know if they have any constables over there on that side of the House but Senator Garrett should be put under some restraint. You are the ones who will be paying for it in the end. I enjoy myself on my feet.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is a free country.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

In this article the Taoiseach said:

...this is the only solution. I consider that any attempt to follow up a new set of discussions by integrating the North into the United Kingdom would be disastrous.

These are serious words, to integrate the Six Counties into the UK—for all practical purposes they are now, in fact, integrated into it. I cannot see where that is necessarily a disaster. To be using that inflated language, to be devaluing the real worth of what you are saying, is a very serious thing for a Taoiseach. It may be all right for a junior Minister but it is a very serious thing for a Taoiseach to do. He said that the incorporation of the Six Counties into the UK could not work. Time has already proved him wrong about that because it is incorporated into the UK for all practical purposes. The bloodshed is still going on at roughly the same rate as it was before.

Comment on this

It is not working.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The Senator knows me well enough to know that I do not admire the constitutional arrangement on the island any more than he does, but it is a damaging thing for a Taoiseach to take it on himself to play Moses. That is what Deputy Lynch has been led to do by his script writers. It is not part of the man's own nature. He has been led by his advisers, and I believe there are more than one of them, and that they do not consult or compare notes with each other on these positions. He said that the British Government, by handing over the North of Ireland to the settlement achieved by the 1920 Act, abdicated responsibility for it. They did not abdicate responsibility; they carried the responsibility. In a sense they failed to discharge the responsibility but it is not true to say that they abdicated their responsibility. The Northern Government or the Northern Parliament were never sovereign.

When I find this kind of thing going on I ask myself if I was a middle of the road Orangeman or Unionist in the North what would I make of this man? What would I make of him when I hear him playing the prophet and saying that the only solution is integration with the Twenty-six Counties either in the long or short term?

Comment on this

The Senator is castigating him the same as he does——

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I will have to castigate him because it grieves me to read this rubbish day in, day out. It grieves me still further to see leader writers not tearing to pieces what he has said in a manner which it deserves, not just because of the man himself or the party to which he belongs— there are sufficient other grounds for criticism and opposition—but this involves human lives. While we are speaking here somebody is, perhaps, being blown to bits North of the Border.

We are dealing with a situation in which this Government could play a positive role. In fairness to Senator Keery, I agree with him 100 per cent in what he said about the necessity for a generous and new approach to those who hold different views from us. I am sorry that he did not express in clear words what he meant by that remark. I suspect the reason why he did not spell it out was because it does not suit his party to be anything more than equivocal on this matter and therefore it is not put in any more concrete form.

The Taoiseach has repeatedly said —the instance in this American paper is only one—that there can be no lasting solution except in a United Ireland context. This is the solution that I and probably everybody in this House would like to see but to talk in such a manner invites the inference that we will not support any measure which does not lead towards that solution. I know I am putting words into the Taoiseach's mouth which he has not used but I am only a Southern Nationalist. What about a Northern Unionist? Which words would he put into the Taoiseach's mouth on foot of these ill-considered reflections? What interpretation will be put on this Mosaic prophecy that there will never be peace until there is unity? It is conceivable that there could be peace without unity. I should be sorry to see that particular solution but I do not have the right to predict what will happen in the future and to say there will not be peace without unity. To talk in such a manner invites those who are sales-resistant to Irish nationalism to conclude that the Taoiseach will dig his heels in—that he will wreck any effort at settlement which falls short of unity.

There are other minor details which enhance and lend colour to that picture. The Taoiseach has said he is opposed to the holding of a plebiscite in the North of Ireland. Our Foreign Affairs spokesman has expressed the same idea but he has grounded his views by saying that to hold a plebiscite at the present time would be a dangerous and inflammatory thing to do. He is right. But to say, as the Taoiseach has said—apparently without qualification unless I am doing him an injustice— that he is against the holding of a plebiscite there at all would reinforce my suspicions, if I were a Northern Unionist, that he did not care about how I felt and that he was afraid— which is shameful—of what a plebiscite might show.

I suspect this is what is at the back of his mind. He is afraid that if there was a plebiscite—perhaps it would be a bad idea to have one now but later when things get more settled—that nothing like 33? per cent of the population, which we think of as nationalist, would prove to be so. He is afraid that not even 25 per cent would turn out to vote for incorporation in the Republic. He is afraid that that plebiscite might disclose that more than 80 per cent would vote for the status quo.

I should be very interested to hear what Senator McGowan has to say on this matter because he lives nearer to the scene than I do. This is a sad situation, but it is shameful to be afraid of the truth. It is shameful to put yourself in the position where your opponents can accuse you of being afraid of the truth. This is the impression given by the blanket opposition to a plebiscite, quite apart from the fact that the holding of one is not logically reconcilable with the view often expressed by the Taoiseach that he wants unity by consent. If he wishes this, how is that consent to be measured except by mounting heads?

When is the counting of heads to start? If he were to say that the matter is a foregone conclusion and that we accept there is an 80 per cent majority against incorporation but that he would like a plebiscite in ten years' time, it would make some sense, but simply to say, in other words, "We will not allow you to express your point of view; we do not want to hear what the proportion in favour of incorporation is; we are not interested", if I were an Orangeman that kind of talk would make me reach for my gun. I am sorry to have to speak like that but it is the truth.

Deputy Lynch or the script writers who draft his public statements have not reflected sufficiently on this matter. An ill-considered statement such as that does terrible damage North of the Border. I express this view as a distant observer. I do not pretend to have the same knowledge of the situation as other Senators would have.

Last October the Taoiseach spoke in Paris. He demanded that the 1949 promise, as it was called, about the retention of the Border should be reconsidered by the British. What happened in 1949 was that, as a riposte to the declaration of a republic in the Twenty-six Counties, the Northern Unionists prevailed on the Labour Government to pass the Ireland Act and one section of it, which the Taoiseach refers to, says that no change in the constitutional status of the North can be made without the consent of the Northern Parliament. It does not say——

Comment on this

It was not the Northern Government that——

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I do not mind dealing with interruptions if you listen to what I say.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Does the Senator not remember the 1949 Coalition policy of putting their pride and prejudice in their pocket?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

What are we talking about now? I have had occasion to tick off Senator Ó Maoláin before. He is addicted to Stone Age politics.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I will tell you what happened in 1949.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly must be allowed to continue on the motion.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I will tell you about 1949 and I will rub your noses in it.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Mind you, I am no believer in Stone Age politics like Senator Ó Maoláin,

Comment on this

It was the result of——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not believe in Stone Age politics.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly to continue without interruption on the motion.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I do not mind the interruptions if they come one at a time so that I can deal with them. I cannot deal with a disorderly rumble from the other side of the House.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Will the Senator get off the Taoiseach and come down to business?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I thought the Taoiseach was the business. I thought that was where the action was.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator told us he did not know what was in the Taoiseach's mind.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The Senator will not allow me to speak my view about the man whom you say is the most important man in the country.

Comment on this

The Senator is inconsistent.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senators will have an opportunity to make their own contributions. They should refrain from interrupting when other Senators are speaking.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You would want superhuman patience to put up with that fellow.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I have been invited to go back to 1949. No sooner did Mr. de Valera find himself in Opposition than he went off galloping the globe on a most rabid anti-Partition campaign with the sole object of embarrassing the Government. That is what I remember about 1949.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely somebody in the world besides Senator Kelly knows something.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The 1949 Act to which Deputy Lynch referred, let me get back to that and rub your noses in it.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Surely somebody in the world did some good besides the Senator.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senator Ó Maoláin knows that I am not mean-minded in giving credit to Fianna Fáil when it is due. He is holding up the business here.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Why does the Senator make a suggestion like that?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Because I actually remember it. I am not that much of a baby. I was 18 years of age in 1949. I remember the incident very well. I also remember drawing my conclusions about it at the time. I do not remember 1925. I will make you a present of that. The Act to which the Taoiseach referred in Paris last October did no more than say that the constitutional status of the North could not be changed without the consent of the Northern Parliament. It has been represented here by the Taoiseach, or by his script writers or the publicity hounds who are behind him, as something quite different but that is all it states. If there is a Northern Ireland Parliament with a majority which supports a change in the constitutional status, that Act will not prevent them from getting it.

It does not matter about the ignorant people here and the ignorant leader-writers and those who neglect to criticise the Taoiseach. If I were a Northern Unionist or if Senator Ó Maoláin were one—if he has enough imagination to put himself in such boots—he would boil with rage on seeing this and say: "What is this man going on about: what does he want? On the one hand he wants to remove from us the only protection we have while on the other, he talks of unity only by consent. Where is the logic in that?" As I have said, I would reach for my gun.

I do not wish to be inflammatory. I probably would never reach for a gun but, figuratively speaking, I would dig my heels in and nothing would get me into this Republic until the Taoiseach was out of office, and perhaps not even then.

Comment on this

That is the sort of support Mr. Craig wants. He will be delighted. You will get the headlines for those statements.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I am not seeking for headlines in the North of Ireland.

Comment on this

Those are the headlines you will get.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I assure the Senator I am not seeking headlines in the North of Ireland but since he has mentioned the names of two men in the North of Ireland and because of the philosophy to which I thought we all subscribed, I would remind him that even these people are Irish, violent and irresponsible though they may be and that they have as much claim to a point of view as the rest of us.

Why should the Senator think I will wilt like a salted snail when he states that what I say will be very popular with Mr. X or Mr. Y in the North of Ireland? These men are as much entitled to a say in the future of this island as Senator McGowan or myself. If he does not believe this he is not in the right party because if I understand correctly the manifesto about which Senator Keery spoke, you are the party of Wolfe Tone, who do not recognise any differences in creed, class or background in which Protestant, Catholic and dissenter will all be one.

Comment on this

Social Democrats.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

If you mean that, act accordingly. If you mean it do not behave as though the only Protestants you could approve of are the ones who go against the traditions of their people. In Senator McGowan's book the only Protestants from the North I am allowed to admire are those who in the eyes of 80 per cent of their own people are Lundys. That is not Wolfe Tonism in my book.

Comment on this

If you take the word "protestant" out of it there are certain individuals there—I am sorry to interrupt the Senator, I am not going to continue his speech.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I do not mind. I am sure the Senator has something useful to say as he comes from up there and if the Chair allows the interruption I do not mind.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly.

Comment on this

In peace, I hope.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

It is an area of contradiction that we cannot discover from what the Taoiseach is being made to say by his script writers whether he really means that there is to be unity only by consent. I cannot discover that. It is a serious matter for the gentlemen about this, especially for the gentlemen that Senator McGowan has mentioned. If they are in a war-like posture, it is certain that the ambiguity and the muddle-headedness of the Dublin Government's approach has contributed in a desperately bad way to that situation.

Comment on this

It would be a good thing if you could tell us what the Opposition point of view is to the Government's suggestion.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The Opposition's view as to what?

Comment on this

On how this situation can be dealt with.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The Opposition's point of view is that there can be unity only by peaceful means but we do not say in the next breath, with the tone of a prophet, that this or that cannot happen or that this or that solution is out of the question. Such prophesies are dangerous when you are dealing with people who interpret them as a threat to them.

So far as it can be judged from his published words the Taoiseach's policy is a mass of muddle and contradiction. This is desperately dangerous when dealing with the Northern majority because they do not understand it. I do not blame them.

Another contradiction which is a footnote to that is the question of how far in the future is this solution which the Taoiseach regards as inevitable or as the only acceptable one. Here there has been contradiction too.

On the 11th July, 1970, he made what I must concede was a good and a valuable address on Telefís Éireann appealing to the minority in the North not to allow themselves to be provoked by the Orange marches which were taking place two days later. He began that address by stating: "We are on the brink of a great achievement." It is dynamite for the Taoiseach of a State such as ours to use words like that about the North of Ireland. He is the Leader of a Government who only two months previously had to fire two Ministers for suspected involvement in gun running and did so, as Mr. Boland stated, only because the squeeze was put on him by Deputy Cosgrave. It is deadly, and I mean that in the strictly literal sense, for expressions like that to come across the public media from a Taoiseach. These are words put into his mouth by people sitting in God knows which Department who should be relieved of the anonymity which they enjoy in the public service. I do not mean they are not doing their jobs as best they see they can, but it is appalling that this country's policy should effectively be determined by people who cannot be got out and put in front of this House and asked to state exactly what they mean. That is the result of this image building which now takes the place of genuine personal government and personal initiative.

Comment on this

Will the Senator be here tomorrow when there are replies to these questions?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Tomorrow evening, I hope.

Comment on this

We will be here all day tomorrow.

Comment on this

The Senator would need to be here to listen to the replies.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senator Crinion came in here only five minutes ago. I do not know what entitles him to suppose that every other Senator should be here all the time. I see a number missing from his own front bench, though I will not put their names on the record.

Comment on this

The Senator cannot unload a lot of stuff like this and then absent himself from the replies.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

If the Minister will give me notice of the hour he proposes to reply I will try to make it convenient to be present.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There are others besides the Minister who would like to reply to the Senator.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Perhaps Senator Ó Maoláin would like me to promise there will be no further speeches from the Fine Gael side. That is the way he would like the Seanad to operate.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

No further what?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

No speeches from the Fine Gael side at all.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not think there will be any need for them.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Wait until this one is finished. Regarding the present trouble, a very recent example of this confusion which, as I say, is deadly, can be found in the interviews which the Taoiseach gave on American television early this month. So far as the Irish reports went he gave almost identical interviews on two successive days and again the same thing came up—"we support unity by consent", but our Northern Unionists could suppose he meant "we will not force you in but we will not allow you to stay out". That is the long and the short of the Lynch position on the North of Ireland.

Comment on this

Did he say that?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I know it is poison to the gentlemen on the other side to hear the leader to whom they owe whatever electoral success they have criticised without my putting a tooth in it. I am not going to put a tooth in it and you can just wait until I am finished. Senator Honan asked for a direct quotation. The Taoiseach said in an American television interview:

I wouldn't support any arrangement in which the possibility of the reunification of Ireland wasn't a very important feature...

The Taoiseach knows that is the one feature that the settlement will not contain. It is the one feature which would guarantee its failure, for the very simple reason that it would guarantee the passionate opposition of the Northern majority.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Nonsense.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Maybe Senator Ó Maoláin has seen a rush advance copy of the British White Paper.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Senator suggesting that any Irish leader should give up for all time the possibility of Irish unity?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

That is not what he said. Perhaps the Rules of Order of the House require that I give the exact reference. I have not got the date but I will get one of my colleagues to read it on to the record. It is a front page article which appeared in The Irish Times about ten days ago from a reporter in New York named Andrew Whittaker and which purports to give the text of an interview which the Taoieach gave.

Comment on this

You have qualified your statement by saying it "purports" to give.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

It is there even with inverted commas around it. Perhaps Mr. Whittaker is misrepresenting the Taoiseach but, if so, I have seen no denial in the correspondence columns. The article continued:

Asked what his attitude would be to the White Paper if it suggested maintaining Northern Ireland as part of the United Kingdom, while guaranteeing Catholics equal rights and proportional representation, Mr. Lynch answered:

"I wouldn't support any arrangement in which the possibility of the reunification of Ireland wasn't a very important feature..."

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

You have been shouting "hear, hear" and that blather for the last 50 years and where has it got you? Where has it got any of us?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Unless it suits your purposes you will be shouting it for the next 50 years as well: "Hear, hear. Never say die. We never gave in." That is the sort of thing on which the Fianna Fáil Party floats, and will ultimately sink, if I may be allowed to play the role of prophet for a change.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The Taoiseach said that he would not support anything in which this was not a conspicuous feature. In other words, in this deadly matter on which lives hang he is preempting a position which any sensible man would leave until he sees what is there. Even the dimmest of his Ministers would say: "I have not seen this White Paper and I should prefer not to comment on it until it comes out", but he has as good as promised his unfriendly reception to this White Paper unless this thing is an important or conspicuous feature in it. What is a Northern Unionist to make of that? It just does not square with the Taoiseach's talk about unity only by consent. It is as though I were an occupant of a house and somebody who thought he had a claim on my house squatted outside and said: "I am not going to come in and throw you out by force. I intend to put you out by peaceful means. I consider that there can be no solution whereby you can live in peace in what you consider to be your own house unless you come out on the street, take me by the hand and bring me in and let me live in the house with you." That is what it boils down to.

Comment on this