We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Appropriation Act, 1972: Motion.

Contributions 112–222 of 222. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Who are the squatters in the north-east of Ireland?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Now we are getting it. I doubt if Senator Garrett would have the nerve to say that to the Chairman who has just been replaced by the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I am amazed that he has the nerve to say it in front of Senator Keery.

Comment on this

I am not being sectarian.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil have thrived on sectarianism when it suited them.

Comment on this

I am not being sectarian and you will not lay any such charge at my door.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I am afraid——

Comment on this

I am not being sectarian.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator will have a chance to speak.

Comment on this

I will make a speech.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

What Senator Garrett has just done is to describe as squatters the Northern majority who are cherished every other day by the Taoiseach in well-publicised speeches as "our sundered brethren".

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly should address the Chair, make his remarks to the motion and other Senators should refrain from interrupting.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senators opposite do not want me to refer to what Senator Garrett said and are hoping the report will not have picked it up. What Senator Garrett has just done is to describe the Northern majority as squatters.

Comment on this

You will not put words into my mouth.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

If the Northern majority are squatters and if that is the Fianna Fáil policy, let the Taoiseach be man enough to say that. Let him put it on the record somewhere. At least the thing would be understandable. He would be a kind of General Amin then, and everybody would know where they stood with him—that if he once got his hands on the North of Ireland he would put out the whole lot of them. It would be inhuman, dastardly, unreasonable and something so lunatic that only somebody on Senator Garrett's side of the House could think of. But at least it would be straight forward and there would be some logic in it. I want to dissociate myself personally from anything to do with a party which can produce a gentleman who can describe the Northern majority as squatters. I will not go along an inch of the way with a bipartisan policy in which I am smeared with the dirt——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I did not call the majority or the minority in the North of Ireland squatters. I call the British Government who are in occupation of part of our Irish territory squatters. The Senator may not attribute to me something which I did not say.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I am sorry.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Since Senator Garrett has given that explanation it must be accepted. But I would point out to Senator Garrett that, if he would refrain from interruption, he would not be misunderstood.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I am sorry if I have offended Senator Garrett and I accept his explanation. If I have said anything disagreeable to him in response to what I took him to mean, I apologise. I am afraid that I must still say that the approach to the situation which can generate terms like that is one which I imagine would embarrass the Taoiseach if he found himself unambiguously saddled with it.

I find that an expression by the Taoiseach in the same interview in which he speaks about unity by consent, to the effect that he is not going to support anything, and perhaps therefore may inferentially oppose something, which does not include unity with or without consent— because that is the gloss that will be put on it in the North—is dangerous and is a non-contribution to peace. It will postpone peace further.

There are other contradictions in his point of view which need to be seized on. In the same interview he said we do not want the people of the North to come into our State as it is. What is our State as it is? Our State as it is is the product of the Constitutional ideals of Éamon de Valera. That is the State which was designed, as Mr. de Valera believed sincerely, to accommodate the six north-eastern counties at some future date. His successor in title, the Taoiseach, now says we would not expect the North to come into the State as it is; but note that the State, as it is, is as it is because of the insertion in the Constitution of a number of provisions which did not exist in the prior Constitution, which are unnecessary and inflammatory and which now, of course, everybody is agreed we have got to get away from. The fault for that does not lie——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator cannot get away with that now. Everybody has not agreed.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senator Ó Maoláin has a healthy conservative streak. There is a kind of suede-shoe consensus about certain articles of the Constitution. It has not penetrated down to the breeches-without-seats level in the Fianna Fáil Party yet.

Comment on this

The greatest beneficiaries from the Constitution were the members of the legal profession who were charging into the courts every day raising questions about unconstitutionality.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senator Honan is raising this hare about the legal profession.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly should resist the temptation to reply. Interruptions that are wide of the Bill should be completely ignored.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

There are more lawyers on the Fianna Fáil front bench in the Dáil than there are on the Fine Gael side. Let that be understood once and for all. There are more lawyers making a fat living out of their Fianna Fáil allegiance than ever did out of Fine Gael. I know the Parliamentary Secretary is a good-natured gentleman and that you cannot rise him to incoherent rage by remarks like that, but I remember making that remark here in some debate and it had the Minister for Justice absolutely speechless and beside himself with indignation. It is the simple truth that the Fianna Fáil Party is far more closely connected not only with the legal profession but with the corrupting and buying of the legal profession than ever Fine Gael were.

Comment on this

Is it in order to call a party and a profession corrupt?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is not out of order to make a political charge of corruption against a political party. It is out of order to make a charge against an outside profession.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senator Honan has gone. This interview contained a statement that we would expect the North to come into our State as it is but what is the Taoiseach proposing to offer? He said a start was made with the sections of Article 44 which we deleted but, as I said in the debate on the Referendum Bill at the time, that is a large piece of bluff and will not change anybody's mind in the North of Ireland, because the fear of the people in the North of Ireland is that the Catholic Church has a special position down here whether or not the Constitution says so. That is their fear. Tinkering with those two sections, as we did last month, is not going to remove that fear. Let the Taoiseach come up with something which will really bite.

Talking about things which really bite, I see where he was asked by one of the interviewers about our contraception laws. Guess what his answer to that question was? He said that "there is a case pending before the courts." Was it he who brought the case? On the contrary, it is the State, presumably at the political direction of the Government—because they could consent to judgment—which is bitterly resisting this plaintiff who has pursued her case about section 17 of the 1935 Act.

Comment on this

Is that the issue?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Yes, it is very much the issue. I am sorry I do not know the Senator's name and I am sorry he should come into the House in a state of ready-made rage.

Comment on this

I was here a long time before you came here.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I have never heard you speak before, sir.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly to continue.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Senator Kelly inferred that the Government could direct the courts. As I understand it, the courts are above the Government and above any intervention by them.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

This is perfectly right, but the Government are entitled to say to the Attorney General: "Do not defend this action. Let judgment go by default." If the Government had wished, the action about section 17 of the 1935 Criminal Justice Act could have been left undefended. It could have been done by the Attorney General simply not opposing and entering no defence and letting it go by default. But the Taoiseach's answer was that "There is a case pending before the courts." A Northern Unionist who follows affairs down here would say: "What kind of a man is that? Is he a man at all, who can give an answer like that to a straight question? Why cannot he say straight out that his Government have not the guts to make up their mind whether they are against or for this legislation? Even if he said something that was dictated to him by a cardinal, it would be "yea" or "nay", but this kind of unmanly dodging of the issue annoys people.

Comment on this

Are you for or against contraception?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

If the Senator be-labouring me had been in this House as often as I have in the past three years he would have heard me on at least four separate occasions state my opinion.

Comment on this

I could not make out whether you are for or against it.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

On at least four separate occasions—those on the far side of the House will remember this —I stated unequivocally what I would do if I were voting on that issue and I am not going to repeat it and hold the House up for the Senator's benefit. I am not going to give the Senator that satisfaction. Let him go and read the debates that come in his letterbox every other day. He will find the answer in the Official Report, not once, but four times if he searches for it.

Comment on this

Can you not say it now?

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The Senator can go and look up his Seanad debates.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

He is for it.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

The constitutional changes that the Taoiseach impliedly is looking forward to have not been outlined to the interviewers nor to anybody else. That part of his interview is just another element in his fog-and-muddle policy.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kelly should be allowed to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

We had some trouble in here with the Forcible Entry Act but I have never heard such barbarity from the far side as I have heard today. What is the reason for it? I have spoken here very often and have never had any trouble with gentlemen like the Minister for Education or Deputy Kitt and others—except for the Minister for Justice, who usually causes trouble when he comes here. We have had fairly peaceable sessions. What is the reason for the savagery today? Is it because the Taoiseach cannot be criticised? If so, we should make a law about it. Why cannot we have a Lynch (Immunity from Criticism) Act, 1973, and then we would know where we stood? So long as that law is not on the Statute Book I propose to say what I like about him without putting a tooth in it.

Comment on this

Nobody has more respect for the Chair than I have and I respect you, Sir, but this gentleman here——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That may be true but it is not relevant to the debate.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Senator Dooge is not a lawyer. I mean no disrespect to Deputy Kitt in saying that I am sorry that the Minister for Finance is not here but the note I wish to end on is one peculiarly relevant to himself. I have tried to show as well as I could the inner muddle and contradicition with which Deputy Lynch's approach and the Government's approach to the North has been consistently infected and the dreadful impression and the dreadful damage that it must be doing in the North. I have confessed here before that no party in this state can claim a monopoly of concern about the North. I said here last year that five or six years ago we were all inclined to treat the North as somebody else's bother and somebody else's trouble which they could fix up any way they liked, and if you raised the question of the North you were regarded as a bore and a sorehead and a nuisance. You could comb the Dáil reports for the years 1963, 1964 and 1965 and you will scarcely find a reference to the North of Ireland. I remember I did find one somewhere. Deputy Flanagan asked the Taoiseach, who was then Mr. Lemass, when he had last made representations to the British about the disabilities of the Northern minority and Mr. Lemass, for whose memory I have an unfeigned and sincere respect, said: "About 18 months ago." He was allowed to get away with that. I believe our party were to blame for letting him get away with it. We were all to blame in those days for not taking enough interest in the North. The party which are now in Government are perhaps, least entitled to make a fuss about the national objectives because that party were founded and have been led over the years on the basis that they had a peculiar insight in regard to the national objectives and a peculiar innate dedication to them which the shoneens in the rest of the Parliament did not have.

Comment on this

That is it. Tell us now what he said.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

If you give me a chance I will tell you something which will give you a laugh. The Minister for Finance early in 1971, and not long after the Donegal and South County Dublin by-elections, made a speech in which he stated that Fianna Fáil had been accused of indifference towards the North but that the truth was that for years before 1969 they were deeply concerned with the situation there and had made the most strenuous efforts to bring about the national objectives. He said that a fundamental objective of Fianna Fáil is and always has been the achievement of national unity in the spirit of harmony and brotherly affection between all Irishmen. That is a great phrase but I will tell the House something about it. It occurs in the report of the Committee on the Constitution which was published in late 1967. That Committee were presided over by Deputy Colley and I hope I am not in breach of anyone's confidence in revealing that that phrase is in the report because it was suggested by the late Deputy Sweetman, and it was suggested to him by myself.

Four years after the committee reported, Deputy Colley comes along and nails to the Fianna Fáil bannerhead a phrase thought up by a member of my party. "Unity in a spirit of harmony and brotherly affection between all Irishmen" was the formula which that committee put forward in substitution for the existing——

Comment on this
Michael F. Kitt Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for the Gaeltacht (Mr. Kitt) Fianna Fáil

It was enshrined in the Fianna Fáil constitution when that party were founded.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

Far from it. I have not got that Fianna Fáil constitution off by heart but that phrase will not be found in it. The reason why that phrase found its way into print was because that committee on which Senator Eoin Ryan sat, suggested it as a substitution for the claim in Article 3 purporting to recognise the right of this Parliament and Government to exercise jurisdiction over the Six Counties. That is the genesis of that phrase.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is now time for the adjournment.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

I should like to make a few remarks before finishing as I do not wish to hold up the House after the interval.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is a matter for the House to determine.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Professor Kelly Fine Gael

May I say on a personal note that if I have said anything hurtful to anybody in the heat of the moment during the past hour I am sorry, though I do not retract any of the opinions I have expressed.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7.30 p.m.

Comment on this

I should like to refer to Senator Kelly and his criticism of statements made by the Taoiseach, and to state that the people are those who will really judge the statements because it is they who will decide if he is to speak on their behalf. From hearing comments from the ordinary people, it is accepted everywhere that the Taoiseach is speaking on their behalf. It has been recognised that the peaceful policy pursued by him is the best one for Ireland and the best one to use towards the reunification of the country. The fairest way of putting it is to say that his policy is the policy wanted by the people.

I was amazed at the Senator mentioning such items as contraceptives and criticising the Government for not defending the action in the Supreme Court. Any government must recognise the courts. When an action is before the courts, it is the duty of the Government, as it is for an individual, to recognise their decision.

On the Appropriation Act, particularly under the headings of industry and commerce, there are three main headings. They are: exports, the increasing investment in facilities for technological research and development. The State-sponsored bodies with responsibilities in these areas are the Industrial Development Authority, the Shannon Free Airport Development Company in the field of industrial promotion, Córas Tráchtála in relation to exports, and the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards in the field of technology. In the Book of Estimates for the year 1972-73 there is a figure of £35 million, which compares with a sum of £33 million, which included a supplementary estimate of £5 million, in the year 1971-72. This demonstrates our interest in industry and how we value its potential. The principal agencies are the IDA, the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards, the Shannon Free-Airport Development Company and Córas Tráchtála. The increased finance for industrial promotion is particularly important in view of our entry into the EEC. The enlarged Community will enhance Ireland's attracttions as a base for new industry and will provide better prospects for our exports.

The Japanese industrialists' association sent representatives to Europe and other parts of the world to find the most attractive countries for establishing factories. They reported that Ireland had the best potential for setting up factories; Belgium was second. This demonstrates that our position is recognised throughout the world. America recognises that we have potential here. Our incentives are very enticing to industrialists. During the Taoiseach's stay in the US he was able to announce three new industrial developments which will give an extra 1,000 jobs here. The results of his visit there will be seen during the months and years ahead. Our promotional drive there will bear fruit, notwithstanding competition from nine other industrial agencies which were trying to entice industries to their own countries.

In the employment field, despite adverse circumstances surrounding the drive to secure more industry, the trouble in the Six Counties and the unfavourable economic situation in some of our principal areas from which investment might be expected, the number of new jobs created has helped to offset redundancies. Assistance schemes, such as adaptation and re-equipment grants, will be given to industrial services. Special agencies, such as Fóir Teoranta, have been availed of by many firms that would otherwise have experienced serious difficulties. The Fóir Teoranta Bill went through the Seanad over a year ago. Many industries have been put on a reasonably sound basis since that Bill became law. Factories which found it hard to get sufficient development capital from the ordinary banks have been able to get capital from Fóir Teoranta if there is a basis of management there. The only security they have is management. If Fóir Teoranta consider that there is good management in a factory or that a good management team could be brought in, or if the industry could be allied to another industry, they provide money. This has kept a number of factories going.

There are bound to be some failures, but so far there have been few. That is the type of work that any Department, particularly one interested in industry, should be doing. Such a Department should get finance to develop it first, and then to provide the employment and development that is needed. The IDA regional industrial plan for the five years—1973-77—proposed 55,000 new jobs in industry. More intensive efforts are planned to counteract the possible effects of a higher level of industry, should it occur. The IDA realise that there is a great opportunity in the new and enlarged Community. In any big change there are bound to be some adverse effects on industry. Firms that are heavily protected will find it hard to survive. The IDA have planned ahead for that also, with re-training and re-equipment.

The fact that there are 55,000 new jobs proposed for a five-year period would counteract any adverse effect that might arise. We are an exporting country and our exports have continued to grow steadily in recent years. The industrial exports now represent over 52 per cent of our total exports. Progress has been achieved despite economic difficulties in some export markets, notably Britain and the United States. Since 1957, when there was a feeling of gloom and despondency throughout the length and breadth of Ireland and a feeling that Ireland was finished, the Government, through their planning and initiative have achieved much both in the industrial development of the country and the rising standard of living that the country has enjoyed.

More and more interest has been displayed in the exploration of minerals and gas in Ireland, and off her shores. The benefit of the development of mineral resources is amply demonstrated by the value of ore exported. It was £18.5 million in 1970 and £14.5 million in 1971. The main reason for the drop was the fluctuation in metal prices, which were determined by world market conditions. This was the prime factor in the drop in the value of exports last year.

We have heard it said that the mineral industry should be nationalised. Some years ago the Government invested money in the Avoca mines in County Wicklow. I remember the Minister saying while looking for money that they had drilled 15 or 20 holes 200 yards away from the mine shaft and that the analyses of those drills were exceptionally good and that if the company had enough money to tunnel far underground the mine would prove to be a paying proposition. Six months later the Minister looked for more money. He said it was disappointing that when they were drilling they just happened to pick all the small, good seams that were there. They were unfortunate not to get the bad areas which were mixed through it. Extra money was poured in again, and it was the same story. Eventually the mine had to be closed down and it has been redeveloped since.

This shows that developing a mineral industry is very "chancey". If there was a Minister for Industry and Commerce coming in here every year for £2 million for development of mineral resources, he might come in for five or six years running without getting any results at all. I know what the Opposition would be saying outside the church gates during an election campaign. They would be saying that the most expensive drilling equipment in the world was being used for drilling holes and that we were spending £2 million of the taxpayers' money and getting nothing out of it. Even in my own county—County Meath—the Tara mines who had the development rights there went over and did a survey of the area and found nothing. It was another body who happened to be analysing spring water from well, in that area that found the traces of metal. They looked it up and saw who had the mineral development in the area and suggested to them that they carry out another survey of the area. It was from that second survey that they found the rich mineral ore that is there.

Tynagh is only one mine that has paid back the capital invested in it. This shows how "chancey" it is. The Government are doing the best thing in getting royalties. I hope they will increase the royalties on the newer mines.

The setting up of the National Prices Commission to scrutinise applications for price increases and to make recommendations to the Minister has been an important development. The commission's monthly report, which has been widely publicised, plays an important role in fostering a discriminating attitude by the public towards prices. The Minister has made price display orders to assist the public in assessing and comparing prices in different shops and areas. The monthly reports of the National Prices Commission have been widely discussed in the newspapers and on radio. People are beginning to think and to compare prices in one shop as against another. This is helping to keep the competitive element alive.

I should like to mention another aspect of the work of the Minister's Department and that is the insurance industry. It has now become impossible for a person under 25 years of age to get new motor insurance cover. Most of the young people need car transport to get to work. Encouragement should be given to the existing industry to cover that field. If that fails the nationalisation of the insurance industry should be considered. I am not advocating the nationalisation of life or other insurance business, but only of the insurance to cover cars. If a company are not prepared to take on motor insurance, they cannot have the lucrative business such as fire and theft insurance which have always been the "bread and butter" of the industry. I would agree that the insurance companies have a point when they say the accident rate around that age has been excessively high. The insurance companies must operate economically. Perhaps companies covering motor insurance could arrange for tests to be made on cars every year as is done in England. People in the 25-year-old age group could be brought in for regular driving tests, although one cannot discriminate against one particular section of the community, particularly the section which contributes most of the productivity of the community.

In discussing industry one thinks of labour. The Department of Labour have an active manpower policy with emphasis on the training and retraining of workers, and the development of our national information, guidance and placement service for those seeking jobs. They also provide information on the operation of the redundancy and re-settlement schemes, and offer guidance on careers for those leaving school. They also provide a manpower forecasting unit which assists in analysing and predicting employment trends. An important objective is to promote good industrial relations, and the Department are responsible for legislation on trade union matters. They are also concerned with the safety, health and welfare of workers while at their places of work.

Comment on this

Is the Senator going to circulate his speech?

Comment on this

No. I often noted that the Senator read quite long extracts from notes. The Senator will get the text of my speech next week in the Seanad Official Report.

Comment on this

Could we read it in the Seanad debates and leave it at that?

Comment on this

The Department will spend more than £5 million this year. Details show that the main increase this year of £800,000 is for an increased grant-in-aid for AnCO. This is the body concerned with the training and re-training of workers. This is significant in that it shows that the Department realise the importance of this work.

The Government and the Department of Industry and Commerce have before them more protection for the safety and health of industrial workers. Under the Factories Act, 1955, and the Mines and Quarries Act, 1965, the Minister for Labour is empowered to make detailed regulations to protect workers from employment hazards. We are all aware of the employment hazards which existed over the years in industries, particularly in England and on the Continent. In the period October, 1971, to the end of this year the Minister will have made 15 sets of regulations under these Acts. Among these regulations there are new measures to prevent untrained workers from using dangerous machinery, to control the use of dangerous substances, such as asbestos and radioactive sources, to require the provision of suitable eating facilities in glass factories, and to lay down safety requirements for the use of locomotives, electricity and explosives in mines and quarries. Such measures only reduce the risks facing industrial workers. Education to reduce human error is another major safeguard. The National Industrial Safety Organisation are a voluntary organisation who run safety courses to encourage the setting up of safety committees in industry. The organisation need more support from management to this end. The enthusiastic co-operation of both workers and management in setting up safety committees is very desirable. It is good for a factory to have an accident-free record. There is always an element of danger in using machinery. Where management and staff are conscious of this and co-operate together it is bound to improve industrial relations. If people are nervous or worried about using machinery not considered to be safe it does not make for good staff relations and impedes productivity.

More than 2,000 adults and apprentices have been trained by AnCO in the past three years. Only a small proportion of the redundant workers have availed of the re-training facilities available and only 8 per cent of all adult trainees were over 35 years of age. The reason for this may be that the services provided by AnCO through the Department of Labour may not be widely known. If there was more publicity through the trade unions and the Department, it might raise the number. Some people, naturally, if they lose their employment will look elsewhere but this is because they do not have the full facts. In the coming years this matter will be developed further. If redundant workers opt for retraining at the AnCO training centres they now receive their full redundancy payments in addition to travelling allowances from AnCO. By 1970 AnCO hopes to have nine or 10 training centres and 2,000 training places. There will also be a mobile training capacity of 500 places and the aim is to provide adequate regional coverage. In cities it is easier to get alternative employment. If a person is trained in a particular job it is not always that easy to get alternative employment in rural areas where there are only one or two industries.

With regard to industrial relations, the first national agreement by the employer/labour conference was almost universally held and operated strictly in accordance with its terms by both sides of industry. As a result, the number of man-days lost through strikes in 1971 was only 273,770.

Comment on this

What did the Senator say was the percentage of redundancies over 35?

Comment on this

I did not say redundancies. I said only 8 per cent of all adult trainees were over 35.

This was a major improvement on the figure for 1970 when there were over a million man-days lost. In 1969 there were almost a million and in 1968 there were even 400,000. The national wage agreement has had wide-ranging repercussions on staff relations throughout the country. In 1969-70 we were, unfortunately, at the top of the league for industrial strikes. Recommendations by the Labour Court still seem to be rejected by workers in too many cases. In 1971 the court made 167 recommendations. The employers accepted 158 of these findings while workers accepted only 127. The findings of an industrial court should be accepted. They have no axe to grind. They give what they feel is the proper decision.

EEC developments on the harmonisation of company law and draft proposals for a European company statute will create interest in worker participation in management decisions.

Ireland has only two unions with more than 20,000 members. Given the number of small unions and the low level of union subscriptions, the ability of some of them to cope with the comlex issues of the future must be open to doubt. In the 1971 Trade Union Act we gave power and encouragement to small unions to amalgamate with larger unions. A small union in order to gain recognition must achieve results.

The success of the manpower service depends on the extent to which employers notify their vacancies to the service. A resettlement assistance scheme provides financial help to workers, including emigrants, who must leave their homes to take up employment, provided the jobs are notified to the manpower service. This scheme might be noted as an incentive to employers to use the service. From my own experience of the manpower service, they have been very helpful in providing positions for people who have become disemployed or for the school-leavers seeking positions, even in cases where firms have trained more apprentices than they needed. The number of surplus trainees this year was 1,000. The manpower service went out of their way to get employment for these people.

From the returns from industrial labour and the growth of the economy we must try to provide increased benefits for our less well-off sections of the community, that is, the social welfare recipients. The State expenditure on social welfare, including insurance and assistance services, has risen from £31 million in 1963-64 to £95.9 million. This is a very large increase in a ten-year period. As well as this, there is the estimated cost of the improvement provided for in the Social Welfare Act in 1972. The total social welfare expenditure figure has risen from £45 million to £153 million in the same period. This expenditure represents an increasing percentage of the GNP. In 1971 it was 7 per cent of GNP. This figure is quite startling when viewed over a ten-year period. It shows that if industry does as well as agriculture, the present Government are really justified in increasing the benefit to the less well-off sections of the community.

It was our policy, when we took over office, to increase social welfare benefits. They have been increased every year since then. Social welfare insurance rates have increased ten times in that period. When we look over the period of office of the present Government we realise that the increase in benefits has been quite dramatic and many new schemes were introduced in that period. The old age contributory pension scheme was introduced in 1961, the occupational injuries insurance scheme was introduced in 1967; free electricity and free travel for pensioners came into operation in 1967 and in 1968 free television licences were issued to them; increases for incapacitated pensioners were introduced in 1968 and death grants came into operation in 1970. The year 1970 also saw the introduction of the deserted wives' allowances and old age (care) allowances.

That is a fair record for any Government. No other Government could come anywhere near that record. Most of those schemes have been improved and extended since their introduction. For example, free travel is now available to all persons aged 70 years and over. Incapacitated and old age care schemes have been extended to include male relatives taking care of the aged.

The remuneration limit for compulsory insurance is now £1,600. It was raised from £600 to £800 in 1958; from £800 to £1,200 in 1968 and to its present level in 1971. I am sure that a different system will come into operation later on this year which will give everybody insurance cover. In 1969 the upper age limit for qualifying children of widowed pensioners was raised from 16 to 21 years where the children are receiving full-time education. In 1970 the age limit for qualified dependent children under the social assistance and assurance schemes was raised to 18 years. It was particularly difficult for widows to provide higher education for their children and the Government have helped them in every possible way.

Prior to 1969 under our social welfare scheme old age pensioners could obtain cheap fuel from November to March but this now operates from October to April. Last year pensioners aged 80 years and over were given an extra 50p per week. Those people who have lived more than the normal span of life were given some little extra benefit to enable them to enjoy the few remaining years of their life. In last year's budget deserted wives became eligible for an allowance at 40 years of age.

In the social welfare scheme the biggest increase has been in pay-related benefits. This has been the first increase in the flat rate but, like the unemployment and disability benefit schemes, it will improve immensely over the years and will lead to a pay-related retirement pension and a pay-related old age and widow's pension.

Comment on this

I suppose when the Senator reaches 80 years he will get a pension. At the rate the Senator is progressing we will be here until he is 80.

Comment on this

I have only been three-quarters of an hour speaking. Senator Kelly took well over an hour——

Comment on this

Senator Kelly was drawing fire.

Comment on this

——and Senator Alexis FitzGerald spoke for two and a half hours. I imagine that what I am saying is a little hard to listen to from the Opposition's point of view.

Comment on this

Very.

Comment on this

It gets a little bit under their skin.

Comment on this

Not in the way the Senator thinks.

Comment on this

Particularly in the social welfare sphere.

Comment on this
William O'Brien Mr. W. O'Brien Fine Gael

When did the Senator leave us?

Comment on this

The committee of agriculture in Meath, the Fianna Fáil members, co-opted me in 1955.

Comment on this
William O'Brien Mr. W. O'Brien Fine Gael

The Senator was Fine Gael in 1955.

Comment on this

No other Government can outstrip the record of the present Government in their efforts to improve the lot of the less well-off sections of our community. One Estimate that usually comes in for criticism is Posts and Telegraphs. The Estimate this year amounts to £46 million which represents an increase of £6 million over the previous year. It proves that the Government have in mind the expansion of the field of posts and telegraphs. On BBC television the other night I listened to the director-general of the Post Office apologising for the late delivery of nine million letters and cards at Christmas. He admitted that a mistake was made by effecting savings in a few fields but he said that savings were necessary in a body which was losing £750,000 a week.

The Department of Posts and Telegraphs Estimate covers the National Instalment Savings Scheme which was introduced in September, 1970 and last year saved £5 million. This was directed to the regular saver, the weekly or monthly wage-earner. If he put in money and left it for three years, he received a 25 per cent bonus. It has been shown to be successful as it realised £5 million last year. Our wealth depends on the savings of the community. The ordinary wage-earners were one particular section who had not been saving as much as heretofore. This was an incentive that was needed and it has been effective.

In the field of staff relations, the Department of Posts and Telegraphs are second to none. Good relations between the staff and the public are essential to improve efficiency. In 1971 improvements were made in retirement gratuities for part-time staff and a pension scheme for full-time unestablished staff was introduced. When one considers that the Post Office staff comprises 22,000 men and women and that it represents 2 per cent of the country's working population, it speaks well for the personnel administration that no strikes have occurred during recent years.

The postal service is recognised internationally as being an excellent one. There is a post office to every 1,300 persons in the State, and about 90 per cent of first class letters posted at the correct time to addresses in the Twenty-six Counties are delivered the following day.

Comment on this

First class letters? I think the Senator is talking about the British system.

Comment on this

I suppose I have used the wrong wording. Any letters posted at the time stated on the letter-box are delivered the next morning.

The one regard in which there is much criticism is in regard to the telephone service. However, the waiting list for telephone connections has diminished. A few years ago it numbered about 20,000: now it is down to about 9,000 or 10,000.

Comment on this

Is the Senator sure of that? I think he is wrong.

Comment on this

I am open to correction.

Comment on this

I think the Senator is very wrong.

Comment on this

A programme for more rapid development in the provision of new telephone kiosks in rural areas commenced in 1970-71 and there is now an all-night service in those areas where kiosks have been erected. Last year 150 new kiosks were erected and another 150 will be erected in the coming year. In most rural areas where the post office closed at 6 o'clock there was no direct link with the outside world. The provision of a kiosk made it possible to preserve such a direct link.

There is only one disappointing feature in connection with kiosks and that is the amount of vandalism they suffer from. The percentage of public telephones rendered useless through vandalism is higher than it should be. Telephone kiosks provide a useful service, particularly in cases of accident or illness.

Agriculture is our greatest industry and concerns a wide section of the community. With our entry into the EEC we should push ahead and give more emphasis and encouragement to young farmers to go into a four or five year apprenticeship at 16 years of age, as happens in industry. This would enable them to take over the family farm or to work on a farm. If parents are prepared to let a boy wait until 18 years and if the farm is big, it is desirable that he should have a degree in agriculture. When I was in Denmark about 20 years ago, every farm owner there had either served his apprenticeship or had a degree in agriculture. If we are to get the most out of the land, our farmers must be expertly trained for the years ahead. This system existed in Europe 20 years ago and we need it urgently now. There is a trend towards such apprenticeship but the one aspect missing is the fact that those boys who graduate with a degree in agricultural science do not return to work the family farm. Some go into the management of institutional farms but few return to the family farm. This is a disappointment, particularly when we are now producing more graduates in agricultural science than are able to be absorbed.

At present there is no provision for the sale of our calves, our yearlings, abroad. The price of our calves here at present is much higher than in the EEC, but there is the danger that if the price comes down and the European price goes up, in EEC conditions the younger calves could be sold just the same as the bigger cattle. When producing animals you expect to keep them for two or 2½ years but if they are sold in the first year it would be necessary to double the supply of calves to keep the supply of cattle. Our policy is to increase our cattle numbers and at present we have more than 6,000,000 cattle in Ireland. To get the optimum benefit we should keep them until they are mature. If all our farms were properly utilised the number of cattle could be increased to 10,000,000 and that would be an enormous benefit to the country. Some of the heifer incentive schemes that we have had over the last ten years have helped to increase the number of cattle. The number of cows has been increased to 2,000,000 and we hope this trend will continue. Good planning of this scheme will be a great benefit to the country.

It is being said that the high price of beef at present is due to our entry into the EEC; in fact, it is because there is a worldwide shortage of beef. Previously the Argentine exported frozen meat to England but now that has been done away with completely. In addition, Australia does not export as much because that country has not got sufficient beef. The standard of living is rising in many countries and because of that there is more demand for beef. This has been one of the causes of the increased prices because if there is a shortage of any kind the price will go up. There is no use saying that the price of beef can be controlled. If there is a higher price for the exported commodity there will be none on the market here.

England is an importing country and the Minister there realised that he could not put a control on prices. The only way he could control the price of beef would be to have rationing and nobody wants that. The only way to stabilise the price of beef is to give an incentive to increase the number of cattle and in that way the prices will level out.

In the EEC it may be difficult to give the grants to land project applications in the future. I hope this is not the case because the land project schemes for reclamation of the wet areas of Ireland is something that must go hand in hand with development of farms. The Danes were the first to realise this some 70 or 80 years ago. They knocked every ditch in the country and they laid pipes so that land was not wasted. I would not advocate this course for Ireland although I should like the land to be drained. Farms without ditches are all right for corn crops but not for grass. The Danes have an absolute shortage of grass in July because it is dried up from the sun but if there were ditches on the farms there might be more grass. In Ireland the animals need shelter but we certainly need to get rid of the rushes and the wet areas.

The Department of Finance could be criticised for the priority they give to arterial drainage. It is not as high as I would like it to be. It is maintained that the money spent there does not yield the same employment as money spent in other forms of industry. Arterial drainage provides a considerable amount of work while the scheme is going on and it also provides a big increase in employment and output in later years. The drainage work will go on afterwards in a private capacity with the farmers themselves and there will be an increase in the number of stock and an increase in corn crops. There is a big potential for increased employment apart from the increase in output and exports.

The Land Commission sometimes retain farms too long. I think they should be divided as quickly as possible. On the eastern seaboard it is becoming difficult for the Land Commission to divide farms on account of the price of land, but unfortunately sometimes it is the farmers who are shoving up the price. Also, speculators and business people invest their money in farms because they consider it is the best chance of capital growth they could have for their money instead of investing it in the stock exchange or some other business. As a consequence the farming community is deprived of much of the land. This is happening in County Meath and in parts of County Kildare where business people are living. I was glad to hear the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries stating he would endeavour to stop speculators buying up the land.

The 1965 Land Act gave power to the Land Commission not to sanction the sale of land to people who were not farmers. This should be implemented because it is bound to cause unrest in an area when land is bought by non-farmers. There is no objection if a farmer or his son, regardless of where he comes from, buys a farm but there is an objection to a person who is getting his livelihood from another source buying land needed by farmers. The Minister's announcement should be followed up quickly.

With regard to health matters, those who live within three miles of the dispensary or the local doctor have to get their drugs from the chemist and this is causing some hardship. This does not cause inconvenience in towns but it does in rural areas. The regulation also states a person must attend a doctor within seven miles of his residence. The local doctor will be supplied with drugs if the chemist's shop is more than three miles away. This should be reduced to one mile and thus minimise the hardship involved.

I was pleased to see some type of control put on house values. They have been rising at a colossal rate during the past few years. The Minister is introducing a certificate for value for money and this is welcome. The Department will keep a check on the builders. Young people who are depending on loans are very vulnerable. Legal expenses which can be up to £100 can be a financial strain on those who are buying a house because they may not have budgeted for that cost. It is easy to exploit young people who need money badly.

This certificate can be used only in grant-aided houses. I should like the Minister to examine the feasibility of introducing a certificate for houses which are not grant-aided, the prices of which are fantastic. The rates are high on this type of house and the builders can put in a high tender for their work. This means everybody along the line is getting a good crack out of those high-priced houses which cost from £6,000 to £26,000.

We are really concerned with grant-aided houses as they are the houses young married couples buy. We can hold up the grants which run around £600 to £1,000 according to the persons concerned. The policy we have been pursuing over the years is bearing fruit when one considers the number of new houses going up all over the country. People are happier when building their own houses.

We get complaints about the slow inspection but this is caused by the big increase in the housing programme.

There have been tremendous developments in the field of education over the years. The increased allocation given by the Government has greatly benefited our educational programme. They are now getting five or six times the amount of money spent on education six or seven years ago. The public are now realising the importance of education.

One aspect of education I should like to stress is that some guidance should be given to a child in the 15 to 16 age group. This would help them to decide whether to follow an academic career, do their leaving certificate and then attend a university or take up a trade or attend a school of technology. Too often we find young people with a pass in their intermediate or leaving certificate but there are very few openings for them. Possibly if such young people had received guidance at the age of 16 and had been advised to take up an apprenticeship or attend a school of technology more openings would be available to them. There are opportunities available for those who have attained third-level technological education.

I should like every secondary and vocational school to have a career guidance teacher who would advise the child in the 14 to 16 age group and direct him to the career most suitable for him. Parents also need encouragement because in some areas of the country they think when a child has passed his leaving certificate his education is complete. They do not realise that when a child sits for his leaving certificate and receives a pass or one honour he cannot follow a university course. He has gone past the age for some apprenticeships and two years may have been wasted. Often it is the parents who need the advice at that stage to give them an idea regarding the future of their child and what career is suitable for him. Parents are as much in need of guidance as the child. I should like to support this motion in recommending the Book of Estimates.

Comment on this

Before we proceed with the next speaker I should like to make a short reference to the matter of reading speeches. It is very difficult for the Chair to decide when a speech is read. It is difficult to prove that a speech is being read. On page 40 of Seanad Éireann Rulings and Precedents I find the following sentences:

Reading speeches is not in order. Further down on the same page I find:

While the use of notes and written memoranda is permissible, the practice of reading speeches is undesirable.

It is a matter the Chair must leave to the good sense and good taste of all Senators. When speeches are not read "they come more trippingly on the tongue", as William Shakespeare has said. I do not wish to interfere at any time with any Senator making a speech because often he is under great tension and I should be very reluctant to interrupt. I leave it entirely to the good sense and good taste of all the Senators concerned.

Comment on this

This annual debate on the Appropriation Act gives the Seanad an opportunity to comment on the performance of the Government and the Oireachtas during the year. To that extent, and this has been demonstrated by the last speaker, it is often a test of stamina. However, unlike Senator Crinion, I find it a depressing exercise. I do not share his complacent satisfaction with the status quo. I would prefer, in my capacity as an independent Senator, not to dwell at length on Government policy on the Northern question or, indeed, on internal politics as such. Instead, I should like to use this opportunity to review the record of the Government and Parliament, particularly the legislative record, and to consider our performance, or the lack of it, in certain specified areas. Here, I think the record is a very disappointing one.

The Seanad sat on 34 days since the debate on the Appropriation Bill took place last year. This is not a very heavy or distinguished workload when one considers that the European Parliament expects its members to attend for approximately 100 days on average, including a contribution towards committee work. I have been reviewing the Bills which were submitted and passed by the Seanad during that period. I should have liked to have had more time to do deeper research because it would be interesting to do a statistical study on the effect that debate in this House had on legislation. It would be interesting to assess the change that was made in any Bill from the time it was submitted to the House on the Second Stage—or even on the First Stage, if it was initiated here—in its passage through the various Stages and to calculate just how many changes were made in the text of the Bill, how many amendments of any significance, or even minor amendments, were accepted; in other words, how much impact either on Government policy or on the text of any of the Bills submitted was made?

Let us not fool ourselves. This House is not in the mainstream of Irish life at the moment. It is not fulfilling a role which satisfies the desire for democratic control over Government policy and for participation in the legislative process. I would submit that the Oireachtas is fast rendering itself redundant. It is no longer in the mainstream of Irish life. The energy, the thinking and the policy making are taking place elsewhere. These, I agree, are serious allegations and I am prepared to back them up by a fairly detailed examination of our legislative record this year and a consideration of the matters which we did not choose to legislate on or implement as policy.

I take, as my starting point, the fact that we are in this Appropriation Act voting the salaries and expenses of the Houses of the Oireachtas. We do so, first of all, in a sum of £64,000 up to 31st March, 1972, and then in a further sum of £1,080,000 for the year up to 31st March, 1973. These are not by any standards small amounts of money. If the recommendations of the Devlin Report are implemented it is possible that an even greater sum will be requested next year. In view of this it is legitimate to examine our performance during a legislative year.

Taking first of all the Acts which were passed; very few of them were of major importance. The three Acts to amend the Constitution were of importance, namely, the Act to enable us to assume the obligations of the Treaty of Rome and join the European Communities, the two other amendments, to lower the voting age to 18 years and to remove the recognition of the special position of the Catholic Church and the other named churches. The Value-Added Tax Bill was an important one. There were two fairly significant inroads into the extent of civil liberties in this country, namely, the Prisons Bill and the Offences Against the State (Amendment) Bill. Apart from that, the record is one of minor amending Acts. In some areas the promise was made that a further comprehensive Act would be brought in in due course. That seems to be the pattern: to isolate particular aspects of a Department's activity and bring in a piecemeal piece of legislation rather than to review the area and try to deal with it in a comprehensive way.

To take an example of this, the Garda Síochána Act, 1971, which was the first Bill of the year, was a minor amending Bill to provide an increase in numbers of the Garda Síochána. It did not consider the conditions or the method of appointment of members of the Garda Síochána even though this would have been appropriate as it coincided with the 50 years existence of this body and might have been a suitable time for a major review and changes in appointment and conditions of the gardaí.

I should now like to consider the Agricultural Credit Bill, 1972, which was passed in the early part of the year. This Bill is typical of the type of legislation introduced in this House since 1969. Its purpose was to increase the capital resources of the Agricultural Credit Corporation in order to keep pace with the growing demand for agricultural credit. I should like to quote briefly from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare's introductory speech on this Bill which appears in volume 72, column 619 of the Seanad Debates:

It seems inevitable that the expanding demand for credit will accelerate during the next few years, particularly with the prospect of entry to the European Economic Community. Farmers will be seeking additional credit to increase their livestock numbers, acquire better buildings and machinery and generally to adapt their enterprises to EEC conditions. Such investment will enable them to benefit from the higher prices and improved marketing conditions available in the EEC. Additional credit will also be required by the agricultural processing industries, especially the industries engaged in milk and pigmeat processing.

That is a very simplified attitude towards the implications of entry into the Community and towards the precise problem we are faced with now, where meat prices have gone up beyond what was predicted and the meat processing plants, therefore, are unable to compete with foreign buyers. Jobs in this area are at risk. There is also a difference in value of the return on export of live cattle on the hoof and the return which could be got from processing this meat. Legislation which does not adequately control the implications of a policy is bound to lead to unforeseen results of this nature.

We also had some minor Bills, such as the Wireless Telegraphy Bill and the Electrical (Amendment) Bill. I am not saying these Bills are unimportant. What I am saying is that this was not a great legislative year.

The Court Officers Bill, 1972, is typical of another type of legislation which came before this House. Perhaps it is a good example of this. It was introduced by the Minister for Justice. I quote from his opening statement on Second Reading which appears in Volume 72, column 761 of the Seanad Debates:

The purpose of this very short Bill is to allow time for consideration by the Government and by both Houses of the Oireachtas of comprehensive recommendations made by the Committee on Court Practice and Procedure in their Sixteenth Interim Report. Implementation of the recommendations would mean a substantial increase in the jurisdiction of the Master of the High Court, within, of course, the provisions of Article 37 of the Constitution.

He then goes on to explain that this is a temporary measure pending the introduction of the recommendations of the report. It is a good thing that we have a committee which submits a report which will influence the legislation. But there seems to be an incredible timelag. This House, and to my knowledge, the other House of the Oireachtas, have not considered the implications of this report since April, 1972, when this Bill was passed through the Seanad. Why is there satisfaction with temporary inadequate legislation when informed and comprehensive legislation should be brought in in the first place?

Another Bill which came before the Seanad shortly after that was as a result of unforeseen and very unwelcome circumstances, namely, the riot in Mountjoy Prison on the 18th and 19th May, 1972. This was the Prisons Bill, 1972. It was the first Bill of the year which was influenced very radically by the climate in which it was passed. To that extent it was an emergency Bill and there was a legitimate reason for this emergency in that the conditions in Mountjoy Prison required that prisoners be transferred elsewhere. Nevertheless, it was used to provide a useful extra power which would not normally have been forthcoming, the power to transfer a person from a civil prison to military custody. It was stated that the Bill would be a temporary one on the grounds that it was an extension of the normal powers of the Minister for Justice. The temporary nature of this Bill could well be an illusion. Again, I quote from the Official Report, Vol. 72, column 965, where the Minister for Justice stated:

The length of time which this Bill will remain in force was fixed in the Dáil today: it is until 31st May, 1974. However, it is subject to the proviso that if it should prove possible to do away with military custody before then, Dáil Éireann could pass a resolution taking section 2 of this Bill out of it before 31st May, 1974.

The question arises as to whether there will be an attempt to render the provisions of section 2 absolute before 31st May, 1974.

Other Acts which were passed at this time—the Industrial Development Bill, the Restrictive Practices Bill and the Local Elections Bill—were minor but necessary additions to the Statute Book. Then I come to a Bill which was initiated by three Independent Senators, Senator Horgan, Senator Owens and myself, namely, the Adoption Bill. This Adoption Bill was withdrawn after having received its Second Reading because of an undertaking by the Minister for Justice, in replying to the Second Stage debate, that he would bring in legislation in this field. I will quote from the Official Report, Vol. 73, where the Minister explained that some of the provisions in the Adoption Bill, as we had drafted it, were not acceptable to the Department. At column 166 he went on to say:

As for the rest, it is my intention to have a Bill prepared to amend the Adoption Acts. The Bill will contain provisions on matters not touched on in the present Bill. It will, I hope, include some provision to deal with the problem of consent, a provision to permit a married couple of different religions to adopt where one of them is of the same religion as the child and its mother, if the mother consents to adoption by such a couple, and a similar provision in relation to orphans of a mixed marriage.

The Bill will also contain provisions on the lines of sections 7, 8 and 9 of the present Bill and will provide for the repeal of section 15 (2) of the 1952 Act, which is also proposed in the present Bill. I regard these latter matters as ancillary and not worth legislating for in themselves. At this stage I would hope that I might be in a position to introduce a Bill before the end of the autumn session. However, I want to emphasise that very careful consideration will have to be given to the drafting of proposals to be embodied in the Bill. As none of the problems to be dealt with is of pressing urgency the measure will have to take its place behind other urgent matters. For that reason I am not in a position to say definitely that the legislation will be introduced before Christmas although I shall, of course, do my best to ensure that this will be done if possible. It is my intention to consult with the members of the Adoption Board before I formulate proposals for amendments to the Acts. Indeed, some preliminary consultations have already taken place.

This amounted to an undertaking by the Minister to bring in a new Bill if possible before Christmas.

I now wish to refer to the present situation in the Adoption Board where members of the board who were due to retire, having served two periods of five years, have been requested by the Minister to remain on the board pending the introduction of this amending legislation. This is quite a serious matter. There are two members involved who ought to have retired as of 1st January of this year. In former years other members of the board who had served ten years but who would have been willing to continue were compulsorily retired. This is a departure from normal practice in order to allow the present board to continue pending this new legislation. Does this mean that the Minister intends to bring in an entirely new type of legislation and to change the nature or composition of the board, or does he intend to confine the amending legislation to the matters which were dealt with in the Private Members Bill last year? If so, why is he not making new appointments to the board and why is he continuing the service of members of the board beyond ten years? It is important that the Oireachtas be informed of the Minister's intentions in this respect. I would welcome a comment on when it is intended to bring the Adoption Bill before the House.

While on the subject of ministerial promises, I recall that another promise was made by the Minister for Justice to this House during the debate, which took place in 1971, on the Prohibition of Forcible Entry and Occupation Bill. In the debate on that Bill, the Minister gave an undertaking that at the first opportunity an amendment would be made to section 4 of that Bill which would change the words "encouraging and advocating" to the word "inciting". The Minister accepted that the word "inciting" was more acceptable to the House and to some extent he got the Bill through on that assurance. Once again, I would welcome some indication of when the Minister intends to bring in this amendment and why he neglected to use the opportunity of inserting it into either the Prisons Bill or the Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill. That would appear to have been appropriate legislation in which the amendment could, without too much stretching of the draftman's imagination, have been included.

There were other Bills introduced during the year, the major one being the European Communities Bill. Here the Seanad provided some useful amendments, particularly the amendment which the Minister himself introduced, that the Government must report twice a year to each of the Houses of the Oireachtas on developments in the Communities. It is not a very precise or specific requirement but, nevertheless, it imposes a statutory duty on the Government and it will provide the Oireachtas with an opportunity for a debate twice a year on what is happening in the Communities and an opportunity for a review of the performance of the Irish Minister at the Council of Ministers.

In reviewing legislation, the saddest moment of the year was on Saturday night, 2nd December, when we debated the Offences against the State (Amendment) Bill. It is clear in retrospect that the panic which, I believe, was deliberately engineered and which caused the House to sit late on Saturday night and early Sunday morning, was unnecessary. It became clear, less than 24 hours afterwards, that this legislation was not needed imminently to preserve the safety of the State. This underlines the arguments that were made to the effect that consideration of legislation without proper time being devoted to it was dangerous and also justifies the objections which were put forward to allowing a Bill which had been passed in this way to be put permanently on the Statute Book. We may possibly find that this Act will suffer the same fate as the previous Act passed in a single day, the Act which gave powers to the Public Accounts Committee to compel witnesses to appear before it.

Comment on this

The Senator should be accurate. The grounds on which that Bill or Act was declared unconstitutional were grounds which went back for many years in many Acts of the Oireachtas. The passage of the Bill at considerable speed was quite irrelevant to the grounds on which it was rejected by the Supreme Court. The Senator knows that.

Comment on this

No. I would not accept that. There should have been more time for considering the Bill. The fact that the powers were contained in other legislation is not relevant. Each Bill is considered on its merits and the important thing is to have the time to do this. In the case of the Offences against the State Bill there was not the time to consider the full implications of the wording of the Bill and there was not the time to draft considered amendments to it; it has not got the safeguards built into it of having a defined time limit and it is permanently on our Statute Book. For me, personally, it was the blackest hour of this year in the Seanad.

Comment on this

We had to protect the private banks.

Comment on this

I did not get that. So much then for the Bills, or some of them, which came before the House. The general impression remains that this was not a great year of legislative endeavour.

Let us now look to another possible field of activity for the Seanad —the debating of motions. Considering the number of motions which have been on the Order Paper of the Seanad, it is strange that so few were actually debated. I notice that we did debate the motion on votes at 18, but it was a very brief debate because it was clear at that time that there would be legislation and a constitutional amendment to that effect.

We debated the accession of Ireland to the European Communities. It was a useful and constructive debate. We debated certain matters on the adjournment, such as the higher education grants, and the Prisons Act, where it was alleged that certain safeguards under the Prisons Act were not complied with; and we debated the report on equal pay. However, there are many other motions which have been on the Seanad Order Paper for many, many months. Indeed, I heard a suggestion on the last occasion, when we were trying to get time to debate these motions, that it would be interesting if the motions could be dated from the date when they were first placed on the Order Paper. Then we would certainly see the slow and lazy way in which we approach these matters. The motions which can be pointed to that have been a very long time on the Order Paper are a motion in relation to the Report of the Public Services Organisation Review, a motion to debate the Buchanan Report on regional development, a motion to debate the White Paper on local government reorganisation, a motion which Senator Kelly was anxious a few weeks ago to bring before us on the personnel and terms of reference of the body appointed to review the working of Radio Telefís Éireann; motions regarding the McKinsey Report on public transport, the Fletcher Report on the ESB, and the Report of the Trustee of the National Library of Ireland, for 1970-71 and for 1971-72. That gives us an idea of how long those motions have been lying on the Order Paper.

Taken in conjunction with the fact, which I mentioned at the beginning, that the Seanad sat for a mere 34 days since we last debated the Appropriation Bill last year, I do not think this is a record of which we can be proud. It may be stated that it is difficult to get a particular Minister to appear before the House and I have no doubt that this difficulty will be compounded as our Ministers fly off in executive jets to various cities in Europe. The argument is answered by the point that it is not necessary to have a Minister present. These motions can be debated constructively and usefully without a Minister being present, if necessary without even a Parliamentary Secretary being present. If there is a record of the debate and a possibility of some reply, or a comment on what has been said in the House, on another occasion, if necessary——

Comment on this

But is it not possible for these resolutions to be debated now?

Comment on this

I would hope so, but I have a feeling that the next time we debate an Order of Business we will be told: "No. The Order will be as it was today—one matter for consideration."

Comment on this

That is only a presumption. The Senator is contesting now and saying whether or not they are permissible.

Comment on this

That is encouraging, but I have some doubts if it will actually happen.

Comment on this

I think the Senators are at cross-purposes.

Comment on this

Communications are bad.

Comment on this

So much then for the legislative year and the record of the House during it. Now I should like to turn to the other side of the picture and to select merely a few areas where there has been an absence of either legislation or a policy approach. The first area that comes to mind—this is possibly to some extent a subjective reaction—is that it seems that we are going to wait forever to have a reform of the Children Act of 1908. In every——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I would like to point out that the Senator is not in order in advocating legislation in the debate on this motion. That may come as a surprise, but that is the position.

Comment on this

I am rather astonished to hear that. If I could work this into a reflection on the administration, may I say that I noted this afternoon while serving on the Seanad Committee on Statutory Instruments, that there is an excuse being used in the Department of Education of preoccupation with the recommendations of the Kennedy Report. I should like to draw the attention of the House to a letter which was written asking why there was a delay in laying a Statutory Instrument under the Children Act, 1941, before the Seanad. There had been what the committee regarded as unnecessary delay here. The explanation from the Department, written on 6th December, 1972, reads as follows:

I am directed to refer to your minute of 17th September, 1972, and to express regret at the delay in laying the Children Act, 1941 (section 21) Regulations, 1972, before Seanad Éireann. This delay was due to the unprecedented volume of new areas of work being handled in the section of the Department which deals with this matter arising out of the implementation of the recommendations of the Kennedy Report publication in November, 1970, and the reorganisation of the administrative staff.

I would hope that that letter is an indication and, if it is, it is the first indication that I have had, that there will be the implementation both of the full recommendations of the Kennedy Report, and not the one or two which have been implemented to date such as the closing of Marlborough House, and also that there will be a general reform in the Children's Act.

Comment on this

But before you make an accusation you should take all factors into account. I remember a Senator who said they were overpaid and underemployed. The Senator should relate her remarks to the number of hours that this Senator spent in the House.

Comment on this

I suppose they will refuse their increase.

Comment on this

I had intended, a Chathaoirleach, before your explanation of the scope of the Appropriation Bill, to advocate that the Government introduce, as they promised, the legislation in the area of family planning and to amend the law relating to contraceptives. I think I can do this within the bounds of what is permitted by noting the failure of the Government to introduce the legislation despite, admittedly, vague assurances. I find the statement by the Taoiseach, on more than one occasion, that the matter is now before the courts and the Government must await the outcome from them, much more annoying than those vague assurances.

This, as the Taoiseach must know as a barrister, is not the legal position. There is nothing to stop the Legislature from assuming the proper jurisdiction to legislate or amend legislation on a particular matter. The fact that there is a private action before the courts is not relevant. It does not displace the competence, jurisdiction or responsibility of the Legislature. Any vague statements to that effect are misleading and inaccurate. The case brought by Mrs. McKee which did not succeed in the High Court and is being appealed to the Supreme Court is not relevant to the Government's responsibility in this area and to the possibility of bringing in legislation to amend the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1935, to legalise contraceptives and also amend the Censorship Acts.

During the year, one of the motions which we debated was that on equal pay. In this area there have been assurances that some of the recomendations of the committee will be implemented. Since we have now become fully-fledged members of the European Communities, the Government must be prepared to go further in this matter. We must consider an equivalent of the Equal Pay Act, 1970, which has been introduced in Britain and which will be fully operative in December, 1975.

Comment on this

But not in the rest of the Community.

Comment on this

I think the Senator would agree with me that, of the countries in the Community, we have the worst record in relation to equal pay and the worst discrimination against women. In that respect, I would hope that Dr. Hillery, a former member of the Government, who is now the Commissioner for Social Affairs, will be able to influence the situation here, not in his capacity as a European Commissioner, but because he will be the focus of journalistic comment on the Communities. This ought to be an effective lobby for change and improvement in our social welfare benefits and in our general social welfare code. If an Irishman is putting the social affairs of Europe right, then perhaps the collective body of Irish people can put their own house in order.

I have been critical of the performance of the Seanad and its legislative record over the last year. I should like, rather than rest on negative criticism, to make the argument for a necessary change in the approach to both the legislative enactments and the administration and policy of the Government. The necessary step to do this must be the introduction of a committee which will review and survey the many State-sponsored bodies and public enterprises. I am well aware that the argument for the advantages of such a committee has been made from time to time. I propose to argue on its necessity for the following reasons.

First, nobody has overall responsibility for State bodies at present. Although the Minister for Finance has responsibility for the Capital Budget, there is no way of ascertaining the aggregate statistics of State bodies, the total number employed in them or their total capital without going round to each one and adding up the totals. There is no coherent, overall policy towards these various State-sponsored bodies.

Secondly, these bodies, or many of them, have been in existence for up to 50 years. They were set up for different reasons and there was no institutional method of reviewing their functions and their operations over this period. For example, the ESB, which is nearly 50 years old was set up in 1927 and has been examined by the Fletcher Committee. That committee made very far-reaching recommendations. Unfortunately that report, as Senator Brugha will know, is still lying on the Order Paper and we have not had an opportunity to consider its recommendations in detail. It has the disadvanage of being a report of an ad hoc body rather than one of a continuing body which can, if necessary, up-date its report and have the value of sustained expertise in this area.

Comment on this

What about the universities? Are they not State-financed?

Comment on this

I think the universities are coming under a great deal more control in that area than some other bodies in which one would like to see more control.

The argument for an approach which would allow for a general philosophy of investment in public enterprise and for a definition of Government policy towards these bodies is a very strong one. At the moment there is no overall philosophy. By philosophy I do not mean an ideology. It is possible, as has happened in Britain, to have a pragmatic approach, but nevertheless, to lay down the criteria under which these bodies have been set up and to which they will be accountable.

I should like to refer to one sentence in the Third Programme on Economic and Social Development to show the lack of terms of reference and lack of criteria on which to judge the State bodies. This sentence is on page 123 of the report, in paragraph 57 of chapter 8. There is a reference to Córas Iompair Éireann as follows:

The annual grant of £2 million represented what the Government considered to be a realistic estimate of the minimum subsidy with which CIE could get by on the basis of effective management and increased efficiency and productivity.

This is the key to the morass of public enterprises and State-sponsored bodies. There is no criteria on which to judge them. We give a grant of £2 million as the minimum on which a body like that "can get by". It is relatively impossible to judge the performance of a body of this nature when the criteria have not been clearly established.

Using a phrase such as "social benefit" is not helpful unless in some way we have defined what we mean by "social benefit" and what relevance this has in relation to bodies such as CIE, the ESB or other bodies which receive a large amount of public grants and subsidies.

Comment on this

How much do they give for the universities?

Comment on this

I do not think this constant griping at the universities is particularly relevant.

Comment on this

It is relevant anyway.

Comment on this

If a select committee were introduced to review State-sponsored bodies I would advocate a joint committee so that the manpower of the Seanad could be used for this purpose. It would be useful for the following reasons.

Firstly, the only people at the moment who are paid to think about State bodies have a special interest in them. They are either on the management of these bodies or they are civil servants in the particular Department linked with that State body. Therefore, they have not the time nor the encouragement to think in terms of a general overall policy or of general working criteria.

Secondly, there is no mechanism whereby policy-makers can draw on the advice or expertise of people other than personnel in the management of the bodies or civil servants. If an ad hoc committee is set up, as is a fairly common practice, or if we get experts to come in from outside the country, that has a certain usefulness but it does not have either the continuity or the possibility of acquiring expertise of a permanent body. The work of an ad hoc committee could not compare in usefulness to the evidence which could be elicited by a select committee with the use of verbatim minutes and the issuing of regular reports.

Thirdly, this would seem to be a way in which outsiders could influence, by being called upon by the select committee to give the benefit of their expertise and by having an opportunity to comment on the reports which this committee would issue from time to time. This would lead to a constructive and helpful debate in this area.

Fourthly, the range of activities in which we have State-sponsored bodies and public enterprises is much wider in this country than in many other countries, particularly in Britain where there is a mechanism for control of this kind. Particularly, as we have State-sponsored bodies which are engaged in manufacture and commercial enterprises, we ought to have the possibility of having a more general policy in relation to them.

Fifthly, this committee could define the criteria by which one can assess the performance of public enterprises and give us guidelines on which to judge this performance. We are increasingly faced at present in the Oireachtas with Bills whose sole purpose is to increase the funds towards a public enterprise either because the estimate was not sufficient in previous years or because of the effects of inflation or of inadequate planning.

Comment on this

Does the Senator not understand that this is a deliberate policy to ensure that these matters come before the Oireachtas at regular intervals?

Comment on this

It is useful for the Oireachtas to be able to debate in this way but the traditional methods of debate are not adequate. It is not enough for various Senators to express their subjective opinions on the performance of State-sponsored bodies during the year. We need more time and a comprehensive survey of performance. We need the expertise, the possibility of cross-examining expert witnesses on this.

Comment on this

Whatever view one may take of that, I should not like the Senator to have the wrong idea. I should like to make it quite clear that this question of bringing forward Bills to increase the capital of State-sponsored bodies is a result of a deliberate policy to ensure that at least that amount of debate on the particular body is available to the Oireachtas at regular intervals.

Comment on this

The sort of debate we get is entirely inadequate. I should like to refer to a recent example of this. I shall quote an Opposition spokesman to show that I am not trying to make a political point. On the 15th November, 1972, in Volume 73, No. 10, we were discussing the Electricity Supply (Amendment) Bill, 1972. Speaking from the Fine Gael benches, Senator McDonald said—and I quote from his speech to show the level of debate which this will arouse in the House:

The amendments incorporated in this Bill cannot in any way be regarded as contentious. We should like to compliment the Minister and the ESB for coming back so quickly to remedy the difficulty that arose subsequent to the passing of the legislation in 1970. This speaks well for the Minister and the ESB. The board must be complimented on the excellent service they are continuing to provide. I hope that with this additional piece of legislation their service will improve and that it will lead to more harmonious relations between the board and their employees.

I submit, without wishing to be critical of another Senator, as on our feet we are all much less fluent than we would like to be, it is just impossible in open debate on the floor to be constructive and to understand the sort of policy review and studied approach which is necessary in trying to define how much of the national cake one ought to allot in this way and by what guidelines one judges performance. For that reason I urge the necessity for a proper working committee on public enterprise.

Another reason for doing so at present is because of the implications of the European Communities. It is necessary to have a committee examining the implications of a common transport policy and to review our public enterprises in the light of this. It will become increasingly necessary to review the common energy policy of the Community. This cannot be effectively tackled in a debate on the floor where Senators have not got the information or the expertise and cannot do more than give their own subjective reactions. We are entitled to expect a more thorough and detailed performance from the Members of the Legislature. The methods of control and the power to influence policy must be improved or the Parliament will have rendered itself obsolete in relation to the major issues of the day.

There is a second area where the performance of the Parliament could be improved and that is in response to the challenge of membership of the EEC. At present consideration is being given to the setting up of a committee on European affairs and I would like to comment on the problems which the Oireachtas will face as a result of our joining the EEC and as a result of adapting to this European dimension. The basic problem before the Oireachtas is twofold. There is the question of how to define its role in relation to the legislation which will be in the form of regulations and directives coming from the Council and Commission and, secondly, how to become aware of and react to policy formation and administrative practices within the Community.

The first problem we have to cope with involves the legislative output of the Community. The second problem is how to devise ways of ascertaining the policies and proposals which will ultimately become the legislation and to react to those and ensure that there is an awareness and sufficient information on these matters. The problems are real ones because it would be possible for the Oireachtas to adopt a passive attitude. I am afraid lest we would be tempted to adopt this passive attitude towards the whole area of Community legislation and decision-making particularly because the legislative powers of the Community are exercised not by the Parliament, as is the case in the national area, but by the Council and Commission which are executive bodies. Strictly speaking, the Oireachtas does not need even to take note of Community regulations and decisions. The mere publication of regulations in the Community's Official Journal is enough to make them law, and similarly decisions take effect as soon as they have been notified to the person to whom they are addressed.

Directives have to be implemented by the national authority and it has been provided in the European Communities Act that this will be done by way of Ministerial regulations. There is a minimum of participation provided in this statute for the Oireachtas in that these regulations which will implement the Community directives and which can, if necessary, amend, repeal and adapt existing Irish law will not remain in force after six months unless confirmed by an Act of the Oireachtas.

Has this been sufficiently thought out? The extent to which these confirming Acts will give a genuine choice and will inform the Oireachtas is debatable. If Acts merely list the regulations which are to be confirmed they will not involve the Oireachtas very constructively or intelligently in the process. It is hard to see how these confirming Acts can be rejected if the position is made clear that these are directives from the Communities and that we have implemented them in this way and that we are obliged to continue to do so. The Oireachtas would not have any means of influencing the choice or method of implementation or of considering the alternatives which might have been open in implementing the directives. In that way the review by the Oireachtas, by way of confirming Acts, may not be effective.

The problem of getting information is already with us in many areas. The most important issue for the Oireachtas will be how to get knowledge of Community legislative proposals sufficiently in advance to be able to influence their content. This is going to be a problem because the Oireachtas is unaccustomed to acting in this way. We do not see legislative proposals at a stage when it is still possible to influence their content. All we do in the passage of a Bill through the House is, on a rare occasion, to provide sufficient reasoning for some change in scope or to insert some minor drafting amendment or seek out the explanation for the legislation. It is useful to have a Minister steering a Bill through the House so that he can be questioned on the effect of a section. To that extent there can be a watch-dog role for the Oireachtas.

In relation to Community legislation, if there is to be a constructive approach it will have to be at the stage when the proposals are still very much in draft. To this extent the Community legislation is more democratic than one finds in the national systems. It is possible to have more influence on a Commission draft proposal when it is sent for the opinion of the parliament or sent to the Council than it is possible for a national parliament, particularly the Oireachtas, to influence a Bill once it is tabled in the House.

There must be a realisation that the decision-making process in the Community is more fluid and more open to change and development before final decisions are taken. We must not adopt a passive role and we must not have a negative approach to these draft proposals. The problem is to secure the necessary information to be aware of the proposals when they are in draft form and to be aware of the considerations behind them. It will be necessary for the Government to provide this information service to the Parliament because the Parliament do not have the powers or ability to seek information directly either from the Council of Ministers or from the Commission. The Council of Ministers is composed of ministers from the EEC countries including an Irish Minister, so it seems appropriate also that this information should be supplied by the Government.

During the debate on the European Communities Bill, Deputy Hillery, the then Minister for Foreign Affairs, recognised the need for the Government to supply information. He said:

The Government has already taken the decision to put in the Library such draft legislation, other than Commission proposals, which deals with matters which must be regarded as confidential, for example, relating to trade negotiations with countries outside the Community...

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Might I point out to the Senator that it is now past the usual time for adjourning?

Comment on this