Protection of Young Persons (Employment) Bill, 1974: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–174 of 373. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1974 ›
This is just a drafting amendment. The definition of "day" meaning a period of 24 consecutive hours has little meaning in relation to other sections in the Bill and I am informed that it would be better in terms of the general drafting of the Bill that the normal interpretation of the word "day" meaning midnight to midnight will suffice.
Comment on this
The Minister leaves me in some puzzlement. He was at pains to insert this rather curious definition that a day means a period of 24 consecutive hours. He said it had little meaning and one should forget about it. It must have had some meaning. There must have been some reasoning for it. I would assume that to me, to the Minister and to most people a day is a day that begins at midnight and finishes at midnight the following day. This is a totally different type of day, any period of 24 consecutive hours.
There must have been some reason for putting this rather eccentric definition of the word "day" into the section. Indeed, if one looks at section 7 (1) (a), section 8 (1) (a), section 9 (1) (a) and (b), the word "day" appears and would have some importance with the original definition inserted by the Minister. It would mean, for example, as in the original definition, in the case of a young person who worked five hours for an employer one afternoon and five hours the following morning, that that employer would be committing an offence because the employee would have worked too long. I take it this must have been the intention of the Minister in bringing in this definition and he now quietly drops it.
It is not good enough for the Minister to say that he had this definition which wrenches the meaning of "day" out of its normal sensible meaning to which we are used all our lives and into a totally different type of meaning. Now he comes along and says, "Well, after all, perhaps it does not matter and it is going to be dropped." There must have been some reason for putting it in in the first place.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that if the definition which appears in the Bill goes out there will not be any danger that you might have a situation arising where a young person might work six hours before midnight and six hours after midnight making a total of 12 hours in 24 rather than ten hours as provided for in the Bill?
Comment on this
There is nothing more complicated behind this change than that we were informed on looking at this again there was a possibility of conflict with sections 13 and 14 and that this was an improvement on it. There is no heavy weather to be made out of this change. As I say, this seems to be an improvement which makes the meaning clearer and avoids potential areas of conflict with later drafting.
Comment on this
I know we have a lot of amendments to go through and I do not want to waste too much time on this one, but it puzzles me why this was put in in the first place. The Minister says—and I think he is right— that the Bill is better without it, but the fact remains that it was put in for some reason and I would be interested to know what the reason was.
There is no doubt about it that under section 8, for example, which covers the employment of a person between the ages of 15 and 16, with the original definition of a day meaning a period of 24 consecutive hours, if an employer employed a 15-year-old for five hours in an afternoon and five hours the following morning he would be committing an offence because he would have worked for ten hours in a 24-hour period. This is the point which the Leader of the House was bringing in—he would have worked for ten hours in a 24-hour period, that is a day, whereas the maximum he is allowed is nine. With this change he is allowed to work for ten hours. I am not making any point about that because the number of hours he works in all will not be any higher. There is, nonetheless, a legal change as a result of this and it must have been put in in the first place for some reason. Was it put in in order to ensure that, for example, under section 8 that if you were a 15-year-old you could not work for five hours one afternoon and five hours the next morning? Has the Minister any idea why it was put in?
Comment on this
Whatever about the idea why it was put in I am quite clear about the reason it is being taken out.
Comment on this
Very well. If the Minister does not know why it was put in and he has decided that it is better out, OK.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In subsection (1) after "service" in line 19 to insert ",contract for services".
This amendment is more or less a technical one. It has regard to the fact that the Minister is endeavouring to protect the employment of young people in every conceivable way. My amendment will afford him an opportunity of ensuring that they will not be taken advantage of in other areas. This is why I am making the suggestion that there should be "contract for services" included in this section.
I have in mind, for example, what are very well known now as "lumpers" taking advantage of the scene, people who are not covered or who would regard themselves as not being covered by the Bill if it became law. I consider this as being purely technical and I should like to have the Minister's view on it before I say anything more.
Comment on this
I should like to support this amendment. It is very much in the spirit of the Bill, which purports to be a comprehensive measure to protect young persons. I can see that it might be more than just a technicality. There could be a loophole which could be taken advantage of. In many cases it is a matter of the surrounding circumstances whether the relationship is a contract of employment or a contract for services. I could see a possible avoidance of the protective measures of the Act when it comes into force by a clever way of adapting the relationship so that it became a contract of employment rather than a contract for service and I should like to see the term broadened to include "contract for services" for this reason.
Comment on this
I accept the general intention behind Senator Mullen's amendment. Senator Robinson will know that the concept of contract for services covers many kinds of contractors or proprietors who have little in common with and certainly no relationship to employees as we know the term. I therefore would put forward the following formulation of Senator Mullen's amendment which I think would meet his objective. If Senators have reservations about the revised formula, it could be dealt with on Report Stage, but I would be agreeable to accept it at this Stage. In page 3, line 20, where Senator Mullen wishes to have his amendment inserted, after "contract of apprenticeship" to insert, and I quote:
A contract personally to execute any work or labour.
That could be introduced on Report Stage, if that satisfies Senator Mullen. I think it is more or less what he has been seeking to bring about.
Comment on this
I suggest it would be wiser to leave it until Report Stage so that everyone can have a look at it in print.
Comment on this
Perhaps Senator Mullen would withdraw amendment No. 2. This does not prejudice his right to put down exactly the same amendment on Report Stage if he wishes, if he stills feels he would prefer it, but leave it open to the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In subsection (1) to delete "does not include" in line 29 and substitute "includes".
This amendment has been suggested because as far as I can see there is no definition of rest periods in this Bill. If there is, and the definition was in respect of short periods of rest that occurred in every employment apart from tea breaks, periods from five to ten minutes, I think that "period of rest" so defined should be included in the hours of work. Without a definition of periods of rest, the section could be interpreted as meaning the period during which a worker ceases work for the day and resumes the following morning. It could be a period of 16 or 17 hours, and of course no one would suggest that such a period should be included in the hours of work. But bearing in mind that, as far as I can ascertain, there is no definition of periods of rest, the periods of rest I have in mind in interpreting this section should be included in hours of work.
Comment on this
It was not my intention to have in the legislation a provision which would include lunch hour in the hours of work. Certainly it is my intention that the rest periods, afternoon tea or coffee breaks, be normally included in an employee's daily hours of work normally calculated. I would not be in favour of the inclusion of lunch hour breaks in such hours of work because that could lead to many abuses. I could look again at this point put by Senator Kennedy about there being an absence of definition of "rest period", of the period he has in mind and I have in mind. I am assuming that the normal position throughout industry obtains here. That is my intention. I certainly would look again at Report Stage to see if we can copperfasten what I understand, and what I am sure the Senator understands to be the normal position.
Comment on this
Arising from what the Minister said, it is important to bear in mind that we are seeking to protect young people in employment. There are various types of rest periods. I do not regard the lunch break as one of them because people must have a lunch break. It reminds me very much of some people being inclined to think that you should give persons a mash of bran and leave them working. I am concerned with breaks and I think that if a child comes under the responsibility of an employer during the course of breaks the employer should bear that responsibility and it should not be calculated when deciding what hours he should have.
We all recognise that a rest period is socially necessary. Why should we legislate otherwise having regard to the fact that we are setting out to protect young people in employment? I would urge the Minister to give consideration to rest periods, and I am talking about the 10 o'clock break or the 11 o'clock break or the afternoon break. There is legislation in existence at the moment that one must have a break within a certain number of hours. I see no reason why the worker should have to pay for such a break by way of that time being taken into consideration. If one goes out to lunch it is a different thing entirely—one has a lunch break not controlled by the employer.
Comment on this
The amendment does not have anything to do with pay—it is on the question of hours. The net effect would be to shorten the maximum permitted hours of work. Is that not right?
Comment on this
The employee should not be required to pay in any way whether it be in cash or time for a break that he is properly entitled to, to afford him an opportunity of standing up and working.
Comment on this
The point I was putting was that the net effect of the amendment seems to be to shorten the maximum permitted number of hours of work. If you include breaks in the maximum number the actual number of hours worked would be less. You could plead this in either of two ways, either reducing the maximum permitted hours or else include breaks up to, say, an hour or whatever it might be in the maximum number.
Comment on this
After all we are talking about young persons in employment and we are not to compare them with adults who would go for the same break as the child will. I agree with what the Senator has just said.
Comment on this
There is a lot to be said for the later remarks of Senator Mullen. I think that really what we need to refer to is the rest periods laid down in section 11. As Senator Mullen said, of course we cannot expect people to pay for lunch and so on, but in section 11 there are various rest periods laid down. For example, if a young person is employed for five hours at a stretch then there must be a half-hour period of rest. Alternatively, at the expiration of normal working hours, before any overtime of more than one-and-a-half hours can be worked, there must be a gap of half-an-hour.
In these cases it would seem that one could put up a very strong argument saying that where these hours are compulsorily laid down by the Act, very particularly as Senator Mullen has pointed out, the worker is not in his own time. It is not like going home for lunch or anything of that kind. He is there at the behest of the employer; he cannot leave; he has got to be around.
Again, section 11 provides in subsection (5) that the period of half-an-hour shall be provided where the normal working hours end and overtime is beginning. This can be cut to 15 minutes by agreement between the worker and the employer, but in this case the employer must pay. It is specifically provided there. If an employer can pay for 15 minutes why on earth should he pay for 30?
The Leader of the House raised the issue of whether this would increase the number of hours worked. I take it that the payment for rest periods would not be counted as part of the number of hours worked, although strictly speaking one might put up a case that it should because he has to be there anyway. If this amendment were to be drafted to refer specifically to the rest periods laid down in section 11 there would be a very strong case to be made for accepting it.
Comment on this
There is general agreement on the intent but both the original text and the amendment are inadequate. Perhaps the Minister would think about redrafting this?
Comment on this
Certainly I shall have a look to see if anything can be done on Report Stage. There is a problem in that it is very difficult to define legally what is meant by a short rest period. I shall have a look at it for Report Stage.
Comment on this
First of all, the definition "employee" means a young person or a child as the context may require. I know what is intended here, but it does not seem a very good use of the English language. To say that a young person or a child is the same as an employee is nonsensical and as a definition it is entirely inadequate. If it is said an employee includes a young person or a child, that makes sense. It is nice and tidy to say that a definition means such and such, but in this case tidiness has led to a breach of plain English. I shall try to draft an amendment for Report Stage to embody what "employee" includes, not to change the effect of the definition, but to put it into plain English.
The second point is merely a query. In line 26 it says "a trade union is a body entitled under the Trade Union Act of 1941...". I have been unable to trace the section in which this phrase occurs and perhaps the Minister could tell me where it appears in the Bill.
Comment on this
I am informed that the title "trade union" is in the definition of collective agreements—"By or on behalf of an entitled trade union or entitled trade union representative of employees."
Comment on this
We have a definition section which I take it refers to a particular section. I have not been able to find it and I am wondering where it is.
Comment on this
I am a little worried about subsection (2) where it states:
The Minister may, by order, declare any form of work to be industrial work for the purposes of this Act.
There is a similar subsection in section 4. This seems to represent a certain pattern running through part of the Bill. We have in section 4 "The Minister may, by order, declare any form of work to be work which is not, in fact, industrial work" while in the following subsection the Minister can say that any form of work is industrial work. In other words, he can declare work to be light industrial work simply by order and I am not clear on the necessity or the desirability of this. We can declare work to be industrial work here in this House, and this can be reversed overnight by order of the Minister. I should be interested to hear the Minister's views on this.
Comment on this
There is some flexibility needed so that we may be in a position to declare a form of work to be industrial work for the purpose of the Act. This power enables me to clarify any case in relation to exceptions to the general rule concerning the minimum age of employment contained in section 4 where we set down the minimum age. It provides the necessary flexibility to decide in borderline cases and to lay down clearly what exactly we include in the definition.
Comment on this
Am I right in thinking that here the Minister is taking a quite distinct point of view from the point of view in the British legislation on the same topic? In the British legislation the powers given to the Secretary of State are very wide, whereas what the Minister is attempting to do here is to define various categories of work in section 2, and to a certain extent in section 3. There is a relevant section in the British Employment of Children Act, 1973, which empowers the Secretary of State to make regulations "with respect to the employment of children and any such regulations may distinguish between children of different ages and sexes and between different localities, trades, occupations and circumstances and may contain various further provisions". There seems to be two different philosophies here: the philosophy which gives a Minister or Secretary of State complete discretion with regard to what he may or may not define by order, and the question in this Act where there is a very serious attempt to import some of these definitions, which in the British context would be made by way of order, into the actual legislative instrument. Is the Minister satisfied that this is the right way of going about it and has he considered the possibility that he might perhaps be trying his hands too much by putting this definition into the legislation rather than making it the subject of regulation?
Comment on this
I think it better to set out as clearly as possible the areas of application. In general I am against the excessive use of regulatory powers. I think the best blend is to set down as clearly as possible what can be done and to retain a certain power to interpret or clarify, which is all I seek under this power. It is arguable whether the British procedure may be marginally more effective, but in general this way is better from an accountability point of view to the Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
The matter of defining what is industrial work and what is not industrial work can be a very important one. Section 13 states that an employer in effect shall not allow a young person, that is a person between 15 and 18, to work at any time between the hours of 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. The Minister has put down amendment No. 46, to which I must refer, which states that this section will not apply to an employee who is employed to do industrial work. We will come to this in due course. Subject to what the Minister will say in due course, it seems to me that this suggests that the 15- to 18-year olds can work through the night if they are in industrial work. I hope that will not be the case. It has some legal effect which we will get to in due course.
Comment on this
The fear expressed by the Senator is not justified because this is covered in later sections of this legislation.
Comment on this
I am happy to hear that. The mere fact of the existence of Government amendment No. 46 shows that there is an importance attached to whether the work is industrial or not. Therefore, this power to declare any form of work to be industrial work for the purposes of this legislation has an importance which is increased by the existence, and I presume in due course the acceptance, of this Ministerial amendment. I accept that legislation of this kind tends to have this type of subsection. One may regret it but one hopes that the Minister will use this power only in very exceptional circumstances.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In subsection (1), page 4, to delete "section 4" in line 36 and substitute "sections 4, 5 and 6."
Section 3 provides that this legislation —other than section 4 which deals with employment of children from 14 to 15 years of age—shall not apply to a fisherman, a lighthouse keeper or seafarer. One can see clearly that these types of employment are such that it would be very difficult, and in many cases impossible, to enforce the various provisions in this Bill for hours of work and so on, but I think the Minister has gone too far. He includes section 4 for these people. That is perfectly all right with its limitations on the employment of children between 14 and 15, but I cannot see why he excludes section 5 which states that any employer who employs a young person or child shall get a birth certificate, the written permission of the parents or guardian, maintain a register giving the name of the person and the amount of work they do, what they get paid and the number of hours. Why should a fisherman not do these things in respect of any child or young person he employs? I cannot see why the Irish Lights authorities should not keep these records and obtain birth certificates and parental permissions. For example, steamship companies keep all kinds of registers and I do not think it would be an additional burden on them. At the very least, the Minister should include section 5 in the provisions of this subsection.
With regard to section 6, I am not given to urging Ministers to take power on themselves but I think in this case we must do so. Section 6 provides that the Minister, after consultation with representatives of employers, in the case of any work which by its nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out is likely to endanger the health, safety or morals of young persons, can by order raise the minimum age at which the young person may be employed in such work. He is specifically taking power from himself to do this in respect of children who are employed by fishermen, lighthouse keepers, lighthouse workers or seafarers. I am not suggesting that there is any obligation on him to take such action in section 6. He may never wish to do so but he should at least keep that power. Why should the Minister say to himself that he is never going to have to make such an order to deal with the health, safety or morals of young people who are employed as seafarers? Even though he may never wish to use it, he should keep the power. Therefore, he should be willing to accept this amendment which would in effect provide that under section 5 birth certificates and parental permission must be kept. This would give him, as Minister, the power, if he ever wished to use it, to safeguard the health, safety and morals of the people concerned.
Comment on this
Generally I feel that the people involved in these areas are engaged in a work pattern which is notably different from the rest of the population and other forms of work, especially work on shore, which is really the division involved here. There would be little point in asking these employers to fulfil the obligation of record-keeping set out in section 5. They have the obligation of complying with section 4 and the minimum age. I consider that the banning of employment under a certain age in these work patterns is an adequate safeguard. The obligation of filling in forms of other details would be inappropriate for these categories. It is for that reason that I am providing that the minimum age will operate here but not the other sections which in consideration of the nature of the work involved, it would be impossible to monitor and to police adequately.
Comment on this
I find this difficult to follow. I am not clear to what extent 14-year-olds are employed as fishermen, in lighthouses and as seafarers, but because the Minister has specifically included section 4 under this head I presume that at least some 14-year-olds must be employed. Otherwise there would be no reason to refer to section 4. If, for example, a 14-year-old has been employed as a seafarer I find it altogether extraordinary that the Minister should say that it is not necessary to have parental permission. I cannot see the obligation to maintain a register in any way as a burden on these people. If their method of doing business is so defective, then the fewer young people they have working for them the better. The very minimum that should be done is to add section 5, particularly in respect of children and young persons. Young persons can be anything from 15 years of age upwards. I know in the case of a 15-year-old it is not necessary to have the permission of parents, although I am doubtful whether that is a good thing. In the Bill as it stands it is not necessary to have permission of the parents except for those under 15 years. At the very least I would have thought that a birth certificate and some kind of register ought to be kept in respect of people as young as 15 years and I do not think it would be a burden on them.
The Minister is right in saying that the work pattern is different. We are talking essentially of certain precautions that ought to be taken in recruitment. Even though the work pattern may be quite different I think that the name, date of birth and other particulars of the young person should be stated and also the wages paid. There cannot be all that many involved. The Minister has said that 65,000 young persons over 15 years are involved in this Bill but the proportion of those involved in the section 3 category must be quite small.
The Minister has not referred to my point about section 6 where he would have power to deal with possible dangers to the health, safety or morals of young persons. He is deliberately excluding himself from dealing with fishermen, lighthouse workers or seafarers whom one might consider would be in more danger in regard to these matters than many other categories. The Minister should include section 5 and certainly he should give himself the power under section 16 to deal with any problems that may arise.
Comment on this
With regard to this section, I should like to consider the situation that arises in rural areas where 14-year-olds may be employed on their parents' farms, or in certain circumstances where parents send their children to neighbours to help out at harvest time or at busy periods. Listening to the debate, one gets the impression that work is being discussed here as if it were necessarily a case of exploitation or of danger. In fact I always regarded these children, these 14-year-olds who had work to do on their parents' farms, as extremely lucky children. I thought they were given a wonderful experience and opportunity to learn something about work to discipline themselves. Indeed I knew children, and had the experience myself, where this work was a greater pleasure than a game of football.
I should like to know if provision has been made here to cover this situation. Often in this city I see 14-year-olds, big, strong, healthy young people bashing windows and kicking walls. If they were given the protection the Minister is seeking to give them, perhaps some of their energy could be channelled into doing something useful during the summer months. I think it would help them to be better citizens and it would make life an awful lot easier for them at a later stage.
The question of payment is another matter. The Minister most definitely in his own good way will look after that but even work without payment is not necessarily exploitation. It could be a very useful channelling of energy. I feel very strongly about this. I would not like the attitude to be adopted in this legislation that work is necessarily something which we must do, just because we have to live. It can be a wonderful thing to teach young people to work; it can be good for them and I think it can help to make life a lot easier for them later on. As I come from a rural area I should like to bring this situation——
Comment on this
The Senator is talking in very broad terms now when one considers section 3.
Comment on this
I realised I was straying from the section but I was coming back to the special situation in rural Ireland. What is the situation where a person sends his child to help a neighbour who has no children? A 14-year-old could find himself in a situation where his parents needed his assistance on the farm or perhaps in the family business. One found that children got a very useful training there. There must be other legislation to prevent cruelty to children and to protect them in these special circumstances but I would not like to see a situation in which work for 14-year-olds was regarded as wrong in all circumstances.
Comment on this
I cannot understand why the Minister does not appear to be willing to agree that section 6 should be included, because it is arguable that the categories that are mentioned in section 3, for one reason or another, might not be brought under section 5. However, they are brought under section 4 in relation to minimum age, and presumably if the minimum age applies at all it should be possible to vary it in the future. I presume that it would be the intention of the Minister, in due course as we progress in regard to the protection of young people, that minimum ages in many areas would increase. Consequently, it is difficult to understand why a certain category of young people are being put in a less advantageous or a less protected position. They should not be put in that position. Consequently, whereas I support the amendment put down by Senator Yeats to include sections 5 and 6, I am particularly anxious to know why the Minister should not at least include section 6.
Comment on this
We had this in the other House as well. I asked Deputies who had ideas about what should be that higher minimum age to state what that year should be. I am not clear whether, in fact, the Senators are suggesting a higher minimum age in these categories. What I do not understand in Senator Yeats' suggestion is why we should seek the inclusion of the keeping of detailed records listing obligations when, in fact, the employers will not have to fulfil those obligations. Why should we ask them to fill in records when, in fact, these will not apply in these cases?
If the Senators are suggesting a higher minimum age I will be glad to hear their suggestions but I think that there has been enough argument about the minimum age. I think it was Senator Markey who talked about the benefits of children working under 14 years. I would like to make it clear that all such work is outlawed under the terms of this legislation here. I am aware that there have been family situations on farms and so on but I am aware of other situations where there has not been trust on both sides and where there has been a strong element of exploitation. I am aware that the provision under this Bill that any such work under 14 years will be totally outlawed will be bad news for many people who have exploited such young people in the past, but I do not know whether Senator Yeats is suggesting that there should be a higher minimum age. I do not wish to have this power of amending by order what should be the minimum age. I prefer to have the debate out here in the House, to come to a decision on it and to put that down in a later section.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister has retained the power to vary the minimum age for all kinds of other categories. He cannot say that he does not want to retain that power, that he wants this House to decide it. The Minister is retaining the power to raise the minimum age for every category of young persons except fishermen, lighthouse keepers, outworkers and seafarers. All that is being suggested here is not that the Bill should be changed at this moment, but merely that the Minister should retain the power in the light of events, of representations made to him, and of the progress we may make in regard to the protection of young persons, to vary the minimum age in years to come.
Comment on this
I am giving consideration to section 6. As I look at it now I do not see the point but I would be ready to give some thought to it on Report Stage. But I really do not see that section 5 is an imposition here.
Comment on this
If a boy of 14 years and nine months seeks employment at the end of the school year in the month of June, working in a catering establishment or public house gathering bottles, washing glasses, or something like that, I take it that his employer will have to obtain a copy of his birth certificate, obtain the written permission of the parents and maintain a register with names, wages and so forth. Three months later, when that boy is 15 years of age, do I take it that he can get a job on a fishing trawler, that he can go out to sea throughout the winter under very dangerous circumstances, work very hard possibly returning in the early hours of the morning and that he can get this employment without having to give his employer who in many cases is the skipper of the trawler, a copy of his birth certificate or, more important, without having to provide the written permission of the parents and that the employer does not have to maintain this very important and useful register? Could the Minister tell me is that the position?
Comment on this
Is the Senator suggesting that fishermen—and he is from a fishing constituency—should be brought under all provisions of this Bill?
Comment on this
Certainly. I think that if, for example, some 14-year-old runs away from home and comes to me for employment I must comply with section 5 of this Bill. On the other hand, if a 15-year-old runs away from home and gets a job on a trawler, a very dangerous occupation as the Minister knows, none of these provisions must be compiled with. I would ask the Minister to have another look at this matter.
Comment on this
If the Senator produces between now and Report Stage an amendment to that effect I will be very glad to look at it.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a simple question. I would like a simple answer without any smart cracks. Does the Minister think it is right in this day and age, 1975, that a child aged 14 should be allowed by his Bill to go off to sea without his parents' permission, without any obligation on his employer to get a birth certificate, to keep any kind of records, any kind of register, any kind of details as far as this Bill is concerned, about his employment? Let us have a candid, straightforward answer. Does he think it right that under his Bill a boy should be able to go off to sea at 14 without his parents' permission?
Comment on this
I was just going to say to Senators that we had this type of argument throughout this Bill. It is one of the strange things in this country that when you try to remove an evil, as soon as the reform measure sees the light of day it is attacked from both sides, those who do not want to see any change in the bad status quo or those who say that it is not good enough, that it must be much better. I understand there is a legitimacy in both points of view, but for the person bringing in legislation after an absence of almost 30 or 40 years of legislation in this area, obviously a start must be made at some point.
I accept that it is not possible, and any reasonable man would accept it is not possible, to meet both points of view. I adhere now to the second point of view. I hope that any reform legislation is as good as it possibly can be, but I do not accept the kind of criticism of a reform measure which hides itself in obscurities. What I am asking the Opposition here now is if they wish this difficult category of workers to be brought under the provisions of this legislation, if they want the fishing fleets to be subject to this legislation. If they do, let them put down an amendment on Report Stage and I will look at it very closely indeed. But I will not be subject to rhetorical questions or requests without a factual basis. If the Opposition are making a request that we include fishermen under the full provisions of this legislation I certainly will look at that very seriously.
Comment on this
I must remind the Minister that he is no longer in Opposition. He is now a responsible Minister of State——
Comment on this
He is coming into this House with legislation dealing with small children and young persons. He must get out of this business of thinking he is still in Opposition. I tell him here and now, and it may save a lot of time later in this discussion, I do not care a hoot what happened 30 years ago. I accept there has been a long gap without legislation. When we were in office, we were at fault. The Minister's own party, when their Leader held the Ministry of Social Welfare on two occasions, and did nothing were also at fault. We were all at fault. Now, having admitted that, let us get on with the business. I do not care what happened 30 years ago. I am dealing with a Bill the Minister is introducing. I am not asking rhetorical questions.
The Minister seems to be under a misunderstanding. On the Second Reading of this Bill, I congratulated him for bringing in this Bill and I meant it. I congratulate him again: I think he has done a good job. But he does not seem to be able to distinguish between an honest effort to improve a Bill, on which I have already congratulated him, and criticism. A couple of months ago I was present at a meeting in Brussels where he told the assembled members of the European Parliament that they would be amazed at the vehemence with which Senator Yeats opposed his efforts to reform social welfare legislation. I regarded this as a half-joking remark and so on and did not take it too seriously. Nonetheless I think it does and did show an element of feeling that a discussion of a Bill of this kind is necessarily an attack. It is not.
Comment on this
It is not. I would put this to the Minister. If, on the Report Stage, I put down an amendment to add, besides the reference to section 4, paragraph (b), subsection (1) of section 5, would he agree to that? All right—leave out the register, though I cannot see why seafarers and so on should not keep registers so that there would be some inkling as to what is happening to the unfortunate children. But if I draft an amendment so that at least the parental permission is needed for 14-year-olds going to sea, will he accept that? That is a simple issue. That is the first point.
The second one is on section 6. The Minister said, as he said in the Dáil, that people were asking him to raise the minimum age and so on and the indications were quite good and the Opposition could make their own suggestions. This is not an issue in this case. If he asked me what I personally think the minimum age should be I would tell him straightaway it should be 15 and I would be happy to vote for any suggestion that nobody should be allowed to work under the age of 15. But that is not an issue. What is an issue in this is that he has, in his own Bill, given himself the power to raise minimum ages. This is not what the Opposition asks him to do at all. This is his own section 6. In order to safeguard the health, safety and morals of young persons, he has taken the power to raise the minimum age. I am merely asking him to give himself the power to do this. He may never wish to exercise it and nobody is forcing him to do anything. I am merely asking if he or his successors ten or fifteen years from now should not be put in the position of having the power to raise the minimum age for seafarers, lighthouse keepers, fishermen and so on. He may never wish to do it but this places no obligation on the Minister or these employers. It merely leaves the door open. I cannot see why the Minister should not agree to that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5.
In subsection (2), page 4, after "sections 4, 5," in line 42 to insert "6, 8.".
This is a similar case, though of less import. It covers the Defence Forces. Here again most of the Act is excluded, and for reasons which one can perfectly understand, but here both sections 4 and 5 are put in. I find this puzzling because the Minister made the point that there was no advantage in keeping registers and so on when they were not covered by the hours of work laid down in the Act but the Defence Forces are, in fact, made keep these registers.
I do not see why the Minister should not have the power to raise the minimum age at which young persons should be permitted to take work in the Defence Forces. He may never wish to do it, and I have no doubt he would wish to consult his colleague, the Minister for Defence, before doing so, but nonetheless I think it would be a good thing to do. I take it that there is no other Act under which this can be done. I would have thought that the Minister in charge of labour affairs should keep the power to do that. I am attempting to add in section 8, which is the one dealing with the employment of young persons under 16, that is those between 15 and 16. The reason is this: in the Defence Forces, quite obviously when they are on Border duty and so on you cannot simply say that the number of hours per day or week or per month will be limited in a certain way. It is not practical.
This section deals with 15-year-olds. I understand the Minister mentioned in the Dáil that the people concerned are Army apprentices. It seems to me that if the Defence Forces run their business with any kind of efficiency they must be able to organise the life of an Army apprentice in some relatively straightforward fashion and it should be possible to lay down that a 15-year-old who is an Army apprentice will work for a certain number of hours a day. I do not see why they should ever be excluded from the provisions of section 8 which would say that an Army apprentice aged 15 or up to 16 could not work for more than nine hours in any day or 40 hours in any week. I think this is an eminently reasonable—perhaps even too wide—latitude given to them and I would suggest therefore that section 8 and section 6 should be added to the number listed already in subsection (2) of this section.
Comment on this
I would be prepared to consider the inclusion of section 8 but section 6 would, I think, present certain difficulties. I will have a look at it for Report Stage but I cannot say at this point. I could accept section 8, anyway.
Comment on this
I am not that worried about section 6, because after all it is open to the Minister for Defence to lay down rules for employing his apprentices, but I would hope that the Minister would add in section 8 which would be an encouragement to those in authority not to overwork them.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us what his intentions are on subsection 3, where he says he may by order extend any provision of this Act to any work to which this Act does not apply. I am not clear what is intended there.
Comment on this
I do not have any specific area in mind at present but I thought it a useful power to have. I have made it clear in relation to this legislation that I am anxious to see how it works in practice and then bring in any further changes that may be necessary by affirmative order. We are in the difficulty that we do not know the extent of youth employment. We may all have from our particular interest area an idea of its extent but I sense it is an area which has been neglected for quite some time and it will take us some time to discover—and I would hope the record section of this legislation will help us—the extent of it, the categories of age groups involved, the income groups involved, the kind of work that is done in the majority of cases. With that kind of information and experience I would hope to come back to both Houses shortly with affirmative orders bringing in further improvements in this legislation. In its passage through both Houses many points have been made by Deputies from the various interests in their constituencies. The very appearance of this Bill has evoked a certain amount of public interest in the area. I have been approached by all manners of organisations with their ideas on what should be done. Provisions such as this give me the possibility of adding to it in the way I have mentioned here. At present I do not have any specific action in mind.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear about the Minister's point. The subsection says the Minister may by order extend any provision of this Act to any work to which this Act does not apply. The question is: to what work does the Act not apply. It seems to be that the only things listed are (a), (b), (c) and (d) under subsection (1) of this section. Is it to these he is referring or is there some other kind of work that the Act does not cover? It seems to me that since this section says that this Act shall not apply to work as (a), (b), (c), (d), fishermen and so on, then every other kind of work must be covered. Therefore, the only people that could be covered by subsection (3) are these four classes. Perhaps I am wrong but I would be interested to know.
Comment on this
Could it apply to anything else? That is what puzzles me. As I understand it, the Bill says that these four are excluded and unless I am wrong this means that everything else is included. Therefore, all subsection (3) does is to give the Minister power which, indeed, I hope he would use as soon as possible, to cut down these four items. Is that all it does?
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 6, 8, 9 and 10 are related. Amendment No. 7 is consequential on amendment No. 9. Accordingly, is is suggested that all of these amendments should be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
To delete subsections (2) and (3).
In moving the deletion of subsections (2) and (3) of section 4 I can do no more than repeat some of the remarks I made during the Second Stage of this Bill, and principally, the fact that the trade union movement, out of its vast experience of these matters, is totally opposed to the employment of children during the school terms. That opposition is based on the contention supported by many educationalists and others that such work in most cases is harmful to the health or the normal development of the child. In most cases it will affect the attendance of the child at school or his capacity to benefit from the instruction given.
There is, of course, the serious possibility of moral danger and the absolute certainty of exploitation of some children by some employers. In this connection may I quote from the report of a survey conducted by eight local teachers into part-time working by school children in two towns in this country? The report was published in The Irish Times of April 5th, 1975. It begins by saying that large-scale exploitation of post-primary school children in part-time jobs is taking place.
It goes on to say:
The survey, which was carried out by eight local teachers, calls for the total ban on part-time employment of post-primary pupils of 15 years or over during school term.
It expresses dissatisfaction with this Bill which it describes as "inadequate" and recommends parents to take greater care because of the adverse effects of part-time employment of their children. It continues:
The number of pupils who filled in the questionnaire was 1,930, of which 354 were working part-time and were earning, on average, less than 50p an hour. Four examples encountered showed a pupil of 15 years working 41½ hours for £4.50; a 14-year-old working 18 hours for £1.60; a 13-year-old working 29 hours for £2.75 and a 12-year-old working 18 hours for £1.74.
Further on, the report states:
The Committee held discussions with a local union.
And the report continues:
The latter are greatly perturbed at the extensive use of pupils in shops and requested the Committee to do all it could to bring it to an end. Apart from contributing to the current unemployment level pupils engaged in part-time employment damage their own chances of full-time employment in that they themselves are replaced by other pupils.
I take the point the Minister made a short while ago that at the moment there are, and for many years past and indeed at the time this survey was carried out, there were no legal regulations at all about this important matter. The Minister is to be complimented on introducing this Bill which does introduce some measure of control.
For instance, young people are confined to working two hours in any one day during the school term. This is a tremendous improvement on the present situation but I would suggest to the Minister that it would be quite impossible to implement this provision. Even with an army of inspectors I do not think it could be implemented. I would ask the Minister to give further consideration to withdrawing these two subsections. If he finds himself unable to do that, he should make some provision to ensure that, if within a period of six months or nine months it is evident that the Bill is not working out in that there is tremendous continuing exploitation of young people or that work during school term is shown to be having an adverse effect on the pupils' capacity to learn or to attend classes, then he should amend the Bill deleting these two sections.
Comment on this
I must say at the outset that I sympathise very much both with what Senator Kennedy has said and with what I believe is an honest and serious attempt by the Minister to come to grips with this problem of age of employment. I hope the Minister will bear with me a while on this point. It is a point that one cannot really go into too often, if only for the sake of awakening public opinion to this very important issue.
It seems to me that there are two basic questions involved. I take it that on this series of amendments we are talking exclusively about children who are still under the compulsory school leaving age. First of all, there is the question of whether such children should be allowed to work at all at any time. Secondly, there is the question of whether, if we allow these children to work, when should we allow them to work, what kind of differentiation are we going to make between the way in which they work and the times at which they work. We have to decide further whether they should be allowed to work during term time at all or whether we can simply make a differentiation between the amount of time they work during term time and the amount of time they work during holidays.
The Minister has made on several occasions what I think is a very valid point, that to a certain extent we all work in the dark. There are no statistics on which he can base legislation of this kind. He has to approach it to a certain extent intuitively, basing his proposals on individual case histories, on his general "feel" of the situation and on his general "feel" of what needs to be done. The Bill before us is in many respects an honest and serious attempt to come to grips with that question.
The survey of which Senator Kennedy spoke is one of the first pieces of scientific evidence in this field that we have. It can be called scientific as it is being carried out very rigorously and is being very carefully monitored. Some of the statistics from the report itself which were not mentioned in the newspaper report to which Senator Kennedy referred, are, I believe, even more alarming. For example, there is a table in the report in relation to the range of hours worked by 14-year-olds. In this table reference is made to the total number of 14-year-olds working, which is 116. If you look at the histogram for the number of hours worked by these 14-year-olds you will see that fewer than half of them worked for a number of hours lower than the maximum envisaged in this Bill. In other words, more than 50 per cent of them were working for a number of hours partially or substantially in excess of the maximum which would be allowed under this Bill. Two of the 116 were actually working between 40 and 50 hours every week. Again, we notice that the average number of hours worked by all 14-year-olds was 14.7. In other words, even the average was above the maximum which would be permitted by this new legislation. The report further notes that the average number of hours worked by 14-year-olds is significantly greater than that for pupils as a whole. The average for 14-year-olds is, as I said, 14.7 hours. The average for all the pupils is 13 hours. This indicates to my mind that the 14-year-olds are the category of pupils who are most open to this kind of exploitation.
This Bill, even if it were passed in its present form without any amendment, could not but improve this state of affairs. In some cases I would hope that it would improve it dramatically or at least in the cases for example, of these two 14-year-olds who were working between 40 and 50 hours a week, nine 14-year-olds who were working between 30 and 40 hours a week and 13 14-year-olds who were working between 20 and 30 hours a week. If this Bill is to mean anything, and I hope it will, it will catch the exploiters of these children and deal with them as they should be dealt with.
What I would ask the Minister is whether, in the light of the factual and statistical information from this fairly substantial survey which has become available since the Bill was introduced—in fact, since his Second Reading speech in this House—he will now consider again sympathetically the appeal that is being made to put a total ban on the employment of children under the compulsory school leaving age at least during the period of term time.
The economic aspect mentioned by Senator Kennedy is one I would also like to stress. This report calculated simply by totting up the hours worked by these young people, that in one supermarket alone in the town of Drogheda the equivalent of 14 full-time adult jobs were being lost as a direct result of this exploitation of child labour. There are multitudinous aspects of this. As a result of the exploitation of children, 14 adults in Drogheda have not full-time well-paid jobs and are unable to support their families. If they were employed presumably they would not be leaning on the State for unemployment benefit and other forms of assistance.
This new evidence seems to be enormously strong. I ask the Minister to consider it. I have no doubt he has seen it already. We would be very grateful for his views on this evidence and on whether, in his mind, it changes the situation with which he and we are dealing in this Bill.
There is another point with regard to the employment of children under the school-leaving age which I feel I should bring to the attention of the Minister and the House. In Britain, where there is a parallel legislation relating to the employment of young people, there are marginal differences between age limits, hours and so on, which I do not propose to go into in any great detail. But there is one substantial difference between Britain and here which is to our disadvantage. In Britain, a Secretary of State makes regulations about the kind of employment that can be taken by young people, at what kind of age and subject to what kind of conditions. There is also a wide-ranging and comprehensive network of local education authorities. Under the relevant British legislation these local education authorities have substantial supervisory power with regard to these regulations, how they are being observed and so on. In fact the local education authority there has power to make its own regulations and to require employers to conform to these regulations, subject to fairly substantial penalties for breach. Presumably it does so in order to safeguard the educational welfare of these children.
We have no education authorities here who could operate this kind of supervisory role in relation to children of compulsory schoolgoing age who are in employment. I tried to think of ways of introducing amendments into this Bill which would give persons involved in the education of these children some kind of responsibility and power in regard to supervising any work these children may be doing. I found it totally impossible to do so because our education system is so fragmented and has so many different foci of responsibility.
The Bill before us goes as far as any Bill can go in its attempt to make sure that what must be done will be done. There is this huge lacuna. It is very much a Bill which operates from a central government authority. In trying to fight the situation we are hampered by the lack of something which is provided in Britain: the input from the local education authority who know the circumstances, who know the people and are aware of the injustices and dangers, is missing. The Minister is fighting with one arm tied behind his back. Because this second arm of enforcement is missing, I would again make a strong case, especially for these children under the age of 15. In the light of the evidence available to us in this survey, the Minister should think again.
Comment on this
I support what Senator Kennedy said on this matter and, indeed, all Senator Horgan said. The important thing to bear in mind is that none of us knows all about everything and some of us know a lot about some things and less about others. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions is flatly opposed to the employment of children under school-leaving age. I recognise also that this is a real effort on the part of the Minister to do something that has been neglected for a long time. Might I ask the House to consider why we arrange for children to have school holidays? Surely it is not to put them to work.
My understanding is that men and women at work try to have their holidays with their children. I submit that this section is not capable of being put into operation, because we would need an army of inspectors to put it into operation for a small number of school-going children, taking into consideration the need for inspectors in other areas. I am sure the Minister and his advisers are aware of the existence of joint labour committees under the aegis of the Labour Court. These joint labour committees provide for minimum wages and working conditions for all types of people. There is nothing like that suggested in this section of the Bill. The recommendations of the joint labour committees are legally enforceable. They do not contain Shangri-la for working people. As a matter of fact, in trade union circles we regard them as the starting points from which we can improve. The Minister should look at the various joint labour committee recommendations particularly those affecting messenger boys. The entire Executive of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions are opposed to this section. They want to delete it. They consider this matter could be tackled by ministerial order, if the Minister so wishes, provided of course that he guarantees there will be an advisory committee, sufficiently representative, to properly advise on matters of this kind.
I am not attempting to enter into a controversy about this section but I believe this: no matter what one's politics are, there is a certain amount of credit given to the Irish Congress of Trade Unions for knowing working class needs. Within the confines of congress there are all shades of political thought. I urge the Minister to give serious consideration to the proposals made by Senator Kennedy and myself on behalf of congress that this section be deleted.
Comment on this
I thank Senators for their contributions on this very important section. Senator Horgan is right in saying that there is a great deal of ignorance about the exact extent of exploitation. I, too, commend the authors of the Drogheda report. I am glad to think that this had some part to play in the motivation of those who undertook that very valuable survey.
Senator Kennedy and Senator Mullen referred to the enforcing of certain sections of this legislation. Undoubtedly, in enforcing any section of this legislation I would be the last to pretend that the inspectors available to me—though I did, in fact, increase their numbers in the last year by 50 per cent—even with round-the-clock surveillance, would be able to enforce every section of this Bill. This Bill cannot operate without the support of the community, of the trade unions, of the employers or without genuine community assent. That is what I have been attempting to achieve in selecting a point of commencement. This is something which our community, on all sides, has neglected to attend to for too long. There has been no public controversy on youth employment; that has been a neglected area. Now there is a welcome interest in the subject. But at what point does legislation take effect?
The worst cases of exploitation referred to in the Drogheda Survey will have to end the day after the President signs this Bill. The information provided in that survey will have the early attention of the inspectorate of my Department. That area is well-chronicled and we can inform the employers of Drogheda that the days of exploitation will be over with the enactment of this legislation. I do not wish to single out any particular area because there are cases of exploitation of young persons all over the country. I am sure the employers of Drogheda are as good as employers anywhere else. There is no greater concentration of unscrupulous people in Drogheda than anywhere else; the same average mix exists there as anywhere else in the country. Because our community have ignored this area of employment for too long, certain unwelcome practices have grown up and are widely prevalent.
At what age should the Bill commence to take effect? There are those who say that the age of 14 years chosen by me is unreal, that a lower age should be specified. Others say the school leaving age should be the age of commencement. I believe that the mixture chosen in this legislation, which is to outlaw all work by young people under the age of 14 years and to control the period of hours of work between the ages of 14 and 15 years, both in the school term and during school holidays, is the best possible point of commencement. Enforcement will need the support of the community and the inspectorate. As Senator Hogan pointed out, the British local education committees have a role to play. There is no such provision in this legislation which I hope will be supported by the community in general.
I stated in the Dáil that I intend to set up a committee to monitor the progress of this legislation and to report in a matter of months how the terms of this legislation are taking effect and where omissions are occurring. We have not a great deal of information at our disposal to give us a reliable picture of the national position. There have been some isolated surveys, such as that carried out in Drogheda, but an equally alarming situation could occur in any town or district without our knowledge. Therefore it is necessary to have a committee representative of educational, trade union and youth worker interests so that we can accumulate reliable information on this subject. This committee would report back to me relatively quickly on amendments or certain improvements required to this legislation. I have already announced my intention of calling a conference in Dublin of interested parties to discuss youth employment. If we are honest with ourselves, we must admit that, apart from guesswork or uninformed opinion of what may be happening in a particular area, we are ignorant of the actual situation existing around the country.
The Bill will provide much-needed information. We will have evidence of age and we will have the written permission of parents. The Bill will be more effective in remedying undesirable situations if it commences, as we suggest, at the cut-off point of 14 years of age, with a controlled period between 14 and 15 years. We think this is the best way to obtain community support for the Bill, which is so necessary if the provisions of the Bill are to be effective. There is no point in choosing an age point which may not have general consent. It might have support from one side and attract the opposition of another section. I have received representations from people well acquainted with problems of youth employment in both town and country. There is a vast difference in the employment pattern of young people in town and country. They told me that the provisions for prohibiting employment of children under 14 years of age are unrealistic and unworkable and will not gain acceptance. These are not the opinions of reactionaries. They are the opinions of people who believe that the situation is bad and the best remedy would be to begin at a more modest age group, understanding, as they do, the many problems arising in urban areas, especially in Dublin.
Having studied various opinions and representations from many sources, I believe the provisions in this legislation are the best possible to enable this Bill to be effective. There were no great differences expressed here as to what was desirable for our young people but there may be a difference in deciding what is the best commencement point for legislation of this kind.
I hope to be back very shortly to both Houses of the Oireachtas with affirmative orders making the changes sought by Senators to have the age set at 15 years—the age at which in my opinion it should be settled. I also hope to raise it to this age as soon as we assess all the information about conditions which the Bill is designed to unearth. If this legislation is passed it will be in operation during the summer, the worst months for exploitation of youth in employment. I have brought in an amendment ensuring that over those summer months there will be a period which will be completely excluded.
I hope therefore that in thanking Senators for their contributions they will understand the approach I have adopted to this legislation. I respect the views of Senators Mullen and Kennedy. As representatives of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions they are in a good position to know exactly the kind of exploitation that has been going on in years past. I perfectly understand why, with that knowledge, they should seek for a higher age. I hope there will be recognition of the fact that it is equally important to choose a point of beginning for this legislation and then work up towards a situation which is even more perfect than the age we have chosen. I believe that the answer to much of the exploitation of the lowly-paid and the young in particular, lies in an extension of the joint labour committee system to shops and restaurants. In another area I have spoken about my intention, with the co-operation of the unions, to seek extensions of the joint labour committees in these directions.
Comment on this
On a point of order, a Leas-Chathaoirleach, as I understand it, we are taking amendments Nos. 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 together. I take it the Minister has now moved No. 8 in which case my amendment No. 10 would seem to be——
Comment on this
No, we are discussing them together. They will be moved separately.
Comment on this
Is there some kind of priority to move one's own amendment?
Comment on this
When amendment No. 6 has been moved, there was agreement that a discussion take place but we can have separate decisions.
Comment on this
I am using the wrong technical term. Is it not normal that if somebody has an amendment down he should be allowed speak on it? I have not yet been able to speak on my own amendment. I am wholly in favour of Senator Mullen's amendment. To my mind, in principle, it is a ridiculous situation where the State declares that no child shall leave school until the age of 15 and then allows him under that age to continue working. If we take education seriously, or are serious when we say that children will remain from 14 to 15 at school in full-time education and get the best possible benefit from that education, then it would be impossible to achieve that aim if the child could work two hours after school. Perhaps he left home for school at 8 o'clock in the morning, came home at 4 o'clock in the afternoon and had his dinner. Then he went to work in the local supermarket, when he should have been resting or doing his school work.
Senator Mullen knows better than I that one of the great problems with education in Ireland is at university level. Only about 2 per cent of students at university come from the working class, or trade union circles. This is not so much a matter of income, because often a skilled worker will have a higher income than, say, a minor bank clerk. The bank clerk will traditionally send his children to university but the plumber or carpenter traditionally will not. One of the reasons, obviously, is that the whole educational process is taken more seriously in one case than the other; there is a more learned background in one case than in the other.
If there is a tradition of a child going out to work at a very early age when he should be engaged in full-time education, inevitably education stops at a certain point. Even when it does continue, it is less satisfactory than it ought to be. I would be completely in favour of the amendment by Senator Kennedy and Senator Mullen. I am not sure that it is framed in the right manner from a technical point of view, but its contention is that no one under the age of 15 years should be able to work. My amendment does not go nearly as far. I confined myself to saying that no child should be able to work during a school day. I am not particularly enamoured of the idea that a child at school, aged 14, would be able to work for four hours on Saturday and four hours on Sunday, and during school holidays. I proposed this because, as the Minister said, there is an economic problem involved. There is a tradition that at a certain age children will be able to go to work. In families with a very low income the money brought in, even though it may be small, is very valuable and it would be difficult to do without it. As the Minister has rightly said, there have been suggestions from surprising sources that the age for children to go to work should be 12.
There is the problem. It would be difficult to obtain general approval for a suggestion that all work by children under 15 would be banned. Personally I would be in favour of making the attempt and banning it altogether. I have framed my amendment as a compromise so that, at least during the hours of day when school is taking place, no child under 15 would be allowed to work.
Of the three non-ministerial amendments before us, I prefer Senator Mullen's after that Senator Horgan's who would allow them to work during the school holiday but not during term, and only then my own amendment which, as I said, is a compromise. The Minister's amendment is in two ways an advance on the Bill as it stands. It provides that on Saturdays and Sundays the child can work for approximately two hours a day only. It also provides him with a fortnight's holidays in the summer from any work. All this is obviously a limited advance only because the 14 hours a week permitted during school term is still there and the two hours a day while school is on is still included in the Bill. While the Minister's amendment is certainly a minor improvement, I would urge him to take the bit between his teeth and eliminate this action altogether, as was suggested by Senator Mullen and Senator Kennedy.
While initially the Minister might have to face considerable opposition from a number of quarters, in the long run he would gain a considerable amount of kudos for something which would be accepted very rapidly as a very useful forward step. The concept that a child who was still compulsorily at school, and under the school leaving age, was allowed to work, would be looked upon in most countries as a retrograde attitude. I would urge the Minister to accept the proposition that no child under 15 should be allowed to work.
I hope the Minister's amendment is not passed. The last sentence reads: "Provided that during the period of the school summer holidays, the child does not do any work for a period of not less than fourteen consecutive days" is a most unfelicitous phrase. I worked at this for some time and was unable to get any meaning out of it. Only when I came back to Ireland and found some people whose command of the English language was greater than mine did I find out what it really did mean. It seems to me that it could be rephrased in a way which would do less violence to the English language. I will do my best to do something with it on Report Stage. At the moment the succession of double negatives is mind-boggling in complexity.
Comment on this
I understand that we are discussing section 4, amendment No. 6. Senator Yeats has complained about the wording of the amendments submitted by Senator Kennedy and me. We are arguing for a deletion of a subsection.
I think it is important to put this on the line. Senator Yeats made a comparison between trade craftsmen and minor bank clerks. I think he is all wrong. There is a great need to emancipate the craftsmen here because they are not being paid anything like what a bank clerk is being paid.
Comment on this
I want to make the point that I have been trying to express the views of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. For the Minister's benefit, let him understand clearly and distinctly we are not hung up on the age of 15. We have no hang-up about that age. We are quite prepared to accept the age of 14, providing of course that there is some real way of regulating this whole process. This is why we suggested that there should be a ministerial order. With due respect to the Minister, what he said was that he would have what to me conveys a watching committee. We have far too many of these committees without any real result. I think that the best way of doing it is in the light of all our experience. Again, I go back to the joint labour committee for formulating wages and working conditions in the hope that they would be enforced. We have found that it is almost impossible to enforce them. I would suggest to the Minister that he bear that in mind and think in terms of having a committee working in conjunction with the power which he can obtain through ministerial order. Then this job can be properly tackled.
The Minister is on record, he used the expression here when he was dealing with this amendment, as making a point about exploitation. The Minister has very rightly taken time to refer several times to exploitation and the difficulty experienced by his Department in doing away with exploitation. Let us not add to the load. I again say to the Minister that he should take lessons from our experience of minimum wages and conditions and have regard to this in particular. This is not out of disrespect to the Minister's advisers, I would describe them as being attritions. We will have to have regard to practical experience. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions, when considering the Bill, did not consider it lightly. They had regard to experience.
I would earnestly entreat the Minister to do what has been advocated in this amendment and delete the subsections. In place of them he can make his ministerial orders and set up his committees and have them working. There are oodles of joint labour committees in existence and there are many complaints in existence about their inability to enforce their regulations. They provide for minimum rates of pay and working conditions which are described as being legally enforceable, but it is almost impossible to do that. I am not saying that every employer is an exploiter. One would want to be up all night watching the people who set out to take advantage of young people.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the frank way in which the Minister has approached those amendments. We learned a number of important things from him—for example, his personal conviction that the cut-off age should be at least 15 years, and his undertakings, or proposals at any rate, with regard to the monitoring of the progress of this legislation. When he was speaking about the need to have a general consensus working behind this legislation, or any legislation of this kind, there was a whole grey area that he to a certain extent and all of us have been treading rather delicately around.
We have had representations in the course of this debate and even outside these Houses from two very substantial interests connected with this Bill, from the trade unions on the one hand and from educational interests on the other. Both these interest groups, for different, equally valid reasons, have expressed themselves alarmed by the continuation or even regulating employment for 14-, 15- and 16-year-olds. The one group of people we have not heard from are the people most directly concerned themselves, the children and their parents.
I am not saying that children like being exploited or that parents like their children to be exploited, but it is a hard and bitter fact of life for many of these children and for many of their parents that without these earnings, pitiful and miserable though they may be, those families would be in a very much worse off state than they are at the moment. I say this with a very heavy heart because it is not a situation that anybody should be proud of. We have learned a lot since the days when free education was introduced. We have learned a lot about the costs of education. We have learned a lot about the fact that the real cost of education is not simply a matter of fees paid to a school manager. It is also a matter of the cost of what that child would have been bringing in to his household were he to start working at the age of 15 instead of staying on at school. This can be critical, not just for the children but for their parents.
It is not just a question of children allowing themselves to be exploited in order to earn pin money and drink pints with it, if, indeed, today they are drinking pints at the age of 15. It is a question of providing something, however pitiful and miserable, to help balance the family budget. It was a very great tragedy that at the time when the free education scheme was introduced it was not accompanied by some form of income supplement for the less well-off families to enable them to take advantage of the educational opportunities then being offered but which were kept from them by their poverty—not by their alleged class attitudes to education but by their inability to forgo the income they would receive by going out to work instead of staying at school. It is a particular irony that many of the children who are out earning money in this part-time fashion and in this way are doing it precisely in order to be able to stay at school; and yet it happens time and time again that their money-earning activities, the ways in which they are occasionally being exploited by employers, conspire together to rob them of so much of the benefit that they can get from that education.
These points must be firmly stated and must be eventually faced up to. When I spoke on my amendment earlier I described the Minister as attempting to fight this problem with one arm tied behind his back because while he had the central regulatory authority he had no local supervisory authority. Looking at it again I would say that he is trying to fight it with two hands tied behind his back because not only does he lack this local supervisory authority but he lacks, as far as I know, the power or the statutory authority to give to the lower income families the kind of financial assistance that would enable this form of exploitation to be brougth to an end and allow these children to continue on at school.
It is often said by people who should know better that the only reason children of a certain social stratum do not continue on at school is because they lack the social attitude towards education which would encourage them to participate in education beyond the minimum school leaving age. I would say to these people: "If that is what you believe then offer these families money, offer them the difference between the net total family income for the child going to school and the child going to work, because if as you say it is true that their class attitudes alone are preventing them from continuing in education, then you will save your money. The children will not take advantage of it, they will go out to work anyway." But this is a risk that many social planners are unwilling to take. They are unwilling to put up the money because they know in their heart of hearts that the real obstacle for many of these children and for their parents is financial.
It is on the existence of this obstacle that employers are capitalising and that children, families and parents are being crucified. I cannot make this point too strongly. I have been encouraged by the Minister's response to the amendment and would merely ask him to take these points into consideration when he is instructing any committee and furthermore to press on his partners in Government, especially on the Ministers for Finance and Social Welfare, the absolute need for approaching this problem on a broad front. He will not end the problem of exploitation of child labour by this kind of legislation alone. It will have to be ended, among other things, by increased emphasis on the educational side and the social welfare side to make it unnecessary for these children to allow themselves to be exploited in this way.
If he is appointing a committee, as I hope he will, I would urge him to have them report, as he suggested, in a very short period of time. I would also urge him to give them the resources necessary, also under a very sharp time guillotine, to provide the maximum amount of information in the shortest possible time so that any amending legislation or regulations can be brought in with a minimum of delay. That, I would hope, would be by full community consensus based on facts. We will never get all the facts but in a short time with a reasonable amount of money we ought to get enough facts to awaken the public conscience to help to end this misery.
Comment on this
There is just one dimension I should like to add to this discussion. Looking at section 4 and at the amendments put down to it, I must say I tended to support the section as it stands in the Bill. Since I have come in and heard the very sincere and, indeed, impassioned views of Senator Mullen on the matter, I have perhaps changed my ground a little. There is one point that I would put forward for the Minister's consideration. The emphasis in the Bill seems to me to derive very strongly from an urban milieu, an area where exploitation of children obviously takes place. I accept Senator Mullen's view that it does, and it apparently takes place to a far greater degree than I realised.
On the other hand, I come from a rural area. The emphasis on children working there was not the emphasis on workers' exploitation at all. It was work very often as adventure and as a means of moral edification. It was constantly believed, and it is still believed in rural areas, that the really responsible parents are those who see that their children are not idle for a great deal of the day and who do not have the economic incentives and necessities that Senator Horgan spoke of. Very often they are quite well-to-do parents who think it is a very good thing for their children to go to a neighbouring farm and work for a few hours and maybe collect a few bob at the end of the day.
Comment on this
Not during school term, during holidays, very often on a summer's evening after a day's work in the meadow when their hay is there and so forth—by no means during school hours. That would be regarded as deliquent even in the society to which I was referring.
Comment on this
So as not to delay the thing, let me proceed to my point which is a very simple and perhaps old-fashioned one. Within that framework, work was not seen primarily as exploitation at all but, from the point of view of the child, very often adventure, the chance to make a little money on the side. It was often open-air work which in no way could be injurious. It was, in fact, character building and health building too. On the other hand, the parents saw it not merely as a means of getting money but of seeing that the child was kept out of mischief. That is certainly part of the ethos of rural Ireland. I am not sure how familiar the Minister is with this ethos. He is a very learned man in every other respect and perhaps in this too.
It is a dimension to the problem and I wonder whether legislation quite as Draconian as is being suggested in some of the amendments would not do a good deal of harm in that direction. I would counsel moderation in the matter—the balance of one thing against another. For instance, I have just come back from America and the attitude there towards work would be almost radically different. It is regarded as a good thing, even in quite affluent middle-class homes, for a young fellow to distribute newspapers in his spare time, to learn what work is, to be industrious and not to spend all his spare time idle—in other words, work off his animal energies and develop the qualities of ambition and perhaps the puritan respect for work at an early age and so forth. What I am suggesting is that work seen, merely in a negative way, as exploitation and so forth is perhaps too narrow a way of looking at work from the viewpoint of the argument in relation to this subsection.
Comment on this
First of all, one ought to recommend Senator Martin to the amendment by Senator Horgan which meets his requirements. I can assure Senator Martin with regard to this Bill that the provision in section 4, not amended by the Minister's amendment, is that on each day on which school takes place a child may work for two hours. I, and many of us, think this is wrong. I am happy to hear Senator Martin thinks it is wrong. But, it is in the Bill.
Comment on this
I did not say I thought that was wrong. I think during school hours would be wrong. But on a long summer's evening, two hours in the meadow I would not regard as wrong at all.
Comment on this
Or a short winter evening when it gets dark at 4 o'clock. That is the scale that is in the Bill, unfortunately. These romantic rural meadows on a long summer's day with the sun shining are very nice and I would be the last to wish that a child would not be able to work on his parents' farm and, indeed, obviously one would encourage this. What we are dealing with here, this applies in rural and urban Ireland, is a poor family who need the money and little Johnny aged 14 goes down to the local pub and washes the glasses and collects them in the lounge bar, or little Joey goes down and takes in the money at the local supermarket, or more likely he fills paper bags at the checkout. That is what we are dealing with. We are not dealing with romantic sunny evenings in the hay-meadow.
Comment on this
As Senator Ryan points out, under a contract of service. We are not dealing with the odd shilling that a young man gets from the local farmer. I think it is highly unlikely that they should be covered by any section of this Bill. We are dealing with an actual contract of service as a commercial proposition—the kind of work usually in dreary buildings, which has little inspiration behind it and does nothing for anyone except bring in a few pence into the family.
There have been certain suggestions, and by the Minister himself if I understand him right, that by some means he may be able in due course to achieve his end—and I am happy to hear he has it—of raising this age of 14 to 15 by some sort of ministerial order. My interpretation of this section and of the Bill is that there is no provision anywhere in it for the Minister, by order or any other means, to raise the age from 14 to 15. He can vary the hours of work and so on but he cannot raise the age to 15. To do this he has to come back again with a new Bill. I think I am right in my interpretation of this Bill. So no matter how many committees and so on he sets up, he cannot by ministerial order amend this Bill in this sense. If the age goes out from us at 15, that is where it will remain until new legislation. In 1975 we should send the Bill out from this House with the age of 15, or at the very least some such suggestion as Senator Horgan has made that there would be work in the school holidays but not during the school term. We must decide once and for all whether we are going to take education seriously and whether we can take seriously the step that has been taken in recent years to raise the school leaving age from 14 to 15.
One can exaggerate the financial element here. Clearly, there are families who would be at a loss if they were unable to send out their children under 15. It is a postponement of only 12 months. Little Johnny is 14 in 12 months he will be 15, and under the other sections of this Bill, with which we are not quarrelling, he will then be able to work. The worst that can happen to any family is that between 14 and 15 there will be this relatively short period during which this extra income will not come in. Undoubtedly it would be important to some families, but I think its importance can be exaggerated with regard to many.
I am not suggesting for one moment that there is any real valid comparison that one can make, but I think it is worthwhile pointing out that way back in the nineteenth century, when there were suggestions made that little children should not be sent up chimneys to sweep them, the argument against making a change was that the families needed the money. I am not making any comparison with social thinking then and now, but the same kind of argument is being used in very different circumstances. There are things that clearly should be done.
The Minister agrees, and there is hardly a Senator who as regards school days does not agree, that it is better for the child not to work when school is on. The only problem the people are raising is—and I can understand it—that certain families need the money and that this would lead to hardship. However, the time has come when we have got to say "Well we regret this". In so far as there may be hardship, and I think it will be very limited, the State should try and step in to deal with it. We cannot undermine the whole educational process of 14-year-olds for such reasons. Therefore we should accept once and for all that at least during a school day a child is not entitled to go out under a contract of service.
Comment on this
I should like to emphasise that every contract of service is covered under this legislation. The child under 14 goes out and does one hour's work and gets paid £1 for it, that is totally excluded. Anybody who talks about the age 15 as being the age to be brought in here is talking about that kind of situation. The amendment, which I accepted in principle from Senator Mullen earlier this afternoon and which we will draft for Report Stage, will further copperfasten that exclusion under the age of 14 in the Bill as it is here. If the age were 15, all such acts would also be outlawed under this legislation.
Certain Senators give me the impression that they imagine it has to be a continuous working week before it comes under the provisions of this legislation. Theoretically, if you asked a child to get a bag of sweets for you and if he is under the age of 14 and there is a reward, it is covered. My instinct in that situation is that when you have a social evil neglected over many years I am sceptical of the efficacy of advance in that area by taking a kind of universal age like 15 after so many years of neglect and saying that all under that age is outlawed, excluded.
That is my impression of the situation and it is the impression of many I have listened to. Some Senators, particularly Senator Horgan, said that the people really affected are the people doing the work. They are not here naturally: we have not yet got to an age of 14 or 15 for Senators in this country, though probably that will come.
I have received many letters from children telling me that they think this legislation is completely mistaken. That is true. These were not dictated notes. I am as good as the next at realising when a note is dictated by some employer anxious to have some child write to me conveying some sort of information that I might not care to receive. Any letter I have received from children on this legislation have been uniformally against. That may not be a scientific sample of the children of the country. It may be a very biased sample but I want for the records to put it that way.
Comment on this
I make the qualification that this is not a scientific sample of all children in the country. It may be only a selection of a particular grouping of children. I would say that all of the notes I have received from children have been against the legislation as proposed.
We have to take an age that is in the circumstances realistic. That is what I have been attempting to do in the age chosen here. By outlawing it under the age of 14 and confining it with certain safeguards between the ages of 14 and 15, I think we are in a position to see this legislation will gain the necessary support essential for its success. There is no difference between us in our desire to see 15 as the age below which we would not wish to see children in employment. I do not think there is anyone here against such a situation coming about, a situation which does not exist at present. As evidence of my goodwill in that direction and my acceptance of that desirable outcome—Senator Yeats is right in saying that the legislation as drafted would require new amendments—I have indicated my willingness to come back here in what I hope will be a relatively short time to bring in the change that 15 would be the age, even in controlled conditions, to work under contracts of service. What I would suggest is that I will come back on Report Stage and I will be ready to put forward a new subsection giving me power by affirmative resolution to delete the provisions regarding 14- to 15-year-olds working, that I would have that power by affirmative order under the legislation to bring in that change when conditions warrant it.
We are working in an area where there is little information available to us on which we can reliably see the full picture. I have indicated that I would like to see this representative committee in operation, this committee representing educationists, trade unionists and youth workers. If in our experience of the working of the legislation we see it is possible to proceed earlier than I now see, then I want to see our legislation in itself constituting no bar to that welcome development.
I will withdraw my own amendment here and on Report Stage I will come back with a new subsection giving me that power—the power to delete the provisions regarding 14- and 15-year-olds working. At that stage we will have a legislation which will bring in a total ban on those under the age of 15. As legislators we would not be acting responsibly in the existing situation which has existed for so long, in moving directly without adducing all the evidence, collecting it and getting the full picture. None of us is in possession of the full picture. Our feelings may incline us to one way or another but there is quite an amount of conflict about what should be the age.
I have received representations on this matter—admittedly I have received predictable representations from certain sections that it should be at a particular age—but I have received sincerely meant criticism from people who do not differ from me in many of my political and social objectives, who point to the actual situation and say that putting it at the age of 15 years is really unrealistic in that given situation. Therefore, I will withdraw my own amendment and on Report Stage I will come back with a new subsection giving me power by affirmative resolution to delete the provisions regarding 14-and 15-year-olds.
I want to be honest with the Senators. I still adhere to my belief that 14 years is the correct age in our circumstances but I accept the criticism made by Senators that this legislation as drafted does not give me the power by affirmative order to move rapidly on this question of age. If the representative committee we have set up recommend that we should move in that direction then I do not want to have our legislation here a bar to that desirable movement. I would therefore ask Senators to bear with me in that suggestion and let us look at it again on Report Stage. Perhaps there could be some sort of a quid pro quo here? Could I ask the Senators if they will withdraw their amendments?
Comment on this
On the basis that other Senators withdraw their amendments I would appeal to the Minister not to withdraw his amendment. I cannot see any point in that operation because, while I do not think it is much of an improvement, it clearly is an improvement on what is in the Bill. It provides, for example, for an extra two weeks holidays for the child in the summer and it provides for limited work at weekends. Therefore, it would be a great mistake to withdraw his amendment. On the basis that the various non-ministerial amendments are withdrawn, I would hope that the ministerial amendment, which is an advance, would be inserted. Secondly, I should like to thank the Minister for his proposition regarding the affirmative order which I think would be a considerable advance and would, I hope, bring us closer to the day when we would be——
Comment on this
I am prepared to deal with this amendment which is an improvement and also to add the powers that Senators have sought.
Comment on this
So long as the Minister's amendment will eventually be moved that is all right, my worries are over on that point of view. I thank the Minister for his offer to put in the provision regarding the affirmative order. While he is considering in terms of affirmative orders, I would like him to have a look at the affirmative order that he says he is withdrawing in subsection (4). I know that strictly speaking I should deal with this under the heading of the section but since we are having a quid pro quo I might perhaps mention it now and I promise not to mention it again later so that we will not waste any time.
This subsection (4) says:
The Minister may by order vary the hours of work specified in subsection (3) of this section.
My interpretation of this may be wrong. The Minister can only vary the hours. I would like the Minister to take rather more power than this so that he could say, for example, that work on a school day should be banned and so on. To my mind he can only vary the two hours a day, he can vary to one or to three, but he cannot say that the child is not to work on a school day. That is my interpretation of it, which may be wrong. If I am right, then he should take increased power in subsection (4).
Comment on this
The Senator is correct in his point and I think the amendment which I have undertaken to bring in on Report Stage would cover that.
Comment on this
The Minister's affirmative order would, in other words, (a) give him power to raise the age to 15 years and (b) give him power regarding weekend work, work during holidays and in term times and so on. On that basis I am happy to withdraw my own amendment.
Comment on this
To escape the vigilance of the Senator's drafting suggestions at Report Stage, I will let him have the draft beforehand.
Comment on this
I should like to thank all Senators for their constructive approach in this matter. I do not think there is any difference between us on the question of what we hope will be adopted very rapidly.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 11 and 12 may be discussed together.
Comment on this
Senator Yeats brought to my attention on Second Stage a desirable drafting amendment in relation to this subsection. He tabled an amendment to this subsection but I am advised that my particular amendment, which is a little bit more specific—at least, so it is argued on our side—could be accepted. I do not think there is much difference but this is what I have been advised.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's amendment and thank him for bringing it in. Of course it is a very temporary phenomenon because he is going to change it anyway.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 13 and 14 may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I have a query under subsections (6) and (7). The point about this section is that the only type of work a child of 14 to 15 years is entitled to do is light non-industrial work. Under subsection (7) the Minister can add any form of work to this type of work and, on the other hand, in subsection (6) the Minister can say that work which is accepted as light non-industrial work, is not such work. So, in this subsection he can add to and subtract from indefinitely the type of work which a child can do. I can see there is a problem in regard to the area of light non-industrial work, but it seems to me that the Minister is taking rather extensive powers here. I am perfectly well aware that he has no intention of saying that a child of 14 years is to be allowed work in a steel mill and so on, but nevertheless he has the power to do it under these subsections. It does seem undesirable that powers so wide should be included in the Bill. One wonders whether there would not be some rather simpler, more restrictive form of power that could be given to the Minister. It seems to me that under these subsections very extensive powers indeed are given to the Minister to declare that any form of work is work which a child of 14 can do. I appreciate he has no intention of doing such a thing but, as we are legislating, we should try to legislate in a form which is less vague than this.
Comment on this
The powers available to me are not quite as wide as that. They are pretty carefully defined under the section and in previous legislation. There is also the further limitation imposed in section 4 (2) (a) in that it should be work that is not harmful to the health or normal development of the child. This might require that certain work, perhaps not covered in previous definitions under previous legislation, could be declared harmful to the child. That is why this double-edged power is considered desirable.
Comment on this
The section, as amended, faces this very basic problem which I spoke about in my last intervention, that very often children of very young age nowadays are simply itching to go out to work. Teachers, trade unionists, and parents to a certain extent, may throw up their hands in horror, but it is a fact of life and we have got to approach it in a sensible way. This section now approaches it in a particular way. I am not at all in favour of the approach which has been suggested by the National Youth Council, for example, that it should be approached in an even more different way by reducing the age at which people can start work to 12 years. We have got to face the fact, whether we like it or not, that very often children, especially in the urban environments and perhaps very different reasons in the rural environments, see access to work and to work experience as a very important part of growing up, a very important way of establishing their own independence as human beings and their independence indeed from their parents, teachers and other authority figures as well. In much the same way we can accept that, while many of the reasons for wanting to prevent young children from working come from the highest motives there are always some people who prefer not to see young people working precisely because they resent the independence that an independent source of income gives these people. The question is what is the best form of work and work experience for young people.
To my mind the conflict we are trying to resolve in this Bill, and in this section of the Bill in particular, is very often based on the fact that school in particular becomes a bit of a ghetto for the child. It reacts to the child's wish to establish his own independence, to go out working, by attempting to build the walls higher and higher, often for the best of motives. There is another worry of introducing children to work within the context of school and this is not dealt with in this section as it exists at the moment. Perhaps it may need a Report Stage amendment in order to make it possible. What I am talking about here are schemes of work experience for children. Very often these schemes of work experience are forming a substantial part of many school programmes in these islands. They have been part of school programmes in Britain for some time. They are being introduced into some schools in Northern Ireland and only the other day I heard on the radio an example of an experiment in Tuam which was carried with the co-operation and assistance of the Minister's own Department involving the release of pupils from school for a certain time to work in local enterprises.
This is a particularly appropriate way for children to be introduced to the work experience. I am glad to see them starting off in this country. On the other hand I would hate to think that the restrictive provisions of this legislation would operate in such a way as to limit the possibilities children may have to engage in this kind of work experience programme, a programme often devised by and with the full approval of their school authority and their parents. I suggest that I put down a Report Stage amendment designed to exclude from the operation of this scheme work experience schemes of this kind carried out with the full knowledge, authority and cooperation of the school managers and perhaps the children and parents. Otherwise you might find yourselves unable to take advantage of this very important educational experience and experiment. This is a useful option, a very valid alternative to the kind of exploitation that we see nowadays. I would urge its benefits on the Minister and I would urge him to consider favourably my Report Stage amendment when it comes because I intend it to be a facilitating amendment, one which would facilitate the right kind of work experience formed at school.
Comment on this
I agree with what Senator Horgan has said here. There are regrettably in our society probably significant numbers—I had occasion to consider this problem in the course of preparation of this legislation—of young people between the ages of 12 and 15 years for whom the present alternative to work-school—is meaningless and irrelevant. That is a problem arising from the raising of the permissible age for work. It should be studied and the solution sought and I agree with the Senator that we want to see the possibility of these work-school experiments commencing. The exact number of young people in this unhappy situation is probably unclear, like a great deal of other statistics relating to employment of youth. The opinions of probation officers and school attendance officers indicate that the numbers involved are significant and therefore the need for an alternative, a link-up between school and work, a connected educational experiment for such children, is very important and is a serious question. The experience of teachers in many of the large Dublin vocational schools would bear this out. In some schools there are large numbers of young people in this age group—I have been informed probably as high as 40 per cent —whose presence is simply physical and who derive no benefit at all from the school. After nine years at school many come out illiterate.
Therefore the need for discussion of this matter is clear. It means that we must act on it. I would remind Senator Horgan that this was raised in the discussion on this legislation and I think we move towards it in section 15, which we will be discussing later. In section 16 (5) we permit co-operation between myself, the Minister for Education and employers who might be willing to co-operate in such a measure where we could begin to tackle this problem. I hope that at the conference on young people and their employment, which will take place in some weeks' time, this matter can be further explored and again, like everything else connected with this legislation, we can begin to assess and collect the facts relating to youth employment. I thoroughly agree with what Senator Horgan has said and I think the legislation gives us the possibility for proceeding into that area.
Business suspended at 5.50 p.m. and resumed at 7.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I just want to make a few observations. Unless young people are being exploited, they are far healthier in mind and body if they are doing some light work. We should concentrate more on the provision of youth leaders and youth groups such as Macra na Feirme and Macra na Tuaithe. We need more voluntary effort to provide sports and leisure activities for boys and girls. This need is greater now than ever before, because the present generation is more reckless than the youth of ten years ago. Parents are very anxious to take part in school management activities but they would be better engaged in organising the young people in their areas during their leisure time and holiday periods. There is much to be done in organising games and outings to places of interest, musical events and so on.
There is an element of danger in young people being employed at too young an age because when they begin earning a pay packet, very often they do not want to continue studying and entering for examinations and they take the first job that comes along. We should ensure that there is more career guidance for young people who are about to take up any work during holiday periods.
Comment on this
There is one relatively minor point which I should like to raise on section 4. In subsection (2) (a) the Bill refers to work not being harmful to the health or normal development of the child. A variety of terms is used throughout the Bill and they appear to be all different. In this section we have reference to the health or normal development of the child. In section 6 it refers to endangering the health, safety or morals of young persons, which of course covers only those from 15 to 18 years, and in section 16 there is reference to the health, welfare and safety of both children and young persons. I am not sure why there should be a distinction. Health is involved in all cases but otherwise the words used are different. I am not sure what "normal development" means. I put it to the Minister that it would be better to use the phrase that appears in section 16, "health, welfare and safety". By using these words "normal development" would be covered and it would avoid having different wording in various sections of the same Bill. This would improve the terms of the Bill. I shall put down an amendment on Report Stage and perhaps the Minister would consider this point.
Comment on this
The Senator is not questioning the substance here? He is suggesting alternative wording?
Comment on this
The wording of the various sections should be the same.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In subsection 1, paragraph (c), line 44, to delete ",or other satisfactory record" and substitute "to be supplied on request by the National Manpower Service and paid for by the employer".
This amendment is an attempt to tighten up to the maximum possible extent the control mechanism which the Minister agrees is all-important. This amendment has been suggested to me, and perhaps to other Senators, by the National Youth Council, and they feel that it will make the job of the Minister's inspectorate a great deal easier. If this amendment is accepted it means that when the inspectorate are trying to control the employment of young people or children they will have a readymade record of persons who are already employing such children. Therefore, they can apply their energy and researches in seeking out people whom they suspect of illegally employing young people and only secondarily come back to the people who are actually keeping the registers and check whether the registers display anything which may lead to comment on their part. I do not feel that he has pressed this very strongly and perhaps the wording might be improved. It is suggested purely to tighten up yet again the work of enforcement in what is going to be a very difficult section to enforce.
Comment on this
A similar suggestion had been considered earlier but the real purpose of the register to be kept by the employer is to help in the collection of information more than anything else. This legislation puts new obligations on employers, but I am not anxious to insist on a uniform record system where there may be different forms of records in the hands of employers. Many of the employers I have in mind would be small employers probably adopting different methods of collation or retention of information and probably not having access to computerisation. I do not think that the existence of separate registers will be of any great assistance to us as far as the collection of statistical information is concerned. It must be recognised also that if the requirement sought were to be fulfilled it would have to be fulfilled in respect of about 65,000 new persons who will be covered by this legislation for the first time. I am therefore reasonably satisfied that we will be able to obtain the required statistical information as a result of visits to inspectors and of records being kept.
With the arrangements made in the Bill we should be in a relatively short period of time in a position to have definite information where now we simply have surmise. While I understand the motivation of the Senator's amendment I hope he will understand why I am not in a position to accept it.
Comment on this
A great deal of information is sought by this section and it seems that employers may very often be at some difficulty in remembering precisely which items of information are sought in respect of which employees and so on. Quite apart from the enforcement side of things, if the Minister is interested in getting the information it might well repay him, not necessarily to issue registers to employers, but at least to issue standardised sheets of account which the employer could fill up in respect of each child employee rather than have to fabricate his own which might or might not contain all the information which might lead to extensive correspondence between the inspectors and himself or the Department and himself. It is important and right that all this information should be sought. If the seeking of information is not to be used as a method of enforcement it should be made as easy for the employer as possible. One way in which it could be made easier for the employer and which would encourage compliance with the legislation is if some standard form could be made available by the Department for this purpose.
Comment on this
We are satisfied with what is there but we will have another look at it again on Report Stage.
Comment on this
On the section, I have a couple of points to raise and in the interests of clarity I will deal with them one at a time. Before the interval I was urging that the various registers listed in this section should be used in cases other than as provided in the Bill. I hope the Minister will not think me inconsistent in suggesting that there may be other cases where it would be very difficult to deal with the provisions of this section. I am thinking in particular of the type of employment that Senator McCartin so eloquently spoke of: the typical case in rural Ireland, where a neighbour offers the youngsters half-a-crown to come and help with the hay or something of this kind. There are numerous transactions of this kind that take place. Even though I am appalled by it I am sure the Minister was quite right in saying that such a transaction would be covered by the Bill. The mind boggles at the thought of a farmer asking his young neighbour to come and help with the hay and saying: "You have to get a birth certificate" and so on. This will not be done and anyone who suggests such things would be thought to be mad and yet they would have committed an offence under this Bill and could, in theory be prosecuted.
Up to a point the Minister has power to deal with a situation in the fourth subsection of section 16. It says "The Minister may, by licence, exempt any class of employers from complying with any provision of this Act ...." That is not merely a class of employers and he would have to say that all farmers were excluded. We are not on section 16 but I will not raise this matter on section 16 again so that there will be no time lost.
I would suggest to the Minister that he might consider elaborating on this provision and add to "class of employer""class of employment" or "form of employment" or "temporary" or something of that kind. The kind of typical part-time, unofficial, informal type of employment that takes place all over the country and, even in towns, while it is covered by the section, is of such a kind that nobody will pay any attention to this legislation in regard to it. Nobody will provide birth certificates or set up the registers with the full name of the young person, date of birth, time of commencement of work, time of finishing, rate of wages, total sum paid to each person and so on. Yet, under subsection (4) of this section the Minister says an employer who fails to comply with the provision of this section and the parent or guardian of a young person who aids and abets an employer in a contravention in this section shall be guilty of an offence and liable to a penalty of £100 and £10 a day while it continues and so on. Some kind of let out is needed and it would have to be done by ministerial order or regulation. Therefore I would urge the Minister to consider taking power, possibly under this section 16 to deal with that matter.
Comment on this
The Senator again comes up against the difficulty that appears in every section of this kind of legislation. If one seeks to limit the area of operation of the legislation at what point do you stop and how can we put that into legislative form? If the Senator wishes to put any suggestions under this heading I will be glad to look at them on Report Stage. The Senator and myself and the officials of my Department will be aware of the difficulties of drafting of that kind to allow for those exceptions he mentions. If one commences on the exceptions one has the difficulty of where to cut off. I do not think that one can relax this provision. I do not see how we can legislatively do it but if the Senator has any suggestions about areas which could be regarded as involving merely trivial or small periods of employment, we could look at them.
Comment on this
I hesitate to embark on this kind of operation without the assistance of the parliamentary draftsman but I will do my best. The way to do it is probably in subsection (4) of section 16, so I will see what I can think up.
The other point I have on section 5 is in regard to the otherwise useful provision for getting a birth certificate without having to pay for it where it is required by the employer. Subsection 2 provides that forms for the requestion—that is, to get the certificate for nothing—should on request be supplied without any charge by every registrar of births and by every superintendent registrar or other person having custody of the register. In view of the fact that the Minister has told us that there are approximately 65,000 people over 15 and I presume there are few more thousand under 15, say, 70,000 in all, would it not be sensible to have these forms in the post office also? There are a considerable number of people involved and it is not so easy for a parent, perhaps when little Joe is sent down to go to a local supermarket, to start finding the registrar or even finding out who he is going to get the form from. I would have thought that the post office, which has the largest number of forms anyway, would be a sensible place to have them.
Comment on this
In support of that point I feel that if some arrangement other than what is here could be made it would be preferable, because anyone who has the experience of going down to Pearse Street or other places like that knows it is a dreadful task to get hold of a birth certificate. There may be some urgency in the boy getting the certificate to get the employment because nowadays one does not go on his own to get a job: he may be sent by Manpower in a group of perhaps 50 other boys. They are sent in numbers now as distinct from before when one went on one's own to look for a job and the best of the boys are picked out. Consequently you may have about 50 people converging on Pearse Street with all the delays that involves. All certificates are written in longhand and so it is a fairly tedious job.
Comment on this
Under this section we have the ordinary procedure as adopted in the other Acts of a similar nature in welfare; we have taken them over the same kind of procedure. I think it is quite sufficient. I do not see that the Senator will have any cause for dissatisfaction on the grounds that this will not be adequate.
Comment on this
I think there is a difference between someone who is looking for a pension, actually going to get a profit from getting the birth certificate from the State, and this type of case. There is also the point that, I take it that once the Department of Social Welfare have your birth certificate, then no matter how often you deal with them they have this on a file somewhere and you have done the job for life. Now, in this instance every time little Joe goes to a new employer he has to get a new birth certificate. He could be at a job a week and each time, I take it, he has to have a birth certificate. I suppose, in theory, he could get it back from his employer but we all know that this kind of thing does not work out. It is likely, in fact, that many parents have to make numerous applications for birth certificates. To have 65,000 people involved —perhaps 70,000—fairly frequently in this job of collecting birth certificates seems unwise. We do not want to have parents coming to Deputies and Senators saying: "How am I going to get a birth certificate for little Willy because he needs a job in a supermarket?" Let us make it as easy as possible. Even with regard to other social welfare matters the fact that it has always been done this way is not a reason for not changing. There is much to be said for changing this in all social welfare legislation. The necessary forms for acquiring birth certificates could well be made available in post offices and, indeed, the Minister could do a good day's work by arranging this so that there will be forms available in the post offices for everyone who is entitled to free birth certificates in that way.
Comment on this
Senator Yeats might say what he means by a form for a birth certificate. Having been at one stage an acting superintendent registrar of births, deaths and marriages, one does have to go through official records and one is superintendent of those records. Does the Senator mean to requisition it so that it comes back a few days later?
Comment on this
The situation is that under section 5 an employer of a young person or child—any of these I think are affected by this Bill—must obtain a birth certificate from the parent. The Minister very reasonably does not see why the parent should have to pay for that. These forms which I have been talking about are forms which enable one to get a birth certificate without paying. Therefore you have to apply first of all for your form, then you fill it out, send it off to the registrar and he will provide you with a birth certificate without requiring whatever the sum is. It is merely to enable you to get it for nothing. I would not for a moment suggest that you should get a birth certificate in the post office, but merely a form which is a requisition. This would enable you to send it off in lieu of a cheque or postal order, to get your birth certificate for nothing. That is all that is involved. There is no complication with the State records or anything of this kind. It is simply a means of saving money.
Comment on this
If the Minister could do this then I would put down an amendment for Report Stage to add the words "post office" to the other places listed in subsection (2).
Comment on this
An employer who fails to comply with the provisions of this section or the parent or guardian of the young child who aids or abets an employer in the contravention of this section shall be guilty of an offence. Am I right in thinking here that contravention is a positive thing? In other words, if an employer forgets or fails to do something, it seems very difficult to prove that the parent or guardian aided or abetted him in his forgetfulness. Is this subsection over-stringent, I wonder?
Comment on this
That would be a question to be decided by the courts. If this matter comes to that level it would be for them to say what exact significance one would give to the contravention.
Comment on this
One of my problems has been trying to read this Bill in aeroplanes. I now realise with some horror that I have totally misread this subsection (2). I had thought it was the parent that was involved in looking for this birth certificate, but in fact it is the employer—no, it is not. I have read it correctly. I have read it right after all.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 6 after "morals of" in line 23 to delete "young persons" and substitute "employees".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 17 is consequential and accordingly these amendments should be debated together.
Comment on this
These two amendments propose to give the Minister more power than at present he seems to be willing to take upon himself. This short section enables the Minister, after consultation with the various people concerned, in the case of work which is likely to endanger the health, safety or morals of young persons, to raise by order the minimum age at which a young person may be entitled to do such work. This means, for example, in the case of any kind of work that he considers is unsuited for 15 year olds, he can say this particular kind of work may not be done by anybody under 16. I am entirely in favour of that power being given to the Minister. But the problem I can see with the wording as it stands is that it only applies to young persons —people between 14 and 18—and in such a case it would still be open to an employer to employ a child from 14 to 15 in that work, because to my mind they would not be covered by this section, unless I have got it wrong. The purpose of my amendment is merely to ensure that both children and young persons are covered—in other words that if the Minister were to say, for example, that a particular kind of work was not to be allowed under the age of 16, then this would cover everybody under the age of 16 and not merely those between 15 and 16. It is a relatively simple amendment but I think it is needed.
Comment on this
I do not think this amendment solves the problem. The problem is to remove the danger to health, safety or morals whether young people or adults are employed.
Comment on this
I am not really convinced of the need for these amendments. Section 4, dealing with minimum age of employment, contains the general prohibition of the employment of children; and they are, by definition, young children under school-leaving age, at present 15. On the other hand section 6 deals with young persons in the 15-18 age group. Here I am given power to set a higher minimum age for entry to particular sectors of employment, if there is clear evidence of danger to health and safety there. Any order would be framed so as to prohibit completely the employment of young persons below the age stipulated therein. I do not see the need for the changes in the amendments as requested by the Senator. If he is convinced, after what I have said, I would be obliged if he would withdraw the amendments.
Comment on this
Suppose there is a certain form of light, non-industrial work of a kind which a 14-year-old is allowed to do under section 4. Of course, that type of work can be done by 15-year-olds as well as the 14-year-olds. In a particular instance the Minister might feel the morals of the young people concerned are likely to be affected and say: "All right, nobody under 16 is to do this work." This would not cover the section 4 cases. A boy of 14, who is allowed to do that work under section 4, would not be covered by the Minister's action under section 6. The Minister has no power under section 4 to prevent anyone doing work that might affect his morals. He has to take into consideration the health, normal development of the child, attendance at school, his capacity to benefit from instruction given to him therein, but when it comes to safety and morals these are not mentioned. Therefore it seems sensible that they should be included in section 6. I am not saying it would happen very often but it does seem sensible, if he is giving himself the power to fix the minimum age at which work can be done, that he covers any work under this Bill, and not merely this Bill minus section 4. He need not use this power but it is a power he should have and might need.
Comment on this
On the advice available to us, it would seem that any order made under this section would automatically cut out the age groups below 15.
Comment on this
This section refers to young persons. In the definition section, section 1, a young person is somebody who is beyond school-leaving age. In other words, the definition of "employees" in section 1 is children or young persons. Then there are children who are below school-leaving age, that is, below 15; and young persons who are 15 to 18. The Minister has specifically said "young persons" in this section, which is why I want to put in "employees".
Comment on this
I am satisfied with the section as it is, but I will look at it for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
As the matter is being discussed on Committee Stage there is nothing to bar the same amendment or another version being put down.
Comment on this
I should like to bring two drafting points to the Minister's attention. In line 23 there is reference to "work which may endanger the health, safety or morals of young persons". It might be a good idea to insert here after "safety" the words "education or educational welfare". There will be many young persons who are at school and whose educational welfare should take at least as high a priority as any of the other three things we are talking about. I would be interested in the Minister's attitude to this before I decide whether or not I should put something down myself on Report Stage.
The second point I want to make is again perhaps a drafting point. In the following line the Minister is empowered "to raise the minimum age at which a young person may be employed to do such work". I wonder whether the word "raise" is the right one. The Minister may decide after raising the minimum age that it was a mistake to do so, and would like to reduce it. A better word would be "specify" or "state"—in other words, give the Minister the power to move in either direction with regard to specifying ages of employment.
Comment on this
I will look at that point on Report Stage. It could be the raising of the minimum age by another means, but however, I will have a look at it.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Horgan's first point: "Health, safety, morals or educational development" might be a useful term to put in because, after all, a 15-year-old may still be at school. As regards raising the minimum age, I would urge the Minister at all costs not to pay any attention to Senator Horgan on this. It is one of the advantages of this section that he says "raise the minimum age". I would hate to give him the power to reduce it. Our whole trend in this Bill should be to raise the minimum age and under no circumstances consider reducing it. On the contrary, I would be in favour of reducing the hours of work and would not be in favour of giving the Minister the power to increase them. In this case I would urge him to keep "raise".
Comment on this
The question of grouping arises here. Amendments Nos. 18 and 29 are cognate and amendments Nos. 19 and 31 are consequential. Accordingly, amendments Nos. 18, 19, 29 and 31 should be debated together. If desired, there could be separate decisions on Nos. 18 and 29. It is agreed then and ordered that amendments Nos. 18, 19, 29 and 31 be debated together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
Before section 7 to insert a new section as follows:
"7.—An employer shall not employ during school terms a young person over the age of sixteen years who is still attending school."
This section, and my amendment, both put me in considerable difficulty. I believe the whole question of work for school children assumes different proportions and different characteristics depending on ages. With regard to the younger children of 14, 15 or thereabouts, quite apart from the legal necessity for them to be in school, there is a more obvious health aspect to whether they should be allowed to work. With regard to the older children it is much more difficult in some senses to deny them the right to work or to restrict their right to work. At the same time it must be recognised that they are faced with a different set of stresses and strains in education and allowing them to work, and perhaps to work too much, could seriously affect their educational progress. We are all familiar with examination psychosis and the effect this is having on children in our society. It is commonly thought of in popular romantic fiction as being only the prerogative of expensively educated Cambridge undergraduates on drugs and that kind of thing. But it is also very prevalent in post-primary schools here, especially, as I said, coming up to examinations.
The section as it stands is far too wide. To give an indication of how wide it is, I again refer to the survey which pointed out that the range of hours worked in the 15-plus age group was not nearly as wide as is allowed in this Bill. The largest single category of people in this 15-plus age group—71—worked for between five and ten hours. In other words, they worked for no more than one-quarter of the maximum number of hours permitted by this Bill.
It seems to be anomalous in the extreme to have provisions in the Bill which are so greatly in excess of what seems to be the average obtaining in an urban area in relation to this type of employment. It seems equally anomalous to bring in such a major extension of the possibility of employing young people in a way which makes no differentiation between term time and holiday time. I believe it is quite unrealistic to expect 15-, 16-, or 17-year-olds at school not to work at some stage even during the school terms. I would prefer that this work be restricted to weekends. In fact, if Senator Yeats put down an amendment rather like the amendment he put down to the earlier section with regard to the younger children, I would support it, rather than the amendment down in my name at the moment.
One of the big problems we are facing here is that we are legislating for young people after the compulsory school leaving age. Putting too many restrictions on the employment of children who are at school may lead them to throw their hats completely at education and say: "If that is the choice I have, there is no choice for me, I am leaving school and going into full time employment". Perhaps they will go into a succession of dead-end jobs. We must strike a balance here. If we allow young people over the age of 15 to work, even though they are at school, we should make some differentiation as between the number of hours they should work in term time and in holiday time. The school day can be a pretty testing one for a 15- or 16-year-old. A couple of hours work on top of that could be as much as he could take. Yet we are allowing a situation here in which he could work up to 40 hours a week, even during the school term. The results of the survey indicate that no child in Drogheda, however exploitative his employers might feel, has been able to rise to that kind of challenge. The majority of them are working five to ten hours a week; a certain number are working ten to 20. After the 20-hour-week point the proportion diminishes very sharply. Only about 17 children out of 174 are working more than 20 hours a week. It seems strange to double this for all children and not make a differentiation between children who are at school and children who are not.
Comment on this
There are many implications of these amendments which probably begin to grow on you as you look at them. The kind of prohibition desired would cut right across the existing apprenticeship arrangements. It might be considered a good thing to scrap certain features of the present apprenticeship system, but it is the one we have and we do not have any alternative proposals as yet. That would require to be altered immediately because all these arrangements involve periods of attendance at school, on block release or day release, and the employment would have to be terminated if provision of the nature requested was made in legislation in present circumstances.
There are many examples also of young employees seeking to add to their occupational skills by attending night classes at technical schools or regional colleges. They could not continue to be employed during the school term if they were also attending school under terms of the proposed amendment. The net effect for many young people would become a choice forced on them by the law between full-time employment or full-time education without any intermediate choice being available to them. This is one implication we would see in the amendments suggested. This would also mean that there would be vast disruptions of the lives of many young people who at present have the arrangements which the amendment would seek to terminate.
In addition those who had to leave school early and who might later want to improve their education on a part-time basis would be debarred from re-entering unless they went back to full-time education, which would mean in our circumstances perhaps no further contact with education. There could be a definite barrier to part-time education assistance for disadvantaged young people. I have considered whether some variation of the concept would be more workable but I have not come up with a satisfactory solution. I do not know if as yet we have the arrangements in our society, educational and work alike, to provide what the Senator is seeking. In the light of these considerations there are many implications to be read into these amendments. These are some of my reservations to why I could not, at this stage, see my way to accepting the amendments.
Comment on this
The Minister's points are very powerful. Given the employment pattern for a 15- or 16-year-old revealed in the survey and the employment pattern legislated for in the Bill, is the Minister satisfied that passing this Bill would not actually worsen the situation by increasing pressures on these people who are in full-time education to leave it for full-time employment? Is he satisfied that it would not worsen the situation, especially in the light of the other argument he has put up against the amendments, which I feel I could not press?
Comment on this
I do not see it changing the existing situation. There is a free choice between full-time or part-time in the existing situation. Without alternative arrangements of a very wide reaching nature indeed, I do not think we could in this Bill proceed to take the steps mentioned by the Senator.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In subsection (1) (a) to delete "ten" in line 29 and substitute "nine".
Comment on this
Here we should have a grouping of amendments. Amendments Nos. 20 to 28 are related and perhaps should be taken together. Would that meet with the agreement of the House?
Comment on this
The only point I make is it seems to me that amendments Nos. 21 and 26 are on a rather different point, as to whether the Minister should have power to vary up and down or simply downwards. The others are on figures. It might therefore be more convenient to take amendments Nos. 21 and 26 by themselves.
Comment on this
We have the alternative suggestion by Senator Yeats that we take amendments Nos. 19 to 28, with the exception of amendments Nos. 21 and 26, together, and then have the second debate on amendments Nos. 21 and 26. It is agreed then to take amendments Nos. 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 27 and 28 together.
Comment on this
The reason for this amendment is self-evident. It is possible for an employer under the subsection as it stands, to require a young person to work for ten hours, five days a week. For instance, a young person could be required to start work at 8 o'clock in the morning, to continue until 1 o'clock, break for an hour for lunch and resume at 2 o'clock until 7 o'clock in the evening.
These hours, in my opinion, are excessive. Indeed, they are excessive even for adults. I know of very few adults who work these hours. I venture to suggest that on very few occasions Members of this House have worked such hours as Senators. Even the reduction of one hour, from ten to nine, would still make it excessive, but the Minister should give way on this problem. In my view, this is a very reasonable request.
Comment on this
Bearing in mind what you have just said, a Chathaoirleach, about the way we are taking these amendments, the same type of argument can apply to the amendment submitted in connection with 50 hours as compared with 45 hours, as we suggested. I want to emphasise this point. I understand that it is the intention of the Minister and all parties in this House to protect the employment of young persons. This is the purpose of the Bill. That being so, it is important that we take lessons from what is in existence. As my colleague, Senator Kennedy has said, no adult works 50 hours per week. I submit that to make provision for people to work ten hours a day or 50 hours a week is not consistent with what is happening around us. I cannot over-emphasise the importance of realising that we are comparing children or youths with adults. Common sense tells us that we should get away from this figure. With respect to the Minister and the people who helped him to draft this Bill, I believe it is insincere. It is not affording protection to the people we purport to protect.
Earlier I referred to joint labour committees. We get the same lesson there. It is almost the equivalent to legislation. There is not a single joint labour committee in existence, under the aegis of the Labour Court, which in turn is under the control of the Minister for Labour, which provides for a 50-hour working week minimum, a ten hour working day maximum, not even for adults. Why this should be perpetrated on juveniles is beyond my conception. As a consequence I ask the Minister to have another look at this. I do not think that our amendments are way off the beam but are very reasonable. The difference of an hour a day means five hours in the week. The Minister should remember that we are not dealing with adults.
The 40-hour week, for example, is recognised and approved. Here we have advocated a 50-hour week or a ten-hour working day for children. Adults who have the protection of the trade union movement would not agree to that. Where there is no such protection, it is incumbent on us to do everything we possibly can to protect children at work. I urge the Minister to have second thoughts on this matter. Again, I think he is badly advised here.
Comment on this
I should like to make two points. When we take into consideration that a person might work nine hours a day, or 50 hours a week, we must consider that a number of apprentices and boys may be attending technical school during the week. If a boy was in the type of employment that necessitated his giving the employer nine hours a day, and then going to the technical school two or three nights a week, or girls attending technical schools at night to learn shorthand and typewriting, then we are not talking about nine hours a day because even these classes could be considered as work.
I wish to support Senator Mullen's point. There was a campaign for the introduction of a 40-hour week. The idea behind that was to create more leisure time for adults. This amendment does not meet that idea in an area where, in my view it is more necessary than for adults.
Comment on this
Basically, while I have several amendments down, essentially I am trying to establish that 40 hours should be the maximum in any week. Just as the Minister has done, I scaled down the number of hours you can work in any period of four consecutive hours and the number of hours in any year—40 to 37½ down to 35 over a whole year. But one could discuss them on the basis of the 40-hour week. I agree completely with amendment No. 20 put down by Senator Mullen and Senator Kennedy. A ten-hour day is too long and nine hours would seem to be perfectly adequate and even perhaps too much. After all, we are dealing with 16- to 18-year-olds and ten hours is a very long time.
The reason I fixed 40 hours rather than 45 as suggested in the amendment by Senator Mullen and Senator Kennedy is that, as the Minister knows, while we are approaching the universal 40-hour week, it will soon be forced upon us by an EEC directive. The Minister, in the course of his Second Reading speech, at column 1094 of the Seanad Official Report, said that one of the general aims of the Bill was:
To raise the protective standards incorporated in the legislation in accordance with modern trends and international standards for the employment of young people.
The international standard which will hit us hardest and most rapidly is this EEC directive which has been passed by Parliament and will in due course come before the Council, of which the Minister is the present President. I hope that at the Council whether as President or not, depending of course on when it comes, the Minister will be wholeheartedly in favour on our behalf of the 40-hour week. When that directive comes in, we will have a maximum working week of 40 hours. The Minister will tell me that this 40-hour week is not a 40-hour maximum, but a 40-hour normal working week. In other words, you could work 40 hours and after that you had to be paid overtime.
I must stress—and I am sure the Minister will accept my point—that the principle behind this directive and the international move towards the 40-hour week, is not simply to ensure that workers will get overtime after 40 hours: it is to ensure that workers, young or old, will have more time to enjoy themselves. Indeed, in the debate in the European Parliament in Strasbourg recently when this matter came before us, several leading figures in the Socialist group in the Parliament pointed out that it would be pointless if it meant that people worked longer and got more money. The aim was that people should spend less time on the job. The Commissioner, Dr. Hillery, agreed that this was indeed the aim behind the directive.
It is not good enough for the Minister to say that it is only normal working hours and people are allowed under this directive to work longer. They are, but that is not the aim of the operation. The aim is that no one will need to work more than 40 hours. I am not suggesting that it is possible to abolish overtime; obviously it is not. Many circumstances occur in employment when from time to time overtime is necessary. What one wants to abolish is perpetual overtime, which is organised in a certain trade in such a way that people work week after week on overtime. Of course they get more money. That is part of this whole idea of the 40-hour week.
We have the position, then, that the 40-hour week fortunately is coming, but while it is 48 normal working hours everyone concerned with it hopes that it will end up in practice that people will not have to work, except as an exception, 48 hours. Yet we find that the 16-year-olds in section 7 of this Bill are expected to work 50 hours in a week. It is a maximum admittedly, but for 16-, 17- or up to 18-year-olds it seems far too much. If the norm is supposed to be that for adults, 40 hours would be the normal maximum. Surely it should be only that, and if possible less, for the young people dealt with in this Bill.
I would urge that 40 hours ought to be more than enough for a 16-year-old in section 7 and I suggest bringing it down, as the Minister has himself, even from 150 hours for any four consecutive weeks or 1,960 in respect of any year. If the Minister will not accept the 40 hours, I think he ought to if only because of this coming directive which will definitely have to be enacted in legislation here almost immediately as soon as it goes through the EEC Council of Ministers. If he would not accept that he should at least accept Senator Mullen's amendment and say 45 hours. To my mind a more realistic approach would be to say 40 hours in view of the fact that the 40-hour week is coming sort of willy nilly whether he wants it or not.
Comment on this
This is not a normal working week. It is maximum and beyond the hours here there would be an actual breaking of the law. Of course one must not forget that we have limited it during the entire year to an average of 2,100 hours which works out as a maximum on average, if you work around the entire year of 8½ hours per day. You break the law beyond that average.
Comment on this
Yes. That is the maximum and there is a vast difference between the normal hours permitted and the maximum number of hours. The difference, of course, is overtime. None of us is in favour of overtime but it happens to be a fact of life and the Irish delegation at the Council of Ministers of Social Affairs will be very strongly moving for that directive for a 40-hour week. However, I fear we will have moved to that point in this country long before the European Community reach that point because, even if there is agreement in the Council of Ministers in Brussels on this matter, it will be still only a recommendation with no value whatever.
Comment on this
No. We are many years from a directive stage. So we need not worry, Europe will not push us in this direction very diligently. We will have to do the pushing ourselves. The Irish delegation in Brussels will be moving very strongly for rapid progress towards the 40-hour week having the status of directive. But there is a vast difference, I must emphasise, between maximum and normal working hours. We have the provision whereby in effect it can only be, at maximum on average, around the year 8½ hours.
I understand the view of anyone seeing any hours suggested in any maximum capacity, in any maximum fashion, one should not seek to reduce them. That is natural enough and proper, but again one has the problem here of deciding what seems to be a realistic base to start with on the figures mentioned in the Drogheda survey. What are listed here as maximum hours are being at present worked by people in Drogheda under this age so we can see how bad the situation really is, a situation which has gone on without any publicity, no public outcry about it for a long time. The maximum suggested here will be lower than what they are working at present.
If we get that sense of proportion about that reality which has gone on unchecked and which our maximum hours will if brought into operation cut dramatically, we are beginning to see the proportions of the job before us. I think that as soon as we see the extent of the kind of hours being worked by young people—at present we are working very much in the dark; we have the advantage of the survey in Drogheda which has given us some very alarming figures indeed—we can consider further downward movement in the maximum hours area. Remember the normal working week as we had it is a 40-hour week. That is the norm and the maximum is on this basis of 43½ over the entire year. So I would ask Senators to see that between these proportions we have struck a reasonable balance.
Comment on this
I could understand this if it came from somebody other than the Minister because I could not accept what he has submitted just now in defence of this section. I am not concerned about what they are doing in Europe and I do not believe we should wait for Europe. We are introducing our own legislation here and I hope we do not look over our shoulders in the process.
Another point I want to refer to in particular is that the Minister has emphasised that this is the maximum. The reason why I said I could understand it coming from somebody other than the Minister is that the Minister is in the happy position of knowing what the state of play is and every time I have spoken here in connection with this matter I have referred to the joint labour committees where the minimum is found to be the maximum and where that is found to be the application all the time. I defy contradiction on this. I would invite the Minister to check up in his Department and he will find not a single joint labour committee operating which provides for the type of maximum he refers to.
I would hope at least that we bear in mind we are dealing with people of over 16 years in this section. We are talking in terms of people who are working during school leave. We are talking about children at work, and I hold that it is not right for this State to legislate for children at work with a maximum of 50 hours a week, when the trade union movement has advanced so well that a 40-hour week is recognised as the maximum, after which they get overtime, and in submitting my amendment I am sure nobody else is advocating overtime for people.
It is about time we faced reality if we are going to do what we purport to do. This Bill is described as the Protection of Young Persons (Employment) Bill. Let us protect the young persons in employment and let us not compare them with adults. I repeat that the Minister is wrongly advised about this. I have often thought that people who are preparing legislation of this kind should indulge in a little bit of experience and see what is happening down on the floor. I and my colleague feel so intense about this one that we would rather see that this Bill eventually would provide for the minimum conditions —the minimum not the maximum. I would expect that if this goes through it will end up with union action to ensure that children who go to work and at 16 years of age are taken into employment will not in any circumstances be found to have regard to the maximum because there will be a different approach to it if the working week will be 40 hours or perhaps less after which they will be paid overtime, and there will be a limited amount of overtime that they will be allowed to do. It happens right through the trade union movement. I would entreat the Minister to have another look at this matter.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that between now and Report Stage he might discuss these aspects with the Irish Congress of Trade Unions with a view to carrying out an examination of the general run of trade union agreements in relation to working hours of young people, and have a look at the situation in relation to joint labour committees and industrial councils. If the general run indicates that ten hours a day in respect of young people is excessive, the necessary action can be taken on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I know that when one sees these maximum hours they seem excessive, but I would point out that there is a profound difference between the joint labour committees and what we are suggesting here. No joint labour committee sets out anywhere what maximum hours should be. They set down what the normal hours per week should be and the overtime rates applicable. So far as I know, the JLCs do not set down any hours of work beyond which, if worked, the employer will be prosecuted. That is what we are attempting to do here.