We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Protection of Young Persons (Employment) Bill, 1974: Committee Stage.

Contributions 175–373 of 373. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Protection of Young Persons (Employment) Bill, 1974
Enacted

No. 30 of 1974 ›

I challenge the Minister on this. His advice is wrong.

Comment on this

All right. I take Senator Kennedy's suggestion. I wish to conclude by saying that what Senator Kennedy said, I shall certainly accede to. On any contention here today, I shall examine it very carefully between now and Report Stage and consult with the people concerned.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister to have regard to the spreadover? When we speak of a maximum of ten hours, some of the people attempting to justify this Bill, including the Minister, have regard to spreadover. You can have a person at your beck and call with a spreadover duty of ten hours. There is no mention of that here. It stated "a maximum of ten hours", but the young person might be in the position where he could not go home.

Comment on this

This is not a point of argument but I should like clarification by the Minister. I was trying to have a look at this Bill in the back of a car and I can assure Senator Yeats that it is far more difficult than reading it in an aeroplane. I know of situations where young people between the ages of 16 and 18 have a working week of 37½ hours. Would the section, as it is written, facilitate any subsequent employment in these concerns if we increase the hours of work? I shall rephrase this. There are many employments where the hours of work for people between the ages of 16 and 18 years is 37½ hours per week. We like to stress the need for leisure time for sporting activities and, with the lower voting age of 18 years, for involvement in youth political work. In some areas the trade union movement has succeeded in achieving a 37½ hour week. The position is static at the moment. I am not quite clear whether this section would allow the employer, if he is subsequently going to employ people between the ages of 16 and 18 years, to say that this section states that the working week should be one of 40 hours.

If the law is not written correctly, the employer can invoke the law and say that he can now make employees work 40 hours a week. Some young persons may be in their jobs from about 14 years of age; and if a new situation develops where young people are employed at 16 years because of the higher school leaving age, this problem may arise. I should like to know if young people already employed to work a 37½ hour week can be protected? They might be in danger.

Comment on this

Like Senator Harte, I should like some clarification. Perhaps the difficulty here arises because of the way in which the section is drafted. It seems to me that there is a relationship between the hours to be worked in paragraphs (b), (c) and (d) which goes in a descending order. In other words, you cannot work 50 hours per week for 50 weeks of the year. Therefore there is a danger that perhaps the Minister is being accused and the House, if it were to pass this legislation, could also be accused of legalising and authorising continuous working at the rate of 50 hours per week for 50 weeks of the year, assuming a minimum of two weeks' holidays.

Likewise, it is impossible to work 12½ consecutive periods of 190 hours for a period of four weeks. If one were to work continuously at the rate of 50 hours per week under (b), one would be working for 2,500 hours per year, which would exceed the maximum in (d) by 400 hours. If one were to work continuously at the rate of 190 hours in every period of four consecutive weeks, then one would be working 2,375 hours in a 50-week year which again would exceed the maximum as laid down in (b). My mathematics may be wrong, but it seems to me that the average number of hours in a year which is being permitted under (d) is 42 hours per week. So what this legislation is saying is that no young person may on average over the year work more than 42 hours a week in a 50-week year.

If somebody works a week of 50 hours then he has to work another week at the rate of 30 hours in order to work out the average over the year. In fact, the maximum number of hours allowed in (b) is not too far away from the necessary social objective which all of us have here of a 40-hour week because then over 50 weeks the maximum yearly hours worked would be 2,000. We are only 100 hours over that desirable maximum.

I should be grateful if the Minister would explain the reasoning behind the relationship between (b), (c) and (d) because it seems to me that the relationship between these three periods is that one sets a base for the maximum amount of hours to be worked in any one year but there could be a situation where an unscrupulous employer could employ a young person for nine months of the year and in that nine months make him work the maximum number of hours. He could thereby increase the weekly average number of hours worked by one third. He would still be employing him for a number of hours below the annual average but he could grossly exceed the weekly average. If the employer were to condense the annual average number of hours into six months employment, he could be permitted to have somebody working for 84 hours a week.

It seems to me that the idea set down in (b), (c) and (d) was to prevent that type of situation arising. But there is another interpretation possible and that is that we are giving some kind of social acceptability of what would be extremely long hours of work. Anyone who would say that a young person could work for ten hours per day over 50 weeks of the year would be endorsing a very distressing social situation and one which none of us could condone or support.

Is the purpose of (b) and (c) in relation to (d) to permit a certain variability in the daily and weekly hours worked but imposing a limit on the variability so that on average a young person may not work for more than 42 hours a week? If young people, say, on a 37½ hour week as Senator Harte has indicated, go on overtime, say over a period of ten weeks, could we then have a situation where because of the maximum in (d) people would be forced to work perhaps 35 hours per week to comply with the legal maximum and then be at a loss in wages over five or six weeks at the end of the year. Towards the end of the year every employer will have to log up the hours by any young person in order to see that the young person does not exceed the 2,100-hour maximum. If people still object to the inclusion of (a), (b) and (c), the point can be met simply by excluding them altogether and simply by retaining (d). It looks as if (d) should be reduced to 2,000 hours which would meet the 40-hour week, but that would not prevent an employer using a situation to bunch somebody into a shorter period than 50 weeks.

It may be the House would decide to have (d) in in order to prevent a misrepresentation of (a), (b) and (c). On the other hand, I can see real danger unless the House not only ensures a maximum on an annual basis but also a maximum on a monthly and indeed on a weekly and on a daily basis. There is a great deal of social benefit to be gained by preventing young people from working more hours than a certain norm on a daily basis, on a weekly basis and on a monthly basis. In certain circumstances I once myself, to the ruination perhaps of my health, worked on the basis of 20 hours per day for six days a week over a period of some months. Young people would want to do that sort of thing in specific circumstances simply to make money. This is obviously wrong and has got to be prevented. As far as I understood, that was the intent in (a), (b) and (c), but if it is going to be misinterpreted perhaps the best thing would be to simply eliminate them altogether and leave in (a), perhaps amended downwards.

Comment on this

Senator Halligan has made an interesting point, but before I deal with it I should mention that his calculations in regard to (d) are not quite accurate. As I understand the Minister's calculation, what is involved is perhaps three weeks holidays. The Minister's calculation is 43½ hours on average taken over the whole year, not 42. It is quite substantially over 40 which to a 16-year old seems excessive. If it is spread over the whole year, 40 hours would seem to be the absolute maximum that should be authorised.

With regard to the point about an unscrupulous employer bunching the work, it could be done in this way. One is allowed 50 hours in a week or 190 in any four consecutive weeks, which is very high. That is three weeks of 50 hours and one of 40 hours. By running that consecutively in about 44 weeks one would have run out of time and the young person would have a remaining eight weeks. As against that, under the Minister's amendment of 42 hours, there would have to be 25 per cent extra in overtime for this period beyond normal working hours. The income of the young person concerned would probably be higher at the end of the year. He would have an enforced holiday at the end of the year but his income would be higher than by working in a more normal way.

Comment on this

He could spend the enforced holiday in a sanatorium.

Comment on this

There is a point and it would be interesting to hear what the Minister has to say on it. It is very hard to say how to stop it but it is fair to say that the young person would end up with more money than he otherwise would.

Comment on this

We must remember we are talking about the protection of young people here. To add further to the points made by Senator Halligan and Senator Yeats, I have been looking at it from the point of view of the casual employee. A youngster over 16 years of age taking on casual employment could be told by his employer that he wanted regular work done irrespective of who is doing it. He can work that youngster at 50 hours a week for three weeks and then let him go and take on another youngster and continue on the same routine. By doing that he is certainly exceeding the 2,100 hours in any year by employing a continuing number of young people and he is not breaking the maximum monthly figure of 190 hours because he is not keeping the youngster beyond three or four weeks. If he works them 50 hours for three weeks and then another 40 hours and then lets them go and take on another youngster, there is a deficit there, and we are talking about the protection of young people.

Comment on this

The point I want to make is that we all naturally support all efforts to prevent abuse and overloading of young people. I should like to call the Minister's attention to the overload that is very prevalent among many young people in the schools and in the universities where you have students in secondary schools who work four, five or six nights a week after a day's work in school and are putting in more hours than is mentioned in this section. I do not know if anything can be done about this but at least we should realise that there is a very significant overwork problem associated with education.

Comment on this

I am especially struck by the point made by Senator Markey there about the casual worker. Certainly it would not be our intention at all that that could happen. That would not be our intention but I am afraid it could happen as I see it at present. It is difficult to provide for all contingencies. We must remember the employee is the person concerned who went over the four-week period. From that point on there would be a check in the control. I certainly will go back on this in the Report Stage to see if we can prevent, even over the four week period, this kind of thing happening on a continuous basis.

Senator Halligan put some points. Over the year, taking in the holidays, our average would be a 43-hour week. That would be the maximum and I do not know if we are doing ourselves a service in attempting to mention the figure 50. That is what it would be over a year where a person was in continuous employment—43 hours is the maximum permitted on average. Above that the employer breaks the law. I will look very carefully again at this section to see whether there is any escape route that an unscrupulous employer could take whereby a young person would be penalised over long hours. Senator Harte has also raised the question of getting a 37-hour week. Of course there is no problem at all about that. There is nothing in this legislation that would in any way affect that being effected.

Comment on this

The point I made is that the fellow has been in the job since he was 14 years of age. Now the new people coming on because of the higher school leaving age will be employed at 16 and over.

Comment on this

Why distinguish between under and over 16 years?

Comment on this

It may be relevant to the section.

Comment on this

If the Senators will bear with me, we have worked it out on average. What we have been trying to do is to work it out over the year to see that it came up with a fair average, to get some reasonable check-off where there would be an absolute breaking of the law if somebody went above it. We have worked it out, as Senator Halligan has said, in a sort of gradation of circles, that over a shorter period a longer maximum is permitted while over the longer period the figure comes down. Perhaps we have adopted a complicated procedure in this but for Report Stage I will look at this again.

In a section desiring to cover all cases, legislation covering all sorts of work situations, it is possible that by a particular combination—for example, the casual person comes to mind—a young person even with this legislation possibly in a few exceptional cases could be penalised with overlong hours. To avoid that I will certainly look at it again because I am aware of the point made, I think by Senator Halligan, that the young people themselves may by spirit be inclined to work overlong hours. He referred to his own experience and it has been my experience. I recall at 17 working an 80-hour week and it did not do me any good either.

Trade union conditions, of course, obviously vary, but I can certainly assure Senators that I will look at this once more and I will discuss it with the interests involved to see if we can come up with something even better on this. As I explained in the other House, as well as in this House, I am only too happy to incorporate workman-like suggestions in legislation. I will certainly follow that out in this section because it is not my intention to produce legislation which does not do the utmost possible for the young people it seeks to help. I will have a look at that again for Report Stage.

Comment on this

I would never accuse the Minister of having bad intentions in connection with this Bill because I know his interest in working people and I take the point he has made that he is going to give this matter further consideration. I would ask him also to bear in mind that what we are seeking to do is to protect young people in employment not from good employers —I have already said there are very good employers—but from the unscrupulous employers. The Minister would be well advised to take into consideration lumpers in the building trade who can slash in all the hours they want with a young person or anyone else they employ.

Comment on this

I think we are inclined to get away from one original task, to protect young people. There is no doubt that we are talking about protecting young people from bad employers and these employers will be only too anxious to try and circumvent any regulations that may exist. They have been using the least well represented class of workers in this Irish community, namely the young people. They have nobody to represent them and to stand up for their side and we must not forget this. We must try and write everything into this Bill. We have got to write into it a specific regulation regarding casual and permanent work.

Comment on this

Perhaps the distinctions between sections 7 and 8 might be eliminated. The relationship between (a), (b), (c) and (d) in subsection (1) should be descending all the time. In other words, ten hours in any one day should not be 50 hours in the week; it should be less. It should not be possible to work five days at the maximum under (a). It should not be possible under (c) to work the maximum as permitted in (d); and likewise it should not be possible under (d) to work the maximum in (c) on a continual basis. The section has been complicated by the fact that (b), (c) and (d) have a specific relationship with each other but the relationship does not exist between (a) and (b). That is what is causing the confusion. Perhaps it might be looked at anyway. Perhaps there might be no distinction between those under and those over the age of 16 years, taking into account the point that Senator Harte has been making in regard to the new school leaving age.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 21 and 26 can be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In subsection (1), page 6, to delete "other" in paragraphs (a) and (b) and substitute "lower".

In regard to amendments Nos. 21 and 26, they are both dealing with the same points. Section 7 refers to the maximum hours of work for young persons over the age of 16 years. None of us would consider for a moment that it should get any higher. Paragraph (a) states that ten hours in any day may be specified and paragraphs (b) and (c) refer to 50 hours in any week and 190 hours in any period of four consecutive weeks. I do not believe any trade union would make an agreement which would raise the hours beyond ten in the day but I think it would be a good thing just to establish the point and to say that it may be varied. My amendment says ten hours in any one day or a lower number of hours as may be specified in an agreement.

In section 9 subsection (2), we find that a similar point. The hours of work specified in paragraphs (a) and (b) of that subsection—ten hours a day and 50 hours a week may be varied by an agreement or by regulation made by the Minister. I do not think that the Minister would for a moment think of increasing them but nevertheless I think it would be wise to say they be varied downwards by an agreement or by regulations made by the Minister. We should establish the point in this legislation that these are definitely maxima and that under no circumstances could they be made any higher.

Comment on this

I should like to support Senator Yeats. I harp back to the point that young people of 16 years and in that age bracket do not have anyone acting on their behalf. They do not have a trade union to make any agreement on their behalf. The agreement may have to be made between themselves and their employer. I think the State has got to act on their behalf if that is the purpose of this Bill in the first instance.

Comment on this

The most sensible thing to say is that we may take this in conjunction with the rest of our discussion on the hours. Most collective agreements do not have this provision about the upper limit but I certainly will have a look at it for Report Stage. I think I should look at it in conjunction, because it is possible to recast the section to make more clear our intent to stop some of the possible, perhaps rare abuses, we may have to change the order about.

Comment on this

Section 7 refers to persons over 16 years and section 8 refers to persons under 16 years. It seems to me that, as we are going through the Bill, we are going up the age bracket. There is a sort of inversion. What is the reason for it?

Comment on this

There is no great issue of principle here. I will see if we can change the order.

Comment on this

With regard to amendment No. 23, this is in accordance with what the Minister has said, that he is giving further consideration to this.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 29 has already been discussed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:

In subsection (1), line 53, to delete "of age".

This is merely a drafting amendment. I do not propose to speak on it unless the Minister feels that I should. The word "age" appears twice, once before and once after "sixteen".

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 31 has been already discussed.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 32, 33 and 34 may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:

In subsection (1), paragraph (a), page 6, to delete "nine" in line 55 and substitute "eight".

We have had a lot of discussion on these general topics. Here again, nine hours in any day for a person under 16, and these are 15-year-olds, seems a great deal. In view of the fact that we are getting towards a normal 40-hour week, to ask a 15-year-old to work 40 hours, which is supposed to be the maximum for an adult, seems altogether excessive. I suggest, as Senator Mullen and Senator Kennedy have done, that eight hours ought to be more than enough in any one day. I suggest that 35 hours in a week for a 15-year-old is a very adequate working week.

Comment on this

I will have to look at it, with the other sections.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister why in this case he does not have any paragraph (c). There is 12 months between the ages 15 and 16 years and it is rather puzzling to find that there is no mention of how long these young people can work in any four weeks. In section 7 a person can work 50 hours a week but, as Senator Halligan rightly points out, when it comes to four successive weeks they are cut down a bit, so it is 190 instead of 200 hours. In this case a person can work 40 hours in a week and then in any four weeks there is nothing stopping him doing 160 hours. I would have thought the Minister could have put in something like 150 hours or some figure like this. I did not put down an amendment because I thought there might be some reason for it but I would like the Minister to consider the question.

Comment on this

I thought it was a tighter formula than in the other cases and that is why we do not have that provision there. I will certainly have a look at it to see whether we can improve it.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40 and 41 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

This is essentially a drafting amendment. The draftsman has advised us that in the light of the reference to normal working hours in the definition in section 1 there should not be reference in section 9 (1) to sections 5 and 10. Subsection (2), dealing with offences, is being transposed to the new section which follows in relation to overtime pay where it relates to the type of situation for which it was originally intended.

Comment on this

We are really in the same situation except this is on a different section. This is not a matter of maximum hours of work. This is a question of normal working hours.

In amendment No. 42, which I may not discuss yet, we cannot but recognise its existence. The Minister is providing that 25 per cent overtime pay should be paid to everyone who works more than these normal working hours. Essentially therefore we are not discussing here the actual hours that these young people will be working but the number of hours they have to work before they can begin to get overtime pay. I am not going into it in detail. We have had a good deal of discussion on this question of hours but I would suggest that for a 16-year-old, eight hours in a day and 40 hours in a week seems a long time before the employer has to start paying overtime. Indeed, as maximum hours of work, they seem long enough without having overtime on top of this. In the case of a person between 15 and 16 years, in paragraph (b) of subsection (1) they can work eight hours in a day before they start being paid overtime. I put down these amendments, which of course I am not going to press. These hours are excessive and I suggest they should be reduced, as Senator Mullen and Senator Kennedy also suggest in a couple of amendments. Perhaps the Minister would consider these along with the various other items he is considering between now and Report Stage.

Comment on this

I have considered that the 40 hours here is a reasonable provision as a normal working week. That has been my approach in this area, but I will certainly have a look at it since I have decided to have a look at other hour sections for Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister is having another look at this. I would ask him to bear in mind that we are thinking in terms of a normal working week for young people. My understanding of things is that the State recognises the normal working week as being 40 hours. Consideration ought also be given to the amendments that Senator Fintan Kennedy and I found necessary to submit. We are looking for a distinct difference, not much of a difference, between conditions for a boy and a man.

Comment on this

On subsection (2), I am a bit puzzled why it says a person who contravenes subsection (1) of this section shall be guilty of an offence. The only offence I can imagine under this section would be the non-payment of overtime and the only person who could be guilty of such an offence would presumably be an employer. I am wondering why the Minister says a "person" since in other cases he says "employer" where offences are to be committed by the employer. I should have thought that in this case it would be clearer.

Comment on this

That is deleted under amendment No. 35.

Comment on this

This is subsection (2) which is not amended.

Comment on this

It is deleted.

Comment on this

I am refering to section 9, subsection (2), which reads:

A person who contravenes subsection (1) of this section shall be guilty of an offence.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Subsection (2) has been deleted by the House accepting amendment No. 35.

Comment on this

The Minister in introducing amendment No. 35 merely referred to the problem of normal working hours, referred to it in section 1 and said it was a drafting amendment. It is more than a drafting amendment. It is an amendment of some substance because it appears to eliminate the offence under subsection (2) and I wonder why this is so.

Comment on this

We transferred it to section 10. That is why I referred to it as a drafting amendment. It does not disappear, it is just transferred.

Comment on this

I am happy to see that in this case he uses the word "employer" and not "person".

Comment on this

This amendment provides that overtime pay at the rate of time and one quarter will apply to young workers covered by the Bill in respect of hours worked between normal hours and maximum hours. This preserves the entitlement under earlier legislation of young workers in hotels, shops and in industry. Representations had been made to me that there might be a worsening of their situation. We decided to meet that objection by this amendment and I would ask Senators to support it.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 43 and 44 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:

Before subsection (1) to insert a new subsection as follows:

In this section "stated number of hours" in relation to an employee means—

(a) five hours if the employee is a young person

(b) four hours if the employee is a child.

The problem here is that in section 11 the Bill provides that an employee can be allowed to work a period of five hours at a stretch and only after five hours must the employer give him a half-an-hour off before he can start again. Five hours seems a long time and it seems a particularly long time for a 14-year old. My amendment, therefore, proposes that if the employee is a child, that is aged 14 to 15 years, he should be allowed to work for four hours before he has to have the half-hour off. This would not apply in the school term but in school holidays when he can work seven hours daily. If he is 14 years old he should be allowed to work for only four hours without a break; if he is 15 to 18 years that he can work the five hours as specified in the Bill.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

I should like to refer to subsection (7) of section 11. This provides—I am not altogether clear as to its implications—that, where an employee is employed to do industrial work within the meaning of the various Acts on shift work, the five hours does not apply. In other words, on shift work an employee could work more than the five hours provided in this Bill. The four hours will not apply because a child cannot do industrial work.

I can see the need for this but I think that it is going a bit far in the case of a 15-year-old. I suggest that we might limit this to perhaps people over 16 years and that the Minister might consider amending subsection (7) to say that it will not apply to an employee over 16 years who is employed to do industrial work, because a 15-year-old on shift work doing six or seven hours at a stretch seems rather a lot.

Comment on this

He will get his break after three hours under the existing legislation.

Comment on this

It is better for him rather than worse. I am happy to hear it and I am sorry we cannot insert the three hours in other places.

Comment on this

I am not sure what this means. Subsection (1) of section 12 says that where the employee has to work more than five days in a week and is also required to do more than three hours work on a Sunday, then he must have a full day's rest in every period of seven days. This means that if he has to work on Sunday he must have at least one day off in the week. He has to work a six-day week. Subsection (2) states that this section shall not apply to an employee who is employed to do industrial work. Shift work is not mentioned here. I am not sure what is meant by saying that it does not apply. Does it mean that he need not have a day off, or that he has two days off? Perhaps the Minister could explain the implications of subsection (2) which, on the face of it, seems rather sinister.

Comment on this

The more restrictive sections of the 1936 Act apply here and they prohibit industrial work on a Sunday by young persons except in certain cases such as newspaper printing and publishing. The young person who works on Sunday in any of these accepted occupations must be allowed 24 hours' rest before the next following Sunday. That comes under section 49 of the 1936 Act.

Comment on this

That appears to be the same as subsection (1) of section 12, which says that if he works on Sunday he will get the day off anyway.

Comment on this

It is more favourable.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:

To delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:—

"(1) An employer shall neither permit any young person to do any work at any time between the hour of 8.00 p.m. on any day and the hour of 8.00 a.m. on the following day."

In moving this amendment I want to make the point that I do so as a result of serious consideration that has been given to this section by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. I feel it is important that I should say this. We want the section amended to read:

An employer shall neither permit any young person to do any work at any time between the hour of 8.00 p.m. on any day and the hour of 8.00 a.m. on the following day.

There are a host of reasons for this. In order to have a proper understanding of it, it is important that I should say that section 13 prohibits the employment of any young person between the hour of 10 p.m. on any day and the hour of 6 a.m. the following day. The observation of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions on this is they have to have regard to other legislation in existence.

For example, section 47 of the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936, prohibits the employment of any young person between the hours of 8 p.m. on any day and the hour of 8 a.m. on the following day unless such young person is a male young person. In the 1936 Act the expression "young person" means a worker whose age is less than 18 years and more than 14 years. Therefore under this Bill the position of young females between 15 and 18 years has worsened. The existing prohibition in the Conditions of Employment Act should be extended to all young persons, every single one of them, and to nonindustrial employment. This is what we are advocating. I should ask the Minister to have another look at it. While he is doing this, would he also examine what I have already spoken about: the importance of keeping one's eye on the spreadover duty. I know the Minister understands what I am talking about from his own experience.

Comment on this

I am quite certain the Minister would not wish to worsen the legal position of women workers under any circumstances, particularly not in International Women's Year.

Comment on this

I am moving amendment No. 46 to preserve the conditions of young industrial workers covered by the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936. Section 13 will then apply to all other sectors of employment and will represent an improvement in the conditions of shop and hotel workers and those not previously covered by legislation. This means that the section will represent for the first time protection under that section for about one-third of the young persons covered by the Bill. Taken with the provisions on normal and maximum hours the provisions of section 13 represent a realistic and good advance.

Comment on this

The Minister might consider them realistic but I submit that it is important to give this more consideration, especially having regard to the point I made about spreadover duty. In other sections of the Bill provision is suggested for a young person being employed for ten hours a day. If we are to take steps to ensure that they do not work within a certain period of time we must have regard to the spreadover and there is no point in regulating the situation at one end and forgetting about it at the other end. If the Minister will not give further consideration to this amendment I would suggest that we will not put it to vote but we will have something to say about it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

My anxiety is to preserve the conditions of young industrial workers who are covered by the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936. Section 13 specifies that young persons may not be employed between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. and they must also be allowed a 12-hour break from the time at which work ceased on any day. It has been represented to me that the position of young industrial workers under the 1936 Act, where work is prohibited between 8 p.m. and 8 a.m., should be preserved and that is why I am proposing this amendment here. I would ask for the support of Senators on this because I think it makes for an improvement in the situation.

Comment on this

We agree cheerfully to this amendment of the Minister. I am sorry that this amendment, and indeed a few others of this nature are drafted in this way. If one is trying to find out the situation either by looking at the amendment now or in later years looking at this Act when one looks at the section, as amended, all one will see is the reference to section 3 of the Conditions of Employment Act which has, as the Minister knows, an extensive list of different types of employment which are classified as industrial employment. There is no reference to the specific section which governs the working hours of those who are covered under that Act. It would be much preferable, if an amendment of this kind is becoming a section of the Bill, that there be a reference to the actual section of the Act concerned which provides for the hours of the young person concerned. Otherwise, in reading this Bill you will find out on the first subsection of section 13 the hours allowed under this Bill but you will not see anything in the new subsection (2) about where the hours are to be found for the people concerned in the industrial work under conditions of employment as modified by the Conditions of Employment Act and so on. There is no reference of any kind as to where this legislation can be got and it seems unnecessarily complicated for anyone who is trying to look into this.

Comment on this

We will be providing explanatory material. This point has been made before. I think Senator Mullen spoke on this—and Senator Harte—on the last occasion. We will be providing clear explanatory material so that the people concerned will be able to understand its provisions.

Comment on this

I appreciate that, but the trouble is that lawyers who read these Bills are not really interested in pamphlets: they like to see in the legislation what it is all about. If the Minister would again tell me the section of the Act concerned I will see if I can exercise my ingenuity on this before Report Stage.

Comment on this

Section 47 of the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936.

Comment on this

This section is opposed for the same reason as we sought the deletion of subsections (2) and (3) of section 4. As the Minister has given us assurances of dealing with section 4 on the Report Stage, we take it the assurance applies also to section 14 and, on that basis, we withdraw our opposition.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47.

Before subsection (3) to insert a new subsection as follows:

"(3) A parent or guardian of an employee who facilitates an employer in acting in contravention of this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section."

We have submitted this amendment because we believe that the House should have regard to the fact that already there is provision in regard to employers having a good defence when a situation reaches a certain stage. I think it is imperative that we do not give anybody an opportunity of breaking the intention of the Bill, or this particular section of the Bill. It is important that no parent or parents should be given an opportunity of conspiring to defeat the Bill, bearing in mind that the objective is to act in the interest of the young person concerned. I am repeating now when I say that the employer will be considered to have a good defence and therefore I hold that, if there is a new provision made making a parent or guardian liable, it would be a greater protection to ensure that there is not multiple employment in excess of the hours fixed by the Bill. It would be wrong if we had any sort of outlet given to young persons to do two jobs. I am very conscious that adults, because of the way things are going, find it necessary to have two jobs, but in their own interests we should not allow children to do this.

Comment on this

I accept the sense of what the Senator is attempting to achieve here. Again, I think there was an amendment to accept it in principle earlier today from the Senator. We accept it, as I say and unless there are some drafting changes—I think it is roughly the same as what the Senator requests— we would suggest that a new subsection be inserted to read: "In page 8 before subsection (3) to insert the following new subsection to read: the parent or guardian of an employee who aids or abets an employer in the contravention of this section shall be guilty of an offence." The Senators can have their choice of whether they are accepting that now or would prefer to have a look at it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I would be worried about this. I am entirely in favour of the concept that parents should be prosecuted if they are allowing their children to accept obviously unsuitable and unlawful employment. We should remember that the concept in subsection (1) of section 15 is quite complex. First, there is no offence at all in allowing your child to work for two people on the same day. The only offence arises if he works beyond permitted hours. I am not at all sure that parents would know what these were. Take the Murphy family, for example. You have little John, aged 14. He is allowed to work for seven hours in the day if it is during school holidays. Joe, who is aged 15, is entitled to work nine hours in one day; and Bill is, shall we say, aged 16, and can work ten hours in a particular day. To expect parents to be able to remember these varying times and to add up the total time worked in respect of each child with two employers is a tricky operation and I am not sure that many of us, a couple of days from now, will be able to remember precisely the times involved for the different ages. While in other parts of this Bill I would be in favour of inserting subsections to fix the parents with responsibility, in this case it is peculiarly the employer who ought to know this and I am very worried about the idea of going to the parents.

Comment on this

I think the view has been expressed that without general co-operation from members of the community any part of this legislation would be virtually useless, because it would require that kind of support and assent to be really successful in all its provisions. We should make some attempt to involve the parents in this. That is my thinking on it and that is why I more or less agreed to that amendment of Senator Mullen, that we should try to arrange for the parents to be so involved. It does not, obviously, cater for parents who, as the Senator suggests, forget some details; it talks about aids or abets. But if the Senator has any different wording to suggest or what he considers a better formulation, I would be prepared to look at it on Report Stage, as I am sure Senator Mullen himself would also be prepared to do. What we are anxious to do is to try to nail the parent or guardian who is aiding or abetting.

Comment on this

I doubt if you will catch anyone; they will just say they did not know.

Comment on this

I can understand Senator Yeats's diligence. I appreciate many of the points he made and I admire him for the patience he has taken in examining this Bill. However, may I direct his attention to the fact that we are seeking to do something in connection with subsection (3). Subsection (3) reads:

Where an employer is prosecuted for an offence under this section it shall be a defence for him to prove that he did not know or could not, by reason of the inquiry, have known that the employee has done work for any other employer on the day in respect of which the prosecution is brought.

If we are going to do this, surely it follows that we must further protect a child with a view to ensuring that the parents do not get in on the act. That is the only purpose of the amendment and I am glad the Minister recognises that.

Comment on this

I think Senator Yeats is prepared to accept that. I would be prepared to look at it.

Comment on this

I am all for this. If the parents were brought to court they would just say: "We knew that he was working for two employers but we had no idea that the hours exceeded the permitted level." I am not sure that it would be very effective. If there could be some way of putting an obligation on the parents to inform each employer that there was another employer, then you could get after the employer to check on it.

Comment on this

Would the Senator bear in mind that these children have no real protection? The trade union movement cannot protect people who are not organised. I imagine that this Bill is directed at situations where there are unorganised children at work and, that being so, it is imperative that parents look after them. But in some cases, unfortunately, through force of circumstances or otherwise the parent does not take the necessary interest and it would be absolutely wrong to give an opportunity for a child to work twice, or for two employers in the one day.

Comment on this

Does the section refer to children? My reading of it is "... shall not permit an employee". In this section a child is not mentioned.

Comment on this

It covers children.

Comment on this

Does it cover employees other than children?

Comment on this

It covers both.

Comment on this

This is what I want to be clear about.

Comment on this

It covers both.

Comment on this

Yes, but the section reads "... shall not permit an employee...." I am referring to adults. Does this section refer to adults?

Comment on this

No. The Bill does——

Comment on this

I am all for this proposed subsection about the offence committed by parents. But I think it could be put in more effectively in sections 13 and 14. Parents should know at what time of night children of 14 years of age should be home. I suggest that the Minister look at a number of sections in this Bill, particularly in regard to cases where it was fairly simple for parents to keep an eye on their children—as they should keep an eye on them— to see if he could bring them to accept their responsibilities. This refers not only to section 15 but to other sections also. Perhaps he could insert some sort of all-embracing section which would do the job.

Comment on this

I suggested a reformulation of that. I shall bring it in on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

This is a drafting amendment and it arises from a recommendation made by our legal luminaries to the effect that it makes it more explicit in relation to sections dealing with hours of work and the dealing with hours of work and the nature of a defence which an employer who was genuinely unaware of the fact of double employment, can present. That is what it is designed to bring about.

Comment on this

On subsection (2):

Wherever an employer employs an employee in contravention of this section the employer shall be guilty of an offence under this section. The employee shall also be committing an offence under this section.

I am a little worried about young persons of 14 years of age being prosecuted. To suggest that a 14-year-old person who has worked for too long a number of hours, or who has worked for too many employers and so on could be prosecuted, is going a bit far. Perhaps the Minister could have a look at this. If he deleted the word "employee" and inserted "the parents" all would be solved.

Comment on this

Again, what we have been trying to ensure is that young people themselves, if they wilfully break the law, shall have the law equally invoked against them. But I shall have a look at it again.

Comment on this

I think a distinction should be drawn in that section between those of 15 years of age, those of school leaving age, and children over that age.

Comment on this

I shall have a look at it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 9, lines 3, 19 and 24, after "Act", to insert "other than section 4".

This is a very general kind of section which, putting it rather broadly, enables the Minister to do nearly anything. It states:

He may, in any case where he is satisfied that the health, welfare and safety of employees are not endangered by regulations, modify any provisions in this Act in respect of any undertaking....

I want to insert "other than section 4" because section 4, which relates to children of 14 or 15 years, should be the maximum and there should not be any suggestion that the requirements of section 4 could in any way be relieved. I am prepared to concede with regard to the rest of the Bill that circumstances could easily arise of a complex nature which would require the Minister, by regulations and so on, to make changes. The Minister has power in several subsections of section 4 by order, affirmative and otherwise, to vary hours and conditions. I think that in section 16 it would be wise to eliminate section 4 and just allow the Minister this general power to change the remainder of the Bill.

Comment on this

The purpose of the powers of exemption in section 16 is to ensure that there should be some flexibility in the application of the general legislation and the section, as drafted, already contains a number of constraints on my powers of exemption. There is the necessity to publish notice of my intention to make regulations under subsection (3) and there is a further obligation of consultation with representatives of employers and employees. Together these ensure that the community in general can know what is proposed by way of exemption under the Act at any time.

The suggested amendment would remove this element of flexibility in regard to the minimum age for employment covered by section 4, which might have the unfortunate consequence that it could frustrate particularly certain possibilities which I see in combined schemes of employment, experience and educational training which can be developed under subsection (5). Such schemes are a very interesting and important section of this Bill. They may not excite a great deal of interest but I think they are very important sections and in time it will be seen that they form some of the more interesting parts of this legislation—possibly the most interesting part.

There will inevitably be a period of experimentation in regard to the curricula and the combination of employment and experience. Senator Horgan raised this matter and referred to two schemes which are at present in operation. But such projects of combined work and educational training are in their infancy. Many problems remain to be resolved because we are not quite clear what the blend should be yet nor do we see any national pattern emerging. I should like to leave the way open for the development of suitable schemes for the 13 to 15 year age group, to whom I referred this afternoon, who may be less academically inclined. In the circumstances outlined I would not at this time see my way to accepting that amendment. The Senator will understand that this is not for any frivolous purpose.

Comment on this

I should like some information from the Minister. Subsection (4) states:

"The Minister may, by licence, exempt any class of employers from complying with any provision of this Act or of regulations under this Act, in any case where, in the opinion of the Minister, compliance with such provision would be impracticable.

"The Minister may, by licence, exempt ..."—this is too broad. It is like giving a licence to adult employees to work shifts. In that case, where workers are organised would the trade unions be notified to see if they had any objections to arrangements?

Comment on this

There would be consultation with unions. We covered that in another subsection.

Comment on this

The practice under the Conditions of Employment Act is that, where a change is to be made in working hours or conditions, the trade union must be notified.

Comment on this

In subsection (5) we speak about "any class of employers". I may suggest an amendment here on Report Stage which would possibly relate it to individual employers, because we must leave the way open for experimentation to take place in this area. Unfortunately, we are unlikely to see a class of employer taking part in such schemes for some considerable time.

Comment on this

This amendment provides that, after consultation with the Minister for Education, I may grant exemption licences where employers participate in schemes which combine limited employment experience with education or training. This provision arose as a result of suggestions made by both educational interests and youth leaders. I have been asked by the employee interests to consult with trade unions and employers. That is a good suggestion, and I accept it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

To add a new subsection as follows:

"(8) Every licence issued under this section shall be published in ‘Iris Oifigiúil' as soon as may be after it is made."

These licences granted under subsections (4), (5), (6) and (7) cover a lot of ground. For example, under subsection (4) the Minister may, by licence, exempt any class of employers from complying with any provision of this Bill or with regulations under this Bill in any case where the Minister considers it to be impracticable. Under subsection (5) the Minister may, after consultation with the Minister for Education, by licence, exempt any class of employers from complying with any provision of this Bill or of regulations under this Bill where the employer is participating in an approved scheme which combines limited employment experience with education and training. The other subsections are consequent on these.

These are extensive powers. Unlike orders, which must be deposited before the Oireachtas, a licence is issued and disappears into the morgue. I do not know where licences go, but they are not available freely to the general public, although obviously they are received by the people immediately concerned. That would be desirable from the Minister's point of view because people would see that he was not in any way abusing the powers given to him under this section. Where licences are given to exempt all classes of employers from the provisions of this Bill, it would be desirable that they should be published in Iris Oifigiúil. This would show the public how the issue of licences was administered. As I said, these are fairly extensive powers and the Minister would benefit from being in a position to publish them.

Comment on this

The conditions imposed by this amendment would be somewhat wasteful because licences granted under the section would give exemptions to one or a small number of employers subject to conditions which would be imposed by me. There is an obligation on me before giving such licences to consult with representatives of the employees concerned. Naturally I have to comply with this part of the section. I will do this and will take full account of their observations. Therefore it seems unnecessary and contrary to the provision in other labour legislation to have such licences publicised on a nationwide basis after they have been granted.

Comment on this

They could be published for a particular industry.

Comment on this

Do I take it from the Minister's remarks that any employer will be in a position to apply for exemption to the Minister under this section?

Comment on this

He can apply, but whether he gets it is another matter.

Comment on this

I welcome this section. It is useful that the Minister should have this power. Most people speaking here today appear to be violently opposed to the employment of school children. When I was at school the tendency during the three months holidays was to play tennis and lie about. Senator Mullen stated that school children are given holidays to enjoy. In recent years the tendency has been for young people to seek employment on a fixed or part-time basis for part of their holiday, at the same time ensuring that they would have a certain amount of holidays during the period.

I am interested in the catering industry and can speak personally of my establishment, which is not very big. An average of 50 or 60 school children apply to me each year for employment. There are a number of reasons why parents want to see young people working. First, it helps to discipline the children, secondly, it keeps them off the streets—these are the main reasons given for seeking employment—and, thirdly, they need the money they may earn. I accept that no industry has been more responsible for exploitation than the catering industry. I also accept that the trade union movement has played a major role in trying to eliminate this exploitation. It is also true that there are many good employers in the catering industry who have not been guilty of exploitation. There is a danger that they too may suffer as a result of this legislation.

In my 13 or 14 years in business I can think of many young people who became teachers and so on who in their earlier days earned sufficient money to clothe themselves and to buy the necessary books to go through school and college. The fact that they were in a position to get work was very useful. The catering industry is seasonal. It would be very difficult to get sufficient workers from June to September to carry out the work without relying on students.

I accept that children under 14 years of age should not be employed. I accept also the provisions laid down in section 5, but I feel that some latitude should be given. If people are in a position to apply to the Minister for exemption, his Department's officials will then have an opportunity of studying the conditions under which they are working as sympathetically as possible. That is important for those engaged in the catering industry and for thousands of young people who will be looking for employment in the catering industry this summer. It is obvious that, as a result of this Bill, certain people who had expressed a desire to work in my own establishment this summer cannot now be given employment. Some of them are too young, but I hope the Minister will give favourable consideration to that industry when exemptions are applied for.

Comment on this

I did not intend speaking but I find it necessary to say something as a result of what Senator McGlinchey said. I have sympathy with part of what he said but if we were talking in terms of the ratio of juveniles as compared with senior people I could understand his point of view. We know from experience that there are many industries such as the catering industry, in which employment is described as "seasonal". This is not always true. All young people are employed in some areas. These people do not come under the trade unions and must be protected. We must also bear in mind the importance of maintaining good standards in the catering industry, because catering is the backbone of tourism.

We must also have regard to an important body which looks after the interests of people making a living out of the catering industry—CERT, the council for the education, recruitment and training of staff. They would not go along with the idea of training people for seasonal employment. We must bear in mind that we are trying to protect young people in employment and ensure they are not exploited. There are many good employers, even in the catering industry. But there are many who are exploiters. If we are to concern ourselves about children of necessity having to go to work, surely the obvious thing to do is to ensure that their parents are given better pay and working conditions, and so ensure that the children are left at school.

Comment on this

I would not be agreeable to giving wholesale exemptions. That would defeat the whole purpose of the Bill. I will look at any applications from an employer on its merits. But it would not be possible to give specific answers to future hypothetical cases. The feeling that there is a scarcity of workers in the catering industry cannot be used as an excuse for excessive hours for young workers in that industry. The unorganised section of the catering industry is one of the areas it is hoped this legislation can assist materially. However, there certainly will be that possibility open to an employer to make an application. Then of course, consultation with the employees concerned would follow. It is only fair to say that whole exemptions are not in contemplation under this section.

Comment on this

CERT are involved in the hotel industry mainly but there are other branches of the catering industry.

Comment on this

The hotel and restaurant section.

Comment on this

We have never come across them and certainly they have never helped.

Comment on this

They have been extended recently.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that there should be excessive hours. Nobody working for me works more than seven hours, no matter what their ages. But I feel that there would be exceptions. I know plenty of girls, in spite of what Senator Mullen might say, who want to work. Their main reason is that they are bored unless they are working during the summer. They are not prepared to spend three months doing nothing. This legislation could hit hard at many young people who want to work in this industry because they enjoy working.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

To add to the section a new subsection as follows:—

"(3) If in any proceedings involving a prosecution for a contravention of any provision of this Act it becomes evident to the Court that a sum of money is due by an employer to a person or persons it shall be competent for the Court to order the payment of such sum to such person or persons".

This is not a contentious amendment. One of the main reasons we have submitted this amendment is because we consider there should be no vagueness about the intention in this legislation. Senator Yeats referred to the importance of ensuring that people knew what an Act meant. As we say in working class circles: "It is hard to understand civil service language when it comes to an Act." Very often one is told that the Act did not mean this or that. We are advocating in this section that the Bill be given teeth and that the court be competent to make an award.

Comment on this

There is one aspect of that amendment with which I hope Senators Mullen and Kennedy would agree. Take the case of a person who enters employment and his employer does not stamp his cards. Sometimes this is not discovered until four or five years later, when the young person goes to draw his National Health benefit or goes to the labour exchange and gets no money. That is a loss of money to that boy. I do not propose at this time to confuse the issue. I will leave it as Senator Mullen and Senator Kennedy put it.

When the Minister comes back on Report Stage, he might bear that in mind, because not only is the person cheating the young employee, but he is also cheating the State. There is no effective legislation at this time, ever introduced by any Government to make an employer pay the stamp. A certain amount of pressure can be put on him. One can write to the Minister for Labour to put pressure on the employer to stamp the card.

For example, we came across this problem on several occasions—I hope Chairman Mao does not get to hear about it—when the Chinese opened a few shops but refused point blank to stamp their employees' cards. One employee wrote to the Department of Labour. They did their best to put pressure on the employers, but before they knew what hit them the man had gone out of business or moved somewhere else. To my personal knowledge, this happened to four employees. Such a situation is not covered in any Bill. If people are cheated out of their money, it would be a good start if they could recover it through the courts.

Comment on this

I urge the Minister to accept this very good amendment. The great problem is that in many cases the employee would be suing the employer for quite a small sum. Subsection (2) states that proceedings can be instituted and maintained on behalf of the employee by his trade union or by his parent or by his guardian. If it is a trade union he is all right, although going to law to recover what may be a very small sum is still a cumbersome, expensive and long-winded process. In many instances there is no trade union involved, particularly where young children are concerned. If there is no trade union involved, it is highly unlikely that the parents would either have the ability or the wish to go to court on a matter of this kind. In many cases there could be a prosecution by the State, and the parents then have not all the worry and upset of having to go to court. If it becomes clear that the money is due, as the amendment suggests, then all the court need do is to say to the employer, "Hand it over". That would be a very useful, short-circuited process.

Comment on this

I accept the point made in this amendment by Senator Mullen. Again, I am advised by our legal mandarins, following the imagery of Senator Harte's Chinese restaurant, that we could amend it by adding to section 10 a new section 4 as follows:

Whenever a court convicts an employer of an offence under the section, the court may, if it is satisfied that the employer is liable to pay to any of his employees a sum of money in respect of overtime pay, order the employer to pay that sum to any such employee.

Comment on this

Can I take it that amendment No. 52 is withdrawn, because it is not possible at this stage to make an amendment to section 10?

Comment on this

I appreciate that——

Comment on this

I accept the point. There must be some redrafting of this.

Comment on this

There is more than overtime involved here. There could be money due under section 19, which says that if working hours are reduced wages may not be reduced. In the case where wages were reduced, and there would obviously be some due, it would be fitting not to include that in the provision the Minister is making.

Comment on this

There is another point I should like the Minister to take into consideration. What Senator Yeats said earlier reminds me of it, that is, the financial inability of a parent or guardian to be able to go to court and engage the services of a solicitor and so on. If the Minister can devise any way in which that can be overcome it would be very proper.

Comment on this

We will get a few shillings from the Minister to help us with the legal funds of the unions to process claims like this.

Comment on this

The legal funds of the unions are all right, but I am thinking in terms of the unorganised people. The trade union movement provide a service of this kind for a member. What about the unfortunate child not covered by any trade union membership?

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to draft this document himself and not let anyone else do it. It needs to be in plain, simple English. I have the highest respect for civil servants and their work but if we start talking about young persons and all the other verbiage there is in this Bill, nobody will read or understand it.

Comment on this

It will be described in an abstract that must be displayed.

Comment on this

I have explained to the Senator that accompanying this legislation we will have notes that will explain clearly in more simple English some of the provisions of the legislation. It will be the abstract of the Act. Civil servants apart I do not know if any kind of drafting arrangement will get us away from the necessary obfuscations.

Comment on this

The Minister has me worried on this.

Every employer shall display at the principal entrances to the premises where any of his employees works, and in such other places as an inspector may require,

in such a position that it may be easily read by employees so employed the prescribed abstract of this Act.

It is there to be read by the employees, not by the Minister's inspectors or by the employer. In other words, it is children of 14 and young people of 15, 16 or 17 who have to read it. The abstract will be an utter waste of time if it is written in a legal fashion. It should be aimed at the 14- or 15-year-olds. Otherwise, the Minister can forget about it.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with the Senator. We will see what can be done in that direction.

Comment on this

There are two points on this. Paragraph (a) of subsection (1), like the rest of this rather long section, deals with the situation where a young person is now employed for a shorter time than he was formerly and yet his total wages are not to go down. I would be interested to know what the position is if he was formerly paid by the hour. I am not sure if there is any answer to that. I am also puzzled why there is no subsection here dealing with offences by employers who do not maintain the level of wages. As I understand this section, if the hours of work are reduced the employer may not reduce the wages but if he does—if he pays the employee less than formerly—there does not appear to be any offence committed. Subsection (3) of the Minister's amendment to section 10, which provides for the payment of overtime, reads:

An employer who contravenes subsection (2) of this section shall be guilty of an offence.

I would have thought an equivalent subsection would have been required here.

Comment on this

It may be that we have to put in that amendment. We did not see this as exactly something having known mens re or intent, as we saw in the other cases. I will see whether it would make for consistency to have such a section here.

Comment on this

There would need to be some incentive for an employer to continue to pay the same wages for shorter hours.

Comment on this

Possibly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

To delete subsection (2).

The trouble with subsection (2) in this section is that it could only be described as an act of charity by the Minister or other Ministers—you scratch my back and I will scratch yours. There is a tendency in legislation for Ministers to be exempted from all the requirements of the legislation.

Subsection (1) states:

It shall be a good defence to any proceedings taken against any person for a breach of any of the provisions of this Act if such person shows to the satisfaction of the court before which such proceedings are brought that any act occasioning such breach was rendered necessary or reasonably proper by the actual occurence or the threat or reasonable anticipation of fire, flood, storm, violence, a breakdown of plant or machinery or any other emergency.

Obviously if a man's premises are about to be flooded, it is a case of all hands on deck and they work all night. If a young person, who should not be working at midnight, is working in such a case, it is reasonable and it should be a bar to prosecution.

Subsection (2) reads:

A certificate signed by any Minister that an act done by or in relation to any person employed by that Minister was rendered necessary by an emergency shall be evidence that such act was so rendered necessary.

This seems outrageous. I cannot see why a minor employee of some Minister down the country who is employing people too late at night should be allowed to come into court and say "I certify that there was an emergency". Nobody can investigate this. I cannot see the necessity for it. I suggest that the Bill would be better if subsection (2) was eliminated altogether. The Minister's officials should take their chances, like everyone else, and let the courts decide.

Comment on this

I sympathise with Senator Yeat's viewpoint. However, there is this to be said for the subsection: it does not attempt to make the Minister's certificate absolute as evidence. It is simply evidence which the court presumably could accept or reject. It is really a distinction without a difference. I should imagine that, if this were operated and a certificate were given by the Minister, it would be automatically accepted by the court not merely as evidence which the court could have regard to but as an absolute defence. I should like to hear why this subsection was introduced. It seems to contain certain dangers which, I am sure, would not arise in the case of the present Minister—and I am not making suggestions against any other Minister. It could put a Minister in an awkward position. He might have to face political pressures to give a certificate in the event of proceedings having been taken.

The Minister will be aware, as I am sure Senators are, that it took a considerable time for legislation to be introduced which took away discretion from the Minister for Justice—for example, in the case of drunken driving. The Minister has no discretion and it is purely a matter for the court. Here we seem to be going in the reverse direction and we seem to be putting the Minister into a position where he will have discretion to give or not give a certificate, which in fact——

Comment on this

Any Minister?

Comment on this

Quite right— which would provide effectively an absolute answer to a prosecution. I should like to hear the Minister's reasons for this. I rather doubt the wisdom of it.

Comment on this

The subsection is rather similar to provisions contained in similar legislation. The equivalent of subsection (2) is section 20 of the 1936 Act. Therefore it is a habitual kind of provision for legislation of this kind. The purpose of it is that I can simply place before the courts in a convenient form what I hope would be an authoritative statement on the circumstances in which an alleged contravention of the provisions of the Act occurred, due to emergencies of the nature described in the section. The lodgment of such certificates by me does not in any way restrict the court. It can call for any further evidence or explanation which it requires in the circumstances. On the basis of that explanation, if the Senator is happy with it I would ask him to withdraw his amendment.

Comment on this

I am afraid, despite the hour of night, I am not satisfied with this. We talk of fire, flood, storm, violence, a breakdown of plant and machinery and so on and it says at the end the sinister words "or any other emergency". In other words, a postmaster, shall we say, in some small town—it is not even, by the way, the occurrence; the threat, or reasonable anticipation will do—thinks that there is going to be some kind of emergency and so he employs all kinds of people at times which would otherwise be forbidden.

Comment on this

I do not mind having a look at this on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Bear in mind that if the postmaster is prosecuted it means that some other Minister is prosecuting him. Officialdom has decided that he has been naughty and that being so——

Comment on this

Senator O'Higgins pointed to a very salutary kind of example and I will certainly look at it again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Is there any provision in the Bill which makes it illegal to discuss it after 10.30 at night?

Comment on this

Let me get amendment No. 53 dealt with.

Comment on this

Senator McGlinchey has anticipated the Chair, who at this time was going to point out to the House that at 10 o'clock we agreed to continue the debate in the hope or understanding that the discussion would be concluded relatively rapidly. Since then four sections have been passed.

Comment on this

I would say ten minutes should do it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 54:

In page 11, line 21, after "A person" to insert "or body corporate".

In this amendment I seek to add in the phrase "or body corporate", the reason for this being that if you refer back to section 21 (1), where an offence under this Act is committed by a body corporate or by a person and so on, it states:

Where an offence under this Act is committed by a body corporate or by a person purporting to act on behalf of a body corporate and is proved to have been so committed with the consent or approval of, or to have been facilitated by any default on the part of any person, being a director, manager, secretary, or other officer of the body corporate, that person shall also be guilty of the offence.

We have a fair distinction made between the body corporate which is guilty and the official, the person, who is also guilty. Yet when you come to prosecuting them in section 23 you only say "a person who commits an offence under this Act shall be liable on summary conviction ...". It seems to me that under section 23 there is no provision at all for summoning a body corporate, which clearly the Minister would want to do. I would suggest therefore that this amendment ought to be accepted which simply adds, as envisaged in section 21, the term "body corporate" along with the person.

Comment on this

It is in section 11 (3) of the Interpretations Act of 1937. The word "person" shall be construed as including a body corporate whether it be a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole. I do not therefore see the point in the amendment.

Comment on this

It does include a body corporate.

Comment on this

I should like to know about paragraph (b), which gives the Minister power to make regulations to amend or modify any provision of this Act so as to comply with any international obligations which the State has or has decided to assume. Would this cover EEC directives and such like?

Comment on this

That is the intent.

Comment on this

This is a bit drastic. If it covers EEC directives it would mean, for example, if there was an EEC directive, which normally speaking is an instruction to a national Government to introduce legislation, that there would be no need to come back to us at all. The Minister could make regulations, not even an order which would have to come before the Oireachtas. It seems a rather casual way of doing it. If the EEC brought in a directive, and they might, which covered the field of youth employment this entire Bill could be rewritten by the Minister by regulation.

Comment on this

It applies only to those which the State already has or has decided to accept. The obligation is assumed by the State.

Comment on this

We assumed a variety of obligations under the Treaty of Rome on joining the EEC. We passed various Acts to do this. The obligations are there——

Comment on this

What does the Senator desire in this case?

Comment on this

Taking this section, there could be no objection at all to the Minister making regulations for the purpose of giving effect to any of the provisions of this Act, nor does it prescribe any matter referred to in this Act. When he comes to (b), "to amend or modify any provision of this Act so as to comply with any international obligations", I would have thought that should be done at least by order.

Comment on this

I will have a look at that. I assure the Senator I do not visualise anything happening in Europe which will be ahead of anything in this legislation for some considerable time.

Comment on this

Bear in mind five years from now—who knows how many directives will have come out from the EEC by then. If we are going to start introducing them by regulation——

Comment on this

All regulations have to be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Still, a regulation is a very subsidiary type of operation.

Comment on this

I will look at it.

Comment on this

It is not that I object to the Minister having the power but it seems a very casual way of doing a very large rewriting.

Comment on this

Subsection (1) states:

The employer shall keep such records as are necessary to show whether the provisions of this Act are being complied with in relation to his employees,

I am wondering which records could be involved besides the fairly extensive ones already listed in section 5.

Comment on this

That is what it refers to.

Comment on this

Why say it twice?

Comment on this

That is drafts-man's advice. It was necessary to do this because of subsection (2).

Comment on this

It is too late at night to do anything about it now.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:

In subsection (1), paragraph (e), page 12, to delete "(other than questions tending to incriminate him)" in lines 21 and 22.

This is the kind of thing that one could have two views about. While normally speaking one would certainly be in favour of the kind of words that appear in brackets in paragraph (e) of subsection (1) to the effect that an employer need not answer questions tending to incriminate him, one wonders what questions can be put if this is left in. The position appears to be under this section that an inspector visits an employer and starts cross-examining him, and so long as he is innocent he has to answer, otherwise he commits an offence. As soon as he is guilty or the inspector begins to get near the bone, all the employer has to say is, "Well, I am sorry, I have said enough, I am not going to say any more." If he is brought to the court he has the defence that the questions might have incriminated him.

Many of the questions that have to be answered by the employer are peculiarly in the knowledge of the employer: "Did you employ little Joe So-and-So last August and, if so, for how many hours?" Nobody else is likely to be able to answer that except the employer. If the employer is in the position of being able to say, "I will not answer", and then defend himself in court by saying that the questions could have incriminated him, one wonders what will be left for inspectors to inspect.

Comment on this

There are the records. There is a section which deals with the obligation of the employer to maintain pretty comprehensive records. The power of inspectors contained in the section is similar to those in comparable legislation. There are, I think, reasonable counterbalances between the rights of the individual and the powers proposed to be given to the inspectors under the legislation. The words the Senator is worried about are one element which protect the individual who may be a prospective defendant in a prosecution under the terms of the Bill. The wording in the brackets in subsection (1) (e) merely recognises the longstanding Common Law right of an individual to avoid self-incrimination in such cases. As I see it, at any rate, the amendment would take that right away and there would be the possibility of being somewhat unjust. However, if the Senator is very anxious about it I will have a look at it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I would go completely against Senator Yeats in this because, not alone is there a question of answering questions, but coupled with that there is the question of signing a declaration which is going to commit himself.

Comment on this

I may seem inconsistent but I propose, as soon as this amendment is dealt with, to complain about the signing of a declaration which I think is going too far. I can quite see that there are two sides to this question of incriminating. I am a bit worried about it simply because, while the Minister rightly says there are records which the employer must keep, there are also certain matters on which he need not keep records— for example, whether he knew that little Joe So-and-So was working for another employer at the same time for excessive hours between the two of them. That would not appear in the employer's records which he had at the time he employed him and he might know perfectly well that he was working for somebody else but he can refuse to answer. This is what worries me, but I can quite see the general principle involved and I must accept that the Minister is probably right in leaving it there, so I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister completely in this matter. We are talking about protecting the individual or the young person or the child. At the same time, when we come to this section, if we did not have that particular wording inserted we would not be defending the right of the individual. I think subsection (3) actually brings in the balance because the employer has got to produce records and he has to allow the inspector to examine the position lawfully. If he goes against that and produces or causes to be produced or knowingly allows to be produced to an inspector any record which is false in any material respect, knowing it to be false, or wilfully fails or refuses to comply with any lawful requirement of an inspector under subsection (2) of this section, such person shall be guilty of an offence. The whole balancing factor in subsection (3) circumvents the effects that might arise through somebody having the right not to answer questions that might tend to incriminate him.

Comment on this

I am a little worried about this requirement to sign a declaration as to the truth of the answers. After all, if you are involved in a road traffic accident and have some kind of problems with the Road Traffic Act you do not have to make a statement. Whether you are innocent or not, it does not make a difference, you are never required to make a statement. It is going too far to say that an employer must inevitably sign a declaration on the truth of the answers he is making to the inspector. It is all right to be cross-examined by the inspector but to have him write it all down and say you have got to sign this seems to be going rather far.

The second point I should like to make is on subsection (3), which says:

If any person—

(a) obstructs or impedes an inspector in the exercise of any of the powers conferred on him by this section, ...

I should like to know precisely what "person" includes. Naturally it includes the employer. Would it also include the parent or perhaps the employee? I am not saying that it should not, I think perhaps it should. I would be interested to know what it means.

Comment on this

The only answer really is that it is a pretty standard provision in several Acts.

Comment on this

About signing the declaration or the other one? I had two questions, one about the signing of the declaration and the other about the meaning of "any person obstructs" and so on.

Comment on this

Would the Senator repeat the question? I am very sorry.

Comment on this

I will ask one at a time. In subsection (1) (e), after putting all these questions the inspector may require the employer to sign a declaration of the truth of the answers. My first question is whether this is normal practice or whether it is necessary.

Comment on this

That is the normal practice.

Comment on this

The second question is: in subsection (3), if any person obstructs or impedes an inspector, refuses to produce a record, knowing that it is a false record or refuses to comply with any lawful requirement of an inspector and so on, such person shall be guilty of an offence. The word "person" obviously includes an employer, which it should. Does it also include a parent or perhaps an employee?

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

Any of these people?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This provides a drafting Schedule in the subsection in relation to the commencement dates. It would give some flexibility in bringing the provisions of the Act into operation.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give any very general indication as to which day or date he proposes to bring the Act into operation. Is it to be a fairly rapid process?

Comment on this

Rapidly.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister in regard to the catering industry. Many hotels and catering establishments, lounge bars and so on, have geared themselves to the summer season, employing young people, some of whom may be employed after 10 o'clock at night. The arrangements are made and I am afraid it would be very difficult for them at this stage to make alternative arrangements. I would ask the Minister, in order to give this industry a chance, to consider making the operation period possibly September to give them 12 months to prepare for this situation.

Comment on this

I think the Senator is making the point that I should give some period between. Certainly I will give some consideration to that but my general line is to have the impact of this legislation felt as soon as possible and to have it operational for the summer season, but as soon as possible.

Comment on this

This is now the month of April and it is quite possible that the people I refer to had made arrangements from last season to bring back employees or students and so on this year. It may be very difficult for them. I feel this will create a very serious hardship throughout the country and every seaside town in particular.

Comment on this

Did the Senator say a month or 12 months?

Comment on this

September.

Comment on this

I will think about it but I would not be in agreement with it—that is my first reaction.

Comment on this

I am trying to make the point that, if it becomes law before the summer season, it will definitely create very serious hardships. Listening to people here on the protection for the young and so forth, there are many young people who will be highly indignant at some of the provisions of this Bill. I do not think it is protecting them at all. What this Bill is doing is giving people the opportunity to get involved in all sorts of rascality and all sorts of trouble. Many of them will not get employment at all because of the sections dealing with hours, the time of night they must stop and so on. Above all, I think that people who have made arrangements—and I am sure that most people in towns have made their summer arrangements long ago— would have tremendous difficulty in changing them at this stage. For that reason I would ask the Minister to give consideration to my suggestion that, as far as the catering industry is concerned, this Act should not be put into operation until September.

Comment on this

Senator McGlinchey has made the point that we should postpone the bringing into effect of this legislation until next September, but I must say in response to that request that it is my intention to get it into operation as rapidly as possible and certainly to have it operating in the coming summer season, in the next two or three months. I will give that request consideration but it will take only a relatively short time after the enactment to produce publicity material. Publicity material is important to explain its provisions to the young people whom it seeks to assist. Obviously if we do not get the publicity material out, then the terms of this legislation will not be understood by the people whom we desire to assist and to help. It would not take that many months to get that publicity material out. I am not anxious to disrupt arrangements made by employers, but I am very anxious to end rapidly and as soon as possible certain abuses which are taking place and which this legislation is designed to end.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister would have power under this Bill by order to declare for this summer that it was impractical to introduce the legislation in respect of any particular industry? He has the power so that he could say to any section of industry "All right we will not do it".

Comment on this

I would have that power.

Comment on this

Under this amendment has the Minister not the power? It states that any specified provision shall come into operation on such a day. The one that I feel would hit the catering industry most is section 13. I agree entirely with the suggestion that under-14s should not be employed at all, but section 13 also affects young people who are 17 years and 11 months of age. Many of these people would have been in employment last year and the year before and it could well be that they will not be given employment this year.

Comment on this

We will give consideration to what the Senator has been saying here. I have indicated my opinion that on Report Stage we will be back and presumably discussing this aspect of it. We do have power to listen to representations for exemption from it.

Comment on this

Subsection (4) of section 16.

Comment on this

Given the fact that this amendment commits the Minister in regard to the time sequence, could I make a point that perhaps on Report Stage the Minister might give consideration to transposing sections 7 and 9 which would add to the logic of the Bill?

Comment on this