Ceapacháin Rialtais. - Wildlife Bill, 1975: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–119 of 223. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1975 ›
Cavan): Before the Committee Stage gets under way I should like, with your permission, Sir, to refer briefly to the extensive list of amendments which the House is asked to consider. It is true that many of these amendments are merely drafting points designed to tidy up the original text. However, others are of a more substantial nature whose overall effect will be to improve significantly the Bill as a whole. Senators will recall that in the course of my Second Reading speech I mentioned that I would be quite prepared to amend the Bill to such extent as would be warranted by the corpus of constructive criticism which I had by then received from various interested voluntary organisations. These bodies included the National Association of Regional Game Councils, the Irish Wildbird Conservancy, the Field and Country Sports Society, the Irish Deer Society and others.
Prolonged discussions between my Department and these organisations have since taken place and I wish to compliment most sincerely the various organisations concerned not only on the care and clarity with which they presented their proposals but also, and more important, on the spirit of cooperation and goodwill which, without exception, characterised their entire approach to this comprehensive and complex Bill.
For my own part, I can assure them that I have given the most careful and sympathetic consideration to the extraordinary wide range of suggestions which these organisations, by virtue of their long and varied experience in the wildlife sphere, were in a position to put forward.
The proposals at present before the House reflect many of these suggestions and I have no hesitation in saying that the important piece of legislation with which we are now dealing will benefit significantly from them.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment proposes to define the expression “airgun”. This definition is necessitated by the proposed amendment of section 33 to include reference to an airgun, air-rifle and air-pistol. I think it will be acceptable to the House.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is necessary to remove doubt as to the meaning of “firearm” in section 28, as it would be amended, and in sections 29, 33, 44 and 72 (6).
Comment on this
(Cavan): The purpose of this amendment is to give the same prominence to fungi and algae as is given to other wild plant groups such as lichens, mosses, etc. in the definition of “flora”. Although all these groups are comprehended by the words “all wild plants (both aquatic and terrestrial)” they are specified in the definition in the interests of clarity and emphasis and should have been including originally. The amendment is primarily a drafting one.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is for the purpose of clarification. The text as it stands suggests that flowering plants, ferns and fern-allied plants are not vascular plants whereas in fact these comprise all the vascular plants. The amendment will clarify the matter.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is purely a drafting amendment for consistency with the use of similar terms in section 15, subsection (1) (a).
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment, which seeks to define the term “the territorial seas of the State”, is considered desirable because the term is used in sections 15 and 58 and in the proposed amendments of section 59 but is defined only in section 58. A consequence of the amendment will be to delete the definition in section 58.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is intended to cover the meaning of the term “wild duck” in sections 35 and 37. In some parts of the country the term is equated with mallard only, but it includes other wild duck species such as widgeon, teal, shelduck and so on.
Comment on this
I should like to make one comment on one of the definitions in this section. Before doing so I should like to thank the Minister for his explanation about the numerous amendments. In fact, I think it is much better to have flexibility and have a large number of amendments, even if it does make the Committee Stage of the Bill somewhat difficult. The question I should like to ask is in relation to the definition of conservation. The definition states:
"conservation" includes management and regulation of the use of land in relation to the interests of wildlife and, where appropriate, development and improvement of land having regard to those interests.
I wonder whether this might not be a rather narrow definition of conservation in the context of the Wildlife Bill. After all, conservation in general terms is the wide use of resources and in this case wildlife resources itself. While I welcome the approach and the inclusion of a definition of conservation here, I am wondering whether it focuses too much on the land on which wildlife may be conserved and less on the wildlife resources themselves.
Comment on this
(Cavan): With regard to the point raised by Senator Robinson, the Senator will note in the definition the word “includes”.
Comment on this
The main point I am making is that the whole focus is on the land and not on the wildlife itself.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I would like to point to the Senator that “conservation” has its ordinary meaning but it is extended here to include the lands. Before this Bill was introduced and at the present time protection was extended to wildlife in general, but there was no protection whatever, or any worthwhile protection to the habitat of wildlife. That was a great shortcoming in the efforts to conserve wildlife. “Conservation” here includes the management and protection of the land. The ordinary meaning of the word “conservation” will still stand. It in no way limits or delimits it but, I would suggest to the Senator, extends it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The purpose of this amendment is to enable any licence granted by the Minister under the Bill to extend to persons other than the licensee. A case at point would be the grant of a licence to the master of a stage hunt under section 26. The effect of this amendment would be to extend the application of the licence to all bona fide members of the stage hunt. Another example which would serve to explain the amendment in detail would be the grant of a licence to a person under section 22 (7) (a) to capture or kill humanely a protected wild bird for research purposes. By virtue of the amendment the licence could be expressed to extend to another person or persons who would be assisting the licensee in the research project. Under paragraph (a) the licence could be expressed and operated to enable the assistant to do all that the licensee is permitted to do.
Comment on this
When this Bill was given a Second Reading in May, various Members of the House received detailed submissions from the National Association of Regional Game Councils. One of the points that was made in the submission was on section 9 on the question of licences. The submission stated that it would be desirable that the condition be written into this section making it obligatory on a firearm and/or game licence holder to take out insurance cover, for personal and public liability. Has the Minister considered the suggestion of insurance cover?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I have given consideration to that suggestion but I do not consider that making insurance cover obligatory for persons operating or using guns is a matter for me in the conservation of wildlife. The insurance suggested is really more a matter of protection or compensation for persons who are injured by the gun. This is a matter for another Department and another Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 9, line 16, after "wildlife" to add "and the protected species known as game in consultation with Regional Game Councils or their representative body at national level".
This amendment is to ensure that the existing arrangements remain and that the Minister or his Department would continue having consultations with the regional game councils as in the past.
Comment on this
(Cavan): In the wildlife measure in the broad sense—and, of course, that includes the various species traditionally regarded as game—section 11 (1) sets down the Minister's function in the broadest terms and any attempt to circumscribe that function in the manner suggested in this amendment would be detrimental. In practice, of course, where game species are concerned—or any other species for that matter—it will be the policy of the Department to continue to have consultations as appropriate with those voluntary organisations directly concerned. Indeed, I will go so far as to suggest that the Department's record in this sphere to date is such as to have won the confidence of the various groups involved in game development and wildlife conservation. In these circumstances I am not disposed to accept the amendment. I suggest that, in the light of my approach to this Bill to date and of consultations I have had with all relevant interests and of the number of amendments I have put down following those consultations, Senators would be satisfied that that sort of consultation will continue and that the amendment is not necessary.
Comment on this
I take it, then, that the Minister will continue, as in the past, consulting the regional game councils?
Comment on this
(Cavan): Senator Ryan may take it that, without writing his amendment into the Bill, the policy of consultation with the regional game councils and other interested organisations and associations will continue.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 9, between lines 20 and 21, to insert the following paragraph:—
"(b) initiate and support such research as is necessary for the sustenance and development of fauna and flora in the community interest."
I regret that Senator Higgins is not here to move this because I am not very familiar with it but I shall move this in order to give the Minister an opportunity of replying to it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The statutory basis for research is provided for in subsection (3) (a) and will be quite adequate to enable all necessary research to be undertaken either direct by the Department or by some other agency at the Department's request. Since the provisions of the Bill generally are very much geared to the community interest, it follows that research activity under the Bill will be in line with what the Senator has in mind and I see no justification for writing the proposed amendment into the Bill. In other words, I do not think that the amendment is necessary. The Bill already confers adequate powers on the Minister to make this type of research.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 9, line 34, after "loans" to insert "which shall be channelled through existing Regional Game Councils".
Here again we are asking that we continue as in the past—that the grants given to the regional game councils will continue.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I had better make the position clear. Grants and loans will not be confined to game projects only, as paragraph (b) of subsection (2) indicates. Their relevance will, inevitably, be much broader in scope and may well arise in situations which are of no direct concern to purely game development. However, where the moneys in question relate specifically to game projects, the bulk of them will as heretofore be channelled through the regional game council structure. But here too the Minister must be free to deal with other recognised game development agencies, such as joint committee projects aimed at providing shooting facilities for visiting sportsmen. Where the making of grants or loans to organisations engaged in wildlife conservation as distinct from game development arises there could be no question of channelling the appropriate funds through regional game councils. The paragraph I have drafted provides the flexibility required and I am not disposed to alter it on the lines suggested by the amendment. Again, I can assure the Senator that there will be no change in policy. Consultation will continue. We welcome suggestions, particularly if these suggestions are calculated to improve or help us in our activities under the Bill. I emphasise that the Minister reserves the right to flexibility under the Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is purely a drafting amendment. The qualification now being deleted is unnecessary.
Comment on this
I regard this as one of the most important sections of this Bill. I wonder is it possible to make a provision that, in exercising the functions under section 11, the Minister will have an obligation to consult with the body which it is proposed to establish under section 13, the Wildlife Advisory Council? It would be an improvement on the operation of the Bill if the Minister in discharging his functions did consult with the Wildlife Advisory Council. It would be a way for him to get a broader appreciation of the various factors which might apply and it would be welcome evidence of an accountability by requiring this in the actual section itself.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The point raised by the Senator might be more appropriately dealt with under section 13, which sets up the advisory council. The Senator may take it that the whole point in setting up the advisory council is for the Minister to have the benefit of the advice of that council on various matters and on various aspects of his duties. I shall be moving an amendment later which will oblige the Minister to keep the council informed of developments and of new scientific approaches. From that amendment the Senator will see that the principle of the Bill is that there should be a flow of advice and an interchange of views and opinions.
Comment on this
I accept that, but would it not be more satisfactory from the point of view of consultation and participation if section 11 included an obligation on the Minister to consult the Wildlife Advisory Council prior to discharging the various functions under section 11. It is one thing to report to an advisory council afterwards about activities which have been going on but it is much more serious participation if they are consulted prior to the discharge of functions.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I do not think it is necessary to write that into the Bill. When we come to section 13, we shall find that the council are at liberty to communicate with the Minister and that they can make recommendations to the Minister. That is one of the principal objects in establishing the council.
Comment on this
It is very hard for a council to make recommendations in an abstract way without perhaps knowing in what way the Minister would exercise particular functions under section 11. If the Minister had an obligation to consult with them it would put the council on notice that a particular activity was taking place. It would be a genuine improvement in the mechanics of the Bill and I ask the Minister to consider the matter.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If the Senator will refer to section 11 again, she will see that that section deals with broad principles and broad powers. For example, it says:
It shall be the function of the Minister to secure the conservation of wildlife.
That is really the substance of section 11. Then it says without prejudice it shall do this, that and the other thing. If I were to accept the Senator's amendment, it would mean that the Minister would be obliged to consult the council in respect of every step and every movement and that would not be desirable. The object of the council is to advise the Minister on broad policy. I am going further in one of the amendments by giving power to the council to advise the Minister on administration and on administrative matters without giving it power to interfere in any specific point of administration. If we look at the Bill in that way we will appreciate that section 11 is a broad policy section. I am sure the Senator will agree that what we are doing is satisfactory.
Comment on this
I accept that. Section 11, subsection (1), is a broad general clause setting out the general function of the Minister to secure the conservation of wildlife, but under the particular functions in subsection (2) and subsection (3) that it would be reasonable to have consultation and it would make the role of the Wildlife Advisory Council much more significant. It would mean that there would be a greater dialogue. It would mean that the council would have an opportunity before decisions were taken of giving the Minister the benefit of their advice. It is only a provision to consult. It obviously would not bind the Minister in any way in the discharge of his functions under section 11.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If we were to analyse this section a bit further, subsection (2) (a) says:
give assistance or advice to any person on any matter affecting wild life.
It would be unreasonable to assume that before exercising that function the Minister would have to refer to the council. Subsection (2) (b) says:
When the Minister considers that the management, or supervision of management by him or on his behalf, of any land in which he has not an interest, is desirable in the interests of wildlife, he may manage or cause to be managed, or supervise or cause to be supervised the management of the land upon such terms and subject to such conditions as may be agreed upon between him and a person having an interest in the land.
Once we accept that as desirable policy it would be unreasonable if the Minister had to consult the council on details or in individual cases. The same could be said about subsection 2 (c). The same could be said about individual grants. If the Minister had to consult the council before making any specific grant, the council might be turned into a pressure group in respect of these grants and that would not be desirable. The object of the council should be to advise the Minister on broad principles. It would lead to delays and obstructions and misunderstandings if the Minister were to consult the council on the day-to-day running of the Department or the day-to-day operation of the Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The effect of section 12 is to require other Government Departments or State agencies and certain public bodies, before reaching decisions or undertaking works which might adversely affect nature reserves and refuges or fauna established under sections 15 and 17 of the Bill, to consult the Minister for Lands with a view to avoiding or minimising damage to these areas. In other words, the section is intended as a safeguard for important wildlife habitats in which the Minister has a direct involvement. The purpose of the amendment is simply to extend the range of areas in which such consultation will be necessary, including habitats which become the subect of a management agreement in accordance with section 18 of the Bill. These places will also be significant in the context of wildlife conservation and it is only right that they should be given the benefit of the constraints envisaged in section 12.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is a minor drafting point aimed at making paragraph (b) consistent with the final part of the preceding paragraph.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 19 and 20 are related and may be taken together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The first of these amendments relates to subsection (2) of section 13. With the permission of the Leas-Chathaoirleach, I propose to take them together as they are intended to clarify the role of the Wildlife Advisory Council. The amendments are aimed at enabling the council's recommendations to extend to the sphere of general policy, including administrative policy, but not so far as would enable the council to become involved in specific matters of day-to-day administration. The existing wording of the subsection, by preventing it from making any recommendation of an administrative nature, could unreasonably restrict the council's performance and the proposed amendment will ensure that a recommendation from the council may include proposals affecting the Minister's administrative policy. Indeed, there may well be situations where such proposals would be an integral feature of a recommendation by the council.
Comment on this
Obviously, from what I said in my earlier remarks, I welcome this amendment. It should make a substantial difference to the terms of reference under which the council operates. It would have been a very artificial distinction at certain stages and it might have meant that the council could not consider or recommend on an area because there was some administrative involvement. This would have reduced the council to a very narrow range of policy consideration.
Therefore I welcome this amendment. I would welcome still further the possibility of inserting a provision that the council would know in advance the major areas of policy consideration which were coming up before the Department and that they would know this as of right and not when the Minister decided in particular instances to consult them. It is not good for the morale of an advisory council if they are only consulted about matters on which the Minister may wish to consult them and if they do not feel they have a right to be consulted about any of the significant policy matters.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The object of this amendment is to ensure a flow of information from the Minister to the advisory council in relation to wildlife conservation programmes generally so that the council may function more effectively. The absence of such a provision from the section, as drafted, was a serious omission and needs to be rectified. If the advisory council are to serve the Minister to the best advantage, they will need to be in possession of the fullest possible information and it is only right that they should get from the Minister any data which he considers might help them in their work.
As Senator Robinson will see, the points raised by her are being taken care of in the Bill. The amendment which I have now moved reads:
The Minister shall take such steps as he considers appropriate to keep the Council informed of matters relating to the conservation of wildlife which are, in his opinion, likely to assist the Council in performing the functions assigned to it by subsection (2) of this section.
Subsection (2) reads:
The Council may, either of its own volition or at the request of the Minister, make recommendations to the Minister as to the Minister's policy in relation to the conservation of wildlife or as to objectives to be fixed or programmes to be implemented by the Minister in relation to such conservation, but nothing in this subsection shall be construed as enabling the Council to make to the Minister any recommendation as regards an administrative matter.
We have just amended that subsection. If Senator Robinson will take section 13, subsection (2) and the amendment I have just moved, she will see it is the clear intention that the Minister will make available to the council all information which would be necessary to enable them to perform their functions under subsection (2). The functions clearly set out in subsection (2) are advisory functions, to advise the Minister. I agree with Senator Robinson that it would be foolish if they were to advise the Minister in retrospect, or after he had taken a decision. I would ask the Senator to accept that subsection (2), coupled with the amendment I have just moved, meets her point. It does not state that the Minister must consult them beforehand, but the gist of the matter is that he will make them aware of what is happening and will welcome and even await their suggestions.
Comment on this
This amendment will improve the possibility of the Wildlife Advisory Council discharging their functions in the best possible way and having a good flow of information. I am still not sure it ensures that the council will receive this information at a sufficiently early stage. As the Minister said, it would be absurd if the council were informed after the policy decision had been made and after a whole programme had been set in motion. For example, the amendment does not say: "The Minister shall take such steps as he considers appropriate to keep the council informed in advance of matters relating to the conservation of wildlife."
I am glad to hear his undertaking in relation to the role of the council and I am sure it will be appreciated. However, it is important that the section itself does ensure that the council will get the adequate information in advance of any decisions in order that their own recommendations may influence and be part of the decision-making process. I accept that this new subsection will improve the dialogue between the Minister and the advisory council, but I am still not quite satisfied that it will necessarily mean that the council will, as of right, get the information sufficiently in advance. The absence of a statutory obligation to consult leaves some gap, but the amendment is an improvement on the original section.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I suggest to the Senator that there is the parliamentary safeguard. The idea in having an advisory council is so that they may advise the Minister, so that the Minister may consult them in advance of important policy decisions or administrative steps which might effect policy. If a proper and harmonious relationship is to exist between the Minister and the council, it is essential that the Minister would make available to them such information as is necessary in advance of decisions being taken by him.
Senator Robinson will not overlook the fact that the Minister's Estimate is debated in the Dáil once a year and that on the Appropriation Bill, Seanad Éireann has an opportunity of discussing these matters. Therefore, if the Minister were to be guilty of such a dereliction of duty as to simply set up a council and ignore them, the council would react and convey their reaction to Members of Parliament. We would have that threshed out both in the Dáil and Seanad. That is the great parliamentary safeguard which democracy exercises over ministerial functions and the day-to-day workings of Departments.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 22, 23 and 24 are related and may be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 11, line 35, to delete "The members" and substitute "Fifty per cent of the members of the Council shall be elected by the Regional Game Councils. The remaining members".
With Senator McGlinchey's permission, and I am sure he will agree, I will withdraw this amendment. He is looking for too much in that amendment. He is proposing that 50 per cent of the council shall be elected by the regional game councils. We are proposing in amendment No. 24 that the game councils would be included. The Minister has an amendment in which field sports are mentioned. I should like the Minister to tell us what he means by field sports.
Comment on this
The Minister should specially mention regional game councils.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I understand that Senator McGlinchey's amendment will be withdrawn. I accept the views expressed by Senator Ryan on that. The composition of the Wildlife Advisory Council is deliberately widely cast in order to provide the fullest possible representation consistent with efficiency. I am not prepared to write into the Bill the names of any individual organisation or the proportion of its representation on the council. At the same time, I can accept the general tenor of the amendment in the names of Senator Ryan and Senator Garrett, and say that there will be no difficulty as regards giving the National Association of Regional Game Councils representation on the council. To this end, and to remove any possible doubts on the matter, I propose to expand the categories from which members would be chosen by adding “field sports” to the list. The Government amendment to subsection (6) takes care of that
I am not prepared to write in, in black and white, that any particular organisation or association shall be represented, or be entitled to representation, as such, on the council. If the Senator refers to subsection (6) of section 13 he will see:
The members of the Council shall be appointed by the Minister and shall include such number of persons, by reason of their knowledge or experience of, or interest in, agriculture, fisheries, the conservation of wildlife or some other science, as he considers will ensure that the Council will assist materially in the furtherance of wildlife conservation.
I have added "field sports" to that list. There will be an obligation on the Minister in appointing members of the council to ensure that they have the sort of qualifications set out in subsection (6) of section 13 to enable them to perform the functions assigned to them under the Bill. It would not be right to write into the Bill that any particular council or association should be represented. This has not been the practice over the years.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister why he has chosen to keep entirely in his own power in making an order rather than specify in the Bill the composition of the council. It is strange when a body of this sort is being established that so much relating to it will depend completely on the particular Minister and that there will be no parliamentary view about it—for example, about the size of the council. I could see that it might give rise to quite substantial difficulties if the council were either too large to discharge their functions efficiently and adequately, or so small that they constituted a clique and were not therefore sufficiently representative.
I appreciate that there may be difficulties in establishing a wildlife advisory council of this nature. We seem to have given the Minister carte blanche. He will decide who the members will be, the constitution of it, the size of it, on what terms people serve on the council, and so on. As a lawyer, I am always apprehensive of giving carte blanche in relation to the establishment of institutions. I am not sure it is good for the morale of those who will serve on the council. It may be that they will feel unable to give sufficiently independent advice and that they will feel unprotected. For example, if we had a clause in the section that the members would serve for a three-year, or five-year period, at least they would know that they would have a fixed term, but even this is not spelled out in the section. I would be interested in the Minister's view as to why he feels he requires such total control over the composition of the council.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It is true that the section which establishes the council is wide and that the details of the council are left to the Minister. Subsection (1) of section 13 provides:
The Minister shall by order establish a body which shall be known as the Wildlife Advisory Council (which body is referred to in this Act as the Council) to perform the functions assigned to it by this Act.
Subsection (2) provides:
The Council may, either of its own volition or at the request of the Minister, make recommendations to the Minister.
Subsection (3) provides:
The Minister may request the Council to furnish to him its opinion in relation to any function assigned to him by this Act.
Subsection (4) provides:
Subject to subsection (5) of this section, the Minister may by order, made with the consent of the Minister for the Public Service in so far as it relates to allowances for members of the Council, provide for such one or more of the following as he considers appropriate:
(a) the constitution of the Council,
(b) the period for which and the terms and conditions upon and subject to which the members of the Council are to hold office,
(c) the manner in which a member of the Council may resign,
(d) the business and procedure of the Council,
(e) the payment of specified allowances to members of the Council,
(f) any matter which is ancillary or incidental to any of the foregoing.
Subsection (5) provides:
Before making an order under this section which contains provisions relating to the constitution of the Council, the Minister shall consult any other Minister of State or a body established by or regulated under statute considered by the Minister to be concerned.
Subsection (6) spells out the qualifications of the members. I agree with the Senator that if it were to end there and if Parliament had no further control over the establishment of the council, she might have grounds for complaint. The Minister cannot establish this council until he gets statutory authority from the Oireachtas to do so. When he does establish this council he will establish it by order and that order must be laid before each House of the Oireachtas in accordance with the terms of the Bill, and each House of the Oireachtas will have an opportunity, if it so wishes, to put down a motion to discuss and rescind the order establishing the council. I would ask the Seanad to accept that, in that way, both the Dáil and Seanad are retaining effective control over the establishment of the council.
Comment on this
I accept that the Minister's order will come before the House under the procedure in section 8, subsection (4), subject to annulment. However, the reality is that a motion of that sort very rarely is raised on the floor of the House and a more effective control, given the very broad terms of section 13, would be in this particular instance if the order were to be laid in draft and subject to the approval of both Houses, in which case time would have to be given and there would be a discussion on the composition of the council.
Comment on this
We are opposing the setting up of these boards. I know the Minister does not intend to set up the boards just now, but he is leaving the gate open to set them up at any time he or any other Minister thinks fit. We all agreed with the setting up of the advisory council. That was a good day's work. The advisory council are capable of doing all the work necessary without boards being established.
We have a number of different boards: Bord na gCapall, Bord na gCon, and various other boards. They are all doing a good job. If we have a board and also an advisory council, I wonder will they work hand in hand. There is always the danger that, if you set up a board, by degrees it will eventually take over everything and set up a dictatorship if you like. That is why we are opposed to the section. I suppose there is no point in pursuing it too far because the Minister probably has his mind made up, but I just wished to express the views of my party on section 14.
Comment on this
I understand the logic of the general argument put forward by Senator Ryan but I do not agree with his conclusion that there should not be this power to establish boards. In section 14 the Minister is taking a very wise precaution, enabling the establishment, if it should seem appropriate to him, of boards for certain purposes. I will give just one example where the Minister might consider it appropriate. It might be that a particular problem in relation to wildlife existed in part of the country which did not exist in another part of it and it might be appropriate for the Minister to have some special board to keep an eye on the situation there.
I would have thought that the idea contained in amendment No. 24, which I think was withdrawn by the same Senators, might have been based on the need for regional representation in respect of specific tasks and that there might have been a desire to have a representative of the National Association of Regional Game Councils on the council to be set up under this Bill because of particular local circumstances. If I were arguing for that amendment that is the basis on which I would have made my argument.
The Minister's view in that regard was accepted by the Seanad, and rightly so. The Minister was probably right in refusing to look on the council which he is establishing as being a body, so to speak, representative of existing bodies or on which members would serve, regarding their mandate as being merely representatives of particular existing bodies. But by reason of the power contained in section 14, he can meet the same kind of necessity should the occasion arise and, again, if he is doing it, he must do it by order and the order must come before the Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is intended to be a very comprehensive measure. Indeed, it is desirable that it should be a comprehensive measure if we look at the history of conservation and game preservation and wild bird preservation. No effective Act has been introduced here to deal with the subject since 1930, and that is 45 years ago. In the order of things, I suppose conservation, the arts, and so on, are inclined to be put on the long finger when there are commercial matters and bread and butter items to be dealt with. Therefore, it is highly desirable that we should put on the Statute Book now a comprehensive measure which will will not only meet with the situation as we see it today, but which will last for many years to come and will serve to conserve wildlife and to provide machinery for conserving wildlife not alone for the foreseeable future but beyond that.
As Senator Ryan has said, and admitted, it is not proposed to establish these boards at the moment. We are merely providing here machinery to establish them. I do not accept Senator Ryan's suggestion that their establishment could lead to little dictatorships. I do not accept that at all because again, just as the order establishing the council under section 13 must be laid before this House and the Lower House, so also would any order establishing the boards envisaged in section 14 have to be laid before the Oireachtas and it would be open to debate and discussion and decision there. The activities of the boards would come up for discussion annually on the Estimate for the Department.
If I were to be pressed to give details of what I envisage these boards doing, I might indeed find it difficult. I concede that difficulty, but it is anticipated that, if in the future, it appears that some facet of wildlife conservation could be more effectively dealt with by a board, then such a board would be set up to deal with it. The order setting it up would come before the Houses of the Oireachtas and would be debated there. That is what is involved in section 14.
Comment on this
This is another broad enabling provision, as the Minister has made clear, enabling him in the future, if the specific need arises, to establish a board. In the matter of conservation it is necessary to have this sort of reserved power. It is desirable to have this possibility rather than not doing anything because of the difficulty of getting another Wildlife Bill passed through both Houses. The arguments I made in relation to the advisory council are even stronger here in relation to the board. It is not sufficient, it is not a genuine parliamentary scrutiny, to provide that the Minister must lay the order before both Houses and then it can be annulled if a motion is passed to that effect. That is not in reality a control because time will not be given for a debate on it unless the Government want to defeat the order of their own Minister, which is highly unlikely.
Therefore I suggest that in this particular circumstance the Minister should reconsider making provision in relation to this section for the order to be laid in draft. The reason for this is that the Minister has said with commendable honesty that he could not specify the particular areas where it may be necessary to establish boards in the future because this will be an evolving problem. I would very much welcome the fact that he had this reserved power and that, if a specific need arose which required delegating the functions which he exercises under this Act, he would be able to delegate those functions, subject to being able to give directives which the board must comply with. It would seem to me that it would be much better, if there was a specific requirement for a parliamentary review by the Oireachtas in relation to a specific proposal, that the Oireachtas would be given an opportunity of commenting in detail on or referring to the precise function which will be delegated to the board sometime in the future when this question arises. It might be that, after some years, there would be several of these boards.
In the circumstances it would be preferable to have a positive guarantee that there will be a parliamentary view on the nature and functions of this board to be established in the future and that it is a reserved power which the House would feel is appropriate to the circumstances. I ask the Minister to consider the possibility that the order be laid in draft.
Comment on this
The Wildlife Advisory Council is a purely advisory body. It has no statutory powers and its only function is to advise the Minister. It is representative of various interests such as agricultural, fishing, wildlife, fauna, and field sports. It may be necessary for a board with a statutory basis to carry certain functions. I could visualise that on the advice of the advisory councils the Minister might set up a board to carry out certain functions. That could be done effectively only by some body with a statutory basis. I hope the Minister would be consulted and advised by the advisory council before the setting up of this board. There is a valid necessity for it and it will be useful to all the interests represented on the advisory council as well as to the Minister.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Regarding Senator Robinson's comments, I could not accept her argument regarding a draft of the order setting up the board being more valid on this section than under section 13. She would have a stronger case for asking that the draft order establishing the advisory council be brought before the House now because it is intended to proceed with it immediately.
When these boards are being established procedures might be different. The activities of the Forest and Wildlife Section of my Department might have changed, views in general on wildlife conservation or certain sports associated with it might have changed and a different type of board might need to be established.
I refer Senator Robinson to the Second Schedule to the Bill which sets out in considerable detail a constitution for the boards it is proposed to establish. I would suggest to the Senator that that Second Schedule provides guidelines and gives an indication of the working and constitution of the board. Having regard to that I would ask her to accept that this House is not giving an entirely blank cheque to the Minister for Lands. If he decides to establish these boards he will have to operate within a constitution provided in the Second Schedule.
Comment on this
I do not accept that the distinction drawn by the Minister between the order establishing the Wildlife Advisory Council and the possible future order establishing a board in relation to unknown functions really supports the point made. The argument is stronger for the order to be laid in draft before both Houses of the Oireachtas than establishing the advisory council. As Senator Russell has said, the advisory council, although an important body, exercises advisory powers. This is a significant difference. This section relates to the possible future establishment of a board which will exercise the powers which the Minister is to be conferred with in the sections of this Act. What the Minister is asking both Houses of the Oireachtas to do it to give a blank cheque to delegate some of those powers in the future, subject to the Minister's authority to give the board binding directives. In such a way the Minister retains control. Otherwise there might be constitutional difficulties.
The fact that this is not a power to be exercised at this point in time and that there is not an intention to establish a board in relation to particular areas, makes it all the more important that there be a positive parliamentary involvement so that when in due course a board is established that board will exercise the powers of the Minister. I accept that there is a shell constitution of the board in the Second Schedule. The Minister may choose particular provision relating to it. Apart from whatever shape the board may take, of equal significance is the area of operation—the fact that a board is to be established in that area. While that is in draft there will not be any effective parliamentary view. I ask the Minister to concede the reality. A provision for the laying of an order subject to a motion for annulment is a very minor form of control and most unlikely to come before either House of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I believe that conservation has suffered over the years. Although the Game Preservation Act and the Wild Birds Protection Act passed by the Oireachtas in 1930 were at that time far-seeing and enlightened measures, as years went on they proved to be inadequate. However, it took 45 years to replace them. It takes a long time to get such a measure drafted. It is highly desirable that there should be flexible machinery provided in this measure now to enable the Department of Lands to perform their functions in regard to conservation and wildlife in general to the end of this century and beyond it.
Senator Robinson invites me to prepare and lay before the House a draft order establishing the board which may never be established, or at any rate not for 20 years. The whole climate of opinion and approach to these things may have changed. It might then be necessary to amend this draft order to introduce an amending Act. That could put the matter on the long finger again. I am honest enough to say that. Section 14 is merely an enabling measure. I do not concede for one moment that it is giving a blank cheque to a Minister or that Parliament is divesting itself of authority or of control of the Minister.
If I go back to my argument about the proviso that compels the Minister to lay the draft order under section 14 before Parliament, giving Parliament an opportunity of discussing it and rescinding it, I would repeat that that is an adequate safeguard. If I reject Senator Robinson's contention that such an order will never be rescinded, if it is not rescinded and if Parliament lets through or ignores an order that has been laid before it, even a bad order and one with which it disagrees, that is a reflection on Parliament and not on the Minister or on society in general. I do not accept that any Minister would grant an order of a dictatorial nature or which was undesirable, defective or objectionable and put it before the Dáil, because that Minister would know that if there was an Opposition worth its salt it would avail of the opportunity to highlight that and to debate and discredit the Minister who brought it before the House.
Senator Robinson said that rarely are these orders rescinded or debated. Perhaps the reason for that is that the Minister who is drafting and bringing them before Parliament knows that they can be debated and that it would damage his own standing and that of his Government if he were to bring before the Dáil a measure which did warrant annulment. I am not certain, but I think that in recent history such an order was annulled.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It would be very controversial if one were to deal with a case which happened not long ago. I think one did come before the Dáil and was annulled.
Comment on this
The Minister has made his views on this clear. I should like to make one further comment arising out of his reply. In seeking to have particular safeguards in a Bill there is a danger that one is seen to be suggesting that the Minister may try to do something wrong. He may try to do something dictatorial and obviously that is an important part of the control, but I believe that there is another side to it which is extremely important where the subject matter is conservation. I share the Minister's desire to get a very comprehensive, flexible and good Bill in this area. It is difficult to get time for such measures but I think it important that these matters be brought before the House with regularity.
The Minister has mentioned that this Bill, or any orders under it or the operation of it can be debated in the Dáil on the Estimates of his Department and that it can be debated on the Appropriation Bill in this House. These are certainly useful but limited matters. The effect of laying an order in draft, if this enabling power were to be exercised in the future, would be that there would be perhaps in 20 years' time the view of both Houses on the area chosen to delegate powers to a board and the particular functions that board would have. That has an educational value and a public interest value. It has an involvement of Senators and Deputies in 20 years' time who will be examining it. To think that the machinery of laying an order in draft subject to being confirmed by both Houses in only a policing role is too narrow a construction. It will also have a very substantial educational effect and it is a way of highlighting the activities in the area of conservation and specifically the role and activities of that board.
I regret the fact that the Minister is not open to this suggestion because I think it is very substantially and specifically the sort of control which should be here where we are discussing an enabling power which may not be exercised for about 20 years. By that time the whole surrounding circumstances may be different and the danger is that this power may go by default. There will be nothing specifically wrong with the measure, and therefore it will never be raised in either House because nobody will want publicly to annul it, but they would have very much liked an opportunity to debate and discuss the functions of a particular board.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 25, 27, 28 and 29 are related and may be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 13, line 13, after "land" to insert "or water".
The general purpose of these amendments is to extend what is one of the most praiseworthy activities of the Department of Lands to the area of water. I am aware that many young children have benefited immensely through participation in the forest walks organised by the Department of Lands. I propose in these amendments to extend the Department's activities to water.
I think all of the amendments speak for themselves. Amendment No. 27 states:
"(d) water which constitutes an ecosystem of scientific or community recreational interest."
This amendment has an importance which might be lost. As oil and gas development takes place and as pressure is built up—in the extent of the fishing industry, for example— very often there will be inlets and areas of water which constitute an ecosystem of scientific or community recreational interest. I think that this Bill might benefit if the Minister had power in that area.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I appreciate Senator Higgins's anxiety to ensure that this Bill can deal with water as well as with land. Having considered the amendment, I am not satisfied that it is necessary. If the Senator will refer to the definition of land given in section 2 of the Bill, page 6, which we have amended today. It says:
"land", where the context admits, includes land covered with water and in relation to the acquisition of land also includes any easement, profit á prendre or other right in, to or over land or water (including any easement, profit á prendre or other right granted to or held by the Minister);
I think that the Senator will agree that that meets his point adequately and that his amendments are not necessary.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister to what extent do our territorial waters extend? Is it three miles or 12 miles?
Comment on this
(Cavan): They are defined in another statute. I cannot tell the Senator offhand what it is.
Comment on this
Does the Minister for Lands have control over the fish life in this territorial area?
Comment on this
The Minister's reply to my amendment indicated his admirable intentions for this area. However does the Minister not think, particularly in the case of amendment No. 29, that if "or marine reserve" was inserted after "reserve" the Bill would benefit from that? The purpose of the group of four amendments is recreational. The phrase "or marine reserve" would enable the Minister to expand administratively something which has been accepted as being very important and beneficial to date.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I understand that it is a principle of draftsmanship that it is not desirable to define too closely what one wishes to say because that may give rise to trouble in interpretation of the Act.
I am advised that the proposed amendment is superfluous. The expression "nature reserve" will include marine nature reserves, and the section, as it stands, makes adequate provision for such habitats. In other words, I am advised that section 15 (1) (c) will be the basis of marine reserves and the points raised by the Senator are already covered in the Bill as drafted.
Comment on this
I wish to comment on section 15 regarding territorial waters. We are all hazy as to whether our territorial limits extend three miles or 12 miles. I advocate that it be 50 miles. We have been most lax as a nation in not seeking greater extension of our limits.
Comment on this
Yes, but we are not sure whether it is only three or 12 miles in this country. The Icelanders will be on top of us soon if their limits are extended. They have gone out 200 miles. We should start thinking in terms of at least a 50-mile limit.
Comment on this
(Cavan): A discussion on our fishing limits and territorial waters would be very interesting and is very important. The proposals are elastic at the moment, extending from six miles to 200 miles, but it is not relevant on this section.
Comment on this
In relation to what Senator Deasy has said, will the Minister's Department be making a submission, for example, for the redrafting of the law of the sea which will protect "an ecosystem of scientific or community recreational interest?"
Comment on this
(Cavan): There is a convention of the law of the sea in progress at the moment, and this country is represented thereon by the Attorney General. No doubt the remarks of Senator Deasy and Senator M.D. Higgins will be brought to the attention of the Attorney General, and I will mention the remarks to him.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is essentially a drafting point. Section 15 is intended to relate to all State-owned land and was not meant to be restricted to lands owned by the Minister for Lands whether jointly or separately.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that the making of an order under section 15 is a matter in which the Wildlife Advisory Council could have have some views.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Yes, there is no doubt about that being one of the important matters on which the would be expected to have some views.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 30 and 32 are cognate and may be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
To substitute "land or foreshore" for "land" in each place where the latter word occurs throughout the section.
I was speaking to Senator West this morning and I know he was of the view that another Bill was to be taken before this one, which explains why he is not here to move these amendments himself so, in his absence, I should like to move these amendments so that the Minister may indicate his attitude to us.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am advised and I accept that these amendments are unnecessary. “Foreshore” is land and any doubt as to its being land when it is covered by water is removed by the definition of “land” in section 2.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
To substitute "fauna or flora" for "fauna" in each place where the latter word occurs throughout the section.
I should like to hear the Minister's attitude on this.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am not disposed to accept this amendment which seeks to include “flora” in the section which is designed to deal exclusively with refuges for fauna. The protection of flora is adequately and appropriately catered for under sections 15 and 16, nature reserves; section 18, agreements relating to management of privately owned land; and under the overall protection of flora in section 21. While the protective measures included in an order under section 17 designating a refuge for fauna would almost certainly contain a spin-off benefit for flora of the area, it would be quite inappropriate to deal with rare or endangered species of flora under the section. The reasons would be obvious.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am satisfied that the publication of a notice of intention to make or amend a designation order in Iris Oifigiúil and in the local press does not go far enough and that a copy of the notice should also be served on the owner or owners or occupiers of the land concerned to ensure that they would be fully aware of the proposal. The amendment provides accordingly.
Comment on this
Under this section of the Bill it is considered that provisions should be made to the appeals court by agreed parties against Ministerial designation orders. It is also a question of compensation made by the Minister under section 17, subsection (11) and (12). These should be challengeable in the courts and the payment of costs incurred by individuals in connection with matters concerning designation orders and appeals under this section should be payable by the State, wherever appropriate.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Senator makes the point that designation orders should be the subject of appeals to the courts and that compensation fixed by the Minister should also be subject to appeal. I shall look into both these points which have been raised by Senator Walsh and I shall deal with them on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 34 and 35 are consequential and may be taken together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It has been proposed to me—and I accept the point that the definition of “management” as drafted is too restricted. The effect of these amendments would be to define “management” as including all use of land for agriculture and forestry, all forms of development of land and all changes in the physical, topographical and ecological nature of the land and use of the land for educational and recreational purposes. It is extending the definition and it improves the Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This rather elaborate amendment is aimed essentially at clarification. Subsection (4) is intended to establish the offences relating to wild birds which are to be protected under the Bill. In that sense the subsection should correspond with subsection (5) of section 23, page 21, lines 9 to 21. As it stands, however, the subsection has been interpreted in different ways and the new paragraph (a) is aimed at putting the meaning of the subsection beyond doubt.
The second part of the amendment, the new paragraph (b), is intended to "catch" the deliberate injuring of protected wild birds, for example, by pelting stones at them. Though the definition of "hunt" in section 2 is very wide, it does not extend to injuring fauna. It would not be appropriate, having regard to the use of the word "hunt" throughout the Bill, to include "injure" in the definition of "hunt". A corresponding amendment is being made in regard to the protected wild animals in section 23. This will improve the section considerably.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 19, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following subsection:—
"(4) For the purpose of giving jurisdiction under this Act an offence under this section shall be deemed to have been committed where the person complained against has been apprehended or found in possession, as the case may be."
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 37 and 45 are cognate and may be taken together.
Comment on this
The reason we tabled this amendment is to prevent people who would be brought to court putting forward the argument that the offence was not committed in that particular court area.
Comment on this
It may be. A man may see somebody poaching, but before he can reach the poacher, who may be two or three fields away, the man might have to travel quite a distance in his car. If that poacher is apprehended with an illegal possession, a bird or a hare, I suppose he will be brought before the courts for the area in which he is apprehended. If he is aware that he is being pursued he will get rid of his illegal possessions. The only evidence available will be that of the person who saw him committing the offence. The place where he is apprehended may be ten miles from the place where the offence was committed, but it is in the court of that area he should be prosecuted. When he is brought before the court his solicitor will argue that his client is not being tried in the appropriate court. The Game Council feel very strongly about this. It is a loophole in the Bill through which many offenders will escape if the Minister is not prepared to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I am not sure to what extent it is necessary to plug this alleged loophole, but if it is necessary it would seem to me to be a sensible step to take. I assume that the position at the moment is clear enough. An offence can be prosecuted in the District Court area where it has been committed. The purpose of the amendment is not to extend the jurisdiction of the District Court but to extend the definition of the offence so that the offence can be deemed to have been committed in another area if the person who has committed the offence is apprehended there or is found in possession, as the case might be, in that other area.
It seems to me that it would give greater protection and would eliminate a possible loophole if it was quite clear to everyone that, if an offence was committed, a person may be prosecuted where the offence has been committed or that he may be prosecuted in an adjoining court area if, in fact, that is where he is apprehended. I am in some doubt whether or not it is necessary. A second doubt which arises is that it seems to be going a bit far to say that the offence should be deemed to have been committed where a person is apprehended if, in fact, that is going to fly in the teeth of the evidence, if everyone knows that it was not committed there. I feel there should be some way of remedying this position—I do not know whether it comes within the Minister's bailiwick at all—by ensuring that, regardless of where the person is apprehended, a prosecution can follow, whether it is in that District Court area or within the area where the offence has been committed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I can appreciate Senator Ryan's difficulty on the points raised by Senator O'Higgins. The purpose behind the amendment is to give jurisdiction to a district justice in the case where it is clear that an offence has been committed but where the exact location cannot be established. Under the District Court Rules, 1940, Rule 25, the case could be heard in the District Court area where the accused person resides, but this could be very inconvenient for witness if the accused lived a long distance away.
I am satisfied that the Government amendments, to section 45, which are aimed at making possession of unlawfully taken species an offence, will meet the vast majority of cases which the Senators have in mind. However, my Department are considering the matter further, in consultation with the Department of Justice, to see whether more can be done to meet the Senator's point. I will deal with the matter further on Report Stage.
As the law exists at the moment and as the rules exist, a person may be prosecuted in the District Court area, (a), where the offence is committed or (b), where the defendant resides. Senator Ryan poses the question, if he sees somebody shoot a pheasant or contravene the Act in some other way, and that person, knowing he has been seen, drives off, what is the position if Senator Ryan is able to catch up with him later on? If the poacher has the pheasant, hare or whatever it is, he is guilty of an offence where he has been caught and he can be prosecuted then. Also, if Senator Ryan can establish that the person committed the offence in a certain place; if he can prove that he saw him shoot the pheasant and saw it fall but that when he caught up with the poacher it was not in his possession, he can still prosecute him in the District Court area where the pheasant was shot.
While it might be an inconvenience to follow the accused to his native District Court area, which might be 50 or 60 miles away, it could also be more serious for the offending person to be prosecuted there because the likelihood is that, as well as being fined £X, the accused would also be ordered to pay witnesses' expenses, which would cover the travelling expenses and loss of time of the witness who had to travel from the locality in which the offence was committed.
I do not honestly think that there is as much in the Senator's point as might appear at first sight, because if he can establish where the offence was committed, the townland where it was committed, a prosecution may then be brought in the District Court area which includes that townland. If the accused drives off to some other part and is found with the game or a gun, he can then be prosecuted in the area where he was caught. Failing all that, if for some reason or another, the person who detects the accused is not able to say where the offence was committed, if he is not able to name the townland, the accused can be prosecuted where he resides. While I shall have a look at this matter again, the Government amendment to section 45 to make possession an offence, goes a long way to remove the problems which Senator Ryan feels exists at the present time.
Comment on this
In view of the Minister's statement—I accept that there is some doubt—that he will have another look at this matter before Report Stage, I am prepared to withdraw the amendment. I would ask the Minister to have another look at this section before it goes to the Dáil.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is purely for consistency of drafting with the similar provision, relating to protected wild animals, in section 23 (7) (a).
Comment on this
(Cavan): The essential amendment here is to allow for the humane killing of protected wild birds injured in the manner described in paragraph (g).
Comment on this
(Cavan): It has been represented to me that there is no let-out in this subsection for the unintentional killing or injuring of a protected wild bird except in so far as ordinary agricultural, fishery or forestry operations are concerned. A case in point, which happens occasionally, is the accidental running down of game birds with a motor car. While I consider the point to be a very fine one I am nevertheless proposing this Government amendment to meet it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
(6) It shall be an offence for any person or body to carry out any work described in subsection (5) (g) of this section without obtaining the advice of a zoologist or botanist where the community interest so demands."
Comment on this
(Cavan): While recognising fully the intention behind this proposal, I am afraid that such an amendment would not be practicable, especially in the light of the inclusion of the phrase “where the community interest so demands”. The subjective nature of this phrase would, in my view, virtually negative the underlying idea of the amendment. Apart altogether from that, the restrictions contained in section 12 will safeguard the really important habitats. In other cases, I would expect that where the value of wildlife is significant, in connection with the sort of activity mentioned in subsection 5 (g), common sense will prevail and advice will be sought before any irreparable damage is done. My Department will, of course, be available to give such advice wherever the need arises. In short, I consider the amendment as unduly restrictive and to a large degree impracticable. Therefore, I cannot agree to its adoption.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is necessary because of the wide definition of the word “hunt” in section 2 of the Bill. The effect of the amendment would be to add a further exception to the hunting prohibition in subsection (4) (a) which would permit the training and trial of gun dogs. While game birds are necessarily disturbed or flushed by discharging a blank cartridge from a shotgun, in such training and trials there is no killing involved. The training of gun dogs is a long-established business which includes an export trade and would not conflict with the purposes of the Bill. It is an improvement on the Bill to facilitate the training of gun dogs without in any way interfering with conservation.
Comment on this
Before putting that amendment, may I say it is related to amendment No. 43 for the purpose of discussion and No. 43 may now be taken.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
To add to the section the following subsection:
"(9) The Minister shall make regulations enabling persons, who have to train young gun dogs, red setters or retrievers, to hunt without guns for at least one month prior to the commencement of the season."
Comment on this
(Cavan): The underlying objective of amendment No. 43 has been met and I suggest that the amendment be withdrawn.
Comment on this
This is a rather small point but I have been looking down through the list under subsection (5) where it shall not be an offence for a person to do something. I am puzzled by the scope of subsection (5) (e) which provides:
to take eggs of a protected wild bird or to move eggs from the nest of such a bird to that of another bird of the same species for the purpose of having them hatched out.
I should like to ask the Minister whether, as this paragraph stands, it is possible for a trespasser to take the eggs of a pheasant and transfer them to a tame pheasant to hatch them out. This seems to be broad enough to make that a perfectly legal activity.
Comment on this
(Cavan): No. I am satisfied it does not permit trespassing. Trespassing is dealt with in other sections of the Bill. I cannot refer the Senator to them offhand. I am satisfied that that particular paragraph does not give authority for somebody to do something which one could not otherwise lawfully do. It means, and the Senator who has a much more refined knowledge of the law than I have, that it would not be an offence under this section.
Comment on this
Yes. I am not sure I made my point clear. I am glad that paragraph (e) does not legalise trespassing, but is it broad enough that if a person is trespassing and may be guilty of trespassing, he still cannot be found guilty and would have a defence here if he were found taking eggs from under a pheasant to transfer them to a tame pheasant?
Comment on this
(Cavan): No. They would then be guilty of trespassing and larceny, or as they used to say in regard to other offences long ago, “with aggravation.”
Comment on this
Would they? Would they not be covered by this paragraph?
Comment on this
Why put it on the basis of trespassing at all? I was interested in trying to get the answer to the query Senator Robinson raised. Suppose I, on my own land, take the eggs from the nest of one pheasant and bring them along to a tame pheasant, it seems to me that I am permitted to do that under the Bill. I presume there is a reason for that. If it came to my notice, for example, that the hatching hen pheasant had been killed or run over by a car, it would obviously be a good thing for me to take the eggs and have them hatched out elsewhere, even if I did not stick to the same species, and got a clucking hen to do it. I assume there is some explanation like that for this. I agree with Senator Robinson that the exculpatory power of this is very broad. It need not be put on the basis of the person committing the offence of trespassing or any other offence for the purpose of doing this.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I can only say to Senator Robinson that I respect the views expressed by her and I will have it looked into before the next Stage or before going to the Dáil. I am satisfied, and in no way being insulting, that, in applying a commonsense view to it, it is not broad enough to permit the person to do what the Senator suggests.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This rather elaborate amendment is aimed essentially at clarification. Subsection (5) is intended to establish the offence relating to wild animals which will be protected under the Bill and is the parallel of section 22 (4). The new paragraphs (a) and (b) have been recast, for clarity, on the lines of the corresponding paragraph (a) (i) and (ii) of subsection (4) of section 22, relating to protected wild birds. The paragraphs were also being amended to exclude from the hunting prohibitions of the section any action taking in accordance with the permission granted by the Minister under section 30 or 42. A new paragraph (c) is intended to cover the deliberate injury of protected wild animals. As explained in the similar amendment in the new paragraph (b) of section 22 (4), the definition of “hunt” in section 2 does not extend to injuring fauna nor would it be appropriate to include injuring in that definition. The new paragraph (d) has been extended to make unlawful the blocking up of entrances to or other wilful interference with badger setts, otter dens or other breeding places of protected wild animals. I take it that that would commend itself to the House.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is purely a drafting amendment for consistency with the wording of section 22 (5).
Comment on this
This can be taken in conjunction with amendment No. 49.