Ceapacháin Rialtais. - Wildlife Bill, 1975: Committee Stage.
Contributions 120–223 of 223. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1975 ›
(Cavan): This is also a drafting amendment consequent on the amendment on page 21, line 20.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The purpose of this new paragraph (e) is to provide exceptions for the humane killing of protected wild animals captured or injured in these circumstances. It corresponds to the similar provision in section 22, subsection (5), paragraph (d).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:
In page 21, subsection (7), lines 42 to 45, to delete subparagraph (i).
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 51, 61, 111 and 112 may be discussed together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The provision in the paragraph referred to merely repeats the existing situation and, having regard to the general attitude to coursing as reflected in the Bill, I do not propose to delete it.
Comment on this
If the Minister is not prepared to go so far as to eliminate coursing, would he not feel that it would be appropriate to at least regulate coursing to prevent cruelty and abuses in connection with it? For example, the present law against cruelty to animals is the Protection of Animals Acts, the later one being in 1965. This legislation applied to wild animals and did not stop, for example, hares being kept in a shed for a long period of time before being coursed and being cruelly treated in relation to that.
Comment on this
I was going to suggest to Senator Higgins it is agreed that we should rise at 5.30 p.m. and it does not seem to me that the Senator would finish within a minute. Possibly he would like to report progress.
Comment on this
I must pay tribute to the perception of Senator O'Higgins nothing that I will not finish within a minute. I am very grateful to Senator Robinson for having taken up this amendment, which I regard as being extremely important, and I shall resume on it. I now formally report progress.
Business suspended at 5.30 p.m. and resumed at 6.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I seek the support of the House for this amendment. The effect of this amendment will make coursing illegal. Subsection (7) states:
...nothing in this section shall make unlawful,
(i) the taking and killing of hares by coursing at a regulated coursing match which is held both during a period specified as regards hares in a hares order and in a place to which such order applies.
The Act would give a very minor level of control. The Minister has suggested that in the future attitudes towards wildlife may change. My view is that the barbaric practice of hare coursing should be stopped immediately. If this amendment is carried, then that will be the position.
Comment on this
I have not many observations to make. Coursing seems to have been a time-honoured pastime right down through the centuries in this country. Ancient histories and annals tell us that during certain months of the year people indulged in this sport. In recent times it has become commercialised and it provides employment for many people. I fail to see how, by introducing an amendment or making a law, one can prevent what is the ordinary cycle of one animal killing another. In coursing and bloodsports it is well known that the hare will get killed. It is inevitable that accidents will occur. I would not like to see hares hunted which had been kept in confinement for two or three days. The natural instinct of greyhounds is to hunt the hare and the natural instinct of the hare is to get out of the way as fast as he can. So far as animal nature and bird life is concerned, I do not think we can be blamed for it.
Comment on this
There is nothing wrong with hare hunting. There is keen competition attached to it. People involved in hare hunting will not attend meetings which are not properly organised. There is scope for escapes. Those hares are properly trained today. The greyhound industry is in the same position as our horse industry in that it is highly commercialised.
Comment on this
I am surprised at Senator Higgins's amendment. The Senator comes from a well-known coursing county. I was against coursing years ago when hares were killed very frequently. But that day is gone. The Irish Coursing Club have gone a long way to see that that does not happen any more. Any coursing club that does not have strong hares or does not care for the hares properly should not get a licence from the Irish Coursing Club for the following year.
While none of us likes to see a hare being killed at a coursing meeting, I believe the number that are killed now is much reduced on what it was in previous years. I would ask Senator Higgins not to pursue the prohibition of coursing. If it is prohibited, a lot of people will miss a sport they enjoy and, as a result, many people will be out of employment.
Comment on this
I, too, am a bit surprised that Senator Higgins is bringing this amendment before the Seanad. There are claims by minority groups that coursing is a very harsh sport. On the other hand, we have to take into consideration that coursing is fundamental to our greyhound industry. The Irish Coursing Club are doing an excellent job in the preservation of the hare species, irrespective of what those minority groups say. The coursing club see to it that the hares are allowed to roam free through the country when coursing is completed.
There are people who claim that the hares are ill-treated prior to coursing meetings. I attend coursing meetings and I have never seen evidence of this at any coursing meeting, but quite the opposite. The hares are adequately and perfectly cared for, both prior to the coursing meeting concerned and afterwards. I would advocate that coursing be maintained in its present form.
Comment on this
I am fascinated listening to the contributions to this amendment which I have the pleasure of supporting. I find it interesting. We are now on amendment No. 51 of this Wildlife Bill and I did not hear a squeak out of this side of the House until we started to discuss an amendment to abolish coursing. I have been told that there is a very strong procoursing lobby in this country and I now see evidence of it. I believe that coursing is a very cruel sport. It is cruel in its intent and cruel in the way it is applied. I would accept that certain improvements have been made in the past few years but I do not think they meet the principle of trying to prevent unnecessary and deliberate cruelty to animals. I do not think any safeguard which may have been mentioned would be sufficient to take away the essence of what this is all about—coursing a hare: trials where a number of hares are killed, the cruelty of the whole matter.
Curiously enough, as a member of the Joint Committee on the Secondary Legislation of the European Communities, I had the pleasure of going on a deputation to the Westminster Parliament. We met various members of the House of Commons Committee who had stayed up until 4 a.m. the night before to pass a Bill to abolish coursing. Here we have an opportunity, by supporting this amendment in the name of Senator Higgins, of not staying up until 4 a.m. but of achieving the same result.
Comment on this
I should like to support Senator Higgins's amendment. Like Senator Robinson, I am fascinated by the capacity of the Senators who have spoken in favour of coursing to minimise the total barbarity of this concept, which they support, of using two very fast animals, greyhounds, which are trained exclusively for this particular purpose, to hunt, to tear apart and to kill probably one of the gentlest of God's created animals, inflicting, inevitably and invariably, unnecessary pain on this tiny animal. I know most of the Senators who have spoken here well enough to know that they are kindly and gentle people, who would not go out of their way to harm or to hurt anything or anybody. I am totally astonished at this extraordinary blockage, which quite obviously they have about this acceptance of this barbaric practice of using extremely skilled, fast greyhounds to kill a little animal of this kind. They cannot be unmoved by the fact that, as Senator Robinson has said, the British House of Commons—in which there is such a high percentage of the kind of people who believe in these types of sports— passed an Act ending this kind of thing. They obviously appear to have much more civilised beliefs on this subject of killing little animals, painfully, deliberately and, above all, most shamefully enjoying the spectacle. What kind of human being can indulge in this kind of sport and enjoy it?
A Senator talked about the cat killing the mouse, an animal hunting in the ordinary way and killing painfully in the ordinary way. But these are animals; we are meant to be higher creatures altogether with the capacity to reason, to examine, and to project our own feelings into the experience of other people or other animals. Surely there is no individual here who would get up and try to defend these things: that to be hunted is heavenly, to be hunted is a happy experience, to be hunted is something which is great sport. To be hunted by two animals with this wonderful apparatus of the powerful jaws and the teeth, who, if they catch you, will tear you apart until you are painfully dead— that this could be considered to be a sport by any mature adult human beings defies my comprehension.
As I said, cats follow mice. All right. Do we accept that this is a natural activity on the part of the cat? Do we then put ourselves on the level of cats, of the lion, the leopard and the tiger? Are we no higher than these animals? Have we no capacity to understand pain and suffering in others? Do we necessarily respond to our most primitive instincts: to kill and to enjoy killing?
How can these kinds of attitude be reconciled with any kind of civilised behaviour? The whole movement in the world is against this kind of thing — the imposition by human beings of unnecessary and avoidable pain on one another and particularly on innocent animals who are doing absolutely nothing. It is understandable that the lion that is terrorising the herd of sheep or pigs, or whatever it might be, in Africa or India might create resentment and anger on the part of the people who suffer as a result of the loss of their stock. But the hares are doing nothing to us. They are running away as fast as they can from us; they are trying to avoid any contact with us at all. We have to catch them and then, as somebody suggested, train them to accept that they will be killed painfully and enjoy it and give us sport in watching their horrible death. Surely for us this is a totally shameful pastime—"pastime" and "sport" are the words being used. We in Ireland will be the last outpost of this barbarous sport. We will have all these other half-savages from Britain, denied in their own country the spectacle of watching these little animals being tortured and killed painfully, flooding in here in order to get the enjoyment, the thrill, the excitement, the pleasure denied to them by the civilised decision of the House of Commons to stop them doing these terrible things to little animals.
Frankly, speaking as a psychiatrist, it is worth examining the kind of people who indulge in this masochistic practice. What is wrong with you people that you enjoy this kind of thing? Have you ever wondered about your own emotional makeup that makes you enjoy the sound of an animal screaming to death, being torn to pieces, bleeding to death, being hunted, frightened, running away? Do the Senators ever wonder why they enjoy this kind of grotesque and horrible state? This is the kind of thing that one gets in the more disreputable night spots in Soho—this kind of pleasure. What is wrong with the Senators who enjoy this kind of thing? What happened to them on their way up what they have emotionally become so totally disturbed that they get pleasure from watching tiny animals killed painfully?
One of the Senators suggested that it has been commercialised. Yes, indeed, it has been commercialised. What is worse is that it is going to be further commercialised in order to give the English barbarians the pleasure of joining with the Irish barbarians in the pursuit of this particular pleasure. That, of course, adds to the moneys involved. Clearly, as a race, we will do anything for money. This is one of the dangers that the Minister has to face. What kind of protection has he given in this Bill except the protection of those with a vested interest in seeing that it is expanded and extended as rapidly as they possibly can extend and expand it, irrespective of the consequences to these unfortunate animals?
Evidence has been produced to show that the Irish Coursing Club have not supervised carefully the way in which these animals are, what is so euphemistically and misleadingly called, trained. One has visions of the gladiators entering the arena in ancient Rome who were trained to fight the lions before being torn to death. "Trained." How we can misuse the word. How can a tiny little, five or six inch high, animal, terrified out of its life, become trained in order to prevent two greyhounds trained to catch it and kill it from catching and killing it? Surely it is completely disgraceful that you should attempt to mislead the House, even if you are misleading yourself into believing that you do not know quite well what you are doing in your advocacy of this cruel, horrible, revolting spectacle known as greyhound coursing, racing, or whatever you like to call it.
Comment on this
I just want to reply to Senator N. Browne. The Senator accused us of misleading the House. If there is anybody misleading the House about coursing it is Senator Browne. I should like to make it very clear that nobody in this House gets any pleasure from seeing a hare killed at a coursing meeting. We get pleasure and enjoyment if the hare escapes. Ninety per cent of the hares escape at coursing meetings. In any sport there are bound to be casualties. Very few are taking place now on our coursing fields. Senator Browne seems to think that we will have an invasion from Britain because coursing is prohibited in Britain. As far as I know coursing is not prohibited in Britain yet. It has been passed through the House of Commons but it is not law yet and I do not believe that it will be law in England. I should just like to assure the Senator once again that we get no enjoyment from the killing of hares. Thank God very few hares are killed at coursing meetings today. This is due to the steps taken in recent years by the Irish Coursing Club.
Comment on this
I could not agree with Senator N. Browne. The man has gone a bit hysterical. He is seeing us all as barbarians just because we support coursing. He is being unfair to the Irish Coursing Club. The Senator does not give them due credit for the improvements they have brought about in recent years and the efforts they have made to eliminate cruelty at coursing meetings.
The greyhound industry contributes millions of pounds to this country and the abolition of coursing would eliminate this valuable source of revenue.
During the Second Reading of this Bill it was stated that frequently hares which had been coursed at a meeting were then sold off to another coursing club. I am informed that this is not so, that it is illegal, and that action is taken by the controlling board against any individual, or any club, who might do this. It may have been done in the past, but it is a practice which has been largely eliminated.
A coursing club is paid £5 for each hare which it releases after a coursing meeting. Surely this is a tremendous incentive towards abolishing cruelty and giving the hare a fair chance. Hares are not sold by one club to another. They are let go free. I fail to see the consistency of people who support this amendment. Why do this pressure group not advocate that cruelty to other animals, which is far more widespread and far more cruel, should be eliminated? Why do they not protest against other forms of cruelty? The leading zoologist in this country has assured me that a fish which is caught on a hook, be it a salmon, a mackerel, or any other fish, suffers as much as if it were a human being. Surely this is considerably more cruel than the fate of a hare which dies within seconds of being caught by a greyhound or two?
Comment on this
Senator Browne made no reference to any of these forms of cruelty. I am sure Senator Browne eats fish. He probably also eats lobsters and crabs which have to be boiled alive. I cannot imagine any more excruciating form of pain than to be boiled alive, yet we condone this practice. I have never heard an objection to it. Let us be consistent.
Many people go out shooting. I am sure more birds are grievously injured than are actually killed. I am sure there are thousands of birds flying around with a considerable amount of buckshot in their posteriors and suffering grievously. There has been no mention of this from anyone. As Senator William Ryan has pointed out, Senator Browne made a very incorrect statement in saying that coursing followers enjoy the spectacle of seeing the hares killed. This is untrue. They do not enjoy it. They are delighted if the hares escape and go free after the coursing meeting. There is widespread publicity whenever hares are killed at a coursing meeting. This is spotlighted and given large headlines. There was nothing in the newspapers about a coursing meeting held in Donabate two weeks ago when no hare was killed. Surely that should have been commented upon. There is none so blind as him who will not see. They did not want to take note of this.
It is not true to say that coursing has been abolished in Britain. The Bill outlawing coursing was passed in the House of Commons. It was not passed in the House of Lords. I believe the Bill has died and will not be brought forward again. Coursing is continuing in Britain and it looks as if it will continue for many more years. I definitely oppose this amendment.
Comment on this
I also oppose the amendment. People from the rural areas are completely opposed to this amendment. It is marvellous to have a hare in a hunt. Why was the hare created? The hare was created because greyhounds were created. If hares are not hunted and are allowed to stay together in large numbers, they become inbred in a very short time. Everyone knows that an inbred hare is nearly blind and will die in a short time. No pair of dogs will ever kill a good black hare. Inbred hares are good for nothing. Coursing clubs are doing a very good job by releasing hares in different parts of the country at meetings. If hares are properly fed with oats, turnips and cabbage they will not be killed.
As previously stated, there was a coursing meeting recently in Donabate and not one single hare was killed at it. Our greyhound industry is one of our greatest industries and we will not have a greyhound industry unless we have hares. We will not have good greyhounds unless they hunt hares. For these reasons I am totally opposed to the amendment.
Comment on this
It is important to keep a sense of proportion in this debate. It is a debate that can be easily coloured by emotive phrases by Senators who give me the impression that they have never been to a coursing meeting and who got most of their knowledge from articles in magazines written by the anti-coursing fraternity. I am not a member of either the pro-coursing or the anti-coursing lobby. It is many years since I attended a coursing meeting, although I live very close to one of the most famous meetings in the world, the Irish Cup at Clounanna.
As Senators said, it is true that all sportsmen who go to coursing meetings go to see the dogs. It is a contest between the dogs and not between the dogs and the hare. Everybody regrets when a hare is killed. I notice that none of the abolitionists has produced any statistics, but statistics have shown over the years that there has been a steady decline in the number of hares killed, particularly in long coursing, which is now the most usual type of coursing in Ireland.
The greyhound industry is a very valuable one. Every sportsman regrets the killing of any animal, whether it is a fox killed in the hunt, or a hare killed by beagles, or by dogs, but the basic industry is so large and has so many ramifications that any amendment put down without going fully into all the aspects of it should be considered very carefully before it is supported. I see no reason for supporting it. I acknowledge the concern of those who see only the hare being killed or maimed. They should remember that the hare is a necessary ancillary factor in the sport of coursing. The main thing is the dogs. People bet on the dogs and watch them coursing and applaud when a hare escapes.
It is also well to remember that the number of hares killed after a coursing meeting, outside the course itself, by youths or itinerants with guns, is generally far greater than the number of hares killed at a coursing meeting. As has been stated, hares who escape at a coursing meeting are not destroyed. They are resold. All coursing clubs prohibit the shooting of hares within their own confines. It would have been more helpful if somebody had suggested methods by which the rate at which hares are being killed could be decreased. That would have been a constructive proposal, but to try to demolish a valuable industry by one sweeping amendment is something which this House should not countenance.
Comment on this
I want to make a few points perfectly clear. Dr. Shirley Summerskill, when she was speaking on the Bill which was introduced in the House of Commons—I am referring to the Official Report, Volume 893, No. 137, of Friday 13th June, 1975—quoted from a speech by the Leader of the House in which the following was said justifying why her Bill should be taken: "It is always right to spend time trying to get rid of cruelty whether to human beings or to animals. That is what we are doing."
I hope to have time to deal with other forms of cruelty, cruelty to children, and so on, in whatever time I am allowed in public life. This is just cruelty to hares. The point is that in that debate in the House of Commons no one justified this practice. We should be unemotive about this matter. Senators said that statistics were not used correctly. Where are the objective statistics which show that 90 per cent of the hares escape? We know that does not happen.
Anybody who has studied instincts —I have studied instinctual behaviour in human, sub-human and extra-human life—will know there is no necessary connection between the instinct to chase and the instinct to kill. There is no proof whatsoever that the greyhound industry is at risk. There is not one whit of evidence for that. It is inaccurate to say the greyhound industry is at stake. I had hoped this matter would not be controversial and that the different parties would not disagree on it.
An important point was made by Senator Dolan, for whom I have the greatest respect. He is a sensitive teacher in a rural area. There are many ways of encountering life, wildlife in particular. On Second Stage I asked Senators to recall their experience as children of holding an injured bird or animal in their hand. They respected it and wondered at it. It is a terrible reflection on them that as educated adults they find it necessary to go coursing for entertainment.
I did not mislead the House. If amendments Nos. 51, 61, 111 and 112 were accepted there would be an end to this barbaric practice. The facts are there. There will still be greyhounds, but the circumstances of an encounter between a small animal like the hare and those who pursue it will have changed. People can look at hares, photograph them, and admire them, but they will not be able to be present at the spectacle of a hare being torn apart. That is what the amendments are about. As someone who wants to eliminate cruelty in life generally, even on this very minor case of a hare, I could not withdraw those amendments.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I should like to bring this debate down to reality. First of all, I should like to tell the House the exact purpose of the Bill we are now discussing. I can do that best by referring to the Long Title of the Bill. It is:
An Act for the conservation of wildlife (including game) and for that purpose to protect certain wild ceatures and flora, to enable a body to be known as the Wildlife Advisory Council to be established and to define its functions, to enable certain other bodies to be established to provide or administer certain services, to enable reserves and refuges for wildlife to be established and maintained, to enable dealing in and movement of wildlife to be regulated and controlled, to make certain provisions relating to land, inland waters and territorial seas of the State, to amend certain enactments and to make other provisions connected with the foregoing.
The principal objective of this Bill, and all else is subsidiary to it, is to conserve wildlife. Such information as is available to me and my Department does not indicate that there is any danger of the hare species becoming extinct. As a matter of fact, I would think that the last people in Ireland who would like to see the hare becoming extinct are the organisers of coursing matches. If the hare became extinct coursing as it is known now would come to an end. I am not denying that there is an argument for and against this view. There is a coursing lobby and an anti-coursing lobby. I suggest that this Bill is not the appropriate place to deal with what is essentially, if the sponsors of the amendment are correct, cruelty to animals. The legislation dealing with cruelty to animals, the Acts of 1911 and 1965, are under the aegis of other Departments. The Act of 1911, which dealt with cruelty to animals, apparently only dealt with domestic animals. The Act of 1965 extended the provisions of that Act to wild animals.
What we are dealing with in this amendment is the practice of coursing. Coursing is regulated by the Greyhound Industry Act, 1958, which was passed by Dáil Éireann and established Bord na gCon, restructured the Irish Coursing Club and consolidated coursing. Senator Browne was a Member of Dáil Éireann in 1958. Without doing some research—and I do not mean to be offensive—I cannot say exactly which party he belonged to, or if he was in any party. I know he will not take that as an offensive remark. The Greyhound Industry Act passed through its final stages in Dáil Éireann on 5th March, 1958. The Official Report shows that Senator Browne was a Member of Dáil Éireann on that date, that the question was put and that the Bill was passed by agreement without one single, solitary, dissenting voice. I am putting that statement on the record of the House so that we may have consistency.
I accept the fact that there is an argument for and against this matter and some people feel emotional about it. I must say I sense a lack of consistency in proposing this amendment to bring an end to coursing on the ground that it is cruel. Senator Browne has obviously overstated his case because he said it is deliberate killing of the hare. Deliberate killing is not involved in coursing. People who organise coursing matches, if they had a choice, would like to see the hare escape. Matters are so arranged that the hare gets a reasonably long slip and has a chance of escaping. It has been said here that 90 per cent of the hares coursed escape. I do not know whether that is too high a percentage. Certainly, all the hares coursed are not killed, and that is an understatement. I would say more hares escape than are killed.
There is no doubt that hares which are killed suffer, but I find it very difficult to understand people picking out this particular form of sport, or this particular form of activity, and seeking to bring it to an end in a Bill which is riddled with activities which inflict some degree of suffering and pain on wildlife. Nobody has raised a voice in this House against the practice of fowling or shooting. We all know that if a pheasant or a duck is shot, it suffers. We also know that if it is maimed and not killed, it suffers an injury to a wing or a leg and escapes into the reeds and lives for a time, it suffers. There is no objection to that practice here. I am not asked to outlaw fowling or shooting of wildfowl. I wonder is it because this is an emotional topic, because the practice of coursing is emotional, that we have this amendment put down which I say is not relevant to the Bill.
The Bill is not introducing coursing. It is not extending coursing. I admit the Bill is preserving the status quo as far as coursing is concerned. It gives me authority, as Minister for Lands, to protect the hare if the hare needs protection in order to preserve the species. I want to emphasise that. That is what the Bill is all about.
It has been said here that coursing has been declared illegal or prohibited in the United Kingdom. The position there is that a Bill to do just that was passed by the House of Commons. It had not been passed by the House of Lords when the session came to an end. I am informed that, that being so, it must now go back to the House of Commons, and be reintroduced there and processed all over again. I am also informed that it did not appear in the Queen's speech referring to legislation to be dealt with during the new session. Therefore, as of now, or in the immediate future, there is no danger of the rush of people from across the water Senator Dr. Browne fears.
I regard this as a Bill to conserve wildlife. It is the first Bill introduced towards that end in over 40 years. It does not deal with cruelty to animals or cruelty to anything else. We have elaborate statutory provisions dealing with coursing. Prior to the Greyhound Industry Act, 1958, coursing matches had to get licences from the Irish Coursing Club. I assume that is still the position. If it is still the position, the licences issued by the Irish Coursing Club or Bord na gCon—I think it is the Irish Coursing Club—have the statutory backing of the Greyhound Industry Act, 1958. If any change is to be made, it should be made at that level.
Reference has been made to the Bill introduced in the British House of Commons to outlaw coursing. If I may say so, with respect, that is the proper way to deal with it, if it is thought necessary to deal with it. A separate Bill was introduced to deal with it. Here we are asked to use a Bill introduced for one purpose to make a major decision in regard to another practice, and in regard to one of our major industries. I make no apology for preserving the status quo. I am preserving the status quo as far as coursing is concerned. When the day comes when I am advised, or my advisers are advised, that the hare is in danger of extinction, I can declare a close season without exception, or with limited exception, just as I could for pheasants, wild duck, partridge, woodcock, deer, and so on.
Comment on this
I have no regrets for the way in which I spoke about this practice. A few points were raised by other speakers. The question of protesting against the other horrible practices of contemporary Irish society, otter hunting, was raised. It was suggested that I had not protested against it. I spoke at some length, and with equal vehemence, I hope, on the appalling practice of hunting and killing that most delightful and wonderful little creature, the otter, by the completely insensitive and obviously in some way or other emotionally disturbed human beings who organise a pack of hounds in order to hunt this animal to the extent that they finally club it to death. Of course I protested against that. The Minister continues to allow that practice to go on. I have protested against the killing of birds by shooting them and the way that they are killed and maimed and made to suffer. One Senator referred to the boiling of lobsters. I like lobster but I do not eat lobster for the very reason he pointed out, that they are boiled alive.
Comment on this
I happen to be dealing with us. I have to live here and I have this tiny bit of responsibility for the way we behave. Somebody seems to get a little satisfaction from the fact that, in our pursuits, in our sense of sport, in our attitude to animals, we are on a par, not with the House of Commons—the ordinary decent people of Britain; some in the Conservative Party, most of them in the Labour Party there—but we are on a par with the House of Lords and we are quite pleased about it. We know well who the House of Lords are.
Comment on this
Before the Senator goes on to make close comparisons I might point out that the Minister is required in another place. It is a matter for the Senator himself whether he wishes to continue speaking in the absence of the Minister.
Comment on this
It is open to the Senator to continue to make his contribution and for the debate to continue even though the Minister absents himself.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I have no objection at all to the Senator continuing with his contribution and I will have an opportunity of reading it in the Official Report later on.
Comment on this
I am very sorry that we are apparently not ashamed of the fact that we share with the House of Lords these attitudes on cruelty and the hunting of tiny animals with these greyhounds.
The Minister referred to the question of conservation. One of the points mentioned by the anti-coursing lobby which he mentions is that, because coursing has been uncontrolled or not properly controlled by the Irish Coursing Club, there is the real danger that the hare might disappear and that we will not succeed in the conservation of animals. I do not think the Minister can absolve himself from the responsibility to amend laws when the defects in them are brought to his attention by saying that this is something that was passed in 1958, 20 years ago, and that because it was good enough for all of us 20 years ago it is good enough for us now.
One of the wonderful things about experience and growing old is that one learns, and one should learn. This is the depressing conclusion one must come to about so many of the Senators here: we are all products of the same dreadful culture which educated all of us to believe that there was nothing wrong about cruelty to animals, or a particular kind of animal, at any rate. I shared all of these beliefs. For a great part of my life one of the most shaming things in it was the fact that I held these views until I came to have the capacity to reason about these things myself and decided that the evidence I saw, which is available to all the other Senators, is that this is a very cruel sport.
In reply to Senator Russell, of course I have been to a coursing match. It is a very cruel sport. I have seen two hounds tear a hare apart, catch the hare at the same time and simply tear it apart. That has happened. Part of me would prefer the Senator who says that it is just too bad if that happens. I think there is an element of hypocrisy in Senator Russell's suggestion that everybody regrets if the hounds kill the hare, and they would prefer the hare to escape. But who puts the hare at risk? Who catches the hare in order to course him? Who allegedly trains them to run in a straight line or whatever else it is he wants him to do that he would not do anyway, hunted by two hounds trying to kill him? Who organises the coursing matches in which the hare is going to get killed? If there was any sincerity in this protestation that "we would prefer the hare to escape", why put the hare at risk at all? Quite obviously, that is a hypocritical reflection and I would prefer the Senator who says, "This is a great sport. I am going to go on enjoying it and getting pleasure out of watching the deliberate killing of a tiny animal by these highly skilled greyhound racing machines."
Anybody who has been at a coursing match will recall the extraordinary excitement, the completely disturbed excitement, at the end of the competition just to see which hound will catch the hare first and tear it to pieces. First, there is the excitement between the two poor animals who are depraved in this way by being made to take part in this revolting spectacle. What is even more obscene is to listen to the blood lust cries of these dignified elders of our society— Senators amongst them, presumably. The leaders of society, pillars of the Establishment, lose themselves in these wild cries for the blood of the unfortunate tiny little hare. How could anybody attempt to defend this as permissible sport?
One of the shocking things is to hear a teacher talk in this way—the teacher who is responsible for inculcating into little children attitudes and values and standards. If he enjoys this killing, if he enjoys this cruelty, if he enjoys the spectacle of the tiny little animal running for his life from these dreadful animals who are trying to kill it, what is he going to convey to these little children put into his care, except a contempt for love, a disregard for suffering, a disinclination to avoid inflicting pain on the dependent animal, or even on another human being; thus turning out from our schools so many youngsters who basically are wonderful, fine children but corrupted in their values, in their understanding of man's responsibility to something so completely put into his care as is a weak defenceless animal?
The whole process to taking the animal, hunting it and killing it for sport—not even to eat the thing—is its own other dreadful commentary on the primitive remaining in our society and reflected in many other aspects of our lives. How little have we achieved in half a century? How little leadership have we given to the world in any of these finer aspects of human behaviour? We appear to give in to the most primitive lusts and the blood lust is the most primitive of all. This is a shameful neglect on the part of the Minister.
Comment on this
If I believed, as Senator Browne obviously believes, that coursing is purely for the enjoyment of people seeing hares being torn apart, then I would be opposed to coursing. The Senator has a completely mistaken idea of what the sport of coursing is. I make no apologies for calling it a sport. The Senator is quite right when he says there is a certain exclamation when two dogs pass one another and people are concerned with the winning of the chase. The same applies when an artificial hare is involved. The same situation applies when racehorses are involved. People are interested in the speed of the animals involved, and perhaps place a bet on the matter as well.
We should try to understand what is involved. This is part of nature. It would be just as logical to oppose rod and line fishing as to oppose any type of sport that involves the risk of animals losing their life. Those involved in coursing have a greater interest in preserving wildlife and in some cases possess a greater knowledge of it than many of those who decry coursing. They do not tolerate unnecessary suffering where wild animals are concerned. To a great extent the unnecessary suffering of the past has been eliminated. This is due to the influence of people concerned who are ensuring that no unnecessary suffering takes place. If a hare is killed nobody regrets this more than the people involved in this very important greyhound industry.
Those who are involved in rod and line fishing would like to ensure that no fish were killed. Unfortunately this is not so. This is how nature has arranged things. We have to accept facts as we find them at the moment. We are doing less than a service to the people involved in the greyhound industry when we imply that they attend coursing meetings just to see hares killed or torn apart. This is a mistaken idea and one that ought not to be put across in a responsible debate.
Comment on this
I gave my reasons for supporting coursing at an earlier Stage of this Bill. Since Senator N. Browne has classified those opposed to this amendment as barbarians, it is only right that I should comment. Is it a coincidence that it seems to be the same lobby of Senators who oppose coursing also want contraceptives introduced?
Comment on this
It seems that the Senators who are putting forward this amendment are more worried about the odd hare that is killed than about the whole moral structure of our people. Every care is taken at each coursing meeting to see that no hare is killed if at all possible.
Comment on this
I have never witnessed coursing. There is no coursing carried on in my area. I am neither in favour of coursing nor against it. I object to the hysterical, passionate pleas from some people who I think do not understand nature. I have spent all my life caring for animals. As a young boy I looked for birds' nests and studied their progress. I know what animals suffer in the natural course of events. The otter may be described as a lovely little animal, but in another sense he is a vicious creature which kills other animals.
Years ago I gave up fishing because I did not like taking a hook out of a live fish, but I do not try to stop my neighbours from doing it. On the other hand, I see that the other fish eat the little fish. If some of them were not caught they would probably suffer from some malignant disease that would be much worse than taking them out on the end of a line and hook. We are making an uproar out of nothing. If we hear a passionate speech and the other side of the story is not heard, we can be led to believe that the people who take a certain line are very humane people. I do not accept that. The same humane people would cut to the bone their political opponents if they got the opportunity. They would seize the opportunity to be very cruel to people who have understanding and feelings. Some people a few months ago seemed to enjoy the spectacle of the Americans being chased out of Vietnam. I cannot accept that their concern for animal life is entirely sincere.
I do not like the idea of the two hounds killing the hare at a coursing match. On the other hand I do not want to stop my neighbours from coursing because I have a fair idea how the hare would die anyway. That hare would not die in a nursing home, being tucked in by nurses, injected by doctors to kill the pain. Did anyone ever see a hare dying from liver fluke on a cold hillside in the winter months? This is nature, and nature can be cruel too. I am not particularly concerned with the hare that is killed by the hounds because I have a fair idea of how that hare would be killed otherwise.
I have seen crows caught in traps. I would not set a trap for a crow, but I have seen crows grow old and die around the ditches and being picked up by the fox. It does not make any difference how the crow meets his end. With nature being what it is these creatures do not die what we consider a very happy death.
I pity the people who seem to enjoy for itself the spectacle of the hare being killed more than I pity the hare. I have no doubt that such people exist. If we prevent them from killing hares it will not make them any better, nor will it make the hares any better off. I have seen farmers and people in the country inflict suffering on animals. On the other hand I have seen farmers in the height of the summer season take their machines out of a meadow for fear of killing a few pheasant chickens, and wait for the mother bird to take them away.
Nature is very complicated and diverse. It is far too easy for someone to paint this picture about suffering and cruelty when they do not understand the situation. If there is anything I can do to prevent cruelty in this world, I would do it. If there was no coursing I would not be asking for a law to legalise it or make it possible. However I do not feel we have anything to achieve, but possibly something to lose, by getting rid of it at the moment.
These are my personal views and I would like to see people being more realistic and putting every side of the story properly balanced. I do not think there is anything to be gained by pressurising the Minister to inconvenience a number of people, to put a certain section of our people at a disadvantage and deprive ourselves of what some people consider a sport, and at the same time not to gain anything in return.
Comment on this
I think that it would always be a terrible reflection on this House or on any other legislative assembly if we were afraid to inconvenience people to stop cruelty.
A lot has been said. Senators have spoken from all sides and explained their points of view. There are two points on which I should like to reply. I think the Minister will agree that on the Second Stage of the Bill I paid tribute to the positive sections of the Bill. You cannot have positive sections—for example, the sections on the extension of forests—and at the same time continue to allow this practice. Perhaps that should have been the subject matter of separate legislation, a separate Bill. Another Senator has pointed out that simply by accepting this group of amendments—Nos. 51, 61, 111 and 112—we can do what it took an entire Bill to do in another House. The advantage is that we are disposing of this matter in a much faster and easier way than anything else. This is why it is important this evening.
Other phrases have been used. One Senator said "nature being what it is". Nature can be many things. In my own Second Reading speech I mentioned the symmetry of the universe, the delicate balance which exists between different life systems and so on and the necessity for men, for example, in mindless technological pursuits and indulging in mindless consumerism, to try to have a respect for life in general. That is what nature means to me. Other Senators have said that I should know better because I am from an area where coursing is strong. That is one of the reasons I am insisting on this. I am from that area and so I know what coursing is. In accenting these amendments I think we would be making a beginning towards the elimination of cruelty in society.
Comment on this
I should like to support Senator Higgins. I cannot accept the argument that we must feel inhibited in putting restrictions on certain sporting activities. As someone who comes from the country and has taken part in a number of activities which have been referred to, I think there are limits and that these limits change as society's view of life and of nature changes. For example cock-fighting was at one time legal practice here and it was seen fit to make it illegal. Coursing falls into the same category. One of the great problems is that of the widely reported abuses which occur at coursing meetings. These amendments are designed to try to tighten up coursing regulations. Coursing is a sport which should be abolished altogether like some other sports.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I should like to refer to one or two matters that have been raised by Senator Higgins. The Senator came to the heart of the matter when he said that, without any lengthy Bill and by half-an-hour's discussion here this evening on an amendment to another section, we could do away with coursing once and for all. That would be a bad day for democracy if we were to deal with a major issue like coursing with what I might call a side-kick like this.
This is a Bill dealing with conservation. Coursing has been here for a long time. There are arguments for and against it, but I certainly do not think it should be brought to an end in the casual way that has been suggested by Senator Higgins, without a proper debate, without due notice that the proposal was coming before the Oireachtas to abolish coursing in toto. When the day comes that coursing is to be abolished and there is a sufficient majority in Parliament or a sufficient consensus to do it then it should be abolished by the introduction of a Bill for that purpose.
Senator West referred to cock-fighting. He said that it was legal at one time. I did not know that it was ever legal, although I knew it had been practised for a long time. If cock-fighting were regulated by law the cruelty might be minimised. The other battles on the Border probably have reduced the number of cock-fights that we had in that area, but until recently there were a number of cock-fights all over the country each year.
In the course of my research about Senator N. Browne I discovered that in 1958 he launched an all-out war on rats. He had a question down in the Dáil asking for a more energetic attack on rats with a view to exterminating that dangerous tribe. He did not include in his question that any precaution should be taken to ensure that they had a painless death or that they were chloroformed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It could be said that coursing has something to do with the economy. I would seriously suggest to the Senator——
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Senator did not put this proviso into his question about the rats. I would say in all seriousness to the Seanad that this is not the Bill and now is not the time to deal with coursing. To deal with coursing in a few amendments in a Bill with 72 sections covering a variety of things, fauna, flora and so on, would be most inappropriate and most undemocratic. I suggest that the amendments be withdrawn and that this major matter— some people would call it a major industry, others a major problem—should be dealt with at another time.
Comment on this
I am in agreement with the Minister in this respect. We should all be sensible and realise, as Senator Deasy has said, that the coursing industry is very important to the economy. It brings in almost £9 million at present. In the economic climate in which we live that is nothing to be sneezed at. Bord na gCon was set up in 1958. It had certain controls over coursing since its establishment—I am happy to say that its first chairman was a County Cavan man, the late Dr. Paddy Maguire—and it has standards which have been improved as certain things were brought to its notice. We must be sensible about these things.
I am often amazed at how eloquent Senator Browne and others can wax about various brands of cruelty. One would think to listen to them that they had cures for all these ills and that they would never inflict suffering on any animal or human being. Yet, as we know through their speeches and often through their actions, they have been very cruel indeed. Although we do not know their habits, I would respectfully suggest that some of them may have swallowed live oysters in their time. Some of them may have been fishing in our lakes and taken out fish and thrown them back again. Indeed some of these Englishmen to whom Senator Higgins has referred have come over to this country and caught fish with hooks, have taken them out, taken a look at them and thrown them back into the river or lake so that they undergo the same cruelty and hardship when the next band of fishermen come along.
As I said at the beginning, we cannot legislate here to prevent the ordinary chain that has been set up since the world was created. While people may wax eloquent about cruelty, at the same time they eat meat, they may wear fur coats and lizard skin shoes. You may be sure that in one way or another they are indirectly— if not directly—contributing towards death and cruelty because that is what all life seems to be about. While I am not from a coursing country, I know people who have greyhounds and they have not yet succeeded in breeding greyhounds without teeth or greyhounds who will not injure hares. In the ordinary coursing events I have been convinced—and my conviction has been strengthened by what I have heard here from people who come from counties in which coursing is practised as a sport and as an industry and a safety valve for relaxation— that there is no great pleasure taken from the death of a hare by those attending the event. There are ample and various escapes for the hare. If some of them get killed, we know, as Senator McCartin has said, that that would happen eventually anyway. If we search through nature and in our own country for various examples of cruelty it is something that is very difficult to define. There may be many shades of it both in the physical sense and other senses of it. In the course of our lives we may do something with which some people may agree, but there will be others who would feel that we are very cruel to them.
Senator Browne referred to teachers speaking in this debate. I, certainly, do not try to inculcate cruelty into pupils under my care. I never did. At the same time I am not so foolish as not to realise that young children have some idea of the facts of life and have some idea of what life and death mean. Many of them have experienced it in their own families and they often go to the butcher to buy meat, and surely they ask questions as to where it comes from. All these things are relevant. We need not think that we are going to get through life by being mute about these things. We are not going to rear some generation of children who will pass through the schoolroom and who will think that no animals are ever slaughtered or that there is no cruelty of any kind in this world.
Comment on this
I oppose this amendment, firstly, for the reason the Minister has just given. The greyhound industry is very important to the country. While I am not pro-coursing, I visited such an event many years ago, and the people who were agitating for the abolition of coursing may be doing so for very good reasons. I have been given very good reasons from time to time and the Minister should later on in the Bill make provision for bringing in regulations to deal with coursing where it has been degraded. I have only once attended a park coursing meeting and that was about 50 years ago and at that I was disgusted. But I have attended open coursing for several years and I have seen very few hares killed in that sport. In the park coursing people left themselves open to criticism for the cruel way in which animals were dealt with, particularly being kept in confinement for many weeks and maybe months in some cases before they were released, after having gone from place to place, and probably not fit for coursing anyway. In the natural habitat I have not seen the same cruelty. Perhaps it will be said that even if it is only one hare it is cruel. We must realise that it is a sport and many of the people who participate are not, in my opinion, barbaric. I am not a psychiatrist and therefore I would not know the background of the reasons why we kill. If we stop coursing we can logically go on to stop the killing of anything at all, even for the purposes of eating and living. I would not be in favour of this amendment at this stage. Later on in the Bill we will have an opportunity of giving the Minister an opportunity of bringing in regulations to ensure that the cruelty that has prevailed in coursing—and from those who are against coursing I gather there has been an improvement—will be stopped. I am neither for it nor against it. I am just looking at it as realistically as I can, and at this stage it would be unrealistic to ban coursing.
Comment on this
On a point of information, to the best of my knowledge, cock fighting was made illegal in the last century by an Act of the British Parliament which applies here. I hope that I do not take it from the Minister's reply that he intends to bring in a Bill legalising it because this would be a very retrograde step. I just wanted to make sure that I am not taking it up wrongly. There is a point which Senator Kerrigan made that needs to be amplified. I would agree with him. There is a considerable difference between the open and the closed coursing, and the abuses which I referred to are abuses that take place in the enclosed coursing and that is the particular sport to which I strenuously object.
Comment on this
I take great pleasure in opposing this amendment. The opponents to this amendment have been depicted as bloodthirsty psychopaths. I do not know if these are the exact words, but I do not consider myself to be in that category. I have never attended a coursing match in my life, nor have I ever wilfully killed a fly. Yet I oppose this amendment because the proposers have over-dramatised, overstressed their case. The case made this evening sounded ludicrous and hypocritical. There are other forms of life, both human and animal, which I would commend to the humanity and kindness of the proposers of the amendment who seem to be overflowing with the milk of animal rather than human kindness.
Comment on this
I want to correct an impression given that, first of all we have not had an opportunity of considering the seriousness of the amendments. When this Bill was debated on Second Stage I indicated that I would be putting down these amendments and it is not true to say that they were put down quickly and casually. They were put down deliberately and carefully, and in my speech on the Second Stage I said I would be putting down precisely such amendments. Neither is it true to say that we have had only a half an hour to discuss the impact of the amendments. We spent quite a long time on them. Quite obviously, few people are going to support my viewpoints. I would prefer if we took the points now. I wish to correct one other point. Senators have suggested that it is the same lobby which is involved in this as are involved in——
Comment on this
The other legislation with which I was associated is legislation that draws a distinction between Church and State. I intend to proceed with that legislation for a long time to come. We have had a fine debate in the House and we have discussed these amendments sufficiently. We should just make up our minds about them one way or the other.
Comment on this
From my experience of coursing—and I have attended quite a number of coursing meetings in my lifetime—hares in general are well treated. I do not believe that people go to coursing meetings to see hares killed. We all regret the killing of a hare. I can state with knowledge how hares are treated in Clounanna. For over two months of the season they are put into an enclosure and get the very best feeding. Anyone who has attended meetings there will have seen the strict conditions imposed before the dogs are released. If the stewards are not satisfied with the standards, the dogs are not released and this is signalled by a flag to the slipper. I have heard it said that this is a cause of cruelty to the dogs and not to the hare. A dog who has reached the finals has run on that course for 500 yards six times in three days. That is described as cruel by many people.
If hares are not hunted and if a small percentage of hares are not killed, what happens? Most of us here come from the rural areas. We have seen what had dropped. As a result the rabbits rabbit population and there was no mention of that here today. The number of people who used hunt rabbits had dropped. As a result the rabbits became so numerous that to save their crops the farming community were forced to import a disease which was transmitted by injection. Thousands of rabbits lay dying on the roadsides and in the fields. Their heads became swollen, they lost their sight and thousands of them died. By injecting one rabbit and placing him in a burrow the whole area was affected by myxomatosis. This resulted in the almost total destruction of the rabbit. That was extremely cruel and yet I heard very little objection to it. The same thing would have to happen to the hares if a number of them were not killed. Without coursing, hares would multiply rapidly and the farmers would be forced into action in an endeavour to protect their crops. One Senator mentioned that a number of hares die from fluke in a wet year. That is true. Were it not for coursing clubs thousands of hares would die because they would not be as well fed as they are at the moment.
Bord na gCon and ICC have gone a long way towards protecting the hare. Up to about eight years ago hares were often coursed at one small meeting to ensure that they would be put up before the dogs three times in a day. A week afterwards that hare would be sold to another coursing club for other meetings and would be put to the dogs perhaps another three times. Thanks to the ICC and Bord na gCon that has stopped. The hares are being cared for. As one Senator said, we never expect hares to die in a nursing home, but I am quite satisfied that the maximum care is taken to avoid as much cruelty as possible. Some people love to see something being killed. They love to hear of people taking poison or being shot. They are fanatics. But the vast majority of the sporting public do not go to a coursing meeting to see a hare killed.
Comment on this
I just want to answer a couple of points. One is about the sporting industry being very important. I know it is. It would be a great hardship indeed if greyhound racing in our cities and larger towns was discontinued, but it is possible to use an electric hare in ordinary greyhound racing, which is a totally painless experience but giving all the excitement of a race between competing dogs. But there is no element of pain, and nobody referred to that at all. It would surprise me to hear that the British, if they abolished greyhound racing and coursing, anticipated without some measure of apprehension the disappearance of all their greyhound tracks in the cities and towns of Britain. That was not being suggested.
Having been a little bit unkind to my Senator colleagues, I have to remind them that they have a kind streak somewhere within them, because if they go back to the legislation they will find that Senator Dolan, for whom I have great admiration, reminded us that there is great cruelty in the world, that this chain of cruelty is there and there is not an awful lot we can do about it. I dealt with this by saying that what is done in nature by animals should be different from the behaviour of human beings.
I acknowledge that there is great cruelty, that hares die from fluke and so on, but these are all the accidents of nature. What I am talking about is a deliberate act by human beings in hunting and killing these animals, but that is not really my point. My point arises out of, say, the eating of meat, which many people feel they should do, and the killing of animals, which is the obvious corollary to that. When I say they have a kind streak I mean that if they want a bullock killed for steaks and other beef products or if they want a sheep killed, the Oireachtas has been particular as to how they are killed.
There are the most stringent precautions because of the sense of kindness and decency and the anxiety not to hurt. So we surround the butchery trade with the most rigid precautions in order that the animals will not suffer. If they disobey these rules laid down by the Government they are prosecuted and brought before the courts. Nobody suggests that we should change the system and introduce one whereby a bullock from which we wanted a steak should be brought out into a large field and large-sized bloodhounds should be sent after it and hunt it until it was killed and then we could eat it. The same goes for sheep, lambs and pigs. We would think this was being very cruel to a helpless animal. It could give wonderful sport. The Spaniards do it to a certain extent in their appalling bull-fighting exhibitions to which there is worldwide revulsion. We hope eventually to see the end of that barbaric sport. We are not the only barbarians.
This is an important consideration when we are talking about this chain of cruelty in the world, natural cruelty. We do not treat any of the animals we eat like this, because it would be a very cruel thing to do— to put an animal out and hunt it with large bulldogs trained for this job. But we think there is nothing wrong at all with taking an eight or nine inches high animal and putting it into a virtual enclosure and setting these highly skilled, highly trained, fast animals on it to tear it apart painfully as a sporting spectacle for our enjoyment and pleasure.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
(Cavan): The new paragraph proposed is necessary in order to exempt the sports of beagling and harrying in pursuit of a hare during the open season for hares. These are long-established field sports which seldom result in the killing of a hare.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This final amendment to section 23 is intended to exempt the unavoidable killing of a protected wild animal. A similar amendment in respect of protected wild birds has been made in section 22. It deals with killing by motor car or accidental killing of an animal.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 54 and 57 are cognate and should be debated together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Sections 24 (2) and 25 (2) intend, among other things, to provide for the imposition of bag limits in the interests of conserving game birds and game animal stocks. However, it has been represented to me that the subsection, as drafted, would make its practical operation in the matter of bag limits very difficult. The proposed amendments would improve this situation by applying the limit to the number of game birds and game animals which may be taken by an individual shooter rather than to the overall number which may be shot in a particular open season.
Comment on this
It is a very sensible amendment. It is much the same kind of thing as operated by the Inland Fisheries Trust in regard to operated fishing on a number of lakes.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In subsection (1), line 34, to delete "may" and substitute "shall".
My personal view on this is that it is not necessary because I think I am right in saying that we are constantly being told by Ministers that there is no difference between "may" and "shall". Senator McGlinchey wishes to ensure that the Minister will make such orders as provided in this section and I gather the purpose of the amendment is to ensure that he shall. I should like to hear what the Minister has to say because my memory certainly is that Ministers always tend to tell us that, according to the parliamentary draftsman, "shall" is the same as "may". It never made sense to me but it looks as if the Minister is going to give us a different story.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I would not profess to propose that “shall” is the same as “may”. “May” is put in here to make it flexible because it is desirable that it should be flexible. The power in section 25—and, incidentally, the corresponding power in section 24—is an enabling one and flexibility in its operation is essential. While the intention is that ordinarily open seasons for the hunting of game species will continue to be declared as heretofore, full account will have to be taken of the circumstances surrounding each species. It may be that from time to time these would be such as would not warrant the declaration of an open season for a period in some particular case. For that reason the provision for the mandatory making of an order, as envisaged in the proposed amendment, would be too inflexible.
In other words, I am saying that ordinarily there will be an open season. I am also saying that there could be circumstances in respect of certain game species when it would not be desirable to have an open season in the interest of conservation. For that reason, the onus will be on the Minister to decide whether or not there should be an open season.
Comment on this
This section gives the Minister power to do what he has claimed in his closing remarks, namely, the power to have no open season at all except that provided for in section 27 under certain emergencies. Perhaps it is not section 27. It may be some other one.
I understand that the interpretation put on "may" and "shall" by parliamentary draftsmen is that there is not much difference between the two. But the feeling is that if "may" remains in this section it is not mandatory for the Minister to do this, whereas "shall" is mandatory. There is a fear that one day there may be a Minister for Lands who will not share the present Minister's views on game and wildlife in general. For example, if Senator Higgins was Minister for Lands he might not exercise the power provided under section 25 and would be protected by the word "may", whereas if "shall" is used he would be obliged to do so. This is the fear expressed by those people interested in this section.
Comment on this
Even if Senator McGlinchey's amendment is accepted it could not possibly achieve an open season of reasonable duration every year. If we read section 24 and section 25, the Minister could, if he was compelled by insertion of the word "shall", declare an open season for one day and one day only. Therefore the whole section would need to be re-cast to achieve it. I would have thought that the approach to this might have been rather different and that there might have been a case made to provide that the Minister shall in each year provide for close season rather than for an open season, if you are thinking of this in terms of conservation.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I should like to impress on the Seanad that the object of this Bill is to give the Minister sufficient and adequate powers to conserve the species and to ensure that they do not become extinct. If there were an obligation on the Minister to declare an open season or a hunting season each year in respect of any particular species, then a situation might arise where the species would become extinct. It is for that purpose that discretion must be given to the Minister to decide whether or not he should permit shooting of wild fowl or hunting or shooting of deer, hares or any other wild animal.
As Senator O'Higgins has pointed out, even if Senator McGlinchey's amendment is accepted at its face value, if the Minister wanted to be as unreasonable as Senator McGlinchey fears he might be, he would then only have to make an order declaring a minimal period, and that would become ridiculous.
I emphasise again that this is fundamental to the conservation objectives contained in this Bill. Various Ministers have declared close seasons all the year around in respect of certain birds. That has been the practice. Indeed, there is a close season all the time in respect of hen pheasants.
Senator McGlinchey also says that section 27 would give the Minister the necessary powers to protect any species in danger of becoming extinct. Section 27 is an emergency section to deal with an emergency situation. It gives powers to suspend an open season if the weather was so severe that birds or animals would become helpless and defenceless and would be slaughtered wholesale. That was the idea behind section 27. I am extending section 27 by way of an amendment to cover cases other than severe weather, such as disease and so on.
If the Senator considers section 25 again I think he will agree with me that it is properly drafted. To delete "may" and substitute "shall" would render it dangerous and would allow for a Minister to make an ineffective order in certain cases, to make an order of only a few days. It is necessary to deal with birds and animals which are becoming extinct. There is nothing new in it. I just cannot point at the moment to the Game Preservation Act, 1930, but it obviously contains a similar provision because otherwise it would not be possible to permit the shooting of cock pheasants and to prohibit the shooting of hen pheasants.
Comment on this
I take it therefore that the chances of Senator Higgins or Senator Browne becoming Minister for Lands are very remote?
Comment on this
The Minister interprets "may" in the way which would occur to one as being in accordance with the usual tenets of the English language. The next time some colleague of his tells me—in fact, I have been told this often in the past—that "may" and "shall" are equivalent—in parliamentary terms I will be happy to refer them to the present Minister for Lands.
With regard to the intention behind this section, one can quite see what the Minister intends and I do not think there will be any disagreement about this. Would the Minister consider the possibility of accepting an amendment on Report Stage which would perhaps more clearly reflect his intention? One could, for example, say that the Minister shall make an order to provide in this section except in such cases that he was satisfied that an order ought not be made for reasons of conservation, or some phraseology like that, which would make it clear that an order was to be made.
Comment on this
Possibly, but there does appear to be a worry that some Minister, at some future date, might interpret this to mean that he did not have to do it at all, which is clearly not what the Minister intends. It seems there is something to be said for putting in some such word as "shall" and a proviso that where some form of wildlife needs to be preserved conservation will be involved and the order will not be made. Perhaps one might be able to come up with something between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am satisfied that sections 25 and 27 combine all the situations that may arise. I will consider any amendment put down on Report Stage. I am obliged to do that. I do not want to give Senator Yeats any hope that I would change section 25 as it stands. I think it is adequate. It is reasonable and necessary to have it drafted in that way in order to give the Minister for Lands sufficient discretion to exercise the powers conferred on him under the Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is introduced for consistency in the provisions of section 24 (2).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:
Before section 26 to insert a new section as follows:—
"(1) Notwithstanding the provisions of any other enactment the Minister shall have power to make regulations governing every coursing match held by any coursing clubs affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club.
(2) A record of the number of hares killed during a coursing match held by any coursing club affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club or during captivity for the purposes of such a match shall be given to the Minister by the club concerned within 14 days of such a match.
(3) The Minister may direct that the proceedings of any coursing match held by a coursing club affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club may be photographed, filmed, televised or in any other way recorded."
We have had a debate on coursing. It is clear that there is a strong majority in favour of retaining the sport. I do not agree with that decision, but I accept it as the democratic decision. I realise that coursing will not be abolished. The reason I supported Senator Higgins's amendment, No. 51, was that I felt that at the moment there are frequent and widely reported abuses in coursing meetings. If the sport continues as it has been carried on over the last number of years then it is an entirely unsuitable sport which involves unnecessary cruelty to hares. The House feels that this is not a reason for abolishing the sport altogether.
I hope that I will receive some support when I put forward the view that, if coursing is to remain, some stricter controls should be exercised. Those controls would have two main objects: first to prevent unnecessary cruelty and, secondly, to protect our rapidly dwindling stock of hares. This is a very serious situation which is commonly referred to in the sporting media. In many parts of the country where coursing is extensively carried on the stock of hares has dwindled practically to vanishing point.
The proposals I make on this amendment are really proposals which, first, give the Minister power to make regulations concerning coursing matches; secondly, to ensure that a record of the number of hares killed at each coursing match is kept, is furnished to the Minister and is therefore available to the public, and, thirdly, that a televised, filmed or photographed record of each coursing meeting may be made on the direction of the Minister. These seem to be perfectly reasonable proposals. They do not in any way cut across the sport of coursing. I hope the Minister will see fit to accept them. This Bill deals with conservation. These proposals are aimed precisely in this direction.
I should like to refer to the many reports I have to hand of abuses at park coursing meetings. There is a distinction, which has been outlined by Senator Kerrigan, between enclosed and open coursing. I do not have these objections where open coursing is concerned. My remarks refer to enclosed coursing meetings.
I wish to quote from sections of the press to illustrate the abuses I refer to. The first quotation is from The Kerryman of 19th January, 1973. It is from the Tony Meade column, and he says he is not in the cruelty to animals lobby. It is a good illustration of the point I am making:
In this column last week I mentioned the coursing at Ballybeggan Park over the Christmas and the number of hares which died. There has been quite a response to it both from members of the general public and from coursing fans and where there was criticism it was mild. In other words, there is a general admission that the slaughter of hares is getting out of hand. Then I had a phone call from a friend in Valentia telling me of the coursing meeting there on Sunday —30 hares died. A woman who saw the hares being driven from the escape pen to the start made a plea for one hare who was obviously injured and the official in charge of the drive removed the injured animal. Some spectators did not take this too kindly and the woman in question was struck in the face with a handful of mud.
That people who run coursing would not stand over this kind of behaviour goes without saying. That 30 hares should die before the hounds can give pleasure to no one, least of all to the real coursing fan. But the slaughter goes on and now it is not merely the cruelty to animals lobby which is involved. Others—and I would place myself among them—regard the high death rate among hares as a reflection on the meetings and on the competence of those who are in charge of the meetings. What is the total death rate among the hare population of Kerry this coursing season? How long does any reasonable person think it can continue unless the clubs clean it up a bit by reducing this appalling toll. Why do some clubs run perfectly reasonable meetings at which the death rate is not above a handful and when hares are in a good condition for the tussle.
I have another couple of quotations I would like to make to illustrate the shortage of hares in various parts of the country. From the Connacht Telegraph, 6th December, 1973:
Westport coursing meeting, which was to have been held last Sunday, was postponed indefinitely when sufficient hares could not be found. This year's meeting was plagued with troubles, hares having escaped from the compound on two occasions. The first time the hares were deliberately freed, and it is understood they escaped on the second occasion.
A quotation from The Sporting Press 22nd November, 1973:
The National Open Cup sporting meeting, which was to take place at Newbridge this weekend has been postponed. At a committee meeting this week it was agreed that because of a scarcity of hares it would be inadvisable to attempt to run a meeting. The matter will be reviewed in the new year and a new date will be applied for then.
A quotation from The Nationalist, Clonmel, August 31st, 1973:
There was a remarkable decrease in the number of hares in West Tipperary. At one time it was the haven of animals like hares, foxes and rabbits. However the latter are very numerous.
One can read reports of this sort in the press regularly. One of the problems which the amendment here is designed to overcome is the fact that we have not any definite records. I have a list. Admittedly it is compiled by some members of the Irish Council Against Blood Sport. They have a particular point of view and so this list must be read with this point of view in mind. They have a list of hares killed in the season 1973-74. At Saggart, County Dublin on 14th, 20th, 21st and 22nd October, 1973, 44 hares were killed; at Mallow, County Cork, 20th October, 1973, 25 hares were killed; at Roscrea, County Tipperary, 3rd November, 1973, 22 hares were killed; at New Inn, County Tipperary, on 10th and 11th November, 1973, 26 hares were killed; at Castleisland, County Kerry, on 10th and 11th November, 1973, 14 hares were killed; at Mitchelstown, County Cork, on 11th November, 1973, 15 hares were killed; at Listowel, County Kerry, on 17th and 18th November, 1973, 46 hares were killed; and the list goes on. For the purpose of this debate, and for the purpose of proper public debate, and for proper evaluation by the public and the Members of the Oireachtas, we should have an official record. Subsection (2) of the proposed new section is designed to ensure that there is a proper public record so that the speculation can end and so that the public will know what they are doing and the people who have to make decisions on matters of this nature will know what they are doing in any discussion of this nature. It is a perfectly reasonable proposal that the records should be kept.
The Seanad has decided to retain coursing. As I said, I accept this decision, whatever my own personal feelings are. It is perfectly reasonable to expect that, if coursing is to be retained in its present form, some stricter regulations should be put on the clubs affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club so that the abuses which take place, and which are recorded so frequently that one cannot ignore them, will diminish.
A sport like coursing—it is not the only one—is a sport in which cruelty is involved. The purpose of this amendment is to ensure by legal means, by legal restrictions, that unnecessary cruelty is kept to a minimum. Everybody should agree with these sentiments. The proposals here are very mild ones: First, to give the Minister power to make regulations governing each coursing match; secondly, to have an official record of the number of hares; and thirdly, to ensure, by direction of the Minister in any situation in which he feels it necessary, that a record of a coursing meeting by means of photograph, or television, or film, may be made. I hope the Minister will see his way to accepting these proposals in some form or other.
Comment on this
I want to refer again to something mentioned on many occasions this evening, that is, the matter of cruelty. As I said on a previous occasion, there seem to be many degrees of cruelty. Senator Higgins quoted what took place in the British Parliament and their standards and their evaluation of cruelty to animals. I remember a time when they were making great propaganda about cruelty to horses and had very little interest in cruelty to human beings. Many of these people who speak so glibly about cruelty, and how it is exaggerated and so on, forget that there are many people in our society who have scant respect for the conditions in which people are employed, or the conditions in which children often find themselves, and the conditions in which certain people have to rear families. That is a type of cruelty and it should take precedence over this trash we are listening to on this Bill.
I want to find out from the Minister, who happens to be from my own constituency, if in section 26 any curb is being put on a certain type of hunting that takes place in our constituency. We have not the glamour of horses, or coursing either, but hares are hunted in a different way, by beagles. Our dogs are not as fast as Kerry greyhounds and they do not kill as many hares. I do not accept the figures of the deaths of hares as the be-all and end-all of what is happening. It often puzzles me where these correspondents get their figures, how well versed they are in the various processes of cruelty, and how on a few occasions they can actually have a photograph of a hare being torn asunder by two dogs. They very seldom present a photograph of the happy expression on the hare's face when she gets through the escape left for her.
I would not like to see anything in this Bill which would curb in any way the humane activities people in my constituency engage in when they follow beagles on foot. Sometimes they hunt hares. It is provided in this section that a licence might be needed to hunt otters or course hares. I would not like to see any such licence being introduced in relation to the traditional sport which has existed in our area for a long time. As I said, we have not the glamour of going on horseback. We are not John Peels. Even in Goldsmith's day hares were hunted and they were often glad to get back to the place from whence they flew. We would not like to see this sport eradicated. The coursing club and Bord na gCon have been doing their utmost to ensure that these elements of cruelty are lessened in each succeeding year.
It has been said that a certain number of hares have been killed. Perhaps that is because more coursing meetings have taken place. I would like an answer from the Minister, who I am sure, is interested in this matter. I would not like people living in rural Ireland, who follow hares with humble beagles which seldom catch up with the hares, being deprived from taking part in that innocent sport.
Comment on this
I support Senator West's amendments. If the Minister cannot accept them in their entirety I would ask him to examine them with a view to incorporating in the Bill something on this line. I have already voted to retain coursing. It is in the interest of the people who run coursing clubs, and the Oireachtas, to ensure that some monitoring of the situation is at all times possible. We have seen unbalanced programmes. It depends on who is shooting the film. It is in our interest as well as that of the clubs to ensure that all meetings are held with the intention, at least, of trying to prevent as much killing of hares as possible and, at the same time, not having slanted views presented to the public and building up an anti-coursing lobby. We should incorporate some of the amendments Senator West has proposed.
Comment on this
On the whole, even though I was one of the few who went into the anti-coursing lobby a few minutes ago, I am inclined not to support this amendment mainly because, to my mind, if, as I hope he will, the Minister accepts amendment No. 65 in my name, the matter could be dealt with in a simpler and more practical way. I will not anticipate the discussion which will take place on amendment No. 65, but it would enable the Minister to prevent the infliction of unnecessary and undue suffering on any animal. The difficulty with amendment No. 58 is that there is a certain "big brother" aspect to it which one does not like.
Even though one may oppose the principle of coursing, it is not necessary at the same time to assume that the the Irish Coursing Club are in any way dishonest or unreasonable in their attitude. I am quite certain they are anxious to see that no undue suffering is imposed on any animal. They want to run their business in a reasonable way. Therefore it would be wrong in a Bill of this kind to give the Minister power to have photographs taken and send out spies and so on. He should lay down conditions, as suggested in my forthcoming amendment No. 65, but detailed regulation of the activities of a private organisation like the Irish Coursing Club is unnecessary and suggests— although it may not be meant that way but the wording would appear to suggest—that in some way the Irish Coursing Club and affiliated coursing clubs are not sincere and genuine in their efforts to avoid cruelty. Unfortunately sometimes they are unsuccessful. They do their best and for that reason I would not be inclined to support an amendment framed in this manner.
Comment on this
I am totally opposed to giving a Minister or a Government the power asked by Senator West to make these regulations. The people best qualified to deal with this matter are the members of the Irish Coursing Club. They are doing a very good job. If we were to have Government interference in what they are doing, the sport would be killed.
I am inclined to agree with the second part of the amendment which provides that a record of the number of hares killed during a coursing match which should be given to the Minister within 14 days. If that were the case, what Senator West has said here and has read from newspapers would be proved wrong. He said that in Castleisland 14 hares were killed. Out of 140 hares there, 14 were killed. A newspaper quoted a number of hares killed at a coursing meeting in Kerry and said more hares were killed than the number of hares at the meeting. This proves that one should not pay too much heed to what is said in the press, especially when it is said by people who are totally opposed to coursing.
Last year the Irish Coursing Club withdrew the licence from one coursing club because they felt they were not carrying out their instructions. The ICC have a steward at every coursing meeting who sees that things are carried out properly and makes a report to his headquarters. If headquarters are not satisfied with what has been reported, they need not give that coursing club a licence for the following year.
It has been said that hares are very scarce in West Tipperary. I come from West Tipperary and I agree they are scarce, but West Tipperary is a big area and there is no coursing club there. I believe that is why hares are scarce there. They are not being protected. Coursing clubs protect hares When there is no coursing club in an area, anybody can come in and shoot hares, net hares, snare hares, or do what they like. That is why hares are scarce in West Tipperary.
It was stated that open coursing meetings had to be postponed on a few occasions last year in Newbridge because they had not sufficient hares. I understand the reason for that. The hares were killed by dogs owned by itinerants. Wherever there is a good coursing club, there will be plenty of hares and they need not worry about a hare shortage.
We have seen films of hares being killed at coursing meetings but if one hare is killed that is the only part of the film shown. As Senator Dolan said, you will not see anything about the one which got away. It would be very wrong to insist that photographers should be present at coursing meetings. Indeed, I would not care to be a photographer, because if he goes down the country he might come back himself but his camera might not.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I do not want to be drawn into a discussion on whether cruelty is practised at coursing matches. As I have said, I do not believe this Bill is the proper measure to deal with that sort of thing. However, lest it might be taken that I accept that people who are engaged in coursing, people who organise matches, people who own greyhounds and course them, people who go to coursing matches, are all cruel people and engage in this sport for the cruelty that is in it, I want to say fairly and squarely, I do not believe any such thing. I say that, not as one who is an habitual courser. I have been at Clounanna and Clonmel and lesser coursing matches from time to time, but not for some years.
Well organised coursing matches are organised in such a way that the hare gets a fair run. As somebody said earlier, the dogs will not be slipped if the hare is obviously weak or if she does not run properly. Part of the procedure is that the slipper gives the dogs a fairly long slip; in other words, gives the hare a good start. As I said, it is some years since I have been at a coursing match, but I want to say people who go there do not applaud the cruelty or the pain. My recollection is that there was always a cheer when the hare escaped and I never heard a cheer when the hare was killed. I recollect also, that when the hare was caught, a dash was made to kill her and put her out of pain if she could be rescued from the dogs.
On the other hand, as Senator Ryan said, photographs have been taken of hares being pulled asunder. I suppose that is part of the build-up by the anti-coursing lobby. Those who have attended coursing matches have often seen the dog which was coursed, and which took umpteen turns out of the hare, lying there panting with his tongue out after the hare escaped. The dog can be completely exhausted but we do not see any of those photographs. I am not saying it is not cruel, and I am not saying hares do not suffer pain, but I believe that, ever since I attended coursing matches, things have improved considerably. Matches are regulated by the Irish Coursing Club under the Greyhound Industry Act, 1958.
Senator West gave particulars of the number of hares that have been killed. I am glad Senator W. Ryan gave us the number of hares that would be coursed on any given day because I was thinking that, if that figure were given, the number of deaths given by Senator West would not appear so bad. That appears to be the case. A couple of instances were given by Senator West where the number of deaths was above the average. The average seemed to be 14 or 15. From the conservation point of view, not alone must you get the number of animals that have been killed, but you must get the number of births and you must know the population. Such evidence as I have is to the effect that the hare is not in danger of extinction. When this Bill is passed my Department and I will have machinery to enable us to assess these matters and, by an administrative process, to enumerate the hare population and ascertain whether the stock of hares is increasing or decreasing.
Senator Dolan raised the question of beagles and beagling. That is a form of hunting I have known since I was a child. There was always a conflict between the greyhound owners and the beagle owners. The beagle owners always referred to the greyhound owners as pot hunters, and the beagle owners regarded themselves as sportsmen who did not kill the hare. Beagle hunting packs are slow moving. They rarely, if ever, kill the hare, as Senator Dolan said. The Bill as originally drafted would have made it obligatory on the master of a pack of beagles— and I would love to hear him being called "master"—to get a licence to hunt. Under an amendment which I shall be moving later on, a licence for beagle hunting will not be necessary in the open season. It is necessary if the hunting or beagling is to take place in the close season. The idea there would be, perhaps, to grant a licence for a couple of weeks in the month of March. I do not think Senator Dolan has anything to worry about there.
Let us look at this amendment and see what it invites the Seanad to do. It provides:
(1) Notwithstanding the provisions of any other enactment the Minister shall have power to make regulations governing every coursing match held by any coursing clubs affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club.
Obviously, Senator West appreciates that the regulation of coursing matches is entrusted to another organisation, the Irish Coursing Club, which operates under statute. As has been said here by Senator W. Ryan and others, the Irish Coursing Club grants licences and refuses to grant licences. I am not saying this categorically, but I think it can grant licences subject to conditions and, if it cannot, perhaps its power should be extended. The powers given to the Irish Coursing Club are adequate. I do not think it would be desirable that two Departments should regulate the same activity. That would be a duplication of effort and I would not agree with it.
In the second part of the amendment I am asked to get a record of the number of hares killed during a coursing match held by any coursing club affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club or during captivity for the purposes of such a match within 14 days. That would be duplicating the control of coursing. It may be that, for the purposes of checking up on the hare population to ascertain if it is increasing or decreasing, my Department might like to find out the number of hares killed throughout the country, whether at coursing matches, or by shooting, or other means, throughout the year. If we want to do that, we can do it.
I am somewhat surprised that a Senator of the liberal trend of Senator West should invite the Seanad to enact the third part of his amendment because, quite candidly, it smacks to me of the police state. I am asked to enact in this Bill a measure which would provide a camera control of a legitimate activity of private people and record it and I suppose file it and use it against them without warning, or without their knowing this was being done. This could lead to all sorts of things. People might be at a coursing match when they were supposed to be somewhere else. They could find themselves caught by the camera and they could get into all sorts of trouble. In all sincerity, I am surprised that it should be suggested in this day and age that we should enact in this House this provision that:
The Minister may direct that the proceedings of any coursing match held by a coursing club affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club may be photographed, filmed, televised or in any other way recorded.
This is compulsion. I would not stand for that for one moment. The day we have to descend to that sort of thing will be the day when we should abolish coursing altogether and I do not think that day has arrived.
Comment on this
There are just a couple of points concerning the Minister's reply. I can see he has objections to subsections (1) and (3) but I do not understand his objection to subsection (2). The point about subsection (2) is that, as I said, I could not stand over the figures I quoted because there are no authorised figures about hares killed at coursing meetings. It seems to me quite reasonable in view of the fact that there is considerable debate and that not all coursing meetings are well run. That is really the problem we are trying to tackle. Many coursing meetings are not run as they should be. I do not mean to imply that people who go to coursing matches are necessarily cruel. Most unnecessary cruelty to animals is by default. It is not done on purpose. It is done because certain precautions are not taken rather than because certain specific things are done. That is what the second part of the amendment is designed to do and I cannot see any objection to that.
As far as subsection (3) is concerned, the problem is that of harrassment of people attempting to take photographs at coursing meetings. Senator Ryan alluded to this matter. The amendment to subsection (3) is to ensure that if it is necessary to take photographs this will be done without harrassment.
As far as subsection (1) is concerned, I take the Minister's point that the Irish Coursing Club is the body which regulates coursing meetings. Perhaps statutory control on the Irish Coursing Club should be tightened up, but this would have to be done through the Act which gives the Irish Coursing Club the authority to regulate coursing meetings.
If the Minister accepted some regulation such as provided for in subsection (3)— I cannot see how that in any way smacks of a police state or interference; it is simply a matter of getting an accurate and authorised record—it would stop much of the controversy which goes on. I was pleased that Senator Kerrigan supported this argument because it would clear up much of the ambiguity which surrounds coursing.
Comment on this
I am sorry I have arrived so late in this debate but I had to fulfil some academic commitments. I am very interested in this whole question of coursing. As a token of that interest I went to the trouble of going to a coursing meeting.
With regard to the entire debate, I notice that there has been a very strong moral case made against any kind of cruelty to animals at any level. With regard to the coursing of hares that kind of moral objection has taken, perhaps, a most emotive force within the discussion in the Seanad. Indeed, one of the things which emerged in the discussion of the entire business of wildlife, is in regard to the relationship between the human species, if one might put it that way, and the animal species. Senator M.D. Higgins spoke in a very profound and poetic way about the fact that we have so disregarded our environment that we have taken too little account of how badly our animal population has been treated by the human population. He almost reached the stage—not quite— of saying that it was a great pity that there had not been more consultation with the foxes, hares and badgers before certain legislation had been introduced.
Senator John Horgan spoke in a different key of moral discourse when he said that it was a woeful pity that the otter should be destroyed. Senator Horgan is a fisherman and as such he said he would be very happy if an otter approached him when he had caught a fish to give the fish to the otter. This was said in a speech in which he deplored coursing.
Later, Senator Noel Browne spoke, again in the kind of autobiographical way in which Senators have been speaking on the subject, and recorded the fact that he was a vegetarian and deplored the destruction of wildlife of any kind. As I listened to the different speeches I was struck by the fact that all of us, human beings, the species which is assembled here, without representation by otters or fish, are capable of such extraordinary moral emotion on the entire subject. A man who was fishing and perhaps had played that fish——
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Senator but he has not yet discussed the amendment before the House and he has been speaking for quite some time.
Comment on this
I did mention the fact that we were speaking about the coursing of hares.
Comment on this
Would the Senator relate his remarks to the amendment before the House? This is not a Second Stage debate.
Comment on this
Is it proper, with the amendment before the House at the moment, to speak about the principle by which human beings regulate the survival of animals?
Comment on this
If the Senator relates it to the amendment before the House it would be in order, but it is not a general debate on the moral principles of coursing which we had under section 23 some time ago.
Comment on this
I take your point, a Leas-Chathaoirleach, and am very grateful to you for having drawn my attention to it. It seemed to me that with regard to the entire hierarchy of life on this planet, even if one is a vegetarian one must accept that his survival depends on a whole effort of chemical warfare against slugs or even beautiful insects like butterflies. The whole range of moral rectitude in this matter must come back to the fact that the human species, as such, survives by a kind of predatory activity against the animal and insect life of the planet.
I speak as one who, after the age of 12, has never either fished or hunted. However, I did go to the trouble of going to a coursing meeting. At that meeting one of the things that struck me as being untrue was the idea that people were being involved in some kind of bloodlust. In fact, the killing of the hare happened away in the distance. The people were far more interested in the hounds breaking from the traps. By and large, the people did not range themselves around that part of the course where the animal was killed.
With regard to the general principle of coursing, I would feel that the balance of nature within the country——
Comment on this
We have already agreed that the general principle of coursing is outside the scope of the amendment. The amendment deals with making of regulations for the controlling of coursing interests.
Comment on this
It seemed to me that if the survival of the hare as a species within the country is to be some kind of priority then somebody must look after it.
Senator Michael D. Higgins gave a horrendous description of a posse of people who went out to kill indiscriminately all kinds of animal life, even innocent animals like cranes.
With regard to the coursing of the hare, if it is in the hands of a responsible body which monitors the hare population, looks after its general health, establishes its survival and does that without an undue degree of violence and cruelty, then it seems to me from the experience of having gone to one coursing meeting, that the survival of the hare could be in worse hands than in the hands of the Irish Coursing Club. My feeling from the experience of that coursing meeting was that there was no sense of delight in the destruction of that innocent and beautiful animal nor was there anything abominable happening. Perhaps the survival of the hare, its health and its place within the natural life of Ireland could be fairly honourably committed to the Irish Coursing Club.
Comment on this
A while ago I asked the Minister to examine the amendments with a view to incorporating some of them. Having listened to the Minister I can apperciate the difficulties in regard to subsections (1) and (2) of Senator West's amendment. It struck me that, to take the numbers of the coursing match without giving a balanced film, might simply be allowing people to put over the view they wished. I do not think that would be fair, and there should be consultation with the coursing club.
The Minister should devise some way to monitor the situation, where some record is kept by him. I know there are certain returns to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries from Bord na gCon and the Irish Coursing Club but I am not sure whether they are reliable or not. There should be returns not only of the numbers of hares killed but also of the numbers used. We would need a factual report of these matters. I have been told that things have improved vastly since the time when I was coursing, 20 odd years ago. The public are not aware of that and they accept certain facts. We, as Members of the Oireachtas, have a duty to have some way of monitoring this situation. I would ask the Minister to examine it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The debate on this amendment has now reduced itself to subsection (2) of the amendment. It is conceded that I may reject subsection (1) and certainly subsection (3). Subsection (2) asks that
"a record of the number of hares killed during a coursing match held by any coursing club affiliated to the Irish Coursing Club or during captivity for the purposes of such a match, shall be given to the Minister by the club concerned within 14 days of such a match."
My attitude to that is that if such a record is to be kept, it should be kept by the Irish Coursing Club, which is the body authorised by statute to regulate coursing matches. If I were, in this Bill, to take power to require those records and that return to me, I would be cutting across the powers already given to the Irish Coursing Club by the Greyhound Industry Act of 1968. Moreover, Senator Kerrigan made the point that a record of the numbers of hares killed would be valueless unless we also had a record of the number of hares coursed.
In greyhound racing there was a gentleman known as the Stipendary Steward, who used to go round and inspect what was going on there and report back. I am certain that the Irish Coursing Club have such a steward, authorised, and indeed obliged, to attend meetings and report back to them. If there is any weakness in the control of coursing which needs tightening up, it should be tightened up by an amendment of the Greyhound Industry Act. I am not to be taken for one moment as conceding that there is any necessity for such tightening. I have not made a study of it and I have not had reports on it. The Greyhound Industry Bill was introduced by an inter-Party Government in 1956 or 1957 and filibustered until that Government went out of office. It was reintroduced in 1958 and the volume shows that all Stages —Second Stage, Committee Stage, Report Stage—were passed within a few days, and with only one division. I do not like saying this in his absence, but Senator Browne was then a Member of Dáil Éireann. That is the Bill which authorises coursing, which consolidates coursing and he— although if he was here now he would be speaking loudly in favour of this amendment—never opened his mouth against that Bill in 1958. He certainly never voted against it.
I do not want to be introducing over-controversial matters here but I repeat that it may be that this suggestion in paragraph (2) of this amendment is desirable, but it is a duty I am not going to take on myself, as Minister for Lands and as the Minister charged with conservation. If I were to get a record of the hares that died at coursing matches without record of the hares that were killed, trapped, snared, shot or died from some disease, as well as a record of the hares that were born in any particular year, this information would be useless. It may be that as Minister charged with conservation I will be looking for this information, maybe through co-operation with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or the Irish Coursing Club, but if I get that sort of information it will be only a part of more extensive information covering the entire activities of the birth and death of the hare population. If this was a Bill to deal with cruelty to animals or to regulate coursing, I would have difficulty in resisting this amendment. This is a Bill which deals with conservation only.
Comment on this
I should like to put one question to the Minister. Could he tell me if the Irish Coursing Club have such records and, if so, are they available to the public? There is no point in having the number of hares killed unless you have the total number of hares coursed. Is this information in the hands of the Irish Coursing Club and is it available to the public?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am informed that this sort of information is available to the Irish Coursing Club. I have not before me the Greyhound Industry Act. I know that, even before the Greyhound Industry Act became law, coursing matches were regulated by the Irish Coursing Club with its headquarters at Clonmel. If a club's coursing match was not recognised that club would not get a nomination to the Irish Puppy Derby or to some such event, and that being so there would be no match because nobody would course their dogs at it.
I am sure that since the passing of the Greyhound Industry Act their powers and control have been strengthened and I believe that that sort of information is available to the Irish Coursing Club, I do not know whether it is available to the general public.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 22, lines 47 to 54, to delete subsection (1).
Comment on this
Amendment No. 59 is of a different nature from the previous amendments we have been discussing. They were dealing with abolition of or regulation of coursing. This amendment is designed to abolish otter hunting and stag hunting. These practices are now very rare and I do not see any reason why they should continue in view of the fact that both the otter and stag populations are dwindling. They are under severe pressure and I think that all hunting of otters and stags should be stopped.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The purpose of this amendment appears to be to ban otter and stag hunting completely. This I am not prepared to do, but I am ensuring under subsection (1) of section 26 that these forms of hunting will in future be carried out only under licence. It will of course be possible under section 9 to impose such conditions in any such licence as may from time to time be appropriate particularly in the interests of the conservation of the species. My information indicates that the number of animals killed in these sports is not significant. In the circumstances I do not propose to accept the amendment.
As I have said before, this is a Conservation Bill and I have said that I suppose ad nauseam at this stage, but up to the introduction of this Bill and until it becomes law otters are not protected at all. Deer are not protected at all and this Bill is giving a measure of protection to these animals and regarding them as game in the same way as game was dealt with under the Game Preservation Act. The position is now that there will be a close season for otters and deer and that they can be hunted only during an open season which will be regulated by the Minister from year to year and as the occasion may arise and it will be possible to hunt them under licence only and a licence may have conditions attached under section 9 of the Bill. That is a vast improvement. I think that it is going too far to propose to ban otter hunting and stag hunting altogether.
Comment on this
Could the Minister indicate the number of types of otter hounds and the number of types of stag hounds now operating in the country? I know they are very small.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I know there are about two types of stag hounds and two or three types of——
Comment on this
I think a distinction could be made on the one hand between the hunting of hares which are a palpable, obvious menace to oats, grass, wheat and young corn, and on the other hand the hunting of otters and stags. I was born in the country and I have never heard of complaints of farmers against the depredations of otters or of deer.
There is a kind of an aboriginal rationale behind the hunting of the fox and of the hare, a feeling that you are wiping out something that is in fact deleterious to the whole agrarian health of the environment. Even though I grew up in a part of the country which was very jealous of its young turnips, corn, wheat and so forth, I have never heard anybody complain against the depredations done by either otters or deer. Therefore, in my earlier contribution I made a fairly strong case for the rationale behind coursing. It is a much more difficult proposition to make a case for the hunting of otter or of the deer. It would seem to me that that kind of hunting would be one that would come within the more cosmetic aspects of what we call in the trade blood sport, in other words that the deer and the otter are not in fact a threat to the environment. Therefore there is a harder case to be made for taking joy in their being hunted down. Consequently I would tend to support Senator West on this.
Comment on this
I do not agree with the Minister. I think that the stags and otters are too rare. This is a conservation Bill. I think we should protect them completely and I intend to press the amendment.
Comment on this
(Cavan): When I heard Senator Martin speaking I thought “There is a country-man speaking and he knows what is involved in hares,” but now I think that he is only half a country-man. Hares do some damage but I fear that the damage done by deer is infinitely greater to trees, crops and grass. Farmers complain bitterly about deer trespassing and eating as much as their own sheep. I understand that otters also do damage to fish; but even if the deer did damage that would not be an excuse or a reason for exterminating him altogether. The stag is a lovely animal and I think he should be preserved. The country would be much the poorer if the deer population were to be exterminated.
I am not very familiar with stag hunting but I believe that it is seldom the stag is killed. He is hunted all right and recaptured and hunted again at different times, but he is well looked after and I am told that he is rarely killed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Yes. I understand it is rarely that that happens. I am not an authority on that either. Otters are sometimes killed. I am improving the position here. I am protecting these animals and giving a large measure of protection to these animals under this Bill. Prior to this Bill they had no protection whatever. They were regarded as vermin. Anybody could kill them how and when they liked at any time. The position under the Bill is improved.
Comment on this
I take that point. But if the Minister accepted my amendment it would improve the position as far as the deer and the otter were concerned even more.
Comment on this
Will Senators seeking a division on that question please rise.
Senators M.D. Higgins, West and Martin rose.
Comment on this
The Senators' names will be recorded in the Official Report as dissenting.