Wildlife Bill, 1975: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–129 of 261. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1975 ›
Cavan): Section 36 is designed to stop the wilful disturbance or excessive killing of wild fauna by or from moving vehicles, boats or aircraft. It is, of course, aimed also at the poacher. The recasting of the section is designed to take account of certain points which have been put to me and which I accept as valid.
The first of these, which is covered by the new subsection (1) (a), is aimed at stopping what has been represented to me as a typical poaching activity in so far as deer are concerned, namely, shooting them from a parked car. The amendment extends to stationary vessels, such as boats, and aircraft. This is not as outlandish as might appear at first glance. For example, in certain parts of the country, it would be possible to shoot deer from a stationary boat, also, certain protected species of marine animals such as seals, porpoises, and so on, could be shot from sea-going vessels. As regards aircraft, the availability of private helicopters which could land or hover over an area inhabited by deer could provide opportunities for shooting the deer. The new subsection (1) (b) merely retains the proposal in the original draft in regard to protected wild birds.
The second point put to me — and this is covered by the new subsection (2) — is that bona fide scientists and researchers should be allowed, under licence, to kill as well as capture, protected wild birds or protected wild animals for scientific research purposes. The amendment also proposes to extend the exemption to educational or other approved purposes, for example, the necessary culling of deer on enclosed land where the use of a vehicle by the owner of the land or other authorised person would not be objectionable. The subsection, as amended, would be consistent with and complementary to the provisions in section 22 (7) (a) and section 23 (6) which exempt, under licence, from the prohibition on the hunting of protected species the capture or killing of such species for “such educational, scientific or other purpose as shall be specified in the licence”.
The new subsection (3) is a necessary saver for section 3 (3) of the Whale Fisheries Act, 1937, which permits the pursuit and killing, within the exclusive fishing limits of the State, of a whale which has been wounded outside those limits. The new subsection (4) repeats, with necessary modification, the original subsection (3).
Comment on this
Before the Senator intervenes I might point out that acceptance of this amendment involves the deletion of section 36 from the Bill. Accordingly discussion of the amendment will include discussion of the original section 36.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister if this outlaws the use of the punt gun.
Comment on this
(Cavan): No. The punt gun is not dealt with in this section. We have already dealt with that under an earlier section and it has not been completely outlawed or banned.
Comment on this
I am in favour of outlawing the punt gun and it seems to me that the new section 36 (b) more or less does that in any case. There is a certain amount of propulsion of a vehicle involved in firing a punt gun, or in using a punt gun.
Comment on this
Supposing the punt gun with a silencer has been outlawed, it seems to me that section 36 (1) (b) of the proposed new section outlaws it completely.
Comment on this
(Cavan): No. I did not say we had outlawed it completely. As a matter of fact I said we had not. We dealt with this on an amendment under an earlier section.
When dealing with the amendments under section 33, I said that the proposal to delete the punt gun from the existing subsection (1) is prompted by consideration of representations that have been made to me that punt gunning is an art which is now practised in this country by only a few wild fowlers. Moreover, while the type of gun is undeniably indiscriminate in its effects, it has been represented to me that the numbers of birds taken by this method are not at all as great as critics of the sport sometimes claim. If the need to control or abolish this form of shooting arises in the future, it can be dealt with under the powers conferred by subsection (4).
Comment on this
The problem is, as far as I can make out, that the new section 36 (1) (b) would outlaw punt guns as far as protected animals are concerned.
Comment on this
It always is. They do not row them any more. Essentially the point is that the punt gun is used from a mechanically propelled boat. That is the situation nowadays. You do not row punt guns any more. You do not have some water buffalo to tow you. You have a mechanically propelled vehicle and you fire your gun off from the boat.
Comment on this
(Cavan): My information is that the punt gun is not used from a mechanically propelled vehicle but is attached to a flat-bottomed boat which is manually propelled. This particular section, as the Senator knows, deals with mechanically propelled vehicles and other vehicles that are propelled otherwise than manually.
Comment on this
My information leads me to the somewhat opposite conclusion that there is an outboard motor fitted to the boat that drives it to within a certain range of the duck and from there on it is rowed. Obviously you cannot come up on these birds with an outboard motor when you are within range. The outboard tends to propel it for a certain distance and from there on you row in. It is quite a standard procedure.
Comment on this
I just want to make this point. First of all, I have never used a punt gun but I have seen it used. The only way in which I have seen it used was the manner which the Minister described. I do not know the particular make of boat. I assume it was a flat bottomed one, but certainly it was propelled manually and the punt gun was used out of it.
On the point Senator West was making, I think he will see that subsection (1) (b) of the amendment to section 36 refers only to the mechanical propulsion while it is being so propelled. Senator West said an outboard motor is used to bring a boat within a certain distance, then is switched off, and the boat is manually propelled from there on. It would seem to me that from there on it is excluded from the section because the shooting is not taking place while the vehicle is being mechanically propelled.
Comment on this
If it is stationary, then it is ruled out under subsection (1) (a). You have to be moving. It is a nice legal point.
Comment on this
As far as I know the practice of using punt guns has practically disappeared. There are very few in use now.
Comment on this
As the Minister said, this is really designed to outlaw certain types of poaching. There are certain types of poaching which use mounted guns on propelled vehicles in some areas. This is really what I was trying to get at. This sort of practice should be stopped.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I do not know what experience Senator West has of the art of using a punt gun.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The section we are dealing with now concerns itself with hunting from mechanically propelled vehicles. My information is that, whether we agree or disagree with the punt gun, it is not used from a mechanically propelled vehicle. Indeed, if it were used from a mechanically propelled vehicle, the whole point in using it would be destroyed, because the birds or ducks would be disturbed and dispersed before the boat would get near them. According to my technical advisers, it is used when attached to a flat bottom boat which is propelled by oars and it is not appropriate for discussion on this section. My information also is that the number of punt guns being used is not more than a couple of dozen. Of course, if they continue to be used when this Bill becomes law, they will have to be licensed under the Bill. As I said, if it becomes desirable to outlaw or ban them completely, we have sufficient machinery in the Bill to do just that.
Comment on this
I want to make one further point which I know Senator O'Higgins will appreciate because he and I fish in a lake in a certain area on which, by local custom, for many years the outboard motor was not used. As he and I know, the outboard motor is now used very extensively on the lake. I do not think Senator O'Higgins uses it. I do not use it myself. It is not correct to say that if you have an outboard motor on a boat you will frighten the birds, or the fish, because you use the motor to get within a couple of hundred yards of the birds, then you switch it off and row in. This is the point I was trying to make to the Minister. You do not frighten the birds because you have an outboard motor. The question was; if you are not using your outboard motor and you row in, does it come in under this section of the Bill?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I would say this section of the Bill applies to a mechanically propelled boat or other vehicle. We could have a long and learned discussion as to when a mechanically propelled vehicle ceases to be a mechanically propelled vehicle. You could take off the outboard motor, and throw it in the body of the boat, and use oars. The idea is to protect wildlife, wild birds particularly, from being hunted from mechanically propelled vehicles while they are being mechanically propelled. That is the intention and also the effect of the section.
Comment on this
There is a distinction between paragraphs (a) and (b), as Senator West pointed out. Paragraph (a) applies to a mechanically propelled vehicle, whether it is so propelled or not at the time, or whether it is stationary. Paragraph (a) is applicable only to wild animals. Paragraph (b) is applicable to wild birds. It only applies to a mechanically propelled vehicle while it is being so propelled.
Comment on this
I would like to see paragraph (b) widened so that, whether the vehicle is being propelled or not, the birds would be protected. That really was the point of my remarks.
Comment on this
(Cavan): As Senator O'Higgins says, birds are protected from this sort of activity while the boat or vehicle is in motion, and is being mechanically propelled. Animals, particularly deer, are protected whether the vehicle is in motion or stationary, because it is a well-known fact that deer are shot from stationary motor cars.
Comment on this
I would be interested to know if shooting from a motor car or truck to a lake along the side of the road comes into this. Close to me there is a tourlough and ducks are shot from the opposite side of the lake. A road runs along this lake. Years ago I had an old mare that I could ride down to the lake side, carrying a gun, and while the mare was drinking I could get a good shot, whereas if I went down walking along the road, or even on a bicycle, the ducks would be gone. They paid no attention to the old mare going to the water's edge. The first time I remember that I tried this, the mare was not trained to guns. She was gun shy, and I landed in the lake. To my great surprise, I had also shot two duck. Now I see people in trucks going along the road. The ducks are quite close to the road until you walk along the road. They are used to cars passing. These people can pull the truck up right close to the side of the road and wait for a few minutes. The ducks will not bother and they will have a kill. I wonder whether there is any section to prevent this kind of mechanical vehicle from being used for shooting duck or other fowl.
Comment on this
The point Senator Lyons made is a good one. I would be interested to hear the reply because I am sure Senator West would agree with this. What Senator Lyons said is absolutely right. It applies not merely to water fowl. Anyone who does any pheasant shooting will have had the same experience. They apparently get so accustomed to the noise of cars on the roads, they will even stay on the road while you pass them, and maybe while you stop. If you try to open the door, they are gone in a flash. I would have thought that the answer to this — I am not sure of this — is that you are not entitled to shoot from the public road anyhow.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I think Senator O'Higgins hit the nail on the head in his last sentence. It is illegal, as I understand it, under the Summary Jurisdiction (Ireland) Act, 1851, to discharge a firearm on the road or within a certain distance of it. What we are doing here is quite simple. In so far as birds are concerned, it is illegal to fire at them from a moving vehicle. For example, a man who was stricken with polio and was using a jeep or something like that could bring his jeep out into his field and park it and fire at the birds.
So far as animals are concerned, particularly deer, the Bill prohibits the shooting of these animals from a vehicle whether it is in motion or stationary.
Comment on this
The acceptance of this amendment means that the original section 36 is deleted.
SECTION 37.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 120, 121 and 122 are related and may be debated together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Section 37 (1) is designed to control hunting of protected species—primarily game species — by night, that is, the period from one hour after sunset to one hour before sunrise, on the grounds not only that it is an unfair and inhumane practice, but also that it is detrimental to the interests of conservation. The various implements — for example, lamps, mirrors and dazzling devices — used as aids to hunting by night are prohibited under section 38.
The new subsection (1) (a) relates solely to woodcock. A practice is emerging — mainly, I understand, on the part of visiting game shooters — of shooting woodcock on their morning and evening flights which take place near sunrise and sunset respectively. This is regarded as an unfair sporting practice, with implications of undue pressure in terms of disturbance and killing on this particular species, and needs to be prohibited. The proposed amendment will achieve this by forbidding woodcock shooting between sunset and sunrise. In other words, the hour's grace permissible for other game species will not apply in the case of woodcock.
The new subsection (1) (b) repeats what is contained in the existing subsection (1) in regard to other species of protected wild birds and protected wild animals. It also includes the exception in the case of wild duck and wild geese contained in the existing subsection (2) (a).
The deletion of paragraph (a) of the existing subsection (2) is, first of all, consequential on the new subsection (1) (b) and, secondly, because the words which occur after "wild geese" are being deleted as they are considered unnecessarily restrictive and might lead to inequitable treatment of different areas in the practical operation of the exemption.
Comment on this
I agree with this amendment but I am surprised at the reasons given. I have made an effort at shooting woodcock flighting in the evening and I can assure the Minister that, when they are flighting, as they do, out of a wood to a bog nearby, one would want to be an extremely good shot even to hit one in the course of an evening. I am surprised to find that apparently this is a growing practice and obviously it must grow because people are able to get good bags out of it. In my view, they must be extremely good shots to do it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): As I stated in support of the amendment, the practice apparently is more prevalent among visiting shooters than it is with the native shooters. My Department discussed this at some length with the various organisations concerned and we reached agreement. Senator O'Higgins said that he agrees with the amendment in principle and I do not think it unreasonable that these birds should be safe from sunset to sunrise. That is really all we are doing in the amendment.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 121, we feel the Minister is not going far enough where lamping at night is concerned. This is why we have asked that the word "protected" be deleted. There should be no hunting at night. If hunting at night is allowed, it will be difficult to distinguish whether somebody is hunting a protected wild bird or animal or an unprotected wild animal. It should not work that way.
Apart from that, this practice is highly dangerous. Every farmer is opposed to lamping or hunting at night because, down through the years, damage has been done to valuable animals — and, indeed, all animals are valuable today, horses, cows and so on — and crops. Crops have been damaged because people who are out at night hunting leave gates open. If they were hunting in the daytime they would be seen crossing the fields and if the gate were left open it could be closed. If they hunt at night this is not known. You go out in the morning and find a herd of cows in a field of beet or wheat or something else.
As well as speaking for the Game Council I am speaking, I think, for every farmer in the country. They do not want hunting at night whether of protected or unprotected birds or animals. I would appeal to the Minister to change the section for that purpose and to eliminate hunting at night altogether.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Amendment No. 121 and a corresponding one by the same Senators in relation to section 38 would be acceptable were it not for the fact that it is proposed to broaden the scope of section 44 which deals inter alia with trespass so as to embrace all fauna instead of only protected species. I will be dealing with that and other amendments on section 44 later.
In the circumstances it is not now considered necessary or desirable to drop the word "protected" either in section 37 or in section 38. To do so would unnecessarily restrict landowners in taking suitable action at night time against unprotected species, for example vermin, where such measures proved necessary. I do not therefore see the need for the amendment and I suggest that it be withdrawn. I am not clear in my own mind whether Senator Ryan is clear as to what we are doing here. In section 44 we will be making it an offence to trespass for the purpose of hunting any fauna at night whether it is protected or not protected. But we are still leaving it open to the owner of land to hunt and destroy vermin at night if he wants to. If I have made myself clear on that, the Senator should be reasonably satisfied.
Comment on this
If Senator Ryan considers what the Minister has said he will agree that the Minister's approach is quite correct. I am thinking particularly of farmers in the west during the lambing season. Very often, they have to keep an all-night vigil to protect the sheep and the lambs against foxes. If Senator Ryan's amendment were accepted that would be ruled out. They would not be able to hunt foxes off their land or to protect the ewes or lambs against marauding foxes. The Minister's approach is to allow the farmer to protect his own interest and his own livestock but, in a later section in connection with trespass, at the same time to protect the farmer against anyone else going in and trespassing on his land after either protected or unprotected wild life.
Comment on this
I am prepared not to move my amendment, but I would like to point out that we have no intention of preventing farmers from hunting on their own land at night foxes and other vermin. In the next section, section 38, we have an amendment to cover that. At no time were we trying to prevent farmers from protecting their own livestock at night by the killing of vermin, foxes and so on.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Arising out of what Senator W. Ryan said, I think we are ad idem. I am doing exactly what Senator Ryan wants me to do. Under the Bill I am forbidding trespass at night in respect of fauna of any description. protected or otherwise, game or vermin, but I am retaining to the farmer or owner of land the right to hunt vermin at night. We may be using different words and different techniques but I think we are ad idem in what we want.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Section 39 deals with the burning of vegetation near woods or certain other land. This amendment is aimed at curbing the deliberate lighting of fires or discarding of cigarette ends in such a negligent manner as to cause or be reasonably certain to cause vegetation growing within a mile of a wood, nature reserve or refuge for fauna, to burn and spread to such vulnerable areas. As the section stood it was not at all certain that such indirect burning of growing vegetation would be covered.
In other words, it was not certain that the section as originally drafted covered negligence. The amendment proposes to make the negligent throwing away of cigarettes or the negligent lighting of a fire an offence under the Act. I think it is hightly desirable that this should be so.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister how he proposes to catch people who light fires. It is not as easy as this section of the Bill implies. I come from a country which is full of vegetation, most of which belongs to the Department of Lands. A considerable amount of damage has been done by day-trippers from the city picnicking and we have no come-back with those people who deliberately light fires and leave them to cause thousands of pounds worth of damage, as has been done even this year. I should like to know how the Minister is going to cover this matter.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I agree with Senator Walsh that it is never easy to detect these offences. At least we are making it an offence to negligently throw away cigarette ends or matches or to do any other negligent act which might start a fire. How evidence of this offence will be gathered is another matter. It may be that some civic-minded citizen will see the culprit and report the matter to the forestry and wildlife officials; or it may be that, following damage by a fire of this sort, the officers of my Department or the Garda will make inquiries and find out who did it. I can tell the Senator that it is an offence under the Forestry Acts to cause damage to a forest or to start fires within a certain distance from a State forest, and that since I became Minister for Lands there have been many prosecutions. Files are continually coming up showing that, following investigations, culprits have been prosecuted under the summary provisions of the Forestry Acts. In many cases they are also followed for damages. I am surprised that the Senator has not been making representations to have some of these claims mitigated.
Comment on this
It is the last thing I would think of doing.
There is a marked difference between the type of offences to which the Minister referred and the ones to which I referred. Most of the offences the Minister mentioned would be a type of arson or vandalism. The people to whom I refer are the Sunday picnickers who wantonly throw debris and lighted matches near forestry plantations. These are the type of people who should be dealt with forcibly. If necessary there should be patrols at weekends in areas adjoining forestry plantations. The amount of damage done is immense. It goes into millions of pounds in a year.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I do not think that it goes into millions, but it is very extensive. We are providing the machinery to outlaw the deliberate or negligent starting of fires. The enforcement of this and the gathering of evidence to bring prosecutions under these sections will be a matter for my Department and the Garda. I can say that respect is gathering for our forests and I am sure that there is and will be a healthy respect for the conservation and preservation of wildlife. As this Bill gets publicity and people's attention is directed to what we are doing I am very hopeful that the sense of civic spirit will improve. The masses of the people disapprove of destruction of our natural amenities and will, if not immediately, in the course of time draw the attention of the authorities to it.
Comment on this
Amendments No. 126 and No. 127 are alternates and may be taken together.
Comment on this
Under the circumstances we will not move our amendment because there is only a question of a day or two between our amendment and the Minister's.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 128, 129 and 130 are related and it is suggested that they be debated together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I will take amendments Nos. 128, 129 and 130 together. The effect of the preceding amendment which we have just dealt with will be to set aside for wild birds and wild animals a period of four-and-a-half months each year during which breeding and nesting can proceed untroubled by destruction of the habitat through burning operations. As I have already stated, this will leave a period of seven-and-a-half months annually in which burning will be permissible. This is not ungenerous. I am now satisfied that the restrictions envisaged from mid-April to the end of August should be rigidly adhered to and that the limited exception — in so far as burning is concerned, implicit in subsection (2), should not be allowed. This is the explanation for the present amendments. In other words, under the Bill as drafted burning in certain circumstances would be permitted throughout the year. The amendments now propose to prohibit burning totally and altogether from the 15th April to 31st August in each year.
Comment on this
I wish to say something on section 40. I question the value of the change of the date from 18th March to 18th April because in my experience quite a number of birds nest from mid-March onwards, and I wonder if 18th April is far too late. One can get regional differences in this country. There is a considerable difference between the times of nesting in the south and north of Ireland. Some of the protected birds are nesting towards the end of March, whereas in the northern part of the country they may not start nesting until the middle of April. I have seen quite a number of birds which are protected by this Bill, nesting in late March. Their natural habitats are not going to be protected now until 18th April. I would ask the Minister to reconsider that. In our part of the country, St. Patrick's Day, 17th March, would be regarded as a typical date for birds to start nesting. On the question of the exceptions, this section shall not apply in relation to:
the burning or otherwise destroying, in the ordinary course of agriculture or forestry, of any vegetation growing on or in any hedge or ditch.
It refers to clumps of gorse or furze. Why would one destroy bushes or gorse or any type of scrub unless one was engaged in agriculture? The section serves little purpose because the exceptions allowed eliminate any advantage it may contain. I do not believe that because it has to do with reclamation is sufficient reason for destroying the habitat of valuable or scarce protected birds and animals. This gives too much leeway. Anybody caught destroying the nests of a pheasant or woodcock could plead that he was doing it in the course of agriculture. I would ask the Minister to tighten up the section somewhat.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Senator Deasy thinks that it would be desirable to prohibit burning from St. Patrick's Day and that we are being too liberal in allowing burning up to 14th April. The best technical advice available to me in my Department recommends 15th April. We had prolonged discussion with the National Association of Regional Game Councils on this matter and they are satisfied that the 15th April is adequate, and the correct date. A good deal of thought has gone into this and a lot of consultation has taken place with the National Association of Regional Game Councils. As a result of that the 15th April was decided upon.
In regard to the point raised by Senator Deasy that we are being too liberal in allowing interference with or the destruction of a hedge or a ditch in the ordinary course of agriculture and forestry, I would point out to the Senator that burning is not permitted. By one of the amendments we have just dealt with we have removed "burning or otherwise" from subsection (2) (a). Subsection (2) (a) now reads:
destroying, in the ordinary course of agriculture or forestry, of any vegetation growing on or in any hedge or ditch.
Might I suggest to the Seanad that if we are to succeed in our efforts to conserve wildlife we will do so only if we bring all sections of the community with us in a reasonable way and if we have the goodwill and support of all sections of the community? In other words, we must have a reasonable balance between our conservation activities and the activities of farmers and agriculture.
Senator Deasy asked what anyone would be doing destroying a ditch or a hedge if he was not engaged in the ordinary course of agriculture. Well, he might be engaged in a bit of devilment or in destruction for the sake of destruction. We are not going to permit that. Furthermore, as the Senator will see, it will be permissible to interfere with the hedge or the ditch in the ordinary course of agriculture only. It is doubtful whether land reclamation operations would be in the ordinary course of agriculture.
I think that the section as drafted creates a reasonable and a necessary exception to the prohibition. If we were to reach the stage of saying that, in the interest of wildlife preservation, farmers cannot engage in the ordinary agricultural activities we would immediately be called upon to pay compensation, and we would build up bad will instead of creating goodwill.
Comment on this
If there was a protected species nesting in say a hedgerow that was going to be cut by a farmer during this period, have you got any device for protecting that bird while it is nesting? Have you got any machinery? I think the onus should be on the landowner to report that there was such a species present and that, if necessary, he should be compensated rather than have the nest destroyed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Unintentional killing or destruction in the course of agriculture is exempted under an earlier section of the Bill. Senator Deasy asked me have I any device or machinery. I am sure he does not mean have I any cutting device, which I will bring in, that would not destroy nests. I do not know what experience Senator Deasy has of farming and agriculture, but I think that experience shows that there is nobody more sorry than the farmer if he finds that he has taken the leg off a hen pheasant in the course of mowing a meadow. Farmers in general do not go in for destroying game or wildlife. It often happens that if you are mowing a meadow you will take the leg off a pheasant or come across her nest and destroy it unintentionally. The exemption here seeks to allow a farmer to destroy in the ordinary course of agriculture or forestry any vegetation growing on or in a hedge or ditch. I venture to suggest that if the farmer knew that there was a pheasant or other bird hatching there he would pass her by and would not harm her.
Comment on this
I know someone who shot a pheasant and boasted about it.
Comment on this
In reference to this Bill, the ancient sport of falconry is left within the discretion of the Minister. It seems to me that this sport has certain horrific features about it which even hare coursing has not. I was recently in the house of a man in Ireland who engages in falconry and I was taken on a tour of his yard. I was shown a rather horrendous sight, that is, a whole series of cages of day-old chicks. I said, "What are the day-old chicks for? I did not know you had a chicken farm here." He said, "These are the favourite food of falcons." I put this in relief against the horror which was evinced over the killing of hares. After all, the killing of the hare in coursing is something that happens per accidens. I was at a coursing meeting recently where out of 60 hares only four were killed and the whole thing seemed to be regulated in a very sincerely humane way. The interest of the spectators seemed to be far more on the breaking of the dogs from the slips than on the killing of the hare. In fact I was far closer to the killing of the hare than any of the spectators. It struck me that the rearing of day-old chicks because they were the particular delicacy of falcons was something considerably more horrendous, horrific and inhumane than anything that I saw in my one day at a closed coursing meeting. I assume the Minister has carried out his own research on the matter of falconry, which is in its way a most dramatic and poetic sport, but if it has this rather inhuman substructure to it I would be interested to know what the Minister has to say about it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The position is that falconry is practised to a very limited extent here. Our information is that there are only one or two falconry farms or falconry menageries, I do not know which is the correct term. I saw one of them last year myself. I must confess I do not know what the birds of prey are fed on. They were not caged but they were tied with chains on their legs. If Senator Martin says that they are fed on day-old chicks I cannot contradict him. We do take power here in this section to make regulations to regulate the whole sport or art of falconry should that be necessary. At present we do not propose to make regulations but if the necessity arises or if there is any malpractice we can introduce regulations.
I was interested in the distinction drawn by Senator Martin in regard to coursing. As he very properly says, the end object in coursing is not killing the hare, it is the coursing of the greyhounds, and indeed the escape of the hare is enjoyed much more than the death of the hare. But I agree that in the art of falconry the birds of prey descend on their prey and kill them. I suppose these birds do that in the wild. We have all seen hawks, the bird of prey that we are most familiar with, descending on the smaller birds and killing them and we have seen the feathers in the fields where they had been operating. But we are moving forward here in so far as we are taking power to regulate the whole sport if necessary.
Comment on this
I am quite happy as long as the Minister does what he has said: that he will keep this under review and see that no inhumane practices relating to falconry take place.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 131:
In page 31, line 28, after "Where" to insert "there is adequate scientific evidence that".
Comment on this
I wonder if this amendment is realistic at all. How would one proceed to produce scientific evidence that wild birds or wild animals are causing damage, or where are these scientists to be had?
Comment on this
Galway University is a bit remote. The areas of the country where this damage occurs are usually remote areas. I am deeply concerned about damage caused to root crops by deer, particularly in the case of small farmers. Representations have been made to me on numerous occasions——
Comment on this
The amendment deals with the question of evidence.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Senator Walsh has stolen my thunder in regard to this amendment. The Senator was dealing with the question of deer, but we will deal with them later on. Section 42, as drafted, says that where damage has been caused by protected wild birds or wild animals certain steps may be taken against the wild birds or the wild animals. Senator Higgins seeks in amendment No. 131 to insert after the word “where”“there is adequate scientific evidence that” ...The section would then read:
Where there is adequate scientific evidence that damage is being caused by protected wild birds or by protected wild animals...
As Senator Walsh said, this is not practicable. I do not know what scientific evidence would be required in order to establish the damage caused. In most cases the damage will be visible. The basic objective of section 42 is to provide a speedy and suitable machinery for dealing with damage caused by protected fauna. In this context, the safeguarding of agricultural interests, that is, livestock, poultry and crops, will obviously be the primary—though of course not the only — concern and I would see deer as being the most likely "offending" species.
The provisions of sections 22 (6) and 23 (8) already impose constraints on the extent to which aggrieved landowners may act under section 42 with a view to stopping the damage. I would regard the Senator's proposed amendment as imposing a further constraint of a type which in the prevailing circumstances would not be at all warranted. After all, the kind of damage we are talking about will invariably have to be gauged by on-the-spot evidence rather than by scientific assessment. Accordingly, I do not think the amendment is necessary, and it would not be feasible to operate it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 132:
In subsection (4), page 32, line 7, after "bird" to insert "other than game birds."
My reason for tabling this amendment is that there is a danger that a person could claim that a game bird was damaging his crops whereas this may not be the case. There could be a situation where a poacher would say that he did not have time to apply for the licence and that his crops would be eaten. Would it be possible for the Minister to consider accepting the amendment?
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Senator proposes to exempt game birds from the section. I am advised that the type of damage envisaged under this section is unlikely to be caused by game birds. However, where this should happen, the right of the injured party to deal with them should not be withdrawn. I would point out, however, that the exercise of this right, apart from the special emergency situation provided for in section 22, is subject to ministerial permission, and this will apply its own limitations to what an aggrieved person can do. In the circumstances I am not prepared to accept the Senator's amendment.
Under section 22, an individual may in certain cases take action to prevent fauna causing the kind of damage which, if the person did not take action immediately, would lead to irreparable damage. If the damage is of the type which does not require immediate action, a licence from the Minister to deal with this fauna is necessary. I think that should meet the Senator's point.
Comment on this
Yes, but my fear is that an unscrupulous person could abuse this subsection. The person could kill game birds under the pretence that they had damagd his crops. The person could apply for a ministerial licence for this purpose and get away with it. The Minister has stated that the amount of damage caused by game birds is very small and this is a very good reason for the Minister to accept my amendment.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am sorry, but I do not think the Senator's amendment is necessary. The Senator is worried about a person getting a licence under false pretences and then abusing the powers given to hunt protected birds under that licence. If a person applies for a licence he must state his reasons for doing so. He must describe the type of damage which the offending birds are alleged to have caused. At that stage the applicant will be dealing with the scientific personnel in the Department of Lands. They will be able to decide if the applicant is talking fact or fiction and if it is the latter he will not receive a licence. If a person hunts protected wild birds without a licence he will be guilty of an offence unless he can prove that not alone were the birds damaging his crops or wild flora but that they were causing this damage in such a way as to require immediate action or else irreparable damage would be caused. If a person is caught shooting or hunting wild birds and offers this excuse the same test will be applied. If it is discovered that the person is merely telling fairy stories, he will be prosecuted and brought before the courts; the courts do not usually accept fairy tales as fact.
Comment on this
As a solicitor, the Minister knows better than I do that most laws can have a wedge driven through them. I could picture a situation where someone discovers that there are a number of hen pheasants on his land and he decides to apply for a licence which he can justify by alleging that the birds are damaging his crops. He will do this merely to kill the hen pheasants. If he is caught and prosecuted he can produce his licence in court and claim that he received this licence and shot the birds on the evening in question because he felt they were damaging his crops. I think a person could get away with such an argument.
Comment on this
I think there is a lot to be said for both sides in this argument. It is a situation which cannot be resolved except by the kind of discretion, residing in the Minister, which it is proposed to give him under this section. I can appreciate the case made by Senator McGlinchey. It is true to say that in any collection of people there is likely to be a rogue who will try to get around the law; possibly, this section might provide a loophole which an unscrupulous person might use for the purpose of getting around the law. That, in a nutshell, is the case which Senator McGlinchey is making and I appreciate the force of it. Essentially this section applies to hunting out of season and it applies to hunting during the prohibited hours in season or to hunting birds which are completely protected and in respect of which there is no open season at the moment, such as hen pheasants.
So long as the law is trying to deal with the person of the type Senator McGlinchey has in mind, it does not seem to me that the amending of this section will protect the wild animal or bird in question. The unscrupulus person who is determined to hunt out of season or to hunt protected game, birds in respect of which there might not be any season at all, will probably do that anyhow and all the amendment would do is that, if it could be proved that the offence had been committed, he would be subject to the penalty of the law.
It is open to the Minister under this section to deal with the situation by means of the conditions which he may attach to the granting of permission. He may attach conditions and, as I read it, it would be open to the Minister to accede to an application or to attach a condition to the permission that the person may drive out without killing the animal or bird that is doing the damage. Under the section he specifically has authority to attach to the permission a condition in respect of protected wild birds, that they be put into some other area, that if captured they will not be killed or destroyed but put in some other habitat. That authority is specifically given to the Minister.
I think the Minister is quite right when he says that, by and large, game birds are unlikely to be doing the amount of damage which is going to cause an application under this section to be made. Supposing we come to the situation where a game bird or a flock of birds, a gaggle of geese or whatever it might be, are doing considerable damage. If Senator McGlinchey's amendment is accepted it means that the poor landowner cannot protect himself against that even by seeking and getting permission from the Minister, because the Minister would have no authority under the Act to give anyone permission to deal with that state of affairs.
If you have a number of game birds that were doing considerable damage and possibly damage sufficient to cause severe financial or economic difficulties to, say, a small farmer or nurseryman or somebody of that sort, there would be no method under the law to allow that person protect himself and his interests if the amendment were adopted.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is a necessary saver for the existing powers of the Minister for Lands under sections 59 and 60 of the Forestry Act, 1946, to take steps to deal with hares which are attacking trees or tree plants.
Comment on this
I am not entirely happy about this section. It deals with damage by wild birds and so on. I wish to refer to deer and I have already spoken about the damage to crops, especially root crops, particularly in mountainous areas where the farms are small and people cannot afford the loss of a root crop which is damaged by deer.
Subsection (6) (c) states:
the Minister may grant the permission subject to a condition that—
(i) any capture pursuant to the permission is to be effected by a specified means,
(ii) any wild bird or any wild animal captured pursuant to the permission shall be removed to a place specified by the Minister for subsequent release or be disposed of in such other manner as may be so specified.
What exactly does he mean by this? If I were a small farmer on the mountains around Aughavannagh and I found about six young deer in a crop of turnips or cabbage devastating it in the morning, I do not know how I could capture these deer and remove them to a place where the Minister could deal with them. It is not quite as easy as that. I think the farmer concerned should be in a position that he could protect his own crops by using the gun himself and be within the law in doing so.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Senator has referred to subsection (6) (c) and that reads:
the Minister may grant the permission subject to a condition that——
He is not obliged to impose that condition——
(i) any capture pursuant to the permission is to be effected by a specified means,
(ii) any wild bird or any wild animal captured pursuant to the permission shall be removed to a place specified by the Minister for subsequent release or be disposed of in such other manner as may be so specified.
I would imagine that in the case of deer that are doing a lot of damage no such condition would be imposed. The provisions referred to by Senator Walsh are purely enabling provisions. Indeed in regard to many of these offending fauna the Minister could decide to have them dispatched by his own forestry officials. Indeed, it is not unlikely that where you have deer roaming wild you would also have forests suitably staffed. There is no certainty that the Minister would give the permission. He might instruct his own officials to cull the animals.
Comment on this
The Minister has said these deer could be dispatched by his own officials. I think it has been the practice of the Department of Lands to employ the services of a deer stalker in most areas. In recent times that does not seem to be the case. By the time the farmer would notify the forester in charge and notify the Minister and all this legality would be complied with, I can see the crop of turnips non est. I am inclined to see a situation where the farmer could, in this instance, without ministerial permission or without the animals being dispatched by one of his officials, protect his own crops.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If the Senator would refer to section 23 that section gives the landowner permission to take instant action for the protection of his own crops.
Comment on this
That is the point I was going to make, that it seems that that right is antecedently present in the Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to address more a question than a statement to the Minister on this section. Section 43 gives the Minister virtually no power, so far as I can see. It specifies that the commissioners, if they are to engage in the various activities described in the Bill, "shall, before commencing the scheme, consult the Minister to ascertain..." and so forth. Having consulted the Minister, do they in any way have to obey the Minister's judgment on the matter? This is just a question I would like to have answered.
Comment on this
(Cavan): No. The answer is that the Commissioners of Public Works would not be subject to the control of the Minister for Lands. The section provides that there must be consultation and discussions between the various Departments. It is almost certain that, as a result of that type of consultation between the two Departments, a reasonable solution would be arrived at.
Comment on this
This is a very praiseworthy section to have, because land drainage can do untold harm to natural habitats of various birds. This prohibits any undue damage being done to such habitats. As well as protecting areas such as specified in this section, I would submit that a lot of the land drainage done eliminates marshy ground, minor streams and so on. It must drastically affect the numbers of birds which use those habitats. I would ask that thought be given to the possibility of providing artificial alternatives where there has been extensive drainage, if necessary the provision of minor lakes or ponds to give the birds an alternative habitat. I am concerned with the drop in numbers of some very common birds in this country. Numbers have dropped quite a bit from my observations and those of bird watchers. For instance, in many areas there has been a marked drop, it seems, in the number of house martins, and martins, swallows, even the common thrush, and very much so in the case of the yellow hammer. These are all common Irish birds. I have no doubt that that reduction in numbers can be attributed to the partial destruction of the normal habitats of those birds. We need to do a lot more research to find out to what extent this type of destruction is affecting their numbers and how the decline can be arrested. This matter of land drainage might be the best place to start.
I have a book compiled by a bird watcher in County Waterford. It is a very interesting document. It verifies much of what I have been saying. We will just take one common bird which has almost disappeared completely from our part of the country, the corncrake. According to this booklet, there are only four reports of a corncrake being heard in County Waterford in 1972. Fifteen or 20 years ago there would be several thousand throughout the country. The Department of Lands, the Minister in particular, should make a point of finding out the reasons for this decline. I also notice in some of this literature that the natural habitat of seagulls has changed in the Dunmore East area from the cliffs, which is their natural habitat, to houses in the area. That is a startling change. We had an instance last year in the village of Kilmacthomas where a seagull actually nested in the chimney of the local public house. This has great relevance, in that these birds are hunted out of their natural habitats and no alternative is being provided. We should go to great pains to see that they have an alternative.
Land drainage is probably most significant of all. For instance, snipes and curlews must show a drastic drop in numbers if land drainage continues at the rate at which it has been going for the past number of years, and no alternatives are provided.
Comment on this
I am sorry to come back again on the same point, but what Senator Deasy said is of such central importance and significance, I feel I must add one point to the question I asked. He raised the much larger issue which certainly arises out of this part of the Bill, that is, the issue of the health of the entire environment, the birds listed behaving in such aberrant ways. To find a seagull taking possession of the chimney of a public house, either inside or outside licensing hours, should draw our attention to the fact that things are getting extremely urgent and difficult. What I would like, however, to contemplate on is the implications of the Minister's answer to my question "the commissioners shall consult the Minister" but they do not have to obey him. In other words, the Minister argues correctly, and convincingly, that, of course, when reasonable men meet to discuss a matter like this, each side has the general good at heart and a reasonable solution is arrived at.
What emerges through this Bill, from section to section, is the fact that different Departments have to deal with different aspects of the problem of conservation. Conservation is almost like a motif in an opera running through this Bill. Wild life is what it is called, but conservation is one of the major themes in it. Conservation is one of the major themes when you come to look at urbanisation and plans for cities, when raised on the adjournment or otherwise, as to what should happen to Wood Quay. Conservation has to do with what is happening in Fitzwilliam Square, Bantry Bay or Dublin Bay. That is the larger theme that is constantly being invoked in different Bills here, that is, the question of our concern with the entire environment urban, rural and maritime. The slight dislocation of powers involved in section 43, subsection (b), that the commissioners shall consult but cannot be instructed, is a symptom of this larger problem which Senator Deasy raises. In other words — and it is not the first time I have said it here — the Minister for Lands has a great deal to do with what is in this Bill, but there is a larger, more urgent concern, that of the health of our entire environment, and the case to be made for a Ministry for the Environment, a Department of the Environment, becomes increasingly urgent as the years go on. I will just take this opportunity of once again reiterating the urgent need within our community for at least a Department of the Environment, if not a Minister for the Environment.
Comment on this
I fully agree with the last two speakers, particularly Senator Deasy when he refers to the scarcity and decline of all our small birds, the corncrake and several other birds of that kind. This should not be raised under section 43 because that section deals mainly with the Office of Public Works and drainage. Since this Bill was introduced, Members of this House have been approached by the Irish Coursing Club, the game councils and so on to have something done for their respective interests, but I have not heard anybody asking what was being done about the small bird. It is up to some Department to do something about this. The Minister should appoint a committee to investigate the migration of our small birds. Perhaps the Office of Public Works may have something to do with it.
Comment on this
It is, but at least the game council are interested in mallard and they have made some suggestions as to how mallard could be increased. That is not so with the small bird. That farmers have been putting down extra fertiliser in recent years must have something to do with the falling numbers of those small birds.
Comment on this
I appeal to you, a Leas-Chathaoirleach, to exercise not only your usual discretion but your indulgence. An appeal has already been made by Senator Deasy and other Senators concerning the future of certain birds. I am grateful to those Senators who moved amendment No. 131 in my absence. I thank Senator Ryan for that.
A problem arises concerning the land drainage scheme and its effects. Senator Martin referred to the problem and to the extent we are willing to assess the effect of a particular administrative Act on the ecosystem in general. This section states:
...the Commissioners shall, before commencing the scheme, consult the Minister to ascertain if and to what extent the proposed scheme if carried out would affect or interfere with the suitability of the land affected by the scheme for a nature reserve or refuge, as may be appropriate, and take all practicable steps including, where appropriate, the limitation of the drainage scheme to minimise or avoid such effect of interference.
I put the question to myself to what extent this is practicable without adequate scientific research into the eating habits of the fox and the hare. In The Irish Naturalist's Journal, Dr. Jim Fairley of University College, Galway, has published what these much maligned animals, particularly the fox, eat. Without such research how can you do an ecosystem impact study, which is almost implied under section 43?
If section 43 declares an intention of doing such an impact study, I would ask why that emphasis is not present in the other sections of the Bill? How is it scientifically possible to honour subsection (b) and not possible to accept, on the other hand, many of the amendments which have gone?
Comment on this
(Cavan): Before dealing with the section, may I deal with the point just made by Senator Higgins? If he refers to section 11, he will find out that that section sets out the functions of the Minister in regard to wildlife and starts off by stating that “it shall be a function of the Minister to secure the conservation of wildlife”. Subsection (2) states:
Without prejudice to the generality of subsection (1) of this section, the Minister may in particular do all or any of the following:
In subsection (3) (b) the Senator will see the Minister may:
promote the knowledge and understanding of matters to which the functions assigned to him under this Act are related.
The Minister is authorised and empowered by section 11 to do the very sort of research that the Senator has in mind, to find out the very sort of information that the Senator thinks he should find out. Section 13 of the Bill sets up an advisory council to advise and make suggestions to the Minister. But I should like to refer to section 43 because this section deals with land drainage schemes under the Arterial Drainage Act of 1945. I invite the Seanad to consider for a moment the position in regard to those schemes as of now while we are still discussing this Bill and before it becomes law.
There is no obligation whatever on the Commissioners of Public Works to have any regard to the conservation of wildlife or the habitats of wildlife as of now. The only concern of the Commissioners of Public Works is to get water out of the way, to make land better, to do away with flooding and to promote drainage. That is the obligation of the Commissioners of Public Works under the Arterial Drainage Act. I think that is unreasonable. In carrying out their obligations and duties under the Arterial Drainage Act they should do as little damage as possible to our wildlife. They should have regard to matters like the environment. Let us not however go to the other extreme in discussing this Bill and say that the principal object of the Commissioners of Public Works must be the conservation of wildlife and that they must down tools altogether if in carrying out their own obligations they are likely to damage wildlife habitats in any area. That would be equally unreasonable. Let us have a balance between wildlife and wildlife conservation, on the one hand, and arterial drainage, on the other. Let us have a balance between the thinking of the farmer and the wildlife conservationist. The farmer seeing half his farm lying under water throughout the year believes that, if he could get it drained, he would make a good living for himself and for his family. The wildlife conservationist sees beauty in all living things and in wildlife in general and believes that they should be protected. I put it to the Seanad that section 43 strikes that balance exactly, because it reads as follows:
(1) Where the Commissioners propose to undertake either (a) a drainage scheme within the meaning of the Arterial Drainage Act, 1945 which is one to which this section applies, or, (b) any other land drainage scheme in respect of an area which includes land to which an establishment order, a recognition order or a designation order applies, or land to which an agreement made under section 18 of this Act applies——
those orders and agreements deal with wildlife habitat. The section goes on to state:
——the commissioners shall, before commencing the scheme, consult the Minister to ascertain if, and to what extent, the proposed scheme if carried out would affect or interfere with the suitability of the land affected by the scheme whether nature reserve or refuge, as may be appropriate, and take all practicable steps including, where appropriate, the limitation of the drainage scheme to minimise or avoid such effect or interference.
Perhaps I went a bit far when I said in reply to Senator Martin that the Commissioners of Public Works might consult with me and then ignore it. I believe that that section as drafted leaves it open to any wildlife conservationist or anybody else interested in the conservation of wildlife and of the land mentioned in this section to proceed against the Commissioners of Public Works if they act recklessly, if they drive a bulldozer or their drainage machines through some valuable or irreplaceable wildlife habitat. If they did that they would be acting in contravention of the section. The spirit of this section and the draftsmanship of it means that they have to act in a reasonable manner and I believe that the courts would so interpret this section. Therefore, I believe that, without intruding too much on the rights of the people who want their land drained, this section as drafted steers a canter course, without going too far and improves the situation as it exists at present in so far as wildlife conservation is concerned. I recommend it to the Senators.
Comment on this
I want to complement what the Minister is asked on section 43 not only in relation to habitat but also in relation to something which does not concern us directly in this legislation, inland fisheries. The fact that such drainage should be controlled has become extremely apparent to those of us who live in an area like my own, quite near the River Corrib, where drainage schemes have seriously interfered with, for example, the future of trout stocks. That does not directly concern us here.
I should like to ask the Minister one simple technical question. Would he not agree that section 43 would have been strengthened had section 11 (c), which was quoted in reply to my earlier comment, contained the words "initiate research"? In this sense the Minister has the power, as he quite rightly told me, to enter into an agreement with another person to participate in a scheme or undertake a project for the conservation of life. This leaves it open to the Minister to contract for work from the scientific bodies or from a university institution that might be involved in a particular species. Should the Minister not have retained for use by the officials in his Department the phrase "initiate research"? I know this is something which was rejected earlier.
Comment on this
Indeed no. With respect to my colleague, Senator M.J. O'Higgins, might I say that in the history of art, for example, people have promoted art and have patronised art but have not been artists. In exactly the same way people have promoted research and have not themselves been researchers. Therefore, I am pushed back to the meaning of the words "initiate research".
Comment on this
I agree they can "carry out or cause to be carried out". I want to assure you, a Chathaoirleach, that I am not needlessly delaying the Seanad. What I am saying is that the words "cause to be carried out" gave me the impression, perhaps wrongly, that the Minister would contract out such research and would give away the power to initiate such research within his own Department.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister must act through agents. I have no intention of undertaking the research myself. I would not be competent to do it.
Comment on this
I compliment the Minister on this section, which I think is very praiseworthy. The point I made was that if drainage was carried on continuously, as it is at present, there would be diminution in the stocks of birds that use damp lands and ponds as their natural habitat. There is evidence of a great decline of bird numbers as a result of the destruction of habitat and so on.
I have here a booklet from the Minister's Department, the Forest and Wildlife Service. It is called A List of Commoner Irish Birds. It illustrates that point photographically. I shall quote some extracts from it.
Peregrine Falcons have decreased recently from over 150 breeding pairs to about 30...
The Corncrake is decreasing everywhere except in small hay-field areas of the west and rough-grass areas around the coast and elsewhere.
The Arctic Tern has decreased greatly this century.
Nowadays only c.300 pairs of the Little Tern breed in Ireland.
The Cuckoo has decreased in recent years.
The Barn Owl has decreased greatly.
The Sand Martin appears to have decreased greatly in recent years.
Those are comments from this official booklet which was issued some time ago.
Comment on this
Some are. Their natural habitats have been destroyed. This section protects the habitat of water birds.
It is obvious that a number of species are on the decline. I am asking the Minister to investigate the reason for the decline and to try to arrest it.
Comment on this
In this connection I will not be laborious. Indeed, I think the Minister has shown exemplary patience with us. I totally applaud this section. The only reservation I have is that perhaps it does not give enough power to the Minister. I should like to ask the Minister one question. He may not choose to answer it because it could perhaps be judged in some sense as not being totally relevant to the precise terms of this section. With regard to what Senator Deasy, Senator Higgins and Senator Ryan have raised, there are a number of very technical questions involving the accumulation of knowledge and the judgment of that knowledge. These small birds are no-body's children, so to speak, and are not of any interest to the game people. Would it not be of help to the Minister to work hand-in-hand with a Department of the Environment which would have an even more specific concern with the technical and investigatory processes at its disposal? Would the setting up of an environment ministry help the Minister?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I admire Senator Martin's persistence in introducing the Department of the Environment into this discussion. This is essentially a wildlife conservation Bill. Wildlife is only one particular part of the environment. I am satisfied that this Bill, as introduced and amended, contains all the machinery necessary for the Minister for Lands to conserve wildlife, and for that purpose to get all the technical know-how and information about the habits of wildlife and why some species are becoming scarcer and are liable to become extinct. I am satisfied that the all-embracing section 11 of this Bill— and we are very far moved, with all due respects, a Chathaoirleach, from section 43, which is really a drainage section — enables the Minister to carry out research and promote knowledge and is wide enough to give me all the powers I need.
Section 13 deals with the Wildlife Advisory Council, which are set up for the purpose of bringing together a cross section of the people who are interested in wildlife and in its conservation. So it will enable them to sit down, exchange views with and be consulted by the Minister for Lands, and on their initiative to tender advice and suggestions to the Minister for Lands. We have there all the machinery we want. It is agreed by all, if I interpret the Seanad correctly, that section 43 is a worth-while section and that it improves very considerably the situation in regard to the habitat of wildlife. With all due respect, I suggest that we move on.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 134, 143, 144, 145 and 191 are related. It is suggested that they be debated together.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Minister has tabled amendments which cover most of what we asked for, I will not move the amendments in my name.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 135 and amendments Nos. 137 to 139, inclusive, are related and may be debated together.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Hunting any fauna on land without the permission of the owner or occupier of that land or of the holder of the sporting rights over it is clearly objectionable. Section 44 (1), as drafted, is deficient in that it makes only the hunting of protected species without such permission an offence. These amendments, by making the provisions of subsection (1) apply to all species, protected or otherwise, will remedy the deficiency. The inclusion in the amendments of references to firearms and other devices is aimed at making what I would regard as a reasonable exception for accidental trespass which can occur in other forms of hunting in which firearms and other such devices are not used — staghunting, beagling and so on. The purpose of the amendment is not to make such accidental trespass an offence under the Bill. It is important to point out, however, that the owner's right to take civil proceedings for what I would call simple trespass would not be affected in any way.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Amendments Nos. 140 and 141 are merely minor drafting points. Their purpose is to ensure a uniform description throughout section 44 for the holder of sporting rights and to replace different descriptions at present contained in the section.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment is to remove an unnecessarily restrictive and, indeed, largely impractical requirement to have written authorisation. In the section as drafted the owner could delegate his authority to another person but he would have to delegate that authority in writing. It was considered that that was going too far and the amendment removes the writing requirement and proposes that the owner may authorise an agent by word of mouth.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Section 45, which deals with the sale and purchase of protected species of wild birds and wild animals, is one of the most crucial sections in the Bill. It is clearly essential to support the other protective measures in the Bill by having a tight control on outlets for the purchase and sale of protected fauna. In the circumstances I can say that the section has come in for very close scrutiny by various interested groups with whom my Department have had a series of useful discussions since the Bill was published. As a result of these discussions, and following a further examination of the section as drafted, I am satisfied that the rather elaborate amendments now being put forward will greatly improve the effectiveness of the section as well as the overall protection of species being afforded by the Bill.
Amendment No. 146 arises from the problem of poaching and the fact that some past prosecutions for offences in this respect have failed because the culprit was not caught in the act of killing or there was insufficient evidence as to where the unlawful killing took place. The new subsection (2) is designed to make possession of protected fauna an offence, subject however to such lawful possession as occurs as a result of things permitted to be done under the new subsections (3) and (8) and under sections 22 (5), 23 (7) (d) and 42.
The new subsection (3) makes exceptions to the blanket prohibition on the sale of protected fauna in subsection (1). The exceptions are as follows:
Paragraph (a) exempts sales which are for the sole purpose of propagating or improving the quality of the species — a very desirable conservation process.
Comment on this
One question on the amendment. How extensive is the phrase used in the amendment here "shall not have in his possession a protected wild bird" and so on. I know it may seem far-fetched but the courts have to have a look at this if prosecutions are brought and they must interpret the Act in accordance with the words used in it. It would seem to me that, if the Minister owns land on which there are protected wildlife, wild birds and eggs, and so on, that by reason of his ownership of the land he has those in his possession. Is he automatically then committing an offence——
Comment on this
It does not only apply as I see it to "in possession for sale". That is not the point I am making here.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) of the amendment. In other words, I am wondering should it really be "shall not have in his possession for sale".
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Senator may have a point there I concede. The section as drafted originally reads: (1) “A person who is not a licensed wildlife dealer shall not sell, keep for sale or purchase for resale”. The amendment reads: “Subject to subsections (3) and (8) of this section and to sections 22 (5), 23 (7) (d) and 42 of this Act, a person who is not a licensed wildlife dealer shall not have in his possession a protected wild bird or a protected wild animal, whether alive or dead, or the eggs of a protected wild bird”.
All I can say is that at first sight the Senator might appear to have raised a hare, so to speak. He will bear in mind that we are dealing here with wildlife, that we are dealing here with wild fauna, wild birds, and wild animals, that is, wild birds and wild animals which are not in the ownership of any particular person because, if they were owned, they would be domestic animals and they would not come within this Bill at all. If there are wild birds on my land they are really not in my possession in the purely physical sense.
Comment on this
(Cavan): They are not in my ownership and they are not in my possession. In fact, as long as they are on my land I have certain control over them in so far as I can prevent people trespassing on my land to take them. I think that, on reflection, the Senator will come to the conclusion that unless I have the fauna housed, or controlled, or in my physical possession, as apart from being on my land, I would not be guilty of an offence.
Comment on this
The Minister is probably right in this but I would like him to have a look at it before the Report Stage. It seems to me that there is a doubt. There is, as the Minister adverted to quite rightly, a distinction in law between wild animals and domestic animals. Presumably that would apply to birds as well, to domestic fowl, for example, as distinct from wild birds. I have forgotten from my student days precisely what the Latin name was. There is that distinction, I agree.
As I understand it, and I may be wrong in this, the distinction between the wild and the domestic is essentially one of ownership. Even though there are wild birds or animals on my land, I do not own them. It may be that that is sufficient to mean in the context of this amendment that therefore they are not in my possession.
On the other hand, it seems to me that at least there is a case to be made for saying that if there is something on my land, because the entire of my land and everything on it is legally in my possession, therefore the wild bird or the wild animal, as the case may be, is for the time being in my possession. As I said when I spoke first, it may be far-fetched but, in case the matter should be interpreted literally, or a court might feel compelled to interpret it literally, I would ask the Minister to have a look at it again. As I say, he may be quite right in the answer which he has given to me.
Comment on this
(Cavan): While I am fairly satisfied that the view I take is right, I have not sufficient information or authority with me to show conclusively that I am. I rather think there are many many legal cases on this sort of thing in the courts. I will certainly have a look at it between now and Report Stage to put it beyond doubt.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This amendment proposes to insert a new subsection which is necessary to enable authorised persons to inspect records of protected fauna in hotels, restaurants, and so on, to ensure that there is no breach of subsection (3), now to be renumbered subsection (4). This is a very necessary subsection.
Comment on this
I presume that is the best the Minister can do to try to prevent abuses such as this.
Comment on this
The inspection of registers. It seems to be the only method the Minister has at his disposal in trying to ensure that people who poach will not have sales.
Comment on this
(Cavan): We have elaborate provisions in other sections dealing with wildlife dealers. Of course, it will be an offence for any person to purchase from somebody who is not a wildlife dealer. For example, a hotelier who purchases from a poacher will be guilty of an offence and can be prosecuted. That is the idea behind inspections — to check up on the origin of the fauna which might be found in a hotel.
Comment on this
When this inspection takes place the bird will probably have been cooked and it will be very difficult to check it then.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If the goose is cooked our goose will be cooked at that stage and there is nothing that can be done about it. However, there are such things as cold stores and cold rooms and deep freezes which can be inspected.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This is a minor drafting amendment which is necessary as a consequence of the new subsections (2) and (3).
Comment on this
(Cavan): Whereas the new subsection (2) is designed to make possession of protected fauna an offence, these amendments make exceptions to the blanket prohibition. The exceptions are:
(1) Where the specimen is lawfully held by a person before the passing of the Act.
(2) Where the specimen has been either lawfully killed or captured by the person himself or from another person who had lawfully killed or captured.
(3) Possession of a specimen of protected species, or the eggs of a protected wild bird, which arises from anything lawfully done under a licence or a permission granted either under the Bill or under any other statute. A case in point would be the possession of protected wild birds or protected wild animals by a research worker operating under a licence granted under section 22 (7) or section 23 (6).
Comment on this
Possibly an extension, mentally, of paragraph (a) of the new subsection (8) may meet the point I made earlier. Subsection (8) makes it clear that possession is not unlawful if the person either had lawfully acquired the wild bird or wild animal before the commencement of the section, or had acquired it or them from a person who had lawfully acquired it or them. Presumably, if one traces the succession of title it was there before this section would have become law. Even if there is no other answer, that might answer the point I made earlier regarding possession.
Comment on this
Is a taxidermist legally entitled to hold birds under this Bill? Not that he would have a great impact on wildlife in general but it is a point which might arise.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I know what Senator Dolan has in mind but, if they are protected wild fauna, the person would have to be a wildlife dealer under the Bill to deal in them. The case Senator Dolan has in mind is the taxidermist who would receive, say, a badger from a client and then proceed to stuff it. This taxidermist would not be engaged in selling it. Senator Dolan has raised an interesting point. If the taxidermist is engaged in buying or selling the bird or animal, then he is engaged in wildlife dealing and he must be licensed. There is no doubt about that. Under the section, amended, he would be in possession of the bird or animal for the purpose of processing it. Therefore, he would have to have a wildlife dealer's licence.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 150:
Before subsection (2) to insert the following new subsection:—
"(2) The Minister shall make regulations providing that game or wildfowl purchased by a wildlife dealer for sale to the public or for export shall be purchased by him only from a game licence holder who has been licensed by the Minister to sell game or wildfowl."
I do not wish to press this amendment because the Minister has gone a long way in facilitating us. However, I should like to hear the Minister's views on it. A short time ago, he said that if a hotelier purchased a bird from somebody other than a licensed dealer he could be prosecuted. What guarantee have we that the licensed dealer did not purchase the bird or animal illegally?
Comment on this
The Minister said a hotelier could be prosecuted if he purchased a bird from somebody other than a licensed dealer, but how do we know who the licensed dealer bought it from?
Comment on this
(Cavan): We could carry on this argument ad infinitum. Is it likely that a man who goes to the trouble of equipping himself with a permit, or what used to be called a game dealer's licence, would co-operate with a poacher in relieving him of game? That seems to be the Senator's suggestion.