We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Wildlife Bill, 1975: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 130–261 of 261. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Wildlife Bill, 1975
Enacted

No. 9 of 1975 ›

It could happen.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We cannot legislate for every possibility.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This is a minor amendment aimed at removing doubt. Its purpose is to ensure that, where the import of any species of wild bird or wild animal is prohibited by regulations made by the Minister, the ban will extend to the eggs of any such wild bird, or the spawn of fish, or certain amphibious species, for example, toads. The amendment puts it beyond doubt that the ban applies to eggs and spawn.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 155 is consequential on amendment No. 153 and they may be taken together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I propose to take amendments Nos. 153 and 155 together. Their purpose is simply to enable the Minister to authorise another agency to grant licences for the export of protected fauna or flora. The amendment will make for consistency with the similar provision in regard to import licences contained in section 52 (1) and (3) as originally intended. I might say by way of clarification that such an enabling provision would empower the Minister, if he saw fit to do so in the interests of administrative ease or economy, to authorise the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to exercise these particular licensing functions in conjunction with that Minister's similar functions under the Destructive Insects and Pests Consolidation Act, 1958, the Diseases of Animals Act, 1966, or the Fisheries Acts, 1959-1974. In other words, this amendment enables the Minister for Lands, for the sake of convenience, to authorise the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to exercise certain powers under this section which it would be convenient for him to do in conjunction with existing powers and obligations on the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This amendment is simply to remove doubt by extending any prohibition on the export of protected wild birds or protected wild animals to the eggs in the case of birds, and spawn in the case of fish, or certain species of animal, for example, toads. We had that in an amendment a few moments ago.

Comment on this

Would this cover a taxidermist who might be engaged on a very big scale and might feel like exporting stuffed animals or stuffed birds of a wild species?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He would have to get a licence.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): These are drafting amendments, as recommended by the draftsman.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This is purely a drafting amendment made necessary by the decision to define territorial seas of the State in section 2 of the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 159 and 160 are related. I suggest we debate them together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The main object of section 59 is to enable the Minister to regulate public access to and use of nature reserves, whether on State-owned or private lands, and refuges for fauna. The section is, therefore, meant to provide protective provisions complementary to the provisions of section 15, which enables the Minister to establish nature reserves on State lands including foreshore and territorial seas, section 16, which formally recognises nature reserves on private lands, and section 17, which sets up refuges for fauna.

Subsections (1) and (5) were intended to provide these protective provisions but it has been brought to my notice that subsection (1) as it stands would not cover all of the State nature reserve categories as intended and as set out in section 15 (1) (a), (b) and (c). These amendments are therefore necessary to rectify this oversight.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Subsection (4) seeks to limit the scope of any regulations which may be made relating to refuges for fauna. As the subsection reads it goes further than intended by providing that any such regulations shall regulate access “to such extent as is necessary for the conservation of fauna for which the refuge is established”. This appears to me to be far too wide on its scope, having regard to the fact that any compensation settled in respect of such refuges under section 17 will relate to the dimunition in value, loss or disadvantage arising from the protective measures contained in the statutory order designating the lands as a refuge. The effect of this amendment would be to confine the scope of any such regulations, in respect of a refuge for fauna, to the purposes of fulfilling the protective measures indicated in the designation order under section 17 setting up the refuge.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It has been represented to me that provision should also be made so as to enable the Minister at the request of the parties to agreements made under section 18, which regulate the management or use of land in the interests of some wildlife value, to make regulations governing access to and use of such lands by the public. I accept the proposition and this amendment will so provide. This deals with refuges, and so on, which are privately owned and set up under agreement by private individuals and it gives the Minister power to cooperate with them by regulating access, making regulations to regulate access. It can only be done at the request of the people concerned and with their agreement.

Comment on this

Could a gun club request the Minister to assist in this matter if they want to preserve a certain area?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): With the agreement of the landowners and all concerned. There is nothing compulsory about it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The purpose of this amendment is to apply section 9 of the Forestry Act, 1946, which relates to the acquisition of land, buildings and so on for forestry purposes to the acquisition of buildings or works required in connection with the Minister's function under this Bill. The omission was inadvertent. Under the Forestry Act, section 9, the Minister has power to acquire buildings as well as land. This section as drafted did not confer those rights on the Minister and the purpose of this amendment is to extend the provisions of section 9 of the Forestry Act, 1946, to the functions of the Minister under this Bill.

Comment on this

Does that mean that on previous occasions when the Forestry acquired land they actually did not acquire the buildings thereon?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No, it does not. The Forestry Division of my Department very rarely exercised its compulsory powers under the Forestry Acts, but it had power to acquire land and buildings. This section, as drafted, enabled the Minister to acquire only land for the purposes of this Bill. The amendment will enable him to acquire land and buildings.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This is also a drafting amendment. The words being deleted are superfluous in the context of the subsection.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The purpose of this section, as drafted, is to make it unnecessary for officials of the Minister's Department to attend court in order to prove that an open season order, under sections 24 or 25, or a licence granted by the Minister was not in force at the time the alleged offence was committed. The purpose of the amendment is to extend those provisions to permissions granted by the Minister under the Bill or to acts which are lawful by exclusion from prohibitions under the Bill.

There are many precedents for this type of section. It simply means that if somebody is prosecuted for shooting in closed season it will not be necessary to send down somebody from the Department to prove an open season order was not in force.

Comment on this

The purpose of paragraph (a) of the amendment is quite clear and could not be quarrelled with. The Minister is certainly right in saying that there are many precedents for it. Perhaps the Minister could explain or illustrate what is intended by paragraph (b). I do not understand it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There are many things under the Bill which are unlawful to do. For example, to hunt or capture a protected bird in a closed season is forbidden, but it would be legal to do that for certain purposes if the person concerned had a licence from the Minister to do it. The object of proviso (b) here will mean that it will not be necessary to negative the existence of such a licence in order to suceed in a prosecution. If the accused defends the summons on the basis that he has a licence the onus will be on him to produce it.

Comment on this

That explains (a) but does it explain (b)?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Paragraph (b) is the same. Paragraph (a) refers to an open season order and (b) to a licence granted by the Minister. While it would be illegal, say, to hunt or to capture a wild bird in a closed season normally speaking, it could be legal to do that for scientific purposes, provided the person who did it had a licence from the Minister to do it. That is the type of licence referred to in paragraph (b). The amendment means that it would not be necessary for the prosecution to negative the existence of such a licence.

Comment on this

Am I correct in thinking that paragraph (b) goes a bit further? There are provisions in the Bill — some amendments dealt with them earlier — that while normally it is an offence to kill, capture or take a hen pheasant, if a person kills one accidentally while driving along the road for example, that would not be an offence. Does paragraph (b) provide that, where a person is charged with having killed or taken a hen pheasant, the prosecution do not have to satisfy themselves as to the circumstances in which the hen was killed, but that it will still be open to the defendant in court to prove that he accidentally killed the bird while driving his car? That is a perfect defence under the Bill once it is established, but paragraph (b) puts the onus of showing that on the defendant rather than on the prosecution. It goes further than merely the question of a licence or a permit.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What Senator O'Higgins said was substantially correct. That is the effect of the section. Section 22 (5) and section 23 (7) exempt from offence certain unintentional acts or acts which are otherwise lawful. Paragraph (b) of this amendment is to cover them.

Comment on this

Acceptance of this amendment involves the deletion of section 71.

SECTION 72.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 168 and 169 are cognate and should, accordingly, be debated together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Section 72 deals with powers of the Garda Síochána and authorised persons. I propose, having obtained permission, to take amendments Nos. 168 and 169 together. They are designed to include in the list of suspected offences which may be investigated under this section by the Garda and authorised persons, offences against the wildlife dealing provisions of sections 45 and 47. The section as drafted, did not clearly cover these particular offences. That would be a serious shortcoming in the Bill because the sections dealing with wildlife are really very important sections to ensure that abuses of poaching and so on are stamped out.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether the owner of the land, if he apprehended somebody who was shooting on his land, would be considered an authorised person or would be entitled to ask if the offender had a licence?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The owner of the land would have the powers given to him by section 44 because the person who was on the land without permission of the owner would be a trespasser.

Comment on this

Has he any authority to ask him for his licence?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He has under section 44. It is dealt fully with in section 44.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This new subsection is intended to ensure that a member of the Garda or an authorised person will be in a position to stop a suspected offender anywhere except in a building—where a search warrant would be required in accordance with section 73. This would be of particular importance in the case of suspected poachers.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This amendment is consequential on the amendment of section 34 (1) (a) which proposes to prohibit the use of bows and arrows and certain other devices in hunting game birds or game animals.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This amendment is proposed by way of assistance to the Garda. Authorised persons would be in a position to use their technical knowledge of wildlife to assist the Garda in such matters as identification of protected species.

Section 73 enables the Garda to search certain places with a warrant and the proposed amendment authorises the Garda to take with them, when carrying out such search, authorised officers. Authorised officers could have technical knowledge that the Garda would not have.

Comment on this

Amendments No. 173 and 174 are related and may be debated together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The purpose of this amendment is twofold. Firstly, it is to enable dwellings which are suspected of being used in connection with offences involving protected species of fauna or flora to be searched under warrant. It has been strongly represented to me that the excepting of dwellings from search under warrant as provided under subsection (3) of the section would seriously weaken the section. I think it would render it impossible to enforce not merely the provisions of this but of many sections of the Bill.

Senator McGlinchey has a similar amendment down, amendment No. 174. This amendment I am introducing goes a long way towards meeting it.

The second purpose of this amendment is to provide that where an authorised person searches a dwelling under warrant he must be accompanied by a member of the Garda. I consider this new provision desirable even though such searches are likely to be fairly rare.

With regard to the Garda accompanying the authorised person, under the section as originally drafted it would not be possible to search a dwelling house at all. That, as the amendment illustrates, would render it impossible to enforce many of the provisions of the Bill. It is proposed to enable either a member of the Garda or an authorised person to search a dwelling house provided he has a search warrant, but it goes further and it says that an authorised person must be accompanied, even if he has a warrant, by a member of the Garda. That is reasonable, because the authorised person might be a local person going into somebody's private dwelling house and it is desirable that he should have a garda with him for his own protection.

Comment on this

My reason for tabling the amendment is very well given by the Minister in that the section was useless without it. I think that the Minister's amendment meets my case.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 175 and 177 are cognate and may be debated together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I apologise for the fact that these amendments have been put down rather late in the day but I am sure the Senators have had an opportunity of considering them.

On reading the section it appeared to me that as subsections (2) and (3) stand there is an inherent risk in them in regard to prosecutions on indictment, that it would be known to the court in advance of the trial that the accused person had previous convictions for similar offences. These amendments are therefore being proposed in order to remove that risk and to ensure a completely fair and impartial trial. There is no question that the amendmens will weaken the essence of the section.

I want to draw the attention of the Seanad to section 74 (1) which provides in regard to penalties:

(a) in the case of a first offence, under the particular section or subsection, to a fine not exceeding fifty pounds,

(b) in the case of a second such offence, to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds, and

(c) in the case of a third and subsequent such offence, to a fine not exceeding two hundred pounds.

Subsection (2) covers offences of failure to comply with regulations under section 59 which deal with habitats. Subsection (3) deals with offences in regard to what I will call loosely endangered species, species which are in danger of becoming extinct. In both these cases the section as drafted provided in the case of a first offence, on summary conviction a fine of £100, in the case of a second such offence £200. This is where the trouble crept in. In the case of a third or subsequent offence, on summary conviction the fine was to be not exceeding £250, and in the case of a conviction on indictment the fine was to be a sum not exceeding £500. The court hearing the case would know that if a person was charged on indictment he must have been guilty of previous offences, otherwise he could not be charged on indictment. It is a well-known legal maxim and legal procedure that evidence of previous convictions cannot be brought before the court until the person has been convicted, unless in very exceptional cases where the person himself has put his own record in evidence. The purpose of this amendment is to use a procedure from which it will not be apparent to the court that there was any previous offence.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Amendment No. 176 is merely a drafting point.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 178 to 182, inclusive, and 185 to 189, inclusive, are all related and may be taken together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Section 78 deals with the disposal of things seized as evidence by an authorised person or a member of the Garda Síochána under sections 72 and 73. Under subsection (1) of the section disposal can be carried out in two ways: (a) with the owner's consent or (b) in the case of dead fauna, an application to and under a direction from a peace commissioner. The reason for the departure in the case of dead fauna is its perishable nature and its likelihood of becoming unfit for human food before the relevant court proceedings are concluded.

On reconsideration of the section it has occurred to me that the exceptional measures of disposal in the case of dead fauna should also be applied in the case of certain other things seized, such as protected wild plants which would also be perishable, live fauna—where the question of holding it pending the conclusion of court proceedings would present difficulties—and explosive substances, referred to in section 33, which could deteriorate and become dangerous if not destroyed quickly.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 183 and 190 are related and may be debated together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The purpose of these amendments is to allow for the disposal of things seized by means other than destruction, for example, by sale. Any moneys received by a sale would be payable to the Minister who in turn would be obliged under section 5 to remit the moneys to the Exchequer.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I consider, on reflection, that this amendment is a very desirable further safeguard for the owner's interest in the property seized as evidence. In effect, it imposes an obligation on the peace commissioner to whom an application for disposal of seized property is made, to consider the application in depth before giving such a direction.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 191 has already been discussed with amendment No. 134.

Comment on this

I was not aware of that. I was not here if it was.

Comment on this

The information available to me is that it was debated with amendment No. 134 and that amendment No. 134 was withdrawn.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): For the benefit of Senator McGlinchey I would point out that this point has been met. Authority is given to game protection associations to prosecute under section 44.

Comment on this

Just one point——

Comment on this

If the Senator wishes to make a point he should move the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 191:

In the third column of the reference to the Wild Birds Protection Act, 1930, after "The whole Act" to insert "except section 15".

I understand that section 15, and particularly subsection (1) and part of subsection (2), gives recognition to game councils and gun clubs, and that if this is repealed this recognition will no longer be forthcoming. Is that true?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No, that is not so. The Senator's amendment was taken with amendment No. 134 and Government amendments Nos. 143 and 145, and amendment No. 144. I said Government amendments Nos. 143 and 145— which I was satisfied met the proposals behind amendment No. 134 put forward by Senators Ryan and Garrett, and Senator McGlinchey's amendment No. 191 to the First Schedule—were proposed in order to maintain certain provisions of the Game Preservation Act, 1930, whereby the Minister for Lands could grant formal recognition to game associations for the purpose of enabling them to prosecute offences for trespass in pursuit of game over lands preserved by them. I said I was satisfied that section 44 as drafted would enable such game associations to prosecute trespassers on their preserves, but that it had been represented to me that the 1930 Act provisions, whereby formal recognition was afforded to such game associations and that they in turn published in the newspapers circulating in their districts the fact that they had preserved certain lands, were of vital importance to them in that they gave a valuable local status to bona fide game preservation associations and enabled them to sound a warning to would-be poachers. I thought there was validity in those two arguments, and I repeat that these amendments are designed to emphasise the role of such organised game associations in the development and protection of game stocks. So I have done substantially what the Senator wanted.

Comment on this

I should like to commend the Minister on having a table setting out the enactments repealed in the Bill. Although this is a very common sense and desirable thing to do, there are many Bills in which it is not done. I have very often deplored the fact that it has not been done in other Bills and, as I have criticised various Ministers for not doing it, I think it is only proper that I should commend the Minister here for doing it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am obliged to the Senator.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 192:

In page 57, article 2, after "members" to insert "who shall be elected by ballot by holders of game licences from amongst their number".

I feel that the members should be elected, and who better to elect them than the people involved in game themselves? They are the best qualified people and should be able to judge who are the best people to take up their case. This could follow the type of election we have for the Inland Fisheries Trust.

Comment on this

Here, if I understand the Schedule correctly, I would be in favour of the manner in which it is set out, namely, that it intends to broaden the group of people from whom such a body might be selected. The narrowing down of the basis of selection itself would almost contradict the very many conservation sections in the Bill earlier on. While I have been very critical in a number of ways I have not had an opportunity yet of complimenting the Minister on its many worthwhile features, including its consolidation features, which have been commented upon by Senator Ryan earlier on the First Schedule. I think it would be a serious narrowing of social accountability on the grounds of conservation if we departed from the Schedule as set out.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I think Senator Higgins has hit the nail on the head and has made the point that I actually was going to make. This amendment appears to be based on a misapprehension in that it implies that the board in question would be a game board. However, having regard to the broad scope of the Bill this is not necessarily so. Moreover, the Minister must have reasonable flexibility in connection with the establishment of any board under the section. To confine membership of the board to a single group would be far too restrictive. I am therefore unable to accept the amendment. As a matter of fact, as pointed out by Senator O'Higgins there could be a serious conflict between the holders of game licences from whom Senator McGlinchey would constitute the board and conservation. They would be essentially interested in hunting, whereas the Bill as a whole has a conservation object.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 193 to 197, inclusive, are related and may be taken together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Third Schedule is intended to list the wild birds which, because they are common or pest species, do not call for special attention under the Bill and are, therefore, not being afforded statutory protection. I have had the list re-examined in the light of representations received by me and I accept that on balance there are a few other species which could likewise be excluded from protection without detriment to the objectives of the Bill. These are the carrion crow, jackdaw, jay and rook. These predatory species which are quite plentiful are responsible for a certain amount of damage to agriculture and sporting interests. Accordingly I propose, under this amendment, to have them included in the list of unprotected wild birds in the Third Schedule. On the other hand, as a result of more recent studies and findings I am satisfied—and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries agrees with me—that the inclusion of the cormorant as an non-protected species was not warranted. Accordingly it has been deleted from this Schedule and will therefore become one of the protected species.

The final amendment of the Third Schedule will ensure that carrier pigeons, racing homing pigeons and doves are not part of this pest category. Carrier and homing pigeons are not classified as wild birds at all as they are bred in captivity, but since they are valuable birds some of which command prices of up to several thousand pounds each, it is necessary to put the situation regarding them beyond doubt. In fact, that situation will be unaffected by the passing of the Bill. The effect of the amendment in so far as doves are concerned will be to make it clear that doves are not being treated as pests and will have protection under the Bill.

The clarification is necessary having regard to the popular equating of doves and pigeons. The dove species, listed below, which occur in this country are not sufficiently numerous as to be pests and there would probably be objections to their being treated as such. If they reach pest proportions in the future, they can be declared pests by regulations made under section 22 (2). In summary, the amendments will give the following status to pigeon and dove species. The city pigeon and the wood pigeon will be unprotected. Carrier pigeons and racing pigeons are not wild birds, but the amendment is being made to make it clear that their position is not affected by the Bill. The collared dove, the rock dove, the stock dove and the turtle dove are protected.

Comment on this

I would like to ask——

Comment on this

Senator William Ryan has an amendment. I think I should call on him if he wishes to speak.

Comment on this

We are not moving it.

Comment on this

I do not disagree with the amendment the Minister has made, but he mentioned as regards the giving of protective status to cormorants that he was advised on looking into it further in consultation with the Department of Agriculture that it was unnecessary, so to speak, or that it was not desirable that they should remain in the unprotected category. I would be interested to hear the reasoning behind that. I am certainly not an authority on this, but it has always been my understanding that cormorants are fairly damaging to fish stock in the country, particularly in the fresh water lakes, salmon lakes, sea trout lakes, brown trout lakes, adjoining the coasts. Certainly there does not seem to be any shortage of cormorants either around the coast or on these lakes. I am not suggesting that everyone should go out on a cormorant hunt—in fact I have seldom seen cormorants shot at—but I would be interested to know what is the particular reason for altering their status in this amendment. As regards the other species the Minister has mentioned, I think I would agree with them all.

Comment on this

By a singular coincidence when the Minister was speaking I wrote down the word "cormorant" because I find myself in agreement with Senator O'Higgins. It is well-known that they have been very destructive so far as fish are concerned. As the Minister knows, in the constituency from which we come there are plenty of lakes and certainly we are looking forward to getting more and more fishermen every year. Therefore we would not like to see anything interfere with the fish there.

Comment on this

I think amendment No. 194 tabled in the name of Senator Trevor West is now made redundant in the light of the Minister's assurances. Two matters arise; first of all the preservation of inland water life is the function of another Department and could be the subject of a separate Bill in this House, and might appropriately be discussed even by tabling the Murphy Report on this matter generally. With respect to the other Senators who have spoken on this point, the Department of Education are involved. As Senator Dolan says, I think the problem has been that people have not been sufficiently precise in defining what a cormorant is. The trouble is the classificatory system. If the original drafting was allowed, one could have what the Leader of the House has suggested, a cormorant blast-out in many cases, and, indeed, many of the allegations which have been made against the cormorant should be levelled against the collared dove. Therefore the general effect of the amendment as suggested by the Minister is to give greater precision and to replace what is an inaccurate ornithological general expression with a specific species-type against whom the allegations are more accurately related.

Comment on this

The cormorant probably owes its elevation, if we could call it that, to the work carried out by people such as Dr. David Cabot, Dr. West and Mr. Greer-Walker, who did an exhaustive study of the eating habits of cormorants on these islands. They showed that cormorants depend upon salmon and trout for only 2 per cent of their total food. It was believed— and this is why over the years there had been a bounty for cormorants— that they killed large numbers of young salmon and trout. This has been disproved. It seems that they feed on a small type of coarse fish by the name of rass, various types of eels and a variety of flatfish, most of which have no commercial value at all, especially the rass, which is their major food.

It looks as if the cormorant was maligned over the years and it seems that we here in Ireland are one of the last places to have a bounty on this bird. There is still a bounty in existence for the killing of this bird. It is misplaced. This booklet proves that they are not predators to the extent we assumed.

I should like the Minister to tell us very briefly the reasons why some of the birds mentioned in the Third Schedule are not being protected— this is just for my own information— for instance, the house sparrow, the jay, the magpie and the starling. Again I feel the starling may be mistakenly blamed as a carrier of diseases and o'her damaging effects from the Continent. I understand this is not altogether true, that the starling is a comparatively harmless bird. I should like the Minister to clarify that for me.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I should like to deal with our friend the cormorant first, and I should like to compliment Senator Deasy on the research. I think he was quoting from Dr. Cabot's report. Dr. Cabot, very recently on a television programme, described this Bill as a feast after a famine. It is true that the cormorant is a controversial character. We have the House more or less divided, but I propose to give him the benefit of the doubt and put him into the protected schedule. The research undertaken by Dr. Cabot has shown that not more than 2 per cent of the cormorant's stomach consists of salmon or trout; that the bird really lives on coarse fish and other matter. I believe the cormorant is deserving of protection. At worst he is a controversial bird and there is a difference of opinion about him. It would not be right to condemn the cormorant without giving him the benefit of the doubt, and that is what I propose to do.

Comment on this

I appreciate that the Minister is a very humane man in this regard. With due respect to Dr. Cabot, his evidence might depend on the number of cormorants examined and from which locality they came. If salmon were not very plentiful it would be easy to surmise that the cormorant needed only 2 per cent to keep alive. However, when salmon is not available the cormorant is very fond of coarse fishing, in particular. While we would not deny the cormorant his food we should like to see some coarse fish protected in the interests of tourist fishing. Therefore, I would not like to depend entirely on the excellent evidence given by Senator Deasy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am sure Dr. Cabot did not arrive at his conclusions lightly. He is a scientist and zoologist of international stature. I am sure he considered cormorants in detail before writing his report. This is not final as there is machinery within this Bill to change either birds or animals from one Schedule to another. If proof is given that this should be done it will be done.

Comment on this

May I put this point briefly to the Minister? I do not doubt what the Minister has said, but to what extent is the cormorant in any danger of extinction? I do not see any evidence for this view. Personally, I would prefer to give a protected status to the house sparrow than to the cormorant. Whatever scientific examinations are made on the cormorant's digestive system, it is clear that a percentage—the Minister has said 2 per cent—of their diet consists of the salmon and trout species. To that extent the cormorant is destructive to a valuable fishing industry, whereas the house sparrow does not live on salmon or trout. That is my first point.

If it could be shown that there was any real danger of the cormorant becoming extinct, there would be merit in the Minister saying that it was a controversial bird and that he would give it the benefit of the doubt and have it protected. With no evidence of it becoming extinct or any danger of people hunting cormorants but with evidence to show that the cormorant is destructive of valuable fish life, the Minister's attitude might be that as long as there is doubt about the bird he would allow the status quo to remain, the status quo being that the cormorant is not a protected species.

Comment on this

I, too, intended to mention the house sparrow. I do not know who decided that the house sparrow should be put in death row. If this concession is made then there would be the temptation to shoot wrens, robins and other songbirds. Last year there was a spate of this shooting by visitors, some with airguns and some with ordinary guns. This deserves a rethink.

Comment on this

I must apologise if I tend to bore the House. Two wonderful experiences recently prompted my original remark to the Minister, that not only is he right in giving the benefit of the doubt to the cormorant but in my earlier assertion the term "cormorant" was a confusing one. The Minister has not commented upon this. In the proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, Volume 75, there is comment on the document concerning the cormorant already referred to. This is the document by B. West, D. Cabot and M. Greer-Walker. This document draws a distinction between what is generally referred to the cormorant, and refers to the common cormorant and the shag—the common cormorant is referred to as the Phalacrocorax Carbo and the shag as the Phalacrocorax Aristotelis. The latter, that is the shag, is the subject of a very beautiful painting called "Shags Colony" by Cecil Maguire, who paints scenes off the west coast of Ireland. The cormorant feeds on freshwater and sea food. The latter does not. From information available, the latter, the shag, is in danger of dying out, but the cormorant is not.

Senator Dolan said the cormorant represented a real threat to the tourist industry, in so far as it represents a threat to lakes frequented by tourists. In many cases the nesting habits of this bird are such as will not mount any serious danger to inland lakes. More serious dangers to fish in the inland lakes come from the inadequacies of the 1963 Planning Act and the totally irresponsible attitude of the farming organisations which refuse to tell farmers not to pollute their lakes. We have the example of Lough Sheelin in Senator Dolan's own constituency.

The evidence of this document, which Senator Deasy has admirably brought to the attention of the House, is that the sub-type popularly known as the shag is in some danger, whereas the other one is not. Sampling was carried out, in a number of coastal regions where this bird species colonises or nests. The truth of the matter is that generally there is not any common pattern. I think therefore the Minister is taking the wise course. Some salmon and eels have been found where cormorants nest, although Senator Deasy has reminded us that eels rank second after rats in the diet of the cormorants studied by Dr. Cabot and others. On balance therefore there is a very weak case against the cormorant generally. Therefore I think the Minister has been quite right in being more precise in his terminology and in giving the benefit of the doubt to the species.

Comment on this

I am sure the menu would vary among various fishes from the sea coast.

Comment on this

I cannot say that I am able to distinguish between a cormorant and a shag. We refer to a shag as a woolly diver in our part of the country, but it is very difficult to distinguish between the two species. Senator Higgins may be able to do so. The shag is not even referred to in this Bill. We generally consider the shag and the cormorant as the one bird. I would make the point that the cormorant probably does quite a bit of damage in and around salmon and trout hatcheries. There is a suggestion in that booklet that others are damaging these hatcheries, that they are killing a lot of young salmon and trout and should be culled. Is there provision in the Bill to cull a bird such as a cormorant, which is now protected, in cases where it is causing undue damage only for short periods of the year?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We could shift them about to the other Schedule.

Comment on this

If there is evidence they are causing great damage in these hatcheries that might be the answer. I asked earlier if the Minister would give us reasons why the house sparrow, the jay, the magpie, and the starling are included in this Third Schedule, because the cormorant would have been retained in that Schedule if it were not for that exhaustive survey carried out by these three gentlemen. I wonder if the same type of exhaustive survey were carried out in each of those other cases I have mentioned, would we come up with some startling results that they were not doing the damage we presume they were doing. That could apply to every bird in the Third Schedule. A lot of our views on them is very much second-hand. It could be said to be old wives' tales in many cases. I should like to know what scientific or practical knowledge there is to back up the assumption that they should be in this Third Schedule of unprotected birds?

Comment on this

I want to finish this point once and for all. The second of the sub species to which I referred actually feeds totally on marine food. It is therefore distinct from the first or more general kind. It is true, as Senator Dolan says, that the diet of the bird is somewhat varied; but it is far more accurate to suggest, as Senator Deasy does, that where they are near hatcheries they represent real danger. Not only would it be necessary to shift them from one Schedule to another, but it would be necessary also to discriminate between, for example, areas where thee nesting habits of birds such as this provided no danger whatsoever. It would also be necessary to be specific. I am satisfied that the Minister is doing the right thing. I think that Senator Deasy has raised a very important point: what kind of research is proposed to enable these shifts to be made from one Schedule to another in regard to, for example, species not already covered by people such as West, Cabot and Greer Walker?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Having listened further to the debate, and particularly to the contributions of Senators Deasy and M.D. Higgins, I am satisfied now that the innocence of the cormorant has been established beyond all reasonable doubt. I think it is very fortunate for this bird that we have had such research available and that we have had the results of the research of Dr. Cabot available. It has enabled us to assess the habits of the cormorant more accurately. We have the results of the research carried out by Dr. Cabot available to establish that this bird is not really a pest. As of now, he is not as destructive as some people might lead us to believe. In the absence of that type of research, the cormorant would have been left to the tender mercy and rather biased or prejudiced views of Senator Michael J. O'Higgins, who is approaching the matter from the point of view of a fisherman. He really sees the cormorant as a destructive bird that should be treated as a pest. As of now I certainly do not propose to treat him as a pest. That does not mean that in years to come, if the species increased and multiplied, it might not be necessary to do something about it. The shag, of course, is protected, as he is not treated as a pest.

We are trying to protect all the bird species other than those set out in the Third Schedule to the Bill. That is why we are removing from the current Schedule the cormorant and putting them in another Schedule. The other birds in the Third Schedule — those which we propose to leave in it, such as the bullfinch, the carrion crow, the greater black-backed gull, the herring gull, the hooded, grey, crow, the sparrow, jackdaw, jay, lesser black-backed gull, magpie, pigeons, rook and starling — are all pests for one reason or another. They are treated as pests either because they are destructive or because they are so numerous. If we were to give protection to the species which are prolific and which at present abound in great numbers we could bring about an imbalance which could lead to, perhaps, disease and so on in the particular species, apart from making some species extinct. We are treating the birds mentioned in the Third Schedule as pests because (a) they are destructive or (b) they abound in such numbers as not to need protection, and because of the great numbers they are in danger of becoming pests.

Comment on this

I want to ask one question of the Minister. I have no desire to go on a cormorant hunt, but this question is prompted by the current notice in connection with open and close seasons. I am very glad the Minister made the point because it is very easy to fall into an error in connection with this. The remaining Schedules in the Bill set out lists of protected animals and species, whereas in relation to wild birds the Schedule sets out those that are unprotected. Every bird other than those which appear in the Third Schedule will be, when this Bill becomes law, a protected bird. It is very easy to fall into the error or regarding all of the Schedules as merely containing what is protected. That is not so in the case of birds. Is the Minister for Lands or the Minister for Justice, or whoever is responsible, going to find himself in the position that when he is deciding on open seasons for different birds he must list a whole clutter of birds that are not now dealt with?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Only for game birds.

Comment on this

Well and good, if it is only for game birds. Everyone will know where they stand. But it follows from that that every bird other than a game bird is going to be in close season all the time. In other words, there will be no open season for the cormorant or any other bird other than a game bird. Once it is clear, I, certainly have no objection to it, but I think it should be clear.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The position is that all birds not scheduled in the Third Schedule are protected and there will be open season for shooting or hunting certain birds, normally the birds known as game birds. That is the position.

Comment on this

It would appear from the make-up of the Third Schedule as in the original Bill, and now in the amended Bill, that the birds in the Third Schedule were put there as a result of an educated guess. I deduce that from the fact that we now have erased one, the cormorant, from that list and we have added four—the carrion crow, the jay, the jackdaw and the rook. That makes me feel that it is only a guess and that there is not a great deal of scientific evidence to back up the placement of them on this list. I would ask the Minister to make a study if possible of each bird on the list. It may be that there are some birds which should be on it.

Comment on this

I am pleased that the cormorant has been removed from the list in the Third Schedule by this amendment, because it is one of the birds, as Senator Deasy said, considered to be a pest by many people, just as are the otter, the heron and various other wild animals. In the mythology of the countryside these are animals and birds that do great damage. In fact, they probably do more good than harm. The cormorant numbers have decreased quite rapidly and I am pleased that this bird has been removed from the Third Schedule. I would argue for the insertion of another bird, the collared dove. About eight or nine years ago, this bird was not known in this country at all. I remember quite well when the first pair of collared doves in the east Cork area arrived in our establishment in Ballinacurra. It was quite well known that there was a pair of these collared doves nesting in Ballinacurra and there was quite an inflow of bird watchers.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not want to interrupt the Senator but we have already dealt with collared doves. They are protected birds.

Comment on this

I think they should not be protected. The Minister did not give me a chance. I was just saying that eight or nine years ago the first pair of collared doves arrived in our part of the country and caused a sensation. They were then a new migrant, but since that they have arrived in such increasing numbers that they are a damned nuisance, to put it mildly. They are pests everywhere and are one of the species of bird our opinion of which, as Senator Deasy said, we might have to change from time to time. Eight years ago we went to great lengths to protect the few nesting pairs that were in our area. Now we are trying to get rid of them as fast as we can because they have bred at a tremendous rate. They have proliferated all over the country and they are now a pest. I would argue that this Third Schedule should include the words "collared dove" because the collared dove is one of the birds that has come in recently and is now definitely a nuisance.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): My information is that the collared dove is numerous and prolific in Britain but so far here the species is not over-numerous. He does not present any problems here. I do not think it would be fair or reasonable to anticipate that he will become a pest here. If the numbers increase to such an extent that they are a pest, then it is a simple matter by a Ministerial order to add him to the Third Schedule.

Comment on this

That is a fair reply but I would just say to the Minister that this bird has migrated from somewhere in Central Europe. It has been a recurring pattern and, in a number of Western European countries, particularly on the Western European seaboard, the bird was not seen until relatively recently. In each one of those countries the bird has become a pest. It has moved from Britain to here only in the past ten years but it is now definitely in pest proportions in Britain. My feeling is that in certain parts of the country, especially in East Cork, it is a pest. In other parts of the country it may not be very common. It is one of the birds to keep an eye on, vis-à-vis, this Third Schedule here.

Comment on this

Is this a bird something like a pigeon but smaller and with a raucous cry?

Comment on this

It has a very raucous screech and a very high flutter.

Comment on this

They have spread out from East Cork in recent years.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We will follow the example of The Skibbereen Eagle and will keep an eye on them. If they increase and multiply we will deal with them.

Senator Deasy said the Third Schedule seemed to be put together on an educated guess. When I introduced this Bill in the Seanad I said in my Second Reading speech that we would hold consultations and discuss the Bill with interested organisations and interested people with a view to improving it. The Senator will see that we have done that and, as a result, we have put down a great number of amendments to improve it.

It is true that the Third Schedule has been listed on the best estimation we can get at present. One of the objects of this Bill is to initiate research to acquire knowledge about wildlife. In the light of that research, and in the light of that knowledge, our guesses will become more accurate. They will cease to be guesses. They will be balanced decisions on actual scientific data. As I say, there is nothing sacrosanct about these Schedules. They can be changed from year to year. I am not saying that as of now they are infallible but they are based on the best information available to us.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am now advised that the osprey, which is a bird of prey somewhat resembling a large sparrow-hawk is, in fact, a monospecific bird. In other words, it is not comprehended by the generic term “hawks”. The osprey has recently been seen from time to time in this country and, being rare, it is imperative that it be given special protection being afforded to other species listed in Part I of the Fourth Schedule. The effect of this amendment will be that the “good defence” plea provided for in section 22 (6) on page 20, will not apply to the osprey. That is the defence that enables the owner of land or the owners of crops to despatch or shoot an offending bird without permission from anybody. That right does not extend or apply in the case of a rare species. We are putting the osprey into that category.

Comment on this

The Minister seems to be catalouging the rare species in this Schedule.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is the purpose of the Fourth Schedule.

Comment on this

Is the raven included?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No.

Comment on this

Could it be?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No.

Comment on this

I think it should be included because it is a rather rare species.

Comment on this

There are three other categories of birds which I feel should be included in the Schedule, namely, the kingfisher, the chough and the raven. They are very rare species in this island.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The object of the Fourth Schedule is to give special protection to birds and animals that are in danger of extinction, that need special protection. I can only act on the best scientific and ornithological advice available to me. I am prepared to accept the contributions in this House as very well worth while. Listening to the Second Reading debate here was a most enlightening experience. I heard some very down-to-earth contributions. I was particularly struck — not because he happens to be on this side of the House — by the contribution of Senator T. Kilbride who spoke from the depths of sincerity and from an obvious deep knowledge of nature and animals in general.

I am prepared to accept and to have regard to the contributions and advice which I have received from Senator West and Senator Deasy and, indeed, all Senators. At the same time, I have technical advisers in the Department of Lands who are authorities on these subjects. The contributions and suggestions made here will be brought to their attention between now and Report Stage. That does not mean that I am giving any undertaking that I will change these Schedules between now and Report Stage. What I am saying is that what the Senators have said here will be borne in mind.

I am advised that neither the kingfisher, nor the chough nor the raven are in danger of extinction. They are not regarded as needing the special protection afforded by the Fourth Schedule. As I have said, what the Senators have said here will certainly be considered. I am sure Senators appreciate that these three birds are protected. They are not treated as pests. They are given the ordinary protection. The only special protection taken from them is the protection afforded to birds which are damaging crops and which, if they are in danger of extinction, the farmer is not allowed to shoot or to kill off without a licence from the Minister.

Comment on this

I am very heartened to hear that the Minister has an open mind on this and that these matters are not closed because there is a lot of room for debate and there is different advice from different people. We understand that, I would agree entirely with Senator Walsh that the kingfisher is a bird that does need protection. It is a most beautiful bird and it is very rare. It does not quite come under the general ambience of this section because these are really birds of prey. The other two do.

The chough and the raven are quite as rare, if not a good deal rarer, than hawks and owls. Hawks and owls are still relatively common. All four are birds of prey. I would argue very strongly that the raven and the chough should be included in this list if you include at the same time hawks and owls. Whereas I can quite see the argument for buzzards, eagles, falcons and harriers, I would like to ask when has the kite last been seen? Is the kite extant in Ireland? We could suggest a number of other birds which have been here for years, but is the kite extant at the moment?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Political kites are quite common.

Comment on this

I know the osprey is very rare, the buzzard is occasionally seen, the eagle is seen, the falcon is seen, the harriers are common enough, but has anybody seen a kite recently?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Our information is that the kite is extant.

Comment on this

It is an animal form of kite, not one of those flown over Leinster House shortly before election time. It is not one of those sort of birds; it is a real one. Could the Minister comment on the chough and the raven?

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to ask his technical advisers to have another look at these three types of birds and see if they could be included in the Fourth Schedule. My technical advice is that they are very rare species and that they are in danger of extinction. For that reason they require special protection. I would ask the Minister to reconsider this, please.

Comment on this

I support that plea. The kingfisher is probably one of the most attractive, if not the most attractive, of Irish birds and is not very plentiful or common. This booklet to which I referred earlier today, published by the Forest and Wildlife Service, states that ravens are distributed throughout the country but that they are not very plentiful. As regards the chough, this is a species very like a crow. You could very easily confuse it with a crow. Its habitat is on the cliffs, especially on the south-east coast. According to this booklet there are only 1,000 pairs of them in Ireland. Any bird which is as rare as that needs very strong protection.

Referring to the point made by Senator West about kites, you could also make the same comment about buzzards. They are also included in this. We will not deal with eagles because there are not any in this country. I said on Second Stage that we should make an attempt to specially provide habitats for birds such as the kite and the buzzard to bring them back in reasonable numbers. They are quite plentiful in Scotland but I doubt if we have any at all, maybe a couple of pairs.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Senator Deasy invites us to provide habitats for kites and buzzards. We have taken power earlier in the Bill to provide habitats for fauna in general and to protect the habitats of fauna in general. We will do that and those provisions are in the Bill.

Regarding these three birds, the kingfisher, the chough and the raven, I welcome any specific scientific information which any Senator can give me within the next week or so. What Senator Deasy read out would not suggest that the chough is in danger of extinction. Even on that count, there are 1,000 pairs. The raven, I think he said, was thinly scattered throughout the country. That is not evidence that they are in danger of extinction. These birds may be on the borderline and I am quite prepared between now and Report Stage, or between now and the discussion in the Dáil, to have a look at them. I welcome any scientific information or, indeed, information in general, which is given to me on this.

Comment on this

I want to make a point which the Minister made before. We should bear it in mind. The fact that the kingfisher, for example, is not included in Part I of the Fourth Schedule does not mean it is not protected. All it means is that it does not come under the provisions of the defence proceedings under subsection (6) of section 22 of the Bill.

I have never known a person to go out hunting kingfishers. They just want to see them. I have seen kingfishers several times. I suppose there might be danger from those who might be interested in collecting birds eggs. The kingfishers have the protection afforded to them by the Bill. The same applies to the raven and the chough. There is no additional protection except in relation to the defence of proceedings given by being included in Part I of the Fourth Schedule. It seems to me to be most unlikely as regards the raven and the chough that their habitats will be interfered with, for example, by a farmer in operating his farm. He will not bring his tractor up a cliff. He will not interfere with the nests of birds whose habitat is on the face of a cliff. I do not think the inclusion in this Schedule of birds who nest in that way would be of any particular value. They have the general protection afforded by the Bill already.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 199 and 200 are similar and may be debated together.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Despite the many exemption and licensing provisions in the Bill which are aimed at avoiding or reducing interference with such activities as agriculture, game propagation and so on, I am satisfied that, in present circumstances, the inclusion of the stoat in the list of protected animals is not warranted. While precise population statistics are not available for this particular animal, we know that it is a numerous and widely-distributed mammal. Moreover, there is evidence to suggest that it can and does cause a certain amount of damage to farm livestock and also to game birds, especially at the rearing stage. In the circumstances, I feel it could be unfair to these interests to apply the restrictions which statutory protection of the stoat implies, and I therefore propose to delete it from the land mammals listed for protection in the Fifth Schedule. I do so, however, in the knowledge that if the necessity arises in the future, for example, in the event of a serious decline in numbers, it will be possible under the provisions of subsection (2) of section 23 to restore the stoat to the protected list. This amendment also meets the point put forward in amendment No. 200 by Senator McGlinchey.

Comment on this

That is fair enough. In fact, I feel the stoat is already sufficiently protected in folklore and does not need any other protection from the Minister.

Comment on this

I believe there have been a couple of sightings of wild cats in various parts of the country and I would like to ask the Minister if he has any information to this effect. If this is the case, the wild cats should be included as one of the land mammals and be given this protection because its occurrence is so rare.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Senator West raises a question about wild cats and asks whether we have any evidence that there are any wild cats here. My information is that there is no evidence available to the Department that any such wild cats are to be seen. I am told it is necessary to draw a distinction between wild cats and what are known as feral cats, that is, domestic cats that run wild. I am not aware of any wild cats per se.

Comment on this

I take it the Minister is really saying that we have very good industrial relations. We have no wild cats. I am very glad the Minister has included the red squirrel in the Fifth Schedule. I do not know an awful lot about them, but they appear to be quite rare. I have seen a number of them from time to time. I am also glad, if my information is correct, that while he has included the red squirrel in the Fifth Schedule he has not included the grey or the black squirrel, or whatever it is called. I think it is called the grey squirrel. My information is that they are quite prolific and there are a number of them around. They drive the red squirrel out of an area. They decimate the population of the red squirrel which is certainly the nicer looking animal, and the very much rarer animal.

It seems to me that, with the distinction drawn by the inclusion of one and the omission of the other in the Schedule, people will have an opportunity of trying to preserve the red squirrel if necessary by putting down the grey squirrel. I understand that in some areas the Minister's Department had very considerable problems with the grey squirrel in connection with young forestry plantations. I should imagine that the Department are fairly well versed in the art of squirrel control.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator O'Higgins in what he stated about the red and the grey squirrel. The red squirrel is comparatively harmless. In Britain, the grey squirrel is very common and all efforts to get rid of him have proved a failure. He does great damage to trees, young trees especially. There are vast numbers of them in all parts of Britain, I have noticed. I would hate to see them proliferating here. We should try to preserve the red squirrel and eliminate the grey squirrel if at all possible. The pine marten, I notice is also protected. There seem to be only a very small number of pine martens here, especially in the north of the country.

I would like to see more pine martens in the country. The pine marten was common, I believe, in all parts of the country up to about 50 or 60 years ago, but he was killed off in the southern part. He is quite an attractive animal. Could the Minister please explain the reference to the seal species. I believe we have two types of seals here. The common seal does immense harm to fisheries. These colonies should be culled to quite a large extent. They cause tremendous damage to salmon fisheries and also to herring stocks at times. The grey seal, on the other hand, is quite rare. He is found only along the west coast and needs protection. I wonder does the common seal need protection? I doubt it.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister on Second Stage to give us some information about the animals listed under "amphibians", the natterjack toad. The only concrete information we got the last time was that Senator Deasy had seen a few of them down in his constituency.

Comment on this

The pine marten has been mentioned. Where forestry is reasonably plentiful, these animals are also very plentiful. The forestry people have been trying to trap them and to curb their activities as much as possible because of the damage they do to young trees. It would be strange if we were protecting them here while the Minister's Department were pronouncing sentence on them. I was under the impression that the Forestry Division considered them as pests. I am also wondering here why it was necessary to include the hedgehog, in Irish an gráineog, which as the House may know, is the staple diet of some travelling folk.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): First of all, regarding the squirrels, the red squirrel is not rare, but it is not as prolific or as damaging to trees as the grey squirrel which was imported into this country many years ago. The grey squirrel is a pest as far as the Forestry Division of my Department are concerned. We have to control the grey squirrel and, indeed, we employ trained trappers for that purpose. Senator Dolan may be confusing him with the pine marten. The pine marten is rare. A special study is being made of him in the forest in Portumna. The natterjack toad is a very rare specimen, I understand. The only evidence we have about him is that he is available in County Kerry. He is a type of frog.

Senator Deasy raised the question of the culling of the seal. I do not think that culling the seal is inconsistent with protecting the seal. Deer will be culled as the necessity arises to ensure that they do not become too numerous. I do not think any other question arose on the Fifth Schedule.

Comment on this

I just mentioned the hedgehog.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Speaking from my own observations, hedgehogs seem to have become more numerous in recent years. Some years ago you would never see one. We have protected them because they are harmless creatures and they kill slugs.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned that deer would be culled where it was considered necessary. In County Wicklow deer are very numerous, and quite an amount of culling could be done around the perimeter of the forestry plantations. As I have already suggested the deer-stalker should be employed again, particularly in parts of Wicklow where forestry plantations adjoin small farms and where a considerable amount of damage has been caused. I am a preservationist especially in regard to deer. In Wicklow we have a very unusual species, a herd of white deer which is practically unknown. A number of the Department's officials had not heard of them before and I should like them to visit Wicklow at Grangecon estate and see them. But there are farmers in Wicklow who would not take very kindly to the preservation of deer because they are suffering financial loss due to destruction of crops by deer. I would ask the Minister to consider this matter seriously in conjunction with the foresters in areas where complaints have been made by farmers about the destruction of crops.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I should like to make the position in regard to deer as clear as I can. Sometimes it would appear from what is said that all the deer in the country are the property of the Department of Lands. Deer are wild animals and the Department are not responsible for damage caused by them. Any question of fencing State forest properties where deer occur would be ruled out because of the prohibitive cost. The Department have been aggravated during the last few years because of security restrictions on the possession and use of rifles by the general public including hunting bodies. Prior to the unsettled state of affairs in Northern Ireland rifles were available to people who wanted to despatch deer but those rifles are not now being licensed.

However the Department are engaged in a comprehensive culling programme throughout the country. It is being carried out in a manner which is consistent both with the conservation of the species and protection of agricultural interests. Section 42 of the Bill will strengthen the Minister's powers in that regard and will enable an owner of land to take direct action with the permission of the Minister. Where immediate action is necessary to prevent damage being caused by deer the good defence clause in subsection (8) of section 23, as now amended, will enable a landowner to take direct action without prior permission, except in the case of native red deer. The Bill provides for the issue of licences to farmers. From what Senator Walsh says, these licences would be readily available to farmers in County Wicklow to enable them to shoot deer causing damage to their crops. If there was an invasion of deer the farmer could despatch them without any licence. If he is persecuted with them he has a good defence clause in section 23 (8).

Comment on this

I welcome the statement from the Minister, because prior to it there was a widely held view in Wicklow that the destruction caused by deer was the direct responsibility of the Department of Lands. Indeed people who made representations to me on this matter have spoken of compensation by the Department for the destruction of their crops. It would now appear that deer, being wild animals, are as much the farmer's property as that of the Department of Lands and the farmer would be at liberty to shoot them where necessary without a ministerial licence. Is that the position?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Up to now the law has been that wild animals are not the property of any person in particular. As long as animals remained on a person's land they could be protected by that person in so far as people could be prevented from trespassing on the land to kill them. Once the wild animal escapes from the land of one owner and goes to another, the owner of the first-mentioned land ceases to have any claim on it. At present, for the benefit of Wicklow people, deer are not protected. Up to now and until this Bill becomes law they are treated as vermin. If deer escape from forests or other lands and trespass on property they can be shot, without fear of any action being taken against the person who shoots them. Under this Bill deer will still remain wild animals but they will be protected. It will be illegal to shoot them unless in an open season, such as for pheasants or hares. Deer causing damage can be shot at any time of the year under licences from the Minister for Lands. Deer causing irreparable damage to crops can be shot without any licence. Section 23 (8) affords a defence to the farmer.

Comment on this