We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–117 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976
Enacted

No. 42 of 1976 ›

Section 7 introduces for the first time one of the many matters to which I objected on the Second Stage and to which I will continue to object here in subsequent sections dealing with the excessive control now exercised by both Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance in literally translating the Agricultural Institute, as it has been known heretofore and as it is dissolved by subsequent section 10, into a mere agency of the Department for all practical purposes. Our main opposition to the Bill on Second Stage was directed towards this factor of very extreme bureaucratic control exercised through the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture on the whole operation of this new agency— I call it that because that is all it now is—at every level. An institute that had for over 20 years exercised an honourable autonomy and independence in the discharge of its functions, particularly in the research area which demanded this flexibility and autonomy in order to be effective is now, under this Bill, and particularly by this section, being translated into a mere executive agency of the Minister's Department.

It is quite clear from the White Paper that was issued prior to the preparation of this Bill and from the debate that took place in the Dáil and the Seanad during the legislation which set up the Agricultural Institute that everybody took the view—I take it the Minister still takes the view; he did not refer to this aspect at all in his reply on the Second Stage—that autonomy and independence in regard to research and investigation is all-important in an institute of this kind. If an issue of this kind is going to be tied both in terms of finance and in terms of decision-making to the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Finance, then the very important element in legitimate research, legitimate investigation, legitimate testing, the essence of any such operation, will go by the board and the institute will be translated into an executive agency. That executive agency will be largely just a section of the Department of Agriculture functioning basically at the whim of the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance.

It is for that reason that we are opposing this section. The fact is that every enactment set out in the Fourth Schedule is repeated. This, of course, is one of the basic sections in the Bill taken in conjunction with section 10, which we will be opposing shortly, in which the actual institute itself is dissolved, to use the legal phraseology. Therefore, the effect of section 7, and section 10 is effectively to dissolve the Agricultural Institute, as we knew it heretofore and then, linked in with the remaining sections of the Bill, effectively to bring in an executive agency of the Department of Agriculture that will be tied to the Department and to the financial exigencies of the Minister for Finance in regard to its future research programmes for the benefit of Irish agriculture.

Comment on this

I also wish to oppose this section and the whole spirit behind the dissolution of the Agricultural Institute and the effective establishment of firm departmental control over what was up to now a body corporate. Senator Lenihan has made the case particularly well and I would just like—again speaking from the university point of view—to reiterate the need, as I see it and as very many other people see it, of independence for the researcher and freedom of research in agricultural matters is just as important as in any other sphere of scientific investigation.

Many people have pointed out in the Second Stage debate on the Bill what a fine reputation has been established by An Foras Talúntais, The Institute has an international reputation as a research body in agriculture and is something of which we in this country can be justly proud. I would like to pay a very warm tribute to the director, Dr. Tom Walsh, who has done such a tremendous job in building up the institute and making it such a vital force in innovation in Irish agricultural circles. Nobody knows better than the Minister how important this is in the present situation, in the EEC context.

If I might just digress for a moment, I would like to pay the Minister and his officials a very genuine tribute which they deserve for their outstanding work in Brussels. Agriculture is our most important industry. In almost every respect our Agriculture Minister is our most important Minister in Brussels; and Deputy Clinton, sometimes by using the soft pedal and sometimes by using what appears to be ruthless methods with his colleagues when the need arises in Brussels, has been extremely successful.

One of the reasons our economic situation is not a great deal worse is because the farming industry is an extremely buoyant one at the moment. I have experience of it myself. I live in a farming area in East Cork which has always been a very strong area for mixed farming, barley and the dairy industry. I do not have to go outside the door very far when at home to see what a healthy state the industry is in, and this reflects tremendous credit on on the Minister. There are now great incentives for our farmers to become more efficient, to use more scientific methods to increase their output. There is no doubt that the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Clinton, has been, to a considerable extent, responsible for our good position with his hard-nosed negotiations in Europe.

Having paid that tribute, which is absolutely genuine, I would rate Deputy Clinton as the most successful Minister in the present Government— and I do not go through this rating that some of the Sunday newspapers do. I would so rate him precisely because of the success of his negotiations in Europe. I think they are absolutely crucial to the whole country. Having said that, I feel the Minister has transferred the hard-nosed approach he has used in Europe to the local scene in this Bill, and I am not at all happy about it.

I do not see any reason why we should bring an institute which has achieved an international reputation, which is working so well, inside the ambit of the Department of Agriculture, which is essentially what this Bill is doing. For my money, that is what it is doing. This move has been opposed by numerous farming interests. It is a difficult technical point to get across: it is not the sort of thing that will hit the headlines on the newspapers, a reorganisation of a research institute. Who knows whether it will be better under the civil service than under the independent set-up which currently exists? It is one of the important, philosophical points we have to consider in this House. For very many reasons I dislike seeing extension of civil service control over autonomous bodies. Particularly in the area of research this is something to be deplored. I do not see why the institute could not be left as an independent body. I know, and everybody interested in agriculture knows, that there has been friction between the institute and the Department. That is not always a bad thing because the Department have one job to do and the institute has a totally different one.

In this Bill and the particular provisions we are talking about in section 7, it seems to me in many ways that the Department is issuing the coup de grâce to the independence and freedom of the institute and, personally, I totally oppose that. Senator Butler in his speech on the Second Stage said that we must not criticise the Department. That is absolute nonsense but perhaps he meant that we should not criticise the Minister for Agriculture when the Coalition is in Government. That is a straight-forward party political point, but we are the people who have to decide where departmental control stops and where independent institutions begin. As Members of the Oireachtas, we have to decide this, and of course we can criticise the Department and their policies. I have always said and will consistently say that we have an outstandingly good civil service in this country. We have a great many talented people in the civil service. Perhaps in some ways it is too good as it wishes to extend its control outside the areas in which it should be legitimately involved. I think this is a specific case of extension of ministerial power and authority over an independent body which has up to now done a tremendous job.

The Minister in his speeches on the Second Stage in the Dáil or here did not indicate how the research work of the institute will be improved by this administrative move. I can see many reasons why the research atmosphere in an institute as such could disimprove if it comes totally under civil service control. Of course the argument will be that the establishment of the authority is not going to spancel the research people in the institute, is not going to give the civil service control; but, in fact, it is a move which is designed to do that among other things and I totally oppose it. Here we are talking about a very big organisation. I do not know what the total staff membership is—the Minister can give me that—but last week there was a letter from 170 or 190 members of staff of the institute deploring this move. That appeared in the newspapers the day we debated this measure last week. The Minister then said that was only a small proportion of the staff. Obviously, it is a very big staff, 500, 600 or 700?

Comment on this

2,500

Comment on this

Bigger still. This is a big organisation and it is a powerful one. Obviously if an organisation like this is going to be worth its salt, if it is to generate ideas or if it is going to have its own administrative structures then, of course, there will be friction between it and the Department. Everybody who has been in this game knows quite well that this has been going on for years, but this is a good thing. Elimination of this friction will mean eliminating a lot of the tension which goes to make a contribution to our society. There is no argument which anybody has produced up to now to point out how this reorganisation, this dissolution of the institute or the repeals in this section are going to improve the research, the quality of the work or the feedback. Perhaps there is integration of advisory and educational services but if you wanted to do that, why not take these services away from the Department altogether and put them under An Foras Talúntais and thereby make it bigger and more powerful? It has shown it can do the job; why spancel it as we are doing?

I have looked at the speeches that were made by the politicans who set up the institute 20 years ago. The debates both in Dáil and Seanad were fascinating. Senator Lenihan was here for the Seanad debate on that occassion and he has referred to it. I would like to refer to the Dáil debate, which he has also mentioned, and I would like to refer to Deputy James Dillon, one of our distinguished politicans. I would like to quote what he says about this independence. He is talking in a general way in the Second Stage speech about an institute, the setting up of it and how it should be run. I quote from column 864 of the Official Reports of the Dáil debate of 21st November, 1957:

I agree with him entirely when he says that the whole scheme of the Bill revolves around the council and it is not too much to say that the potential value of the institute will be directly proportionate to the efficiency of the council in discharging the heavy responsibility entrusted to it. That is profoundly true. I have always believed, and I still believe, that neither Parliament, the Government nor the Minister can run a university nor, indeed, any teaching establishment. You have got to try to get the best governing body you can. You have got to give them the resources and then you have got to trust them to do the job and if they do not do it there is not very much you can do about it.

Deputy Dillon is absolutely clearly in favour of an independent research institute without question. The other interesting speech on that occasion, not in the Dáil but in the Seanad, was made by Deputy de Valera and he went at great length into the need for an agricultural research institute and the need for it to be independent of ministerial control. What are we now doing here? We are totally reversing that position. I am totally opposed to this. I do not think it is a party political issue. I bet that if you took a head count—perhaps not a free vote of the other side but what we wanted last week, a secret ballot— there would be people hopping up all over the House on the other side and they would all oppose it. But, of course, they must keep the heads down now. There is an election coming up. You never know, when you stick your head over ground if it might be shot off and that will not do you any good. However, the point is, it is not a political issue. I do not think it is a question of one party versus another. It is really the Members of the Oireachtas, asking how far will civil service control go. I say it should stop here: the buck stops here. The civil service control should stop before section 7. I am totally opposed to this whole idea of dissolution of the institute and therefore to section 7.

Comment on this

I remember quite well the debate that went on 20 year ago and I am surprised that Senator West's perusal of the debates did not extend to the contributions that I and some of the others made on that occasion.

Comment on this

I had not time, Senator, but I knew you were coming after me and I was sure you were going to get your dig in.

Comment on this

Anyway, I sympathise very strongly with the Minister and with the necessity to co-ordinate the advisory service because we all realise that the work at county level as it is has been carried on has been rather wasteful of resources, especially in the modern climate. Integration with research I think could have been better. So I sympathise very strongly as regards the problem that is there. The reorganisation as far as it affects the advisory services will do an immense amount of good and will also probably enable the sharing of specialist advisers on a more regional basis. Again, all to the good. But I am rather unhappy about the position of the research side and I hope as the Bill progresses that we will be able to tease that out a bit more and give more guarantees.

I would have no real worry about the research side if I were assured that Deputy Clinton would be Minister for Agriculture for the next 20 years but I think that is probably asking a bit too much. I can recall indeed in my own time here in the Seanad at least one, if not two, Ministers for Agriculture, in whom I had no confidence whatsoever to restrain the natural tendency of the Department of Agriculture to take over completely. That is not a failing of the Department of Agriculture alone. Every Department of State, not merely here but in England and everywhere else has it. It is simply a question of control, and that is opposed to real progress, enlightenment and statesmanship. It means devolution. It means giving to other bodies the resources and the facilities to carry out their job.

There is nothing in which the Department of Agriculture are more lacking than in research experience: it is not their job. They are not recruited on the basis of the research they have done. Therefore it is hard to ask people recruited in that way to have an understanding of what research is all about. That goes for research in all areas, whether in agriculture or in industry or indeed in science, because basically it is a rather long-term investment. It is one where you cannot demand instant results. You may have to wait a while before something really good is produced; but when it is produced it more than pays for all the effort that went into it in the past. You have had your failure but that is the price that you pay for the success. Therefore, it is difficult for the ordinary administrator, who wants things black and white, who wants things nine to five, who wants things covered by memos and so on, to understand the research mentality and the research approach because the research man is always working on his problem. Even when he is asleep, he is working on the problem. I have done quite a bit of research myself and very often if you are lying in bed in the morning for an extra half hour there seems to be some process that operates. It is very often in that type of relaxed atmosphere you can see a way through problems that you were not able to see when you were bashing your head against it.

We are particularly lucky here with the Agricultural Research Institute because of the calibre and the training of the men who went into it. I think no consideration of this matter would be complete without paying tribute to the farsightedness of the American authorities who in 1954 and 1955 diverted some of counterpart funds to the development of agricultural research in this country. It was a most enlightened and far-sighted effort. It was the counterpart of the Marshall Aid that went to countries directly involved in the war. The American authorities were very insistent all through the fifties on the necessity for autonomy, the necessity for freedom from any control, especially hidden control by the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

It is against the spirit of those who contributed so generously the funds for the institute to reorganise it as is being done unless we can get some very specific assurances and statutory safeguards built into the Bill as it passes through.

Another piece of farsightedness on the part of the Americans was their insistence on quality and training for the men. The result was that the funds as provided made it possible for some of our young Irish graduates to go to the best American universities, Ohio State, Cornell, Iowa, Kansas and others, where they made a tremendous reputation for themselves. Since then they have made a very big contribution here, and not alone to agriculture. Many of them have used their training to branch out into other areas as well. That is an invaluable resource. I can see the friction that would necessarily develop between that type of independent outlook, that type of challenging approach to problems, and the professional administration—not meaning any disparagement whatsoever of the professional administrators. They are in two altogether different games.

On the other hand, we need the product of research to be brought as quickly as possible into practice. There is a certain misconception at that level as to what is research. Research is not simply something that somebody else has done well or that we see done well in New Zealand or even on a good farm, on which we run a few trials and sell on that basis to the ordinary people. That is development. That is just selling to the stage beyond research. Research consists in efforts to develop better utilisation of grassland, efforts to breed better strains, to improve marketing, and efforts to improve and diversify the produce in which milk is used. All that needs autonomy. In that spirit I would hope to try to approach the present Bill and I have confidence in the openness and objectivity of the Minister.

The Minister will recall that, when he and I were quite a few years younger and were concerned with the foundation of the National Farmers' Association, we later became involved in a desperate stand to prevent the Department of Agriculture taking over the research and advisory services, getting control over the counterpart funds and over the institute to be built by them. At that stage the young National Farmers' Association, as it was then, set up an independent commission, a most extraordinary effort. They acted fully in the manner of a commission. Credit goes to Professor Louis Smith, Mr. Seán Healy, Mr. Paddy O'Keeffe and others who were involved in that. The Minister was close by in the wings and very sympathetic to the efforts of that date. I would hate to think that we would do anything to undo that good.

I know the Minister's mind is to give research the freedom it should have. I hope, as we tease our way slowly, painfully but carefully, through the present Bill we will put in safeguards that will meet, on the one hand, the Minister's desirable and laudable wish to integrate services and maximise the service to agriculture and, on the other hand, that will guarantee the freedom so necessary for research.

Comment on this

I had a lot of personal sympathy with the sentiments expressed by many of the previous speakers. Indeed, having discussed the problems that the staff foresaw in this situation I began to have still further sympathy for their point of view. I have sat down and coldly calculated what the Minister has been trying to do in this section and the section dealing with the abolition of the institute. "Abolishing" is a very strong word. This section is not really abolishing the institute; it is abolishing the Act that set it up. The Minister in his reply to the Second Stage satisfied me that this is what he is about.

I referred on the Second Stage to the fact that the institute, as it now stands under this statute, is an autonomous body; but I reiterated in my contribution how difficult it was for me, as a democrat, to justify the word "autonomous". It could be an excellent opportunity, I suppose a dream, if those of us responsible for public funds did not have to be accountable. Not being accountable is autonomy, in that one can carry on regardless, if one has sufficient funds to carry on. I do not suppose that that is possible in this day and age when every pound we spend must be accounted for through the system of public accountability but also to the electorate. The Minister, in his reply on the Second Stage, reiterated that consultations go on every year, even as it is, with the Institute, which now stands as an autonomous body—they are autonomous only within the amount of money available to them.

Research is the area that worries me particularly. I have some little experience in this field. Because of its very nature it must certainly remain independent of any dictation or trend. Only the people engaged in research realise how a particular research project is progressing. Agricultural or veterinary research either in the field or in the laboratory obviously needs a lot of independence. The Minister satisfied me in his contribution that this independence enjoyed by the institute since it was set up will be retained, as will its freedom of movement and its freedom of research in the field in which it is currently engaged. Of course, it must have discussions beforehand on the spending of public money.

As I say, it would be absolutely ideal if none of us had to account for anything we do with public money. The staff certainly are really concerned in this area and I have had consultations and discussions with them. I have listened to their point of view. Naturally they have worked within a vacuum, so to speak, up to now.

The statute setting up the institute is now to be abolished and the institute is to be accountable to this board, but I honestly feel that the Minister has no intention of stopping any good work. Indeed, from my knowledge of the man I know he is keen to progress in this area. If agriculture and all the industries allied to it are to succeed we must have research. We must have as much money as possible available for research, whether this is State money or money that is put in to it by concerns that feel that investment in this field is imperative for the future of our nation. There is a tremendous future for research and I have no qualms of conscience now that I have considered all the aspects of it.

As I mentioned at the opening of the Second Stage, I was concerned that this was an emotive subject. Having listened to the Minister's reply—I have no doubt he will have more to say on it just now—I would be satisfied that the institute can and will function as efficiently as it has. Indeed, if it needs to be put on record, I should like also to congratulate the staff and their director on the excellent work they have done and, I have no doubt, will continue to do in the future.

Comment on this

We on this side of the House are totally opposed to this section, particularly on the basis that it repeals the legislation setting up An Foras Talúntais. Senator West has conveyed to the House the thinking of the late Mr. de Valera and Mr. Dillon on this institute. They thought it was highly important that the Agricultural Institute should have total independence to function properly. The present Minister in his speech in the Dáil on this Bill clearly stated that he thought the Agricultural Institute had done a wonderful amount of work down through the years. He had great praise for them in every respect. If that is the case, why make this drastic change in regard to their autonomy and total independence? The word "research" itself clearly highlghts the importance of their independence to function properly.

At this point I should like to congratulate the Agricultural Institute on their wonderful work through the past 19 years. I think it is a retrograde step on the part of the Minister to take that independence from the Agricultural Institute and hand over control to a board of 24 members. None of us here knows who these people will be. Judging from the experience of the present Government in regard to the formation of specific boards, we are all well aware that it will be politially rigged. Who are those people to tell the highly-talented men in the Agricultural Institute what they should do and what they should not do? This is what will be done through this legislation. The institute itself will be dictated to in a sense by the members of the board. This is something that should not happen. We on this side of the House are totally opposed to it.

Comment on this

I have always had great respect for the research people in An Foras Talúntais and I have that respect for them today. I know of the work they have carried out in Moore-park and in many other stations. This Bill will improve that situation and not disimprove it. There will be a greater demand now for research because there will be a greater demand for production within the industry as a whole. That greater demand for production will create a greater demand for research.

If that is the interference that people are talking about, then it should be welcomed by all the farming organisations in the country. I do not think this is the interference that the Opposition are talking about. They are talking about interference by the Department of Agriculture themselves. I cannot see such interference taking place because there will be a board set up and we will have time to talk about that board when we reach the relevant section. If that board functions as I think it will, then interference by the Department of Agriculture will not take place. There will be a demand by that board for further researchs into different aspects of agriculture. That is the way I see the new institute working. It will be working for research and for the development of agriculture in this country.

Comment on this

Among the repeals in this section would be the Agriculture (An Foras Talúntais) Act, 1958, as has been pointed out. I share the view of the Senators who have pointed to the work of An Foras Talúntais as being very much a success story and an important contribution to agricultural research in this country. However, it is clear in the Government's White Paper that this would be one of the intentions of the Bill before us. On page 5 of the White Paper, under the heading "An Foras Talúntais", it is stated:

Under the changes now decided upon, the foundation of An Foras Talúntais will be transferred to the National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority which has been referred to above. The advisory and education service and An Foras Talúntais services will thus have a common direction, and a corps of specialist advisers located at convenient centres. This will ensure that research findings are brought without delay to advisers for dissemination to farmers, and problems requiring research carried in the reverse direction.

I share the concern that significant research should be carried out in this area, the most important area affecting the country, our most important industry, our most important resource as a people. I share the concern that adequate provision be made in this research. It is that point, and not so much the repeal of the 1958 Act and the bringing of An Foras Talúntais under this authority, that concerns me.

I am not satisfied that the other important aspects of the White Paper are, in fact, reflected in this Bill. Therefore, I view with some apprehension a section which repeals the 1958 Act, because I do not think that the objective of the White Paper of achieving a transfer of An Foras Talúntais with its full research status is going to be achieved. On page 6 of the White Paper, under the heading "Organisational Structure", it is stated:

6.2 National Level

Under the guidance of the Board, the Director (who will be assisted by Deputy Directors in appropriate areas, including particularly (i) advice and education and (ii) research) will be responsible for the direction and administration of the Authority and its overall effectiveness.

One of the features of An Foras Talúntais is that it has authority to research. Obviously it has a research budget. It has a clear provision in that area. That, I think, is not so clear under the subsequent terms of the Bill. Obviously we will raise this point again, but it is important in considering a section which proposes to repeal the 1958 Act. I should like to ask the Minister why there is not provision in the Bill for a deputy director of research, as was the intention in the White Paper, and why there is not provision for a separate research budget. Surely these are the minimum requirements in order to achieve the general purpose as stated in the White Paper? An Foras Talúntais is regarded in the White Paper itself as a successful institution of the State. If it is to be transferred without damaging it, without diminishing it, without undermining it, surely the other safeguards in the White Paper should be met before we decide to repeal an Act which has set up a successful research institute? I should like to know from the Minister at this stage why the provision for a deputy director of research and also the provision for a special budget for research have not been inserted in the Bill. I will at a later stage go into some detail on the importance of these two matters. I do not think it is appropriate under this section. I should like to know at this stage why these are not expressly inserted in the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

May I draw Senator Robinson's attention to amendments Nos. 7 and 8 under section 31, which I think deal specifically with the appointment of a deputy director.

Comment on this
Mark A. Clinton Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Clinton) Fine Gael

I am a little bit disappointed that, at this stage of our efforts to explain what this Bill is all about, there still seems to be an amount of misunderstanding and concern. It may be a quite genuine misunderstanding.

The Bill is concerned with the improvement of services for agriculture. What I am really saying in the Bill is that we have a number of agencies, unco-ordinated and fragmented, providing services separately and independently for the agricultural industry. These agencies will do a much better job when they are brought together in one co-ordinated entire service working as a team for the agricultural industry. I explained that. It is, perhaps, a little unfortunate that some of the Senators who have spoken here today were not present when I was replying on the last occasion.

In my reply in the Dáil I explained this question and, If I may, I will quote from the Official Report, Volume 298, column 63:

...I am as fully convinced of the correctness of the course of action I am taking. I am putting the research services into the authority, side by side with the education and advisory services, because nothing gives the same amount of stimulation as research, and I want this stimulation to be as close as possible to the other services. I want to create an overall integrated service with willing teamwork between all the agencies concerned. I want to remove whatever barriers or lines of demarcation that may exist between them. I am conscious that research results are not applied on as many farms as I would like or as quickly as I would like them to be.

The Agricultural Institute is concerned mainly with applied research and it tackles practical problems of interest to different branches of the industry. It is also involved in development work of various kinds. The organisation which has been established will provide the presesnt institute staff, together with the staffs of the other services which are being transferred, with a more effective means of promoting the well-being of our agricultural industry than at present existing through those services working more or less independently or in isolation. In this integrated organisation they will be every bit as free to carry out their work as they have been in the past.

I am supposed to have taken complete freedom and autonomy away from the Agricultural Institute by integrating them with the other services. In fact, I think I have enlarged the scope of their work. I have brought in, for instance, plant breeding and veterinary research. In fact, they can do a certain amount of research in the educational area also. Therefore, I am not taking away from the Institute, which I have admired so much for so long. Nobody recognises better than I do the excellent work that has been done by the institute, and I agree wholeheartedly with everything that has been said about the director of the institute. I have said that myself on numerous occasions. Why should I try in any way to destroy the institute or take from their work or possibilities? In the discussion on the Bill setting up the institute, James Dillon said, and it was repeated today, that you must get the best governing body you can find and then give them the resources. That is exactly what we are setting out to do—get the best governing body we can find and give them the resources to the extent that that is possible.

In this legislation we are doing something which has never been done before: we have guaranteed that the separate money provided for the three departments which we are integrating will not be less in real terms in the first year. Such a guarantee has never been given before. How can the new board or the staff of the new board prepare a budget without preparing separate budgets for research, advisory work and for education? Of course their budget must be based on all these matters separately. They will retain their independence to the extent that that is desirable but they will not be enclosed in separate compartments.

Mention has been made of friction and that it may be a good thing. I disagree with this. I think friction has done an immense amount of harm in the past.

Comment on this

The Minister used it very effectively in Brussels.

Comment on this

For the very reason that I felt that some friction existed, one of the first things I did in the Department of Agriculture was to say that the doors of this house must be open in future to everybody who has an interest in agriculture and who is providing a service for agriculture. I must say that I was pushing an open door, in fact, because I found that that was what the officials of the Department wanted too. I do not believe that anybody today in the institute will tell you that the Department of Agriculture is not an open door. Nobody in the advisory services or in the educational services will tell it to you either. The degree of co-operation and agreement between these various agencies and the people in the Department of Agriculture was never better, and that is the way I want it to continue. That is what we are trying to set out in this legislation. We want these people to work together and we want to give them an opportunity of crossing barriers without the fear of being accused of taking the other person's job or interfering in his work.

On the last day I was in the Seanad I had to quote section 12 of the Agriculture (An Foras Talúntais) Act, 1958, setting up An Foras and what was required of them then. As I have said, a number of Senators were not present. Let me quote it again. Section 12 (1) states:

For the purpose of assisting the Institute to carry out effectively its functions under this Act, there shall be paid to the Institute in every financial year, out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, a grant towards the expenses of the Institute the amount of which shall be determined by the Minister for Finance in consultation with the Minister—— That is, the Minister for Agriculture. ——and the Council after due consideration of any information furnished under subsection (2) of this section.

Subsection (2) states:

The Council shall furnish to the Minister such information regarding its income and expenditure as he may from time to time require.

I maintain that under this Bill which we are trying to get through the Oireachtas we are not doing any more than that. We are asking them and saying to them: "You must come in, discuss your programme, get agreement on the finance and off you go and do your own job and we will interfere in no way with the day-to-day work of the Institute." We are not qualified to interfere with researchers; they have their own job. That is the intention in this Bill and I hope it will always remain so. It is a misunderstanding of what is in the legislation to say otherwise.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister has paid such a tribute to the institute. I know he has done this before but it raises a question. If he is so keen to integrate all these services why does he not just transfer the other two services to the institute as it now stands? The legislation would be less complex than this legislation. That, to me, seems to be the solution to this. Why not?

Comment on this

Might I say to Senator West that this would be a very simple operation but then I would have the other agencies on my back and I would probably have the majority of the people here fighting on their behalf. Nobody seems to express any concern at all about the advisory services or the educational services. Up to the present not a word of concern was expressed about these.

Comment on this

There has not been the same degree of lobbying.

Comment on this

And the same was so in the Dáil. It is mainly because a certain number of people in the institute have expressed a concern and have gone to considerable trouble to convey that concern to Members of both Houses.

Comment on this

As I made clear, I see this Bill as implementing the provisions of the White Paper, and those provisions included specifically the transfer of An Foras Talúntais to a new authority to be created. I raised a specific point—I do not think the Minister has quite answered it; he certainly has not satisfied me in the answer he has given—as to why there was not separate provision made for a deputy director of research and budget for research as provided in the White Paper.

Comment on this

I drew the Senator's attention to the fact that it was coming up, and I refrained from referring to it on that account.

Comment on this

Just to come back on the reply the Minister gave, in so far as he gave it, he made the point that section 48 provides for an assurance of no diminution in the overall budget. That still does not meet the point, because that is a global budget for the authority. One of the concerns is that within that global budget it could be that the research people in it would not be able to hold their own against the short-term, more immediate, more urgent pressures for advisory and education services. I do not think there is any question of valuing research over advisory or education services or putting one against the other. Of course not. The Minister is quite right that what is wanted is an integrated approach to the provision of these separate services—advisory, education and research—that all three are very important. There is no doubt—and this is something certainly evident to anybody who has had any association with a university or knows some of the problems relating to funding research— that, when it comes to pressure for funds, it can be more difficult to argue for funds for research than it can be to resist pressure for immediate advisory or education services. These are instant; the people are there who need them, the farmers are there, and the pressure for them is there and immediate. Whereas when one is looking for funding for research, it may seem more remote, it may seem more long-term or less pressing.

Therefore I do not think that is an adequate protection of the research element to say that there will be no real diminution in the global funding. I would prefer that a specific budget be set aside for research in order to ensure that it cannot be diluted internally although the global budget of the authority will remain the same. I think this is one of the basic reasons for the uneasiness by the research staff, and I have certainly, like other Senators, read some of the written expressions of their uneasiness and I have met some of them. I do not regard myself as seeking to put forward the views of researchers at the expense of those involved in the advisory and education services. It is not a question of either or; it is a question of trying to ensure that we carry on the successful record and the approach of An Foras Talúntais and that we promote the research. I do not intend to go into detail at this stage on the importance of promoting Irish research and not trying to use research elsewhere by applying it directly in an advisory way. That would be totally inadequate to our needs and would, in fact, be madness from the point of view of the vital part which agriculture plays in our whole economy and in our society.

I am not satisfied that the Minister, in trying to create an integrated approach to the various services, has met the problem of safeguarding the budgeting within that authority and within that global budget, which it is agreed will not be diminished, safeguarding the portion of that which will go to research and ensuring that the research criteria will be well maintained by having the senior officer referred to in the White Paper, a deputy director, specifically directing research and fighting the research corner internally in dividing up the global budget.

Comment on this

An Foras Talúntais was set up in 1958 and there have never been these difficulties. Each year the budget has to be discussed and they have to get the money. Successive Governments have been quite generous towards research during that time, and I think rightly so. Even last year there was £5.6 million provided for research from the Exchequer; for the advisory services there was £3.7 million provided, and for education there was £2 million provided. Nobody can say that the research arm came badly out of that, even though as I say, they have to come every year to have their budget considered and then an amount agreed for research. They have a very small amount of money independent of Exchequer money, and I think it would be all wrong if the Minister of the day would not ensure that bodies of this kind would be accountable. I think it is reasonable that they should be accountable. They are in no way worse off now nor is there any reason to suspect that suddenly the Minister for Agriculture, whoever he happens to be, is going to turn against research and in favour of the advisory services or education. The same power and the same authority was there to do it over the years, to curtail money for one section and give it to the other, but that has not happened. I do not think that the concern is really justified. Section 44 of the Bill provides that the Minister may look for these estimates to be prepared and put up to him in whatever form he seeks them. He may seek to have them separate. There is nothing to prevent him from looking for separate budgets from the three agencies that are being integrated into one service. Therefore I think there are adequate safeguards and there is no change.

Comment on this

I was impressed by what the Minister said in regard to the general philosophy of the Bill, that is, that what he wants, if I interpret it properly, is an integrated service which will be operated by a benign, over-arching authority with which the research, advisory and teaching people will agree their budgets from time to time and, having agreed their budgets, will go off and do their business without any interference. As he said it, it sounded very persuasive, and I am sure that if the Minister himself were supervising it at close range it would work out extremely well. However, it is a fact of academic, administrative and indeed any kind of life that involves the co-operation of what we call the administration people—or if you want to be less kind, bureaucratic people, civil servants—that a tension nearly always arises very quickly between those who are engaged in the creative aspect of an operation such as this and those who control the purse strings and who see to it that people clock in and out on time.

An outstanding example is, for instance, television in the national broadcasting service. There is a notorious tension there and an anomaly there in the fact that the administration building is far bigger than the studio. That can be seen as symbolic. Of course, the creative people are to be given full freedom but the people who really control the budget are the ones who are calling the shots, and that kind of tension tends to develop. The point about research people is that they are probably very well advised with regard to what they want to do themselves, and I am not saying that they should have total autonomy, but it seems to me that the Minister is rather blandly producing a blueprint which, as he explains it, could produce a very bland and co-operative operation but which in the end could add an extraordinary degree of frustration for the research people, indeed the advisory people, the teaching people. I have for instance, heard certain civil servants, friends of mine in the Department of Education, tell me with rather sinister but jocose intent that they are looking forward to the day they get hold of the university, and as soon as they do, by God, we are going to clock in at nine and clock out at five. There will be none of this nonsense of coming in half way through the day, and they will not accept the story that in fact you can do some of your best work at home, that you may sometimes work all through the night and that you use a lot of your holidays for research and thinking and so forth.

There are two ways of thinking. There is the creative way of thinking and there is the bureaucratic way of thinking. It seems to me that what the Minister has done here is, with the very best of intention, and with the purpose of creating total efficiency, laid up for himself an extremely radioactive packet in which the research people will feel that they are not being given enough scope; the administrative people will feel that research people have ideas about their station and the administrative side will increasingly tend to interfere in and direct the research. In that way a great deal of ill-will could be built up. That is probably one of the results of this. It is a very great pity that a situation that is working so well as it stands, particularly with regard to the institute, should have the heavy hand of administrative uniformity laid upon it, with whatever good intention. At the end of the day we might live to regret the price we had to pay for that kind of administrative uniformity.

Comment on this

I think the point was put down very well by Senator Martin, but I want to go back first to what the Minister said, that the only logical reason that he is bringing the research sector into this authority is to make them accountable. It might be impressive to say that we spent £5.6 million last year on research, but it is a very small percentage of the gross national product. There is no doubt but that the Agricultural Institute have done a tremendous amount of work for agriculture. I believe that in his heart of hearts the Minister does not want to do this but it is being imposed upon him. He talks about the situation between An Foras Talúntais and the advisory service. He made the remark here that nobody seems to speak for the advisory service but I would remind the Minister we do not have an advisory service, that we have not an advisory service since the Department of Agriculture lobbed on top of every adviser here the task of the farm modernisation scheme. They left the advisory capacity then and went into the jobs that the Minister and his Department should have given then and still should to graded young fellows leaving school.

There is no advisory service now. If you were in the town of Tuam tomorrow morning you would stand in a queue for ten minutes to talk to those poor unfortunate fellows who have the boots of their cars full of files from which they are trying to arrange their day's work on this farm modernisation scheme. So if they want to get out of their situation, I do not blame them, because at this moment it is not an advisory service.

However, I can see the other side, because I lived quite adjacent to the institute in Belclare, and I can see why they do not want to go into the Department. They see what has happened to the advisory service who are paid by the Department. It is a good institution doing good work and it is autonomous, as it is entitled to be. If we talk about accountability, the Minister said on a previous occasion in Ballinrobe, if I remember clearly, that the institute had not got money at one particular stage to stay in Creagh; yet the people in Ballinrobe were not aware that the same institute who the Minister said had not the money were in favour of Belclare trying to purchase an additional farm of 900 acres. The Minister is contradicting himself here, because I was listening to him then and I am listening to him today. He could account publicly for them in Ballinrobe one evening, and today the Minister says he wants to bring them under this Bill because he wants to make them accountable. They were always accountable to the Minister because it was to the Minister and to the Minister for Finance and to the previous Ministers for Finance and Agriculture they came at every stage for their money. There is nothing wrong or sinister in what they have done. In this Bill the Minister is trying to lead people to believe that there was something sinister in what the institute were doing. The Minister should have another look at this because he is really destroying the institute. He might not see that now but in time he will. They will become nine to five men and they will clock in and clock out, as Senator Martin says.

Comment on this

And fill in forms.

Comment on this

Fill in forms, that is the next job they will get. There will be no more open days and open discussion because they will be afraid of who will be down at the back listening to what they are talking about. I can well see it. I saw what the Minister did to the advisory service and I now see what he is doing to this fine organisation. I would ask the Minister to forget this section, to leave An Foras Talúntais as it is or else give me one logical and clear reason other than the miserable one of accountability why he is making the change.

Comment on this

I find the argument at this stage rather difficult to follow. It seems to be one in which we are back into a Second Stage debate. There are a lot of comments in regard to research and with regard to control of the new board, which will be dealt with on subsequent sections. I think if people are concerned in a liberal context with the matter of research, then either section 17 or section 26 might be the more relevant area. I think the White Paper is quite clear on the need to co-ordinate the advisory service, the research service and the educational service, which is the stage we are at now. I find the arguments put forward from the other side of the House in so far as they pertain to section 7 not really all that strong and not standing up to the counter points that we put forward.

Comment on this

I would like to provide some of the details for Senator Quinn, if he wants them, concerning the repeals, which are the things being discussed in section 7. First of all, I would like to say that I did ask the Minister a question which I think is relevant and I have not got any reply.

Comment on this

I wanted to reply——

Comment on this

Just to repeat it: why not just extend the institute and transfer educational advisory services to that? I think that is the way to do it. Just to fill in the details for Senator Quinn, because we are talking about repeals of a 1958 An Foras Talúntais Act, and later on substituting the provisions in the Bill before us, and bringing out in the way so graphically described by Senators Killilea and Martin how the bureaucracy gets a grip on things and how when you give people less independence they spend more time filling in forms between nine and five and more time drinking outside those hours than they might have done heretofore.

The point is that there is a danger in an increase in bureaucracy. As Senator Killilea has pointed out, he finds people going around with the boots of their cars filled with files when of course they should be filled with manure if they are agricultural advisers involved in the industry. But it is the file mentality and the great file world we are facing. There are three sections in the 1958 Act, under which the institute was set up as a body corporate, which gave it a great measure of independence. That is now removed. A body corporate has legal ramifications which the authority does not have at all. It has a legal position which no authority has, and so the Minister has undermined the legal position of the institute. The second thing is that the original council, under section 5 of the 1958 Act, had 12 members and a chairman. How would you make a council less effective? Double its numbers—that is the simple way to do it. Then who controls the show? The Minister does. Now he has got 23 members and a chairman.

Section 7 of the 1958 Act, which we are about to repeal, allows the council to fix the director's salary. This was the right way to do things. I think we have had, in my time, when I know something about the issue, an outstanding director. He should be one of the most highly-paid people in Ireland. Now we are going to replace this with the Minister fixing his salary having consulted with the Minister for the Public Service. This is the sort of banal provision which is coming into all these Acts. If you want to get an outstanding individual to head a body like the Agricultural Research Institute, you should be prepared to pay him commensurate with his abilities and with the task he faces. Not likely. The spirit of the Devlin Report is: reduce them all to one common denominator.

However, the salary determined by the Minister, having consulted with the Minister for the Public Service, is not going to be high enough. I hate this sort of total uniformity. This is the sort of bureaucracy that will reduce effectiveness. We wipe out the legal base of the institute, the body corporate with the legal foundation, on which its independence was built. We have substituted for it an authority which has very little legal base. We have doubled the number of members on the council, the sure way to make it less effective. The next move is that the director's salary is to be fixed by the Minister having consulted with the Minister for the Public Service. The same uniform clause occurs in all these Bills as the semi-State area is drawn more and more into the civil service ambit. I am totally opposed to that.

We have points that are not just points between political parties. Senator Robinson and Senator Ferris have spoken from the other side of the House to show their disquiet about the spirit of what is being done here. This is very serious and I hope the Minister will be generous and not treat us as if we were talking with holes in the backs of our heads. I would take his commitment as absolutely genuine in that he is trying to improve the services and integrate them, but my theory is that we are doing it the wrong way.

Comment on this

Senator Quinn made a very reasonable plea, in saying we are going round in circles with a Second Reading approach. What is needed and what I hope we can do is to sit down and tease out the individual sections and see where we can strengthen them. I accept the Minister's assurance of his desire that research and so on should be no less free than it has been. I hope the Minister will meet the amendments, especially the one on the deputy director, or perhaps he will show us that there is some other way of doing that. We would make better progress if we could concentrate on individual sections as they arise—and in doing that, I feel confident that we will have the sympathetic approach of the Minister—to ensure that what emerges is a unified structure that provides the proper advisory service and yet carries on the tradition of research and work that the Agricultural Institute has developed so well.

Comment on this

I would like to make a point concerning what Senator Quinn and Senator Quinlan have said. I accept that the Minister means what he says when he tells the House that he will see personally that the institute will not be hampered or tampered with, but we might not be too far away from the time when we might have a different Minister for Agriculture. When they criticise us because we spend time trying to tease out this point of separation of the institute from the other two, they are trying to do your job, a Leas-Cheann Chomhairle, as well as to rush on to their own inconsequential points. This is a vital question. It is the most singular vital question in the entire Bill, because I have seen, and I am sure many Senators here have seen, the disintegration of individualism when the mammoth dog, as it were, stretches his claws. That is what is going to happen here. The Minister for Agriculture has seen this happen in other spheres. He knows that it is going to happen here, that they will get lost in the morass, that they will be doing the documentation and not the field work, and that they will not be doing the open-type educational work that they are now doing. I have given a clear answer why they will not do that; they will be afraid of the man in the shadow down under the tree. The Minister knows that. We have seen it in the Sugar Company; CIE is reeking with it. That is intellectual hypocrisy by so-called intellectuals. Those people who should be at drawing boards should stay at drawing boards and leave the agricultural situation to the agricultural people who are the most real people existing in this land.

Comment on this

Does that make the rest of us unreal?

Comment on this

Ninety per cent of them. They quibble about everything but they know nothing.

Comment on this

The Minister said a short time ago what the Bill was all about was to improve the services. We all agree with that. We all want to improve the service and, by and large, we all agree that the Minister wants to achieve that objective also. What this debate is about is whether or not the Minister is going about it the right way. The debate is about whether or not the method is the right one, whether or not control should be taken from those who have it—I am talking about the institute now—and given to those who seem to want it badly. There is a tendency to interfere with things that are doing well and not to interfere with things that are doing badly. Everybody agrees that the institute has done excellent work. The Minister has said so; everybody has said so. Here is an institute which has been in existence for many years, which everybody agrees has done good work, but the Department cannot leave it alone, and the Minister apparently cannot leave it alone. It must be interfered with. Why not leave the things that are working and do something with the things that are not working?

There has been no argument made in the course of this debate which proves that there should have been any interference with the institute. Its only sin seems to have been that it was independent. Its only sin, I will go so far as to say, is that it was doing too well and getting too much credit, credit that possibly the Department of Agriculture think they should have themselves. Why interfere with this particular institute? Nobody believes the Bill will improve it. The most they will say is that it will not do any harm. At best it will not be improved by this Bill; at worst it will be very much disimproved.

We have had cogent arguments which suggest that the institute will be undermined by the decrease in autonomy which it is going to suffer under this Bill. It is hard to understand, and in my view impossible to justify, interference with something which has done good work, which can and will do good work if it is left to carry on as it did in the past. It is not, in my belief, in the interests of agriculture in this country and in broad terms it is not in the interests of the country generally to interfere with a body which has committed no sin, except perhaps to be too good and to be a little more independent that it should be.

Over the years there has been a development of allowing certain spheres to be detached from the civil service and to be put under independent or semi-independent boards. In an article reviewing the development of this country since its independence, it was said that we followed slavishly what we got from the British in regard to our parliamentary and other institutions and that possibly the only single development we have taken up for ourselves was these semi-State bodies, such as the institute and others. It is our only contribution to the democratic structure of this country. Although it could not be said that all these institutions were successful, this is one which has been very successful.

An Foras Talúntais is not the only semi-independent body which has been set up. If one looks at Bord Bainne, would anybody believe that the Department could do that job? I think it is ludicrous to suggest for one moment that the Department could have been as successful as Bord Bainne have been in the past. I am not convinced that we will not have a Bill brought in to bring Bord Bainne back under the Department.

We have a tendency to interfere with what is good and ignore what is bad. To be fair to the Department of Agriculture and to the Minister, this is not confined to that Department; it is a tendency which has developed in many Departments. If this development of handing over certain functions to independent or semi-independent bodies was looked upon by the civil service over the years as an insidious revolution—and I think many civil servants would look on it in that way—it is true to say that the counter-revolution is now in full swing. I will give two examples. In the Department of Industry and Commerce the chairmanship of CTT is now in the hands of a civil servant and the chairmanship of the IDA is now in the hands of a retired civil servant.

This is a very serious and undesirable tendency which has been going on over the past few years. I have great admiration for civil servants, who are outstandingly able and dedicated people and who in their own sphere do an excellent job. The trouble is that they are not always as objective as they might be about what is and what should be their sphere. They unfortunately suffer from the mistaken belief that they can do everything better than anybody else and that anything they lose control of is likely to get into dangerous and incompetent hands.

It is not fair to blame the civil servants for this. This is a human, natural tendency and it is up to the Minister of each Department and the Government to curb this tendency and to keep it in balance. I am surprised the Minister has allowed this tendency to develop in his Department, because I think he is a competent Minister. I am surprised he has allowed himself to be talked into this situation of taking away the autonomy, the flair and the talent which this institute had. No matter what the Minister thinks and no matter what arguments are made, this is going to undermine the institute, but not in a dramatic way. It is not going to collapse, but in a few years' time it will not be as good an institute as it has been up to now. It is clear that the Bill will be passed and that talking about it is a lost cause, but it is our duty to say this. If I am right in thinking that the institute will not be successful in the future as it was in the past, at least people will be able to turn up records and say that we pointed out the dangers of doing what this Bill is doing.

I would like to invite those bureaucrats who suffer from illusions of infallibility to make hay while the sun shines because this trend of giving autonomy, independence, in certain spheres was a good trend. An attempt is being made to turn it back, to stage a counter-revolution. When Fianna Fáil get back to power that counter-revolution will be defeated and we will give autonomy and independence where it is appropriate to do so. I hope too much damage will not be done in the meantime.

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan has very ably misrepresented and distorted what is contained in this Bill. The impression he seeks to convey to the House is that everything is being taken in under the Department and that there are a group of grasping officials there who want to have their hands around the necks of anybody who is outside the Department choking them. Nothing could be further from the truth. I take full responsibility for what is in this Bill. Any question of this being pushed on me by civil servants or by officials of the Department is completely wrong. It is a complete misunderstanding of the actual situation.

What we are doing is taking a number of services under the Department and putting them under an independent authority, simply and solely because I think the Department of Agriculture are growing too fast. The EEC have put an immense burden on that Department and I want to get as many services as I can out of the Department and dealt with by competent outside bodies. Somebody who has already spoken on this said we were taking away the independence of this body by putting them under a board. What were the institute under if it was not a board, a board comparable to the type of board we are proposing——

Comment on this

And half the size.

Comment on this

All right, half the size. That may be so, but it is because we want all rural bodies to be interested and concerned about agricultural development and to have a definite and positive say on the board of this authority.

Comment on this

The point here is that there is no simpler way to make a body inefficient than by giving everybody representation who you feel should be represented and increasing the size of the board or the council. It is being doubled here. I would have liked to have seen the original numbers halved.

Comment on this

No. Twenty-four is not a big number.

Comment on this

It is chaos. It could get like a university.

Comment on this

Senator West was also very concerned about the fact that the Minister was responsible for the funding of this organisation. He was concerned that the Minister of the day, whoever he happened to be, would likely starve research and perhaps would give the extra money to the advisory services or to education.

Comment on this

I think Senator Robinson said that.

Comment on this

I think Senator West came back on it. I would just like to remind the House that the Department of Agriculture are responsible for funding three faculties already—agriculture, veterinary and dairying. I have never heard a single complaint from one of them about the Department of Agriculture. In fact, none of these bodies ever suggested that should be changed. They are all perfectly happy. Immediately we talk about funding a new authority everybody is concerned that we in the Department are going to do them down. I say "we" because I am the responsible person for the time being.

Comment on this

The specific point I made was on the director's salary. Why does the Minister want to control that? Why not let the board do it?

Comment on this

I want to ensure that we have the right. I have given a guarantee that nobody's salary or conditions of employment can in any way be worsened as a result of coming in here.

Comment on this

But they will not be improved?

Comment on this

That is another day's work. We all know there is an immense amount of difficulty in this area. This is the way democracy works. In no organisation that I know are people rewarded according to their ability. That is almost an impossibility unless you have a dictatorship. I know that there are times when it causes embarrassment to me, just as it causes embarrassment to other people, where there are people of outstanding ability and you cannot say that a man should be paid more and he automatically gets it. It was never so in any Government.

Comment on this

Supposing he got more than the Secretary of the Department, is that not really the problem?

Comment on this

Anybody who pretends to think that that was ever so is misleading himself and everybody else. Perhaps it was raised as an irrelevancy. Senator Killilea said that because we imposed the operation of Directive 159 on the advisory services we have no advisory services now. Senator Killilea knows the advisory services were on strike for about six months to get this job for themselves. I believe the services have been immensely improved as a result of their getting it and they were right to look for it. For the first time they are on their mettle. When they give advice now they have to stand over it. That is the most important thing in the world. They are doing the job that they should have been doing all the time. They are advising people on farm management, on the reorganisation of their farms and programming the work for farmers. This is real advisory work. That covers the points raised.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 24
·
Níl 13
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I am concerned with the good name of An Foras Talúntais. Is it proposed that this name will totally disappear or is there any possibility that the name in the title should not in fact become a Gaelic name? Would the Minister like to comment on that? I accept the legal arguments and the reason he gave on the Second Stage, but certain members of the institute were concerned about the very cold-blooded way section 10 is worded—"The Institute is hereby dissolved".

Comment on this

I can quite easily understand this sort of concern and loyalty to a name that has been in existence over a number of years but the same concern could arise in the case of the other services that have been integrated. I do not think you would get acceptance because they would simply say that they were all being brought in and dominated by one of the three agencies that have come together.

Comment on this

The actual structure as laid out in this Bill shows that that is not the case with regard to the service. We are talking about the title. I am concerned that we are losing the bilingual aspect in this regard. We are having an exclusively English name and there should be an Irish counterpart. I shudder to think what the precise Gaelic translation of this particular body might happen to be. I think An Foras Talúntais is a very acceptable title. Anybody who would argue that the other services are being gobbled up, because the Gaelic name of the body, in An Foras Talúntais could be refuted by the sort of arguments we have had already and that are going to continue throughout the rest of the day. I would implore the Minister to retain this name in some form.

Comment on this

Would it not give the impression that the only thing in future that the institute was providing was a research service and not including education and advisory work? I do not think we could do this.

Comment on this

Could I back Senator Quinn here? What in the words "An Foras Talúntais" has anything to do with research? There is absolutely nothing in An Foras Talúntais, if my Gaelic is correct, that says anything about research, advisory services or education. It just says an agricultural institute. It seems to me a perfect title for incorporating all these and a number of other services, if the Minister likes to assign them to them.

Comment on this

I would like to associate myself with this. I am not sure that either Senator Quinn or Senator West has worked out the legal implications of what they are saying, because you might be caught in a legal situation where an antecedent body which held certain powers might be identified with the continuing Irish translation. That might make for absolute chaos, and nobody wants that.

What Senator Quinn said has highlighted what I have to insist, and reluctantly insist: that there is a certain brutality about the entire operation. An Foras Talúntais have a long record of splendid service. To have their functions appropriated by the civil service, their research directed, every move they make clocked in and clocked out, a situation where any researcher who had stayed up until 12 o'clock at night with a test tube might have to answer a question the next day if he turned up ten minutes late. "Ar mhiste leat a mhíniú cén fá go raibh tú déanach ar maidin?" That is bad enough. But there is a certain brutality in obliterating an institution as venerable, as effective and as well recognised and admirable in their performance as An Foras Talúntais to be replaced by something unpronounceable as NAAERA. There is a lack of delicacy about the whole operation. The point raised by Senator Quinn points to an extraordinarily imperial attitude on the part of the Minister and his Department towards this entire operation.

Comment on this

I am reading some wisdom from the Second Stage debate on the Agricultural Institute Bill, 1957. Under section 4 of the Bill there was no doubt that all areas of an agricultural institute could be embraced by what is called the activities and the functions of An Foras Talúntais. There can be nothing wider than that. It is really flying in the face of logic for the Minister to come in here and suggest that, because this is a Bill embracing advisory, education and research functions, it is adding to research by including advisory and education functions and that in some way this necessitates a change in the Title of the Bill. It does not. The Bill as originally drafted, setting up An Foras Talúntais, that is, the Agricultural Institute, was deliberately drafted with very wide terms of reference designed to bring in the whole area of agricultural activity including marketing.

Advice, research, education, marketing—this was the whole purpose of the exercise at that time. Indeed the Minister is aware that the IFA—or the NFA as they were at that time—in their White Paper of 1955 suggested just this: that the wider the terms of reference, the better. That was the main thinking behind having the Agricultural Institute established as a wide-ranging agricultural body. An Foras Talúntais as it was known officially, and which is now established over 20 years as an excellent institute with an excellent reputation. You do not throw a reputation of 20 years' work and 20 years' standing out the window just for the sake of establishing a new label that is meaningless in terms of the letter heading label, "NAAERA". That will mean nothing. We have spent 20 years' time, money, energy and buildup by an excellent team of a tremendously high reputation as the foremost international and world specialists in the whole area of agricultural research, education, investigation, marketing and so on. Having built up this goodwill and established this reputation, why throw it out at this stage?

An Foras Talúntais have become part of our national heritage as it were. Why change a name that is well established throughout the world for a meaningless, bureaucratic, letter heading? That is all we are doing here.

Comment on this

I think we do less than justice to the staff of the Agricultural Institute when we make such an issue out of such a small matter. If we feel that by debating this issue in this narrow way, we can in some way evade the worries, or compensate the members of the Agricultural Institute for whatever grievance they may feel, we totally misrepresent them and underrate the name.

Comment on this

So they really have a grievance?

Comment on this

This is the first time I have spoken on this. Yes, I think they probably have a grievance and I want to say it is because of my respect for the quality and the standard of the people who work in the Agricultural Institute that I think it shameful that we should think we can offer them this sort of assistance and expect them to be impressed by it— the name of the Agricultural Institute. Whatever way things were in the past, they will not be different in the future as a result of this Bill. I accept that there are some small disadvantages but on the other hand I think that the amount of good which can be achieved by this legislation will far outweigh, and will be seen to outweigh in the long run, the grievances or disadvantages that one section of the new authority may feel. We should remember of course, that when we talk about the Agricultural Institute we are talking about a very small proportion of the total number of people who are involved in the whole agricultural service, a very small proportion when you take advisory and development sections and the Department of Agriculture itself and the research arm. I would not dispute that the quality of the research has been outstanding and has a source of great pride for the agricultural industry in Ireland. Nevertheless, we are talking about a minority of the people employed in what was one complete operation. The position of the Agricultural Institute should not be seen in complete isolation from what the agricultural industry was nor in isolation from the services that were provided for the agricultural industry by the other sections, in development and advice and by the Department of Agriculture itself.

I think we should not make too much of an issue of this. The indelicacy, the brutality is, I think, purely imaginary. The abolition of the Agricultural Institute may be necessary from the point of view of drawing up clear, concise legislation to which people can refer in the future. That is important. But, on the other hand, when I telephone Moorepark or Oak Park or go to some of the conferences they organise to get out their information, I do not expect that I will find that the Agricultural Institute has vanished from the face of the earth or that the legislation has made them less effective. I expect this legislation will give them added powers and increased opportunities to do the job they were set up to do. We should not condemn the name of the new authority which gives a fair representation to the various sections that will participate in the job in the future: it is rather small to do so. There are other things that we could discuss to greater advantage.

Comment on this

I like the way Senator McCartin slips down the slippery slope. We are not creating the situation; it is the Minister who is creating the situation by putting this name on it. In so doing he is confining the operation, whereas, as Senator Lenihan said, prior to that An Foras Talúntais was a broadly-based organisation. It implied education, research and a whole range of other things. Now, as the National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority, we shall be confined. It cannot be any more and, obviously, it will not be any less. Senator McCartin, in his argument for this name, says we belittle the institute by our argument. We did not put this name on it. It was the Minister or the civil service that did it. It was not us. We are protesting against it and there is logic in our protest.

There is no way, despite what Senator McCartin may think, by which in time the Agricultural Institute will be the same as it was in the past. I can assure him here and now that in six months' time, after this board is set up, it will not be the same and it never will be the same again. The Minister knows that, too. History proves this. Senator Ryan on the previous section went through a whole range of cases and all were drastic. This is another one. What we are telling Senator McCartin and those people who think that way is that we oppose this business. We believe it is cruel and crude, to say the least of it, because it does not give us anything new. It confines us to four single activities. An Foras Talúntais had a broad base and could have branched into other agricultural activities.

Comment on this

Read the section of the Act.

Comment on this

Do not mind reading sections of the Act. Go down and live among the farming community. That is the best education you can get. I saw plants done on heifers recently and not alone was it done by An Foras Talúntais, but they went about to their neighbours and, if they wanted help, they got it. Is that included in this sort of rubbish? They will be confined to the letter of the law. The more I see of this Bill, the tighter I can see the grip growing of the men at the top of the civil service and of the Minister, seeing that he has taken responsibility for it. It will be a vicious circle with no escape from it. An Foras Talúntais did give a service to the community apart from the employment part of it. I have seen it about me. Recently I even saw it in regard to electric fencing. The institute have two-thirds of the parish in which I live. We are told it will not change. It certainly will because no member of that institute in future will dare under this board planted by the Minister, to move one inch outside his own area. It might not be done under the Minister's eyes but in case it would come before the Minister's eyes, it will be nipped in the bud. You can write all the epitaphs you like on An Foras Tálúntais but until they are given back their freedom with their proper title and are allowed to continue in the way they have done in the educational and scientific areas and to improve and increase their services, they will not function at their best. We should not begrudgingly say that they got £5.6 million last year: that is not the point; if they needed £45.6 million they could get it because they have always given a good service.

Comment on this

In this section we are concerned with the name; the functions will be specified by the Act. The name suggested sticks in my throat —NAAERA. What the devil will we call that? Unfortunately, it is becoming very prevalent to be known by initials like the HEA, the NCA and all the rest. It is a type of Americanisation or computerisation of naming. I do not think this is right. I much prefer some type of a decent, Irish-sounding name for those bodies. We should show more initiative and imagination than is involved in capital letters. Apart altogether from functions or anything else, surely we are not going to baptise the new board with this appalling absurdity—the NAAERA. At least, the HEA has only three letters even though it still does not stand for much; neither does NCEA which is four letters. But now we have run to six letters. It is all wrong. I do not see that there is any necessity for a change. The function can be changed and that is what matters, what the Bill accomplishes. Surely, An Foras Talúntais is well known. It is a nice Irish, Gaelic-sounding title. How shall we translate this? I am not a Gaelic scholar and I will not make an effort to translate it.

Comment on this

It is in the title of the Bill.

Comment on this

We should have at least sufficient nationalism left to give some Irish title to the Bill. I would much prefer that. So I ask the Minister, quite seriously, between this and Report Stage to give consideration to getting an Irish title for this. If he does look for an Irish title, "An Foras Talúntais" is wide enough to embrace everything that is involved here. As a tribute to the generosity of the people of the United States who contributed to the foundation of the Institute we should retain the name. I make a very special plea for that.

Comment on this

Will that remove all the objections?

Comment on this

I just want to say a brief word on this. Honestly, I do not mind what the Minister does about it. We are wasting a lot of time. I am not ancient yet but already in my lifetime the name of this State has been changed three times.

Comment on this

Presumably by referendum.

Comment on this

At one time we knew it as Ireland; then we knew it as Saorstát Éireann; then we knew it as Éire, and now I do not know what we are to call ourselves. One of the Houses of the Oireachtas has spent the best part of a half an hour talking with bleeding hearts about a name in Irish for the agricultural advisory body which the Minister is establishing. Let us stop wasting time and if we want to talk about the Bill, let us talk about the Bill.

Comment on this

I want to talk about the the Bill. I have been trying to talk about it for a long time. Somebody has made the statement that we could not retain the name as it stands because the institute does not have the functions of an advisory and an educational service. I have just looked at the 1958 Act setting it up——

Comment on this

The argument was that the other two bodies coming into it would not be covered.

Comment on this

Let me read the relevant section. People said the institute could not do this. Section 4 of the 1958 Act, which set up An Foras Talúntais, in paragraph (d), listing the functions of the institute, states that the institute may do any of the following:

(d) consult with and advise persons engaged in carrying out agricultural research in relation to their programmes of agricultural research,

(h) provide and organise courses of study for advanced students in agricultural research and related subjects,

(i) provide and organise seminars, conferences, lectures and demonstrations in agricultural research and related subjects and on specific problems and programmes in relation thereto,

(j) disseminate, or procure the dissemination of, the results of agricultural research to interested persons, including, in particular, persons engaged in providing advisory services in relation to agriculture...

So, those subsections of section 4 of the 1958 Act seem to indicate quite clearly that An Foras Talúntais could take on the advisory part and the whole lot without changing anything, with a much simpler Act and without half the discussion or nonsence that is going on.

Comment on this

To hear this sort of argument put forward brings home to me how far removed people are from what actually happens. I do not recall exactly when An Foras Talúntais was set up but I know the advisory service was not as widely available to the farmers at that time as it is now. The truth of this situation is that in the past ten or 15 years there was a very comprehensive advisory service available to farmers. These people had their own field of activities and were quite jealous of their own area of operation. For anybody to suggest that it has been in practice possible for the Agricultural Institute to come out into the fields and give direct advice to the farmers is an indication to me of how little is understood of what the actual position was.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Nobody has more practical experience of getting the results of research from the Agricultural Institute than I have. Nobody has a longer history of working closely with the advisory service than I have. I know exactly how information from the Agricultural Institute was made available to farmers and what were the normal channels and what were the channels that one had to be very quiet about.

Comment on this

I would like to get back to the question of a name for a moment. I acknowledge that it is a relatively unimportant thing, certainly unimportant compared with some other aspects of this Bill. Nevertheless, as we are obviously not going to make great improvements in other sectors, perhaps we could save something. It is of some importance. Those who believe that the institute created a good reputation for itself and did good work feel that the name is the only thing most people, outside the country recognise and remember. The name is what they know about and it is of some importance.

Perhaps again it is the difference between the bureaucratic mind and the non-bureaucratic mind. In most other services, most commercial bodies, most academic bodies, a name is important particularly where something has gone on for a considerable length of time, where something has built up a reputation and that reputation is typified in the name. It is something that is not easily cast aside. It is something which should be maintained. Sometimes it is worth hundreds of thousands of pounds to have that name. Yet, not only are we, as many of us think, throwing away many of the tangible and real advantages and attributes of this institute but we are really throwing away the name as well.

It seems to me that if An Foras Talúntais has been in touch with various research bodies, bodies similar to itself all over the world, and in future if they write, if they have papers, if they put forward suggestions and so on under this new name, it will not be realised that it is the same body. It will certainly not get the same respect, the same consideration as it would under the name that has been built up over the years. To a certain extent, perhaps not to the same extent, the same applies in this country in the case of people who are looking for advice and so on. Therefore, although I acknowledge that it is not all important—the Leader of the House says we should not be wasting time on it: I am sure the Leader of the House has a long list of Bills which we should be devoting ourselves to and perhaps we should get on with this as soon as possible—it is of some importance, it should not be overlooked and I can only think that the only justification for changing the name seems possible an excess of honesty and integrity on the part of those who drafted this Bill, who acknowledge that it is not going to be the same institute and that it would be wrong to allow it to retain the name

Comment on this

Since I raised the question I do not think it is necessary to mention again the whole range of functions of the board of the authority. But I am speaking again for three reasons. First, what is the girl on the switch going to say every time she answers the telephone? How is she going to announce the new boss? I happen to be a partner in a firm of architects and our title is virtually unusable because there are so many names in it. It may sound very trite, but in fact it becomes a problem. Some recognition in whatever form is found suitable should be given to this. It is going to be the "Ag" Board something or other. It will certainly not be what is here. NAAERA, depending on the regional pronunciation we have of it, will create problems. It may appear to be silly, but since it is in a section of this Bill I am addressing myself to it.

Secondly, it is an institute of research we are taking into a new body. It has a tradition of research which, as Senator Eoin Ryan has pointed out, has an international facet; and I should like to see some kind of continuity maintained between the two. Finally, An Foras Talúntais is registered with a number of development agencies, such as the EEC, for work abroad; and presumably there is some kind of continuity in this regard. It is for those reasons I would like to see some acceptable form of Gaelic name which would encompass these things and which would be purely a name. I discount the argument about functions we have had on this section because they are not relevant. We are talking about a name for this new authority.

Comment on this

I think it is rather strange that the Leader of the House should say we are wasting our time discussing this. It only indicates to me that there is a certain line of thought here, that this thing will be bulldozed through at all costs. If we take it that this is a new Bill to help the agricultural industry, we start off with the very name of the Bill, which I think is as clumsy as the intentions that are in it. The man in the street, the farmer, and those who are involved in a practical way in agriculture can actually make an assessment of the Bill by one glance at the name. The name never came from anybody involved in agriculture. It came from the bureaucracy, people who are far removed from agriculture. You can do a lot with a pen and a bit of paper, but when you get out on the ground it is a different job. If the Minister wants to have this new Bill as an instrument for the Department and for the whole of the agricultural community to believe in, then he should start off on the right foot. I see it as a clumsy Bill right through from its title to its contents. I think it is totally unacceptable to the agricultural community. The name is unworthy of a new Bill for agriculture today.

Comment on this

I just want to say that we are obviously looking for trouble if we select the name of one of the three agencies that are coming together. The other two agencies have been in existence since 1900 or so. This one came into existence in 1958. I have no objection to An Foras Talúntais as a name but it is clearly synonymous with research. It is known in the country as nothing else but the research institute. It would be giving a completely wrong impression if we were to call the new organisation An Foras Talúntais. It is a nice name, of course; I appreciate this. Senator Quinn asked "What will the lady on the switch say?" She could say "This is Miss Quinn, how can I help you? I am anxious to help you because we have a comprehensive service here".

Comment on this

Could you simply call it "The Agricultural Institute" or "The Agricultural Commission"? This is a ridiculous name. If you were addressing a letter to them you would have to get a longer envelope.

Comment on this

Could I appeal to the Minister to try to meet the genuine wishes that have been expressed to get a better name than the clumsy one that is here. I would suggest it would be better by far to continue the name we have as a tribute to the work that has been done but more especially as a tribute to the benefactors who established the institute. Without the far sighted statesmanship that made those funds available we would not be in our present position today. Even if it were considered necessary to change the name—and I do not think it is—the words that occur to me are, perhaps, An Bord Talúntais, although it has not continuity. Or perhaps An Foras Ginearálta Talúntais, if you feel that the other services would be a bit worried about the particular name. Again, I think they could be contacted between now and the Report Stage and told that there is a genuine wish in Seanad Éireann between all parties here to get a better name.

I think if Seanad Éireann could achieve that much it would have done something. We are proud of the name. We like to have Irish names rather than combinations of capital letters and especially this awful combination. Perhaps the Minister would take that as a genuine appeal. I think all parties and all the Independents as well agree on this. We will probably get a consensus. Senator Quinn and other speakers have made very valid points about what we would like to do in this regard. I ask the Minister to meet the Seanad on this point between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

A Leas-Chathaoirleach, can the Senators actually make a proposal on that issue?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

An amendment may not be put down at this stage.

Comment on this

I can think about it but I do not see it being changed without a lot of trouble.

Comment on this

The Minister made it clear earlier this afternoon that he takes full responsibility for the Bill and for all its contents. We have been trying to get him to achieve this very desirable object in a different way from the way in which it is set out in the Bill. We have made a number of suggestions, all of which he has turned down. He says that on Report Stage he may consider a different name but indicates that it is unlikely.

We have gone through these arguments in considerable detail and I certainly would not be here still if I did not believe exactly what I was saying, even if at some times we are getting a bit exasperated by the Minister's attitude of not an inch, an attitude associated with the famous politicians in another part of the country. Perhaps he is getting exasperated by our attitude but I want to move to another point on which I think this Bill falls. I do not think we can pass section 10 without abrogating the treaty signed between the United States and Ireland in 1958 which set up the institute. This has been referred to on a number of occasions. Both Senators Quinlan and Lenihan took part in the debate which established the institute and they referred to the fact that the money which established the institute was a sum of around £1,800,000 and it was a counterpart of the Marshall Aid Fund which came to us in the fifties. This is brought out very explicitly in the discussions that went on about the establishment of the institute if one reads the speech of the Taoiseach of the day in Seanad Éireann in 1958. Mr. de Valera in his introductory remarks outlined the long and protracted negotiations that had gone on between the United States and the Republic. This resulted in a treaty which was agreed to by the two Houses of the Oireachtas and passed by a special motion in the Congress of the United States of America. I will quote from the treaty which set up the institute because I think we are breaking this treaty by passing section 10 of this Bill.

It is headed: Treaty Series, 1958, No. 7. Agreement between Ireland and the United States of America (subsidiary to the Agreement of 17 June, 1954), respecting the use of Counterpart for the Establishment of an Agricultural Institute. It is dated 16th April, 1958. I will quote the sections that I think are the vital ones. The Governments of Ireland and the United States of America have agreed as follows:

ARTICLE I.

The Irish Government undertake to establish an Agricultural Institute to be known as An Foras Talúntais, and to place at the disposal of the Institute £1,840,000 (one million, eight hundred and forty thousand pounds) from the balance in the Counterpart Special Account. This money shall be utilised by the Institute in the manner specified in paragraphs 4 and 5 of the Annex to this Agreement. The functions, government and other regulations relating to the finances and administration of the Institute shall also be set out in the Annex.

ARTICLE 11.

The Irish Government undertake, in pursuance of Article IV of the Principal Agreement, to furnish to the American Government as soon as possible after 31st March, 1959, a report on the progress of the project referred to in Article I and to furnish similar reports as soon as possible after 31st March in each subsequent year. Each such report shall be accompanied by a copy of the annual report of the Institute referred to in paragraph 13 of the Annex to this Agreement.

There are a couple of other articles which I will not quote but in the annex to the agreement the functions of the institute are clearly set out and these were incorporated in the 1958 Act. They can be read in the 1958 Act. Section 2 of the Annex to this treaty states:

GOVERNMENT OF THE INSTITUTE

(i) The Institute shall be a body corporate and shall be governed by a Council.

(ii) The Council shall consist of a Chairman and 12 ordinary members. The Chairman shall be appointed by the President of Ireland.

The rest of that section deals with the establishment of the Institute.

Section 5 of the annex states:

ENDOWMENT FUND.

(i) The Irish Government shall place at the disposal of the Institute the sum of £1,000,000 out of the monies held in the Counterpart Special Account which sum shall be placed by the Institute to an endowment fund, to be called the Endowment Fund of An Foras Talúntais, and invested by the Institute in such securities as may be approved from time to time by the Minister for Finance of Ireland.

(ii) The interest on the Endowment Fund shall accrue to the Institute as annual income.

So a sum of £840,000 was granted by the United States in Marshall Aid for the initial capital expenditure to set up the institute and then a fund of £1 million was given by the United States Government which was to be invested and the income was to provide the annual income to run the institute.

The Bill before us simply abrogates that treaty. This raises a number of difficult legal questions. If this is in fact the case, if there have been no amending treaties, then it seems clear that this Bill is doing something very serious indeed. As the Government have stated—in particular the Minister for Foreign Affairs has said this on a number of occasions—that for small States international agreements must be interpreted in good faith as our protection against great power machinations.

This is the principle on which our foreign affairs have been conducted for many years. It is different from the principle which adheres to legal agreements internally, where the letter of the law is interpreted. It is clear that to protect ourselves in international agreements we have to interpret the spirit of these agreements as well as the letter. It is the spirit of the agreement which counts.

Anybody who knows anything about the United States knows that that is a country in which bodies such as the Agricultural Research Institute are distanced as far as possible from departmental bureaucracy, probably further than in any other country. They are very particular about distancing their institutions from the central bureaucracy. There is a continuing debate in the United States about the encroachment of bureaucracy. So not only in the letter but in the spirit are we abrogating the agreement that was signed in 1958 between Ireland and the United States. This is very serious. It has very serious ramifications. I should like to know if the United States Government are aware of what the Minister intends to do in this Bill and, if so, what their reaction has been.

It seems strange, and not a little sinister, that the Agricultural Institute was founded by means of a treaty between Ireland and the United States and that this is the first time in the two debates that this has been mentioned. That is very strange. I think there is something funny going on. The institute was founded by an international treaty between two sovereign countries and if I had not fortuitously discovered this during the Second Stage debate no reference would ever have been made to it. Surely the Minister should have referred to this in his speeches.

It also raises an internal question of our own domestic law. The institute was established by a treaty as a body corporate. The body corporate is the crucial thing. This meant that it had its own legal status, which is totally different from the limited legal status of an authority. A body corporate has all sorts of legal rights and it can undertake all sorts of legal obligations in legal contracts, which an authority cannot do. This is the point we have been trying to make.

It could be that the employees of the institute would be in a position, in view of this treaty, if this Bill is passed, to take an action. I am not sure what the actual legal term would be under which the action would be taken but in the case of private citizens it would be a breach of trust action. In the case of a private citizen it would be a case of winding up a trust—we are winding up an institute here. There certainly would be a case for taking a breach of trust action. I do not know what the corresponding legal name is here. There could be a prima facie case that the employees of the institute are in a similar legal position to the beneficiaries of a trust. If a trust is wound up then one can take a breach of trust action. It could be that because of this treaty, which as far as I know has not been mentioned, the employees of the institute might be in a position to take an action against the Minister on these grounds.

There are two points here. There is the important point of international law if we do not adhere to the terms of the treaty set out in 1958, which this Bill does not; it clearly breaks them. Then there is the point of our own internal law concerning the establishment of this institute and the position of the employees in view of the treaty signed between the United States and Ireland.

Comment on this

Perhaps I could help Senator West. He says there has been no mention of this. It is mentioned in the explanatory memorandum and in section 54. Earlier Senator West expressed his admiration for the officials in Government Departments. Having expressed that admiration he should accept that they were not foolish enough to go ahead and run point blank into such serious legal trouble without first seeking and getting the agreement of the American Government for the changes proposed in this Bill. They have done that. As I say, it is explained both in the explanatory memorandum and again in section 54. In the explanatory memorandum it states that section 54 provides for the treatment of any unexpended balances in the capital and endowment funds of An Foras Talúntais in accordance with an agreement recently reached between the Government and the United States authorities. Again it is a misunderstanding and a failure to read what has been circulated to Members of the Seanad and Dáil.

Relating to another matter that has been raised twice or three times, it has been stated that this is not a body corporate. Of course, it is a body corporate. It is set out in the First Schedule that the authority shall be a body corporate with perpetual succession and so on. So there were two misreadings there.

Comment on this

I listened to the Minister stating that it was necessary, legally, to dissolve the institute. I think this is a big mistake because the Agricultural Institute was a by-word with the farmers, who would not be very familiar with the language of the parliamentary draftsman. Only time will prove the retrograde step that has been taken here by abolishing the institute.

The provisions of the Bill do nothing to encourage the farming community. I believe it has been a step backward. No matter what the Minister says, the farming community will not be convinced that any fresh thinking has gone into this. We have an institute whose work has been praised. It does not become more efficient by broadening the scope and changing its name or taking it in as part of a broader board. In my opinion it makes it much less efficient. The Agricultural Institute was well known, well established and it provided a service with which the agricultural industry found it very easy to communicate. The consequences of abolishing the institute will be seen in the short term.

I have my doubts about the new board because it is very hard to see the additional benefits. I do not see any assurance given by the Minister. He wants to broaden the scope of the advisory service and to involve the rural community. I do not think it does that. It contracts, restricts and prevents. It is like the high-powered architect who draws up plans without serious consultation with those who are going to perform on the ground. This is the trend here. The damage this will do will be felt because it will not create any confidence whatever within the industry. The expressions of fear are there already. Those who are engaged in agriculture do not know what the board's intentions are. They know that the Minister is adding duties and functions to the agricultural advisory service and there is no practical use or benefit accruing from that. We should restore the confidence of those engaged in agriculture.

New legislation should be drafted with the greatest possible simplicity. We should be getting away from the day when the ordinary people have to look up a subsection and relate one Bill to another before they know what benefits or disadvantages are in the Bill. All of the functions and benefits provided by the Agricultural Institute are provided for in this Bill. To me, this all adds up to a recipe for complication, and it does not inspire any confidence among the farming community.

Comment on this

The wording used in section 10 is, to say the least, ruthless: "The Institute is hereby dissolved." The Minister has made reference to this in previous discussions on the Bill in this House and I gather he has taken legal opinion on it. I understand the Minister's commitment to the continuation of the institute and its research. As I read it, that means that it is the legislation that set up the institute which is dissolved, not the institute itself. The institute remains intact, and the Minister has given a commitment that it will be maintained to the same degree as in the past.

Surely, the parliamentary draftsman could think of a better way of doing this. The section could state "The legislation setting up the institute is hereby rescinded" or "The powers vested in the institute are hereby transferred to this new board". Would that not have a more desirable effect on the staff of the institute? I would ask for the Minister's comments on this. I know that he has legal opinion available to him that we have not. We are looking at the practical side of it. We know that the institute is not hereby dissolved. As Senator McCartin says, he will contact them next week and expect them to be there, functioning as efficiently as always. There must be some other terminology that can be used instead of saying "The Institute is hereby dissolved".

Comment on this

I am less concerned with the actual wording of the legislation than with the effects of it. If the effects of the present situation were all that the agricultural industry might have expected, if the progress in agriculture was all that the Irish people expected from the industry, I do not think there would be any need to change the legislation. But more could have been made of our resources in the past. More could have been made of the money that was spent in all the services which cater for agriculture. Therefore it is time somebody took action. Successive Ministers studied this problem, got reports, got opinions and looked at it all and were afraid to do anything. The present Minister has made up his mind, in a situation where there was bound to be dissatisfaction among some element. I believe he has produced the best package and proposed legislation which, I believe, will have the right effect. I have found the institute to be one of the most efficient bodies, employing a most dedicated group of people. Their freedom of movement and ability to follow their own conscience and judgment was most refreshing. In the future, rather than see this aspect of the Agricultural Institute diminish, I would hope to see them pass on some of these advantages and some of their dedication to the other bodies with whom they will become involved.

When the Agricultural Institute was first set up the advisory service was much weaker than it is at the present time. As the years went on certain tensions did develop between the research people and the other services which were longer in existence. While it did not do a great deal of damage in the past, the best interests of Irish agriculture would not be served by allowing the situation to continue.

The work of the Agricultural Institute did not come directly down and give its benefits to farmers as it should have given. I believe that this was in the minds of both the civil servants and the Minister when they drafted the legislation. I know that the findings of research carried out by the Agricultural Institute have been implemented in other states and not here. There was certain lack of communication in some ways and certain tensions that might have been unjustifiable. Nevertheless, the working of the bodies concerned, the development and research can be better served under the umbrella or a new authority in which the best example of the Agricultural Institute together with their research and the result of their work will be passed on to development and advice, and that, rather than losing a precious commodity which we had in the Agricultural Institute, we will improve the good sense and the dedication of the people in the Agricultural Institute. We will have the sort of co-operation that we have come to expect from them in the past and the elements that were missing for progress in agriculture.

People looking into the future forecast increased production in agriculture by 5 or 6 per cent. Other people say this is not realistic, it is too much. I confidently believe that Irish agriculture is capable of expanding at the rate of 7 to 10 per cent annually, given the market. We have the prices, and given the leadership and the encouragement together with the advice, development and research that this new body can give, I think we will have an accelerated expansion in the agricultural industry. The problems of the research people have not been fully understood in the debates in this House. There has been a tendency to fish in troubled waters rather than to analyse what exactly was the history of the worries and concerns that a number of people in the Agricultural Institute have, and I feel they have some. There was a very belated, very hasty search for information to try to uncover some argument that might seem plausible but I think that we have an obligation to be more constructive with regard to an industry which is so important.

Comment on this

I listened with great interest to what Senator McCartin has just said, and, indeed, there are very few people in the country as qualified as he to talk about matters like this because of very great experience in both the industrial and the agricultural areas. However, I do not think he has absolutely demolished the case, a case which I do not think is the result of lobbying, though there has been lobbying. Primarily I do not think it is that at all. I felt through this House today on both sides of the floor a certain sense of compunction about the, let us say, perfunctory way—I will not use words I used before; I will not use Senator Ferris's word "ruthless" in which an institution of such strength and force and obvious value can be snuffed out. We are discussing section 10, which reads:

The Institute is hereby dissolved. The summary of that is "dissolution of the institute". That is what we are talking about. That is a rather ruthless formulation. Senator Ferris found it so even though he is not primarily opposed to the Act itself. He thinks the formulation itself is anything but adroit. I think it is extremely maladroit, but I cut a little further beneath that. We have a lot of institutions in the country, semi-State bodies, bodies corporate, and they think they are doing a good job. Very many of them are and the energy, enthusiasm and dedication which makes these institutions do a good job is the sense that people repose their trust in them and that the Government do too. I think they have reasonable hope to go on with their work and expand it and pour their enthusiasm and work into it, as long as they know they are doing a good job and as long as that is granted to them.

If, however, they are unfaithful in their stewardship, of course, they will be brought to book and they should be, to quote this, "hereby dissolved"— the operation summed up in "dissolution of the institute" or whatever it is. But that is not the case here. There is no question of incompetence or bad stewardship. Instead the argument is in favour of what Senator McCartin I think has eloquently enough said: greater efficiency in the discharge of their duties.

There are a lot of institutions analogous to this one and I am not sure that rather perfunctory formula is going to engender a great deal of trust in the people working there, and I am not sure that, in fact, it will not undermine the sense of their future. In other words, they say, if the institute can be so easily dismissed from its office, what is the use of enthusiasm, energy, working beyond your hours, pushing out the frontiers of your achievement. That is the first thing. The second thing is this, and it is the one that keeps recurring. We are a mixture, I suppose, of a State-aided and free enterprise economy.

There are semi-State bodies. State bodies, and then totally private bodies. It has been recognised by us as being a reasonably good mix, not a perfect mix, but speaking for myself I find, if I might put it without being toffee-nosed or snooty or elitïst the energy that goes into such a body as the institute is intellectual energy. By and large the people who are working there are concerned with the pursuit of knowledge and very often they are willing to do that for very little money. Very often they do it well beyond the call of duty. They are very touchy people. If they are going to be asked why they did not turn up at nine o'clock in the morning, when in fact they may have been working until 12 o'clock the previous night, if you start doing that with them, I think you can kill the very source of their dedication, energy and their intellectual work.

Therefore it would seem to me that, this is a real problem for the Minister. Obviously a Minister wants to get things done and if he is in the position that this Minister is in, that he has to spend a lot of his time in Brussels arguing cases, he really has not much time for the more cumbersome processes of democracy and so forth back at home here. It is better to get everybody under the same whip and make them dance to his tune—all in the interest of the common good of course, no sense of autocracy involved. I can understand the impatience of somebody who has so much on his plate and who finds three bodies here not quite working in the triple harness that he would like, not stepping it out, so to speak, together with the élan and obedience he would wish for.

However, there are two ways of solving that. One of them would be the one he has chosen: that would be, bring them right under my thumb and then we can make them really toe the line. But there was the other way, and looking at those cold words "the institute is hereby dissolved". I wonder why could it not have been the other way. Why not separate the national agricultural advisory element, then the education, and again the research, and create an over-arching authority based on the three of them, growing from below instead of above with adequate Government appointment and so forth, and let them go their way? These processes of advice and education and research mean they are partners and they could very well work under that kind of partnership. That cold and pitiless formulation there—"The institute is hereby dissolved" will be a kind of death knell to dedication in a lot of bodies corporate and semi-State institutions, if they think that their tenure of life is so easily at the will of Ministers.

Furthermore, it is a pity that the dissolution of that institute should involve the increasing bureaucratisation of what should be a very outdoor, a very much on-the-ground industry, which is an industry that probably exhibits individuality more than any other industry under the sun—a farmer with a piece of land, working it. It is sad to see it so irrevocably and implacably under the bureaucratic or the civil servants or the administrative—I have nothing against them; some of my best friends are civil servants and bureaucrats and——

Comment on this

The Senator might be one himself yet if they get hold of the universities.

Comment on this

The Senator will be described as a dangerous devil if he continues on that.

Comment on this

That will be the day. It seems to me a pity that the one industry that is left which depends on sturdy individualism should be one that is now almost totally at the mercy of men sitting in offices, drawing lines, making decisions to cut back on this or that. Has that researcher turned up on time? Where is he? He is down the country. He has spent too much time talking to that farmer; he should be back at home. Senator West, with his immense experience of academic life. as I have, truly says that is going to drive a lot of good men to drink.

Comment on this

I share the concern expressed by a number of Senators who faced with this bald section which would propose to dissolve the institute. An Foras Talúntais. It clearly is agreed on all sides of the House and agreed by the Minister that the institute has been a very successful body, that it has provided independent and important research in the area of agriculture, that the staff are of a very high calibre and are very dedicated people. If the Minister puts forward a persuasive case for integrating the agricultural services, education, advice and research, surely it should have been possible to combine them without reaching the situation where, in a rather unusual way, concern is expressed on all sides of the House about what is being done.

I would like to come back to the point I was making earlier. The proposals in the White Paper were more acceptable than the terms of this Bill in so far as they effect the transfer of the research area from An Foras Talúntais to this new overall authority. It would be possible, even at this stage, to write into the statute itself the sort of safeguards which would remove a lot of the fears and apprehensions which are shared by Senators on both sides of the House. A number of these relate to the question of ensuring that there is within the global budget of the new authority to be established a definite commitment to a research budget, that there is a top level official, a deputy director, in charge of research and also—we will come to these points later—that there are better provisions relating to industrial relations within the authority. These are specific improvements which would remove a lot of the real disquiet which is felt by Senators. This disquiet has not been helped by the approach which the Minister appears to have adopted towards the people who are going to be very dramatically affected by this section, those who work in the Agricultural Institute and who see it being dissolved and who see themselves being transferred into another and different body so that we will have an integrated approach to agricultural advisory, educational and research services.

Reference has already been made on Second Stage to the fact that the vast majority of researchers in the institute were finally reduced to paying for very substantial advertisements in our daily newspapers in an attempt to communicate with the Minister. I do not want to go into that again—I think it has been sufficiently raised—but researchers are concerned about their own independence, and by that one does not mean total autonomy and total remoteness from any situation and the right to do anything you like with the taxpayers' money. That is not what is at issue, but independence so that research into areas such as land development, taxation of farmers, rather politically sensitive areas, can be embarked upon without interference or curtailment by bureaucracy or by ministerial interference.

If there is concern about that and if there appears to be an unwillingness to meet the people affected and to discuss these very serious issues with them and to hear their representations and to take time on it, so that they are reduced in the end to putting an advertisement in the paper, this can only accentuate these fears; this can only appear to give substance to the apprehensions which have been voiced by a number of Senators today. I know that the Minister has already given assurances. He may say to me that I was not here on Second Stage when he gave these assurances. Unfortunately I was attending a meeting of the Joint Committee which was taking place at the same time or I would have been here. I read his Second Stage speech and I know the type of personal forceful assurances he gave.

Nevertheless, this is not an adequate response because personal assurances by a Minister for the time being, however sincere—and I have absolutely no doubt that they are sincere in the case of the Minister—are not a substitute for ensuring that the statute itself, that the letter of the law, guarantees for all time that there will be the safeguards which are desirable and which would continue the same environment for research, the same protection for those engaged in it and the same sense of respect, and an assurance that they will be able to carry out their work as they have under the present working of the institute.

The Minister has referred to the terms of the 1958 Act and has said there is not really all that much difference. The money has to be voted, has to be agreed by the Minister. There is no independent source of funds. Why are we pointing to the independence of the institute and contrasting it with the system that will be established here? There is a very substantial difference The institute was a separate body devoted to research. Yet it had to make a case for a budget each year, make a case for funds, and the case depended on the willingness of the Minister of the day to provide funding. That is certainly true, but it also appeared as a specific item which one could look at, the amount that was going for research.

When this question was raised by me earlier the Minister drew my attention to section 44 of the Bill on the question of the board preparing for each financial year an estimate and the form that this may take. Then he referred me to subsection (4) which provides that the Minister, in conveying his approval, should indicate such if any amendments of the estimate that he considers necessary. I think the Minister's point was—he can correct me if I misunderstood him—that he could at that stage insist that there be separate budgeting for the advisory services, for the education services and for the research services in the estimates put up to him, that if it was not clear how the particular categories were to be delineated, he could send it back for amendment and could make this clear.

That would be some help in the matter. It would be better still if the Minister could both give a specific undertaking and perhaps amend section 44 to reflect that undertaking that there would be a budget broken down into special compartments and that this would be published in the Estimates of the Department so that it wou'd be clear not only to the Minister himself in deciding to approve the budget of the board but clear to members of the Dáil in looking at the Agriculture Estimates how much of that global budget was definitely earmarked for research. That would certainly help to create more confidence among the researchers, because we deal always with human beings.

When a body like the institute has built up its own spirit, its own goodwill, has carved out for itself a role which is acknowledged on all sides of the House today, has created its environment for independent research and is making its contribution, we must be very slow to abolish it because we want to do something else, and risk losing the very substantial values and quality of the work of the institute and of people involved there. I would ask the Minister to take very seriously the sort of representations that have been made. I would like to make it clear, as I think Senator Martin said, we are not speaking as people who have been very successfully lobbied by a few people who have a vested interest. If there had been no representations made, we would make the same points of concern about the fact that there are not adequate safeguards in the present text of the Bill to ensure that the best features of An Foras Talúntais and of the people who work there are carried on in the research work which they will be required to do and will want to do under the new board.

This is a widely-shared concern and is one which I hope the Minister will take very seriously. Even at this stage I hope he will introduce subsequent amendments to the Bill or accept amendments that are down for consideration by us this afternoon in order to allay some of these apprehensions, in order to ensure that the environment for research is continued, that the independence and budgeting for research is continued, in order to ensure that within the new larger authority there is not unfair competition for funds between researchers who have a more long-term perspective, who are more remote from the immediate requirements of farmers, requirements of the public, political requirements, which would result in pressure behind the advisory and educational services in competing for those funds. There are also improvements which could be made in the industrial relations side to secure the status of the people involved in research, and if these specific points were met then this would not be quite as much as a weight over the institute as it is turning out to be.

Comment on this

Very briefly, this section, which we are opposing, epitomises the basically wrong-thinking that has gone into the preparation and the production of this Bill. I agree with the Minister and I think everyone of us here agrees—everybody anyway has said so—that we are all concerned about the whole question of agricultural research, concerned about improving it, concerned about channelling down through the advisory services to the farmer, concerned about having a proper educational structure in respect of both the education of the professional agriculturist and the education of the professional farmer. If this is so and if, at the same time, we can all pay full service, be it lip or otherwise, to the Agricultural Institute and its staff over the past 20 years of its existence, and if everybody here says that the Agricultural Institute has performed a magnificent service, that Irish agriculture has made striking advances owing to its existence, as was said in the Minister's White Paper, then why is the Institute dissolved? Why not bring in a simple Bill, amending the Agricultural Institute Bill of 1958, and giving the institute extra functions in the advisory and educational areas? Why not expand section 4 of the 1958 Act, which is the section giving the institute its general functions and simply go along that, and amend the legislation to improve the functions and add to the functions of the existing Foras Talúntais? If that were done, we would have a very even and level debate here. There would be total agreement in the other House and in this House. There would be no confrontation and none of this obvious erosion of the morale of the staff of the institute which is taking place in the course of this debate, promoted by the fact that under this Bill the institute, An Foras Talúntais, is being dissolved under this section.

The Minister is setting up another creature. Is it not a plain fact that the reason the existing Act was not simply amended is that the Minister. the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Finance, wanted to get their fingers right in on top of the day-to-day administration of this body. As sure as night follows day that will be the way in which this body's activities and functions are going to be frustrated, negatived and driven into the ground. All that had to be done was to improve on the framework of the existing institute situation, not dissolve the institute, but merely extend the powers and the functions of section 4. Indeed, I might say that is what I suggested myself here 20 years ago—that there be an amendment put down by the Government to extend section 4 to spread the functions of the institute into the educational area.

There is much that is valid here in the section, adding the educational and advisory areas to the institute, but the basic trouble is that the authority cannot move in regard to these areas without the prior approval of the Minister. It is only with the prior approval of the Minister that the new body being created can move in any of the areas of finance, research, advice and education. For the first time we have the Minister coming right in on the regulation of the research aspects which are the most unamenable to any form of ministerial control or direction. That precise area of research that was left independent under the existing legislation—and rightly so—is one that flourishes best, and has flourished very well over the past 20 years, under a global annual grant with complete freedom to operate within that grant as it sees fit in research areas.

On the Second Stage I was going through, section by section, where the Ministers for Finance, Agriculture, Public Service and Education are brought in with the whole departmental apparatus, in effect, to supervise the activities of this board in these areas. The Minister may say with goodwill that that is not his intention, that is not what is in the statute. If that is not the Minister's intention, why this section: "The institute is hereby dissolved", and I ask the Minister in all seriousness why, if consideration was not given, why simple amending legislation was not brought in here, maintaining the existing Foras Talúntais and adding to its functions by simply adding to or improving section of the existing legislation that gives the institute its functions. That was all that had to be done, and if that was done the Minister would have the situation of making certain that the institute had a say in the advisory and educational areas, but also the institute would have preserved its independence in the research areas and its general freedom from arbitrary ministerial control and direction. I want to know why a simple amendment of the existing legislation was not put in. I would like a straightforward answer to that because I feel that there is nothing that could not be done in the direction the Minister desires in the field of advice and education added on to research by a simple amendment of the existing legislation.

Comment on this

I cannot help feeling that Senator Lenihan has amazing courage and imagination in Opposition and he had none of this when he was in Government, and he was in Government for many years. He did not certainly succeed in persuading his colleague and my predecessor that this was what was needed when all the pressures were there for the reorganisation of the services. He was not able to persuade his own Government at that time, and he tells me it is the right thing.

Comment on this

There were never pressures about An Foras Talúntais before.

Comment on this

That is the purpose of a Parliament.

Comment on this

There is some quite genuine concern being expressed by some Members of the Seanad and I want to try and reply to them.

Senator Robinson has raised on more than one occasion this evening one of our concerns, and that is, the absence of any reference whatever in the Bill to the appointment of a deputy director who would be solely concerned with research and the fact that there was mention of this in the White Paper. The An Foras Talúntais Act did not make provision for a deputy director, but they were free to appoint one and a deputy director was appointed. This authority can appoint all the directors they think necessary for this job. There is no restriction on them.

Comment on this

Why not give them statutory functions?

Comment on this

Why compel them? Why set up a board and then tell them in advance what they are going to do, day by day and step by step?

Comment on this

The Minister told them that in the Bill.

Comment on this

That is not in the Bill. That is what I want to impress on Senators. I am not bringing things in under the maw of the Department and the officials of the Department, as has been said. I am pushing things out to an independent board. I am saying "You are the interests concerned. It is for your people that these services are being provided. You decide what is the right thing to do". Everybody is condemning me for this and telling me that I should indicate and chart every step of the road. That would be totally wrong and nobody would want it.

I gave all the reasons why I felt it was extremely desirable for the overall good of the services being provided for agriculture that these three agencies be brought together into one organisation so that they could work as a team and with real team spirit. I do not want to go over the same ground time and time again, but no matter how often I say it somebody else will say that what I am doing is giving the service in the Department a grip. I am doing nothing of the sort. I am setting up a board and letting this board use their own imagination and decision-making in relation to what is best for Irish agriculture and that is as it should be.

Comment on this

The Minister is setting up a board and I support that.

Comment on this

I am setting up the board in exactly the way Fianna Fáil set up the board of An Foras Talúntais, every step of the road, so do not start reflecting on me. This is nothing new.

Comment on this

The Minister is controlling finances, too.

Comment on this

There are 12 more on this board.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

Why change it?

Comment on this

I am just increasing the size of the board. That is all.

Comment on this
Joe J. McCartin Acting Chairman (Mr. McCartin) Fine Gael

The Minister, without interruption, please.

Comment on this

I was directing Senator Robinson's attention to part of section 44:

The Board shall prepare, in respect of each financial year, an estimate in such form as the Minister may require of...

The Minister may require that the estimate is broken into three parts, indicating where the money will be spent and how much will be spent on each. I expect that that would be the normal and natural way to produce an estimate. That is the way they will convince the Ministers concerned that that is the amount of money required. It is easy to examine it that way because that is the way Ministers have been accustomed to seeing it coming up. When I draw attention to that fact, that also overcomes part of the anxiety.

Comment on this

Instead of dissolving the institute why was the existing legislation not amended?

Comment on this