National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976: Committee Stage.
Contributions 118–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1976 ›
I thought I had adequately answered Senator Lenihan in relation to that. It shows the insincerity of Senator Lenihan——
Comment on this
If he felt so strongly about this 20 years ago, and in 16 of those years his party were in office, how did he fail to persuade Fianna Fáil to do exactly what he is trying to persuade me to do in this House? But perhaps the only person who is in step is Senator Lenihan. That is a very good answer.
Comment on this
Would the Minister indicate the position vis-a-vis the United State in this? In the original agreement there was a special treaty involved, as Senator West pointed out, and the amount involved was very considerable—in the 1950s it was £6 million which today would probably be £60 million. I know the United States representatives at that time had an unholy horror of the type of hidden strings that the Department of Agriculture were capable of putting on agricultural research because I was privy to many of the meetings with the National Farmers' Association and others in trying to iron it out. It took eight years before the United States were satisfied that the provisions had been agreed.
Comment on this
The Minister did not explain this. I am just bursting to get up and ask about this. There was mention here of an agreement but nobody knows the terms of that agreement. Has it been laid before the House? Had Parliament any say in it? As nobody knows about it that is not an explanation. I back up Senator Quinlan.
Comment on this
We have the agreement of the United States authority on the changes we are proposing in this Bill.
Comment on this
Could we see the text of that agreement because the whole matter hinges on that agreement?
Comment on this
I must defend Senator Quinlan's right to proceed.
Comment on this
I would like to be assured that the United States are satisfied that the provisions in this legislation are satisfactory—in other words, that they give the necessary autonomy. I have respect for the separation between bureaucracy and research.
Comment on this
I would like to know if the United States authority are satisfied with all these provisions.
Comment on this
I want to ask about this agreement. Firstly, I should like to admit the error I made on the body corporate because I discovered that what I said on that issue was incorrect. The position with regard to the agreement is quite unsatisfactory. As Senator Quinlan said, there is a treaty, which everybody can see—I have read the relevant sections into the record—which was signed in 1958, establishing the institute. It did a lot more than just spend money. It specifically put down how the institute should be run. This Bill is changing all that. There is a section dealing with money but we want something more than just money. There is mention of an agreement in the explanatory memorandum, but the explanatory memorandum has no legal significance. We have never seen any House? Has it been ratified or has House? Has it been ratified or has it just been proposed? Is it a draft agreement? What is it? If this agreement has been worked out, surely we should have the text of that agreement with this Bill, not just two or three lines on page 6 of the explanatory memorandum.
Comment on this
What is in the explanatory memorandum should be accepted. It should be expected that no Government will proceed knowing that they are proceeding illegally or taking chances.
Comment on this
The Department of Foreign Affairs dealt with business of this kind between the United States and ourselves. They have dealt with it and I cannot deal with the legal niceties of it.
Comment on this
If the Senator is so disbelieving about what happened in relation to all this, all these texts can be provided.
Comment on this
Surely I have the right to be disbelieving when the whole Bill hinges on an agreement that nobody has ever seen. Have any of the Members seen it? Has Senator Butler, who is nodding his head, seen the agreement?
Comment on this
Every time the Minister said anything the Senator nodded his head. This is degenerating into a low farce when I ask for an agreement which is mentioned in the Bill and the Minister gets up and says "If you are so disbelieving, then we might show it to you". I am really trying to be responsible about this. If we do not see that agreement and if we do not have time to consider it, the whole Bill is not worth a root. We can just throw it away.
Comment on this
Let the Senator challenge it outside if he is not satisfied. That is all I can say to him now. Section 54 would not be worded as it is if it was not regarded as being legal.
Comment on this
That is not what I am saying. I am saying: let us have the agreement.
Comment on this
I have not seen the agreement. Have any of us had the opportunity of seeing it? I would not have raised this point if it had been available. I must see the text of the agreement. If there is an agreement between the Irish and the American Governments, whether it has been laid before Parliament or not, we must have the text of the agreement, otherwise the discussions must cease.
Comment on this
I agree with the point raised by Senator West. As far as the employees are concerned, the position with regard to possible legal action is very serious. We are talking here about a solemn agreement between Ireland and the United States of America which was presented to Dáil Éireann by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, dated 17th June, 1954, and ratifications exchanged in Washington on 17th February, 1955. The agreements governs the disposition of the ballot. The counterpart special account was to be used by the Irish Government for the purpose of establishing an agricultural institute to improve and develop the agricultural production and marketing potential of land. It said that the Irish Government will carry out the projects and programmes contemplated in the agreement and that the agreement provided for the establishment of an independent institute.
The onus on the Irish Government under this agreement, in exchange for the money given to them by the American Government, was to set up an institute, not an agricultural institute as part of the Department of Agriculture. That solemn agreement laid before the Dáil became effective on 17th February, 1955, and was signed on behalf of the Government of Ireland by Liam Cosgrave and on behalf of the Government of the United States by Michael William Howard Taft III. That agreement is still international law and is a solemn treaty between our two countries.
It is not good enough for the Minister to come to this House and say that, as mentioned in the explanatory memorandum, which has no legal significance, section 54 does not in any way interfere with the solemn agreement to which I referred. That section deals with the transfer of moneys accruing to the authority and no more than that. There is no mention in this Bill, good, bad or indifferent, of the solemn agreement between Ireland and the United States of America which became effective in 1954 and on the basis of which a subsequent honourable Government decided to implement the Agricultural Institute Act, 1958— an Act which, in effect, implements this agreement between Ireland and the United States of America—which set up an agricultural institute in consideration of the granting by the American Government of special funds under the counterpart special account.
There you have the flow of events, the signing of the agreement by the second inter-Party Government between Ireland and the United States of America, its implementation in the form of legislation by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1957, supported by the then leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy James Dillon, whom I met today and is still hale and hearty and very proud of his contributions of that occasion. Now, apparently under pressure from the Department of Agriculture, its independent status is being taken away without any written agreement with the United States of America, or any agreement on record that we can see amending that agreement. This institute is being dissolved and the moneys so graciously and generously given by the United States Government are being absorbed into the maw of the Department of Agriculture to distribute and administer as they think fit over the years ahead, under a new creature which would be subservient to the Department and through which the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance can subsequently direct and control Irish agricultural activities in every area.
What we are talking about here is a very legitimate question put through the Chair asking the Minister to tell us in what way, if any, the agreement reached between Ireland and the United States of America back in 1954-55, has been abridged, changed or amended to bring in this legislation? We are also asking him what is happening here? Not alone are the farming community or the employees of the Agricultural Institute being subject to the whip of the Minister for Agriculture, but we now have the situation where something is being carried on behind the backs of the American Government. I say that in all seriousness. This is not a matter for telephone calls to the American Embassy asking if that will be all right. We would like to see the treaty between the Irish and American Governments amended. I would also like to see the document where the American Government authorised the Irish Government to proceed as they are proceeding in this legislation. We should be informed of the details of such an agreement. If there is an agreement amending this treaty, it should be placed in the Library for perusal by all Members of the Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I was quite taken by the point raised by Senator West. I thought it had been answered by the Minister in the first place, but I feel now that it really has not. One line in the explanatory memorandum does not quite meet the case. I do not think section 10 can go forward until that agreement is made available to us.
Comment on this
The Minister in his reply did not actually deal with the points raised, particularly his legal advice as to the actual abolition of the institute. Perhaps it is tied up with section 54, which states that there is an agreement and I have no doubt that such an agreement exists. The only concern expressed on the other side is that the Americans are being hoodwinked in some way. Surely, if agreement was reached——
Comment on this
I, too, would like to see the agreement but I do not doubt that there is an agreement.
Comment on this
Senator Ferris, without interruption. We will come to section 54 in due course.
Comment on this
The Minister might say that he had to use such language, "The institute is hereby dissolved" and that for legal reasons he could not possibly consider the other routes I suggested.
Comment on this
As I said in the Dáil, and reported at column 83, Volume 298, of the Official Report:
While the wording of this section might be considered somewhat harsh, it is dictated by legal requirements.
I went back to the Attorney General's office on this.
I hoped it would not be necessary to put it in this way, but we are setting up an integrated organisation and, when doing so, one has first of all to dissolve the existing organisation. Rather than emphasise the negative aspect I would rather stress the positive side of this section. The institute is being integrated into a larger organisation where it will have greater scope in achieving its objective of promoting the further development of the agricultural industry.
As I said, the institute had to be dissolved. That was a legal requirement in order to integrate the services. It was one of three agencies. There was a difference, for instance, in the agricultural advisory services, because only a portion of their responsibilities was being transferred to the institution and certain parts were being retained. It was a transfer in that case. Here, all the powers and responsibilities are being transferred to the new authority. Therefore, there had to be dissolution. That is the explanation given to me by the legal services and I have to accept that that is right. If the Department of Foreign Affairs tell me that they have reached agreement with the American authorities, I have to accept that as a fact. I am not qualified to scrutinise a legal agreement and say whether it is 100 per cent right or if it could not be contested at some stage in the future. That is not my job.
Comment on this
Does that mean the Minister has never seen the agreement?
Comment on this
The Minister's advisers must have seen this agreement which involved an amendment of Treaty Series 1958, No. 7. Somebody must have seen it. This is all hearsay. It is now the Department of Foreign Affairs——
Comment on this
Somebody will have to see it before section 10 is passed. That is my attitude. It is our duty as democrats to see the agreement on which this Bill is based, and the Bill hinges on section 10. I must see the text of the agreement.
Comment on this
That is a very expansive, trust uncle attitude—"You know I am always right". I would trust the Minister a long way but it would be a complete abrogation of my functions as a Member of the House if every time a Minister came in and said "There is an agreement, do not bother about it, you do not need to see it", which is what has been said to me, I sat down. I would not have raised this point if the agreement was available. I tried to check through the records this morning to see if the treaty signed in 1958 which established the institute had been amended. I could find no agreement, unless it had come through in the last day or two. There was nothing in the published list. I would like to know exactly what is the status of the agreement the Minister referred to. Is it a draft agreement? Has it been laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas? Has it gone through the requisite period downstairs and appeared since on the list and is now part of our statute? Or is it something that is being concocted at the moment? We cannot go on with this debate unless we see this agreement and know the status of the agreement. Is it a draft agreement? What is it? There is a big hole in this.
I would like to get the 6.30 p.m. train home to Cork. I would not be making this speech if I could have got the agreement. I tried this morning. Obviously I am not going to contact the Minister's advisers and give the whole game away and say "I am going to cause a row about the treaty in the debate this evening". I have a few tactics left in me, like the Minister. The 6.30 p.m. train to Cork has gone. It is not unreasonable to want to see the agreement. Even Senator Ferris almost agreed with me. He said, of course, he trusted the Minister: he trusts him even more than I do, naturally. This debate hinges or falls on this agreement.
Comment on this
We can trust the Minister but can we trust the man the Minister trusts?
Comment on this
I have already asked people about the status of this treaty. Supposing the Minister or the person who advised him is wrong, supposing the agreement is not an agreement under the terms of this treaty, supposing it is only a draft proposal between the two Governments—a telephone call between Jimmy Carter and somebody else—it might have been fixed up over the weekend.
Comment on this
What is the legal status of the agreement? Is it an agreement between Ireland and the United States of America? Is it an agreement between the Governments? Is it a draft agreement? Has it been laid before the House?
Comment on this
The present position is that we have got agreement from the United States authorities to go ahead in accordance with the terms of this Bill. If Senators want me to produce an agreement here, I cannot do it.
Comment on this
I wonder where that leaves us. Let me go back on the points I made earlier because I think they are rather important. First of all, I get the body corporate wrong. I concede the point. Then I said that the treaty was never mentioned. That was technically correct. The treaty was never mentioned by the Minister in his Second Stage speeches in any part of the debate or in the explanatory memorandum. There is a reference in the explanatory memorandum, which has no legal significance as the Minister knows only too well, which I will read into the record. On page 6, it says:
Section 54 provides for the treatment of any unexpended balances in the Capital and Endowment Funds of An Foras Talúntais in accordance with an agreement recently reached between the Government and the United States Authorities.
There is no mention of the treaty on which the institute was founded. This is an agreement recently reached. I contend that it is not an agreement with any legal status. It has not come before the Houses of the Oireachtas. This Bill is based on an alleged agreement. Was it just a telephone conversation or were there discussions between the Department of Foreign Affairs and the US authorities? The Department of Agriculture do not even know what is in the agreement.
There are some proprieties to be observed, and that is all that has to be done. If the people of the United States and the people of Ireland, through their Parliaments, come to an agreement, that is absolutely fine, no problems, no further arguments. That should be done first and then the Bill should be introduced. Maybe just the timing is wrong. I certainly cannot sit here and accept people saying that the agreement is between the Department of Foreign Affairs and the United States authorities. Which authorities? I am going to do a bit of telephone calling after this to find out what the United States' view of this is. Is it really an agreement, or are there discussions going on about agreements or about getting agreement on agreements? Where are we? The whole affair should be postponed at this stage until this agreement and the whole business has been sorted out. We cannot go on with the Bill on foot of an agreement which is not really an agreement.
Comment on this
We are entitled to basic information. When preparing the existing legislation—the Agricultural Institute Act, 1958—scrupulous regard was had to the agreement reached in 1954, and made effective in 1955, between Ireland and the United States of America in regard to the disposition of these funds. The actual phrase "the Agricultural Institute" is written into the treaty. Article 1 of the treaty empowers the Irish Government to use the funds for the purpose of the establishment of an agricultural institute to improve and develop the agricultural production and marketing potential of Ireland. That phrase "the Agricultural Institute" was transmitted from that treaty into the legislation passed in 1958. That phraseology is now being dissolved by section 10.
Section 10 says that "The institute is hereby dissolved", that is, the Agricultural Institute, which was established through the generosity of American moneys. The Irish Government accepted those moneys on the basis that they would establish an agricultural institute under article 1 of that agreement. Following that, legislation was introduced implementing an agricultural institute with all its functions. That is what we are now dissolving here by section 10.
We are entitled to know under what part of this Bill or under what proposed draft agreement that situation is being changed. The Minister made a glib answer, and was taken up by Senator Ferris, that section 54 as set out in the explanatory memorandum on page 6, provided for it. Section 54 does not provide for it. It refers to an agreement recently reached between the Government and United States authorities. Was that a telephone call? Was it an exchange of letters? What sort of approval was given? What sort of draft amendment to the treaty is going to be made? Although the explanatory memorandum refers to an agreement recently reached between the Government and the United States authorities, there is no mention of this in section 54 of the Bill—and it is the Bill which is important. Section 54, subsections (1), (2), (3) and (4) refer to the transfer of the moneys of the institute to the new authority. There is no mention whatever of any agreement recently reached by the Irish and American Governments.
The case is very strong that the Minister should take back the matter for further elucidation and come back with a more thorough understanding of what is involved. We shall be glad to suspend the debate here and adjourn for a week to enable the Minister to understand fully the situation. I appreciate that there are law officers involved in this, and the Department of Foreign Affairs are involved in it. We would be reneging completely on our duties if we were to allow the Minister to proceed with this legislation on the basis of a Bill that appears to run counter to a solemn agreement entered into by the Irish and American Governments. It is an international treaty and not just an agreement over the telephone. It has all the force of international law. The legislation under it still has the force of international law as implementing that treaty until that treaty is amended or abrogated. We are passing a Bill which completely abrogates both the treaty and the legislation under it. They can abrogate the legislation by the section we are discussing but the treaty I think still subsists. We are entitled to know whether there is a treaty in force between the Irish and American Governments and if we have a draft of the treaty. If there is no draft but there is an exchange of letters, we would like to see the letters. It is important that we should come clean with the American Government as well as with the Irish public and the agricultural industry and the agricultural scientists who have been working in the interests of the Irish agricultural industry in the Agricultural Institute heretofore.
Comment on this
I am not legally minded but I have the document of this agreement. Now that we are, in section 10, declaring the institute dissolved, we are breaking this signed agreement. The Minister says he does not know much about the legal side of the matter either, but if we are doing such a thing, should we not see what we are doing? Is the Minister not running amok by breaking a treaty without giving us the contents of the agreement to the breaking of that treaty? It is, after all, as far as we know, still a treaty. By section 10 we are breaking that treaty.
Perhaps this new agreement between the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Ambassador is no more than that they whispered something to each other or one nodded to the other and said "That is all right". That is not good enough. You cannot deal with such agreements as you deal with a Fine Gael executive meeting in Dublin South County. It is more serious than that. We are still a democracy: we are heading slightly away from it but we still are one and we will fight to continue to be one. I should like to see this new agreement to the effect that the US were willing to have this Bill brought in.
Comment on this
Irrespective of whether the Minister produces this agreement or not—and I doubt very much, having listened to the debate for the past 20 minutes, that he is going to produce it—the Minister, in reply to some of the speakers, made reference to the fact that the very strong language used in this section had to be used on the basis that, in regard to the advisory services, only portion of the powers was being transferred. Then when it came to the transfer of the powers of the Agricultural Institute, all powers were being transferred. This signifies how the Agricultural Institute stand when this section becomes law. They will be completely devoid of all powers. The Agricultural Institute in the future will be dictated to by departmental officials and by the Minister in regard to their essential research work. Suppose the Agricultural Institute tackle some particular project and investigate the research end of it—and we are all aware of how tedious and long-drawn out this research work can be-and having gone a certain distance in this project, the Minister then asks them: "How far have you gone in this? How much money have you spent? You seem to be spending a lot of money?" They might not be in a position to say to the Minister "We will continue with this and we may conclude in another month or so." The Minister would have the power to say "I think you have gone far enough. We will use this money to some other effect and go ahead with some other project."
In the Minister's reply to statements made here he clearly illustrated that the words used in this section, "The Institute is hereby dissolved", had to be used because all powers were being taken from the Agricultural Institute. I would like to know what the future for the members of the Institute is. The fact that the majority of research staff have openly stated through the medium of the press that they have grave reservations about this Bill clearly highlights where they think they stand. I feel confident that they had section 10 in their minds when they made that statement. It is essential that this agreement be put before the House. I feel it is not in writing and that it was a telephone call or some message from one Department to the other in regard to this agreement and that this is why we cannot use it.
Comment on this
Could I move the adjournment of the House for half an hour or so to give an opportunity to the Minister and the other Senators to have tea? We have not got a quorum at the moment. So, in the absence of a quorum, I call the attention of the House to that fact and I suggest that we adjourn for half-an-hour.
Business suspended at 6.40 p.m. and resumed at 7.15 p.m.
Comment on this
Before the teabreak we had quite a lot of talk about this agreement between the USA and the Irish Government as regards the dissolution of An Foras Talúntais. I do not intend to dwell on that but to say that I heartily agree with what has been said from this side of the House concerning the agreement. The agreement certainly in my opinion should be made known to the Members of this House and of the other House. Of course, it is not the first time that we have had secret agreements in recent times. It was only a few weeks ago when we had a mining Bill going through both Houses and the Minister at that time refused—not the Minister in question now but another Minister refused—to make certain information available to both Houses. I think that was very wrong. I accept the Minister's word that there has been an agreement but what I would like to know is who was consulted in this country as regards the agreement. I am quite sure that it was the Department of Foreign Affairs that finalised the agreement with the American Government.
The Department of Foreign Affairs, I imagine, would know very little about agriculture and I take it that it was the Department of Agriculture that briefed them in order to get this agreement passed between both countries. I wonder was the council of the Agricultural Institute or the director of the Agricultural Institute consulted about this agreement? Were their views put to the USA Government? If they were, this agreement might not have gone through at all. I am certain that the council of An Foras Talúntais and the director and his staff would not agree to dissolving the Agricultural Institute. As the county committees of agriculture are another group that are involved in this, I wonder were they asked? I am quite sure they were not because I happen to be a member of a committee and I know that we heard nothing about it.
The Minister, long before this Bill was introduced, asked for submissions from most of the rural organisations. I am quite sure that in all the submissions he got no rural organisations suggested that An Foras Talúntais should be done away with. Yet he went against the advice of all rural organisations as far as that was concerned. An Foras Talúntais are highly respected and admired by the agricultural community all over Ireland. Without being disrespectful in any way to the officials of the Department of Agriculture 1 say that in the lifetime of the institute, for the 19 years they have been there, they have done more for agriculture and achieved more in that 19 years than the Department of Agriculture achieved in 70 years. I think it is certainly a bad day's work for agriculture in this country to abolish the Agricultural Institute.
I was listening to other speakers trying to persuade us that the new body would be completely independent. If you shout that until the cows come home nobody will believe it because you have taken the independence An Foras Talúntais had and you have brought them back under the umbrella of the Department of Agriculture. There is no use in saying that the Department of Agriculture and the directors of An Foras Talúntais and the others were a happy family. They were not; but it was not the fault of An Foras; it was the fault of the Department of Agriculture. I happened to be a member of the council of An Foras Talúntais in the early years and we had pretty hot meetings at that time. We were very fortunate that we had a very good director, a man with strong will and he was more forceful than the people who represented the Department on An Foras. Certainly, if it had been left to the people who represented the Department of Agriculture, An Foras Talúntais would not have gone as far as they have gone.
It has already been mentioned here that the money for the establishment of An Foras Talúntais was American Aid money. I think this money was given to Ireland in 1948 or 1949 and it took from that time to 1958 finally to decide how the money would be used. Consultations had to take place from time to time with the American Government. Indeed, I might say during that period we had a number of changes of Government here. I think we had three or four changes but, all Governments agreed on the same thing: that an agricultural institute should be set up.
We got almost £2 million; £840,000 to begin the work of An Foras Talúntais. We had £1 million which was invested and the interest on that money is still being used. The £1 million that we got from America and also the £840,000 are now being transferred from an independent body back into. I might say, the Department, because it is the Department who will have the big say in the present set-up. At that time, when it was established, the council and directors decided to buy land and property around this country. They bought big farms in Old Park and New Park and many other places around the country and they have various substations. No later than a month ago they leased a farm in my area to carry out some kind of dairy research there. It has already been mentioned here that £1 million was invested at that time. It must now mean that An Foras have at least £10 million worth of property—if it stops at that. This property is going to be taken over from that body and used for some other purpose because certainly it will not be used as well as it could be used in the hands of the director of the Agricultural Institute and his council.
The council was composed of men representing a number of farming organisations—two or three from the universities and one or two from the Department. In the early days the Department were represented by the Deputy Secretary. For the first few years money was available. They had plenty of money from their own resources. But then they had to go to the Department, and I remember at that time it was difficult enough to get money from the Department. During my time there my party were in office. The director and the whole council at one time had to go to the Department to prove that they needed this money. I have a feeling they would not have had any difficulty in getting the money were it not for the fact that some senior officials in the Department thought they should not get it.
This year I understand that £6½ million was given by the Department. I may be wrong in that because I have not got the figures with me. Whatever money was given was very well spent. If £6 million was spent that way I am sure it brought £20 million into the country. Were it not for An Foras and the way that we have developed in recent years our agricultural community would not be as well off as they are today.
We have heard a lot of talk about the staff of An Foras and that they are most unhappy about this transfer. I do not blame them at all. Those people were devoted to the job they had. They were not tied down like other civil servants. As people have said here today, they are people who were not watching the clock. They sometimes worked 24 hours in the day. We know that sort of work does not go on as far as the civil service is concerned. Now that they are in the civil service no doubt they must act the same as a civil servant because they cannot give him good example by working later hours than he would.
I feel they have a genuine reason for being unhappy about this change. It is all right for a Minister to say "You are not going to suffer in any way whatsoever. You will get the same salary as you had in the other job and if promotion comes along you will be entitled to it." Some years ago a section of the Board of Works was transferred to the Department of Lands. They looked for those guarantees before they went to the Department of Lands and they got them. They were told they would not suffer in any way whatsoever. It did not work out that way.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator would allow me to intervene. The Chair is somewhat troubled on two points. One is that he is going rather wide of the net issue of this section and, while several of the points he is mentioning are relevant to the question of whether there should be a formal dissolution of the institute, many of these matters have, I understand, already been discussed on section 7. It certainly would be most improper if arguments were to be debated on section 7 and on section 10 and possibly on later sections and on amendments. I would ask the Senator to make his best endeavour to keep to the net point at issue and to avoid arguments already made.
Comment on this
I am speaking on the section which says "The Institute is hereby dissolved." I did not speak on section 7. The discussion on section 10 has gone on here for quite a long time today and I did not speak on it. Quite a lot of others did, not once but maybe four or five times. With all due respects to you, a Chathaoirleach, I am just comparing the staff of the institute with the staff of another Government office who were transferred to the Department of Lands and did not get the guarantees they were promised. For instance, if a Department of Lands official and a man who came in from the Board of Works were equal, the man from the Department of Lands got the promotion before the man from Board of Works. That happened all the time, not just in one case.
Comment on this
Perhaps I could intervene again to try and explain to the Senator that it seems to me this point he is making now might more properly be made on section 33, which is concerned with the employment of the staff after the passage of this Bill. I might point out that I have not said the Senator is out of order. I merely intervene to ask him to be careful so that we can have an orderly debate. I would be anxious now that, if the Senator wishes to speak on this point, on section 10 he may well be entitled to do so. He should speak only on one section in regard to this and, indeed, for the proper conduct of the debate I think the House should agree whether these matters would be taken on one particular section and not taken on a number of sections of the Bill.
Comment on this
I will conclude now on section 10. I will have another opportunity when we get to that other section, whenever that will be. It will not be today anyway. I should like to ask the Minister why when he was taking An Foras Talúntais and the committees of agriculture and a certain section of agriculture into this new body, he excluded the bovine TB section and the brucellosis section. They are two very important sections.
Comment on this
We have been discussing whether or not we are acting legally in dissolving An Foras Talúntais and whether the treaty, as it was so described, still exists and what happened to that treaty. I have been able to get some information during the break. There was nothing that was ever described as a treaty. I would not really know the legal difference between a treaty and an agreement, but it was an agreement anyway. That agreement was changed simply by an exchange of letters. Some Senators were insisting on seeing the agreement that was given to the change proposed in this Bill. An Cathaoirleach, if you will permit me I will read the correspondence. It consists of two letters—one from Foreign Affairs and a reply from the United States.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister intends to read the full text of the letters and make the text available in the Library?
Comment on this
Is this actually an agreement that has been laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas?
Comment on this
No. It is an exchange of correspondence and we were legally advised that that was all that was necessary.
Comment on this
Let us hear the agreement now and see what happens.
Comment on this
This is the letter sent by the Minister for Foreign Affairs:
Excellency
I have the honour to refer to the Agreement between Ireland the United States of America respecting the use of Counterpart for the establishment of an Agricultural Institute, signed in Dublin on 16 April 1958, which was subsidiary to the Agreement between Ireland and the United States of America Governing Disposition of the Balance in the Counterpart Special Account signed in Dublin on 17 June 1954, and to propose that, the funds referred to in the former Agreement having being placed at the disposal of the Agricultural Institute (An Foras Talúntais) and the requisite reports having been furnished, it be hereby terminated and the Government of Ireland released from all obligations thereunder.
If the foregoing is acceptable to your Excellency's Government I have the honour to propose that this Note and Your Excellency's reply concurring therein shall constitute an Agreement between our two Governments, which shall enter into force on the date of your Excellency's reply.
Accept, Excellency, the renewed assurance of my highest consideration.
I can read the reply from the American authority, which is a bit longer, but one paragraph explains and gives their agreement and that is the last paragraph.
Comment on this
As long as the Minister is prepared to place the full text in the Library it would be sufficient for him to read the relevant paragraph.
Comment on this
The whole debate this afternoon has hinged on the text of the agreement. I think we should hear the full text of this letter.
Comment on this
It is not wasting the time. This is what we have been at all the afternoon.
Comment on this
The Minister appears to be willing to read the full text and there appears to be a desire on the part of a considerable number of Members of the House that he should do so. So, if the Minister is willing, perhaps we will let him get on with it.
Comment on this
The letter is as follows:
Excellency, I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your note of January 5th, 1977, which reads as follows:
I have the honour to refer to the Agreement between Ireland and the United States of America in respect of the use of the Counterpart for the establishment of an Agricultural Institute signed in Dublin on the 16 April 1958, which was a subsidiary to the Agreement between Ireland and the United States of America Governing Disposition of the Balance in the Counterpart Special Account signed in Dublin on the 17 June 1954, and to propose that, the funds referred to in the former Agreement having being placed at the disposal of the Agricultural Institute (An Foras Talúntais) and the requisite reports having been furnished, it be hereby terminated and the Government of Ireland released from all obligations thereunder.
If the foregoing is acceptable to your Excellency's Government I have the honour to propose that this Note and Your Excellency's reply concurring therein shall constitute an Agreement between our two Governments, which shall enter into force on the date of your Excellency's reply.
Accept, Excellency, the renewed assurance of my highest consideration.
Your proposals are acceptable to the United States Government and I confirm that your Note and this reply shall be regarded as constituting an Agreement between our two Governments in the matter effective from the date of this reply.
Accept, Excellency, the renewed assurance of my highest considerations.
That is how agreement was reached. I said agreement was reached and that the Department of Foreign Affairs dealt with this matter as they normally do and that I was not legally qualified to interpret whether this was absolutely legal or not. It was apparently a simple agreement and no such thing as a treaty, such as was emphasised here this afternoon. I am assuming the matter is now understood and accepted.
Comment on this
I cannot accept this, because this is the first thing we knew about this. Nobody has ever heard of this correspondence before. There is no record of it whatever. The document I referred to previously and to which the Minister has already referred is published in the Eire Treaty series 1957-59. The title page reads "Treaty Series 1958, No. 7, Agreement between Ireland and the United States of America. Subsidiary to the Agreement of 17th June, 1954, respecting the use of the Counterpart for the establishment of an Agricultural Institute, signed in Dublin 16th April, 1958." The point is that that agreement is an agreement between the United States and Ireland, not between the Government of the United States and the representative from the Government of Ireland. In other words, it is something that has been processed through the normal parliamentary procedure. It was laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas.
So the correspondence which the Minister has quoted is just correspondence. I am glad to see that there was some correspondence and that there actually is some substance to what the Minister has said, but let us recall what we elicited earlier in the debate. The Minister pointed out that he was responsible for this Bill. He knew everything about the Bill. Then, when we asked him about the reference to the agreement, he said it was in the explanatory memorandum, which has no legal significance at all. Then the Minister comes in and says he has never seen the agreement.
We are being asked to swallow this. This is not a party political matter. There are the serried ranks of Fianna Fáil waiting to hop up after me. Fine, but any Opposition would do this in a situation in which there was a lacuna of that nature in the Bill. The Minister more or less said to me when I raised the question first of all "Trust me; I trust the Department of Foreign Affairs." The Minister has shown that there is a substantive correspondence and there is clearly going to be agreement but when will that agreement be ratified? We should be discussing this Bill and this section after an agreement has been properly ratified between the United States and Ireland and not when the Government or some Government officer in Ireland has written to some Government officer in the United States and had a nice pleasant correspondence starting "Your Excellency" and all that sort of stuff. There is none of "Your Excellency" in this; that is an agreement.
Comment on this
If it was an official agreement, surely the Minister would have seen it? The Minister for Agriculture, the person involved.
Comment on this
The point is that the Minister comes into the House with a Bill which we have resisted for various very good reasons on this side of the House, as any Opposition would, as the gentlemen over there would resist if they were in Opposition. I was in Opposition with them not so long ago. They would have been hopping up and down resisting this as hard as they could and they would have been perfectly right. This is what the democratic process is about and what I am doing is well within my rights. I have elicited from the Minister that he never saw this correspondence and yet he came in with this Bill. That is a really preposterous situation. I am quite prepared to acknowledge that there will be an agreement and that it will be properly ratified legally but I do not hold that that is the position now.
My argument—and I said this all along when I paid a tribute to the Minister and his advisers—is that the techniques that sometimes work in Brussels are not necessarily the ones to apply here. This is being pushed through. There is a steamroll on. When I heard that the Minister had brought in a Bill without ever reading the text of the agreement, I said that there was something funny going on, and it has turned out that something very funny is going on. The proper procedure is that the agreement be placed before the Houses of the Oireachtas, that it be ratified and then the Bill should be brought in. But how can we go on discussing section 10 when we have an agreement which is only correspondence, though I agree it will become an agreement.
This is a Parliament. It is not just a Fine Gael cumann or a Fianna Fáil cumann or a Labour cumann. It is not any cumann. It is now quarter to eight and we are still on section 10, the crucial section. I still hold that the agreement should be ratified by laying it before the Oireachtas so that we have an opportunity to table a motion against it. When has it appeared on the Order Paper of either of the two Houses? That is when this agreement becomes a legal agreement, after it has gone through the Oireachtas. Why should we on this occasion, just to facilitate the Minister, bypass the normal procedures? That is what I want to know. I would have been quite happy—as I have said, I would have got the 6.30 train to Cork—if the Minister could have produced an agreement that was really an agreement that had been ratified and gone through in the normal way.
Comment on this
It is only Tuesday night and not Friday night.
Comment on this
I like to go home on Tuesday nights too. I do not know where Senator Quinlan normally spends his Tuesday nights. He has a good time in Dublin any time. No better man for a good Tuesday night in Dublin, whatever his views on the last Bill were.
Comment on this
Perhaps Senator West would return to the present Bill.
Comment on this
I have made my point on this. The whole procedure is totally wrong. I am prepared to accept that at some stage there will be an agreement. I do not think that correspondence of that nature constitutes an agreement. A Minister can come in here and produce correspondence—your excellency this and your excellency that—but an agreement becomes an agreement when it is laid before the Houses and it has gone through the normal procedure. I would have gone home and shut up hours ago if I had the agreement. Neither the Minister nor his officials had a copy of the agreement here. They had to go scuttling off at the tea interval. What sort of performance is that? I am the black sheep in all of this. I know I have started a hare. But I am doing just what a democrat should do. Thank God, there are a few Independent university Senators around.
Comment on this
Senator West expressed the view that this was neither a Fianna Fáil cumann or a Labour cumann.
Comment on this
It is not but at least it should not be reduced to the level of a university debating society. It would be discussed at a common-sense, down-to-earth level if it was a Fianna Fáil, a Labour or a Fine Gael cumann.
Comment on this
The Senator has only just appeared out of the back rooms of the Fianna Fáil cumann or the Fine Gael cumann.
Comment on this
The Chair must intervene here to say that it is highly disorderly for Senators to refer either to the absence or to the presence of other Senators.
Comment on this
In fairness to Senator West, he was referring to the documents rather than the personnel. Am I right? I hope so anyhow. Otherwise I am merely being unnecessarily charitable.
Comment on this
Of course an agreement is a meeting of minds. An agreement can be made in a number of different ways. An agreement need not necessarily be in writing at all. I will not give Senator West a lecture on law but I think he should understand fundamentals, whether they are spoken at the level of a Fianna Fáil cumann, a Labour cumann or a Fine Gael cumann or even a university debating society. An agreement is a meeting of minds, two parties. It can be carried into effect in writing, by verbal exchange or it can be in the solemn form of an executed deed. It can be an agreement between nations, it can be treaty ratified by Parliaments or it can be an agreement between Governments. I do not know the history of all this but I know that in the Agriculture (An Foras Talúntais) Act, 1958, it was referred to not as a treaty but as an agreement between the two Governments. If Senator West had taken the trouble to read section 10 of the 1958 Act he would see in subsection (5):
In this and the next following section "the Counterpart Special Account" means the American Grant Counterpart Special Account established by the Minister for Finance in the Central Bank of Ireland pursuant to Article IV of the Economic Co-operation Agreement between the Government and the Government of the United States of America, dated the 28th day of June, 1948.
Senator West went to town, or thought he was going to town, on his reading of the situation that this was not an agreement between Governments and it was not good enough for this Government by an exchange of letters to come to an agreement with the American Government. According to the 1958 Act the whole thing was an agreement between Governments.
Certainly the correspondence which the Minister has read out is as solemn, as formal and as binding an agreement between Governments as it would be possible to get in business being operated between two democratic countries with democratic Governments. There was a formal proposition put by the Minister for Foreign Affairs on behalf of the Irish Government. A formal proposal was made. The manner in which the proposed agreement should become operative if accepted was again formally proposed in that correspondence by the Minister for Foreign Affairs. It was accepted in the manner in which it was proposed, again formally and solemnly on behalf of the American Government.
Could anything be more reasonable, more open, more honest or more simple than to carry out and transact an agreement between two democratic Governments in that way? What is sinister about that? I have forgotten precisely how Senator West put it and I do not wish to be unfair to him but he seemed to be honestly under the impression that there was something sinister in this, that some kind of back-room manoeuvring was going on to enable the Minister to come into the House with this Bill. He takes the Minister to task because the Minister was not able to give chapter and verse.
Comment on this
Let me get to the point. One of the essential ingredients of an agreement is that there should be trust. In any community we can only do our business on the basis that there should be trust and honesty, certainly as between colleagues in the same Government—and it applies to this Government. A degree of trust exists between one Minister and another and between one Department and another. Is not this merely normal practice? Is it not just an exercise in ordinary trust that the Minister for Agriculture and his Department should be prepared to accept, if it was done in this way, the word of the Minister for Foreign Affairs and his Department that the proposal was made and had been agreed by the American Government? It was not necessary for the Minister to come in here with that information. The Minister—and I do not say this sarcastically—is, no doubt among the best Ministers for Agriculture we have ever had in this country.
Comment on this
I have said that several times and I stand over it.
Comment on this
He is not clairvoyant. He is not possessed of the power of knowing in advance every thought that will pass through the mind of Senator West or any other Senator when he talks on a five-word section which says the institute is hereby dissolved. How is that going to give the Minister any clue that there is going to be a witch hunt engaged in by Senator West or anyone else to inquire as to exactly how an agreement was made, what were the terms of the agreement and all the rest of it. Is it fair, having regard to the fact that the Minister is not clairvoyant, to charge him with something on the lines of negligence in that he did not foresee that Senator West was going to look for the terms of this agreement and has not got it in front of them in order to deal with this five-word section?
Comment on this
The Minister was taken to task as I understood it, and I listened carefully to the last remarks of Senator West. I confess, quite openly, that I did not think it necessary to listen to his various other contributions to this section but I did listen to the last and, as I understood it, he was taking the Minister to task because the Minister had not got it here in order to answer everything that Senator West erupted with before the debate.
That is the situation. An agreement is there. The Minister has read out the simple terms of the agreement, the solemn agreement that was arrived at. He has been in conformity with the procedures here, undertaken that that will go into the Oireachtas Library. If Senator West or anybody else has not been able to digest the meaning of it when the Minister read it out, no doubt they will have ample opportunity of doing so if they find it necessary to go down to the Library to peruse it any further. But now we have the additional advantage that it will appear in the records of this House.
Senator West said a very considerable length of time has already been taken up in debating this section. He is quite right, an unusually long time has been taken up in debating this section. I marvel at the patience of the Minister, and if the Seanad do not feel capable of taking a decision on this after the lengthy discussion that has taken place already, it is unlikely that they will find themselves in a position to take a decision at all on it, and the appropriate thing would be that the question should be put. I do not want to curtail discussion in any way unnecessarily, but if, notwithstanding the undoubted patience of the Minister, Senators feel it necessary to keep hammering home points already made in relation to this five-word section, I would invite the attention of the Chair to that and I will make a formal proposition later.
Comment on this
It is nice to get a lecture on the proprieties from Senator O'Higgins, done in such a pleasant, fatherly style, rather like the one the Minister adopted with me earlier, but I am not as easily put off as that. I would just like to read the title page of the document that I quoted from earlier:—"Treaty series 1958, No. 7, Agreement between Ireland and the United States of America, subsidiary to the agreement of 17th June, 1954, respecting the use of Counterpart for the Establishment of an Agricultural Institute, Dublin, 16th April, 1958,"— and now the crucial words—"presented to Dáil Éireann by the Minister for Foreign Affairs." That is the whole thing. That is what we have been trying to get at. We have made a good deal of progress—even Senator O'Higgins might agree with that—in that we have actually got the terms upon which the next agreement is going to be made. But it is not an agreement in the sense that this is. This was an agreement which had been presented to Dáil Éireann and ratified in the normal sense of the word when the Agricultural Institute Bill, An Foras Talúntais Act, 1958, was debated. Therefore people did not have to go through all this hassling. If we had not gone through all this we would not have known anything about the agreements, or letters or correspondence or whatever status the documents have.
I am not a bit clear about the legal status of those documents. All I am clear about is that they are not an agreement which we are abrogating by the terms of this Bill and by section 10. It is not an agreement in the sense that it is being laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. This is the point I have been trying to make. It seems to have passed completely over Senator O'Higgins's head, but it is the vital point. If this had been laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas earlier this afternoon when I went looking for it I would not have been able to say anything. There was an agreement which amended the agreement of 1958 and I would have, as I said to the Minister, to the Cathaoirleach and to Senator Quinlan, got the half-past six train home to Cork. There would have been none of this trouble.
To get back to my initial point, I think there was something funny going on. I stand over the statement I made. The institute was founded on an agreement and there had to be some amendment of that agreement. There is correspondence suggesting an amendment. The Minister has never read the correspondence. He asked me to trust him because he trusted the Minister for Foreign Affairs. Now, I stand and fall on that. That is not the way to proceed. That is not the way this House should go on, and all this threat about the guillotine and all that, that is not the way to proceed either. If there had been an agreement I would have had no case to make at all. That is not an agreement in the sense that this is an agreement between the United States and Ireland and not just between Governments. It was ratified by laying it before the Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I admitted very early on in this discussion that I had no legal training and consequently I did not feel qualified to interpret an agreement, but that I had been assured by both the Attorney General's office and by Foreign Affairs that the necessary procedures had been followed and that we had been legally released from our obligations under the agreement that existed under An Foras Talúntais. Now, how is any Minister who is not legally qualified to come into the House and say: "I am sorry but we may be acting illegally." I do not know whether Senator West is qualified to say——
Comment on this
If Senator West is not qualified he should not then categorically and emphatically say that this is not being properly done.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that I should not raise the point at all?
Comment on this
That is more or less what Senator O'Higgins said. He talked about me wasting the time of the House. I got all that sort of guff. That is just guff.
Comment on this
Somebody is guffing now, if I may say so. I do not think anybody has the right to hop up and down like this. Now we have an admission. The Senator is admitting that he is not qualified, any more than I am, to decide whether that is a legal document or not that fulfils the obligations, and I think the discussion should end. All of us have to depend on the legal services to tell us whether something is right or wrong, whether we are following the legal procedures or not. I accepted that what the Bill was based on was legal because I was aware of all the tooing and froing that there was between the Department of Agriculture, the Attorney General's office and Foreign Affairs. We were all aware that this agreement existed and that it had to be changed. I think we are making a sing-song about something that is not all that important. We have to accept that people act responsibly and, as Senator O'Higgins says, there must be some trust at some stage. All of us have to depend on somebody to guide us in matters in which we are not qualified ourselves.
Comment on this
Like the Minister, I am not much of a legal expert, but I think that Senator West was correct in elucidating this point. What amazes me is that the Minister for Agriculture, who personifies himself and is personified by his two party backers as the greatest thing that has ever hit this country, the most open man that has ever existed, should produce a Bill in this House although he never saw the legal documents. There is no excuse for that. You are either on top of your job or you are not on top of your job. When questioned on any part of this Bill the Minister should be able to put his hand on top of the file and say, "In case there is any doubt, this is the answer to it".
Comment on this
If he could do that we would not have got the green £.
Comment on this
Senator Killilea should leave Senator Quinlan's activities, political and agricultural, aside and concentrate on section 10.
Comment on this
There is another point apart from this treaty or agreement or whatever one would like to call it. The Minister said here today that what he has done in this section of the Bill is to spread out from the Department of Agriculture, this overloaded Department of his. He has distributed the work to this new board, but An Foras Talúntais was out there all the time. What the Minister has done is just to bring it in. The Minister insinuates that he is putting this section of the Department out to the wind, going to give it its eternal freedom. An Foras Talúntais is out there and has proved itself. This provision is not necessary. Despite the fact that the Minister insisted that some Senators were lobbied I can assure him I was not lobbied. But I have seen the Agricultural Institute at work——
Comment on this
——as the Minister has seen it. There is no need to lobby my support for the Agricultural Institute because I see it every day I get up. The Minister is trying to tell this House that he is actually taking An Foras Talúntais and putting it out there under this body, when, in fact, it was way beyond the body outside and was working far more efficiently than it is going to work in this body.
Comment on this
The Minister did. The records will show that. The Minister said on two occasions "My Department is so overloaded, so much work from the EEC, that I am taking this section and putting it out there." Then one has to take into account this board—and this is really the kernel of all the problem in this Bill—and the formula for selecting the people on it. I am not naive and the Minister is not naive. I know why the Minister is rushing this Bill. The Minister knows why he is rushing this Bill, because he wants his appointees on this board before the end of June or at least before the end of September.
Comment on this
Senator Killilea is straying back to section 9. There are no directorships to be filled under section 10 and he should stick to section 10 and the dissolution.
Comment on this
That is exactly what I am talking about, the dissolution of the institute, An Foras Talúntais. The point I am making is that in so doing under section 10, they are dissolving the system of the board that runs An Foras Talúntais now and creating a new one.
Comment on this
They are not creating a new one under section 10. It is under another section, and the Senator should stick to the dissolution under section 10. That is all that is in section 10.
Comment on this
I would go as far as to say that I have never in my life seen words so strong and so savage, just five short words, brutal, as if it never existed, to be forgotten forever—"The institute is hereby dissolved." It is like quenching a cigarette.
Comment on this
No. I am almost nine years here listening to Senator O'Higgins. I have listened to him here and I am listening to him over there. It must be a particular privilege and pleasure for a Minister to be defended by him in this House. I have watched Senator O'Higgins for years and years and he has a beautiful way of twisting facts just to suit himself. The Minister for Agriculture must really have been proud to be defended by the Leader of the House here this evening.
Comment on this
Senator, do not make the tribute too long.
Comment on this
"The institute is hereby dissolved." It is now being taken away and put into hiding. As a spokesman for our party said in the other House, the first thing that a solid Government would do would be to restore it to the same situation as it was in.
Earlier today, when I made a point concerning the Agricultural Institute or An Foras Talúntais, that it was educational and that it was giving other services, Senator McCartin was quick to his feet to say "No, it never did." But we proved the point quite emphatically when we said: "yes it did" and we quoted the terms of reference in the original Bill. My point still holds, that it was about and around An Foras Talúntais that this new organisation should be created, not by means of the words in section 10: "The institute is hereby dissolved." This is where the eternal mistake has happened in regard to this great organisation that has done a lot of work, most of it voluntary, with enthusiasm, with a willingness and an eagerness always to try and find something extra and something special for that part of the community that needed it so much. Each year and each week and each month they are making progress and they are continuing to make progress.
They will not make progress much longer, because now they are being brought into a political grip under this new board to be created or to be selected by the Minister. I feel certain that those people in authority in the Agricultural Institute will not be happy about them, and have no intention of agreeing with the political "wigwags" that will be picked and if we are to judge by the way the Minister's Government have picked members of other boards they certainly could not be happy with them.
We have seen instances of it in my town. Some of the people are on State boards looking after CIE and they are not able to drive lawnmowers. It is a disgrace. To bring the institute to that level is humiliating. It is one of the biggest marks against the Minister, with the exception of his calamity of 1974. I suppose that will go down in history.
The three grave mistakes the Minister made are that he forgot about the farmers in 1974, he destroyed the institute in 1977, and he defended the taxation of the small farmers in late 1976. These are the three miracles of the man who is being personified by his own party and by his own hacks as the superman of all time for agriculture and for agricultural industry. The three most important points in agriculture are the very ones the Minister stood firmly against.
Comment on this
Senators should not indulge in side conversations with Senator Killilea. I appreciate that he enjoys it.
Comment on this
There are some Senators who hardly have their ears wet and they come in here cheekily as if they knew all the answers. There are an enormous number of small farmers who are depending on the Agricultural Institute for help and guidance. They have been helped and guided all their lives but they now will lack that benefit. The Minister and Senator Ferris know that. Now is the time when we need the Agricultural Institute more than ever. They have given a greater service than even the advisory service. As I mentioned earlier today, the agricultural advisory service, despite what the Minister says, is lacking and has been lacking since this log of work was thrown upon its shoulders by the Department of Agriculture. The Agricultural Institute are the next people who will have the files. Instead of their test tubes and other apparatus to improve farming they will have documents and files. They will be responsible to their board and that board will be responsible to the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister, so far as I can see from his performance on this Bill— he brings a Bill through the House not even knowing of the legal agreement —is certainly being led by top officials in his Department.
Comment on this
I have a formal motion from Senator O'Higgins that the question be now put. I have been in the Chair since 7.15 p.m. and during that time a number of new points have been raised. To accept the question now would be to deprive Members of the House of the opportunity of adequately discussing them. I do not accept the motion.
Comment on this
I want to congratulate the Cathaoirleach on having the sense not to allow Senator O'Higgins or anybody else to bulldoze this legislation through the House. Before the section is passed, we owe it to the people involved in agriculture to fight for a clear undertaking from the Minister and the Department that something better will be put in its place. I congratulate and thank the Cathaoirleach for not allowing the dictator—he is nothing short of that— to push us down.
Comment on this
It would be better if Senators did not comment on decisions of the Chair in regard to such matters.
Comment on this
I welcome them anyway. Before this House agrees to section 10, and agrees to dissolve the Agricultural Institute, we should have as much time as the House needs to discuss every aspect of the Bill and the intentions and provisions of the board. The Minister and his Department have an obligation to satisfy the public that the new board will provide all the services, that the new Bill will be a better one and that it will meet the agricultural needs of today.
The Minister, in his Second Reading speech, says there was a common factor among the suggestions submitted, that the advisory services would need to be re-organised. Even though the Minister recognises that common factor, that is contrary to what we read in section 10, that the advisory service is hereby dissolved. There is a big difference between "re-organised" and "dissolved". The people engaged in agriculture are entitled to be concerned. Far from the attitude of the Government and the Minister allaying that concern, it will only tend to confuse and give people the impression here that the Minister has some cynical reason for bulldozing this Bill through the House. We should have clear undertakings about the board that will replace the institute, to the extent of the advice and help that it will give to farmers, especially at a time when we are standing at the crossroads in agriculture, when there is more than ample evidence that the Department of Agriculture have fallen down completely in their ability to influence agricultural policy in the Common Market. We heard the leader of the IFA stating recently that it was they, after a lot of difficulty, who convinced the Minister as to what the green £ was. The leader of the IFA said it took them nearly two years to educate the Minister. If we are to believe that—and we have no reason not to believe him.
Comment on this
I heard him stating the difficulty he had in educating the Minister for Agriculture about the benefits the green £ would bring to agriculture. The record can be produced, if necessary. Having accepted that the IFA took so long to educate the Department and the Minister on the value of the green £, it is only fair that we should be concerned here about what the new board will do, how powerful they will be and what way they will influence agricultural policy.
Will we be more in touch with the policies of the Common Market? Will the average farmer in rural Ireland today have better advice? Will he be more attuned to what is happening in the Common Market? The Common Market policies, which affect the west of Ireland, are based on what happens in Belgium, France and England. They are totally unrelated to the needs of the average farmer in rural Ireland today. This board will do nothing but perhaps bring about easier administration for the Minister. Our fear is that you are going to produce a board that does nothing to allay the fears that exist already in the agricultural community, that is, that we have a Department that is totally out of touch with the needs of the agricultural community. This has been borne out by the fact that, for example, the farm modernisation policy today is totally unsuited to many farmers in the west. This is due to the totally out of touch administration by the Department of Agriculture.
Therefore, I say I am entitled to question this now before we agree to dissolve an institute that has advised and assisted the farmers in every way. It may not be a perfect advisory service, but we should look at it, extend it, and help to bring what is happening in Europe today to the notice of the farmers and to bring the voice of the farmers to influence policy in Europe. That is not being done by the Department or the Minister, and I fear that it will not be done by this board. I can see nothing here but pure adamancy and dictatorship. That is not what the farmers want. With one voice they propose to guillotine the motion and with another voice say that we must have confidence and trust.
I would ask the Minister to be reasonable about this and to accept that a very serious step is being taken and that the people in agriculture are entitled to be alarmed. Over the last number of years we have seen very little progress in agriculture. Less than two years ago I put down a motion for discussion here, "that this House notes the right of those engaged in agriculture." A Senator from that side of the House complimented the Minister and said that he was recognised as the tiger of Europe. I recognised him as the white elephant of Europe, because there is no Minister in Europe more out of touch with what is happening than our Minister for Agriculture. This is borne out by everybody who is interested in agriculture in the west of Ireland.