National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–195 of 390. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1976 ›
I was criticising the Minister and the Department for the decision to dissolve the institute. Many people in the agricultural industry are very worried about the institution which will replace An Foras Talúntais. There is an outline of the proposed board that will replace the institution and its functions but this is far from satisfying those involved in agriculture. I have listened to many fears being expressed and to the good grounds for those fears. Let us look at some of the boards that exist under the Minister's own Department.
If you will allow me I will refer briefly to the Potato Marketing Board. I would ask the Minister to allay the fears that now exist. The Potato Marketing Board are under the Minister's control. One of the nominees of the General Council is still acting on the Potato Marketing Board and is no longer——
Comment on this
The Senator asked the Minister to deal with this point. I am afraid I must intervene to say that it is very wide of section 10 and it would be most undesirable for a debate to continue along the lines of such specific points which, if related at all, are very tenuously related, to the question of the abolition of this particular body.
Comment on this
With respect to the Chair, I am trying not to go wide of the section here, but I must——
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Senator is trying and I do not want to interrupt him, but up to now his contribution has been related to the section. While he has been trying not to go wide, I am afraid he has not succeeded, he has gone considerably wide of the section.
Comment on this
I respect fully the Chair's wishes that I should keep to section 10. The agricultural community are far from satisfied that the Minister has given any clear indication of what will replace the Agricultural Institute. The broad outlines are there, but one has to look at what is going to replace the institute. The only knowledge we have is of other similar boards that exist under the Minister's control. I must refer again to the experience of boards already in existence. We in the west have got a very raw deal. We feel that whatever organisation replaces the institute, the farming community will get a very raw deal. This is quite a genuine fear. We feel all this has been necessary because of the sluggish inactivity in the Department of Agriculture. We felt that the taking away of fisheries would open the door and that the Minister for Agriculture would become active in the day-to-day administration of agricultural affairs. We welcomed that decision and hoped the Minister would get down to business. This is far from anything like that. The Minister is pushing the problems further away from him. If we look at the size of the country and the amount of business, we will see that this is a small area. It is really only a small region in Europe.
To abolish an advisory service that has been established, trusted and proved is a backward step. The advisory service can be a much better service if it is kept completely aloof. People engaged in agriculture believe that it is much better if it is kept away from the practical side of agriculture. To dissolve it and amalgamate it with something that is uncertain and over which the Minister will only have remote control, only makes people engaged in agriculture suspicious.
The Minister may argue that he will have a completely new approach to agriculture but this does not give those people confidence. When the Minister saw fit to abolish the Agricultural Institute, he should have looked at the whole agricultural administration and done a first-class job. This is only piecemeal, and those engaged in agriculture will demand at the first opportunity that this decision be reversed.
I am precluded from giving details of what I believe to be the experience of those in agriculture of the committees set up under the Minister. I will be able to give these details under other sections, but they will only confirm the fears that the new board will not be in the best interests of those in the agricultural industry today. This is a clumsy effort to encourage those people to believe that the Minister is active.
I am a member of Donegal County Council. They applied to this Minister two years ago to have approval for a sheep dipping bath. There was a political involvement here because a local sheep dipping inspector recommended his uncle's land as a site. That Minister did not act on behalf of those engaged in agriculture. I am pointing this out to show the Minister's lack of sincerity. My colleagues put down a parliamentary question but it did not make any difference. Despite the fact that the chief veterinary officer and the Donegal County Council made a recommedation for the siting of the sheep dipping bath, for the past two years this Minister for Agriculture did not make a decision. Is that being active? How does one relate sincerity in that instance to sincerity here? How could the Minister expect people in my county to believe that he is going to do something for agriculture? I do not believe it and I know many more involved in agriculture who do not believe that this is a sincere and honest attempt to bring the agricultural organisation up to what is needed in Ireland and Europe today. This lack of sincerity does nothing to allay the fears that have been expressed in the industry.
There is no widespread acceptance from the farming community, the IFA or anybody else. I only hope the Government will soon see that this is not a popular move. We are restricted on this section, but we will have to show the public that we are sincere in challenging this move. To abolish an agricultural institute that was ready to give good service to the country, which has been long establised, long trusted and long accepted, is the most ridiculous step that has ever been taken in either House. I hope the day will soon come when we are able to re-establish the agricultural advisory service.
Comment on this
We should get back to reality in this section. The first fact is that for the last 20 to 25 years the agricultural sector have demanded the reorganisation of the advisory services. It was recognised that the country was proving too small a unit to allow the efficient utilisation of the expert and special skills in the service. Also, it was recognised that while the county committees had done good work, again there was too much of a political flavour about the county committees as such and it was necessary that the rural organisations, especially the farming organisations, should be involved and get representation. These organisations have emerged only in the last 20 or 25 years. They have emerged fast and are now comparable to corresponding farmer and producer organisations anywhere. They have done us proud. Their development over the past 20 to 25 years has been a great tribute to many, but especially to the advisers who nurtured Macra ne Feirme in the early fifties. One of those advisers is seated behind the Minister today. We pay tribute to their work——
Comment on this
Reference to persons present in their official capacity is not appropriate.
Comment on this
I want to pay a general tribute to the members of the advisory service who contributed so much to the developments in Macra na Feirme, which, in turn was responsible for the development of the IFA. We have that genuine demand for these services. That demand was realised in England 25 years ago when the National Agricultural Advisory Service was set up there. There is a need for intertwining research and advisory work. The pattern, by and large, has been set. As far as I know, farmers organisations and other bodies have been in favour of the organisation.
What are we making a song and dance about? Of course there is some genuine fear. A number of research people would like a little more protection. That can be achieved. I have put down amendments which would ensure that the deputy director would get a certain sum out of the budget for research. The Minister's view seems to be that that can be achieved and that he would expect the council to do that of their own accord. Somebody at deputy director level should be expected to be responsible for that and, provided it would be perfectly legitimate to have Dáil questions, we could extract a breakdown of the figure in the Vote for the newly reorganised body that is accountable for the research services. If we can get that, then there cannot be any running down of research.
Naturally, we are reluctant to see the name, the Agricultural Institute, disappear. It was suggested, and some might feel rightly so, that the institute could have been expanded to include the advisory services. If that had been done, we would have a bigger row here than we have at the moment. The advisory services, who regard themselves as in the front line with the research people at their back, would regard that as a takeover by the research arm. We have to strike a balance. The present reorganisation has been accepted with certain reservations or suggestions of change by all the leading organisations connected with agriculture. If that is the case, I do not see why we should have such ologóning on the passage of this Bill.
I am not at all happy with the name. I can understand——
Comment on this
I would remind the Senator that the only name mentioned in section 10 is that of the Agricultural Institute.
Comment on this
I am not happy at losing that name. If it is at all possible I know that the partners in this— and the advisory service, numerically, are probably the larger partner—have an interest in the name. I do not think anyone could have an interest in the name NAAERA.
Comment on this
I must intervene. The Senator is now going over matters which were dealt with on an earlier section. The name of the new body does not come within the scope of the debate on section 10.
Comment on this
We are abolishing the name of the Agricultural Institute.
Comment on this
The position is that the question of the name of the new institute was adequately debated on an earlier section yesterday. This debate should not be entered into. The fact that the Cathaoirleach was not in the Chair at the time should not mislead Senators into thinking that it can be debated on a later section with impunity.
Comment on this
I respect the Cathaoirleach on this point. We would feel happier to accept section 10 if we had a name that came somewhat nearer to the one we are changing. In section 10 we are abolishing a name that is well known, both nationally and internationally. We are abolishing the Agricultural Institute, An Foras Talúntais. The same functions continue, the same work continues, but according to the wording of this Bill section 10 abolishes this body. There must be some other way of saying this because we are not abolishing the Agricultural Institute.
I hope the new institute will lead agricultural research in the years ahead into bigger and greater activities and that there will be more funds placed at their disposal because our whole future depends on agricultural production. The Agricultural Institute has made a major contribution to the future of agriculture since its foundation. This has saved us and enabled us to ride relatively well out of the recession of the last couple of years. There was a tremendous depression everywhere, but 50 per cent of our exports are agricultural exports. Because of the work of the institute and others, agriculture had a boom period while other countries suffered as a result of the depression. I would like to pay tribute to those who have helped so much in the creation of these conditions.
I do not see why we should drag out the passage of this Bill or why we should contribute to creating unnecessary or undue alarm. Some Senators asked if the abolition of the institute was legal. I think the Minister answered last evening that its passage had been cleared. I wish there could have been some better way of wording section 10 than its present terse form, but that is the work of the parliamentary draftsman. If he could come up with a better formula it would be accepted, but it is still something that should not be raised to the extent of creating national alarm and anxiety amongst research people. As the debate progressed, I believe that there is no need for alarm. I am sure that the assurances we seek can be got on a later section.
Comment on this
I must reiterate my distress at the bleakness of that formulation. As Senator Ferris said, the formulation itself is so final, total and pitiless that it seems to destroy and set at naught the entire existence and identity of the institute. I do not know whether we can meet Senator Ferris's suggestion that perhaps a better formulation could be found. For my own part I wonder if, instead of just bleakly opposing the section, as the Opposition propose to do in their amendment, the Minister would not accept some such formulation as: "The Institute, while retaining its name and identity, is hereby brought under the authority of the NAAERA". Would it be an enormous abrogation or surrender in principle to allow the name to survive in some form within section 10? The words, "The Institute is hereby dissolved" and summarised as "Dissolution of Institute", are bleak and final and disheartening for other bodies of the same kind. The man who formulated that section must have received training in Belsen or elsewhere, or perhaps in Lewis Carroll's fiction—"off with its head"; end, dissolution, instant apocalypse at the stroke of a pen.
It seems that a better formulation could be found, but the thought behind it is rather callous. I would suggest that it would not be a surrender of any kind of principle to say that "The Institute, while retaining its name and identity, is hereby brought under the authority of the NAAERA", that is of course if you do not change the latter rather clumsy appellation.
Comment on this
I have sat very patiently listening to the various comments in this debate. I am speaking on this debate because I am angry. A person employed in industry can be sent for and told that there will be no work for him in four weeks' time. We pass Acts to facilitate that arrangement, to ensure that certain moneys will be provided, that it would be legal for the employer to embark on this course of action and so on. We say we are doing that in the name of change and that we think change and progress are necessary. The whole basis of this debate seems to be that we do not mind change so long as it affects the other fellow. On the one hand you are able to send for someone and say "you are redundant, you are gone" and there is nothing wrong with that, and we pass legislation to approve it. But when we come to what legal terminology can be used when you are merging certain sectors in the agricultural field, that is different. It seems to be very hard to say that an institution is dissolved, but it is not too difficult to say to a man "your job is gone".
The arguments on this section are a bit crazy. I have listened with great tolerance to the whole situation. I am not arguing about the rest of the Bill. I am merely arguing about this particular section. I am not the type of person who goes along with closure motions. It was quite right to allow the debate to develop the way it did. But we are getting a bit of a hangup on this, and my points have not been heard up to now I would like to ask Senators a question: would they stand up and scream when a man is being made redundant, or when a company is going out of existence because of a merger or for some other reason? No matter which way you describe it, the job is gone. I cannot see the common sense in this argument.
It is proposed in this Bill to merge certain bodies, which happen to be under an executive agency, and there will be a board. If this Bill dealt with industry or anything else, the same thing would happen; one body would have to lose its identity. Other people lose their identity. A worker loses his identity if he is moved from one job to another. He loses his identity completely if his job is taken away from him. I cannot see why we have these crocodile tears about the change of a name. I am not arguing about the rest of the Bill. I believe there were some very good points made in respect of it, but I think the arguments in this case are weak.
Comment on this
I am going to keep my contribution to two minutes flat. I want to emphasise why we are opposing this section. I believe it is unamendable. I accept that if the Minister wants an executive agency of the Department of Agriculture, hogtied to the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Finance, that that sort of innocuous, anonymous name is all right for an organisation or agency of that kind. Fundamentally we are opposing the section because we believe that the basic principle of the Bill, removing an independent autonomous research organisation which has the capacity to expand into the educational and advisory areas is disastrously wrong and capable of very serious deterioration in the administration of agricultural education, research and advice.
Briefly, that is our position on the matter. We think that this whole expansion of the area of activity of the Agricultural Institute could be much more easily done by an amendment of the existing Agriculture (An Foras Talúntais) Act, 1958, by adding these extra functions in the areas of education and advice to it. In that manner we preserve what is good and add all that is required to it by way of an amendment giving it extended functions. That is our straightforward position. We are opposed to this section. We, like others here, think it is unamendable. If the Minister wants to set up an agency, as seems to be the basic principle throughout the Bill, then that sort of name is as good as any name or label.
Comment on this
I have already contributed on this section. I, apologetically, stand up again. I would ask the Minister, in view of all that has been said—and I know he is restricted in what he must do in this section—if there is any way in which he could convince the institute that they are not being dissolved? You know they are not being dissolved. I know the Minister does not want to dissolve them; he wants to repeal the Act which set them up. Can the Minister not say that the institute are hereby dissolved and their functions transferred to the new board? Can the Minister not add any rider to this that would make it more evident and more convincing that they are not being dissolved? Surely there must be a half dozen words that can be used to protect their identity, which is what we are trying to do, when we know it is being protected? Surely, the Parliamentary draftsmen are not so lacking in ingenuity in the use of the English language as to be unable to convince them that they are being transferred. We know they are. Why not say it in this section?
Comment on this
I have gone to a good deal of trouble previously indicating why it was necessary to do it in this way. I went back to the office of the Attorney General and I was told there was no other way to do it. I have to accept legal advice on this. What Senator Ferris is looking for is being done exactly and is explained in section 17 of this Bill, where it shows everything that is being transferred totally to the new authority and preserved there— all the things they do at the moment and some additional things which they will be doing under this new authority. While it looks, as some people have said, harsh and cruel, we overestimate the sensitivity and delicacy of people dealing with agriculture in this country. In the main, they are people with their feet on the ground. There is a lot of nonsense being talked about all this, if I may say so. It is similar to the nonsense talked here this morning by Senator McGowan about the people in the west of Ireland.
The people in the west of Ireland have never done better and that is true particularly of Donegal. Of course, he is preparing for an election which he imagines is coming up later on in the year, but it has nothing at all to do with the Bill. That is all I want to say except that quite genuine concern was expressed here yesterday evening that we were acting, perhaps, illegally. I got some additional information on this point. The change in the agreement was notified in Iris Oifigiúil on the 1st February, 1977. It is provided that every international agreement to which the State becomes a party shall be laid before Dáil Éireann but it has not to be ratified. It has just to be laid before Dáil Éireann. This agreement will appear in the Treaty Series published annually. All the legal requirements have been fulfilled in this case. That is the point I was endeavouring to make. We would be very foolish if we were proceeding illegally having got all the advice we could possibly get from the legal resources of the Government and from Foreign Affairs. I hope that anxiety has now been removed.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 7, line 23, to delete ", advisory and research" and substitute "and advisory".
I believe in reality; I do not believe in repetition. Fundamentally the point we have down here in this amendment has been very adequately dealt with in our earlier amendments and it is really consequential on the sort of attitude we have expressed both on the Second Stage and in our earlier amendments that the research functions should be deleted from this Bill in order to maintain the independence of research and the autonomous aspect that is so essential if research work is to be carried out properly in an environment free from day-to-day control which is envisaged in this Bill, free from day-to-day financial management restrictions.
This view was expressed at all Stages during the passage of the Agricultural Institute Bill through the Dáil and the Seanad by all parties and notably at the time by the then Taoiseach, Mr. de Valera and Mr. James Dillon, who spoke in the Dáil very eloquently on this aspect of the importance of independence in regard to research functions. This independence as operated heretofore by the institute in regard to research is now being diminished substantially. In fact, this is one of the main purposes of the Bill—to diminish the independent research functions heretofore operated by the institute. Research, along with the other areas to be controlled by the new agency, will in effect be submitted to the day-to-day accounting procedures of the Departments of Agriculture and Finance. The purpose of the amendment—we know it is not possible to implement this but we are just being consistent in suggesting it—is to have research deleted from the functions of the Bill and the institute rendered independent to operate as heretofore.
Now, while it does seem that is impossible, I would like to hear from the Minister. I am sure he appreciated as well as I do the importance of having research dealt with in a rather different way from the administration point of view, compared with other aspects of administration. Given that this Bill goes through and given that this amendment is not acceptable—we will not push it beyond just making the case—given all that, would the Minister give some assurance to the House as to the possibility of an independent division of the new agency? I appreciate this would be a matter for the new board, but the Minister of course will have a strong say in putting a point of view on this aspect of having an independent division of the new body devoted to research with the possibility of a deputy director in charge of this independent section and the possibility of a different type of financial allocation towards that division as compared with the other operations of the new agency. This, at least, would be a constructive reassurance and in the event of such a reassurance being forthcoming I would accept the reality and withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
I could not accept the amendment. First of all, I think the authority would be a very weak authority if research was not included. Research is so vital to the industry that we are talking about—the agricultural industry—that it must be included in the authority. Research must have its say in the functioning of the authority and must have a say on the board. Having a say on the board, it will be able to put its point to that board. Without research, you can only go so far, and the advisory section and the educational section cannot fulfil what is required for the industry as a whole unless research is included. I would accept that there must be a committee which would represent research but that committee must be within the authority. I would also accept that there should be a deputy director responsible for that committee. I would hope that the new board would set up such a committee and such a deputy director. This is what is required for the country: We want to get agriculture going. We want to get full development of agriculture and unless we have that, unless we have all sections combined with one another, then we cannot have full development in agriculture.
Comment on this
For the many reasons that I have already given in relation to sections 7 and 10, I must oppose the amendment. I think I have given all the assurances that should be reasonably required by the Members of the Opposition that I want to see research, not only continuing in its previous functions and its previous independence but I want to see these functions and the scope of the institute's work enlarged. In fact, I am making such provision in the Bill. Therefore, I find it difficult to understand why we require any further assurance. In regard to the ideas that Senator Lenihan had as far back as 20 years ago, I have to remind him that over all these years— 16 of them—his own Government were in office and he, as a Minister for so many years in that Government, was not able to impress his views on them and make the changes he pleaded should have been made over the years.
Comment on this
I have a query on paragraph (e) which says the authority may
provide scholarships to students of agriculture at institutions of higher education, or such other institutions as may be approved by the Minister;
I take it that it is first of all accepted that, as far as institutions of higher education refer to the universities or to other bodies eligible for the type of four honour grants, those of course are open to all students. I presume what is at issue here are some scholarships over and above those, that aid in the recruitment into certain areas which in the judgment of the institute board are areas that need a certain boost.
Comment on this
In this section I am simply transferring the Minister's present responsibility for scholarships to the new body.
Comment on this
The grants for creamery manager training and so on presumably come under this.
Comment on this
I think this is a very important section. If a certain criticism might be made of the Agricultural Institute in the past it was that there was not sufficient co-operation. There was some, but I would like to have seen more of it. I hope that in the future every encouragement will be given to this and especially co-operation in developing research and encouraging the universities to play their full part in it. I think there is a big field there and I hope the maximum co-operation will be sought and given.
Comment on this
Section 14 is a ticklish one implementing directives of the EEC. Some of those directives may be rather controversial. In fact we suffer from the defect in the EEC that we are committed to carrying out what is agreed. It may be something that we would not do and indeed that we recognise as not being in the very best interest of our own section, but yet we have to carry it out. On the other hand, it may not be good that the advisory service should have the odium of having to either try to sell something they do not really believe in or carry out certain directives that the Minister has probably done his best earlier to resist. At this stage we have no option but to carry them. But there is always that question about the advisory services in implementing policy that, where policy is wrong or has certain overtones, it undermines a certain amount of the confidence in the advisory service. I wonder is this even a greater difficulty now when it involves directives from the EEC.
Comment on this
I just want to say that this work is already going on in the advisory services. An example is Directive 161. It is about the authority providing courses, not implementing the policy of EEC or EEC directives.
Comment on this
I know that the Minister himself has given this advice at times, which was that we should not fall for switching over to beef and so on.
Comment on this
And the advisory service will still be in a position to give advice that may be counter to what the EEC wish for the Community as a whole?
Comment on this
We will leave that to Senator West; he is an expert on bulls.
Comment on this
First, but without withdrawing from my firm opinion that this whole matter could be met by an amendment of the existing legislation, I would like to say that I agree in principle with what is incorporated here in regard to the advisory functions. There is no question but that there is a need for this sort of direction in regard to the advisory services throughout the country. I see no reason why the existing institute could not have assimilated these functions as set out in section 15 by a simple amendment of the existing legislation. However, we have gone over all that ground, but certainly, in general, I feel it is desirable that an overall national policy in regard to agriculture should be brought home to every farmer on a regionalised basis throughout the country, having regard to the different needs and requirements of each area of the country, and that we should have a co-ordinated approach to the advisory services backed up by the sort of research that is available, has been available, and hopefully will be available under the new authority so that I go along in principle with the section here.
Just one question to the Minister, and I know that this has been contentious internally between the institute and the Department over the years or so my information goes: it is not really relevant to this work; it is more relevant to the research function on section 17. So, I will not raise it here at this stage. Certainly, as far as the principle of this section is concerned and on the assumption that this authority is inevitable I have no objection whatever to the advisory service being added to it.
Comment on this
I am very pleased that Senator Lenihan is coming around now to my views in relation to this Bill and the ideas behind it.
Comment on this
I think the Minister for Agriculture will have difficulty in convincing the agricultural community that the advisory service is going to be any better. In fact, in my county the committee of agriculture actually has done a useful job. If it has fallen down anywhere it has fallen down because of restraints that the Minister and his Department put on it. The agricultural advisory service has been first class but any difficulties and any restrictions are due to the lack of response and the lack of action and the lack of communication by the Minister and his Department. I am familiar with the advisory service and the administration of the farm modernisation scheme in Donegal at the moment. It saddened me to see how little authority the committees of agriculture had in giving advice and the restraints that were placed on them by the Minister.
I do not see any new attitude here; in fact I see more restrictions, more difficulties, more problems, more reports from one advisory service to the other. We shall have local committees now in a county giving a report to a body or board and which in turn will be giving a report to the Minister. We shall have the whole Department and the whole system clogged with reports from one advisory service to the other. I speak with knowledge of my own county and, right across the Border, where we have the farm modernisation scheme in progress in two counties, County Donegal and County Tyrone, side by side. I am certainly in a position to look at them. The farmers in County Tyrone actually have no difficulty. They have one advisory centre. The local committee of agriculture is on the ground giving advice, giving practical knowledge and administering the grants. This is a cumbersome arrangement here, where one section of the farm advisory service is advising by report. I see nothing but trouble and delay. I only hope that the Minister will finance this whole service and that he will cut out any red tape and delay in providing the service. Last year's headage grant scheme is not yet completed in Donegal, and the Minister has already embarked on paper on next year's scheme and has reduced the headage payments.
The Bill will do nothing to modernise the farm advisory service, to make it more easily understood and more easily availed of by the farming community. The difficulty is that of late, and more especially since we have become Europeanised, committees of agriculture have not been allowed to play their part in giving an advisory service. In Donegal we have an advisory service split into three parts. Any man who applies for farm modernisation scheme advice, planning or grant has to first send his application to Lifford, then it is referred to Raphoe and it finishes up with an inspector of the Department and final examinations are made from Letterkenny. I do not see anything in this Bill that will streamline or replace this system or will help the committee of agriculture on the ground to be more efficient. This is out of control. It is a useless exercise on paper that is being put forward by the brains trust in his Department, far removed from the practicalities that are needed on the ground. I am sorry that the grasp of the Minister of the needs of the agricultural community is slipping away all the time. This will be seen to be so if this legislation is carried through.
Comment on this
I should like to say that Senator McGowan is speaking only for himself. He is not speaking for the farming community because organised farming set up a group to study what is being done and I quoted what they had to say. I will have to quote it again:
The Minister must be congratulated for introducing this Bill to streamline the operation for the advisory, education and research services to farmers. With a few minor amendments this authority will be very capable of meeting the challenges of the ages.
In relation to Donegal and the operations of the modernisation scheme, which is not included in this, we have not had one single complaint and we have not had an application for one single extra member of staff to carry out the modernisation scheme in Donegal. As far as the payment of grants in Donegal is concerned, when I came into the Department I found that there was a backlog of two years; now it is only a matter of two months, if it is that. All this does not cut any ice with me.
Comment on this
I do not accept what the Minister says. It costs him nothing to reply in that tone and he has no records here. I hope he will go back and consult his records. This is a totally inaccurate reply he has given. There is widespread disillusionment in Donegal about the farm modernisation scheme. Those are facts. The Minister gave a misleading answer in the other House not too long ago when he gave the number of people that are accepted. I have been a member of the committee of agriculture for 15 years. I know the number of applications in Donegal. It is nearly 3,000. I know the number who are accepted as development farmers in Donegal, and the Minister knows it, but he is not honest enough to give the reply as it should be given. The farming community in Donegal do not believe that the Minister and the Department have been pursuing the best interests of agriculture.
Comment on this
There is a query about section 15 (g). I take it the authority here is permissive rather than mandatory. In other words, "the authority may, in particular"—is that "may" just permissive? Paragraph (g) states:
adopt measures to ensure that those engaged in agriculture——
and paragraph (g) (ii) states:
are encouraged to avail themselves of those schemes and facilities;
I have in mind the General EEC policy of encouraging people within the Community to get out of milk and providing certain financial inducements towards this. We all recognise that, while that may be good policy in the Community as a whole, as far as we are concerned, we are by far the best situated area in the Community for milk production. It is our life line. The Minister has said so again and again. Therefore, I would like to feel that the "may" was permissive and that if the board, and indeed the general agricultural opinion, shared the view that it was not wise for us to drag our feet in this situation, in this directive, that the "may" would be permissive rather than mandatory. Am I correct?
Comment on this
There is no question of the new authority being compelled to do something that would be detrimental to the development of agriculture in this country.
Comment on this
I will not go into the whole aspect of the importance of independents and autonomous operation of research functions in agriculture and, indeed, research in any area. I should like to ask the Minister a question. I notice in the list of agricultural research and basic veterinary research activities under subsection (2), giving the authority discretion to carry on various activities in that area, there is no question of agricultural marketing research mentioned in any of the functions. Did the Minister and his Department give thought to the idea of having agricultural marketing research included as one of the functions in that area? Unless there is a link between research activities and actual marketing there is an important practical element missing.
Comment on this
In the Second Stage debate, volume 86, column 656, I referred to the interpretation of the words "basic veterinary research" which appears in section 17 (1), section 17 (2) (g) and section 17 (2) (k).
I stated:
In my opinion and in the opinion of other people the term "basic veterinary research" is negative and meaningless.
I have made suggestions to the Minister to delete the word "basic" before the word "veterinary" in each of these sections. I realise and have agreed that the Minister, under EEC Regulations, must retain unto himself and his Department of Agriculture responsibility for veterinary research on the compulsory disease eradication programme, notifiable disease and so on. Veterinary research as I have outlined it in my contribution and in a memorandum to the Minister should be part of the board's function. Between now and Report Stage I should like the Minister to consider seriously my suggestions in this regard and that sections 2 and 17 which refer to the restrictive basic research should be looked at with a view to incorporating my thoughts and those of many others involved in veterinary research.
There are other sections which deal with grey areas which may be areas of disagreement as to whether they are applied research or otherwise. I know it is only technical, but it has a fundamental bearing on the importance of this board and the importance of veterinary research to the agricultural community and the availability of veterinary research to the board proper so that they can continue their full programme. I am prepared to wait for Report Stage if the Minister would give me the commitment that he would look at my submission to this.
Comment on this
I was going to raise the same point as was raised by Senator Ferris. The words "basic veterinary research" seem to be very unusual. It seems to exclude only (a) and (b) on page five, that is, the functions specifically reserved to the Minister. Elsewhere, it places veterinary research on the same level as agricultural research. I do feel there is a difference between the two in that there are very few veterinary research facilities coming under the authority at present. Those research facilities are in the veterinary college, whereas there are agricultural research facilities in the universities. The institute has also got a very wide range of those, so obviously there is more scope for it in carrying out agricultural research rather than veterinary research. I would like to feel that, in the years ahead, this is something which will be kept under review, and that there would not be a parallel development in veterinary research in the institute and the policy would be to centralise it in the veterinary college.
Comment on this
This matter was raised in the Dáil also. In replying to that in the Dáil, in Volume 298, I stated:
In the functions being transferred there are clear areas and grey areas. What we want to do is leave the grey areas for discussion between the board and the Minister when the time comes for the transfer of these functions and to decide what is appropriate to transfer and what is appropriate to hold. In other words, it is to wait until the board are set up and we can get the views of the members as to what they think they should have and what is appropriate for them. There are certain regulatory functions the Minister cannot give the new authority because of his responsibility for disease eradication and so on.
I think it is understood that the Minister has to retain responsibility for disease eradication and for certain matters in relation to the EEC.
Section 17 (3) states:
In case of doubt as to whether any activity in relation to veterinary research is or is not proper to the Authority, the decision of the Minister shall be final.
It shall be final when he has discussions with the board, and that is indicated in the Bill.
Comment on this
We are leaving a grey area and we have the facilities available to us in legislation to make it more black and white, if possible, at this stage. It does not preclude the sentiments the Minister has expressed if there are further grey areas. Veterinary research consists in diagnosis on behalf of the Minister, herd-owners, flock-owners, or veterinary practitioners of diseases of animals or poultry by means of clinical or laboratory examination of animals or birds or herds or flocks, whether alive or dead, or their carcases or of specimens taken from them and investigations and consultations leading to the solution of these diseases. That is veterinary research.
Comment on this
That could be precluded from the functions of this board because of the grey areas that are left there and because of the words "basic veterinary research". The other researches, which are also veterinary, are the specific responsibility of the Minister and must by statute remain his responsibility. I would define that veterinary research does not include investigations, tests, inquiries or trials arising from disease eradication schemes and hygiene control programmes operated by the Minister. That would cover the Minister's requirements in that he must retain unto himself that responsibility. All the others should be available to the board. It is a pity to leave such a vital and important section of research in the grey area when it can be defined and must, in fact, be available to the board and to the agricultural community. This is the normal examination of disease control, not necessarily eradication.
Comment on this
All the things Senator Ferris describes do not constitute research. This is ordinary veterinary practice. They have——
Comment on this
The Minister might look at it again at Report Stage to see if a form of technology could be used which would leave no doubt.
Comment on this
If there is any doubt it can be rectified as soon as the board is set up. We have a specific reference to it here in subsection (3):
In case of doubt as to whether any activity in relation to veterinary research is or is not proper to the Authority, the decision of the Minister shall be final.
Comment on this
That is what I am trying to do too, and I am trying to leave the responsibility with them in discussion with me to decide the details of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 10, lines 16 and 17, to delete "in order to avoid duplication of effort and, for that purpose,".
It is the phraseology and the intent of this about which I am in doubt. As I read it here the authority should know what is happening elsewhere and it states:
In order to avoid duplication of effort and, for that purpose, the Authority may, subject to the approval of the Board, engage in joint research activities with such institutions and bodies.
The words "in order to avoid duplication of effort and for that purpose" seem to me to be unnecessarily restrictive because it appears that the Authority, to engage in joint research, would have to establish that there was duplication of effort. It might well mean that the other body was not making an effort at that time. There might be some research that the university or college could carry out but were not carrying out at that time. I should like to feel that the board could decide the best way of having this research carried out. It could hardly be called duplication if it were not going to take place at all so those words seem to be unnecessarily restrictive.
Comment on this
I understand the view of Senator Quinlan but I think that he has misrepresented this section when he suggests that the authority can engage in joint research projects only for the purpose of avoiding duplication. The phrase "for the purpose" refers not only to avoiding duplication but to the entire preceding part of the section. In other words the Authority may, in maintaining close liaison with other bodies involved in the field of agriculture and veterinary research, engage in joint projects with them. It is just a misreading, I think.
Comment on this
It is a cumbersome section but I accept the intention. I endorse that intention and I am happy now.
Comment on this
With regard to the institute that was extinguished half an hour ago, I understand there are about eight veterinary people at work. Is it envisaged that the Authority, under the direction of the Minister, could take them out completely and transfer them to a university institution? There is this very small research element in the institute as it stands. Under this rationalisation Bill, would it be possible now for the Minister to lift those eight vets and disperse them among the universities, to extinguish that element of research in the institute or build it up into something far bigger? How large are the powers? Could he in fact transfer the personnel? Could the Authority transfer the personnel and run down that operation?
Comment on this
I want to point out that the entire functions and responsibilities of An Foras Talúntais as it stands are being transferred to the new Authority.
Comment on this
The council were not able to do it. When they were set up they did not appoint their director. Their director was appointed by the Minister.
Comment on this
I am just trying to point out that the functions of the new authority are not the same because the director is now always appointed by the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister said that all the functions were the same. They are not.
Comment on this
My question really was about research functions. The Minister did not quite answer me except to raise the issue which made it possible for Senator West to raise the issue on which he was rebuked. My question was quite specific. Under the new authority as it stands, would it be possible for the authority now, in fact, to so act as to remove the entire veterinary research operation from the institute that was and replace it elsewhere?
Comment on this
It is something that could not have been done in Trinity, for instance.
Comment on this
There is lack of clarity here. This section provides that the board shall be established and another section refers to powers to dismiss a member of the board. These two should be related, because it is very important that the board will have the confidence of those engaged in agriculture, and I want to stress this strongly.
I can now refer to a board that is under the Minister's control, the Potato Marketing Board. A member of the board was a nominee from the General Council but he retains membership of the Potato Board while he is no longer a member of the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. That situation has existed for some time and I hope that the Minister will give an assurance that no such anomaly will be allowed to prevail in relation to this new board. We should have directors who will be qualified in every regard and who will not qualify because of their political affiliation to the Minister's party or that such affiliation will be the only qualification needed to become a member of the board. I hope that the public fears are allayed here. This should be made quite clear and not allowed to drift while it is convenient for the Minister and his party to overlook such a point. The general public and those engaged in agriculture must see that there is fair play and that the Minister will not turn a blind eye to anomalous situations.
Comment on this
As far as the Minister is concerned I do not think that the record of this Government would bear scrutiny in regard to the appointment of peace commissioners, directors, and right across the board. No Government in any country would have a record like it. There are 4,000 peace commissioners——
Comment on this
Senator McGowan is travelling outside section 25.
Comment on this
——and every board appointed by the present Government is loaded, and the only qualification of most of them is to be tagged to the party that the Minister represents.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 11, subsection (1), to delete line 30 and substitute "twenty-four ordinary members of whom not less than eight shall be members of the staff of the National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority equally distributed as between the research, advisory, processing, and marketing areas."
This is seeking to make more explicit section B by making provision for the nomination of a representative of the staff. In accordance with some of the recent efforts on industrial democracy we should give substantial staff representation, and that representation should recognise the four main areas involved— research, advisory, processing and marketing. Processing and marketing are becoming more and more important in our agricultural effort. It is at least 50 per cent of it, and therefore, I would like to see that each of those areas would have at least one or I would suggest two representatives in the nomination scheme to be introduced by the Minister by way of an order. To that end I am inclined to suggest that a third of the membership would come that way in accordance with recent practice, which might mean increasing the number of the board from 23 to 24. As one who has had very considerable experience on boards— whether on the governing body of University College, Cork, or the Senate of the university or in other places— I was amazed to hear Senator West concerned about numbers. I would have thought that any board in the order of 20 to 30 is quite a reasonable board. I shudder at the small board Senator West seems to favour. He seems to suggest six or eight as the most effective board. Six or eight can be dominated by one man, but a board of 24 will not be so easily dominated. It also provides a much greater cross-section of interests. Today a board, of necessity, has to have extra technical advice available to it from the administrative and executive side of the operation, so you will have some members present on that account. This again tends to give the board a type of establishment complex unless the board is of reasonable numbers. I am quite happy with the numbers suggested, but I would like to see provision for recognition of vital areas.
Comment on this
There are two points that I want to raise and get on the record. First could the Minister indicate whether it might be possible, if not now at a later stage, for a body of this nature to have representation from the Irish Congress of Trade Unions on it? The rural organisations and the agricultural organisations are represented by the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. That to some extent is the national representation. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions have a very deep interest in this Bill because not only do they represent rural workers and the staff of the authority but because very often demands are made in economic programmes for further industries based on agriculture. When regard is had to the nature of the present authority and to the fact that there are Irish Congress of Trade Union representatives at State board level and also involved in the question of industrial research and standards, I think it would be consistent with that practice to have a representative of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions on this body.
The other point is that I feel the section should be so written that representation on the board of the authority would be in accordance with the recent decisions on levels of staff representation taken by the Minister for Labour in regard to worker participation. It is generally recognised throughout this whole debate that industrial relationships in the other bodies that are now merging, particularly An Foras Talúntais were very good indeed and these bodies had a very healthy respect for one another's position. It will be of great benefit if that relationship continues and if we carry on the trend that we started by the introduction of workers participation in the State boards, because the workers can make a very valuable contribution through their knowledge and the ideas they can bring to board level discussions. They will be able to play a useful role in helping through a difficult transition and also in contributing to humanising the relations in this new executive agency. Nothing but a beneficial effect can come out of those two areas. Perhaps it may be jumping the gun to suggest that the ICTU representation should be there straight away. Possibly some consideration would have to be given to that. I do not think that the workers who have built up this very good relationship in other agencies and who are now being merged can be denied such representation. It is actual Government policy now to involve workers in State boards and I do not think the fact that it is an executive agency debars it. There is a board there and there is ample evidence to prove that this is the natural thing to do, particularly in view of worker participation.
Comment on this
I agree with the principle behind the suggestion by Senator Quinlan that staff should be well represented on this authority. As one who has had experience of carrying on discussions and working with the representatives of the people engaged particularly in the advisory services, the CEOs, the AO and also the Agricultural Science Association. I can say that the representatives of these people, when they all come together, can have nothing but the most important contribution to make to the working of this board. If it never was the aim to pursue workers' democracy ideas or the involvement of the people who must actually carry out the work, I think from my own experience of having had dealings with the people involved, the Minister for Agriculture cannot go wrong by giving them important strong representation on the board of this new organisation.
There is provision for the appointment by the General Council of Committees of Agriculture of one person to the board, and, while I have nothing specific by way of amendment to put forward, I would like the Minister for Agriculture to seriously consider giving considerably more than one place on the board to the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. Much reference has been made to the agricultural institute which, somebody said in this House, will cease to exist. In a way the same thing could be said of the committees of agriculture. I agree that as far as the institute is concerned this is so in theory, but not in practice. While the role of the committees of agriculture has been greatly reduced in theory, they were the people who provided the advisory services, employed the agricultural advisers and paid them, the people who directed the whole process of giving advice to the farmers in the past. They have definitely suffered a serious loss of power in theory. The General Council has looked at the new Bill, and while they have put forward suggestions as to how the situation could be improved, they were very responsible in their acceptance of the general idea put forward by the Minister, and I think he should consider the position.
I am glad to see that the Minister has made provision in the Bill for the annual submission by the county committees of agriculture of a plan for the workings of the new body in their particular county. In the past too many of the committees—probably for the reason that a number of them were politically dominated, and this does not refer to one party more than another— used political tactics in the appointment of committees of agriculture. The Minister, by his provision here that some of the rural organisations must get representation, which in fact the majority of committees have already given, will improve the standards and the quality of the committees of agriculture in most counties. The introduction of the idea that they must at all times prepare and submit a plan for the carrying on of advice and education in their county is a step forward and a good idea. I would ask the Minister again to further consider the possibility of giving stronger representation to the general council on the new board.
Comment on this
I would like to endorse Senator Quinlan's amendment, which seems to be a very good one and one of extreme importance and urgency. I would like to go even further and say as regards those who would be on the board representing the research, advisory, processing and marketing areas, that if some mechanism could be arranged to have them elected rather than selected, it would be better still, because Senator McCartin has spoken about this notion of industrial democracy. This Bill has taken a rather strong line with existing institutions and with existing sensibilities and with people's feelings and it is very important that its passage towards success should be alleviated as much as possible. One of the ways in which the wounds inflicted by the extinction, at least the formal extinction, of the institute, could be healed would be to make sure that the people involved in research there would have a guaranteed place on the board and the authority. Indeed, it strikes me as strange, that a man like the Minister for Agriculture, who even in his very deportment here has shown a great deal of patience and courtesy, and always has in every area of his life, should produce such an autocratic measure. From top to bottom the matter is over-ridden by the notion of appointment: "The Minister shall appoint". Everybody on that board will be appointed. If Senator Quinlan's amendment is accepted and if research, advisory and processing people are included on the board, by the very terms of the Bill, they are still going to be appointed. That is not the best idea in the running of institutions; in other words, that the boss reaches down and picks a safe man from this or that area. That does not make for industrial democracy or for the smooth or democratic running of an institution. It is much better if the people in the field select one of their number and appoint him, admittedly for a short period, to such an authority. That is an aspect of this that has disquieted me from the very beginning, that the Minister must be very anxious indeed to get an extremely strong, autocratic hold on the entire organisation.
The whole burden of what Senator West and myself and a number of others have been saying with regard to the entire operation is that the autonomy of individual bodies—the institute just happens to be one that stands out most—their very raison d'etre, the very things that give them a reason to get out of the bed in the morning and to embark on the research or on their teaching or their advice have to do with giving them the dignity of arranging their schedule and their programme according to the needs of the disciplines to which they have dedicated themselves, not according to the needs imposed on them from without by civil servants, however excellent. I am not saying that civil servants are either unnecessary or undesirable or in any way objectionable, but merely saying they operate on different sorts of principles. The proposed operation of this board seems very autocratic. It is done entirely from the top. Everybody is selected. Ultimately at the end of the day it is the will of one man that is operating down the line. Is that not true? The Minister looks outraged.
Comment on this
I do not know where the Senator sees all this selection by the Minister. It is not in the Bill, wherever he got it.
Comment on this
I am sorry I missed the earlier part of this discussion. I was at a meeting in another part of the House. I would like to comment very briefly on section 26 and to take the last point that Senator Martin made. I understand that in fact the order has to be set out by the Minister defining the procedure. My interpretation as of now reading this section—and you will have to allow that I am not in this House more than nine months—is that it is up to various bodies to nominate people, that the selection process is an open-ended one in which people will put forward names on the basis of an agreed procedure. Taking that point, I would suggest that all of the debate we had on Second Stage and a lot of the debate we had earlier regarding the autonomy and the independence of this institute could be very much enhanced and strengthened if the principles of representations laid out in the Worker Participation Act were to be adopted in the order which the Minister has yet to bring in and define allowing for representation along the lines that Senator Quinlan has suggested. No research authority and no group of research officers can seriously claim exclusive autonomy while they are at the same time obtaining public money. In fairness to them, that is not the position they are putting forward. Under the heat of debate in this Chamber, it would appear that this is what they are asking.
I do not think that any responsible group of research officers or any responsible trade unions could simply argue that they must be given something in the region of £6 million to do research as they see fit without accountability to anybody. That is an exaggeration that does an injustice to the people involved and plays down the very responsible attitude with regard to this that the institute has had over its lifetime in existence. The whole function of research with which we have concerned ourselves very much in the past would be very much sustained and strengthened if positive and satisfactory recommendations for research were followed by members of the new board along with the education and advisory staff in a manner suggested in the amendment put forward by Senator Quinlan.
The procedures are already there, and we are getting to the stage in all of our semi-State bodies where it would be very undesirable, to say the least, that one process for representation would exist in one authority and a different one in others. I know CIE, Aer Lingus or these companies are not analagous to this authority; they have a different kind of function altogether, but the principle of representation, the principle of workers having a say in the overall policy decisions of the board, is basically, so far as I am concerned, the same. An amendment, as such, is not necessary at this stage. The Minister can, quite simply, give an undertaking at the end of this stage that in the order they would have to be defined, that he will meet those requirements. I would formally ask the Minister to give that undertaking either now or at the Report Stage to report back to us on it. Many of the fears expressed today on section 17 in regard to the organisation of workers in An Foras Talúntais, as it is at the moment, and in particular those in the research office who are more concerned with policy and the allocation of funds than technicians or administrative staff, could be allayed Technicians are going to have to work an experiment irrespective of what that particular experiment happens to be and the administrative staff, generally, are going to have to administer the institute irrespective of what the direction of research happens to be. Discretion with regard to the application of funds into different areas of research should be argued out by representatives of research officers around a council board with members of the rural organisations, with the nominee from the Minister for Education and they should get the programme sorted out there before they go to the relevant Minister looking for funding for that programme. The input should not come up from the research and development section by way of written submission to the board in the hope that something will come out of it into the programme. The research officers and the advisory staff should do it
I do not claim to have any real knowledge of agriculture in the general sense, certainly not like my colleagues, Senator Ferris or Senator McCartin, but it seems to me that problems have obviously arisen with regard to the relationship between the benefits of research as discovered in An Foras Talúntais and their non-application or the delay in their application throughout the country. It is in the interest of all concerned that this time lag should be shortened. If there is adequate representation on the board then this kind of difficulty could be got over. I would impress on the Minister that this should be done.
I would also suggest at this stage that the Minister, as a member of the Government, should consider the need to co-ordinate research in the various institutes that are now emerging. It was mentioned yesterday by Senator West with regard to sensitive areas of research, like looking at farm taxation, farm economics and so on. This might be an area which might be sat upon or warned off by people who felt that it was a political minefield. This area of social research could equally be undertaken by the Economic and Social Research Institute or by other such bodies in the country. Some attempt to co-ordinate the research bodies between the various groups should be made. The board could possibly be encouraged to do this. One of the functions of the board should be to establish links with other such bodies, like An Foras Forbartha, the new Science and Technology Board, and the ESRI, because there seems to me to be an overlapping there. In terms of resources, which are going to be scarce, and competition for research funds, there should be complementary benefit derived from the spending of these resources.
To conclude, I would like to support what Senator Harte has already said on this, that the Workers' Union of Ireland have already made comments to this extent, and I understand that the Irish Congress of Trade Unions are in a similar frame of mind—and it is fair to say that the entire trade union movement would welcome an announcement by the Minister for Agriculture with regard to the nature of the order that he has to make under section 26.
Comment on this
I, too, agree with what Senator Harte has said. A case has certainly been made in this debate for the Minister to make it possible to include on this board a member of the trade unions. It is important that there would be perfect understanding between workers and the whole agricultural sector because, as you know, agriculture is our greatest industry. It is an area in which we hope to extend employment and create many jobs based on agriculture, such as food, milk and meat processing and other allied industries which can arise by virtue of extra production on the farms. The small farmers and workers are the most important people in this whole exercise, regardless of the competition of boards and so on. The people who produce the materials are the important people. It might help to improve relations between workers and farmers. It might stop an idea being put across, particularly by this Government, that the farmers are all millionaires and that the workers should lie into them and squeeze all they can out of them and make sure they pay their share, which the majority have always done, especially the small farmers.
On the composition of the board the Minister has been wrongly advised if he feels that in a board of up to 24 members only one representative from the committees of agriculture will be sufficient. Surely one must recognise that the county committees of agriculture who have sent their representatives up to the general council are a very important body. Indeed, half the members of the committees of agriculture are members who had to go through the process of election and run the gauntlet, put themselves in front of their neighbours and seek their endorsement through the ballot box. They have come through that and on to the committees of agriculture and entered the general council. It is wrong for any Minister to say that from that representative body, representing all Ireland and representing our basic industry, there should be just one person. So far as I know, he will not even allow the committees of agriculture to select that one person; the Minister will do the picking. It is fundamentally wrong and bad for democracy.
In the county council and the committee of agriculture in my area we allowed the IFA to select their representatives and we allowed the Creamery Milk Suppliers' Organisation to select their representatives and their two nominees are on our committee of agriculture. It has been working tremendously well. We did not say that we would pick the person we would think should represent the IFA or the Creamery Milk Suppliers' Organisation on this committee of agriculture in County Cavan. We allowed them to do the picking, and that was the proper way to do it. The Minister is wrong if, out of these 24 people, he selects one from the general committees of agriculture and then does not allow these rural organisations, to whom he is boasting that he will give them great representation on this board, to do the selection.
I know, and indeed the country knows, how the Minister will do the picking. He will make quite sure that it will be his own political hacks that will be on these committees, and they will not be there because of their ability or their knowledge of or interest in agriculture.
That is fundamentally wrong, no matter which Minister is in office. The Minister should have another look at this. It is undemocratic for any Minister—and particularly this Minister, who will be trying as he has been doing in the past, to please two elements of a Coalition—to pick these people. It is wiping out existing institutions. It is very unfair to An Foras Talúntais and to many dedicated men who worked for the benefit of agriculture.
Let nobody believe that there is any democracy in this type of exercise. It is a complete dictatorial take-over by the Minister who is going to set up this committee with his own political hacks in charge. It is very wrong to ask educated, well versed and interested members who have proved their worth in An Foras Tálúntais to sit on such boards in such company.
Comment on this
The board of the authority is so important that the organisations who will be selecting members for that board should think seriously about whom they select. There are people attached to those organisations—very good members— who would be the obvious choice but who may not have the time necessary to give to this board. The members will have to give a lot of time to the development of agriculture and to the functioning of this board, especially at the initial stages.
After the formation of the board many problems will have to be ironed out. I suggest that these organisations —the farming organisations and the associations involved in the processing and marketing of agricultural products—think seriously of whom they suggest and select to be members of this board. If we recognise that the board is important, then we must recognise that those who are involved in the working of the authority—that is the staff—must also be represented on the board. I believe they will be represented on the board because it is already stated in the Bill "That the board shall consist of members, who shall be representative of the agricultural and rural organisations, the staff of the authority..." Therefore the staff of the authority will be represented on the board and that representative will take a deep interest in the working of the authority.
I agree that technicians and workers should be represented on the board by a member of their trade union. That problem will be considered and ironed out later. The co-operative movement has a vital part to play in the working of this board and the authority. They also should be represented on the board because they are involved in all sorts of agricultural production. The most important thing here is the selection by those organisations of the personnel for that board.
Comment on this
This is one of the most vital sections of this Bill. Senator Eoin Ryan made a very important statement yesterday when he said that it was obvious that retired senior men in the civil service recently were appointed as chairmen of certain boards. The farming community do not want such an appointment on this board. I say that clearly because I have a sneaking suspicion, despite the Minister's statement that he was responsible for this and for every word in this Bill, that there is an idea at the back of his mind that such an appointment might be appropriate in this case. I live in an area where agriculture has improved and these people do not want such an appointment.
Under this Bill, the Minister makes the selection himself. I am not going to go into the history of the type of selection done by this Government, because that is obvious to everybody. When mention is made of appointments to State boards on the streets of any town people just laugh and say: "Well, you are the wrong colour". Even Fine Gael and Labour people will say that their brand of Fine Gael or Labour was not strong enough or good enough for that appointment. To get such an appointment you had to be an absolute hack; you had to be trusted in every sphere. Then the Minister had the audacity to come here and say, after the annihilation of the county committees of agriculture, that he had the right to select the members of that body—a body selected by the people. In my view, that is the lowest symbol of this type of appointment.
Comment on this
I will read the last part of subsection (3) (a):
and such other agricultural interests as may be prescribed shall be selected for nomination in accordance with the provision of an order made for that purpose by the Minister....
Comment on this
I will read subsection (3) (a):
One member of the Board shall be appointed on the nomination of the Minister for Education, at least one member——
note the words "at least one member".
on the nomination of the Minister and at least one member on the nomination of the General Council referred to in section 43.
Comment on this
Would not the Minister be as well off to say in the Bill "there shall be one", "there shall be two", or "there shall be ten"? What is he afraid of? Does he think I have not noticed that when he put in the words "at least one" he put in the minimum? We all know this was done because politically speaking the Coalition Government do not control the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture. The Bill says that there will be "at least one".
Comment on this
Yes "of the Minister's choice". We know that now. We know a lot more than the Minister thinks because we can read it right through this Bill. This sinister performance by the Government will be regretted by the farming community until such time as the Coalition are removed from office. Whether that will be sooner or later, this Government will be remembered as a great failure.
Another point was raised by Labour Senators. Senator Harte is a personal friend. He is a very sociable man and a very good man for his cause. What amazes me is that this problem was not solved behind the closed doors of Government. The way this Minister will deal with Labour appointments to this board has now been brought out into the open. Do I scent a little rift in the Government? It was mentioned in the other House. Has agreement not been reached about the way they will fix up the tail-waggers on this board?
Comment on this
I doubt it. I think there is a good argument going on about it at this moment of time and, fair do to Senator Harte, he is fighting his case.
Comment on this
Under instruction, the Labour Party are making their case and are seen to be fighting for it. I will be anxious to hear what the Minister has to say when replying to that point. We know that the love the farming community have for the Labour Party is extraordinary. They will shed crocodile tears for the way the Labour Party will be fixed up in this board. They care a lot about the places for nominees of the Labour Party in the actual setting up of this board. They are worried that the Labour Party will not get their nominations.
The Labour Party will be fixed up in this board against the wishes of the farming community. An Foras Talúntais and many other organisations. There is no question or doubt but that they will get their appointment. It seems to me that this will not be done the way the Labour Party in the Seanad want it done. The Minister's nominee will have to be a farming type Labour man. He will have to have some background in agriculture. He will not be a worker. He is not going to be an ordinary shop floor worker in any of the groups that will be considered here. No, the Government will have to say "He is a Labour man but he has a good farming background" because that is the only way out of it. It is a disgrace that the Minister has rejected the county committees of agriculture.
As was said when discussing An Foras Talúntais on another section, this Bill has destroyed a body elected by the people. These representatives may have been elected on peculiar policies, or on different types of policies, but they were elected by the people and, from the agricultural point of view, did a good job for this country since the foundation of An Foras. They have worked hard under difficult circumstances, although they may have been politically orientated one way or another.
I foresee that the Minister in his reply will make an inference about the Galway County Committee of Agriculture. When he makes that remark I shall be quick to my feet to reply to it word by word. It is a humiliation in terms for the people who worked diligently in agriculture without pay for many years to hear the Minister say "Just wipe them out". They will be forgotten, their work, efforts, sadness and victories will be forgotten.
Until he took the reins of the Department the Minister was a great speaker on behalf of the county committees of agriculture. I cannot understand how this change came about. In my view the Minister has not been responsible for this Bill at all, it has been lobbied on him. He said he wondered why Senator Lenihan, when he was in Government, had not made some of the statements he made in this House today. The situation prior to the introduction of this Bill was much more acceptable than it will be when this Bill is passed. If you cannot do things better, do not ever do them worse.
We have watched appointments on other boards. This is not the first time I have made the remark in this House. I have seen appointments on semi-State organisations that amazed me.
Comment on this
The Minister would not be fit to put him off because he could not replace him with any man in the Fine Gael organisation on any board and dare this Minister or any other Minister put him off. I challenge the Minister to put him off.
Comment on this
Senator Killilea, please address your remarks to the Chair.
Comment on this
No doubt the Senator will retain his good reputation.
Comment on this
Dare I mention one word concerning the problems of Senator McCartin in his constituency because——
Comment on this
If it is relevant to section 26, the Chair will be happy.
Comment on this
He will never be in a position to put himself further than this House. From what I hear he will be lucky to get back into this House after the next election. However, I will be sad to see him gone. He makes some good contributions He gets a nice bit of television coverage now and then.
Comment on this
Getting back to the point, on which I was so rudely interrupted, concerning the county committees of agriculture, I would like the Minister to explain when replying why has he had this change of heart towards that great organisation. If, for instance, it is not operating to his satisfaction, would it not have been better for him to make suggestions as to how it should work? Could he not have said "Ladies and gentlemen, you are on the wrong road, let me redirect you. Let us solve this problem for the people who were committed not alone to agriculture but to the public at large, who always saw that reasonable fairness was applied." I will stand over that statement anywhere.
I am lucky enough to be still a member of the local county committee of agriculture and I am proud of that fact. We have done a lot. Had the Minister and his Department tried to do as much for us as we have done for our county, we would be a better county from the point of view of agriculture. How many times has he refused to appoint advisers? How many times have we sent requests and how many times have we got letters back saying no? Yet, in his twisted way, he tried to infer that the county committees of agriculture were not doing their job. They were doing their job, but they were hindered by the Department in many ways and by the Minister, too. What I can never understand is how his man who spoke so highly of the General Council of Committees of Agriculture took this sudden twist in the last three years.
Then we come to the most sinister part—the last three lines of subsection (3) (a). The Minister is responsible for this. If you listen carefully to the words, you will hear what they really mean. This section concerns membership. I will read those three lines to show clearly what the Minister and his Government are doing. It reads:
...and any such order shall indicate the procedure for filling casual vacancies in the membership of the Board.
What is the definition of a "casual vacancy"? There are about ten different types of casual vacancies, and I know one of the best. If the Minister makes a mistake in the appointment of the first board and some guy at the back is pressing the button on the Minister and the Department, then that individual on the board will be classified as a casual vacancy on the reappointment of that board. That is the first criteria for this Government and their performance. If he sits down doing nothing at the back, would the Minister classify him as a casual vacancy?
Comment on this
Would the Minister, in his reply, fill us in on what he really means by a casual vacancy? Let me clarify a point raised yesterday and reiterated today. It concerns this section, from the Fianna Fáil point of view. Our spokesman said clearly in the other House—and it is only right that it should be put on the record of this House—that he would dissolve and obliterate this Bill. I agree wholeheartedly with that. Never in the life of a Fianna Fáil Government would we dare to put on paper such arrogant, dictatorial methods for selection of State boards. We never did it. In my time in politics we never appointed men to State boards who were not capable of defending those boards and their positions on them. We put on representatives of the Labour Party on State boards. These men were representatives of their union, not of their political persuasion. We always saw to it that the unions and the people were properly represented. We put it into print and produced it before both Houses. Do this Government do that, or did they ever do it? Has this ever been stated? While we were in Government we never had a Member of the Labour Party standing up on this side of the House asking that the appointments on a State board be done the way Members in this House felt they should be done. We never gave them that opportunity. We did the job properly, logically——
Comment on this
If the cap fits, wear it. I know the Senator's politics. He is sitting on the wrong side of the House, because there is no man so blue on that side of the House as this man. I have had him under observation for the last four or five years. There are two decent Independent men behind me——
Comment on this
Would Senator Killilea please return to section 26?
Comment on this
They would not dare sit beside him in case it might rub off. I have had Senator Quinlan spotted for a long time. I have watched him for the best part of nine years here and he is the greatest bluffer, politically speaking, who has ever come in these doors.
Comment on this
I am not too sure what that has to do with section 26 or the amendment.
Comment on this
He even slips into the Order Paper a couple of meagre words, such as, change A to B and change B to C and so on. I have made my point concerning the General Council of County Committees of Agriculture and the county committees of agriculture. I would like the Minister, in his reply, to state where this turnabout came from.
There is another tricky point in this. Why has the Minister not named in this Bill those beloved rural organisations from which we will nominate members? Is he afraid to name the farming and other rural organisations which he believes should be represented on this board? It is very important that we should know because I have a funny feeling that at this moment there are many unreliable Labour people and diligent Fine Gael people pushing into these organisations because they can foresee a State board job coming up in the near future. I am certain that the Minister is not going to appoint the people who would have the courage to make good members of this board, as a Government Senator said.
Comment on this
Before the House adjourns for lunch, I would like to point out that technically we are still discussing an amendment. As the amendment is very much at the heart of the section, I allowed a rather broad debate on the section on the basis that it will not be repeated when we come formally to the section.
Business suspended at 1 p.m. and resumed at 2.30 p.m.
Comment on this
Before lunch I was discussing the mode of apointment to this board and I assume that the logic applied by the Government to it would be as clear as the logic that they have applied to the appointment of other boards. During lunch a Member of the Government side said to me: "You are debasing the standard of debate in the Seanad." I am not and I have no intention of doing that and I had no intention of doing that but I am talking clearly under section 26 of this Bill because that is the level at which this Government have created this debate. They have created a situation where we have to talk at that low level in this House. That is a sad reflection on this nation and indeed a terrible reflection on this Government. Sadder still, the Minister for Agriculture, the man who is held in certain respect throughout the country has allowed himself to be debased. I think it is sad; it is tragic. It is a national catastrophe in its own way. We have known that until now, unless the Minister for Agriculture is going to change it, the criterion this Government used for appointment on a State board was that if you had primary education upwards you qualified and if you did not have that qualification you were sure to be appointed a peace commissioner. That is the level of the performance on appointments by this Government. That is a sad fact.
Comment on this
Fact or no, the Chair is worried about its relevance to the amendment, however proper it might be to raise it on the section.
Comment on this
The Senator would have to persuade me that the farming community are worried on the question of whether or not the staff should be represented on the board, because that is what is in amendment No. 4. We are on amendment No. 4. When amendment No. 4 is disposed of we can discuss the whole section, but it would be as well to keep to the amendment. Otherwise, if the debate is allowed to spread, the Chair would be in the position of not allowing for the discussion. It is a matter for the House. There cannot be two debates.
Comment on this
I agree wholeheartedly, but the point I am trying to make is: what is the qualification for a member of the staff to be a member of the board? This is the point I want to bring out. We do not know, and I am suggesting that so far, the qualifications to be a member of a State board have been, and as far as I am concerned continue to be, that from the level of primary education upwards you qualify. It is not specific and we even had a situation where the Labour Party in this House themselves asked questions and they are part and parcel of this national Coalition. If they are baffled, so am I and I am sure the farming community are in a desperate state about it. They do not know whether they are coming or going. There is no qualification at all. Where do you come from? What is your qualification? I am saying that to date, the qualification is if you are a sound, reliable member of the Fine Gael or the Labour Party and you have primary education upwards you are guaranteed to be OK:
That is not good enough and I think it cannot be good enough for an industry that is so highly rated in Europe, not alone here. The prime gross national product of this country is treated with contempt due to the standard of political obedience you have. It is a national scandal. Up to now that the only guide I have, and that, obviously, is the only guide the Government benches in this House have: are you a good political hack? The better you are the more chance you have. At this moment the hacks around the country are getting into rural organisations, arranging themselves in positions where the Minister will be able to pick them out and put them on this board. I say that because the Minister has not in this Bill named the organisation, or the qualifications or the level in that organisation at which you would qualify to be selected as a nominee.
That is a fact. We have an illustration of it from a recent appointment. The west of Ireland from Donegal to Kerry is the main tourist attraction of this country and is there a nominee on the tourist board, even a Fine Gael nominee on the tourist board in that region, much less a decent independent man with a mind for tourism? Not even a Fine Gael hack or a Labour one. I do not know whether they are aware of that. There is not one in the prime region for tourists. Here we stand without even a Fine Gael hack on the tourist board.
I believe that under this Bill that will continue in the appointment of members to this board. Would the Minister state clearly and emphatically what are the qualifications? Where do you come from? What organisation are you in? What qualifications of intelligence and knowledge must you have to qualify to be on this board? There is not a word in this Bill about that question. To me that is very relevant We have situations in other agricultural boards. It was noted in this House today and yesterday that we have a Fine Gael hack who was nominated from the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture and the Potato Marketing Board. When he failed to qualify with the electorate and be re-elected to his local county council, was he taken off the Potato Marketing Board by the present Minister for Agriculture? It is a fact. That is not suspicion. That is fact and what happens? Nothing. Is that fair? What does he represent? Nothing. What are his qualifications? Nothing. He was beaten in a county council election. That is his qualification. I say it is not above suspicion. I can see this and I illustrated it earlier on the question of the chairmanship of this board. Again, at lunch time, I was told I was a suspicious man. By nature I am not suspicious. I say what I feel. I say it because I feel I am clear in saying it. It has been illustrated twice to us on two occasions that senior civil servants are being appointed to those arduous tasks.
I said it before lunch and I reiterate now that if such an appointment is made to the chairmanship of this new board it will be resisted throughout the country. Perhaps I am helping the Minister in saying that because perhaps he is under duress to make this appointment by those people about him in Government who want this type of chairmanship. He can now go back to the Government and say that at least Senator Killilea said in the House that he could feel or had a suspicion that perhaps such an appointment would be made. It will be resisted at a political level as well as at the level of the staff working under this board. The Minister is getting prior warning here and now that it would be resisted and it would cause trouble and, in any event, it would be a bad decision by him. But, perhaps like this Bill he has not the decision in this matter; it may be pushed on to him. He may be told to put Mr. X on as chairman of that board. Perhaps he will resist and come out fighting but at the end of the day, this open Government behind closed doors will make the decision and the Minister will come out and justify such an appointment. That is perhaps something that I am prejudging; perhaps I should not be prejudging, but this is a very very important point and it has to be reiterated as often as possible.
I want to ask the Minister a few simple questions: would he put on the record of this House in reply the names of the organisations, the farming organisations, the educational organisations——
Comment on this
I must intervene. The Senator is now solidly on the section and not on the amendment and I must warn him that while passing references to these things certainly would be in order, if such matters are brought up on the amendment then the Chair will have to be absolutely rigorous in regard to repetition if there is any attempt to discuss them again on the section. It would be far better for the orderly debate of this House if the net point of the amendment were dealt with and disposed of so that there could be a full, free debate on the section so that neither Senators nor the Chair would have anxiety about being out of order.
Comment on this
But not twice. The Senator has already threatened reiteration on this particular point.
Comment on this
No, perhaps I took you up wrong. When I was asking the Minister certain questions I did not get to the point of asking him about the level and the organisation at which he will make——
Comment on this
That arises on the section and not on the amendment.
Comment on this
I yield the point. I will bring it up on the section. I trust that the Minister will make a clean break from the present ritual and the present criteria for nomination. I trust and hope that the Minister will tell us clearly if he and the Labour cohorts in Government, have come to any agreement as to who will be nominated from the Labour section. It is very clear that they have not reached agreement on this point yet. They should, because written into this Bill should be the qualifications and the mode by which a person from the labour movement would be qualified for nomination. There is division amongst the ranks of the Government on this very important question. It is clear to me that the Minister for Agriculture wants to appoint some farming-labour type rather than the trade union type to the board. They may come to a point where they will differ so greatly that probably those working inside a section in this new body may again be disappointed by the Minister's performance. I will personally be delighted if the records of the House hold the qualifications of the chairman, the type of man that the Minister wants and has the right to want and put on this board. I shall wait to see what the Minister has to say on those very important points.
Comment on this
In my view the amendment has some considerable merit. I am aware that correspondence and discussions are still proceeding between the Minister and the Irish Congress of Trade Unions in regard to section 26 and also in respect of other sections of the Bill. Because the discussions are still proceeding I was reluctant to put down amendments but those discussions are proceeding, not as has been suggested behind closed doors but quite openly. The whole matter has been considered in so far as it relates to the staff of the board and the authority and has been considered quite openly at many trade union meetings throughout the country. I cannot understand the reference to closed door discussions. I hope, although I personally have not submitted any amendments, that when the discussions have concluded and when the Minister has another opportunity of considering the representations made by Congress and indeed by every body, every individual and every political party, including Fianna Fáil, of course, that he will re-examine his own viewpoint. May I say that this should be the axiom of all Ministers and all Governments: if something in the course of time should prove to be unworkable or unfair, then the Government and the appropriate Minister should always be prepared to reconsider the position. I hope that in this case, if he is unable to agree to this amendment at this stage, he will re-examine the position and, if necessary, bring in further amendments to the Bill.
Comment on this
I would like to support Senator Kennedy but I am worried about the procedure. I think Senator Quinlan's amendment is a sensible one. It may not be acceptable in the terms in which it is expressed but the spirit of the amendment seems to be supported by all parties. There does not seem to have been any opposition from the Fine Gael Party, the people on this side clearly support it, the Labour members support it. It is one of these cases where there is universal agreement. It is not a political issue. Whatever Senator Killilea says, even the Independents support it, so it must be good.
The problem that I see is that, if we pass the section as it stands, it would take an amending Bill—not just the order which the Minister will make by virtue of this section—to do what we all want. The real point is that—and I think Senator Kennedy would agree with this—amending Bills can be long-fingered for ever. They just never come. One of the great last resorts is to say: "Yes, provided you pass the Bill in the present form, then we will be able to amend it later on". That is the sort of thing that never happens and we should not accept that. I would like to support this and help the Minister but it is a feeling that all Members have subscribed to. That somewhere in the Bill concretely written in there should be a statement which would satisfy the feelings that we have expressed on representation on the board of the authority. If we pass the section now, the difficulty is that it will take amending legislation and we might have to write that off forever. That is the substantive point I would like to make.
Comment on this
I do not think Senator Kennedy actually envisaged the passing of the Bill before these consultations are completed. Certainly, there should be room for staff representation provision and I would welcome the opportunity at another stage in the discussion —on Report Stage possibly when the Minister has completed his consultations—to discuss this. I would refer to my own reference to representation of the staff on the board, in Volume 86, column 656 of the Official Report where I said:
Representation of staff on the board is important because the Houses of the Oireachtas recently initiated legislation regarding industrial democracy. I would like to see the principles of that industrial democracy forthcoming in the relevant sections of this Bill to ensure that there is adequate representation of the staff on this board.
Those are my views on it. They would be the views I would express on amendment No. 4 to secton 26, tabled by Senator Quinlan and spoken to now by Senator Kennedy. We know there are discussions taking place presently. I would hope that these discussions could be completed before Report Stage so that we would know that if we were passing legislation that we were unhappy about there would be amendments, possibly by further legislation which is a cumbersome way to deal with the problem. There is no point in steamrolling something through if there are still areas in which negotiations are going on. They are not behind closed doors but they are within the proper democratic set-up of trade union negotiations. This is democracy and this is, I am sure, what the Minister is welcoming, the views of everybody concerned and there is nobody better to represent the staff on these boards than their trade unions. These are the people who are and should be doing the negotiations.
Comment on this
Just a matter of clarification on a point made by Senator Kennedy—when I made the reference to closed doors, it was not on the negotiations end of it because one can clearly see what the Congress of Trade Unions are doing. That is not where the decisions are made. The decisions I referred to are being made behind the closed doors of Government meetings when they do not seem to be aware of the urgency of the situation and where they just want to bide their time to get what they want eventually. That is what I feel is dangerous in this Bill.
Comment on this
I am very glad that Senator Kennedy has exposed the fiction that was being put forward by Senator Killilea in relation to all the terrible things that were happening in secret between the partners in the Coalition, "behind closed doors". We have all listened to him for at least an hour, putting forward a lot of fiction, a lot of stuff that is not in the Bill and which would be much more suitable outside the Church gate at Tuam.
Comment on this
If I recited what is contained in section 5 (8) of the An Foras Talúntais Act in relation to the appointment of the board it might be helpful. It is very short:
Five persons shall be nominated by such agricultural and rural organisations and in such manner as may be determined by the Government to be ordinary members of the Council.
Comment on this
I have gone much further in this Bill and have made much greater concessions to democracy, the new type of democracy that the Opposition are now talking about.
Comment on this
At least I took the trouble in the Dáil to name the organisation that I have in mind and there may be others.
Comment on this
Strictly dealing with the amendment, I have been pressed very strongly to spell out the exact number of representatives that some of the groups listed in this section will have on the board but I have resisted this pressure and I will continue to do so. I can assure all concerned that the final composition will be determined only after the fullest consideration of all representations from whatever quarter. I can give Senator Killilea one assurance——
Comment on this
——that any comment coming from Senator Killilea will not have the slightest effect on my judgment in the appointment of any member that I have to appoint on this body. I can assure him of that.
Comment on this
I would remind Senators that there is an ante-room for private conversation.
Comment on this
With regard to Senator Quinlan's proposed amendment, this section provides for staff representation on the board of the authority. As I have already said, I am not prepared at this stage to be more specific than the section is about the exact number of representatives which any group will have on the board because if I were to be more specific at this stage we would not finish this legislation in 12 months, we would have so much argument about it. There is no precedent in any previous legislation where any Minister ever spelt out in a Bill the exact number that should be appointed from every section on a board. The type of board that was provided for An Foras Talúntais has been praised at length. I gave the vague prescription that was laid down in section 8. There was no specific there and it was all the Minister.
Comment on this
This is not the Minister. Perhaps I may quote what I said in the Dáil:
This section provides for the appointment of the members of the board by the Minister on the nomination of bodies such as the General Council of the County Committees of Agriculture, such farming and rural organisations as the IFA, the ICMSA, Macra na Feirme, the Irish Countrywomen's Association, the Irish Creamery Managers' Association, and the staff of the authority, the universities, the Irish Veterinary Association, the IAOS, the processing and maketing sectors of the industry, and the livestock breeders. These are the rural groups I have in mind who will nominate people to this board. How can Deputies opposite by any stretch of the imagination say it will be rigged and only who I want will be on the board?
All these organisations will have an opportunity to nominate people whom I will accept when they have made their decision. How can this be said to be a board rigged by the Minister of the day? How can this be continuously said?
Comment on this
Because they have to be sanctioned by the Minister before they are finally taken onto the board. Why does the Minister have to sanction them after the rural organisations have chosen them? The Minister has to sanction them and has to nominate them.
Comment on this
It is exactly the same, word for word, as the legislation put through by the Fianna Fáil Government setting up the previous board.
Comment on this
The Minister put a man on the Sugar Company board who did not know the difference between a swede turnip and sugar beet. He comes in here today and says openly that he has not the right. Has he not got every right? Is it not the Minister who selects after the nominations have been put forward? Is it the Minister's intention to cod the people in that way? If they send in 45 nominations the Minister has the right to select 24 or 25 of them. Does the Minister mean to tell me that he would not look at their political history before anything else? Does the Minister mean to tell me that I would be so naive as to believe that he, and the Government he belongs to, would not pick them for their political history? That is what the Minister and his Government have done in the last four years on every single board in this country, and if the Minister would like me to name the appointees on those boards I can do it. I will do it. I know them. A man from my town was put on the board of CIE and he would not even come up on the train to Dublin; he drives up to gather his expenses. Does the Minister mean to tell me he stands over those appointments? The Minister should not stand up there, all pious, pompous and arrogant, saying that he will do all good things. We know that they have been done. There are about 4,600 peace commissioners, for God's sake.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the question which I was under the impression Senator Kennedy asked of the Minister but which has been deflected by the internecine struggle between Senator Killilea and the Minister. What is the position, as Senators Ferris and Kennedy have asked, as regards the Minister's consideration and possible acceptance of an amendment, along the lines of the amendment here, for the Report Stage? Has the Minister anything to say on that? Is he prepared to accept it?
Comment on this
No. I say that these discussions will take quite some time before they are completed. One can imagine from the list of organisations which I have named and which I intend to consider for representation on this board, in addition to the staff, that we could not possibly have all this settled and defined before the Report Stage of this Bill. It would be totally unreasonable to expect it, and in no previous legislation have we spelled out exactly who would form the membership.
Once again, I have named the organisations. I have said that I will decide at the end of the discussions what the proportions will be, but I will certainly not say who these organisations will send up to me as their representatives. Once they select their people, I will appoint them. But I will have to decide first what the representation will be and the numbers they will have.
Comment on this
That is not what the amendment says. I am trying to speak on the amendment. The Minister is now talking about the section.
Comment on this
The situation is that the Chair has been endeavouring for the best part of an hour, and the Leas-Chathaoirleach was endeavouring to do it before lunch, to ensure that the House would conduct its business in a proper fashion, which would be to confine itself to the amendment, dispose of it and then go on to the section. In spite of the efforts of the Leas-Chathaoirleach and myself, the discussion has ranged all over the section. That has been the position. The Chair has not been obeyed in this regard, and so we find ourselves willy-nilly discussing the whole of the section. There is nothing the Chair can do if Members continue to disregard the indications from the Chair. Senator West to continue.
Comment on this
I wanted to ask the Minister about the specific point Senator Quinlan makes in the amendment. Senators Kennedy, Ferris, and I have made this point. We are not asking him about organisations; we are asking about amendment No. 4. It states, basically, that a certain number of staff members of the institute should be on the board. That is the position which, as far as I can see, is impossible if the section is passed as it stands. The question is: are we going to have an opportunity to amend this at Report Stage? It is not an unreasonable question. I know the Minister has been deflected, but I should like him to answer that if he could.
Comment on this
I now read the Minister as saying that he concedes and agrees that the staff will be represented on the board. He agrees that all these organisations which he has mentioned will be represented as soon as they nominate their members. He will not dictate who they should be or what their political affiliations are or should be. He is going to say that the IFA can say X number, one, two or three. The General Council to which I referred are looking for more than one and the term is used "at least one". He is now saying that he guarantees that these people will be on the board but because consultations have not been completed he is not in a position to say how many each particular section will have, only the principle that they will be there and the numbers will be thrashed out at a later stage. Is that what the Minister is saying? If that is so, I am prepared to accept it.
Comment on this
On a point of information, what I want to get into Senator Ferris's head is that that is not what is really acceptable to us. It might satisfy him and the Labour Party but we are resisting it in toto. I have asked the Minister a question about the chairmanship of this board; he did not even think it worth his while to reply to it.
Comment on this
The chairmanship of the board does not arise on amendment No. 4.
Comment on this
It arises just as much as several matters which have been brought up here by Members against the urging of the Leas-Chathaoirleach and myself. Senator Killilea cannot have the position of continually disregarding the Chair and then saying that further matters are as relevant as what he has got away with before.
Comment on this
On a point of information for myself, if the Minister agrees with this, can he not solemnly get up and say it? What is he hiding from? What is he hiding concerning the negotiations with the Congress and trade unions? If he agrees with it let us hear him say it openly today. What is he afraid of?
Comment on this
I have simply written into this section that the staff will be represented on this body and I have not said in what proportion these various organisations will be represented. I am not going to say it. I have given a guarantee to one organisation only, and that is the county committees of agriculture and the advisory services. There is one organisation that has been guaranteed—"at least one"—and there is a cry about that too.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned in the Dáil a list of organisations which could nominate members and he left out, I notice, the national executive representing the Irish livestock trade.
Comment on this
The national executive of the Irish livestock trade had a nomination in An Foras Talúntais. Will they continue to have a nomination?
Comment on this
I have come in late in the discussion. On our county committees there are elected representatives and there are nominees, but there is no doubt they are all from farming organisations. They belong either to the ICMSA or the IFA. Without asking these organisations specifically to appoint somebody or to have another rat race in their organisation, they are already—automatically, I believe—on the county committees of agriculture, be they the ICMSA or IFA.
The only group not represented there are the rural women. I will make a point that the others are already represented on the committees of agriculture all over Ireland and the only group that has no representation is the farm home advisory service. I would make a plea for those. As regards the others, they are already adequately represented.
Comment on this
After the discussion we have had it is clear that on all sides there is full support for the necessity of staff representation. The Minister has conceded that point. I can see the difficulties of the continuing negotiations. It is stated here that the Minister will, by order, set out the conditions and so on. That is something, of course, that has been used many times in the past and it is a device that is acceptable provided that the order would be made amenable to the Houses; in other words, the order in question should be laid before each House of the Oireachtas to be considered by the House within the 21 days usually allowed for that procedure. This is stated in section 35 (7) in connection with the superannuation provisions. It is something which is quite normal and I do not see any reason why the same procedure would not apply to the orders made by the Minister under this section. This applies in the Agriculture (An Foras Talúntais) Act. Having had the debate and having had such a volume of support for that representation—indeed I feel we are pushing an open door with the Minister who recognises the necessity for that—I would be quite happy if he would bring the orders under the regular routine provision and lay them on the table of the House. There could be a debate on it then if there was volume of support for the view that justice had not been done. If that were the case I would be quite happy to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
In that case, then the debate has served its purpose and, I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
Senator Quinlan, who was the proposer of the motion, has asked for leave to withdraw it. That is a matter for the House to decide. If Senator Martin wishes to raise a point that is entirely on the amendment then this would be in order but otherwise, if it is something that can arise in the section, he should wait until the question of the amendment is disposed of.
Comment on this
It is a rather tricky situation when on one's feet. If the Chair would just listen for a moment to what I am saying he could perhaps decide—help me to decide— what the issue is. I raised a point earlier about which the Minister expressed a sort of horror. The representation from the research, advisory, processing and marketing areas was mentioned in Senator Quinlan's amendment. Would such people be elected or selected? Section 26 (3) states:
... shall be selected for nomination in accordance with the provisions of an order made for that purpose by the Minister and any such order shall indicate the procedure for filling casual vacancies in the membership of the Board.
That was something decided on after the Bill was passed. The explanatory memorandum states:
The remaining members will be selected from prescribed organisations, in accordance with the terms of a statutory order.
This is still very much on the amendment.
Comment on this
I have heard enough from the Senator to realise that he is quoting from subsection (3) whereas subsection (1) is the subsection that is the subject of the amendment. I should be glad if we could dispose of the question of the amendment and then allow the——
Comment on this
It could be disposed of very amicably if I could simply confirm what I think the Minister has said. Various bodies will have representatives on the board. I should like the Minister to confirm that those representatives will not be selected from above but will, in fact, be elected by their peers from below. If I could get assurance from the Minister on that I would be silent on the rest of the section, on the lot. With all due deference to my colleague, Senator Killilea, the Minister has in a way been blocked from giving straight answers to straight questions for some time by very colourful rhetoric from this side of the House.