National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 196–390 of 390. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1976 ›
May I say something about the request for the withdrawal of the amendment? The amendment, Cathaoirleach, is strictly in accord with the provisions of the legislation on worker participation in respect of the number of staff to be appointed on the board. It is not in accordance with that other Bill regarding the method of appointment of the staff. For this reason, and in the hope that the Minister, when reconsidering this whole section, will bear in mind the desirability of having a uniform system of appointment of staff in State and semi-State companies and boards, I would welcome the withdrawal of this amendment. It is very desirable that there should be a uniform system, otherwise the whole concept of the worker participation legislation would be in jeopardy. Apart altogether from this, it is only a question of time before the EEC Green Paper on worker participation is translated into a directive and it is certain that that directive, whatever else it may contain, will suggest a uniform system of appointment nationally and amongst the member countries. If we have a uniform system of appointment and procedure of appointment of staff to public boards it will be easier for us to conform with the EEC directive.
Comment on this
We have given a guarantee of representation to the farmers. I have been asked if the representatives will be selected or elected. This is part of the discussions that must take place. We will have a composite staff and this staff will be represented by a number of unions. There will have to be considerable discussion as to how the representation from the staff will be appointed, but I will not appoint them. They will have to be nominated by the staff representatives. That is the only way I can see it.
I would just like to say about Senator Kennedy's contribution that I do not accept that we should have uniformity for the sake of uniformity. If we are dealing with totally different situations and totally different boards I do not think that at all times it will be suitable to have the same uniform system and this, in fact, was not accepted even by the Minister who put the legislation through the House. He did say that the legislation he was putting through applied specifically to commercial-type boards and that it did not apply to the other types boards.
I have given a solid guarantee here that there will be worthwhile staff representation. I will not interfere unduly in the way that the staff go about selecting the people who will represent them. I want them to work that out as efficiently and effectively as they can. That is their responsibility.
Comment on this
I must point out to the Senators that the Chair is only prepared to hear on the section arguments that have not been made before.
Comment on this
I do not think that is very fair to me, because it is not my fault——
Comment on this
When I say arguments that have not been made before I mean arguments not made before by that particular individual.
Comment on this
I will be very brief. The General Council of Committees of Agriculture feel that they are entitled to eight members on this new board. I do not agree because to look for a third of the membership of this board is going altogether too far. While they have gone to one extreme the Minister has gone to the other extreme in saying that at least one member will be from the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. When he provided for at least one member we know it will, in fact, be just one. It cannot be less than one. I would suggest to the Minister at this stage that he should be good enough to say to us that the General Council of Committees of Agriculture are entitled to two members and that he will give them two members. After all, they represent 27 committees of agriculture and there are three representatives from each county on that body. It is a fairly big body of people who know quite a lot about agriculture. They are not all politicians. There are a few people on that board who have been co-opted and who never stood for the county council or anything like that. The one representative will represent one political party.
In fairness to the Minister, I do think that he will probably select the man who will be nominated. I think the Minister should do so. It would be very wrong if the Minister did not do that. I would rather see two political parties represented at that level.
The Minister has mentioned a number of rural organisations that may be represented on this new board. It is a difficult thing to decide which rural organisations should be represented and which should not. Quite a number of organisations will spring up straight away now looking for representation.
The Minister did not mention two organisations that are doing a lot of work for the small farmer. They are the Land League and the Small Farmers Defence Association. The latter was founded during the past few years and the work they are doing is principally for the small farmers. With all due respects to the farming organisations like the IFA and others, while they may be doing a bit for the small farmer it is the big farmer who is gaining most by their work. The Land League and the Small Farmers Defence Association are two bodies that are endeavouring to get the Land Commission to take over land and divide it amongst the small farmers in order to improve their lot in life. When the time comes around for the final selection of this board I hope that those two bodies will not be left out.
The Minister also mentoined how the council of An Foras Talúntais was set up and he said that the Minister appointed the five people on that board who represented the farming bodies. The Minister, I suppose, had the final say, but he appointed the people who were selected by the farming organisations. I do not know how many farming organisations there are but I do know that in 1950 when the first council of the Agricultural Institute was set up there were 25 farming organisations seeking nominations on the council. In order to sort things out the Minister suggested that they be divided into five different classes. One class or section represented the dairying section, comprised of members of the Creamery Milk Suppliers Association, the Dublin milk producers, the Cork milk producers, the creamery managers association and I think the IAOS; they came together and selected one person. The tillage farmers did likewise and so did cattlemen. There were five sections, and that is how the council was set up. I think it was a very good way of doing it. I hope that the Minister will do something like that when it comes to the setting up of the board rather than let them all fight for it. As I say, there were 25 rural organisations in 1958; there are probably 50 such organisations today who will be seeking representation on this board.
Comment on this
I want to make a couple of points concerning this section and particularly the appointment of the chairman and the board. First of all, I would like to refer to Senator Quinlan's remarks concerning the board and his suggestion that the numbers were suitable. Clearly the Minister has a problem if he is going to try to give representation to the many organisations who have a claim to membership of the board. These claims should be resisted. I do not like to see boards of this size.
Senator Quinlan gave the university analogies, and this is right. The boards work relatively well in universities. All universities have boards of about this size. As Senator Quinlan will recall from the debate in the Seanad when the institute was set up, there was considerable discussion as to whether the institute should be an agricultural university or whether it should be more narrowly defined. The vote came down in favour of setting up an institute whose function was essentially to do applied research in agriculture and to have much more specific tasks than an agricultural university would have had. The analogy failed on that ground. I do not think that what is suitable for a university is suitable for an institute of the type of the Agricultural Research Institute or, indeed, of a board of this size. What I see happening is that when the numbers get to the size of the present numbers, 23, 24 or 25, the board becomes less efficient. Therefore, it becomes easier to manipulate a board of this size than a smaller number such as the 12 we had previously in the council of the Agricultural Institute.
I have soldiered on through this debate and I am feeling somewhat like the Minister with my patience expiring, and I do not intend to continue much longer, but I have done so because of the points so succinctly made by Senator Eoin Ryan earlier on the Committee Stage concerning the bureau-cratisation of a successful body such as the Agricultural Institute and the extension of civil service control—the sort of thing set out in the Devlin Report, which I dislike intensely. I shall continue to oppose this process. The test of this process is in the sort of appointment the Minister will make of the chairman. The director of the authority is covered in section 31 and the first appointment is made by the Minister. From there on the board makes the appointment which is similar to the set-up in the Agricultural Institute where, in 1958, the first director was appointed by the Minister and from there on the council chose their own director. I do not see how anyone could find a better director for the authority than the man who is currently Director of the Agricultural Institute, Dr. Walsh, who has made an outstanding contribution.
On this section we are concerned with the appointment of the chairman. It would be wrong if the chairman of this board turned out to be like the chairman of so many of these boards have turned out to be in recent times, a civil servant or a former civil servant. This would be doing precisely the thing that we have been trying to resist.
Comment on this
Section 27 deals specifically with the chairman.
Comment on this
This deals with the chairman. I am not going to dwell on it for very long. This discussion has gone on long enough. But I would like to make the point before I sit down. We are talking about the very sensitive area of appointment. I do not know who the chairman might be— whether he is a civil servant or a former civil servant—but it would be the wrong thing in this situation. A strong chairman from outside all the bodies concerned is needed—the Department, the Institute, or the other two education and research services which work from the Department— because one wants to be in a position where one has an independent person, obviously with a strong farming background, who is able to stand up to the Minister, if necessary. The Minister has the power to dispose of the chairman, but he will appoint the chairman. The appointment of someone from the civil service, which would mean, in this case, someone from the Department of Agriculture, would just be cementing the grip that I believe the Department would get on this new body. It would be totally wrong. That is the point that I have striven to fight in the Committee Stage of this Bill. All I could say is that if the Minister does make an appointment of that nature, then it confirms all my worst suspicions.
The Minister talked about threats when Senator Killilea talked about appointments. Nobody is in any position to threaten the Minister. The only threat that has been issued is something that I would go along with when Senator Lenihan said that Fianna Fáil would repeal this Act if and when they get into office. That is not a threat. That is a political statement.
Comment on this
That is a point. As an Independent I will do my best to hold them to that because I dislike the whole spirit of this Bill. The appointment of the chairman will be one of the tests as to whether bureaucratic control from the Department of Agriculture will allow the board to develop its own identity and personality, and whether it is going to be able to get the freedom it will need.
I would make a final plea to the Minister to appoint someone from outside the civil service, from outside the areas we are talking about, someone who is independent and someone who can give the lead that such a chairman will have to give.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister if he has any intention at present of appointing a member of the Mountain Sheep Breeders' Association to this board. We all realise that the sheep stocks are decreasing at an enormous rate. With the disaster we had in Mayo and Galway last year, as a result of some errors or a lackadaisical attitude by the Department of Agriculture, we had a very severe outbreak of scab in both counties. I think the Minister has accepted that the responsibility lies with the Department of Agriculture. I am sure that under these circumstances it will be of benefit to the method of increasing the sheep numbers. They have been practically reduced by half within the last five or six years. The sheep trade is in a very sorry state at present. The Mountain Sheep Breeders' Association should have a representative on this board in order to look after the interests of the sheep farmers.
Comment on this
I agree with what Senator Garrett has said. The Minister is only picking one representative from the committees of agriculture. This is too small a number. These committees represent the agricultural committees of all Ireland. There should be one from each province, because if there is only one person, that person will probably be from the south of Ireland. There are other parts in Ireland, particularly along the western coast, where sheep farmers suffer a lot because the Department went back to the single dip in a season instead of having a double dip. It is important that the people in the grass roots of farming would know that they are being adequately represented on this board. Despite the expert knowledge civil servants have, it does not mean the same thing to the farmer. They have been proven wrong last year as far as delivering sheep is concerned and, indeed, on many other aspects.
If a committee such as this is totally dominated by a wealthy section of the community it will be to the detriment of the ordinary small farmer who will find it hard to spare a day to come to a meeting, and who, when he is here, will feel inferior amidst people of that calibre. The Minister will have to have a representative from the general council of committees from this province. This is a big organisation but there are other farmers and other people engaged in producing agricultural goods who are not under the umbrella of those organisations. At the same time, they would feel that they should be represented. A man is free and a farmer is free to do what he wishes, but at the same time if there was one member on this board who was an elected representative of the committee of agriculture, at least he would feel there was some representation. Because of the small numbers in, the Beekeepers' Association, the Sheep Breeders' Association and other associations, they will not have any hope of getting representation.
Comment on this
I have spoken prior to this on most of the issues in this section. I want to ask the Minister about the chairmanship of the board. I would also like to add to the points made by Senator Ryan and Senator Dolan concerning the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture. I think Senator Dolan's suggestion is quite an appropriate one. It is important that we have a member from each province, and it is vitally important to us in the west of Ireland that we have a member on this board and that he should come from the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture.
In my county we are very big producers of store cattle and potatoes and the second biggest producers of beef. We are coming into our own at last as milk producers. It would be foolish of the Minister to thwart the wishes of those people. He cannot in conscience, as has been done in previous boards, deny the claim of the good reliable Connachtman, be he political or otherwise. Politicians can be acceptable to the community. The Minister himself has recognised that in the Wool Marketing Board with Deputy John Callanan. He is very acceptable not only to the local community but also to the Government. I can explain why Deputy Callanan is left on that board. The Minister would not have the guts to put him off because he could not get another man in Connacht to replace him.
Comment on this
Senator Killilea should not labour the point.
Comment on this
I am just making that point in case the Minister might think otherwise. The people of Connacht are no fools.
Another organisation that deserves recognition is the Horse Breeders' Association. They command worldwide respect for the types of animals they breed, including the Connemara pony, which is a great national seller. A person representative of that organisation should be included for selection by the Minister for this board. That of course will not guarantee selection. The proper political elements for selection must be presented to the Minister. The tactics are quite clear. If he is of the right political persuasion he is a certainty. Even the Labour Party are going to lose. The idea is: "all things being equal, we will look after ourselves". Another point is in connection with a casual vacancy. I have indicated two types. There is the obvious one, R.I.P. The definition of "casual vacancy"——
Comment on this
Senator Killilea is repeating himself.
Comment on this
I have no intention of continuing on. I just want to put this on the record of the House. There should be some explanation in this regard. There are many people on this and on the other side of the House who would like to know the meaning of "casual vacancy". The Minister has given off the top of his head a number of rural organisations. I did not get them all. I got some of them. He meant well, possibly, but he was going so fast I could not think of them all. In regard to the 50 good solid, rural organisations who submit the names of their nominees for selection by the Minister, will he explain to the House his definition of what he considers the most worthy to serve? How, for instance, will he deal with the situation of a tillage farmer as against a milk farmer? There are two organisations representing the milk farmers. We have one organisation representative of the tillage farmers.
This year the Minister and his Department have been getting the whole country to turn to tillage. How is he going to pick? How is he going to choose a tillage farmer to be a representative on this board? He himself stated—and I think maybe he has made a mistake in this Bill—that in the Foras Talúntais representation the Government reserve the right to have five. Which of the bigger organisations is going to produce a tillage farmer? It is a problem. Maybe if the Minister had thought a little longer he could have reserved two or three and I certainly would not be against it if the Minister was in earnest about the type of men he would put on the board. What are the potato growers going to say to the Minister if he is still Minister next Autumn? Where will they turn if they are not on this new board? There is no point in putting down motions in Seanad and in the other House, as we did before on several occasions, asking the Minister to do something. We are late. Nearly every field from here to Belclare, on the Minister's own instruction, is filled with potatoes. I hope he is not going to leave the potatoes as he has left them in 1974, rotting by the sides of the walls.
Comment on this
No, but I may be and the Minister may be very sorry they are grown in the quantities in which he has allowed them to be grown. I live in one of the best potato producing parishes in the country, and I have seen the misery and misfortune arising from this type of chat from the Department of Agriculture: go out and do this and go out and do that. We have always grown potatoes, and under Deputy Clinton's Ministry we had two terrible years and if we are now heading for the third what are those people going to say?
The Minister and his officials know they have made a terrible blunder in regard to this Bill. Maybe it would not have been such a bad thing at all if the Minister had copied from the previous Act. Under the previous Act, which was proposed by a Fianna Fáil Government, we would get five out of 12. There is still a majority; but under this Bill the Minister has a complete majority, the 20 for himself.
Comment on this
The Minister may have 50 nominations and I ask him how he will sort them out. What is the qualification? He may have 60 or 70. He has referred in this Bill to "the remaining members who shall be representative of agricultural and rural organisations"—words used by the Minister or by someone who drafted this for him. How is he going to fix them? He could pick out two or three big organisations and fix them up. He would fix them up anyhow, because he would be afraid to do anything else. But how will he pick the remainder? I know how he will do it. He will pick the remainder as he picked them before, not possibly the Minister but what he will be told to do. There will be letters from Fine Gael and Labour TDs swarming down on top of him. His Private Secretary will be bursting at the seams. There will be party meetings above in the Fine Gael room deciding who is the best Fine Gael man.
That is how it is going to end. That is how it has gone on for the last four years. That is how the Minister has operated for the last four years. There is no indication in this Bill that he will now operate any differently, although the Minister will stand up and try to be sincere on this point. His party have hogged the appointments. It did not matter what their qualifications were. So long as they were above primary education they qualified. As I said before, if they did not achieve primary certificate standard then they were eligible to become peace commissioners. That is how the Minister sorted them out to date.
Will the Minister tell us now how he is going to overcome this problem if every rural organisation that he has named in this Bill makes a nomination to him? Will he go about it in a different way to that which this Government have done in the recent past? It is a disgrace. That is why I ask the Minister, a man with respect throughout the country, why does he not hold two or three positions here so that he will have the right to pick men he knows are capable of working on this board honestly and with integrity, whether they be politicians or otherwise. It is not the end of the world to be a politician.
Therefore I say now is the time for the Minister to protect himself. Do not get lost in this morass of the old Cumann na nGaedheal type talk. I listened last night when the Leader of this House got up to defend the Minister for Agriculture. What I heard can only be described as the old Cumann na nGaedheal line. One speaker stands up, makes his speech and is then forgotten.
That is the situation one finds oneself under this section. I want the Minister to tell me how is he going to pick the nominees from this 50 or 60. He has only named about ten. In so naming those ten does he exclude the other possible 40? Is this a new trick? Nominate ten and get the Government to fill the other ten. Now it is becoming clear to me. Now I understand what the Minister has done. I knew there would be no change in performance. He picked ten out of the bag, named them in a very sly way, a typical Fine Gael way, and then let the Government pick the other ten political hacks. If he picks the chairman he controls the board. That is a real Fine Gael set-up and we have caught the Minister in the act.
I am not being cynical. I thought there was more to the Minister for Agriculture than that. I did not think he would come here, slyly name ten and say that that was it. This will be done by the decision of the Fine Gael and Labour Parliamentary Parties. They will decide the majority on this board, as they decided the majority on every other board. I hope that when the time comes the Minister will not forget a certain nominee, Professor Quinlan.
Comment on this
I said earlier that the Senator was allowing his imagination to run away with him. I think he still imagines he is outside the church in Tuam. I do not know whether he is even going to be a candidate at the next election, he may be even Independent as he threatened before. I do not know where he is getting all his confused ideas. One moment he is applauding the idea of appointing politicians—they are great people, unpaid people—and the next minute he is decrying the possibility that politicians may be appointed.
Comment on this
I do not think he knows what he wants. He expresses a lot of concern about the people in the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. The Fianna Fáil spokesman on Agriculture in the Dáil last October brought out the Fianna Fáil gospel. He said they should be all abolished because they were a ridiculous outfit. He said that the control of the advisory services by committees of agriculture had become an absolute absurdity. That was Fianna Fáil thinking in October. Now we cannot get sufficient representation for them on the board. He blackened them and now wants to put some other organisation he has in mind—a co-op or something—in their place. Nobody said a word about co-ops here today. Nobody said they should be represented on the board. I simply named the sort of organisations I felt should be represented on this board because I felt these people should be close to the farming requirements, close to agriculture and knowing something about the industry and its needs. I named those organisations. As soon as Deputy E. Ryan spoke he specified two further farming organisations he thought it was a shame not to have named as important organisations. I think we have one too many farming organisations at the moment. We would be better if we had one farming organisation representing the lot. I always thought it was a pity, and I said so publicly before, but to add two more organisations to this is a bit too much for me.
I am endeavouring as far as possible to have all the important sectors represented on this board, and now the Opposition have suggested other possible organisations. They complain on the one hand that the proposed board is too large and then name new organisations they think should be represented. Also, I should hold three, four or five members up my cuff who I know would be useful members on this board and I should have the courage to appoint them, even if they are politicians.
One of the things that has pleased me most throughout this debate, and it has been mentioned on at least three occasions by Senator Killilea, is that the agricultural sector was never doing as well as it is at the moment in the west, and particularly in Galway. This does not agree with what some of the people on that side have been saying, but I am glad that the Senator had the courage to come here and say what is a fact.
Comment on this
The people have responded well, and I am very pleased to acknowledge that they have never done better. They have increased milk production——
Comment on this
When I assumed office I was told by the people in the west that sugar beet could not be grown there. Arrangements were being made to close down Tuam. What is happening now? I said we would grow beet in the west, keep Tuam open and spend £750,000 re-equipping Tuam, despite what the people were saying down there.
Comment on this
The Minister, without interruption on section 26.
Comment on this
We are nearly embarrassed now by the amount of sugar beet that is being grown in the west. I hope we will have to expand the sugar beet factory in the west. I am proud we are getting that sort of response. To hear Senator Killilea regretting the fact that they have responded by increasing tillage, in a country where we have less than ten per cent of the total land area in tillage, is appalling. Perhaps I am going a bit outside the section.
Comment on this
The Chair maintains order, not the Senator.
Comment on this
On section 26, the Minister is replying to points raised in the debate.
Comment on this
I would like to explain why I have opted for a large board. The functions of the authority are many and diverse, and the organisations with a direct interest in agriculture are also diverse. You have education, research, and many different sectors. I have provided for a large membership to allow for the fullest involvement of all these organisations. The section has also been criticised on the basis that it allows the Minister to exercise undue influence in appointing board members. It is clear to me that those who have levelled this sort of criticism have either not read this section or have chosen to misread it. Under this section the agricultural and rural organisations represented on the board of the authority will choose their own nominees for appointment. So, too, will the general council.
Comment on this
They will choose their own nominees for appointment, and I am giving that positive undertaking. I do not want Members of this House to continue to misrepresent that situation. The staff and the other interests listed will also have the same privilege. How then can criticism of this kind possibly be justified? I have said this over and over, and I can do no more. I want this to be a good board. I want it to exercise its authority as it should. There is no difference in the procedure I am following in setting up this board and the procedures that have been laid down under the Foras Talúntais Act—I have read them— except that in this case I am making provision for representation for the staff. That was not done under the Foras Talúntais Act and was never done before. If they complain about the methods being used here under section 26, it is very difficult for the Opposition speakers to justify their criticism.
Comment on this
Now that the Minister has mentioned that we are all very reassured.
Comment on this
I am not reassured. The only thing I am reassured about is that he has named about ten of the board. That is an assurance, but he has not yet said how many of that ten were coming from the General Council of Committees of Agriculture.
Comment on this
That is such a stupid remark that I would not even comment on it. That is not what we have been talking about here all day. The second point is that the Minister made no reference to the chairmanship of this board. He has not told us who will get the last 12 or 13 seats. He now says that we should have only one farming organisation in the country, and that would leave 22 or 23 seats to be filled. The Bill says "at least one member", and that is all there may be. Assuming the maximum would be ten, how are you going to fill the remainder?
Comment on this
That is what I am saying. Senator Martin quickly accepted and was delighted with the Minister's statement. So was I, but I would have been more delighted if the Minister would tell us how he will fill the remaining 12 posts. This is what I want to know.
Comment on this
This is again misrepresentation, I am sorry to say. I want to explain again. I have listed ten organisations that I feel at this moment are entitled to representation. That is not to say that they will each get one; some might be entitled to two or three. I will not know until I have looked at all the organisations that should and could profitably be represented on this board. You have to accept that I am trying to find the best possible board to do the job. Why would I not? I have a very big responsibility because when it comes to agriculture the buck rests at the table of whoever is in this job. If there is trouble he has to answer. He is not going to foolishly pick a board that is going to do a bad job.
Comment on this
This is the point I am trying to make. If the Minister has taken this Bill through both Houses and has not yet made up his mind about allocating seats on the board, then my argument is that he has made no commitment concerning at least ten remaining seats and that he is open to pressures for those seats. Those pressures could come, and I say they will come, from his own political party more than from the rural community. He does not deny that fact.
Comment on this
I call his bluff when he says that we are misrepresenting the facts. I have illustrated the facts in this House today, and if the Minister wants to pick out any other board, I will name the people he put on them and their qualifications. I dare any Fine Gael Senator to ask me about any board.
Comment on this
Senator Killilea, we are on section 26.
Comment on this
I am on section 26. It is very important because the Minister certainly has not changed my opinion, or the opinion of any Member on this side of the House, about the remaining ten members. He glibly said some organisations might get two or three. How do those organisations know today that they are supposed to send in for selection a range of ten names, for instance? Some organisations may get up to ten, if the Minister sees fit. What happens if they only send in one or two nominations, when they might actually get four members on the board? What instructions will be given to those individual organisations that he has handpicked for nominations to this board? What is the general council of committees of agriculture going to do? How many names are they supposed to send in? They are supposed to send in at least one; but "at least one" is not good enough. The Minister may even have a change in mind about the county committees of agriculture and he may even give them four or five. What are they to do? They do not know how many names they are supposed to send in. Would the Minister clarify this point? I think it is vital.
It would be a disgrace and a catastrophe if an organisation sent in one name for selection and later complained because they did not get all their seats. The Minister could turn round and say "you only sent me in one name, what happened the rest of the names? Why didn't you send me in four or five to pick from?" Where do they stand? How many names do they send in? How many names do the IFA, the ICMSA or the ICA send in? How many names does the general council of committees of agriculture send in? What is the criteria? Where do we go? Where do we turn? We are all lost in this morass. Would the Minister explain that point? I will call the Minister's bluff a thousand times.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that he is appointing members of the staff on the new board. He went further and said that that is more than was done when An Foras Talúntais were being set up. At that time, a staff member could not be appointed to the board because they had no staff. There was nobody but the council and the director at the start.
Comment on this
Yes, there is. Does the Minister mean to say that the 2,000 people now working on the staff of An Foras Talúntais are not regarded as staff? Those people are worried that they will be completely ignored.
The director of An Foras Talúntais looked after the staff very well but the position has changed. That staff will be integrated with other groups and they will not know where they are. I hope that when the Minister is appointing staff to the board that members of the present staff of An Foras Talúntais will be included. I I should like to point out that there will be no credit to the Minister for appointing them because he must do it. At the same time he should not make comparisons between what is happening now and what happened when An Foras Talúntais was set up because at that time they could not appoint anyone from the staff because they had no staff.
Comment on this
The Senator will notice if he looks at section 26 (2) (b) that provision is made for the appointment of the staff representatives when the staff come into existence. There is no staff in the new authority yet, and there was no staff in An Foras Talúntais when it was first established. Fianna Fáil could have made the same provision at that time. They could have waited for the staff to come into existence, left the places vacant and then appointed them, as we propose to do under this Bill.
Comment on this
That is exactly how it is being done in this Bill, and the provision is there. But it cannot be done immediately because the staff are not in existence.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that the existing staff of these bodies are to be sacked? The whole point is ridiculous.
Comment on this
No, we want the staff to nominate their own representation. When they have time to come together and do that, we will appoint them. We are leaving the vacancies for that purpose.
Comment on this
I have told Senators that I am not prepared to say how many or to put a number on anything. I have said at least one for the county committees of agriculture. Further than that I will not go.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot say that we are misrepresenting him. He is the person who got up in this House, as the record will show, and named approximately ten rural organisations. In the next breath he said that his personal desire is that we would only have one rural organisation. We are not misrepresenting anything. It is clear to me that the Minister has put all those organisations into a situation where— and this is where the trick is—they will all send him about ten names. If they do not do that, they could lose out. What does the Minister do then? He picks from the ten.
Comment on this
Explain this. If those rural organisations want nominees on this board, could the Minister tell the IFA, the ICMSA or any other body he has named how many names they should submit for selection?
Comment on this
When I have finished holding discussions I will then tell them the number, and that is the number they will send in.
Comment on this
I am holding discussions with whatever organisations I think are relevant to the board.
Comment on this
The point is very clear now. The Minister is in touch with organisations he thinks fit.
Comment on this
I am not talking about previous legislation. I am talking about the legislation the Minister is responsible for in this House. What he is saying now is that he decides which organisations should be represented on the board and the number of seats to be given to those organisations. One of those organisations he has specifically stated "shall have at least one member" and that he is most afraid of. The general council of the committees of agriculture to whom he gives at least one seat and whose members are responsible to the people through the ballot boxes, may not get as many on this board as some private rural organisations who are responsible to nobody. I would go so far as to say that the people who run these organisations could not get elected to the local bodhrán team. The Minister is now going to decide, on his own, that the elected members of the general council of the committees of agriculture are not as entitled to, and shall not get, the same representation as some of those other rural organisations.
I have no intention of naming any of them because this is where the Minister committed a big sin. He is going to take his preferences of A, B, C, D, E, and F. He will say that A will get so many, B will get so many, C will get so many and when you come to F he will say: "Well, we had better try to divide up the rest". Is that the way he is going to do it?
Comment on this
Do you know why we had to suggest doing that? The Minister read part of a statement, but he did not read it all. That is what I call the Fine Gael bluff. The reason why we had to say things like that was because the Minister created the impression that the county committees of agriculture were not doing their work. The Galway County Committee of Agriculture requested from the Minister and his Department over the last four years the appointment of at least 12 county advisers and he refused them. I can say the same for Mayo, Sligo and some other county committees of agriculture. Those committees could not function because the Minister choked them. The Minister and the Department of Agriculture have deliberately done that and the blame rests on the Minister's table.
Comment on this
There are only ten Fianna Fáil members on the Galway County Committee of Agriculture. The only problem concerning that issue was that despite all the pundits of Fine Gael at the council election, and some of whom were on the county committee of agriculture at that time, they blamed the Fianna Fáil Galway County Council for not doing A, B, C, D, E and F. What I said then I say now: the next time they make that accusation they will be telling the truth because the Galway County Council is now a Fianna Fáil organisation, and we are proud of that fact. When we get beaten we will take it and we will not go around crying in the wilderness.
Today the Minister for Agriculture has created the greatest morass of all times. He made the decision that the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture shall get at least one nominee and that he shall pick the remainder of the board from whatever organisations he deems fit and which are, I assert, Fine Gael/Coalition minded. The more they are aligned towards the Government, the more they are steeped in political hackery, the better chance they have of getting on this board. The Minister has not mentioned the chairmanship of this board and he has dodged the issue of putting clearly on the record that he shall not be a civil servant or an ex-civil servant. He has refused to do that.
Comment on this
We will be delighted when it comes, but as this Bill is being teased through this House, new elements of——
Comment on this
No, weird crookedness —begin to emerge. I never thought that the Coalition were so bad. I knew they were bad but it never dawned on me that they were so twisted. It never crossed my mind that a Government under the Taoiseach, Deputy Cosgrave could be so twisted as to have the audacity to nominate the rural organisations of this country, numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6. I never thought that in the passing of this Bill through the House, we would find that the Minister for Agriculture—supposed by the hacks of the Fine Gael Party and some of the Labour Party to be a genius— would stoop so low as to nominate in order of preference and he has now admitted that is what he is doing—in order of his choice the rural organisations of this country 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6. Would the Minister let the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture—a responsible elected body— know how many members they would submit to the Minister for selection? Will he do that? Will he answer that question now for me?
Comment on this
The statement made by the Minister a few minutes ago in reply to my question about the staff is a very serious one because it is the first time that we have learned that the staff of the Agricultural Institute are going to be sacked. He has said that he has no staff: when this board is set up there will be no staff. Now, I would take it that when the Bill is passed, if the Minister is really taking on the 2,000 or so people who are working for An Foras at the moment, as in other cases they would automatically become members of the staff of the new authority. He cannot appoint the 24-member board until the Bill is passed. Could he not, there and then, appoint those people to the staff? It is no use his saying that: "You did not do it when you had the opportunity when An Foras Talúntais was set up". As I have said, they started with a 12-man council and one employee, if you like, a director. It took him years and years to build up a staff: they are still building up that staff. In the first year of their foundation I think they had not any more than 50 people working for them.
It is ridiculous for the Minister to say that we could have waited at that time to appoint members of the staff, that we could have waited until we had the staff, because they have not a full staff even yet in An Foras. The difference now is that some 2,000 people are going over from Foras Talúntais to a new authority. They are not happy about it at all; they are worried in case their status or salaries might be affected. The Minister has told us all along that that would not happen. Now he says that when this board is set up there will be no staff. That means that the new board is going to recruit a staff. Have we any guarantee that the 2,000 people who are working for An Foras Talúntais at the moment will be taken into that staff?
Comment on this
When I say 2,000, I reckon myself that the total staff of An Foras is about 1,460 or something like that; I think that is the exact figure, if you want the exact figure.
Comment on this
Would the Minister answer the questions I asked him about the mountain sheep farmers' association?
Comment on this
I do not mind considering any worth-while rural organisations. I would certainly have a look at it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister refer to the point I raised regarding at least one from each province who was a member of the general council——
Comment on this
It may even possibly happen in the foreseeable future that only one member of the staff will be appointed. With all the Minister's peculiarities, he may say: "Give me one member." They may not accept it. What does he do then? He has made a hash out of the whole thing because he is trying to speculate in his own peculiar way. There was a time when one would believe what he said, but after what he said here today nobody could believe what he is saying. He does not know whether he is coming or going. What do we make of a man who would dare say that he would make a decision on who were in the rural organisations of this country in priority, the strong and the weak? It is a disgraceful performance. Senator Martin says that he accepted what the Minister has said. I do not even accept what Senator Martin agreed with, because I do not know what will happen if the Minister says at the end of the day that the staff of An Foras Talúntais are only going to get one member. What will happen then? This is no way to treat this House and try to fool the people in the most peculiar way I have ever seen in a democracy. It would not happen even in a banana republic. Fidel Castro would not do this in such a filthy, low way. I thought Cumann na nGaedhael were bad when I read about them in the times gone by. They would not blow wind to this outfit. That is the lowest performance by any Government since we got our freedom or what we have of it. No government should say to the rural community, to the agricultural community, that this organisation is better than that organisation or that organisation is worse than the other. The Government have not the courage to say to the elected representatives who go before the people, the General Council of the Committees of Agriculture: "You will have four or you will have two or you will at least have one." We do not accept that situation.
We now see the Minister in his true light. Now we see that the National Coalition Government is 50 times worse than what we read about the Blue Shirts. Never in the history of this State have I seen such a performance. I think it is crude; I think it is low. We are almost in a state of anarchy. The Minister for Agriculture and the Government will now decide, among the rural organisations built up voluntarily by the sweat of many people, that this is No. 1, this No. 10 and that No. 24. This is what they are at. I have asked the Minister at this late stage to change his attitude of saying "I will not give numbers". By so saying he is naming numbers because he will be compelled to name numbers.
I smell trouble in this Government. I smell trouble between the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party at Government level. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions do their business openly, but the decisions on these matters are dealt with behind the closed doors of Government. Fine Gael and Labour are "at it". I do not think we will have an election in June because we will not have this board before June. A few other boards will have to be filled in July. I think we will probably have it in the last week in September when we have another fixing operation done. The decision of the Minister and the Government is distasteful, to say the least of it. They have taken it upon themselves like dictators to say to the rural population: "We will decide which of your rural organisations is good or bad." That is nothing less than dictatorship. That is what we are witnessing in this House and it is a sad day. We witnessed some of it last night; we witness much more of it as this Bill goes through. I am sorry for the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I want to protest again that the attitude of the Minister here in not saying that at least there will be four people from the General Council of County Councils on this board. I think that is a fair assessment. After all, the General Council of these Committees of Agriculture are, for the most part, elected representatives and they represent the various committees of agriculture at central level. Is it right for a Minister to ignore that great volume of opinion, and especially opinion from people who know agriculture from A to Z, people who have worked on the farms and who have produced the goods and who are members of their own committees of agriculture and who as Senator Killilea has said, have been trying to push the Minister to appoint extra staff so as to have better jobs done at each level? Or is it that the Minister is not satisfied with this General Council; has he something up his sleeve so far as each county committee of agriculture here is concerned? The majority of the committees deplore the attitude of the Minister and pass resolutions deploring his inefficient attitude on behalf of the people of this country in Europe. In particular, they remember in 1974 when the farmers of this country were losing an average of £70 per animal or £60 to £70 per animal by virtue of the fact that the Minister sat there glued to his seat in the EEC when the beef came in from outside the EEC. The Minister then has the audacity to take credit for what the farmers are doing at present, rejecting the fact that it was Fianna Fáil who pioneered and advocated openly and financed the entry of this country into the EEC, and that the very Coalition to which he belongs were the very people who shot it down at every church gate in Ireland. If the farmers are doing reasonably well now, nobody may thank the Minister for that, because the Minister is today ignoring these county committees of agriculture, every one of them, and their personnel. He has the audacity to say that he will appoint one from that very representative body, I think it would be a shabby performance on the part of any Minister and certainly from this Minister, who was so completely out of touch with the real issues of farming until very recently, until he was goaded into it by the county committees and by the farmers in general.
Comment on this
I ask permission to withdraw the amendment standing in my name because of the disgraceful turn the debate has taken and its total irrelevancy, and I intend to re-table it on the Report Stage when at least we will have one speech from each Senator. The display by Senator Killilea was the worst I have witnessed in my 20 years of attendance in this House. As a protest against that I want to withdraw the amendments standing in my name and I will re-table them for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Casual vacancies are dealt with in the Bill. Casual vacancies, as Senator Killilea should know, occur if a member dies, if a member resigns or if a member is removed for any reason, for misconduct or one thing or another. That is a casual vacancy. There is no difference in the way we propose to fill that casual vacancy and the methods used under the Foras Talúntais Act.
Comment on this
I do not fully accept it. An Foras Talúntais is a live, working autonomous body. This is a completely different setup. This is a different organisation altogether. This, financially, is under the control of the Minister.
Comment on this
Perhaps I could clarify it further. If an organisation loses a member, where they nominated a member, that organisation will be asked to nominate another member and that member will be appointed. Is that clear?
Comment on this
I would like to intervene here and say that casual vacancies do not arise on this section. They arise on the Second Schedule, and the position is that if casual vacancies are discussed now, then there will be no debate on the Second Schedule. There cannot be two debates on such matters.
Comment on this
But it is quite clear here: "... any such order shall indicate the procedure for filling casual vacancies in the membership of the Board".
Comment on this
The fact that something is mentioned in several parts of the Bill does not entitle a full debate to take place on every section. Every time the Senators decide to discuss a question, for example, on section 26, they are abrogating their right to discuss it on the Second Schedule, and I want that to be absolutely clear.
Comment on this
Under section 26 (3), line 45, I want specifically written into the Official Report what the Minister meant in this line, as regards the filling of casual vacancies in the membership of the board. He has illustrated one or two or three points. I think he should at least run down through the list of what a casual vacancy in his opinion would be or should be. There are ways and means of dealing with casual vacancies. What I would normally assume is gone out of my mind now after the Minister's statement here concerning rural organisations and his definition of what he should be the judge, the lord and master of. I just want clarification of the phrase as it stands in this section.
Comment on this
I want it to be absolutely clear to Senator Killilea that the question which he has raised on this section cannot be raised again on the Second Schedule.
Comment on this
Question put: "That section 26 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
Will the committee be made up of members of the board or will there be a new type of representative on it?
Comment on this
Subsection (2) explains that. It says:
A committee may include persons who are not members of the Board.
Comment on this
Who will select the members who are not members of the board for the committee?
Comment on this
Do they have to go back to the Minister for sanction if the board picks them?
Comment on this
There is nothing under the control of the Minister or the Department once it goes out to the board. That is the board's job.
Comment on this
The selection is under the control of the Minister. Is that not the important part of it?
Comment on this
There is much that is objectionable in this Bill. Senator Killilea has made an excellent series of contributions in the earlier section, section 26, concerning the composition of the board. The real, basic, fundamental objection to this Bill arises in sections 30 and 32. Section 30 sets out the powers and duties of the board and section 32 sets out the annual programme of activities.
Section 30 (1) (a) states:
The Board shall exercise general supervision over the work of the Authority and be responsible for the attainment of the objectives of the Authority and the completion and implementation of such educational, advisory and research programmes as may, in accordance with section 32, be adopted with the approval of the Minister.
That is the section that effectively hamstrings this National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority, especially when taken in conjunction with section 32 (1) which states:
The Board shall prepare, in respect of each financial year, a programme, in such form as the Minister may require, of the projected activities of the Authority in that year.
That means that there is no board. We have an independent institute that could carry out its work and the legislation setting it up could have been amended so that it could still carry out its work in a reasonably free manner. That cannot be done by reason of this section and by reason of the subsequent section, section 32.
The Minister may check me up on this, but I have gone through the 1958 Act and through this Bill and counted the number of times "Minister" is mentioned in each piece of legislation. It occurs 175 times in the current legislation and is mentioned 24 times in the Act under which the institute has operated effectively for 20 years. That is the sort of bureaucratisation that, in my view, will totally stultify and frustrate this measure. All that had to be done was to amend the Bill by adding the extra advisory and educational functions. The independence and separateness of the institute could be preserved. In the 1958 legislation the functions of the institute are set out in great detail, and they have been operating accordingly for 20 years and there is not one, single reference to the Minister, except at the end where it is provided that the institute shall advise the Minister on any matter relating to agricultural research or agricultural science on which its advice is requested by him. In subsequent sections the Minister requires that the activities of the authority for the current year shall be submitted to him. This is not mentioned in section 4 of the original legislation. It goes through the functions of the institute without any reference to approval or requirement of the Minister or Ministers.
In section 4 (3) it states that: "The institute shall advise the Minister". In other words, the institute is put into the primary position. It does not have to have the requirement of Ministerial approval, literally and metaphorically, to dot every i and cross every it in regard to its annual programme of work. That is what is envisaged here if one reads sections 30 and 32 together. It is very graphically brought home in the figures I have mentioned; 175 examples of Ministerial intervention under this Bill; 24 examples of Ministerial intervention under the legislation setting up the institute.
The capital situation is the very same. The capital fund is established under the foundation legislation and again, the fund is to be used by the institute solely for certain purposes. It is stated in the opening of section 10 of the foundation legislation that "the Minister for Finance shall, when requested by the Council to do so, pay to the Institute". The institute is in the strong position that the Minister for Finance shall pay the council of the institute when they require. It is put into reverse in this legislation whereby the institute is effectively being translated into an executive agency where the Minister, himself, must approve the programme of work or approve of capital or current funding expenditure.
The same thing applies to section 11 of the foundation Act.
The Minister for Finance shall, when requested by the Council to do so, pay to the Institute, out of the moneys held in the Counterpart Special Account, a sum of one million pounds and that sum, when paid to the Institute, shall be known as the Endowment Fund.
The important section is section 12, which deals with the current fund. This is the fund that shows the big leap backwards that we are taking in this legislation. Section 12 (1) of the foundation legislation, setting up the State endowment of the institute, states:
For the purpose of assisting the Institute to carry out effectively its functions under this Act, there shall be paid to the Institute in every financial year, out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, a grant towards the expenses of the Institute the amount of which shall be determined by the Minister for Finance in consultation with the Minister and the Council after due consideration of any information furnished under subsection (2) of this section.
Subsection (2) states:
The Council shall furnish to the Minister such information regarding its income and expenditure as he may from time to time require.
We have here a global grant situation. The council requests, the Minister gives the annual grant and the council shall furnish the Minister with information. That is the basic, annual, working current grant provision. It is set out here that the board shall exercise under this legislation general supervision over the work of the authority. The programme shall be adopted with the approval of the Minister. That is the key phrase. Section 32 (1) states:
The Board shall prepare, in respect of each financial year, a programme, in such form as the Minister may require, of the projected activities of the Authority in that year.
Not alone must the authority be submitted to exercising functions which must have the approval of the Minister, it must submit a detailed programme which the Minister must approve before they can implement it. We will go on to the financial provisions at a later stage in which this is set out in greater detail.
We are going backwards instead of going forward into a progressive situation. Great progress has been made over 20 years and we are effectively limiting the objectives of this new agency. It will be so circumscribed, so hamstrung, so spancelled to the Minister's Department that in effect it can do nothing in the way of any initiative or any creative or original contribution to Irish agriculture without the approval of the Minister in detail in regard to its programme of work. That is what is happening under this section.
Ministers come and go, as I happen to know well, and basically what is involved here is the power of the administration that would be there day in day out. Some principal officers at some level will be handling these accounts, handling this programme of work, dealing with the powers and the duties of the new board, and in effect they will decide what will be done with the approval of the Minister and what will not. They will decide on the programme of work.
The whole idea behind setting up a body such as An Foras Talúntais was that it would be a creative, original body endowed originally by way of direct capital grant out of the American counterpart funds. Having been set up in that way, it was agreed between the Irish and the American Governments that an annual grant from the Irish Government would suffice to keep it going and to carry on the particular functions for which it was established and that there should be the minimum of interference.
This legislation runs right through the foundation Bill and I challenge anybody to go through it. I have gone through it line by line, and running right through it is the establishment of the independent and separate authority with a view to giving it the desired freedom to do a good job for Irish agriculture. That freedom is now being frustrated and stultified by this measure, and the figures I have quoted show that this operates right through the Bill. Nowhere is it more evident than in this section, which is one of the key sections in the Bill. It deals with the powers and the duties of the proposed executive agency. When that section is taken in conjunction with section 32 one sees how effectively, in fact, the administration in the Department of Agriculture, Finance and the Public Service have taken over this fine independent body that has done such magnificent work for Irish agriculture for over 20 years. It will now be effectively muzzled.
There is no point in the Minister for Agriculture standing up here and telling us that he does not intend to do this or does not intend to do that. In fact, the basic programme has to be approved by the Minister and the projected activities of the authority for the year have to be approved in detail by the Minister. That is the sort of situation that will exist as against the situation that exists currently where the council of the institute submit for an annual grant. The Minister may enquire into the operation of that grant from year to year with a view to making a decision the following year but the institute is not required to submit the sort of detailed programme of work that is envisaged under sections 30 and 32. If that in effect works out so that the authority is no more than an authority in name and is, in fact, totally subject to the administrations in the various Departments I have mentioned, well then everything is finished as far as the excellent work that has been done by the institute for 20 years is concerned.
We all know what happens when a creative institute or organisation of this kind gets totally within the ambit of civil service control. Now I am not decrying the civil service or anything of that kind. Administration is essential in any community. The job of administrations is to administer, to ensure that the law is carried out, to ensure that the basic administration of the State moves forward, but it is not an administration's job to put its fingers into research work. It is not an administration's job to put its fingers into basic matters concerned with development, concerned with organising new techniques and new developments for Irish agriculture. This is a highly specialist important business where there must be the maximum of specialist investigation at research and development level and the maximum communication from that through advisory and education channels. That is not the work of an administration. An administration has its own job to do, and a very important and fundamental job, but my view as to how society should be run in Ireland in this respect is that these educational, research and development associations, as far as possible, should be removed from the day-to-day administration of the civil service, should be given their annual grant to carry out their work in accordance with a certain mandate and that the basic administration is a separate matter altogether for the civil service.
We now have this Bill—and I think this was said earlier on—which is as much the thinking of the Devlin Report as it is of the administration. This report, by the way, was commissioned by the previous Government and it is a report with which I disagree. It will be disastrous for this small country of ours if we are to have a total takeover by civil service administration in every aspect of creative activity and so frustrate the sort of work that is being done by giving fine bodies in various areas of social and economic activity a reasonable degree of independence to carry out the necessary job. This section is a very real example of what I regard as a retreat back instead of a step forward in regard to public administration.
Comment on this
A Chathaoirleach, I will be more than brief. I would like simply to endorse everything that Senator Lenihan has said. With regard to the last section when a division was challenged I had intended this morning to vote against the issue because the whole thing had been so party-politicised in the course of the afternoon that I deliberately and pointedly absented myself from the Chamber so as not to be a party to that kind of in-fighting and rather indecorous treatment of what is very serious and important.
I wish to say that the distinction that Senator Lenihan has made between administrative and creative activity and the clash that may occur between them and the predominance given to the administrative as above the creative in this section of the Bill strikes me as most undesirable. That is all I wish to say.
Comment on this
A Chathaoirleach, I do not know how Senator Lenihan felt that counting the number of times the Minister is mentioned in this legislation and counting the number of times the Minister is mentioned in the Foras Talúntais legislation helped to make his case. It was rather peculiar sort of research. He also quoted section 32 when making his case and I would remind him that earlier on one of the things that made the Opposition feel very happy was the fact that section 32 states:
The Board shall prepare, in respect of each financial year, a programme, in such form as the Minister may require,
giving him the power to say to the authority "Put your estimates up to us in such a way that we know what you are providing for research, what you are providing for education, what you are provivding for advisory services." That was applauded. Now Senator Lenihan seems to be quoting that to support an altogether different case. It is very difficult to follow what is really being said.
Senator Lenihan sort of half quoted section 12 of the 1958 Act and he did not make it quite clear—and it is made quite clear there—that each year the Foras had to come to look for their money and the programme was looked at to see whether the money that they wanted could be justified. I have been looking at these programmes for the last four years with the Minister for Finance and the people from An Foras Talúntais and there was never great difficulty and there was never any interference once the money was agreed. The size of the money is what they were concerned about and, of course, the Minister had to be concerned about it too. It is all right to have grandiose programmes, but if you have no money to carry them out, well, you just cannot go on with the programmes and if the Minister for Agriculture, for instance, is not interested in or concerned about the sort of work that is being done by any part of this new organisation, then I do not think he should be Minister for Agriculture, because almost all of the money is being provided by the Exchequer.
It is natural and normal that there should be reasonable accountability. I have said over and over again that after that annual look at what is being done and agreement on the amount of money that can be provided, that is the end, except where the authority come back and say to the Minister "We feel half way through the year that we would like to change this and we would like to use in a different way some of the money that we intended to use for something else." They look for agreement and invariably they get the agreement if it seems impossible to carry out the work that they thought at the beginning of the year they were capable of doing. The whole thing is totally reasonable, and I regret to say that the contents of this Bill are being totally misrepresented. The two speakers misrepresented it and go on misrepresenting it.
Comment on this
I heard the Minister say that when An Foras Talúntais have come in in the past few years with their budget, they were examined by the Department and by the Minister and then the money was granted. Is that correct?
Comment on this
When we came as a deputation last year about the closure of Creagh, the Foras Talúntais institute in Ballinrobe, he told us he knew nothing about it. He had no function in it and he could do nothing about it.
Comment on this
He did not accept the responsibility of saying that it was in their programme that it was to be closed and that he knew they were going to close it. The Minister deliberately refused to accept any responsibility for the closure of Creagh. He said he had nothing to do with it, that they were a corporate body that he could not disrupt, although he told us a few minutes ago that he knew every penny they were going to spend because they had to put the budget before him before he sanctioned the money. The Minister cannot have it both ways. He is either responsible or he is not.
Comment on this
They get a block sum and, in fact, the examination of the programme is not what would be called a detailed examination. It is a global examination and the question is asked "Have you not gone as far as it is advisable to go in this particular research? Are you going to get anything more out of it?" If they say "Yes, we feel we are not at the end of the road there, that we have more to explore here and it is worth going on." That is the sort of discussion that goes on. We cannot say day in day out, week in week out, month in month out, "You should not be doing this, you should be doing that and you should not be doing the other."
It is wrong for the people in any part of the country to feel when the institute go in to do a job and have done the job that it should be kept going regardless, simply because a little industry is set up and there are a certain number of people employed. The job of the institute is to go into as many areas as possible, show what can be done in those areas and demonstrate the findings of research in those areas and then move on, if possible. They should not encounter total opposition to moving on because that restricts the activities. I would not like to have any part in restricting the activities of An Foras Talúntais. They would know when they have done their job in a particular area. They felt they had done their job at that time in Creagh, and every public representative had the local people on his back simply because there was local employment. That is the answer there.
Comment on this
I am sorry, the Minister is wrong. It is not because they were losing their employment. Perhaps the Minister will explain to me why a property that An Foras Talúntais owned completely was vacated and another property leased outside Tuam and all was transferred from Creagh to Tuam. Was it not because some of them wanted to live near Galway so that their children could go to university? Let us be straight about this. The Minister has no function at all, nothing to do with it or nothing to say in it, although he supplied the money. He could not keep Creagh open. We want it straight or we do not want it at all. It is not a little industry either.
Comment on this
When the Minister appoints a board he leaves it to the board to conduct the business of the authority. I have just reappointed a board that was appointed by my predecessor. Anyone who criticises that board is criticising the board that was appointed by my predecessor.
Comment on this
I am criticising the Minister for taking no action on the closure of Creagh.
Comment on this
I want to make one point. Section 31 provides that there will be a director of the authority. I would like to suggest that it might not be at all inappropriate if it could be provided that there would be a director of research, as a statutory requirement. Over and over the Minister has very sincerely reassured us that the research of the new authority will go and keep coming through. Would it not be a very nice gesture in terms of that reassurance if he were to say that a director of research as well as a director would be appointed in order to make sure that the essential element of research would not only continue but be seen to continue under the new authority?
Comment on this
I have replied to this already. I have said that there was no mention in the 1958 Act of a deputy director but a deputy director was appointed. There was nothing to prevent the board appointing a deputy director, and there is nothing to prevent this new authority appointing a number of deputy directors. That is entirely with them. I do not want to start doing their job before they are set up. I am giving them more freedom. That will take care of itself, as it has taken care of itself before.
Comment on this
I will be very brief because I have made most of the case already on section 30. Concerning the principle of separateness or autonomy which is now being taken from the institute and the proposed executive agency. In this section the situation is even worse in terms of Ministerial control.
Section 32 (1) states:
The Board shall prepare, in respect of each financial year, a programme, in such form as the Minister may require, of the projected activities of the Authority in that year.
First of all, the programme of activities has to be referred to the Minister. This covers the whole area of research, education, advice and so on.
Subsection (3) states:
The programme as adopted by the Board shall be submitted to the Minister for his approval. The Minister may, in conveying approval, indicate such further amendments of the programme as he considers necessary. The Board may, however, with the approval of the Minister, make such alterations in the programme as it subsequently considers necessary.
That is the most gorgeous bit of gobbledegook I have ever read. In plain language, we have a situation in which the Board shall submit its programme of projected activities for the authority in that year. We understand that. This programme as adopted by the board is submitted to the Minister for his approval and the Minister then conveys his approval and then it is back to the board. However, "the board may make such alterations to the programme," in the final sentence of subsection (3), "with the approval of the Minister." What is it all about? Why give the board any power to make such alterations to the programme as are considered necessary if the making of those alterations again has to be with the approval of the Minister? We are right into total civil service control here. The programme of activity has to be submitted. It may come back to the board and they may make alterations, but they can only make alterations with the approval of the Minister. The file will be going from the board to the Minister for his approval with regard to their programme of activity. The Minister may amend that programme if he thinks fit. It goes back to the board and the board may alter that programme and send the file back to the Minister again and the Minister must approve of the alterations. The file goes back to the board and if they decide to alter it, it goes back to the Minister again, but the Minister may reject the alteration. That is what section 32 means, which, in my view, is the worst section of all in the Bill in regard to bureaucratic control.
I have made the case on Second Stage, and earlier on in another section, in section 30, that section 32 is the provision for which one should have reserved all one's contribution to this debate; that means the Agricultural Institute and its expanded areas in regard to advice and education, the whole area of research, advice and education within the Department.
That section makes it totally unnecessary to have an authority allegedly independent. That section carried to its logical conclusion makes redundant the whole notion of this creature called an executive agency. Effectively there is no need for a board at all if that sort of power as set out in section 32 exists in regard to the annual programme of activities of the board. It effectively stifles, frustrates and stultifies the board which the Minister is establishing. That is why I took no part in the earlier discussion on the composition of the board because I regard that as superfluous, that the fundamental idea of what the Minister is about is contained in that section and in section 30. It is all there in section 32. The whole principle of what is going to happen on the dissolution of the institute under section 10 is embodied in that.
Who is on the board or who is not on the board is, in my view, of very small significance compared to the sort of power held by the Department of Agriculture under section 32. Effectively that means that they will be running the bulk of activities of the new authority. That will, in effect, be, as envisaged in Devlin, who recommended strongly that these independent institutes—this is only one of them— be brought right back under the control of the civil service machine. That is what we have here in section 32.
Comment on this
We had sense enough to let it be and to ignore it. I am one of the people responsible for it being ignored, if I may say so, and very proud to be responsible for having it ignored. If the present Government are going to adopt holus bolus that ultra-bureaucratic document in regard to bringing all these independent institutes in under civil service control, the Minister is on a very dangerous road to total liquidation of these bodies that over the years have been effectively set up by successive Governments to do independent and effective work and take independent and effective action.
Comment on this
Speaking on section 30 Senator Lenihan referred to the number of times the Minister had been referred to in these sections. It is simply because the Minister is pushing out a whole lot of services that he has personally under his control, under a board and under a new authority, simply and solely because he wants to get rid of them. He wants to give them to an outside body to operate because he thinks they can be done more effectively in that way.
Comment on this
But under this section the board will submit its programme annually to the Minister for approval. This section has been criticised on the basis that it will lead to undue interference by the Minister in the activities of the authority. That is the burden of complaint about it. Again, of course, this is misrepresentation of the provision. The Minister for Agriculture has overall responsibility for the development of the agricultural industry, and since the authority will have such a vital role to play in this development the Minister must be in a position to make sure that its programme is consistent with overall policy in the agricultural sector. I do not think that is unreasonable.
This section is not aimed at getting the Minister or his officials involved in other people's business. Once the programme is approved the authority will be completely free to carry it out without any further interference from the Minister. One of the things that has been commended by all is the fact that the programme can be amended, that they can come back to the Minister and get the programme amended. I think that is necessary, too, because a programme could be pursued that would require a sum of money vastly in excess of what was agreed at the beginning of the year. That is the sort of reason why it should come back, but I can foresee no difficulty whatever in relation to this type of accountability that is being sought. Nothing more, nothing less. There is going to be no interference, and it is not provided for in this legislation that there should be interference on a day-to-day basis, no more than there is interference with the day-to-day functions of any of the semi-State bodies.
Comment on this
It is very hard to reconcile that with subsection (3). It really is an astonishing piece of prose. I think Senator Lenihan is quite right. It rolls around upon itself: "The programme as adopted by the board shall be submitted to the Minister for his approval.""The Minister may, in conveying approval, indicate such further amendments of the programme as he considers necessary.""The board may, however, with the approval of the Minister, make such alterations ..." and on and on it goes. It is an astonishing piece of writing.
Comment on this
It seems built into that that anything the board does comes back to the Minister and there is an incredible—almost incestuous—interaction between the Minister and board throughout the whole thing. When the Minister says that the whole purpose of this Bill is to push that thing away from him, it is very hard to accept that in the light of a paragraph such as that. It seems to create a kind of centrifugal force which will keep pulling it into him. I agree with Senator Lenihan when he said that most of the things we are discussing— and this is in fairness to the Minister as well as everybody else—have been discussed already. All the issues are coming back again inevitably. It is the same problems we are reiterating. I am probably as exhausted as the Minister is with regard to it.
However, I could not read that paragraph and at the same time hear the Minister saying that he wants to rid himself of all this difficulty and get it out into an autonomous world. I have no doubt at all that the main thrust of this Bill is to bring all that research activity far closer in under bureaucratic and ministerial control. At the end of the day I do not mind if the Bill wins, and it is going to win and it will come through, but I would hate it to succeed on the understanding that we all agreed that it was a gesture towards the greater autonomy of these services. It is certainly not that.
Comment on this
Before anybody tries to make a meal out of what I am going to say, I would appeal to them to understand that all I am standing up for is clarification on two specific points and nothing else. I hope nobody is going to attempt to take what I am saying into Disneyland. I would make a special appeal at this late hour of the day. The section provides for consultations between the associations and the trade unions with regard to the setting up of a scheme but does it cover negotiating machinery, disputes procedures and so on? That is the main part of my first point. I should like clarified the position of the Civil Service Staff Association with regard to representation of the civil servants who are responsible to the authority.
Comment on this
We have not at this stage any clear or detailed ideas of what sort of scheme may be set up, but whatever sort of scheme is to be set up it must be agreed by the staff themselves. So that the unions representing the staff will have full play in trying to decide and agree on a scheme.
Comment on this
I could make the same sort of speech I made earlier but I will decline at this stage because I would be quoting the same arguments and there is no point in going into repetition.
Comment on this
The amendment that I am proposing in this section has been suggested to me by representatives of some of the staff who will be transferred to the new authority. When this section was discussed in the Dáil I was pressed to give a guarantee that nobody would be transferred from their existing place of employment. I refused to give such a commitment because I was not prepared to straitjacket the authority in this way. I did say, however, that I would be surprised if the authority would be unreasonable in applying the provisions in this section and that transfers would not take place without prior consultation with the staff concerned. This amendment now formally binds the authority to consult with representatives of the staff concerned before any transfers take place, and I hope it will therefore allay any remaining fears of the staff in this regard.
Comment on this
First, I want to thank the Minister for introducing that particular amendment, which was very necessary. On one aspect I would like some clarification. The section provides that the conditions of service will not alter. Can I take it to mean that they will be no less favourable? My next point is an important one. Does it imply that, even though one retains one's previous conditions, one cannot improve on those conditions on transfer until such time as a scheme has been agreed? This is a little bit puzzling.
Comment on this
No, it does not mean that at all, because a scheme might never be approved. There is no guarantee, so we could not hold up promotions on that.
Comment on this
I should like to ask a question regarding the consultation machinery. The Minister has clarified the position for me in some of the pertinent sections. I am slightly puzzled with regard to section 69. With regard to the appeals procedure, for example, is a man debarred from going to a rights commissioner or to the Labour Court?
Comment on this
Section 70 could have repercussions concerning the deputy CAOs. As the Minister is aware, recently he appointed or gave instructions for us to appoint in each individual county committee of agriculture deputy CAOs with special responsibility in certain areas. We find in this Bill, after that deliberation by the Minister and his Department, that they are not mentioned at all in section 70. Some of them, particularly in the area of education, have undertaken a very onerous task, have set about the task in their own peculiar way and have these functions now working. What is the status of deputy CAOs throughout the country who have operated individually, if not directly, under the chief agricultural officer? I find this very low of the Department and the Minister not taking upon himself the responsibility of mentioning their positions in the Bill. I would like the Minister to clarify what his intentions are in this regard.
In Galway we have had classes for young farmers and educational symposiums that went on over an indefinite period of time, and they were a great success. Those deputy CAOs took it upon themselves to go about this task. There is a lot missing in this field. That is a very important point. There should be an assurance given here as to what the Minister's intentions are or what status they are to operate under. There is another question too which I think the Minister should consider, especially in regard to authority or known authority in An Foras Talúntais. In our constituency in east Galway and Clare there was the proposed renting of an estate in addition to the one the institute already operate in. The local people, through the Land Commission and through the farm advisory service for the CAOs, were anxious to acquire this estate and found resistance from An Foras Talúntais on it.
Questions were asked in the other House about it, but at least up to now the people responsible in this field were not faceless people. We knew who they were, what their functions were and how we could counter-attack any efforts they made. We had the deputy CAO, but the deputy CAO is not mentioned in the Bill. What relationship will this new board hold with the Land Commission? It is a thorny question in my parish. Nine hundred acres on top of five is a lot of land. As I said, we knew until now to whom we could talk but as from now to whom do we address ourselves? The Government should have used their influence in getting the Land Commission to move in and acquire this land and divide it among the tenants. This has been resisted by An Foras Talúntais, despite the fact that the people in the community about them are all people who attended those classes and who should qualify for land; and who if they had this land would be better off by it.
One organ of the State is going around educating the people under the deputy CAO, while another, this new board will be nullifying that activity. Would the Minister explain to me what propositions he has on either of those two important issues. The deputy CAO was always a respected person who did an enormous amount of work. There were two deputy CAOs, one looking after the farm modernisation scheme and the other looking after education, and both have done tremendous work, all probably under the county CAO but in many ways autonomous in themselves. There does not seem to be any autonomy for them under this Bill. The CAOs are mentioned ad lib, and I am speaking of a big county like my own which commands at least two deputy CAOs because in such a big county one deputy CAO could not do all the work, and he was relying totally on the deputy that was appointed to do much of the work. In many ways they probably had as much work to do as a CAO in a smaller county would have to do.
Should there not be some facility made for a man who found himself in that situation, not by his own wish or desire but out of necessity? The Minister seems to have forgotten, among other things, this particular aspect of the Bill. Even though their title might not be as strong as that of a CAO, they work just as hard as many CAOs throughout the country, and I am sure the Minister himself would be the first to admit that. If he would consider their situation I would appreciate it.
Comment on this
I think Senator Killilea misread this section. This section has nothing to do with what he is talking about at all. In fact, what this section is doing is ensuring that the committee, for its retained functions, has a secretary and a clerical staff. What it is saying is, in fact, that in future the chief agricultural officer will also act as secretary to the committee for its retained functions and that sufficient clerical staff will be provided. All other staffs are being transferred to the new authority in their present capacities with a guarantee that there will be no worsening of their positions.
Comment on this
As regards the clerical staff, this is something that committees of agriculture at the present time are not too happy about, because since our entry into the EEC the work of an agricultural instructor has changed quite a lot. In the old days he was able to visit maybe 14 or 20 farmers in a day, but now there is so much book work, accounts to be kept, farm modernisation along with everything else, that if an instructor gets around to two farmers in the day he is very lucky. As well as visiting the two farmers and discussing everything with them he also has to give hours in the office doing clerical work, work which I do not think an agricultural instructor should be doing. This is work that should be done by an office staff. I do not know what the position is in every county. In south Tipperary we are short of clerical staff. There was a girl on a temporary basis, and we wanted to keep on this girl when the permanent girl took office. That was refused by the Department of Agriculture, although the committee and the CAO and his deputy CAO had plenty of work for this girl. Now the work she should be doing has to be done by agricultural advisers who should be out instead with the farmers.
I hope that when this new authority take up office they will not be restricting committees of agriculture as to the number of staff they should have. We in south Tipperary have about 14 agricultural advisers. We would need two more to give the farmers in south Tipperary the service they need, but we have been told by the Department that we cannot have them.
Under the Bill the Committees will have to sit down once a year and draw up a programme for the following year. It is very hard to draw up an agricultural programme for a full year. If during the year they have to make changes, I hope they will not be told by this new authority, "Sorry, you will have to wait until next year. We have already given you so much money, and that is all you are going to get."
Comment on this
The point raised about the possibility of amending the programme during the year was fully dealt with on the previous section. I said it was possible to amend the programme during the year. The House will appreciate that it is not possible for me to deal here with the individual situation of the number of clerical people required in each individual county. In a number of counties, temporary staff are employed to take care of a backlog of work that had built up because the advisory people we are arguing about had taken on certain responsibilities. We caught up on that backlog. Like all temporary staff, they get an establishment and there are local pressures to make them permanent.
It is unfair for Members of the House to raise under the section of a new Bill matters that are individual to each county committee, and make that a point to discuss under a section of a Bill. It would be impossible for any Minister to be au fait with the position in every county. There is one county referred to this evening by Deputy Ryan. I am sorry that I cannot——
Comment on this
I am only speaking about one county, the county I know. I am quite sure the same applies in every other county.
Comment on this
I am not asking for the answer. I am just stating what I hope is happening now under the present system, under the Department. It is not An Foras Talúntais we have to blame for it but the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
It is like everything else this Minister has said today and yesterday. Pass the buck when it suits, twist it, shift it. The Minister for Agriculture is well aware that it was he and his Department—and his Department is under his control—that starved my county and my two neighbouring counties. On the other hand, he says that all the miracles happened while he was in office.
Comment on this
The Minister and his Party have consistently tried to infer that he was the man who was responsible for the improvements in the agricultural sector. They happened in spite of the Minister in many cases. There was little heard or seen of the Minister in October, 1974, when we were selling stripper cows for £1.50p.
Comment on this
That may be very interesting but it has no relevance to section 70 which deals with staff of the committees.
Comment on this
Section 70 (2) is relevant here. Because of this Minister, who has been personified as the greatest thing ever to happen to Irish agriculture, we could not get enough people in the advisory service. His Department refused to sanction the recruitment of extra staff. We asked, not once but at least ten times, and the Minister was the person who refused us. The backlog is still there and will continue. The Minister will say that the advisory service has never been so good. I contradict that. If the Minister was sensible about the matter he would contradict it too and would do something about it. Section 70 (2) says:
Every committee of agriculture shall, in each financial year, pay to the Authority in respect of the services referred to in subsection (1) such sum as may be agreed between the committee and the Authority or, in default of agreement as may be determined by the Minister.
That is another very peculiar twist. The Minister refused to give us these services when we did not have to pay for them, when the Department of Agriculture were committed to pay the advisers, clerical work and so on in the county council and to make available a certain amount of money. We prepared our budget each year. When the Department of Agriculture were running the show they were not prepared to pay for these services. Now the Minister comes along and is putting the gun to the head of every county committee of agriculture. The Minister knows that now, I know it, and nearly everybody else knows it now. The committees did not get the service when the Department were supposed to be paying for it. They are not going to get it now and they are going to be asked an exorbitant price for the little they are getting. The cost of living index and the movement index will be used in arguments. The Minister is placing himself again in the onerous position of deciding who is in default.
Comment on this
Without any doubt, the Minister is the finest ever to bluff his way as Minister for Agriculture. There is no question about it. I have proved that here unequivocally today. If Senator O'Toole was not here today to listen——
Comment on this
It is just as scurrilous as the statements the Senator made. I have nothing against the Minister, Deputy Clinton——
Comment on this
Yes, in this House over the last three years. The Senator said the Minister was the greatest thing that ever happened to us since we went into agriculture. The Senator is a bit wet behind the ears in politics if he thinks that I am so naïve, or that his county committee of agriculture are so naïve as to believe that. How long have his county committee of agriculture been seeking to get extra advisory staff from the Minister? Would you tell me, Senator O'Toole, seeing that you know so much about your own county——
Comment on this
The Senator should address his remarks to the Chair.
Comment on this
In my opinion, when I hit the nail on the head concerning an individual who has been——
Comment on this
The Senator cannot break the rules of debate in this House.
Comment on this
I ask Senator O'Toole to tell the House how many letters have gone from the Mayo County Committee of Agriculture to the Minister for Agriculture in the last three years asking for extra staff to get rid of the backlog. He is not fit to answer it, or if he is, he dare not do it here because he will be giving in on the bluff that I talk about. He would be recognising the fact that it is a bluff, and nothing but a bluff.
Does he think that the county committees of agriculture will accept this proposal? Have they not lost all their authority? Are they not now naked? If this new board say to them, "you give us a certain amount of money" and they say "no, you cannot get it", the Minister will say, "by default I am the guy who decides this and you must pay up". This means that the committees no longer have any authority. It is the axe waving again.
The Minister and Senator O'Toole seem to know an awful lot about the situation. Could the Minister tell me how he proposes to tell the rural community that they are going to be by default decided upon by the Minister? Does he expect the rural community to take any more of this dictatorial attitude?
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I want to comment briefly on the term of office of members. It says:
Eight members of the Board to be established on the commencement of section 25 shall be appointed for a period of three years, a further eight members shall be appointed for a period of four years and the remaining members for a period of five years.
I agree with that because this means we will have continuity all the time. Paragraph (2) reads:
The members to be appointed for the several periods of three years, four years and five years shall be determined by lot.
If you adhere strictly to that, could it not happen that one sector, say the people representing agriculture, could be left off? Will a clause be included to ensure that every sector is represented in the three years, the four years and the five years?
Comment on this
I am sorry I have not gone into the details of exactly how this could be most effectively done. I appreciate that it will present a difficulty but it is hard to find a fairer way than by lot. It is not going to be easy to have the various sectors reasonably represented. Whether there could be agreement on the sort of mix that would go into the hat for the drawing of each lot is something we could look at and try and reach agreement on. I do not know which would be the best way to deal with this.
Comment on this
I accept that the Minister has problems in this area. To bring a Bill into the House in such a haphazard way is not usual. He has not any clear idea in what way he is going to run this board. It is lackadaisical, to say the least, for the Minister to have allowed himself get into such a situation. Here again we see the wielding hand of the Minister in action. The point that seems to flow freely from the Bill is that this board, as he described it this morning, is a body he has taken out of the Department of Agriculture and "put out there", to use his own words. In really every section of the Bill, the long arm of the Minister is there hovering over them, and in the Second Schedule it is quite blatantly and savagely stated:
The Minister may, at any time remove a member of the Board from office.
In almost every section of the Bill the Minister's power is the overriding factor. The Minister has the right to do this: the Minister has the right to do that. The board has no autonomy. This board is under the Minister for Agriculture from section 1 to section 72. I spent most of this day trying to clarify a point. Maybe I used some harsh words but I tried to the best of my ability. How will the Minister define which rural organisation is better than another. The Minister has the right to make that decision. Some moments ago I spoke on section 70 —the Minister has the right to intervene; the Minister has the right to make decisions. In the Second Schedule the Minister may at any time remove a member of the board from office. It is very clear to every Senator, no matter on which side of the House he is, that the staff of An Foras Talúntais are afraid of this board. I believe they were not afraid of the board but of the Minister. There is no autonomy in this Bill for this advisory board. In every page of this document they are mainly the puppets of the Minister.
It amazes me that the free thinking Senators on the Government side will walk into the lobby and vote for this Bill. In the last four years—with the exception of the revision of the Constituencies Bill which was a political Bill—we did not have even one Bill brought before this House with such brutal acts attached to it, and which the Minister has deliberately written into this Bill. I am of the opinion that this Bill was written for the Minister. I believe he is putting it through under duress. I remember his performance earlier today when I asked him a question about the chairman. He was unable to give me a reply.
Comment on this
We are on the Second Schedule and we cannot go back on sections that have been already passed.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that we are on Committee Stage and we are discussing the Second Schedule.
Comment on this
I know, and I am aware that the Minister dodged this issue and other issues all day. At one stage he sang dumb altogether; he had no answers for me. He knows that as well as I know, as well as this House knows and I hope as well as the people of the country will know if the press and the television are not satisfied. It is not beyond this Government to stifle the press and the national television network, as was seen as recently as last night. I am sure that it would not be beyond the Minister for Agriculture, seeing he has now put himself into the position where he can decide against elected representatives and for different rural organisations. Never in the history of the State have I seen this done in a democracy.
In case anybody is under any illusion, it is here again in the Second Schedule: "The Minister may at any time remove a member of the Board from office". Then he says in paragraph 6 (1):
A casual vacancy occurring among the members of the Board shall be filled by appointment by the Minister in accordance with an order under section 26.
There it is again, clear as a whistle. He tried to twist it and maybe he meant it himself, but that does not mean that every other Minister for Agriculture would take the same meaning from it. He would hand it back to the organisation that lost the seat. If I were a member of a rural organisation and I was sacked by the Minister I would think very poorly of the organisation that would nominate a person in my place. Rural organisations are voluntary bodies. There is no doubt in my mind that any rural organisation worth its salt would stand by a member who in the first instance, they recommended or elected—I think was the phrase the Minister used was elected for selection by him. Who then has the power when that organisation does not renominate? I know who has the power: the Minister for Agriculture and the cohorts in Government. They have the power and, as I said, if that organisation does not nominate some person—and I am sure it would not— who gets the job? When the Minister plucks one from the group and fires him, he eliminates an organisation and, as he himself rightly said, he would like to see a situation where we would have only one organisation representing farmers and rural organisations. So if he fires that member or those members, then we would have complete political hackery. This can happen; it would not be the first time it happened and it will not be the last time. What galls me is this idea that is being pumped through the country by all the media that the Minister's performance is above reproach. In actual fact, it is far from it. This is clear to me, and I do not care what the Press may say: the people will find out in their own time anyhow because this Minister, no more than any other Minister, is not infallible. This Minister has proved beyond all shadow of doubt by his performance in this House today that he has messed up this Bill. He has annihilated An Foras Talúntais and we are left with a political job lot to do the job that is necessary and so important and so crucial for the farming community of Ireland.
Comment on this
I have already protested regarding the composition of the board and the method of selection. I notice now that the Minister may or will, when he establishes this board, select eight and some will be for a period of three years extending to five years. It seems these selections will be made by lot, which would remind me of a bingo session. In other words, a man's suitability or eligibility or his standing as a useful member of an agricultural committee will not be the criterion by which he will be selected. It will depend on whom the Minister draws out of his political hat. I do not think that is the best method of using the personnel that he will get for this board.
The people of rural Ireland will have to realise that the Minister for Agriculture is wiping out the agricultural committees and that any powers they have in future will mean very little. The power is being vested in this board and in these members and to ensure that, the Minister, even in the case of the material he gets from the voluntary organisations, is deciding that he will select them by lot and will decide which members will do three years and which members will do five years.
Comment on this
No. Could I explain this? I think it was accepted by Senator Ryan that this was the fairest possible way to do it and that it was a way that would preserve the continuity he agreed with. The only way you can get continuity is to have people appointed for different periods. However, it does not at any time change the balance of the board, because if there is a certain number of them on for three years—that is the smallest period of time—it is people from the same organisations that will replace them at the end of the three years and you will have the same balance always. Whatever number is going out will be replaced by people from the same organisations when they nominate them. When Senator Dolan talks about me selecting, hand-picking and deciding, over and over again I have said that these are people nominated by bodies in rural Ireland but I have to formally appoint them. As they are formally appointed by the Minister, if there is one of them to be dismissed from the authority, he has to be formally dismissed by the Minister; and that is the same as it is in all other legislation. There is nothing new in this. There is nothing sinister in it, but the trouble with Senator Killilea is that he sees something sinister in every line of everything that is brought in by the present Government. That is the unfortunate state of mind that the man is in.
Comment on this
The Minister may say that everything is all right as far as the committees of agriculture are concerned. But the fact of the matter is that he is setting up a board here and there are not elected representatives on it, people who will answer back to the electors. These people will be there for five years and will not have to answer to the people, whereas in ordinary politics they would have to go back to the electors and get a mandate in two, three or four years.
Comment on this
I admire the courage and tenacity of the Minister in trying to force the Bill through the House because the support he has got from his own back benches on that side of the House has been very remarkable by its absence. The only little support he got was in the form of a few queries from the Labour Party. According to the Second Schedule of this Bill, the board shall hold at least three meetings in every year. Section 30 of the Bill says, in subsection 1 (a), that the board shall:
exercise general supervision over the work of the Authority and be responsible for the attainment of the objectives of the Authority and the completion and implementation of such educational, advisory and research programmes may, in accordance with section 32, be adopted with the approval of the Minister.
It lists seven or eight things here that the board shall do. Seeing that agriculture is our principal industry, a board of 24 meeting at least three times a year will not be able to supervise any actions or functions of the Authority whatsoever. It says that the board shall hold special meetings. I do not think the General Council or the Agricultural Committees can hold a special meeting to make sure that the expenses will be paid to the people who travel to it.
Sanction for a special meeting of the General Council of Committees of Agriculture was refused recently by the Minister, and if he refused them sanction to hold one in a year there will not be much probability of holding special meetings by this board. I wonder how any board can supervise the functioning or the operations or the running of any authority and see that the advisory staff in their local county committees of agriculture carry out their functions under the authority when they meet only three times a year. You would be as well off not to have the board there at all as to have it meeting three times a year. One of those meetings, I am sure, will take place during the Spring Show and the other during the Autumn Show and the meetings will last for a few hours and then they will be off to see the machinery. I think a board responsible for the largest industry within the country meeting three times a year is rather sad and ridiculous.
Comment on this
This is more of it. This is what I cannot understand. This quietness is bad. I cannot understand why a query such as that made by Senator Garrett is not answered. This is on the Schedule but there is no answer. There is nothing sinister in my saying this. I am a bit more knowledgeable about and observant of the performance of this Government than perhaps many other people. Seeing the hold the Minister has on this board from A to Z, that is about all they will do—meet for the Spring Show and the Autumn Show and they might come up to visit Santa Claus. That could be the sum total of what this board would do because the Minister can say yea or nay to every single thing they propose.
The most beautiful part of this Bill —and this is where I thought the Minister might have made a statement— is paragraph 5 (1) and (2) of this Schedule. He spoke today about a Member of our Parliamentary Party in a sort of undercover type of remark, a Member who is entitled to be at this moment of time a member of the Wool Board. He made absolutely certain that no member of his party, of the Labour Party or any other party in this House or in the other House will ever be a member of this board. I think that is bad. In addition to what he has done to the county committees of agriculture he has now degraded the politicians to the level of stating emphatically that they would not be capable of serving on this board, that they are all biased and bigoted.
If I tend to be cynical, then the thinking behind those two particular subsections is very cynical. A man in public life is always responsible to the people, but the Minister would still turn to me and say "I cannot deal with anything Senator Killilea would say because I feel he is too cynical". But the cynicism that is in this Bill is cruel, and it is not at the whim of any politician that he included this in the Bill. I am not cynical in saying that to the Minister. I know where that came from: it is not the first time that I have seen it printed. I know the cynicism behind the Bill; I have seen it from the first day and yet the Minister would say that my thoughts are sinister.
The thinking behind that Schedule is not good for democracy. Every man in this land is a free man or, at least, every man in this land should be a free man until he is proved guilty. I despise this type of attitude by any Government. A man's profession is now against him if he wants to serve a section of the community. I think this should be deleted from the Second Schedule. Does the Minister think fit now to reply to that allegation as to why he included it? What have the politicians done wrong? Why are they not entitled to serve the community that have asked them to serve? The people ask the politicians to serve them. It is not all a gangland out in the constituencies. Members of every party do not have to wear the galoshes going around their constituencies. There is no need, no blood running down the road at all. Ninety per cent of the politicians are fine, respectable people who try to do their best under duress on many occasions.
Certainly in this Bill there is the hand of the Minister again. I wish that Senator O'Toole from Mayo were here to hear me say this: this sinister hand of the Minister is blocking a man selected and elected by the people from serving on a board that is and will have to be one of the most important boards in this country. The Minister in two short paragraphs eliminated that particular section of the community. I would like an explanation from the Minister on this point.
Comment on this
I would like to support Senator Killilea in this. All through this Bill there seems to be an attitude of mind aimed at keeping the elected representative off the board. On any board or council, or in any House of the Oireachtas or in any county council or any other board of any kind where public money is involved, it is important that the elected representative would be there and free to voice his opinion and that he would not be inhibited in any way. A public representative is one who has to go before the electorate and seek a mandate in any election. He is a free agent going into these boards independent of any civil servant or anybody sitting around the table of that board. On health boards, regional development organisations and various other places where civil servants and elected representatives are present it is tremendously important for democracy that an elected representative is free to go into those gatherings and voice his opinion independently. Without being personal to the civil servants he can be critical of them knowing that he will not be demoted because of something he says at that board meeting.
This is the very type of thing that could happen on this board. Where somebody's superior is on the board he will be afraid to voice his opinion. That is wrong in such a situation. There is fear running through all this, fear of the public representative, no matter what his qualities are, being free to go in there and to voice his opinion and to say what he thinks and what he feels is best for his own area and for his constituents.
Comment on this
One of the most recent boards set up by Fianna Fáil was Bord na gCapall and the same provision exactly as we have here operates.
Comment on this
The Minister has tried to use throughout this Bill comparisons between this and Fianna Fáil Bills. For 16 years we governed this country and we never said in any Bill that a member elected by the people is not entitled to serve on any board.
Comment on this
It was an awful pity that they were not on them. They would be doing very badly if they did not do a better performance than the shower that this Government put on CIE board with their £37 million or £42 million, almost a million a week loss. That is the performance we are talking about. That represents the cynicism in this Bill. Right through this Bill—Senator Dolan put his finger on it—there is a fear. It started in the first section of the Bill when it was obvious that those in An Foras Talúntais had a real fear about every single iota of it. It is obvious now, after we have teased it out that there is a good, logical reason for that fear because that hand of the Minister for Agriculture hangs over it. Far be it from him, but I believe he will rue the day when he sees the annihilation of agriculture as it should be, or as we should be making every effort to have it. He is now working positively and clearly against the rural community, and this is obvious in every word not alone in the Second Schedule but in every single line of this Bill.
After all of this day's performance he has failed to answer an important question. He has dodged that issue by trying to swing it against us in the debate. That is the issue concerning the chairmanship of this board. On that point, it amazes me that a paper which has great circulation amongst the farming community. The Farmers' Journal, has not made much comment on this Bill. They were great prophets of An Foras Talúntais. They were the people who had their pages full of photographs of this place and that place and the details worked out. If the first part of my so-called cynicism, as referred to by the Minister concerns my belief as to who will be chairman, the second part is very clear. I would lay any odds that I will name the two people, either privately or publicly, who are considered for this post and woe betide this country on the day that either of them get it. I wish good luck to the Minister.