We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Finance Bill, 1990 [ Certified Money Bill]: Second Stage.

Contributions 1–75 of 175. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1990
Enacted

No. 11 of 1990 ›

Albert Reynolds Minister for Finance (Mr. A. Reynolds) Fianna Fáil

The purpose of this Finance Bill is to give statutory effect to the taxation changes announced or foreshadowed in this year's budget. It also provides for a number of other important changes which I have drawn up since the budget.

The Bill is a lengthy and complex one. Unfortunately, there is no way of avoiding this, given the complexity to the matters with which the Bill is dealing. I hope, however, that this House's discussion on the Bill will be facilitated by the revised Explanatory Memorandum which I have now circulated and which reflects the changes made during the passage of the Bill through Dail Eireann.

The Bill contains a number of very fundamental reforms to our tax system. These build on the changes I introduced last year. The essential objective is to bring us further down the road towards a fairer and more efficient tax system and to help develop the economy by encouraging more growth and more jobs. The key changes are: the reduction in the standard rate of income tax to 30 per cent and the reduction in the top rate to 53 per cent; the reduction in the standard rate of corporation tax to 40 per cent and the associated measures to increase the corporation tax yield; the extension of the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing industry to the year 2010 so as to create greater certainty for investment planning and job creation; the extension of the urban renewal incentive package to 1993; the reduction in the standard VAT rate which has already taken effect and is helping to reduce inflation; changes in stamp duties to further encourage the development of the financial services sector; the abolition of the 60 per cent rate of capital gains tax which has been an inhibiting factor on investment; and the introduction of the current year basis of assessment for the self-employed as part of the development of the self-assessment system. Before outlining the significant provisions of the Bill in more detail, I would like to take this opportunity to review briefly the present economic position and prospects which provide the overall framework within which the measures in the Bill must be assessed.

The primary goals of Government policy are to maximise economic growth and sustainable job-creation and to achieve greater social equity. By implementing the right policies we have achieved a major turnaround in economic fortunes over the last three years. Gross National Product has risen by an average of 3½ per cent annually over this period. Real benefits are coming from the improvement in economic performance.

First, more people are at work. The most recent Labour Force Survey confirms that some 30,000 extra jobs emerged in the private sector, excluding agriculture, in the two years to April, 1989. More recent indicators suggest that employment is continuing to expand.

Second, people at work are better off. While we have had moderate pay increases under the Programme for National Recovery, there have been major income tax reliefs and low inflation. This combination of developments has been putting real money and purchasing power into workers' pockets —in contrast with the situation for most of the 1980s.

Thirdly, those outside the workforce —whether retired or unemployed—are also sharing in economic advance. Growth has made it possible to provide real increases for welfare recipients. This is only as it should be. It would be a poor form of progress if the disadvantaged were to be denied a fair share.

Finally, and most importantly, the foundation for further economic and social advance is being laid.

The overriding concern of the Government remains the creation of additional jobs. More jobs would cure many of our social as well as economic ills. Unemployment is root cause of poverty. While progress has been made on this front, I readily admit that it is not adequate and that much more remains to be done. We can, however, feel encouraged by what has been achieved in a short space of time.

Competitiveness is a factor of vital importance in all of this. It is essential that we maintain the improvement in our relative costs over the past few years. Indeed, with our employment needs we should think in terms of progressively improving our competitiveness. The aim must be to price more people back into work.

The present Programme for National Recovery represents an eminently sensible arrangement as well as a potent force for progress. It protected living standards of workers through a combination of pay increases geared to give us an edge on our competitors and reliefs in personal taxation which enhanced real take-home pay. We have got away from the ridiculous situation of former years where we had large money increases, which undermined our competitiveness but proved worthless to the majority of employees when inflation and taxation had taken their toll. Worst of all, these increases pushed a minority right out of work.

The formula in the present programme can be a model for the future. The wider terms of any new agreement must be consistent with our growth needs. It must deliver both stability and competitiveness. Our exchange rate policy is a virtual guarantee of low inflation over the medium term but we must recognise and live up to the disciplines which this policy entails. In this year's budget, the Government have made a substantial contribution to lower inflation. We are on course for a significant reduction in inflation — to a little over 3 per cent in 1990 as a whole, with the annual rate slowing down to about 2½ per cent by the end of the year.

I am confident that, despite some moderation in growth internationally and in particular the weakening in the UK, we can again achieve this year a growth performance on a par with that of the past three years. GNP should continue to expand, by 3½ per cent or better. With inflation falling — and provided we let this carry through into our costs and our prices — we can anticipate further solid export growth. Rising investment and exports, and the capacity they offer for higher personal consumption, should all have a strong positive effect on jobs. A net increase in non-agricultural employment of 16,000 can be achieved this year.

While international trends inevitably affect us, the Government are doing everything possible to promote lower interest rates. Domestic market conditions have shown considerable improvement in recent months, as evidenced by the recovery of the official external reserves from £2,282 million at end-February to £2,458 million at end-March with further improvement since. Interbank interest rates have also eased considerably from their peak levels during March. Against this background, the Central Bank is more optimistic about the general trend of domestic interest rates than was the case last February when it issued its 1990 Monetary Policy Statement.

I am not alone in the belief that we are on the right track, policy-wise, for the longer term. Last week's update by the ESRI of their July 1989 Medium-Term Review suggests that Ireland could achieve GNP growth of near enough to 4 per cent annually, through the 1990s. While I may not subscribe to all of their expectations, their broad thrust seems sound, but they also clearly indicate that this potential progress, while plausible, is conditional. The authors do not see this scenario as enabling soft options to be taken. To cut further into the overhang of Government debt, and to reduce the drag on economic activity which the debt poses, their assessment is that fiscal policy over the medium term will have to be tight. Despite economic growth at almost 4 per cent each year over the period, tax cuts or increases in public services will, in view of the ESRI, have to be on a more limited scale than this year. This is a clear message that despite the progress to date we are in no sense out of the woods in so far as the public finances are concerned.

They also indicate that even this rate of advance, if sustained for a decade, will not resolve all our problems. Encouragingly, they see unemployment and emigration declining in the next few years. However, they see both threatening to rise again from mid-decade. This is because the ESRI anticipate that growth will prompt demand for pay increases of an order which, in turn, will slow expansion in the trading sector. Unfortunately, this has too often been our experience in the past. We must not let it happen again.

There is of course a significant element of trade-off between income and jobs. As a society, we have to make choices. If we wish, we can give overriding priority to expanding employment — which is the best means for tackling poverty, and the only answer to emigration — but this will involve considerable restraint on the incomes front, or we can regard increases in living standards for those at work as the higher priority but this would, inescapably, curtail the prospects of those disadvantaged through unemployment.

In summary, I welcome the ESRI update of its view of medium term prospects for two main reasons. First, because it confirms the appropriateness of the broad economic strategy which we have adopted and, secondly, because it puts the key choices we must face in the future firmly on the agenda for discussion. That can only be in all our best interests.

A key ingredient in our improved economic performance has been the strict fiscal stance adopted by the Government over the past three years. I am pleased to report to the Seanad that the Exchequer returns to end-April indicate that the results to date this year are running broadly in line with budget expectations. The Government will continue to monitor the trends closely over the remainder of the year so as to ensure that the budget targets will be achieved.

I would emphasise to Senators that the Government are fully committed to reducing further both the level of annual borrowing and the debt/GNP ratio. Specifically, the aim now is to achieve broad balance on the current budget by 1993. By the same deadline, it is intended also to maintain a significant rate of progress in reducing the debt/GNP ratio towards 100 per cent, down from its end-1989 level of 121 per cent. Our medium-term objectives are far from being soft options. They will require that tight control is maintained on current expenditure and that borrowing for investment purposes continues to be subject to rigorous scrutiny. It is all about difficult choices and priorities but there is no going back to an era of fiscal laxity. Any attempt to do so would be self-defeating since it would undermine the basis on which all our progress has been secured.

As I have already indicated, tax reform has a major part to play in encouraging initiative and promoting more jobs. Last year was a watershed. I was able then to begin the process of reducing our high rates of personal taxation. This year's Finance Bill continues the process of major tax reform notably through the significant new reductions in personal income tax for all taxpayers to which I have referred; major further development of the self-assessment system by placing self-employed taxpayers on a current year basis; further significant reform of the corporation tax system; initial steps to reduce our indirect taxes so as to help lower inflation and to bring our rates closer to European levels in preparation for 1992, and new steps as part of the Government's determined efforts to curb tax avoidance and ensure greater equity in the system. Tax reform is, and will continue to be, a major priority with the Government.

I would now like to turn to describe in more detail the more significant elements of the Bill.

Chapter I of the Bill deals with the important income tax changes. I am pleased that we have been able to make further progress this year in reducing the burden of income tax.

I have again extended the standard rate band by £400 for a single person and £800 for a married couple, in order to keep at 63 per cent the proportion of taxpayers on the standard rate. I have again reduced the standard rate itself to 30 per cent and the top rate to 53 per cent. I have also further improved the exemption limits which are of particular benefit to those on low incomes: I have increased the general exemption limit for a single person by £250 and for a married couple by £500 and I have increased to £300 the special child addition to the exemption limits which I introduced last year. I addition, I have reduced to 53 per cent the marginal relief rate which applies where income does not greatly exceed the relevant exemption limit.

The reduction in tax rates — which means that five percentage points have been taken off both the standard and top rates over the past two years — will be of benefit to all taxpayers.

The increases in exemption limits will be of a substantial benefit to low-paid taxpayers generally, not just low-income PAYE workers but also small farmers and low-income self-employed taxpayers. Overall, the package of measures for the low-paid should exempt an estimated 31,000 taxpayers with 58,000 children from tax altogether, while a further 65,000 taxpayers with 123,000 children will benefit from marginal relief. The Revenue Commissioners, at my request, have taken practical measures to bring these changes to the notice of low-paid taxpayers: they have conducted a publicity campaign about them, and have also sent an information leaflet, incorporating a short application form, with the tax-free allowance certificates issued to low-paid taxpayers in recent months. I will be circulating to Members of both Houses of the Oireachtas as soon as possible leaflets giving details of the income tax exemption scheme, so that Members can send them to low-income taxpayers who should be benefiting from the scheme.

Overall, the income tax changes introduced in recent years have, on a cumulative basis, cost over £800 million, compared with the £225 million commitment contained in the 1987Programme for National Recovery.

The Government are, of course, committed to further progress on income tax by way of further reducing the standard rate to 25 per cent by 1993 and by moving towards a single higher rate of tax.

In addition to the main changes in income tax, Chapter I of the Bill contains a number of other provisions. There are three new provisions which were added to the Bill in the course of the discussion in the Dáil. Section 4 doubles, from £2,500 to £5,000 the allowance granted to a taxpayer where he or his wife is totally incapacitated and he employs someone to take care of the incapacitated person. Section 5 exempts from income tax the investment income arising to a totally and permanently incapacitated taxpayer from a court award or out-of-court settlement of his personal injury case. While the actual awards or settlements themselves in such cases are already tax-free, the investment income arising from them has been liable to income tax up to now; this section will exempt such income from now on. The exemption applies where the investment income is the sole or main income of the taxpayer; in other words, where he or she is mainly or completely dependent on such income. Section 7 exempts from income tax, payments made by the Haemophiliacs HIV Trust. Senators will be aware of the sort of circumstances which these sections are designed to deal with and I am sure they will receive wholehearted support.

Section 6 deals with life assurance relief. Senators will recall that last year I restricted this relief to 80 per cent of the amount which previously qualified as a means of obtaining a small contribution from the income tax code to the substantial measures of relief provided by the 1989 budget. This year, I am reducing this figure further to 50 per cent. This restriction, which will yield about £13 million in the 1990-91 tax year, must be seen in the context of the overall budget package of income tax measures. Even taking account of the restriction of life assurance relief, these measures will cost in total £200 million in the current tax year. The restriction of life assurance relief also reduces distortion in financial investment.

Section 10 extends the business expansion scheme to the construction and leasing of advance factories in areas which are in particular need of development and of the creation of employment opportunities and where the construction is promoted by a local community group.

Section 10 has two other purposes. It removes an anomaly under which the BES applies to certain international services in respect of which an IDA employment grant has been made but does not include such services for which the financial assistance was received from the Shannon Free Airport Industrial Development Company or from Údarás na Gaeltachta. The section ensures as well that activities being retained in the 10 per cent corporation tax scheme by section 41 of the Bill are also retained in the business expansion scheme.

Of course, while anxious that the business expansion scheme should be available in respect of these important economic activities, I am conscious that the scheme has been the subject of substantial abuse in recent months, despite the measure I took last year to try to preserve the scheme as a scheme for providing real risk capital. Accordingly, I am taking new measures in section 34 of the Bill. Under this provision BES relief will not be available where arrangements exist to guarantee the investor's share-holding regardless of whether or not the company he has invested in is successful. BES relief will not be available where an arrangement exists which can reasonably be considered to eliminate the risk that shareholders might be unable to recover an agreed amount in respect of their investment within an agreed period. In other words, no longer will guaranteed investments qualify for BES relief. This section also counters similar type tax avoidance investment schemes in other areas which were devised last year.

Section 11 is also concerned with the BES, and is aimed at preventing the possibility of investors getting interest relief on loans taken out by BES shares, as well as the BES relief itself on the capital invested under the scheme. Such interest relief could be available where the investor is an employee or director of the BES company. However, I see no reason why an investor, having obtained tax relief on the capital he has invested through the BES, should also be able to obtain tax relief on the interest he pays on a loan taken out to enable him to acquire the BES shares. In short, he should not be able to get relief on both the capital and the interest.

Chapter II of the Bill gives effect to the change in the basis of assessment for self-employed taxpayers. This represents an important new step in the development of the self assessment system which has proved such a success since it was introduced in 1988.

As a result of these provisions self-employed taxpayers will, with effect from the present tax year, have their liability for tax based on the profits of the current rather than the preceding year. This major change is necessary if the momentum of progress under self-assessment is to be maintained. A pre-requisite for further progress is that all sources of income — trading income, investment income and so on — should be assessed for tax on the same basis: at present some income is assessed on a preceding year basis and other income is assessed on a current year basis. This gives rise to considerable confusion and, in effect, necessitates the submission of two years' returns before the liability for a particular year can be finalised.

The switch to a current year basis of assessment for all income is, therefore, the next logical step in the progress towards a full obligatory self-assessment system where taxpayers would be required, in due course, to compute and pay their tax themselves. The switch will bring greater certainty and efficiency to the system and in particular will result in: a lower compliance burden for taxpayers and their advisers; better service from tax offices and the intensified pursuit of tax evasion through better use of resources.

Details of the legislative arrangements for the new assessment regime are set out in the explanatory memorandum to the Bill. The main features are as follows: For the 1990-91 and subsequent tax years all income will be charged to tax on the basis of the income in the year of assessment. In the case of trading profits of the self-employed, which are computed by reference to annual accounts, the charge to tax will, as I indicated previously, be based on the profits of the accounting period ending in the current tax year. Preliminary tax will now be due on 1 November in the tax year and, to avoid an interest charge for underpayments, the taxpayer must pay not less than 90 per cent of the current year ultimate liability or not less than 100 per cent of the preceding year's actual tax liability. As a result of the switch to a current year basis this year, accounting periods ending in 1989-90 will not now form the basis for an assessment. A transitional measure is included so as to reduce any hardship that might arise, as a result of a significant fluctuation in income between 1989-90 and 1990-91. The Bill provides that where the profits for 1990-91 exceed the profits for 1989-90 by 50 per cent or more, the assessment for 1990-91 will be reduced to the average profits of the two periods. Marginal relief will be available where the profit increase is between 25 and 50 per cent. Farmers will, of course, continue to have their general averaging option available. Transitional provisions are also included to deal with the treatment of capital allowances in the changeover year 1990-91 in the case of unincorporated business. Notwithstanding that 1989-90 will not form a basis for an assessment, a return of income for the period will still be required. This is necessary to settle outstanding matters relating to 1989-90 tax liability and to ensure that no one is taking unfair advantage of the changeover to transfer income into the period which would not form a basis of assessment. The tax return filing date is being changed from 31 December in the year of assessment to 31 January in the year following the year of assessment. Provision is made to retain the existing arrangements as regards crediting of tax deducted in the preceding year and the operation of the interim refund procedures under the scheme of withholding tax on professional fees. There are certain other mainly technical consequential provisions.

While these measures will bring the tax treatment of the self-employed closer to that of PAYE taxpayers, I would emphasise that important differences still remain and the chage does not provide any justification for extending the PAYE allowance to the taxpayers affected.

I would like to underline once again the importance I attach to this change in our continuing efforts to have a simpler and more effective tax system. Much has been done in this regard in recent years and we can now go further. The proposals were, in general, well received in the Dáil and I commend them to this House. A simpler and more efficient tax system will bring considerable benefits to all concerned.

Sections 30 and 31 in Chapter III give effect to the budget decision to extend, from 31 May 1991 to 31 May 1993, the time limit for incurring expenditure which qualifies for the urban renewal tax reliefs in the designated areas. This measure will enable many pipeline projects to be completed and will give a major boost to the pace of development and renewal in those areas. In tandem with this extension, sections 32 and 33 are directed at removing the opportunity for certain abuses and unintended uses of these urban renewal tax incentives.

The Bill continues the process of reform of the corporation tax system with a significant new package of measures. The aims are: to broaden the corporation tax base; to encourage more employment — especially in the services sector, which is such an important source of new jobs — by reducing the standard rate of corporation tax, and to refine and extend certain important incentives. The changes are in line with the approach of the Commission on Taxation, which recommended a lower tax rate on a wider tax base. They are also in line with international trends.

Turning to the individual elements, the reduction in accelerated capital allowances which is provided for in Chapter VIII will remove the excessive bias which has existed in the tax system in favour of capital intensity rather than extra jobs. The current level of 50 per cent accelerated capital allowances will be maintained up to 1 April 1991 and will then be reduced to 25 per cent for a further year, before being eliminated on 1 April 1992. This gives adequate notice of the change to taxpayers and will enable them to plan accordingly. I would point out that the normal annual capital allowances are not affected and can be applied to the balance of any expenditure not written off under the accelerated allowances. As was the case in 1988, the 100 per cent accelerated capital allowances are being maintained for qualifying service companies in the Custom House Docks area, Shannon customs-free airport and in the tax incentives package for the urban renewal areas.

Specific provision is being made to cater for two categories of pipeline projects. These are projects which are approved for grant aid by the industrial development agencies on or before 31 December 1990, and hotel and other tourist accommodation projects where the construction contract is signed before the same date and where Bord Fáilte registration is subsequently obtained. The current 50 per cent level of accelerated allowances will continue to be available to these pipeline projects.

Section 46 in Chapter IV implements the budget proposal to reduce the volume of domestic-sourced section 84 loans. The effect of this is to disallow all new loans of this type from budget day except where the total loan volume of the lender does not exceed 75 per cent of his loan volume as of 12 April last. I have introduced a special transitional arrangement for certain loans for new manufacturing projects which were under negotiation with the industrial promotion agencies as of budget day. This will enable up to £170 million to be given in section 84 loans to such projects in the period 31 January 1990 to 31 December 1991 where the relevant qualifying conditions are met.

Another important change is the restriction in section 41 of the definition of manufacturing for the purposes of the special 10 per cent tax rate. As Senators will no doubt recall, I announced in my Budget Statement that I was concerned about the fact that the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing now applies to a wider range of activities than was originally intended when it was introduced in 1980. As a result of a series of court and appeal commissioner decisions within the last ten years, the concept of manufacturing has now been extended well beyond the ordinary everyday meaning of the term so as to include activities which are not really manufacturing operations at all. This is obviously quite costly to the Exchequer because the profits in question are charged to tax at only 10 per cent instead of 43 per cent. This situation has to be remedied and section 41 accordingly introduces new provisions to restrict the definition of manufacturing to what was originally envisaged. These provisions will achieve their effect by excluding certain categories of activities from the scope of the 10 per cent rate.

However, I would like to emphasise that the changes will not impact on genuine manufacturing activities. The vast bulk of activities which now qualify for the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing will not be affected. In order to provide further reassurance on this point, I introduced a number of drafting amendments on Committee Stage in the Dáil. These amendments made clear the intention that for an activity to be excluded from the definition of manufacturing, it must primarily fall into one of the five excluded categories specified in the section. In addition, the industrial buildings test was deleted because it had given rise to considerable uncertainties about the status of some genuine manufacturing activities. Also, fish-processing and certain computer equipment activities are not specifically mentioned as qualifying for the 10 per cent rate. These amendments give greater clarity regarding the application of the section without undermining the basic objective.

All these provisions — in respect of accelerated capital allowances, section 84 lending and the qualifying manufacturing activities for the purposes of the 10 per cent rate — will broaden the tax base.

poration tax package is the reduction in the standard rate of corporation tax from 43 per cent to 40 per cent. This will take effect from 1 April 1991 and will mean that in the period since 1988 the rate will have been reduced by 10 percentage points.

As I mentioned earlier, a number of specially targeted incentives are being extended or introduced. The major incentive being extended is the special 10 per cent rate for manufacturing which was scheduled to expire on 31 December 1990. The termination date is now being extended by ten years up to 31 December 2010. This special low rate of tax is the key incentive for attracting mobile international manufacturing investment, which has provided very large numbers of new jobs throughout the country. The fact that the incentive is now guaranteed for the next 20 years will be a tremendous help to the IDA and the other industrial promotion agencies in continuing to attract vital new foreign manufacturing investment. The decision to extend the date follows a study by an international consultancy group which compared Ireland's competitiveness for internationally mobile investments with that of other regions in the EC. At a time of increasing competition for investment funds from all over Europe it is vital that we have an effective incentive package.

The business community was invited in my 1989 budget speech to launch an initiative aimed at creating jobs and alleviating poverty in areas of particular need. The business sector has responded to that invitation by creating a trust for community initiatives, which will receive corporate donations and use these to assist suitable projects. Section 45 provides for tax relief on donations made to the trust in the period 20 April 1990 to 31 March 1991. This will encourage companies to contribute to the trust, and will enable the trust's work to commence at an early date.

The idea here is that in blackspots, in very poor areas or areas of diminishing economic activity, companies could make donations into a trust fund that will be allowed as a write-off against tax at the corporate tax rate applicable and at the same time be non-refundable to the companies. It would serve as a revolving fund, where they will provide and seve capital for projects that are short of it and cannot get off the ground, thus providing a back-up to the enterpreneurial scheme for new projects I introduced in last year's budget or indeed for any community-based project that would increase economic activity and help in alleviating poverty and deprivation.

The special incentives being introduced include the extension of the 10 per cent rate of corporation tax for shipping to offshore supply vessels which are engaged in taking supplies and personnel to and from drilling rigs and production platforms at sea. This measure will assist Irish vessels to compete successfully in this area and to develop their potential for further business in the spin-off expenditure associated with exploration activity offshore. We have not got any slice of the whole North Sea servicing area. We should be in a position to do a particularly good job on our own and this gives an opportunity to the very small number of Irish-owned companies to put them in a position to compete for a slice of that business.

A brand new incentive is being introduced under section 39 to encourage scheduled mineral exploration activity. In future, Irish prospecting companies will be able to set off their exploration expenditure in Ireland against their other income or gains with the exception of income which is subject to deposit interest retention tax. The ten year time limit which formerly applied to the carrying forward of abortive exploration expenditure is also being removed. These changes in the taxation treatment of exploration expenditure of scheduled minerals will help to boost the current momentum in that sector.

Chapter IX of Part I of the Bill deals with capital gains tax. In addition to providing for the abolition of the 60 per cent rate, I am making further amendments in relation to certain areas of the tax. Included among these are provisions which extend the relief available on disposals of certain business assets by individuals aged 55 years or over to disposals of shares in holding companies of trading groups.

Parts II and III of the Bill implement the budget reductions in excise duty and VAT, as well as certain technical changes aimed especially at bringing our law more into line with European requirements. The reduction of two percentage points in the standard rate of VAT from 25 to 23 per cent will make a significant contribution to lower inflation this year.

I am postponing, at no cost to the Exchequer, the introduction of VAT on telephones until 1 January next to allow Telecom Éireann time to complete the installation of their new billing system. There will be no additional cost to the consumer. It is purely an administrative function that has to be carried out by Telecom Éireann and we are facilitating an amendment in this situation.

All the measures I am taking are consistent with what is required of us in the context of 1992 tax approximation. While developments on this front are moving slowly, progress is being made, especially in regard to the elaboration of the VAT system to be put in place when frontier controls are taken away. Detailed proposals as to how the new system will work are now emerging from the Commission and the Irish Presidency intend to commence work on these as soon as they have been presented formally to the Council of Finance Ministers at our next meeting in June. It is important that early decisions are taken so that businesses have time to plan for the major changes ahead.

I would also mention specifically the question of increasing the VAT on ESB up to 10 per cent, again at no cost to the consumer, as I said at budget time.

The basic questions of the precise rates of VAT and excise to apply after 1992 and the goods which will qualify for the different rates of VAT have still to be settled. The timetable set last year does not envisage decisions in these sensitive areas until next year but we are trying to make as much progress as possible during our Presidency.

By reducing our standard VAT rate this year we have shown that we are willing to play our part in advancing tax approximation, despite the very serious financial implications for this country. Following the request which I made last year, the EC Commission are at present studying our problems. I hope that this study, which I expect to be completed shortly, will help to indicate solutions to some of our difficulties in this area.

Part IV of the Bill deals with stamp duty. Sections 108 and 109 deal with two stamp duty levies. The bank levy is being renewed for 1990 and will yield £36 million, the same amount as last year. The 3 per cent levy on investment in life assurance linked funds is being extended to investment in unit trusts and similar investment funds, so as to remove a tax distortion between these two categories of investment media.

What is happening at the moment is that unit trust funds were being marketed into this country out of Luxembourg. They enjoyed a competitive edge here and would seriously damage the sale of our own unit-linked funds. This is basically a balancing factor. I, therefore, introduced amendments in Part IV of this Bill which rationalised rate bands under various headings. These changes would clarify and simplify the way stamp duties are applied.

The Stamp Duty Act is almost 100 years in existence and the types and methods of transactions, especially in the financial services sector, have changed over the years. I have, therefore, introduced amendments in Part IV of the Bill which rationalise the rates bands under various headings. These changes will clarify and simplify the way stamp duties are applied.

I have also made provision for an exemption from companies capital duty for collective investment undertakings which come under the UCITs directive. This measure is at section 115.

As I announced in my budget speech, provision has been made, at section 112, for the charging of full stamp duty on certain expensive new houses which could previously avoid duty. This measure will not become operative until 1 September next in order that persons who signed contracts prior to my announcement may complete their transactions. Basically, what is involved there is two separate contracts — one for the site and one for the house — and you pay stamp duty on the site and nothing else. It was an abuse of the stamp duty and was certainly totally inequitable when compared with the sale of a second-hand house in the same bracket or category where stamp duty would have to be paid at the full rate.

Part V of the Bill deals with residential property tax. In addition to a number of technical amendments which will facilitate self-assessment of this tax, I have made provision at section 125 for the restoration of child relief in respect of the tax. Which had been taken away some years ago.

Part VI of the Bill deals with capital acquisitions tax. Since capital acquisitions tax was introduced in 1976 it has undergone a number of amendments which impinge on the exposure to this tax. This exposure arises roughly once every generation and unless provision is made to meet it the resources of a taxpayer can be diminished. Special insurance policies can be taken out to cover inheritance tax liabilities. The amendment at section 130 of this Bill will enhance their popularity. Section 127 of the Bill provides for an exemption from tax for gifts taken by one spouse from the other.

The Bill also provides for the indexation of the capital acquisition tax thresholds which have remained unchanged since 1978. These thresholds will, in future, be indexed in value each year and this should give useful relief in certain cases. The revised thresholds will apply to all gifts and inheritances taken on or after 1 january 1990.

In this opening address I have concentrated on the key provisions of the Bill as well as outlining general Government policy on the economy and on tax reform. The Bill also contains additional measures to counter tax avoidance as well as other provisions of a mainly technical nature and these items can be discussed on Committee Stage.

I commend the Bill to the House.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

On the Order of Business it was proposed that time limits should apply. They are that spokespersons for the individual groupings will have 30 minutes each and all other Members will have 15 minutes each. I call Senator Doyle.

Comment on this

I would personally like to thank the Minister for his comprehensive address to the House here this morning on the Finance Bill, 1990. As he pointed out to us, this is the annual ritual whereby the Houses of the Oireachtas give statutory effect to any taxation changes for the year in question, particularly those foreshadowed in the budget of the year in question, in this case this year's budget.

There are many points I welcome in the Bill. All of us must welcome the reduction in VAT, the reduction in income tax, rationalisation in taxation areas and we welcome also the changes in section 84. I personally am very pleased with the trusts for community initiatives and I hope that industry now responds. We see some on-ground results from that, particularly in the more remote and isolated areas. I welcome very much the amendment introduced yesterday to section 5 — the income tax exemption for the permanently and totally disabled on the income accruing from their court awards and compensation generally. They must be welcomed. They are positive measures which will improve conditions and improve the situation for the different sectors.

Above everything else there is one question I, and my colleagues, would like to ask the Minister, and I hope the Minister will answer frankly and honestly. Why did you not try to balance the budget in 1990? Why this missed opportunity? Why wait until 1993? You are in a time of waning political consensus for further budgetary restrictions, for further belt tightening. We are now getting into an era of increased demand for spending when it will be generally harder for politicians, and for the Ministers for Finance of the day, to keep the rein on public expenditure. Over the last couple of Governments, helped by the very responsible role of Fine Gael in the Tallaght strategy, I think public opinion was conditioned to resolving our budgetary and debt problems to balancing the budget. We had managed to bring, albeit with some screaming and shouting in certain sectors, the vast bulk of the responsible public with us in what we were trying to do. I do not think we will be able to hold that line with them for too much longer. I would love to have seen — and the Fine Gael Party would love to have seen — this opportunity that you have now missed, grabbed, taken, balance our budget and, once and for all, get the very difficult problems we have had in terms of the budget behind us.

I cannot understand your reasoning and your rationale in your response to that question over the last few months. When I read the views of the Governor of the Central Bank and the various other economic reviews and reports on the budget and on subsequent months, I see that they cannot understand either why you missed this great opportunity. Above all else that hangs over the Bill we are talking about today — it is the budget of the great missed opportunity, Minister, and it must hang around your neck.

Comment on this

That is what you think.

Comment on this

No, Minister. I know it and others, with far more experience in this area than I, also happen to concur and have offered their views. You had an over-reliance on buoyancy in your budgetary figures. This fact, combined with the very poor and what in fact are very disappointing first quarter Exchequer returns, must make us look again at what you are trying to achieve. I do not buy, Minister, your reference to the first quarter Exchequer returns. It was a nice bit of diplomacy and nicely worded. The fact is, if we are honest with one another, the first quarter Exchequer returns were extremely disappointing; and you recognised that fact to us and no amount of smooth talking will take away from it. With that, and with the buoyancy figures you included in the budget, there are serious questions to be asked as to how the targets are to be met this year. We only have to look at the recent reduction in sales in the used car sector, holiday sector, the reduction in new mortgages and so on and use these as indicators as to how your buoyancy figures will not be met in terms of Exchequer returns.

Minister, there is a lot yet to be added up and a lot of questions that we have to have answered by you. I hope, when you are replying to Second Stage, that with the overall sums of the budget you will be very frank and indicate exactly how you expect your targets to be met in all the different areas. I would appreciate if you would indicate what contingency measures you have when the targets are not met. You referred to that vaguely in your speech. You stated "The results to date this year are running broadly in line with budget expectations". Therein hides an awful lot, Minister —"broadly in line with budget expectations". You went on: "The Government will continue to monitor the trends closely over the remainder of the year to ensure that the budget targets will be achieved". Could the Minister tell us what he will do if they are not achieved? There is a feeling in the economic sector and in the financial sector that those targets will not be achieved. They are not my views. They are not my words. I am borrowing from the wise and the experienced when I quote that fact. Minister, what are your contingency measures when your targets fail to be met?

We have difficulty in this country in terms of competitiveness. One of the greatest contributors to this area are the present interest rates. Over the last 12 months or so we have had four different rises of interest rates on different occasions. We are out of line with the D-Mark, even though we are in the EMS. The cost of money is a crippling factor in terms of investment and in creating jobs. It is one of the major factors in preventing us becoming more competitive as we face the Europe of 1993.

Could the Minister tell us more about his new debt management office that he is going to have in the Department of Finance? Apparently we need legislation for it — or do we need legislation? I believe you have indicated that. But have we seen any sign of the draft legislation, or has there been any legislation circulated? When will we have this legislation? When will we have it enacted? If you are going to save £35 million, as you indicate, this year with that new debt management office we would want to be getting it into operation very quickly — we are half way through the year, June starts next week. What are your plans in this area? Could you please tell us exactly how and why £35 million can now be saved, whereas the expertise you have had in the office all along and the excellent, committed people you have had in the Department of Finance all along have not been able to save that to date? A lot needs to be explained in this area.

The Governor of the Central Bank is on record saying that your borrowing targets were too soft, so interest rates will have to remain high. Minister, not my words, I borrow from those whom I presume know what they are talking about. I do not pretend at all to have the experience of——

Comment on this

One minute ago you were talking about the interest rates being too high so——

Comment on this

The interest rates are so high because of your borrowing. The interest rates are high and cannot be reduced, we are being told by the financial pundits out there, because the borrowing targets are so soft. As long as your policy is wrong and as long as you have not held the policy that we had hoped you would have held, interest rates cannot come down. That is the view of those in the Central Bank and those in the area who, in fact, govern interest rates. They are not my views, Minister. I am just quoting what I have read extensively about. I am quoting the concerns of the industrial, commercial and general private sector in this area.

We know what a brake on economic activities generally high interest rates are. However it must be achieved, Minister — and you paid little attention to interest rates in your speech — I would like to know what your plans are to ensure that your policies are such that interest rates can be reduced and to remove this unnecessary brake on economic activity in our country.

The whole target of reducing the debt to GNP ratio apparently has to be looked at again. The Minister appears to have had a rethink on that, too. We all support the Minister in what has been the ambition of all concerned and serious politicians in both Houses, to get the debt-GNP ratio down to one as quickly as possible. One hundred per cent of GNP by the year 1993 is what the Minister has promised us in this area but, again this is considered too soft a target, another missed opportunity. We wait for the Minister's explanation on this. We need to be at 75 per cent — the Minister need not brief his colleagues until I am finished talking. I did not get a brief while he was talking. The Minister can brief his colleagues to reply to me later on when they get up to speak.

Comment on this

We do not need briefing.

Comment on this

Will the Senator tell that to the Minister?

Comment on this

It sounds so ridiculous. Will the Senator tell the House how she will raise the £2 billion in taxation to achieve the 75 per cent. That is what it amounts to.

Comment on this

The Minister has the experience to understand that he has the opportunity of a reply to Second Stage. Am I correct? The same procedures will hold today?

Comment on this

I will be here.

Comment on this

I will be here, too. There is no need to reply to me now. As I go along there will be a further opportunity——

Comment on this
Tom Fitzgerald Acting Chairman (Mr. Fitzgerald) Fianna Fáil

Unfortunately the Senator appears to be looking for the answers now.

Comment on this

No, not really. I know the Minister is coming back to me.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will the Senator please continue?

Comment on this

The Acting Chairman must know questions are a normal format in the House in addressing the Minister. We need a target of 75 per cent of GNP by 1993 and not the 100 per cent. We would like to hear the Minister's figures and his reasons why he has taken the soft option when we had political consensus. That political consensus may wane by 1993. Why did the Minister not run with the ball when the support was there to do it this year?

The Minister's figure for growth for 1990 was 4.5 per cent but even if we take a 3.5 to 4 per cent growth in GNP over the next few years, while maintaining the same level of Exchequer expenditure, that would achieve the Minister's target in 1993. If we maintain the same level of Exchequer expenditure, growth in GNP will achieve the Minister's target for 1993. The Minister is not adding anything to what we can naturally expect to happen. Again, a tragically missed opportunity. Fine Gael believe the Minister's target in this area to be unacceptably soft and we accuse him of missing this golden opportunity. In 1982 when Fine Gael-Labour Coalition took over Government, inflation was running at 21 per cent. When we left office in February 1987 the inflation rate was 5 per cent; a year later, with the Minister's predecessor in office, it was down to 3.5 per cent and under the present Minister's guidance this progress continued.

The whole benefit of the strong punt in relation to sterling has not been passed on to the consumer. Could we please, perhaps, have some of the secrets from the Cabinet table on this? Perhaps the Minister would let us into the secret why the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not being even more radical. He stepped in last autumn and, after many months of consumer resistance and consumer outcry, and he questioned in certain sectors but we still have appalling problems. The time of response and the time lag before the consumer gets the benefit of the present exchange rate is far too long. In the book and magazine sector, for example, we are still paying 40p, 50p and 60p more than the sterling price for the average magazine, at a time of virtual parity between the two currencies at the moment. There has to be a reasonable lag for forward ordering and for processing orders but at the moment the lag is unacceptable.

Consumers deserve to be told why they are not benefiting from the virtual parity between the pound sterling and the punt. When it goes the other way and when the differential increases, prices go up very quickly but when there is good news the prices come down very very slowly. Why is there this discrepancy? Why can consumers not benefit now when they have had to pay the price on imported goods for so long? Is there a question of cartels and monopolies in this area generally? Can we expect legislation? I understand from the Minister for Industry and Commerce that maybe we can expect legislation and that there are actual problems preventing a free open market in this area at the moment. Perhaps the Minister could indicate to us the intentions of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to allow us to benefit from the anti-monopoly and anti-cartel provisions of the Treaty of Rome.

Another matter that was raised in the other House was the liquidity problems in banks and building societies. Apparently the Minister feels there is no problem in this area at all. The House would benefit from his explanation on that response. The insurance companies, as we all know, are attracting more savings than the other financial institutions at the moment. Consequently, there is a possibility of a credit squeeze in the banks. What is the whole position in this area particularly at a time when we have come to expect huge investment from the Structural Funds? Investors in this country must be able to go out and borrow to match, hopefully, pound for pound or at least one third to two thirds, the moneys coming from Europe so that we can fully benefit from this once-off bonanza of European money. If there is a credit squeeze when our developers and investors want it now, the Minister will be held responsible in years to come for this country not being able to benefit fully by the proper and productive investment of the Structural Funds. Apparently on this point the Central Bank will only allow a 10 per cent expansion of credit this year. What is the Minister's response to that? Does he think that will be sufficient to ensure that we do not restrict the proper and productive development of the Structural Funds moneys in this country.

On the general taxation issue, the Minister knows that when his predecessor was in office, and again during the Minister's term, Fine Gael endeavoured to get an all-party taxation committee established in relation to taxation reform. The Minister refers in his contribution to taxation reform. There is none. There are welcome changes in certain areas but they are the same type of changes that have been made over the years.

The Minister is not alone in not being radical in relation to taxation reform. No Minister has picked this one up and run with it, perhaps for very obvious reasons in recent years. When there was a political consensus and an offer of an all-party committee to sit down and have a serious look at taxation reform and integrated social welfare and taxation code, it is tragic that the Government have not taken that opportunity as it was offered. It will be very hard for any Government, even a Coalition Government, in the years to get through measures that will have the political and popular consensus we will need in this most difficult area. I ask the Minister to look again at that request to see if there is a role for an all-party committee to examine the integration of the taxation and social welfare codes and reform in both of these areas together.

The Minister mentioned the changes made in relation to corporate tax and, indeed many are welcomed. An interesting point is in relation to the extension of the 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate to 2010. I am prompted to suggest that the Minister might have jumped the gun in announcing this. I am not saying I object to it. I can see some very good reasons why we have to look to it but there are two questions I ask the Minister to answer when he is responding in this area. Why this announcement now without waiting for an overall review of industrial policy, why a unilateral announcement of this particular aspect of industrial policy? We have got to have incentives but the Minister has apparently jumped the gun. Maybe it was his Cabinet colleague, maybe it was getting back at the Minister for Energy jumping the gun at the Progressive Democrats party conference on another Cabinet issue that was announced last week. I know the Taoiseach confirmed it was Cabinet policy and had been agreed by Cabinet, but under pressure and under questioning from different sides of the House.

Comment on this

The Senator should return to the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

Is the Acting Chairman in the Chair?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Yes.

Comment on this

I am not in the Chair but as a Government Senator I am asking the Senator to keep to the Finance Bill. I was here before her and I will be here when she is gone, too.

Comment on this

The Acting Chairman is entitled to call me to book any time he wishes. That is his job, not the would-be Cathaoireach's job.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I will. The Senator should return to the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

With regard to the extension to the year 2010 of the 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate how does this fit in with Commissioner Schrivener's view of harmonisation of taxes? I hope it fits in and I hope we have no problem in selling this to out colleagues in the EC but it would seem to fly in the face of all that we have heard about the harmonisation of taxation levels across the board. That fact and the fact that the Minister has anounced it outside an overall review of industrial policy requires an explanation. I would like the Minister to explain his thinking on those matters.

The 10 per cent manufacturing tax and the definition of the manufacturing industries that qualify are ill-defined. Is there a statutory definition for manufacturing? If so, I have not found it. I thank the Minister for confirming that I did not think there was. The Minister and his officials should make a greater effort to define exactly what he means by manufacturing. We are preparing a field day for the legal profession. I can see them going straight to court as soon as this Bill is enacted, one after the other, and even though the Minister blamed the courts and the appeal commissioners of one type or another for extending the original intended definition of it, it will be back to court again and off we will go again with more of this. As long as the Minister has this ill-defined definition it will be very hard to satisfy the different interest groups. He will have comparable manufacturing industries; some will come within the definition but others will be outside it.

I will give one example in this area and the Minister is well aware of it. The whole industrial process of grain drying satisfies all the criteria necessary for the definition, such as we have, of manufacturing. As the Minister has confirmed, we have no statutory definition of manufacturing, so what do we then do? We turn to the Oxford dictionary or some equivalent source to advise us. That dictionary defines manufacturing as "to work up into forms suitable for use".

We have also legal precedent in this area and I am sure the Minister is aware of it. That concerns the whole business of McCausland versus the Ministry of Commerce in Northern Ireland on the rye grass issue. It would be even harder, in my view, to consider the rye grass issue manufacturing than it would be our industrial grain drying process down here, yet that was defined as manufacturing after lengthy legal consideration. When the Minister looks through that and the legal justification and judgment that was given on the issue at the time, it would be very hard for him to exclude the industrial grain drying process in this country and the various other manufacturing industries.

Comment on this

The Wexford barley lobby.

Comment on this

The malting barley industry is extremely important to Wexford and I will not apologise for defending it. The tillage industry is under siege, as the Minister knows. The tillage section in agriculture has a few very bleak years ahead of it. This will put another nail in the coffin of an indigenous industry that creates a great deal of employment. We have an increasing export potential in malting barley. Therefore, I appeal to the Minister to look at the legal precedent, what is already on the books, and not give the legal profession a field day. Let the Minister define exactly what he means by "manufacturing" and let us discuss and debate it so that we know what we are talking about. It is very hard, effectively, to do so at the moment.

The Minister spoke at some considerable length about the business expansion scheme. Again, woeful abuse was occurring in this area. The Minister heralded changes last summer but it took him until the budget and until now to put those into effect essentially. I fully support his view that unless it is genuine risk capital being invested it should not benefit from the various taxation freedoms that have been granted in this area. The Minister has removed the area of guarantee for any moneys that have gone in here. I support that measure.

There is a lot more in the BES that we have to look to, even some of the projects now qualifying. I have a big question mark over agricultural production. Either all of it goes in or none of it goes in. There is no problem with processing manufacturing and marketing. That is what it is all about. However, we certainly have agri-business areas gone in a minute, where they are competing with BES money, very favourably, or rather there is unfair competition in this area with the average farmer who is producing the primary product on the land. The Minister probably knows the type of thing I have in mind. I feel we are being ripped off as a State. This must be watched very carefully. I suspect the Minister might agree with me on that. I know we will not get into individual cases but there is something afoot that I do not like, the farmers do not like and the farm organisations do not like.

Comment on this

The farming organisations do like it.

Comment on this

Not what I am referring to. The Minister knows what I am referring to. We have to be absolutely sure that risk capital is used for what it is intended and that it is not used in unfair competition against primary producers who have to use ordinary commercial rate money and where the normal competitive factors in the market place apply to them. We must watch this carefully and stamp it out rapidly if our suspicions are confirmed, which, unfortunately, I believe they will be.

We support the move to tax on a current year basis. It is a natural progression from the introduction of self-assessment. It is, as the Commission on Taxation suggested initially when they mooted self-assessment. The Commission on Taxation also suggested that the same allowances for the self-employed and Schedule D taxpayers that now apply to the PAYE sector should apply on the introduction of self-assessment and current year assessment. Again, none of the Minister's arguments for not doing so are sustainable.

It is very hard to understand how he can take the line he takes now in this area, particularly when a former colleague of his, the Minister for Finance in 1980, stated in the Official Report, volume 313, column 73 that the purpose of the PAYE allowance was:

to take account of the fact that self-employed generally have, at present, the advantage of paying tax on a previous year basis.

The justification at the time for the introduction of the PAYE allowance was because of the benefits enjoyed by the self-employed of not being taxed on a current year basis. If that was justification for the Minister at the time — we all took that at face value and in good faith — how does that lie side by side with the reference in the Minister's speech today as follows:

I would emphasise that the important differences still remain and that change does not provide any justification.

The justification was the lack of current year assessment for the self-employed sector back in 1980. The Minister now says he has changed that and that they are on current year assessment, but there is no justification for extending the PAYE allowance to taxpayers. That does not add up. I hope on Committee Stage we can develop that much more fully.

The levels of indexation for the thresholds for CAT are paltry. Let the Minister remember the tragedy of death duties and the reason there were changes to inheritance tax. We must look at those levels and, in fact, make them realistic. On Committee Stage I will also be appealing to the Minister with regard to the retention of the accelerated capital allowances. There is no mention of the continuing PRSI anomaly for the self-employed aged over 56. What are the Minister's plans in that area?

While we talk about the different areas in which we have interests, some personal interests, others general interests, we forget one area where the Minister for Finance has failed, that is our contribution to ODA, overseas development aid. That was always relative to the GNP in the country. We have reduced our overseas development aid yet again this year. It is now equivalent to 0.158 per cent of our GNP in a year when the Minister's words are that "the GNP is increasing by 4.5 per cent". While we selfishly look at our problems at home and all give our examples of what personally affects us and our constituents, could the Minister please justify why we cannot be more generous to the developing countries and to the countries where there is continuing war and famine? There is no justification, to balance our contributions here today, for accepting that; it would be a general all-party view of the Houses and the Irish people as a nation are extremely generous. If we can take that as a yardstick we know what their wishes are in this area.

This is a complex and long Finance Bill, with 133 pages added to our tax law. We must ask the Minister for plans for consolidation of the tax code, a very difficult issue, but we have to have it sorted. As we await the outcome of the multilateral trade negotaitions under the auspices of the GATT and as we await the advent of the Single Market in 1992, and all the difficulties that will accompany that event we must look to the Minister, above all Ministers, to answer the questions to which the country requires answers. I look forward to those answers.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister to the House. I thank him for giving his time to ensure the safe passage of what I would call a very complex and, at the same time, a very expansive Finance Bill. I also welcome the progressive comments of Senator Doyle relative to the reductions in taxation. Might I use the opportunity to ask the question: what for four and a half years were Fine Gael doing in terms of taxation when they had the reins of government?

There is a suggestion in what the Senator said that the economy is faltering. My understanding of it is that car sales are up 20 per cent this year; I know for a fact that retail sales are up 7 per cent this year and that there is a 10 per cent increase in employment in the construction sector. Yesterday the Minister of State responsible for Trade and Marketing, announced that the trade surplus was at a record high of £54 million. All of these seem to suggest that what the Senator is saying is not in fact correct.

Comment on this

No. They have taken a downturn since Easter. Will the Senator check the figures?

Comment on this

Let me also take up the question of an all-party committee on taxation. This sounds to me ironic because when an all-party committee on the review of local government was offered to Fine Gael, they refused it. Such a review would have financial implications of funding for local authorities.

Comment on this

On a point of order, that was not what was offered. It was local taxation and financing of local government only. It was not an overall review.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will the Senator let Senator O'Keeffe make his contribution without interruption.

Comment on this

I find it ironic that this would be suggested. The Senator also suggested that the debt ratio should be 75 per cent of GNP by the end of 1993. The Minister might correct me if I am wrong here, but that to me would seem an extraordinary adjustment. I understand it would give the Minister two options, to reduce public sector spending by £2 billion or, alternatively, to raise that £2 billion in taxation. The question must be asked, is that what the Senator is proposing?

The Finance Bill has to be welcomed as a further broadening of the tax base and the simplification of the operation of the tax system. While there are many technical matters in the Bill, the main thrust is to improve the system and to ensure that the burden carried by the various sectors, such as PAYE, is distributed much more fairly. In conjunction with the substantial social welfare improvements that were granted in the budget, the main features of this Finance Bill must be looked upon as another example of the Government's deep concern for the less well off members of our community, while at the same time ensuring that the incentives and the reliefs are there for the purpose of generating economic activity and creating jobs.

The higher than inflation social welfare increases together with such a welcome innovation as the carers' allowance, taken in conjunction with the reduction in income tax, the basic rate going from 32 per cent to 30 per cent, and the increase in income tax exemption limits, are a clear indication of the Government's concern for those who are genuinely on low income and those in need of assistance from the State. The widening of the 30 per cent tax band, and the reduction of the top rate of income tax from 56 per cent to 53 per cent are further proof of the Government's commitment to reducing the income tax burden on the personal taxpayer. This is further evidenced by the reduction in the top rate of VAT from 25 per cent to 23 per cent. These adjustments must be seen as positively supporting the Government's basic objective of keeping inflation at an extremely low level but at the same time encouraging confidence in the economic climate by ensuring that people have more disposable income.

I refer the Members to the section of the Minister's Budget Statement where he invited the business community to launch an initiative which would alleviate poverty and increase employment. I am glad Senator Doyle welcomed that initiative. It is also to be welcomed that the business community itself should respond to this by setting up a trust and operating it. As a Corkman I welcome the decision of the Power group of companies to give 1 per cent of their profits. I am particularly pleased that a group caring for the elderly, an extremely deserving charity, will reap some of the benefits from that amount of money. I also welcome the challenge that the Power group have laid down for other top companies, who can reap the benefits of a tax write-off for doing likewise. This, in my view is another example of the Government's commitment to the less well off in our society and to the generation of economic activity within unemployment black spots.

The reorganisation of the business expansion scheme will help to ensure that funds raised under it are applied for the purposes for which the scheme was originally intended, that was to create employment and to generate activity in areas which might not otherwise be attractive to investors. Developments over the past number of years for quite a number of these schemes were seen to be nothing more than tax shelters for those in a position to avoid tax. This is now being restricted. That has to be welcomed by everybody in this House.

The basic principle of the issuing of ordinary share capital in any company is that this capital carries a risk. The Government, in providing incentives for the issuing of such shares, cannot be expected to support the elimination of the risk attached to such shares. This became widespread with the BES scheme and other such arrangements. The tax relief granted to the taxpayer must be balanced by the element of risk to which he is exposed. We had, up to now, the ridiculous situation of no risk investments. Persons who were determined to become involved in a risk undertaking could not get money due to the fact that it had been swallowed up by people involved in no risk investments. It is great that this has been eradicated, and the tax relief granted to the taxpayer must be balanced by the risk to which he is exposed. The BES scheme was never intended to be purely a tax sheltering exercise.

The amendments to the urban renewal scheme have also helped to ensure that such schemes are not abused. Undoubtedly, the availability of various reliefs under urban renewal has led to substantial improvements in the appearance and the activities within such areas. We have to look at the major cities in this country to see what refurbishment and generation of activity this urban renewal has brought to date. The centres of many of our towns and cities have improved, the extension of the urban renewal scheme to other areas recently announced by the Minister is also welcome.

Some of the specific sections in the Finance Bill dealing with certain arrangements which could be considered abusive to the scheme are now to be altered. With both urban renewal and BES, the Government have indicated clearly that they wish to support economic activity and development and are willing to do all in their power to support such development. However, it is also clear that the Government do not wish such schemes to be used as purely tax avoidance methods. The Minister in his budget speech indicated that manufacturing relief is to be extended to the year 2010. Unlike Senator Doyle I welcome this extension. It was called for by the CEF and in attracting major industry into this country, one can only see it as being positive.

Comment on this

I welcomed it but the Senator was not listening.

Comment on this

I listened very attentively to Senator Doyle. Manufacturing relief over the years has again become something of a lawyer's and a tax practitioner's realm, in that its application now extends far beyond those companies originally intended by the Government to benefit. Steps taken in the Finance Bill to redefine qualifying activities for manufacturing needs are to be welcomed and it is important that we ensure that genuine manufacturing activities are not excluded from the relief because of the wording of the Bill. I share some of the concern Senator Doyle expressed in relation to this matter because without a definition of manufacturing, there is cause for concern.

I welcome the Minister's decision to limit the ambit of what can be considered manufacturing. However up to now we have had all types of spurious activities, such as banana ripening, fast food chains and coal grading, regarded as manufacturing. Obviously, this was not the spirit of the 10 per cent corporation tax. The original intention was that the 10 per cent corporation tax would instigate labour intensive manufacturing activity geared to exports and, certainly, geared to import substitution.

Obviously, as I am from Cork, I welcome the amendment relating to the computer industry because without that amendment the Bill would have had serious effects on companies such as Apple Computers, Western Digital and other companies in Cork. That being said, I would like to call the Minister's attention to other areas that may be anomalous. For example, in the clutch and tyre industries — I call them processing industries — there is a total dismantling and complete reprocessing giving 100 per cent added-value and providing import substitutes. These industries are grant aided by the IDA on the basis that they are a manufacturing process. I suggest that where there is total reprocessing, where there is 100 per cent added value to products, where the process is satisfying the IDA's manufacturing criteria and fulfilling an import substitution, such activities might be regarded as suitable for the 10 per cent corporation tax. The Minister should have regard to those facts.

Under capital taxes there are a number of elements in the Bill which remove unfair anomalies and provide a much needed simplification of our tax system. For example, it has always been claimed that capital allowances are a disincentive to creating employment. Indeed, many people have been critical of the IDA who have pursued this policy with foreign investors, that is machines replacing men. This Bill has substantially reduced capital allowances, a move that must be welcomed by all sides of the House. An example is the extension of the retirement relief for capital gains tax purposes to family holding companies and the removal of CAT liability on gifts or inheritance between spouses, which are particularly welcome. A most welcome feature of the entire capital acquisition tax code is the indexation of the threshold. While it could be said that that it is not enough, it certainly is a step in the right direction and has been welcomed by everybody. The number of people coming within the ambit of capital acquisition tax has increased substantially over the past few years and it is only right that the thresholds should be increased.

I would like to spend a few minutes on the film industry. The Government have been accused in the past of dismantling the film industry by, for instance, selling Ardmore Studios. I reject that criticism totally. In doing so I am mindful of the international achievements of the film "My Left Foot" with Irish actors, directors, producers and film crew. We now have an opportunity to create an indigenous industry and one might ask how the Government are helping in this process. The Government are helping by including the film industry in the business expansion scheme, by specifically targeting the film industry for the 10 per cent corporation tax and by allowing companies to invest up to £200,000 per annum, which can be written off against tax. We should never under-estimate the value of television and radio as a generator of expertise and consequent new employment. Our writers and producers have achieved international fame and this with the above Government incentives, give people an opportunity to come together to build on the achievements of the past and to make this industry into a major job creation vehicle. This Finance Bill provides an opportunity to continue this process. The introduction of the current year basis of assessment for the self-employed is a further simplification of the total income tax system. There is general recognition that this change should simplify and improve the administration of the tax system with benefits for the self-employed, taxpayers, their agents and the Revenue Commissioners. This procedure was introduced on a voluntary basis in 1988 and was such a tremendous success that further development was essential if the momentum and progress were to be maintained. The essential element of this procedure was that all sources of income, from trading or investment, should be assessed for tax on the same basis. At present some income is assessed on a procedural basis and other on a current year basis. This obviously causes considerable confusion and, in effect, necessitates a submission of two year returns before the liability for a particular year can be finalised. Benefits from this procedure will mean a low compliance burden for taxpayers and their advisers, greater efficiency and therefore a better service from tax offices. It will also mean that there will be an intensified pursuit of tax evaders and better use of resources, something which all sides of the House desire.

A reduction in the number of rate bands for stamp duty from 14 per cent to 6 per cent and the reintroduction of child allowances and residential property taxes are further indications of the attempts by this Government to bring as much simplification and equity as possible into our taxation system. The Bill contains many technical provisions but its overall thrust is to attempt to simplify certain elements of taxation, remove anomalies within the various taxes and ensure that the various incentives and reliefs granted by the Government are used for the purposes for which they were initiated and to respond to areas of general hardship. Overall, the Finance Bill must be seen as a positive instrument in the Government's stated aim of generating employment and economic activity, while at the same time reducing the burden of taxation. I welcome the Bill and I recommend it to the House.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire. Ceann des na rudaí maith a dheanann sé ná go dtagann sé anseo agus go bhfanann sé anseo go minic chun éisteacht le cuid mhaith a deirimíd.

The Minister is very welcome. It is nice that he has the time to stay here and listen to us. All I can tell him is that what he is going to hear from me will be totally different from what he has heard so far. I will start with a few throw-away things. One of the nice things the Minister did in the budget, which was of particular benefit to young people, was to reduce the excise duty on records and compact discs. However, if the Minister toured the retail premises which sell those products he would not be so sure that there has been a substantial reduction in excise duty on those items. My admittedly less than expert understanding of excise duty is that it is a fixed cash value. When I see a number of compact discs standing together, half of which have been reduced by £1 because of the abolition of excise duty and the other half reduced by £2 because of the abolition of excise duty, I think somebody is being ripped off because it is a fixed rate of excise duty. People are being codded and I believe this has a rip-off factor built into it mainly because the consumers are relatively unsophisticated young people one of whose major interests are in this area. They are a captive audience, they cannot travel far and they are being ripped off. I ask the Minister to carry through his good intention and ensure that excise duty reductions, like the ones he introduced, are passed on to the consumer and do not make the companies and the retailers better off?

There is much reference to enterprise, in discussions on taxation. I would like to invite the Minister, Senators Doyle and O'Keeffe to tell me what sort of enterprise was involved in buying Carysfort College for £21 million and offering it for sale again for £29 million, a profit of £8 million for simply buying and selling property in an opportunistic fashion. What tax will be paid on that masive capital gain? There will be a sugestion that tax should be paid but the probability is that none will be paid. There is an extraordinary capacity to rip off consumers by masquerading enterprises which neither create wealth nor do anything else except make a certain group of individuals — who happen to be in the right place at the right time — rich, for doing nothing. That is not enterprise; it is not initiative, it is simply the capacity to be in the right place at the right time, with no real vision of any new product.

The Minister has provided an incentive to encourage community initiative which is to be welcomed. I agree with what Senator O'Keeffe said. However, the Minister should look at the extraordinary anomalies in the general area of covenanting as they apply to income tax. This was drawn to my attention by the contradictory position under which most charities cannot benefit from the covenanting of personal income tax and normal corporate taxation while a private fee-paying school in my own city can encourage people to covenant money to them and get the full benefit of covenanting. Apparently, charities which look after the poor of this country are not deserving of covenanting, but a school which looks after the children of the rich is. That is social equity turned on its head. The whole thing should either be abolished or be made, in some way, to reflect the realities of life.

I want to challenge a thesis, that is almost taken as holy write here, that is, that we must reduce taxes to encourage enterprise which, in turn, will stimulate growth and, consequently jobs. That is what the Minister implies and, knowing the taxation policies of the Fine Gael Party, in particular, I am sure they would not disagree with that thesis. It is a thesis based on the assumption that that cause and relationship exists. However, being a well-trained scientist I believe that any theoretical model should be challenged or tested by the evidence available, not because it feels good, sounds nice or is very easy to put together. The real test of any throry is how it works. That should not have to be said but in the area of economics, one has to keep on saying this because most of the economics I have read are based on the assumption that we work out a theory and then change reality to conform to our theory, rather than the reverse, which is to work out the theory and then test it against reality.

I would like to have a look at that theory about the relationship between levels of taxation, enterprise, and so on, because there is a lot of evidence available. It is common practice to look at the growth rate and at all taxes as a percentage of gross national product. Paul Tansey in The Sunday Tribune of 17 January 1988, whose source, I am sure, was the Department of Finance, said: “... 34.2 per cent of GNP was taxes in 1982 and 44.3 per cent in 1987”. I gather it has gone down slightly since then, down to around 40 per cent. Apart altogether from the less than complete fairness of using gross national product, given the extraordinary relationship between GNP and GDP here, taxes have increased. The argument is that they have increased and have stifled enterprise. The argument, therefore, is that we must reduce them in order to do something about enterprise and initiative. We have been told that these tax levels, as introduced here, stifle initiative, discourage enterprise and, indeed, in the most ludicrous of all the these, we have been told that the levels of personal income tax are encouraging emigration. We have been told that people are leaving because of the high levels of taxation. There is not, let it be said, a single scrap of empirical evidence to justify the these that people leave this country because they are highly skilled and income tax rates are too high. There are many anecdotes but no demographer who has studied emigration has come up with a single, tenable piece of hard information to prove a relationship between the emigration of highly skilled workers and our levels of income taxation. There are good reasons there is no such evidence because it is probably not true.

We have been told that taxation stifles development, etc. The first thing to be said about percentages of gross national product and gross domestic product as taxes of the percentage of those things in that what is hidden in those figures over the early part of the eighties, from 1980 to 1987, or the first three-quarters of the decade, is that at that time, a very significant change in the ratio of gross domestic product to gross national product took place. One can play wonderful games with changing numbers about percentages. Without boring the House, because the Minister knows more about the relationship between GDP and GNP than I do, in most countries the gross national product exceeds the gross domestic product. We have worked ourselves into a position where the gross domestic product is greater than the gross national product because of the substantial transfers of funds. We then beat our breasts and blame ourselves for this peculiar position and we talk about it all in terms of interest payments. A substantial part of the reason our gross domestic product is actually greater than our gross national product is the re-patriation of profits by multinationals.

Let me say something that is not very socialist, or classically so: the function of industry is to create wealth, not to create jobs. If the industry we have is exporting most of the wealth it creates, it is not fulfilling its primary function and is of doubtful long-term benefit to the country. What we are getting ourselves into is an inverted, peculiar and almost Third World situation where we are prepared to pay any price for jobs which probably cannot last if they are not jobs which are generating reinvestment and modernisation, which means the reinvestment rather than the repatriation of profits.

I wish to continue on the the theme I want to develop, that is, the alleged relationship between enterprise and taxation. We have been offered a considerable amount of evidence to support this thesis. My good friend, Senator Raftery, spoke at length about one country, the United States, and the wonderful success that lower taxes had there. There are a couple of things to be said in this regard. We have been offered a number of models of this and the United States was one. I do not have either the time nor the inclination to keep the Minister by going on too long about this but I could refer him to an article in the Scientific American in May 1987 which demonstrates that half the jobs created because of the tax regime in the United States gave people an income less than the official poverty rate in that country. I do not regard that as an achievement. I regard it as a loading of the dice against the poor in favour of the rich because that is what happened.

I will come back later to deal with what happened within that model and within that alleged limited success, to the incomes of those people. As Jesse Jackson said, half of the jobs created were poorly paid — hamburger turners and so on in MacDonalds and places like that. There is no evidence of real substantial job creation. It needs to be said that the United States, as a result of its determination to reduce certain levels of taxation and, at the same time, to finance a spiralling defence budget, has run up an enormous budget deficit which is concealed by the deliberate theft of money out of the social security fund to fund the current day-to-day expenditure of the United States Government. The budget deficit would be enormously bigger if they were not sneaking funds out of the pension funds of the old, the sick and the elderly to finance day-to-day Government expenditure. On top of that they have a trade deficit which is staying stubbornly large and with that there is the savings and loans fund which has to be rescued and which costs the State 130 billion dollars, according to the Director of the Federal Reserve. That is one country which, we are told, is a model for enterprise. The truth is there has been no significant enterprise. They have a trade deficit, a budget deficit, massive poverty, poor housing and the worst health service in the civilised world.

There was a time when the United Kingdom model was fashionable. I do not think I need tell an Irish Minister for Finance that the United Kingdom experiment of the last ten years has been something of a disaster. They have a trade deficit and if they did not have the most savage retrenchment of a modern welfare State anywhere in the western world they would have a budget deficit too. They have also managed, as Neil Kinnock pointed out last week, at the same time as they were doing all this to increase the tax burden on the average family all through the Thatcher years.

We are not talking about a taxation which is based on the problems of ordinary people, we are talking about certain people's taxes being unacceptable to them. Other models developed. When we got beyond the United States, Denmark became fashionable. I have two articles, one written in August of one year and the other written in September. One was written by a journalist for The Sunday Tribune and the other written by a journalist for The Irish Times. The journalist in The Sunday Tribune said that the reason Denmark got its public finances under control was because of massive and substantial cuts in public expenditure. The journalist writing a month later in The Irish Times said the reason Denmark got its budget deficit under control was because it increased taxes and, at the same time, there was a consumer boom which reduced unemployment dramatically and, therefore, reduced social welfare. One journalist told us the cutbacks caused the benefits and the other journalist told us the opposite, that the cutbacks were caused by the boom which reduced public expenditure. It is true that if we could reduce unemployment from 250,000 to 50,000 the Government would no longer have a budget deficit.

It is interesting to work out how it was that the Danes managed to have increasing taxation and, at the same time, a booming economy in which there was a consumer boom. I appreciate there were problems later but the Danes have a good record over the past 40 years of managing to deal with economic problems and holding a good and far more liberal and generous welfare State than we have. I would not use Denmark as an example of this alleged relationship between enterprise and taxation.

The modern fashionable model over the past six months is Germany. An eminent academic from the Limerick region spoke about his graduates preferring to emigrate to work in Munich than to work in Ireland. He maintains it is because of the the levels of tax and PRSI they are being forced to pay in this what he called, "pink country with its pink Governments". I have accused the Minister of a lot of things but I would never accuse him of being pink, either physically, metaphorically or any other way. He develops an elegant tan but I would never accuse him of being pink. This particular individual has been joined by the host of a wellknown modern radio programme who ran into a love affair with the United States for a while and told us about low taxes there and another television host, who developed a love affair with Australia, and told us about tax there. The thesis always is, (a) the taxes are lower in these countries and (b) that this produces enterprise.

The one country that is an unquestioned success economically in the western world is West Germany. It is a successful, booming economy. Only a booming economy would consider taking on a bankrupt state beside it, which is about one-third of its population; a bankrupt state which called itself a democratic state.

Comment on this

A socialist state.

Comment on this

I never accused it of being democratic and, therefore, the Senator should not accuse it of being socialist. I define my socialism quite satisfactorily to myself and Senator Raftery need not bother interrupting me. West Germany is so prosperous that it can do that.

Let us look at the thesis that somehow the West Germans are enterprising because of the levels of taxation in West Germany. I would like to quote post-budget figures courtesy of an article in The Irish Times on 1 February written by an individual who works for Ernst Young. He quotes Ernst Young's offices in Dublin, Melbourne, Munich and Paris as the source of his information and his article was all about the United Kingdom but I do not think he looked entirely at his own figures. He said that a single person in Ireland on £10,000 a year would take home £7,100 and a single person in Germany on £10,000 a year would take home £6,700. That is £400 a year less in enterprising, vigorous, powerful, economically successful West Germany. According to these figures a single person in Ireland on £15,000 will take home £9,199. The reason I pick £15,000 is that it is the average salary an engineering graduate of the kind we produce in the Regional Technical Colleges would expect and, similarly, graduates from the Institute in Limerick, are so worried about emigration would expect. In West Germany a single person will take home £9,520. Are those people emigrating for £8 a week to live in Munich? Who is kidding whom in the discussion about income tax being a disincentive?

When one goes through the figures and stop's at the salary of £75,000 which is larger even than the Minister's salary, or at least his income from politics, there is a difference in net salary of £3,000 a year. Is somebody telling me that top-class Irish enterpreneurs are emigrating so that they can pay £3,000 less income tax on a salary of £75,000 a year? If a person is worth £75,000 to any Irish company — and some people perhaps are — they will happily pay him an extra £10,000 to make up the difference in his take-home pay between what he gets here and in Germany. There is not a scrap of evidence to support this fashionable thesis that if tax is reduced, enterprise will increase, or that there is some correlation between levels of public expenditure and enterprise or between levels of personal income tax and enterprise.

In that table, and I admit I quoted the two examples that suited me, there are other variations. For people on low incomes, for example, £15,000 downwards, there is no significant difference between the overall level of take-home pay here and in most other countries, with the exception of the United Kingdom where there is a lower tax band. Most other countries reduce income tax and push up social insurance contributions. This has happened in the United States and allows for this wondrous reduction in personal income tax which is being paid for by pushing up the average worker's social contributions dramatically.

There is no low tax bonanza because welfare states have to be paid for. Most countries are profoundly reluctant to sacrifice the welfare state they have, or want or aspire to in return for reductions in taxes. This has been done, and done badly, in the United States and it has not done ordinary people any good. The average family in the United States is paying proportionately more of their income tax than they were 13 years ago, after eight years of Ronald Reagan's tax cuts. This is what bothers me about the whole thesis. The thesis about reducing income tax is not based on the concerns of the 96 per cent of taxpayers whose income is less than £25,000 a year. I was astonished to discover that I am in the top two per cent of income earners. I know I am not but I know that the 96 per cent who declare their income to the Revenue Commissioners are earning less than £25,000 a year.

Comment on this

Four thousand four hundred earned over £50,000.

Comment on this

I do not earn over £50,000. The Minister is in an even more elite group than I am. For the 96 per cent of Irish PAYE workers who are earning less than £25,000 a year there is no enormous difference, with the exception of our nearest neighbour and we know the way that country has gone regarding the levels of income tax. Let it be said again and again that the most successful economy in Europe has not been based on low taxes. It has been based on the ability to organise the workforce efficiently, to organise research efficiently, to develop proper modern industries based on a huge reinvestment of profits in research, based on a banking system that recognises that a long-term loan is ten or 15 years, not four or five like the Irish banking system, and that does not demand property based security for loans for new ideas, which is prepared to assess the quality of an idea, not the quality of security, when it decides to lend money. These are the sort of issues we need to encourage enterprise. I reject completely the idea that if we halved our income tax we would suddenly produce a whole nation of enterpreneurs. I do not believe a word of that. The evidence is there. The most successful economy in Europe taxes people——

Comment on this

What about the eastern European economies?

Comment on this

The most successful economy in Western Europe is the West German economy. They pay as much in income tax as we do, or the differences are insignificant when one adds social security contributions. That is the myth. In this country people have a justified perception that the tax system is unfair and that there are people getting away with murder. The groups that I would identify are particularly the farming population who pay buttons relative to their total net, after costs, income. If the average farmers, earning the same income as I do, had to pay the sort of tax that I have to pay they would squeal so loud that they would put any Government out of office, because they are ruthless, unpatriotic and self-centred in the sense of their own self-interest. The farming community are the most unpatriotic, unnational, unwelfare-orientated group in our country. They think of nobody else but themselves. They do not think of the nation. They do not think of the welfare of the State. They do not even think of the fact that their taxes should be paying for their children's health, education, housing, etc. The farming community are totally and utterly selfish. They would shoot down any Government that would attempt to have them pay the same amount of tax as the rest of us.

That is the first big inequity. The second big inequity is the increasing——

Comment on this

That is a totally unscrupulous attack on the farming population.

Comment on this

——public perception of the incompetence of successive Governments in their capacity to even assess how much tax certain groups should be paying. The first was the DTRT tax, which was estimated to bring in about £50 million and in one particular year it brought in £300 million, which was a magnificent fourfold increase. It is going up fast again now because of interest rates going up. One of the few benefits of interest rates increases is that the Government's revenue increase quite dramatically. Fianna Fáil were going to abolish that tax until they discovered it was too substantial and too lucrative. It did not drive capital out of the country. It did not stifle enterprise. It did not do any of those things. It caught a lot of people who were fiddling their income tax and had their money stashed away with the connivance of various banks and other institutions, as emphasised and as underlined by the advertisement that an account is totally confidential. Confidential from whom? Who is the only person who would be interested in it? Confidential from the Revenue Commissioners. There is something very, very malodorous about allegedly reputable financial institutions offering confidentiality to crooks who want to fiddle their income tax. It is rotten. It stinks. It has nothing to do with enterprise in this country.

The Minister made an extraordinary decision to reintroduce child allowances for the poor hard pressed payers of residential property tax, earning £26,000 a year at least and owning houses worth at least £85,000. He introduced tax allowances for them when the average male industrial worker on £12,000 a year cannot have them. For whose benefit is this country being run? I know for whom it is being run. It is being run for the rich, the powerful, the vocal and the articulate, because that is the centre of the tax campaign. It has nothing to do with enterprise, nothing to do with initiative and all to do with greedy people in this country earning large incomes — the sort of income that I earn — who resent paying a reasonable level of tax and who resent paying a West German level of tax. The genius who wrote this article said that the reasons West German taxes are so high was because West German social welfare benefits were so high. I have lost patience with the income tax lobby in this country. It has nothing to do with the average citizen and an awful lot to do with the rich.

I would say that if the Minister wants to release enterprise in this country then he should grasp the Stalinist bureaucracy for which he is responsible within the Department of Finance and let us have genuine decentralised power and decision-making. There is a belief in his Department about the power of central government that no eastern European Stalinist would stand over, not to mention people who claim to believe in individual enterprise and initiative.

There is taxation that is never talked about because perhaps it does not come under Revenue, but it is taxation and that is what we do to people on very low incomes and on non-contributory social welfare. For instance, if I win the Lotto — which I will not do because I never buy a ticket — it is tax free. If I invest it the interest will be taxed at whatever my rate of income tax at the top rate is. If I am a non-contributory old age pensioner and I win the Lotto they will take all my income off me, which is 100 per cent tax, and they might well take my medical card off me as well, which means that the marginal tax rate to an old age pensioner who wins the Lotto is about 110 per cent. That is the highest marginal level of taxation which is paid by very poor people who actually make some money. It is the same with people on non-contributory pensions who work. Once they go above the minuscule threshold they are actually taxed at the rate of 100 per cent. For each pound extra they earn their income is reduced by an equivalent amount. That is the most penal and savage level of taxation in this country.

I bet this is the first time it has ever been mentioned in either House of the Oireachtas. We do not think of those sort of penalties. We do not think of the people at the bottom of the heap. I know the Minister is not responsible for welfare, but he has a hand in how it is funded. I would suggest that if ever there is a disincentive to people to do anything, it is the fact that they are taxed at rates in excess of 100 per cent when they actually earn a little bit of money.

Finally, on those particular anomalies the Minister did something that was generous, humane and spontaneous about people who benefit from substantial damages and who would be paying enormous amounts of income tax on those damages; I am glad he did this. It is typical of his good sense to deal with this quickly and immediately. Let me remind him that for somebody on social welfare in a similar position, his social welfare stops immediately if he gets damages from something like that. If one is on a means tested level of welfare and gets damages, income from welfare will stop. This happened to an elderly relative of mine who had a non-contributory old age pension. She got a small sum in damages — about £30,000 — and her non-contributory old age pension ended, so she got no compensation for her accident. She simply started paying for herself again out of the damages she had got. She got no compensation. That happens to anybody on a non-contributory welfare allowance, whether it be unemployment assistance or old age pension. If such people get damages from an accident the Department of Social Welfare will assess their income on the basis of the attributed income from that investment and they are taxed at 100 per cent. On the other hand if I got damages I would be taxed at 50 per cent at the very most on the interest paid. I do not think that is right. There is an area of unjust discrimination in terms of take-back by the State, which effectively is taxation, and which is the most savage in the whole of the taxation system.

Comment on this

On behalf of the Progressive Democrats, may I welcome the Minister to the House here today. At the very outset, may I say that I find words like, "ruthless" and "unpatriotic" in relation to the farming community offensive and totally out of order. The Senator belongs to a privileged society. It was pointed out to us last week that the 60 people who are here have responsibilities to the State and that very many people would like to be here.

Comment on this

I earn my money here.

Comment on this

I can tell the Senator that there are very, very many farmers and non-farmers in this country who would be only too happy to earn the income which he earns for being here, which in itself is a modest enough income. Unfortunately, I do not have the figures in front of me but I think it is correct to say that the average income for a farmer in the west in regard to cattle production is of the order of £2,300 a year. It is patently obvious that there are huge numbers——

Comment on this

You have had your say and I will have mine.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I was doing.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator, without interruption.

Comment on this

There are people in this country who do not have a taxable income. I congratulate the Minister on excluding more of those who were previously in the tax net. It is quite obvious that they do not have a taxable income. It is quite obvious that there is immense poverty — silent, dignified poverty — in rural Ireland. I regard the remarks which the Senator has made as being totally offensive. I do not for one moment support any people in any sector, whether they be in farming or otherwise, in using devices which allow them to avoid and evade their proper tax bill. I realise fully that the Minister and the Revenue Commissioners are fully committed to ensuring that every citizen pays the tax for which he or she is liable.

I also find the matter of quoting Germany as rather curious. Certainly we may point to the tax rates in Germany, but we should also point to the income levels in Germany and what the take home pay is.

Comment on this

Unquestionably, there are people in the average income levels in Germany who are immeasurably better off than people in the average industrial income levels here. What really concerns us and what this budget is all about is to ensure that the take home pay of people is improved. In that regard I am quite pleased that some of the things which the Progressive Democrats have been speaking about for several years have been taken on board by the Minister and his colleagues in the agreed Programme for Government. They are to be implemented over the lifetime of the Government — over the entire and, I hope, full lifetime of this Government.

I would like to join with Members of this House and of the other House in congratulating the Minister on the way he responded to the matter of permanently and totally disabled people in granting the concession in this Bill. The Minister is to be congratulated on the speed with which he responded to that need. There is a lesson there for all of us. If this Oireachtas could respond more quickly to some of the needs of the people in the country and, indeed to some of the things that press for discussion in this House and do not always get on to the Order Paper, then the House would be very much more effective than it is.

One other matter that needs to be raised is in relation to the contribution from Senator Doyle, who spoke about the virtues of the balanced budget. It was rather amusing to hear the commitment to that type of a budget coming from that side of the House. History will teach us that there has not been a dramatic commitment to the balanced budget from that side of the House.

Comment on this

They are in the Guinness Book of Records, going in the opposite direction.

Comment on this

I must say I do not see any objection, in principle, to budgeting for a modest deficit, provided that it leads to growth and employment and provided the country can afford it. I do not see any particular objection to a budgetary deficit although, of course, it would be preferable to have a balanced budget. The progress which we have made in this budget and which we hope will continue to be made is one, of course, in which my party has a very close interest. For the first time in the history of the State, it is fair to say that we have charted a four-year programme for tax reform. For the first time there is a commitment to establishing a two rate income tax system. For the first time we are on course for the establishment of a 25 per cent standard rate of income tax. I am glad that modest progress has been made in bringing down the rates from 32 per cent to 30 per cent and the higher rate from 56 per cent to 53 per cent.

When we first argued this case in relation to income tax it is fair to say that very few people agreed with us. Now it appears that not only is it part of the Government programme but people on the other side of the House seem to agree with it as well. Their conversion in this respect has been quite dramatic. I also agree with what the Minister said in relation to the fact that the economy is by no means out of the woods yet, and that prudence is required in relation to the way we manage our economy if we are not to lose the very significant advantages which have accrued to us over the short lifetime of this Government.

It is gratifying to note that our GNP is rising by 3.5 per cent per annum, that economic growth should increase by 4 per cent, and that 30,000 extra jobs are being created. It is unquestionably a fact that reductions in the levels of income tax are central to the generation of growth within the economy. We need to be careful, not complacent. The achievement of the 25 per cent tax rate can only be judged in relation to the span of income which it covers. I was very glad to hear the Minister agree that tax reform has a very major part to play in encouraging initiative and in promoting more jobs. Really, that is the bottom line. We must encourage our people to go out, to be enterprising, and to work.

Some of the things that were being done under the business expansion scheme should be referred to. That scheme was devised to encourage people to take risk. In fact in some cases they were using devices under that scheme to avoid taking risks. I do not see how people can be guaranteed an income from money which they invest in the business expansion scheme.

It is not necessary to remind the House that the 30 per cent tax rate applies only to the first £6,500 of taxable income for a single person, and that with a single person's average tax allowance it follows that many workers earning about £9,500 are paying 48 per cent income tax and seven and three-quarter per cent PRSI on their marginal earnings. Putting that in a different way, somebody well below the average industrial wage can expect to pay in tax and PRSI more than half of any extra earnings which they get from overtime pay. A single person on the average industrial wage pays nearly twothirds, or 60 per cent, of any extra pound earned by him or her.

It is asking a lot to expect people to go out and undertake extra work if they are going to take back only £1 out of every £3. It is obviously fundamental to the creation of jobs. It is fundamental to the expansion of the economy that people be rewarded for effort. People who are prepared to put their money on the line and provide their labour should enjoy a reasonable degree of comfort. The State has a responsibility to them in that respect. We need to contrast our position in this country with that of the average Irish worker in London or, indeed, in Derry which is nearer to us, who has a 25 per cent tax rate the whole way up to £19,000. Even with their social security payments taken into account, they would never be docked more than one-third of their marginal earnings. I am glad that Senator Upton has arrived in the House. Through the Chair — and I am sure he is well aware of this already — Senator Upton knows that the Labour Party in Britain are proposing to reduce that 25 per cent rate to 20 per cent.

Comment on this

Are the Progressive Democrats on their way to the left?

Comment on this

On taxation matters, we are all in favour of reform, I am glad to tell the Senator. I apologise to the Chair. The problem is that many people in this country regard work and effort as some sort of luxury when, in fact, we all know — and I know the Minister will agree — that it is a dire necessity. My reason for concentrating on the rates of tax is just to show how far the process of tax reform must go before the fiscal disadvantage of employment in Ireland is countered. The 25 per cent tax rate linked with the rate of income to which they apply is a critical factor in all that. I do not think we can ignore PRSI from our considerations. Certainly in my own view PRSI is just another form of income tax for very many of our citizens.

I know there has been talk of fixing the upper rate of income tax at 48 per cent. That is certainly a rate I would not agree with and many of my colleagues in the Progressive Democrats would not agree with it either. The reason is that, combined with PRSI and income tax it suggests that the ordinary single worker would be paying more than half his marginal earnings in tax and PRSI. There is no question whatsoever that those tax rates smother ambition, kill effort and create despair. They do nothing for business, except perhaps for the business which we all regret and which has been too frequent in recent years, and that is the business at the passenger terminals at our airports.

I am asking the Minister to take his courage in both hands and to continue on the road of even more imaginative tax reforms. There can be no denying that Irish people at home could achieve just as much as Irish people seem to achieve overseas if they were given the incentive. It is a very curious factor that our citizens seem to be able to succeed when they go to America and other countries. I keep wondering why it is we cannot do at home what we seem to do so very well when we go abroad. A lot of it is to do with the fact that we do have the capacity to work hard but we must be given the incentive to work hard. If we had that incentive here at home the country would be transformed. I realise there are risks involved in going a long way quickly in terms of tax reform, but I believe that the rewards for the country would be immense.

There are precedents in other countries; for instance, in New Zealand in relation to those matters. I fully understand that there can be inflationary pressures and so on, but with prudent management and provided we do not print too much money, those inflationary pressures can be resisted. For both reasons, we regard the 25 per cent standard rate of tax and a single 48 per cent upper band on the present system of tax bands as unacceptable as a final goal. I am saying that now, I do not think it would imply penal taxation on below average earnings. There is a colossal leap in taxation of 25 per cent to 48 per cent, a 23 per cent jump. That is a major disincentive to effort.

I do not think we can cross the bridge in just two or three steps. We are talking about radical tax reform and I am appealing to the Minister to go down that road of radical tax reform. He has taken one or two steps and I encourage him to take big bounds. A faint-hearted approach to taxation or to public spending can be easily blown off-course. Ireland needs someone of courage to act on this matter. As I have said, the economic achievements of New Zealand should be a lesson for a Minister for Finance in this country.

I referred to the inflationary fears. I believe they can be allayed. The document which the Progressive Democrats published in 1988 shows that the upper rates of tax and PRSI can be brought down to around 40 per cent without inflationary pressures if it is done in the context of major reforms in allowances and extension of the PRSI. I believe the step of setting our a four-year programme of tax reform in the agreed Programme for Government has already created a sense of confidence in our future. There is a more optimistic mood in the country. The identification of clearer targets for the upper tax rate, the reform of PRSI and the structure of allowances and bands should strengthen that confidence and accelerate economic growth. The fiscal distortions between the manufacturing and the service sectors is damaging. It is unjustified by any criteria whether it be employment or the interests of the Exchequer.

The combination of all the payroll taxes and the differences between payroll taxes to employees and take-home pay is, of course, what we all call the tax wedge. I would submit that is where the basic problem lies. The Minister, said that unemployment was the root cause of poverty and I fully agree with that sentiment. I believe, fundamentally, that one of the most effective ways of tackling it is to make it rewarding for people to take risk and to work.

I realise in relation to reaching agreement on the programme for National Recovery that one of the things that must be stressed is the need for restraint in wage demands to copperfasten the progress which we have begun to make. We can contribute to increasing take home-pay on the taxation side. I hope that in reciprocation for that the people who are negotiating show restraint in relation to the size of the demands which are made. As the Minister has said, we are on a very delicate course, and it would be very easy to be thrown off it. We must not throw away the advantages which we have begun to gain. The process of lifting the tax burden off income up to the average industrial wage, the reform of allowances and the reform of PRSI must be made part of our new Programme for National Recovery.

Before the arguments and the negotiations about indexation go too far the tax wedge and PRSI should be taken into account. Everyone's eyes should be fixed on the issue of real take-home pay. The Bill is a compicated document and it requires very detailed study. The explanatory memorandum which the Minister has given us goes a long way to making it a clearer document.

There are a few matters in the Bill which I would like the Minister to look at. One of them is in relation to capital acquisitions tax. I congratulate the Minister on the indexation moves he has taken. It has now got to the point where a quite modest family farm with a dairy herd finds itself very quickly coming into the capital acquisitions tax net, even taking agricultural relief into account. We are now looking at a farm of maybe 80 or 90 acres coming into the capital taxation net. I do not think it was ever the intention of the capital taxation legislation that that type of property should be liable for large capital taxes. That is something that needs to be looked at. Above all else, we must never get to the point of having to split up holdings which are of quite modest acreage — certainly by international standards. We must never get to the point where it would be in the interest of their financial management that farms would split up. We did that years ago in different times, and I hope we never have to return to it again.

The other matter which, perhaps, the Minister might look at is in relation to accelerated capital allowances. I agree with most of what he has done but there is one area which is causing concern within farming which he might consider, that is, in relation to investment to control pollution. There has been a lot of talk — and rightly so — about the need for farming and, indeed, industry in general to clean up its act. Many farmers were encouraged to invest money at different times and to put money into buildings for livestock and developing their farms. Now we are being faced with measures to make sure that the investment which they were encouraged to make by the State and advisers went out and showed them what should be done — are being followed by other measures to make sure that these facilities are "environmentally friendly".

I realise the difficulty of making distinctions between enterprises in relation to accelerated capital allowances, but in terms of environmental aspects alone and in terms of making sure that the country is as we desire it to be, I think this is a matter which should be looked at and that the accelerated capital allowances should be made available for investment in pollution control. I understand that 20,000 people have applied for assistance under the schemes for pollution control. Even if that accelerated capital allowance period were extended for a year, I think at that stage a lot of the investment would have taken place and the Minister would have done a good day's work.

In relation to the manufacturing activities which are eligible for the 10 per cent rate, I think I am correct in saying that fish processing has been included as a manufacturing activity. Other areas could be considered, one of which is grain drying, where there are very modest margins; and I would submit that it does make a material difference to the product that it is dried. Certainly, if grain is left undried we all know what happens to it, it will just rot. I think milk pasteurisation is another area which might be looked at.

The other matter relates to VAT. The Minister again is to be congratulated in going down the road towards 1992 and reducing the rate from 25 per cent to 23 per cent. My hope is that we do not find ourselves at the very last lap having to make very big reductions in VAT to harmonise with the rest of the Community because it would place an intolerable burden on many of our businesses. I know the Minister in this budget has taken it into account and I hope he continues along that road so that we do not find ourselves at the last hurdle having to make very dramatic adjustments.

The final matter relates to inflation which I mentioned earlier. I think we can contain inflation. People keep citing what happened in England and say that if we were to do something similar on the taxation side it would lead to the present levels of inflation in England and which, thankfully, we have been spared. I do think that it is not about the taxation reform measures in England; it is to do with printing too much money. It is as simple as that. We must make every effort to ensure that inflation is kept under control, that interest rates are kept at reasonable levels, levels which people can afford, levels which encourage investment and levels which do not make people put their money on deposit in banks and leave it there, which is of no use to us and it is no use to generating any growth in the economy. I am sure that the Minister will take these factors into account. I congratulate him on the broad thrust of his budget and we look forward to continued progress over — I will not say the temporary arrangement — but the long lifetime of this Government.

Comment on this

At the outset it is nice to see that the marriage is working well, that the happy couple still love one another and that they are prepared to publicly declare their love for one another. I am, as they say, reassured——

Comment on this

Jealousy gets you nowhere.

Comment on this

We have not been making overtures, as far as I know. At the outset we have to be very critical of this Bill. There are two main fundamental criticisms. First of all, it does not look as if it is going to solve the awful problem of unemployment; and, secondly, it does not look as if it is going to address in any sort of fundamental way the great problem of poverty. These are the two great issues which are facing this country at present and, as far as I can see, this Bill simply makes minor adjustments to those two fundamental considerations.

More specifically, there is a number of items we would be very critical of. There is the question of how the self-employed are going to be assessed in relation to the year 1989-90, which is not going to be used as an assessment period and creates a loophole which, of course, can be exploited by these people to give themselves a very rewarding once off little present. There is also the question of the BES scheme, and that is widely acknowledged now by pretty well all sides to have been a failure. I am glad to see that there has been some tightening up done in relation to the scheme. However, it is not going to be adequate. What is really needed now is to scrap that scheme and to replace it with new schemes which will be devised to maximise investment in truly productive enterprises.

We are, it appears, facing into a period of sustained economic growth. One ERSI report talks in terms of growth on average of 5 per cent a year over the next five years. That, of course, is very encouraging; but if does raise the question as to how this growth will be distributed — in other words, who is going to benefit from it? That is a fairly fundamental question and, it is in relation to the approaches and the answers to that, that we would have to be very critical of this Government.

We feel strongly that that growth is not going to be shared in anything like a fair or equitable manner for the vast bulk of the people. We feel that the rich, will get richer while the poor will continue to be as it were cast aside and written out of the equation. In other words, we feel that the essential principles of social justice will not come into play in determining how that growth is going to be distributed.

What we expect to see, and what we fear, is that emigration will continue to be the great problem that it now is. There is no doubt but that whole parts of this country are being absolutely devastated by emigration; and it seems, I am sorry to say, that that is to be allowed to continue in this Bill by virtue of the lack of action contained in it.

We are also seeing at this stage a polarisation of our society. We are seeing a two-tiered health service, where those who can afford to get treated and those who cannot do not. I speak in terms of a two-tiered health service on the day I have heard that this child, one of the quintuplets, could not be treated short of a critical four day lag period because of inadequacies in the facilities which are available to treat such children. I understand it is going to be all over this evening's papers for anyone who has an interest in the details. There is, of course, the virtual collapse of public housing. There is the elimination of free education and there is the dismantling of many social welfare schemes. Equality and justice are now issues which no longer rate as essential items on the agenda. They have been pushed aside in preference to matters like profit, efficiency and so on. These are the new buzz words; justice and equality are from yesterday.

In relation to the whole question of jobs, here again we are facing another series of disasterous failures. The jobs simply are not coming. The solution that is being provided for that lack of jobs is essentially one of emigration, where those elements of society who are not privileged are simply pushed aside and ultimately forced out of the country. We, as it were, export our problems; they are written out of the equation. That is a terrible commentary on any notions of social justice and equal treatment for all people in this country.

The main areas of growth, as I see them, have been in multinational companies' profits and in profits in the financial services sector. Many Irish companies have not been doing well and have not been a part of this growth process. We do not seem to have adequately addresed the question of how Irish industry can produce adequate levels of value added to Irish products. It is that inability to add to Irish products in this country that I think is one of the fundamental problems in relation to our inability to create the types of jobs that will be sustained over a long period; and we still do not seem to be making any real effort to face up to that. We are not, to any meaningful extent, talking in terms of creating full employment; and that has to be a matter of great regret. We are talking in terms of this continued process — admittedly, with some reservations in later times — of multinational investment from abroad.

Multinational investment is all right but only in a context of a strong domestic industrial base. We are not working to develop that strong domestic industrial base to anything like the degree to which we should be. To do that, inevitably you are talking in terms of very major public investment in generating large corporations, Irish owned, and whose first loyalty is to this nation. We are not setting about doing that in anything like the manner that is necessary. The whole drift of industrial development is towards corporations becoming larger and larger. We are talking here in terms of very substantial investment; and I do not think we are facing up to those issues. We are still going to be dependent on these multinational companies. They will come, they will do their thing and, as soon as it suits them or as soon as the weather changes, they will toddle off again back to where they came from. A lot of the time those people have not any fundamental commitment to the Irish economy. They are multinationals, they are globe-trotters, they are all over the place. They will clear out again as soon as it suits them. Irish industry is a different story. We have to face up to this business of building large Irish companies so that we will be able to look after ourselves in the very unpleasant market realities of the present day world.

We should be doing a lot more in terms of creating a financial stake for workers in their own employment. There should be various employment funds and so on generated. There must be great scope here for increasing workers' commitments to companies by providing those types of opportunities for them.

I want also to address the business of privatisation. "Privatisation" is a new type of buzz word, admittedly it came from across the Irish Channel where most of the ideas in this country originate. Privatisation seems to me to be some type of new contagious disease, which has almost become an epidemic in recent years, and its symptoms are many and alarming. Certainly, one of the symptoms of this disorder is the commissioning and the production of consultants' reports. We should have one last great consultants' report that would deal with the value and the genesis of consultants' reports. We have had the consultants' report about Irish Life. I believe there is one on the Irish Sugar Company, on the Great Southern Hotels, on Irish Steel and God knows how many more that we do not know about. Certainly, the disease is spreading. It seemes to be mainly originating from some public houses not that far away from here; certainly it seems to be spread in these places. At the end of it all, what are these reports contributing to the genesis of Irish jobs, to the elimination of poverty, to addressing the great issues of the time in Ireland? I would like to be informed how these reports have any real value in relation to solving and providing answers to those great questions. It seems as if we are on a treadmill and we will get more and more of them. Certainly, I do not see that they have anything much to contribute to the solution of our problems.

On top of that we seem to have some public company managers who, to be fair about it, have their own problems in relation to the way the Government Departments have sought to influence them, to restrain them and bind them over the years. They have a legitimate complaint when they have to compete with other companies who do not have anything like those type of restrictions on them. But, at the same time, some of these people seem to be excessively enthusiastic for this whole business of privatisation. Ultimately, these people work for the Government. Certainly, if people in private industry took up the same sort of public positions on issues that relate to how their companies are run, then they would certainly be hearing from their managers as to whether it was expedient and wise for them to go on in the way they do. In many ways, if these people want to get into that kind of value, that kind of meeting, the place for them is not business; it is politics. If they do want it, then so be it. In my view, that is the way the game should be played rather then to have briefings for journalists, leaking information, and all the rest of that kind of carry-on.

Privatisation has become a sort of new panacea, a new suggestion, that will solve everything. I reject that. Public companies were established for a very difinite purpose: they were established for the most part because the private sector would not be prepared to do that job. Taking one thing with another, public companies have served this country very well. They are a fundamental part of the whole structure and they have served the country exceedingly well over the years. I think they have a very valuable role in continuing to serve the country and, indeed, in providing jobs and answers to many of the problems with which the country is now faced. I would welcome a White Paper on the role of State companies. Indeed, I would welcome a White Paper on how the role of State companies should be enhanced so that they could contribute in a more effective way to the genesis of jobs, which is a fundamental matter facing this country.

Moving to the issue of poverty, there is the Conference of Major Religious Superiors — I like coming back to this statistic. There is still talk of the million people who are poor; we have the high unemployment, the low pay, and increasing number of people on part-time and casual work who are simply exploited in an appalling manner in some cases; we have changes and cutbacks in essential services like health care, education and so on. In particular, there is the awful problem of the exploitation of part-time workers. These in many ways are the weakest, most disparate, most disorganised of the labour force who are exploited by very many unscrupulous employers who simply rip them off in a disgraceful manner.

We also get from the forces of the Right talk about social welfare payments being too high. The reality, of course, is that it is not that the social welfare payments are too high — in many ways they are too low — but, when people talk about disincentives and all that sort of thing, the basic problem is that the competing pay is not adequately high. It is a problem of low pay not excessive levels of social welfare. Anyone who doubts this notion that pay is too low or, for that matter, anyone who agrees with the suggestion that social welfare payments are too high, has only to look at reality; that for a child you get something of the order of £10 a week, when it would cost twice as much to clothe and feed a child. There are 350,000 children in this country who have to exist on social welfare. Anyone who has any knowledge or experience of these people could not be of the view that the levels at which they are being funded are anything other than too low.

Most of the benefits in this Finance Bill are going to the wealthy; the poor have done badly out of it. They have, to a large extent in recent times, been written out of the whole equation; and this Finance Bill, as I see it, is simply another part of that trend.

There is also the question of housing. We are still talking of housing in the aftermath of the death of the late and much respected Willie Birmingham. This year we can expect perhaps 500 or 600 houses to be built in this country, when, we are talking in terms of a need of perhaps 25,000 houses. Those are the kind of numbers which are on the list. The amount of Government funding available for public authority housing is of the order of £6 million and that would build 250 to 300 local authority houses in all the country. That is totally inadequate. The idea that local authorities can build as many houses as they like provided they get the money — to a large extent, is not a particularly high standard to set. Anyone who is familiar with the problem knows that this is inadequate.

There is a housing crisis, we are back to the way we were 15 or 20 years ago in the sixties and seventies when we had an earlier housing crisis. This whole problem of housing and all these inadequacies have led on to some areas becoming almost ghettoes. There are areas where you are talking in terms of perhaps 75 per cent of the people there being unemployed with all the attendant social problems. That is a very serious matter and something we can disregard only at our peril.

There is the question of the financial services sector and how they conduct their business. There is the question of adequate levels of information on financial charges and so on. Again, that is an area that would have been very interesting and useful for the Minister to have taken some initiatives on so that the average person who deals with these institutions would know exactly what they are paying by way of charges on those services, whereas for the most part now the whole thing is confused and they do not know what they are contributing or what they are being charged.

With regard to the BSE scare and so on, if anybody doubts the necessity for branded value-added products in international markets, it has been illustrated with the greatest of clarity over the past few days when Irish beef on the British market is sold there in the same way as Sainsbury's beef, or some of these chain stores so that there is no way for the consumer to distinguish between Irish beef and British beef, or God knows what other type of beef happens to finish up in the British market. A great opportunity is being missed now when Irish beef would have a very definite advantage over these other products. Yet we have not the capacity to brand Irish beef and identify it for the consumer in Britain so that we would be able in this country, at this time of opportunity — indeed, also a time of crisis for the whole beef industry — to exploit that. However, we are simply boxed in and cannot do anything. We are going to have to face the wrath, as it were, that is going to be dished out to British and indeed to beef in general and that has to be a matter of great regret. It arises because of an inability and a failure to put the investment into branding products, into developing new products and so on.

I do not want to suggest for a second that that is simple or easy; or, for that matter, that it is cheap. I know only too well that it is very expensive, time-consuming and that you have to be prepared to accept an enormous number of failures for success in the end. You are talking in terms of 5 to 10 per cent of new products or branded products making it, and that is probably an optimistic figure. However, the only way you can do it is by being big enough. That is what I am talking about when I am saying that the Irish State should be putting in the investment so that they are big enough to be able to soak up the failures which inevitably will arise because of the fact that they are sample size and the whole effort or organisation will be so big that the pluses will cancel out the minuses and that, rather like the insurance companies, you can work with a reasonable degree of confidence on a certain level of success. The great failure over the years has been that we have been, as far as these things are concerned, into the politics of the next five minutes, a quick fix, the attitude of off we go and as soon as we can unload it why would we worry any more about it?

There is a big educational job still to be done in bringing home to Irish people, and particularly to Irish farmers, the necessity for that type of long-term investment. It bothers me when I look around and see the dairy industry which, I am happy to say, is still for the most part co-operative dominated, not coming together to get that critical mass which is absolutely essential for these players to be able to compete and hold their place with the type of players they are playing with on the international markets. To be honest, I suppose I have been part of factions in some of these things in my past — I see the Minister, Deputy Daly, smiling at me, a man who knows much more of the nitty-gritty of how these things arise than I would and has much more experience of it in the past 20 years or so — but unless people sink their differences and get that capacity together, then we will simply be brushed aside and we will be selling into these places and we will not basically be at the races at all.

There are two other aspects of the Bill about which I have had a great concern. First, there is the question of the facilities and resources which were made available to the mentally handicapped. Indeed, I see Senator Honan in the House and I acknowledge her own contribution over the years, particularly in relation to the mentally handicapped. It bears comparison with the best.

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I speak with some deference in the Senator's presence on this matter. However, I think it is appalling that we have not been doing more as a Government. I do not want to get into the statistics, but they are not acceptable in a civilised society. The mentally handicapped have been described as special and so on. I wish that special description related to the special privileges and the special effort that was made for them. Certainly, that has not been the case.

Finally I want to allude to the question of homelessness, particularly the question of homeless children in this city. There are at present, approximately 1,000 children homeless in this country and approximately half of them are located in the Dublin area. It is an appalling commentary on the values and standards in this society that we have not been making money available to deal with that problem.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman (Mr. Farrell)

I have to remind the House that by agreement, each speaker from now on will have 15 minutes.

Comment on this

I hope that was not meant personally in any way; I am sure it was not. Our spokesperson on Finance, Senator O'Keeffe, made a very comprehensive contribution here this morning on the complex Bill before us, so I will deal only with certain parts. It is a most unique Bill and we have an extraordinarily complex piece of legislation. There are 137 sections, nine Schedules and the Bill makes reference to 62 other Bills or past legislation. I am going to take the advice of somebody given to me long ago; I will just speak on certain parts of it because you could well speak yourself out of here — something that I would well nearly be doing in recent times, but I am sure I will survive.

I would like to pay a well deserved tribute to the Minister, Deputy Reynolds. I have found him to be one of the finest Ministers for Finance this nation ever elected. I have also found him absolutely human in the approach to problems and finance and he has time to listen. It is a lesson some of his colleagues could take. When senior Ministers do not give time to constituents and persons elected to listen to their problems and the deep concerns of their families, it could be serious.

I would also like to pay a tribute — this is not usually done, but I am going to do it anyway — to certain staff in the Department of Finance for their advice and help at all times to me with regard to problems in constituencies. My constituency is not like that of the Minister here present, Deputy Daly. My constituency is the nation, Deputy Daly's is Clare. In his presence here I pay tribute to the Minister, Deputy Daly, as Minister of State at the Department of Finance. He has not been given the high profile for the amount of work that he has done in the Department of Finance, but other people will judge him on another day and then the results will be seen. I understand he will be making a major announcement regarding part of his own constituency in the Burren in north Clare. I wish Deputy Brendan Daly and Deputy Albert Reynolds every success for whatever length of time they serve in Finance.

If the Minister, Deputy Reynolds, was asked what he saw as the finest part of the contribution during his Presidency of the Council of Ministers of Finance in Europe, he might well turn and say that it is the best Exchequer return in 40 years for his nation. That I am sure is what the Minister would reply even though one might ask him the question at a European level as he is President of the Finance Ministers of Europe.

The whole process of correcting financial imbalances is not on its own. One result of it has been to restore confidence among the people and in the workplace, and that was badly needed. I know that there is still much to be done but the Minister for Finance and his Minister of State are confident that we will succeed in that regard.

It is excellent that, as the Minister has promised, leaflets will be prepared setting out details of the budgetary provisions as they affect low income tax payers. Such an innovation is not surprising, though — it is typical Reynolds style.

Since becoming Minister for Finance, Deputy Reynolds has got the Government strategy going to create jobs. Exchequer borrowing has been kept well within the targets of his programme. The income tax and VAT changes announced in the 1990 budget will reduce costs and inflation rates, thereby further strengthening our competitiveness. The public capital programme for 1990, I understand, is up by 20 per cent. I hope that all this will result in strong recovery in private investment. We are now well ahead on our targets. It is not just consumer spending that has increased. Much more has happened and much more is to come.

New building output increased by 16 per cent in 1989, and I believe a similar rate or thereabouts could well be on target for 1990. The amount of new building activity and the number of new homes to be seen around us in Clare and elsewhere is extraordinary. It is marvellous to see the amount of employment and job creation that the construction industry has provided for tradesmen and the many others engaged in this industry, either directly or indirectly.

I should like to comment on a reference made recently regarding the Minister and the Central Bank. As this is a Finance Bill, it is better to put the record straight. The reference was that the Minister said that at times he likes to pass over his problems to the Central Bank, that he does not have the responsibility for interest rates. That is not his choice. The Dáil has given the statutory powers to the Central Bank to regulate the monetary policies for this nation and the Minister has not the power, and the House has never given a Minister for Finance, the power to direct the Central Bank to either bring down interest rates or increase them. Let us get the record right when people start talking about what powers Ministers have. That is the power which the Oireachtas gives to Ministers for Finance or does not give, whichever way one likes to put it.

The economy is doing very well. Anybody who says otherwise is not being honest. As one who has served for a long time in politics, I say sincerely that we must not get back to the madness of the seventies and overspend. We will have to remember that never again can people with power or who want to get into power, make promises just to get votes. The economy is going well now and we must all behave responsibly. Reference was made this morning to the fact that there is more closeness within all our parties, much more common sense and less of the political bashing that went on before and which really benefitted none of us. We should watch the control the Minister has put in place in finance and support him on it.

I am glad to refer to sections 25 and 28 because they are directed towards urban renewal. The incentive packet is being extended by two years from 31 May 1991 to 31 May 1993. I welcome this excellent iniative. Clonmel and many other places that I know well have benefited greatly from urban renewal. I have travelled a good deal, though I hope, for certain reasons, that I do not have to do so again soon, and I have looked very closely at Waterford. Urban renewal has transformed Waterford City into a magnificant place. The overall effect of sections 27 and 28 is to curb excessive levels of tax benefits — such benefits were never intended under the package for the designated areas — by reducing the potential of excessive tax gains but enabling market forces to operate more freely in regard to rental levels. I sincerely hope that the urban renewal schemes that have been put in place in the past will be extended to other towns and areas.

Someone, in an address recently said he was worried that urban renewal would give unequal advantage to business coming into a newer area of a town. I am in a position, firsthand, to contradict that. I sit on a council where we have just been sanctioned for urban renewal, I am well aware, because of the conditions laid down for us, that the renewal has to be in the heart of the town, in other words, in the old area of the town. The same applies to Clonmel. The rules are steadfast, they are tough, they are laid down for us. There is no question of new investment coming in and having an advantage over old businesses. As a person sitting at the council table, I would have strong views on this. I say that, too, as one who has been in business for 26 years. I would have to support the businesses. New people coming in and investing in urban renewal do not have an advantage over well-established businesses.

I ask the business people to co-operate absolutely and fully with us and I ask the Departments of Finance and the Environment to do everything possible to make this scheme a success. Risks may have to be taken but I suppose that is a factor of life for us politicians. Limerick city is another example of where urban renewal has been a success. Perhaps Senator Raftery will refer to that area.

I warmly welcome the Minister's major income tax reliefs and also that the standard rate of tax has fallen from 35 per cent to 30 per cent and the top rate of tax has been brought down from 58 per cent to 53 per cent. I appeal to the Minister to take a look at the Nursing Home Bill, which is in the other House at the moment, which might be relevant to the Finance Bill. An elderly person staying in a nursing home costs health boards over £200 a week. There is a maximum subvention of only £40. I appeal to the Minister to increase that suvbvention to £60. The reality is that people with the £60 allowance will be able to acquire a place in a nursing home but people with £40 will be unable to do so.

The tourist industry is a key industry in the development of our economy. It is a labour intensive industry with enormous growth potential. It is estimated that in 1989 tourism supported 74,000 jobs throughout the economy in a wide variety of activities and sectors. While talking about tourism I would like to tie in the Office of Public Works, the Department of the Minister of State, Deputy Daly. When we talk about success stories in one place perhaps times we forget about another Department that has also played a major role in a success. Tourism is the one area where jobs can come on stream. Side by side with that, the Board of Works under Minister Brendan Daly has played a major role and does not always get the credit.

I am grateful to Senator Upton for his kind remark about my role in the area of the mentally handicapped. As a person who has had the privilege of being elected six times on the nomination of the National Association of Mentally Handicapped of Ireland, I am delighted to put on the record that the budget made provision for an extra £2 million to fund day care centres for people who are mentally handicapped.

The way the Minister for Finance reacted and amended the Finance Bill in relation to the Dunne child deserves to be commended and portrays the human side of the way he carries out his work. It was enlightening to hear on "Morning Ireland" the father of the Dunne baby paying tribute to the Minister. We do not get many tributes and certainly the Minister does not get any these days. I do not remember a Finance Bill being amended so rapidly on a request. It was staggering to learn that £300 was going to the Department of Finance and only £30 to the Dunne family.

I welcome this Bill. I look forward to keeping today's confidence in the financial sector. There is a lot more to be done. The Minister never pulls punches or pretends that he can do all things in one year in Finance. I hope he will be in Finance for several years to come. That may not be what he would want me to say. I congratulate the Minister again and warmly welcome the Finance Bill.

My comments were on areas of the Finance Bill that I understood and that had to be said. Other people with greater expertise in finance will make their contributions only on finance. Everything I said was relevant to the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I would, first of all, like to place on record my appreciation of the Minister coming here this morning and spending so much time with us. I am sorry that he has left us but I appreciate that he has many pressing duties. Before I begin to comment on the Finance Bill I would like to comment on Senator Ryan's contribution — I am sorry he is absent — since he dragged my name into it, and not for the first time misquoted what I had to say, and not for the first time disagreed with me on issues. He said there was no evidence that tax is driving people out of the country. I do not think he is living in the country I am living in. He has only to consult his past students and my past students to find that not all of the people who emigrate today are unemployed. Some of the people with the very best jobs in the country are emigrating because of the tax problems thy have to contend with.

It was in relation to the United States, he referred to me, I certainly do not say the US is perfect but I argue that it has a spirit of enterprise and work which is to some extent attributable to its taxation system. Senator Ryan has such a phobia about the US that he reminds me of the late President Khomeini who referred to the US as the great Satan. I put it to him that they must be doing something right in the US since they nearly have to put an iron curtain around that country to keep out millions of people including thousands of our own, whereas the countries he so admires in Eastern Europe had to put up an iron curtain to keep the people in. That is the reality, I wish he would see the facts as they exist.

With regard to our nearest neighbour, Great Britain, which he referred to in scathing fashion, let it be said that Great Britain took and continues to take the people we are unable to employ. That is partly due to the success Mrs. Thatcher has had in turning that economy around. Not everything is right there. I believe they moved too rapidly in changing their taxation system which has contributed to the present inflation problem and balance of payments deficit.

He then referred to West Germany. West Germany has an extremely successful economy but to take just the personal taxation in isolation from all other taxation and compare one country with another is giving a very unbalanced picture. For instance, he made no reference to the low levels of indirect taxation in Germany. One has only to look at the price difference between motor cars in Germany and Ireland to see a huge gap. One can be selective with figures and prove anything. The Senator really went off the deep end when he became hysterical about the farming community and made unwarranted, disgraceful accusations about farmers in general. I repudiate that. I would remind the Senator that 70,000 family farms have to survive on a family farm income of less than £5,000 a year. If the farming community are not contributing a lot of tax it is primarily because the farming community, by an large, are not enjoying good incomes.

Senator Upton spoke about Irish companies becoming big, and so on. Of course, that is true. He was very critical of multinationals that we have imported here. I would remind the Senator that the moment Irish companies get big they become multinationals too. That is a good thing. I would further remind him that without the 80 or so multinational companies we have here we would be a few thousand worse off as far as unemployment is concerned. I wholeheartedly agree with him when he says that workers should have more of a share in the profits. I have been advocating that for years. I can see companies like Kerry Foods moving in that direction. It is the direction in which we must move.

The Senator spoke rather scathingly about privatisation. Sometimes the Left in this country have a blind ideology that prohibits them from seeing realism and pragmatism. He talked of it as a new disease. I would remind him that that new disease has caught on more strongly in the socialist governments of the world than it has in the capitalist governments. The New Zealand privatisation programme would make Margaret Thatcher's look rather modest. The Spanish socialist government within two years of gaining power had privatised 22 publicly owned companies. When the Spanish Minister was asked by a British socialist why they had gone this route, or how did they reconcile it with being a socialist government, he gave the perfect reply when he said, "Sir, we are interested in results, not in ideology". If our socialists became interested in results and forgot their ideology we would all be better off.

The Senator referred to the Major Religious Superiors' figure of one million people in poverty. I dispute that figure and I make no apology for disputing it. I have disputed it with the Major Religious Superiors. I happen to know that the Hierarchy are more in line with the figures I give than the figures given by the Major Religious Superiors.

Senator Upton quite rightly said that Irish beef should be branded or that Irish food should be branded. That is certainly very true. There is something else we need as a nation and as a Community: we need some kind of impartial objective, independent body to give facts in relation to food and drugs. We are now in a situation in the Community where it is one scare after another, most of it without any foundation, scaremongerers in the media and in politics. That is doing irreparable damage to the food industry in Ireland and in the Community as a whole.

We need the kind of body which the United States is lucky to have, the Food and Drugs Administration, which enjoys the confidence of over 70 per cent of consumers in the US. It has certainly earned that confidence but as long as we have regulatory bodies under the control of Ministers in Governments all over the place, we will have this lack of confidence, particularly where Ministers for Agriculture are responsible for food quality. They will be perceived as being more interested in farmers than in consumers. That is a difficulty that we have to get over.

I am sorry the Minister has departed because I have a few things to say to him as well. The last time I shared a platform with the Minister for Finance, the other Coalition were in power. The efforts of that other Coalition were derided. That Coalition were accused of being monetarist, of being Thatcherites, of fiscal rectitude, of bookkeeping government, and so on. It is amazing what a Mercedes and a Department of Finance can do. The Minister's conversion to financial rectitude in a short period of time makes the conversion of St. Paul on the road to Damascus seem like a minor event. Let us be grateful for it, because he is moving in the right direction.

I remember some years ago chairing a lecture in UCC when the late Dr. Roy Geary said that Governments had very little power to do good for an economy but enormous power to do harm. If anyone wants to see the truth of that statement one has just to look at the record of this country over the past 12 or so years and to see that in a few short years in the late seventies we did enormous damage to the economy. It has taken a hell of a lot longer to put right the mistakes we made then.

Let me give an example of the kind of things that happened. In 1977 we had the cheapest electricity, the cheapest post, the cheapest transport, the cheapest communications in the whole Community. Five years later every single one of those was significantly dearer than in any other Community country. That is what we got as a result of financial recklessness. I am glad to hear Senator Honan refer to parties becoming more responsible. I would add that parties need to be responsible in Opposition as well as in power. I hope when Fianna Fáil find themselves in Opposition again that they will behave more responsibly than they did when in Opposition in the eighties.

With regard to taxation, on which the Minister dwelt for some time, I liked a lot of what he had to say. Any taxation system must be not only effective and efficient, but must be seen to be equitable and, of course, it must also provide incentives for savings, investment, risk taking and hard work. We are moving in that direction. I am not sure if our collection method is efficient or even effective but I am certain that it is not seen to be equitable. That is a big problem.

A commission on taxation which were set up produced a marvellous report. It seems that no single party are prepared to take on the job of reforming the taxation system. The taxation system has become so complicated that thousands of consultants and accountants are making a good living out of helping people to avoid or evade the tax system, when these people should be using their time more productively in helping businesses to run their businesses better.

I am suggesting that our taxation system must be simplified; the base must be broadened and it must be seen to be equitable as between all sectors of the community. In that respect, I have to say the PAYE sector see themselves as paying an unfair share of the burden, and perhaps they are. I am a PAYE person too. On the other hand, farmers are seen as not paying their fair share. A lot of that has to do with the reckless leadership of one farm organisation in the late seventies. When a presidential election was coming up in the farmers' association they went out on a limb scaremongering about taxation and attacking the late George Colley about his proposed taxation for farmers. Lack of income and not income tax was the real problem for farmers then as it is now and they did no service to the farmers then or now by that behaviour. In fact, they discouraged many farmers from developing their farms, from increasing their milk output and so on rather than encouraging them to increase output. If they had gone along the right road, gone along the road of increasing farmers' incomes, not concerning themselves with income tax, we would have had a decent national milk quota by 1984, not what we have now, which is a rather inadequate one for our farmers. The two gentlemen involved subsequently took the Fianna Fáil soup and have become very silent in the meantime, even though the farmers' plight is a lot worse now than it was then.

One issue which was not referred to in the Minister's speech, and which is very important, is the poverty trap. Those on low incomes who are being taxed often find that it is not worth while going to work. That issue must be tackled.

In relation to taxation, and to income tax in general, we should have an all-party approach to it because it is such a difficult matter and it is important that we get it right. An all-party approach is highly desirable.

The Minister dealt with corporation tax and I am delighted to see that the 10 per cent manufacturing tax is being extended to the year 2010. How he got by the Commission on that, I am not quite sure. He referred to inheritance tax and said it is now going to be indexed but, in fairness, it should be indexed back to the figure we started with in 1978. Inheritance tax is becoming a major problem for many people and it should have been indexed from the beginning.

With regard to indirect taxes, VAT and excise duties, I fear the Minister has not moved far enough. We have only two more budgets before 1991, when we will have to bring our taxation more into line with that of our neighbours, particularly with the one neighbour with whom we have a common land border. Much has been made about the loss of revenue we will suffer as a result of harmonisation or convergence of taxation. That is exaggerated because it takes no account whatsoever of the enormous amount of goods being smuggled from Northern Ireland to Southern Ireland from which we are getting no tax at all.

Interest rates, of course, are too high and the Minister did not pay much attention to that. They must be reduced because they are a disincentive to investing and borrowing for productive purposes. The Minister quite rightly made adjustments in the BES. It was ridiculous that people could borrow money and get tax relief on it, and invest it and get tax relief on that also. In relation to taking the risk out of the scheme, the whole purpose of the BES was to get money into venture capital.

I disagree with Senator Ryan's comments on residential property tax. Many people, who are not wealthy, have extended their homes because they have large families and wanted to give them a decent standard of living and then found that they could get no tax relief. That was certainly discriminatory.

In general it is a cautious Bill. It is moving in the right direction but there are many other things we would like to see done. I would particularly like the Minister to do something in the near future about interest rates because they are a terrible brake on the economy, particularly in capital intensive industries.

Comment on this

The Finance Bill, which gives detail to the budget, is an opportunity for us to take an overall look at the position and one has, first of all, to say that there has been great success. It is a marvellous success story. In the past three years there has been a transformation from the very deep gloom and pessimism which spread through many sections of the population. There was almost a universal view that things were bad and that there was no real hope of improvement. Students coming out of school or graduates coming out of technical colleges or universities all said there was no hope for them here and that they would probably have to go abroad. Their parents were very worried for them, and rightly so. Blame for this would be easy to apportion in an immediate political sense but I am not attempting to do that. The Minister has taken a personal interest in what has happened and has had a major input to it as well as the Government and, indeed, his colleague the Minister of State.

There has been a quite astounding record of success in turning around the economy, and our reputation abroad but, most of all, in giving back hope to the community. Without that hope and optimism we will not have any improvements, jobs, or future for ourselves and, more importantly, for young people following us. This is not a complete success story or anything like that. The tide has been turned, but there is a long way to go. There is no way we can let up on the various measures that have been taken but at least now we know that there is a future ahead.

The Government cannot do this on their own. One must pay tribute here to the trade union movement, to farmers and all sections of the community who have joined in a combined effort which is essential for success. Countries that have been successful — those which spring to mind are Germany, Japan, Singapore and so on — are where there has been a combined effort. The Governments of these countries set the conditions for success and the people in industry, in the unions, in the universities and in various other sectors have combined to work towards that objective.

Success does not only mean economic success. There is a cultural and an environmental aspect to success. Yesterday, we had a debate in relation to Irish, one of the classical languages, with Greek and Latin. We think of Greek civilisation and how marvellous it was. We read about it and, if we are very fortunate, visit the Acropolis and read the various classics, Socrates and Plato and so on. We do not realise, as the economists and philosophers of those faroff days would quite openly say, that that culture was based, effectively, on a slave economy. That tiny group of people lived in an extremely civilised manner, they had the opportunity to write books on philosophy, to lay the foundation for medicine which exist to this day and to construct those marvellous architectural wonders but they did that at an appalling cost to the vast majority of people living in the Greece or in Rome of that time.

We have not entirely got away from that. Here I sympathise with speakers on the opposite side and on my own side. There is a proverty trap and we have not achieved a balance between people who are genuinely in need and are not getting the support we would like to give them, and people who are successful and, at times, are exploiting that success in one form or another in an unjust manner. As the Minister said, if we really do want to do something about poverty here, and if are genuine about eliminating it, as opposed to just making speeches about it and condemning it, then we have to take the sort of economic measures we are taking. The way to abolish poverty is to have jobs and riches in the country and there are only two ways to do that. One is to have the good fortune of certain countries in the Middle East, of finding themselves, by chance, sitting on a huge economic resource. They had their own problems in gaining control of that resource but, having gained control they could afford on a massive scale to subsidise their population. Even there, there are countries where there is poverty far beyond the experience or the imagination of most people living here. The other alternative if we want to abolish poverty is to ensure that by Government policy and individual and other success we are in a position to enlarge the cake so that we can give to those who deserve it but who through no fault of their own, are unable to look after themselves and we should be able to give them the support and services they deserve.

There have been very practicial improvements. There have been 30,000 extra jobs created in the last two years. The idea of creating that number of jobs in the private sector would have been ridiculed and laughed at if it had been said four years ago. At that time it was being said was that the private sector had failed but there had not been an increase in Government jobs, in fact there had been a reduction and yet there was that increase in jobs. I am delighted that many of those jobs are in the high technology areas which have hope for the future and which have a long term gain for this country. If we are to succeed, we must succeed in the up-market niche, in the top 10 per cent, in the quality of goods, products and services. If we are going to compete on a mass basis we can forget about it. We can subsidise industry at enormous expense for a very brief period but then be far worse off than we were before.

I am glad to see that despite our severe economic circumstances, we are still trying our best to emphasise the importance of education and providing money for it. We have a talent for and appreciation of education, if we get the chance to be educated. If we are to have up-market high technology we must have the basic educational training and opportunities.

We have had this period of successful fiscal correction, of economic and investment growth in industry. Capital utilisation last year was at the highest level in our history. We have growth of exports of goods and services and we have a significant trade surplus. People do not often realise that, for example, we have a trade surplus with West Germany, and a very substantial one. One of the great things about the union of East Germany with West Germany is that we are going to have an enlarged market, and there are very positive aspects to that. There are one or two difficult signs, one or two warning signs as it were. An internal one is, perhaps, a fall on the order books. This concerns one a little and I hope it will be corrected later in the year. Another difficulty, which we will deal with very effectively and of which the Minister is well aware, is the possibility of a rise in German interest rates as the Deutsche Mark takes responsibility for the Ostmark. That, in turn, could put pressure on our currency which has done extremely well, either to have some form of increase in interest rates or some form of realignment within the EMS. What is far more likely to happen is that the United Kingdom, will, for its own good reasons, some of them very political connected, perhaps, with the next election, will probably join the EMS and this should be very beneficial from Ireland's pont of view. Our companies deserve some degree of credit for the way, despite the EMS and the value of sterling, they have succeeded in maintaining and even recently increasing, exports to the United Kingdom, something which seemed almost impossible bearing in mind the difference between the a rates of the two currencies.

There has been a lot of success, very crucial success. Without that sort of economic success we could not alleviate poverty, maintain the environment, provide education, halt unemployment, allow people to emigrate if they want to but not feel they have to do so and give people hope. There has been a great success in setting this new climate which is so much better than that of a few years ago. In company terms, the improvement in optimism encourages business confidence, encourages companies to come here, encourages Irish companies and companies already domiciled here to invest and to expand and that has been very beneficial. Then there have been partical measures — changes in corporation tax, a gradual reduction to 40 per cent and the definition of "manufacturing" for the purposes of the 10 per cent rate has been changed. I was concerned when I first saw the Finance Bill and I am delighted that the Minister — a considerable part of this was his innovation — looked at this definition of manufacturing and introduced the amendments which are, of course, included in the Finance Bill which has come to this House from the Dáil. Those are very important, crucial and beneficial amendments and I am delighted they have been included. I have an interest in the general idea of shipping, and I have always felt we, as a country, should be more involved in shipping. As an island nation we have an advantage over other countries and I am delighted to see that matter is being attended to. Many Norwegian students often ask me why this country, an island, has no shipping industry and they have.

It is not mandatory in this House to declare interest, but I have and declare an interest in mineral exploration. I have no hesitation in welcoming the changes which have been brought in by the Minister in relation to mineral exploration activity, but beyond the direct company benefits it must be clearly understood that, of course, one cannot discover anything. We were all told as children that there were no minerals here. There are; we have one of the largest base metal mines in the world and the likelihood is that we are going to have others in due course. We cannot discover any minerals without exploration. Therefore we must have a regime that encourages it.

There have been a number of other provisions in the Bill that I was delighted to see, for example, advanced factory building, the clarification of the business expansion scheme, the section 84 provisions, the unit trust provisions and the harmonisation which has been brought in. I am glad the Minister is addressing so effectively the tax position in 1992 which will, certainly, have major implications for VAT and many other aspects of tax. I am sure we will deal with them very effectively but these major changes are coming.

I was interested to note two small points. It is high time that the Stamp Duty Act was looked at. The united Kingdom Stamp Duty Act, 1891 has been the basic Act here and will be until this Bill is passed. I was glad to see it revised. I should like to draw attention to the Succession Duty Act, 1853, a very ancient United Kingdom Act. Perhaps, at some stage, we will have a new Bill — we have already had some modifications — which will bring this into a modern era. Again, congratulations to the Minister on his truly impressive success, and that of the Government, in transforming our economic climate and giving us all a basis for hope.

Comment on this

I am glad of the opportunity to speak on the Bill at a time when economic activity, especially in the retail sector, is slowing down and when the farming industry is coming under threat. It is clear that by the end of this year farming incomes will have dropped substantially. The price of milk has dropped by 20p per gallon since the start of the year and this will be seen in the amount of money available to farmers to spend. Beef is still in crisis and there is no move to assist that sector or to get it out of the disastrous state it is in. In fact, this is likely to be compounded by the BSE scare which will be debated this evening. It is incumbent on everybody to realise that one of our main industries, agriculture, is under threat. Action must be taken to head that off.

Some provisions in the Bill are important to the farming community. The personal allowance has been discussed at length but it bears further mention. It is obvious now that there is discrimination against farm families in that they have lower personal allowances than the PAYE sector. This must be terminated. When the PAYE allowance was introduced in 1980 the justification given for it by the then Government was that it was to offset the disadvantage suffered by the PAYE taxpayers because they were then the only taxpayers taxed on current year basis. In the 1980 Budget Statement the Minister said the PAYE allowances were given "to take account of the fact that self-employed generally have at present the advantage of paying tax on a previous year basis". There can be no justification for the continuation of such blatant discrimination. The non-availability of the PAYE allowance, and the PRSI allowance, is very significant in terms of the tax liable on the farmers incomes. Some farm families, in effect, have to pay the equivalent of a 5 per cent surcharge on their incomes by way of additional income tax in comparison to the PAYE sector.

Another matter of concern to the self-employed, especially the farmers, is inheritance tax. This may seem not to be an issue in most cases but having spoken to many farming groups and attended farm organisation meetings, I am aware that this raises its head on almost every occasion tax is discussed. It may not be a problem for the farmer on any one day but they all fear it, and rightly so. The Minister should have amended the law on inheritance tax to take account of the increases in the value of property. This is a particular worry to farmers, and increases in the value of land over the past five years are bringing people into the inheritance tax net. The tax was never designed for them or meant to encompass such people.

In the transfer from a parent to an immediate family, say, a son or a daughter, assets up to £156,000 in value will be tax free. Agricultural relief applies in the case of farmers lands. Farm buildings and the farmhouse are valued at 50 per cent of market value. The result is that farms up to £312,000 market value can be transferred from a parent to a son tax free. Increases in the value of land which I have already mentioned have brought the value of many holdings above this level. This leaves the young son or daughter who is inheriting the land with two options: either to borrow to pay the tax and involve themselves in high interest rates at a time when farm returns are dropping or to dispose of part of the land and part of their livelihood to pay the tax. This problem is very urgent and should be considered by the Government before the next budget.

Transfer between relatives is extremely onerous and, I believe, unfair. Take a case of two brothers who live on a farm: one of them dies leaving the surviving brother liable for the full whack of inheritance tax. In many cases that person has no option but to sell the land to pay the tax. The same applies to people outside the farming community. I am referring to people with a business such as a bar, a shop or any family business valued for inheritance tax in this fashion. The thresholds for this tax have not been raised in line with inflation since 1978. This is of immediate importance and should be taken on board by the Government.

I welcome the Minister's statement on sections 30 and 31 which give effect to the budget decision to extend from 31 May 1991 to 31 May 1993 the time limit for incurring expenditure which qualifies for the urban renewal tax relief in designated areas. I compliment the success of this scheme. I am talking from experience and noting the results the scheme has achieved for the city of Limerick. It has changed the profile of our native city. Compliments should be paid to Shannon Development and, indeed, to Limerick Corporation for the excellent work they have done in the city of Limerick.

I would request the Government to consider the extension of that scheme to a town in County Limerick — Rathkeale — for particular reasons. The scheme was recently extended to cover other towns and cities, many of them not much larger than Rathkeale. A special case can be made to consider Rathkeale for the scheme and I will briefly outline it. We need to ensure that the centre of the town is returned to commercial activity. In Rathkeale the shops and other business premises throughout the town are being bought by members of the travelling community and turned into antique goods stores. When I say "travelling community" I am not talking about itinerants; I am talking about wealthy, successful, multi-million-pound business people known locally as the Hiace or Volvo brigades. Their activities are killing economic activity in the centre of the town. If an urban renewal programme was applied to that town, it would create an incentive to change the use of those premises and return them to the use for which they were originally built. It would develop economic activity within the town. I have made quite a detailed proposal to Limerick County Council on this and, in fact, got advice from Shannon Development who are very keen on the idea. They recognise my argument because of the special circumstances. If the Government look at the town and see the circumstances they will not create a similar state in any other town in the country. Such circumstances do not exist elsewhere. I would also like to refer to the opportunity which is being lost for the development of economic activity along the estuary in County Limerick. Two hundred acres are in the ownership of Shannon Development for development in Askeaton. I would urge the Minister and the Government to use their influence with Shannon Development to bring industry to that site. It is urgently needed and would halt or reduce the level of emigration and unemployment in the immediate area, and especially emigration from further west in the county and from Kerry.

I would also like to refer to the opportunity that is available for the creation of employment and the development of economic activity in Foynes Harbour. At the moment there are 350 jobs at Foynes Harbour for which there is a £19.5 million development plan. That is about to commence. They have asked the Government to match as far as possible up to 50 per cent of the funds of the harbour trustees to ensure that that development takes place without delay. If the Government decide to grant from £6 million to £8 million in Structural Funds to Foynes it will change the economic life of the area and double the number of jobs now in existence there. I am sure the Minister knows quite well what is happening in Foynes.

Comment on this

Can you sell it to the estuary authority?

Comment on this

If you wish me to speak on that, Minister, I am quite happy to do so. The Minister and his predecessors have tried for 25 years to introduce an estuarial authority. The arguments for and against that have been debated at length between us all. It is obvious that the decision has come down on the argument that Foynes must remain independent. It will remain independent and will develop to a level, which I have already mentioned, with the help of the Government in granting us the Structural Funds which we deserve on the basis of the plan which is outlined. It is 100 years this year since Foynes Harbour was established. The only investment made by the State in that 100 years was £500,000 made by the then Minister for the Marine, Deputy Jim Mitchell, in 1985.

I am glad that I have had the opportunity to discuss these issues. I urge the Minister and the Government to consider them.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Finance Bill. I would like to give particular thanks and praise to the Minister for introducing this Bill and indeed, to the Minister of State, Deputy Daly, for being with us today. It is indicative of the seriousness with which the Government and the Ministers concerned are taking this particular piece of legislation.

I would like to endorse what some of the previous speakers have said, particularly the words used by my learned collegue, Professor Richard Conroy, in relation to the upsurge and economic success of this Government and their predecessor in the past three years. There has been an economic renaissance over the last three to four years. Despite some criticism from the opposite side of the House, Fianna Fáil and the current coalition Government are achieving what Fine Gael had hoped to achieve in past years but in which respect they failed miserably. We appreciate their support as outlined in the Tallaght strategy. I am sure that is continuing ——

Comment on this

It turned the economic activity around.

Comment on this

I welcome a number of important items in the Bill which I support wholeheartedly. I will be making some comments which may appear to be critical, but I trust that the Minister will take them as constructive criticism and nothing else, and something that may be looked at at a future date.

Initially, as a person in business I can say that the increase in the stamp duty exemption from £1,000 and £5,000 is very welcome. I would even go so far as to say that we should in future consider increasing all of the bands. There should be a minimum of £10,000, so that below that figure there would be no stamp duty applicable. The other bands where 3 per cent and 4 per cent rates of stamp duty are payable could be improved. The purchase of a house now for £50,000 or £60,000 as a family home is a quite frequent occurrence. In modern terms that is not an expensive purchase. For many years there has been a high rate of stamp duty. That, too, is something that could be looked at.

I would also welcome the fact that there is provision in this Bill concerning all transactions or transfers of property between spouses. There is a total exemption from stamp duty where the transfer creates a joint tenancy. This, too, is welcome. Up to now, it merely applied in relation to the family home situation. The broadening of this device is to be lauded.

I would like to compliment the Government and the Ministers concerned in not reducing further the mortgage interest relief. It was feared that the level of the relief would be reduced again in this year's budget but the Minister, quite rightly, having regard to some increase in the interest rates over the last two or three years, realised the difficulty and left the mortgage relief untouched.

Having welcomed the Bill, there are a number of matters which I would like to touch on. First, the relief available to disabled persons is not what I would like to see. Disabled persons, because of their inherent disabilities and particularly those of them who have not the back up or possibly an award arising out of an accident or otherwise, should not be taxed as single persons. They have no free travel and must adapt to their disability sometimes on a long-term basis. There is room here for certain additional concessions, in particular to people in wheelchairs and who are dependent on others and on society to help them.

I also welcome the extension of the manufacturing tax relief into the next decade. I compliment the Minister on the swift and efficient manner in which he moved in relation to the Dunne case, which was particularly laudable and, hopefully, will meet with total and unequivocal agreement from all sides of the House.

Some Opposition Members have referred to the cumbersome and possibly difficult way in which our tax is collected. There is need here for this Government, and indeed all Governments, to continually review the methods of collection and the administrative side. There are certain anomalies. This administrative sector is somewhat top-heavy. One particular matter on which I have practical experience is that there are small farmers who are obviously not in the tax net and who, on a regular basis, get tax assessments, etc. Where it is clear and obvious that a farmer is ekeing out a subsistence living, there should be some method that possibly once every five years would be a sufficient period of time to investigate his circumstances, and not on an annual basis.

The VAT band is too low and should be looked at. I am particularly concerned that at the moment if you want to register for VAT it cannot be done, particularly in the south of Ireland, in the Cork office where there is a huge tax office in O'Sullivan's Quay. There is a huge administration there and yet if one has to register for VAT in the county or city of Cork — and I presume in other counties as well — one has to go to Dublin. This is an administration aspect which I would query. I hope, without in any way being critical, that this will be taken on board by the officials of the Department of Finance.

I welcome the increase in the thresholds concerning capital acquisitions tax, particularly in relation to inheritance tax. I would broadly agree with some of the points made by Senator Neville, that certain difficulties exist in this area. The increase is welcome but it is not sufficient. There are certain anomalies within the CAT liability that should be rectified. A situation which I frequently encounter is where a farmer or some property owner wishes to leave property to a nephew or nice. The threshold there is inadequate and it is something I hope will be looked at. I welcome the new initiative whereby there is now no CAT liability in relation to transfers or inheritances between spouses.

There are certain anomalies in the position regarding capital acquisitions tax. I quote a practical example which I recently encountered where a couple about seven years ago transferred their family farm on their son. In the intervening period the father died and about 12 months ago, tragically, the son was killed in a road traffic accident. The mother, who is in her eighties now, inherits that property by virtue of the provisions of the Succession Act and is now faced with a substantial capital acquisitions tax bill by virtue of the fact that she, in getting this property back as a result of this tragic accident has only an exemption of £20,800. Possibly you can double that if you give the agricultural relief, but at any rate the liability, having regard to the value of the farm, farm buildings, capital, etc. in excess of £150,000, that this old lady is faced with is a bill of £10,000 or £15,000. I urge that in such situations the converse should apply and that where property reverts to the original transferor — in this case, the mother or, possibly, a father — the full exemption should apply, and that it should be £156,000 and not £20,800.

It is not a unique instance. In the past two years I could quote another situation where a young man in similar circumstances, who was unmarried, had cancer and died at the age of 36. The property reverted to the parents, not that they wanted it back but that is the way the law works, and they had to face a CAT bill. I do not think that was what was intended under the capital acquisitions tax legislation and I ask the Minister and his officials to have a close look at it. I believe it is one area which, without creating too many ripples or too many problems, can be tackled successfully by the Government. Next year, when the Finance Bill and budget is being prepared some of the points I made may be taken on board.

I would like to say clearly and unequivocally that, as a businessman, I have been the practical improvements that have been created by the economic renaissance and the success that has been generated by Fianna Fáil after 1987 by the current Government. I wish to see this continue. I believe the Government, with the support of the trade unions and the people in agriculture, can certainly bring the economy of this small national back on its feet. At the moment, in industry and commerce, in the property markets, etc. there is a great resurgence. There is a belief that we are doing the right things and that is very important. It should not go unnoticed that over the past 28 or 30 months each month our balance of payments, our exports over our imports has been excellent. this is the direction this Government is going, and one which must be lauded.

I would like to say "well done" to the Minister for Finance and the Minister of State at the Department. Keep up the good work. Hopefully, the problems of emigration and unemployment will gradually be eroded. We are going in the right direction. I am delighted to see that sort of resurgence.

Comment on this

I welcome this opportunity to contribute to the debate on the Finance Bill. Bearing in mind, the time constraints we are adhering to, I will confine my remarks to a few matters in the Bill and will suggest some changes which the Minister might consider.

The Finance Bill obviously gives effect to many provisions in the budget. Some of them are technical and will be discussed further on Committee Stage. First, I stress the importance of getting people back to work. Certain progress has been made in this regard over the past few years. Part of the progress was due to the constructive policy and attitude taken by Members on this side of the House and, in particular, the members of the Fine Gael Party. It is important that Member's on the other side recognise that contribution. In facing up to the problems which the country has, and continues to have, we need a combined effort.

In relation to unemployment and job creation, and rewarding initiative and risk takers, we must go further down the road. As the Minister says, unemployment is the root cause of poverty. While certain progress has been made, he admits that it is not adequate and much remains to be done. We have all to work towards getting more of our people back into employment by helping to create the climate that is necessary for jobs for the many young people who are at present doing examinations. There are probably going to be fewer people going into training. More openings must be provided through our position in the EC. We have got to reward people who are prepared to take risks, prepared to take initiatives and to put up money in order to give employment. All we have got to do in relation to that is extremely important. There is the whole situation of job creation and taxation, which are related.

The moves made to reduce our penal tax rates are welcome. I would like to see the Minister accelerating the progress. On the tax rates here one can quickly reach the highest rate of tax. People on low salaries are looking at their pay slips and wondering which is the tax and which is the net amount they are going to take home. We have got to ensure that if people work hard they take home a satisfactory amount of money. Friends of mine and other people who go to London would like to be back here working if the jobs were here and if the tax rates were more equitable.

There has got to be commitment towards reducing tax down to a standard rate of 25 per cent, the higher rate being somewhere between 40 per cent and 50 per cent. It is criminal that a person has to pay over 50 per cent of his wages, after a couple of allowances. It is no wonder people are finding it very hard to make ends meet.

Interest rates have risen alarmingly and have become a heavy burden over the last 12 months. This time last year, interest rates were approximately 8.25 per cent. Today they stand at almost 50 per cent more, so they are at 12.4 or 12.5 per cent. This extra increase in interest rates is placing an intolerable burden on people who have committed themselves to buying their houses, and who now have this noose around their necks in relation to mortgage repayments. On an average mortgage, which is about £30,000, an extra £1,000 in repayments has to be found. Most people enter into mortgages on set guidelines. They have only so much money for food and house hold bills, running a car, education for their children, and maybe putting a little bit by for a holiday. Having to find, as they are having to find at the moment, an extra £1,000 or more, is really choking people. They are literally on the breadline because of mortgage interest increases.

It must be remembered that mortgage interest relief had been reduced from 100 per cent to 90 per cent, down to the present 80 per cent. While I suppose we ought to be thankful it was not reduced any further there was a case this year for restoring a certain amount to try to relieve the present situation. The Minister should look at the situation again. There is no immediate prospect of interest rates coming down. Thankfully, they have not gone up any further, even though that was threatened some time ago. The reality is that they are going to remain very high for some time. The Minister should look at this. Many people make a very big commitment in relation to their mortgages. It is breaking some families at the moment. I ask the Minister to keep it under consideration and to do everything he can to see that the rates are reduced. It is a crippling burden on many young couples. What is happening is that more and more people are getting behind in their repayments. There may come a time when the houses have to be repossessed and these people will arrive back on our housing lists.

In relation to the whole question of property tax, in the area that I represent it does not take a very big house now to have it on the threshold for property tax. In certain areas this has got to be looked at. I welcome the amendment providing for relief in respect of children. In this day and age it does not take a massive income into a household or a very big house to create liability for the property tax. When the property tax was introduced it was meant to be for semi-mansions or small castles. Ordinary three to four bedroom semi-detached houses are now entering into this net. People on reasonable salaries are suddenly finding themselves caught. I would ask the Minister to look at this in the light of recent increases in the house prices.

In relation to stamp duties, I would ask the Minister to consider having a tax relief base or allowance for smaller houses and possibly to have no stamp duty on houses costing £20,000 to £25,000 in order to give more encouragement to that end of the market and to regenerate that market. Obviously, there are not that many of these houses around. While people are buying some houses cheaply and doing them up, if they are sold at a later stage at an increased price, the Minister will then get his whack at that stage. This is something the Minister should consider.

I would also like to see a further reduction in VAT rates. While the reduction from 25 per cent to 23 per cent was to be welcomed, 23 per cent on people's fees is quite a substantial hike on to a bill, particularly for people who cannot reclaim it. We have to work towards getting our VAT rate down to something like 10 per cent and to try to cut out these very high rates.

I would acknowledge and welcome the Minister's initiative in responding so quickly to the call not to tax court awards to people who are either permanently or long-terms handicapped. The plight of the Dunne case, which moved the Minister, goes to show that there is a willingness in these matters. It was a case which touched everybody and I am glad the Minister was able to respond. The way he responded is to be welcomed, and in that case and other cases credit should be given where credit is due. As a result, people who unfortunately become involved in accidents which may permanently incapacitate them will now have a chance of getting by.

In conclusion, I would ask the Minister to concentrate on getting more people into work, giving them a decent wage in their jobs and trying to reduce taxation further. It is obviously the key to getting more people back to work. It is important that we do not rest on our laurels and continue to push towards getting our people into jobs, particularly our young people.

Comment on this

First of all, I welcome the opportunity to make a brief contribution on this excellent Finance Bill and in doing so I want to congratulate the Minister on a very complex Bill, also the Minister for State, Deputy Brendan Daly, who is here with us this today. I would like also to compliment our own spokesman, Senator O'Keeffe, on his excellent contribution.

The Finance Bill is positive and progressive and again indicates the Government's concern in regard to our tax bands. A section very close to my heart are the lower paid workers. Their net take home pay has been further reduced over a period of time by the deduction of PRSI contributions. The payments of these contributions was a major imposition on those below the poverty line. Tremendous credit is due to these people on taking up low paid employment as in many cases they would be much better off on social welfare. However, the Minister has now decided to exempt lower paid workers from PRSI contributions and this will not affect their entitlement to social insurance benefit.

Last year's budget saw the standard rate of tax reduced from 35 per cent to 32 per cent and now it is reduced to 30 per cent. The high rate in 1989 was reduced from 58 per cent to 56 per cent and again this year to 53 per cent. These changes are very welcome across a wide spectrum. No doubt this is due to the tremendous improvement in the economy since 1987. I welcome the commencement of a 25 per cent tax rate band for 1993 with a substantial reduction in the top rate of 53 per cent as at present. The widening of the income tax bands has made matters more attractive for the worker. In the case of a married couple the limit has been increased from £6,000 to £6,500. The reduction in the rates of income tax and the widening of the exemptions limits has meant that extra money has been put into the pockets of the PAYE worker.

Many critics of this Government have been calling over the past few years for major improvements in the area of taxation. Some of these critics were in a position to tackle the situation in the previous Coalition administration but failed to do so. The progress made to date since 1987 is excellent, not least in this Finance Bill. The extension of the period to the year 2010 during which the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing will apply is to be welcomed, as also is the extension to 1993 of the period during which the urban renewal package will apply. Also welcome is the reduction in the standard rate of VAT, the changes in stamp duty to further encourage the development of the financial resources sector, the abolition of the 60 per cent rate capital gains tax and the indexation of capital acquisitions tax.

I wish to make reference to the building industry, which, it is now accepted, is going through a boom period and in doing so creating much needed employment. We were told a few years ago that it would never again get back to a sound footing. These pundits have been proved wrong, and not for the first time.

As one interested in tourism, and also involved, I appreciate the efforts made by the Government since 1987 with regard to tourism. The Government over this period have given it top priority and it has certainly made a remarkable progress. The upsurge in tourism in 1989 continued and records were broken. Estimates show that the number of overseas visitors increased by over 15 per cent to 2.8 million. Foreign tourist revenue more than kept pace with this growth and was close to the £1 billion mark. In the three year period 1987 to 1989 the number of visitors increased by 900,000 while revenue increased pro rata. This increase in tourism activity has been responsible for the creation of 18,000 jobs in that period.

This performance highlights the enormous growth potential of the industry and justifies the priority which the Government have afforded tourism since assuming office. The results have been brought about by a series of progressive and co-ordinated measures initiated by the Government. I have watched the growth in my own county of Kerry, which is considered to be the primary tourist area in this country. New hotels have been erected in Killarney and Tralee. Millions of pounds are being invested in a hotel in Kenmare. In their first venture into northern Europe, Club Mediterranean and Ryanair are investing £5 million in Waterville. Domestic holidays have increased. New golf courses are proposed at Ballybunion, Tralee, Killarney, Killorglin and Castlegregory. The CorkSwansea ferry has returned. Here again I want to compliment the Government on their allocation of a grant of £500,000 and a loan of £500,000. This is money well spent and the bookings to date show a substantial increase on the same period the last time the ship was in operation. It is an outstanding tribute to the Government and to all those concerned in the industry that this should have happened when it was believed it could not be done. Many of the things which people believed could not be done have been achieved by this Government.

Perhaps one of the most positive approaches by this Government and the previous Government was their investment in regional airports. Few would have believed a few years ago that many of these airports would have become the success they are today. The Government gave a grant of £1.25 millions towards Farranfore airport, County Kerry, which lay dormant for years. That amount was quickly matched by the business community of County Kerry. Between June and December of 1989, 49,000 passengers passed through Farranfore and projections for 1990 are that 100,000 passengers will pass through the airport. I look forward to the Government's continued support of Farranfore airport by providing the essential Structural Funds to help make it an airport of international status.

I wish to refer to the submission of the ICMSA regarding the tax allowance for farm families. The ICMSA state that the Government decision to propose a current year basis of assessment for farmers and other self-employed people removes the justification put forward in 1980 when PAYE was introduced. It was stated that the purpose of the PAYE allowance was to take account of the fact that the self-employed generally had the advantage of paying tax on the basis of the previous year. They point out that the Commission on Taxation recommended that when all taxpayers were taxed on a current year basis of assessment taxpayers should receive the same overall personal allowances regardless of the schedule under which they are assessed. On behalf of farm families I ask the Minister to ensure that an appropriate amendment is adopted in the Bill to cater for farm families. It would be an advantage to them and it would appear to be reasonable that they should be treated in this manner.

When the business expansion scheme was introduced it was considered a very positive innovation, and certainly it has created tremendous economic activity. The Minister recently referred to abuses of the scheme; but, like all good projects, it tends itself to abuse by a small minority. I am glad the Minister has addressed this problem. I hope he will continue the scheme in view of its job creating possibilities.

Section 10 extends the business expansion scheme to the construction and leasing of advance factories in areas that are in particular need of development and of the creation of employment opportunities, and where the construction is promoted by a local community group. This is a very important development, especially for towns in my own county such as Ballylongford, Tarbert and Listowel, where we need advance factories in order to attract industry.

Section 11 is also concerned with the business expansion scheme and is aimed at preventing the possibility of investors getting interest relief on loans taken out to buy BES shares as well as the BES relief itself on the capital invested under the scheme. Such interest relief could be available where the investor is an employee or director of the BES company. However, the Minister has stated that he sees no reason why an investor, having obtained tax relief on the capital he has invested through the BES, should also be able to obtain tax relief on the interest he pays on a loan taken out to enable him to acquire the BES shares. In short, the Minister has stated that he should not be able to get relief on both the capital and the interest. I agree with this.

In my constituency of North Kerry An Post have indicated that all rural post offices throughout the country will close over a period of time. To date I have experienced four closures in North Kerry. This is sad, as the post office means so much to a rural area. It is a focal point where people meet, and to close them means a further blow to rural communities. An Post should be reconsider this harsh decision. I appreciate that they are a semi-State body but they may find other ways to remedy their economic problems.

The Finance Bill contains many excellent provisions but its overall aims is an effort by the Minister to simplify certain elements of the taxation system, to remove certain anomalies within the various taxes, ensure that the various incentives and reliefs granted by the Government are used for the purpose for which they were initiated, and to respond to areas of need. The Bill is a major and lengthy one. Once again, I congratulate the Minister on his tremendous foresight in the way he has dealt with all aspects of the economy. I wish him well.

Comment on this

Ag labhairt ar an mBille seo ba mhaith liom tagairt don tionchar a bheidh aige ar áiteanna iargúlta ar nós Chonamara agus ar cheantair eile in iarthar na tíre, go speisialta. Thar aon ní eile, tá aicme amháin daoine sa tír seo faoi láthair a bhí ag súil go ndéanfaí teacht i dtír nó fóirthint orthu sa Bhille seo, an Bille Airgeadais.

Baineann an Bille seo le sláinte daoine nach bhfuil ar fónamh ach nach bhfuil ina ngnáthchónaí in ospidéil nó in institiúidí leighis den chineál sin. Bhí an-cion agus an-mheas ag pobal na hÉireann i gcónaí ar a muintir féin, agus ar sheandaoine, ach go háirithe, nuair shroichidís deireadh a saoil agus nuair nach mbeadh sé ar a gcumas aire a thabhairt dóibh féin níos mó. Thugadh an pobal coiteann cúnamh i gcásanna mar seo go fial agus go flaithiúil, gan ceisteanna a chur.

Tá a fhios ag an saol Fódhla go bhfuil fadhb againn maidir lenar seanmhuintir agus maidir lena sláinte. Téann an fhadhb i ndéine nuair a smaoinítear ar an líon mór seandaoine atá ina gcónaí leo féin, in iarthar na tíre, go speisialta; iad tréigthe, gan chúram ceart ná éinne chun aire a thabhairt dóibh. Le blianta beaga anuas, tá ainriocht na seandaoine seo á thabhairt os comhair aghaidh an phobail de bharr tuairiscí éagsúla ar an ábhar; tá siad i gcónái i bmaol ó dhaoine gan scrupallacha a ghoidfeadh a maoin uathu agus a ghéaródh ar a gcuid deacrachtaí, dá mb' fhéidir sin a shéanamh.

Má theipeann ar an Stát aire ceart a thabhairt do dhaoine sa chás seo, le reachtaíocht dhlithiúil ar nós an Bhille Airgeadais seo, fágtar i dtuillemaí iomlán a mhuintir féin sa bhaile iad. Bítear ag brath ar ghnaíúlacht agus ar ghrá chroí an mhuintir sa bhaile. Ní hé nach mbíodh muintir na seandaoine sásta aire a thabhairt dóibh nó go mbídís ag iarraidh iad a chur ó dhoras; is amhlaidh go gcreidtí go raibh dualgas ar an nglúin shláintiúil aire a thabhairt don seanmhuintir. Bhí súil agamsa agus ag daoine nach mé, go dtabharfaí aitheantas nó cúiteamh éigin don líon daoine sin atá ag foirthint ar sheandaoine. Tá aitheantas áirithe tugtha dóibh cheana féin ach ní leor é; de réir alt 3, feasta beidh an duine atá ag tabhairt aire do sheandhuine i dteideal liúntas de £5,000 saor ó chíos nó ó cháin. Bhí deis ann, sa Bhille seo, dar liom, chun aitheantas níos féile a thabhairt.

Feictear dom go raibh seans ag an Aire Airgeadais rud fiúntach amháin a chéanamh; is é sin, cinneadh a dhéanamh gan teacht isteach an tsaoránaigh phríomháidigh a chur san áireamh do cháin ioncaim.

Tá gach duine sa stát, idir bhocht agus saibhir, i dteideal liúntas leanaí. Tá aitheantas tughta ag an Stáit don bprionsabal sin agus bhí deis ag an Aire sa Bhille seo, an prionsabal céanna a leathnadh chun an dream daoine ar a dtugtar "the silent majority", atá ag glacadh cúram an Stáit chucu féin agus ag tabhairt aire dá seanmhuintir sa bhaile. Ní thig liomsa dhá thaobh an scéil seo a réiteach le chéile. Deir an Stát go bhfuil an uile dhuine i dteideal liúntas leanaí ach, i gcás aire a thabhairt do dhaoine atá ar a mbealach amach as an saol, is é dearcadh an Stáit ná nach bhfuil dualgas ann chun cúiteamh ginearálta a íoc. Tá cúiteamh ar fáil d'aicme áirithe daoine, le teacht isteach faoi bhun méid áirithe. Theip ar an Aire Airgeadais sa Bhille seo an deis a bhí aige a thapú chun as cás seo a chur ina cheart. Is amhlaidh go bhfuil an scéal ag dul í ndanas, mar go n-áiríonn daoine atá eilach ar an ábhar nach mbeidh ach tuairim is 2,000 duine sa tír feasta, a bhéas i dteideal faiosimh faoi fhorálacha seo an Aire. Tásúil agim go mbeidh an tAire ábalta míniú simplí a thabhairt bom ar an aimhrialtacht seo.

Ba chuma, ar bhealach, mura mbeadh an dlí á athrú i mbliana. Tá sé cruthaithe, áfach, ó staitisticí a d'ullmhaigh lucht sláinte na tíre, gur cinnte go bhfuil na milliúin punt costais á spáráil ar an Stáit, toisc go bhfuil mná pústa ag tabhairt aire do sheandaoine ina dtithe féin. Tá na mná seo lánsásta an obaire seo a dhéanamh ach is é an trua é go gcuirfear ioncam iomlán an líon tí sin san áireamh, de réir an Bhille seo. Bealach eile atá anseo le cáin a ghearradh ar dhaoine, go háirithe ar an mheánaicme.

D'fhéadfadh na daoine atá ag tabhairt aire dá seanduine a rá: "Tabharfadh an Stát aire don duine seo; cuirimís isteach in ospidéal nó in institiúid do sheandaoine í nó é". Is eol do chuile dhuine sa Teach seo an costas seachtainiúil a ghabhann le duine a choimeád ina leithéid d'áit. Meastar go mbíonn breis is £400 i gceist agus má mhéadaítear an figiúr sin faoi 50, gheofar an costas bliantúil.

Tá aimhrialtachtaí eile sa Bhille seo maidir le cáin chorparáideach, a bhí le leasú, agus déanadh amhlaidh. Chuir an páirtí s'againne leasú isteach mar gheall ar Údarás na Gaeltachta agus SFADCo i Luimneach; níor thug muintir an Chláir nó muintir Luimní faoi deara ar chor ar bith é. Chuir mé féin leasú isteach sa Bhille, tríd an urlabhraí aitheantas d'Údarás na Gaeltachta agus do SFADCo i Luimneach maidir leis an gcáin corparáideach a híslíodh ó 43 faoin gcéad go dtí 10 faoin gcéad. Bhí an tíosmhéad á níoc ag an IDA ach bhí an tuasmhéad dá n-íoc ag an Údarás agus ag SFADCo, go dtí seo.

Mar fhocal scoir, deirim arís go raibh seans ag an Aire rud fiúntach a dhéanamh i leith daoine ag tabhairt aire dá muintir. Tá a fhios agam go bhfuil sé rodhéanach anois leasú a dhéanamh ionas nach mbeadh "means test" á gcur i bhfeidhm i leith an liúntais seo nuair nach mbainean means test le liúntais leanaí. Chaill an tAire an deis agus in féidir tada a dhéanamh faoi go dtí an bhliain seo chugainn.

Comment on this