We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Finance Bill, 1990 [ Certified Money Bill]: Second Stage.

Contributions 76–175 of 175. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1990
Enacted

No. 11 of 1990 ›

The Labour Party have many reservations about this particular Finance Bill, 1990. It does, of course, implement the changes in the budget. That is its purpose — to give statutory effect to taxation changes in the budget. The Minister indicated what he considered were the key proposals. When we are assessing a Finance Bill we assess it, to my mind, in the context of what is does to improve the quality of life of the people.

The key proposals that the Minister lists there are first, a reduction in income tax levels, which nobody would disagree with; second, a reduction in corporation tax level, which I certainly would disagree with our corporation levels are among the lowest in Europe; third, an extension of 10 per cent for the manufacturing industry in terms of tax reincentives to the year 2010, which again is hardly likely to improve the quality of life for the ordinary persons; fourth, on extension of the urban renewal incentive package which, of course, is done on a very discriminatory basis and is piecemeal, ad-hoc. I know from my own constituency in Dublin Central how it creates injustice through giving scope to speculative activity in prime areas and does not develop other areas. I see the Minister is shaking his head but that is the situation. I can see quite clearly in the urban area how the line of demarcation wanders and meanders around to give scope to prime speculative areas, which will be used and abused by those who have the money to do so rather than a broad approach to urban renewal, which is what we should be doing; fifth, a reduction in the standard VAT rate, which is desirable; sixth, changes in stamp duties to encourage the financial services sector — here we have 100 per cent capital allowances. Again, to what extent that will improve the quality of life is a big question mark. Then there is abolition of the 60 per cent rate of capital gains tax. All these relate to the business sector in terms of concessions; and finally, the introduction on a current year basis of assessment for the self-employed. That is an extension of the process for self-assessment which is a desirable development.

When we look at the balance of the changes to my mind it does not improve the quality of life as a budget should do. It is one thing to maintain the balance of payments, but the quality of life is what we are talking about because in the last analysis it deals with the lives and the livelihood of people. We must ask ourselves what will these changes do in the context of emigration — which remains at very high level — and unemployment, with approximately 250,000 people unemployed. What will this budget do to stem emigration and reduce unemployment which is at about 18 per cent at present, one of the highest in the EC? What will it do for the homeless when no money is being provided by the Exchequer to construct new houses and no money is being provided for the maintenance of the existing stock of houses? What will the budget do in that respect? Will it provide more section 30 residential concessions for the speculators? What progress is there towards the elimination of poverty in this budget? Does it address that point? It mentions it as a desirable target but it does not make any concrete proposals. Our education system has been hammered since this Government came to power. There is no concession in this budget for the education sector in terms of class sizes, extra personnel or resources.

What is on offer for the environment? With £3 millions for Dublin we are to have smog, pollution and dereliction eliminated. Smog will be eliminated by the end of the year. We will believe that when we see it, if we can, in fact, see through the streets of Dublin next winter. That is what we have on offer. What has the Minister done in the context of the residential investments? The extension of section 23 on residential investment is an area that should be curtailed rather than allowed to continue. What will that do for the economy? We have nominal taxation on unit linked insurance funds, which is just a device for avoiding tax. Why do we not have a reasonable level of taxation on that — 40 to 50 per cent at least? Why can we not have mortgage relief at the standard rate of tax on 100 per cent of the repayments so that the ordinary taxpayer who is buying his or her own home, will benefit?

The business expansion scheme has been an absolute disaster, totally exploited and abused. While what has been introduced here to close loopholes is welcome, to my mind the entire system needs to be thoroughly looked at before it is allowed to operate again. Instead of business expansion it was used to acquire money for schemes that were never intended and were not covered by the scheme. What about the VHI subsidising the Blackrock Clinic and the Master Private Hospital? What is being done to prevent that type of tax relief being granted, which was never intended either?

The child benefits are totally inadequate and there is no real family support here. That could have been dealt with in the context of tax relief. What is being done in the context of the banks which made a profit of half a million pounds this year with all the loopholes that are there for the accountants to help them avoid their tax liabilities. Why can we not have a more effective, system of taxation that could prevent that because we can see how easily they have avoided paying their taxes as they have been doing, over the years.

There are a couple of areas I will dwell on to some degree. One is poverty. Poverty is probably the most predominant characteristic of the constituency I represent since I became involved with the Labour Party. Nothing has changed in the last two years. We still have excessive deprivation. There are no houses being built and people are almost cutting each others throats trying to get accommodation. There is a queue of maybe a dozen to 20 people for every flat that becomes vacant and there is no programme of construction in Dublin or in the greater Dublin area and none whatsoever in the inner city which is in need of major revitalisation.

In terms of employment the only thing that we have on offer is the Financial Services Centre with its 100 per cent capital allowances and various incentives. How many local people will get employment there? The Government look at this not in terms of employment but of what can be given by way of financial incentives on the unproven basis that if you create profit you create jobs. That has been the great lie of the private sectors. What are the private sectors doing in terms of job creation? They have done very little to date. They have expatriated £2 billion in profits, which is roughly the same amount as Ireland's trade surplus over the last 12 months.

We have a booming economy in terms of exports but instead of the profits being reinvested in this country, they have gone abroad. What has this Finance Bill done to ensure that that money is productively invested, that it will produce jobs for our people as it should? All we got from the business sectors is the promise to set up a trust for community initiative. Did Senators ever hear the like? That is what the business sector is doing. The real money that could produced the jobs is still leaving the country and there is nothing in this Bill to try and prevent that from happening.

I am particularly concerned with education which has been sufferings for many years not just because of this Government but previous Governments throughout the 1980s. Teachers and the school system in general in terms of resources have borne more than their share of the brunt of the sacrifices that have been made to get the country back on an even keel and to try and deal with the national debt. In this budget or in the last budget there was nothing in terms of acknowledgement of that for teachers. At primary level and at second level we have the largest classes of any country in the EC. In relation to second level, while we have a 20:1 pupil-teacher ratio, Italy has a 10:1 ratio. We have double the ratio so we have double the workload for teachers. Obviously that has implications for the quality of schooling, even though our business sectors, and our private business sector in particular, will sell this country on the grounds that we have a fine educated youth, perhaps the best in Europe.

The Government are not ensuring that the resources are put there to maintain that quality of education that has been built up over the years in this country. How can we go into Europe in 1992 if our budget of 1990 does not address the situation where every other European country has a six year cycle at post-primary level and we have only five? Germany has a nine year cycle we have a five year cycle. How will we have a competitive edge on that type of European once we are in the greater European setting in terms of trade and of monetary and political and economic union. Why is something not done in that context? There will be no sense in wringing our hands and giving crash courses as has been stated by the Minister earlier on in relation to ab initio language schemes. We need a major look at our educational system and the provision we are making in the context of 1992. If it is not done now it will be too late to do it in 1992.

There are 40 per cent of our third level applicants who have no place to go in this country. Those youngsters who want to go to third level either cannot go in this country or have to emigrate to England to do so. That is a scandal. The grants system is very inadequate in terms either of the poor people who are unable to go to college or indeed more or less middle-class people who would be PAYE earners. They are very much hit by the low income limits that are required in terms of eligibility for grants. It is an area that needs to be addressed.

The whole educational area is part of the infrastructure of any developing country and any country that hopes to be able to expand and complete in the European context. One of the most necessary requirements is that we have the skills and the education. One of the things that Ireland has always been tax in has been research and development in the context of international companies in Ireland. They do two and a quarter times more research into the products and markets than we do. Those are the multinational companies that come in and we are far behind the European countries.

I would like to say a ward about the environment. That is an area that at this time could have been addressed with much more forthrightness and given much more fundings. I have major concerns about action in the area of pollution control. Nothing has been done in that context other than making promise of a nominal contribution of £3 million to the Dublin area and no grants have been made available for the conversion of existing types of heating to smoke-free zones. How can one introduce change unless one directs people in the right direction? The right direction is through fundings or grants towards conversion.

The second area is what I referred to earlier, the urban renewal incentive scheme extended to 1993. I have grave reservations about that scheme. It is operating in a discriminatory fashion. I see it with my own eyes day after day. I would much prefer that there was an overall comprehensive approach to urban renewal. You cannot simply pick little areas and say that in this year we will designate them as urban renewal areas entitled to the urban renewal incentives while we neglect other areas. You have to look at the city or certainly major parts of the city as a unit and talk about overall comprehensive development. Otherwise all you are doing is creating disparities; certain investment comes in and you create wealth on the one hand and side-by-side with it you create ghettoes of poverty. We have had that for far too long in this country. My main criticism of this Bill is that it does not address the real problems in relation to the quality of life of the people.

Comment on this

I am very glad to have the opportunity of making a brief contribution on the Finance Bill, which is one of the most important debates to take place in this or in the other House during the whole legislative period.

The Finance Bill we are discussing today provides a statutory basis for the taxation measures announced in this year's budget. The reduction in the standard rate of income tax to 30 per cent and the reduction of the top rate to 53 per cent are just two of the changes made in the Bill which are now begining to reflects themselves in pay packets. Other changes made include the reduction in the standard rate of corporation tax to 40 per cent which will help job creation in the services sector.

There is the extension of the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing industry to the year 2010 to create greater certainty for investment planning. The others are the reduction in the standard rate of VAT, which has already taken effect and indeed is helping to reduce inflation, changes in stamp duties to further encourage the development of the financial services sector and the abolition of the 60 per cent rate of capital gains tax which has been an inhibiting factor in investment. Those measures I have outlined are all part of Government policy designed to prime the economy and generate employment and investment.

The annual growth in real GNP has averaged 3.5 per cent over the past three years and shows the Government are pursuing the right economic policies. In the world league we are indeed one of the top performers. That did not happen by accident but by carefull planning and prudent management of the economy. The fact that inflation is set to fall to 2.5 per cent by the end of the year shows that progress is being made on the economic front.

Progress is being made in correcting the imbalance in the public finances. In 1986 Government borrowing stood at nearly 13 per cent of GNP. As a result of the firm action taken by the Government this has been more than halved by the end of 1988 to 6 per cent of GNP. Last year there was a further significant fall in Government borrowing to 2.4 per cent of GNP.

In today's Irish Independent we read that exports have hit a new record of £1,427 million for the month of March, a strong 30 per cent improvement over February and a corresponding 18 per cent growth on March 1989. We had a trade surplus of £314.2 million in March which is almost double the surplus recorded in March, 1989.

The CTT forecast is that Ireland's exports will rise this year by a further 12 per cent to £16.4 billion. All the economic indicators are encouraging and are proof that the Government are pursuing the correct policies. As the Minister has pointed out, the key element in our economic success over the past three years has been the Programme for National Recovery. Employers and employees have responded to the Government's lead, employees by adhering to the moderate pay increases provided for in the programme and employers through increasing investment and job creation.

Job creation, of course, is an area of concern to everybody, I am happy to note that real progress is being made here also. The building industry, which is a fair barometer of how the economy has undergone a remarkable transformation in recent times. Everywhere one goes one can see new developments taking place, particularly in the bigger population centres. Thousands of jobs for skilled and non-skilled workers have been created. According to the CII the prospects for job creation in this sector are good. I have no doubt that that trend will continue and that we will see further improvements and further jobs created in this particular sector.

Anybody driving in or out of Dublin can see the remarkable improvement that has taken place in the road network. We read about the huge numbers of planning applications for multi-million pound develoments in this and other cities. This shows that the investors have full confidence in the Government and are prepared to put their money in to revitalise our cities and towns.

I hope that this development will spread evenly throughout the country and that the other centres will not be neglected. I am talking in particular about the smaller centres. In my constituency there is a fear that this might happen in Tuam and the north Galway area generally because development in Galway city is proceeding at a fast pace while Tuam at the present time is an industrial black spot. I ask the Minister to ensure that Tuam is accommodated and that they share in the industrial developments now taking place in other centres.

The town has been declining steadly since the closure of the sugar factory and indeed morale is very low at present. There is a genuine fear, because of the rapid development in Galway city, that Tuam might be neglected. We do not want to see that happen. I am appealing to the Minister today to make every effort to attract a major industry to Tuam. The Minister for Finance, who is responsible for this Bill we are debating here today, as well as the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Tourism and Transport have all been made aware of the situation in Tuam, I hope they will respond favourably in the near future.

There are many issues which one could debate on this Bill. I realise that our time is limited and I want to ensure that other speakers get an opportunity to make their contribution so I will confine myself to these few remarks. Before I finish I would like to refer to the farming community, in particular to the farm families. I understand that a submission has been made by the ICMSA to the Minister regarding the tax allowance for farm families. All taxpayers are now assessed on a current year basis of assessment and, in my opinion, should receive the same personal allowances regardless of the schedule under which they are assessed. This to my mind would make the system of taxation more equitable.

I cannot understand why farm families cannot be assessed on the same basis as PAYE workers, God knows they have enough hardships to endure. Maybe there is some genuine reason for it, maybe there are other concessions that the farm families are getting that I am not aware of but I would like the Minister to spell out why the farm families are not treated in the same way as the PAYE workers. If I had that explained to me maybe I would be able to satisfy some of these people who are pressing me and other public representatives to have this system of taxation changed.

Farmers are going through a rather difficult time. The income increases of recent years have been eroded to some extent in the past six months or so as a result of decreases in the prices of lamb and milk. In addition, the market for beef is not too steady at present so farmers have many harships to contend with.

The recent increases in interest rates have created problems for mortgage holders. I was very pleased to hear the Minister's reassuring words that interest rates would not continue to rise. I hope that is so, having regard to the problems that have been created for young people, in particular, who are faced with high mortgages and in some cases with unemployment.

I congratulate the Minister and the Government on the work they are doing. They are working well as a team, they are providing the right type of leadership for this country and the country is responding. The social partners who are involved in the Programme for National Recovery are responding well. If those policies are continued, this country will be much better and far more prosperous for all of us.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

I welcome the opportunity to respond to the Minister's address this morning. Firstly, I will refer to the effect of mortgage interest relief on so many families, especially young couples taking out their first mortgage. I wish the Minister would respond and restore the mortgage interest relief when he comes in to speak to us later. The effect of both high interest rates and the added effect of reducing the mortgage interest relief is going to push more and more people on to the already over crowded housing waiting lists of local authorities. That does not apply to Dublin alone. Throughout the country huge numbers are queueing up for housing. My own local authority in Limerick who are responsible for a large county, will have 32 house starts this year. Obviously, there will be repercussions as more and more people are forced into a queue because they cannot afford to buy their own homes.

The Minister told the Dáil that if he were to restore mortgage interest relief to 100 per cent on £4,000 it would cost £55 million. He stated that it would benefit 325,000 people at an average benefit of £169 per annum. That may not sound very much but when one breaks it down to £3 per week to many people that is a tremendous amount. Senators on both sides of the House have referred to that issue and the Minister would do well to take the suggestions on board.

With regard to unemployment today, despite the upturn in the economy, despite today's Irish Independent figures indicating a bonanza in exports, I still look at my own city where I can see black spots of 91 per cent unemployment. Of course, the creation of additional jobs is an aspiration, but I hope it will be more of a reality than an aspiration. I cannot see jobs being created. I cannot see the cycle of poverty being broken in housing estates such as Moyross and Southill. I teach children from those areas and I understand the poor start they are being given in relation to supposedly being treated equally with the children of the nation, which they are not. The cycle of poverty is, like the Third World cycle, very difficult to break.

For the last ten years I have taught students for whom there was no question of being able to say, "Tá Dadaí ag obair," because he was not, nor was Mammy, for that matter. Their whole background is two and three generations of unemployment. It is impossible to talk about a work ethic to people who have never seen their parents in meaningful employment. I am not saying they are not working in the home, but they do not go out to work in the morning as should be the norm. Therefore, I cannot accept that anything is being done by way of a realistic approach to unemployment.

Reference was made by Senator Hussey to the social partners. For the last few months we have heard what began as small ripples of indignation, but which now have become quite vociferous expressions of indignation from the trade union sector. Certainly, they are not happy with the so-called improvements in living standards of employees. There is a lot more the Minister will have to do in that area.

Senator Foley in his contribution dealt with the development of tourism. Senator Foley is from County Kerry but I could not accept his comment that Kerry is a microcosm of the tourist success in the country. That county has a long tradition of tourism and it will always attract tourists, whether we are in the deepest of recessions or not. I do not think that is a good indication of how the tourist scene is throughout the country. Many of the people coming in and out of Dublin airport, Shannon airport, Knock airport, Cork airport and so on, are emigrants who are coming and going and trying to keep in touch with the homeland. Certainly, I would not quantify them as tourists. They are our own people who are living abroad, as a result of our economic problems. Small villages have been decimated. We are looking to the EC for a bonanza in relation to integrated rural development and there has been no mention in the Dáil or in the presentation to us today of the Structural Funds. I wonder what secrecy is associated with the Structural Funds. Other member states seem to be able to debate who is getting them, who has got them, how they are being used and not from the top down as happens, unfortunately, here through the Minister for Finance and the Government.

There has been no reference by the Minister to Community initiatives which have to be the way forward. We cannot be different from any of the other EC countries, and we must work from the bottom up and try to improve the standards of living of a country which is basically agricultural and rural. A certain percentage of our population live in urban areas but there will have to be alternative employment for people who are no longer able to operate successfully from farming. However, there is no mention of that.

In relation to VAT and our approach to 1992, I am very concerned with the sloth and tardiness of the Minister in relation to the precise rates of VAT and excise duty and the goods which will qualify. Already — I think it was last week on radio — I heard warning bells in relation to the cost of cars. We were all looking forward to having cheap cars and driving around using unleaded petrol, hopefully, but we will not be doing that at what we thought would be reduced costs. From what I gather, if one wants to get a cheap car one will have to go to the nearest travel agent, get a ticket for another country and pay hotel expenses. By the time all of that is paid the money saved on purchasing a car elsewhere within the EC will not be great. That is the first warning bell as regards VAT rates and what we were expecting, the pluses of 1992. Unfortunately, there will be more minuses. I am a positive person by nature but I am worried about that.

I would like to refer to retention tax and its application to professionals, particularly those who earn money within the public service. I am talking about county council officials, be they architects, engineers, solicitors, hospital consultants or GPs. It is very important that the Minister rectifies the situation so that retention tax relates to the current year's tax liability. In his Budget Statement some months back, the Minister made a commitment to get self-employed people to pay their tax on a current year basis. He stated that the problems which have been created by the long delays in refunding money withheld in excess of the agreed liability would be resolved. Apparently, they have not been resolved and that is something I would like him to take heed of. The Minister said that refunds would be given priority and would be processed within seven days of receipt of the relevant paper work, but that has not happened. I hope he has a greater commitment towards what he promised us in the budget.

In relation to education, as Senator Costello said, we have the highest pupil-teacher ratio within th 12 EC countries. We have a very high quality education system but, in years to come, and I am not looking too far ahead, it will be something that we will be associating with the sixties, seventies and eighties rather than the nineties. We are familiar with the statistics, we look at them, read them and cry out in horror but nothing is done about them. I asked on an Adjournment matter the financial cost of giving all teachers within the three unions the option of early retirement. One teacher union has it already and I was told the total package would cost £30 million. Not every teacher, thankfully, is that stressed that they want to opt out immediately and, certainly the package would not cost £30 million. However, the option should be there for any teacher. There should be equality among teacher unions and all teachers should be able to avail of early retirement because of the stress involved in teaching classes that are oversized. The alternative could mean the alleviation of stress and possibly would cost very little. When one can do something, one may feel that one should do it. Teachers should not be forced into a straitjacket and told they have to stay in overcrowded classrooms, or feel they have to live with stress. That is a simple matter that the Minister could have dealt with and I hope he will respond to it.

In relation to language development, we hear about integration in 1992 and about increase resources. I have seen nothing to show that the teaching of languages, such as German, Italian, Spanish, unlike French, which has been taught in schools over a number of years will be developed. It is grand to say that we should encourage our students to take second and third foreign languages. The University of Limerick will shortly be insisting that any student must have a European language, not just for studying the humanities, but also for science. If the money, and the resources are not there to tune those students at a very early stage — I am going back even to primary school — to language development they are not going to have the language. In that event it is more an aspiration, is theory rather than practice and that is something that has to be either supported or forgotten about. Again, in relation to the integration of new curricular programmes no resources are being given and that adds to the stress level of teachers. There will be no extra money and, therefore, we cannot blame the programmes if they are not successful.

Reference was made there to the environment. We understand the cost of conversion grants and the cost of trying to avoid pollution on farms and so on. Obviously, money will have to be given to specific areas. I referred a moment ago to the fact that there was no reference by the Minister to Structural Funds. In relation to the financial services centre in Dublin, I would remind the House that we have had a financial centre ready made in the mid-west since the establishment of SFADCo and the development of the industrial estate around Shannon Airport. It is the oldest in the country and is economically and socially viable. There has been much controversy over the last few months, as the Dublin lobby subtly pushed towards centralisation, rather than decentralisation. This is certainly not in line with the reasons we are getting Structural Funds. The Minister should cut out the squabble in relation to two airports and realise that the mid-west region has a tremendous employment level and has been successful since the fifties. It was the first financial services centre, perhaps even in the EC, but, certainly, in Ireland. It is extraordinary, when we have a successful decentralised regional policy active and alive, that nothing pleases the eastern seaboard, particularly Dublin, but to try to centralise again. For that reason I would ask the Minister in relation to Structural Funds, to take heed of the mid-west region because decentralisation, and the creation and retention of jobs is what we should be working towards.

Senator Hussey referred to submissions from the ICMSA and I am glad he is supportive of the farming community. The same law should apply to farming families as to PAYE workers and I hope the Minister will listen to him and us in relation to that. Small farmers in particular, did not do very well out of the meat bonanza over the last number of years and I hope they will be more vociferous in outlining their needs to the Government. It is the small farmer at the end of the day who is most at risk and for whom the crisis looms, and has loomed. To a large extent, it is those farmers' children who are emigrating and from 1992 onwards small farms will probably be deserted. Will we then wring our hands in horror and wonder why, suddenly, we are surrounded by deserted farms. We should be counterating that now, so that there will be a generation of young people who will want to stay here. At present they are not staying because they have no option. Parents are bringing up their children to emigrate. It is even more horrific in rural areas than in urban areas because there has always been mobility within urban areas. I am saddened by the fact that in rural areas we have an aged population and nobody to tend the grassland. However, we can rest assured that after 1992 Europeans with entrepreneurial skills will decide to make us the bread bowl of Europe. We are taking the whole 1992 business far too casually. I am amazed that the Minister did not address the question of Structural Funds which, surely, must be coupled with his business as Minister for Finance to save the country and future generations, if they are there to inherit the greenlands.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom, i dtosach báire, fáilte a chur roimh an Aire go dtí an Teach. Beidh mé ag caint go ginearálta ar an mBille Airgeadais.

I do not intend getting involved in local issues because the Finance Bill, basically, concerns all the citizens of the State. It is very general legislation but has a fundamental bearing on the direction the country is taking. It is a pleasure to be debating the Bill in view of the obvious and clear direction that has been taken by the Minister for Finance. We are now in the happy position that borrowing is being brought under control. I look forward to the day when we will once again have a balanced current account. On this level, we should also look at the question of increased capital expenditure, where necessary. I have never had any fundamental objection to borrowing for necessary infrastructural development. This should be done efficiently and effectively, and the sooner we put in the infrastructure the country needs the better. Another direction that any budget and this is a second or series of budgets, must take is towards providing the incentive to create wealth and then, of course, to try to achieve an equitable distribution of that wealth when created.

On the general tax front, the object must be to have low tax rates and high compliance and to make the tax system as simple as possible. For the lower paid, in particular, it is important to have coordination between the social welfare code and the tax code. As a person who believes very much in incentives for the many being as important as big incentives for the few, I welcome the steps taken over the last two years to increase dramatically the exemption levels for the lower paid. Our aim must be to try to raise these further.

I particularly welcome the recognition of children in the exemption limits. This year a person with four children on an income of between £7,700 and £8,000 or £150 and £160 a week, will gain, approximately, £10 per week. To have achieved that under the tax rates that applied two years ago, a person would need to have had a gross increase in their income of £17.50 a week. The recognition that was due to this significant improvement has not been given to it. I would like to see single people with an income under £5,000, and married people with an income under £10,000, being exempt from tax. The big question is, where does the money come from for such a change? My experience of people in employment is that some of the smaller tax reliefs that exist cause more hassle than they are worth. They would swop a greater basic tax free allowance for some of those reliefs. I refer as an example to the dependent relative allowance which gives a person on the 30 per cent tax rate 63p more per week.

There have been significant reductions in the higher rates of taxation. It is agreed that our higher rates of taxation are much too high. However, we also have to ensure that scarce resources are used in the best way possible. An example of that tax reduction is that a person with an income of £100,000 on the highest rate of tax is saving £5,000 as opposed to a saving of £250 for somebody with an income of £5,000 on the highest rate of tax. Despite significant improvements, a single person on an income in excess of £12,600 is still on the highest marginal rate. We should look again at increasing significantly the thresholds at which people move on to the higher rates of tax. Significant improvement could be made in this area at a relatively low cost. In reducing the marginal rate there are other things that could be done. For example, is it time that an upper limit was put on the total amount of VHI relief that can be given?

Another issue in relation to taxation which has caused problems which have, to a large extent, been solved, but not totally, by the increase in exemption limits is the fact that non-contributory pensions and widows' pensions, particularly, are taxable, while unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit is not. A raising of the exemption limits would solve this problem. However, overall, the total taxation package over the last two year has been significant. The removal of large numbers of the lower paid from the tax net has been one of the most revolutionary changes in the tax code in recent years. When we talk about income tax and incentives we must remember that most workers are on the lower rates of tax. Given the right incentive, and if each worker increased his or her output by 10 per cent, the overall effect on the economy would be dramatic.

In relation to corporation tax, I welcome the lowering of the rate to 40 per cent and the extension of the 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate. I also welcome the steps the Minister has taken to limit abuse in this area. The reduction of capital allowances is justified. We have argued for long enough that the tax relief on capital as a method of creating employment was a contradiction in terms. The increased take from corporation tax is welcome. It has long been my contention that the idea of taking high taxes through employment, transport, and so on, which are taxes before profit based on turnover, and low taxes on profits, is wrong. More taxes should be based on profits rather than on overheads or turnover.

Will the Minister examine the possibility of exempting, like people with overseas accounts, old age pensioners who clearly do not have a taxable income from DIRT tax on a long-term basis? This is administratively possible and desirable because many old age pensioners are not claiming the rebate they are entitled to under this scheme.

On the business expansion scheme, the business community will have to learn that when such tax relief schemes are introduced they are introduced for the purpose of creating risk capital. There can be no justification for abuse of these schemes or using them to attract funds for schemes that have no risk attached. Under these schemes people with large incomes can, effectively, increase their tax free allowance up to £30,000. If this is used to direct capital into risk-taking business it is justified. The move by the Minister to close the loopholes is welcome. By doing this he is helping businesses that have a risk factor involved and often find it difficult to attract capital.

Similarly, I welcome section 45, which provides tax relief on donations made to the trust for community initiatives. In the time allowed to me I will not be able to go into this matter in detail. However, we must look again at new ways of creating funds for development, particularly in rural areas where lack of capital can be one of the greatest inhibiting factors to the start-up of local enterprises.

On the question of computerisation and service to the public, at the end of the day the taxpayer should be treated by the tax office as a customer. I would like to pay tribute to the courtesy and understanding of the officials working in the Revenue Commissioners and in the tax collection system. However, I would like to see major development in this sphere to simplify the amount of paperwork involved for the ordinary taxpayer in making his tax return each year. As a first step, I suggest that when an income tax return is desired one would be presented with a tax form with a printed record of mortgage relief and all those details so that those figures would not have to be resubmitted to the tax office year after year. One would then be obliged only to fill in any changes in these matters. In this way a lot of the fear of dealing with the tax office would be eliminated. In relation to capital gains and inheritance taxes on farmers, it is time to look at this in a new light. We should ensure that no tax is paid on the transfer of small and medium type farms, upon death, to the nearest living relative.

Finally, I welcome the first steps that have been taken to bring us into line on the rates of value-added tax and customs and excise duty. As the economy improves under the present Government I hope we will be able to take further steps in that direction and that something will be done to reduce the cost of both motor cars and the excise duty on petrol which tends to discriminate particularly against people living in rural areas, so that we would not be out of line.

I compliment the Minister on his vision and the consistent direction he has taken in the last two budgets. I welcome the Finance Bill as presented to the Seanad.

Comment on this

I am glad to have the opportunity of making a few observations on the Finance Bill, 1990. Domestic policies and administration have visibly suffered by virtue of the fact that Ministers spend so much of their working week in Europe on duties associated with our responsibilities as a member of the Community and, indeed, now, having the Presidency. However, I congratulate the Taoiseach and his Ministers on that score.

It is important that public administration should not be neglected, even for the greater European cause. I would hope that our administration here, will introduce whatever re-organisation, even at Oireachtas level, is necessary to facilitate a situation that, hopefully, will be ongoing for the next 100 years, when the Community, in their policies will be calling on Irish Ministers to play their role in an ever-expanding Commuinity. Since all of these ideas will be financed by the Department of Finance, I hope the Minister will set up some commission or working party to see in what way the work of our Ministers, and Deputies, too, can be facilitated. It is unfair if either the constituents or the Departments here might suffer from lack of manpower or whatever because Irish Ministers must undertake greater responsibilities in Europe. This is clearly an area on which thought must be focused. I hope that the Taoiseach, after his six months' experience, will effect some changes to ensure that the six yearly rota of the Presidency, will be organised in such way as to ensure that public administration in this country will not suffer during our Presidency.

I would like to mention briefly a few areas where I feel decisions have been delayed for too long. In my own county there is the question of education. The Department propose to close five or six schools next month, yet the new college or community school board have not got around to appointing the architects to build the new accommodation into which they should be moving next September. To me, as a public representative for 35 years at local authority level, that seems to be a fairytale. It creates uncertainty, especially in the minds of parents, as to where their children should be educated and, indeed, what services there will be for them. It certainly creates uncertainties in the minds of the teaching profession who have been told that they are transferring to such and such a new complex next September when the first sod has not even been turned in May. Much explanation and straight talking is necessary. There should not be so much uncertainty about a subject as important as education in any county.

In the course of her speech Senator Jackman mentioned the problem of the retention tax as it effects the medical profession. I want to avail of this opportunity to fully support the case the Senator made. When the former Minister for Finance, Mr. MacSharry, introduced this measure, he gave very clear assurances in this House that the problem — if there was a problem — would last for one year after the taxation was brought forward. From speaking to medical practitioners who seem to be most affected by this scheme, it seems that all the payments from the health boards or whatever source are subject to the retention tax — that includes the expenses they receive in respect of secretaries, receptionists, clinics or accommodation. They now find that by the end of the year, when everybody else is expected to have their tax up to date, they cannot get a refund of tax until they have paid the following year's tax, so they are forced into a situation where they are paying tax on incomes they expect to earn in the following year. This is some change from the taxation system we have had up to now. There is also an element of expenses being taxed. This is the first instance, in my experience here as a public representative, where expenses are taxed. I hope this is not the thin edge of the wedge. Expenses are either expenses or they are not. I would ask the Minister for Finance to look seriously at this particular aspect which is causing considerable and unnecessary expense and hardship to the medical profession at a time when the Department of Health's policy is, very clearly, to transfer the greater responsibility for hospital care back to the community. This responsibility will be taken up by the dispensary doctors or the professional people working in the community. It is a poor recompense for the additional responsibility which these people are expected to undertake on behalf of the community if they are to be taxed in this extraordinary fashion. The Minister said when this Bill was being introduced that the disadvantages would only be apparent for one year. It is now in its fifth year. Some review of the present situation must surely be called for.

The Minister for the Environment recently announced many new areas which are to benefit from the urban renewal scheme. I must confess to a little surprise at the numerous green sites selectively included in the list for that scheme. One would have thought that urban renewal would apply to the renewal and modernisation of rundown urban or built-up areas. That does not appear to be the case at present. I am not too clear as to whether that is the responsibility of the Minister for the Environment or of those who made the submissions on behalf of the planning authorities throughout the country. However, it is something that warrants close examination. It would tend to discriminate in a very serious way against some people who had high hopes of getting benefits for renewal of the areas concerned.

In the question of agriculture, it is now quite apparent that the large amounts of money the Exchequer spent on the eradication of the bovine TB over the past 25 or 26 years have proved to be an absolute failure. Over the past few years quite serious outbreaks have occurred, even on State-owned farms, where one would expect that management should be top-class and where they would be observing every possible precaution and working with modern methods of husbandry and hygiene. What amazes me is even with everyday news items on this Mad Cow Disease overseas, our Ministers do not appear, in their utterances at least, to take the matter very seriously. Looking at the important role the export of beef and meat generally plays in our economy, the health of our farm animals must, or should, rank very high in the order of priority in the Department of Agriculture and Food and, indeed, with the Government in general.

I am rather nervous that greater emphasis is not placed on the whole question of animal diseases. It is quite clear, looking at the statistics, that we are not making sufficient progress. Surely the country is not bereft of sufficient scientists and professional people who understand these problems? It must be possible to look at what is achieved in other countries and decide by comparison whether we are making the same kind of progress. For the amount of hassle and work that the testing of animals causes to the ordinary farmers in the country, the returns are, indeed, moderate. Perhaps the time has come for a very significant review of the entire situation, if only to relieve the taxpayer of the cost of a scheme that has very limited effects, other than a window-dressing approach from the country's point of view.

I welcome the improvements contained in the Bill in section 127. I appeal to the Minister before the next Finance Bill to review the thresholds pertaining to succession, inheritance and gift taxes, especially where they apply to the agricultural sectors. This is very difficult. While he is providing for indexation in this particular case, it is necessary that he should reassess the entire area here. There are many instances, not just in the agricultural sector but where inheritance is concerned where families, both large and small are being faced with burdens that ultimately mean the disposal of the properties. In many instances this is regrettable. We should be getting away from that particular problem.

A Leas-Chathaoirligh, I would like to say that in years gone by we had distinguished colleagues on these benches such as the late Senator Alexis FitzGerald whose utterances on Finance Bills were a tremendous education to all. Listening to his approach to reviewing the finance legislation on a yearly basis, I think that with a Bill like this of almost 130 sections the appropriate place to raise the number of questions I have is on Committee Stage. I look forward to that.

Comment on this

I would like to congratulate the Minister on an excellent and far-reaching budget. I am pleased to note that he has made further progress towards achieving the Government's stated aim of reducing the standard tax rate to 25 per cent by 1993. The reduction in the standard rate to 30 per cent, and the reduction of the top rate to 53 per cent, should be welcomed by all parties. Although some have expressed dissatisfaction at the rate of progress to date, we need only look across the water at our nearest neighbour to have a vivid example of the adverse effects of drastic reductions in personal tax rates. Their inflation rate is currently touching 10 per cent. I need not remind the House that it was crippling inflation rates which contributed to the adverse economic performance of our country during the late seventies and early eighties. We should continue along the road of slow, but sure, progress towards our stated goal and not allow short-term considerations to stampede us into taking action which may have long term adverse consequences.

Having applauded the Minister, I would like to remind him — although he probably does not need reminding — of the necessity of ensuring that tax rates continue to reduce over the next few years. High rates of tax contribute to unemployment, impede enterprise and particularly disadvantage this country in the context of the Single Market. The reduction in the VAT rate from 25 to 23 per cent is a helpful step in that context. It will also have a beneficial downward effect on inflation and will reduce the cost of living across the board. It will be of particular help to low income families in the reduction in the cost of a wide range of household items. I seek an assurance from the Minister that his colleague in the Department of Industry and Commerce has taken all the necessary steps to ensure that this reduction has been passed on to the consumer. I would also like to say I am a little disappointed at the absence of any price reductions due to the decline in the value of sterling. I ask the Minister whether any monitoring has been done to see that these lower prices have been passed on to the consumers.

Pay-related social insurance falls heaviest on the lower paid as there are no tax-free amounts which may be earned before full PRSI is levied. In this context the new PRSI exemption for those on low wages of £60 per week or less is an extremely welcome move towards relieving this burden. I seek the Minister's assurance that this limit will be increased at least in line with inflation for each subsequent year. I also call on the Revenue authorities to adequately advertise this exemption to ensure that all of those who are entitled may avail of this appropriate tax relief. In addition, I urge the Minister to ensure that a widespread advertising campaign is commenced to advise families of the possibility of obtaining a total exemption from income tax due to family size and low income. We should strive to ensure that all those who are entitled to such benefits are adequately advised of their rights.

I would like to thank the Minister for his recent initiative in making tax exemption on moneys received by severely disabled persons from court-awarded damages. This is an extremely humane move. It will mean a lot to the families concerned at a little cost to the State. I trust the Revenue authorities will take the necessary steps to ensure there is no abuse of this provision. It would be a pity if genuine cases were to suffer in the future by restrictions being placed on the scheme because of any irregularities.

I would just like also to mention — and I think it has been mentioned by quite a few of my colleagues — that I am aware from meeting with constituents that many elderly persons are unaware of their possible entitlements to a refund of the DIRT tax. Many of these people have modest savings and are now suffering the DIRT tax on their small savings. They are unaware that due to their low level of income they may be entitled to a refund of this tax. Every effort, therefore, should be made to ensure that all eligible persons are encouraged to approach their local tax office and query their entitlements. Many people, and particularly the needy, find it difficult to deal with bureaucracy. I feel we owe it to these people to make a special effort to reach out and help them.

In this context I would call on all of the main banks to redirect a small proportion of their large advertising budgets to aid the elderly customers. I would suggest that the banks consider drawing up a brochure which would simply and clearly explain the procedure by which the tax may be reclaimed. Such a brochure should be freely available in all their branches. In addition, bank officials should be educated to make customers aware of this facility.

The dramatic increase in Dublin property values has brought many people into the property tax net for the first time. Many families who have grown children are faced with high education costs and find it extremely difficult to meet this extra tax. It is particularly difficult for many individuals as they must meet this property tax bill out of income which has already been subject to high personal tax and full PRSI. Therefore, the reintroduction of child benefit for property tax purposes must be welcomed. We must always remember that rising house prices have made this tax applicable to very many people particularly in the Dublin area. We should not dismiss out of hand any claims for relief under this heading on the grounds that property tax applies to rich people.

As well as welcoming the Minister's reintroduction of child benefit under this heading. I would strongly urge him to consider the reintroduction of child relief into the mainstream personal income tax code. This would dramatically improve the financial position of couples with young families. At the current time there are people who are facing the full brunt of increasing educational costs and increasing mortgage repayments. Any positive move in this area by the Minister would be very welcome.

As the Minister is aware the change to the current year basis of assessment is a very major change in our tax code. This change is going to create many transitional problems for self-employed business people and their professional advisers. Any tax system can only work effectively and efficiently if there is co-operation from all sides. The implementation of a current tax year basis of assessment so soon as after the introduction of self-assessment is placing a very heavy compliance burden on the self-employed business person and his professional advisers. I hold no brief for people who work in the black economy or who are not willing to meet their obligations to pay the correct amount of tax. I am speaking on behalf of the honest taxpayer who is faced with a bewildering series of changes in the taxation code, having planned and protected his business expansion and his future growth on the presumption of a five year basis of assessment, and all the implications that may have for capital allowances. He now finds that the rules have been changed. If I may use a sporting analogy, the Minister changed the rules two years ago by the introduction of self-assessment; he has now moved the game to a new playing pitch by the introduction of the current year basis of assessment. I feel that this underlines the necessity of putting in place a statutory method by which major changes in our tax laws should be made the subject of informed debate by interested parties prior to the budget.

I understand that the Minister cannot give any indication in advance of changes in relation to revenue collection. However, I feel that major policy changes could be indicated in advance, perhaps in the form of a Green Paper. The circularisation of a Green Paper would allow all interested parties to discuss in detail and make their recommendations concerning these proposals prior to the budget. The necessity for this is particularly borne out by the experience for the current year basis of assessment. This was mentioned by the Minister in his speech. The exact details, and even confirmation that it was to be introduced in the current tax year, only became known on the publication of the Finance Bill on 29 March 1990. Interested parties, therefore, only have three short months to digest extremely technical changes in the legislation. I trust the Minister will agree with me that the fullest co-operation of the professional bodies in the operation of the tax system makes the Minister's and the Revenue authorities' jobs much easier. I would suggest to the Minister that this co-operation cannot be one way only. The Revenue authorities' themselves must co-operate with the professional bodies. My suggested Green Paper approach to the major tax law changes could allow all interested parties to make considered and well thought out submissions. The increasingly technical nature of tax related legislation, which is the old system, is no longer relevant.

Another area I would like to urge the Minister to review is the restriction on claiming entertainment expenses as a tax deduction. I trust the Minister would agree that in today's business world if we are to compete on the international market it is imperative that companies be free to entertain their clients in a similar manner to foreign competitors. At present all such expenditure on entertainment is not allowed for tax purposes. Therefore, actual monetary cost to a company is almost double what it would be if a tax deduction were allowable. I feel that legitimate and fully vouched expenditure should be allowed. I feel that the impact of same on revenue returns would be quite low, due to the fact that companies pay modest amounts of tax in the first place due to tax relief, and additional revenue would arise on extra activity in the hotel and catering industry.

We must not forget that the hotel and catering industry is a major provider of jobs. It is they who ultimately suffer from the lack of companies spending due to the lack of a tax deduction. This is an area which would require examination in conjunction with our stated aim to improve and encourage growth in the tourist industry. In Dublin, we have lost thousands of jobs in the manufacturing area and this is the area in which we are looking for these jobs. The Minister might take this on board.

Finally, I would just like to mention, as I have no doubt the Minister knows, that the provision of créche facilities is becoming more and more a part of conditions of employment. The provision of same should be encouraged by the State to facilitate women who wish to remain or return to the workforce, but who have growing families. In order to quell the fears which have been expressed to me by a number of people, I would particularly ask the Minister to address himself to the following questions. What is the Revenue authorities' attitude to the provision of créche facilities? Do they consider them to be a benefit in kind accruing to the employees? Will they, in any circumstances, seek to tax same as a benefit made available to the employee? Will the Revenue authorities allow full deduction by the company providing the créche facilities for all the costs involved? Individuals have expressed doubts to me as to whether such a deduction is allowed on the basis that Revenue would argue that the expenditure is not exclusively in the course of trade being carried out by the business. I would like a positive response from the Minister, as it would relieve a lot of women's anxieties in this matter.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is there any interest in the Finance Bill from the opposite side of the House? I do not see any pseudo-intellectuals who spend all day, every day, talking about everything. There are no members of the Labour Party. No one is offering at all. Have they any interest in this Bill?

Comment on this

Could we have a quorum?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

In fairness there were a fair number of speakers.

Comment on this

Could we have a quorum?

Comment on this

Tá áthas orm seans d'fháil tagairt faoin Bille seo.

Comment on this

You do not have an option once a quorum is called.

Comment on this

There are a number of Fianna Fáil Senators here but no Sénators from the Independents, no Senators from the Labour Party and only one Senator from the main Opposition party. We would be very happy to join the call for a quorum.

Comment on this

Seeing that I have the floor, may I just make a comment? I am delighted that Senator McDonald is on the benches opposite. It is a pity there are not a few more of his Fine Gael colleagues with him. However, I am really extremely disappointed that there are no Labour Senators and, indeed, no Independent Senators——

Comment on this

On a point of order, it has never been in order to refer to the absence or the presence of Members of the House. I would ask you to rule with the Standing Orders at your disposal. The procedure should be followed here, irrespective of who is here or who is not. I think it is a disgrace to start off naming the——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

No particular Senator has been named. Senator McKenna has the floor.

Comment on this

Could I just mention to Senator McDonald that in actual fact it was widely publicised in the papers exactly what——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, a quorum has been called for and you have no option but to ring the quorum bells.

Notice taken that 12 Members were not present; House counted and 12 Members being present,

Comment on this

Is this an unusual situation in the Seanad when the Government side who were already very well represented, they find themselves in a situation where there was no speaker offering on the Opposition side on this perhaps the most important Bill of the year. It would have been a great pity to have allowed the debate to come to an end. It does seem an extraordinary situation when the one and only Senator on the Opposition benches finds himself obliged to call for a quorum to be present.

Comment on this

As you rang the quorum bells, Sir, the leader of the Independent group and the leader of the Fianna Fáil group were having a discussion on the availability of speakers and the length of time of the debate. The leader of Fianna Fáil had indicated that there were quite a number of speakers left on the Fianna Fáil side and, in order to accommodate that, I had just told him that I would simply go in around 6.30. That is the record of the events. However, I can assure you, Sir, that the question of calling for quorums in this House is a technique which is used quite regularly. It is used quite regularly to draw attention to certain things. Now that the matter has been used and started and abused, to my mind, in order to——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are dealing with the Finance Bill, Senator, and I am ruling you out of order.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, we did not ask for a quorum.

Comment on this

I can assure you, Sir, I am glad to note the diligence of the Government side of the House——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I would ask you to resume your seat, Senator, we are dealing with the Finance Bill and you are out of order.

Comment on this

Could I ask who is in possession, Sir?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator McKenna was speaking when Senator McDonald called for a quorum, which he is entitled to do under Standing Orders.

Comment on this

I think then you should correct the record. It was not a question of nobody offering from the other side of the House. There was a Fianna Fáil speaker in possession. Let the record show that.

Comment on this

I want to reiterate that it was not a Fianna Fáil Senator who called the quorum. In fact it was Senator McDonald who called the quorum——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I would ask the Senator to return to the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I just set the record straight? I called for a quorum after a Government Senator called attention to the fact that certain persons were missing.

Comment on this

There was no mention of individual Senators——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The quorum is present. Let Senator McKenna continue on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I drew attention to the fact that there was none of the pseudo-intellectuals there, that there was nobody from the Labour Party——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Please resume your seat, Senator McCarthy.

Comment on this

We are now back to the name calling which we are accustomed to from the far side of the House——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am asking Senator McKenna to continue on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

As I said initially, before I was interrupted, I welcome the opportunity to say a few words on the Finance Bill and to congratulate the Minister for Finance in bringing forward such a Bill. As a number of speakers have said, it is a very complex piece of legislation and, in bringing it forward, the Minister and the Government have proceeded along a path they started out on some three years ago. It is widely acknowledged on all sides, by all people from every area of activity within the economy, that the Government must continue to reduce our huge debt. We have daily demands for a reduction in tax burdens and the lowering of interest rates. It is an extremely difficult task for the Government; it is not nearly as easy as some people might suggest.

This Finance Bill and the Programme for National Recovery provide the evidence that the Government are determined to achieve a balance in the current budget and are prepared to take action to do so. The proper management of the economy over the past number of years has placed the country on a firm road to growth. I am glad that it is the Government's intention to continue in that particular vein.

Exchequer borrowing as a proportion of gross national product has been reduced from 13 per cent in 1986 to just over 2 per cent in 1989. By any standards this has been a remarkable achievement in such a short time. Our balance of payment deficit has been wiped out and there has been a surplus over the past number of years, with a surplus confidently predicted this year again. As a teacher, I remember regularly explaining to students, when they asked, why we had a constant adverse balance of trade. The standard explanation for this constant adverse balance of trade — it was contained in all the textbooks and all of the economists were at one as to the reason for it — was that the demand for imported products far outweighted the demand for the home-produced products and that our exports were not able to match the demands for the imports. It was commonly accepted that this country, being such a small open economy, depending so much on international trade, it was natural to have an adverse balance of trade but the Programme for National Recovery over the past couple of years has proved this theory to be very wrong.

The signs are there also that the huge problem of unemployment is beginning to reduce. It is accepted on all sides that no one likes the level of unemployment we have; it is one of our major difficulties at the moment. However, people must accept that in order to tackle this huge problem the proper economic climate must be created. Those who expressed the view that unemployment could be reduced overnight were, to say the least of it, being unrealistic or in many cases politically opportunistic. Now that that climate has been created considerable progress is being made in relation to the whole area of unemployment. The key sectors in the economy are making very steady progress on job creation.

Mention of job creation brings me back again to the area of taxation and the proposals contained in this Finance Bill. The reduction in the tax rates and the changes in the tax bands have been brought about in a situation where there is a high level of dependency on the people who are working and paying tax. I am very glad the Minister for Finance has returned, because I want to take the opportunity to congratulate him in relation to the lowering of the tax rates and also the widening of the tax bands. The reductions have been achieved against a background where our National Debt is consuming over 80 per cent of the Government's main source of income, namely, income tax. This, in the circumstances, is a marvellous achievement and one on which the Minister must be warmly congratulated. I also welcome the extension of the self-assessment system to put self-employed people on a current year taxation basis.

I welcome the curbs being introduced in relation to the business expansion scheme. That scheme was set up initially to help to promote and encourage developoment in business where there was risk, but ways were found around that where in quite a number of cases people were availing of this scheme but in actualfact there was absolutely no risk involved. I welcome also curbs on the definition in relation to manufacturing industry for the purposes of the 10 per cent corporation profits tax rate.

A very welcome development in the Bill and one on which, again, I congratulate the Minister, is contained in section 9, which exempts local authorities from paying income tax on investment income. This measure could save local authorities millions of pounds. As we speak, a number of local authorities have been served with income tax assessments and threats of court action in respect of huge sums of money through prudent investment and that type of thing. If this section was not included and if local authorities had to pay these demands, then there would have been a huge increase in rates on commercial property and service charges or indeed a combination of both. This section removes an anomaly whereby one State sector, the Department of the Environment, were paying money to local authorities in the form of block grants, road grants etc. and another sector, through the Inspector of Taxes, was taking it back in the manner mentioned. All local authorities, when they see exactly the benefits accruing from this section, will see it as a very welcome step in the whole area of taxation reform.

Turning to the question of poverty and the measures outlined to tackle that problem, I am disappointed at the Conference of Major Religious Superiors and their criticism relating to social welfare and that the budget was anti-family. I am surprised that such a body would make such misleading and inaccurate criticism. The Minister, and indeed the Government, have given the highest priority to social welfare. I think the package of benefits over the past few years given to the unemployed and other dependants is ample evidence of the Government's commitment in this area. The Minister devoted a very substantial part of his budget speech to social welfare and to the elderly and disadvantaged.

The Conference of Major Religious Superiors stated there was no commitment to implementing the recommendations of the Commission on Social Welfare. The four priority areas in that report are being followed by the Government, and it has to be stated that 40 of the 65 recommendations in that report on social welfare have been already fully or partially introduced by this Government. As the report states, many of those recommendation can only be introduced on a gradual or a phased basis. How the conference can say that the budget is anti-family is a mystery to me because this budget increases the child dependant payments, child benefits were increased, there is a new carer's allowance, a clothing allowance, increases in adult dependants allowance, free fuel and the free travel is extended. If that is anti-family, all I can say to the Minister is: continue the work and let us have more of this anti-family legislation.

The Bill is very complex legislation and the Minister is to be sincerely congratulated on the magnificent job he has been doing and is doing in this Bill. I wish him well and ask him to continue the good work.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I want at the outset to take strong issue with the remarks of Senator McKenna in relation to the Conference of Religious Superiors. These remarks are totally out of order. Nobody can question the bona fides of that body and their commitment to the alleviation of poverty. I think they are one of the most progressive elements in the Church at the moment——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I would also make the point——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I did not criticise the working of the Conference of Major Religious Superiors. What I criticised——

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

You criticised their comments.

Comment on this

——was their comments in relation to social welfare. It is a totally different thing. If the Senator is making comments in relation to what I have said, he should quote me accurately.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

The implication of the remarks of Senator McKenna is that they were acting in an improper fashion. What I would also say — the point has to be made; it is a hare I did not intend raising when I came in here — in relation to Senator McKenna's comments he is misleading in his presentation of the carer's allowance because the carer's allowance in the Social Welfare Bill is a means-tested allowance and will be inaccessible for the vast majority of carers. The amount in question is approximately £45.47 and then to qualify for that amount the means-tested person would have to have a non-existent form of living.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

It is important for the record that we put those things straight.

Now, to address the issues in the Finance Bill, what I propose to do is to take six or seven pertinent issues arising from the Finance Bill that I think should be immediately addressed. The first question is the extraordinarily high level of interest rates that we have in this country at the moment for the commercial sector, for the agricultural sector and for personal borrowers. Interest rates at the moment are about four times the rate of inflation. We have an inflation rate of approximately 4 per cent; interest rates are approximately four times that amount. How that we have the Minister in the House — I appreciate the fact that he is presenting the Bill in the House — I want to say in very clear terms to him that it is time the controversy between himself and the Central Bank came to an end. It is time we got interest rates at a realistic level instead of what is the case at the moment. I am alluding to the newspaper commentary——

Comment on this

Do not believe what you read in the papers.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

It is important that we get a proper level of interest rates at the moment. The second point I would like to make in relation to the Finance Bill is that, given that we are in the EMS, at present there is reasonably small risk of currency fluctuations. That is why I propose the Minister should undertake or should underwrite the risk for businessmen and farmers in this case. What I am saying is that there should be loans in Deutsche Marks for farmers and business people to give them the chance to avoid the penal level of interest rates in existence at the moment and to improve our economy and create employment.

I would argue that at the moment, with the dreadful reduction in the standard of living of our farming community because of falling agricultural prices and with the crisis in employment reflected in the number on the live register and in the high level of emigration, it is incumbent on the Minister to look at every possibility, at everything that can give a realistic chance of job creation and that can give the farming community some viability at the moment. I put to the Minister that one very easy method of achieving this is to have special loans in these categories in Deutsche Marks because of our membership of the EMS and to underwrite the risk here.

It is important that the point be made in the discussion on the Finance Bill that the role of my party in the last couple of years has been in stark contrast to the role adopted by Fianna Fáil when the last Coalition were in power. At that time many leading Fianna Fáil politicians took issue with every attempt to bring the public finances into shape. We have adopted a much more constructive approach to the national finances and a much more constructive approach to Opposition than was the case then.

One of the aspects of the Finance Bill which I feel is worthy of welcome is the adjustment in the BES scheme. I believe the adjustments in the scheme were in order because there was a gross abuse here and a gross waste of public finances.

The move towards a reduction in personal taxation is welcome, but it would be my submission that in the interests of equity and job creation we would need to progress much further on the road of reducing personal taxation.

In the area of indirect taxation the gap between us and the other European countries and the kind of indirect taxation adjustments that will be necessary in the 1992 context have not been achieved and there will be radical need in the next two budgets to reduce indirect taxation. The Minister on this occasion did not go far enough to make a more even spread in the reduction.

Along the Border with Northern Ireland where I come from there is a grievous problem for the trading community there, for the business people and, indeed, for the ordinary citizens because of the differential, particularly in the cost of petrol, between prices in Northern Irealnd and the Republic. The great problem with people crossing the Border — it is their constitutional right; they cannot be stopped doing it — is that when they cross the Border to buy petrol they buy many other items as well in all of these shops that have grown up in the Border region. I believe that is causing a chronic situation in the whole northwestern area and the area around the Border. It is incumbent on the Minister to address this question in a very radical fashion in the short term; otherwise the penal situation will continue for the traders in that area. It also gives rise to smuggling, and the only people who are involved and profiting from the smuggling along the Border are known terrorists. For that reason it is again critically important that that question be addressed.

I do not propose to rehash all that has been said all day except to make those couple of observations. I think these matters are worthy of consideration as they reflect the defects in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

At the outset I would like to welcome the Minister to the House and the Minister of State as well. The Minister, in particular, has to be singled out and congratulated on doing a splended job in running the financial affairs of this country, which had gone out of bounds completely. While I agree with many of the remarks of Senator O'Reilly, there were some I could not agree with, especially when he said that this Government were not doing enough. I remember a Government, of which the Senator's party were part, between 1983 and 1987 and all they ever did about running the finances of this country was an amount of shadow boxing. They were talking about getting the national debt under control and they were talking about reducing——

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

On a point of information, they brought the finances under control despite destructive opposition.

Comment on this

——income tax to proper levels and so forth and all they seemed to do about it was talk. During that period the national debt actually doubled; it went from something like £12.5 billion or £13 billion to £26 billion. This Government had to come in and bite the bullet. They have done a darn good job and the Minister should be congratulated for his foresight in trying to get the affairs of this nation into proper perspective.

Everyone would like to see more improvements with regard to the income tax bands, but at least we are moving in the right direction. Last year we had reductions and we had them again this year. The Minister, in his address to us this morning, indicated he is going to continue down this road, which is the correct road. At the end of the day it will give more incentive to young people to work overtime and to produce more. At the end of the day, I think we will create more employment. I am delighted there is a reduction in the standard rate of income tax — down to 30 per cent — and I am quite sure the Minister and this Government will bring that down to 25 per cent within the next couple of years, and they will have to be congratulated on that.

Significant new reductions in the personal income tax of all taxpayers have been referred to. Then you have another development — the self-assessment system. I believe this was badly needed because people, particularly private business people, used to get enormous assessments from the Revenue Commissioners and they had to prove that the money was not being made. The self-assessment system is very good and very fair.

I also compliment the Minister on the initial steps to reduce indirect taxation, to help lower inflation and to bring the rates closer to European levels in preparation for 1992. It is very important that we would not be thrown in at the deep end in 1992.

Another matter I would like to speak about is the designated areas. I am delighted that in this budget the Minister is extending the period from 31 May 1991 to 31 May 1993. This will qualify people in the designated areas for the urban renewal tax relief. This is a move in the right direction because in large towns and cities, where the centres were deteriorating rapidly, these incentives made a great difference as there was massive growth. I compliment the Minister on that and I should like to see it expanded.

The Minister should also include seaside resorts which depend on a very short tourist season, from July to the end of August. People in those areas are trying to make a living in eight weeks. They also pay full rates and insurance on their premises and they just cannot make enough money in that period to upgrade their premises. If the incentive scheme could be expanded to include Ballybunion, Ballyheigue and other seaside resorts in County Clare — many of which have become shantytowns — and people could get the incentives granted to other areas, they would reinvest in their own premises and bring them up to proper standards. The Minister should look at that.

I am also glad that the projects are approved for grant-aid for the industrial development agencies, the hotel and tourist industries on or before 31 December of this year. I would also like to see some kind of incentives being introduced for the large land banks of property owned by the IDA or Shannon Development. There is definietely a need for some type of tax incentives which would encourage people to invest their money.

The business expansion scheme, which was mentioned by all sides of the House, has been abused. It was a good scheme, there was nothing wrong with it. However, there were loopholes and I am glad that the Minister has closed them. It was a very good scheme and rural areas will benefit from it. If people come up with the right ideas many towns all over the country will benefit from the business expansion scheme, which could help to provide indoor facilities, recreation facilities and leisure areas. A lot could be done in that area.

This Bill has gone a long way towards creating employment. The emigration trail is slowing down and unemployment is on the decrease. That is due to Government handling of our affairs for which they should be highly commended. This legislation will also take us a step further in keeping our young people here. I congratulate the Minister and the Government on this legislation.

Comment on this

I welcome this important legislation.

Comment on this

I wonder why the debate did not move across the floor of the House.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As I understand it, there is a long list of names. I am going by the list in front of me and the Senator may speak after Senator Mooney.

Comment on this

That is precisely what caused a row 15 minutes ago. We are working on a list of names but somebody from the far side of the House stood up and said that nobody from this side was offering. Will they get their act together over there? You have to have agreement on how to operate the business of the House. Perhaps we might have a quorum?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator O'Toole, please resume your seat.

Comment on this

I am sorry that my——

Comment on this

The point should also be made that, pro rata, we have had far more speakers from this side of the House than the Government. The Government have 32 Members, our party have 15 and ten have contributed already today. Let us get the facts on the record, stop the nonsense and get this Seanad on the road it should be.

Notice taken that 12 Members were not present; House counted and 12 Members being present,

Comment on this

I am sorry that my complimentary remarks about the Minister's excellent Finance Bill were caught up in a flurry of vocal activity a few moments ago. This legislation is probably the most important going through either House of Parliament at present. It sets the financial agenda for the 12 months and indeed, as elements of this Finance Bill show, it sets the financial agenda well into the nineties. There has been a budget and this Finance Bill reflects the pragmatic, flexible approach that has all the marks of a successful businessman, which Minister Reynolds is. It is also coupled with Christian compassion and those of us who know the Minister will not be surprised at that approach.

I, too, should like to congratulate the Minister for acting so quickly to ensure that recent awards by the courts to handicapped members of our society will now be tax free. Congratulations are due, not only because of the decision but because of its swiftness. Those of us in political life who are familiar with the mandarins in the Department of Finance, irrespective of the Administration in power, will know what I am talking about when I say that decisions of this magnitude are not normally, or usually, made in such a short period of time. It is to the credit of the Minister and his personal intervention that it has taken place.

On a more general level, the improvement in the external reserves are also welcome because, surprisingly enough, while it may seem like dull reading to the vast majority of the population, the swings and roundabouts of the external reserves impinge on the daily activities of the population. Specifically, one hopes that further improvements will result in a mortgage reduction and give practical effect to the very real tax improvements in the recent budget. The 4 per cent increase in mortgage rates over the past 12 months, due mainly to external pressures and reasons, is causing extreme difficulty for mortgage payers. The Minister is to be complimented for his remarkable restraint, however, in framing a budget that recognises the continuing serious financial difficulties facing the country while, at the same time, conceding that the hard-pressed taxpayer can at last see a narrow but increasingly bright shaft of light in the areas of tax reform and tax reduction.

It is interesting, in the context of the contribution made earlier where talk of the national debt was bandied around, that despite the remarkable restraint of the Government and the previous Administration in 1987, the national debt is still at the horrifically high figure of £25 billion. It puts in context the profligacy of the previous Coalition Administration from 1982 to 1987 in doubling that debt. It is usually fair game for the media, and for certain sections of the political establishment, to fire brickbats at a Fianna Fáil Administration for profligacy. That sort of selective criticism——

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

What about the 1977 manifesto?

Comment on this

——is not a true or accurate reflection of the reality that since the early eighties, and at a time when Fianna Fáil were not in Government, we had the highest level of emigration, the lowest level of economic activity and an increasing tax burden. Those are facts that, sadly, are not always highlighted in the proper places. However, I do not wish to take up too much time dealing with the past. Fianna Fáil have always been a party of the future and I am proud of that.

I would like to recommend that the Minister press ahead with tax equity especially as it applies to trading differences between North and South. The Minister with his business background, is only too well aware of the difficulties facing traders in the Border counties as a result of the disparity in VAT between North and South. I join with my colleague, Senator O'Reilly from the neighbouring county of Cavan, in highlighting the difficulties that traders and the general population have in relation to those disparities in the tax regime that operate between North and South. I would be interested to learn if the Minister's enlightened approach to the VAT regime — a reduction from 25 per cent to 23 per cent — has benefited the economy rather than leading to a reduction in Exchequer receipts. The latter was the perception among certain economists who for years have resisted any suggestion that a reduction in indirect taxation would be of benefit rather than an inhibiting factor in generating more income for the Exchequer.

In the context of North-South relations this is an opportunity to reflect, albeit briefly, on the highlights of the Taoiseach's speech to the Institute of Directors in Belfast recently on his historic journey to that city. He highlighted the disparities, not only in the tax regime between North and South but in the imbalance in trade between North and South. The statistics in relation to the intra-trade relationship between the people of this island made depressing reading. I hope the Government will redirect their efforts, in consort with the social partners, to generate more economic activity within the island and so benefit, and give added prosperity to the national population. It is a said reality that some 60 years after partition there is still the partition of the mind as well as the physical partition of people between North and South. Northern businessmen think in terms of moving to the United Kingdom and Europe, while Southern businessmen orient themselves away from their Northern neighbour. This requires debate and analysis. It has been ignored and neglected for too long. The Taoiseach, by highlighting these imbalances in our trading patterns, has at least set the ball rolling and started a debate that was long overdue.

I would like to make one specific suggestion to the Minister and I raise this hare practically every year on the Finance Bill. Will the Minister initiate a discussion within his Department, on setting up a tax free enterprise zone along the Border counties? The economic and political climate in recent years has been against creating more tax breaks. The trade union movement constantly criticise successive Governments for feather-bedding industry. The taxpayer is constantly saying that the Government are not spending money in the right places, particularly if it does not apply to their area. It is interesting to note in a recent report that the biggest economic growth area in Ireland over the next decade surprisingly will not be the east coast or Dublin and its conurbations but the mid-west. Apart from the natural attractions of the mid-west, its geographic location and its energetic and enterprising people, this economic growth will take place because of the enlightened approach of successive Governments to the tax free zone operating out of Shannon. It has, to some extent——

Comment on this

I am sure it also had something to do with representations.

Comment on this

——created that perception now. The reality is that the mid-west will be the growth region over the next ten to 15 years. It is in that context that I, respectfully, suggest to the Minister that, because of the unique dispartities economically between North and South, evidenced specifically along the Border counties, he might consider giving a tax-free enterprise zone status to counties, such as my own, which have been ravaged economically, more so perhaps, than our neighbouring Border counties. I know that when one governs one must govern for the whole country rather than for part of it, but this is something that I could not in conscience ignore.

As I stand in this House I must highlight, once again, the economic disparities as they affect my own county of Leitrim, especially in light of the imminent withdrawal of the ESB from the Arigna coalfield. I must refer to the resultant economic impact that will have, not only on my own town of Drumshanbo, but over three counties with the loss of upwards of 250 jobs in an area that traditionally has not an industrial heartland. It is something that will to be very difficult to contend with. It will be very difficult for the various State agencies, and local enterprises to attract the type of viable industry that will be necessary to maintain the people in my county and the region. The reality in economic terms is that business people will not look to my part of the country automatically to invest their money. They tend to go to other areas such as the Shannon free zone, Dublin and large centres of population. It is because of this natural handicap and their geographical location that counties such as Leitrim are suffering from the traditional impact of emigration. I once again urge the Minister, and the Government, to consider some realistic alternative to the existing incentives for private investment to encourage enterpreneurs to set up not just in the area where I come from but in other parts of the country which are economically declining and which need that extra little lift.

My colleague, Senator Kiely, referred to the seaside resorts. The Minister may respond by saying that if he was to set up tax free zones in every part of the country the entire country would become a tax free zone. I am making the argument for my own part of the country because of the handicaps it has experienced and suffered. I do not have to remind the Minister of this. He is intimately aware of the difficulties facing our part of the world and his own county of Longford. I hope he will continue the work he has started of reducing indirect taxation. He was the first Minister to reduce direct taxation. We are truly fortunate to have a person of the calibre of Deputy Reynolds as Minister for Finance at this critical time in our nation's history.

Comment on this

I would like to put it clearly on the record that there was an agreement between the Whips about the order of speakers and the method of dealing with today's business. We have bent over backwards to accommodate the Government Whip, and the Leader of the House to get the business disposed of today and to proceed to Committee Stage tomorrow. We entered into the debate in a spirit of co-operation and goodwill so that everybody would have their say. Before the row in the House I checked with the Leader of the House who indicated to me that he had a number of Fianna Fáil speakers waiting to contribute and he said "that is fine, let them go ahead." I deeply resent the implication that came from the far side of the House. I regret that the spirit of co-operation could not have even lasted more than ten days. However, I suppose we should be used to it at this stage and not be surprised. That is politics. I am a slow learner but I have finally got the message.

I should like to compliment the Minister on the amendment he introduced yesterday in the Dáil. I welcome the fact that he was able to respond so promptly to a real problem. He dealt with it efficiently and effectively. Everybody welcomes it and it is a tribute to the Minister that he was able to respond so quickly.

In dealing with the Finance Bill it is also critically important that we look at the economy as a whole. The economy is, of course, not the cosy, rosy scene we hear it might be. First, we seem to get a consistent flow of conflicting reports on the state of the economy. I always look forward to the Minister's budget speech and, indeed, to his words when presenting the Finance Bill. Now and again I would like to see an economic medium-term forecast from the Department of Finance, not from the Central Bank or the ESRI, issued in a publication we can depend on to indicate the thinking of Government in certain directions. There should be an official record in the same way that we get the quarterly report from the Central Bank and the reports from the ESRI. I should like to indicate the kind of chaos we come up against. There is a debate going on at the moment as to whether the reunification of Germany will affect interest rates. That would seem to be a load of nonsense. I find myself on the Minister's side on this. I do not honestly see how the changes in the German economy are going to trickle through and cause a worsening of Irish interest rates. My understanding of it is quite the reverse. The changes in the German economy can easily be absorbed by the Deutsche Mark and will not result in any desperate shock effects running through Europe. I do not believe they will worsen Irish interest rates.

Over the past number of months it has been noticeable that reserves are growing rapidly. I would like a response from the Minister as to what stage in the growth of reserves he expects the Central Bank might move to reduce interest rates. We are now at a very crucial time for the development of the economy as a whole. There is a sort of rule of thumb we always apply, that the building game is probably the best reflection of the state of the economy. There has been a massive upsurge in building in the past 18 months. However, we should take note of the fact that in the last month house sales have levelled off. From my information, they have dropped. Houses which a few months ago were selling like hot cakes are now sitting on the market. One of the reasons is the higher mortgage interest rates and the threat of even higher rates. It seems to me that the quicker the Central Bank resolves the doubt as to whether our interests rates are likely to go up or down the better. We have had an increase in reserves which, by now, should be at the stage where the Central Bank would think about reducing interest rates, or at least setting in train the process which would lead to a reduction in interest rates. On the other hand, there is a doubt about the shock effects through the European economy arising from the reunification of Germany. I do not think this will trickle down to us for the simple reason that the German economy can absorb the total affects of the exchange rate with the Ostemark which will only account for approximately 5 per cent of the West German economy. That will not have any shock effects on the West German economy and, even if it does, the excellent and plus balance of trade in the West Germany economy will allow it to absorb an awful lot more. I do not believe that German reunification will affect our interest rates. If some economists believe it will I would like them to specify how. I am sick and tired of listening to them surmising and making forecasts without explaining how they make the link between Berlin and Dublin. At least they have failed to do that so far. I would like the Minister to clear up that point. If that is the case we can say, without a shadow of doubt, that interest rates in Ireland will, in fact, reduce in the short term.

A recent ESRI medium term commentary took the view that interest rates do not necessarily have to rise. More and more people have been saying that in the last week or so. If we could have that clarified the house market could sort itself out and there would be some buoyancy, but I believe prices plateaued out in the past month or so or just before Easter which is traditionally the start of the auction season. The market seems to be stagnant at the moment. That is critical and should be sorted out.

In listening to the speeches, particularly from the Government side, I heard a welcome for the fact that in general terms our interest rates are far lower than they were some years back and that our inflation rate is among the lowest in Europe. There was a welcome for the fact that it is only a fraction of what it was a short number of years ago and that there is control of the national debt. If anybody thinks that a Government, or a Minister for Finance, no matter how skilled or excellent he or she may be, or how efficient or effective the Department of Finance may be, can deliver these kinds of results by simply sitting in ivory towers of offices and taking decisions they are mistaken. That is not the case. It should be understood by people that the developments that have taken place in the economy, particularly in the past three or four years, have been brought about by a co-operative and determined drive between the social partners. I would like to put that firmly on the record.

I have defended the Programme for National Recovery in many different fora over the last number of years. It is important to recognise that it has brought a certain stability to industry and to workers on the shop floor. There is now a sense of stability. It is important to note that the part the trade union movement played in that was crucial. It allowed the Government implement their philosophy and objectives.

However, income tax is the area which is causing most problems. I would like to go back three years to 1987 when the Minister for Finance of the day announced that he would, in the following years, relieve income tax payers to the tune of £220 million. That was to be worked out on the basis of £70 million per year. I would like to put it very firmly on the record, because it is important that this be noted, that no matter how much we argue with Government progress should always be marked and new targets established. The Minister did not wait for three years to implement the £220 million worth of cuts. In fact, that figure was exceeded within 18 months, within two budgets at least, and has been far outstripped at this stage. I do not mind putting this on record, as one who has been critical of the Government on such issues, that they discharged their commitment on the question of income tax. They more than discharged it and, in fact, are well above the figure of £220 million. I want to put that in a context. This involves referring back to the time when that agreement was signed in 1987. At that time we were deep in an economic recession and belt tightening was called for and supported. Co-operation came from all sectors. In the meantime, there has been a massive growth in the economy and an average growth of 4 per cent in the past three years. If I am wrong on that, I am sure the Minister will correct me. Certainly the figures are in or around — depending on who you listen to — the 4 per cent mark. Taking that into consideration, I would now say to the Minister that we need to look at income tax for the future. I take a slightly different line to my colleagues on both sides of the House. I have certainly communicated this to the Minister on a number of occasions. I listen very carefully to people, and I certainly listened to the previous speakers referring to the trade union movement. The trade union movement have very strong views on income taxation. I would like to hear from the Minister, because it needs a certain political will and courage to take this matter in hand. There is also a bottom line about the reduction of income taxation. We should not be raising people's expectations by saying that we can go on reducing income tax levels. I have always talked in terms of fair taxation. I certainly do not believe, on my understanding of the economy, that we could ever sustain and survive on an income taxation standard rate of 25 per cent. That is too low. I am putting that on the record. I do not think that would create the income and the revenue for the State that we need in order to do things, whether it be the reopening of the Ballyconnell Canal which was mentioned by the previous speaker last year, or the Arigna Mines. These things will not be done on 25 per cent taxation. It is not possible to go too far below the 30 per cent mark. I would certainly feel that about 28 per cent is as low as we can ever afford to go. My own view is that there should only be two rates of income tax. That is the way it should be looked at. There was a commitment given by Government that before 1990— as I recall — two thirds of the taxpayers would be on the standard rate. We have just reached that figure, or very close to it. I am not sure if it is one above or one below, but it is very close.

I compliment the Government on achieving that level of taxation. I think our target should be 75 per cent of people on that rate. The standard rate means standard rate. The people who are above the standard rate should be the exceptions. I would certainly like to see the number of people on the standard rate being three out of every four — 75 per cent in other words — and the remaining people on the higher rate, whatever that happens to be. There should be two rates. I can sustain that argument by saying "let us hold the bottom rate somewhere around 28 per cent". I do not think that 25 per cent is an attainable target. It is one of those things that goes down well in the pub. It sounds great, but it just does not work because it will not balance the books. There is no point in just pretending that it will.

From my point of view the most annoying feature of the changes in taxation over the last number of years — and we could go back years to the change in the taxation system — was in 1980 when capital taxation accounted for approximately half of a percentage point of total taxation. I certainly would want to hear a response from the Minister on this point. In 1990 we are now talking about capital taxation being approximately 0.6 of 1 per cent, by my calculation, of the total tax take. So while capital taxes have gone from 0.5 of a percentage point to 0.6 of a percentage point, the income taxation on the other hand has gone way up. I just do not believe that we can sustain that kind of thing. That really is where the problem is created. It is not the rate of tax. It is the people who are not paying their fair share. I listened with some amusement to the question of the tax breaks. I think it was Senator Mooney who just said: "Let us open the particular tax breaks that we have available in Shannon and also at the docks centre". I would just like to tease those out. I would like to put a few things on the record about it. I am not one for knocking grant schemes. I think they are good, even if they only result in a few jobs for the lads who work on the building sites.

Comment on this

You do all right.

Comment on this

I do. It is my source of income. We have a position now where people are moving into the docks site. Take the AIB — and I am not singling them out for any particular reason — who have moved from Ballsbridge to the docks centre, and consider the financial effect of that move on economies in general. My understanding is that they shift part of their overseas operation, part of their mainland UK operation, and instead of operating it through one of their UK companies, they now operate it through the Customs House Docks company. That is all very well so far. The profit that is gained by the UK operation is shifted directly and immediatly from Manchester or London or wherever it is, to the Custom House Docks Centre, where 10 per cent tax or whatever is paid on it when you have allowed for management fees and consultancy fees and all the other odds and ends. Who gains and who loses in that? I would just like to have it on the record Minister. Is it the British taxpayer who loses out and we gain? Is it part of the European culture? Is it something we should be worried about or is it something we should be glad about? Is it neighbourly? I would just like to understand how in fact it works.

Comment on this

The Senator should not worry about it.

Comment on this

I just like the look of gift horses. I always like to look them straight in the face.

Comment on this

You are not objecting to UK taxation.

Comment on this

Not at all. I am quite clear about what is on my mind. I would be worried about Senator Mooney talking about the difference in the——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator has two minutes.

Comment on this

I will finish when I am finished. That is the answer to that one. I apologise, a Chathaoirligh, that was not meant to sound——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

My Standing Orders are here in front of me.

Comment on this

I am sorry, a Chathaoirligh, you have to refer me to Standing Orders because——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I understand the agreement was made this morning. Senator Brendan Ryan had 30 minutes as spokesman for the Independents.

Comment on this

We had agreed on many things and on all sorts of ways of doing business until people started breaking those agreements. I have some more to say. I would advise you that I would wish to continue to say what I have to say. I am not going to go on all night.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I have to tell the Senator he has two minutes and that he is wasting time.

Comment on this

I am not going to be thrown around any more by these people here. There was a gentelman's agreement on how we could do business today but that was overthrown by the far side of the House.

Comment on this

On a point of order, could I make it quite clear that from this side of the House we continue to have speakers operating? We are very happy to see the Independent Senators come in for their full allocation of time. No action was taken which would have in any way prevented the Senator coming in.

Comment on this

For the record and in response to that point, there was agreement on the number of speakers. The Leader had indicated the number of speakers he had. We said: "Let those people go through." At that stage somebody said: "Why is there nobody offering from this side of the House?" I am not going back into the whole thing.

On the question of the Shannon free zone, I would also ask the same question. I do not understand the leasing companies' operation. We have a system where if, let us say, Air France decide they want to buy an aeroplane, they go to the Banque de Paris or they go to one of their satelites in Belgium or Luxembourg. Those are two of the European countries who do not tax dividends. They buy shares in a company based in the Shannon free zone. This company leases back an aeroplane to Air France. The profits of that company are paid back to the bank in Luxembourg or in Paris who own the shares in the company. The money gets finally back in that untaxed way. Who gains in that particular operation? What do we gain from it? I think it is a tax trick; that it is a cheat, unless somebody can explain to me in a better way how it works. I just do not understand it.

On the question of income taxation I would like to raise one point which I intend putting down as an amendment on Committee Stage and I would like to hear the Minister's response to it. It is a question of the writing down allowances: I found it in section 243 of the Income Tax Act, 1967, that is, the allowance for assets of short life. One of the difficulties about that was that when that section was written in 1967 there was a different concept of obsolescence to the present position. The position that is there at the moment is that many capital items being used in offices, or wherever, can be written off in a much shorter time than two years.

I am particularly thinking about computerisation, computerised products and computer hardware. It is very often the case in small companies nowadays that they buy and set up a computer system to help in the operation of the company. They are only allowed to write off maybe ten, 12 or 20 per cent, it varies, and I think in one case it is up to 25 per cent, in fact, for a year or so. They can write off the assets over a period of time. The reality is — and the Minister and I know it — that there are computers that are out of date in two years. There are many companies who replace their computer system in less than three years. We should recognise that, because it is hurting small industry and small business. There should be a special allowance in that section to allow companies to write off certain assets which become obsolete by virtue of technological advance. For instance, if you take the new UNIX system of computerisation which is going to boom through the world in the next 18 months anyone who went into one of the previous systems last year is now, in effect, out of date. Any company that wants to keep abreast of developments will find itself, not able to write that off. So the company which set up a new system two years ago now find that it is out of date and has to replace it although they only got 20 or 35 per cent of a write down on that particular asset. I do not believe it is good enough. The amendment that I will be proposing would allow companies like that to give the equivalent of 25 per cent on a reducing balance basis on the cost of such assets. It is very clear. It is not an item which anybody can pull a fast one on. The hardware is there. It is clear enough if it is out of date or if it is useful for the company. There is another aspect. A company which is developing very quickly and which expands quickly will very often find that the computer system and the technology installed have no longer the capability to deal with the expansion of the company. Therefore, it has to replace it with brand new technology, technology which it cannot write down.

I want to make one final point. I am conscious that there are other speakers, and we want to get the business finished. In a new programme, and negotiations will definitely begin in any new programme towards the end or this year, there has to be a commitment to share in benefits. That is one of the reasons I am talking about the tax level. We have people talking about improving the health service and I am talking about improving the education service and all social benefits but that costs money. We do not get it for nothing. The workers are also entitled to decent standards and increases in wages and salaries over the next number of years. That also has to be paid for, whether it be in the public or the private sector. We should recognise that fact. One of the things I am most worried about — and it is my final point — is the child allowance. I do not have time to develop my view now, but if things go the way they are, not only will there be nobody to pay our pension in X number of years' time but there will not be anybody to turn out the lights. The management of the population is going to be the most serious thing that we will need to adjust to in the next ten years. Having said that, there is only one way of approaching it and that is to have pro-natal policies from the Department of Finance to encourage people to have families that will ensure that the State continues. This has operated very succesfully. There is a case for pro-natal policies. I would certainly ask that those allowances be increased. I firmly believe that the fertility rate, which has shown an increase in both France and Sweden in the last number of years and is on the increase in other areas, will also increase in this country. The developed countries are watching this. We need to bring into law proper facilities for maternity and proper allowances for children.

Comment on this

Is this INTO policy? Keep up the numbers of children.

Comment on this

My point is that every child is one-thirty fifth of a teacher's job. I could go on at length. When I stood up I intended to speak at length as a form of protest, but I have said what I wanted to. I will revise the other matters on Committee Stage. I am conscious that other people want to speak.

Comment on this

I would like to congratulate the Minister on a very imaginative and far reaching budget. Many of the measures in it would have been impossible a number of years ago. I am glad to read today that the economic strategy is working. We have a £314 million trade surplus, which is one sign that we are going in the right direction. As Senator O'Toole mentioned — and it would definitely get support on this side of the House — co-operation between the employers, the trade unions and the Government is one of the main planks the Government set out when they came into power. It is a very important one. If one is to look at England, the unfortunate thing about it at the moment is that not alone are the Government not co-operating with the unions but they are insulting them. In a small country like ours, it is essential that we work together. I hope that the agreement between us all will continue for many years to come.

I would agree with the points Senator O'Toole made with regard to interest rates. The link between Dublin and Berlin was one on which many economists spoke saying that there would be great gloom and doom and that it would send interest rates soaring but they never explained why. In fact, a number of economists were on the radio one morning saying that it was a brave man who would say that interest rates in Ireland were not going to rise because of what was happening in Germany. If I may say it, obviously the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach are brave men because they predicted what was going to happen, and they predicted it correctly.

One of the many welcome features in this year's budget was the announcement by the Minister of the employee PRSI exemption scheme for persons on very low incomes. The effect of this scheme is to exempt employees whose gross earnings are £60 per week or less from employees' social insurance in respect of that week. Although I confess that I am puzzled by the fact that the maximum relief appears to be £3.50 rather than the £4.65, which would be the amount of PRSI payable on £60, and perhaps the Minister could clarify if such is the case.

However, when we talk about low paid workers, I think it would be fair to say that that would be an apt description of people earning much more than £60 per week. We are all well aware of the large number of single young people, many of them highly qualified, who are paid no more than £6,000 to £8,000 per annum and whose PRSI deductions alone are from £465 to £620. In addition, because they are single their qualifications for tax allowance is minimal. They are the people who are so fed up with their lot that many of them are giving up their jobs and emigrating in search of a more benign climate as far as tax and wages are concerned. Much of the fault, of course, lies with employers who are exploiting the situation for their own ends by paying wages far below what is just reward for the skills they are being offered. However, it would be a help if the Government would see their way to encourage these young people to stay by offering them some incentives.

I have noted an idea put forward elsewhere by Deputy John Stafford which was, perhaps, not heard by the Minister. I would like to make a similar proposal here. I would suggest to the Minister that he should examine the possibility of exempting the first £60 per week from PRSI payments in the case of those whose gross earnings do not exceed £8,000 per year. This would at least be a first step in improving this situation. The Minister has already shown himself to be imaginative in his concern for the less well off in our society. I am confident that he will examine this suggestion at the earliest possible time.

Comment on this

I am not going to commence my contribution by congratulating the Taoiseach or the Minister. I would congratulate the Minister on his stamina, listening to the debate not only in this House but in the other House. No doubt he has put in very long hours. I hope his arrival in this House will be a bit more pleasing to him, having spent so long in the other House. Neither am I going to agree with Senator Eoin Ryan in regard to his reasons for congratulating the Taoiseach and the Minister. He failed to mention that the interest rates here are four points higher than with the Deutsche Mark.

In my discussions with businessmen in recent times I notice they are tending to become extremely cautions as compared with 12 months ago. I am sure that development is known to the Minister also. I know that he is taking on board what the businessmen of the country are saying. Not, indeed, that I wish things to go that way but we must keep our fingers on the pulse and see which way things are going.

The Minister has been bombarded in relation to many points in the budget and, indeed, many points that were not in the budget. I am not going to bombard him a great deal. I am certainly not going to repeat much of what has been said. I have no doubt that he has taken on board all the points made by the Senators today, as he usually does. There is extreme concern for the small businessman. Some Senators spoke about that. This is the point I would like to make to the Minister. We have small businessman particularly in the service area. The IDA have indicated to us that they are stepping up their efforts to increase activity within the services area. This is where they see the greatest opportunity for further, increased employment. I am not disagreeing with that. As a matter of fact, I wholeheartedly agree with the efforts being made by the Government with regard to tourism. I have no doubt that increased tourism will bring an increase in employment in the service sector.

A greater effort should be made with regard to tourism. It is going to be increasingly difficult to attract industries to this country now that all the walls and barbed wires are coming down in the eastern part of the Continent. Tourists who have been looking at this country are turning their eyes in other directions. I have no doubt as the years pass there will be more and more attractions for them. Certainly the new governments in these east European countries will be looking at ways of attracting new industry. That, of course will increase the difficulty of the IDA and others who are interested in attracting tourists here. We will have competition that we did not have to face before. It is going to have a major effect.

I would urge the Government to redouble their effort with regard to tourism. The citizens of Europe, and especially Eastern Europe will in the future flock here because we have attractive resources. We have a climate that will attract them. Certainly there are some who will go to more sunny parts, the Algarve and other parts of southern Europe, perhaps, but once they have got the sun for a couple of years their attention will be turned to what Ireland has to offer. I sincerely hope that we will be geared to receive them when they come. I would draw the Minister's attention to the effect that the tax system is having on the services sector which will be unlikely to make a substantial contribution to employment as long as the present high taxation policy on services remain.

The services sector, unlike manufacturing industry, is the most heavily taxed sector in the Irish productive economy, excluding the drink and cigarette firms. Most services pay the full 23 per cent rate. They do not benefit in any way from the low 10 per cent tax rate on profits. They receive few, if any, subsidies. Where the customer is the Government, many services are further discriminated against by the policy of withholding payments against anticipated tax demands.

A sine qua non to expanding employment in services is a reduction in the heavy burden of taxation upon services, especially in relation to self-employed services. The total Government take from such businesses can easily exceed the take home pay of a sole employee. An employee as an unmarried person earning a net £7,000 could expect to pay the Government income tax and VAT totalling between £7,600 and £8,000. I will give the Minister figures in a few minutes. Obviously, our high rates of income tax have a lot to do with this extraordinary situation, but the real culprit is the high rate of VAT on services generally. If the Minister is serious about expanding employment in the services sector the very best thing he can do is to reduce VAT on services to not more than 15 per cent. I urge him to have a look at this area. Ideally I believe the reduction should be to 10 per cent or even 8 per cent. I can assure the Minister this simple amendment to the present Finance Bill would do more than any other change to secure a massive increase in service employment in this country.

In relation to the figures I have just given, I could point to a small firm operating in this city where a self-employed director is paid £10,000. His tax is £3,000; his take home pay is £7,000. Business use of the car is £5,000 and if you include petrol there would be approximately £650 tax on the petrol, which I have not added in on the other figures I have given. The general business expenses of the same firm are £5,000, bringing in a net turnover of £20,000. Add VAT of 23 per cent to that and it comes to £4,600, £24,600 in total. Of the £24,600 the total take home pay for that person is £7,000. The total Government take, including the £650 tax on petrol, would be £8,250. There is something substantially wrong when a self-employed person is working more for the Government and contributing more annually to the Government than he is earning for his own family. There is something seriously wrong there. I would ask the Minister to have a very serious look at that. I have given the example of a very small firm. The greater the proportion of business expenses to salary the worse is the position in that respect. This is very serious and if the same position obtained within the PAYE sector I predict it would lead to a national outcry.

I will refer briefly to the activities of the national lottery and I express my own and the concern of others at those activites, at the manner in which they appear to have taken over gambling in this country. Probably not many Members will have known — because the matter did not receive much publicity at the time — that I did not vote for the establishment of the national lottery even though it was initiated by my party, then in Government, and although I was at that time a Member of this House, I refused to vote on it because I did not like the idea. When I see the hype of publicity given to gambling, the massive sums of money involved, with people now glued to their television sets for that three minute slot on Saturday evenings, when somebody may be lifted out of the sphere of everyday life into perhaps the destruction of their soul, never mind body, I am convinced we have gone beyond the bounds of reasonable activity with regard to gambling. I would ask the Minister to take a serious look at the activities of the national lottery. I reiterate that there is grave concern that they have taken full control over that type of activity within this State to the exclusion of all others.

I know there are other smaller lotteries in operation and I contend it is wrong that the national lottery will not locate their machines or allocate tickets to outlets sponsoring other charities. It is my firm belief that traders have a constitutional right to sell what they want, within reason, on their premises. Equally, I believe the matter would not withstand the test of a court case if such were taken. The great hype of publicity devoted to national lottery activities is pushing out smaller ones. I am thinking in particular of the Rehab Lottery. I know there are a couple of others in smaller areas. Naturally traders are attracted by the hype and the large amounts of money involved in the national lottery.

I hope I have managed to draw the Minister's attention to the concern of many people at the lack of information emanating from the national lottery. I have written to them requesting information on the amounts of money accruing to them from particular areas. I fully appreciate they cannot detail the take from every outlet but undoubtedly the overall figure could be broken down considerably more than was done in their most recent publication so that we would have an idea of the yield from areas such as, say, Tallaght, west Tallaght, Terenure and others. Again, I would ask the Minister to take a very serious look at the activities of the national lottery.

Comment on this
Albert Reynolds Minister for Finance (Mr. A. Reynolds) Fianna Fáil

I want to thank all the Senators who contributed to this debate and to respond as best as I can in the time available to me.

I will take up the last point made by Senator McMahon in regard to the activities of the national lottery. I understand the Minister for Industry and Commerce has the matter to which the Senator referred in hand and is on the point of taking appropriate action as a result of an inquiry carried out by the Director of Consumer Affairs.

I shall deal now with the other points raised in the course of the debate. I might add that many of the detailed questions posed can be dealt with at greater length on Committee Stage.

To begin, it was ironic that Senator Doyle should have suggested that the Government's budgetary policy is too soft since her party, when in Government, were simply unable to deal with the huge problems obtaining in the public finances in 1986. They took the easy way out allowing the debt to roll up, year after year, until it reached the stage at which the country was on the point of international bankruptcy.

The fact is that Exchequre borrowing is now at its lowest level in 40 years. The situation has been transformed in the past few years. The Exchequer borrowing requirement has fallen from £2,145 million or 13 per cent of GNP in 1986 to £449 million or 2.1 per cent of GNP in this year's budget. The debt-GNP ratio was stabilised in 1988 and has now begun to fall at a significant rate: down from 131 per cent at end-1988 to about 123 per cent at end-1989 and it will fall further this year. This is dramatic progress by any standards.

The pace of reduction in Exchequer borrowing has, in fact, been even more rapid than expected. Last year the budget envisaged an Exchequer borrowing requirement of 5.3 per cent of GNP but in the event we reduced borrowing to 2.4 per cent of GNP.

Against this background the priority this year was to consolidate this exceptional progress while, at the same time, doing things which needed to be done to develop the economy, reduce inflation and ensure greater social equity. We managed to introduce major packages of tax reductions and welfare measures and, at the same time, to keep Exchequer borrowing down to £449 million.

If the Government had gone further in reducing borrowing this year this could have caused difficulties for the economy, especially given the somewhat slower pace of economic growth internationally as compared with last year. I am quite satisfied that the balance in this year's budget was right — continued downward pressure on borrowing, combined with new measures to promote growth and jobs.

We must keep things in perspective. While we undoubtedly have a problem with the overhang of debt, our level of annual borrowing is now below the average in the European Community. I might also put our performance in context by pointing out that West Germany's general Government borrowing requirement stood at 2.1 per cent of GDP in 1988. It will be seen that we are in good company.

Let me assure the House, and Senator Doyle in particular, that there is no need for concern about this year's budget targets. The Government are determined to achieve them and are on course for doing so.

It is true that the end-march returns showed that borrowing for the first quarter was rather higher than had been expected at the beginning of the year. I explained in my statement on the 1st Quarter Exchequer Issues why non-capital spending was running ahead of expectations. It was due essentially to timing factors relating to the receipt of European Social Funds on education and to higher than anticipated health expenditure due to the increased incidence of influenza in the early part of the year and to a greater than usual rundown in health board overdraft facilities. The timing factors and the run down in health board balances will correct themselves as the year progresses — they are well on the way to self-correction — and indeed should have worked themselves out of the system by the end of June half year figures. Let me add, indeed, that the latest expenditure data available to my Department indicate that spending is now back broadly in line with expectations. It is the Government's intention to continue to monitor developments on spending closely for the remainder of the year to ensure that the budget targets are achieved.

I can assure the House that the revenue picture at end-April was quite satisfactory and continues to be good in May. This does not support Senator Doyle's argument that the budget arithmetic was based on an over-optimistic estimate of tax buoyancy. Indeed, some outside commentators said at the time that my Department had been over-cautious in their revenue forecasts.

However, I accept that there is no room for complacency in regard to the public finances. I said at the time of the publication of the first quarter Exchequer returns that the Government will be monitoring trends closely over the remainder of the year, in the light of developments at home and abroad, to ensure that the budget targets are achieved again this year.

There is nothing in the other economic indicators to suggest that the assumptions underlying the budget are optimistic. All the indications are that new car sales and retail sales generally are in line with expectations.

The Bill to establish the debt management office is practically drafted at this stage. I expect to be able to introduce it in the Dáil shortly. I do not see any difficulty in setting up the office within the general time scale I indicated in my budget speech and in staying within the estimate for debt-servicing costs this year.

Turning to our forecasts for the medium-term and what should be our objectives, again Senator Doyle felt they were too soft and would be achieved automatically with the economic growth in prospect. This view is far too optimistic. The objectives I announced in my budget speech are to reduce the debt ratio towards 100 per cent of GNP in the period to 1993 and achieve a broad balance on the current budget account, in other words, to do away with the current budget deficit. These objectives are by no means unambitious. On the contrary, as I pointed out in my budget speech, they will be difficult to achieve while at the same time addressing the other problems facing us. Success will depend on continuing tight control of expenditure and, in part, on the continuation of a reasonably favourable international climate. If conditions should enable us to do better we will, of course do so, as we have in the past three years.

Does the Senator genuinely want us to aim for an end-1993 debt ratio of 75 per cent of GNP? Does she not realise that this is totally unrealistic? To achieve such a target would require progressive improvements to have a negative Exchequer borrowing requirement, that is, a surplus of more than 10 per cent of GNP by 1993. This would require an unsustainable adjustment and, to put it in context, by comparison with our economic policies for 1990, an average net reduction in annual expenditure of some £2 billion or an increase in taxation of the same order. The Senator conveniently avoided addressing how this could be done and how at the same time we could accommodate further reductions in income tax rates and the requirements for harmonisation of taxes within EC levels. She, like her colleagues elsewhere, did not say whether her party would support the necessary measures.

As an indication of constructive opposition which we are told exists and the consensus politics which still exist, when concluding the debate on the Finance Bill in the other House yesterday evening I added up the cost of all the amendments put down by the Opposition parties which came to the princely figure of £937 million.

Comment on this

That was the other House.

Comment on this

Is that what they regard as consensus politics and constructive opposition?

It is all too easy to set targets but they will have meaning only if they are part of a coherent overall financial and economic strategy. Given the great progress we have made since 1986 in improving the public finances there should be no doubt about the Government's determination to continue this process.

A number of Senators expressed concern about the level of interest rates. I fully agree that interest rates have a vital role to play in generating economic activity. Indeed our success in reducing rates after we assumed office in 1987 played a major role in our subsequent improved economic performance. Despite recent rises in interest rates I would point out to Senators that since March 1987 — to take the key three month rate as an example — the differential between Irish and UK interest rates has improved by well over six percentage points and the differential with the corresponding German rates has improved by well over five percentage points. This is a dramatic improvement in competitiveness terms and is the true measure of the interest rate gains arising from the policies being pursued by the Government. However, let me hasten to add that I consider rates generally to be too high and that the differential between Irish and European rates has further scope to improve. With the lessening of uncertainty about future events in Germany, I would hope that pressure on interest rates will continue to ease as we move into the second half of this year.

I have noticed in recent weeks that belatedly many economic commentators are coming around to the view that the level of our external reserve has improved quite significantly — the low level of our external reserve and three other international factors led to the increase in interest rates in December — and that we are in a much healthier position now than when the Central Bank report was issued some time ago.

When people talk about interest rates it does not matter what line of business you are in — a small or large business, industry or agriculture. I have always believed that the level of interest rates is a key factor in determining the level of economic activity we will have. The Government will continue to pursue the policies which will lead to lower interest rates. However, the ultimate decision must always be made by the Central Bank who have the independent statutory authority to fix our interest rates, bearing in mind the level of reserves and the operation of monetary policy. As I have said, I hope that with the lessening of uncertainty about future events in Germany the pressure on interest rates will continue to fall.

One of the interesting factors in the trade figures which were published last night was the increase in our exports to the United Kingdom market. Despite the fact that the punt is very close to parity with sterling — sterling has depreciated by some 16 per cent over the past 12 months — the most encouraging factor from those figures was that we still managed to increase our exports into a market where we had to take on board that level of depreciation of their currency as against our currency. Many of our indigenous companies still use the British market, to which 35 per cent of our exports go.

Comment on this

That was a great achievement.

Comment on this

I believe it was a great achievement. It is the best news to come from figures published over the past six or 12 months.

Senator Doyle also referred to the decision to extend the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing beyond the year 2000. Indications were given on a number of occasions last year that the question was being considered. The CII and other organisations had looked for an early decision on the matter because international business planning now has a very long time span and companies wished to know now what the tax situation would be post-2000. The issue was, therefore, becoming increasingly important for the IDA, SFADCo and other agencies, in their endeavours to attract foreign multinational companies to invest in Ireland. The key tax incentive we have to offer to these multinational companies, which are one of the most important sources of new jobs, is the 10 per cent rate. Before the Government took their decision, a study was carried out by an international consultancy firm on Ireland's competitiveness vis-à-vis other regions in the EC for attracting internationally mobile investment. The Government, therefore, had the findings of this study in mind as well as other relevant factors when they took their decision.

EC permission was not needed when the 10 per cent rate was introduced for manufacturing in 1980 and it is also not needed for its extension now to the year 2010. The extension is not affected by any EC proposals for harmonisation of corporation tax rates. The EC Commission had put forward proposals of this nature in 1975 but had to abandon them earlier this year because of the lack of progress in proceeding further with them in the intervening years.

Senator Brendan Ryan advanced the view that high tax rates do not impact on an individual's enterprise or incentive to work or on job creation. I find this view surprising. Detailed empirical evidence may be hard to come by. Real international comparisons are difficult and will depend very much on the income levels you take. It seems clear to me, however, that people work to earn and are anxious to see a good return for their efforts. That return is very much affected by the level of the tax rates facing the individual. If you face a tax rate of 35 per cent rather than 30 per cent or 58 per cent rather than 53 per cent, then clearly the return from your effort is going to be affected. Your willingness to take up a job, to work overtime when it is required or to accept promotion naturally takes account of what you can expect to gain by it. That is not the only motivating factor, of course, but it would be idle to deny that it is a motivating factor.

Employers' attitudes to taking on workers also come into the picture. If it costs too much with high tax rates to employ additional workers then employers will be less inclined to increase their labour force. It still takes £2.90 to give £1 extra to a single employee on the average male industrial wage.

Tax improvements also have an important role in the vital area of wage moderation. This factor was clearly recognised by the trade union movement in the negotiation of the Programme for National Recovery. As Senator O'Toole rightly said, in the programme the Government gave a commitment to introduce income tax reliefs costing some £225 million on a cumulative basis over three years. As the House will be aware, the Government have introduced reliefs costing over £800 million in cumulative terms over that period. These reliefs have had a substantial effect in creating the conditions for wage moderation which is so important for our international competitiveness and so important, therefore, for our ability to sell our goods on the international market. I am sure I do not need to remind Senator Ryan of the success we have achieved in this area. You cannot, therefore, look at tax without taking the need for pay moderation into account if we are to have more jobs. The foundation stone to the success we have achieved was undoubtedly the Programme for National Recovery.

When people are debating this matter there are a couple of issues they seem to leave out; everyone conveniently seems to ignore the huge bill which is building up for the harmonisation of taxes; the lower rate of tax has just been reduced from 25 per cent to 23 per cent. I have heard many Senators, those who live near the Border and some distance from it, refer to this. Senator McMahon referred to the effect on the service industry by bringing down rates but he must remember that there are bills to be paid and that we do not get anything free. Realistically our rate will have to be in the area of UK standard tax rates, if the UK are not going to move up. It is unlikely that that will happen. Therefore, we are talking about a standard rate somewhere in the region of 17 per cent. That will be some bill to have to pay. I believe that it is the only answer to the problems of smuggling and the distortion of trade between North and South. It is an objective that we should have. At the same time we are facing the position in the Community that any possibility of a harmonisation of DIRT tax, which is a big Exchequer earner here, seems very remote. It is still on the table but very remote. We are at 30 per cent and the tax will probably bring in more than £200 million this year. That is an issue.

There is another issue that people tend to ignore although I accept that it will be a once-off cash-flow problem. I am referring to the dismantling of VAT at the point of entry. That has to go and will mean a further cash call on the Exchequer, whenever it is done, and will involve about £150 million. When people suggest that tax rates should come down they should remember that there are many bills to be paid. We will have to bear in mind certain timetables. Those who suggest that the targets for 1993 to achieve a balanced current budget deficit and eliminate the Exchequer borrowing requirement is soft should look behind the scenes and take all factors into consideration.

I have noted the points raised by a number of Senators regarding the indexation of capital acquisitions tax thresholds. I am aware that problems can arise in this area and in my review of capital acquisitions tax this year I accepted that some degree of movement was desirable, I had, however, to balance this view against the fact that the yield from this tax was only some one-third of 1 per cent of total tax revenue in 1989 and that substantial changes in this area, in particular, any significant increases in the thresholds, would reduce the yield and would lead to a narrowing of the tax base.

While bearing in mind these factors, I included important reliefs in the Bill, including a provision for the indexation of the thresholds. These thresholds will, in future, be indexed in value each year and this will give valuable relief. The revised thresholds will apply to all gifts and inheritances taken on or after 1 January 1990. I would also point out that it has been possible since 1985 to make provision for inheritance tax by way of special insurance policies. These policies are very popular and the amendment at section 130 of the Bill will enhance their popularity. I am sure Senators will agree that my proposals in this year's Bill represent a reasonable and realistic response to the circumstances.

Senator Doyle asserted that I have no strategy for tax reform and that my policy was not radical enough. She suggested, as her party have been doing for some considerable time, an all-party committee on tax reform. I have stated before that I am not in favour of talking shops which are nothing but a recipe for inaction. What is needed is positive action on tax reform and that is what has been delivered over the past three years. Our achievements include major reductions in personal income tax rates; radical reform of the corporation tax system through curbing allowances and lowering rates and significant expansion of the tax base through curbing tax avoidance schemes and the introduction of a radically improved tax assessment, collection and enforcement system.

It is my belief that taxation is a budgetary matter and a matter for the Government. It is not a matter for open discussion in committee. I hold that view very strongly because committees tend to be talking shops. The Government of the day must make decisions in relation to the collection of revenue. They must stand behind those decisions; that is what they are elected for. They will be judged on those decisions when they go to the electorate.

By contrast Senator Doyle's party appear to have nothing to offer in this area. During the course of the Dáil debate on the Bill Senator Doyle's party tabled amendments, the more significant of which in the income tax area would cost in total £275 million in a full year. These amendments were put forward wihtout suggestions as to how they could be financed either through higher taxes or lower expenditure. This approach certainly does not represent tax reform and, indeed, I note that Senator Doyle indicated that she would be seeking to ease the restrictions on accelerated capital allowances. Needless to say this approach also makes a mockery of Senator Doyle's advice that I should have balanced the budget this year and should have a much more ambitious medium-term fiscal target.

It is nice to suggest changes and, at the same time, call for a balanced budget. The simple answer is that one cannot have a loaf and eat it. One has to make up one's mind. There are choices to be made and priorities to be accepted. The Government have specified clearly their objectives for lower rates of income tax — a standard rate of 25 per cent by 1993 and a single higher rate — and we are well on the way to achieving them.

Senator Dardis thought a 48 per cent rate was too high and I agree with him. I would be only too delighted if we could go further but we must pay all the bills. Senator O'Toole held a different view, as he is entitled. We have to make up our mind as to the level of services we want. I am referring to social welfare, disablement, welfare, education and health services. We need those services and we must decide on how to pay for them. There are only two ways the Government can get money, from taxation or borrowing, and most people agree that both are too high. It is nonsensical to suggest that we should introduce a range of new services or improve the existing ones if we are not prepared to pay for them. The Government are not prepared to countenance borrowing more money to pay for services. We need reductions in expenditure and to focus the resources on the priorities because we are committed to changes in taxation.

Many Senators welcomed the current year basis of assessment for the self-employed and certain other taxpayers. Senator Doyle quoted the then Minister for Finance on the introduction of the PAYE allowance as justification for the extension of the allowance. In fact, the Minister made clear at that time that the primary reason for the introduction of the allowance was to improve the tax progression for PAYE taxpayers. Notwithstanding the change to a current year basis, it is my view that this consideration is still a valid one. In general, self-employed taxpayers will not be paying on their income for the current tax year; they will be paying on profits for an accounting period ending in that year. They will also still have a more liberal expenses regime. Farmers have their averaging of profits.

The need for the change suggested by Senator Doyle has not been established. If the self-employed, farmers and so on, agreed to the disbandment of the advantages they enjoy we would have a look at the suggestion but I do not think there is any likelihood of that happening. The case for a PAYE allowance has not been proved.

I would like to make it clear that the PAYE allowance is and always has been viewed as an allowance for employed taxpayers, that is those who pay their income tax weekly, fortnightly or monthly through the PAYE system and who, generally speaking, discharge their entire tax liability within the year of assessment. On Committee Stage we can go into this matter in more detail and I hope to convince Senator Doyle, and other Senators, of the validity of my view that, notwithstanding the change to a current basis for the self-employed, the important differences which remain between their income tax regime and the regime for those on PAYE justify confining the PAYE allowance to the latter group.

Senator Doyle suggested that there should have been a positive definition of manufacturing in section 41 of the Bill for the purposes of restricting the coverage of manufacturing relief to genuine manufacturing activities. Not alone have many new areas been covered by the 10 per cent tax code by the courts or by the Appeals Commissioners, there are many more in the queue. Nobody in the other House disagreed with that action and we are now trying to implement it. My Department and the Revenue Commissioners examined this possibility — the coverage of manufacturing relief to genuine manufacturing activities — but concluded that to give a genuine, legal manufacturing definition of "manufacturing activity" was simply not a suitable approach as it is extremely difficult to define. It would have involved the creation of complex legislation, setting out positive criteria, which would have to be met by every existing manufacturing company in order for these companies to retain the 10 per cent rate. This would obviously have generated a much greater degree of uncertainty for companies than the approach set out in section 41 which is based on limited exclusions.

Senators O'Keeffe and Doyle asked if specific activities mentioned by them would now lose the 10 per cent rate as a result of the new rules in section 41. The section does not exclude any particular activity and it has been misunderstood and misrepresented in many areas. The section sets out general categories of excluded processes and an activity will only lose the 10 per cent if it falls primarily into one of these excluded categories. It all depends on the exact process involved. "Process" is the key word. If you take something in bulk and break it down to process it, the question is if there is a process in between and if you produce a different product — or a major change in its characteristics — at the end of the process. However, I can assure the House that the Revenue Commissioners will interpret the section in a reasonable way and, as I said earlier, the vast bulk of activities which now qualify for the 10 per cent rate for manufacturing will not be affected. I will also, of course, be open to any excluded company to go to the Appeals Commissioners and the courts if they wish. No legislation in this area could eliminate the possibility of legal cases in particular instances.

Despite Senator Raftery's comments about the pace of indirect tax reform, the VAT and excise reductions which came into effect earlier in the year have been warmly welcomed by industry and consumers. Our European partners — and indeed the Commission — have also recognised the measures as a significant first step towards eventual approximation within the Community. To put the matter in context, I wish to remind Senators that the full year cost of the reductions on indirect taxation this year is £140 million or nearly 4 per cent of this year's total revenue from VAT and excise duties. This is no small step.

In the general area of tax harmonisation, the Commission is at present carrying out a study relating to the problems which will have to be confronted by the Exchequer. That study will bear out some of the things we have been saying in recent times in that regard. The one objection I have to tax harmonisation of Community level is that it should not be all one way traffic. The higher tax countries should not have to make all the adjustments, adjustment and approximation should mean that those at the bottom of the scale should come some of the way and that those at the top should come the rest. It is not a view shared by the larger countries, nevertheless it is fair and equitable.

Senator Joe O'Toole raised questions about the international financial services centre and asked whether it would result in a bonanza. It is simple, 110 projects have been approved for the centre but, naturally, he picked one of the few Irish companies — AIB — who will not be able to move into the centre and replace their 43 per cent tax by a 10 per cent tax rate.

Comment on this

That was not my point.

Comment on this

It is only on new activities that this will apply. I do not think anybody should turn their backs on 110 projects involving international names which would otherwise not come into Ireland. Many big companies are involved including Daiwa Securities, Japan, City Bank, Chase Manhattan, in the United States and Commerzbank in Germany and they are all coming here because of the financial services centre. The 10 per cent tax is a bonus; it will give good jobs and provide us with business which we would not have had otherwise. It is marginal cost selling, if you want to look at it that way. It is trying to get the most out of assets.

I dealt with interest rates and as soon as they come down there will be more economic activity. Senator Mooney mentioned tax free zones. There are many such zones in Europe and, with some of my friends in the SDLP, we examined the possibility of a tax free zone straddling the Border on the basis of discussions that Mr. John Hume had with Congressmen in the United States. If they could provide us with access to the American market it might be a better approach than looking for extra visas. That matter is being pursued and it would generate good cross-Border activity if it came into being.

Any questions which were omitted can be asked on Committee Stage——

Comment on this

What about the ODA and the present level, given the backdrop the Minister painted of increased economic activity?

Comment on this

Where is that in the Finance Bill?

Comment on this

There were other matters, not in the Finance Bill, to which the Minister responded, such as the national lottery. As the Minister referred to these, I wonder why he left this one out.

Comment on this

I would not specifically leave it out; I have adjusted those areas in the budget this year according to the rate of inflation.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If I did not, the Department of Foreign Affairs must have done a little side twist somewhere.

Comment on this
Denis Foley Acting Chairman (Mr. Foley) Fianna Fáil

Is Second Stage agreed?

Comment on this

Before the question is put, by agreement with the Leaders of the parties, on completion of the vote it is proposed to take a half hour sos.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 29
·
Níl 15
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I should like to welcome to the House Shirley Collins, a Member of the Canadian Government and the Minister responsible for disabled persons, who is here with her assistant.

Comment on this