We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Finance Bill, 1992 [ Certified Money Bill ]: Committee Stage (Resumed) and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–147 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1992
Enacted

No. 8 of 1992 ›

There is a phrase in line 19, page 125 of the Bill which states: "‘records' includes information in a non-legible form;". What exactly are we talking about here?

Comment on this
Bertie Ahern Minister for Finance (Mr. B. Ahern) Fianna Fáil

Computer records.

Comment on this

Section 92 (e) reads:

in the case of beer delivered for consumption in the State, withdrawn from the market because of its condition or age renders it unfit for human consumption;

Who benefits from the repayment of duty, the importer, the brewer or the retailer?

Comment on this

The beer would be returned to the brewery, so no duty arises.

Comment on this

Duty would be already paid on it so there is a refund involved.

Comment on this

Yes, there is.

Comment on this

The brewery would benefit from this?

Comment on this

The brewery would benefit.

Comment on this

What is meant by "unfit for human consumption"? That is a wide ranging definition in terms of its implications. Many beers may taste very badly, they may be unpleasant, but they may not be unfit for human consumption. At the same time they may not be fit to be sold to customers who would expect a high standard. I worry about that definition. It is wide ranging and may result in retailers having to hold on to a product and dispose of it, in other words, waste it when it would not match this definition.

Comment on this

The best before date is not a test of whether the beer is good, bad or indifferent. Once the best before date has passed the duty is considered to be refundable. It is not a definition of whether the beer has gone off or anything else.

Comment on this

When foods have passed the date where it is desirable to consume them it does not follow that they are unfit for human consumption. It follows that the most desirable thing would be that they be consumed by that date but it does not mean there would be unacceptable side effects as a result of consuming them. Indeed, many items which are consumed after best before dates are still all right. It may not be particularly wise to use them but they still would not be unfit for human consumption. What concerns me about that definition is that it opens the possibility of publicans being left holding a barrel of beer they would not be able to sell.

Comment on this

The point is that it is not sold for public consumption and the duty is refundable at that stage. One must have a cut off point and that is a fair one.

Comment on this

Basically, the duty is refundable.

Comment on this

Yes. We are trying to get a date from which to refund the duty.

Comment on this

I require an explanation of two matters arising under section 99(1). The end of subsection (1) mentions a penalty of £1,000; that appears to be a mandatory penalty. Is that the maximum fine or can the court exercise discretion in imposing a fine? Are we simply specifying that it is £1,000 with other option?

Comment on this

It is a fine of £1,000 but the district justice can mitigate the fine by one half.

Comment on this

Would it not be preferable to say: "a fine not exceeding £1,000" rather than this mandatory figure? The line between the legislature and the judiciary is becoming more blurred as time goes by, but I have always felt that we should not take from a presiding judge the discretion to decide on the gravity of an offence, especially have heard the evidence.

Comment on this

He cannot go above £1,000 but there is some flexibility.

Comment on this

We will not pursue that aspect further. I made my point and will leave it at that. Regarding subsection (2) Senator Upton might consider that this is another matter not unrelated to the previous matter we spoke about. I often wonder what becomes of the beer that is forfeited. There must be a disposal factor involved. Spirits are disposed of by putting them up for auction. They do not have a sell by date.

Comment on this

The Minister has a large vat in the Department.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Let us not be disorderly.

Comment on this

The Chair encourages this unreasonable behaviour at times.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am joking Senator Doyle, on this occasion and she should accept it in that spirit.

Comment on this

Stick to the beer.

Comment on this

We are legislating and saying that it will be forfeited. Let us know what becomes of it.

Comment on this

Anything that is forfeited by the Revenue goes to the Revenue auctions. I do not think anything has been forfeited from publicans, but in the case of smuggling, if it is forfeited then it goes to the Revenue auctions.

Comment on this

The beer?

Comment on this

Anything. I am not too sure how quickly they would organise an auction to sell perishable goods.

Comment on this

Would it be fit for human consumption? Is it consumed by humans?

Comment on this

Whether it would or not it would be consumed.

Comment on this

It goes into intervention.

Comment on this

That is the theory.

Comment on this

I do not wish to question the Minister's sincerity in the reply he has given but there is a widespread belief among the trade that the beer which is forfeited never comes back into the system. What becomes of it if it has a sell by date? There is a point beyond which it is no use for consumption.

Comment on this

It is destroyed if it has gone beyond the date. It is like the other question in the trade where, in some publicans' records, one cannot find records of them buying Guinness or Guinness products in the Republic, but still they sell large amounts of Guinness. That is extraordinary and I have not got to the bottom of it yet.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

And probably will not.

Comment on this

I am not opposing the Minister and that would be the position for many publicans. If there are people operating illegally, they have an unfair advantage over those of us who trade legally. I have no pity for them if they are in difficulty.

Comment on this

I accept that. In fairness to the Senator who is putting forward points on behalf of the trade, these points have been raised by the trade and they are identifying these areas for me but I have not found a solution. It intrigues me that some of the biggest pubs which serve thousands of customers only buy a few barrels of Guinness a month. When I get to the bottom of this problem I will be delighted to let the public know how that happens.

Comment on this

We wish the Minister success.

Comment on this

As I was a publican for 27 years, I am entitled to comment on this.

Comment on this

There are as many publicans as teachers here now.

Comment on this

I am not one now; I am a full-time public representative.

Comment on this

Is this a state the rest of us are meant to aspire to?

Comment on this

I do not know where the Senator is going, but I know where I am.

The trade have had difficulty with this for a long number of years. There are cowboys in this trade as in any other. It is interesting to hear the Minister say he is aware of big pubs only buying so many barrels of Guinness. They were there in my time too and the organisation Senator Howard represents tried to rout them out but the licensed vintners and previous Ministers for Finance were not successful. With regard to section 99 (2), would it not be better to leave that beer with the publicans rather than throwing it away?

Comment on this

On the same point, the subsection says that any beer in respect of which an offence was committed shall be liable to forfeiture. That does not mean it is mandatory; there is discretion there. How is the discretion exercised? What constitutes the necessity for forfeiture? How is it decided? Is it possible for this beer to go back into the system?

Comment on this
Mr. Doyle

Could the Minister indicate in the last year for which we have records the amount of beer on which duty was repaid? What quantity are we talking about? He also indicated that beer which has passed the best before date was no longer fit for human consumption — there are many who would be prepared to take a chance on that — and that it is auctioned off but he said later that it was destroyed. What happens to it? Have we any evidence of when an auction has taken place? I recall auctions where goods seized are sold by the State but I do not recall auctions where beer with outdated best before date is sold by the State.

Comment on this

As regards Senator Costello's point, normally the beer would be seized and the courts then would decide whether it was to be returned. The number of times the beer would be confiscated and forfeited are small. The customs officials would seize it and the courts would decide whether it was to be forfeited.

I do not have figures Senator Doyle asked for but not a great amount of beer is sold off at auctions because of its perishable nature.

Comment on this

Is there a dye inserted when the duty is refunded because it has passed the best before date?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Would that not be an idea to stop it coming illegally back into the trade? As the kegs were sealed before the duty is refunded a dye could be inserted.

Comment on this

We will look at that. With regard to figures, Senator Howard knows better than I that if this did happen the duty would not be refundable. It would be offset. That is why the figures are not readily available.

Comment on this

Section 102 states:

This Chapter and Part I of the Third Schedule shall come into operation on such day as the Minister for Finance may appoint by order, and different days may be so appointed for different provisions or for different purposes.

I object in principle to that degree of discretion and flexibility being left to the Minister in relation to the implementation of provisions in legislation; it means that it might or might not happen. It means that in relation to relief in respect of oil exploration or natural energy sources, payment of duty on various items, inspections and so on there is no specific date for their implementation and an order has to be brought in. It is not stated how this order is to be introduced. Will it come before this House? Will we have an opportunity to discuss it? Is it simply by the diktat of the Minister? Would it not be more appropriate to specify the nature of the orders and the manner in which they are to be introduced or to state a clear date which would give the Minister a reasonable amount of time so that certain provisions could be implemented?

Comment on this

The reason for this is that the proposed EC target date for the changeover to end product taxation for beer is 1 January next. Everybody is agreed that is the system we are moving towards from the worts in pre-fermentation to the end product. Even though the relevant directive has to be adopted, we are working towards this date as are a number of other member states who are currently operating the wort system of beer taxation. The industry are anxious to have legislation now to signal what is happening. In preparing for the change-over the Revenue Commissioners will continue their discussions with the Irish brewers. The actual transition date will depend on the adoption of the directive and the resolution of the many technical issues that are still outstanding. They changed the technical proposals which were causing difficulties for the brewers. We must keep the competitiveness of Irish brewers in mind in this process. The rate of duty to apply to the end product and the system of beer taxation is a budgetary matter for determination at the appropriate time. The advantage of including it in the legislation now is that the industry will know what is happening. The discussions with the brewers and the Revenue Commissioners on the technical aspects will go ahead. As soon as every member state of the EC is satisfied that the directive can be adopted it will be enacted, it will become law. It will operate from the effective date.

Comment on this

I have done my best to find the appropriate section which would clarify this matter. I raise this query on this section and I will put this in simple terms to the Minister. We are dealing with the movement of excisable goods. As a retailer, it is very unlikely I would attach a trailer to my car, drive to Newry or Derry and load it up with 10 or 15 kegs of beer and come back and sell them in my premises. What will be the position of somebody in the licensed trade after 1 January 1993 who decides to drive over the Border, into another state as it were, and purchase beer there? For example, Senator O'Reilly from County Cavan is quite near the border. If Senator Costello was back in his native Sligo he would be near the border. They could drive over the Border and purchase beer. If there is a financial advantage in doing this, it will de done. If a person retails the beer on his premises, what must he do to keep within the law as a result of the new situation as and from 1 January 1993?

Comment on this

Somebody who does that will be liable for duty.

Comment on this

Does he pay that in Newry or in the Republic?

Comment on this

He will pay the duty in the Republic. He will pay the full Irish rate.

Comment on this

What about the English rate?

Comment on this

If he buys it in Newry, the person from whom he buys it can claim a refund of his duty. He must pay the full duty in the Republic.

Comment on this

He can, as it were, go to a wholesaler in Newry, purchase it quite legally and then come back here. Is the Minister saying that the obligation is then on that person to declare to the State that he has purchased this product?

Comment on this

He is meant to declare it in advance.

Comment on this
Mr. Doyle

That he is going to do that?

Comment on this

Yes, that is the law.

Comment on this

Taken together with the provisions of section 106 where no duty will arise for individual use of such goods, there comes a point when it is unreasonable to say that alcohol or tobacco could only be for the individual's use. Quantatively, what has the Minister in mind in terms of what he would accept as a reasonable amount for individual use? When would the scenario arise, which was pointed out by Senator Howard, where it is obvious it is for resale? There would appear to be a difficulty in defining what would be reasonable.

Comment on this

I think I have answered Senator Howard's question in that the excise duty is refunded to the person who sold the beer. The person who brings it across the Border must then pay the duty here. The section deals with duty paid excisable products coming from another State. The general position is that such products are liable to duty in the State. However, where alcohol and tobacco products are acquired in another member state by a private individual for his or her own private use, no liability to duty will arise in this State. Fuel in the fuel tanks of vehicles entering the State will likewise attract no further liability.

The main requirements of the section are, therefore, focused on persons commercially importing duty paid products and for these there are stringent requirements to be followed. They must inform an officer of the Revenue Commissioners in advance of the dispatch of the goods from the other member state of their intention to acquire the goods. They must also provide a financial guarantee in advance to cover liability of duty on the goods in this State. The section also provides for penalties for breaches of the section and for the forfeiture of goods imported in breach of it and by any vehicles used to carry the goods.

Dealing with duty paid goods in open circulation, the provisions of the section are necessarily stringent because of the risk that such goods might cross frontiers to the high duty member states without being declared for duty purposes. In our own case, this risk has been considerably reduced in recent years to a combination of indirect tax rate reductions. There is a liberal policy of restraint regarding duty increases in the case of named excise duties.

At present private persons are restricted in the amount or volume of duty paid goods they may import without further tax payments from another member state for consumption in their own state. These limits on travellers' purchases are set out in the EC Directives. They are absolute and they cannot be exceeded in any form. Importations above the limits are illegal, if not declared at Customs. In the Internal Market the transition of concept and application of travellers' allowances will no longer apply. Private individuals will be allowed to purchase goods in other member states, virtually without limit, for consumption in their own state.

In the case of excisable goods, however, the authorities in determining whether the goods in question are for private consumption or have been bought in the State for commercial reasons may take a number of factors into account. These include the status of the person involved, whether he is a private individual or a trader, the mode of conveyance being used, whether a car, a van or truck, and the actual volume of the goods in question for tobacco and alcohol products. Indicative guidelines have been established by the Community in this regard.

Regarding indicative guidelines, they are not absolute limits. There would be a presumption by State authorities that quantities under these minima would be for private consumption, although flexibility and judgment are allowed. Where the quantities are greater there would still be no duty charged if the person could show that the goods were for his or her own use. The balance is with the individual. As there will be no systematic border checks after the end of 1992, enforcement will be through mobile customs patrols. A person may be stopped by a customs patrol in the midlands and may be queried about goods and drink purchased in Northern Ireland. This is the concept which I explained in great detail in the Dáil. The whole concept of the Single Market is that there are no frontiers at the point of entry into the country but that the frontier does not disappear. The frontier is everywhere and to protect your revenue base you must have controls and checks. The Customs officers about whom we spoke last night, by and large, will be redeployed by the Revenue service elsewhere. We will hear about some of the Revenue Commissioners powers later. This is the reason you have to give what were the powers of Customs and Excise people at the frontier to these people, whether it be Rosslare or the Border.

The yield from VAT is £2 billion and two thirds of that is taken at the point of entry. With the Single Market changes all of us can see the threat to the Revenue base and it is only with stringent powers being implemented that we can protect that base, not to mind talking about extending the powers. Most of the powers given in the Bill to Revenue officers are in the area of VAT.

On the last question, guidelines will apply. They will apply in Ireland's case for cigarettes, 800; cigars 200; smoking tobacco, one kilogram; spirits, 10 litres; intermediate products, 20 litres; wines, maximum 45 litres, that includes a maximum of 30 litres of sparkling wines, and beers 55 litres. If you have all of those in the boot of your car, then you are safe.

Comment on this

I wish to refer to the point the Minister made about the litres of wine. There is an inconsistency here. Let us extend the argument to France, for instance. If I go to France as a private individual in a small car I can travel to Bordeaux where I can get wine at a fraction of the cost of what it is in Ireland. The case could be argued that I could buy a container load of wine and ship it in a container for my private use. To my mind, that would be in accord with the Single Market ethos, whatever about the provisions. It would be legitimate for me to do that, whereas the imposition of a restriction of 45 litres would seem to be inconsistent with that.

Comment on this

The only difficulty is that you have to carry it in yourself. You would hardly carry in the full cargo of wine.

Comment on this

I submit that if I were to put it in a container it still could be for my own personal use. I could argue that case.

Comment on this

You can argue it, but if you are travelling with the container, then the officer would have to take it into account.

Comment on this

I hope that it is not going to be ruled out.

Comment on this

It would be a bit suspicious.

Comment on this

If he went to that trouble, he would get away with it.

Comment on this

I hope that in the course of this debate it has been purely coincidental that there has not been a reference to Annie Murphy.

Comment on this

I was going to make the same point as Senator Dardis. If you read section 106 (2), there certainly seems to be a degree of flexibility for an individual consumer in that it states it is for his or her own use and not for commercial purposes. That is the distinction that is being made. It is not the quantity but it is the purpose. If somebody can argue, irrespective of the quantity, that the purpose is for his or her own use and can argue that adequately, it would seem that would satisfy the requirements of this section.

There is the other point about transportation. It must be transported by such private individual. It does not mean that the private individual must have it in a haversack on his or her back, but it is to be transported in the company of that private individual. It would seem possible that it could be on a trolly or it could be an adjunct to a vehicle for transportation so long as the purpose is being fulfilled.

Obviously ignorance of the law is no excuse but I presume there will be quite an amount of documentation circulated in relation to the regulations implementing this section.

Comment on this

What is meant by one's own personal or private use? Is that restricted to the individual in question or does it extend to his family or friends? If it is restricted to the individual in person, then there is obviously a very clear limit on the amount one can consume, even in a lifetime. If it is extended to what would be a normal lifespan, it still is fairly restrictive. If it is broadened to the extent of family, friends and acquaintances, then it seems to be unlimited at that stage.

Comment on this

Christmas presents.

Comment on this

The purpose of the series of questions I asked was to try to clarify the position of the commercial operator, the retailer, the publican. My understanding of it is that if I am within reasonable distance of the Border and I can purchase beer in, say, Newry, at a wholesale price that makes it worthwhile to go there, provided apparently that I inform a Customs officer that I am about to embark on this exercise and provided I make suitable arrangements to pay the duty on the beer when I take it in, then I am perfectly entitled to drive up there and take the goods across the Border. It appears as if certain quantities of beer are being brought across the Border and those of us who are trying to trade legally are in competition with this. The new arrangement is going to be looser than the existing situation. I am concerned that what is now happening, which should not be happening, is going to occur on a larger scale.

We are often concerned about the fly-by-nights who come into the trade. There is the person who leases a pub and is suddenly selling his product 10p a pint less than what I am selling it at, and I am losing customers. We find that in about two years he bails out. He has not paid VAT, he has not paid tax, he has not paid PRSI, he has not paid anything. He is gone and his lease is up. The next thing you find is that he has started up another business in another part of the town. He has leased another pub but by the time the Revenue catches up with him he is gone. Perhaps I am preaching a bit too much on the problems about which I am concerned. I believe from the information I have received that some of us can now legally go across the Border, buy goods and bring them in here. Others can always take the chance and they will probably have a better opportunity of escaping when taking a chance now.

Comment on this

The free movement of goods and services is there. That is the whole purpose of the Single Market for individuals. What is meant by "own use" would be the extended one of your domestic family — your own house use.

Comment on this

What about the case of a politician coming up to an election?

Comment on this

We know what house to go to with the crate loads of wine. It is not a case of having to drink all the wine yourself and the officers having to breathalyse you to check whether you had all the drink, rather than whether the rest of the people in the house had some.

I would say to Senator Howard, who I know has a great deal of knowledge in this, that this is far stronger than the position at present, none of the local publicans I know would consider going to Northern Ireland and bringing down large quantities of drink. Let us assume for the purpose of debate that one of them had that terrible thought. They could go to Northern Ireland if the price differential and everything else was right. Senator Howard knows the products that are worth bringing down. If publicans go to the North at present and collect their goods they have no obligation to check with anybody until they are back here. What happens is that we normally hear rumours of what is happening. That will not be the way under the new law. If the person carrying the goods is 100 yards on the other side of the Border and they are stopped, they are open to the full powers of the law not on what they have, but why they did not inform the Revenue in advance. That is a very strong power.

Comment on this

I move recommendation No. 15:

In page 139, after line 50, to insert the following:

"(7) Any person who has been refused approval by the Commissioners as a State vendor will have the right to appeal to a Tribunal, consisting of the following three persons: (i) the Chairman of the Revenue Commissioners or his nominee (ii) the Secretary of the Department of Finance or his nominee (iii) the President of the High Court or his nominee. The operation of such an appeal procedure shall be governed by regulations which the Minister may make under section 117.".

This provision provides for an appeal against a decision by the Revenue Commissioners to refuse approval to a State vendor. It is a fairly straightforward recommendation which makes provision so that a variety of reliable people — very much establishment figures — should be in a position to review the case of somebody who feels aggrieved. It is important that somebody who feels aggrieved in relation to being refused approval by the Revenue Commissioners should have the entitlement to a second opinion and to be able to take the case to somebody else who would be distinct and different from the people who refused him in the first place. For the most part, I do not think there would be any great problem but, inevitably, there will be people who will feel they have been discriminated against or that they have been treated badly. It is very important that those people should have the right to take their case to another court.

Comment on this

I second this amendment. A right to appeal for somebody who might be refused approval should be a basic entitlement. There seems to be no criterion in section 107 where a State vendor would be appointed. In other words, section 107 (2) (a) states that "the Commissioner may approve a person as a State vendor." and then they may apply certain conditions, as they think fit, for the operation. There are no criteria laid down for the appointment. Clearly, it would seem that somebody might have a grievance because they were not appointed to carry out business as a State vendor in a member state. In implementing this directive it would be proper that those appointed by the Revenue Commissioners should have authority to become a State vendor, and that those who are refused appointment should have access to a tribunal, not necessarily an independent tribunal, but certainly a knowledgable tribunal that would include a representative of the Revenue Commissioners, and also an independent person from the High Court. That would be a reasonable proposal.

Comment on this

Section 107 deals with distant sales trade and duty paid goods. The subsection to which the recommendation relates covers trade originating in the State and going to other member states. In such cases, Council Directive No. 92/12/EEC places clear obligations on the authorities of member states in relation to the control of its vendors. These have been incorporated into subsection (2) of the section which provides for the approval by the Revenue Commissioners of such vendors, subject to the conditions in question. The operation of an appeals procedure assumes discretion on the part of an authority in a particular area. In this case, however, there is no such discretion under the directive.

We are bound by Community rules to ensure that Irish traders who engage in distant sales activities involving other member states must comply with clearly specified rules. These rules have, in turn, been merely translated into conditions of approval under this section of the Bill. There is no discretion to compromise them in any way. Once they are met, approval will be automatic. In the circumstances, the Senators will see that an appeals procedure is, therefore, not appropriate because there is no discretion.

Comment on this

Surely things cannot be so black and white, almost like the laws of physics or the principles of mathematics, that there are not questions of interpretations there? I would be very surprised if that were the case.

Comment on this

I am advised the conditions are set out in the directive and the member state has to comply with the conditions.

Comment on this

Would the Minister clarify what he means by "the conditions"? As I understand it, the conditions refer to the activities of the person who is appointed, not to criteria for appointment. It is the Revenue Commissioners who make the appointment of a State vendor. Who is entitled to apply? What are the criteria for application? What happens if they are refused? Are they not entitled to appeal the refusal by the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

When a person complies with the conditions set out in section 107 (2) (b) (i) and (ii), approval will be automatic, and the conditions apply to them.

Comment on this

I think that it is the same point; we are referring to conditions on appointment to comply with certain regulations that are specified once they are appointed. What is the criteria for appointing State vendors? Do the Revenue Commissioners off their own bat say "you, you and you and not you"? Obviously, this is a new area where people can bring excisable products into the State. It may be a profitable and sought after appointment. We do not seem to have any defined criteria whereby the Revenue Commissioners can decide that one person is more appropriate, or better qualified to become a State vendor than another.

Comment on this

The Revenue will not select people. People will apply because if they do not, they cannot trade.

Comment on this

Revenue make the appointments?

Comment on this

Yes, provided people comply with the conditions.

Comment on this

What happens when Revenue feel somebody has not complied with the conditions and the applicants feel they have? This kind of thing happens regularly in all walks of life. In those circumstances I would like to see the people who feel aggrieved having the option of taking their case to a second court, and getting another opinion.

Comment on this

This is an EC dimension. If the conditions are clear, people will or will not comply with them. If people put forward their cases and they meet the conditions, Revenue will accept it. Revenue would have no vested interest in stopping them trading once they comply with the conditions.

Comment on this

I am still unhappy with the interpretation the Minister puts on section 107 (2). A State vendor shall not be approved unless he secures, prior to the dispatch of excisable products, the duty payable in respect of those products, and second, he agree to keep such accounts, records and other data or information. That is a regulatory process. One agrees that that would be part of the conditions of taking on the job, but it is not part of the qualifications for the job. We need some criteria on which the appointments are made. Nevertheless, there is still the question of a person who was not appointed and who feels aggrieved, even if they are prepared to abide by all the conditions, and have done so. Are they going to get the appointment? The position in relation to the appointment remains unclear. Where somebody is refused there appears to be no opportunity to air a grievance.

Comment on this

There is a Community dimension to this. We are undertaking our role in protecting the duty base for other member states. The Revenue Commissioners will already have received the revenue and will have no vested interest. The conditions are laid down and people will inform themselves so as to be able to trade. I quote from the Official Journal of the European Communities, 23 March 1992, No. L/76/6:

The member state in which the vendor is established must ensure that he complies with the following requirements: Guarantee payments of excise duties under the conditions set out by the member state of destination prior to despatch of the products, ensure that the excise duty is paid following arrival of the products and keep accounts of delivery of products.

We have no discretion here; this is our community contribution. Other states will do this for us. We have to comply. This is our obligation from an Irish point of view.

Comment on this

May we be informed if the tax representative mentioned here is a new "operator"? The commissioners may appoint a tax representative to act on behalf of, first, the non-state vendor referred to in subsection (3), or a person authorised by the authorities of another member state to operate a tax warehouse. Subsection 3 states:

A tax representative shall be liable for the payment of excise duty on excisable products delivered to the State on behalf of the person specified in paragraphs (a) and (b) of subsection (1)...

Are we talking about a solicitor, an accountant or a bank? Is this a new position?

Comment on this

We are talking about a new breed here. The advantage is that they will be operating within the State. The concept of a tax representative as provided for by the Council directive is new to us. This section provides for the approval by the Revenue Commissioners subject to conditions of such representatives representing suppliers of excisable products established in other member states. The section provides that liability for duty will fall on such representatives. It also provides for penalties for contravention and non-compliance with the section.

The presence in the State of a person representing a supplier from a member state is seen as an advantage, lending extra security to the system in the event of any difficulties or disputes arising with regard to transactions. The Senator can see how these might arise with free movement of goods in large quantities. Rather than have wranglings over all sorts of things, a representative from another member state should be able to clear up difficulties.

Comment on this

Could it be any importer?

Comment on this

It could be anyone within the State appointed by an importer from abroad.

Comment on this

Would the Minister clarify "under the diplomatic arrangements in the State", "international organisations" and "for consumption under any agreement" between member states?

Comment on this

Let me reply to a matter raised by Senator Howard; I passed over the page and left a note in it. The Senator raised the matter of the phoenix companies. I dealt with that in this year's budget. Section 186 in the VAT section provides for security which should deal with the fly-by-nights. I hope the phoenix company syndrome has been dealt with.

Section 113 provides for an exemption from excise duty for excisable products delivered to diplomatic missions or international organisations based in the State. The provision is necessary to honour our obligations under international conventions and agreements to which we are party and broadly reflects what happens at present. There is provision to give effect to the section by way of repayment of duty where those entitled to exemption purchase excisable products which are already duty paid. The section provides for penalties for fraudulent claims for exemption.

Comment on this

Does it refer only to personal use by the diplomatic service? Are there any regulations governing the extent of the concession?

Comment on this

It will mirror the current situation.

Comment on this

My sentiments here are similar to those underlying recommendation No. 23 which I put down to section 232. I am concerned about the lack of provision in this section and in section 232 for a record to be taken of any documents, books or accounts that may be seized by an officer of the Revenue Commissioners entering a premises where excisable goods may be held, that a record of anything taken by the authorised officer is not given to the owner of the premises or the person in question, and that the person in question who owns the goods in question apparently does not have right of access to those records while they are in the possession of the Revenue Commissioners. This may be an omission but in other countries, such as the US where they have a strict self-assessment system, a record of any goods, documents, computer software etc. seized is given to the person who owns them so that they know exactly what has been taken. The person in question has right of reasonable access either directly or through a professional representative, whether solicitor or accountant, to those records while they are being held.

I urge the Minister to take this point on board; and it has been pointed out by the professional bodies also. It may be a case of "methinks they doth protest too much" but this is a reasonable point in the interests of natural justice. If one is in trouble with an official and one's documents are seized on which a case is going to be made against one, one should at least be told what documents they take and the person or his professional representatives should have reasonable access to those documents. I ask the Minister to make a provision in section 116 to comply with what I say. I will make the same case in respect of the recommendation to section 232.

Comment on this

The section is designed to counter evasion or attempted evasion of excise duty. The section empowers an officer of the Revenue Commissioners to enter premises in which excisable products are produced or held and to inspect and take account of the products. Under the section an officer may also require the production of any documents relating to excisable products and may take copies of the documentation or remove any documents for further examination. The section also empowers an officer of the commissioners to question anyone on the premises about the excisable products and any documentation in relation to them. It places an obligation on a person questioned by an officer to give such information as an officer may require. The section provides for penalties for breaches of this section or for obstruction of an officer acting under the powers conferred on him by the provisions of the section. I am advised that if an officer of the Revenue Commissioners were to visit a premises and were to seize particular books or aspects that the individual would have right of access for the date seized. A record is maintained of what a Revenue Commissioners' officer takes.

Comment on this

The owner of the documents should be given details of what has been taken.

Comment on this

I am advised that a person would be told.

Comment on this

It should be included here.

Comment on this

It is the practice and if the person so requires, they will be given copies of any data seized.

Comment on this

They may. They do not have to. It says "or". They may take the documentation. It would be a simple matter to put the minds of many people at ease in an area where I have been generally supportive.

Comment on this

We have given a commitment to accountants and tax people generally that on the passing of this Bill a statement of practice will be worked out in consultation with them as to what these sections mean and what the Revenue will require. That was done after the 1972 Act and has worked extremely well; there have been no complaints or difficulties. I do not know off hand if this section is covered in the sections included in that agreement but we will have no difficulty clarifying it. If these practices prevail it is better to put them into the statement of practice so that accountants, tax advisers, and in some cases legal tax advisers, know what is at issue.

Comment on this

I support this section of the Bill but I share many of the concerns expressed by Senator Doyle and by other people outside this House. The powers are wide-ranging and it is very important that people would be given assurances and left in no doubt that these powers will not be abused. I do not suggest they will be abused on a wide scale but inevitably a small proportion of people in any job who, for one reason or another arising from prejudices or bad experiences in other areas, may decide to take an unacceptable and heavy-handed approach. I welcome the idea of a statement of practice but it still does not assuage the worries expressed. As this Bill now stands many things are possible with few safeguards which is my main concern. I am in accord with the notion of what is involved here and do not want to give a different impression.

Comment on this

The majority of powers accorded under this legislation already exist in law and are not additional powers. They are re-enacted here because of the Single Market and because Customs and Excise have gone, which people find difficult to believe as I do; from I January that will be the case. If one excludes the security consideration, when one hits the Border one will not even have to change gear in a car. Here we are re-enacting Customs and Excise powers and the 1972 powers into legislation. On the later sections only do new powers arise.

By and large, business persons do their own books because they have the knowledge or employ accountants, tax advisers or other specialised people who may not be qualified at all. The Revenue Commissioners are anxious to work with these people and to have an understanding with them. That is what makes the system work. I spoke to Mr. Norman Judge, Head of the Taxation Institute and to Mr. Tom O'Higgins, the former President of the Chartered Acountants Institute about this matter and they are anxious, as representatives of two main national bodies concerned to work closely with the Revenue Commissioners. If in regard to any of these sections, they want to raise discussions or seek clarification about what Revenue want, that can be done.

There was an extensive report in yesterday's newspaper that the Revenue Commissioners attended a conference with the tax practitioners last weekend where they explained their side of the story. People can be assured that we are trying to protect the Revenue base on one hand and to ensure equity on the other. We are not interested in being unduly unreasonable to anybody.

People need to understand the real concerns as we face the Single Market. The VAT we collect is £2 billion and two-thirds of that, £1.3 billion is collected at the point of entry. The system that allowed us to collect that goes on the I January 1993 and the same applies to DIRT. We have £13 billion in reserves on DIRT; £8 billion in the commercial banks and £5 billion in the non-commercial banks. We collect £260 million from that system and we collect £11 million other moneys that people are obliged under law to pay tax on, we collect £11 million so one can see why one would be fearful for the Revenue base. On cars and excise, which we discussed last night at great length, we collect between £140 and £150 million on VAT and excise and the system that returned that has now been discontinued.

If I did not re-enact the Revenue powers and look for new powers for Revenue I would be failing in my duty. We must be clear on what we are talking about. If a handful of people feel beleaguered I will deal with them. If one person has been badly treated by Revenue I will deal with it.

We have a bigger problem in this country dealing with a minority of people but a large proportion of wealth holders, non-compliant tax people who use every trick in the book, every expert on earth and every device that can be found to find a way around our tax laws. Our duty in this Finance Bill is to protect the Revenue base and to give adequate powers to the Revenue Commissioners. The Chairman and Board of the Revenue Commissioners have given a clear statement on trust that these powers will be implemented properly. These powers which I hope will be put into legislation later this evening come under the Ombudsman Act. If people are not satisfied with the method of appeal to the Revenue tribunals they can appeal to the Ombudsman who has full powers, on his own initiation if something is brought to his notice and if a person appeals to him.

My concern is not regardless of what is being said outside, that the powers of this Act have gone over the wall but that they may not have got to the wall. We are trying to protect a Revenue base that we should be expanding. This morning concern was expressed about what would happen if driving a car and instead of using a tow to carry the cases, one carried a load of wine. These are the kinds of concerns we have to face up to. If any Senators have hard information such as names and addresses of evaders I will privately examine them but I have listened for four months, since the publication of this Bill to people — I do not blame them — who say to me; "If you are closing down all the loopholes, it is harder for me to sell my services". It is like a doctor who specialises in arthritis; if we could do away with arthritis he would have a problem too. We are closing doors and loopholes and making life more difficult for tax dodgers, evaders and avoiders and that is my job as Minister for Finance.

If people have genuine concerns we look at them but the vast majority of the concerns I have heard are from people with vested interests. I know many of them and know the profession, but I am obliged to protect the Revenue base and see that there is equity. I am not going to put this House through what I put the other House through when I was asked to put various cases on the record where people with huge salaries pay 1 per cent tax by using various avoidance mechanisms. There are people earning £150,000 per year who pay nothing and people with a few million pounds who pay £40,000. We either want a society of compliant taxpayers or a society where people who can afford legal people, top-class accountants and experts, pay no tax while ordinary earners have to pay 48 per cent. The House has to decide what kind of society it wants. These moderate powers with plenty of protections and understandings with the profession might go some way towards dealing with non-compliance but I have my reservations.

Other Ministers for Finance will no doubt have to come back here and deal with what at times is an epidemic of tax evasion. As soon as the various conditions in this Bill are passed, people are going to be finding ways around them; that is the game and the profession which is fair enough, and is not illegal. Next year, my officials and the Revenue people will have to find ways of tightening up those loopholes but next year we will have another problem because of the figures mentioned. I genuinely appreciate the support I got from Deputy Noonan of Limerick East in the Lower House and from Senator Doyle and her party here, along with my own colleagues.

Let us not get carried away by a few people's sob stories because we are closing a few loopholes. We have to realise what we are dealing with.

Comment on this

The entire House agrees with the Minister's wish to deal with tax dodgers and with anybody in non-compliance with the law in relation to any items in this legislation. That being said, it is extremely important that we ensure that the due process of law is adhered to. Section 116 contains strong language such as "an officer may at all reasonable time enter premises". That may mean entering the home of a person; small trading premises or business premises often incorporate the home of a person and if we look at section 106——

Comment on this

One cannot enter the home of a person without a warrant.

Comment on this

I appreciate that but home and business premises may be identical. Where the distinction is made one would only get into the premises.

Comment on this

If it is the home of the person the Revenue officer needs a warrant.

Comment on this

If the entry to the premises is through the home, how is that difficulty countered? Does there have to be a separate warrant?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I did not realise that.

Comment on this

Everything will be kept under the bed from now on.

Comment on this

I showed a tape in the other House of what we are dealing with in tax avoidance and evasion. The stories are quite horrific. Revenue officials nowadays are threatened, abused and have dogs set on them. Yesterday Senator Hourigan told us about what goes on in America where people see the Revenue official coming they cross to the other side of the street. In this country the Revenue official has to go to the other side of the street to avoid being attacked and abused.

Comment on this

May I take it that you are introducing a loophole here so that somebody who moves documentation into their home remains free from questioning and documentation or books that would have to be produced cannot be inspected if it is not on the business premises? In cases where Revenue officials would haver to go to the gardaí and get a warrant, people may store the goods in a part of their home which cannot be entered or keep the ledgers there. They can keep their own persons there also or any persons who might be wanted for questioning.

Would the Minister clarify what is meant by "on all reasonable grounds"? Is "reasonable" left to the discretion of an officer? "Reasonable times" I presume, refers to daytime or to times regarded as reasonable, but what about reasonable grounds? Where are they specified and how are they determined? Is it the opinion of an individual officer?

I support Senator Doyle's point. If we are to give substantial powers to the Revenue Commissioners, and the Minister may say this is the only way of doing it, then it might be best to provide sufficient caveats and safeguards, and one of them would surely be to give a receipt for any documentation or item covered by this legislation that may be taken by Revenue officers. We may be counter-productive if we come over too strongly. We must streamline the procedures and one of the best ways of doing that is to ensure that there is at least a receipt of any material that may be taken by an officer.

Comment on this

Senator Doyle was concerned that documents taken from a trader by a Revenue inspector would be available for inspection at all reasonable times and that a receipt or a list of the documents would be available. I understood the Minister to say that in the course of four months he looked for many of the problems I listed, but they had not arisen. As far as I am aware, they are on their way. They will include — this is a very good example of the problem Senator Doyle is concerned about — a case from Longford where the documents were taken by a Revenue inspector to Athlone and retained for a period of three months. While these documents were in the possession of Revenue officials the trader was asked to produce linking or supporting documents for some of the figures. Because of the system he operated, he needed access to the documents taken to discover where he could search for the information he was being asked for. He was denied that access until the documents were eventually returned to him.

I agree with the Minister's approach of pursuing tax cheats but, even under existing legislation, cases have arisen that are disturbing. There is need to provide protection for the rights of the compliant taxpayer, and we are attempting to do that in recommendation 22.

I was impressed last evening when the Minister said he is putting in the new powers but that if they are abused he will take them back. He also said that if a case was brought to him where there was abuse he would see that justice was done. I trust the Minister to do that, but, should destiny decide that he is for higher things, another Minister would not be bound by his commitment.

Comment on this

You would have a double assurance at that stage.

Comment on this

That is why I am saying the Minister may — I cannot anticipate it — agree to give the force of law to the assurances that he accepts are necessary, and it would leave us all happy.

Comment on this

I appreciate what the Senator is saying. I could change a word here or there and the draftsman could change a word here or there. These powers are there 20 years; there is a statement of practice for the existing powers. There have been few or no complaints or difficulties for 20 years. That is not a bad test of legislation. In the Department of Social Welfare these changed every year. That is a good test. There was an understanding between practitioners and the Revenue Commissioners and it worked very well for 20 years.

Comment on this

There is no problem between the practitioners and the Revenue Commissioners. It is when the Revenue people deal with the ordinary trader that the difficulty has arisen over a two year period. The Minister indicated yesterday that the accountancy organisations and the Revenue Commissioners would be meeting to set up a fresh charter. The trader who can afford the fulltime accountant is all right because that is dealt with at a professional level but there should also be a charter at the lower level for the trader who cannot afford to employ the expertise that can be used in the wrong way on occasions. There is also need for that.

Comment on this

I listened with great care to the Minister. He is approachable and one can discuss individual cases with him but there can be a change of Ministers. I believe everyone should pay tax but, like Senator Howard, I have had representations that powers have been abused. Party politics do not come into it. The people are from different parties. Documents have been taken, premises have been entered and extraordinarily detailed information asked for. I have always had great co-operation from the Department of Finance, and not everybody in this House can say that. I am talking about the time when Dr. Jim Ryan was Minister for Finance. At that time the officials were great; they did not abuse the system or abuse their positions. The Minister talked about a training period or a course for Revenue officials who carry out inspections. Various Senators referred to this, as did Deputy Noonan in the Lower House. At the end of his speech, the Minister said we should bring specific cases to him and bring the people who had been on the receiving end to talk to him. That might be the solution. I do not think the Minister believes this is happening but he knows as well as anybody——

Comment on this

That may not be quite true.

Comment on this

Politically.

Comment on this

I do not criticise the people in the Department of Finance. I was the first publican in Ennis to register for VAT, and nearly organised a meeting to make sure the rest of them paid it.

Comment on this

That was successful.

Comment on this

It was successful. Anything I did in Ennis was successful.

Comment on this

I did not know the Senator was a sheriff for a while, but we learn something new every day.

Comment on this

The person about whom I am talking has paid his tax, as has his father before him. In the case of which Senator Howard is speaking, a girl runs a family business and she and her father have paid their taxes. Both of those people have had the same treatment. Perhaps these are isolated cases. The public think that we here pay no tax; we pay tax the same as everybody else. I have no sympathy for wealthy people and professionals who try to avoid paying taxes but I am concerned for people who are running small family businesses and chambers of commerce.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his considered response to this point that I raised some time ago. It is worth spending a little time on this because the public at large, the technical advisers and indeed the Institute of Taxation who are not a bit convinced of the Minister's arguments as of now in terms of safeguards for the public in the area of increased powers to the Revenue Commissioners, need assurance from us, and from the Minister in particular, that sufficient safeguards will be built into the legislation to ensure that all of us can support totally the extension of the powers to the Revenue Commissioners in order to catch those who are not complying with the system at the moment. When you spread the net wider you will inevitably catch some who have always complied and who are not outside the law in any sense.

We must have safeguards in the law, as distinct from a statement of practice, that will allow only those two relatively small points, but very important to the individual concerned (1) that a record of any documents or other files seized be given to the person concerned and (2) that reasonable access be allowed to any further documents seized by the Revenue Commissioners while they are in the custody of the Revenue Commissioners.

Obviously the statement of practice from the two cases which were outlined this morning, is not working, as the Minister intends it to work, in all cases. There should never have been a situation in which goods and documents were seized and a record or receipt for same not given to the individual concerned. Obviously there are problems in that area. According to Senator Howard, people have been refused access to their documents and records in certain instances.

Given the goodwill of the Minister and that he agrees with the points raised, I ask him to incorporate his statement of practice and the concepts in it into the legislation. It is very important that that be done. If the Minister does this he will immediately have the Institute of Taxation, the accountancy bodies, chambers of commerce throughout the country and various others on side with him. These arguments will also apply to the new powers given later in this Bill but they are very important in this section.

The Minister referred to the Ombudsman being a court of last resort. The Ombudsman can only act according to the legislation. I stand to be corrected on this but I do not think the Ombudsman would have powers under a statement of practice which was outside legislation in this area. In otherwords, if on this section or a later section if the Minister does not amend it, there is a complaint from an individual that he was not given a record or receipt for documents seized and that he was not given reasonable access and he then appeals to the Ombudsman, having tried and failed through any other procedure involved in the Bill, I do not think the Ombudsman can over-rule legislation just because there is a statement of practice that the Minister issued some time after the legislation was passed. I would like some clarification on this. I do not think the Ombudsman is the answer if we do not put the safeguards I have requested — and I got support from all sides on this — into the legislation. In the UK — it may not be an exact comparison because they have a different taxation system — in the US and in other countries, these safeguards are in legislation. They play an important part in keeping the trust of the compliant public with one in terms of extending one's powers.

There must be no reason for anyone, particularly professional bodies, to be able to complain about what is done. They should be 100 per cent behind the Minister. There should be no complaints, particularly when the Minister can remove their concerns in this area, and he obviously can if he is prepared to put them into a statement of practice. I am asking the Minister to give that statement of practice the force of law. If we fail in our arguments in this regard — and I hope we will not — I ask the Minister to indicate the statement of practice before this legislation is enacted. In other words, it will be quite clear to the Revenue Commissioners, to the professional advisers and to all exactly what code of practice is envisaged in terms of the extension of powers to the Revenue Commissioners.

Can the Minister assure me that the two points I make will be specifically detailed in any statement of practice, that a record or receipt for any goods or documents seized will be given to the individual and that the individual and/or their professional adviser will have reasonable access to all those records while they are in the possession of the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

It is general practice at present for Revenue officials to give a receipt for any books and records taken and certainly this would be given where requested. That is the present position and the instructions the Revenue work under. The powers in these sections are not new. I am no quite sure of the reason for this debate. Debate on the Bill generally has been good and I have no difficulty with that but neither the professionals nor the tax officials were talking about these sections. They were talking about the later sections of the Bill which are new powers. They have worked with these for 20 years as have ordinary people. Many people have been reading these powers as if they are new, either mischeviously or because they did not understand the powers have been there for 20 years. I am not sure which; I am not talking about Members of this House or the people outside the House. These powers have been there and have worked well. They are being re-enacted now because of the changes as a result of the Single Market.

Comment on this

There may be more use made of these powers because of the changes. Perhaps they will become more relevant and more widespread.

Comment on this

Perhaps, but I would also say that the tax consultants made it clear and it was made clear in the Dáil that they were not talking about these sections. They are not talking about VAT as they are not worried about that area. They have made that very clear. I spoke to Norman Judge and others. I had the honour of attending their dinner last Friday night and I had a good opportunity to talk to the profession then. They understand fully the argument about VAT and that is not their concern. They are concerned about other areas. Their concerns are mainly about three or four areas. On Tuesday I brought in amendments to the House. They believed that the limit in money terms we were looking for was too low and that the extent of the information we were looking for was far too much. We agreed to make amendments to that which we did in the House on Tuesday, with the support of all parties.

In the other areas of concern, the profession asked that we would draw up a statement of practice to which they would be party. Senator Doyle asked me to put on the record what they are talking about. That statement of practice is in the new areas of powers but perhaps it is as well to deal with it now, in case we do not get to it.

Comment on this

That is what I am afraid of.

Comment on this

The statement of practice in the areas of new powers would cover where Revenue state they need information in certain areas that the interpretation would be worked out in consultation with them of what information precisely Revenue are talking about and that the professionals would have an input. It would be ridiculous, for example, if in the area of third party, every item over £500 in a large business had to be returned and all the data was returned to Revenue. If every employer were to return all this information, Revenue would have warehouses full of information and they would only need 2 per cent of the information. It would be ridiculous to have business people complying with the law and sending in information which is not necessary. It is a matter for Revenue and the professionals to work out precisely what they are trying to get at. That is what they are going to do after the passage of the Bill. In other cases where agreements have been reached they have worked very effectively. We agreed last Friday that this would be undertaken and the professionals have since said that they are happy with it.

However, they had other concerns which we will deal with later in the Bill. They felt it was unfair of me to ask them to retrospectively comply with certain data, and to go back a year. We made changes that they will start supplying information from current dates, in other words, they will have to start sending in returns from 5 April next year. Their accountancy system was based in a certain way and they will have a fair opportunity to set up the new system rather than having to go back a year. I will answer generally some of the questions asked. The Ombudsman's covers the Revenue area, so that any alleged maladministration could be examined by him. His powers are broad——

Comment on this

Within legislation?

Comment on this

Yes, within legislation.

Comment on this

A statement of practice would not come within the ambit of the Ombudsman?

Comment on this

No. The statement of practice is to help the professionals when companies send in huge amounts of information. It would not arise in the case of a shopkeeper.

Comment on this

Will the statement of practice include access to records held by Revenue?

Comment on this

It is my understanding that if Revenue have taken records from Mr. X, and he wants access to those records, he would either be given copies of them or would get access to them. That is the present practice. If a person was trying to get information to answer Revenue's questions, it would be inappropriate if he was not allowed reference to his own books.

I made a point earlier about the kind of things that happen. You can have your accounts on computer. That small tape represents 1.5 million characters, about 1,000 pages of records. If the Revenue officer arrives at the door, somebody can slip out that tape and put it into his pocket. That is the record and that is the access to the audit trail. This is not an exaggeration. This happens every day. Records are put onto a floppy disc and the disc can be removed.

The days of massive accounts books are gone. I was on the audit trail long enough to see how the old system worked. As Senator Howard would tell you, now even in a medium sized pub, stock control has become automated.

Comment on this