We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Finance Bill, 1992 [ Certified Money Bill ]: Committee Stage (Resumed) and Final Stages.

Contributions 148–287 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1992
Enacted

No. 8 of 1992 ›

My business has not reached that stage yet.

Comment on this

That is because you are a Senator; you are a compliant taxpayer. You would not be a Member of this House if you were not. These are the controls that apply to some people. I wish that the same controls applied to others. People understand what the difficulties and fears are.

All decisions of Revenue officials may, in the first instance, be appealed to higher authority within the office of the Revenue Commissioners itself. Some people will say, not many, that that is one group examining themselves but the case of Revenue that practice has worked effectively over the years. The professions agree with that and the ordinary individuals agree with it also. An initial appeal can be made to the local office. If a dispute cannot be resolved locally, it can then be referred to the head office of the commissioners and, ultimately, to the board of the Revenue Commissioners. There are three steps on the trail.

The procedure is free and is widely used in the Customs and Excise area and follows on to other areas. The Commission on Taxation in their fifth report when reviewing the appeal procedures concluded that the existing appeal arrangements are sufficient to deal with any appeals which might occur in the Customs and Excise area. This included the possibility of appeals against seizure of goods and search of persons. It has been independently examined since the changes of 1967 and 1972. In order to ensure that citizens are fully aware of their rights, the Revenue Commissioners have introduced a taxpayers' charter. This charter sets out in clear and unambiguous terms, the rights of every taxpayer is his dealings with the Revenue Commissioners, including the right to seek a review of his case.

The exercise of the powers in this Bill when enacted, will be subject to review by the Ombudsman and any person aggrieved by a decision of the Revenue Commissioners may seek a review of the decision. A measure of the care with which the Revenue Commissioners exercise their inspection and audit powers in relation to VAT and the direct taxes is that there has never been a complaint made to the Ombudsman in this area. This is significant. It is not that people do not know about the Ombudsman, there is not a day that we do not hear about him in one form or another. Over 12,000 visits are made by Revenue officials annually to carry out detailed examinations of traders' records. In addition, a further 20,000 visits are carried out annually in relation to specific queries. In fairness to my colleagues in Revenue, that has to be put on the record.

A wide range of matters in relation to VAT may be appealed to the Appeals Commissioners. Appeals can be made in relation to a charge to tax, refusal of repayment, the determination of VAT rates and compulsory registration. In this Bill, additional appeal grounds are being provided against the security provisions in section 186 and the treatment of an agent as a taxable person in section 193. The Appeals Commissioners are an integral part of the VAT system and provide an important independent avenue of appeal which is easily and cheaply accessible in relation to a wide range of issues.

The exercise of all Revenue powers are, of course, open to judicial review. The new powers in this Bill are subject to the Constitution and any citizens aggrieved with their operation can seek a judicial review. It must, however, be borne in mind that the powers of search and arrest provided for in this Bill in relation to VAT can only be exercised by an officer who believes that a criminal offence has been committed. The sole purpose of arrest powers are to ensure that a person is brought before the courts and any person who is arrested must be brought before a district justice without delay and charged. Abuse of the arrest provision will be open to challenge.

There are four different mechanisms by which an aggrieved party may appeal against a decision of the Revenue Commissioners, that is, apart from what we are talking about and in addition to the statement of practice worked out between the professions and the Revenue Commissioners. In relation to the search, seizure and arrest provisions, appeal to the Revenue Commissioners and the Ombudsman provide a straightforward and free review system. Furthermore, the full legal protection of the Constitution and the courts system is always available to an aggrieved citizen.

The point can be validly made that these powers are already available to Revenue officials and their exercise is not giving rise to complaint. The sections in the Bill have been drafted in a restrictive manner to ensure that a balance is struck between the rights of the individual, on the one hand, and the interest of the State and compliant taxpayers, on the other. I am satisfied that the existing review and appeals procedures are sufficient to protect the rights of the individual. I noted the concerns that have been raised by Senators. Senator Howard has been kind enough to acknowledge that if I believe there are appropriate measures to be brought forward in the future, I will do so.

My colleague, Senator Honan, who has been here right through the debate knows me very well because she detected from my tone of voice that I do not believe this is a major issue. I have been involved in the tax area for a long time. My closest friends are involved in that area and when out socially the conversation always turns to the tax system. I am not saying there are no difficulties in the tax area. Many people feel aggrieved because they have to pay tax. Nobody likes giving away something for nothing. They find it hard to relate this money to the payment of pensions, unemployment benefit, the hospital services, the health services and so on. People believe if they pay a few pounds towards the running of those services that should be sufficient and this is understandable; I feel that way myself from time to time.

The policy I try to pursue in the Department of Finance is one in which I have strongly believed for over 20 years, that if everybody pays some tax, than all taxpayers will pay less tax and the system will be fairer for everybody. People do not feel nearly as aggrieved if they see equity. The public get upset if they are paying 48p in the pound, are driving a 1984 car and living in a small house and they see others, who they know are paying little or no tax, driving a 1992 registration car and living in a big house on the hill.

It has nothing to do with who is rich or who is poor. If people pay their fair share of tax they are entitled to be as rich as they like. My problem is with non-compliant taxpayers who try to either evade it or dodge payment. Equity can only be achieved in a fair tax system and that is what I seek to do.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am anxious to move on, we have given a lot of time to this matter. Perhaps we could have two or three final questions from Senators Costello and Howard.

Comment on this

The Minister has convinced us all that it is his desire to include in the tax net all who are fraudulently depriving the State of much needed tax. In our contributions on Second Stage we referred to the need to clamp down on tax evasion. Are we now in a position whereby we will have a code of practice or a statement of practice in relation to powers being granted to the Revenue Commissioners to enter premises and take goods?

Is this what the Minister proposes? It need not be specifically stated in the legislation. The concerns expressed here are not in regard to the intent and function of the powers, but to ensure that due process is seen to be done.

The wording of section 116 is extremely strong. If there is a belief that a criminal act has taken place, in other words, if goods have been taken without adhering to the law — there may be documentation on the premsies that would give rise to that belief — Revenue have the authority and right to enter. Can that entry take place forcibly? Must it be voluntarily? Is the person to be consulted or is there any advance procedure? Can an official of the Revenue Commissioners who believes that goods are on the premises use a sledgehammer to break down a door in order to seize goods? In some circumstances the goods may not be on the premises. What procedures will be adopted in carrying out the powers under this Bill?

Surely a record should be taken by the Revenue Commissioners of goods that have been seized. If they inspect a premises, question somebody, take a document or a piece of computer data, surely a record should be taken? They will need a record if the matter goes to court, which is provided for in the legislation. It is a simple matter to give a copy of that record to somebody. Whatever about having access to data, surely it should be part and parcel of the code of practice to ensure that a receipt is available.

Comment on this

Basically, I want to comment on the Minister's list of appeals procedures which provide legal recourse for an aggrieved taxpayer. I accept that a mechanism is in place to deal with decisions, but there are no structures or methods to deal with the attitude and approach of inspectors to the premises. The Minister stated that this procedure has been in place for 20 years, but he is well aware, as I am, that three days ago his five Oireachtas colleagues from Donegal discussed this issue with the Chairman of the Revenue Commissioners. It was a serious oversight on their part if they did not approach the Minister before their visit to that official.

Comment on this

I was aware of my colleagues visit. They were on a briefing session to discover how the system works so effectively in Donegal.

Comment on this

That is a rather creative version of what actually happened. That is not what they told their constituents.

Comment on this

In fact, I have to congratulate our Revenue official in Denegal who had the ability to get 1,200 people to go to a public meeting and when Senator Costello and myself try to get a crowd to a public meeting in our constituency we can hardly get 200. Obviously, Revenue officials have great pulling powers. My colleagues from Donegal were extremely impressed by the understanding nature of the Chairman of the Revenue Commissioners and his concern in trying to allay their unfounded fears about any difficulties with Revenue powers in Donegal.

Senator Costello asked in regard to the right to enter a premises under the section. It is usually on foot of information received by Revenue. Only certain premises would be targeted. It does not take place in a haphazard manner and they do not bring sledge hammers with them either. It is an offence to obstruct a Revenue official in checking the premises, but rather than fight about that, they normally pursue it in the courts. Under Customs and Excise laws currently under discussion, it is an offence to obstruct a Revenue official.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to give us a little of his time — although he has done so quite generously to date — on this section. This chapter was not in the original Bill as published and there is a great deal of confusion as to how the new registration of vehicles will be implemented. What implications will this new taxation and registration system have on the cost of cars next year? I would like the Minister to put his views on the record in this regard because there is a great deal of public concern what exactly the implications might be. Will the radical changes, resulting from our entry to the Single Market, cause a dramatic drop in the car sales this year? Are people waiting in expectation of a better price regime next year? Is that warranted? Would they be as well to get the higher trade-in value on their second-hand car this year against the higher price of a new one as distinct from the lower trade-in value of the second-hand car next year with, perhaps, a lower price on a new car?

I would also appreciate if the Minister would indicate what the relationship will be between local authorities and their ongoing registration and licensing of vehicles and the new offices for registration and taxation of vehicles? I understand the first licensing of unregistered vehicles will be done by the new registration office. From thereon, if I understand it correctly, it will be done as it is at present, through the local authority motor taxation offices.

This Chapter deals with the same issue so, perhaps, we could discuss a few poionts which can be raised on any section. In relation to the transfer of residence and the difficulties attached to the importation of cars, there are many rules and regulations which must be adhered to. I could not begin to recall them all. People who have tried to comply with them and got advice from local offices in the UK or contacted Rosslare or other ports, but on their arrival here they found they could not bring in their cars because of a misinterpretation of the rules on the importation of cars. Before I January next could we clarify the procedures that will be in vogue and which will keep people on the right side of the law when transferring their cars, registered in their own names, to this country? In what circumstances can that be done? The Minister will tell me that the matter is laid down in present law but if the new system is as difficult and complicated for the ordinary person to interpret as it is at present, the confusion will continue. That practice is against the spirit and ethos of the Single Market. In terms of free trade and free movement of people and goods, the rules must be clear, simple and obvious. Therefore, I ask the Minister to put on the record how the matter will be handled post-January.

Comment on this

I thank Senator Doyle for welcoming the overall thrust of this section and she has invited me to give some details. I signalled in my budget speech my intention to replace the existing excise duty on motor vehicles with a first registration charge designed to produce equivalent revenue. The price structure has not changed very much. The recent arguments about the pre-tax prices are another matter. The EC Internal Market obligations mean that the current excise duty cannot be maintained because it is reliant on Border controls for enforcement. Budget considerations rule out any foregoing of the substantial revenues arising from that source, which is about £150 million.

The purpose of this section is to establish the legislative framework for the new vehicle registration tax in keeping with EC requirements and for the consequential administrative arrangements arising from the transfer of vehicle registration functions to the Revenue Commissioners who the Government have decided should handled the collection and enforcement of the new imposition. Responsibility for the road tax will remain with the local authorities, as will the other functions which are performed in the motor taxation offices. It is just a division of the functions, the new registration tax on the first charge is at the Revenue base and all the ongoing work remains with the motor taxation offices.

Under the new system provided for in this chapter there will be a single registration charge subsuming the current flat rate administrative charge for registration imposed at present under the road tax regime. In the case of new vehicles, the chargeable basis will be the open market selling price, inclusive of VAT and the vehicle registration tax, as declared to the Revenue Commissioners by the authorised manufacturer or distributor. The tax will also be based on the open market selling price for second-hand vehicles which are liable to tax and registered in the State for the first time. This is a significant change from the present system which uses predetermined depreciation scales. Specifically assigned Revenue officers will be employed in determining the open market selling price for second-hand cars. They will have reference to trade guides, various depreciation scales and backup from the central valuation unit. Provision is also made for an appeals system in relation to the tax charged.

For motor cycles a framework will be provided to allow for the continued taxation. The tax will be levied at the dealer stage rather than at the importer-distributor level as at present. Instead of having 21 importers a larger number of distributors will be involved. The system will also cater for individuals registering vehicles which they purchased outside the dealer network. Discussions are taking place between the Revenue Commissioners and the trade on the details of the system as it will operate at dealer and distributor levels.

Broadly speaking, provision will be made for maintaining the current scope of reliefs which apply to excise duty, for example, in the case of transfers of residence and temporary importations, while there would be no effective change in the disabled drivers' scheme. To answer Senator Doyle's question — which annoys us all from time to time — on the transportation-importation arrangements, for years our system has been based on the fundamental that there are frontier controls and, we were following Community law, because you have to protect your own Revenue base. Those controls are gone; it is now an internal matter. Whether we have temporary importations is a matter for ourselves. As I indicated, we are going to keep them, but it is our decision how we keep them. I will be introducing new regulations later in the year which will allow us to simplify the system.

Comment on this

Does the Minister accept there is confusion and difficulty in this area?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

I have representations the length of my arm at my clinics on this issue from reasonable people who cannot cope with the system.

Comment on this

My previous post outside politics was in the Mater Hospital where doctors and other paramedics moved in and out of the country on an ongoing basis. I spent my time dealing with such issues. My first priority would be those who are trying to comply with the system. We will endeavour to simplify the system.

Comment on this

That it is transparent and that people know the rules.

Comment on this

With the absence of Border controls from January next, there will be no customs official to stop the non-compliant person who arrives at Rosslare in a car. The abuses of the system that take place at present include that of the stolen car, the burned out car and the missing registration plate cases and we will be far more open to such abuses next January. I agree with Deputy Doyle, it is necessary to have a system that is easily understood by the compliant taxpayer yet ruthlessly tough for those who do not comply with the regulations.

To ensure compliance with the new tax system, in the absence of Border controls Revenue officers will be given the powers necessary to secure the tax, including the power to stop vehicles and check the registration status. This is not at the point of entry. As I said this morning, frontier controls are no longer at the frontier, they are everywhere. People can no longer be stopped coming off the boat, traps will have to be set up elsewhere, more effectively with the back-up of the Garda and the Customs people who will now move into the Revenue section.

Provision is also being made for penalties, including forfeiture of vehicles in the case of defined offences, and for the making of administrative regulations. The actual rates of vehicle registration tax to apply will be set out in the autumn Finance Bill following discussions with the interested parties.

Comment on this

I have reservations in relation to the registration tax which the Minister proposed to introduce in the autumn Finance Bill. I have been buying five year old cars outside the country since 1985. One of them was only the second such vehicle to be imported privately in that year and I have been through the system three times. I discovered that the duty payable was based on the recommended retail price of the car here by the motor importers. It was very clear they inflated that figure. It may well be that they are now in conflict with the Competition Act. I took the deliberate step of going to the importers and said I was a cash customer for that new model. On a £28,000 car the price to me was £3,200 less the recommended retail price. Yet because of the system I had to pay duty on that figure which was an artificial raising of the price level. I ask the Minister to look at that racket which has been going on since 1985. Is it his intention to base the registration fee on the recommended retail price as given by this self-perpetuating body?

Comment on this

I have two questions, first, will the Minister clarify the position in regard to the liaison between local authorities and the Revenue Commissioners and, second, is there a possibility that dealers or garage owners might use this provision to increase the price of cars?

Comment on this

In regard to Senator Howard's query, that old system will be gone and I hope the new one will be simpler.

This provision should not result in an increase in car prices. Statistically, at present we have no proper single system of registration. Revenue will now operate that system and all vehicles will be registered with them. There will then be access to all that data on the new registration charge and that information will be available to all motor taxation offices. As I said in the other House, the data, and statistics available should be far better from now on

We will have to wait and see how the system operates for vehicles that are outside the system, or for secondhand vehicles. It is more complicated for such vehicles because one is not dealing with the distributors. For new vehicles which are being imported the relationship between the distributors and Revenue should provide us with a good registration record base.

Comment on this

When we consider section 104 and all of the areas on which that excisable duty has to be paid we come again to motor vehicles. It appears that the dismantling of borders will not give any great advantage in terms of a reduction in prices. Presumably, when the Oireachts sits in the autumn to agree this new vehicle registration tax it will be equivalent to the present excise and, therefore, we are unlikley to benefit from it. As certain exemptions are given for alcohol, petrol and beer, the Minister might consider a certain model of car that could be exempt if there was very low fuel consumption or if it was environmentally friendly.

If a person imports a vehicle they will have to go through the procedure outlined in section 106, whereby they have to give prior indication to the Revenue Commissioners that they intend to go abroad to bring in the vehicle. If it is done by a State vendor, I presume that is their responsibility but who is responsible for ensuring that the vehicle is registered? Is it the importer who does it in a collective sense, is it the individual who may import it on an individual basis or is it on each of them, depending on the process involved?

Comment on this

The payment system will be dealer-based but whoever has the vehicle in their possession bears the responsibility. In the case of the majority of the vehicles that will come through the distributor, the distributor will probably do the paperwork and register the vehicles under the new registration tax. However, if a person from outside the distributor system imports a car and is stopped at a patrol check, the obligation to comply with the regulations is on the individual concerned. The powers will have to be tougher because people in this system are taken more and more on trust. In many of the Single Market systems a great deal of paperwork has been discarded, there is far less administration and the onus is placed on the individual.

Comment on this

Section 135 deals with the temporary exemption from registration of a vehicle brought into the State for a limited period. What I am looking for here is some sort of definition, or at least a guideline, as to what constitutes temporary. Subsection (a) says that a vehicle is exempt from registration if it is brought into the State by a person established outside the State for private or business use. That would appear to apply to somebody who is not a member of the State, but who is a member of the European Community and is bringing his vehicle here for private or business use. Can that operate in practice, considering the new developments that are going to take place if we approve Maastricht? There will be many joint ventures, and businesses will operate jointly in different member states with the ease of finance and business concerns. Has the Minister anything in mind in terms of defining the temporary exemption from registration of a vehicle brought into the State for a limited period?

Section 135 (c) refers to a vehicle designed or specifically adapted as professional equipment brought into the State. What does "professional equipment brought into this State" for a temporary period mean?

Comment on this

As I said earlier about the general issue, regulations will be worked out later in the year on all the details and some of the questions Senator Costello is asking will be answered then. The section broadly provides authority for the Minister for Finance to regulate for temporary admissions of vehicles without the need to register here and pay the new tax. Precisely what kind of definition we would put on that will be in the regulations. The regulations will cover vehicles brought into the State by foreign visitors for private use. They will also cover vehicles brought into the State by foreigners and foreign companies for business, including vehicles to be temporarily exhibited or demonstrated or used in a competition, and specialised vehicles used by them or under their supervision. The intention is to broadly maintain the existing reliefs.

The last question was about the type of vehicle we would be talking about. Mobile workshops were mentioned. Vehicles designed or adapted for a professional purpose could be brought in by a visitor. Such a vehicle would be used exclusively by the foreign visitor who imported it under his personal supervision. Relief from excise duty on specially designed or adapted vehicles for professional purposes is available at present, so this is continuing that relief. Regulations will be made under the section 141(1)(b). We have described the conditions under which this exemption may be availed of, for example, length of stay, or any other conditions.

Comment on this

The mind boggles to think of visitors bringing in mobile workshops. It is not a category of vehicle I am accustomed to. I am not accustomed to regularly seeing visitors travelling around in mobile workshops. Why would the importation be of a temporary nature?

Comment on this

It would apply to something like the exhibitions in the RDS over the last week, where people were attending Italian and Swedish food fairs.

Comment on this

Is that not included in section 135 (b)? It would seem that this refers to some other category. Another problem arises under section 137.

Comment on this

Racing cars.

Comment on this

There are all kinds of examples — a mobile studio, TV crews etc. There are people passing through all the time.

Comment on this

These can be exclusively for the use of the person under their supervision. May I refer to the wording of section 135 (a): "brought into the State by a person established outside the State for his private or business use". Does that mean that a company director can send a fleet of cars into a member state that would be used for the benefit of the directors or the employees of a company or for the business use of that company on a temporary basis, on the grounds that they have valid and proper business operations in the country, and that as long as the importation is defined in terms of a business use such vehicles can be brought in? It is important that we would be able to define the quantity of the import and what constitutes the temporary nature of this exemption.

Comment on this

The regulations will do that. One could not bring in the vehicles without defining what they were going to be used for. The relief replicates the existing reliefs, they are not new reliefs. The regulations will set out details; they will stipulate and specify precisely how they will operate for people who are bringing in the goods or vehicles.

Comment on this

Do I take it that subsection (8) applies to new unregistered vehicles, or does it mean vehicles not registered in this State? I take it that it will be possible, as on the Continent, to drive freely from one country to another.

Comment on this

We are talking about vehicles that will be unregistered, coming from outside the State.

Comment on this

I take it this is an entirely new section which deals with what many motorists in the country have been looking forward to. With regard to the regulations on registration, I noted in the last week of March the European Commissioner on Taxation, Mme. Schrivener, produced a directive which aims for a substantial reduction in the rates of excise duty on bio-fuels derived from agriculture. This is tied in with vehicles where some of the bio-fuels are being developed for usage in ordinary vehicles. There are other types of vehicle specially designed for the use of multifuels. Do the Department or the Commissioner propose to provide any incentives for people to import multi-fuel vehicles, particularly vehicles which use bio-fuels derived from agricultural sources or non-food crops here. Is the Minister providing for the reduction of 90 per cent on excise duty on bio-fuels, as announced by the Commissioner, to take effect from 1 January next?

Comment on this

I take it the Senator is saying that Commissioner Schrivener was talking about a lower rate of duty on some of the vehicles used?

Comment on this

No, the lower rate of duty on hydrocarbons or oils.

Comment on this

The provisions are neutral. There is no increase or reduction specified. Are these recent proposals?

Comment on this

The last week in March.

Comment on this

They have not been discussed formally. Any incentives for the use of such fuels would be matters for decision. Were they talking about the pre-tax rate on cars also? I have seen documents on that. It is not envisaged in the legislation. There are no changes from the present position.

Comment on this

Do I take it the Minister does not propose to implement the 90 per cent reduction on bio-fuels from 1 January next, as agreed at the meeting on 24 June last year, and as announced as a directive by the Minister at the end of March?

Comment on this

I am not too sure precisely what proposal we are dealing with. It is not covered under this section. Any rates of duties or excise are budgetary matters and are not covered under these sections. The Commission proposals on the bio-fuels have not yet been discussed formally. The paper by Commissioner Schrivener has not come before the ECOFIN Council. The proposals in that will still come up. Many of the proposals adopted last year are on excise matters and will be implemented from 1 January next. The proposal on bio-fuels is not one of those.

Comment on this

I am in difficulty. I may not be speaking on the appropriate section but the point I was raising was agreed politically by the Council of Finance Ministers on 24 June 1991. The directive was to come into force on 1 January next. It related to the reduction of 90 per cent on the duty payable on bio-fuels. I anticipate that those bio-fuels could be readily imported into this country from 1 January next. There will also be a reduction in the price of fuel oils.

Comment on this

The ECOFIN decision of 24 June did not deal with the issue of bio-fuels, so it is not part of the 1991 decisions. The Commission proposals on bio-fuels have yet to be discussed formally by ECOFIN.

Comment on this

I was reading a press release from the Commissioner on 25 March last.

Comment on this

There may have been some proposals. I have checked the position, and it definitely was not part of it.

Comment on this

I thought it referred to bio-fuels. The Minister is correct. It does not. The matter refers solely to the registration, managing, securing and collecting of vehicle registration tax.

My query is in relation to subsection (5) about regulations, and how they shall be made. Subsection (5) states that: "the regulations under this Chapter shall be laid before the Dáil". Subsection (1) (a) states that they shall be made by the Commissioners. There are some very important regulations here. There are many new regulations in relation to identification marks in relation to the method of charging, securing and collecting vehicle registration tax. The basic principle we should enunciate in relation to the making of regulations is that they are made in this House and that the Minister presents them to this House. We must have a positive approach to discussing, debating and adopting such regulations, rather than having them made by an external body and where they pass into law almost automatically. Would the Minister consider taking a more positive approach?

Comment on this

Senator Doyle raised the issue of disability benefit and felt that it should have to come before the House. It involves major changes but most are technical regulations. They are worked out by people involved in the industry. They are purely technical. Having made some of those changes in previous Bills over the years works against one. I remember at one stage that I agreed when Deputy Quinn asked me to bring in regulations on worker-directors, or sub-board directors in semi-State bodies. The Deputy said I would have to lay the regulations before the Dáil. It was the worst thing I ever did. It was impossible to get the Dáil or Seanad to debate them as nobody thought the matter was relevant. It meant asking Opposition spokesmen to provide five minutes here or there. It was usually agreed to take them at 12 midnight at the end of the session. I have already conceded to Senator Doyle's request. These are technical regulations and should be left to the technical people to sort out. They are introduced under the general regulation specified in the Act. The Dáil can deal with them in that way. To lay technical and complicated regulations before the House is not right.

Comment on this

Section 150 deals with hydrocarbons. Perhaps it would be appropriate to put the press release from the Commissioner for Taxation, Mme. Schrivener, on the record of the House. The Minister may be able to give me some guidance on this. The press release stated:

On a proposal from Mme. Schrivener, the Commissioner with special responsibility for Taxation, the Commission today adopted a proposal for a Directive which aims at a substantial reduction in the rates of excise duty on fuels from agricultural sources, or "bio-fuels".

Mme. Schrivener said:

The aim of this tax incentive is to develop a very promising branch of agro-industrial production. It will be a decisive factor in the future of agriculture and for the Community's policies on energy and environmental protection.

The aim of the Directive is to bring about a Community-wide reduction in excise duty on bio-fuels, when they come into commercial use. It lays down that, from 1 January 1993, excise duty in each member state may not exceed 10 per cent of the rate in that same member state for the fuel being replaced (petrol or diesel). This thus amounts to a compulsory reduction by 90 per cent or more in the excise duty on bio-fuels in each member state.

The aim is of course to reduce the total cost price of bio-fuels to a level where they can be competitive with petroleum products. The proposal follows on from the political agreement reached on 24 June 1991 at the Council meeting on economics and financial affairs, concerning excise duty on fuels. Its basis is the same as the one adopted by the Community in the case of lead-free petrol, where a minimum rate of ECU 50 below that for leaded petrol was decided on.

Perhaps I could bring that to the attention of the Minister. I anticipate that it will be possible to have available in this country early next year supplies of bio-fuels, if we are to take diester which is being produced in Germany, France and Austria. I hope that the Minister can give the House an assurance that this country will be in line with the taxation proposals as adopted not only by the Community but by the Federal Government of Germany and the French President who have given very positive indications of their desire to promote the production of bio-fuels and environmentally friendly fuels and the promotion of non-food crops as part of the new strategy for a unified Europe.

I would like a comment from the Minister on Mme. Schrivener's directive.

Comment on this

Before I do, may I say that the section on hydrocarbons provides for a reduction of 2p, including VAT, on a litre of petrol? The equivalent would be just over 9p a gallon with effect from 1 May this year. It also provides for a 50 per cent reduction from 17p per gallon to 8.5p per gallon, which is the rate of excise duty on non-automotive LPG from 1 July next. The Exchequer cost of these measures is estimated to amount to £15.7 million this year, and £25.3 million in a full year. The duty reduction on petrol will have a number of positive effects.

First, it means that the rate of duty on leaded petrol in this State is now 8p a gallon lower than the corresponding rate in Northern Ireland, taking the exchange rate of 91p sterling to the punt. The total tax content is practically the same in both cases. While it is difficult to make price comparisons between prices North and South, as both are now decontrolled, there seems to be a small difference in favour of the Northern product due to the differences in the trade content. The incentive for people to travel to the North for petrol is now virtually gone. This will result in a further improvement in the competitive position of retailers in Border areas. Second, the measure will be of benefit to the motor trade and motorists generally as it is a directive reducing costs. Third, the timing of the reduction will provide a useful boost to the tourist sector.

On the non-automotive LPG, the halving of the duty should encourage consumption of this environmentally friendly fuel. It also takes account of the reality that no duty applies to the product in Northern Ireland.

On Mme. Schrivener's proposals, the June 1991 decisions dealt only with conventional fuels such as petrol and diesel. Senator McDonald was talking about the adoption of the proposals by the Commission. I think we have clarified that. The Commission have adopted proposals, but the proposals have not yet been discussed by the ECOFIN Council. Most of these discussions on outstanding points of excise duties and VAT related issues will be completed at meetings arranged in Brussels and Luxembourg in June and July. The intention is to have these matters concluded before 1 January 1993. Naturally, matters of excise duties, VAT and taxes have a budgetary context, but the ECOFIN Council will deal with them during the summer. If we are to prepare and be ready for an autumn Finance Bill, they will have to be ready before the holiday period in August in Europe.

We will implement whatever is adopted in due course with regard to these fuels.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Recommendations Nos. 16 and 17 are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move recommendation No. 16:

In page 170, subsection (2) (c), in the third row of the Table in the entry relating to £300,000 to delete "£500,000" and substitute "£400,000".

Bearing in mind that the Cathaoirleach appealed for brevity, if the Minister is accepting my amendment I can see no need to speak on it.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator wishes to make his case first. I will wait to see how I feel about it this time next year.

I assume that the intention of these two recommendations is to reduce the rates of licence duty in the £500,000 range. I have moved a long way on this and Senator Howard has been kind enough to acknowledge that. I have sought to replace the flat rate system of charge with a system structured on a progressive element. The rates and the bands have been pitched at levels to take account of the needs of the Exchequer and also the effect on licences. The effect of these recommendations will be to reduce the Exchequer yield and will add to the complexity of the system. I am satisfied that the system and the rates and the bands are reasonable and meet the objectives in this regard. Naturally I am not prepared to accept the recommendation but, by and large, as Senator Howard knows, I negotiated these with the trade. We will see how they work out. I hope they will be satisfactory. They are not unreasonable.

Comment on this

I think the Minister, with the assistance of Senator Howard, has moved in the right direction in relation to the imposition of duty here. Certainly the £100 annual charge or any increase in that would be inequitable. A move towards the rateable valuation on individual premises would have caused the same problem because it would have created an inequitable situation in terms of turnover. The turnover seems to be the appropriate area to be subjected to the duty. I am happy to see this change in the original proposals that were made by the Minister, although I would regard them as perhaps pitched too low considering the turnover that is there.

However, there is a slight element of schizophrenia in relation to the two proposals. The first amendment seeks to delete the figure of £500,000 and to substitute £400,000. The section sets out the rates of duty at £900 on a turnover of between £300,000 and £500,000. The effect of the second amendment will be to reduce that so that you will have £200 duty under £150,000; £400 between £150,000 and £300,000; £900 between £300,000 and £400,000 and £600 between £400,000 and £500,000. In fact, we are going backward before we go forward.

There is a certain contradiction in the two amendments. I am in favour of the first amendment but I do not agree with the second amendment.

Comment on this

There is a widespread feeling among publicans that in the category £300,000 to £500,000, with the cost of the licence rising from £400,000 to £900,000, was a sharp jump. The view was expressed that it might be more equitable if there was another tier included and my amendments seek to do that. I am simply reflecting a point of view that has been expressed in the trade. I have no apologies to make for putting down the amendments.

I acknowledge that this proposal in the Finance Bill is a much fairer system than what was originally proposed in the budget. I acknowledged last evening the response of the Minister to the representations made to him. I also made a point, but the Minister happened to be taking a telephone call at the time, that I believe there is an unfortunate tendency on the part of many people who are not familiar with the licensed trade to look at only the top 5 per cent. We had a number of examples of that here last evening and we have had some of it again today. That is unfortunate and it is doubly unfortunate if only the top 5 per cent of the Dublin trade is looked at.

I do not want to say anything that could be interpreted as a rural versus city division but the reality is that if you relate the number of licensed premises in Dublin city to the population and you do the same exercise in the rest of the country the difference is a multiple of nine. That shows it is unfair and unreasonable to judge the trade by the top 5 per cent.

I would like to put on record the findings of a very reputable firm of accountants and management consultants, Stokes Kennedy Crowley who have completed an investigation into the industry for the Vintners Federation of Ireland. They made the following comments:

1. When wages are charged to the accounts for the publican and/or his family, 43% of Vintners would show a loss in 1989 and 25% would break even.

2. When wages are charged to the accounts, Vintners with a turnover of less than £195,000 display consistent losses.

3. There is a significant and increasing reliance on food sales to maintain overall profitability in thr trade.

4. Over the period 1986-'89 drink turnover decreased in real terms by 2% while overall costs increased by 6.3%.

5. Average trading hours have increased from 82 hours in 1985 to 88 hours in 1989.

6. From 1982 to 1989, Vintners turnover declined steadily in real terms by 14.7% while individual personal consumption of goods and services has increased 14%.

7. Drink volume and value declined by 30% and 12% respectively over the period 1979-1989.

8. The volume of business in rural areas has declined steadily, Demographic trends underline the need to rationalise the over-supply of rural pubs.

Nobody will question the integrity and the capacity of Stokes Kennedy Crowley to do an objective assessment of the trade. I have talked a lot about balance and fairness during this debate. It is important to recognise that once you look outside the top 5 per cent you are looking at a totally different scene. If you look at the bottom 5 per cent, then you might say they should not be in business. I put down the amendment in response to a feeling that there might be a threshold there. I do not intend pressing the amendment. I simply wanted to air the matter and get the Minister's reaction to it and perhaps pursue it on another occasion.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I support the recommendation. I welcome the fact that the Minister has altered the original poposal. The increase from £400 to £900 when somebody exceeds £300,000 per annum turnover is very dramatic. There is definitely a case for a sliding scale there. That sort of increase will be viewed as being inequitable.

The Minister spoke earlier about the problem of tax evasion. I would be very much in sympathy with the thrust of his views, that we must at all times eliminate tax evasion and ensure there is equitable participation in the tax-paying process by everybody. There is an inbuilt temptation in this for a person who is on the border of £300,000 to adjust their books so that they would fall below the £300,000 level. I see a real risk there and I ask the Minister to consider it. Given that the publicans already produce their turnover books — for a publican it is part of the VAT process that they have a set turnover book — it should not be difficult to operate the sliding scale on one to ten points and still achieve the same level of money for the Exchequer.

There are a few hidden costs for publicans which are often overlooked. Publicans are very involved in community sponsorship, sponsorship of clubs and athletes. They also have to pay for VAT collection costs, they have high accountancy and book-keeping fees and, of course, there is the performing rights aspect. They also have a big tourism input. They are part of the tapestry of Irish life.

I believe the Minister would not be at odds with this recommendation if we achieved the same financial return to the Exchequer. As I said, there will be a great risk that a person who would normally have a turnover of £330,000 will now return £295,000, thus denying the State the proper amount of revenue. That is something that needs consideration. I ask the Minister to take the recommendation on board to see if it could be given practical implementation. The recommendation is not intended to deny input into the taxation system but rather to make it more workable.

Comment on this
Rory Kiely Acting Chairman (Mr. R. Kiely) Fianna Fáil

Senator O'Keeffe, I would like Senators to heed the request of the Chair because the proceedings have to be brought to a conclusion at 4 o'clock and there are eight or nine recommendations and more than 100 sections to go through.

Comment on this

I will accord with your exhortation. It is interesting to hear Senator Howard putting his point of view on behalf of the vintners. He has done this very well over a period. However, he puts his point of view in a smug manner. He now feels that the publicans have done well under this new provision as against the rateable valuation. My understanding from most publicans is that they are well satisfied with the provisions as they have been put in place.

Comment on this

He caused trouble last night and he will cause it again.

Comment on this

Is Senator Doyle interrupting me again?

Comment on this

The Senator is introducing a tone that was not in the House all day and it was unnecessary to refer to Senator Howard's contributions as smug. He should withdraw that remark. They have been excellent and considered. He put his interest on the line.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator O'Keeffe, without interruption.

Comment on this

In effect, I was paying Senator Howard a compliment for the excellent manner in which he conducted himself negotiating on behalf of the licensed vintners, but Senator Doyle has a facility for not listening but rather for mouthing.

Comment on this

I object——

Comment on this

May I just ask the Minister two questions; one relates to turnover. I understand from the Minister that he is talking in terms of bringing in £1 million this year and £2 million next year. To an extent, I go along with Senator O'Reilly when he asked if the Minister has reservations that we may not achieve the targets he set in this Finance Bill, and how does he propose to go forward if that situation did pertain? Given that we now have a major investigation into direct sales or cash sales in drink, has he any knowledge of the extent of cash sales and the loss that would accrue to the Exchequer.

Comment on this

Senator Howard has done a good day's work for the vintners and perhaps he should relax now that he is ahead. I want to ask the Minister two questions. First, is it not true that approximately three-quarters of the licensed vintners are below the £150,000 ceiling?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And that all they are paying in turnover duty annually is £200?

Comment on this

Four pounds per week covers the licence to sell beer, etc.

Comment on this

And that covers the vast majority of licensed vintners?

Comment on this

Over 75 per cent.

Comment on this

Second, on the definition of "turnover", is it based on the actual beverage turnover rather than entertainment and other activities?

Comment on this

"Turnover" in a pub includes all turnover — pub grub, food, entertainment and cover charges.

Comment on this

The turnover of most publicans is less than £150,000. One has to realise that the value of a pub is its turnover — it is the volume of business that it is doing. If a pub is trading to the tune of £1 million or more I do not think a rate of duty of £3,000 is excessive. There has been a tremendous level of inflation in the price of public houses.

I would be prepared to accept and understand the position that publicans are taking if there was open, free competition in the market. The reality is, of course, that there is not. There are parts of the city of Dublin where there is a small number of public houses to serve huge populations, and that situation has been allowed to develop and sustained arising from an anomaly in the law. The reality is that in south County Dublin there are five, six or seven public houses serving an area the same size as the city of Limerick where, I understand, there are 150 public houses.

If there is a little extra being asked by the Government in those situations where the law has greatly facilitated the making of profits and the developing of businesses in very restrictive circumstances where, as far as I am concerned, free competition is not taking place, I cannot see too much wrong with £3,000 being collected from people in those very happy circumstances.

If everybody is worried about the plight of publicans in Dublin, all one has to do is to look at the prices which public houses fetch. In that context, this sort of money seems quite small. Most of the pubs in those areas are worth over £1 million.

Comment on this

I support the point made by Senator Upton but would remind him that we are talking about the 5 per cent to whom my colleague Senator Howard referred. We are not pressing this recommendation; this is our way of getting the Minister to put his views on record so that the industry can understand the table that was agreed. I thank the Minister for changing his procedure of assessing licensed premises to set the licence fees. I would like him to put on record what the issues are that might make him change his mind. Rather ominously yesterday, I think it was in his reply to Second Stage, he suggested he would monitor very carefully the changes he has agreed to since budget day and if they did not work he would very quickly revert to what he had originally in mind. That is what he implied. What is the Minister looking for? What might make him change his mind? What did he tell the licensed trade now that he expects from them in terms of implementation of this new procedure?

Comment on this

I listended carefully to the trade. I am not saying they precisely mentioned these rates in the normal discussions. I can accept that maybe somebody can feel either hard done by or others can get away with it. Any changes are a matter for budgetary decision in future years.

It is not possible to be precise on the revenue as Senator O'Keeffe has asked me but I am confident we will be in the ball park estimated in the budget. I am confident the figures can be met. On Senator O'Reilly's question on whether people would adjust the figures to remain under a certain threshold, I have two answers. If they do it by reducing the price of the pint for the drinkers I will not mind. In fact, I would strongly recommend them to do that because they have room to manoeuvre.

Comment on this

The Minister will have full support from this side of the House.

Comment on this

Senator Howard might even support me.

Comment on this

If the Minister will reduce the VAT and the tax I will reduce by a similar amount.

Comment on this

If it is for any other reason naturally we would have to look at it. I talked ad nauseam to the trade and to the industry. The trade, as Senator Howard has said, is agreed that it can be abused, that some people may not play the game and if it were to lead to a position where Revenue figures over the past number of years for certain public houses showed a decline then we would have to move. I moved on that clear understanding. That is what I am saying. It would be very easy for that to show up working on a turnover basis.

Yesterday, I spoke about the current investigations. I do not think I need to say more other than they are ongoing. Like any trade, that is cash-oriented there can be difficulties but those discussions and examinations are being undertaken at present. On the question of £4 per week for a licence, regardless of what part of the country it is in I have never seen anyone giving a licence away for nothing. In the city, the few which were sold in 1992 have all been in excess of £100,000.

Comment on this

If a rural licence was allowed into Dublin it would come in at one tenth of that figure.

Comment on this

I accept that if it was a rural licence but Galway has the same problem as Dublin. Perhaps we could just talk about the top 5 per cent. In some parts of the country almost every public house is a family house, with the pub as part of the dwelling. I think they would manage to make the £4 per week to pay the licence in those public houses but we will not get into that. We will look at the Dublin scene.

As I said last night, the number of pubs in this city has remained the same since 1908 and there are now 600,000 more people living here. Still, they were up in arms about looking for £4 per week. That is the answer to the second question. I was hoping for a recommendation from the House but Senator Upton has at least given me an idea. If lobbies were to object to the £4 per week, instead of doubling the licence fee we might double the number of pubs.

Comment on this

A splendid idea.

Comment on this

I do not intend to do that yet but if the situation were to continue where increases in excise or on the VAT on drink were passed on to the customer and the Programme for Economic and Social Progress rates were passed on to the customer we would have to look at that. It is very unfair. Let us not talk about the small public house in rural Ireland that sees tourists for six weeks, that sees a mart every second Monday and only makes a few shillings when the GAA, the soccer club or the political parties or other functions have their night out once a year. Let us talk about the public houses in west Dublin or in other parts that have absolutely exclusive trade and then get upset over paying a maximum charge of £3,000. We are not even talking about £3,000. That is allowable against their tax. We are talking about far less. The same public houses are charging rates for drinks that are 20p or 25p more than Senator Howard. Let us be quite honest and blunt about it, the people serving in many of them would not know what PRSI meant and the lounge boys would not know either. Some people who led the campaign into this House were up in Dublin for the soccer match and came over here afterwards to lobby Senators and TDs and drove them all half mad at the parliamentary parties. I had to stay back for two hours on behalf of my own party and I know spokesmen of other parties also had to do that. These are the kind of issues we are looking at.

Because of decent, honourable Members of both Houses of the Oireachtas I went soft this year, probably too soft. These are issues that have to be monitored. Nobody is chasing the small family public house in rural Ireland or on the quays of Dublin, that is making no money but I am certainly chasing the massive public house that has a huge pub-grub trade, and rooms to let. I was checking the other day and a room let for a Sunday night function costs £100. At least that will now be regarded as turnover and I will get some satisfaction from it. Having said all that at the end of this long debate about drink, I still look forward at the end of this Finance Bill and four weeks in the House to having a pint.

Comment on this

There were a number of anomalies and misrepresentations in the discussion that took place in the last half an hour. From the Minister's statement it would appear that the publicans are not going to find favour with him in the next few years. I do not object to an increase in the licence fee but the reason for few pubs in County Dublin is that they cannot get a licence which is in the Minister's hands. Outside the city area one is restricted by one of the Minister's predecessor's provisions 20 or 30 years ago which made it impossible to get a licence unless one was over a mile from the nearest licensed premises. That is a ridiculous regulation. Ten years or so ago, in the other House, I spoke two or three times on this matter. County Dublin should be enabled to increase its number of licensed premises. I urge the Minister to rectify that situation.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Minister for Justice. The Senator may think the lobby over the licence fee was bad but to try to extend the number of licences——

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will not consider going back to his budget proposals because some premises in County Dublin have had their valuations trebled this year and on top of the budget proposals that would put them out of business. It is not correct to say that when a pub comes up for sale the sky is the limit. Pub prices are dropping. It is exceptional now if a pub makes £1 million; none of them makes £1.5 million which is an indication of the times. I am not here to defend publicans but when a Minister for Finance puts his eye on something where money can easily be made, he overdoes it, which is what is happening here. The Minister would need to be careful and give every consideration to it before he goes back to increasing the valuation. Are we discussing sections 155 and 156 or only 155?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are discussing Recommendations Nos. 16 and 17 which concern section 155, and if Senators keep making contributions like that we will never get to section 156.

Comment on this

I am pleased at the general tone of the Minister's reply, particularly in relation to the pubs with large turnovers. I hope his ideas will work their way into realities which are long overdue, although some reforms have been made in that area. The real problem is not in Dublin city centre where the population is reasonably similar to what it was when the law was introduced, but in the suburbs of Dublin, in the new expanding towns where everything has changed except the number of pubs. It is high time something was done about it.

I was interested in what the Minister said about the lobbies he met. I do not have any doubt about the power and the lobbying ability of the publicans, and I talk from experience. In the past I have made statements about public houses and I was highly impressed at the level of attention, knowledge and understanding that publicans had of what I said. As I said in this House to the Minister yesterday, I was impressed at his communicating ability when I went to a saloon bar in the evening and was met by the publican who seemed to be au fait with the most minute implications of what the Minister had proposed a few hours earlier. I began to wonder was it the Minister's brilliance as a communicator or what he was saying that governed the manner and the rapidity with which publicans respond to something that affects the amounts they have in their pockets.

Comment on this

That was not bad seeing that RTÉ were on strike.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that I referred yesterday to the first time requirement here to produce a tax clearance certificate. The time span from the passage of the Bill until renewal requirements begin to take place from July onwards is short. Perhaps a lead in time of one to two years may be allowed to enable everybody to come within the system.

I also raised the question of the in-pocket licence on which I would like clarification. These are licences of rural people who have retired or who no longer trade but because they have a valued asset these licences are renewed each year. Owners have retired and may be drawing the old age pension and are not in a position to provide a tax clearance certificate at renewal time. If they cannot produce this document, can their licence be renewed? If not the licence will lapse.

Comment on this

I foresee great difficulty for a bereaved person who at such time could not supply the tax clearance documents necessary or obtain them from the licence holder or the licence holder's representative. In many cases women are bereaved. Would it mean then that they would have to cease trading? Some provision should be made for people who may be in difficulty at licence renewal times.

Comment on this

Regardless of whether a person is trading, they will still get tax clearance or a letter to say they are not trading and will pay the licence in the normal way; they will not be refused a licence. In relation to the point raised by Senator McMahon, if a person has not fully regulated themselves into the system even though from 29 January to 1 October is a fair amount of time, a person refused a licence may appeal and they hold a licence while they are on appeal. I hope people will have their affairs in order by I October but, as I said in the other House, we are more anxious here to get people into line rather than drive people underground or out of business, so we will adopt a sensible attitude in this regard.

Comment on this

Regarding the question I raised with the Minister yesterday in relation to the bringing of clubs into the same regime in regard to availability of a licence I refer to clubs outside Dublin mainly. Many of these clubs have been funded at the taxpayers' expense and have received enormous grants. There is often an exclusive ambience about them. They are in direct competition with pubs with the advantage that they can trade during hours when pubs are obliged by law to close. They have a distinct advantage there. I would like to see that advantage being removed or the same opportunities given to all engaged in the retail sale of drink. I think the Minister is moving towards bringing clubs within that regime and I appreciate that.

Comment on this

All clubs will now pay £400 at licence renewal time which is the same as a pub with a turnover of £300,000 per annum and few clubs are likely to exceed such a turnover. The law on sales of drink by registered clubs are very strict and the main area of complaint against clubs would appear to centre on breaches of these rules and complaints which have to be taken up with the Department of Justice. Late-night drinking clubs are subject to the same £70 charge per night which is being increased to £90 per night. This applies also to hotels except that clubs are only entitled to 15 extensions per annum. Club licences are non-transferable and their issue is restricted only to the number of clubs that meet certain criteria regarding activities and number of members. These rules were tightened up in the 1988 legislation.

Comment on this

I move recommendation No. 19:

In page 222, line 27, after "them" to insert "or transferred between adults who are living together as brother or sister or who are living together as husband and wife and who have been in continuous occupation of the property in question for a minimum of two years".

This recommendation is to allow for the transfer of property between people who are, in effect, married, who have divorced perhaps and are now living together in a new relationship which is the same as if they had remarried. Given our inability to face up to the question of divorce in this country, we should be able to make this allowance for people who find themselves in new stable relationships who should not be penalised when, for example, one of them dies if transfers of one type or another have been arranged between them. That is essentially the point we are trying to make.

Comment on this

I second this reasonable amendment, an important one because many couples are not officially wed, but may be living together in a stable relationship for a long period of time. Numbers in this category of relationship are increasing here and in other countries throughout the world. It behoves us as legislators to recognise that fact and we should broaden the exemption clause to include not simply spouses but those in a stable common law arrangement. It is a logical request. One could argue that this provision might be open to abuse but marriages of convenience are open to abuse as well. As long as it is established that the relationship is stable the provision should include those couples.

In the second part of the amendment the provision for "brother or sister" is equally necessary particularly throughout rural areas where such arrangements are common. Provision for exemption should be made when transferring a beneficial interest in a property to another person. The recommendation contains two reasonable proposals and I would like the Minister to take them on board.

Comment on this

I support the thrust of this area on which we will all have to change our views rapidly. I point to the social welfare treatment of couples living together who are not married. They have conceded the principle in the Department of Social Welfare so it would appear unjust that the Department of Finance do not concede the principle as well. It may not suit the Department financially to concede it which may be why it is not being done, even though the principle must ultimately be accepted. I urge the Minister to take on board the recommendation proposed.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I support this important recommendation.

Comment on this

Stamp duty legislation already provides for a 50 per cent reduction in duty for transfer between brothers and sisters on the point that Senator Costello raised. The reduced rate is not subject to any conditions such as continuous occupation of the property being transferred. Apart from brothers and sisters the 50 per cent reduction in the stamp duty rate also applies to parents, grandparents, step parents, children, uncles, aunts, nieces, nephews and grandchildren. It is fairly extensive and a generous provision and there are no grounds which would justify its extension to 100 per cent relief for brothers and sisters whose occupation of the property is of two years or more duration.

Comment on this

It does not mean they are actually brothers and sisters. It just means they are living in separate bedrooms in one house but they need not be related.

Comment on this

Transfers between spouses are exempt from stamp duty since 1990 and it would not be appropriate to extend the exemption to couples who have been in continuous occupation of a premises for two years or more. Great difficulties could be created for those charged with the administration of any exemption and this would require proof of cohabitation and continuous occupation.

As I said in the Dáil when this matter was debated, I have great sympathy for couples unable to regularise their position before the law. The greatest tax problems for these couples arise in the income tax and capital acquisition tax areas rather than stamp duty.

Comment on this

This is a principle.

Comment on this

I need not emphasise to the House that this is an area involving complex difficult issues and that any potential solution would have to be subject to a thorough legal examination of the constitutional aspects. In addition I would point out that the White Paper on Marital Breakdown is to be published shortly. It would be putting the cart before the horse to attempt to tackle the taxation problems arising from marital breakdown in advance of the publication of and the debate on the White Paper. The ideal solution is for the tax law to follow and not lead the general law relating to marriage.

I can assure the House that when the White Paper has been published at that stage we will have a clear indication of what way arguments are going. On Committee and Report Stages in the Dáil we can start looking then for a solution to our tax laws.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us an indication of what it would cost if he accepted this recommendation?

Comment on this

There are no costings available because the way the amendment is worded renders it totally unworkable and open to all kinds of abuse. Neither is there a figure for the tax law area because it would require the same understanding in all our tax legislation.

Comment on this

If it is not going to cost anything——

Comment on this

The first part of the Senator's amendment, the brother/sister part, is unworkable.

Comment on this

We are more interested in the second part.

Comment on this

A costing has never been done on that.

Comment on this

Certain figures are available from the social welfare code to give an idea of costs of a common law relationship to a degree, it would be possible to cost it from that point of view. The Minister mentioned the problem of capital tax and acquisitions tax. I welcome the fact that the White Paper is examining that area but we have to look at it more carefully on the grounds that this is becoming the norm in society and will have to be addressed sooner or later.

Comment on this

I am advised that the costs may not be great but the issue is not cost but legality.

Comment on this

How did the Department of Social Welfare get over that?

Comment on this

Social welfare is a different case.

Comment on this

Because it suits the Government. They pay less if people cohabit. Of course they got over it.

Comment on this

If you work out the figures the difference is not great.

Comment on this

It is a principle of the Constitution to protect the family. When it suited the Government they got over the difficulty but because financially it does not suit the Department, they are not attending to it.

Comment on this

The issue is the legal aspect.

Comment on this

Social welfare had no trouble on the legal basis. Cohabiting couples are denied full social welfare rates.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is this recommendation being pressed?

Comment on this

Will the Minister come back on this next year?

Comment on this

As soon as the White Paper is available the Department of Finance can plan. People raise this issue all the time and we would rather deal with it.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I move recommendation No. 20:

In page 226, before section 222, but in Part VI, to insert the following new section:

"222.—The provisions of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act, 1976 shall not apply in relation to agricultural property."

It is punitive to continue applying capital acquisitions tax in the case of somebody inheriting a family farm because what happens is that a young farmer goes into debt to pay the tax which is difficult to recover from. They either sell part of their estate or borrow from a finance company. If they are in a viable position they will ultimately come into the tax net and the money will come to the Exchequer. The present tax does not make sense. I will rest my case to allow other Senators to participate.

Comment on this

This recommendation is too broad but we have a serious problem in relation to children inheriting from their parents. When the original capital acquisitions tax on agricultural property was brought in, it was designed to penalise people with large estates. What it is now doing is penalising farmers with small holdings, who are well stocked with no borrowings.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to consider exempting lineal descendants from this tax. It would be in the national interest to do so given the reform of the Common Agricultural Policy, where it is important that land be passed to a younger, more vigorous generation who will farm it in the national interest and contribute to the national wealth. The cost to the Exchequer would be modest and I strongly urge the Minister to take this into account.

At the Progressive Democrat national conference in Waterford a resolution was passed to the effect that children should be exempt where they are going to continue farming. It would be in our interest to encourage mobility and the transfer of land to the next generation.

Comment on this

I sympathise with Senators Dardis's and O'Reilly's sentiments. Looking at Commissioner MacSharry's continuation of the family farm plan, why should we tax a father handing on a working farm to his son so that the young farmer has to get a loan or sell a site in order to meet the tax? We must be concerned about the continuation and maintenance of family farms. I would ask the Minister to look at this next year and to grant an exemption.

Comment on this

The thresholds here have not been adjusted for some time. Basically what is wrong here are the thresholds that have existed for quite some time. They have not been adjusted. There is a specific threshold and allowance for agricultural land.

Comment on this
Division

The Seanad divided: Tá,

Tá 18
·
Níl 13
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I thank the House for the time and attention it has given to the Finance Bill. In particular, I would like to thank the spokespersons who were here throughout the debate — Senators O'Keeffe and Doyle, who put in two long days, and Senators Upton and Costello who were here throughout the debate. I would also like to thank the other Senators who contributed. Senator Howard fought a good battle for his declared interest. I thank the Cathaoirleach and the staff of the House for their work last night when we had a late session. I thank also all the Senators whose journeys home have been disrupted. I know these Friday sittings are not very popular.

This Finance Bill has been debated over four weeks between both Houses and the Special Committee. I thank the Seanad for the opportunity to use the Chamber for the meetings of the Special Committee, it was appreciated despite the fact that we had a slight hiccup. It meant that the time spent on this year's Finance Bill was more than double that has been spent on any Finance Bill for the last ten or 15 years. The Bill itself was treble the size of any Finance Bill over the last ten or 15 years. I thank the House for their co-operation and for passing the Bill. With the help of the staff over the week-end the necessary work on the legislation will be completed within the time limit.

I would also like to thank the officials from the Department and from Revenue who, not only today but over the last five or six months because of changes that will be brought about by the Single Market, put in a huge effort and worked many late nights. I thank everybody for their help and co-operation.

Comment on this

I sincerely thank the Minister for his time and detailed attention to the Finance Bill in the Seanad, because he could easily have handed over to a Junior Minister or another Minister and left us for even half the time; however, he spent all the time the Bill was before us in this House. That is the way we believe it should be done. I thank him for his patience and his detailed replies. I regret that, because of the ordering of business, we did not get to complete all the sections. Many interesting sections were not gone through in detail. I also thank the Minister's large army of advisers who accompanied him. He did not leave himself open to any risk of a lack of information. He was well guarded and well supplied with advice and information. I ask him to thank the staff of the Department and those who supported him in this House.

I would also like to thank the staff of the House and the staff of the Seanad who sat late last night and today, being a Friday. We appreciate very much being able to continue our business when we have a busy schedule.

Would the Minister take with him the recommendations that were not reached and make himself familiar with the recommendations to sections 226 and 232? I am sure other Senators would like their recommendations to be looked at. I would like him to look particularly at the anti-avoidance and anti-evasion recommendations. These two areas are causing some concern. I would ask the Minister to take on board the points made on section 116. Again, I thank the Minister and his staff for the time and detailed attention he gave us in this House.

Comment on this

I will look at them.

Comment on this

I would like to thank the Minister for the pleasant and courteous manner in which he conducted the debate. I want to especially thank him for the fact that he has stayed with this debate throughout yesterday and today. It has been a very long session. I greatly appreciate the respect he has shown this House and, indeed, the attention and the courteous manner in which he treated all our recommendations and our points of view. That is very welcome.

I also want to allude to the fact that he was very well spoken. This is the first time that I have seen a full array of officials on this side of the House waiting to bail him out if he got into any difficulties. Indeed, if you thought that was all the support he had when we went next door there was another army of senior officials from the Department watching the proceedings on the monitor. The Minister did not have a thing to worry about.

Comment on this

A phalanx of concerned people. I thank the Minister for his presence here over an extended period. In my experience, I do not think we have had a Cabinet Minister preside over all stages of legislation going through this House. He is to be congratulated. This is a significant and complex piece of legislation and he dealt with it with his usual expertise. I thank him for his patience and expertise in answering all the questions that were raised. I wish him and the legislation well.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We do not want Second Stage speeches.

Comment on this

We all know Deputy Ahern to be a very amiable and approachable Minister. Like other Senators, I commend him on his commitment, and particularly his respect for this House. He stayed here throughout the debate, having already had four days in the other House and showed patience and a willingness to elucidate every problem that was presented to him. Despite some interventions, it was a very amiable discussion.

I commend the other speakers to this debate. I thank the stenographers for the patience they showed in staying long hours above the call of duty. Finally, I am delighted that we got through this Bill in a very courteous and effective manner.

Comment on this

On behalf of the Independent group, I would also like to thank the Minister, his advisers and the staff of the House for the very courteous and efficient way they dealt with this matter. I would ask the Minister, in support of what Senator Doyle said, whether he will consider the recommendations that were not reached. In particular, I have in mind what I think is an excellent recommendation in the name of Senators Howard and Doyle — amendment No. 21. It is, in fact, a kind of citizens' charter. I believe the Revenue Commissioners, by and large, already abide by the terms of this charter and it would be very good if this became an almost automatic part of legislation. It is very like the citizens' charter that the British Prime Minister, Mr. Major, has been talking about introducing. I wonder if the Minister would consider this, with no implied criticism of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

I would like to congratulate the Minister on his first Finance Bill. While we disagreed with certain aspects of it, we certainly recognise that it is very substantial legislation. I want to thank the Minister for his courtesy in dealing with the debate. It was good to see a Minister stick with the Bill from the very beginning to the end in the Seanad. Too often that does not happen.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Before I call the Leader of the House, it occurs to me that this Chamber played a very important role in what was very important legislation, hiccups and all. We were pleased we could facilitate the Minister, and that the Bill has been so successful.

Comment on this

I would like to inform the House, with regret, of the death today of the Cathaoirleach's wife's father. On behalf of the House I would like to extend our sympathy to her, and I hope you, Sir, will pass on that message. May he rest in peace.

Comment on this

On behalf of my party, I would like to join in that expression of sympathy and to say how much we appreciate it that you, Sir, stayed here today for this Bill in spite of your bereavement. I would like you to convey to your wife the sympathy of this side of the House.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Thank you. When is it proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

At 2.30 p.m. on Wednesday, 27 May 1992.

Comment on this