We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Electoral (No. 2) Bill, 1991: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–178 of 366. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (No. 2) Bill, 1991
Enacted

No. 44 of 1991 ›

Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 98, 99, 104, 105, 108 and 109 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:

In page 61, subsection (1), line 44, to delete "impaired" and substitute "challenged".

This amendment relates to terminology. In particular it deals with terms such as "illiterate" and the use of the term "illiterate" when people are describing themselves. When somebody is illiterate it is embarrassing enough without their being obliged to take an oath and, as part of that oath, to say "I am so illiterate that I am unable to vote without assistance". That terminology belongs to the Dark Ages and I hope the Minister will be able to accept our amendments which talk in terms of people being impaired, incapacitated, challenged, more modern terms.

There is a lot of literature available on the usage of this terminology which is in support of the general principle we are trying to have accepted here. I believe that terminology is out of place in the modern world and it should be replaced with a more modern, more acceptable and less embarrassing usage of words for people who are already in enough difficulty. It is unacceptable for somebody who is challenged, or who is not able to read or write, to find themselves forced to take an oath to that effect. I hope the Minister would accept our amendment, which introduces a more acceptable modern form of words.

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Minister of State at the Department of the Environment (Mr. Wallace) Fianna Fáil

Section 103 restates with amendment the law in relation to voting by blind, incapacitated and illiterate electors. Under this section a person who satisfies the presiding officer that he is so impaired or that he is otherwise so physically incapacitated that he is unable to vote, may have his ballot paper marked for him on his instruction by a companion or, if he wishes, by the presiding officer.

Amendments Nos. 98, 104 and 108 propose to substitute the word "challenged" for the word "impaired". Where it occurs in section 103, amendments Nos. 99, 105 and 109 propose to substitute the word "challenged" for the word "incapacitated" where it occurs in the section. I understand that the word "challenged" in a sense in which it is used in the amendments is an example of a new correct political vocabulary which is currently fashionable in certain quarters. However, I have to say that I have searched in a number of modern standard English dictionaries, as well as in standard law dictionaries, and I have failed to find the word used in that sense in any of them. In legislation we must aim above all for clarity and must as far as possible use words and expressions which have a clear and specific meaning. The word "challenged" which the amendment proposes to substitute for the existing word in this section would, I believe, be confusing, unclear and could leave a doubt over the operation of the section. I would ask the Senators to withdraw this amendment.

Comment on this

I appreciate the point the Minister has made that he has not come across the term being used in that fashion in the standard dictionaries he may have consulted. The term we are introducing here —"challenged" to replace "impaired" or "incapacitated" or "illiterate"— is not one that would have existed in the very distant past. It has come into existence in recent times because of a concern by organisations who are dealing with people who have been impaired or challenged in their sight or hearing, or in their physical and mental ability to cope. Therefore, it is something that is not fashionable as such; it has developed because of the need to treat these matters with sensitivity and delicacy.

I would say to the Minister that, while he may not find this term in his standard Oxford Dictionary, it would be useful for him to consult with some of the organisations that represent people who are challenged either in physical or mental terms and he would find tremendous sympathy for using more satisfactory language in an electoral Bill. Perhaps the Minister would contact some of the organisations involved and see what their response would be to adjusting the language used here to a more benign form of words.

Comment on this

As I have already said, the term as used here is not in the standard dictionary, therefore I am not prepared to accept the amendments.

Comment on this

We have acknowledged that because this new meaning has developed over the last number of years. However, the organisations who represent people with difficulties are very concerned that we should use a more benign form of words. While these words may not be the orthodox dictionary definition, nevertheless they correspond to the human needs in this area. If we are putting together a consolidation Bill in order to provide the basis for our electoral law for the 21st century, the least we could do is to see that it corresponds with the developments that have taken place over the last decade in this area.

Comment on this

Very briefly, in relation to the last point, most of the dictionaries we have consulted were issued within the last 12 months. We have looked at all legal dictionaries and the term does not arise. Therefore I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 100:

In page 61, subsection (1), line 45, to delete "is so illiterate" and substitute "has underdeveloped reading or writing skills so".

I thought we were discussing the amendment when I spoke last. Briefly, what I am saying is that I do not think it is wise, necessary or desirable that somebody who is illiterate should be forced to describe themselves in those terms. We have substituted for the term "illiterate" the words "has underdeveloped reading or writing skills" and we have incorporated that into the oath which somebody may be obliged to take if they are challenged at voting. I do not think it is desirable or acceptable in this day and age that that type of terminology should still be in use. It is very embarrassing for somebody who is illiterate to have to declare that. We should try to facilitate them and be as gentle as possible in allowing them to let that be known. There are a number of people who are illiterate and who go to great lengths to try to disguise that from the rest of the population.

Comment on this

This amendment relates to the most insensitive of the descriptions in the Bill. To describe oneself as being so illiterate as to need assistance means that the electors are being compelled to be self-deprecatory and to desnigrate themselves. The Minister can see the almost blatant need for a more sensitive wording to describe the situation and he should accept the amendment. The words "has underdeveloped reading or writing skills" would describe the same situation but in terminology that would do less potential damage to the feelings and self-esteem of these people.

Comment on this

I join in the protest against this form of words. The terminology is unbelievably offensive. Can anybody here imagine what it must be like to be asked to go in and take an oath, or whatever may be required under this section, and to say "I swear that I am so illiterate that I am unable to vote without assistance"? It does not bear contemplation that we should request a person to do that. I ask anybody in this Chamber, if it were their own case, would they feel happy taking an oath or affirming in whatever form that they are so illiterate that they cannot vote without assistance.

As I and other speakers have said since we started debating this Bill, in order to be constructive, if we could put ourselves into the shoes of people who will be involved in these proceedings, is there anybody here — and I see speakers offering from the other side — who would feel happy, comfortable or at ease making such a statement about themselves? I find it very difficult to imagine. What will happen is that these people will not vote because they will not be prepared to go through the denigrating, mind boggling procedure of having to use this form of words. To substitute them with what is proposed in amendment No. 100 — that is, "has underdeveloped reading or writing skills"— sums up the position more accurately than what is in the Bill. I ask the Minister to put himself in the shoes of such a person and to ask himself if he would contemplate swearing such an affirmation.

Comment on this

From the experience we have gained down through the years at various elections, I think very few people fall into this category now. I recall 25 years ago or more we would have, perhaps, five people in each polling booth in rural parts of Westmeath who would fall into this category; nowadays there may be one or two people. No matter what the numbers are, previous speakers have a point about the sensitivity of the wording in question and I ask the Minister to consider this humane request and to seriously consider a different formula of words.

Comment on this

I, too, support the case being made here because the word "illiterate" is not in keeping with present-day standards. A formula of words is required at this point and I suggest the words, "unable to read or write" rather than "illiterate". It is very embarrassing for votes coming into a polling station to have to indicate that they are illiterate. I appeal again to the Minister to look at this. A very strong case in being made by Senators Hederman and Upton and, on that basis alone, I hope the Minister would have the case reviewed.

Comment on this

I support Senator Upton's amendment. It is difficult to accept that all the advisers, legal and otherwise, could not find another word. I do not know if "disadvantaged" would be suitable but "illiterate" is not appropriate. Senator Cassidy was correct in saying the number of people who lack adequate learning is much lower than it was many years ago, but there are still many of them out there. You discover this when you go to the polling station on election day and find you have to pass them to somebody to be given assistance to vote.

If it does not interfere with the structure of the Bill, there should be no problem using some other word.

Comment on this

I support the tone of the case being made although I do not necessarily agreed with the amendment which proposes to substitute the words "has underdeveloped reading or writing skills" for "is so illiterate".

In the recent referendum, the voter simply had to put and CX in one of two boxes, yet, more than 7,000 people spoiled their votes. Obviously some people used that as a way of protesting, but we should address the question of teaching and guiding people how to cast their votes.

Fewer people today than in the past have the misfortunate to be in the category we are discussing here. Thre are however, many people who find it difficult to vote and we must address their situation. In many polling stations, polling officers are considerate when it comes to giving assistance to those who require it, but individuals living alone may not have friends to go with them or people to assist them at polling stations. First they have to find the table they should go to, and then they have to approach the polling officer. It is difficult for them to admit their circumstances, particularly when there may be many local people present who know them. It is not fair to put them on the spot and have to say they are illiterate or have underdeveloped reading or writing skills. This, is something that should be looked at by the Minister.

I do not know what the Department of Education have been doing about this problem. Obviously some progress has been made to combat illiteracy but a great deal more needs to be done. A more modern discription of diminished capacity in this area should be found and perhaps the Minister could come back on Report Stage with another wording. I would support the concept of the amendment but I do not know whether "underdeveloped" is necessarily the right description. A person may lack or have a diminished capacity for the skills of reading or writing. I ask the Minister to take note of what I and other Senators has said.

Comment on this

I feel very strongly about this section. We must, at all times, ensure that we maintain the dignity of the person many people have a reading and writing disability.

We should make voting as simple as possible to encourage as many people as possible who cannot read or write to vote. Many people do not vote because of the indignity of having to come into a polling station and make it known that they have this disability and they may not want neighbours to know. We should do everything we can do to maintain the dignity of the person.

I agree with Senator Cosgrave when he said that we should look at this situation in toto to see if there is another mechanism by which people who cannot read or write may be given an opportunity to vote. Handicapped poeple have a special voting paper. As the people incapacitated perhaps the Minister would consider giving them a postal ballot which would be properly supervised. I support my colleagues, Senators Foley and Cassidy, who prdoposed that the words “unable to read and write” should be substituted for “illiterate”, but it is my view the issue goes beyond that. We should look seriously at the overall situation, maintain the dignity of the person, allow that person to vote in private where other people will now know them haved this disability, and treat them incapacitated persons.

Comment on this

There is a basic principle involved here: every citizen who wishes to vote should be facilitated in so doing. It should be the objective of the Oireachtas and the State to ensrue that all citizens who have enough interest to go out on polling day to cast their votes should be entitled to do so. In some ways, this legislation contradicts that priciple. I believe it would be very wrong of us to restrict the basic right in any way.

Having said that, I realise that one must strikes a balance, in the sense that we cannot have abuses in the way the election is conducted. We have already discussed marks, numbers on ballot papers and the sort of abuses that could occur, but I do not see how this section can be so abused. I recommend strongly that a simple declaration or swearing that a person is incapacity does not matter. To be illiterate is to be incapacitated. I could envisage an extreme situation where a person is deaf and illiterate. I modated how they would be accommodated within the scope of this legislation. I am sure the Minister agrees with the principle they every citizen, however incapacitated, who wishes to exercise the democratic franchise should be facilitated under this legislation.

Comment on this

I would like to join with those who are suggesting that this issue is broader than the question of hte use of the word illiterate because I do not think there is any indignity involved in the use of that wods. The indignity may arise in relation to how the person who is nsoo describedd is treated at a polling station.

I agree with those who suggest there should be a better way of allowing these people to vote. It does not make any difference whether somebody is described as being unable to read or write or whether he is being described as illiterate; the problem is when he goes into the polling booth, he is taken aside and has to go through the indignity of voing in a special way. The form of words used to describe the disability is irrelevant; it is the way a person is treated at a polling station that is relevant.

I have never heard an illiterate person object to the use of the word illiterate, but I have heard illiterate people criticising the way they are treated, not alone at polling stations but in public places, when they go to collect social welfare benefits or go to a hospital. It may be necessary to widen the category of those who can vote either by post or by arrangement prior ot election day but how that can be done is a matter for the Minister. The word itself is not very important, it is the way people are treated that is important.

Comment on this

If I may take up that last point, I think the word is important, People are extremely sensitive about the way they are discribed when it refers to some challenge either to their mental or physical well-being. They can be extremely sensitive. People make huge efforts to disguise the fact that they are illiterate; in fact, it is one of the biggest blocks in getting people to go to adult education classes where ther are others present. The current approach is to work on a one-to-one basis. People are very concerned lest the public should know, they are embarrassed by the fact that they are illiterate because everybody is suppossed to be literate.

The points being made by speakers from the other benches are most welcome. What we are trying to do in this legislation is to facilitate the greatest number of people to exercise the right to vote and we should ensure that any obstacle to that is taken out of the way. We have pointed out throughout this debate that this is a particular obstacle. The forms of words used, particularly in relation to people who are mentally and physically incapacitated have been most insensitive thorughout the whole Bill. We have instanced it in relation ot references to imbeciles, to those who are physically incapacitated. We are now looking at references to those who are illiterate. The wording here is not in keeping with modern terminology. We should look at the whole Bill in this respect and try to get a better choice of words to facilitate to the maximum those people whose right to vote is being affected by the language that is being used here.

Even at this late stage, I suggest to the Minister that he should contact the organisations which represent the people about whom we are concerned here so that a form of words may be found which is more humane and sensitive and in keeping with modern terminology. The result would be better legislation, would facilitate people who go out to vote without embarassing them in any way. Perhaps the Minister might still take up that suggestion.

Comment on this

The word illiterate is defined in the Collins English Dictionary, 1991 edition, as “unable to read and write”. What is invovled here is a question of draft style. The meaning of the provision, as drafted, is clear. However, I will certainly look at it again and see if we can come up wth more suitablle wording. Senator Foley suggested we could use the wording “unable to read and write”. If the Senator wil withdraw the amendment we will come back to it in due course and have another look at it.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for the attitude he has adopted to the debate. We will certainly withdraw the amendment and hope he will be able to come up with a more suitable wording.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 101:

In page 61, subsection (2), line 48, after "candidate" to insert ",election agent, deputy election agent".

This amendment simply seeks to increase the number of people who can request that an oath be taken. We have sought to broaden it to include election agents or deputy election agents in addition to personation agents. The main concern here is that small parties such as mine may not have personation agents in every station. If an appropriate set of circumstances should arise we would like the election agent or the deputy agent to be able to go in and make such a request.

Comment on this

Under section 103 (2) an elector seeking assistance in voting may be required to take an oath or affirmation that he is unable to vote without assistance. The presiding officer may make a request of his own volition and must do so if required by any candidate or personating agent present in the station. Amendment No. 101 proposes that the candidate, his election agent, his deputy agent or a personation agent may require the presiding officer to put the oath or affirmation.

I notice that an identical expression is used in subsection (4) dealing with a similar situation but no amendment has been put down in that case, whether deliberately or by oversight. A somewhat similar situation arises in section 105 (2), section 110 (2) (e), and section 111 (2) (b) and again no amendments have been put down.

I do not think there is any question or principle or meaning involved here. What is desirable is that, as far asd possible, there should be consistency of expression throughout. If the Senator withdraws the amendments I will have a look at the sections concerned to see if a uniform formula can be used.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for the open-minded attitude he has taken to this matter.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendements Nos. 103, 107, 129, 130 and 131 are consequential on amendment No. 102 and all may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 102:

In page 62, subsection (2), line 5, to delete "sware by Almighty God (or —".

I understand that it has been proposed in the Law Reform Commission report that the use of the term "Swear by Almighty God" be discontinued. We are tabling this amendment so that the recommission report be agreed to and honoured.

Comment on this

Section 103 (2) provides for the form of oath to be taken or affirmation to be made by an elector, if requested, when applying for assistance in marking the ballot paper. Section 111 (2) provides for the form fo oath or affirmation to be used in cases where an elector's right to vote is challenged. This group of amendments would remove the option for taking an oath and an elector would be limited to making an affirmation. I understand it is the general practice in the courts, in tribunals of all kinds and in many other situations where a degree of formality is deemed necessary, tp require that evidence should be given on oath and where a witness does not wish to take an oath, on grounds of conscience, he or she may make an affirmation.

I understand that from the legal point of view the effects and implications are identical in each case. In the sections referred to, we are following this general practice and repeating the existing law on the matter. If it were to become a matter of national policy to abandon the practice of taking oaths and to substitute the making of affirmations in every situation where the taking of an oath is provided for at present, this should be done by way of a general provision applicable to every situation and perhaps something on the lines of the Statutory Declaration Act, 1938 might be appropriate. What is not appropriate is that a matter of this kind should be approached on a piecemeal basis. On this ground and without expressing any view on the principles involved, I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I accept the point made by the Minister that it is difficult to make changes of this nature on a piecemeal basis. The oath, in its present form, is used extensively in other areas also. What we are dealing with here is a matter of a purely secular nature, the right to vote, an affirmation in relation to the exercise of the franchise.

One could also take the view that one must start somewhere. The Law Reform Commission has recommended that this be the place where we start, namely, in the electoral legislation. I wonder why the Minister should choose to go against the wishes and recommendations of the Law Reform Commission report?

There is a certain dichotomy between Chruch and State. There are differences of opinion from time to time as to how that perception should be asserted. It offends a large number of members of the community that there is not a standard form which does no require an oath calling Almight God into play in a matter of this nature. The Minister could consider taking the initiative in this area and perhaps set precedent that could be followed in due course in relation to other matters.

Comment on this

I can only repeat what I have said. It is important that there be unformity in this area. I would prefer that this amendment should not be pressed, for the reason I have outlined.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 113:

In page 62, subsection (5), lines 42 and 43 to delete "and the personation agents".

This amendment has been put down primarily because of a concern that this part of theBill may be unconstitutional arising from the constitutional obligations to preserve the secrecy of the ballot. In the case of some of the provisions here it would seem to me that it may not be necessary to have the personation agent present when the elector is voting. I confess that a certain degree of concern could also arise if one looks at this from the other point of view, namely, that the personation agent may fill a role in ensuring that the ballot paper is marked in accordance with the wish of the elector.

Comment on this

Under section 103 (5) where a blind or incapacitated elector does not wish to have his ballot paper marked by a companion, or where the elector is illiterate, the presiding officer shall mark the ballot paper on behalf of the elector in the presence of the elector and the personaiton agents only.

Amendment No. 113 proposes to delete the provision under which the personation agent may be present where a ballot paper is marked by the presiding officer under this section. The purpose of having the personation agents present during this process is to enable them to satify themselves that the presiding officer complies with the instructions of the elector. An elector who is totally iliterate or has severely impaired vision will be unable to verify that ht presiding officer has marked that ballot paper as instructed. It is considered proper that the personation agents should oversee the marking. Otherwise the presiding officer could be put in an invidious position without protection against malicious charges of misdemanour. The presence of the personation agents would be essential of protect the interests of the elector and the presiding officer.

The procedure provided for the marking of ballot papers by the presiding officer was referred to in a Superme Court case of McMohan v. the Attorney General (1972, Irish Reports, page 69.) the court appeared to accept that the precedure was a necessary limiting of absolute secrecy. The Chief Justice of the day referred to it as reconciliation of the person's right to vote with a general right to vote by secret ballot. I ask the Senators to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister what changes there are in this Bill compared with what happened heretofore? I would like to satisfy myself as regards the point being made, the element of secrecy which should be maintained, and also another point. I know of a case of a home for the blind where 94 per cent of the votes went to one candidate in one party. I do not know whether it was done according to the procedure described here or whether there were one or two people watching at the time. Is the wording in the Act the same of that of this Bill?

Comment on this

Section 103 is identical to existing legislation.

Comment on this

It seems from what the Minister has said that the matter has already been dealt with and that the question of constitutionality has been covered. Is that correct? Has the possibility of its being unconstitutional in terms of a breach of secrecy been covered? I did not catch the gist of the case the Minister quoted, but perhaps he could confirm that for me. Nevertheless it does have a certain dilemma.

The presiding officer is the independent person who is there to preside over the procedure and to ensure that everything is operated in accordance with the law, whereas the personation agent is partisan and is acting on behalf of a particular candidate. It undoubtedly is a breach of the secrecy of the ballot. On the other hand, one has to take certain percautions to ensure that the presiding officer is not operating improperly in relation to the wishes of the elector. As we have seen in the Bill already, there is no comeback against presiding officers if they are in breach of their duties in the matter.

We have a dilemma between, on the one hand, the secrecy of the ballot and on the other, the fact that the personation agent would be obviously in breach of the secrecy of the ballot being a person who may have an interest in seeing how an elector votes. It does not resolve the problem. The problem is still here once the personation agent is present.

Can the Minister confirm that the constitutional issue was dealt with already, and can he indicate how to deal with the dilemma of the secrecy of hte ballot being breached?

Comment on this

The Supreme Court appears to accept that the procedure was a necessary limiting of absolute secrecy. The Chief Justice of the day referred to it as a reconciliation of the person's right to vote with a general right to vote by secret ballot. The need to have the presiding officer's actions witnessed by an independent person was discussed fully in relation to voting by special voters. In that case his actions are witnessed by a grada. The presence of a witness is essentially to protect the presiding officer against any malicious charges.

Comment on this

The merely confirms the point I was making that while the presiding officer is an independent person whose duty is to oversee the full operation of the procedure at the polling station, a personation agent is definitely not so. The matter has been resolved in relation to the special voter by bringing in a member of the Garda Síodchána who is also in an official independent capacity.

The Minister argued earlier that we need somebody present who would be above question and above suspicion while the vote was being cast. In this case it would seem that the personation agent is certainly not the person who should be inspecting the vote that has been cast and becoming aware how an individual person voted. That person may have no wish that any partisan person of any party should be present to see how he or she voted. We certainly have an infringement of the rights of the more vulnerable members of the electorate in this section.

Comment on this

I support the point ably made by Senator Costello. If it is the presiding officer and a member of the Garda Síochána, that independence about which Senator Costello spoke would be maintained, but if it is the presiding officer and the personation officer, that independence is not mentioned. Is there any reason it could not be a member of the Garda Síochána who would oversee the matter?

It must be intimidating for members of the electorate to be collected at the home at which they are residing. They are likely to be either elderly or in a home for the deaf or for the blind. They would be collected, probably by a member of a political party and brought to the polling station and would obviously, by that act alone, feel under a certain obligation. That is the way of human nature. It is right that they should feel under the obligation if they have been looked after, cared for and cosseted and brought along. The driver may offer to wait to bring them home again and will tell them to vote the right way, all that sort of thing. They might want to vote for a member of a different party or even, God forbid, for an Independent who henceforth should be known as "Non-Party", but suddenly they realise that the personation agents will be watching as their paper is being filled out. That can hardly be conducive or helpful to having them vote the way they want. I wonder if the Minister could look at this again.

Comment on this

Agents of all candidates are entitled to be present for the vote if they wish. It is not restricted to any one agent. Making provision for the substitution of the requirement for the presence of agents at this process by the presence of some other person, such as a garda, would not be practicable. While one or more gardaí may be in attendance at a polling station, there is no statutory requirement that they be present, and in practice there may be polling stations at which gardaí are not on duty at all times or for the whole of the polling day. I would also point out that blind of incapacitated person can have a companion with them if they wish when they are voting.

Comment on this

I am still very unhappy with the Minister's response. The provision refers to the presiding officer in the presence of the elector and the personation agent and no other person. A companion cannot be present while the ballot paper is being marked, only the personation agent. The personation agent is an unsatisfactory person to have present.

I thought there was a member of the Garda Siochána present at every polling station. It may not be compulsory but I do not recollect being at any polling station where there has not been a garda present. If the majority of polling stations, if not all, have a garda present, it would be a simple matter to call in that member of the Garda Síochána rather that the personation agent or agents whom the electors might very strongly oppose being present while they actually cast their vote to see what way they cast it.

It remains a big problem for us that it is only those people who are already experiencing difficulty, those people who are physically or mentally challenged, who are to have this further difficulty of having the personation agent present, with or against their wishes, without having any choice in the matter, to see which may they voted. That may cause them trouble and embarrassment at a later stage. It is still not satisfacory.

Perhaps the Minister would indicate whether it might be possible for the Garda Síochána to deal with the matter, whether there is a garda present at all polling stations and, if not, whether it would be possible to have them at all polling stations.

Comment on this

I am getting more worried about this section as I read it and listen to the Minister. As somebody who is not a member of a major or even minor political party, somebody who has heretofore called herself an Independent but now will have to call herself Non-Party, I can assure the Minister that it is only the major political parties that can maintain the presence of personation agents at all the polling places particularly the small ones. If personation agents of a Non-Party person are thin on the ground, they will probably be asked to go to the polling places where there is a large number of voters.

In the case I have outlined, it was a home of the blind. There were over 100 electors on the register for that home and 94 per cent of them voted for a particular candidate. Now, of, course, I realise it came about because one of the candidates was present in the room where the voting was taking place. That candidates was from one of the main political parties and had a personation agent there. None of the other candidates had a personation agent in that hall because it was a small place. I had always meant to check what safeguards were in place in the Act because I was unhappy and concerned at the result.

At the previous election and at a subsequent election where that candidate was running, he got nothing like the same percentage of the vote in that home for the blind. I was aware that something abnormal had taken place, simply because none of the non-party candidates or the smaller parties had any personation agent there. There was the candidate who was in the polling station at the time, the personation agent for the party of that candidate and presumably the presiding officer. A subtle coercion was exercised because the electors realised they were in the presence of people from that party and they felt constrained to vote for their candidate.

There is a serious problem here and some change will have to be made. In the case in question I have not given the name because it would be unfair to do so without giving the candidate involved the opportunity to reply. The candidate is dead now, so it puts me at a certain disadvantage. The Minister would need to look at this section if he does not want a repetition of that kind of thing.

Comment on this
Rory Kiely Acting Chairman (Mr. R. Kiely) Fianna Fáil

We have spent an hour discussing this amendment. I must ask if amendment No.113 is being pressed.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.114:

In page 62, subsection (5), line 44, after "elector" to insert "(or leave it blank or spoil it if so instructed by the elector)".

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendment No. 114 has already been discussed.

Comment on this

Did the Minister reply?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It has been discussed and the Minister has spoken on it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.115:

In page 63, subsection (6), line 5, after "electors" to add ", but in this case, the presiding officer may designate some other person to perform the functions conferred by this section."

This amendment seeks to deal with the provision whereby the presiding officer may run into problems in terms of coping and dealing with requests which are made in the two-hour period prior to the close of poll. He is given discretion to refuse certain people the right to assist in casting the vote, etc. It also allows him to abstain or refuse to assist certain categories of people in the process of casting their vote. That is somewhat undesirable and it certainly creates a discrimination in relation to people who arrive at the polling station in the last two hours prior to the close of poll. We suggested allowing the presiding officer to delegate some of his responsibilities in relation to this matter during that period when he would not be able to cope with the demand for his services.

Comment on this

Section 103 (6) provides that the presiding officer may refuse a request from a voter to mark the ballot paper for him in the last two hours of polling if in his opinion acceding to the request would interfere with the proper discharge of his duties or would unduly obstruct voting by other electors. This amendment proposes to give the presiding officer power to designate some other person to perform his functions under this section in relation to the marking of a ballot paper on behalf of an elector. The presiding officer is authorised under section 94(4) to delegate to the poll clerk anything he is required or authorised to do under this Bill, except ordering the arrest, exclusion or rejection of any person from the polling station.

In theory at least, the presiding officer could authorise the poll clerk to mark the ballot paper for the elector. At polling places where a supervisory presiding officer is employed, that is, in any building housing more than four polling stations, the supervisory officer could be called on to assist. Quite obviously, if either of these arrangements was practical, the electoral request would not be refused. The idea that the presiding officer would delegate one of his statutory functions to any other person, for example, the personation agent or any elector, is not acceptable and I ask that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendment Nos. 116,135,140 and 147 are related and all may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.116:

In page 63, subsection (2), line 26, after "statement" to insert "(which shall be published in Iris Oifigiúil as soon as may be after it is made)”.

This amendment deals with statements which are made by the presiding officer in relation to a series of irregularities. What happens to these statements? Who uses them, who reads them and where are they sent? It is important that at least some aspects of those statements be published. I am not so sure I am in favour of having published the names of the people whose votes in effect were stolen by somebody else, but certainly it is important that the total number of personation incidents be made public and that that information be analysed and scrutinised. It will give an indication of where there are problems and a clear pattern of personation difficulties. If in some polling stations quite a number of ballot papers or votes in effect were stolen and in other areas they were not, then one could set about working out the basis for that and making appropriate measures to prevent it. That would be very important information for political parties, particularly the smaller parties who do not always have the resources to man each table to record all the events taking place. For those reasons I would like to see these statements mads available to the public so that we can have analyses of the difficulties which occur during pollling and the patterns that emerge and can review the difficulties and imbalances in certain areas and between and within polling stations.

Comment on this

These amendments relate to four type of statement drawn up at different stages of an election. Section 104 (2) requires the presiding officer to make out a statement recording details of cases in which ballot papers were issued to electors who claimed to have been personated. Section 114 (2) requires the returning officer to prepare a statement showing the result of the verification of the ballot paper accounts for all the ballot boxes used in the constituency.

Section 118 (3) provides that the returning officer shall prepare a statement showing the number of ballot papers rejected by him at the counting of the votes and giving the reasons for rejection. Under section 127 (1) the returning officer is required to give public notice of the results of the election and details of the voting. Each of the statements referred to is retained with the other election documents for a period of six months and may be produced in court if required and may be inspected and copied at the office of the Clerk of the Dáil. The statement on rejected ballot papers may also be inspected and copied by agents present at the count.

The report on the verification of ballot paper accounts and details of rejected ballot papers are included in the report to the Clerk of the Dáil furnished to each returning officer, which I understand is laid on the table of the House. Details of the voting, including rejected ballot papers, are, of course, published in the media, in works by Deputy Nealon, Magill magazine and others, as well as in the so called Brown Book published by order of the Dáil after each general election.

The proposal in amendment that these statements should also be published in Iris Oifigiúil would not be appropriate and I do not see that such publication would serve any general public interest in connection with a Dáelection receives the widest possible publication. It is very difficult to visualise what segment of the public would be served by publication in Iris Oifigiúil that is not reached by the methods of publication I have already referred to.

Comment on this

I wonder if there would not be a value to the public in having the information referred to in this section published at an early date. What we are talking about is the number of ballot papers, the number of electorate, the numbers rejected and, above all, the level of personation that place. It may be that wholesale personation could take place in a particular area. If that is the case, is it not important that there be an official publication of all the relevant material? It is not much use that it would be published in Deputy Nealon's or Deputy Brennan's guide to the Dáil election. That is unofficial. We are looking for the raw data of the report by the presiding officer of the information available, so that it can be examined clearly by the public to see whether there are any levels of abuse in constituencies throughout the country. It is exactly the type of information that should be published in Iris Oifigiúil to ensure that there is a clear monitoring of the Dáil elections at all times and that there is no non-disclosure of relevant information in relation to the possibility of any abuse taking place in the casting of ballots.

Comment on this

The statement in relation to personated voters under section 104 for a polling station could be referred to in the event of a prosecution for an electoral offence. Essentially, however, it is part of the arrangements whereby the presiding officer accounts for the ballot papers entrusted to him. It is part of the ballot paper account form and is not in a form suitable to publication. There are close on 6,000 polling stations throughout the country; this form is completed for each station. I understand that in the vast majority of cases a nil return is furnished.

The propriety of publishing the names and numbers of the register of persons in whose name someone has already voted is questionable. Under section 111, where a ballot paper has already issued in the name of an elector who applies for a ballot paper, the presiding officer may put to him on oath or affirmation, or the questions prescribed under section 111 or request evidence of identity. If the elector refuses to take an oath or answer the questions put to him satisfactorily, or to satisfy the presiding officer as to his identity, he will not be given a ballot paper.

It would thus be reasonable to expect that the names of electors appearing on the statement prepared by the presiding officer would be those of the presiding officer would be those of the innocent victims of personation. Publication of these names, far from identifying, and embarrassing the guilty party, would merely serve to cast suspicion on the innocent party.

Comment on this

There is a certain merit in all that data being compiled in a readily accessible form. I have been around politics for quite some time and I did not know of the existence of that type of information in the manner which the Minister has indicated which, of course, may be another reason we have not got further in our political endeavours.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 117 to 121, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 117:

In page 63, subsection (1), line 35, to delete "shall" and substitute "may".

This part of the Bill seems to be very restrictive and cut and dry in terms of the requirements on the Garda. I would have thought it desirable that the gardaí should be allowed to use their discretion where presiding officers had reasonable cause to believe that a person who applied for a ballot paper was committing or had committed a personation offence. There should be some degree of discretion left to the gardaí in those circumstances rather than that they should be obliged to comply with such directions as have been issued.

In amendment No. 120 we are suggesting the deletion of "believes" by the substitution of "has reasonable cause to believe". This is a reasonable amendment. The use of the word "shall" removes discretion and leaves very little alternative to people who are given orders by various people. That might be reasonable enough and I accept that there is the provision that they must have reasonable cause to believe that someone is committing an offence. The personation agent has to declare to the presiding officer that he believes and undertakes in writing to prove that the applicant has committed personation. It is possible for these people to be wrong and in those circumstances it would be appropriate that the garda on duty should have an element of discretion in terms of how they behave and how they act arising from requests from the various agents at polling stations. This also has to be seen in the context of total liability in terms of law cases and so on to be taken subsequently. We could fix damages for a maximum of £500 which really is not a lot of money in present circumstances.

Comment on this

Section 105 deals withe the arrest of a person committing personation. this section reproduces existing law without any change. This section permits a garda of his own accord or on the direction of a presiding officer to arrest without a warrant a person suspected of committing personation. It allows the presiding officer to direct the arrest of such a person on his own initiative or at the request of a personation agent. This section provides that no action will lie against the presiding officer in respect of the arrest of a person on his direction without malice.

The group of amendments propose various changes in this section. The garda would not be obliged to obey a direction of the presiding officer. The presiding officer would not be required to act on the request of a personation agent. A rewording of subsection (3) is proposed and a clause protecting the presiding officer against legal proceedings arising from the arrest of a person would be removed. To put this section in perspective, it is fair to say that the arrest of a person at a polling station is a rare event. I would expect that most presiding officers would never find themselves in the position of having to order somebody's arrest.

My reaction to the proposed amendments would be that if the presiding officer is to be given power to order the arrest of a person, then the power must be an effective one. In other words, the garda would have to obliged to carry out the order. If not, there would be no point in giving the presiding officer the power in the first place if the garda were to refuse to act on the direction of the presiding officer. The authority of the presiding officer would be undermined and an intolerable position created. However, I am inclined to agree that the presiding officer should not be obliged in every case to act on the request of a personation agent. The decision whether to order an arrest should probably be a matter for the presiding officer.

I am inclined to agree also that the suggested rewording of subsection (3) clarifies the power of the garda. I think subsection (2) might also be improved by substituting "direct" for "order" in line 41. In regard to subsection (5) I believe it provides a valuable protection and reassurance for the presiding officer which it would be important to retain.

I would see no difficulty in accepting amendments Nos. 118 and 120. I suggest, however, that it might be preferable if the Senators would withdraw the group of amendments and let me have a look at the entire section for Report Stage.

Comment on this

That is a welcome statement from the Minister in relation to amendments Nos. 118 and 120. I am delighted that he is prepared to examine the entire section. May I make one or two points that he might hear in mind when he looking at the group of amendments. The first point is that the garda is subject to the authority of the presiding officer but, of course, the Garda Síochána must enforce the law. He has a primary responsibility, above any other citizen, to ensure that the law is properly implemented and for a presiding officer to actually direct or order—and he must comply with the direction or oerder— another citizen seems to me to be out of line with the powers of a members of the Garda Síochána. A greater degree of flexibility must be allowed in that section in relation to those provisions.

Amendment No. 120 proposes the words "has reasonable cause to believe". If accepted, this would tie in properly with the first line of section 105 (1) which states "Where a presiding officer has reasonable cause" and also with subsection (3) where it is stated that a member of the Garda Síochána may, without any warrant, arrest any person whom he has reasonable cause to believe is committing an offence.

The other point I wish to make is that the powers prescribed for the presiding officer in this case are extensive. Throughout this legislation, we have questioned the extensive powers that are given to the presiding officer without any accountability. I have no problem with the presiding officer having extensive powers but there is no inbuilt accountability. If we are to allow that situation to operate we have to ensure that there is accountability. We must remember that blanket immunity is given to the presiding officer, irrespective of any negligence on his or her part and, therefore, the powers outlined in this section are extensive. I am delighted the Minister has agreed that there is need for a revamping of this section and I look forward to hearing him on the matter on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I understand that if a personation agent believes a member of the electorate has been guilty of personation the agent can request the presiding officer to take action. Before the personation officer does that, he declares to the presiding officer that the he believes and undertakes in writing to prove that the applicant has committed personation. Is that a fairly straightforward precedure? As I see it, that must all happen before the person who has committed the personation has left the polling station. How complicated is that process? I was present on one occasion at Oakley Road where a person was accused of personation and was subsequently arrested. It took a while for it to happen; in that instance the school is quite far inside the grounds. Section 106 (3) refers to "any land within the curtilage of the building". Does that mean land between the building and the gate; between the building and, say, the public footpath? Does it mean within the building itself? If the person committing the personation was still in the grounds of the building, could——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The section deals with arrest of persons committing personation.

Comment on this

Section 105 (2) states:

...a personation agent declares to the presiding officer that he believes and undertakes in writing to prove that the applicant has committed personation,

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That will be dealt with in debate on section 106.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122:

In page 64, subsection (2) line 10, to delete "may at any time" and substitute "shall".

Section 106 (2) reads:

The presiding officer may at any time remove from the polling station all material which advocates the candidature of particular person or persons or of members of a political party.

We want to delete "may at any time" and substitute "shall". Everyone agrees it is undesirable that that type of literature should be available within polling stations. The general practice has been to ban it and to prevent people from carrying or displaying it in polling stations. The general practice has been to ban it and to prevent people from carrying or displaying it in polling stations. There should be an obligation on the presiding officer to remove such material from the polling stations. I cannot see why a presiding officer should not be able to ensure that this happens rather than that the presiding officer should have the discretion. It is possible that the presiding officer, given the way this subsection is worded, could allow people to go around polling stations carrying political emblems, badges and various other means of advocating voting for one person, one party or groups of candidates. It is undesirable that this should be left to the discretion of the presiding officer. Any suggestion of bias which might be levelled at presiding officers in this area, would be removed if there was an obligation on presiding officers.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. Regularly people receive election literature on their way into a polling station which they take in with them and may even look at when they are voting, and leave bundles of it behind them on the table whee they vote. This literature is not removed by the presiding officer and the next person who arrives to vote will see on a leaflet—for example, Vote No. 1: Senator Upton.

Comment on this

Splendid.

Comment on this

It should be the duty of the presiding officer to ensure that there is no election literature left in the voting cubicle. Subsection (3) states:

For the purpose of this section a polling station shall be deemed to include all parts of the building and any land within the curtilage of the building in which the polling station is situate.

I have never understood the word "curtilage" although I use it a lot. What is meant by "any land within the curtilage of the building"?

Comment on this

This is a straightforward amendment but it is an important one. At all elections in which I have been involved, including the recent referendum I have seen material relating to either the referendum issue or the candidates within the confines of the polling station and, indeed, at the polling booth. Subsection (3) shows no sense of urgency about the removal of literature. There should be a specific obligation on the presiding officer not just to exercise his or her discretion but to ensure that it be strictly adhered to and that no material be left within the confines of the polling station. that ties in with the provision in the Bill where it is proposed that, in future, political parties would not canvass or that literature would not handed out within 50 metres of a polling station. If that is the direction being taken, it should be mandatory that all literature be disposed of prior to entry into the polling station. The least we can do is ensure that it is a compulsory requirement—allowing no flexibility or discretion—on the presiding officer to ensure that all material is removed from the polling station.

Comment on this

Section 106 (2) provides that the presiding officer may at any time remove candidates' election literature found in or around the polling station. Amendment No. 122 proposes to make it obligatory on the presiding officer to remove such literature. The intention is that the presiding officer will have any such literature removed as soon as he becomes aware of it. The manual for presiding officers is specific on this point. We must, however, keep in touch with reality and avoid placing a statutory obligation on the presiding officer which it may not be possible to fulfil.

Subsection (3) defines a polling station for the purpose of this section as including all parts of the building and any land within the curtilage of the building— which is the school yard—in which the polling station is situated. This includes not just the room where the polling station is set up but the entire building, usually a school and a schoolyard.

The presiding officer's job is to conduct the poll in his station and to facilitate voting by electors. Obviously, he must concentrate on this task and must not allow himself to be deflected from this and cause delay and inconvenience to electors by spending time removing posters and leaflets. The wording of the provision is correct and is used quite deliberately. It should be retained and I ask that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

It is not being withdrawn. This provision is too vague. The Minister has indicated that there are regulations covering this matter for the presiding officer but the parent legislation does not reflect any strictness of regulation. The words "the presiding officer may at any time remove" are not in accordance with what I would consider to be the appropriate duties of a presiding officer. This provision allows absolute discretion, it does not even suggest that it is desirable to remove such material or show a slight bias that there is anything wrong with it being there. It simply states that he "may" remove it. It does not even say that the presiding officer "must" have it removed as soon as he becomes aware of it but only that he or she may at any time remove it. There must be an onus on the presiding officer to ensure that all material is removed at the earliest opportunity. I urge the Minister to examine this matter again with a view to tightening the wording to ensure that the offending material would be removed at the earliest possible moment.

Comment on this

This is an important amendment. If the Minister's intention was to ensure that there would not be election material within the curtilage of the building or in the polling station, he should tighten up this section. He said the intention was that as soon as the presiding officer becomes aware of election material in the polling station, building or within the curtilage of the building, he would have it removed. I suggest that if the presiding officer knows, sees, or is aware that election literature is being distributed as people come in to vote and that they take it with them to the polling station, that means there is election material in the polling station. Why does the legislation not go further than this amendment suggests and prevent voters from bringing literature into the polling station? I know there is a change in legislation and that those distributing literature will have to stand further from the polling station than heretofore, but surely it is the Minister's desire to ensure that no election literature is inside the building. If that is the intention presumably the presiding officer could prevent people from taking the literature in with them.

I support the case made because every time I have voted, there has been election literature on the table where you sign your ballot paper. That is most undesirable. I will doubt the Minister's bona fides in this matter unless he tightens up this section and I will, sadly, be led to the opinion that he is rowing along with a section which militates against the Independent candidate—or as the Minister now wishes them to be called the Non-Party candidate. On that point I hope the Minister read the article in a Sunday newspaper that there is going to be an——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is not relevant.

Comment on this

It is relevant because an independent Party is going to be formed. I thought the Minister would like to go to their first meeting and tell them how to get an Independent Party registered.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is not relevant.

Comment on this

As Senator Upton said he has been around for many elections —we have all been around for quite a few elections—and when we go into a polling station rarely to we see such literature; many people put it in their pockets or into their bags. Is Senator Hederman suggesting that everybody should be searched before voting? Otherwise how can you stop this practice?

This amendment, if accepted, would put another duty on the presiding officer. I understand waht the Minister is getting at here. the presiding officer has to preside and, in the majority of cases he takes the literature away. What happens at peak-times when perhaps a number of people come in together and for a moment or two there may be one or two pieces of literature lying about? Who is to take an action against him? Do we have to look at that as well? In most cases the presiding officer takes the literature away. As candidates we are not even allowed wear badges and we would be stopped by the garda and the presiding officer before we go in to look at the figures and percentages. If they are strict with us, they will be careful with the literature.

Comment on this

Senator Bennett raised a very good point. I was not suggesting that people would be searched or that their handbags would be examined as they were entering the polling station. I am talking about people who blatantly walk in with papers in their hands, and the writing visible for all to read. Those people take their ballot papers from the presiding officer, walk over to the table with this literature in their hands, but the presiding officer does not ensure that that literature is removed. Dozens of people go into that same polling booth where the election literature is placed.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is amendment No. 122 being pressed?

Comment on this

This subsection is too vague. We have given the presiding officer very strong powers in other sections but here we are saying, in a lethargic fashion, that he "may at any time remove from the polling station all material...". We are not making it obligatory. We should state clearly in the Bill what we want to be the desired outcome; that is not done in subsection (2). The desired objective can be expressed much more strongly and still allow for the situation where the presiding officer is not able to keep an eye on the entire building or the curtilage of the building so that, occasionally, literature is left there.

My view would be that, in keeping with the other amendment, to keep political parties and canvassers well away from the polling station, there should be a sign out front saying that all literature is prohibited and bins should be provided for the collection of such literature. Perhaps the Minister would consider putting that into the legislation because the provision as it stands is unsatisfactory.

Subsection (2) puts no obligation on the presiding officer to remove all election literature. If he wishes he may leave it. This is not good enough when we want an independent and non-partisan ballot in the vicinity of the polling station. I am sure no candidates are unduly influenced by material that has been left advertently or inadvertently at the point at which somebody is about to vote.

Comment on this

Unless he has the properties of Boyle Roche's bird, the presiding officer cannot be expected to hand out ballot papers and at the same time chase literature around school yards. In most cases, particularly in polling stations located in urban areas, it would seem unreasonable to require the removal of such material immediately. It would not be practical for a presiding officer either through his own action or by directing his poll clerk to be fully aware of the incidence of such material throughout the building and the adjoining grounds.

I would like to explain to Senators that this provision is aimed at election posters posted on gates, walls and railings of a polling building or its curtilage, as well as in the actual voting compartments. It would be a matter for the presiding officer to keep himself informed at the opening of the poll, and regularly throughout the day, whether the provision is being complied with and to deal with any such posters, etc., if they are present. The wording of the provisions enables the presiding officer to act under this subsection any time should he consider it necessary. I will look at including the word "shall" between now and Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 124:

In page 66, subsection (2)(b)(ii), line 30, after "Minister", to insert "with the prior approval of both Houses of the Oireachtas".

We are seeking that the various regulations in providing evidence of identity be discussed by the Houses of the Oireachtas rather than be covered by regulation. I have no doubt the Minister will say this type of provision is unwieldly, but I feel it would help significantly if it were discussed by the Members of the Houses of the Oireachtas. We all have experience of elections and know the frustration that some people experience when they are asked for evidence of identification and one cannot provide any. I know of a case where a lady simply refused to vote because she was asked for identification. She felt, somewhat wrongly, that a person who had been voting in the same polling station for the past 20 or 25 years should be known by everybody at that station and she became quite offended when the personation agent demanded that she produce some identification. Members of both Houses of the Oireachtas have considerable experience in these matters and their contributions would be worth listening to.

Comment on this

Section 111 (2) (b) provides that the presiding officer may on his own initiative or at the request of a personation agent request an elector to produce evidence of identity. The elector must produce one of a specified list of documents and if he fails to do so he may not vote. The documents which may be accepted for this purpose will be specified in regulations made by the Minister. Under section 3 the regulation must be laid before each House of the Oireachtas and may be annulled by resolution of either House.

Amendment No. 124 proposes that the regulations should be subject to prior approval of both Houses of the Oireachtas. It is a common, almost universal, practice in legislation to empower a Minister or other specified authority to make regulations for the detailed implementation of the statute. The purpose of this arrangement is to ensure that the Oireachtas itself will not become bogged down in consideration of the detailed and often minute provisions that may be necessary. The intention is that the Oireachtas would concentrate on the broad principles leaving the detail to be filled in by legislation.

In exceptional cases where the matter is of particular importance a requirement may be included that the statutory instrument must have the prior approval of both Houses. We are doing this, for example, in the present Bill in relation to section 8 which provides for extension of the Dáil franchise and in section 20 where power is given to the Minister to amend the rules for registration of electors. I do not see how the present section which simply enables the Minister to list acceptable identity documents can be included in the same category, especially where there is already in existence a set of regulations setting out those documents and we know that it is the intention of the Minister to specify the same documents again. I suggest that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

The Minister said he intends to use the same documents as are specified at the moment. What are those documents?

I am intensely amused to hear the Minister saying that it is not intended that the Houses of the Oireachtas should become bogged down with minute detail, that they should concentrate on the broad principles and leave the details to be decided under regulations. The Houses of the Oireachtas would be a meaningful place if that were adhered to but, as I constantly repeat, the problem is that Ministers consistently and persistently get involved in and got bogged down with minutiae. Is this a change of heart and, for the second half of the year, may we assume we will not see the Houses being bogged down with minutiae but rather concentrating on broad principles and leaving the minutiae and the details where they belong?

I say this specifically in the context of the work of the Department of the Environment. They could leave a great deal of detail to the local authorities but instead we have legislation dealing with taxi drivers, what sort of permits they will be given, minute details of cycle-ways and so on. These matters are properly the remit of the local authority but the Department interfere with every sewerage scheme, rural house, waterworks, and so on. Is it the intention from now on that the Oireachtas will no longer be bogged down with minutiae and that Ministers will attend to the jobs they were elected to do, namely, to concentrate on the broad principles and leave the details where they belong?

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will respond to some of the points made by Senators Upton and Hederman. We are talking about new legislation and a new set of specified documents. When I say "new" I mean we are going to review the situation once again and the Minister, according to the provisions here, will specify them in regulations. I presume this is something that will not change dramatically over the years. I cannot see how the Oireachtas could get bogged down in it. It is simply a question of agreeing what could be regarded as an appropriate set of documents that would be accessible to all citizens.

One will not find more appropriate people to give advice in the matter than the Members of both Houses of the Oireachtas because they all have had to go through the procedure of being elected. They have had to deal with people who had difficulty with identification and being able to exercise their franchise. It is not a matter that should be left simply to the discretion of the Minister. We do not want to put all power in the hands of the Minister and I am sure the Minister would not really want it either. It would seem appropriate that we should approve a list here in this House and in the Dáil rather than leave it to the Minister. The list should cover a considerable period of time and as this matter is sufficiently serious the expertise and the knowledge of Members of both Houses of the Oireachtas should be called upon the drawing it up.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 125:

In page 66, subsection (2) (b) (ii), line 30, after "section" to insert "provided that in advance of making such regulations, the Minister is satisfied that every elector is capable without undue difficulty of being in possession of such a document on polling day".

This amendment was included in case amendment No. 124 was not accepted. It is a very sensible amendment. I cannot see any difficulty about this being accepted by the Minister and I hope he is prepared to do so. It asks that people be asked to provide identification which is readily and easily available to every citizen in the country. Broadly speaking, that is the situation at present but I would like to see a provision inserted which would not allow Ministers in the future to behave in a foolish manner and specify documents which would not be acceptable or readily available to everybody.

Comment on this

Section 111 (2) (b) provides that the Minister may specify in regulations documents which are acceptable as evidence of identity at a polling station.

The House can rest assured that in drafting regulations under this subsection any Minister would, as a matter of commonsense and pragmatism, specify a wide list of documents and would be reasonably certain that one at least of the documents would be available to every elector. The intention is that the Minister will specify the same list of documents as is in force at present.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister when we were dealing with the last amendment if he would tell us what the documents are as of now. He told us that there was no intention of changing them and that they were readily available. I wish to be assured that we would not reach a stage where the only document which would be accepted would be one proving membership of a political party. Is that what the Minister has in mind?

Comment on this

The documents are already listed on the back of the polling card. A wide range of documents can be produced such as a passport; driving licence; an employee or student identity card; a book issued in this State for payment of social welfare allowances, benefits or pensions; a medical card issued in this State; a free travel card issued in this State by the Department of Social Welfare; travel documents containing the name and photograph of the holder; a signing on card issued in this State by the Department of Social Welfare; bank or savings bank book; cheque book; cheque card; credit union membership; birth certificate or marriage certificate. It is envisaged that a similar list would be specified in fresh regulations to be made under section 111 on enactment of the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is certainly a wide range of documents. Is amendment No. 125 being pressed?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 126:

In page 66, subsection (2) (c) (i), line 37, to delete "AB" and substitute "..........".

This is a typographical correction to ensure there is a standard format. In subsection 2 (c) (i) AB is used for the first part of the question: "Are you the same person as the person whose name appears as AB." whereas for the register of Dáil electors we use the words, "for constituency of ..." and we do not put in any letter. If we use AB in relation to the register we should use XY or some such designation in relation to the constituency. We should stick to one form or the other.

Comment on this

I support Senator Costello. It is a straightforward amendment which seeks to create an element of uniformity.

Where is Senator Conroy now when we need him? I am sure if he were here he would classify it as one of those nitpicking amendments he mentioned earlier in the debate. It is a simple and straightforward amendment and I hope the Minister will accept it.

Comment on this

Section 111 (2) (c) sets out the question which may be put to the person who applies for a ballot paper in order to ascertain whether he is the person named on the register of electors. The question is: "Are you the same person as the person whose name appears on AB [and I would like to point out that AB means first and second names] on the register of the Dáil electors now in force for the constituency of...".

Amendment No. 126 proposes to substitute for "AB" a series of dots to denote the point at which the name of the elector is to be called out. What we are dealing with here is purely a question of drafting style which can vary from one draftsman to the next. Where the name of a person is to be inserted some draftsmen will use a series of dots, a blank space or perhaps square brackets. Others will use the initials AB or NM. Thee is no settled drafting convention or drafting practice. The matter is one entirely of drafting style.

In my view, the Oireachtas should concern itself with the policies and principles to be included in legislation and should ensure that the meaning of each provision is clear and unambiguous. Once the intention of the Oireachtas is expressed with lucidity and precision I do not think the Oireachtas should waste time in changing the draftsman's style. There is no problem whatever about the meaning of the phrase we are concerned with here and there is no need to waste parliamentary time tinkering with it. I suggest the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

The Minister is quite right. We should not waste time on something like this and should not interfere with the draftsman's style unnecessarily. The only problem is that the draftsman has adopted two styles, one an alphabetical style and the other one a dot, dash, style. If the draftsman had adopted a single style then it would be quite clear, lucid and standard and would not give rise to any confusion. There is certain confusion and contradiction in the manner in which this is presented.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 128:

In page 66, between lines 43 and 44, to insert a new subparagraph as follows:

"(iv) Are you an Irish citizen, a British citizen or a citizen of... ... (countries, if any, to which section 8 (2) applies)".

This amendment seeks to introduce an additional question which can be asked of an elector prior to casting their vote. I hope the Minister accepts this amendment. It is a relevant question for a very small number of people. If somebody's name is not designated by the appropriate letter on the register it is valid to ask them whether they are a British citizen, an Irish citizen or a citizen of some other country. I know one British citizen — prior to the days when British citizens were given votes in Dáil elections — whose name continually appeared on the register of electors. I am sure that the same gentleman, being a very proper person, would not have cast his vote but it is quite possible that a person in similar circumstances could have attempted to do so. It would be a legitimate question to be asked under those circumstances.

Comment on this

Section 111 (2) (c) sets out the questions which may be put to the elector by the presiding officer in order to establish his right to vote. The questions which may be put to the elector under this subsection are designed to establish whether the person applying for a ballot paper is the person named on the register of electors, whether he or she has already voted and whether he or she has reached voting age.

Amendment No. 128 proposes to empower the presiding officer to ask an additional question designed to establish whether the person satisfies the necessary citizenship requirement in relation to voting. The question of an elector's citizenship is, or should be, dealt with at the registration stage. The necessary machinery is in place and is described in detail in the Second Schedule. The registration authorities are required to make adequate inquiries. They and the county register may require an elector to furnish information, to produce certificates and other documentary evidence, to make statutory declarations and at the revision court to give evidence on oath.

Finally, there is the right of appeal to the Circuit Court and on a point of law to the Supreme Court. As we have seen in discussing an earlier amendment, the concept of nationality and citizenship is a very complicated one. Obviously a presiding officer in a polling station would not be in a position to deal with such questions in a meaningful way. There would be cases where the elector would be unsure about his citizenship. To include the question proposed in the amendment would not serve any practical purpose.

I might add that under section 149 a person who is not entitled to be registered as a Dáil elector commits an offence if he votes at a Dáil election. I suggest that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 132:

In page 67, before section 112, to insert a new section as follows:

"112.—(1) Expenditure by candidates and parties in connection with an election shall not exceed an amount to be determined by regulations made by the Minister with the consent of both Houses of the Oireachtas.

The regulations may also provide for audit of accounts of expenditure.".

This is an important amendment. It deals with candidates' and parties' election expenditure. We specify that there should be a ceiling on the amount of money spent by candidates and by parties on an election campaign. There is no doubt but that money speaks in an election. That is a reality. It is unfair that some people should be in a position to, in effect, buy votes and buy their way into power. We know from the beef tribunal that enormous amounts of money are donated to people at election time. I do not want to cast aspersions on the people who do this — they will answer for themselves — and I do not want to get into that argument. There is no doubt but people outside the political process through investing — and that is the term for it — in certain candidates and political parties, can buy influence. There is no getting away from that.

Obviously money will be spent on elections and nobody pretends otherwise, but I suggest that some limit should be imposed. In other countries, limits are imposed and the fact that we do not provides temptation for politicians and for those with lots of money to buy themselves power and influence in the political process.

There is also a school of thought which says that the wise birds of Irish life simply would not dirty their hands with the political process and would not go through the tough ugly slog that is part of being elected. These wise creatures stay far way from the political process and instead they invest their money very carefully supporting specific candidates or certain political parties. They get influence and power that way without getting involved in the nitty-gritty, humdrum, everyday business of Irish politics that most politicians are involved in. I do not think it is desirable or good for politics that this process be allowed continue without restriction on the amount of money which can be spent. Sometimes these people are simply wasting their money. Some of the gimmicks and stunts at election time are useless. As I said, there should be a limit on the amount of money given to political parties and to candidates at electon time.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Upton that this is a very important amendment. I am sure we will put this to a vote if the Minister is not prepared to accept the exact wording or at least the principle underlying it.

This is a consolidation Bill. Its function is to provide a basis for the future electoral process in this country. In the last century the franchise was limited to people with property and only certain people could vote. The country was ruled by monarchs, then by the aristocracy and then by a further elite. Now everybody over the age of 18 has a right to vote. However, there are still obstacles and not everybody is able to exercise their democratic right. To a certain extent, wealth has replaced property. Of course, the two are interrelated but as we have said, our function should be to ensure that the maximum number of people are able to operate within the democratic process on an equal basis.

If a candidate or a party can spend an unlimited amount of money on an election, obviously somebody who has not access to great wealth or funding will not be in a position to mount a strong campaign. In order to level the playing pitch and give everybody an equal right to present their views and virtues we should have a ceiling on the amount of money spent on campaigns.

The other point to which Senator Upton alluded is that it would eliminate the scope for abuse in the democratic process. We have seen in other countries how unscrupulous political people, business people and the Mafia have influenced politics. The last thing we would like to see is a similar situation develop here. I do not suggest that there was abuse in the past, but we want to eliminate the possibility of any abuse.

I understand that in Britain candidates and parties must produce receipts of expenditure on an election. They can only spend up to a certain amount. I cannot see why we should not ensure that our democracy is as accountable and that everybody, whether employed or unemployed, with business connections or not, whether they are members of a political party or are Independents or Non-Party using their own resources, should fight the election from the same base. The Minister should accept this amendment.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I consider the principle of this amendment to be very worthwhile as I believe excessive expenditure on elections and the influence of mega business in elections through the financing of individual candidates or political parties is dangerous and has serious implications for democracy. In theory, every citizen of the State can be elected to a House of the Oireachtas. While that is the theoretical position, in practice, the high costs which candidates must incur would debar most people from putting themselves forward.

We have been through a particularly sad chapter in Irish life recently in the beef tribunal which is ongoing. It brings into sharp focus the importance of looking at the whole question of financing candidates, parties or elections. My contention in relation to election financing— something which is being mooted fairly widely at present, but must be brought to a head and that is happening in Germany — is that the State should finance the political parties on a pro rata basis in terms of electoral support at the previous election. That would eliminate the private speculator buying political influence at election time. In my view that should be mandatory. I am delighted to see the Progressive Democrats are having further thought about this. I see Senator Dardis is in the House now and I gather his party are rethinking this issue in terms of——

Comment on this

We rethink all the time.

Comment on this

Both for yourselves and Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I am delighted they are seeing the light on this issue because it is important that an all party agreement emerges on this question.

I see practical difficulties in regard to implementing the ceilings from the administrative point of view in relation to how they would be establish in law and monitored. However, the principle is correct, it should and must be done and there is sufficient evidence at present to suggest that.

Comment on this
Mr. Farrell

Does the amendment suggest that trade unions should not support political parties because, as we know, they support them very strongly.

Comment on this

It is in the annual report.

Comment on this
Mr. Farrell

I do not know if the Mafia run the trade unions or the trade unions run the Mafia in other countries, but they are very closely associated.

Comment on this

Not in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Farrell

Thankfully, not in this country. The Senator referred to the Mafia in other countries and I want to make it clear that there is a link between unions and the Mafia, not between the ordinary citizen of the street.

If we decide to make money available from the State for people running for elections there is a grave danger many people would put their name forward and run for election, knowing they had no hope of being elected, but would get a few thousand pounds and put it in their pocket.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Farrell

This is what will happen if you go for State funding, therefore, we would want to seriously consider such a suggestion.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. However, I would have some concern about the fact that the amount of money would be determined by regulations with the consent of both Houses of the Oireachtas. I do not see a great deal of justice in that because the Houses of the Oireachtas are made up of the Dáil and Seanad and the Dáil has a Government majority consisting of Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats and the position is similar in this House. Therefore, this amendment proposes that the amount be determined by Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats. I do not know the Progressive Democrats' view on this and I am glad we have a representative here who I presume will give us his words of wisdom on this topic.

I have remonstrated with the Progressive Democrats on occasions because they have not been successful or, in some instances have not even tried, to implement policies which appeared in their election manifestos at local and national level. Their reply was that they are only a small party and cannot be expected to work wonders in a couple of years. I accept that, nevertheless, what we are saying here is that the Progressive Democrats would not have the say and it would be the Fianna Fáil Party who would determine the amount.

Comment on this

We might go into Coalition with them.

Comment on this

Obviously, they would decide on a sum of money that would be in their best interest. I do not believe they would have a great deal of concern for many Members of the Opposition or a Member of any other party; that is the nature of politics. They certainly would have no consideration for those dreaded Independents who are now to be called non-party people. Presumably, they would not be considered in the matter at all and we might find that an amount was agreed which would put Independents at a disadvantage because they simply would not have that sort of money to spend in the first place.

This matter is obviously very relevant — as was stated by Senator O'Reilly — in view of the revelations being made at present in regard to the beef tribunal, something I am sure, a Leas-Chathaoirligh you do not want us to enter into in great detail.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator can be assured of that.

Comment on this

It obviously spotlights the elite in this country who are controlling the levers of power and who, by the influence they have apparently gained by making substantial investments in political parties and, therefore, directly in the candidates, feel they are in a position to dictate to the Government of the day what will be in their own interest. That is something which I know we all deplore and, therefore, it is opportune that we should be discussing this amendment at present. I hope the Minister will give it genuine thought and that he will do so with an open mind. I hope he will not say that it is out of the question because it was not in the original Bill but that he wil give the whole matter open consideration.

The question of outsiders investing in candidates rather than putting themselves forward is a very serious one. It is well known that the quality of politics is greatly dependent on the quality of individual politicians. I am sure most Senators will agree that if we allow the present situation to continue we will not attract into politics the calibre of people we would like. Most Members, both here and in the other House, have referred from time to time to the fact that it is a pity we do not seem to be attracting the right type of candidates and asked what can be done about it. This is obviously one of the things that could be done, we should no longer allow outsiders to pull the levers by financing the parties. I would like to refer to one election in which I was not involved. I was in California at the time of an election some years ago and I was sitting at one of those thousand pound plate dinners, for which I had not paid.

Comment on this

Who was paying for it?

Comment on this

A free lunch.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Hederman, without interruption, please.

Comment on this

I was a visiting VIP dignitary and nobody had to pay for me.

I was sitting beside the wife of the Democratic candidate for the Senate and she told me that $17 million was being spent on her husband's attempt to be elected and that he had absolutely no hope whatsoever. He was what people here would call a "no hoper". The man who was likely to take the seat was a Republican and it was known that $24 million was being provided to back him. We should bear these matters in mind when we are thinking about introducing legislation to put a ceiling on what people can spend. We are all aware that what happens in the United States, Great Britain or elsewhere very often comes in here sooner than we anticipate. If that is what we want here, it is regrettable.

I support the point that only the wealthy can afford to enter politics, that is unless you are Non-Party, an Independent; who can manage to be elected on a shoestring. Under section 47, candidates are being asked for a deposit of £500, and that is for openers. Then one has to compete with the campaigning, advertising and publicity of candidates of large parties which, as we all know, is enormously expensive. As has already been said, that rules out the unemployed or many young people who would not have that sort of money.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We have dealt with that issue. Will the Senator speak to the amendment?

Comment on this

I will deal with an issue which has not been dealt with. Whether we like it or not, more Independents are running for office — or as the Minister likes to call them "non-party" people. Those people are supported, on the whole, by voluntary workers and because of scarce financial resources have learned to make £1 go as far as others would make £10 go. This might be disadvantageous to parties because if a ceiling of, say, £5,000 is put on each candidate, the Independent or Non-Party candidates would be able to make that go ten times further than the person in the party. That difficulty would have to be overcome. It might mean that parties would indulge in wiser spending on election campaigns and not lash out money in all directions on things which might not help to get them elected.

We should not go down the path of the State funding political parties. I think it was Senator O'Reilly who mentioned that the State should finance political parties in proportion to the results of the previous election. Where would that leave our Independent or Non-Party member, who would not have been elected at the previous election? They would presumably get no funding. Senator O'Reilly might explain what exactly he means when he suggests that the State would finance the political parties in proportion to the results of the previous election.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator O'Reilly is not the Minister; it will be the Minister who will reply.

Comment on this

Not yet, but he is looking forward to it.

Comment on this

Not yet, but he might be. This provision would ask members of the public, through their taxes, to finance political parties which they may have no wish to support and would preclude a situation where their taxes would be able to support an Independent or Non-Party candidate. That would be grossly unfair and unjust. The idea of forcing people, which would be the outcome of the State financing political parties——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I would remind the Senator that we are not talking about the State financing political parties; we are talking about the limit on expenditure at elections. Will the Senator allow the Minister to reply?

Comment on this

That is a fair point, but it was Senator O'Reilly who brought up this question; I did not hear you ask him to stick to the point so I thought you would allow me a little latitude.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

He brought it up in a different context.

Comment on this

I thought he raised the question of the State financing political parties in the same context.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I would not like the Senator to think I am not fair to every Senator.

Comment on this

The Chair is very fair. This amendment is interesting and one to which I hope the Minister will give serious consideration. If he is considering going down the route proposed by Senator O'Reilly, I ask him not to go too far down that route and, perhaps, to consider the problems which might arise.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 132 proposes to insert in Part XVIII a new section providing for a limit on the expenditure by candidates and parties in connection with an election. The limit will be determined by regulations to be made by the Minister with the consent of both Houses of the Oireachtas. The regulations will provide for audit of accounts of expenditure.

I must begin by pointing out that up to 1963 there was provision for a statutory limit on the amount of expenditure which a candidate could incur in relation to an election. This statutory regulation was abolished in that year on the recommendation of an all party joint committee on the electoral law. In their report the joint committee referred to the limits as both obsolete and useless.

I must also put on record that, so far as my information goes, only two of the member-states of the EC operate any control system in relation to expenditure by candidates — Italy and the United Kingdom. No controls exist, for example, in Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Luxembourg or the Netherlands, so far from being out of step with European countries generally on this matter, we are very much in the mainstream.

The amendment makes no serious attempt to draw up a system of control even in a very broad outline. It is, in effect, simply a statement of principle and no more. I realise that it would be difficult for Senators and their advisers to devise a fully developed scheme on this very difficult and complex subject. Nonetheless, it would be reasonable to expect that the amendment would give some broad indication of the type of regime envisaged and suggested and, at least in general terms, how the complex constitutional legal and administrative questions arising might be addressed. It is not good enough to say that the Minister should work it out.

If we are to consider this matter seriously, it is obvious that it could only be advanced on the basis of broad general agreement. At this stage it is very difficult to see any evidence of a basis for such agreement. It must also have regard to the fact that expenditure at elections is just one aspect of a much wider question. It would have to be seen in the context of the financing of candidates and parties generally. Any consideration of it would have to address matters such as the public funding of parties, the question of accounting, the disclosure of sources of income and would have to take account of the parliamentary as well as the electoral role of parties.

I do not believe that the serious and intricate questions arising can be adequately addressed in a brief amendment to the electoral Bill and, therefore, I suggest that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

I would like to speak to the amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I ask Senators to be brief. We have discussed this amendment for over 30 minutes and there are, approximately, 40 more amendments to be dealt with in 240 minutes. I would like, if we could, to deal with them all. I call Senator Hederman, but I would ask for brevity.

Comment on this

This is an important amendment and I would be happy to forego my time on some of the other amendments because they are of a very minor nature. The Minister said earlier that the House should concern itself with broad policy and principle and should not get bogged down in minutiae. He said we should concentrate on broad principles and leave the details to others. It is strange that he should say that in the context of an earlier amendment, and yet he now said that he deplores the fact that this amendment contains a statement of principle and nothing more.

It is difficult to please the Minister. He now seems to want all the details, while earlier he did not. The Minister could not really expect the Senators to have worked out all the details. He said that up to 1963 there had been a statutory limit on expenses but that an all-party joint committee abolished it. As I am a newcomer here, I would appreciate the Minister's assistance. Would that all-party joint committee have been like any other joint committee? It was probably comprised of members of the major political parties. It would be interesting to see if the Independents or, as the Minister likes to call them, the Non-Party people were represented on that committee. I say their voice was not heard.

I am not particularly impressed by the fact that only Italy and the UK have control in regard to expenditure, whereas Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Luxembourg and The Netherlands do not, although one would have to look at their system of election which is very different from ours. There are probably lists and various matters like that.

Why did the Minister say in this instance that he felt this provision would need broad general agreement if it was to be introduced? I am not aware that only legislation and matters which have broad general agreement are introduced. I sit here week after week and watch the Government railroad through measures that have not got general agreement in this House, but they use the unnatural majority which they achieve by having the Taoiseach nominate 11 Members to steamroll and railroad undesirable and undemocratic measures through this House. The same happens in the other House. Yet, the Minister comes along here and says he could not accept this amendment because it would need to have broad general agreement if it was to be accepted. I asked the Minister earlier if I am now to understand that for the next six months we will only deal with matters which include policies and principles and that we will not be bogged down with minutiae but the Minister did not reply. Am I to understand that only those items which have broad general agreement will be pushed through here or will we continue to see the steamrolling tactics which this Government use continuously to get undesirable and undemocratic legislation through the House?

Comment on this

To take up Senator Farrell's point about unions, yes the unions contribute money to the Labour Party. That is a matter of record, it is stated in their annual reports and in the annual reports of the Labour Party. People can draw their own conclusions as the reports are available to the unions to peruse and examine.

In relation to the Minister's criticism of the amendment and the fact that he suggested it does not cover the various aspects of this matter adequately, I believe the amendment is very specific. It states that expenditure by candidates and parties in connection with an election shall not exceed an amount to be determined by regulations made by the Minister with the consent of both Houses of the Oireachtas. That could not be more straightforward. In other words the Houses of the Oireachtas should set a limit on the amount of money which can be spent and the second part of the amendment provides for an audit of accounts of expenditure. That is also straightforward. I cannot see any difficulty in the introduction and implementation of such an amendment. I reiterate what I said about the desirability of putting some ceiling on the amounts of money which are spent on elections by some political parties.

I do not think anybody could be other than flabbergasted by the sums of money which have been spoken about in regard to the beef tribunal. It is huge money by any standards; certainly the sum of £75,000 is an enormous amount of money by the standards of the Labour Party. The average cost of an election campaign by a typical Labour Party candidate would be of the order of £7,000 to £10,000. I am speculating of course, but that is the kind of money you are talking about. Some of the major players in relation to the beef industry have not yet spoken in relation to what they are contributing.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are not dealing with the beef tribunal.

Comment on this

More's the pity.

Comment on this

I am talking in terms of the amounts of money which are available and what we are seeing here is I suspect the tip of the iceberg. It deals with just one part of the beef industry. It does not deal with the remainder of the beef industry or with the other segments of the economy and the key players. What type of money is spent on elections? Is it desirable to spend enormous sums of money? I strongly hold that it is not.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I ask Senator Costello to be very brief. I am only trying to assist the Senators to deal with every amendment, if possible, on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

The first thing that the Minister said was very strange. He felt the amendment was far too vague and general and that it was leaving it all to the Minister to work out. He adopted the opposite position in relation to other matters where he felt it was appropriate for the Minister to draw up the regulations and so on. However, we are being very specific in relation to this matter. It should be dealt with the Oireachtas and the Minister through regulation.

The Minister has a model in the British experience, where there is very strict accountability in terms of the use of the funding in relation to an election. Receipts have to be kept and presented. It is accountable and audited. There is no problem about giving the Minister a model. I am sure the Italian model is equally strict and tight, but I would not know about that.

In relation to 1963, almost 30 years ago, it is amazing that there should be a statutory provision made then, while in the same year an all-party joint Oireachtas committee abolished those provisions on the grounds that the limits proposed were obsolete and useless. I do not think any such joint Oireachtas committee could possibly come up with a similar pronouncement at this time. Many things have happened in the past 29 to 30 years and some of them have been referred to at present in relation to how funding is allocated to the political parties. I do not want to go into details of the beef tribunal, but they are matters of concern.

We must acknowledge the point I made that this legislation will underpin the electoral process into the 21st century. We should make provision for the serious developments in relation to the funding of candidates and political parties and ensure that there are no loopholes in this legislation which will consolidate the position in future. If we do not do that we will be guilty of dereliction of duty. The Minister should take this amendment on board and allow the situation to be dealt with by regulation by the Oireachtas later.

What we are talking about here is not taxpayers' funding of a political party or of an Independent. We are talking about a maximum ceiling to ensure that there is not an over-extravagant use of funds that interferes with democracy, either through the wealthy being able to enhance their position or business interests using a political candidate to enhance their position in the marketplace.

Comment on this

The question of limits on expenditure at elections is a very broad one and one that would probably have to be considered in conjunction with the funding of political parties generally. The present Bill, which deals essentially with the technical aspect of an election, would not seem to be the appropriate mechanism for dealing with these questions and there are no indications at this stage that there is any broad support for a provision along these lines.

If it were desirable to control election expenses in the future the matter would have to be approached in a manner which would take account of the reality that election campaigns are now national rather than constituency affairs. The simplistic approach of seeking to impose a limit on the expenditure of individual candidates for the duration of the election campaign would simply not work; the matter would have to be approached on a broad all-party basis. There is at this stage no evidence of a consensus on this point.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 11
·
Níl 22
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 133:

In page 67, subsection (2), line 44, after "duty", to insert ",the candidates".

All this amendment seeks to do is to provide for the right of the candidate to be present at the count. I think that is desirable and I hope the Minister might be able to accept the amendment. When candidates have slogged it out in the heat of battle in elections, I believe the system at least owes them the right of being at the count if they wish to be there.

Comment on this

Section 113 relates to attendance at the count of the votes at a Dáil election. Subsection (2) provides that the returning officer and his staff, members of the Garda on duty and agents appointed to attend on behalf of candidates may be present at the counting of votes. Any other person may attend only with the permission of the returning officer.

Amendment No. 133 proposes to insert a provision stipulating that the candidates may attend at the count. This amendment is not necessary. I would refer Senators to the provision of section 60(10), page 45. The subsection provides that a candidate may lawfully do or assist in the doing of anything which may lawfully be done on his behalf by an agent appointed for that purpose and may be present, either in addition to or in substitution for any such agent, at any place at which the agent may be present. This clearly covers all the processes at which agents are entitled to be present, including the issue of postal votes, the opening of postal voters' ballot boxes, the polling station and the counting of votes. I think the amendment is not necessary and I suyggest it should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I know that what the Minister said is, broadly speaking, true and I would not disagree with it; but there are parties with a certain frame of mind that candidates did what they were told by higher bodies. I could envisage some of those parties in a certain set of circumstances allowing agents to be at the count but not providing for candidates to be there. It is a matter of respect that anybody who puts their name on the ballot paper should have the right to be at the count.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Chair can advise me whether within the context of this amendment, the Minister, if not now then perhaps between now and Report Stage, could give me a definition of the words "at the count". I am raising this point because of an experience I had last summer in my county as a result of the manner in which the count was structured. All of us who have gone through elections will know that there is a basic physical structure within which the returning officer and his officials operate the count. Outside the barrier, you have access for tallying; and where postal votes are involved, the returning officer will invite the agent or the candidate, in this instance, to scrutinise.

There was one specific instance where the returning officer in the course of the count carried out transfers on doubtful papers which already had been passed, but at a subsequent part of the count he made decisions without the physical presence of the candidates or their agents. In that context could the Minister tell me what is the definition of "at the count"? Does it give full and unrestricted access to all aspects of the count, or does the returning officer have a discretion as to when and where in the count building he or she allows access to the candidates or their agents?

Comment on this

Section 118 says that "count" means all the operations involved in the counting of the first preferences recorded for candidates; all the operations involved in the transfer of the surplus; and all the operations involved in the transfer of votes of an excluded candidate and all the operations involved in the transfer of the votes of two or more candidates. However I do not think that helps Senator Mooney. I will wait until we come on to section 118 because I want to raise a matter on that section.

Comment on this

Subsection (3) requires the returning officer to give the agents all reasonable facilities for overseeing proceedings at the count, including facilities for satisfying themselves that the papers are correctly sorted out.

Comment on this

I am grateful to the Minister and to Senator Hederman.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 134:

In page 68, subsection (1), line 5, to delete "At" and substitute "As soon as may be following close of poll, and not later than".

This amendment seeks to allow the count to take place prior to 9 o'clock in the morning. I am not sure that I would particularly be in favour of that — the count takes place soon enough after the heat of an election — but I can visualise a certain set of circumstances where it might be desirable that the count would start sooner than 9 o'clock, or for that matter that the count would start immediately on the close of voting. It is really in an attempt to open up that possibility that we have introduced this amendment.

Comment on this

Section 114 provides that proceedings in relation to the counting of votes at a Dáil election shall commence at 9 a.m. on the day after polling day. Amendment No. 134 proposes to enable the proceedings to commence as soon as possible after the close of poll but not later than 9 a.m. on the day after polling day. The effect of this amendment would be that the returning officer would have discretion to commence the count as soon as ballot boxes arrive at the counting centre. The existing provisions which require the count to commence at 9 a.m. on the morning after polling day, arises from the nature of the count system under our proportional representation system.

Typically, at a count at a Dáil election, the checking and verification of ballot papers accounts take several hours. It is generally well into the afternoon before the sorting and counting of ballot papers gets under way. In most cases the count is not completed until evening; in many cases it may continue into the early hours of the following morning or may even necessitate on adjournment until the next day.

While commencement of the count a few hours after close of polling may well suit simplified counting methods, such as that used in Britain, involving one count only without the complication of our PR system, I think most of us who have to attend counts would agree that it is preferable to start proceedings with a fresh team of counters. In considering this we must also take into account the fact that the returning officer and his key personnel will have already been on duty preparing for polling day and supervising the conduct of the poll on polling day. It is desirable that they, as well as the candidates and their agents, should have a break before counting commences.

I do not think it desirable to include a discretionary power to commence the count on the night of polling. It could put a lot of pressure on returning officers to start earlier than 9 a.m. I think the existing provision in relation to the commencement of the count strikes the correct balance and I would ask the Senators to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 136:

In page 68, lines 24 and 25, to delete "and the candidates otherwise agree" and substitute "otherwise decides".

What we are trying to do here is change the word "agree" to "decides". What we are primarily concerned about is a candidate at an election who got a very small number of votes and decides for whatever reason — perhaps simply to be awkward or difficult — to object to the continuation of the count after 11 p.m. when it could be anticipated that the count would reach a conclusion fairly soon after that. Rather than having to start again in the morning, we are anxious that the returning officer should be given discretion in this matter — in other words, that he should be allowed to decide rather than that he should have to seek the agreement of all the candidates.

I would be concerned if the candidate happened to be from a major party, was a serious contender in the likely outcome of the election and stood a realistic chance of being elected, but I would also be a little concerned that you could have a crank candidate who, in pursuit of whatever type of objectives, might simply decide to be awkward and to object to the count going on after 11 p.m. when it would be obvious to everybody that the whole process could be finished in perhaps half an hour or an hour if everybody agreed.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I would like briefly to make the point that this amendment is eminently sensible, because a disruptive individual at a count could cause problems. I think it should be at the discretion of the returning officer and I commend the amendment.

Comment on this

This section contains the phrase "except during time for refreshment". Is that covered elsewhere in the Bill? I have a vision of the returning officer deciding at five minutes past nine that they will all retire to the pub and they will not come back until 10 p.m. to continue the count. It seems to give great scope as to the time for refreshment. Is that defined anywhere?

Comment on this

Section 115 provides that the returning officer must as far as practicable proceed continuously with the counting of votes, allowing only time for refreshment and, except by agreement with the candidates, excluding the period 11 p.m. to 9 a.m. I would expect, Senators that commonsense would be used in relation to refreshments.

Amendment No. 136 proposes that the returning officer may continue counting after 11 p.m. at his own discretion without any obligation to consult with the candidates. The count at a Dáil election is required to commence at 9 a.m. on the day following polling day. In the case of some constituencies, the count may be completed later that evening. In many cases, especially in large constituencies or in constituencies where margins between candidates are very slim, the count may continue into the following day. It may become apparent as the count proceeds that even if the count was to continue after 11 p.m. a final result could not be expected for several hours, possibly until the following day. In such a situation the position of counting staff, candidates and agents, who would have been on duty for 14 hours, would have to be considered. It would be obvious and desirable in such a situation to secure the consensus of all parties, returning officers, candidates and agents, if a decision is to be made to proceed with the count after 11 p.m.

The section, as drafted, is designed to protect the interests of the candidates. At the elections, the future of candidates is being decided. If a candidate feels that, for whatever reason, continuing the count after 11 p.m. would be detrimental to his interests, regard must be had to that. I feel it would be unwise to give the returning officer unfettered power in this regard.

I would like to assure the House that, in practice, this provision does not cause any problems. Common sense prevails and if it is apparent that continuing the count for a few hours beyond 11 p.m. will enable the count to be concluded, all parties are happy to agree. Fortunately, in such situations, the interests of candidates of all the parties seem to coincide. I would, however, feel that the provision, as drafted, is a desirable safeguard for the rights of the candidates and should be retained in the Bill. I suggest that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I would like to pay tribute to the returning officers involved in any election in which I have participated. What the Minister says is true. They usually try to reach a consensus and use their common sense. They always seem to take wise decisions. Perhaps it would satisfy Senator Dardis's concern if we were to insert the word "light" before "refreshments".

Comment on this

Having listened to the Minister, I do not think this amendment is needed. I was worried in case I would find myself supporting this amendment or asking that it should be looked at again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Senator could be joining this side.

Comment on this

I have no intention of joining the Senator.

Comment on this

I was referring to Senator Hanafin, not to myself. I know where we stand.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Senator Honan, without interruption, please.

Comment on this

Will the Chair deal with the Senator. As one who has sweated it out at a count, I know there is an option of continuing the count to get a result late at night rather than waiting until the following morning. This also applies to TDs when there are only a few votes between candidates in the final count for the last seat. I am more clear in my mind now after the Minister's contribution than I was as we talked through this amendment. Like the Minister, I do not think there is any need for it. Common sense usually prevails.

I hope all the people who come after us — and they will have to wait a while — use as much common sense at elections as we do.

Comment on this

As has been said by previous speakers, this operates in accordance with common sense. On a technical point, are we talking about remaining candidates or all candidates? In other words, if, at 11 p.m. five candidates have been eliminated and two have been elected, do they have to be consulted or are we talking about the candidates who still remain in the race?

I would like to ask the Minister a second technical question. In the event of candidates not being present for certain consultations, can the returning officer make his decision in their absence?

Comment on this

I am listening to the tone of this debate and, while the Opposition have a right to propose them, many of the amendments are frivolous. Senator Hederman mentioned the word "light" before "refreshments". It is obvious that she has not attended many counts because I have never seen T-bone steaks available at counts. Obviously there is a great lack of knowledge on the ground. Anybody who has attended counts would realise that these are very frivolous suggestions.

A well established returning officer is generally a man of good sense who has been a county manager, or county registrar, a man of stature with vast administrative experience. Some of the minor amendments before the House are an insult to the intelligence of any person who is qualified to be a presiding officer.

Comment on this

There are one or two points to which I want to respond to in relation to what Senator McGowan said. It is not the first time he has said such things. I object strongly to the suggestion that these amendments are frivolous. They have been well thought out and carefully considered. We have put a lot of effort into them and I object to that type of remark.

This amendment does not allude to returning officers behaving improperly. It is designed to allow the proper and easy functioning of counts where a crank candidate simply wants to be difficult, objects and stops the count proceeding to a conclusion, which it is apparent to everybody will arise within, let us say, half an hour. That is what the amendment is designed to do. It has nothing to do with how returning officers behave or conduct their business.

The questions asked by Senator Ó Cuív are relevant and I would like to hear the Minister's response, particularly in relation to candidates who are eliminated or, for that matter, who have left the count.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the amendment but I defend the right of the people across the floor to put down an amendment on any matter they wish. That is how the system works.

In relation to the question I raised regarding the time for refreshment, it is a legitimate concern. I accept fully what Senator McGowan says, that returning officers are responsible people who do a responsible job. They do it very well, and always have done but there have been other sections in this Bill which have been highly restrictive when it came to defining who can vote, when they can vote and the manner in which they can vote. This is unrestrictive and grants extreme latitude. It is stretching things far, and it is a bit frivolous to say that the returning officer could decide unilaterally at 9.10 a.m. that they would have light refreshments or serious refreshments or other refreshments and they could adjourn for several hours to enjoy the refreshments. We have all been at counts where we have seen people during the day and evening being overcome by the nature of the refreshments they have partaken during the day.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 152 is consequential on amendment No. 137 and both may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 137:

In page 68, line 31, after "votes", to add "except with the permission of the returning officer".

This amendment seeks to give the returning officer discretion in relation to empowering him to allow election agents at the count to handle ballot papers. The reason we have suggested this amendment is that it can considerably speed up the way the count is conducted. It can allay fears or concerns that the agents for candidates would have, particularly in regard to whether the franking machine stamp has been used on ballot papers. If it has not been used that would invalidate the ballot papers.

I am not suggeseting that every candidate or everybody at the count should be able to finger every ballot paper and hold it up to the light and look at it. For that reason we have built into the amendment that they could handle the ballot papers with the permission of the returning officer. It would be desirable that the returning officer would have that discretion. If he does not have that discretion he may not be able to allay the fears of the agents of certain candidates.

In a close contested election, the alternative is simply to demand a recount, which will create great difficulties in relation to extra time and resources which have to be committed to the whole process. There is an adequate safeguard built into the amendment which requires that the returning officer would have to give permission to the election agent to handle the ballot paper. That would be a desirable change.

Comment on this

Section 117 prohibits the handling of ballot papers at the counting of the votes by candidates or their agents. Under section 153, contravention of this provision is an offence. Amendment No. 137 proposes to modify section 117 to provide that candidates and agents shall not handle ballot papers except with the permission of the returning officer. Amendment No. 152 is consequential.

In practice, the only person who should handle ballot papers at the counting of the votes are the returning officer and his staff. I can envisage no situation where it would be necessary for a candidate or an agent to handle the ballot papers. In adjudicating on a doubtful ballot paper it is normal practice for a returning officer to consult with candidates or their agents and inform them of his proposed ruling on such papers. Candidates and agents are allowed to inspect the papers concerned but there is no reason whatever they should handle the papers.

I consider this an important part of the mechanism to protect the integrity of the electoral system and I feel the amendments proposed would not help in this regard. I would ask the Senators to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I am disappointed at the Minister's response. This amendment has been tabled at the specific suggestion of my own director of elections who has been director of elections in Dublin South-Central for our party for the best part of 20 years. It is as a result of his experience and his concerns that the amendment was tabled. I am disappointed that the Minister cannot accept it.

Comment on this

I am disappointed too, but more particularly because the Minister did not appear to address the point about the franking machine. It is an important point because a ballot paper is not valid unless it has been stamped. That is not done by the canvassers or the voter so they have no control over it. It is important to be able to establish that the paper has been stamped and it cannot always be done visually. I have experinece where it was difficult to tell. The returning officer said the ballot paper had no been stamped and one had to take his word for it. It is only fair to allow candidates or their agents to finger the paper to see of the stamp is on it.

Comment on this

When a ballot is close enough to require a recount, the question of papers being stamped correctly is very important. People observing on behalf of candidates cannot actually see the stamp unless they can get close to the ballot paper — closer than they can get at the moment. In a limited way, the amendment is necessary although I do not think there will be widespread need for it. The amendment proposes to add the words: "with the permission of the returning officer"; it does not say that they will handle every ballot paper.

In a tight vote, it is very important that the agents see that the ballot papers are stamped because if there is a recount and there are no stamps on the ballot papers, they will not be valid.

Comment on this

I have listened to the points made by the proposers of this amendment and I have heard the reply of the Minister. I have been through as many counts as anybody here and I fail to see why candidates or their agents should be allowed to handle ballot papers. Where will be draw the line?

I have been through two recounts and the returning officer, on each occasion, discussed the spoiled ballot papers with the candidates and the agents. Over my time, I have only heard arguments about four or five ballot papers. I always felt they were fairly adjudicated on and this is what really matters. I would hope that the same procedures would apply elsewhere. Perhaps Senators Upton and Harte had a different experience.

It is of vital importance that all candidates or their agents should be happy with the decision of the returning officer on whether papers are properly stamped and the mark put down by the elector clearly indicated the wishes of the elector. My experience over the years, has been that if the returning officer was satisfied that a mark on the ballot paper clearly reflected a preference for a candidate, wherever that mark was, the vote was given in that direction. It appears from what Senators have said that that is not always the case. We should clearly point out that it would be the express wish of the Members of the Oireachtas that every opportunity should be given to candidates to satisfy themselves that the papers were properly marked. I do not necessarily agree that that requires handling the ballot paper.

Comment on this

Will the Minister outline the powers of the returning officer in relation to the showing of ballot papers? Most of the amendments and most of these sections deal with the counting of votes. Most of these sections relate to doubtful or spoiled votes. They relate to the first count with the showing of papers. I am anxious to know at what point the returning officer can, legally, refuse a candidate or his or her agent the right to scrutinise a ballot paper. This can arise, and it did arise, in an election I was involved in last year. Two candidates emerged with the same number of votes well into the count at about the fourth or fifth count. There was then a recount and, subsequently, more papers were found for one candidate than the other, but I or my agent or any of the other candidates, including the two candidates involved, was not given the opportunity to see the new papers. It seemed to me at the time, and subsequently on reflection, that if the scrutiny had been carried out as well as we are being led to believe — and in most cases it is — these papers would not have shown a different preference. This was not a first count, they were not first preference votes; these were second and third preferences. Surely they should not have shown up at that late stage in the count. I would like to know what rights candidates or their agents have to scrutinise papers when the count is in progress?

My second and minor question relates to the reference to an offence in section 152. I cannot see any sanctions in the Schedule and I have not noticed them in the Bill. What sanctions are imposed on a candidate or his agent if they handle a ballot paper, and what legal steps are taken to impose a sanction on the candidate or his agent if they are seen to do so? I would like the Minister to spell this out for me.

Comment on this

If this amendment were to be carried it would place returning officers in an impossible position because we would be providing for a returning officer to hand the ballot paper to a candidate. Every Member in this House who has been elected knows that the count and the recount involve long hours and cause considerable stress. To authorise a returning officer to hand the ballot paper to a person and ask what they think will lead to disagreement. There must be an authority. At the end of the day, one person has to make the decision. That is absolutely clear.

I am totally in support of the law and regulation under which no candidate ever handles a ballot paper at any stage. If one were to legislate otherwise one would be promoting problems within the electoral system. It is right that where a candidate at a count puts his hand on a ballot paper, that is an offence. I hope it will remain an offence and a serious offence because the count has to be right and seen to be right. That is the cutting edge of democracy and one or two votes have often decided who will have a seat in this House or the other House. Even a fraction of a vote is very important in this House.

I would question the wisdom of those who proposed the amendment. I do not want to be sarcastic or nasty but I would say it is based on a lack of knowledge and experience of counts over a long time.

Comment on this

I strongly urge the Minister to continue with the well established procedure. The provisions of this Bill are safe and can be seen to be right and fair to all concerned.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Cathaoirleach, I would like to welcome the senior citizens from Sallins to this House this afternoon.

In respect of this amendment I do not see that there is any need to improve section 117 which says, "Candidates or their agents shall not handle ballot papers during the counting of votes." and I share Senator McGowan's reservations on this matter.

We all have had experience of an election where there was a scrum of people around the returning officer when the adjudication was being made on ballot papers that might be invalid. Even where people did not handle ballot papers the whole situation was unsatisfactory as it would have been quite conceivable to envisage that improprietary could have taken place. The more rigid the regulations in respect of this matter the better. I see no need to amend this section.

Comment on this

Senator Naughten covered many of the points that were raised by some of the Senators but in relation to Senator Mooney, section 113 (3) covers the points the Senator raised. It says:

The returning officer shall give the agents of the candidates all such reasonable facilities for overseeing the proceedings at the counting of the votes (including, in particular, facilities for satisfying themselves that the ballot papers had been correctly sorted) and all such information with respect thereto as he can give them consistent with the orderly conduct of the proceedings and the performance of his functions.

In relation to the Senator's other point, section 153 sets out the offence and section 157 indicates the penalty involved, which is a maximum fine of £500.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 138:

In page 69, line 27, in the definition of non-transferable paper, to delete "consecutively".

I am not fully sure I understand what is involved here but it seems to me that if somebody votes 1, 2, 3 and, let us say, 5, that invaliditates the transfer of the vote once it has gone as far as No. 3. That is undesirable. It can happen particularly in elections where there are many candidates, where people are voting down a ballot paper and simply lose count. They get the figures wrong. I was under the impression that as long as a preference was shown between candidates that was adequate to allow the vote to be valid. That should be the situation. For that reason I ask the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Section 118 defines the various expressions used in Part XIX in relation to the counting of votes. The definition of a non-transferable paper makes it clear that if there is a break in the continuity of the preference marked on a ballot paper the paper shall be deemed to have become non-transferable from the point at which the break occurs. The returning officer is obliged to comply strictly with the instructions of the elector and must implement them exactly in so far as this is possible. However, the returning officer is not in a position to read the mind of the elector or to cross-examine him in relation to his intentions and he is not entitled to make assumptions. Unless the relevant preference is clearly indicated the returning officer cannot act on it.

To take a concrete if rather far-fetched example: suppose there are nine candidates, the elector places number 1 opposite candidate A and number 9 opposite the candidate B, leaving the other spaces blank. Obviously this is a valid first preference for candidate A but what is the returning officer to make of the second marking? It may be a botched attempt to write number 2 but, more likely, the elector is signalling that he does not want candidate B under any circumstances. There is no way of knowing. If the amendment were accepted candidate B would have to be regarded as the elector's second choice and that would seem to be a doubtful, if not downright perverse, interpretation of the elector's preferences. Therefore, I ask that the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

It seems as if I am right in my interpretation of the provision. The Minister has given a far-fetched example. A more realistic one would be where a voter marks 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6, forgetting the order in which he or she has been marking the paper. The sequence may go 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and then 10. People get confused as they go up and down through a ballot paper trying to work their way through it. I was under the impression that once a preference was shown on the paper — even if it was not in sequence — that vote was accepted, it went into the system and was counted. I ask the Minister if there has been a change in the regulations in this Bill compared to what existed prior to its publication?

My wish in relation to this matter is that as many people as possible should be able to vote and that their votes should remain effective as long as possible. While I accept what the Minister says in relation to far-fetched examples, I also think you can play this thing either way. The case I make is as valid as what the Minister is saying and it errs on the side of keeping the vote going as long as there is some degree of preference shown.

Comment on this

There is no change. The ballot paper is consecutively accepted as long as there is continuity. When there is a break that is when the difficulty arises.

Comment on this