We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Electoral (No. 2) Bill, 1991: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 179–366 of 366. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (No. 2) Bill, 1991
Enacted

No. 44 of 1991 ›

I accept the example the Minister gave as being quite legitimate. It might be the sort of thing I would do myself. When I go into the polling station, I usually put number 1 opposite the name of the candidate I favour. Then I go down the list and put 12 or 13, or whatever, beside the name of the candidate I definitely do not want.

The situation the Minister outlined is quite a realistic one. Some time ago there was a local election and the European election on the same day and there was a pink ballot paper and a blue ballot paper. Quite a large percentage of people took the two ballot papers, had them side-by-side and wrote down the numbers 1 and 2 for the European election and then 3 and 4 on the other ballot paper. The returning officer at the election in which I was involved said there was so many of them it became clear that if a person put 3, 6, 7, 8 or 10 on one paper, 3 indicated his first preference, 6 indicated his second preference and so on. They allowed them through. What would be the position now?

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I understand that is relevant to another section.

Comment on this

I should like to support the Minister in his excellent reply. Both Senator Upton and Senator Hederman have probably made the case for the Minister in that they have been attempting, quite legitimately of course, to read the mind of the elector. Speaking for all of my colleagues on this side of the House, we are most interested and fascinated by Senator Hederman's mode of voting. I understand she has yet to be faced with a ballot paper in the Seanad elections and she will have a fascinating time working out the preferences if she starts at the bottom and works back.

Comment on this

I will get the Senator's assistance. Which section does my comment refer to?

Comment on this
Thomas Hussey Acting Chairman (Mr. Hussey) Fianna Fáil

The amendments have to be disposed of before we deal with the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 139:

In page 70, subsection (2), lines 21 and 22, to delete paragraph (d).

The amendment proposes to delete paragraph (d) in page 70 because it is not necessary to the Bill. That is the point I am trying to make.

Comment on this

Section 118 (2) specifies the circumstances in which a ballot paper will be regarded as invalid. Paragraph (d) provides that a ballot paper on which anything is written or marked which, in the opinion of the returning officer, is calculated to identify the elector shall be invalid and not counted.

Amendment No. 139 proposes to delete paragraph (d). The purpose of the paragraph in question is to protect electors from undue influence or bribery. If an elector is bribed or put under undue influence to vote in a particular way he is, in the normal course, protected by the fact that voting is entirely secret. In an attempt to ensure that the elector will not vote in a particular way he could be put under pressure to identify his particular ballot paper so that someone present at the count could verify he had voted as directed. This could be done by putting a pre-arranged mark or writing on the ballot paper. In this way the secrecy of the ballot could be violated and the way opened for serious electoral abuse. By regarding such ballot papers as invalid, we can ensure that the voters are not subjected to this type of pressure or, if they are, that such pressure would be of no avail.

The effect of the amendment would be that the ballot paper would have to be accepted no matter what extraneous matter is written or marked on it. This could even include the full name and address of the elector. I have no hesitation in saying that this is unacceptable and the amendment should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I am not sure that what the Minister says prevents people voting in a way that can be identified at counts. One hears stories of people using a wide range of pens, biros, fountain pens with unusually shaped nibs, etc. in certain types of elections.

Comment on this

The green biro.

Comment on this

That is basically the point I was coming to. It still does not preclude the possibility of people using certain codes in the way they vote. I do not want to make an issue of it.

Comment on this

When the polls are held on the same day, as happened, I raised the matter of people marking the two ballot papers.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That has nothing to do with amendment No. 139. It is related to another section.

Comment on this

Could the Minister clarify what he means by the statement "the returning officer shall prepare a statement on such forms as may be directed by the Minister, showing the number of ballot papers rejected by him under each of the paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d)". Am I to assume that when this statement is made it will set out the reasons under headings, for example, that people wrote their names on the ballot etc? Is that information available to us as Members of the Oireachtas or how is it made available? The provision is that the returning officer shall prepare the statement as directed by the Minister but it does not go on to state other than that the candidate or his agent will get a copy of it. What is the procedure? Does one write to the returning officer? How does one actually obtain it? This information is very important.

I am curious to know if this is a new provision or if this has always been the case. I was not aware that one could get this information. All of us will agree that it is a source of irritation to politicians to see the analysis of election results. In the most recent referendum, which was a simple matter of a straight "yes" and a straight "no", the percentage of spoiled votes was quite incredible. The number of spoiled ballots in each constituency was much higher than I had thought possible. In a PR election I can understand people being somewhat confused.

Does the Minister feel that the number of spoiled ballots in the most recent referendum is cause for concern? I would be anxious to know if, under the existing law it is possible to analyse those spoiled ballots or is this a new provision? I am giving the Minister an opportunity to set out the position and that is why I have been labouring the point somewhat.

Comment on this

My fear about this section relates to what will happen when we have two elections on the same day, perhaps a local election and a European election, or a local election and a national election. Two ballot papers will be given at the same time. Senators will know what I am referring to. An extensive number of voters mark the two ballot papers simultaneously putting the numbers 1 and 2 on the first and the numbers 3, 4 and 5 on the other, before coming back to the first ballot paper. It is perfectly clear from each ballot paper what was intended. There was a priority, but the difficulty was that the ballot papers which did not contain the number 1 beside anybody's name were disallowed, whereas the ballot papers which had a 1, 2, 6, 7 were allowed. Does this section deal with that?

Comment on this

I think the matters which Senator Hederman is dealing with are covered under section 166.

Comment on this

The points made by Senator Hederman will be coming up in section 158. The analysis is part of the record retained by the Clerk of the Dáil and it can be inspected or copied. Any information required may be obtained and the information is available to anybody. One can also take copies.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain precisely what the word "mix" means in this section? I have attended many counts in my time. Ballot papers are taken out of the boxes, checked and put back in again and then they are taken out for the count. Is that the definition of "mix" or what precisely is it? I heard a legal argument some years ago about the definition of the word "mix". The argument put forward by some legal experts and my interpretation of "mix" would be totally different. I would like the Minister to clarify that.

Comment on this

Senator Naughten is dealing with a very important point in relation to what constitutes "mix". Where a candidate has more than a quota, the surplus is distributed. As I understand it, the surplus is taken off the top of the bundle of votes. If the votes are not mixed properly or uniformly, it is quite possible to have a fairly significant bias in relation to votes which are transferred onwards and which will then move onwards again to another candidate. By a careful selection of votes to be transferred on a surplus, it is possible to influence the course of the election three or four counts onwards. I remember being at an internal party election years ago where I saw a gentleman, who had a tremendous level of commitment and attention to detail, fingering his way through the ballot papers of a candidate who had more than a quota. I wondered what caused this great level of diligence but I figured it out afterwards. In transferring a surplus of, say, ten votes in a small election, if you picked out ten votes to be transferred to the bundle of votes of a candidate who was a "no hoper" which had a number three for a candidate whom you would like to see elected, those votes when subsequently transferred onwards would ensure that your man or woman in the election would be doing far better than a random sample of the ballot papers would justify.

Senator Naughten is alluding to a very important matter in relation to what "mix" amounts to. If the ballot papers are not mixed properly, then there will not be a random sample of them subsequently. By manipulating what is meant by "mix" it is possible to determine the outcome of counts down the road. That is particularly relevant in relation to rural election. If somebody in one area is guaranteed to have a surplus, if you can determine where the number 2s will go, it is possible to influence the count in terms of the votes transferred as part of somebody's surplus. It would probably be nowhere more relevant than in Senator Naughten's own constituency of Roscommon-Leitrim in the next election where I could envisage very clear patterns of number 2s and number 3s going in certain directions arising from who had a surplus and its distribution. I am not suggesting that this is a factor which inspired Senator Naughten to make what I consider to be an excellent point.

Comment on this

They are currently selling tickets for the convention.

Comment on this

By law, votes must be mixed. It is at the discretion of the returning officer what way he mixes the votes. They can be taken at random and for that reason there is a mix. It is up to the returning officer to decide what method he uses and what way he actually creates the mix of votes.

Comment on this

I am not just nit-picking on this issue. I have heard legal argument on it. One legal opinion was that "mix" meant effectively that the votes in every ballot box should be emptied out in the centre of the floor and literally mixed. That was one legal definition of "mix". My understanding of "mix" could well be that the votes, having been checked and put back in the ballot boxes, would be taken out and given to the counters; as they would be put back into the pigeonholes, of course there would be a mix coming from the different groups of counters and boxes from different parts of the constituency.

I just wonder if we could not find a better term than "mix" or at least define what "mix" is. I am not trying to pin down the Minister but it is important that we clarify exactly what we mean when we use the term "mix".

Comment on this

The example given by Senator Naughten is, I understand, the normal way the mix takes place. I have to come back to the point that it is a matter for the returning officer to decide how he proposes to carry out the mix of the votes. That is the position.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider discussing this matter further with his officials and having it reviewed before Report Stage to see if we can have something more defined and clear? I would be very happy if the Minister had the matter examined, together with his officials, to see if we could precisely define what the word "mix" is in terms of a general election.

Comment on this

I support Senator Naughten. This procedure can be very important and it is open to abuse. I do not think the abuse is of any real significance but it is very easy to visualise certain sets of circumstances, particularly where a candidate would have two quotas. In the normal run of events it does not matter because the amount over a quota with most candidates would be fairly trivial. There are quite a number of constituencies where nobody exceeds the quota. It is possible to visualise a certain set of circumstances and I would like to see a definition of "mix" provided.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to define "mix". No matter what way you go about it, somebody will be dissatisfied. I would not want to give any false impressions here. I will certainly have a look at it for Report Stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 141 and 142 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 141:

In page 72, lines 41 to 52, to delete subsection (8).

My reason for putting in those amendments is quite clear and specific. Section 121 provides that where at the end of any count the number of votes credited to a candidate is greater than the quota, the surplus shall be transferred in accordance with and subject to the provisions of this section. I have no difficulty at all with the distribution of a surplus, but subsection (8) goes on to say that it must affect the two higher candidates or the two lower candidates. That is basically what the section provides.

The same principle should be adhered to in a general election or a local election as in a Seanad election, where all surpluses are distributed. Only after the distribution of surpluses should candidates be eliminated. The panel election system for the Seanad clearly provides that all surpluses shall be distributed. I suggest — and what we are talking about here is basic fairness — that all surpluses should be distributed before eliminations take place. It may not make any difference on the next count, but at later counts the fact that the surplus was not transferred could mean a different result. I have seen it happen and it is unfair. It should be a golden principle that all surpluses should be transferred before the elimination of candidates.

In one election I discussed that matter with the returning officer and the reason he gave for not distributing the surplus on that occasion was that he had made a ruling in a similar situation four general elections previously and he was going to stand beside that ruling. I asked him to quote the relevant section of the Act, but he was going on precedent.

We are formulating fair legislation that will give the maximum number of people the opportunity to use their democratic right. This is a non-political Bill. We would wish to ensure when it leaves here and is implemented that democracy will operate to its fullest. It should be a basic principle that surpluses be distributed before eliminations take place. It will not make any difference on the next count but, two or three counts later, in rural constituencies where different geographical areas exist, it can, does and did make a difference. The fact that a surplus was not distributed gave a different result at the end of the day. It should be a basic principle that all surpluses be distributed before candidates are eliminated.

Comment on this

These amendments in the name of Senator Naughten would have the effect of requiring the returning officer to transfer every surplus irrespective of its size and irrespective of the circumstances. Every surplus would have to be transferred whether it could affect the outcome of the election in any way, if it could help to save the candidate's deposit or if it could advance the count in any respect.

Under existing law which is contained in rule 65 of the Third Schedule to the 1923 Act, the returning officer has discretion to transfer a surplus in certain circumstances. Different practices by returning officers in exercising this discretion can sometimes give rise to misunderstanding. It was felt that this Bill provided a suitable opportunity to remove any element of uncertainty in this regard and to have uniform procedure in all constituencies.

Section 121 (8) spells out the very limited circumstances in which a surplus will not be transferred. The returning officer will not transfer a surplus if the surplus, together with all other untransferred surpluses, could not possibly give any continuing candidate a quota, could not save any candidate from elimination or could not save the deposit of any candidate. Outside these very limited circumstances, the returning officer will be obliged to transfer every surplus and the position of any untransferred surplus will be reviewed at the end of each count, and if at any stage the surplus could conceivably have any effect, it must then be transferred.

Section 121 (8) contains a watertight protection for all continuing candidates. A decision not to transfer a surplus may be taken only where it could not possibly make any material difference to any candidate. If the amendments were accepted the returning officer would have no choice but to transfer every surplus. As I mentioned in replying on Second Stage, you could have a situation on the first count where a candidate might be elected with just one vote over the quota. To transfer such a surplus consisting of a single paper would require the examination and re-sorting of all the candidates papers, possibly numbering up to 10,000 in all. The net effect of the amendments would be to require the transfer of a surplus where it would make no material difference to the course of the count and would thus require transfers of surpluses for purely academic purposes. I ask the Senator, therefore, not to press the amendments.

Comment on this

It is not for an academic purpose that I have put down those amendments. Far from it. Any amendments I put down to this Bill were designed to improve it. I am not trying to get into the nitty gritty. I have already stated that I know of a situation where the fact that the surplus was not distributed was disadvantageous to the outcome of a particular election. I also pointed out very clearly that the returning officer when requested by a candidate refused to distribute the surplus of another candidate, not on any legal grounds but because of a precedent created by his direction four general elections previously. It is bad law, it is bad legislation and I am prepared to accept that the Minister may on Report Stage introduce some better form of wording than I have suggested. I ask the Minister to provide that where a candidate requests that a surplus be distributed, that principle should be adhered to. It is the principle I am talking about. It operates in Seanad elections and I do not see any reason it should not operate in general elections.

I take the point made by the Minister about the one vote; that would be an extreme situation. I am trying to ensure that candidates who put their names on a ballot paper and go before the electorate have the right to demand that that surplus be distributed.

Comment on this

A mandatory obligation on the returning officer to transfer every surplus, no matter what the circumstances, is simply not on. If section 121 (8) as drafted is not acceptable, the only realistic option would be to revert to the existing situation where the returning officer has a discretion in certain circumstances.

Comment on this

I will have to press the amendment if the Minister is not prepared to have a look at this matter again before Report Stage. If the Minister and his officials want a clear example of what I am referring to, I will have no hesitation in giving it to them. I am trying to ensure that there is an even playing field. Where, for example, 1,500 votes are untransferred for two or three counts, at the end of the day the fact that those votes were not transferred will throw up a different result. That is morally wrong and does not reflect accurately the wishes of the electorate who voted for the candidate with the very large surplus.

I am aware of the timescale for the Bill and I do not want to drag out this debate. I am trying to get the best possible legislation in place. I am not suggesting that my amendment offers the best possible form of wording but I am open to discuss the matter with the Minister and if we can agree on a form of wording and have it brought in on Report Stage, I would be happy with that.

Comment on this

I would like to support Senator Naughten. I accept in most cases that probably what he is alluding to would not be of any material significance, but I can readily visualise a set of circumstances, particularly in rural areas, where there would be a local vote of say No. 1 for Senator Naughten, No. 2 for his competitor from the other party who is perhaps ten miles down the road. In those circumstances the question of who goes out 40 to 60 miles away in the constituency makes a huge difference as to where seats are won.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I accept that most of the time it will not be of any significance and I do not want to labour the point that there should be a solemn obligation on everybody in the extreme example the Minister has given. I share the Senator's concern that it is a very important point and I appeal to the Minister to have another look at it and see if some compromise can be reached.

Comment on this

Section 121 (8) contains a watertight protection for all continuing candidates. A decision not to transfer a surplus may be taken only where it could not be possible to make any material difference to any candidate. If Senator Naughten has some example he might give it to us and we will have it examined.

Comment on this

I certainly will but there is not much point in giving it if we cannot discuss it at a later stage. I am asking the Minister for an undertaking that he will examine this matter before Report Stage and we will see what we can do at that stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Does the Minister wish to respond further?

Comment on this

If you give me the example we will examine it and see if there is anything we can do.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 143 and 144 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 145 and 146 are related and may be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 145:

In page 75, subsection (3), lines 5 to 8, to delete paragraph (d).

Comment on this

It seems to me that the Government amendment is dealing with something very different from that contained in our amendment. Amendment No. 145 proposes the deletion of paragraph (d) while amendment No. 146 proposes the insertion of a new paragraph (e). We are not concerned with the question of dealing with something forthwith. We accept that. In paragraph (d) is it the returning officer who decides on what is frivolous or vexatious? There is no referee. While it is desirable that the word "forthwith" has been deleted it is not consistent with the question. In other words, the returning officer is given plenty of time, because of the deletion of the word "forthwith", to think about any such request. The implication is that in the case of a request being regarded as frivolous or vexatious the returning officer makes the decision immediately and he does not give any consideration to it.

Comment on this

Section 125 (3) (d) is a new provision which provides that a returning officer shall not be obliged to accede to a request for a recount which, in his opinion, is frivolous and vexatious. Amendment No. 145 proposes to delete this provision. Under existing law the returning officer is obliged to comply with the request from a candidate, or his election agent, for a complete re-examination and recount of ballot papers, irrespective of the circumstances. Under existing law a candidate who receives half a dozen first preference votes and is eliminated on the first count would be entitled to demand a complete re-examination and recount of all ballot papers at the end of, say, the tenth count, and under existing law the returning officer would be obliged to accede to such a request. Such a recount would serve no useful purpose. It would simply delay the declaration of the results and cause annoyance and inconvenience to candidates and other involved in the counting process. It does not seem very sensible to retain this possibility and, for this reason, paragraph (d) proposes to give the returning officer a measure of discretion. I think this is a desirable reform and that the paragraph should be retained.

Comment on this

Having listened to the Minister I accept his views.

Comment on this

I wish to put a brief question to the Minister. I cannot find the reference to a quota change as a result of a recount. We clearly specify where quota comes into it with regard to the first count but where, for example, there is a complete recount, and there is 1 per cent of spoiled ballot papers found in the recount, I do not see any provision in this Bill to allow the quota to be changed. The quota is set after the first count, but in the event of a recount at a later stage, is there provision in the Bill for a change of quota?

Comment on this

I agree that Senator Naughten has raised a very interesting and important point. It is essential that there should be provision in the Bill to allow for the change of a quota. It has been known in elections where people simply counted, being out one, two or three — 99 as distinct from 100 — but the real difficulty in relation to the quota arises where somebody mistakenly counted numbers of bundles of 100. In those circumstances, that could have a serious impact on the quota given that you would be talking in terms of a recount where a few votes could decide who would win and lose seats.

Comment on this

Section 125 (4) provides that where an error is discovered, the returning officer shall, where necessary, amend any results previously announced by him. Where a request under subsection (3) is withdrawn by the candidate in respect of whom it is made or by the election agent of the said candidate, it shall be open to the returning officer not to proceed or to proceed further with the re-examination and recount.

Comment on this

From my reading of the section it is clear that if in the event of the recount, there is a different result, there is no difficulty about that, the returning officer will change it, but in my view it does not cover the changing of a quota. This is a very important principle. I have had experience of where senior counsel had to be called in to get a returning officer to change the quota where there were 57 spoiled votes — Senator Mullooly will be well aware of this — and the quota was changed by 18. Let us be frank about it, there did not appear to be a provision where the quota, once set, could be changed.

This is a golden opportunity to deal with this issue. As far as I am concerned there is nothing in the Bill which allows for a quota change. It allows the decision to be changed if there is different personnel, but I do not see where it is clearly specified that, in the event of a recount and a spoiled votes surplus or a mistake involving a wrong bundle of votes, as outlined by Senator Upton, there is provision for the change of a quota. I would be happy if the Minister would examine this matter before Report Stage.

Comment on this

There must be clear guidelines for the returning officer. If the guidelines are vague that can lead to dispute and the possibility of the returning office being challenged on every vague issue of the day. If we are talking about the quota being changed because of the number of spoiled votes, we are on very weak ground. I would question the strength of the legislation if a quota could be changed after a recount.

Comment on this

Senator McGowan misunderstood what I said. He refers to vague guidelines; that is what I do not want. I want clear cut guidelines. In the event of a number of spoiled votes turning up in a recount, moral justice would dictate that the original quota was wrong. I want a provision in this Bill that will facilitate the returning officer in changing the quota to what should be the right quota.

Comment on this

Any error found in the recount can be corrected, including any recalculation of the quota.

Comment on this

Under what section?

Comment on this

A re-examination and a recount means looking at every paper. It should be said that the counting of votes at our elections is carried out with extreme care and efficiency. The provision for a complete recount has existed in the law since 1963. I am not aware of any occasion in which a complete recount has resulted in a different candidate being declared elected.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is section 125, as amended, agreed to?

Comment on this

I am still not happy with this section. I think it is too vague with regard to the changing of a quota. I am not going to split hairs with the Minister on this, but I would ask him to discuss it with his officials to see if we can clarify this section. I have had first hand experience of this situation and I know how difficult it is to get a quota changed once it is set.

Comment on this

Section 130 provides for the production by the Clerk of the Dáil of certain documents which may be required for the purposes of instituting or maintaining prosecution for an electoral offence or for the purpose of a petition. Under this section a person may not be allowed to inspect the documents except under an order of the High Court.

Subsection (5) provides that where documents are produced by the Clerk of the Dáil under an order made under this section, the production by or on behalf of the Clerk of the Dáil of the documents shall be sufficient to prove that the documents related to the election question.

Amendment No. 148 is a technical amendment to make it clear that the provisions of subsection (5) are not confined solely to the documents to be produced by order of the High Court under this section. The District Court could require the production of documents in hearing a case dealing with an election offence or the Supreme Court could conceivably make an order for the production in court of the documents in the event of an appeal. The effect of the amendment would be to clarify that in the event of an order being made by any court for the production of the documents, the production by or on behalf of the Clerk of the Dáil is sufficient to prove that they relate to the election in question.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 149:

In page 77, line 9, after "fees" to insert "not exceeding the reasonable cost of copying)".

This amendment relates to the fees which would be charged for copying. There has been a similar amendment which the Minister accepted. I hope he will be consistent and accept this amendment also.

Comment on this

I am accepting this amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 150:

In page 81, subsection (1) lines 36 and 37, to delete "date on which the return is made to the Clerk of the Dáil under section 39," and substitute "close of poll,".

I am puzzled as to why the restriction of the definition of when disorderly behavioural conduct at election meetings takes place should range from when the writ for the election has been issued — which is reasonable enough — until the date on which the return is made to the Clerk of the Dáil under section 39. I would have thought that it would be more appropriate to define this period as from the date of the issuing of the writ for the election to the close of poll.

Comment on this

Section 139 which repeats existing law without any change provides that it shall be an offence to act in a disorderly manner at a public meeting held in connection with an election between the issue of the writ and the date on which the return is made to the Clerk of the Dáil.

Amendment No. 150 proposes to substitute the expression "the close of the poll" for the expression "the date on which the return is made to the Clerk of the Dáil". In putting down this amendment Senators may have lost sight of the fact that an election does not necessarily include the taking of a poll. Uncontested elections are, admittedly, rare events in this country. Nonetheless they can occur and section 58 specifically recognises that possibility. It is probably not a matter of great moment when the prohibition referred to in section 138 expires. However, if we are to use the form of wording proposed in the amendment the section would be defective and hence possibly unenforceable.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 151 and 164 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 151:

In page 83, lines 11 to 30, to delete subsection (2).

Section 147 (2) met with a fair degree of agreement from most political parties, including our own. I see much merit in what is being proposed. If I were to have a criticism it would be about the distance or the circumference around the polling station being increased. However, the reason we have put down this amendment is to raise the possibility that what is being proposed here may be unconstitutional. I understand it may be unconstitutional because it may interfere with freedom of expression. I gather that in the United States there has been at least one case Freeman v. Burson in 1990 which says that these type of restrictions are invalid. I would like to hear the Minister's response to that possibility.

Comment on this

Section 147 (2) provides for a prohibition on political activities within 50 metres of a polling station on polling day at a Dáil election.

Section 176 contains a similar prohibition in relation to local elections. Amendment No. 151 proposes the deletion of section 147 (2). This would involve dropping the detailed provision and retaining only a general prohibition on interference with and obstruction of electors.

Amendment No. 164 proposes to extend the area within which the detailed prohibition will apply from 50 metres as proposed in the Bill to 100 metres. The provision of subsection (2), as drafted, is quite comprehensive, encompassing all forms of canvassing, loitering or congregating by persons, display of posters, distribution of leaflets or by use of loudspeakers. The intention is to ensure that an elector can come and go to the polling station to cast his vote, unimpeded by canvassers.

While there was a general welcome by Senators for this provision during Second Stage debate some Senators had reservations about certain aspects of the provision while others, including Senator Ó Foíghil, felt the provision did not go far enough. In a sense the amendments we are now considering reflect these different views. I can understand and to an extent sympathise with the reservations expressed by both sides. The problem that has been identified and which has been raised several times in the Oireachtas is a very specific one. The belief is that the congregation of canvassers outside polling stations can obstruct electors and cause concern to them. The problem is specific and must, I believe, be addressed in a specific way.

The deletion of subsection (2), as proposed by amendment No. 151, would leave in place only a very general provision. I do not believe it would be possible under the general provision to deal adequately with the specific matters complained of. It is likely that the Garda, under general powers, could intervene in any case of actual obstruction. The general provision in subsection (1) would, therefore, not represent a significant advance in this situation and would not be effective in removing an intimidating effect of a mere presence of substantial numbers of canvassers. I consider that retention of subsection (2) is essential if the section is to achieve the objective of allowing the elector to go to a polling station to cast his vote completely unimpeded and free from the pressure of this type of canvassing.

I feel that the proposed limit of 50 metres in the Bill strikes the correct balance. I would like to remind the House that under section 176 the distance of 50 metres is measured from any entrance to the polling station or, if the building in which the polling station is located is situated on its own grounds, from any entrance to the grounds. In many cases, especially in built-up areas where the problem is most prevalent, this would mean that the canvassing will, in effect, be prohibited well in excess of 50 metres from the actual entrance to the building in which the polling station is located. This is a new provision in our electoral law and it is reasonable that we should wait and see how the provision will work in practice. If in the light of experience in the operation of the provision problems arise the matter can be looked at again. Therefore, I suggest that both amendments be withdrawn.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 153 and 154 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 153:

In page 85, line 22, to delete "not exceeding £500".

These amendments seek to remove the limit of £500 which is the total amount of damages which can be paid to somebody who has been improperly arrested as the result of a decision made by a personating agent. I think that £500 is a very small amount to pay somebody who has been treated in that manner. There is also in this section a provision which excludes the possibility of such an individual taking a civil action against the person who treated them in that manner. It is unacceptable that we should have a ceiling of £500 placed on the amount of damages which can be awarded to somebody who has been unfairly or improperly arrested and that their capacity to take a civil action should be limited.

Comment on this

Section 158 repeats existing law. It provides for the payment of damages to a person who has been arrested on foot of a charge of personation made by a personation agent and either the agent fails to appear before the court to support the charge or the court acquits the person and finds that the charge was made without reasonable or just cause.

The court may order the payment of a sum not exceeding £500 at the request of the person charged without the need for the further court action on his part. However, this compensation must be accepted in full satisfaction of all claims arising from the arrest or charge and detention. The compensation figure specified in existing law is £20. Amendment No. 153 proposes to remove the ceiling of £500 on damages payable under the section. Amendment No. 154 proposes to delete the requirement that this compensation must be accepted in full satisfaction of any claims arising from the charge, arrest and detention.

The effect of these two amendments would be that there would be no limit to the amount which the court could order and the person concerned would retain the option of a further claim for compensation by way of civil action. Section 158 provides a simple mechanism for a person against whom a charge of personation is unjustifiably made to claim limited damages for charge, arrest and detention. During the course of trial, this sum could be awarded to him at his request. No separate action with its atendant costs and inconvenience would be necessary. In return, he would accept this award as final settlement. There would, of course, be no obligation on the injured party to use the mechanism provided by this section. He would be quite free to seek redress through the normal civil process.

Acceptance of the amendments would frustrate the purpose of the section which is to provide a simple and relatively inexpensive way of reaching finality. It would be preferable to delete the section entirely rather than amend it in this way. I trust the amendment will be withdrawn.

Comment on this

A sum of £500 seems very small for someone who might be badly damaged in terms of the impact on their character and reputation.

Comment on this

How does the Minister decide to change these figures? The figure is £20 in existing legislation and it has been increased to £500, but are the conditions the same — that such sum when duly paid shall be accepted by the person so charged in full satisfaction of all claims by him in respect of damages arising from the said charge and his arrest and detention thereon — in the present legislation or is the figure of £20 independent of that? It is interesting that it has been increased from £20 to £500 whereas other sums in this Bill have increased from £100 to £500? What equations does the Minister work on to produce these rather arbitrary figures? Is it a type of blackmail of the person who has been charged with personation, they can take the £500 if they do not, they might not get anything because they might not succeed in civil proceedings? There is a form of blackmail in this, and I wonder was it in the prevous Act, and does this section stand up?

Comment on this

The amount of damages permitted under the provision has increased from £20 to £500. The increase is roughly in line with inflation over the past 70 years. There is no compulsion on the individual to take this route. They can take other courses of action if they wish.

Comment on this

The Minister said there is no compulsion to accept this course of action but there is in one way because if a person is certain of being given £500 and does not take it what are the options open to them? One may end up not getting anything at all. There is a certain compulsion in it.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the courts to decide. If the person decides to take another route in relation to this matter that is a matter for themselves and the court will make a decision on that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 155 and 156 are related and both may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 155:

In page 86, line 4, after "proceedings" to insert "or for any other purpose".

These two amendments are concerned with preserving the secrecy of the ballot. The first one broadens the protection given beyond legal proceedings by inserting "or for any other purpose". The second one inserts the term "whether or not somebody had voted". While protection is given to those who have cast their vote, there is concern in relation to people who may not have voted. If somebody has not voted, that might tell one as much as knowing that they did vote. It is a very important consideration. If somebody can be forced to say whether they voted, then I think that could seriously compromise them in relation to the impressions people might have had about their voting tendencies and so on. Pressure should not be brought to bear on them to determine whether they voted, in much the same way as is not acceptable to ask them or force them to say how they cast their vote.

Comment on this

Section 162 re-enacts the existing provision which provides that in any legal proceedings a person shall not be required to state how or for whom he voted. Amendment No. 155 proposes that this prohibition should be extended to cover any other purpose in addition to legal proceedings and under amendment No. 156 it would cover whether the elector voted, in addition to how and for whom.

The section is designed to protect an elector who may be involved in court proceedings, for example, in relation to an electoral offence or an election petition. Under this provision he could not be required to indicate how he voted at an election, even if that could have a direct bearing on the court proceedings, for example, in a charge of bribery or undue influence.

It is not clear what type of situation other than court proceedings is envisaged in amendment No. 155. I am not aware of any situation other than a court or a tribunal having the powers of a court in which a witness could be required to answer a question in relation to voting. The Garda are empowered under certain enactments to require persons to provide particular information. None of these has any relevance to elections. Neither the Oireachtas nor any select committee can compel a witness to answer any question. If what is in mind is the possibility of discrimination against a person because he did or did not vote in a particular way, this would seem to be a matter for anti-discrimination legislation. It could hardly be a matter for this legislation which is intended primarily to deal with the technical procedures at Dáil elections.

Comment on this

Is it possible during the course of a legal case for somebody to be legitimately asked whether they cast their vote? If the answer to that is "yes", then it is a very serious matter because the fact that they may not have cast their vote could be of tremendous importance in certain circumstances. If they were a well-known supporter of a political party and if it were put to them in a law case, did they not cast their vote and they admit that they did not, that could seriously compromise them. That is what we are striving after in one of those amendments.

Comment on this

If a person is being tried on a charge of personation it is reasonable that he should be asked in court whether he voted. The information could also be crucial where a third party might be charged with personating an elector. Similarly in an election petition, evidence as to whether particular electors actually voted themselves or were personated could be vital.

Again, I stress that showing that a person voted does not necessarily mean he actually marked the ballot paper. It merely means that a person obtained a ballot paper and placed it in the ballot box. In any event, whether a person voted is not and cannot be a secret. Entering the polling station, receiving a ballot paper and placing it in the ballot box are intended to be public acts. In the ordinary way the fact that an elector voted can be ascertained by checking the marked copy of the register which is sent to the Clerk of the Dáil for retention for a period of six months under section 129. The register may be produced to a court and under section 131 may be inspected by any person.

This amendment is inappropriate and I ask that it be withdrawn.

Comment on this

Will the Minister look at this section again? It would not be appropriate to interfere with returning officers in the manner outlined in the section as they are independent.

Comment on this

Section 164 enables the Minister to issue instructions to all or any returning officer in relation to the conduct of an election which he considers necessary to ensure the smooth and efficient running of the election and uniformity of procedure in all constituencies. This is a new provision in Dáil electoral law. I am inclined to agree with the Senator that in view of the independent role of the returning officer at a Dáil election, where he or she is not answerable to the Minister, such a provision may not be desirable. I will examine this for Report Stage to see whether this provision should be retained, amended or dropped.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I am very pleased Senator Fitzgerald asked that this section be looked at again. It did strike me that it was not really in line with the Minister's thinking which he expounded on so eloquently when he said the Oireachtas should not concern itself with items of detail and get bogged down with minutiae but should concentrate on the broad principles. It seemed to me the Minister in getting involved in issuing instructions to returning officers was not in line with his enlightened and very welcome new thinking. I greatly welcome the reply given to Senator Fitzgerald.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 157:

In page 88, lines 5 to 9, to delete paragraph (g).

I have a lot of difficulty with this amendment. Section 166 (2) (g) reads:

a candidate who would be entitled to exercise the right to free postage pursuant to section 57 or otherwise in relation to more than one poll may include in a postal communication sent by him material in relation to each such poll.

Does that mean there should be a reference in section 57 of a poll because I cannot see any such reference but it is mentioned in section 166.

I remember a case where a candidate was standing in two elections — let us say a local election and a European election — and was entitled to free postage for one of them. May I ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach if European election candidates get free postage?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is up to the Minister to answer questions like that.

Comment on this

They had free postage for the European election but they were able to include literature in their free post envelope which assisted candidates running in the local election. Unfortunate candidates such as myself, who used to be called Independents and now apparently are to be called Non-Party, did not have that advantage. When I read the section and referred back to section 57, I became confused by my amendment which unfortunately was not accepted. It asked the Minister to agree to give candidates at a local election free postage. I maintain that I would be supported in this by everything that is happening in the European Community and the various dictats that come to us——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It has been brought to my attention that the Senator has an amendment to section 176, which deals with free postage.

Comment on this

What is the number of the amendment please?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 162 dealing with free postage.

Comment on this

That has been disallowed.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator cannot bring it in at this stage.

Comment on this

I accept that. I know, unfortunately, that amendment No. 162 will be disallowed. That deals with the question of free postage for local elections. Am I allowed to refer back to section 57?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

No. The Senator is dealing with amendment No. 157 on section 166.

Comment on this

Section 166 (2) (g) refers to section 57 and states:

a candidate who would be entitled to exercise the right to free postage pursuant to section 57 or otherwise in relation to more than one poll may include a postal communication sent by him, material in relation to each such poll.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

So long as the Senator speaks within the context of the amendment.

Comment on this

I am speaking to this section. Perhaps the Minister would clarify the position. If a person stands for the Dáil, European and local elections at the same time, and he gets free postage for one, can he avail of that to further the interests of his running mates or any other candidate in the other elections?

Comment on this

Under existing electoral law, a candidate at a Presidential, Dáil or European election is entitled to send free of postal charge one communication in relation to the election to each person on the register of electors for the constituency. In the case of a Dáil or European election where two or more candidates are candidates of the same political party in a constituency, they may issue a joint communication only, in other words, they are treated as a single candidate.

Where two or more elections are held on the same day and the person is a candidate at more than one election at which free postage applies, he may, under existing law, issue a separate election communication, separately addressed, for each poll concerned. He would not be entitled to refer to both elections in the same communication nor could he include separate communications in a single envelope.

Section 166 repeats existing law which facilitates the taking of two or more polls on the same day. Subsection (2) (g) includes a new provision to allow a person who is a candidate at two or more polls to issue a combined communication relating to both polls. In order to avail of this arrangement, the free postage provision must apply at both polls and a person must be a candidate at both polls. We are concerned here with Presidential elections, Dáil elections and European elections, in other words, elections at which free postage applies. Subsection (2) (g) has no relevance to local elections because there is no provision for free postage at local elections. Amendment No. 157 proposes to delete paragraph (g) thereby retaining the existing situation.

I want to spell out that paragraph (g) confers no new right to free postage on anybody. The paragraph simply provides that where a candidate would under existing law be entitled to issue two post free letters, he may now combine those in a single letter. For example, if he is a candidate on the same day at the Dáil elections and the Euro elections, he will now have the option of sending a single letter referring to both elections. This will save on the cost of postage which is borne by the central fund and the cost of supplying and addressing envelopes which is borne by the candidates. That is all the paragraph is about.

I want to make it clear that the paragraph has no implications whatever in relation to local elections. There is no provision for free postage at local elections and the paragraph, therefore, has no application to those elections.

Having studied the paragraph very closely I can see that there could be a degree of ambiguity. I am not sure, for example, that it covers adequately the position in relation to party candidates who, for the purpose of the free postage facilities, are treated as a single candidate. It would be desirable, too, that for clarification purposes the paragraph should spell out that no new right to free postage is conferred. I will have the wording further examined before Report Stage.

I ask that the amendment not be pressed and I will have an appropriate amendment drafted for Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Minister said he will come back on Report Stage and in the meantime, I will study what he said. The Minister has been most helpful. I want to establish what the difference would be between the situation under this Bill as opposed to the situation under the last Act. If I read over the Minister's words of wisdom, I think I will be able to establish that. We will have an opportunity to come back to it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 158:

In page 88, subsection (2), between lines 9 and 10, to insert a new paragraph as follows:

"(h) a vote shall not be invalid by reason of a lack of first preference or subsequent preferences if in the opinion of the returning officer it clearly indicates the order of preference expressed by the elector".

This amendment has been designed to deal with the type of problems which arose in the European Dáil elections in 1989. In those elections, supporters of some parties voted, let us say, in the Dáil election 1, 2, 3 for the candidates of their party and then they went on to vote 4, 5 and 6 for the candidates of their party in the European election or vice versa. That was evident to all who had been present at the counts of both those elections. I am easy as to the overall impact of this because it tends to cancel itself out when spread across the different parties. However, I am anxious that the Minister would allow votes to be valid in as far as possible given that a preference is indicated on the ballot paper and it is for that reason we have put down this amendment.

We also put down this amendment because returning officers made different rulings on this matter in the 1989 European elections. In the Leinster electoral area, as far as I recall, ballot papers which were marked with the fourth, fifth and sixth preferences for the European elections were excluded, whereas in the Dublin constituency ballot papers marked in that manner were included and counted. It did not have any great impact on the outcome of the election and there is some evidence to support that in relation to the case which was taken by my colleague, Deputy Bell, in the other House. Mr. Justice Hamilton, when deciding on that case went through some of the ballot papers to see if that factor was an important determinant in whether the seat would have gone to Mr. Fitzsimmons or Mr. Bell. Apparently, from Mr. Justice Hamilton's analysis of the ballot papers it was not a factor that would have changed anything very important, However, I would like to see this matter clarified and standardised. We have tabled this amendment basically on those grounds.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 158 proposes to insert a paragraph in this section to provide that when two or more polls are taken together, a ballot paper in respect of either poll shall not be invalid if the preferences indicated on it do not include a first preference or subsequent preferences. The effect of this amendment would be that the ballot paper on which an elector marked, say, 5, 6, 7, 8 and so on, would be accepted as valid, with the lowest preference being regarded as the electors first preference on that paper.

I have a certain sympathy with the objective of this amendment. It is designed to cover a situation where a voter marks one ballot paper in the normal way, and then continues the order of preferences on the second ballot paper.

This matter can arise in the case of polls taken on the same day. Under the electoral law, it is a matter for the returning officer to decide what the voter's instructions are on the ballot paper. I understand that where this matter has arisen in the past the practice among returning officers in dealing with such ballot papers has varied.

There is a fundamental conceptual problem in dealing with this matter by legislation. I do not see how the law can say, in effect, that in certain circumstances the figure 5 shall be deemed to be the figure 1. If a returning officer finds a paper marked 5, 6, 7, he has no way of knowing that there is a corresponding paper marked by the same elector bearing the marking 1, 2, 3. And I do not think that the returning officer is entitled to make any assumption on this.

Let us look at an extreme possibility. In a particular situation where two polls are held together there are, say, five candidates on one of the ballot papers. The figure 5 is placed opposite the name of one candidate on the paper and all the other spaces are left blank. Under the approach recommended in the amendment this mark would be regarded as a first preference vote for that candidate. With at least equal logic, one could take the view that the elector is signalling that he does not want this particular candidate at any price. He has no particular choice as between the other candidates but he is quite certain that this particular candidate would be his very last choice.

I suggest that this is not a matter that can be legislated for. It is a matter for education and information in which we can all play a part. In the meantime, the decision should be left, as at present, to the returning officer whose job it is to interpret markings on ballot papers. Clearly, it would be desirable to have regard to the views of the returning officers on this matter and, as I have indicated returning officers have divided opinions on it.

I am quite prepared to have it further examined in consultation with returning officers to see if there can be a consensus among them in relation to the type of marking that could be accepted. My gut feeling remains that it cannot and should not be legislated on.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister in terms of the need for information. Part of the problem in 1989 arose because there was an inadequate level of information. Secondly, and very interestingly, the Minister has come down clearly on one side of this argument. By implication he is saying that one very distinguished returning officer with perhaps 30 or 40 years of experience, got it all wrong. I sincerely hope that gentleman does not read the proceedings. I am sure he will be quite upset.

Comment on this

I understand the Minister to say that we were to leave it to the returning officer to interpret the matter. However as Senator Upton, the proposer of the amendment said, it is not evident it had a significant impact. I agree with the Minister that we should leave it to the wisdom of the returning officers. It varied from constituency to constituency depending, for example, on the number of candidates on each paper. Different circumstances prevailed in that case, and I do not think one could say because one returning officer gave one interpretation and another returning officer gave another, that one was right and one was wrong. It would depend on many factors.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 160:

In page 96, line 9, after "Parliament." to add "These proposals shall ensure that the ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population of each constituency, as ascertained in the last preceding census, shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same throughout the country."

This amendment seeks to apply the same standards to European elections in relation to the ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population in each constituency. This principle applies to Dáil elections and I hope the Minister will accept the amendment. I cannot see any reason the principle which has been accepted and guaranteed in the Constitution in relation to Dáil elections should not apply in relation to European elections. It would be unfair to have dis-proportionality between different parts of the country in relation to the capacity to return a member.

Comment on this

Section 174 (a) provides that the Minister shall submit proposals to the Oireachtas for the revision of Euro constituencies before 1 December 1993, and once in every ten years thereafter.

Amendment No. 160 proposes to add a provision to require that the ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population of each constituency, as ascertained in the last preceding census, shall so far as practicable, be the same throughout the country.

It will be noted that the words which the amendment proposes to add are identical with those contained in Article 16 of the Constitution in relation to the revision of Dáil constituencies. However, the similarity ends at that point, because the constitutional and legal situation in relation to the revision of Dáil constituencies is quite different from that obtaining in relation to the constituencies for European Parliament elections.

In accordance with the Constitution, the Oireachtas is required to carry out periodic revisions of Dáil constituencies. In doing so, the Oireachtas is obliged to comply with the relevant provisions of the Constitution, including the provision in relation to equality of representation. If the Oireachtas fails to comply with these provisions, the revision would be unconstitutional and could be struck down by the courts.

There is no constitutional requirement in relation to the European constituencies; the matter is not referred to at all in the Constitution. Neither is there any requirement in this regard in the treaties establishing the European Communities nor in the Community Act relating to direct elections. The formation of Euro constituencies is, therefore, entirely a matter for the Oireachtas to be dealt with in ordinary law. What would be involved in revising the Euro constituencies would be an amendment of the Second Schedule to the European Assembly Elections Act, 1977. Obviously in reviewing the constituencies, the Oireachtas would have regard to equality of representation as well as to the other principles normally applying to the revision of constituencies, but there could be no external requirement on the Oireachtas to have regard to any particular matter.

It is a fundamental principle of parliamentary theory that the Oireachtas cannot bind its successors. Each Oireachtas is free to legislate in whatever way it thinks fit, constrained only by the Constitution, or the provisions of international treaties. To include the provision proposed in the amendment would be futile; the Oireachtas could simply ignore it or repeal it at will.

There is also the point that we are dealing here with a purely temporary situation. The treaties and the relevant Community Act envisage a uniform electoral procedure to apply at Euro elections in all member states. Once a uniform procedure is agreed, the constituencies in this country may have to be changed utterly or disappear altogether. The revision we are talking about now may, in the event, never take place or come into effect or may have effect for one election only.

The proposed amendment would not serve any practical purpose and should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

Section 175 provides for an amendment to section 63 of the Postal and Telecommunications Services Act, 1983. It inserts a new paragraph in section 63 (3) adding to the list of exemptions from the exclusive privilege of An Post, the delivery of documents by a returning officer otherwise than by post, where An Post is not in a position to provide the necessary service.

Amendment No. 161 provides for a consequential technical amendment to section 63 (4) of the 1983 Act to include, in a cross reference in that subsection, a reference to the new provision in subsection (3). The need to amend the cross reference was overlooked when the present Bill was being drafted and this amendment makes good the oversight. It is purely a technical matter.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 162 is out of order as it involves a potential charge on Revenue.

Comment on this

Existing law on Dáil, Presidential and European elections and referenda provides that the returning officer at such elections and referenda may use ballot boxes and other fittings for polling stations provided for local government elections in any electoral area wholly or partly contained in the constituency concerned. These provisions give the returning officer at national elections and referenda the right to use, free of charge, any election equipment which is in the ownership of a local authority.

No reciprocal provision exists in local elections law to enable returning officers at local government elections to use equipment provided for use at national polls. Amendment No. 163 proposes to amend the Local Elections Regulations, 1965 to provide for such a provision.

In practice, as close co-operation exists between both sets of returning officers, it is considered desirable to provide for such a provision as much of the equipment for use at elections is now provided for and held by Dáil returning officers and the same electoral equipment is, by and large, used at all elections. For completeness, however, it is considered desirable that there should be an explicit legal basis in all the codes for this sharing.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 164 has already been discussed with amendment No. 151.

Comment on this

What happened to amendment No. 151, was it agreed?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It was withdrawn.

Comment on this

This amendment is in the name of Senator Ó Foighil.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This amendment has been discussed and may not be discussed again.

Comment on this

Am I allowed to make it in the absence of Senator Ó Foighil?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If you have his prior permission.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 165 and 166 are alternatives and amendments Nos. 167 and 168 are alternatives. All are related and may be discussed together. I call on Senator Pól Ó Foigil to move his amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 166:

In page 102, line 21, to delete "or" and substitute "and".

Is this amendment being taken with amendments Nos. 167 and 168?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 166 is being taken with amendments Nos. 165, 167 and 168.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 166 has been tabled to ensure that the register is as up-to-date as possible and that everybody who is entitled to have their name on the register would have their name on it and be entitled to vote.

Comment on this

Amendment Nos. 166 and 168 proposes to make it obligatory on the registration authority to make a house-to-house inquiry in every case and, in addition, to carry out other sufficient inquiry.

Under existing law, repeated in this rule, the registration authority has the discretion to determine the level of inquiry necessary in order to produce an accurate draft register. Obviously in deciding its approach a registration authority is guided by the circumstances existing in the area in question. A closely knit rural community will warrant a different approach to a rapidly developing urban area. In the case of the former, the field worker will, in many cases, already be familiar with the details of the persons resident in each household. Requiring him to call personally to each house to verify information which he already has would be clearly inappropriate. On the other hand, a rapidly expanding urban area with frequent shifts in population will require a check on each house each year to establish the names of eligible voters.

Making a house to house inquiry mandatory in all circumstances or requiring the registration authority to conduct further inquiries over and above the house to house inquiry would not be warranted. The house to house inquiry is the most thorough method of inquiry used in compiling the register. Putting an onus on a registration authority to go one step further, at a time when its resources are already stretched and where time is of the essence, would not be justified. However, Senators can rest assured that following a house to house inquiry a registration authority carries out any additional checking if they feel that this is necessary based on the information received.

I am satisfied that the rule, as drafted, strikes the correct balance in that it gives the registration authority flexibility in its approach to different conditions within its area. To accept the amendments would unduly tie the hands of the registration authority, would stretch the resources of the registration authority at a time when they are already under pressure, would increase expenditure substantially and would not necessarily lead to any greater accuracy in the register.

I ask the Senator not to press the amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 169:

In page 102, line 46, after "declaration" to insert "or certificate".

This is a minor amendment. The provisions of the Bill provide for the payment of fees where somebody has to make a declaration in relation to various aspects of this Bill. It may also be necessary for somebody to obtain a certificate to satisfy the various agencies in relation to some item which is in dispute, and we are suggesting that provisions should be made for the reimbursement of the cost of the certificate if it is deemed necessary to obtain a certificate.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 169 proposes that fees payable in connection with certificates produced under this article shall also be paid by the registration authority. The certificates involved are a certificate of birth or a certificate of naturalisation.

The provision as drafted repeats existing law. Quite rightly and logically, the provision distinguishes between a certificate and a statutory declaration. Any certificate required to be produced would be inspected and returned and could be used for a variety of purposes other than registration as an elector. A statutory declaration, on the other hand, would be made specifically at the request of the registration authority for purposes related only to the registration of electors. It seems appropriate that the registration authority should meet any fee payable in this particular situation.

A certificate of birth would be called for only where there is doubt as to the precise date on which a person reaches the minimum age for registration. It is reasonable to expect that a person of voting age will already have obtained a birth certificate for some reasons, such as examinations, college admission or employment, and will already have one in his possession. At any rate, the short version of this document would be sufficient for registration purposes and the fee payable would be quite modest. It is envisaged that, following inspection, the birth certificate would be returned and could be used for a variety of other purposes.

In the case of a certificate of naturalisation, we are talking about a person who was not born an Irish citizen and who intimates to the registration authority that he has acquired citizenship through naturalisation. In such a case the person will already have secured the certificate. There is no question of his having to pay a fee to secure such a certificate specially for the registation authority. In case the original certificate of naturalisation is not available for any reason, it is understood that the Department of Justice will, without charge, issue a letter certifying that a certification of naturalisation has been issued and is in force in relation to the person concerned.

In the case of a statutory declaration of the types referred to in this article, a request for the production of such a document by the registration authority will oblige the person to have a declaration made and witnessed, possibly involving the payment of fee. In such a case I feel it is reasonable that the registration authority should pay the cost involved.

In view of the different circumstances pertaining in relation to the two different categories of documents covered by this rule, I hope the Senators will see fit to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 170:

In page 103, between lines 10 and 11 to insert the following new paragraph:

"(7) The registration authority shall not exclude from the draft register a person who is registered on the register in force at the time, without giving prior notice to that person."

I believe there is a 5 per cent turnover in physiological terms in every register, a relatively small proportion. The names of a number of people are excluded from the register for reasons they do not understand. That creates many difficulties and if they were alerted to the fact that their names were being withdrawn from the register, that would be useful because they could protect themselves and ensure that they were entitled to vote.

Comment on this
Joe O'Reilly Mr. O'Reilly Fine Gael

I support the amendment. Having changed residence at one time I had the experience of being removed from the register and not being aware of it until polling day. There should be a system of notification. It is a simple matter and would not involve a major cost on the Exchequer. I support the amendment as a practical step.

Comment on this

We had some criticism this afternoon about amendments being frivolous and in that tone I have certain difficulties with this amendment. I wonder how we are to notify people who are dead.

Comment on this

I thought the graveyard vote was very important in elections in this country.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Some people say they are the easiest votes to get.

Comment on this

That is not what is in dispute; what is in dispute is whether you can connect with those people in a physical sense. The point is a reasonable one. During the referendum I met people who were on the register and did not move house but then found they were not on the current register. I wonder how that can happen. It would seem reasonable to have some procedure to prevent that happening in the future.

We had the curious situation where all but one of the parish clergy in my parish were excluded from the register. I would not begin to speculate how they might have voted in the referendum, but it seems curious that people who are on the register and do not move house find they are not on the current register when they go to vote.

Comment on this

This is a worthwhile amendment. Earlier we had a great deal of discussion about the compilation of the register, etc. Bearing in mind that people must be living to be notified, the amendment is worthwhile and I hope the Minister will consider it. I think the problem arises because people are not aware how the register is compiled. I understand that first there is a draft register. You start with a blank sheet and include only those who are still living at the same address. The general public are understandably of the view that if you have been on the register for 20 years there is no reason you should be left off in the 21st year. They do not understand that once the local authority, whose job it is to compile that register, have gone through the various stages and processes which they are required under law to do, if they cannot locate you at that stage they will take you off the register, although there is usually some latitude allowed. If the amendment could be slightly reworded by the Minister and if what is intended by it were put into operation it would serve a very useful function. I hope the Minister will take it on board.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Hederman. This is a very good amendment. I would like clarification because I know that in Kerry County Council, the authority for the Kerry region, the enumerators are very slow to take anybody off the register. Before the revision court, they compile a list and people are notified if it is proposed to delete their name. Does that satisfy Senator Upton?

Comment on this

This amendment proposes to insert in article 5 of the Second Schedule a new provision requiring a registration authority to notify any person whose name it proposes to exclude from the draft register, that is, any person whose name is included in the current register and not in the draft register. I take the point that in a small number of cases where a name is inadvertently dropped notification along the lines proposed in this amendment would alert them to the fact that they could make a claim for correction to the draft register.

The categories of electors whose names are not included in the draft register are persons who died or moved house or who were not, for some reason, entitled to be registered in the first place. It would obviously be inappropriate and insensitive to address a communication to a person who died recently. In case of persons who have changed address, it would not serve much purpose to write to them at their old address. It is unlikely that their new address would be known to the registration authority.

There is a further consideration that the number of changes that occur in the register in any year, particularly in city areas, is very high. Most of these changes are made following a visit to each household by the enumerator or by the completion of a registration form in respect of the household. Notification to each person whose name is being removed would seem unnecessary in these circumstances. The procedure for making claims for correction in the draft register is in place to enable any person inadvertently excluded from the register to get on the final register.

My Department arrange publicity each year to drawn the public's attention to the need to check the draft register to ensure they are registered. This is in addition to the publicity arranged locally by registration authorities. I feel that the inclusion of this provision in article 5 is unnecessary and undesirable. It would add substantially to the workload of the registration authority at a time when they are already under severe pressure. The additional work would be largely unfruitful and would contribute little to the accuracy of the register. I suggest the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I wonder should the amount of money being spent on advertisements advising people to go to the local post office or Garda station to check the draft register, which amount must be reasonably substantial, be spent on writing to people alerting them of the fact that they are not on the register. For those who have a permanent address they would be alerted, but for those whio have not a permanent address I accept the Minister's point. I really do not think there is anything practical that can be done about it. Given the responses that you meet on the doorsteps and given the number of people who find themselves deleted from the register — people such as those Senator Dardis has alluded to — I wonder if the advertising which goes on at present is of any great use at all?

Comment on this

I support the sentiments expressed in this amendment. It is a system that we have introduced in my county, Roscommon. If somebody is being removed from the register they must be notified and they must be notified 21 clear days before the revision court. I was surprised at the Minister's response. This matter was discussed on Second Stage for quite some time. It is only right and proper that people should not be removed from the register without being notified. I am not talking about sending letters to deceased people. When the people who are checking the register send in their note to have somebody removed they will just put "RIP" in after the name. There is no point in sending a letter in such a case, but a considerable number of people are removed each time the register is done, either by clerical error or for some other reason. All of us have come across people who perhaps have been resident in an area for 50 or 60 years and the next thing is that the whole family, or four or five of them, are removed from the register. We are told it is clerical error, and I accept that, but if this provision was inserted that everybody other than those who are deceased got a notification and if they had gone from the area and did not reply within the 21 days before the revision court, then they were taken off the register automatically. It is an excellent provision. It operates in Kerry and it is operating now in Roscommon.

Comment on this

I want to support the sentiments expressed by Senator Naughten. It would cover the point made by Senator Upton. I will just refer to Kerry. The list is compiled in Kerry and each political party get a copy as well as each Independent member of the local authorities in that county. I say to the Minister that if he could suggest in the form of his advertising that each local authority would take this on board — Senator Naughten has referred to Roscommon and we in Kerry find it most efficient — it would help to reduce substantially the number of errors in the register.

Comment on this

I have just one further point to add to what Senator Foley and Senator Naughten have said. In many ways I would think it is more relevant and more appropriate in Dublin than in Kerry or Roscommon, where people know one another a good deal better, particularly in the flatland areas of Dublin.

Comment on this

It is Senator Upton's amendment, but I think it makes great sense.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister if he would consider the amendment for Report Stage? I do not want to press it or have a vote at this hour of the evening, but I ask him to consider the thinking behind the amendment and see if anything can be done in the context of the resources available.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to make it mandatory on registration authorities to send out letters, but I will convey what is in operation in Roscommon and Kerry to the other registration authorities around the country.

Comment on this

I think it is an eminently sensible proposal. In a time of computerised addressing and so forth it probably is comparatively simple to draw up a computer programme which would automatically convey to people that their names have been removed from the register. It is most frustrating for a person who wants to vote to find that for some clerical error they are off the register and cannot actually vote. The amendment has all party support. The technicalities can be worked out without any great difficulty. I urge the Minister to come back to this on Report Stage with a positive answer.

Comment on this

I would like to say to the Minister that the amendment has this other advantage. Particularly in constituencies in the west from where people have moved to the urban areas of Dublin, Galway, Cork or wherever, if they get a note saying their name is being deleted because they have been gone from that particular address for two or three years, they have the opportunity of being registered elsewhere. It is amazing the number of people who move from rural Ireland to Dublin, Galway, Cork or wherever but who come back home to vote. They have no real interest in getting registered in Dublin. If they get a note 21 days before the revision court saying "Your name is being removed from the register because you are no longer qualified to be registered here", the chances are that they will register elsewhere.

It is an excellent practice, but there is one difficulty with it. For example, if you want to update your register and you remove somebody who has been three years out of the area, unless their names are given to the returning officer 21 days before the revision court they will be on the register for the next year. That is a disadvantage. On balance, however, the amendment is worthwhile. It gives you a real live register and ensures that anybdy who has been removed was removed for a very valid reason.

Comment on this

In fairness to returning officers, they do accept lists later than 21 days.

Comment on this

If we could get the principle accepted we would all be very happy.

Comment on this

I repeat that a statutory obligation by letter is not the line I am pursuing. Under the Bill the supplementary register will come into operation. Just because you sent out a letter does not mean you will resolve all the problems, because in many cases the people who have moved will never receive the letter. Equally, in the case of people who have died, is there much point sending a letter to an individual who is not there? I am not saying that in any offensive way. I accept the sentiment of what the Senators are saying. I believe this is very effective in some areas and I will bring to the notice of the authorities concerned in other parts of the country how efficient they are in Roscommon and Kerry.

Comment on this

I wanted to ask the Minister a question on rule 6 (1) of the Second Schedule concerning those who should receive the draft register. I am intrigued to notice that the draft register must be sent to various people: to the Minister, the county registrar and each postmaster; for a European Parliament constituency it must be sent to each representative in the European Parliament for that constituency; for a Dáil constituency, to each Member of the Dáil for that constituency and each Member of the Seanad residing in that constituency. I am intrigued why a Member of the Seanad residing in that constituency should get a copy of the register were it not for the fact that, perhaps, that Seanad Member was interested in the Dáil constituency so that he or she might contest that election next time around. If that is the answer the Minister is going to give me I deplore that, because I do not think it is right they should be facilitated that way.

Why are local authority members who clearly signified their interest in running for either the Seanad or the Dáil, not entitled to receive a copy of the register for the Dáil constituency? Perhaps the Minister could clarify that for me, please?

Comment on this

Councillors get the register for the local area they represent and I think that is fair enough. Senators also perform a function and the registers are of assistance to them. There is no reason other than that they represent a particular area in a city or county and they get the registers for those areas.

I would like to refer briefly to the table set out in rule 1 of the Second Schedule specifying dates for the various stages in preparing the register. The Seanad will recall that, in relation to section 18, Senator Naughten moved amendment No. 30, which proposed that there should be a supplement to the special voters list to accommodate persons who apply for inclusion in the list during the lifetime of the register. The amendment was proposed on the grounds that a supplement to the special voters list was not an appropriate vehicle for this purpose. I think that, the Senator's basic point was a sound one and that more time should be allowed for disabled persons to get on the special voters list. I would therefore suggest that on Report Stage the House might consider extending the period allowed for this purpose by about two months. This could be done by changing the date specified at item 4 of the table from 30 September to, perhaps, a date towards the end of November. I propose to have an amendment to this effect put down.

Comment on this

May I come back on this point? I understand the Minister's supporting argument is that, in relation to the draft register, these other members will be able to assist in the compilation of the register and making sure it is as up to date and as accurate as possible. Is there any reason TDs, Senators or members of local authorities would not be able to make sure that the European Parliament constituency is tickety boo and the same in the case of a Dáil constituency.

Comment on this

On a point of order, a Chathaoirligh, a word was used there that I am not sure is in any of the dictionaries I know. Perhaps the Senator would explain that word.

Comment on this

Everyone here knows it means neat and tidy. It is self-descriptive — all the knots are tied, the "t"s are crossed, the "i"s dotted, etc.

As a member of a local authority I would be in a very good position, being close to the ground, to ensure the accuracy of the register. Members of local authorities boast that they are nearest the ground, and surely they would be able to assist, if that is what the Minister wants, in ensuring that the register for the Dáil constituency is in order and so on. If that is the Minister's reason, I must urge him at all costs to make available to the members of the local authority the register for the Dáil constituency, etc; I need not repeat the various levels.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister adopting the principle of the amendment I put down. It will undoubtedly contribute to improving the special voters register and I welcome the Minister taking the principle on board.

Comment on this

In response to Senator Hederman, I am at a loss to know why she is pursuing the line that registers should be given to local councillors. My experience is that councillors at local level are interested in their own area, their own patch, and they promote themselves there. Giving them registers for the whole constituency would not be very relevant. I would like to take this opportunity to pay a tribute to Senators. They are leaders of the community and, from time to time, have information to give concerning all their constituencies. For that reason registers are important to them. There is a clear distinction, which I hope I have clarified.

Comment on this

I do not know the way things are in the constituency for which the Minister has been elected on so many occasions, but you can take it either way. The councillor who may be, as the Minister described, only interested in his or her own patch will have an indepth knowledge of that patch and will know if there has been a death or a bereavement or if somebody has gone away and they will be in a unique position to help by passing on that information. There are many councillors who are interested in more than their own patch and they would have a very good knowledge of the whole of their constituency because they might, unlike me, be thinking of running for the Seanad or the Dáil or the European elections and they keep themselves abreast of the general situation in the constituency.

I would ask the Minister, in the interest of being consistent, to either cut out everybody and as in the case of the European Parliament elections to send it only to the representatives of the European Parliament for that constituency. If that is the line the Minister wants to take, may I urge him to do the same for a Dáil constituency: to send it only to the Members of the Dáil constituency, and the same for the local authorities? Alternatively, he could do it the other way around and send the European Parliament constituency draft register to the local councillor, to the European Parliament Member, to the Dáil Member, etc. I do not need to spell it out. The point I am trying to make is fairly clear. Whichever way the Minister does it, if he is consistent I will be very happy.

Comment on this

First, in relation to what Senator Hederman said about local councillors being interested in running for the Dáil, nobody can get registered on the basis that they might be interested some time in the future — in other words, on the basis of an intention — because if that was the way criterion for giving out the registers, you would have to give them to anybody, be they a councillor or not, who had an intention of doing something in the future. That obviously would be ridiculous. I think it is reasonable that you give them to the local councillors for their local constituency and to the Dáil Members for the Dáil constituency.

The only matter that remains to be decided is, as public representatives, as Baill an Oireachthais, what do the Senators get? As Members of Parliament, we have to choose between giving them the register for the constituency in which they reside, as proposed; or the alternative to give University Senators the register of university electors and give the rest of us the register for the whole Twenty-six Counties.

Comment on this

I find myself in agreement with Senators Ó Cuív and Hederman on this point. A little commonsense can sort this out. We are all concerned that the register is as up to date as is possible. In the case of Senators, legally we all represent the entire State; perhaps some of us do — Senator Hederman, Senator Ross, those of us who are in far flung fields and so forth, but the reality is that we all live in constituencies. There is no great difficulty about the register for the particular constituency in which we reside supplied to us, and if we need to get further information we get it.

On the question of councillors, I am in agreement with Senator Hederman. I think councillors play a very important role — we all agree with that — in local democracy and it would not be a huge extension to ensure that, within a Dáil constituency, the councillors are supplied with the register for the entire constituency.

This is a small point and it would be a gesture, from this House especially, on the value we place on the work of councillors.

Comment on this

Is the Minister going to take it on hand?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Thank you, Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 173:

In page 110, line 25 to delete "Where" and substitute "Without prejudice to section 132 (4), where".

This is a drafting amendment. It simply seeks to make clear that this provision is wider than simply being restricted to the Director of Public Prosecutions. I hope the Minister will accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I am accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 174:

In page 114, lines 51 to 55, to delete paragraph 14.

This paragraph puzzles me, because it appears that while an election petition is going on, the vacancy for the Dáil cannot be filled, even if the subject of the petition has died or has resigned. I am at a loss to know what useful purpose is served by keeping the vacancy open, particularly where the Dáil Member would have died.

Comment on this

I would like to remind the House that section 132 (7) provides that if a petition questioning a Dáil election is not dismissed by the High Court, the court shall, in determining the matter at issue, include in its order a declaration of the correct result of the election. If it is unable to ascertain the correct result, the court shall declare that the election or a specified part of it was void. The court may rule that a candidate declared elected at the original election was not in fact duly elected. It may include a ruling that one of the unsuccessful candidates should have been declared elected in this person's place.

Thus if a person whose election is questioned dies or resigns while the petition is pending or proceeding, he may leave no consequential vacancy in the Dáil. Having tried the petition, the High Court may decide that the person concerned was not validly elected and that the seat should have been awarded to another named candidate. The latter candidate would be entitled to assume the Dáil seat on foot of the court's decision. In these circumstances the holding of a by-election would be inappropriate. Rule 14, which provides for this situation, should therefore be retained.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 175:

In page 116, line 15, to delete "may" and substitute "shall".

This amendment seeks to ensure that this section is in accord with standard practice. There is a pecking order in relation to the courts. When something is being considered by a higher court, as I understant it, the lower court simply adjourns it and desists from further consideration of the matter. This amendment would simply be in accord with that standard procedure.

Comment on this

The objective of the rule as drafted is to give the High Court the discretion whether all or part of the trial of the petition can proceed while the Supreme Court is considering the point of law raised. At this stage we simply cannot speculate on the nature of any point of law which may be raised in the course of any future election petition.

The point raised may be central to the whole issue and thus require the suspension of all action on the trial of the petition until the point of law is determined; or it may be relatively peripheral in nature, which would allow the trial to proceed up to but not including the High Court decision. While action on the trial generally may be suspended, the court may consider it appropriate to take or continue with the taking of the evidence of a particular witness or witnesses. There are decisions proper to be taken by the High Court in the light of the particular circumstances existing.

It would be wrong and foolish of the legislation to tie the hands of the High Court in the manner proposed in the amendment. The only limitation that should be laid down is the one proposed in the Bill, namely, that the High Court must not determine the petition until the Supreme Court has ruled on the question of law referred to it. I suggest the amendment be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 176:

In page 119, to delete lines 16 to 29 and substitute the following:

Marcáil ord do rogha sna spáis seo thíos.

Mark order of preference in spaces below.

DOYLE — LIBERAL SOCIALISTS

(MARY DOYLE, of 10 High Street, Knockmore, Builder.)

LYNCH — URBAN PARTY

(JANE ELLEN LYNCH, of 12 Main Street, Ardstown, Grocer.)

NI BHRIAIN — CUMANN NA SAORÁNACH

(BLANAID NI BHRIAIN, as 10 An tStráid Ard, Carn Mór, Oide Scoile.)

O'BRIEN — NON PARTY

(ORLA O'BRIEN, of 22 Wellclose Place, Knockbeg, Barrister.)

O'BRIEN — YOUNG IRELAND

(ORLA O'BRIEN, of 103 Eaton Brae, Cahermore, Solicitor.)

O'CONNOR — NATIONAL LEAGUE

(DARINA O'CONNOR, of 7 Green Street, Carnmore, Engineer.)

THOMPSON — RURAL PARTY

(WILLIAM H. THOMPSON, of Dereen Park, Ballyglass, Farmer.)

TREORACHA | INSTRUCTIONS

I. Scriobh an figiúr 1 le hais ainm an chéad iarrthóra is rogha leat, an figiúr 2 le hais do dhara rogha (más ann), agus mar sin de. | I. Write 1 beside the name of the candidate of your first choice, 2 beside your second choice (if any), and so on.

II. Fill an páipéar ionas nach bhfeicfear do vóta. Taispeáin cúl an pháipéir don oifigeach ceannais, agus cuir sa bhosca ballóide é. | II. Fold the paper to conceal your vote. Show the back of the paper to the presiding officer and put it in the ballot box.

III. Déan deimhin de go bhfuil an marc oifigiúl stampáilte ar do pháipéar. | III. Check that your paper is stamped with the official mark.

IV. Má mhilleann tú do pháipéar de thaisme, tig leat a iarraidh ar an oifigeach ceannais ceann úr a eisiúint duit. | IV. If you inadvertently spoil your paper you may request the presiding officer to issue a fresh one.

(Back of Paper)

Election for Constituency of..............................................................................................

(Back of counterfoil)

Counterfoil No.................................................................................................................

There are a number of items in the changes which we have proposed here. First, we are suggesting that two further instructions be issued: instruction III, which advises people who are voting to check that their paper is stamped with the official mark, and instruction IV which advises them that if they inadvertently spoil their ballot paper they may request the presiding officer to issue a fresh one. Those are sensible suggestions and I cannot see them creating any difficulty. I hope therefore that the Minister would agree to their inclusion on the paper. I wonder how much of this material is read when people go in to cast their votes on election day. Nevertheless, I think it should be there as a precaution; anyone who is in any doubt may resort to reading it.

The second item of change is that we have deleted the number which is to be included on the back of the paper and which will identify the ballot paper. I will not go through all the arguments we had about the possibility that people's ballot papers could be identified arising from somebody noting or remembering the number, or a personating agent passing that information on, or a personating agent turning up at the count and being able to see the ballot paper.

The third item of difference relates to the names of the candidates. I suppose you could ask, what is in a name, but in the specimen ballot paper here of the eight names given seven are men's names. There is just one woman's name on the paper. Maybe this is a reflection of the way things are. That might be the rationale behind it. In the example we have given we have divided it four all.

I have just noticed a number of other anomalies not only in our amended list but also in the list prepared by the Minister. As I look down through the list of occupations of the various candidates, I am shocked and amazed not to find the occupation of publican listed for any of the candidates. That is totally out of accord with the present realities. They are one of the most important elements in Dál Éireann at least in terms of their numbers. They are on both sides of the House here and in large numbers in the other House.

Comment on this

What about teachers?

Comment on this

I was about to come to teachers.

Comment on this

What about lecturers?

Comment on this

There is an Oide Scoile. Just one of the eight candidates is described as Oide Scoile. That is out of proportion also. The business of lecturing is not at all confined to lecturers. Senator Mooney has excellent potential as a lecturer given the way he is breaking in on the debate here.

Comment on this

He prefers a captive audience on a Sunday that cannot answer back.

Comment on this

I think it would be appropriate to change the names to achieve a balance between males and females. The additional instructions would be of some use to the element of the population that would read them and it is worth putting them in for that reason.

We are concerned about the number on the ballot paper but I will not go through the arguments which I have made already. Some of the other points, I must confess, I have made in a lighter vein. If we are to be in accord with what usually happens then, certainly, the publican element would like to be represented on the draft ballot paper.

Comment on this

I feel very strongly about elements of this proposed draft ballot paper. I am not going to refer to the points made by Senator Upton other than to say that if he wants this ballot paper to reflect what happens, what might happen or what should happen in an election, he is quite right to bring in these amendments.

I have a much stronger objection to the ballot paper as is seen here in that nowhere does it leave a blank space after the name. After each name reads Liberal Socialist, Urban Party, Cumann na Saoránach, Young Ireland, National League or Rural Party. The Minister knows how strongly I feel about the fact that one should be allowed to be called Independent. I do not know whether the Cathaoirleach will allow me any latitude to go back over some of the excellent points which were made in that regard.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We have had a long discussion and we do not want repetition on that matter.

Comment on this

In that case I will confine my remarks to noting that nowhere on this draft ballot paper is there a gap after the name. The Minister is proposing here, apparently, that everybody will have some party definition after their name or the term Non-Party. I take great exception to that. More and more Independents will be running in the future. I am quite sure about that. They are going to have to describe themselves as Non-Party if they want to have any description. I know the Minister is prepared to allow them to be nothing or a negative quantity——

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Senator is moving away from the Schedule now.

Comment on this

What I am worried about is that according to Senator Upton's contribution, it appears as though this ballot paper is to reflect what is likely to happen or what might happen. In that context my point is a reasonable one.

Senator Upton also mentioned the occupation listed. I do not think we should put around as an example of the ideal that we should have — farmer, engineer, solicitor, barrister, grocer, builder, Oide Scoile or whatever it may be. What about putting in students, unemployed, community worker, porter or nurse? The occupations listed are all fairly upmarket. Builders are well known to make plenty of money and grocers are usually a prosperous group of people. That is a very unhealthy selection of occupations and I would like it to be changed.

I support Senator Upton's proposal that there should be instructions to voters to check that their papers are stamped with the official mark and if they have spoiled their ballot papers they may request the presiding officer to issue a new one. Of course, I need hardly say I wholeheartedly support the suggestion that the list should contain four females and four males.

Comment on this

On the Schedule, I notice that a name in Irish such as Ó Briain is under "O" rather than under "B". There was a court case which I took and it was agreed that they should be listed under the surname proper and in that case it would be under "B". The surname in the Irish language is variable according to marital status, etc. As this is only a sample ballot paper, does it have any legal effect on that court case?

Comment on this

In response to Senator Ó Cuív, that would be a matter for the returning officer.

The Fourth Schedule specifies various forms to be used in connection with a Dáil election including the form of ballot paper. Part II contains the specified form of ballot paper. It is, in effect, a specimen paper designed to assist returning officers in drawing up a ballot paper in pursuance of the directions contained in section 88. The specimen paper contains a number of fictitious names and addresses, refers to certain fictional political parties and sets out the instructions for voting as they would appear on a genuine ballot paper. The specimen paper is intended as an illustration for returning officers on how the directions in section 88 should be implemented.

Amendment No. 176 proposes to substitute a revised form of ballot paper for that set out in the Fourth Schedule. The only change of substance in the form proposed in the amendment is that there is an increase in the number of female names among the fictious candidates. I would like to explain that the form of ballot paper provided for in the Fourth Schedule is a restatement of the basic form prescribed in the Electoral Act, 1963.

I take the point that the form of ballot paper as drafted does not represent an even spread of candidates of both sexes. If the Senators are prepared to withdraw the amendment, I will consider the matter for Report Stage. In this context I would think a form of ballot paper with an equal number of candidates of each sex might strike the correct balance.

I also propose to act on Senator Hederman's suggestion that the sample ballot paper should include an example in which a non-aligned candidate chooses to leave the relevant space blank rather than use the expression "Non-Party".

Comment on this

I thank the Minister. I realise we are running out of time. May I ask the Minister when he is considering the matter if he would consider, also, the occupation of the candidates?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I would like to mention the need for a technical amendment of the long Title, the reference in line 10, page 11, to the collective citation of the Referendum Acts requires to be changed to take account of the enactment of the Referendum (Amendment) Act, 1992. For the same reason, an amendment will be necessary to section 1 (4) which provides for the collective citation of the Referendum Acts. I propose to have appropriate amendments to the long Title and the subsection drafted for Report Stage to take account of the new collective citation of these Acts.

Comment on this

I would like to thank the Minister for his courtesy and consideration over 11 days and also for his perseverence and that of his staff here. I would also like to thank the Senators on both sides of the House——

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We have not concluded yet. We still have another session.

Comment on this

While it is not normal at this stage——

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am sure it is not the normal procedure; we would prefer to express our thanks on Thursday.

Comment on this

I would like to endorse the sentiments expressed by Senator Fitzgerald. The Minister has been very helpful and I sincerely hope that on Report Stage, he will take on board the points made by the Members here on. The Minister agreed to review certain areas.

Comment on this

I think it appropriate at this stage to thank the Minister for his diligence. He has stayed in the House for an extended period and attended to this legislation at this stage of its passage through the House. It also would be appropriate to congratulate Senator Upton on his diligence as well.

Comment on this

I would like to thank the Minister for his courtesy and fore-bearance during the debate here. He remained courteous and pleasant and that is to his credit. I must say I appreciate it. I would also like to congratulate him on his stamina.

Comment on this

May I be associated with those remarks. I would like to thank the Minister for his patience and courtesy at all times and for his commitment and determination to stick with those parts of the Act which he felt were right. Obviously, on the next Stage we hope we will have agreement on some of the changes that have to be made.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Will the Acting Leader say when it is proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

It is proposed to sit at 10.30 a.m. tomorrow.

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I understand the Acting Leader has some comment to make regarding the Adjournment.

Comment on this

Will the House agree to take the Adjournment Matter now as the Senator involved is here and the Minister for the Environment is standing by also?

Comment on this
Seán Doherty An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is the House agreed on that? Agreed.

Comment on this