We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Universities Bill, 1996: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–224 of 440. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Universities Bill 1996
Enacted

No. 44 of 1996 ›

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 36 and 37 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is there a mover for amendment No. 36?

Comment on this

I think I have Senator Lee's authority to move it on his behalf. I move amendment No. 36:

In page 13, subsection (2)(d)(ii), line 14, to delete "or" where it secondly occurs and substitute "and".

This would change "not less than three or more than five permanent or full-time members of the other academic staff" to "not less than three or more than five permanent and full-time members of the academic staff". I move the amendment so that we can hear the Minister's response and to allow Senator Lee to resubmit if he so wishes on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Niamh Bhreathnach Minister for Education (Ms Bhreathnach) Labour Party

In my view such staff who are either full-time or permanent should be represented on the governing authority. This subsection therefore provides that permanent part-time staff and all full-time staff, whether permanent or not, would have a right of representation. Should a job sharing mother with a permanent post as a lecturer or cleaner not have a right to such representation? The effect of these amendments would be that the representatives on the governing body must be both permanent and full-time and I could not agree with that.

Comment on this

I will not argue the toss now but I take the points made. I am still debating these matters so I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:

In page 13, subsection (3), lines 31 to 39, to delete paragraph (a).

Comment on this

I cannot support this amendment. The wider community dimension — including, as the case may be, employer, trade union, agriculture, fisheries or community interests — is, in effect, the social partners in our democracy. It is an important element in the diverse make up of the new governing authorities.

Comment on this

I reserve the right to put down an amendment on Report Stage. There is a misunderstanding which is probably my fault.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 38a, 39, 41, 51a, 54a, 58a, 60a, 60b, 61a and 63a are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38a:

In page 13, subsection (3)(a), line 36, after "organisations" to insert "Irish language and Gaeltacht organisations".

These amendments concern the Irish language. Ba mhaith liom go mbeadh seans an Gaelige a chuthú sa mhéad a bheadh idir láimh le húdaráis na hollscoileanna. Níl anseo ach iarracht chun iad a tharaingt isteach agus seans a thabhairt dóibh chun pháirt a ghlacadh. There is nothing overwhelming about this nor will it cause a huge problem for the Minister. If amendment No. 38a were accepted, the Bill would read:

(a) at least one but not more than four persons, chosen by a committee of the governing authority comprising the chief officer and two other members, from among nominations made by such organisations as are representative of employers, trade unions, agriculture, fisheries, community organisations, Irish language and Gaeltacht organisations, the professions, business and industry as the governing authority considers appropriate, of whom at least one shall be chosen from those nominated by organisations representative of business or industry [.]

There are issues connected with study of the Irish language. As someone who learned Latin through Irish from an English textbook I appreciate the difficulties which can arise. The first part of my third level studies in a college of education was conducted from English textbooks through the medium of Irish. Many support structures need to be put in place to allow third level institutions to give sustenance to Irish.

I am not looking for anything special, only that the position of college students from the Gaeltacht should be ameliorated and that there should be an ethos of understanding their viewpoint. This does not change anything radically, it is merely a recognition. I am careful not to look for additional special arrangements. I often argue with Irish language organisations but in this case it is reasonable to grant them recognition. I am particularly supportive of people from the Gaeltacht. Sílim ar na deacrachtaí ag muintir na Gaeltachtaí atá ag freastal ar gcoláistí tríú leibhéal Ó thaobh théacsanna agus modhanna na múinteoireachta. Their views should be reflected as appropriate. UCG has made a huge effort in terms of Irish — that may be unfair on other colleges but UCG has always been a Gaeltacht-oriented third level institution. If the amendment was accepted, at least it would have to be considered in the course of implementing the other parts of the Bill. The same argument applies to the other amendments. Does the Minister feel open to them or what is her view?

Comment on this

I support Senator O'Toole. I will not hazard breaking into Irish at this hour. Because I am afraid of being woefully ungrammatical, I will not follow the Senator's ambidextrous act. I see no difficulty with this. I am not speaking in Irish but I understood his remarks. He may correct me if I am wrong, but I take it he does not want anything particularly ambitious. He is looking for an opportunity for the Irish language to be provided — there is no element of compunction in the amendment. If we are serious about Irish we should facilitate its growth and development. My colleague wants to facilitate those institutions who wish to pick members of Irish language organisations; it is one among a number of options. It is reasonable to make a nod in this direction so I am happy to support the Senator.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom cuidiú leis an leasú. The amendment does not mean a great deal, it simply mentions these bodies among many others. Bodies such as Bord na Gaelige or Chomhdháil Náisiúnta na Gaelige should be included as well as trade union, agricultural or fisheries organisations.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom tacaíocht a thabhairt do no leasúcháin seo chomh maith.

Comment on this

I realise that some of the amendments are more difficult to accept or more significant than others. I would be pleased if the Minister made a meaningful gesture.

Comment on this

In the discussions here and in the other House I said I thought it would be possible to include Irish language organisations among the wider community interests. I have a difficulty with Senator Dardis's amendment No. 41 because it would require Trinity College to draw at least two members of its governing body from this category, as would amendment No. 61a proposed by Senator O'Toole.

Comment on this

We cannot have that.

Comment on this

We have reached a satisfactory solution, being as relevant and responsive as possible to the needs of that august institution. I would not recommend being prescriptive in this regard. Of course, the college can co-opt such a person. I would prefer not to have to make it a requirement in that case but to be able to facilitate the other proposals for the other institutions. I propose to return on Report Stage to those amendments, except for amendment No. 41 which I recommend should not be accepted.

Comment on this

I am happy to withdraw the amendment on that basis.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:

In page 13, subsection (3) (a), line 39, after "business" to insert "agri-business".

I tabled this amendment for the purpose of seeking clarification. It might appear pedantic but it is not. Does agri-business count as agriculture or business? At least two universities might want to have representatives from agri-business on their governing authorities. It states later in the section that the Minister shall ensure at least two people from the business community are on the body. How is agri-business categorised in that regard?

Comment on this

The term "business" covers the categories to which the Senator referred. It covers employers, agricultural business and industry. The amendment is not necessary.

Comment on this

Section 15(9) states:

...the Minister shall ensure that there at least two members of the governing authority... who are nominated by organisations representative of business or industry or who, in the opinion of the Minister, are representative of business or industry.

Does agri-business come under that category?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:

In page 14, subsection (3) (b), line 2, after "among" to insert "at least four".

This relates to ministerial nominations. The section states "from among persons nominated". I am not adamant about the number "four". However, if the Minister nominates two people they are, in effect, direct ministerial nominations and the governing authority has no choice in the matter. A governing authority cannot have much choice if it has to choose from two people to fill two places on the authority. Is it intended that they would be direct nominees or that the governing authority could choose from a number of names?

Comment on this

It is an unnecessary level of detail to require an education board to put forward four nominees from whom one would be appointed. It should be left to the universities to work out that matter with the relevant boards. I welcome Senator Lee's support for education boards in proposing this amendment but I oppose this level of detail.

Comment on this

Who will appoint those members? Will it be the authority? From which group will they be drawn? Will they already be employees of the university and subject to the authority? Will they be there just at the whim of the president or the governing authority who can dictate to them? Who are they, from where will they come and what is their purpose?

Comment on this

The nomination will be made by the regional education board.

Comment on this

I take the point that this might be an excessive level of detail so I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 45 is related to amendment No. 43 and both may be taken together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:

In page 14, subsection (3) (c), line 6, to delete "shall" and substitute "may".

This is the crux of the Bill and is particularly difficult to accept. If this provision is enacted, it will be the first time Dublin University will have accepted political nominees on its board. Apart from it being something of a culture shock, it is also totally unjustifiable in terms of logic. If the universities want to welcome people from outside onto their boards, as is the case in subsection (3)(a), that is fair enough. However, it is totally unjustifiable to write into legislation that Ministers should have political patronage which would allow them to place their own nominees on the boards of universities.

I understand the point of view that people from outside should be on university boards, in that it is arguable that non-executives are a protection in certain situations for shareholders. Therefore, independent people on university boards may be seen and interpreted — although I do not share this view — as being there as impartial observers to watch the managers and those who have real and particular interests within the university. However, the idea that members should be directly appointed by a Minister is thoroughly objectionable.

The record of political parties of appointments to semi-State boards is nothing short of disgraceful. I find it very difficult to discover any appointments to semi-State boards which do not have political dimensions. They come across my desk on a daily basis in another capacity. The only puzzle I have to solve when appointments to a semi-State board are announced is to which party they have an allegiance. That puzzle can be resolved extremely quickly. It is very sad that the semi-State bodies have been treated in such a way. People are appointed to such boards because of their political leanings and their ability is a secondary consideration. That is not the way I want to see our universities go.

I do not accept assurances from Ministers who say this is not their intention. I have been in this House for longer than most Members and I have heard such assurances from Ministers before, especially when semi-State bodies are being set up. Those assurances undoubtedly ring hollow when the appointments are made.

I have very little doubt that, because of the fuss which has been made about this Bill, when the first ministerial appointments are made that political aspect will not be as prominent as it normally would be on semi-State or other such bodies. However, we are legislating for eternity rather than for a year. We are introducing something which is not justifiable in the context of the history of this State. The political parties have disgraced themselves with their patronage. When they come to power they ruthlessly appoint their own to such boards. I do not accept any assurances that the universities will be treated any differently. Such appointments may be made to reward constituents or for reasons of political patronage. However, there will be a political aspect to these appointments, whether they be one or four; and the fewer the better. No member of the Government could tell the House with a clear conscience that people have been appointed totally on merit, because if true, it would be the greatest coincidence in the history of the world that so many of them have allegiances to political parties.

The amendment seeks to change the word "shall" to "may". It is not extreme, nor doctrinaire. It gives the Minister the power to nominate, but it also gives the boards of the universities the right to reject a nominee. The present wording forces the board to accept a nominee. No amount of argument will convince me that, at some stage, somebody will not be appointed for political purposes.

Amendment No. 45 in the name of Senator Norris states that the provisions of section 15(3)(c) shall not apply in the case of Trinity College. I would prefer that it should not apply in any case and that boards should be free of political influence. If section 15(3)(c) is necessary for the sake of transparency and to ensure that somebody, on behalf of the Minister, can see what is going on, is it not true that transparency will also be satisfied by the fact that the books will be opened and that the provost of Trinity College and the executives in other universities will be subject to examination by the Comptroller and Auditor General? There is no resistance to full accountability and transparency, but there is resistance throughout my constituency to political patronage entering the universities.

There has been extensive argument about the role of county councillors. I accept there is a point of view here, although I disagree with it. However, given the history of the State, there is no justification for political patronage on the boards of universities.

Comment on this

In one sense I prefer amendment No. 43 in the name Senator Ross because it is simpler and clearer and it extends to all the universities. However, Trinity College is in an unusual situation. The constituent colleges of the National University of Ireland have traditionally had outside intervention of this kind. They may be pleased with the provision because it either stabilises or, in some cases, reduces the number of nominees. However, it would be reasonable for Trinity College to be unhappy because it is being introduced there for the first time.

The Minister has indicated that she will not introduce an amendment on Report Stage. The element of coercion is regrettable. Section 15(3)(c) provides that people "shall" be appointed on the nomination of the Minister. It would be much better to replace the word "shall" with the word "may" because it would be in accordance with the principle of academic freedom, about which we have heard so much. It would also grant to the universities the dignity to decide whether they wanted a particular person foisted on them. If a particularly noxious appointment of a political character were made it would cause dissension and create tension on the board which would not foster good relations nor the efficient functioning of the university; it would inevitably waste time.

I am not flattered when I am occasionally asked to serve on committees because of the need to have a Member of the Oireachtas or whatever — I know I am being added to give extra weight. However, if I am asked because I know something about the subject I am far more inclined to become fully involved. I favour the 0 — 4 principle, in other words there could be none or up to a maximum of four, and treating universities in an adult like manner by giving them the final say.

Senator Ross has indicated that he wishes to extend this new liberation to the other universities, but I am not sure I wish to interfere where they have become used to this and are prepared to live with it. If it were such a good idea presumably they would have petitioned to increase the number of nominees. However, they are happy with a reduction.

Section 15(3)(c) represents an unnecessary interference. It also contains an element of coercion and a danger that it will not increase the efficiency of the universities, indeed, the reverse is possible. The same situation can be arrived at if the Minister is prepared to change the word "shall" to "may". It would be unusual for a university board or authority to dismiss in a cavalier manner the Minister's wish. However, it should be left to them to decide on the suitability or otherwise of nominees. People who have been involved in an institution for 30 or 40 years and have worked their way up through it are more likely to know who is the best nominee.

While I do not envisage a large number of cases of conflict, I can envisage some. Perhaps the two amendments could be combined on Report Stage and that the substitution of the word "may" for "shall" would apply in the case of Trinity College. However, the Minister has indicated that she will not accept that proposal either.

If Senator Ross presses his amendment I will support him, although I would prefer to confine my intentions to Trinity College because the other universities may, perhaps, have a different view. That is why I suggest that the provisions of section 15(3)(c) shall not apply to Trinity College.

I had considerable assistance in the drafting of some of these amendments from members of the staff of the House. I express my gratitude to them because they often assist us with amendments, suggesting how they may framed in the absence of the kind of professional draftsperson's assistance one would expect in a modern Parliament. I am grateful for their good advice and their willingness to help, sometimes at short notice.

Comment on this

The Minister for Education is responsible for this legislation which is regarded as progressive and important. It is arrogant of two Senators from Trinity College to come into the House and tell the Minister that any person appointed to the board on the advice of a Minister would be done for political patronage.

Comment on this

It would be a good idea if the Senator got his facts right. I am being misquoted.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Sherlock without interruption.

Comment on this

I will not tolerate that from these gentlemen. There are three representatives in the House from Trinity College dictating to us because the State provides the bulk of the finance for that establishment. Recently important legislation was passed in the House and none of the Trinity College representatives was in attendance.

Comment on this

Are there rules governing the House? First, the Senator is allowed to tell falsehoods about Members and now he is allowed to draw attention to their absence which is contrary to the Standing Orders of the House. Will the Chair give me protection? I have my own gavel here.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Sherlock without interruption. He should, however, not name anybody outside the House.

Comment on this

He should not talk nonsense either, but that is not stopping him.

Comment on this

I did not name anybody. I object to the perception that a person appointed to a board would have been so appointed for political patronage. That remark is atrocious.

Comment on this

Senator Norris did not say that; I did and I stand by it.

Comment on this

The proposed amendment is distasteful. It suggests that Ministers tend to act in a substandard fashion.

Comment on this

Never.

Comment on this

For example, the implication is that the Minister will try and find total misfits and appoint them to the board, having consulted the chief officer. Politics has taken a thrashing for the past number of years and we are making no attempt to redress that. I know members of boards who were appointed by Governments of which they were not supporters. They were appointed because of their ability. The fact that people are members of a political party should not mean that they should be looked on as substandard beings. Many important and good people are members of political parties at some stage. It has been said here that because they are members they cannot show their faces; they have to hide. They cannot be seen in certain places or appointed to certain positions by Ministers. We have to catch onto ourselves because that is an insult to many people, especially to Ministers. Section 15(3) states there will be consultation. In this sophisticated age we are listening to some very unsophisticated comments from the other side of the House. We have a sophisticated people who make their own judgements on the actions of Ministers. The contributions of speakers on the other side of the House should be examined in context.

Comment on this

We come from a university.

Comment on this

A number of them oppose the Bill in its entirety. The theme of their contributions is that the Minister is putting her dirty hands into the business of universities. They should examine their consciences and withdraw the amendments. We should work together to make the political system more acceptable and should not undermine ourselves from the inside. We have enough to do to try and convince people that politics is a good healthy game. We have enough problems to deal with rather than trying to soil everybody by tabling an amendment of that nature.

Comment on this

I concur with Senator Cotter. Denigrating the position of the public representative, a democratically elected person of the people, is wrong. Members of this House are representative of public representatives. It behoves us to speak on this Bill in a positive fashion. It may be different for half a dozen Senators who represent a different type of body. I have been honoured to represent public representatives for the past 15 years and am not in favour of this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not support the amendments. Their effect would be that the Minister may not even have a single nominee on the governing authority of any or all institutions. The Bill is fully supported and has been accepted by all institutions.

Comment on this

I am not surprised at being attacked for arrogance. However, I thought I made a reasonable case. I did not refer to political patronage; Senator Sherlock misheard me. If he felt I was arrogant, he must be starting from a spectacularly low position on the intellectual scale to feel he was being patronised by me, but I can attempt to if he wishes to provoke me into doing so.

Last night I attended a public meeting on adoption in Dublin. Politicians from all parties were present to defend vigorously the honourable profession of politics against onslaughts from a section of society which was looking for changes. The people involved had very strong feelings, but when one person made a glancing attack on politicians, the entire hall erupted in applause. I told them they were foolish to take this easy, cheap shot at politicians. I have witnessed from the inside how honourable and decent the vast majority of people are.

My colleagues are being morbidly oversensitive and have misinterpreted my position. Senator Cotter gave the impression that everybody believed that Ministers and other politicians were the most saintly people on earth. Most of them are decent, good people who work for little in adverse circumstances but if he believes his view is generally held by the people he has a rude shock awaiting him on the doorsteps in the forthcoming election. They certainly do not. The shenanigans that have gone on in all political parties over the past few years would not lead anybody to the conclusion that this was the case.

Comment on this

The Senator is trying to justify his amendment.

Comment on this

Of course, I am.

Comment on this

The Senator does so by denigrating us.

Comment on this

I would like to try and reach the level of sophisticated debate referred to by Senators Cotter and Sherlock. Senator Sherlock spoke of this point being too sophisticated for my little mind to grasp. I will have to remain at a simple level because I am not capable of scaling the heights occupied by the Senators.

Comment on this

We appreciate that.

Comment on this

We are talking about interference from outside in an area where it has traditionally occurred. It may well be tolerable or acceptable but we are introducing a new element. There is a naked, self-serving self-interest in what Senators are saying to their electorate. We know they are elected by county councillors and are making election speeches about how wonderful they are.

Comment on this

This is not about county councillors.

Comment on this

Privately, some Members might have a different view of county councillors.

Comment on this

The Senator is getting more and more confused.

Comment on this

The wonderful verbiage being produced can be put in election materials.

Comment on this

Senator Norris is also elected by a constituency.

Comment on this

Some county councillors may be fooled but I am not fooled. It is classic self-serving behaviour and goes across all parties.

Comment on this

This has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

Senator Norris is elected by an elitist constituency.

Comment on this

So is Senator Cassidy. Country and western music lovers are a minority.

Comment on this

They are 40 per cent of Fianna Fáil and 0.1 per cent of the Trinity electorate.

Comment on this

It is going to be a long evening and we should have some fun, but I am not going to delay this Bill ad nauseam. However, some Senators are posturing for their electorate and accusing Independent Senators for making reasoned speeches——

Comment on this

Read my lips.

Comment on this

I would if they were in the back of the Senator's head, but that is impossible even given his unusual configuration.

Comment on this

What constituency is Senator Norris after?

Comment on this

I am after 32,000 University of Dublin voters that I have succeeded in persuading before.

Comment on this

That is less than a parish.

Comment on this

I was at another meeting this evening where the Seanad was discussed. Approximately 30 years ago, the Irish Auctioneers and Valuers' Association were having their diamond jubilee and nominated their president. He did not get a single vote, as happened to the President of the Royal Irish Academy: that is a nominating body for the Seanad. I seek an opinion here from Senator Cassidy, who must have been designed by Picasso.

Comment on this

Was Senator Norris's vote being canvassed?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order, please. We are not discussing Seanad elections but the Universities Bill.

Comment on this

The plain people of Ireland can speak as well as the Trinity College intellectual.

Comment on this

Sometimes even better.

Comment on this

It would be a magnificent Minister for Education who would nominate a person who would have such a dramatic effect on the affairs of our universities as to disrupt their governance so much. If the Minister could find that person, he or she would have to be very powerful and wasted on the universities.

Comment on this

Ben Dunne.

Comment on this

The Minister did not reply to the points made but said that she might have one or no nominee, which is precisely the point. The Minister did not justify why the nominees need to be there. We are entitled to know why the Minister needs between one and four nominees on the board of a university. The Minister may giggle, but it is an important point.

Comment on this

She is not giggling. She is being told.

Comment on this

She is being told to giggle. Why should the Minister have a nominee on the board of Dublin University for the first time? Is there a particular reason why Dublin University deserves this surveillance?

I am a politician. I know of and have seen the power and temptation of patronage. When politicians are allowed the power of patronage, they abuse it. The Labour Party has abused patronage in this Government to a savage and unforgivable extent. That is the problem.

Comment on this

Senator Ross should quantify that accusation.

Comment on this

The appointments on the formation of the Government in 1992 were disgraceful and well documented.

Two Ministerial appointments were recently made in Senator Sherlock's constituency to the board of Bord Gáis. I will not name them, but one is the Lord Mayor of Cork, an ex-Fine Gael Deputy, and the other was a financial secretary of the Labour Party. I am sure that a detailed study was done of these people's interest in and knowledge of gas and business and that interviews were held by Bord Gáis and the Minister. Let us not be ridiculous about this; these were blatant political appointments. That is what happens in Ireland and it is why I want to keep patronage out of as many places as possible. I do not welcome Ministerial power of appointment because it is abused.

I heard Senator Cassidy's point. The only time parties close ranks is on the issue of patronage as all their nest eggs are threatened. They all want the power to put people on the board of a university.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is outrageous. I am sure there is a rational case for that power but I want the Minister to give us the reasons why it is necessary. It is an innovation for at least one university. Maybe it is the usual ritual mention of taxpayers' money, but we are entitled to a reply.

Comment on this

I take issue with Senator Ross saying that when county councillors are put on boards of universities they abuse their power.

Comment on this

I did not mention county councillors.

Comment on this

Senator Ross mentioned it in relation to Senator Cassidy's contribution, saying they should not be put on boards because they abuse their power. I object to that and ask the Senator to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I cannot withdraw something I did not say, but I understand the affection of Members for county councillors. I understand Senator Ormonde's outrage and it will be good for her in her constituency when it is time for her re-election.

Comment on this

If someone puts a lot of money into a company they generally have someone nominated to the board or they themselves take a position on that board. This is somewhat similar. The Government is putting a huge amount of money into the university system and I see nothing wrong with the same procedure being applied to allow the Minister to appoint a person or persons to the board.

Comment on this

The analogy is totally incorrect because people go onto boards with the consent of that board.

Comment on this

Today, universities play a very central role in the economic and intellectual development of the country. It is therefore quite reasonable that a Minister would appoint at least one person to the institutions we are now discussing. Those institutions appear to have an erroneous impression that what the State gives in the back door is not to be recognised in the front parlour.

Perhaps it is not for me to enter the debate on attacks on people with party political affiliations. I have appointed people to boards, some because they share my philosophy on the future development of education, and I am more than satisfied that those people have contributed and will continue to contribute to their boards because they are qualified to do so.

Universities are no longer just for the elite. I have opened the gates of university for undergraduates by abolishing the tax relief for covenants. A small sector of society had been able to rip-off that relief to such an extent that, through its abolition, we were able to open the gates for students with ability. Given the importance of that and the intention, aspiration and ambition of people to enjoy university education which was the privilege of an elite, it is reasonable that the centre stage role of universities would be recognised and that the Minister can appoint at least one nominee to represent that public interest on their board.

Comment on this

It is unfortunate that the Minister raised the issue of free education because if she looks at it, she will find that she will have great difficulty demonstrating that it has widened the social range of people entering university. That has simply not happened. I will not let the Minister away with that because it is not true.

Comment on this

The Senator is out of touch.

Comment on this

Vótáil.

Comment on this

The question is: "That the word proposed to be deleted stand". On that question a division has been challenged. Will those Senators calling for a division please rise in their places?

Senators O'Toole, Quinn, Norris, Ross and Lee stood.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 40
·
Níl 2
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 44:

In page 14, subsection (3)(c), line 8, after "officer" to insert "the governing authority to be informed of all proposed names".

I cannot match the high drama of the recent past on this amendment. I will be brief because we obviously want to progress. It struck me, however, given the anxieties that surrounded this issue in general that if the names of proposed members of the governing authority in the consultation between presidents and Minister were to come up, it would give an opportunity of reassuring the sceptics about the quality of the candidate to be considered and the quality of the appointment. That is inserted with a view to assisting public education in these matters.

Comment on this

Senator Lee's proposal would require the chief officer to inform the governing authority of all proposed names. I cannot agree with it because there is an implication in the amendment that in some way the chief officer would be concealing information from the governing authority. If the Senator considers that the governing authority should have an input in this regard, I would point out that the chief officer must always act subject to the policies of the governing authority and is answerable to the authority. I refer the Senator to paragraph 4 of the Fourth Schedule. I do not consider this amendment to be necessary.

Comment on this

I certainly was not implying that. I thought it would be very interesting in terms of the way decisions are made to know the names of those who were being considered. I am withdrawing the amendment in the context of what has been said.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:

In page 14, subsection (4), line 11, to delete "may" and substitute "shall".

The governing authorities of universities ought to have members elected by graduates, as is the case in a number of instances at present. There ought to be specific provision for people having particular regard to artistic and cultural interests. The governing authority of any university would definitely be strengthened by the inclusion of those categories. That is why I would prefer to have "shall" rather than "may". If it is deemed that there is not sufficient cultural calibre on a governing authority as it stands, one may have up to four members, but by what criteria does one decide there is not sufficient cultural calibre starting off? If one believes that close relations with graduates is a good thing for universities — and we discussed that briefly under functions — that should be encouraged rather than being left to the different views which various universities might come to. In general terms that is something we should strive to encourage.

Comment on this

The effect would be that not more than four co-optees and not more than four graduates would be on the governing authority. I am not quite clear whether the effect of the amendment would be that there would be at least one of each or, indeed, if this is what the Senator is seeking. I would prefer to leave this section as an option to the universities themselves.

Comment on this

I come in stoutly behind the Minister on this amendment. It is a refreshing experience for me and it may convince the Minister she is wrong. It is probably Senator Lee's best chance of his amendment being accepted. I see no reason for making this compulsory; it is better to leave it to the governing authority. I agree with the Minister and I congratulate her for being so liberal and understanding of the governing authority on this issue. It is a pity she did not extend it to other areas but perhaps she will do so later tonight.

Comment on this

I come in stoutly behind Senator Ross.

Comment on this

I am now completely convinced of the correctness of my original view. I am glad I have enabled my colleagues from Trinity College to display their statesmanship on this issue.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47:

In page 14, subsection (4)(b), line 21, after "Recognised College", to insert "or graduates of any university who are employees of the constituent university".

The principle that employees of the institution who are not graduates of the institution should be excluded from membership of the governing authority has a diminishing effect on the potential of representation. We are trying to increase mobility between institutions to get away from the idea that everyone is rooted in the same institution for life. Large numbers of staff of the new universities will not be graduates of those universities and their potential for participating on the governing authority will be restricted.

I will give an example of the type of thing I have in mind. The professor of music at the University of Limerick is one of the most creative people in Irish culture. The university is developing music as a major area of activity and it has a magnificent concert hall and an orchestra. If one wanted someone on the governing body — I do not want to mention individuals because they may have no interest in participating in the electoral process — who was the most appropriate person to advise in that area, it would seem to be looking a gift horse in the mouth to insist that it could not be that person and that only someone else who qualified on the grounds of having graduated from that particular institution could fulfil the role. Institutions should be allowed use the talent in them, irrespective of where it has come from, to optimise the potential performance of the institution. These restrictions are increasingly out of date in terms of mobility inside and outside Ireland.

Comment on this

I support Senator Lee's amendment. Things will change in the long-term, so this section is quite restrictive. I wonder if the Minister has fully considered this matter. Electors should have the freedom to elect who they wish in the interests of democracy, even if they are graduates of a different university or college. The wording of the amendment may need to be changed, but it was tabled in the interests of democracy so that no one would interfere in the affairs of an individual university.

Comment on this

I also support Senator Lee's amendment. I assume the Minister will sympathise with it because she suggested that an infusion of blood on to the board from outside would be useful. It seems odd to narrow that representation. A large number of appointments may be from outside the university, which can be good, because otherwise it would become a hothouse atmosphere which can be unhelpful and almost incestuous. Disbarring someone because they are graduates of another university, although they are members of staff, creates a second class citizenship among distinguished people. I support Senator Lee in the interests of democracy and of broadening the board.

The Minister mentioned the need to have a broadly based representation on the board, but this section seems to narrow it to people who have grown up through the system within the college. I am sure some people who come from that background will be elected, but to automatically disbar people because they have not graduated from that university is a mistake, particularly since it is now regarded as good academic practice to try to ensure that people travel.

It is not now regarded as good practice to employ young academics, for example, in their own university. Sometimes this acts as a disadvantage. I have known some extremely brilliant and gifted students who should have got jobs in Trinity College because they were unquestionably the most outstanding people in the field. Yet they did not, because Trinity College was nervous about having a reputation for academic nepotism. I can think of at least two of them who went to UCD and did brilliantly there. I would like to think they would have the opportunity to serve their university. It could also be the case that a brilliant student would not be promoted in one of the constituent colleges of the National University of Ireland because it was sensitive to this accusation of a hothouse atmosphere and an intellectual xenophobia. I would like to think they would be entitled to serve on the board and that they would not be disbarred merely because they got their qualification from a sister college.

Perhaps the Minister could explain if this applies to Trinity College. I know they are on a level playing field if they have a corresponding degree from a previously existing constituent college of the National University of Ireland. If someone, who got their degree from one of the previously existing colleges of the NUI is on the staff of Trinity College, would that be regarded as legitimising their position to be elected to the board?

Comment on this

This amendment would have the effect of allowing graduate employees of any university to vote in the election of graduates on the governing authority of the university in which they are employed. They have a vote in the universities in which they are employed. They would have a right to vote for their own representatives under section 2 (d).

Comment on this

It was the candidates Senator Lee was thinking of and not the voters.

Comment on this

They could be a candidate. Senator Lee mentioned a professor of music in a certain university who I presume is a graduate of another university. There are two ways in which that person, who might be eminently suitable to serve on the governing authority of that university, could be appointed to it. One would be as a representative of the staff on the governing body and the other would be under the co-option clause which allows governing bodies to appoint people. That person would then have a graduate vote for the graduate representations in his own university. I have been told that if he has a couple of degrees from different universities he could vote as a graduate for both qualifications.

A particular person who is not a graduate of the University of Limerick could serve on its board as a staff representative having been co-opted by the board under the relevant headings. He or she would retain a voice as a graduate of the university from which he or she graduated. Therefore, people would have more than one vote but they would not have two votes for the same occasion.

Senator Lee was correct to raise the issue of an optional person. The situation I outlined highlights how a person could serve in the university in which they are employed while retaining a graduate voice in the university from which they graduated.

Comment on this

I am not really concerned with people having a graduate voice in the university from which they graduated. As graduates, they retain their right to vote at that institution. I am more concerned with their role in the university from which they did not graduate. The amendment seeks to ensure that they have the same avenues of access to membership of the authority of the university at which they are employed as do graduates of that institution. I am becoming confused about this issue. However, if the Minister is satisfied that her response covers that situation, I accept her judgment. This issue involves a substantive point about the direction institutions should take.

Comment on this

I am slightly confused. Under subsection (4) (b), could a graduate of the NUI be elected to the governing body of Trinity College?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Senator Lee's amendment suggests that a graduate of the NUI should be allowed to be a candidate under this section. The amendment is not concerned with the electorate but with the candidacy. It appears that the Senator has illustrated a valuable point. If a person is a member of staff of a university, they should be allowed to stand for election. If the graduates do not desire this they will put forward sufficient candidates to ensure it does not happen. However, a possible case exists, at least in hypothetical terms, that a distinguished graduate of the NUI who is a member of staff at Trinity College could be disbarred from standing for election.

Comment on this

No, not on this panel.

Comment on this

I believe the amendment suggests that such a person could stand for election on this panel.

Comment on this

We are discussing the graduate panel with which Members would be more familiar than those outside. There is an option for a graduate from another institution to serve on a governing body under section 15 (2) (d), which covers staff representation. A person of such eminence could be co-opted on to the board. This section provides a voice for the graduates of a particular institution in one of the categories that reflect the community of a university.

Comment on this

It is possible that the graduates might wish to nominate a person who is not a graduate of their university. The Minister referred to two methods by which someone could become a member of the authority but she modestly neglected to mention her power of appointment.

Comment on this

I will not press the amendment. I hope the discussion has been of use because of the implications involved.

Comment on this

Is amendment No. 48 being moved?

Comment on this

No, because I understand the Minister intends to return to the matter on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 50, 51, 63 and 65 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 14, between lines 41 and 42, to insert the following subparagraph:

"(iii) one member chosen by the academic staff of St. Patrick's College, Drumcondra, so long as that College has an association by agreement or memorandum of understanding with the University,".

This amendment suggests that there should be representation from St. Patrick's College on the board of Dublin City University as long as it retains an association or memorandum of understanding with the university. I believe that is a fair request.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 50 and 51 propose that the governing authority of Dublin City University should include a member of the academic staff of St. Patrick's College. Similarly, amendment No. 63 proposes that the governing authority of the University of Limerick include a member of the academic staff of Mary Immaculate College. I support the general thrust of the amendments' objectives but I consider that section 15 (6), as amended by Dáil Éireann, addresses the Senator's concerns. There was a lengthy debate on this issue on Committee Stage in the Dáil and the wording "Where an educational institution is associated with a university" is used in section 15 (6) to cover all eventualities. By employing that wording we are not limiting the options in respect of other institutions. The Senator's amendments, which refer to Mary Immaculate College and St. Patrick's College, Drumcondra, will be covered by section 15 (6), which states "Where an educational institution is associated with a university in accordance with an agreement between that institution and the university and that agreement provides that the governing authority of the university shall have as members employees or students of the institution...".

Comment on this

That is satisfactory.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 52, 54, 55, 57, 58, 60 and 62 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

In page 14, subsection (5) (b), lines 43 and 44, to delete subparagraphs (i) and (ii).

I agree with the Chair's ruling, even though I have not yet come to grips with it. I understand that these amendments are related because they deal with an old favourite, namely, membership of a board. I do not know where is Senator Manning but he usually springs up like a jack-in-the-box when reference is made to county councils. However, I have no doubt that he will appear in the near future.

Comment on this

He will be here in a moment.

Comment on this

To whom is the Senator referring?

Comment on this

Senator Manning.

Comment on this

I would prefer that the Senator did not refer to another Member in their absence. I ask him to continue with the debate on amendment No. 52.

Comment on this

I apologise if I am in breach of the rules of the House. Amendment No. 52 returns to our old friend, the Lord Mayor of Cork, to whom we referred a short time ago. The Lord Mayor of Cork was recently appointed to the board of An Bord Gáis and if the section is passed as it stands he will not only be an expert in gas but also in third level education. Coincidentally, every Lord Mayor of Cork will be an expert in those areas. This illustrates to some extent the anomaly and absurdity of appointing a person by virtue of the office they hold, which has nothing to do with the two appointments they automatically received by courtesy of the Government. I will not harp on the Lord Mayor of Cork, who, I am informed, is extraordinarily decent and nice and is well loved.

Comment on this

That is more than one could say about the Lord Mayor of Dublin.

Comment on this

It is more than one could say about the Lord Mayor of Waterford, with whom I am not familiar. It is absurd that people are being appointed to the boards of universities by virtue of the fact that they are lords mayor of various towns. There is no guarantee that these people have the necessary, if any, expertise to serve on such boards.

I do not wish to say anything which might be provocative or lengthen the debate. Therefore, I will not mention county councillors except in passing. This section deals with county councils. It is extraordinary that they have provoked a reaction on sections in respect of which they should not have been discussed. I do not wish to give Members an excuse make speeches to their electorates once again. However, I do not believe that these provisions, to which I have proposed amendments, should be in the Bill. There are plenty of suitable places for county councillors but they should not automatically be on the boards of universities.

I notice that many Senators wish to speak on this matter — they are as predictable as ever. I know the counter argument is that county councillors should not be excluded by virtue of their being county councillors, but that is not a valid argument. I can think of many others who would have a greater claim to be on the boards of universities than those who hold the office of lord mayor of various towns.

Comment on this

I am sorry my colleague Senator Ross personalised the issue in terms of the Lord Mayor of Cork. He is an extraordinarily nice and decent fellow who will not combine An Bord Gáis with the university governing body because lords mayor change on an annual basis. It can be useful to have alternative viewpoints coming on board, so to speak. The present Lord Mayor of Cork is a respected teacher in Cork education circles and would have a perspective to bring to bear on education in general which may be extremely valuable.

I take the point Senator Ross makes that there is no guarantee that the qualities of an office holder at a particular time will be ideally suited to the membership of a governing authority. However, the personalities of many other members may not be ideally suited, whether they are from inside or outside the institution. It is unbalanced to single out lords mayor in this way for special opprobrium. My experience of the lords mayor who have served on the governing body of my college is that they have made a valuable contribution.

Comment on this

I challenge one of Senator Ross's basic assumptions on subsection (5) (b) (i) and (ii) which refers to the Lord Mayor of Cork and the Mayor of Waterford. He said he would object to their presence on the board because they might not have administrative ability and would not be able to operate in an effective manner. I question that assumption because he is implying that academics, because they are academics, have the qualities necessary to be members of the board. That does not follow. To follow Senator Ross's logic there would have to be a testing procedure to find out if the academics have the qualities he feels members of the board should have.

Comment on this

I challenge Senator Ross's assertion that a lord mayor would not have the expertise to qualify as a member of a governing body. Who is to say that is the case? We cannot question their ability. The fact that they are elected representatives is a clear indication that they are capable people. It is presumptuous of Senator Ross to say that those public representatives do not have the necessary expertise. They are elected representatives and that is good enough.

We have tabled amendment No. 57 to increase from five to eight the number of elected members of a local authority elected by the members of the General Council of County Councils who will be on the governing body of UCD and I am glad the Minister has indicated that she agrees with the amendment. I am a member of the General Council of County Councils and we have had fine discussions on this issue. UCD should have a wide representation because of the number of students there and the number of courses it provides. The communities and the universities must interact. We can only achieve that through the elected representatives who know their communities and can bring that knowledge to the governing body.

The Minister should agree to our amendment to reflect a greater membership from the General Council of County Councils.

Comment on this

I remind Senator Ross that our civilisation is based on the fact that people chose to live in cities. Limerick city has had mayors for an unbroken period of 800 years. That represents 800 years of civilised living. To say that the Mayor of Limerick is not fit to represent the people of the city on the board of the University of Limerick or that the chairman of Limerick County Council is not fit to represent the people of the county on the board of the university is an insult to a bastion of our civilisation. Next year we will celebrate 100 years of unbroken, democratic local government.

As in other aspects of his contributions, I find Senator Ross's remarks on this section undemocratic. He is trying to undermine the basis of democracy. We must reject his argument that there should be no elected representatives on the boards of universities. We represent the ordinary people against the elite who Senator Ross seems to represent.

Comment on this

I am an elected county councillor.

Comment on this

There is some confusion. No one is saying that the present Lord Mayor of Cork is unfit. However, to make a person a member of a board automatically by virtue of their office is outrageous. One may not be able to say automatically that a lord mayor is unsuited but the system will inevitably throw up some lords mayor who are pig-ignorant and prejudiced. Senators should be aware that this occurred in the past. Senator Kelly referred to the 800 years of the distinguished city of Limerick——

Comment on this

The Senator should use temperate language in describing lords mayor.

Comment on this

It is that it is mathematically unquestionable that somebody with the qualities I mentioned will be thrown up. If we look back over an 800 year period we should find royalists, Jacobins and people who were strongly against Catholic emancipation who were lords mayor. I could name lords mayor from the 18th century who fought bitterly against Catholic emancipation. These are the people Senator Kelly thinks are so wonderfully enlightened because they were thrown up by our democracy. Who is she fooling?

Almost all Members have a vested interest being county councillors, Senator Ross included. However, I am not. They are praising themselves and that is small praise indeed. I am saying this simply by virtue of the office. I am not personalising this or naming anyone, although I am tempted. I have frequently referred to some of the elected Members in the past on the basis that I remember approaching the so-called cultural committee of Dublin Corporation 15 years ago. If there was ever an oxymoron it was that august body. The office of Lord Mayor is often elected in the most shabby and venal manner, on the basis of party arrangements, tricks and chances and who arranged this, that and the other. We should not elevate this to the level where no one will believe it. If Senator Kelly believes that in the 800 years of the mayoralty of Limerick every single one of them was qualified to be on the board of a university, she should go back to her history books. This is not an attack on the city of Limerick or its mayor.

The principle is that someone should not be placed on a board just by virtue of their political office. We spoke earlier about the penetration of boards by political interests. It is not enough that the Minister has provided for between two to five members of local councils to be represented on a board but some Senators want eight——

Comment on this

We would take ten if we could get it.

Comment on this

——without bothering about their qualifications. Some Senators and their cronies want to fill eight seats. It is disgusting, morally revolting and totally self interested.

Comment on this

I think some of the Senators making contributions are trying to rise me. Some of the things they are saying are totally out of order. They, especially Senator Ross, have contradicted themselves so many times. He accused politicians and the Minister of jobbery, he said her people would be appointed and that they in turn would appoint their own hacks to positions on boards. We should be fair. The position of the Lord Mayor of Cork and the Mayor of Waterford rotates between different political parties every year. I cannot see how any Minister for Education could appoint her own people to governing bodies all the time. Senator Norris said a moron could be appointed Lord Mayor.

Comment on this

No. I said someone who was pig ignorant and prejudiced.

Comment on this

That would be only one person out of 38 on the governing body. Surely the other 37 could control that one person, if there is such a moron? If they cannot they should not be on the governing body either.

In the amendment proposed by Senator Ormonde and me, the eight members will not be appointed, as Senator Ross said. The General Council of County Councils consists of three representatives from every county council in Ireland. I do not have to tell some Senators this as they know it already but perhaps Senator Ross and Senator Norris do not. The general council nominates and elects eight people to the governing body of UCD every year. These are not eight Labour, Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael people chosen by the Minister. They are selected by members of county councils. Many members of county councils are teachers and academics. There are quite a number of doctors and solicitors on the governing body of UCD. If they are not fit company for Senator Ross, I do not know what to say.

I never objected to Senator Ross complaining about members of a local authority. I complained about the language he used, the manner in which he insulted members of county councils and the derogatory remarks he passed about them. I never objected to him putting up an argument to keep members of county councils out. I object to his sneering and the manner in which he put his remarks. No member of any county council, of any party, should be besmirched by anybody in this way. Senator Ross has downgraded members of local authorities, who are good people looking after the problems of rural Ireland. I am proud and glad to be associated with Senator Ormonde's amendment.

Section 15 (5) (b) (iv) states "not less than two or more than five persons elected by the councils of the administrative Counties of Cork, Waterford, Kerry, Limerick, Tipperary (North Riding) and Tipperary (South Riding)." This means six counties are allowed five members so one county will lose out. I may be wrong about this, but it is puzzling.

We are elected by members of county councils, outgoing Senators and Dáil Deputies. We are proud to get their vote. If Senator Ross thinks I am patronising him, he is right. They are my electorate and he would do the same for his, if he was a man.

Comment on this

I want to keep this discussion calm. However, I regret to say there is an extraordinary and ugly seam of snobbery running through some of Senator Ross's contributions. It is almost as if we were back in the days when the peasantry should doff their caps to the ascendancy.

I have 22 years' experience on the governing body of University College, Dublin, and I have been a member of the NUI Senate for the past 12 or 15 years. I think I know a great deal about the NUI and UCD. Senator Ross is telling me the people I can have on my governing body. What right does he have to do that? How many people has he consulted in the NUI or UCD? The Minister has consulted all the governing bodies and the wider faculties. She is coming to the House following democratic consultation to give us the distilled views of the universities as to who they want on their boards. What right does Senator Ross have to tell me who I can have as my colleagues on the governing body of UCD?

It has been my privilege to serve with the elected members of the General Council of County Councils. I found them splendid colleagues who never divided on party lines and always had the best interests of the university and the wider community at heart. I make no excuse for saying that and I am proud to do so. I am not saying it for electoral reasons but because I know it to be true and I believe it. I ask Senator Ross to allow us the sincerity of our motives without saying "he would do that, wouldn't he?" I am saying it because I believe and know it to be true.

I agree with many of Senator Norris's contributions. However, he stated that there could be a Lord Mayor of Cork or Limerick who was pig ignorant and prejudiced. I know many academics, professors of English, History and Economics, who are narrow, ignorant and bigoted bullies. These people are half daft and so narrow and driven in their own particular discipline, they have no view of the wider world, except their own selfish interest. We all know them. A professor of English could be a fellow of Trinity — I am sure it has happened in the past — and fit some or all of these characteristics. The matter should be looked at in totality.

By and large I have found that the Lords Mayor of Dublin have not made a very large contribution. As they only hold the office for a year, they do not have very much to say and do not get to know the situation very well. The same may be true of Cork. However, this tradition has been in operation for a long time and it has certainly done no harm. A lord mayor may do a great deal of good on occasion. There is no body of views in UCD or in UCC which is arguing that lords mayor should not be represented. Most lords mayor are reasonable and decent people who do not try to impose obnoxious views on others. Those views usually come from within the universities themselves. Senator Fitzgerald and I speak from many years of elected service on the governing body and we are happy with what is being proposed.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Norris when he says that it is possible from time to time to have a lord mayor who is "a bit off". However, as Senator Fitzgerald said, it is surely possible for the other members of the governing body to control such a person. Senator Manning said that a certain number of academics are decidedly off; some are seated not too far from here.

Comment on this

Which side of the House are they sitting on?

Comment on this

I am not looking in any particular direction.

Comment on this

No doubt the people to whom the Senator is referring would benefit from his skilled treatment.

Comment on this

If they were members of VHI, I would be glad to help. I do not accept Senator Ross's comments. We have listened to sufficient pusillanimous meanderings from this party hopping inflated flea. What do councillors in County Wicklow, decent people like Pat Vance, Joe Behan and so on, think of their fellow councillor?

Comment on this

The Senator should be aware that it is not appropriate to name people. Will the Senator please speak on the amendment?

Comment on this

It is an insulting to councillors to make such comments. The Government has introduced much legislation the aim of which is to have good local government. On occasions, attempts have been made to remove councillors from boards and diminish their participation. I am glad to note that the Minister has indicated that she will look favourably on this amendment.

What kind of qualifications do councillors need to be members of governing authorities? I know some councillors who are poor and others who live in mansions. I know of one councillor who drives a Rolls Royce. I know councillors who are barristers, doctors, fishermen and farmers. What disqualifies these people, particularly as they have as many votes behind them in local elections as my colleague has in the university ones? Councillors are just as qualified as anybody else and perhaps have a great deal more savvy than some of the academics sitting round the table with them. Men such as Senators McGowan and Fitzgerald have great nous and knowledge of the affairs of the real world as opposed to the abstruse affairs of academia. Councillors on governing authorities would bring the other lofty people down to earth and would formulate regulations for universities. I support this amendment and I hope the Minister will look favourably on it.

Comment on this

Senator Manning covered this issue very well and I compliment him on that. I welcome Senator Lee's observations on the Lord Mayor of Cork but the comments made by Senators Ormonde and Fitzgerald can only be deemed to be an insult to the honoured positions of the Lord Mayor of Cork and the Mayor of Waterford. They are nothing short of that.

Comment on this

I support my colleagues and I compliment Senators Ormonde and Fitzgerald on tabling a specific amendment in relation to councillors. I support the consensus view on councillors which prevails among those of us who live in the real world. Since entering this House, I and a number of the other Senators have attempted to defend what we perceive to be an erosion of the position of councillors. I do not know where this started; it seems to go back through several Administrations into the 1980s and it has continued since then. When parliamentary draftsmen discuss Bills requiring a representative grouping of people to be appointed to boards, the legislation includes a section which disbars councillors from taking their place on these. County councillors are a representative group who have traditionally served on boards of one type or another. This trend was allowed to develop unfettered until last year when the Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise and Employment, Deputy Rabbitte, introduced a Bill to set up the new science and technology board. He conceded that he saw no merit — I recall that the Leader of the House was of the same view — in having legislation which disbarred elected representatives from various boards. I hope that precedent will be followed. This amendment has been tabled in that spirit.

I am saddened by Senator Ross's comments, though they do not make me angry any more. I am surprised, however, at the comments made by Senator Norris, a person who has suffered a great deal of discrimination and who should be the last person to discriminate against others. His comments are discriminatory and they set aside a group of people in society who voluntarily give of their time and expertise, such as it is, for the greater good and nothing else. Yet, the Senator comes into the House and uses what I consider to be unacceptable language. The Leader of the House has acknowledged that. I object to that kind of elitism and bigoted racism against elected representatives who have been pilloried on more than one occasion in this House by people who should know better. It is in that context that I register my support for the amendment. I am pleased that the Minister seems to have indicated her approval, hopefully her response will indicate that she sees merit in the amendment.

I know a number of people who currently serve and have served on the governing bodies of universities and I have been struck by the fact that, in the main, they do not necessarily come from an academic background. A fellow county man of mine, who is the vice-principal of a 600 pupil school in Carrick-on-Shannon, serves on the governing body of UCG and enjoys his tenure there.

Comment on this

The Senator's comments are more appropriate to a Second Stage debate though I realise the section is a very important one. I ask the Senator to keep his comments relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

I feel strongly about this issue which transcends the entire issue of the allegations that councillors are merely looking after their electorate, something they are entitled to do. I do not believe that it is right and proper in an elected democracy that there should be such a negative strain of thinking, at the highest academic level, among people who are training a new generation to go out into the world. It is not acceptable that these people adopt and convey an ingrained attitude to their students that a section of our society, which is democratically elected, is somehow flawed and should be corralled somewhere in order to prevent them becoming involved in something which is of vital importance to them, their families and the wider society.

Those who participate on governing bodies are proud of their involvement and take their responsibilities seriously. I am saddened rather than angry particularly by the language adopted by Senator Norris because I have great admiration for him and usually agree with his comments.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to accept the amendment proposed by Senators Ormonde and Fitzgerald. I was disappointed by Senator Ross's contribution regarding councillors on the governing body of UCD. I have been a member of Mayo County Council for many years, a position I shared with Commissioner Pádraig Flynn, the Minister for Tourism and Trade, Deputy Enda Kenny, and the former Minister, Mr. Paddy O'Toole. Senator Ross is saying that such people are not fit to be on the governing body of UCD. His logic is that he himself is not fit to be a member.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

I think he is fit to be a member. Councillors give freely of their time; they have been serving the needs of people since the foundation to the State. They bring much advice and experience to various boards. Mayo County Council, for example, administers hundreds of thousands of pounds in grants annually to various universities. Councillors are familiar with the points system, grants, fees and the administrative structures of universities. Councillors make up a cross section of people, with qualifications ranging from general knowledge to the highest levels of education. They bring vast experience to their work.

I support the amendment and ask the Minister to accept it. I congratulate the Senators who tabled it. I wish to reiterate my disappointment with Senator Ross's contribution. He is fit to be a member of the governing body of any university.

Comment on this

I concur with Senator Mooney. On another occasion the Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise and Employment agreed that public representatives should play a role in administering and advising at board level. I congratulate Senators Ormonde, Fitzgerald, Dardis and O'Toole for tabling this amendment.

It is very easy to recognise the Members who were councillors before being elected to the Oireachtas. Their vast experience is obvious. We are enriched by our experience as councillors. We are the honoured public representatives, with the exception of our colleagues who are elected from the University Panel. County councillors work between 30 and 50 hours per week on a voluntary basis administering local authority decisions. In County Westmeath, for example, there is an annual budget of £22 million to be administered.

I support the amendment. Politics will be the poorer when we fail to acknowledge and recognise the great work done by local representatives through local authorities and the Houses of the Oireachtas. The public purse will no longer be administered in a way that recognises the demands and needs of the people. I support a mix at board level and involving public representatives is one way of achieving this.

Comment on this

Sometimes I wonder whether ordinary people should be allowed into this House and sometimes I get the impression that certain people should be in certain places. That was the impression I got when I was in the Chair this evening. During discussion of an earlier amendment I wondered whether only certain people should attend Trinity College. I am a former Lord Mayor of Cork and, to my misfortune, was on the governing body of UCC for 12 months. I was amazed at the level of internal conflict. As an urban councillor if I was seen to be doing, some of the things faculties in UCC were doing I would not last a week. I certainly would not be reelected.

Senator Ross's argument is totally inconsistent. Earlier he was looking for certain rights for everybody. Now he only wants rights for certain people. He did not say whom he thinks should be on the boards, he only said who should be excluded. I ask him to name who can best represent the people on the boards.

As a former Lord Mayor of Cork I was embarrassed to be on the governing body of UCC. I ask the Minister to seriously consider this amendment which provides for the ordinary person to be represented on these boards. All public bodies which do not include public representatives should be examined. I sat on the board of UCC on behalf of the people of Cork and I was glad to leave it. UCC is over 150 years old and I am very proud of it. The first job I got was in 1954 at the age of 13 years and nine months in UCC under Professor O'Reilly. The subsequent presidents were Mr. Hurley and Mr. Carey. The current president, Mr. Mortell, has his hands full dealing with the governing body because there are people on it who are not realistic.

Nobody can say I am not realistic. I believe in basics more than anybody else. Saying that the former Lord Mayor of Cork should not serve on the governing body does not go down well with people. It is a massive mistake for any Government to decide that public representatives should not serve on such boards. We must demand recognition for the role public representatives play on behalf of ordinary people. The previous amendment said that snobs should be looking after the snobs in Trinity College, that only snobs should go to Trinity College because the snobs said so. I defy anybody to offer an alternative interpretation of that amendment. Five Independent Senators were in favour of a division but only two voted for the amendment. If that is democracy, perhaps the Senators could explain it to me. Perhaps I should ask UCC to explain it.

Comment on this

Ask Trinity.

Comment on this

Try UCC first.

Comment on this

Is it democracy that five people support a call for a division and only two vote for an amendment? I sat on a governing body where everybody had a fair say.

Comment on this

This is an emotive subject and the Minister will be tired before the debate is over. Senator Norris referred to the possibility of an appointee being pig ignorant and prejudiced. Some good may yet come of this discussion because people occasionally recognise when they are prejudiced. We have listened to enough prejudice in the last few hours.

Section 15 (5) (b) (ii) and (ii) is being treated differently from section 15 (2) (a) and other subsections relating to staff. The terrible prejudice and arrogance running through the contributions must be confronted but that can only be done by the academics involved. They are not even listening to the debate which is probably another display of arrogance and disrespect for people generally. The Senators should consider what they are saying. They believe there is a subspecies of people who are not fit to serve on boards but that others, just because they are academics, are automatically capable of sitting on boards and handling administration rather than teaching. that assumption is running through the debate. some academics have the ability to sit on boards but others, just because they are politicians or ministerial appointees, are under question.

Senator Norris mentioned the possibility of somebody being pig ignorant and prejudiced. The Senator should examine his conscience and ask himself from where that comment came. It is based on incredible prejudice and arrogance because the Lords Mayor of Cork and Waterford are elected by bodies. The presumption in the debate on previous provisions was that certain people would be fine. However, the presumption with regard to this amendment is that pig ignorance and prejudice will appear. I hope Members confront their own pig ignorance, prejudice and arrogance because that is the only way to dissipate it.

Comment on this

It is disappointing that two schools of thought have emerged with regard to amendment No. 57, but one learns more from the school of the majority. The amendment involves a small increase from five to eight in the number of elected members. I support that and I urge the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Perhaps the Minister could reply at this point.

Comment on this

I have attempted to defend my point of view. I am happy for the Minister to reply but we should move on.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Chair is attempting to progress the discussion by calling the Minister at this point. Members can then make interventions if they wish.

Comment on this

Senator Ross's amendments Nos. 52, 54, 55, 58, 60 and 62, which suggest that county councillors should not be on any governing authorities, are not acceptable. The proposals relate to the NUI and I ask the two Independent Senators who contributed to this lengthy debate to note that, under section 15 (5) (f), the fellows of Trinity College, Dublin, reflect tradition on the board.

I considered amendment No. 57 and I indicated previously that I support the valuable and important role played by county councillors. I want the position whereby councillors are already represented on governing authorities to continue. I have a particular interest in the education of young people. I want to ensure that they will be prepared to participate in democracy in future. I am anxious to ensure that the Bill does not diminish the role of those who reflect society and are prepared to stand for public election. If the House considers that an increase in the number of representatives on governing authorities is desirable, I will introduce an amendment to that effect on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I want to be clear that the number will be increased from five to eight. Will the Minister introduce an amendment on Report Stage to that effect?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I understand the eagerness to curtail the discussion on this matter. However, Members should congratulate and thank me for giving them an opportunity to speak to their electorate. Most of them have taken that opportunity; I have never encountered such unanimity in the House on such an issue. I wish to make a point about lords mayor.

Comment on this

This is not about lords mayor.

Comment on this

One of the amendments addresses the position of lords mayor. I am a county councillor and it is fair to say that I have been involved in certain deals and agreements of which I am not proud. One of those transactions involves the election of the chairman of the county council. Chairmen of county councils are great people in many ways but they are selected through deals between political parties which specifically exclude other people. I understand lords mayor are also selected in that manner.

I am a member of Wicklow County Council and a deal was done in 1991 which ensured that Fine Gael, the Labour Party and Fianna Fáil held the chair for eight years to the exclusion of everybody else. The chairmanship rotates between those parties, regardless of merit, as a result of a political deal. Nobody considers anything about the election of a chairman other than that deal. It is a division of the spoils. I am fed up with the bogus, pious and sanctimonious nonsense in the debate about lords mayor. They are wonderful people but every committee and post to which they are elected is the result of wheeling and dealing.

Comment on this

The Senator is wrong.

Comment on this

Everybody knows that is the case.

Comment on this

Pious hypocrisy.

Comment on this

They are divided proportionally among the political parties. That is the truth. There is no university in Wicklow, but if the chairman of Wicklow County Council was in the same position as the lords mayor under this Bill and was automatically placed on the board of a university, it would be simply and solely as a result of political horse trading. The lords mayor may be good and the position may promote suitable people from time to time but the person holds the office as a result of political horse trading and let us not pretend otherwise.

Comment on this

Politics is the art of the possible.

Comment on this

What is wrong with political horse trading?

Comment on this

Is academic horse trading all right?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Ross without interruption.

Comment on this

It is time we told the truth about this and I make no apology for saying it. I admit I have participated in a deal of that sort and it is not something of which I am proud.

Comment on this

In other words, Senator Ross is not consistent.

Comment on this

That is the political system within which we work and one of the reforms which is necessary. Senator Cregan is right — I am not always consistent, nor is anyone in this House. Like everyone else, I sometimes do things for political advantage — perhaps the Senator does not believe me.

Let us hear the reasons that councillors should be on these bodies. Senators Manning and Lydon were the two stars of the debate. Senator Manning said "it has done no harm". What an appalling reason for putting something into legislation. That is extraordinary. It is not the reason he wants it to be included but it is the reason he gives. He says they are reasonable, decent people — that is another great qualification for being on the boards. Any reasonable, decent person can apply. We have not heard a justification except that they are political cronies.

Comment on this

They are elected.

Comment on this

I am a political crony and I should not be on the board of a university by virtue of that. Senator Lydon took great advantage of this debate to name two of his constituents and say they were wonderful people who would be great on the board of a university. He may or may not believe that but it is not the purpose of this amendment to give Senators the opportunity to address their electorate by name.

This is a serious point which has not been seriously debated and has been misrepresented. People have seized on expressions such as Senator Norris's remark about people being pig ignorant, There are pig ignorant people in every walk of life — academia, journalism, everywhere. There is no doubt about that. People are only prickly about that remark when the people constitute their electorate.

This amendment has provoked an extraordinary attendance in the House which would not happen if world war was declared or if we decided to invade the North tomorrow. It is not a coincidence that they are here for the debate. I congratulate everyone for staying up so late and being so passionate on an issue about which they feel extraordinarily strongly. If the debate had been held three or four years ago we might not have quite such a good attendance.

Let us not have such a bogus argument. There are two sides to this matter but we have not heard the argument in favour of putting lords mayor and councillors on the boards of universities — we have heard people preaching to their electorate.

Comment on this

I am tempted to reply to some of what was said but I am sure there will be another occasion. It would be a great pity if the debate were sidetracked into the merits and demerits of councillors, lords mayor, etc. Senator Manning scored a point in saying that some members of universities were pig ignorant and perverse — that is perfectly fair. My argument is that people should not be placed on boards simply by virtue of an accident of political office. I am happy to leave it there because there is a danger that this important Bill may be diverted on this point until we all get so tired that later matters are not given sufficient debate. I reserve my fire but if anyone wants my views on the historic, apostolic succession of lords mayor — especially in Dublin, of which I have personal experience — I am happy to make this information available in private. The Lords Mayor of Dublin have been a mixed bunch — some excellent but others pig ignorant and prejudiced, and I have the documentary evidence to demonstrate it.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for facilitating us on this amendment. All it does is restore the status quo. The figure was eight, it had been reduced but it has now been changed back. Reasonable, decent and honest people — who have been elected by reasonable, decent, honest people — will serve on this board. There are also academics who are reasonable, decent and honest. I am all for equality and the reflection of the needs of the community, which is part of the reason that public representatives should sit on the boards. I am pleased the amendment has been accepted and it was worth the debate. We need such a debate every now and then to assure our electorate that they are well-established, good at their job and should be there.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is amendment No. 52 being pressed?

Comment on this

It does not have a good chance of being accepted.

Comment on this

The Senator can be sure of that.

Comment on this

On a point of order, will there be an amendment on Report Stage similar to amendment No. 57?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Yes, the Minister will meet that amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 53, 56 and 59 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

In page 14, subsection (5) (b) (iii), line 45, after "the" to insert "Senate of the".

This is to make assurance doubly sure but there is no need for it so I will withdraw it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:

In page 15, subsection (5) (f), line 26, to delete "university" and substitute "college".

This is a drafting amendment. There is a distinction between the university and the college, as is understood by the Minister and her advisers. Trinity College does the teaching but the University of Dublin awards the degrees. It was originally intended that there should be other colleges of the university and, technically speaking, fellows belong to the college rather than to the university. I hope the Minister will accept this drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I wish to support the amendment on behalf of Senator Henry who is not present.

Comment on this

Section 4 defines Trinity College as a university to which this Bill will apply. Therefore, the reference to "university" in section 15 (5) (f) concerns Trinity College and the proposed amendment is not strictly necessary. Indeed, the charter of 1592 refers to the college as the mother of a university. I agree with Senators that the amendment is a relatively simple one and I am not opposed to it. However, I ask them to consider the issue further so that we can consider whether the amendment should be made on Report Stage. I would add that if the amendment is to be made the reference should be to "College" rather than "college".

Comment on this

I am happy to accept that the Minister will return with an amendment with a capital "C". It is fine by me if she proposes to table it as her own amendment, or would she prefer if I tabled it on Report Stage?

Comment on this

I will return with an amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I will still claim it as my amendment in my election literature.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:

In page 16, subsection (7), line 4, to delete "or (4)".

This returns to the issue of employees of universities. The Minister addressed some of the issues which arise out of this earlier. In the circumstances, I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendment No. 68 is related to amendment No. 67 and both may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:

In page 16, subsection (9), lines 16 and 17, to delete "or (c) who are nominated by organisations representative of business or industry".

I have deleted the wrong line in this amendment. I had intended to delete the following line which reads "or who, in the opinion of the Minister, are representative of business or industry". What is the distinction between those who are nominated by organisations representative of business and those who, in the opinion of the Minister, are representative of business? Is it intended that if the organisations fail to make a nomination the Minister shall then make a nomination?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The purpose of amendment No. 68 is to give the governing authority a power which the Minister seems to have taken upon herself. It addresses the subject of those who are nominated by organisations representative of business or industry. I do not understand the point of the last part of subsection (9) which states "or who, in the opinion of the Minister, are representative of business or industry". There does not seem to be an alternative — they are either organisations which are representative of industry or business or they are not. I have puzzled over this subsection several times and I would like it explained to me.

The amendment I have tabled seeks to substitute the "governing authority" for the "Minister" because I do not see why the interpretation should be up to the Minister. The interpretation of who represents business or industry can be extremely wide. Business and industry is a very broad ship, whether large or small. There is an obligation on the Minister to define what she means by business. Wearing another hat, I often have a problem with how far the definition of "business" can be extended. There seems to be a very wide definition of those who are involved in business.

What does the Minister intend this to mean and how broad does she intend the parameters to be? If she is going to interpret this very widely, we ought to know that. I would prefer to leave it up to the governing body to decide who is representative of business or industry rather than the Minister, which is consistent with what I have said about the rest of the Bill. Will she give us a definition of "business"?

Comment on this

Section 15(3)(a) already requires that one such person be representative of business. If a university decides it will only have one such person, subsection (9) requires that one of the Minister's nominees will have to be representative of business. Therefore, where a governing authority has one ministerial nominee and one wider community representative, both must be representative of business or industry. It means there must be two of these representatives, and there are a number of ways in which this can come about.

I consider that representation from business on university governing authorities is desirable. The present provision is in keeping with the recommendation of the Moriarty task force on the implementation of the Culliton report. It gives practical recognition to interaction between universities and the business sector by ensuring the business sector has an input into the decision making processes in the universities. This subsection ensures that will be the case.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for clarifying that. However, why should it be in the opinion of the Minister that they are representative of business or industry rather than that of the governing authority? That is what the amendment is about.

Comment on this

It is because it is on the nomination of the Minister. We do not agree on this but I believe, given the fact that the nomination comes from the Minister, that the governing authority having one ministerial nominee and one wider community representative will ensure business or industry is represented on the board. This definition of the nominations is cognisant of the recommendations of the Moriarty task force and the Culliton report in its practical recognition of the interaction between the universities and the business sector.

Comment on this

I do not think we will reach any agreement on that. What does the Minister mean by the term "business"?

Comment on this

I believe "business" is a commonly understood term, although the Senator may offer definitions. However, in other legislation with which I have been involved in this and the other House we have not experienced difficulties with having a common understanding of the term "business".

Comment on this

I am not trying to be awkward but I have a difficulty every day with how wide that sphere extends. That is very important because this clause will include or exclude certain types of people. What exactly does the Minister mean by "business" in this context? How wide does it go? Does it include professionals? Would it include, for instance, teachers, people on school boards, barristers, architects and those in small and part-time business? It is important that we know the meaning of the word "business".

Comment on this

In this section it is intended that those engaged in business would be involved in commercial and economic activities. As an elected public representative I do not engage in business and do not, therefore, work with profit and loss accounts and financial matters. I do not employ people; I represent them. People would have no difficulty in excluding me from a definition of business activities, which involve commercial transactions. If we accept the Moriarty task force report and note the partnerships with the business community that Trinity College has already established without statute provision, it is clear that the university, other Members of the House and I have no difficulty in reaching a common understanding of what is meant by those engaged in business.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 69:

In page 16, subsection (10), line 22, delete "or approved by the Minister" and substitute "or approved by the governing authority".

Comment on this

If the governing authority had the power to approve a gender balance other than a gender balance determined by the Minister it would provide the governing authority with an opportunity not to attempt to have a fair gender balance. I would prefer that the Minister would retain the power to approve a gender balance, other than that he or she had determined, where it is apparent that the authority had attempted to attain that balance.

Comment on this

Concern has been expressed by the University of Limerick about section 15(5)(g)(iii). The university is anxious that the persons nominated to the governing body by the University of Limerick Foundation would not be employees of the university but would be chosen from outside the university to give a balance to the governing body. Will the Minister advise that this is what the legislation implies?

Comment on this

I note the Senator's comments but I do not want to involve myself with a commitment, because if I say I will address this matter on Report Stage there is an understanding that I am taking on board the point that has been made.

Comment on this

I was seeking clarification. I am not pressing the Minister for an amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 69b and 70 are related to amendment No. 69a and all may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 69a:

In page 16, subsection (3), line 43, to delete "vote of not less than two-thirds".

Section 16(3) states:

Where the governing authority decides at a meeting that a person other than the chief officer should be the chairperson, it shall, as soon as practicable at that or a subsequent meeting, by a majority vote of not less than two-thirds of its members, appoint a person who is not an employee of the university or a member of the governing authority to be the chairperson.

I am at a loss to understand why there should be a majority vote of not less than two-thirds. It should be possible to make an appointment by majority.

Comment on this

Dáil Éireann agreed to the insertion of a requirement that where a chairperson other than the president is appointed there must be a majority vote of not less than two-thirds of the members of the governing authority. This suggestion was initially proposed by Deputies Martin and Coughlan to the select committee considering the Bill. It is important that such a person would have the strong support of the governing authority and therefore I would not favour its deletion.

Amendment No. 69b proposes that where the chairperson is other than the president or the provost, he or she should not be an employee or student of the university. However, I could not support a position where, for example, a professor was answerable to the governing authority and to the chief officer on relevant issues and yet chaired the governing authority.

I do not support the deletion of subsection (6), as proposed by Senator Ormonde in amendment No. 70. I consider that the power of the governing authority to remove the chairperson should apply where it has appointed a chairperson other than the chief officer. It is only fair that the governing authority can remove from office somebody it appointed.

In excluding the chief officer from the removal power, my aim is to ensure that the Bill does not undermine the position of the chief officer in a university. Removal from the office of chairperson would be such a serious step that it is unlikely that any governing authority could contemplate it unless it also proposed to remove the chief officer from office.

Comment on this