Universities Bill, 1996: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 225–440 of 440. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 44 of 1996 ›
I understand that the Minister feels strongly about this but I still fail to understand why a majority of two-thirds is necessary. The purpose of my amendment is to ensure that this is done by a majority by removing the proviso of a two-thirds majority. The purpose is to make it simpler and easier and not to lock the governing authority by a two-thirds provision. It is dangerous to include it in legislation. It is most unusual for such a clause to be included in legislation of this kind. The Minister has not provided me with a satisfactory explanation for its inclusion.
Comment on this
One would hope this would not be the case, but if the appointment as chairperson of somebody other than the chief officer arises it may be very divisive. It is important that whoever takes the chair does so with a clear majority of the board. Otherwise there would be a factionalised governing authority, which would be a potential poison within the institution of the university.
Comment on this
The Minister appears to be giving preference under section 16 to the appointment of the chief officer as the chairperson of the board. In any co-operative or business, the chief executive is answerable to the board. That does not apply here. It is vitally important the chief officer should be answerable where board membership is being extended. In my county, there was a great deal of difference between the president and registrar. If the registrar has a point to make and the president is chairman, would it be difficult for him or her to make a case in an impartial way and for the president to operate fairly in these matters?
Comment on this
Many resolutions require a two-thirds majority. An example that comes to mind is that it takes two-thirds of a county council to fire a county manager.
Comment on this
The president is the chairperson of NUI colleges but there is a provision for an outside chairperson. It is important there is a requirement that a strong support structure exists. Otherwise, the workings of the governing body may become difficult.
Comment on this
There is something to be said for an outside chairperson but only for a person who would have the level of support outlined in the Bill. NUI colleges have presidents and that is not being disturbed. They will make decisions on how that will be carried on after their term.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 17, subsection (1), lines 30 and 31, to delete paragraph (a) and substitute the following:
"(a) to manage the performance of the functions of the university and to control and administer the property and other assets of the university.".
The words "to control" are strong and it would be more acceptable to state "to manage the performance of the functions of the university and to control and administer the property and other assets of the university".
Comment on this
A reference to the functions of the university in section 17(1)(a) is not necessary and could lead to confusion. Given that the section refers to other property, the reference to assets is necessary. The proposal to rephrase with regard to the functions would make us more confused. However, I acknowledge the good intention behind the Senator's amendment.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 76 is related to amendment No. 73 and both may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73.:
In page 17, subsection (2), line 42, after "and " to insert "such other advertising, search and consultative procedures".
The appointment of a president or a chief officer is the single most important decision that at governing authority can take and it is desirable that the mechanisms be defined and developed as effectively as possible for that. If a governing authority gets the decision right, a large part of the Bill will fall into place effectively as will university performance. If it does not get this right, it will be an uphill battle in terms of getting the best possible candidate. In the tradition of appointments we have not developed the most searching exploratory techniques for recruiting the widest range of candidates. We have sometimes been fortunate with our presidents, but the procedures have partly meant that no college — National University or Trinity College — has ever appointed a president from outside. In one case a former member of staff returned and proved a fine president. In an era of growing internationalisation, where there are many talented Irish people abroad who might wish to return home, it is essential that the recruitment procedure be carefully considered.
I am trying to ensure as far as possible that the legislation assists the governing authority in thinking along those lines. For instance, the governing authority shall develop such interview and other procedures as in its opinion will best ensure participation. The phrase "in its opinion" is loose. There should be a minimum requirement which the governing authority can then elaborate on and develop. That is why I include search techniques, advertising and consultative procedures — for example, when to set the process the motion and how much should be allocated in advertisements. There have been cases where potentially talented candidates abroad did not apply in time because the length of time for application in the advertisement was extremely short. That may change in the world of the Internet and so on, but I am trying to ensure the Bill gives as much guidance as possible while leaving details to local circumstances. The intention behind this subsection is admirable, but it does not go far enough. The public has a legitimate interest in ensuring the mechanisms are as developed as possible. I have no doubt the amendment can be improved, but this is its purpose.
Comment on this
I understand Senator Lee's point. There is no doubt that the spirit of what Professor Lee wants and the objective he seeks should be supported but this is too prescriptive and intrusive. The experience of University College, Dublin, over the last number of presidencies is that there has been an evolution from when it was regarded as a closed competition for which only insiders needed to apply. The NUI process was such that an outsider would not have been made feel very welcome, if not made to feel they were not entitled to apply.
That has evolved considerably. In the last presidential election in UCD, as I am sure is the case elsewhere, candidates addressed all sections of the university population and were invited to address the governing body before the position was taken; it was also very widely advertised. This issue should be addressed by each university in light of the philosophy which now prevails on such matters. That philosophy holds it axiomatic that every academic and senior administrative position is widely advertised and all procedures are open, structured and accountable. Professor Lee would agree that this was not the case when he and I began our academic careers in what were rather closed and insulated institutions. We are better off leaving this to the universities and their governing bodies. They would now be sure that the proper procedures are adhered to in order that the best candidates are attracted. It is a matter of judgment. I do not disagree with what Professor Lee is trying to do, but this may be too prescriptive.
Comment on this
Senator Manning must have stolen my speaking notes. Flexible arrangements are provided in sections 24(4) and (5), which will allow universities and the Higher Education Authority to develop a framework. We should not be too prescriptive as we will have governing bodies that will be different in composition and more outward looking than previously. Given those circumstances, it is impossible for me to recommend acceptance of amendment Nos. 109 and 110, which relate to amendment No. 74. The application is too wide and the matters the Senator wishes to raise are well provided for.
Comment on this
We are dealing with amendment No. 73.
Comment on this
I am anticipating.
The effect of amendments No. 73 and 76 would be to affect the process of appointment of any member of staff from a gardener to a senior professor. That the whole employment spectrum would be affected was not grasped by the Senator and the proposal might be seen as an attack on institutional autonomy. The procedures referred to in subsection (2) could include advertising, search and consultative processes if the governing authorities so desired. It was not suitable to put this in as a requirement. If I had included this in the original Bill in the level of detail the Senator wanted, I would have been accused of being prescriptive.
Comment on this
That accusation would have been made but I would have been on the Minister's side. I thank the Minister for answering on amendments Nos. 74, 109 and 110 and now I know what is ahead.
There is agreement on the direction one wants to go, although I would not be quite as optimistic as Senator Manning. It will probably work itself out, as the impulse is as widely and firmly based as one would want it to be. Some of the responses I have had to this general principle suggest that there is still some resistance, which made me feel that there was more necessity for this than I had thought.
When the Minister spoke of framework, that was a legitimate dimension to consider. Remuneration is one of the key factors in attracting high quality outside candidates. I have no more idea how one determines what a first class university president is worth than how one determines how much a first class Secretary of a Government Department is worth. If they do their jobs well, they will be worth more than we are likely to pay them, but what we offer must be given a lot of thought. The development of that framework should not be left to the last minute. I cannot stress enough that the quality of people in that position is perhaps the single most significant variable in determining the overall performance of the university sector. I may return on Report Stage with a refined version of these amendments.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:
In page 17, subsection (2), line 44, to delete "employees" and substitute "members".
This may seem a pedantic change but there is a subtle distinction between "employee" and "member". The outside members of a governing authority are deemed to be members of the university but not employees. Therefore, when one wants those in a university to think of outsiders as possible candidates, they should not be confined to those they happen to know, even if they are very good candidates. I am prepared to withdraw this amendment, but it was an amendment to provoke people to look outwards rather than to settle for candidates they knew.
Comment on this
The aim here is to encourage the right recruitment of university staff. We need not pursue this.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:
In page 18, subsection (4), line 4, after "fit". to add "A committee may consist either wholly of members of the governing authority or such combination of members and non-members as the governing authority thinks fit.".
Later in the Bill there is a clause on academic councils to the effect that they can consist of the same membership as in this amendment. That does not apply to governing authorities. Is that deliberate or is it intended that governing authorities be confined to members of the governing authority when there is explicit permission for academic council committees to consist of members of that council and non-members? Is the difference intended?
Comment on this
Senator Lee's proposal is already the case. The governing authority can decide as it sees fit. Although I think it unnecessary, I support what it is attempting and will consider it further if the House is not confident that it is clear this is already the case. If my offer on clarity is accepted, we can return to this.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77a:
In page 18, subsection (6), lines 11 and 12, to delete paragraph (a) and substitute the following:
"(a) ensure the promotion and use of Irish as a language of general communication, facilitate the use of Irish as a medium of instruction, and provide for the cultivation of the Irish language and its associated literary and cultural traditions as subjects of teaching and research,".
Section 17(6) states:
In performing its functions a governing authority, or a committee where appropriate, shall—
(a) have regard to the promotion and use of the Irish language and the promotion of Irish cultures,
I do not have any objection to that but my amendment seeks to move beyond "have regard to" to try to provide for a greater imperative by using the words "ensure the promotion and use of Irish as a language of general communication, facilitate the use of Irish as a medium of instruction, and provide for the cultivation of the Irish language and its associated literary and cultural traditions as subjects of teaching and research". The amendments are similar.
Comment on this
While the second part of my amendment seeks to extend the use of Irish to the "literary and cultural traditions", which is important the main reason I tabled it is to see whether the Minister would accept placing a greater imperative on the governing body to promote the Irish language so that, rather than "have regard to", they would take this on board and ensure it would happen.
Comment on this
I support what Senator O'Toole said. Neither of us is in the forcing mould but it is fair to say that "have regard to" could be a dead letter. If the balance can be achieved, it is desirable to have something a little more indicative of the direction in which one wishes it to go. That is why I support the Senator in this matter.
Comment on this
Section 16(6) addresses the responsibility of the governing authority as regards the Irish language. This matter also arose in Dáil Éireann and, given the widespread recommendation to include a provision along these lines, I will consider the matter further, address elements in the amendments and return to the matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 79. Amendment No. 80 is related. Therefore, amendments Nos. 79 and 80 may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:
In page 18, subsection (6)(b), line 17, after "socially" to insert "or generationally".
A section such as this is an invitation to insert almost anything which one happens to find desirable of insertion. I asked myself what are the two areas in my experience of university life at present which need to be integrated as a matter of course. While there are general inputs from outside, they may not be represented as effectively as some others.
Physical disadvantage is one of the areas and I do not think it is mentioned anywhere else in the Bill. If it is, I am open to correction. One ought to include a specific recognition of the responsibility of universities to try to do whatever they can in that direction. In fact, a number are doing good work and I am happy to say that my university, University College Cork, is doing very good work. Where the Bill refers in section 17(6) to "economically or socially disadvantaged people and ... people from sections of society significantly under-represented", we should make provision for the physically disadvantaged specifically and the generationally disadvantaged — I am not sure if I coined that phrase. I am thinking of adult education and of those who did not have a chance to attend university who might be in a position to benefit from it. It is desirable that the Bill acknowledges specifically the desirability of moving further in the direction towards which the universities are already moving.
Comment on this
I agree with the sentiments expressed in this section. I would like Senator Lee to be a little more explicit in his explanation of "generationally". I am having difficulty relating to it.
Comment on this
I support the insertion of "physically disadvantaged people" and I signalled that on Second Stage. It is desirable and I hope the Minister will agree with it.
Comment on this
Subsection (6)(b) refers to "people from sections of society significantly under-represented". It is a general statement and it is better to be left in that form rather than attempting to list various elements. However, I would refer Senator Lee and Senator Kelly to section 34, which deals with equality policy. Section 34(1)(a) refers to "access to the university and to university education by economically or socially disadvantaged people, by people who have a disability and by people from sections of society significantly under-represented in the student body". Therefore, I recommend that we leave out the general statement in amendments Nos. 79 and 80 because the concerns expressed on both sides of the House are dealt with in section 34.
Comment on this
There is a reference to disability in section 34 but there is no harm in including it again. Having said that, a person could complain that somebody was left out and it was meant to be totally inclusive.
There is reference to lifelong learning. We still do not take on board sufficiently the sheer bad luck of when a person was born in terms of access to higher education for different age cohorts. Despite provisions for mature students and adult education, we are writing off those who happen to have been born a little too early. Whether that justifies the coinage of such an awful word as "generationally", I am not sure but it is desirable to indicate to universities that this ought to be one of the directions which society would wish them to develop further.
Comment on this
Vocational training opportunity schemes have been introduced and these give access to third level, but I agree with the sentiments of Senator Lee in so far as we must stress the provisions which universities could make to break that cycle and help those who never made the break through.
Comment on this
I can only refer back to the objects of the university. Section 12(i) states: "to facilitate lifelong learning through the provision of adult and continuing education". That was a theme which I pursued during the Irish Presidency of the EU in the past six months and that is why it is provided for among the objects of a university. Senator Lee explained the word "generationally". I am satisfied we would all agree that section 12(i) is seen as a basic objective of a university, and it is provided in statute.
Comment on this
I hope the universities take as much notice of it as the Minister would wish.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80a:
In page 18, subsection (6), between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following new paragraph:
"(d) to promote good relations between people of all religions on the island of Ireland.".
I am puzzled by subsection (6) and I do not know from where these three aspirations came. While I have no rooted objection to the principles involved in them, I can think of other ones which are equally worthy. The Minister obviously has a great attachment to the use of the Irish language, the attainment of gender balance and the promotion of the economic, cultural and social development of the State, whatever that means. While I think it is possible to support the insertion of these type of aspirations in a Bill of this sort, I do not see why it has been so selective. This addition would be a very important one. If we accept the aspirational nature of this Bill concerning the performance and functions of a university, it would be appropriate if we accepted that one of the most important objectives of all institutions — but especially educational ones — on this island is to tackle a problem which is far greater than those identified by subsections (a), (b) and (c). That is the sectarianism in the people of this island and the promotion of non-sectarianism, pluralism and means whereby different denominations can live together.
One of the great attractions some years ago of Trinity College — I do not say this in an exclusive way, but because it is something I experienced myself — was the absolutely free exchange of ideas between Nationalists and Unionists. I regret that has died to a large extent. About 25 to 30 years ago a large number of Unionists and Nationalists was represented in Dublin University — probably more Protestants than Catholics, but I do not know. There were healthy debates at the time in which a fair balance of Nationalist and Unionist opinion was exchanged. That was very healthy and it was one of the few places in Ireland where that happened. There was a great deal of banter and fierce debate, but it was an exchange of views in a friendly non-combative and non-hostile atmosphere.
Because the university gave places to people from all over Ireland it provided at the time an almost unique forum for the promotion of good relations between people of all religions. That is now lost — the Unionists no longer come down here, although some Nationalists do — for reasons which I will not go into because they are complicated and there are several of them. It is not the fault of any particular section of the community or of any Government or party.
If we put in these type of functions — and the Minister will be aware of my reservations about putting anything like this in the legislation, but I accept the inevitability of them being there now — they are more important than the promotion of the Irish language, gender balance or the third one, which is fairly meaningless. In the very difficult situation of the last 25 years, universities have been among the few institutions that could provide a forum for good relations between people of different religions.
Comment on this
This is an interesting amendment. It is a sentiment which neither I nor anyone in the House can oppose. I ask to be allowed to come back on Report Stage in proposing an amendment along the lines that Senator Ross has proposed.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 81 has already been discussed with amendment No. 7. Acceptance of this amendment involves the deletion of section 18. Is the amendment being pressed?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 82 has already been discussed with amendment No. 7. Is the amendment being pressed?
Comment on this
My understanding was that the Minister said she will look further at it. In the light of that I will not proceed further with it.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 83 has already been discussed with amendment No. 7. Senator Dardis is not here.
Comment on this
I am slightly concerned by the appointment of a judge as a visitor and I would not like this to go by without comment. We tend to assume that judges are people who, for some reason, are a cut above the rest of us and that automatically, therefore, they should be accepted as visitors to universities "after consultation with the President of the High Court". I do not necessarily believe judges are the most suitable people to be visitors to universities. Judges are no better, worse or any different from anyone else.
Judges of the High Court are political appointees. They have been appointed by Governments or by Ministers and many of them have declared political allegiances. We tend to accept that judges are people of some sort of impeccable integrity, which may be true, but they all have opinions, including political opinions, and many have been appointed by Ministers in the past. I have never understood why judges are not subject to the disclosure of interests. I would have thought that they, before politicians, should be subject to the Declaration of Interests Bill because they are making judgments on things which affect people's lives. They have far more power than politicians but they have never been subject to that Bill. There is an absolute assumption that a judge of the High Court will be appointed and will automatically be the right type of person. I am not so sure about that. I remain to be convinced that it is better for a judge of the High Court to be appointed by the Government than it is for the university to appoint someone themselves. I do not see anything wrong with the university making the appointment of a High Court judge as a visitor rather than the Government, which may have appointed the High Court judge to the Bench as well.
Comment on this
The experience in the University of Dublin, which has the power to appoint its own visitors, is that on a number of occasions judges have been used and they have been found to be very good. There is an argument that there should be a degree of prejudice in the direction of the Judiciary in relation to the number of points they must preside over or the examination of issues with a strong legal flavour and context. I would not rule out judges in the same way that I did not seek to rule out mayors of Cork or Limerick or members of county councils, but they should not be appointed automatically.
I do not have as much difficulty as my colleague, Senator Ross, with the appointment of judges because a certain degree of judgment and legal knowledge can help. However, I am not sure it should automatically be a judge, which is certainly not the case in Trinity College. On the other hand, this Bill deals with the other universities. It is not my patch to direct other universities on how to manage their affairs. If they are happy with this arrangement, I do not have any committed objection to it.
I accept what Senator Ross said, that judges are sometimes political appointments and that judgments are made in a political context. Although it is unlikely to have a drastic effect on the situation, I am glad the situation in Trinity College has been left intact. It has been seen to work well and it is interesting to note that the university appointed judges. I cite Mr. Justice Kingsmill Moore, who is a most distinguished and learned judge and who operated so efficiently there was never a scandal. He was brought in on a number of occasions and he adjudicated and resolved problems. That is the type of function one wants a visitor to carry out. A former Member of the other House, Mr. Justice Henry Barron, is one of the present visitors, while the other is the Chancellor, Mr. Frank O'Reilly. He has no judicial training, as far as I know, but he is also equally valuable.
Comment on this
The role of visitor is one with a long tradition in our university institutions. The status of the visitor was considered in detail by the select committee and I consulted with the President of the High Court. The NUI colleges want the visitor to be a judge of the High Court or a retired judge of the High Court or the Supreme Court. They probably decided on this as a result of the experience of Trinity College and the nature of the appointments made by the Government. One visitor is the Chancellor and the other is appointed by the Government from senate nominees. Having consulted widely and agreed that the status of the visitor is important, I did not have any difficulty acceding to the request from the other universities that the visitor should be a judge of the High Court or a retired judge of the High Court or the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 84 has already been discussed with amendment No. 7.
Comment on this
I do not remember discussing it with amendment No. 7.
Comment on this
There were many amendments grouped together, but I will allow the Senator to make a brief comment.
Comment on this
I move amendment NO. 84:
In page 18, lines 32 to 40, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:
"(1) Where the Board of Visitors is of the opinion that there are reasonable grounds for contending that the functions of a university are being performed in a manner which prima facie constitute a breach of the laws, statutes or ordinances applicable to the university, it shall so advise the Minister, and the Minister may, after first advising the governing authority of his/her opinion and considering any explanation given in response, and with the concurrence of the Government, request the Board of Visitors to the university to enquire into the matter giving rise to its opinion.”.
This section is one of the most contentious in the Bill. I want to make the visitor the buffer between the Minister and the various powers the Minister could activate by a complex process of activation. Instead of stating that "the Minister is of the opinion", the subsection should state that "the Board of Visitors is of the opinion". It was intended to buffer the Minister against the university, to buffer the university against the Minister and to ensure there was a degree of acceptance in the institution of an unprecedented power and what was seen as an intrusion by the Minister.
I am not one of those who oppose the section, because the Minister must have certain rights, but the mechanism by which they are controlled is important. A worst case scenario under section 19 would be a mutiny in a university against the appointment of an outside governing authority for one year. If such a situation arose it would be important that the basic opinion in the university would appreciate the reasons for what had happened, however much it might dislike what had happened, and would continue to give good and loyal service and to carry on the work of the university. Otherwise, the work of a university could ground to a halt if someone was sent in, which would be the direct opposite of what was intended. I am not sure we have taken on board the reaction of the teaching body and the university community in general to such decisions. We seem to have assumed they will be mutely accepted. A potentially dangerous situation could arise if the full thrust of section 19 is implemented.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 85 to 89, inclusive, not moved.
Comment on this
I propose that we take a sos for 15 minutes because we probably have three or four more hours of work left.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 90, 91 and 93 to 96, inclusive, form a composite proposal, No. 92 is related and all may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 90:
In page 19, lines 6 to 12, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:
"(1) Where the Board of Visitors reports that the functions of a university or its governing authority are being performed in a manner which constitutes a breach of the laws, statutes or ordinances of or applicable to the university, the Minister shall so inform the chief officer and ensure that the chief officer receives in person a copy of the report of the Board of Visitors.".
I believe I anticipated myself before the sos when referring to this section. The Minister will be more than familiar with its intricacies.
The impetus behind amendment No. 90 is based on the existence of the standing buffer — be it a board of visitors or some other body — which would perform the functions required to implement a decision, if one were taken, to suspend a governing authority. The Minister will be aware of a view abroad, with which I concur, that the eventuality of something of this nature happening appears so remote that the inclusion of one and a half pages of text in the Bill to deal with it seems unnecessary. If anything of this type occurs it should be dealt with by means of extraordinary parliamentary response. By virtue of the section's inclusion in the Bill there are those who believe a certain type of Minister might be tempted to consider the potential of implementing it or tightening its provisions to conduct inquiries of various sorts. I accept it is tightly drafted in terms of obliging a Minister to follow closely a particular procedure.
That said, under section 20, as matters stand a governing authority may be suspended and the members may have their membership terminated. While I do not share Senator Ross's full suspicion of the likely behaviour patterns of judges or visitors, I find it difficult if we project forward and consider the situation envisaged in the Bill whereby the Minister would take the initiative, call in a visitor to see if his or her suspicions are justified and, if they are, a procedure would follow. It is difficult to envisage in terms of political realities that a Minister is likely to appoint a visitor who will come up with the wrong answer. It would be extraordinary if a visitor reported back to a Minister, in the public arena, that he or she was wrong, that is to say, that the problems which the Minister thought existed did not exist.
While the fact that a visitor is appointed — on an ad hoc basis as I understand it — appears to provide safeguards, it can leave the anxieties of those who are fearful of an extreme use of ministerial power unassuaged. It is undesirable for unnecessary tensions to arise if they are avoidable. An initiative which comes from a standing body, which I call a board of visitors in my amendment, would make the process more acceptable to the public and to the institution.
If the visitor found that a governing authority was in dereliction of its duty yet a group on the governing body strongly opposed the behaviour that was found to be unacceptable, it would also be suspended. As it stands, the whole governing body would be suspended and the membership of its members terminated. The governing body may be suspended for up to a year and the visitor can, after consulting the Minister, appoint such a person or body of persons to perform its functions. This process is to take place apparently while the remainder of the university continues its usual activities as if in a vacuum or as if nothing had changed. Events such as these would throw an institution into turmoil. Even if the Minister's suspicions were justified, the operational efficiency of an exercise of this sort seems difficult to assume.
My amendments propose that the nominees of the board of visitors shall try to reinstitute the governing authority as rapidly as possible, certainly not taking longer than a year to do so, and that whatever measures it takes in the meantime shall be taken in consultation with the academic council. Thus, the people who are active in the university will feel they have a stake in the process and that events are not taking place over their heads, which is how I understand the mechanism as it is outlined in the section.
I also propose that instead of a new commission being established at the end of the year to appoint a new governing authority, on a different composition perhaps, the board of visitors should perform the function of getting the governing authority re-elected, rather than assuming that one had to compose it differently as if it was the composition of the governing body which was responsible for the dereliction of responsibilities. As the commission stands it would include the president and the registrar who may well be discredited by the suspension of the governing body. I find it difficult to see how that could happen, but as I understand the section that could arise.
The assumptions about what would happen if one got to the stage of having to appoint somebody in these circumstances are a dog's dinner, so to speak. One could end up in a worse situation. I do not think the process in the section would proceed along the smooth administrative lines envisaged. As the events are unlikely to happen, why do sections 19 and 20 go into such elaborate detail on the steps to be taken? However improbable we think it might be, we would be remiss in our responsibility if we did not try to discuss what might happen.
Comment on this
I understand Senator Lee's arguments but I am happy with the checks and balances in the section. For example, the Minister would not act on his or her own but with the concurrence of and through the Government. If a Minister attempted to act in a manner which was considered suspicious the Government would have to examine the situation and make a decision. That decision would be governmental, not ministerial. Given the provisions of sections 19 and 20, a Minister would not be able to act without good reason. The circumstances which the Senator imagines might arise cannot arise given the terms of the sections.
Comment on this
I agree with some of the points raised by Senator Lee. I am concerned that the dismissal would be dealt with in depth. The chief officer should deal with it in such as way that everyone would be aware of the reasons for the suspension of the governing body. It would be a very serious step to take and perhaps the Minister would explain exactly what would be involved.
Comment on this
Subsection (2)(b) of Senator Lee's amendment No. 91 states that "... the governing authority as a whole, or certain members, should be dismissed". Last year the House dealt with legislation concerning a fisheries board which made similar provisions. A manager was appointed in that case but it only involved the dismissal of a member rather than the whole board. I support Senator Lee's amendment that perhaps a provision should be included for certain members. The whole board would not always be involved.
Comment on this
Section 20 provides for the suspension of the governing authority in an extraordinary situation. It is necessary that the Government and the Oireachtas have the power to ensure in cases of serious breakdown in the operation of a university that direct action can be taken in the interests of the students, staff and wider community. The safeguards in the legislation as regards the Minister, Government and the Houses of the Oireachtas are significant. The Minister must be of the view, after receiving the report of the visitor, that the functions of the university are performed in a manner which constitute a breach of the laws, statutes or ordinance applicable to the university and must consider any views of the governing authority and the chief officer on this opinion.
We have already had a robust discussion about the need to have someone from the Judiciary represented and Senator Lee drifted into section 20 on this. The visitor would come to the Minister with a certain status. The visitor must agree with the Minister that the governing authority should be suspended. The Minister would then make a recommendation to the Government. If the Government agrees, it may, by order and with the consent of both Houses, suspend the membership. There is great protection here. Following consultation with the Minister, the visitor will appoint a person or body of persons to perform the functions of a governing authority in the period before a new authority is appointed.
These are safeguards which address reasonable concerns and provide a balanced set of provisions which will enable a Government to take a step it may have to. Given the three stages I outlined, I cannot support the deletion of the provision as proposed by Senators Ormonde, Norris and Ross. However, I believe their concerns are met in the buffers which exist.
I have examined the set of amendments proposed by Senator Lee. The revised subsections (1) and (2) which the Senator drafted do not differ from the subsection in the Bill. We are meeting the concerns his amendments set out to address in the Bill. Senator Dardis's amendment No. 92 which specifies that suspensions should only apply to individual members is related to Senator Lee's amendment No. 93. I do not support this proposal. That function should be exercised by the governing authority, which returns to a question raised by Senator Fitzgerald. This is provided for and I refer the Senator to section 3(1) of the Third Schedule which allows the governing authority to suspend a member.
Amendments Nos. 94, 95 and 96, proposed by Senator Lee would result in a number of changes to the Bill. He proposes that the visitor must consult the academic council. This is worthwhile but I also favour the provision that the visitor would consult the Minister. I agree that a new governing authority should be put in place as soon as practicable. A cooling off period would be required so it is important to include a time limit. Otherwise a Minister could suspend ad infinitum for their own reasons. Senator Lee proposes that the visitor will have the functions of the commission in arranging for setting up the next governing authority. I do not think this is a sufficient buffer. The visitor will have a major role in the initial visitation and in supporting the suspension of the governing authority.
I would prefer the commission mechanism to be used in setting up a new governing authority in the same manner as the first one appointed under the Bill. I will put down some amendments on Report Stage for the reconstitution of the governing authority as soon as practicable and for consultation with the academic council. I accept there is a need to consult it on the composition of the interim authority. There will be a limit of a year but there is no reason it could not happen before that is reached. I am satisfied that in an extraordinary situation, which is difficult to envisage, the Government or the Minister would not be heavy-handed. We have respect for the experience of the Judiciary and the visitor must concur with the Minister. There are three stages before anything happens. I will return to certain matters on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will be reasonably brief and I hope not tedious. It is ludicrous to envisage this situation occuring. It has never arisen in the past. If we are discussing hypothetical situations we should also consider reconstituting a university after it is hit by an asteroid, which is on the same level of probability. With the improvements which will possibly result from this Bill — the democratisation of the university structures, the degree of additional accountability and monitoring, it is absurd to contemplate a situation where the board will act so far outside their own statutes and in defiance of the law that the Minister will have the power to abolish it.
I oppose this section but recognise that at this stage of the night and the number of amendments involved I will got get anywhere. I will not waste the time of the House. I would like to get Committee Stage finished. I am prepared to stay here until four, five, six or seven o'clock in the morning. I do not care because it is important we live up to our responsibilities. It would be an awful pity if this Bill lapsed because we were not prepared to stick it out. There is a particular responsibility on people like myself who have spoken at length to stay here until the job is completed. I am prepared to do that.
However, I would like to ask the Minister about the question of visitors in Trinity. I asked whether it was "visitor" or "visitors" and the Minister said the existing situation remained intact. Should I assume that the method of appointment of the visitors by Trinity remains as it was previously?
Comment on this
That is a considerable reassurance. It would be idiotic to put it to a vote at this time of night. Perhaps someone else will. I am opposed to the section in principle. I will leave it at that because on this and the previous Stage of the Bill I have placed my difficulties with it on the record.
Comment on this
I remind you we are discussing Senator Lee's amendments, not the section.
Comment on this
I share the view that the contingency is remote. I do not know whether the Minister thinks the hassle involved in including this provision was worth it. It created enormous ill will in universities — more than any other provision in the Bill. It was perceived as an assumption of "guilty until proven innocent". This may not have been intended, but it is crucial in terms of perception. It gave rise to a degree of froth in responses which makes one wonder whether it was worth it.
I will not press these amendments and I appreciate what the Minister said about consulting the academic council. She went a little fast through her reply for my level of comprehension. It may be possible to obtain a copy of her reply between now and Report Stage to see exactly what she has in mind. She replied in a detailed manner, section by section and line by line. I did not quite follow all of it. I will not press my amendments. I want to express my continuing concern about getting it right, however remote the contingency.
Comment on this
I support this section. Nobody should be above being accountable and answerable to the taxpayer. I cannot envisage an objection coming from any member of the public to these arrangements. These provisions should apply to every educational institution from the most humble primary school to the most senior third level institution. It is crucial that there are constraints on the Minister's power although she does retain power.
I agree with many of the issues raised by Senator Lee and I draw particular attention to one of his amendments where he spoke about being able to remove part of the authority. Section 3(1) of the Third Schedule gives the authority the right to dismiss or remove some of its members. The Bill does not allow the Minister to remove certain members of the authority, as opposed to the removal of the entire authority.
Comment on this
I am not moving amendment No. 97 as I get confused at times as to whether "constituent university" refers to the National University of Ireland or other universities. I do not think this amendment is necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 99:
In page 21, between lines 11 and 12, to insert the following new subparagraph:
"(iv) the Chancellor of the University of Dublin or a person nominated by the Chancellor,".
This is a function which the Chancellor would normally perform in the tradition of the university and I think he would like to retain it. I hope the Minister will look favourably on the inclusion of the Chancellor as an officer who can act in this manner on behalf of the university. It would just involve adding a couple of lines at subparagraph 4. This would be in line with the history of the university and I think it would appreciate this.
Comment on this
I do not expect that there will be a commission for Trinity College. I am aware it is the intention of the college to draw up a private act which would deal directly with the issue of the composition of its governing board. This section would not apply to Trinity College but, given the concerns expressed by the Senators, I have no objection to the Chancellor of Trinity College being included in section 22 as a member of the commission for Trinity College. I intend to revisit the issue on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. If there is no intention to have a commission for Trinity College, can the Minister tell me why provision is made for this in the section? Is it to cover any eventuality that may arise? I welcome the fact that, even if his presence were only a titular and speculative one, the Chancellor would not be deprived of his brief moment of glory.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 100 and 101 are related and may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 100:
In page 21, subsection 2 (d) (i), line 14, to delete "such officers, and" and substitute "the chief officer and senior reporting academic officer, and such".
These amendments sharpen what is already contained in the subsection. The term "such officers" seems to me to be very loose and I would like to hear the Minister's opinion.
Comment on this
The effect of the first amendment would be that the chief officer would have to be a member of the commission and I have no difficulty accepting that. The second amendment stipulates that the Minister would have to discuss with the governing body which members would be on the commission and that is useful. I want to come back with some precise wording and I envisage that we will tighten this up, as the Senator suggested.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 102:
In page 21, subsection (5), line 30, after "determine" to insert "preferably by consensus, but if necessary by majority vote, the chairman to have a casting vote,".
I do not want to go into unnecessary detail here. Does the Minister feel that the amendment is undesirable or unnecessary? I will leave the matter to her judgment.
Comment on this
I do not think the amendment is necessary. I do not disagree with the intent of the amendment which seeks to ensure smooth decision making processes. However, each commission will be in a position to devise its own decision making processes and I do not think it is necessary to set them out in the Bill. We do not want prescriptive statute; I have not, for instance, specified who will chair the meetings. I think we agree on the spirit of this and I assure the Senator that this level of detail is not necessary.
Comment on this
I thought the Minister would reply to my earlier query but perhaps she wants to leave that until Report Stage. If there is not a commission envisaged for Trinity College, why is this provided for in the Bill? I would be happy to wait for a reply until Report Stage.
Comment on this
I do not expect this to happen as I expect that Trinity College will introduce a private Bill. There is a time limit of three years within which Trinity can come forward with such a Bill but, in the event of that not happening, the Chancellor may have his hour of glory.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but I think the Minister may take it that Trinity College is grateful that this possibility is being permitted. They would be extremely foolish not to come forward with a Bill within three years. I fully accept that there may be some pig ignorant, perverse and prejudiced people on the board but I do not think they are in the majority.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 106, 156 and 158 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 106:
In page 22, subsection (1), line 21 to delete paragraph (c).
I wondered about the point of putting guidelines in this section if they do not have to be observed.
What is the purpose of retaining this paragraph? In relation to amendment No. 156. I do not clearly understand the phrase "An tÚaras may, following consultation with all or any of the chief officers" as used in section 48(1). Does this refer to examining a particular institution with other chief officers being asked for their opinions? I presume this is not the case. However, the construction makes it unclear.
I tabled amendment No. 158 because it would be a useful pedagogic exercise for An tÚdaras to publicly explain why it reaches a particular decision and the response of the university. There is too little open and frank debate between institutions with different ideas on how universities ought to be run. My amendment urges the desirability of open debate on principles of university management and perceptions of their role in society. This type of debate is infrequent.
The formulation used in the Minister's introductory speech on Second Stage was that An tÚdaras would be an omniscient umbrella over the universities which would alert them to best practice at home and abroad. This role seems unlikely to coincide with reality. I expect universities will undertake much of this work themselves to stand their ground and debate their position not simply on the basis of provincialism but participate in an enlightening debate on wider issues. This is the principle behind the amendment.
Comment on this
Will Senator Lee explain what he means by "peccant" as used in amendment No. 158?
Comment on this
Section 48(1) speaks of universities departing from guidelines. This is deviant but it is not in contravention of any regulation — it is merely a deviation. Therefore, it is deviant behaviour but not sinful. Maybe this is an old fashioned formulation. I do not know if sin exists today.
Comment on this
I approve of amendment No. 158 because of the elegance of its phrasing. The nice distinction, in the 18th century sense, observed by the learned profesor between deviant and peccant is one that recommends itself to me as somebody who is deviant but rejects the notion of being peccant. This amendment must be accepted for the sake of the Bill's eloquence and style. I have no doubt that the attractive language will overwhelm the Minister.
Comment on this
As a further example, it may be said that Senator Kelly deviates from the norm and is therefore deviant by not standing when speaking in the House. However, while deviant, she is not peccant.
Comment on this
Section 48 covers guidelines which may be issued in relation to the numbers or grades of employees of a university or the proportion of a universities budget to be applied to different activities. The guidelines come within the support and developmental role of the Higher Education Authority which is also provided for in section 47 and outlined in more detail in the White Paper.
While the guidelines are non-binding, they will provide the Higher Education Authority and the universities with a formal opportunity for dialogue on important issues relating to management. They will also allow, in a formal and statutory manner, the dissemination of best practice nationally and internationally. While they are not mandatory, universities will have to have regard to such guidelines when deciding appointments by statute and may be challenged if it is felt they did not pay regard to them. The dissemination of good practice should not be limited and guidelines should be universal.
Amendment No. 158 was seen as intriguing. The Bill as published contained a number of provisions regarding the publication of views should a dispute arise. I agree that the provisions were not drafted with the eloquence of Senator Lee's amendment, but the Dáil considered it inappropriate to set out such a process and I consider the decision of that House most appropriate. I do not recommend acceptance of this amendment.
Comment on this
I am sceptical at the ability of any institution to determine with certainty what constitutes best practice nationally and internationally. There is great diversity among universities and it is extremely difficult to point to one institution of comparable type and prescribe that model for another institution. Acquiring the necessary degree of knowledge regarding the functioning of potentially model institutions and understanding their use of resources is challenging. It would require a detailed study of best practice, not simply anecdotal evidence. I do not know if we have the necessary research expertise. The model used by the Minister is one which might give a spurious impression of providing a marker against which the performance of Trinity College, UCD or DCU — very different institutions — can be measured. I hope there is no self-delusion about the possibility of conducting this type of exercise in an infallible manner. If we are to do this properly we need to invest significantly more resources. Identifying the best model for a particular institution, if not done properly, could be a dangerous exercise.
There is need for an informed debate to which AntÚdaras and individual institutions could contribute. We would all gain from this. Leaving aside the gracious tributes to the language of the amendments, they raise serious, substantive points regarding the manner in which the performance of individual universities and the university system can be improved, namely, how and what we can learn and how we can most effectively apply what is learned.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 106a:
In page 22, subsection (1), between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following new paragraph:
"(d) the necessity to ensure that it has in its employment an adequate number of staff to enable the university to provide its services through Irish and English.".
This amendment does not achieve what I intended and it has huge cost implications. Because it is incorrectly drafted I wish to withdraw it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 107:
In page 22, subsection (2), lines 22 and 23, to delete "such conditions as it thinks fit" and substitute "the statutes of the university".
This amendment would tighten and strengthen the legislation.
Comment on this
This would not necessarily be the case. Universities will not be able to act in any way which would not be in accordance with their statutes. The amendment is, therefore, unnecessary.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos 111, 111a, 114 and 116 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 111:
In page 22, subsection (6), line 50, after "officer" to insert:
",and which statute should provide for tenure of officers".
I move the amendment on behalf of Senator Norris, but I hope he does not return in fury.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 116 is in the Senator's name.
Comment on this
It has been explained to me that the implications of amendment No. 116 go far beyond what I had in mind.
Comment on this
Is the Senator pressing amendment No. 111?
Comment on this
If Senator Norris does not appear in a second, I will withdraw that amendment. The Senator can re-enter it and amendment No. 114 on Report Stage if necessary. I also intend to withdraw amendment No. 116 on the basis of clarification I received.
Comment on this
The purpose of amendment No. 111a is to establish for employees of the University of Limerick and Dublin City University that the dismissal authority will continue to be the Minister for Education. This matter is of concern to the employees, but I will listen to the Minister's views before I elaborate on it.
Comment on this
The position under the Bill is that the rights and entitlements of current employees are retained. If the governing bodies of Dublin City University or the University of Limerick wish to dismiss a member of staff, they require the consent of the Minister. Employees will continue to have that protection. Following the passage of the Bill, universities, as part of the autonomy conferred on them by the legislation, will have full control over their staff, subject to the position in the University of Limerick and Dublin City University.
A Minister should not have any role in the appointment or dismissal of members of staff of a university. It is important that universities are autonomous. Older universities have enjoyed autonomy since their foundation and the newest university, the NUI in Maynooth, will now also enjoy that position. It would not be in the interest of the universities concerned or their staffs if they were singled out in this manner. Staff, through their unions and associations, will have a central role in the procedures for removal from office, and the fears which may have prompted the amendment will prove to be groundless. The rights and entitlements of current employees of Dublin City University and the University of Limerick are protected.
Comment on this
I understand, while I was momentarily absent, that amendment No. 111 was withdrawn. However, I presume I can re-enter it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 118:
In page 23, subsection (2) (d), line 41, to delete "and exclusion".
The amendment seeks clarification of the term "exclusion" in the subsection. It could be taken to mean the general exclusion of categories but I presume it means expulsion. Does it cover people who are not allowed to return to university after they failed examinations?
Comment on this
Yes. The provision will ensure transparency in university procedures in such matters and that is why it should be retained.
Comment on this
I have no problem with the principle. I just wanted to ensure that I correctly understood the provision.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 119:
In page 24, subsection (2)(f), line 2, after "awards" to insert "to students".
Scholarships, bursaries, prizes or other awards are usually made to students, but fellowships are a much vaguer category. If the provision applied to the appointment of staff, I assume it would require confirmation by the governing authority. What is the position if a demarcation dispute arose between an academic council and a governing authority?
Comment on this
I do not favour limiting the functions of a governing authority. There may be cases where a university gives fellowships, scholarships, bursaries, prizes or other awards to people other than students. I accept they are usually made to students, but a special award could be made to a member of the academic staff to engage in post doctoral studies abroad. The provision should not be too restrictive. The Senator should not worry.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 122 and 123 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 122:
In page 24, subsection (1), lines 16 and 17, to delete "members from what, in the opinion of the governing authority, is an appropriate range of academic disciplines in the university" and substitute "all professors, associate professors, and heads of all academic departments in the university".
I indicated on Second Stage that this matter is of concern to me. I will not repeat the arguments I made then but the more I thought about it, the more convinced I became about the importance of trying to ensure that membership of an academic council does not become an occasion for internal conflict or decision making from an academic political perspective. I could go on at length but I will not do so. What way is the Minister's mind moving? I will await her comments because if I started to discuss this matter in detail, I would continue for some time.
Comment on this
I would wait for some time to hear the Senator's views. The amendments relate to members of the academic staff. I will introduce an amendment on Report Stage regarding amendment No. 122. I indicated earlier that I am open to teasing out this matter further. Following discussions with the Senator, it will be possible to meet his concerns.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 124 and 125 are related and may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 124:
In page 24, subsection (3), line 30, after "officer", to insert "and the senior officer of the university having responsibility for academic affairs".
The senior officer having responsibility to the chief officer for academic affairs should be ex officio a member of an acadmic council. Apart from the president, he is the main academic officer in the institution. The academic council is entrusted with basic responsibility for the development of the academic orientation. Both in principle and operationally I find it inconceivable that the officer in question would not be ex officio a member of such a council.
Comment on this
This amendment would have the effect of giving the registrar automatic membership of the council. I had hoped that each university would decide for itself that the registrar would be a member of the council, but if the House wishes to make this a requirement I will not oppose it. I am trying not to impose regulations.
Comment on this
I wish to press the point. This may appear a minor issue to those not involved in the operation of a university but it is potentially serious.
Comment on this
As long as I will not be blamed for being too prescriptive and that Senator Lee will accept that accusation, I am prepared to return on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I am willing to face the accusation. I think the minister.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 129 and 130 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 129:
In page 25, subsection (2), line 32 and 33, to delete "in such manner as it thinks appropriate,".
Guidance should be given, but the governing authority will know what is the decent thing to do. I am prepared to withdraw these amendments.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 131 and 132 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 131:
In page 27, subsection (1), line 4, after "university" to insert "having regard to the resources available to the university,".
This deals with planning and evaluation. Section 32(1) states: "A governing authority shall, as soon as practicable... require the chief officer to prepare a plan". I am puzzled that the requirement imposed on the chief officer is to prepare a plan setting out aims, etc., but when the governing authority assesses the plan it must have "regard to the resources available to the university". This implies that the planning could be done in an abstract way without regard to resources, but the evaluation of the plan will take the resources into account. I may be told that the plan must by definition have regard to resources, but as the provision stands the explicit injunction to have regard to the resources available to the university only applies at the evaluation stage. How does the Minister envisage the planning process if the resources constraint is not incorporated in the plan from the outset?
Comment on this
There is an error in line 1 of amendment No. 132. The word "from" should be deleted.
Comment on this
The chief officer must always act subject to the policy of the governing authority and shall be answerable to the authority. When he starts to draw up the plan he is doing so on behalf of the authority — paragraph 2 of the Fourth Schedule provides for this. Section 17(1) provides that the functions of the governing authority shall be within the constraints of the overall budget of the university. I bow to the Senator's experience, because I have not been on a governing authority, but I have been on boards which have drawn up a wish list but found that what was recommended was impossible to do within the constraints of the budget. I do not think we need this amendment. It is clear that a university must act within its budget. Section 32(2) merely requires that a strategic development plan must have regard to the resources available to the university. It is not necessary to repeat that in the provision concerning the chief officer. We must accept and not even question that the chief officer would look at all the potential resources of the university in drawing up a plan and would do so on behalf of the governing authority.
Comment on this
If the Minister is satisfied that it is implicit without having to be implicitly stated, I am satisfied also.
Comment on this
Is it required under this section that a chief officer prepare a three year plan? Is that a practical requirement?
Comment on this
It has been indicated to me that it would happen. The Minister for Finance is desperately trying to introduce the concept of multi-annual budgeting to all Departments. It has been agreed that, given the span of study requirement, a three year plan rather than a one year plan is acceptable to the universities.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 133 to 137, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 133:
In page 27, subsection (1), line 17, after "procedures" to insert "having regard to the resources available".
Section 33 (1) provides:
A governing authority ... shall... require the chief officer to establish procedures for quality assurance aimed at improving the quality of education...
The biggest, although not the only constraint, on universities doing these things is resources, as it is with most other institutions. Resources can be misused, but if one does not have them in the first place one cannot misuse them. Particularly where assessment, publication of assessment, etc., are involved, there is potential for misleading impressions to be conveyed to the public if evaluations are carried out without explicit reference to the resources available. If the resources available had been taken into account, one might see that a good job was being done. This is different to my earlier amendments concerning the chief officer.
The Education Bill contains a similar provision. It mentions that inspectors will carry out reviews of schools and individual teachers, and there is a later reference to the resources available. No evaluation ought to take place without explicit reference to the resources available to those being evaluated to discharge their responsibilities. Every evaluation should be made in the context of the available resources. That is why I am puzzled by the disjunction between evaluation on one hand and the later evaluation of the evaluations on the other, taking resources into account only at that stage.
Comment on this
I do not see why the Bill should state that the procedures the chief officer would draw up for quality assurance would have to have regard to resources. The procedures themselves would, inter alia, relate to the manner of evaluations and the assessment by students. I do not think it is necessary to include that here.
Amendment No. 134 would result in the evaluation of faculties only as appropriate, to which I would not object. Therefore, I will look further at that to find the correct language to use. I do not consider amendment No. 135 necessary. Those who would have to evaluate quality would have to be able to evaluate quality having regard to resources.
I do not think amendment No. 136 is necessary as it could not be expected that those availing of the services would be given information in advance of the exact resources. We could put in place here a recipe for extremely useless management of the time of university staff who would then have to provide the information.
Amendment No. 137 is very interesting. However, I remind the Senator that under the Bill universities now have a free hand in the internal allocation of resources. Therefore, in the identification of further resources which might be needed for the implementation of findings it would be appropriate that the governing authority would seek to find the resources, in addition to further resources from the HEA, if appropriate.
There may be cost factors associated with implementing the procedures. I consider the section deals with this. The governing authority is required to implement the findings of the procedures only when they are reasonable and practical, and to have regard to available resources in so doing. I have already signalled that I intend to table an amendment to subsection (2) on Report Stage to replace the plural word "provisions" in line 29 with "provision".
Comment on this
I am grateful to the Minister. It is now stitched into the record that these amendments are unnecessary because it is assumed they are an integral part of the procedure at the outset. That is useful.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 139, 139a and 140 are related to amendment No. 138, although amendment No. 139a has been withdrawn, and all may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 138:
In page 28, subsection (1) (a), line 4, after "university" to insert "having regard to the resources available".
I assume the Minister's reasoning will be the same in reply to this amendment, in which case I will withdraw it.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 143, 155 and 157 are related to amendment No. 141 and all may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 141:
In page 28, subsection (1), line 29, after "university" to insert "with reference to all moneys voted by the Oireachtas".
I would welcome a brief clarification of this from the Minister. What accounting or reporting procedure is involved with moneys from outside the Oireachtas? How do such moneys relate to State funding in terms of finance, property and reporting?
Comment on this
I am also concerned that moneys, apart from State funding, will not have to be accounted for in the statements which will have to be submitted to An tÚdarás.
Comment on this
This section merely gives statutory recognition to existing practices. Private university trusts and funds do not come under public scrutiny in this legislation. Under the Bill the Higher Education Authority will not have access to information on private trusts and funds. It will only have access to information which is at present provided by the universities. Information that is provided on a non-statutory basis for most of the universities includes the accounts of their annual income from all sources, private and public, and their expenditures. Section 37 ensures this is the case. I do not recommend the acceptance of the amendment because I reassure the Senator we are talking only about public funds.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 142:
In page 28, subsection (1), line 29, after "year" to insert "in the context of a three year budgetary framework, or any change in the government budgetary procedures".
This returns to the question of three years. I will be guided by what the Minister chooses to say in that regard.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 145 is related to amendment No. 144 and both may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 144:
In page 29, subsection (1), lines 48 and 49, to delete "not exceeding three years" and substitute "not being less than three years".
Under section 32(1) the chief officer shall draw up a plan for a period "not less than three years". Under this subsection the chief officer shall, having regard to the strategic plan, "as soon as is practicable after the end of each period, not exceeding three years" prepare a report. I presume they have the same meaning, but one is from below and the other is from above. If my understanding of that is correct the amendment would make the drafting more consistent.
Comment on this
Three years is a reasonable amount of time, given the public interest in the universities. Amendment No. 144 would have the effect of enabling the universities to report after four, ten or 100 years, as they decided. That is too open-ended.
It is not necessary to insert the phrase "having regard to the resources available" as proposed in amendment No. 145 because this would necessarily be the case when looking at the operations and performance of the university. Therefore, one amendment is not needed and the other is over prescriptive.
Comment on this
Am I misreading the disjunction between the phrases "not exceeding three years" and "not being less than three years"?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 146:
In page 30, subsection (3), line 19, to delete all words from and including "Oireachtas" in line 19 down to and including "Authority" in line 25, and substitute "the university and the Minister shall consult as to the manner most conductive to the continued achievement of the objects of a university, including the manner in which the university shall compensate the State for the continued use of the land or other assets acquired, developed or refurbished by the university with moneys provided by the Oireachtas.".
This issue may seem remote but it is in the Bill. What happens if a university goes in a primarily private direction? As the section stands, it seems to suggest a fairly abrupt and not very cordial divorce. I am trying to suggest a mechanism for a more cordial or orderly disengagement or continuing the relationship in a more distant way. I do not know if it is worthwhile pursuing this but the question may arise if a university ceases to be funded substantially — which, I presume, means more than half — from public moneys. That could happen, so I need clarification on it.
Comment on this
Where the land and buildings, or their development or refurbishment, have been funded from public moneys it is appropriate that any such moneys would be refunded in the event of a sale or transfer to a private body. The section ensures this will be the case, subject to agreement between the Minister and the governing authority, where the moneys were provided after the date of the passing of the Bill.
There is a provision for arbitration where disengagement may occur too abruptly and where agreement cannot be reached. This will allow time for both sides to be heard. If the university were to decide to seek funds otherwise, there would be a large number of issues involved, not least the protection of the interest of the students and the public interest generally. The section should not attempt to set out how universities should relate to the State if they cease to receive State funding, rather it enshrines the right of the State to have some of its investment returned.
The detailed issues of the protection of the interest of the students and the public interest generally may well be a matter for future legislation, should the need arise. I am inserting a safeguard for the State's protection. The Bill deals with those universities in receipt of State funding through the HEA.
Comment on this
The tone of the Bill suggests that this is an undesirable development; it requires a somewhat frosty reaction. I am trying to envisage a situation where one may decide to develop in that direction, rather than have it happen against one's will.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 148 is related to amendment No. 147 and both may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 147:
In page 32, line 38, to delete paragraph (b).
This section amends sections of the Irish Universities Act, 1908, for obvious reasons. However, section 44, paragraph (b) proposes to delete section 3(2) and (3), while paragraph (d) proposes to delete part of section 7(4) of the 1908 Act.
Section 3(1) of the 1908 Act, which is to be retained, states:
No test whatever of religious belief shall be imposed on any person as a condition of his becoming or continuing to be a professor, lecturer, fellow,... in, either of the two universities, or any constituent college;...
Section 3(2), which it is proposed to delete, states:
Every professor upon entering into office shall sign a declaration in a form approved by the Commissioners jointly under this Act, securing the respectful treatment of the religious opinions of any of his class.
I discussed the issue of religious opinion and ethos in this House over the past two to three months. While I do not accord a great value to consistency, in everything I have attempted in this area I have attempted to value and respect the ethos of beliefs. It may be argued that this provision has fallen into misuse; nobody wants to compel people to sign forms. It should be the professional responsibility of any teacher at any level to respect ethos, which I argued when we debated section 37 of the Employment Equality Bill.
However, in this instance it is proposed to delete a subsection and not replace it with anything. There can be no justification for that. The House would accept that teachers should be respectful of the religious opinions of members of their class. It may not be necessary to say it, but it has been provided for by this subsection and it should have been retained.
Section 3(3) of the 1908 Act states:
Nothing in this section shall apply to any professor of or lecturer in theology or divinity; provided that no test of religious belief shall be imposed by the governing body of either of the two universities... on any such professor or lecturer as a condition of his appointment or recognition by the governing body...
I recognise that this is a different aspect but the fact that there was not a religious test since 1908, while now allowing for the inclusion of such a test, raises issues which the Minister must explain.
Section 44(d) provides for a change to section 7(4) of the 1908 Act, which states:
Any sums paid under this section shall be applied by the governing body of the university or college, as the case may be, in accordance with their charter or statutes, but no such sum shall be applied for the provision or maintenance of any church, chapel, or other place of religious worship or observance,...
This is being retained because the Constitution prohibits the State from endowing any religion. However, it is proposed to delete that part of the subsection which provides that money could not be allowed"... for the provision or maintenance of any... theological or religious teaching or study". This will allow for the use of taxpayer's money in this area.
The subsequent paragraph to the subsection states:
Provided that nothing in this provision shall prevent the recognition by the governing body of the university of any professor of or lecturer in theology or divinity as a professor of the university so long as the professorship is founded and maintained entirely by means of private benefaction, [hitherto, the State could not support the establishment of professorships of theology or divinity; it had to be supported by private benefaction] or the use of any building belonging to the university or college for any teaching given by such professor, or for any other religious teaching no part of the cost of which is defrayed out of public funds. But no student shall be compelled to attend any such theological teaching, or religious instruction,...
Why is it proposed to delete this? It is a very complicated section and I do not know the reasoning behind it. Why was it considered necessary to proceed in this way? Does it now mean that the State is signalling that professors do not need to be respectful of the religious opinions of their students? Does it mean that taxpayers' money can now be used for matters to do with religion, which are specifically excluded under the 1908 Act? Is this the proper way to proceed?
Comment on this
I am concerned if Senator O'Toole is correct. I am sure that it is the intention of the Minister and her advisers that religious difference will be respected. Trinity College used to inquire about the religious denomination of undergraduates on registration. I am glad that, as far as I am aware, the practice has ceased. Although I believe in the complete separation of Church and State and so on, I would be sorry if a difficulty was caused, for example, in architectural terms with the preservation of the chapel in Trinity College, particularly since it is now fully denominational and ecumencial and is available for use to different Christian denominations. It would be a pity if there was an alteration which prevented Trinity using its resources to maintain the fabric of that building appropriately and properly. I assume some of the difficulty comes about because there are differences between the ways in which the Royal University and Trinity were established.
There is a faculty of theology in Trinity but it is not denominational. It is no longer a school of divinity and there is no longer a Regius professor of divinity. There is a distinguished professor of theology who is a former Roman Catholic priest, which is to be welcomed. I would like to think it were possible to have a properly constituted faculty of theology, although it would be inappropriate in modern university terms to have a department funded by the State simply being used for the preparations of ordinants for one particular sect.
Comment on this
The NUI accepted this amendment. There will not be any difference in the conditions applying to the employment of staff between the constituent colleges and the other universities. The Employment Equality Bill, 1996, and the Equal Status Bill, 1997, will ensure respectful treatment of staff and students in equality of employment. It could be argued that the reference to religious opinions reflected a certain preoccupation at the time with the passage of this Bill. A modern statement of these issues would involve a much wider equality policy, as is covered in section 34 of the Bill and in the other Bills. With the passage of the Bill, professors will no longer be centrally appointed by the senate of the NUI, but by individual colleges. Therefore, a central role for the NUI would be inconsistent. One of the core principles underlying the introduction of the legislation was to update it according to the wishes of the NUI, which I took on board. I will consult further on that section.
I prefer to pursue the rationale with regard to the second section. The NUI also requested this amendment. This is not being included without its knowledge. There will be no difference in the conditions applying to the teaching of religion and theology between the constituent universities and other universities. In Trinity, theology and religion can be taught, but they cannot under the NUI proposals. The Constitution provides that the State cannot endow religion, but this does not mean that religion cannot be taught in universities. Even if it were unconstitutional for the State to fund the teaching of religion, the removal of a legislative bar from such funding would not be unconstitutional; the funding would be.
The provisions in the Employment Equality Bill, 1996, will provide comprehensive and modern anti-discrimination provisions. The amendments were proposed by the NUI to level the playing pitch so that there would be no difference in the conditions applying to the employment of staff and the teaching of religion and theology between the constituent universities and other universities.
Comment on this
The Minister referred to the question of constitutionality in terms of the funding of professorships of divinity and so forth. Does the faculty of theology in Trinity come under that heading and cannot be funded by moneys which are at least derived in part from the State and have to be taken from the college's endowments? I am happy with the principle of separation of Church and State as it is not appropriate that the State should be expected to fund the teaching and promotion of one sectarian point of view, but at the same time it would be regrettable if the practice of the teaching of theology in a university such as Trinity were adversely affected by a lack of funds.
Comment on this
That is a reasonable explanation of the first two sections of the Equal Status Bill, 1997. If I were a professor I would find it offensive to be asked to sign a document to say I would respect the ethos and beliefs of the people attending lectures. If we are removing a section from the 1908 Act and if that issue will be dealt with in the Equal Status Bill, I will be much happier. Teachers at any level have a professional responsibility to be respectful of religious beliefs. I was worried that this was being taken out, and it seemed to be sending out the wrong signal.
I am not clear on amendment No. 148. There are complications involved. A private subvention was required for the establishment of the chair for Professor O'Doherty in UCD. My union was involved. I do not understand what is the impact of removing that section. Nobody will argue against providing a level playing pitch. Is there a danger that colleges will be required to spend money they do not have to match Trinity? What are the consequences of this proposal? No student should be compelled to attend any such theological teaching. I presume the reason that is being removed is that it would not arise. Some professorships of the type referred to, which until now had to be maintained by private benefaction, will be paid out of public moneys. That is a significant change.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 148 is easy to understand. The 1908 legislation prohibits the teaching of religion and it applies to the NUI. The prohibition on the teaching of religion will be gone. We have long looked to Trinity College for the teaching of theology at university level and now it will be available in the constituent colleges of the NUI. I will have to come back and clarify the matter of funding, but this section relates to the teaching of theology. The example given was of Trinity College.
Comment on this
I welcome the information that the prohibition on teaching religion in the constituent colleges of the NUI is to be abolished. Many people will welcome that, though what will emerge subsequently is a different matter.
Comment on this
I have learned a lot from this discussion and am glad I raised the matter. This was one section of the Bill that concerned me and it is on the record. Religion and theology are very valid areas of study.
Comment on this
I am glad Senator O'Toole raised this matter, as I would not have seen it. I am also glad that the Minister clarified that religious differences would be respected.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister's comments as they illustrated the difference between teaching divinity as the proclaimed view of one Church, which was the situation in Trinity until 15 or 20 years ago. The intellectual discipline of theology has been greatly strengthened and improved by the introduction of people like Seán Freyne and other distinguished Roman Catholic theologians to the teaching staff. That would have been unthinkable and impossible when the divinity school in Trinity was the province of the Church of Ireland.
I hope it will also be possible to refurbish and maintain the college chapel. It is available to all students and is part of the architectural tradition of the college. If they all became atheists it should still be maintained. On Report Stage I will raise the possibility of a constitutional bar on the college using funding for the retention of the function of the chapel. The building does not appeal to me — it is a gaunt Hanoverian barn — but it is an integral part of the complex of 18th century buildings and should be maintained.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 149 should read "from and including `and"' in line 6. Is that agreed? Agreed. Amendments Nos. 150, 151 and 152 are related. Amendments Nos. 149 to 152, inclusive, to be taken together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 149:
In page 33, subsection (2), to delete all words from and including "and" in line 6 down to and including "review" in line 9.
Is this the most useful relationship one could have between the new senate of the NUI and the individual colleges? I do not see the rationale for it or for doing anything that an individual college cannot do. There is potential for friction in one body acting as external examiner of another. This will create more problems than it will resolve. If requirements for external examining and other matters are necessary, this is not the most effective way to go about them or the one most conducive to harmony in the university. That is the reason for my concern at the list of rights of the senate over the constituent universities.
Comment on this
These amendments delete the possible role of the NUI in establishing committees for reviewing the content and teaching of courses and appointing external examiners to assist in such a review. I was asked by the NUI to include such a potential role for the NUI in the Bill, and it is quite similar to the potential role for the board of studies, which the NUI asked me to delete. One goes out and the other comes in. I cannot support the deletion of this role because I have given the NUI a commitment to support this. It is what the NUI wants to be empowered to do by legislation and I do not want to recommend dismissal of that view.
Comment on this
Many of these things need to be done along the line and I have no problem with that. However, it is unlikely to be conducive to fostering the best possible relations or review system, though that is a judgement call.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 153:
In page 33, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following new subsection:
"(5) The Senate shall foster basic, strategic and applied research into the role of the university in society.".
This is a slightly different linkage. I have long argued about how little research the universities do on universities. They research everything else but do remarkably little research on the university in society or the economy. We have fine Departments of Education but they are concerned with earlier stages of the educational stage. A role for the senate in fostering research would be useful, but if it does not see itself in that role, perhaps that should not be wished upon it. However, the lack of research into the university's role in society is a glaring lacuna.
Comment on this
The suggestion is too specific. This legislation should not set out the precise research priorities of the constituent universities or any of the other universities. An amendment such as this could cut across academic freedom, and surely an institution would decide on issues like this itself. I cannot accept the amendment in the interests of academic freedom.
Comment on this
How long do we have? I was referring to the senate, an institution responsible for the university rather than individual universities. There ought to be an incentive provided by those concerned with university policy for research in that area. Second, an incentive ought to be provided by those concerned with university and higher education policy for research in the higher education area. The way universities have neglected research into universities verges on the scandalous. Universities are major institutions in society which, were they anything other than universities, we would expect universities to be researching and they do not research themselves. I accept the Minister's solicitude for academic freedom. My heart beats equally passionately for it. We will continue researchless into the new millennium.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 159. A closed bracket should appear after "described" in this amendment. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 159:
In page 34, subsection (1) line 31, to delete from "(in which case it may continue to be so described),".
It seems that the phrase "in which case it may continue to be so described" implies that the Minister could not only recognise new universities but derecognise old ones in which case it may continue to be so described. I am sure that was not the intention. Why is it necessary to include that? Is there a specific reason?
Comment on this
I am not sure of the precise technical effect of accepting this amendment but the phrase in brackets is there to outline that the Bill cannot affect any institution using the title university before the publication of the Bill. I not think that the intent of the Senator would be to affect such an institution. If that is the intent, it would be challengeable in any case so I do not favour this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 160:
In page 36, paragraph (3), line 4, to delete "six" and substitute "twelve".
The meetings of governing bodies of universities are highly seasonal. There may be only two meetings in the six months between May and October. The Bill does not state the number of meetings there are to be, but it struck me that it would be a little harsh for somebody who missed two meetings over a six months period to find themselves removed unless they remembered to send in apologies or whatever is intended. Is simply accepting an apology for absence meant to be approving? If that is the case, there is no problem.
Comment on this
The effect of the amendment would be to allow a member of a governing body not to turn up at any meetings for nearly a year and the subsection, as it stands, is flexible enough. A person must not be absent for more than six months other than for illness or with the specific provision of the governing authority. It is only to keep the lines of communication open between members of a governing authority.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 161:
In page 36, paragraph (5) (i), line 24, after "occasioned" to insert "at its first meeting subsequent to the vacancy occurring.".
The purpose of this amendment is to keep movement going because one can find situations where it might be in the interest of somebody to keep a place empty for a while where a key election was coming up, for instance.
Comment on this
I am certainly learning a great deal about the motives of people who serve on governing bodies but,——
Comment on this
——given the Senator's great experience, I suggest we will return to this on Report Stage and perhaps be ready to insert "as soon as practicable".
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 163 and 164 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 163:
In page 37, paragraph (8) (2), line 20, to delete "related" and substitute "aware of being related".
Amendment No. 163 has earned me a reputation for being pessimistic. Nothing could be further from the truth. To preserve the reputation for absolute straightness, I shall withdraw that amendment.
Amendment No. 164 is a little different. I do not know the standard practice but if, in fact, somebody is related, I do not see why a governing authority should have the right to keep them on an appointments committee, for instance. If a person is a relation — I do not know how close the relationship must be; is it brothers or cousins? — I would not give the governing authority the right to decide to let somebody on an appointments board in those circumstances. They should not serve automatically.
Comment on this
A provision allowing a governing authority to have some discretion is not necessary. There is every possibility that the candidates may be related to a member of the governing authority in a close or distant way. In allowing the discretion, the section allows the governing authority to look at each additional case.
The amendment proposed to insert "aware of being related". Surely it would be the case that somebody can only declare that they are related to someone else if they are aware of the fact. I think we are down to the semantics of the hour of the morning. It is my considered opinion that the amendment is unnecessary.
Comment on this
I am a little more concerned about amendment No. 164 but I will not press it.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 165 is in the name of Senator Henry. Amendment No. 166 is an alternative. Therefore amendments Nos. 165 and 166 may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 165:
In page 37, paragraph 8(3), line 29, after "interest." to insert "This section shall place no restriction on the right of staff, student or alumni members of a governing authority from representing the views of those who elect them. Nor shall it restrict such representatives from expressing any views at odds with the views of a governing authority or the executive."
Senator Henry gave me permission to move any amendments for her so that they may be reinserted on Report Stage.
Comment on this
There was much debate on the question of representation by different bodies on the governing body. The Bill states in page 37, lines 27 to 29, that a "member of a governing authority of a university shall at all times act, as a member, in the best interests of the university and shall not act as a representative of any special interest". Does the representative have the right to report back to the body which he or she represents on the governing body? If not, is there not a restriction which should not be placed upon them if they are representing a particular body on the governing body of the university?
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Sherlock, particularly when a student, for example, who is elected by the students, needs to air an issue before the board but also needs to report back to the sutudent body to allay any fears which may exist. If it is interpreted as narrowly as it can be, it will muzzle the students or other staff members who have a disagreement with the way the university is run.
Comment on this
Having formally moved the amendment on behalf of Senator Henry, I join with other Members in the general feeling of support from both the Government and Opposition sides of the House. The principle is a question of freedom of expression. I can envisage a number of instances, although nobody could quarrel with the phrase "in the best interests of the university". That is fair enough, but why should there be a complete chorus of unanimity? Why should a dissenting voice not be raised? Why should special interests of some kind not be expressed which are valid, worthy, and although a special interest, may be in the long-term in the best interests of the university?
The general ethos of the Bill will be strengthened by accepting the principle of the right to freedom of expression even of a minority or dissenting viewpoint. Everyone would accept that the best interests of the university should be served but it may be acting in the best interests of the university to express a dissenting voice. I would hate to think that some kind of homogenised orthodoxy was being imposed under this section of the Bill.
Comment on this
I agree with the points that have been made. There should be freedom of expression. The purpose of having a student representing the student body is to relay whatever information is necessary. It must be in the best interests both of the university and the student body but we must be fair in our reporting. That is very important.
Comment on this
This issue was first raised by Senator O'Sullivan and Senator Kelly. Senator Lee proposed the amendment which addressed the same concerns. It was never the intention of the Bill to muzzle anybody. The idea of democratising the governing authorities was to draw in people with a variety of experience and backgrounds, be they lords mayor or whatever. The Bill seeks to avoid the position that any member, having expressed his or her views, might then act on behalf of special interests at the expense of the vested interests of the university.
I have served on a limited number of boards where normal procedures provide for confidentiality concerning discussions. However, there is no muzzle on people expressing views. The normal representation role exists. I want to strike a balance and I have said I will look at the issue on Report Stage.
The second part of Senator Lee's amendment No. 166 states that "all members of the governing authority shall have equal rights of participation on all issues at all meetings of the governing authority". I would have thought that this would necessarily be the case but if there is a genuine concern that it is not the case we will come back to it also. Freedom of expression is provided for and normal procedures of confidentiality apply to all members, not just students. They would have to be reasonable and would have to be adopted.
There is a technical difficulty about subsection 13 relating to the actions of a governing authority if it subsequently discovered that a member had been incorrectly elected or appointed. I will come back to that.
Comment on this
I wish to make a point concerning capitation and the dispersment of moneys by the central college authorities, involving the recognition of a student society. It may be that a student society would be unpopular with either the conservative or liberal wings of a university. It might be outside the scope of the broad middle ground but at the same time it may well be in the best interests of fostering diversity in the university that the viewpoint be strongly represented at the board. As presently formulated that would be improper because the section states: "no special interests shall be represented". In a healthy debate there are occasions on which a special interest may properly be represented in circumstances where, for example, a club or an association within the university, which is not popular with some members of the administration, comes up for recognition. Subsection (3) could be construed as muzzling anybody who wanted to speak on behalf of that society or group and that would be a pity. At the same time, of course, nobody would challenge the proper nature of the requirement to act in the best interests of the university. However, as presently constituted, it is too restricted and would not allow for the kind of situation I envisage. I could give some examples but it might be rather boring and dull. The Minister probably accepts the principle and will look into that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 167:
In page 37, paragraph (10)(1), line 36, to delete "the chairperson" and substitute "it".
The authority rather than the chairperson should determine the number of meetings. It can be proposed by the chairperson but it ought to be agreed by the governing authority. That allows for much more harmonious conduct. Paragraph (10)(2) states that: "the chairperson shall convene a meeting whenever requested to do so by not less than the number of members who constitute a quorum". I would have thought that would be largely subsumed under the governing authority itself determining how many meetings it needed to have annually.
Comment on this
Very often when legislation of this nature is passed the local administrative body, which is the authority, would have standing orders. However, there is no provision for standing orders in the legislation. The point is relevant.
Is there a restriction on reporting the proceedings of the authority? If so, who has any authority to give information? We are talking about a substantial investment of public moneys in a very representative body.
Comment on this
Section 15 states that "subject to this Act the governing authority of a university may make from time to time such regulations as it thinks fit for the conduct of the affairs of the university". The standing orders are there. In saying that, the governing authority rather than the chairperson would decide when the governing authority meetings are to be held. We have already had a suggestion from Senator Lee that people might only meet every six months. There could be a major problem if some issue arose three weeks before the next meeting the governing authority had decided upon. We were not giving a mechanism for arranging a meeting at short notice. This is to allow such meetings. The power of the chairperson would give that flexibility because there may be a gap between scheduled meetings of the governing body. It is a mechanism which is being used instead to allow meetings to be arranged at short notice.
Comment on this
It is potentially a more substantive issue than it may appear. If questions of tension arose between any substantial number of members of the governing authority and the chairperson, these can be used in the interests of one or other groupings. I will not press the amendment. I can see the point the Minister makes. I may try to come back to it briefly on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 168:
In page 38, paragraph (12), lines 8 to 9, to delete "in the opinion of the chairperson or other person presiding consensus is not possible", and substitute "a vote is demanded by a majority of the members present and voting".
This comes down to the balance between the chair and the governing authority. Paragraph (12) states: "Every question at a meeting of a governing authority shall be determined by consensus". I remind the Minister that she thought my earlier amendment on how the commission would determine its conclusions was too prescriptive. This is a prescriptive model for a governing authority. I am not opposing that, but the amendment suggests that the meeting should decide on a voting basis whether there should be an agreement and then it should proceed by decision of the meeting rather than "in the opinion of the chairperson" which, in contentious situations, could be contrary to the views of a majority of those present.
Comment on this
Senator Lee's amendment would alter the manner in which a decision was made to have a vote. We could land ourselves in trouble about who could call for a vote to be taken to decide if there should be a vote. The Schedule is clear enough as it stands.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 169 and 170 are related and may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 169:
In page 39, paragraph (7), line 2, after "officer" to insert "currently in office".
Perhaps we should introduce a degree of flexibility into the length of time a chief officer can hold office. Ten years is mentioned in the Schedule but perhaps the office might be more attractive to candidates if there was an option of resigning after seven years on appropriate terms so they were not faced with a ten year stint with no possibility of change. I remember the ten year period being discussed in my college when it was introduced and there was much support for seven rather than ten years. No one raised the possibility of ten years with an option of leaving after seven years or between the seventh and the tenth year. The question of recruitment to and exit or resignation from a position is important in terms of quality of university performance.
Comment on this
I would prefer not to accept the amendment. The conditions of service of existing staff cannot be worsened by the legislation. The insertion of a particular term of office for existing chief officer, where it differs from their present term, cannot be accepted because we have already moved forward by not disturbing the conditions of those in situ. The Bill provides that future chief officers serve for ten years. The Senator mentioned seven years, but more than ten years would kill anyone. The universities sought a ten year period and I have no reason to recommend otherwise.
Comment on this
There is no question of inserting "currently in office".
Comment on this
The universities sought a ten year period because that is what they are comfortable with. A Secretary of a Department is appointed for seven years. There is scope for more flexibility because these are issues of substance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 171:
In page 39, line 31, after "Finance" to insert "except in the case of a university or universities which have a funded pension with appointed trustees, in accordance with existing pension legislation".
This deals with the question of superannuation, pensions, gratuities, etc. The Schedule states that if there is a dispute between the recipient and the source of the pension about the amount, it should be referred to An tÚdarás. My amendment states that there should be an exception where there is an existing "funded pension with appointed trustees, in accordance with existing pension legislation". The existing arrangement, which is legal, should not be disturbed.
I am a member of a pension fund in Trinity College which is part of a commercial deal with an insurance company. I am on semi-permanent disability benefit, but I have been hounded by these people. They have written to me stating that I am still involved in public life. I have replied by stating that one of my colleagues was in a wheelchair, so would they suggest he jump out and conduct physical education classes? I have also suggested that the disabled, in whose glorious ranks I am prepared to admit myself, should be entitled to parliamentary representation.
They have snooped around in an extraordinary manner. I have received a number of letters to which I replied so vigorously that I was asked not to do so again as they caused nervous disturbance to those who read them. However, I am unrepentant. I received one recently from the head office in Edinburgh which stated that they had arranged a visit at the "above address". I responded by thanking them for their letter and telling them that they had greatly exceeded the scope of their powers because what they referred to as the "above address" was my home and it was beyond their capacity to invite a third party, whose qualifications, age, sex, height and weight were not specified, to invade it. I am already having difficulties with these persons, so I do not want to get entangled with An tÚdarás as well.
It would be a good idea to leave the existing pension schemes, which are awkward, and not involve An tÚdarás; in other words, the existing pension arrangements should be permitted. I look forward to returning to this theme when the insurance industry is investigated in this House. I may be light-hearted about this matter but these letters have been sent to various people without consultation with the university. One such letter was sent to an employee who had taken retirement on health grounds because of a nervous breakdown. This person was catapulted into a second one as a result of receiving such letters. This exception is reasonable.
Comment on this
I am persuaded by Senator Norris on this matter. He has the capacity to turn an unpleasant situation into something which can be portrayed in an amusing way. This matter is more relevant to the investigation of the insurance industry. Perhaps we could consider it in that context.
Comment on this
I look forward to such an investigation but, in the meantime, perhaps the Minister could clarify if this exception will be allowed.
Comment on this
The effect of the amendment would be to provide that where a university has a funded pension scheme with appointed trustees the provisions of subsection (5) relating to the resolution of disputes would not apply. The Fifth Schedule will apply to the superannuation of arrangements of people who are employed by universities after the passing of this Bill.
It is normal practice for schemes which are funded largely by public funds that the determination of disputes would be submitted to the Department of Finance. It is hoped that there will be very few such disputes, given the duty of trustees to comply with the relevant pensions legislation. I would not favour an option whereby the resolution of disputes for all such schemes would be subject to the agreement of the Ministers for Finance and Education. The involvement of the Minister for Finance ensures a co-ordinated approach to the resolution of disputes for all pension schemes that are funded largely from the public purse. It is of note that over £20 million per annum is provided by the State for superannuation payments in the case of the universities. The total of accumulated funds is in excess of £400 million.
Comment on this
Do I take it that nothing in the Minister's response excludes the possibility of exempting existing pension funds which have been paid for from employees contributions and in respect of which trustees have been appointed in accordance with existing pensions legislation? In other words, the existing Trinity pension scheme will not be altered or interfered with in any way.
Comment on this
The Fifth Schedule will apply to the superannuation of people who are employed by universities after the passing of the Bill.
Comment on this
This seems to envisage the imposition of a new funding arrangement on the universities. Some of them may welcome such a development but I am not sure that Trinity College will do so. The existing scheme appears to be satisfactory and it might be better to continue that and leave it to be determined by the normal forces that operate in respect of insurance and pension schemes. Will the Minister provide information regarding whether there is substantial State investment in the Trinity pension fund? I understand that this is not the case. Is she suggesting that the State will subsequently contribute?
Perhaps I am misinformed, but my recollection is that the Trinity scheme is independent and is funded by a combination of contributions from the employees and the university. I am not aware of any massive State investment. I presume this situation will continue. If that is the case, it is not adequate to state that this will not affect people employed before the passage of the Bill. It should be stated that the provision will involve everyone in the universities after the passage of the Bill. It may well be that Trinity will wish to continue with the existing arrangement.
Comment on this
The involvement of the Minister for Finance ensure a co-ordinated approach to the resolution of disputes for all pensions schemes that are funded largely from the public purse.
Comment on this
Does that involve the University of Dublin? If the relevant information is not available, I will be happy to return to the matter on Report Stage. My understanding is that the Trinity scheme is largely independent and is funded by the college and its employees, which would make it substantially different. However, my information could be incorrect.
Comment on this
In the interests of clarification, we are discussing the superannuation of people employed by universities after the passing of this Bill. Substantial funds are involved and I reiterate that this matter concerns pension schemes that are funded largely from the public purse. The Department of Finance has indicated that it wishes to retain its role in resolving disputes involving such funds. I am informed that these accumulated funds total £400 million.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's statement. However, it is not stated in the Schedule that the provision applies only where these schemes are largely funded from the public purse. My amendment provides for cases where such schemes are not funded from the public purse. However, perhaps we can tease the matter on Report Stage. I will withdraw the amendment with a view to reinsertion on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Subject to the Minister's commitment to expedite matters relating to this Part of the Bill on Report Stage, the amendment is not being pressed.