Waste Management (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 2001: Committee and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 1–144 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 2001 ›
Could the Minister clarify which Community directives, if any, govern the transport of waste between countries? As we do not yet have incineration in Ireland, there are no regulations on the management or importation of waste for either recovery or disposal. What are the intentions in this regard?
Comment on this
I understand that this is governed by EU directives on waste management. Section 2 recites three directives. Is it any of those directives? Does he propose to make regulations or is it the EPA that will make those regulations? It is critical that whereas we do not have incineration at the moment it could be the intention of a company to import hazardous or other waste under European directives into this country. I would like to ensure that this Bill will deal with that issue.
Comment on this
It is dealt with under Council Directive 259/93 and we have made regulations in relation to the matter under that directive. It is already catered for and we have regulations in place.
Comment on this
I raised that matter with the EPA today and they told me that there are no regulations. I question this because I seek information. There is no incinerator in the country so there are no regulations. When will the regulations be made and who will make them? I do not wish to labour the point and will be happy to hear the Minister talk about it later.
Comment on this
I can only repeat what I said. Council regulation 259/93 has direct force here. Therefore the laws and regulations under that have direct effect. I will get a further note for the Senator to clarify it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
3. –A waste management plan shall contain comprehensive provisions regarding separation and recycling of waste.
I am disappointed that amendment No. 1 has been ruled out of order because it relates to a central issue.
Comment on this
The Senator will have an opportunity when we come to debate the section to make the points she wishes.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 2 relates to recycling. The amendment proposes to insert a new section. Section 3 relates to definitions under the Bill and we are anxious that the issues of waste and recycling are included. The amendment is designed to strengthen the purpose and powers of the Bill and to ensure that the fundamental issues of the separation and recycling of waste are incorporated in this section. I ask the Minister to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I support Senator O'Meara. The Minister is enthusiastic in promoting recycling. We have been very successful with recycling of glass and aluminium cans. This is because the industries which use them have been able to substitute them. Unless we include in our legislation the need to have the recycling industry established here we will get nowhere. It is disappointing to see so little has happened to date. I was delighted to see the recycling dictionary brought forward by Mr. Sam Foster and the Minister recently. We are, however, about ten years behind everyone else. We should at every opportunity promote recycling as essential. We want not only the separation and collection of waste, which are easy, but the setting up of a recycling industry, which currently exists only in respect of glass.
Comment on this
I endorse Senator Henry's last sentences. We need to set up a recycling industry, nothing else. The principle of recycling and segregation is enshrined in the Waste Management Act, 1996, but the problem is making this happen on the ground. That is the challenge. It is an operational matter for local authorities to put the infrastructure in place to enable householders and others generating waste to segregate and present for recycling.
It has to be a matter of national policy to put in place and, where necessary, subsidise a national recycling industry. As the Minister knows, paper is a most recyclable commodity, but the market fluctuates. Sometimes one can present paper and at other times one cannot. I am glad to be able to argue again that when the market is rock bottom and the companies cannot carry the cost, the Government should subsidise materials. That needs a national framework and the will by the Government to make it happen. Putting it into statutes will not make it happen but the challenge is to make it a reality on the ground.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. One of the key issues is funding for recycling. Drogheda Corporation, for example, wants a recycling centre but has no funds for it. The Government ought to have a policy of supporting waste recycling, particularly by funding local authorities ab initio in this process.
Under the law at present, if people buy something which has a lot of packaging from a retailer with a badge on his window saying he supports Repak, the waste cannot be left with him. The big stores like Dunnes Stores and Superquinn are avoiding the issue of waste management by contributing to this useless body. The legislation imposes on the small operator, the corner shop, which must take the waste back. The Minister must change the regulations on waste recycling, especially at the point of sale and at large supermarkets.
Comment on this
The amendment states that the waste management plan shall contain comprehensive proposals for separating and recycling. That is in all the plans to date. There should be more emphasis on this. It should not just be a sentiment but should be implemented. The Minister in his Second Stage speech stated that minimisation, reuse and recycling would be prioritised and that he would take initiatives to ensure that this is prioritised by local government. I hope he will expand on how this will happen in practice. That is what is needed rather than duplicating it in the Bill.
Comment on this
I support Senator O'Meara's amendment. I have a query, although I will not get involved in Senator O'Dowd's comments that the supermarkets are not paying their fair share.
Comment on this
As the Minister is aware, there is a huge cost and every retailer is obliged, correctly, to contribute. On the polluter pays principle, Senator Quill talked about packaging, and one of the largest amounts of waste going into tipheads is newspaper, which is not packaging. Almost everybody involved in packaging is obliged to contribute to the cost of recycling, but apparently the newspaper industry has refused to do so, not just in Ireland but throughout Europe. It has claimed that newspapers are not packaging and that the industry should not therefore contribute to the cost of recycling. In every country the newspaper industries have remained at one in ensuring they do not contribute one penny towards recycling as to do so would be to let the side down. Given that newspapers account for a large volume of material in tipheads and that because it is not packaging there is no obligation on the industry to pay for recycling, has the Minister plans to find some formula to overcome the problem? I am not sure it can be done easily and perhaps it is not relevant to this section. However, I would welcome the Minister's views.
Comment on this
I thank the Senators for their contributions. While I appreciate the sentiment behind the amendment, I assure Senators that it is absolutely unnecessary to include it in the Bill. I do not intend rewriting the Waste Management Act, 1996, which is fundamentally sound. We have discovered a number of flaws in it which we are addressing in this and perhaps a further Bill.
Section 22 of the 1996 Act requires that local authority waste management plans contain objectives to, among other things, encourage and support the recovery of waste, which includes reuse and recycling, and to specify measures and arrangements to be undertaken with a view to securing these objectives. The 1997 waste management planning regulations specify in great detail the matters to be addressed in waste management plans, including the separation, segregation and collection of recoverable waste and a range of very specific matters regarding recycling and recovery. In addition, the 1998 policy document, Changing our Ways, set specific targets for recovery and recycling which formed the basis of most of the proposed regional waste management plans. The reason for this Bill is to try to finalise the plans which provide for household segregation and separate collection of organic waste and dry recyclables in urban areas, an extended network of bring facilities in rural areas, typically in a target population density of about 500, an increased network of civic amenity sites and waste transfer stations, a range of centralised composting and other biological treatment facilities and support for home composting of food and garden waste, especially in rural areas. The draft waste management plans have not been passed in some local authority areas.
Given what I have said, Senators will appreciate it is not necessary to include the amendment. The matter is well covered in previous legislation, in regulations and in our policy document. I agree with the Senators in that there is a great commitment, both verbally and on paper, by local authorities and various other bodies to the whole concept of recycling. It is now time to make it happen, and a number of Senators have said that, but we cannot make it happen until plans are adopted by local authorities. It is imperative that local authorities complete the current strategic planning process, but they are not prepared to do that in a number of cases. Once the waste management plans are in place local authorities will proceed with their implementation as a matter of urgency. To deal with recycling, reuse, recovery, composting and thermal facilities, all the plans drawn up so far, if implemented, would result in a national network of bring facilities and a necessary critical mass to put all the facilities in place. We intend to encourage that further, following the passage of this Bill, with the publication of a recycling policy document. The environment fund will allow us to make money available to put some of that infrastructure in place, particularly the mechanisms being talked about.
The fundamental principle of environment policy in Europe and here is the polluter pays principle. We can dance around this any way we like but the polluter pays principle is a core principle of European environmental policy and it has to be a core principle of our environmental policy, particularly in relation to waste management facilities. I do not wish to get involved in the crossfire but I will address the other points made. I do not agree with Senator O'Dowd – it is not the first time we have disagreed—
Comment on this
Those who are familiar with Repak, including Senator Quinn who defended it but did not get into the argument, will know that I had concerns about it from the beginning. It took a while to get started, but the problems it faced have been addressed. There has been considerable change in Repak over the past three or four months. It will reach the target designated for the packaging of waste by the end of this year, and that will be a worthy achievement.
Senator Quinn made a point in relation to newspapers. Newspapers are not regarded as packaging. This is certainly an issue that needs to be addressed. I was delighted to see in a recent newspaper article that I was roundly condemned by one evening newspaper for my environmental performance. I am sure it will fully support my campaign to have the newspaper business contribute to improving the environment. We look forward to speaking to that industry about that matter in the near future. It is a problem and we are trying to make contact—
Comment on this
I was trying to remember exactly what percentage of landfill is used up by newspapers – I think it is considerably more than plastic bags. We intend to put an initiative in place, similar to Repak, or offer the newspapers the opportunity to become contributors to Repak and allow Repak to recycle the waste paper. The amendment is not necessary. The sentiment of its proposers is shared by every Member, but it is already provided for in legislation and acceptance of it would not add to existing legislation.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his response. He is technically correct when he says this matter is dealt with in the 1996 Act. However, those of us who are members of local authorities and have passed waste management plans will know that simply having aspirations and targets does not achieve the objectives of waste management. Almost every Member has commented on this fact. We still have a major problem in building an infrastructure for separation and collection of recyclable material. Targets in waste management plans and aspirations in legislation will not achieve that.
Senator Quill spoke about this matter very eloquently last week in her speech on Second Stage and others have done so too. Unless the Government becomes involved in funding an infrastructure it will not be created because the market will not provide it. Senator O'Dowd referred to his local authority. In my area Nenagh Urban District Council established a community employment scheme to be responsible for a recycling project. I am sure the same has been done by many other local authorities. The Nenagh project was well supported and was very well run on very small resources but it had to close when the community employment scheme came to an end. There is now some difficulty in finding a private operator to do a kerbside collection, and one can see why.
The problem is referred to in a recent Environmental Protection Agency newsletter. The newsletter refers to the absence of an infrastructure for separate collection and recovery of waste. It speaks of "an urgent need for the necessary infrastructure to be put in place for the separate collection, recovery and safe disposal of waste so that a truly integrated approach to waste prevention and management becomes standard practice in Ireland". That is everybody's target but there is a huge missing link without which we will not achieve our targets. I know this from speaking to local authority engineers. The targets and objectives are in place but local authorities do not have the resources to achieve them.
Senator Quill says the local authorities must act. Local authorities want to act but they cannot do so. We must face up to the fact that unless central Government becomes involved, through tax incentives or direct provision, in the establishment of an infrastructure it will not be built. Without an infrastructure the current crisis will deepen.
I accept the Minister's point that a plan for separation and recycling is covered in the 1996 Act but we know that legislation is not working. Unless an infrastructure is put in place provision for separation and recycling will not be made. The object of the amendment is to strengthen the Minister's hand. Perhaps the strength must come not from waste management legislation but through agreement with the Department of Finance on a tax incentive for private operators or financial support for local authorities to build the necessary infrastructure.
Comment on this
Did I understand the Minister to say that until everything is in place nothing can happen anywhere? That would be a recipe for disaster. When waste management measures were taken in the United States they were initially taken in the form of federal legislation. This was followed by state and finally local legislation. Our waste management measures must also begin with central Government and be pursued with determination.
I take the Minister's point about the 1996 legislation. However, five years later we appear to have got nowhere. I get more complaints from the public about waste collection than any other issue. Collection is only the beginning of the problem. It continues through separation and reuse of waste material.
FÁS has performed miracles. Some of the pilot waste management schemes were run by FÁS, but these can only continue for two years. It is the responsibility of the State to put the infrastructure in place. People will not want to get involved until there is a system in place and without State involvement the mess we are in will continue.
I was impressed by the directory and the website. Some support will be necessary for these small businesses, until we realise the value of what we throw away.
Comment on this
There is a definite need to get more involved in recycling. I am concerned at the inability of local authorities to tackle the issue of waste management. Considering that legislation has been in place since 1996, the management of local authorities which still do not comply should be closely examined.
In the area of waste management, County Kerry already has recycling, composting and paper separation bins. Although we are in a peripheral area we have achieved much. I suggest to the Minister that local authorities who are not fulfilling their obligations be fined and that Kerry County Council should be given extra money.
Comment on this
I understand the Minister was recently in Nova Scotia looking at recycling facilities. I received a leaflet from there referring to hundreds of jobs which had been created through the recycling of newspapers into plant containers, trays etc. Perhaps the Minister should initiate research in his Department regarding what is done in the area of recycling in places such as Nova Scotia, with the aim of integrating this into our own plan.
There is a strong case to be made for the provision of State subsidies in order to ensure the viability of the recycling industry. Although it will cost the Exchequer it will ensure that re-cycling remains effective in spite of being marginal in economic terms.
Comment on this
In response to Senator Henry, I am not saying that nothing can happen until everything is in place. Senator Kiely made the point that things are happening. In 1995-96 there were approximately 400 "bring facilities", and this year there are some 1,000. I think there are in the region of 30 "bring facilities" in the Senator's own county. In Dublin, segregated waste collections have begun. The composting of domestic waste is taking place in Limerick.
In some cases local authorities are doing what is required while in others it is not getting the priority it deserves. It is not always down to money, it is a question of priority in the local areas.
The draft waste management plans contain commitments to the segregated collection services. Although I was in Opposition at the time I accept blame with the then Minister for the approach taken in the 1996 Waste Management Bill. At that time it was not felt that regional solutions would work due to the opposition to the "super-dump" approach, from Meath, Wicklow, Galway and various other places. We chickened out and it was decided that each county would look after its own waste.
I saw the error of my ways soon after coming into the Department of the Environment and Local Government. Nothing was happening due to the fact that the critical mass was not there in each local authority. Reasonable systems of waste collection with some recycling might be possible in Dublin, Cork and possibly Limerick and Galway due to their population base. However the rest of the country could not do it, and there would be some doubt over Limerick and Galway and even Cork.
The issue of critical mass prompted us to take the regional route. This should make it attractive to the private sector, which I believe should be doing this. It will do it if there is a profit to be made whether it is recycling, recovery, composting or whatever else. One of the lessons I have learned from Nova Scotia is that once the regime is in place, and the critical mass is there, then the private sector will move in either on its own or through PPPs with local authorities. In this way composting and recycling facilities etc. can be provided. It is a simple and basic message which local authorities should be getting across. It is important to get the waste management plan in place as quickly as possible.
I do not want to down-play the valuable contribution of FÁS, Rehab and the community employment scheme as referred to by Senator O' Meara, but that is only tricking around at the edge and we have to move from there by putting it on an organised footing.
I accept the point made by Senator O'Dowd on the need for more research on the practices of other countries and the need to put them into effect. I hope that some money from the environment fund will be used to research best practice, in addition to the provision of a subsidy towards the cost of infrastructure. Some £650 million has been provided in the National Development Plan 2000-2006 for waste management infrastructure. The breakdown of that sum is as follows: £100 million to come from the Exchequer or the EU, £100 million to come from the local authorities own resources and the remainder to come from the private sector. Obviously those figures will have to be revised as the plans are rolled out. We need a mixture of all three as the State cannot provide all the money for this. It is a matter for local authorities and the responsibility will continue to lie largely with them.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
3.–In exercising his or her functions under the Waste Management Acts, 1996 and 2001, the Minister shall have regard to the polluter pays principle which shall include the desirability of ensuring that the manufacturer or retailer of packaging waste shall contribute to the cost of waste disposal.".
I thank the Minister for his very comprehensive replies to the earlier amendment. We had a useful debate and teasing out of the issues contained therein.
Amendment No. 3 applies to the same section. The Minister has already referred to the polluter pays principle as the fundamental issue at the heart of policy in relation to waste management and as part of the EU approach. This amendment is self-explanatory, providing that the Minister shall have regard to the polluter pay principle which shall include the desirability of ensuring that the manufacturer or retailer of packaging waste shall contribute to the cost of waste disposal.
Comment on this
I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak on this amendment. With your permission, I shall repeat something I said on Second Stage. I wanted the Minister to refer to the first principle in dealing with waste, that of waste minimisation. In this hierarchy of activities the basic one is minimisation. Whatever efforts have been made in regard to recycling, reuse and recovery, our efforts at minimisation have not even begun.
As this is not a Second Stage debate I cannot demonstrate what I want to say except to say that if we are serious about tackling the waste problem we must put more energy into waste minimisation and we should start here in this House. The example should come from the Minister's Department. I invite him to see my office in this building which is like a sanitary landfill, a badly managed tip, with all the paper-based material that comes into it every day, much of which is never read because I do not have the time, interest or inclination.
Much of what I need to read and research to enable me to function could be made available to me on my computer. I understood when the sophisticated system of computerisation was introduced to our offices that there would be a dramatic reduction in the amount of paper that floods our offices every day. That has not happened and I do not know why.
If we are serious about that element of waste management surely we and, in particular, the Minister's Department should seek to give the good example. An opportunity to effect a dramatic reduction presented when the modern computers were introduced but it was not grasped. A great deal of specialised material is sent to my office daily and sometimes it is duplicated and sent to my office in Cork. The specialised material comes from the Law Reform Commission and similar areas. It is the kind of material I would normally only need to access through a well-stocked library. Some of us remember the days when we went to the library to do our research. We did not buy in every book – maybe it was that we could not afford to buy them – but one way or the other we learned the skill of going to a library, seeking out whatever material we needed, accessing it and using it through the library. We did not need to have every document on our own study desks in our houses or on our desks in Leinster House.
As well as making the polluter pay the definition of a polluter should be widened. The Minister's Department is a primary polluter in that it sends me material I do not need and which has become a nuisance. The only way I can dispose of it is to send it to landfill. We need to look at that element of waste management. I have submitted a document to the Minister's Department asking that his Department seek to implement this philosophy of paper reduction in his own Department, to set targets for his Department and set standards for every other Government Department. If the Government gave good example in this respect I have no doubt State agencies and those in the private sector would follow suit. The amount of marketing material that comes to me through my newspapers in sections which I do not read and which clogs my letterbox and falls of my wastepaper basket is disgusting.
I have adopted the habit in my office this year of writing to people who forward unsolicited material that I cannot use or do not intend to use asking to be taken off their mailing list. All of us should adopt that policy. If that was done on a family or household basis there would be a substantial reduction in the amount of pollution coming into our houses. Perhaps the Department should impose a penalty. It may be that I should seek a new job, pollution prevention officer in Leinster House. It would be interesting to conduct an audit of all the unnecessary material that issues from the Minister's Department on an daily or hourly basis and to surcharge him piece by piece. Rather than my doing it, I ask the Minister to have that done.
It is critically important to seek to implement every element of the Waste Management Act, 1996, the first principle of which Act was waste minimisation. No effort has been made to implement it. I have written to the Minister on this subject and I look forward to his response. Perhaps at another time we shall debate this matter more fully. If we could give leadership it would pay dividends.
Comment on this
I agree with practically everything Senator Quill has said. Two of the documents we get are the Order Papers for the Dáil and the Seanad, both of which are available on the website and can be downloaded in two minutes. They should cease to be circulated.
Comment on this
There should be a message to the effect that if one wants to use them, they can be found on the Internet or one can go to the Library. Some 80% of the material I receive is unsolicited and is of no value to me. In regard to documents circulated to all Members, the Library should send a note through our website saying that the following documents are lodged in the Library and anyone wishing to use them should call the Library. That policy, if adopted, would save a tremendous amount of waste. The Government should be proactive. The amount of paper used by local authorities, Government agencies etc. is almost infinite. The Minister should consider making a regulation whereby Government agencies, State agencies, semi-State agencies, local authorities and health boards should use recycled paper.
How proactive are we in regard to recycling in this House? I realise some efforts were made in the other building before we moved here. I suggest to the Leader that we get together and put a plan in place for recycling, reuse and reducing waste in the Houses of the Oireachtas.
The other issue contained in the amendment is important. It is a question of ensuring that the manufacturer or retailer of packaging waste should contribute to the cost of waste disposal. If one buys a pair of socks in a shop, one gets a metal clip to hold the socks together, a piece of cardboard to say who made the socks, a plastic clip between the socks to hold them together and a piece of paper in each sock.
Comment on this
This is an absolute waste of resources. If one buys a shirt one gets metal pins, pieces of cardboard, pieces of plastic and all sorts of things. The Government should set up a body comprising the business community and those in the retail business with a view to reducing the amount of packaging used. The amount of packaging used is a total waste of resources and has no value. Somebody thinks it looks nice but it is a waste of finite resources. This legislation is all about managing and reducing our waste.
On the question of supermarkets, I do not imply that there is anything wrong with Superquinn as opposed to Dunnes Stores. They are in the business of selling. Advertisements in the media and on television are used to sell the product. The product is colour coded and designed to look nice so people will want to buy it. That is the psychology of selling. Most of the packaging on the household goods we buy is neither needed nor wanted. We need to look again at how packaging is designed to ensure there is a sufficient amount from a health point of view but the minimum necessary to have the goods sold safely and undamaged. That is the bottom line.
We need to grasp this nettle. The Minister should give a lead on this issue. If that were done, it would make a significant difference to our waste problem. The issue must be tackled now and this amendment will add to the momentum for change, which the consumer wants but to which the packaging and retail industry is not sufficiently alert.
Supermarkets must be forced to do more. I accept the Minister's assertion that there have been big changes in Repak in the last four months. I welcome that but in the town of Drogheda there has been no change of which I am aware. Look at what happens in the retail sector. Mountains of rubbish are put out every day for private or public collection. The sheer waste is unacceptable.
Comment on this
There is a risk of this discussion becoming a Second Stage debate. The Government can do something. Whenever a Bill is introduced in this House with the object of establishing a new State body I put down an amendment that it must be registered on the Internet. The response to the Internet has been patchy. Some Departments automatically recognise the need and the ability of the community to acquire information through the Internet, therefore avoiding the use of huge amounts of paper. Other Departments are slack in this area. The Government has the ability to force us to use less paper.
Senator O'Dowd and I might end up having plenty of rows here today. This is a market economy and customers decide what they want. If the customer decides to buy an Easter egg covered with lots of wrapping, that is the customer's choice. The customer can also choose to buy an egg with little wrapping because they feel strongly about this issue. This issue is driven by the market economy.
The Minister has grasped the opportunity. He has brought the supermarkets and retailers together and asked them to work with him to educate and change public opinion with regard to waste. I congratulate him on the steps taken in that area. He is going in the right direction but a great deal more work and commitment is required in addition to the type of dedication he has been showing in recent times.
Comment on this
This amendment deals with the polluter pays principle. Senator Quill made an interesting point. Members of the Oireachtas must concede that the amount of paper generated in this establishment is far in excess of what is necessary. I am sure it would be possible to cut it by 75% or 80% without anybody complaining. We are just a microcosm of the problem.
Perhaps there should be a provision regarding prevention and minimisation—
Comment on this
Yes. These are two areas about which we are aspirational but which really require tangible targets. The Minister visited Nova Scotia, a region which has become environmentally friendly in relation to waste management. According to the figures, their waste has been reduced by 50% in less than a decade. That is a significant reduction. The debate we are having now was taking place in Nova Scotia at the early stages of that reduction.
Can the Minister say if a provision could be included in the Bill to set targets and provide for penalties? If the council were responsible, penalties could be levied on it. If the function is given to the managers, it might be more appropriate that the manager would be surcharged if he or she failed to meet certain environmental targets.
We must make this happen. Talking about it and providing for it in legislation will not make it happen. We must enforce the stipulations and the targets. They should be attainable but they should also be vigorously pursued. Could something be done in that regard in the Bill? The charge on plastic bags is certainly progressive but can we do more than that, even with regard to the waste unnecessarily generated in the Houses, to force a change in habits? We are creatures of habit and considerably more than aspirational expressions will be required to change those habits.
Comment on this
I support the principle of this amendment. I disagree with Senator Quinn with regard to customers, packaging and so forth but I will deal with that in a moment. The problem is that manufacturers and, to a lesser extent, retailers use an excessive amount of packaging, particularly in the electrical and fancy goods sectors.
The electrical goods industry is a particular offender. When somebody buys a small television or radio – known as brown electrical goods – after seeing the demonstration model, they discover the product is placed inside a cardboard box and is generally surrounded by polystyrene packaging. Polystyrene emits toxic emissions when burned and does not biodegrade. The consumer is paying for this unsolicited level of packaging when buying the product. In this age of transparency the consumer should know what amount of the money is spent on the packaging. They would be quite surprised.
I do not know how one can deal with this problem but the manufacturers are making a major contribution to pollution. What does the consumer do with the wrapping? It is usually sent to landfill but some people actually burn it.
Senator Quinn mentioned Easter eggs. The Easter egg is wrapped in a huge piece of coloured tin foil and is then mounted in a cardboard box. Easter eggs, like Christmas goods and gifts for Mother's Day, are seasonal products and the manufacturers compete with each other in how they are presented. The colours on the tin foil become ever more garish, as do the colours on the cardboard mounting. The packaging also becomes larger. The objective is to appeal to young children and encourage them to buy the product. The packaging is part of the sales pitch and we ought to do something about that.
When we refer to the polluter pays principle we generally mean that the polluter is somebody who will dump rubbish improperly. In my area people dump their rubbish on remote roads. I wish they were all caught. Most of these bags of dumped rubbish contain packaging, but no blame attaches to those who use that packaging as part of their sales pitch.
There is an excess of packaging. If one buys a small cooker one finds it mounted in a timber frame with polystyrene to cushion it as well as sheets of plastic with air bubbles which are also there to cushion it. None of the products is biodegradable and they are the very products that people object to going into incineration because of the emissions they produce. Use of these products is unlimited and uncontrolled. We banned the use of certain materials of this type in furniture because of the fire hazard they represent, and rightly so, yet we have done nothing in relation to their grossly excessive use in the packaging industry. Polystyrene and such materials are by-products of the oil industry and while we are facing difficulties with oil supply we allow burgeoning and unnecessary manufacture of these products.
The Minister should take this amendment seriously. I hope he will incorporate it as it is designed to make the Bill better. This detailed discussion gives us an opportunity not only to discuss the central issue but the shift of waste management within our areas from being a function reserved for elected members of local authorities to the executive function of the manager, over whom the Minister holds full control. The county managers are not independent agents of the Minister – if he wants a county manager to do something the manager will do that, while often if elected members want their manager to do something he will take much less heed of them. The Minister should do everything he can to incorporate the sentiments behind this amendment as the manufacturing sector gets away with murder in wasting resources on packaging. An element of packaging is necessary to protect a product but when it is used in an over the top manner or as part of the hard sell, that is unacceptable and everything must be done to discourage it. We should do nothing to discourage the necessary level of packaging but we should discourage unnecessary usage of these products.
Comment on this
This could be a historic amendment as a message seems to be coming that we are overproducing paper and that there is a surplus of paper in the market. Some years ago a legendary Galway councillor, Joe Lambert, who is known to the Leas-Chathaoirleach, arrived at a council meeting and stated what are now words of wisdom: "I am afraid, lads, if this continues, some day one of us will be drowned in paper." How wise he was. That is a number of years ago, but matters have become worse. A number of us still hold the dual mandate and often I get a letter addressed to Senator Jarlath McDonagh – I got one addressed to Councillor Jarlath McDonagh – but when one opens them they contain the same letter. It is a total waste of paper and of the time of the person who must open them. We can do a lot in this area.
We should also deal with mailing lists as once one gets on a mailing list it is nearly impossible to get off it. A woman recently came to me whose husband died in 1994 but sales material for him is still delivered two or three times a year, even though she has written to the company many times. We as well as those in business should look at what we are doing. The superfluous use of paper should be cut back and Senator Quill has started a historic debate with this amendment. I hope the Minister will respond positively.
Comment on this
I would be making a Second Stage speech if I tried to respond to all points. I do not propose to accept this amendment. I am not sure what the Senator intended with it but the polluter pays principle is the cornerstone of the Waste Management Act and of our environmental policy. This amendment seeks to put in place a limited interpretation of what the polluter pays principle means by focusing it on a particular group of people or companies. It is at variance and inconsistent with amendment No. 1, though that was ruled out of order. It would lessen the impact of a very important cornerstone of environmental policy which is already contained in our legislation.
Without going into the specifics of Senators' contributions, I am delighted with their comments. The Members' interests committees of both Houses focus on the financial or other aspects of Members' interests but the points made here could be raised with those committees. Pardon me for saying so, but one gets one big brown envelope with one list of amendments, then if someone puts down two or three more amendments one gets another big brown envelope with those. One receives the Order Paper and other communications that could be sent by e-mail or in other ways. The staff of the House have statutory responsibilities and Members must be informed equally of events, but that problem can be overcome if we agree rules in both Houses as to how we are to be informed. I have seen two or three big sacks of paper outside Members' offices every evening and when the bins are tipped out.
There is a provision dealing with this in the 1996 Act and we are putting that into effect with a public authority waste programme which is geared towards preventing waste. That will be included in the policy document I mentioned earlier. There will be a national waste prevention policy statement in relation to that also.
Senator Quill mentioned the Department of the Environment and Local Government. She will be delighted to hear that we are currently striving for the environmental quality mark ISO 14001 to set a good example to other Departments.
Comment on this
A number of other Departments, or sections of Departments like the Revenue Commissioners, are striving at our instigation and through the Government's eco-network to achieve the mark. We have requested every Department to pursue this by putting in place a green housekeeping officer that will come up with methods and means of controlling waste management within Departments. As a general rule, there are principles in relation to buying recycled paper and environmentally friendly or energy-saving equipment, double-sided copying and so on. People often laugh and claim that such measures are little things, but they make a huge difference.
Comment on this
Senators will be delighted that the notes I am writing are on notepaper headed "Ireland EU Presidency 1996". We are even recycling the paper we did not get to use at that time. This is a very important matter, and I accept the positive comments of Senators. As Minister for the Environment and Local Government, I am not supposed to admit things like this, but we are all guilty of waste and not preventing or minimising it. Much of this results from thoughtlessness. The Electronic Commerce Act allows the Government to operate on the basis of IT and my Department is to the fore as we have a good and helpful website. We encourage local authorities, many of whom lead the way, to enable people to apply for various licences on-line. The planning system is going on-line, as provided for in the Planning and Development Act. A lot of positive things are happening.
I do not wish to get involved in crossfire and I accept the sincerity of Senator O'Dowd's beliefs about Repak, a company of which there has been a negative view. Without being patronising, it would be worthwhile for Members to be brought up to date on changes that have taken place. Our audit of Repak showed up its faults and failings, as did an internal audit, which revealed some of the difficulties that had arisen. Repak has put in place a plan and a new system to help it achieve the targets it has set itself. I have no doubt that these targets will be met, and the company is even talking about assisting local authorities in relation to infrastructure.
I hope I am not breaching confidences by saying that there have been internal discussions in Repak about the municipal waste that is collected by local authorities, much of which is packaging waste. We go into shops and buy things, and the packaging ends up in municipal dumps. Repak is talking about ways of assisting local authorities, perhaps through civic amenity sites where waste could be segregated. That would meet the obligations of Repak. I must say that local authorities have failed to pursue those who are not members of Repak. We can criticise Repak as much as we like, but fairly substantial fees are paid by members of the company for collection systems to help meet recycling targets, as Senator Quinn can indicate.
Local authorities must be vigorous in the pursuit of those who seem to want to get up on everyone's back, no matter what business they are in. To date local authorities have been less than diligent, but we have said this to managers and it is being addressed. Some 392 major producers and 373 independent retailers are members of Repak, representing over 2,000 individual sites around the country. The fees for 2000 were £8,574,000 and this year the figure is expected to be about £9 million. The fee is an annual charge based on the quantity and type of packaging.
Repak funded or contributed funding in respect of the collection and recovery of 146,000 tonnes of packaging waste in 2000. This is not an inconsiderable amount, but it needs to be increased by 40,000 tonnes to reach the 2001 recovery target under the packaging directive, a target I am satisfied will be achieved. Members of Repak would accept that they have been slow to get off the ground in the past, but it should be acknowledged that is changing now.
The four largest supermarket chains, Superquinn, Super Valu, Dunnes Stores and Tesco, have joined a partnership with the Department of the Environment and Local Government. The message conveyed to the House today about making choices and choosing goods with less packaging is also the one we are promoting. The supermarket chains have become involved directly with my Department and we recently held a joint launch of the promotion. If we can increase awareness, which is our goal, consumers will demand less packaging and those who do business will be the first to react and respond. If the demand is there, goods with less packaging will be supplied. A joint approach is important. I am delighted to hear Senators expressing forcefully the necessity to minimise and prevent waste and I agree with them.
Comment on this
It clearly was not the intention of this amendment to limit the application of the polluter pays principle and I do not accept that such a limitation would be the effect of the amendment. I agree with the Minister that Members can respond in a practical way to concerns raised about the mountains of waste we are subjected to and add to. We should channel these issues through committees and where appropriate opt for e-mail rather than using stacks of brown envelopes, as the Minister pointed out. We should communicate to the relevant authorities from an Internet mailing list, as a basic and obvious way of reducing the mountain of paper coming our way. To act without delay would be a start and a good model. Although I do not agree with the Minister's comments about my amendment, I withdraw it based on his remarks.
Comment on this
As amendment No. 4 is related to amendment No. 7, which is consequential on amendment No. 6, all three may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 4, to delete lines 6 to 9.
Amendments Nos. 4, 6 and 7 relate to one of the more contentious elements of this legislation, which seems to be the main reason for the amendment Bill. The Bill effectively removes the reserved function in relation to adopting a waste management plan from members of local authorities and makes it a reserved function of the manager.
Much was said on Second Stage on this issue and I do not intend to repeat what I said then. I made the points then as strongly as I could. I fundamentally disagree with this amendment in the Bill. It is a very bad day for local government, a step backwards which we will regret. It is the Minister's response to the refusal by some local authorities to adopt a waste management plan but it is not the appropriate response because it will not necessarily have the desired effect. We have had some discussion on this already when dealing with earlier amendments. The Minister believes that simply adopting a waste plan will effectively change our ways, to use the Department's own term, or change the waste infrastructure. Clearly this is not the case.
At the heart of this amendment is the issue of local democracy. Those of us who are members of a local authority know that we already have a very limited amount of power. While I would make the point, with which others would agree, that in exercising that power we should be responsible, take the wider view whenever possible and act as carefully as possibly, we should also guard our right to have that power and resist all attempts to remove it. It is a pity the Minister takes the view that the whole system should be diluted just because a small number of members of local authorities find it impossible to adopt a waste management strategy for whatever reason.
The point which has been made, which the Minister will probably make in his response also, is that it is only those local authorities which, for want of a better word, misbehave or fail to do their duty by the Act which will have their functions taken from them and transferred to the manager. I do not think that will be the effect of this measure. Simply changing the legislation to make this an executive power means that fewer local authorities will do their duty. Because elected members will know that at end of the day the manager will act, it is quite likely that there will be a great number of local authorities which will fail to adopt waste management plans.
That is a negative effect of this amending legislation. All it will do is dilute local democracy. It will generate even more aggravation among local communities who find themselves living in an area which has been targeted for an incinerator, for instances, which is one very possible result of this. Already members of local communities, who find themselves the target of an executive decision, feel very aggrieved.
I am dealing with one or two issues at present where the manager is using his executive powers to make decisions against the strongly expressed wishes of a local community and the relationship between the local authority and that community is suffering badly as a result. I have remarked at local authority level that the authority should be building good relations with the local community rather than damaging them. When power is exercised in this fashion by a manager it has the opposite effect. That has an implication for the future also. While we are in the era of partnership, transparency and accountability, increasingly local communities feel they are not being heard, their views are not being taken into account and the local authority is riding roughshod over them. Inevitably in the future there will be an even greater feeling that this is the case. That is already having the effect of lessening people's faith in local democracy.
We spend a great deal of time wringing our hands about how democracy is being undermined and about how there is greater cynicism as a result of revelations at tribunals, for example, but people are antagonised and made feel as if their votes at local elections make no difference when councillors cannot act or when councillors have one view and the manager has another. People ask members of the local authority what they are doing sitting in the county council if they do not have any power. If the manager can simply turn around and overrule the local authority members' strongly expressed view, what is their function?
I fundamentally disagree with the amendment in this legislation. I know there are Members in the Minister's party who are not sitting here at present but who share my view on this and it is sad that they are not coming in to express that view. I would put it strongly to the Minister that in adopting this amendment and in taking this approach we are actually storing up more problems for ourselves than it will ever solve.
Comment on this
I support all the views expressed by Senator O'Meara and of course I support those amendments which go to the very heart of what this legislation is about, that is, the removal of the responsibility for making waste management decisions from locally elected councillors and the giving of this responsibility to the chief executive or county manager.
I was one member of my local authority who took a leading part in the debate on the waste management plan for Connacht which involved, my county, County Roscommon, and counties Mayo and Galway. Everything about the waste management plan, with which we in the county council were presented by the same set of consultants which prepared plans for every local authority in the country and which had the full blessing of the Minister and his Department, was predicated on one thing only – landfill and incineration. There was to be hardly any waste minimisation, no recovery of energy from waste and hardly any thought of recycling.
Comment on this
I did read it. It was predicated on telling us that we should go on doing what we had always done in a county where there is no industry and the waste is largely of a domestic nature – there is not much toxic waste such as that which would be generated by a pharmaceutical industry or other such industry. What amazed me about it was that we were literally being told to carry on in the way we always had done and send all our waste to landfill. We resisted that and over two or three meetings the contributions from all sides of the council made common sense.
The representatives of the consultants who drew up the plans for every region came and put their case. At my behest we in my county council asked representatives of a responsible organisation who had an alternative view to come and put certain alternative views to us. They did so and they sounded very credible. However, at the end of the day it was quite clear that our chief executive had discussed all of this with the Department of the Environment and Local Government and wanted to brush aside any suggestions made by the people who had certain alternatives to offer us.
From beginning to end the Minister and his Department were in close consultation with every chief executive in the country and wanted the waste management plans for every region, which inter-linked formed the national waste management plan, to be passed. The councillors who, in the opinion of these people had the temerity to question a part of it were subjected to ridicule. I listened to the Minister one day on "Morning Ireland" and, by implication, he named my county council because we were one of the three which did not adopt the waste management plan as presented to us.
There must be common sense in County Galway, given that the members of the local authority rejected the waste management plan for County Galway on two occasions. They first rejected it last July or September and having allowed six months to elapse during which they examined it more closely, they again unanimously rejected it last night. Some people will say they have a short-term view, but that is not the case. I was not at the meeting in Galway county buildings last night, but I am sure plenty of common sense and alternatives were offered, but they were not listened to. The county manager of County Galway did not have to listen to them, as he knew this legislation was coming through and that locating an incinerator in Galway city would be a matter on which he would make the decision and that the location of landfill sites in County Galway or in the vicinity of Galway city would be executive decisions.
It is the antithesis of democracy, including local democracy, to take decisions of this kind out of the hands of locally elected representatives. All over the world, especially in newly emerging democracies in eastern Europe, where democratic governance structures are being put in place – every country in eastern Europe that has—
Comment on this
I assume the Senator is aware we are not on Second Stage.
Comment on this
I know the Chair will allow me some latitude as I was not here last week to make a Second Stage speech.
Comment on this
I was not here to reply to the Second Stage debate and I am sure I would not be given the opportunity to do so.
Comment on this
The last thing I want to do is challenge a ruling of the Chair, but the Chair will find that the points I am about to make are directly germane and relevant to this section.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister is anxious to reply.
Comment on this
I have given the Senator some latitude.
Comment on this
Where democracies are emerging, a new level of local democracy is being put in place. In those countries in eastern Europe which I have had a chance to examine due to my previous interest in them, the level of local democracy, the level of powers left to the people elected by their local community on decisions that affect them locally are amazing, innovative and new. However, we are going down the direct opposite route. After all the lip service we have paid about local democracy having a new meaningful role and making the term "local authority" mean something, that the local authority has authority to do something, in this instance the Minister is taking back that power simply because, and I hate to use the term, he arrogantly dislikes what two or three local authorities in the country have said about the waste management plan. He has tried to tell them they were passing the buck or not facing up to their responsibilities. However, they were interpreting what was best for their local authority areas. They were interpreting what people were saying to them, and that together with common sense was what they were proposing in their chambers. That is the way it should be. If there are only three local authorities with which the Minister has had a difficulty, this is an enormous sledge to crack what appears to be a small nut. It is the essence of something that is anti-democratic.
When the Minister was in opposition, he paid lip service, by way of acres of newsprint, to the need to increase the power of local authorities, to return local government to local people and to the locally elected representatives. Those are fine sentiments, with which we all agree, but in office the Minister is doing the direct opposite. We must resist that. We do so because what was taking place at local level was not cowardly, as some people like the Minister try to describe it, but was an exercise in common sense. It was an exercise in listening to the local community express fears about emissions from an incinerator or having a landfill site in their locality. Given the Minister's disgraceful history of managing existing dumps and landfill sites, I sympathise with anyone facing the prospect of having a landfill site in his or her locality.
The Minister said on one occasion in Carrick-on-Shannon, although I accept this is a slightly separate issue, when speaking about a communications mast, that he would not like one of them in his neighbourhood, and nothing was done about the location of that mast. I am sure the Minister would also not like a badly managed landfill site to be located in his neighbourhood with all the savaging birds, rodents and everything else that attend upon locations of that kind.
Local authorities such as the one of which I am a member were forcing the issue of ensuring that the disposal of waste should be dealt with to the greatest possible degree by way of recycling, reusing or trying to recover energy from it, which would result in the minimum being sent to a landfill site or incinerated. Those of us who were try ing to change the existing culture have had dust thrown back in our eyes. As a local authority, we were trying to assert that we were exercising the authority we held responsibly, but that power has been taken from us. What the Minister is doing is shameful. It is a retrograde step, given what we considered to be the trend in all modern democracies, including this one. In the past ten years there has been a well informed public debate on this issue.
Comment on this
It was not clear to me what the Senator was taking about.
Comment on this
I do not wish to challenge any of the rulings of the Acting Chairman, but had he been in the Chair a little longer he might have a better drift of the point I am trying to make.
Comment on this
I also point out to the Senator that if he was making a Second Stage speech, he would probably have concluded by now.
Comment on this
As I said to the Acting Chairman previously, he would be aware I am the most taciturn of the Members of this House and at all times I remain germane—
Comment on this
I like the term "taciturnity" and I am always relevant. I am always germane, another term I like to use. I do not wish to be in conflict with the Chair or to challenge its rulings as that would be improper and disorderly on my part, but I am discussing a serious principle, that of democracy, of people elected by their local communities dealing with community issues and having a community input into addressing them. I am making this point from the point of view of being responsible and having common sense. Just because the mandarins in the Minister's Department, the Minister or local authority chief executives do not like the approaches put forward to deal with this issue, as they are more complicated than the simplistic ones they wish to adopt, the big stick is taken out to club democracy. That is why I am making a forceful case to the Minister not to proceed with taking the decision on waste management away from the elected members in any local authority area or in any region made up of two or three local authorities, as that power is enshrined in the 1996 Act, and making it an executive function of the county managers, given that so much has happened regarding local government since 1955 and earlier.
Given all those provisions in those Acts that took the authority from local authority members and reduced the membership of them to something close to meaninglessness, we were promised by all parties in this House that that trend would be changed and matters would be reversed in the name of democracy. It was promised that such changes would be part of international best practice. I made some comparisons with international best practice earlier, but in this instance we are moving in the opposite direction. I appeal to the Minister, in the friendliest possible way, not to proceed with this measure.
Comment on this
I understand the Minister must be fed up with those councils that have not submitted their plans. That is why I asked earlier if all had to move together, or if those not co-operating could be left outside. It is a major step, in view of the failure to get everyone to co-operate in the regional plans, to have to take this action because of three county councils.
I understand the concern of local councillors. This measure really lets them off the hook with regard to the situation in their areas. This is very unfortunate. The protesters may have very reasonable and arguable points, but the executive will feel obliged to bring in whatever suits the regional plan.
I would have far preferred if a national waste management plan had been brought in. I got the impression from the Minister's recent press conference that that was what we would get in this Bill. I ask him to consider these amendments and to take account of the huge influence which the three recalcitrant councils are having on local democracy.
Comment on this
Any action which would reduce local democracy is regrettable. Much has been said in defence of local democracy in this debate. Perhaps if we had time to be more philosophical about the role and function of democracy at local level, we might come to a better understanding and we might be able to segregate the very idealistic theory from the manner in which democracy serves the greater and better need of citizens, householders, consumers and the local community. That is the real purpose of democracy. It is not a self-serving or self-perpetuating entity. It is there to serve the best interests of the citizens by whom councillors are elected.
As a strong believer in the ideal of local democracy, I find it regrettable that central Government has had to take over the function of determining the location of halting sites, for example. Local councillors would not grasp the nettle, leaving central Government with no option. Similarly, central Government had to take over the issuing of taxi licences in Dublin, because local democracy did not respond to the legitimate needs of people for a decent taxi service. For years on end, the local authority was ambivalent on the issue and failed to face down vested interests. Once again, central Government had to assume a function which rightly belongs to a properly functioning local democracy. The same applies in the present instance.
I think it was Bismarck who once said that a bad decision is better than no decision at all. I do not say that this is a bad decision, but it is made in response to the situation in which we now find ourselves.
Comment on this
Not at all and if, with the permission of the Chair, I can have as much time as Senator Connor, I will tell a story. Have I the Chair's permission?
Comment on this
It is a fadó, fadó story. It relates to a conversation among the Fianna while out hunting. Fionn asked the opinion of Oisín and the others as to what was the greatest music on earth. Oisín suggested the song of the blackbird. Goll Mór mac Mórna suggested the sighing of the wind through the birch forest. Others offered different ideas. Then Fionn himself answered – and the Minister will find this interesting –"The greatest music on earth is the music of making things happen."
If there are local authorities where little or nothing is happening in terms of advancing proper, modern, efficient waste management, then the Government has no option but to act. Accordingly, as a strong believer in local democracy, I have to give my consent reluctantly to the Minister's proposal. Democracy is as strong and healthy as those who exercise it. There are people in certain areas who, for one reason or another – and we all know those reasons – are not prepared to exercise their function. Earlier this afternoon, a speaker said that local authorities could not allocate sufficient funding to put in place the infrastructure for the most basic elements of recycling. However, at their annual estimates time, it is their prerogative to allocate funds and to generate the necessary finance. Perhaps the slogan, "No taxation without representation," is applicable here.
Comment on this
How can somebody bewail the loss and diminution of local democracy and, in the same conversation, say that his local authority cannot generate enough money to put a few segregation bins in place? Does that person really believe in local democracy? My point is that the Minister has no other course open to him and accordingly I support the Bill.
Comment on this
This Bill is eroding democracy and denuding councillors of power. At the meeting in Galway last night, 30 very well informed councillors expressed their frustration. There was a very open and informed debate but I have never experienced such tension in the council chamber in my time there since 1985. There was anger, frustration and sadness. Councillors felt somewhat like John the Baptist crying in the wilderness – and the Minister was not listening. Clearly, our manager will be put in the most unenviable position of having to force through a plan which is vehemently opposed by all 30 councillors, including 16 Fianna Fáil councillors in Galway. It is also opposed by the general public, in the main. Our manager is one of the finest, most upstanding, honourable local authority officials in the country, a man of great vision and the utmost integrity. He is now faced with a most unpalatable decision. That is not fair.
Even at this late stage, I urge the Minister to meet a representative group, including management, councillors, consultants and people in organised groups which are directly involved in this issue and have carried out extensive studies on it. Of course, central Government has to be involved. However, it is grossly unfair to shove out the messenger, in this case the manager, to be shot. In Galway, where we have a difficulty at the moment, we should be given another opportunity and a little more time. There are good ideas and, although there is strong opposition to incineration, which I share, we are prepared to discuss a plan for County Galway. The manager should not be left in the unenviable position of having to put this plan into operation, by direction of the Minister.
I do not want to be specific as this is a general discussion on the waste management plan.
Comment on this
This is a specific discussion on the amendment.
Comment on this
Galway is one of the three areas that have a problem with this issue. As a member of the local authority I have first-hand information and I attended the meeting last night. I am sad at what I sense is happening. I know the Minister is decent and does not want to go this way so I appeal to him to give more time to Galway before he pushes the legislation through. I am sure a solution will be found. As it stands, I oppose what the Minister is trying to do here, to erode local democracy and take power from local councillors. This is especially of concern at a time when he has proposed removing the dual mandate and vesting power in councillors. He should think before he acts in this instance.
Comment on this
On section 4 as I read it the manager will be in a position to make a waste management plan where one has not been made to date and where a plan has been made he will be in a position to vary the terms of the plan. Any of us involved in local government would be concerned about shifting powers to managerial functions. The thrust of local government should be in the opposite direction. When the Local Government Bill is introduced we hope it will address that democratic deficit. The Minister's views on the reform of local government are well known and I feel sure this is no more palatable to him than to us. Will the Minister look at the section and consider amending it so that subsequent to the passing of the Bill a local authority will have a period of time to address an effective waste management plan and strategy for its county? If it fails to do that within a set time, the executive element should be triggered. That would allow the councils address the issue. In my own council one of the best debates we have had has been on this issue. Will the Minister consider this suggestion and possibly an amendment on Report Stage?
Comment on this
The Minister proposes a very radical change to present powers. These amendments propose the retention of local democracy. They seek to retain the importance and the function of the elected representative in the making of a waste management plan. The Minister proposes to take that power from elected representatives. I acknowledge that there are different views in different parties and that this is not a party issue. The Minister will land us with incinerators we do not want. On 20 June 1995 when the Waste Management Bill was going through the Oireachtas under the then Minister, Deputy Howlin, Deputy Dempsey stated:
The Minister has chosen to ignore the question of incineration and I can understand why. It has the potential to be politically difficult and that potential difficulty has overtaken environmental concerns. The technology of incineration has a bad name in Ireland and it has raised many serious concerns, not without reason, in view of some of the incineration operations we have had. However, we cannot ignore the issue.
He said a lot more than that but that summarises what Senator Walsh, I and others are saying. We would like to see changes before we push aside local democracy. There are serious health issues and concerns in relation to incineration. The Minister of State, in summing up the Second Stage debate, said that he was prepared to look at the health impacts of incineration. This is the misunderstanding between the Department, the European Parliament and the Irish people who do not believe that incineration is good for their health.
Comment on this
Incineration has nothing to do with the amendments before us and is not included in the section.
Comment on this
We are not discussing the section, only the amendments.
Comment on this
We are talking about making it a reserve function of the manager rather than of the elected members to make a waste management plan. That is taking democracy from the elected council. If the Minister persists with this section I would like to have further debate on the issue within the meaning of the amendments in the same spirit in which you allowed Senator Walsh to speak. It is basic to the whole issue. Last week the Acting Chairman spoke about the quality of food. Many people feel that if there is an incinerator in their area the food chain will be affected and dioxins will enter the food chain. That is a real fear. The Minister did not address those issues and I accept there is not an opportunity today to debate them. I and my party oppose this Bill and we will vote against it.
Comment on this
I call Senator Coogan and I appeal to speakers to stick to the amendments. We have too many Second Stage contributions. The Chair has time only to administer Committee Stage of the Bill. That is all we are trying to do.
Comment on this
I hope the Senator does not suggest otherwise.
Comment on this
Under the rules of the House we discuss the amendments before the House and the section can be discussed when we come to the section.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that there were Second Stage speeches when I came in I felt it was appropriate that I respond. If the ruling is that I should wait for a response, I am willing to wait provided I do not hear long speeches for the rest of the day.
Comment on this
I did not say boredom. It was not my intention to continue making Second Stage speeches, but if the opportunity arises, these issues are important enough to be discussed without clamping down on anyone.
Comment on this
I do not know how much time Senators have, but I am prepared to stay all night to discuss what is contained in the Bill rather than what people are insinuating should be in it. The word "incineration" is not used anywhere in the Bill. We have heard an amount—
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept the amendments because they seek to overturn the Bill's main provision and frustrate its key objective, that is, to provide a mechanism for the satisfactory conclusion of the current waste management programme as soon as possible.
There has been much talk about democracy. The previous Government, during whose term of office the Members who spoke, except for Senator Walsh, were present, passed a Waste Management Bill in which it decided on a particular route. The current Government has followed the policy decisions made in that Act in respect of which democracy must prevail.
Three out of 15 local authorities in three regional groups refuse to adopt regional waste management plans. Section 4 of the Bill amends section 22 of the Waste Management Act, 1996, to transfer the power to make a waste management plan from the elected members of a local authority to the relevant manager. This change will only affect the few local authorities which have failed, despite their obligation to do so under national and European law, to make and pass a waste management plan and deal with the cases mentioned by Senator Walsh where it was purported that a plan had been made, but in respect of which the decisions made were invalid by virtue of the qualifications imposed, as happened in County Roscommon, a matter to which I will return.
We will only use this power in those cases where local authorities have failed to live up to their responsibilities, in some cases after three or four years of consultations. The Bill will allow local authority management to conclude the planning process and move towards what everyone says they want, the effective implementation of regional waste management plans to provide for improved waste services and infrastructure throughout the country.
The planning process is under way for three to four years. Three out of 15 local authorities in three regional groups have failed or refused to adopt the plans placed before them which were drawn up on the basis of technical advice given by consultants. They were not, as Senator Connor claimed to my surprise, imposed by the Department of the Environment and Local Government; rather they were drawn up by consultants employed by the local authorities.
Comment on this
There are regional plans which have been adopted by all the local authorities concerned, in some cases subject to significant qualifications. This must be dealt with in a legal manner. My legal advice is that a regional waste management plan must be adopted on the same substantive basis by all of the local authorities concerned, otherwise it cannot be considered to be valid. If a local authority decides to adopt it with stipulations, ruling out landfill or incineration, it will invalidate the plan. That is what happened in County Roscommon.
Comment on this
I am conscious of the need to meet national and EU targets for waste recovery and the diversion of waste from landfill and the legal proceedings which have been initiated against Ireland in the European Court of Justice because of our ongoing failure to respect our waste planning obligations. This cannot continue. We do not have the luxury of giving the local authorities concerned another six months. I gave then 12 months in which they could not bring the matter to a conclusion.
We must act now to put modern and efficient waste management infrastructure in place to provide for improved services. As Minister, I have to act in the national interest and take the necessary steps to bring this lengthy process to a satisfactory conclusion. Having considered a range of legal options I have concluded that the existing regulatory powers under the 1996 Act are not strong enough to ensure a decisive and satisfactory outcome. That is the reason these proposals, which I deem to be reasonable, are before the House. I would prefer not to have to introduce this legislation, but, as indicated in recent years by the two main Opposition parties in the other House, I have a national obligation beyond that to the local parish or electorate.
While I have heard what is wrong with the Bill, the Opposition has not presented an alternative. All that it has offered is procrastination, preferring to wait and see what will happen. I reiterate that the word "incineration" is not used in the Bill. As Senator O'Dowd is aware, it does not matter if the plans are passed. There is a planning application for an incinerator near Drogheda. Preventing a plan from being passed will not stop the planning or Environmental Protection Agency process. It is disingenuous to tout the line, as the Senator, the Labour Party and the Green Party have done, that this is a major plan to impose incineration. That is nonsense.
In speaking of responsible actions by local authorities Senator Connor is speaking from the weakest position of any Member in either House.
Comment on this
A local authority which states that it is adopting a plan, but that we will not have—
Comment on this
I have no doubt that we can recycle, but it is a myth to say, as some people have, that there can be 100% recycling for everything. The Senator knows this as well as I do. The nonsense of a local authority telling me it has a waste management plan in place but will not deal with residual waste makes a laughing stock of those proposing it. I do not think the Senator should try to insult the intelligence of the electorate in such a manner.
Comment on this
The Senator also said there was nothing in the Connacht regional waste management plan about recycling or composting. It is obvious the Senator has not read the plan.
Comment on this
He would not come to the House and say what he did had he read the Connacht waste management plan.
Comment on this
In case the Senator does not have time between now and the end of Easter to read the waste management plan for Connacht I will give a summary of it. It talks about recycling, 48%—
Comment on this
—and landfill disposal, 19%. The plan's collection policy includes door to door collection of recyclable material with source segregation in all urban areas to expand to service 50% of the region's population; provision of bring banks in other areas not served by door to door systems and towns with more than a population of 200; provision of 21 recycling centres located in Galway city, Clifden, Tuam, Ballinasloe, Athenry, Castlebar, Ballina, Westport, Claremorris, Belmullet and – I offer this for the information of Senator Connor – in Castlerea, Boyle, Ballaghaderreen, Tubbercurry, Sligo, Manorhamilton, Carrick-on-Shannon, Ballinamore; two material recovery facilities in Galway and Sligo, to which Roscommon waste can go; six central composting facilities – no doubt waste from Roscommon can also be sent to these; two biological treatment facilities and the development of a central construction demolition waste recycling facility. To say the plan was not predicated on recycling is absolute nonsense.
This section of the Bill is central and I have no intention of accepting the amendments. I do not think the Members opposite are going to change their minds either. It is essential that this planning process is brought to an end and this is the only way I can see in which that can be done.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to clarify the extent to which this Bill will allow the manager power to vary a plan already adopted and if that becomes an executive function.
Comment on this
I wish to reply to the remarks made by the Minister. We opposed the plan in County Louth because it contained the option of thermal treatment. We only wanted to remove that option and accepted and welcomed the other provisions in the plan. The legal advice given to us by the county manager and the advice of two solicitors from a Dublin firm was that we could not reject part of the plan – it had to be accepted or rejected in total, which is the nub of the problem. We want everything in the plan except incineration.
Regarding the regional plan, it is only such in name and not in nature or in fact as the elected members who have the reserved function to make the plan never actually met as a group to collectively talk about and decide upon it. If the councillors in the region had met none of the plans would have been accepted as I hope all of them would have rejected incineration as an option. Whether they would or not, to say it is a regional plan is not strictly correct in the sense that councillors did not meet collectively as members of the region to decide upon it.
I was in communication with the waste management section of the European Community and was informed by those to whom I spoke that the European directive does not say we must have thermal treatment in our plans. There may be directives relating to incineration, but there is no legal obligation whatever on regional waste management plans to include thermal treatment as an option. There is an obligation to reduce waste and landfill. The Minister is wrong when he says incineration is not part of the Bill. Rather it is the only significant part of the Bill. It is being shoved down our throats by the Minister and it is why we are objecting to the Bill.
I do not know enough about County Roscommon but I know enough about Senator Connor to know the local authority members would have been very reasonable in their discussions. They wanted to reject one part but accept all the other provisions in the plan which are important. I ask the Minister to think again about what we are saying.
Comment on this
I would like to reply to some of the Minister's statements. I do not wish to be parochial, but this issue was discussed in great detail in our local authority with the consultants, the county manager and his staff in attendance. Line by line we took them through these sections dealing with waste minimisation, recycling, composting, etc. Because there is no infrastructure in the county which could facilitate these very desirable things we asked where the money would come from. We found it would take years to put the infrastructure in place and that there was no will in the Department to provide the necessary funding.
Roscommon has two of the most appalling landfill sites in the country. They have been badly managed, have had no resources invested in them and are a scourge to the neighbourhoods which are close to them. Members of the local authority, having common sense, decided they could not accept the plan, that they were buying a pig in a poke full of pious aspirations. In the end Mr. Rudden, the manager, could only say the waste of the county would go by and large to existing landfill sites or for incineration or thermal treatment because there are no facilities for minimisation or recycling and that such provision could not be envisaged for years. It was right that the members of the local authority decided in such circumstances – I was a leader in this regard and am proud of it – to reject the plan as it was presented to us.
We accept the principles of minimisation, composting, etc., but when will such facilities be available? We were not going to allow our area to become a location for an incinerator, given the Department's refusal to answer the most basic question about the health effects of thermal treatment and incineration. That issue has never been addressed and has always been avoided by the Minister. Until we have an independent study on the health effects of thermal treatment or incineration, which result in emissions into the atmosphere, why should any local authority, community or region want to accept them? Those who ran Bhopal, the chemical plant in India, would have said the emissions from it were safe but they resulted in the deaths of hundreds of people. Those in the Ukraine said the Chernobyl nuclear power plant was safe, yet it suffered a melt down. Nobody has scientifically or in any detail studied the health effects of incineration. Elected local authority members reflect the views of concerned citizens in local authority chambers.
Maybe in ten years' time we will have facilities for composting, recycling and facilities to recover energy from waste. Live long enough horse and you might get grass. I ask the reasonable people in this House if we are wrong to vote against the Bill. This attack upon us amounts to abuse, gratu itously insulting abuse because of what we did. We did right by our people. We did right because what was in front of us was totally inadequate. That is why this is wrong. The Minister is saying that the people have no right to be, as he sees it, wrong, that the local authorities have no right to be wrong as they see it. We have no right to assert the genuine desires, the genuine fears of the very people we represent at local level.
Going back to the broader issue, this is an attack on democracy. It is an appalling scandal. This will lead to nothing but huge numbers of local protests. Managers will only be answerable to the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. Under this Act, managers will be able to ignore the elected members and, therefore, effectively ignore public opinion in their own area. If that is not the antithesis of democracy, my name is Davey.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Senator Connor is trying to deliberately confuse the issue. The power given to the manager to pass a regional waste management plan does not give the manager the right to put a landfill site or an incinerator anywhere he likes within the county. The Senator must surely know that. For a Senator who is also a member of a local authority to come into this House and talk about how proud he is to have led his local authority in a particular direction in relation to waste management and admit that the same local authority has badly managed landfills and is doing nothing about it is an appalling admission for a Member of the Oireachtas—
Comment on this
No, nothing at all. The polluter pays principle is long established in waste management. The Senator should know that. I will give him the benefit of the doubt that he does not know it, otherwise he would not make such statements. It is the responsibility of the local authority – it has always been the responsibility of the local authority – to put in place proper—
Comment on this
If we do not get an adequate rates support grant, like many other things, we cannot provide enough housing.
Comment on this
Rubbish. We are talking about the polluter pays principle. The local authority is responsible and has always been responsible. Roscommon County Council, over the past four years, has been given an increase of approximately 60% in its rates support grant. I wonder what it is doing with it. Certainly, by the Senator's admission, if that admission is accurate, it is not being spent on environmental matters.
Comment on this
The Senator should not come into this House and talk about badly managed landfill sites.
Comment on this
The Senator spoke about badly managed landfill sites in Roscommon, appalling landfill sites. The Senator, as a councillor—
Comment on this
—is responsible for ensuring that the manager does his job in Roscommon and that the facilities provided for landfill, for waste management, are up to standard.
Comment on this
No, the council has responsibility under the polluter pays principle. I have no responsibility in relation to the running of local authority landfill sites.
Comment on this
The Minister has responsibility to provide the local authorities with adequate funding.
Comment on this
We need to get rid of the dual mandate where people are not willing to accept responsibility here as national legislators or in their own local authority as local authority members. The provision of the infrastructure in relation to waste management is a responsibility for the local authority. We will be assisting those local authorities which have adopted the polluter pays principle and are putting in place the infrastructure for recycling. Even as it stands today, the local authority has a responsibility and it is not a responsibility that members should be trying to shift elsewhere.
On what Senator O'Dowd said about councillors not meeting as a regional group, I accept that they did not. That is not the way these things are done. Agreements are decided individually under section 59 of the Act to go ahead and do this on a regional basis. The procedure, as is common in these section 59 agreements, is that local authorities then individually adopt it. I accept that what the Senator says is accurate in relation to councillors not coming together in a region. That was never the way it was done, and this is no different. The Senator is absolutely accurate and he did not accuse me at any stage of saying that there was some explicit EU requirement for incineration. I agree with that statement, there is no explicit EU requirement. The consultants concluded that the diversion targets that we have to reach in relation to waste would not be met solely by recycling and composting. That decision and recommendation was arrived at on the basis of experience, not just in this country, but across Europe in countries with high standards of environmental practice and good integrated waste management policies.
Senator Connor accused me of always avoiding the issue of health implications. I spoke in this House during Second Stage at great length on the issue. I have spoken in other fora about the health issues in relation to incineration. The problem is that no matter how often I speak about it, those who are deaf do not hear and do not want to hear—
Comment on this
Some of the Members of this House heard an eminent German expert toxicologist, Dr. Dieter Schrenk, a professor of food chemistry and environmental toxicology, advise local authority members throughout the country on the issue of possible health risks from municipal waste incineration. He does not foresee problems and he is an adviser to the World Health Organisation.
I spoke on Second Stage about the case of the Isle of Man. The chief medical officer and director of public health for the Isle of Man, who is certainly an independent individual, but who seems to have been powerful enough to tell the Government not to go ahead with an incinerator until he had an opportunity to study the possible health effects of the emissions and dioxins from incineration, stopped the project and presented a report after 12 months investigation which then approved the provision of an incinerator on the Isle of Man.
In 1997 the international agency for research on cancer, an agency of the World Health Organ isation, classed the most toxic dioxin compound as a known human carcinogen. However, the WHO also considers that there is a level of exposure to dioxins below which cancer risk would be negligible. It is on that basis that emission levels are set by the EU. There are controls in the EU Directive on Thermal Treatment and Incineration. The directive applies the extremely stringent standard of 0.1 nanograms, that is one ten thousand millionth of a gram per cubic metre of gas emitted. This standard is currently applied by the EPA in IPC licensing and it will apply throughout the EU. The EU Commission estimates that the implementation of the directive will result in a 99% reduction in emissions of dioxins from waste incineration compared to the period 1993-95.
We hear stories about reductions in incineration and Europe moving away from incineration. These are not true. At least 14 member states include incineration as part of their waste management strategies. I find it difficult to believe that the Governments and regulatory agencies of those 14 states are knowingly acquiescing in causing damage to the environment, the health of their citizens or public health generally. I am not afraid of the health issue in relation to incineration. I would prefer to live beside an incinerator than a landfill site.
Senator O'Meara asked about a local authority manager's power to vary a plan. A manager cannot vary an original plan. To do so would be to operate on the same basis as the councils which put in qualifications.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 5 is consequential on amendment No. 10 and they may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
The purpose of this amendment is to curtail the potential opportunity for obstructing the implementation of waste management plans by means of the development plan variation procedure under the Planning and Development Act, 2000. This is a logical and necessary provision and is consistent with the preceding subsection, which already provides that sections 3 or 4 of the City and County Management Act, 1955, or section 1(79) of the Planning and Development Act, 2000, cannot be used to block the implementation of waste management plans.
Waste management plans in most cases are not sites specific for recovery or disposal facilities. Development of these facilities would have to be consistent with the zoning and specific objectives in local development plans under the Planning and Development Act, 2000. As matters stand implementation of the waste management plans, through the provision of the requisite waste management infrastructure, could require the relevant local development plan to be varied under section 13 of the Planning and Development Act, 2000, which is a reserved function following a public consultation procedure.
The proposed amendment provides that the development plan in force in an area shall be deemed to include the objectives for the time being contained in the waste management plan in force in that particular area. In addition, the proposed amendment provides for a notification and public consultation procedure modelled on the standard planning material contravention provisions for situations where a planning authority proposes to grant planning permission for development consistent with a waste management plan but which would materially contravene any other objective of the development plan. Following consideration of any submissions or observations the final decision on whether to grant planning permission rests with the manager.
The proposed amendment also provides for a notification and consultation procedure in relation to any proposed development to be undertaken by or on behalf of a local authority itself consistent with the waste management plan but which in the opinion of the manager would contravene materially any other objective in a development plan. Following consideration of any submissions or observations the final decision on whether to proceed with the procedures set out in the planning Act to allow for the development plan rests with the manager. The provision in the proposed amendment would apply to waste management plans already adopted as well as plans made by the manager under this section.