Waste Management (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 2001: Committee and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 145–283 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 2001 ›
It may seem to the Minister a minor point but after the consideration earlier about the amount of paper published and the need to do something about it by encouraging people to use less of it, I suggest that section (10B)(a)(i) which reads:
publish notice of the intention of the authority to grant the permission in one or more newspapers circulating in that area
include also the additional words "and on the Internet". Also in section (10C) (1) after the words "in one or more newspapers circulating in that functional area", will he consider adding "and on the Internet"? I say this in the knowledge that we had an interesting debate earlier on how some Departments use the Internet and encourage the absence of paper. We know it should be published in the newspaper and we are not suggesting a substitute, but I suggest the addition of the words "and on the Internet" or some other suitable words. In the past when I proposed this on occasions I found that words such as "or electronic means" have suited some Departments. I propose that as an amendment to the amendment.
Comment on this
In an attempt to be clear on what this amendment means I wish to ask the Minister about functions and so on. It is the reserved function of the members to adopt a development plan but the Bill makes it an executive function of the manager to adopt a waste plan where members have not done so. Clearly this has implications for the county development plan.
Comment on this
That is the point I wish to make. The Minister said it is consistent with the Bill. Clearly it is consistent with the principle of removing discretion from members. The language the Minister used was that it is designed to curtail the opportunity to use the development plan to stop a landfill or a thermal treatment plant or whatever going ahead. I would have concerns in that regard. It presupposes that members of a local authority would be looking for ways of curtailing the location of—
Comment on this
I made the point on Second Stage and I do not intend to repeat it all again. I am a member of a local authority which adopted a plan. Nobody opposed it. We swallowed our concerns and said we had to get on with it. At the same time I would stand over the right of any person to oppose the adoption of a plan. We live in a democracy.
Comment on this
Clearly we have difficulties about this. I want to be clear about what we are adopting in this substantial and complex amendment. It is important to spend some time teasing it out. The first paragraph of the amendment, " Where a planning authority proposes to grant permission .. for development which is consistent with the provisions . of . a waste management plan." is critical. In other words, it intends to grant planning permission for some type of waste facility but by so doing would contravene materially an objective of the development plan then the manager has power to act. Am I correct in saying that is the objective of the amendment? In other words, the manager can materially contravene the development plan in order to give permission for a facility which is part of the waste plan.
Comment on this
I have exactly the same questions, though perhaps going further. Here we have an extension of the powers of the county manager to thwart resourceful members of my local authority by inappropriately placing a waste facility in our area. We cannot now use our county development plan. If it could be shown under current legislation that the proposal was a material contravention of our county development plan and that we as local authority members could not intervene to protect it, that would be a serious erosion of local democracy. That power has been a reserved function of local authority members for many years. A material contravention of a county development plan had to go before the local authority which had to give its consent.
In this amendment the Minister is trying to close off all democratic loopholes. He extends the power of the manager, thus eroding further the democratic powers which local authority members enjoyed for many years. That is a retrograde step and smacks of the iron fist approach. In the event of local objection the local authority chief executive, with the consent of the Minister and his Department, can decide to put in place a waste facility that has serious environmental concerns for many people. Local authority members are being emasculated to the extent that if they wanted to be creative, imaginative or resourceful and to attack the manager and the Minister's plans, that role is being taken from them.
Many Members on that side of the House are members of a local authority. Can they allow this to be done to them? Will they allow their hands to be tied behind their back because of the waste management policies of the Minister? Those policies are wrong because they do not allow for a contribution from local people. It is popular to say that this is due to the NIMBY – not in my back yard – attitude, but people have serious concerns about these matters. They look to their local authority members, as the people on the front line, to put their concerns forward and to defend them. Here, however, the Minister is extending the tentacles of the Bill to ensure there is no way local authority members can attack or successfully challenge, within their local authority area, an attempt to do something highly inappropriate.
Comment on this
I received a copy of the amendments on Friday but I did not see this amendment among them and I have not had a chance to study it. I wish to put a few questions to the Minister on the amendment.
Comment on this
I have not had time to study it, which might or might not be a good thing from the Minister's point of view. At present, the development plan is a reserved function of the elected members. If the corporate body wishes to vary the plan, it must publish a notice. In what way is the procedure in the amendment different from what is there already? When local authority members vary a development plan, it is the subject of discussion at the local authority meeting. Is there a reference to that in this section or can that be superseded? In other words, does the amendment allow discussion by the local authority of the proposed draft variation by the manager?
Are there any implications for planning law generally? I presume the Minister will say there are not, but is he sure of that? This has been a reserved function of the elected members for a long time. If that power is removed from them for the purposes of the waste management strategy, can the Minister provide in the amendment a guarantee that it will not or cannot affect any other areas? I presume that a section 4 motion will not be relevant in this respect, in other words that a section 4 motion under this amendment could not compel the manager to do something that was lawful and proper, which is to vary the development plan according to the wishes of the members.
Does this procedure have any planning implications for An Bord Pleanála? Any planning application of which I am aware has had to conform with the development plan which the members have made. Now there will be a number of cases which will not conform with the development plan. The elected members will oppose them and that will create a crisis for local government. What implications will this have for the appeal process? Is there an appeal process or does this disallow it? The Minister is changing the law for varying a development plan. Does that have a knock on effect in any way on An Bord Pleanála decisions?
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain section (10C)-(3) further? This appears to facilitate a situation arising where the manager could bring in a proposed development even though it was against something which had already been decided to be for the common good. This is odd and surely unwise.
Comment on this
I can assure Senator Quinn that under the planning Act any notice which can be published in a newspaper may also be published electronically under section 249(1), which this provision affects. It does not need to be restated. The facility of publishing this electronically on a website or whatever can be used.
Comment on this
Yes, it does not have to be. They may use the facility and in practice most of the local authorities are going down that route.
The explanation I gave earlier was long and detailed because the amendment is long and detailed. I will clarify it again, although Members have grasped the intent. It permits the manager to grant permissions in material contravention of the development plan. As Members correctly pointed out, this function is normally reserved to the elected members because it amounts to a specific variation of the development plan. The purpose of the Bill is to ensure that the planning process for waste management is brought to a conclusion and, when that happens, that the waste management plans can be implemented.
I am simply trying to ensure that this aim is not thwarted. I do not want to be back in the House in three, six or 12 months because an enterprising councillor or member of a local authority decided to thwart the aim of getting the waste management plans implemented by using the planning law or other sections of the local government and planning Acts. It is, to put it bluntly, to fireproof what I am doing in giving the manager the power to adopt the waste management plans. It will apply in particular to those local authorities that have not adopted waste management plans.
It has no implications for planning law generally. It is not an extended power but is specific to waste management and waste management facilities. This amendment supersedes the normal variation procedure in this instance only; it is limited to developments by a private developer or the local authority which is to implement the waste management plan.
The Senator also asked about appeals. The normal appeal procedure under the Planning and Development Act would apply. People have the right to appeal under the Act and the board will have to hear the appeal and have regard to the development plan in all its decisions. However, as we have seen previously, the board has on occasion overridden development plans.
Under section (10C)-(3), the manager could decide to proceed with the procedures set out under the planning Act but he or she is still bound by the requirements of the Act, that is, to provide for the proper planning and development of the area. An Bord Pleanála is also obliged to comply with that. Decisions on the developments we are discussing will be taken as normal after the procedure that is set out in the amendment. In other words, there is a public consultation procedure. The procedure is as it currently exists for all other material contraventions. There will be a period of consultation. Appeals will be allowed and An Bord Pleanála will have to decide them in the normal way.
Comment on this
I was tempted to intervene on several occasions when I was in the Chair but, knowing that it would be inappropriate, I waited until I had the opportunity of speaking from the floor.
Senator Connor spoke about the contribution of local people to these decisions. I would also be enthusiastic about devolving local government and more powers for councillors but one can only devolve powers to those prepared to use them. From my experience in Kildare County Council, people are reluctant to use powers even for simple things like hackney and taxi licences. I have frequently heard people in the council chamber speak about devolving power, but when one points out to them that they have a devolved power they are not prepared to use they do not seem to see any contradiction.
The contribution of local people on this issue is unanimous – nobody wants a dump in their area. I do not want one in my area. How does the Opposition propose that we dispose of waste? Nobody has come up with an alternative for disposing of it. The Minister made a very telling point earlier in the debate when he spoke about his national responsibilities. He is to be applauded for taking those responsibilities so seriously. It cannot be easy to do so but that is a Minister's job and that is what he has done.
I drove to the west last weekend and came back through Galway and Roscommon and so on. One does not travel ten miles without seeing a sign about a superdump. There are no more dumps because they are all superdumps. I was very vocal about the Kill dump, which could be regarded as a superdump, and I opposed it on the grounds of its proximity to the Liffey, ground water pollution and so on. There were real grounds for not locating it where it was planned but that battle was lost even if, from my experience, it was managed well.
We come back to the point that whether the manager or the members make the decision, and whether that decision is favourable or negative, I do not know of one case that has not gone to An Bord Pleanála. Either the conditions were appealed by the applicants or something such as a refusal resulted in the case going to An Bord Pleanála. It was unusual in Kildare in that one local authority wanted to locate a landfill in another authority's area, which meant the refusal from one local authority led to the other making an appeal to An Bord Pleanála, which it won. I cannot envisage a case that would not reach beyond the local authority and be adjudicated on elsewhere.
From that point of view I am more comfortable than I would otherwise be about the manager making a decision as there is a court of appeal and the observations, which the manager must of course have regard to, are legitimate and can be considered by An Bord Pleanála. The inspector's report can be taken into account when the final decision is made.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister but seek clarification on the variation of the development plan. Will that go before the local authority for discussion? I am not clear if he responded to that query. The normal procedure is that the council meets, the variation motion is discussed after the procedures are followed but the Bill does not mention its returning to the local authority for discussion. If that is not included it should be because it is very important that the members should be able to discuss what the manager is doing.
Section (10c)(1)(i) refers to development which is consistent with implementing the waste management plan enforced in the area but which the manager feels will materially contravene the plan, provided the work is proposed to be done by the local authority. However, can the Minister explain paragraph (b)? The Bill seems to state that one could have a partnership or relationship with a local authority where a private company rather than a local authority provides a facility. How is that different from not having it in the Act? What impact does it have? What is the extra reason for paragraph (b)?
I accept Senator Dardis's points regarding sensitivity about dumps. I have received letters on this matter from people in the private sector, and to which I did not respond in one case, about land they have in different parts of Louth. For instance, there was an asbestos dump in Togher and the seven or eight acres there have given rise to a row as to whether the land is sealed or not. According to this Act a developer could look for planning permission for this site under the variation procedure and all the issues would be agreed provided they had entered into an agreement with the local authority.
Comment on this
Is this not a huge power to give the manager, that even if a proposed development would materially contravene the development plan he or she could still go ahead with it? It is an amazing power to give someone. Why bother to have development plans at all if someone who decides to do something in the waste management sector, even if it is going to do terrible damage to the plan, can just go ahead with it? There must be a good reason or the Minister would not have put this in but it has not yet dawned on me what it is.
Comment on this
Is this not a huge power to give the manager, that even if a proposed development would materially contravene the development plan he or she could still go ahead with it? There must be a good reason but what is the point in having a development plans and going through all the consultations if, in the heel of the hunt, the most appalling things may be done? Some managers are better than others and nobody seems to be in a position to override the manager's decision. Even the Minister seems unable to override those decisions and that seems a huge power to give someone.
Comment on this
I do not agree with Senator Henry but it seems to me that a county development plan will never have an incinerator or thermal plant. A plan will never include a dump because on that basis it would never be passed. I understand why the Minister has had to take these draconian measures. It is for that reason, to return to the issue I raised earlier, that we should not limit information about this solely to those who buy newspapers.
If we introduce legislation we should not limit it to people who buy newspapers to get information on that legislation. Many people, particularly young people, now stay at home and do not have to buy newspapers. Many of them depend on local radio for the death notices, for example, which they used to read in newspapers. For that reason I urge the Minister to set an example for local authorities by providing that they have to use electronic means to disclose this information, rather than providing that may use such means. When these matters are advertised and publicised in local newspapers the Minister should add "and by electronic means" in both cases. I know he has explained there is nothing to stop them doing that and that they may do so, but we should set an example here.
It will not set an example for every other case that must be publicised, such as planning, but we had an interesting discussion earlier about the amount of paper we have. We are now entering a new age where we do not need that quantity of paper. People who can buy local newspapers should do so by all means but those who choose not to do so should be able to get the information by sitting at home and glancing at the Internet to see something of interest to them without having to buy a newspaper. The Minister should take this into account and include "by electronic means" where newspapers are mentioned in the Bill.
Comment on this
I will try to answer some of the questions fairly succinctly and clarify whether managers will discuss these matters and whether councillors will have an opportunity to make their views on variations known. This amendment outlines a procedure whereby submissions and observations can be made by councillors or anyone else. The manager must consider such observations.
Paragraph (b) of section (10c)(1) is a reflection of existing planning law and basically allows a joint venture with a local authority or a public-private partnership if an authority is not providing a suitable waste management facility. Rather than dealing specifically with queries that have been raised, I will give a general explanation of this section. We are putting in place a procedure to complete the waste management planning process, a procedure which would be pointless if we did not fireproof it against those who would thwart the intention of the Legislature in regard to waste management planning.
The proposed change in planning law ensures that a development plan cannot be used to defeat the implementation of a waste management plan when sites under the latter plan are selected. That is the simplest way I can phrase this logical change which is a consequence of changes we are making elsewhere. It is designed to ensure that our plans are not thwarted.
Comment on this
In view of what he has said, does the Minister consider it wise to write into the Bill that these matters be discussed by the local authority? I appreciate the Minister's comments about consultation and written submissions, but nowhere does it say that local authorities, as corporate bodies, shall discuss this. In theory a manager, having allowed submissions, may not put further discussion on the agenda and may say that he is doing what the Act allows him to do, although equally this may not happen. I realise that elected members can dictate what is on the agenda, but it should be statutory that local authority members discuss the matter before the manager makes his decision, within the context of the procedure as a whole.
Comment on this
It is neither necessary nor desirable to enforce such a stipulation. As the Senator rightly says, most managers will try to ensure they reflect the views of the council, when directing a waste management plan. I would be wary of putting in specific stipulations making it necessary that it is discussed with elected members. Those who control the agenda for a meeting could continue to postpone the item on the agenda and thereby thwart the procedure. I think we can safely leave it to the good sense of both managers and elected members to ensure that something like this is discussed as part of the normal consultation and submission procedure. I am not inclined to change what I have proposed as I feel that it allows the kind of discussion the Senator referred to.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding anything that may be in the Bill, I wonder if any member of a local authority envisages a circumstance whereby it would not be discussed regardless of whether it was on the agenda. I cannot.
Comment on this
That may be so, but I am asking a different question. In this legislation, is the Minister giving the manager the power not to refer to a local authority if he does not wish to? There is no statutory obligation. Variations on a development plan are a matter for elected members, who discuss such variations when they come before them at corporate body meetings. There is no requirement, as I see it, for the corporate body to meet to discuss the matter. Although I accept the Minister's comments as regards where it would come on the agenda, perhaps he would consider ensuring that it would be the only item on the agenda and therefore have to be dealt with. At least a useful democratic process of consultation would be written into the Bill.
I realise that many of the things we have suggested may never happen, but it only needs to happen once to turn the Minister's provision on its head. This issue is difficult and emotive in local communities. I appreciate I have had a number of opportunities to speak on this amendment and if Minister has anything to say I am happy to listen.
Comment on this
Without being disrespectful to the Senator, I have nothing more to say as I do not think it is necessary to write such a specific measure into the Act. I do not intend to do so as the submissions and observations procedure should be sufficient.
Comment on this
I wish to raise questions about the amendment of subsection (10)(b) of section 22 of the 1996 Act which enshrines waste management plans as the law of the council and gives such plans a retrospective legal status that nobody realised they would have. Consultants were appointed to deal with waste management plans, a reserved function of the elected members. County managers were given the authority to appoint such consultants. Waste management plans were drawn up and discussed by members, a number of whom disagreed on what was contained within them. The amendment will make such plans law. Effectively, the county manager will implement plans completed prior to the passage of the Bill. I am concerned about the implications of this. The Minister may consider that there is none, but there must be some. Any waste management plan drawn up by a consultant in consultation with the county manager, as proposed under the section, effectively, will be law, irrespective of whether members of the local authority support it. In that context, does the Minister have a view on the constitutionality or propriety of the retrospective nature of the amendment of subsection (10)(b) of section 22 of the 1996 Act? I hope I have made myself clear.
Comment on this
I know what the Senator is asking. We are not talking about retrospective legislation. None of the plans to which the section will apply has been validly passed as they currently stand. We are putting in place legislation which is essential to complete a process in order that we can say that we have waste management plans. Section 4 provides that having gone through the procedure, whether the decision is made by the manger or, as has happened in many cases, councillors, we will be in a position to implement what is contained in the plan. We are trying to avoid a situation where people might use aspects of other legislation, such as the Planning and Development Act, to prevent a waste management plan from being implemented. The question of retrospection does not apply in this case.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minister's point of view. I wish to clarify that following the passage of the Bill the preparation of a plan, formerly a reserved function of members, will under this section be a reserved function of the manager. If members disagreed with what was contained in the original plan, it would not make sense to return to it. I would have thought that in such circumstances a manager would have to bring forward a new plan from the date of enactment of the Bill when such a plan would be given retrospective recognition.
While I appreciate the point made by the Minister, under the section retrospective recognition will be given to a waste management plan; it will be enshrined in law and given a special legal status that it did not have when prepared. If councillors knew when plans were being drawn up that they would be given that status subsequently, many plans, or, at least, the plan drawn up by the local authority of which I am a member would have been different in many ways.
Comment on this
An issue arises in the drafting of waste management plans in that most will be drafted by those with technical qualifications and consultants. The manager will have to rely on them together with his technical staff to make an assessment. Allegations have been made that some of the consultants concerned could have a vested interest in some of the proposals made in that they may act for persons who would make planning applications. There would be very significant fees involved. A facility mooted in my area was costed by its proposers, ESBI, at £80 million, of which 5% would be £4 million.
To ensure there is absolutely no conflict of interest any consultant drafting a plan should not be in a position to subsequently pursue an application or represent an applicant to the council. This issue needs to be looked at to ensure that we are not compromised in the manner in which plans will be presented to the council or to the manager in this instance.
Comment on this
I am reluctant to respond to an allegation that there are conflicts of interest in relation to drawing up regional waste management plans. The plans are already drawn up in draft form and have not been passed yet. Any element of the waste management plan that has to be implemented or any facility which has to be put in place by a local authority will obviously have a full and open procurement process. Accordingly, the question of a conflict of interest is not a real issue. I am aware of only two companies being involved in drafting plans and one should be very wary of accusing anybody of having a conflict of interest.
On the matter of decisions being made by managers, they will be aided by the steering group and will have to evaluate the technical quality and the rationale for any recommendations which come before the council, particularly in the context of variation of development plans. The full rigours of public procurement will apply, whether the facility is being provided by a local authority or on a PPP basis. I do not envisage that the difficulties to which the Senator referred will arise.
Comment on this
The north-eastern waste management plan has an illustration showing a recently opened therma-select gasification plant at Karlsruhe in Germany. The document states:
A newly commissioned plant in Germany uses the therma-select process, which combines partial porolisis in a pre-stage with oxygen-blown high temperature gasification, for the treatment of non-hazardous waste. The process looks promising, but is still in the early stages and needs to be closely monitored.
Suppose a consultant decides to opt for that process, what checks and balances are provided in the Bill to ensure that it is a credible decision? Perhaps the manager should refer the waste management plan to the Minister's Department for advice in that situation. A consultant could very well be mistaken in his conclusions.
Comment on this
I have not got a copy of the north-eastern waste management plan with me, but I read the plan, probably 12 months ago. The Senator referred to one particular illustration of the therma-select gasification process, which is a form of incineration or waste-to-energy recovery. The advice which has been available to me at all times is that gasification is probably one of the most promising of the thermal treatments when compared to thermolosis, pyrolysis, vitrification etc. However, I have always been advised that, although it may look promising, it is not a proven technology. Although some consultants and engineers think it has enormous potential, nobody opted specifically for gasification in the regional waste management plans because it is not proven technology. As Senator O'Dowd is aware, the particular plant referred to had to be closed because of measurable levels of emissions.
On the broader point made by the Senator, where a local authority chooses this particular route, landfill, waste water or whatever, the normal procedure is that a client's representative is appointed as a first step. The consultants appointed for that purpose, whether local, national or international, would be qualified to act on behalf of the local authority to ensure that the whole procurement procedure was properly put in place, including all the technical details. Where local authorities have not got the relevant in-house expertise, they can hire it in. The appointed client representative then vets the proposals for a particular facility, both from technical and overview perspectives. This safeguard system has worked well, whether for large contracts or otherwise, including waste water treatment facilities and waste management.
Comment on this
Appointing a client's representative does not necessarily involve the Department of the Environment and Local Government in the assessment. Department officials, for whom I have high regard, should have a role in the decision-making process and the Bill should in some way acknowledge that. The involvement of the Department, which has no vested interest in the matter, would help people to accept an argument which they may have strongly opposed.
Comment on this
The choice of thermal treatment technologies will be a matter for the regions to decide for themselves. The client's representative, acting on behalf of the regional groups, because it will be done on a regional basis, will advise on a range of matters, including the technical solutions, the selection of the projects and evaluation of the various technologies. The Department will participate in the regional steering groups dealing with implementation of the plan and I assure the Senator that it will also be involved in the oversight of the PPP procurement process.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 6, line 39, to delete "facility." and substitute the following:
"facility,
(e) the Minister shall appoint an administrative structure within his or her department to ensure compliance with Article 18 of the Council Directive 96/61/EC, Integrated Pollution and Control.”.
I will not delay the House because it is obvious what I would like to see here. Monitoring is always a good idea and I had hoped the Minister would appoint an administrative structure within his Department to ensure compliance with Article 18 of Council Directive 96/61/EC.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept this amendment. It is unnecessary in the context of waste management. Article 18.1 of the IPPC directive provides that the Council of Ministers shall set emissions limit values – ELVs – in respect of emissions to air and water of an indicative list of polluting substances from a wide range of industrial and waste activities specified in the directive. Under Article 18.2 pending the development of community ELVs pursuant to this directive relevant ELVs are contained in 15 other specified directives and shall be applied as minimum values in respect of the industrial and waste activities concerned.
In so far as the regulatory control of waste activities is concerned, the requirements of Article 18.2 are already fully implemented by the Environmental Protection Agency. All significant waste recovery and disposal activities are licensed by the EPA under Part Five of the Waste Management Act, 1996. Under the waste management licensing regulations, 2000, the agency is required to attach to any waste licence granted by it such conditions as are necessary to give effect to specified provisions of specified community acts in so far as such provisions are relevant to the waste activity concerned. The specified provisions for this purpose include Article 18.2 of Directive 96/61/EC. Accordingly, the EPA applies the relevant ELVs as a minimum requirement in licensing activities. The Senator's worthy amendment is already catered for in legislation.
Comment on this
I am speaking on behalf of An Taisce here. They welcome this particular element of the Bill and the right of the Minister to prohibit certain wastes being recovered or disposed of. They make the point that the understanding is that the Minister has the power to guarantee to communities affected by incineration plants that wastes that are known to cause serious environmental pollution can be removed from the waste stream by regulation, notwithstanding licensing procedures. They would like to see an explanation of why and they suggest we should add to it the words "in order to prevent environmental pollution arising from the recovery or disposal of such waste". The reminder is that in everything to do with waste it is better to reuse rather than recycle. This explanation, if included in the Bill, would be of benefit to it. I propose this to the Minister because it would strengthen the Bill.
Comment on this
I would like to confirm that section 7 prohibits hazardous waste, plastics etc., which can cause pollutant problems.
Comment on this
I agree with the Senators and An Taisce's sentiment on this section of the Bill. Senators will accept that it is not normal in a Bill, for various reasons, not least that our friends in the Four Courts would ride rough shod over them, to state why a particular provision is included in a Bill. In reply to Senators Quinn and Walsh, we are taking the power to allow the Minister to remove harmful streams of waste. This applies to landfill and will apply to incineration or thermal treatment. Another reason is that if the waste streams are not segregated, it allows me to place a ban on certain types goods going into waste facilities and so force people to recycle and re-use. It would not be good practice to put the reason into the Bill, but I assure the Senators that I am at one with them on this.
Comment on this
I agree with what the Minister says about this. I recall our earlier discussion about the amount of newspapers, for instance, going into landfills. I also bring to his attention that An Taisce are concerned about PVC, batteries and treated wood going into any waste disposal facility, especially thermal treatment. I ask him to consider these when he makes regulations.
Comment on this
I will do so. Senator O'Meara's list appeared on the EPA guidelines about the burning of livestock, because of the foot and mouth outbreak, as items not to be used. We are aware of the problem. I also want to ensure that as much as possible construction and demolition waste is taken out of landfill as it causes a problem. This gives me the power to that and I intend to use it in that way.
Comment on this
It is proposed to amend the definition of a plastic bag in section 72 of the Bill providing for the imposition of an environment levy on such bags and other potentially environmentally problematic products. After consultation with the Revenue Commissioners, it is considered appropriate for the purposes of implementation of the levy to define a plastic bag by reference to its composition, that is wholly or partially of plastic, and suitability for use at retail checkouts, rather than by reference to the concept of designed and intended for such use.
It is worth recalling that the purpose of this levy is litter management. It is designed to discourage the use of plastic bags. Even if manufacturers' claims about the biodegradability of certain plastic bags are accurate, they still end up on hedges and elsewhere, perhaps for not as long but it is still unsightly litter. I am not inclined to make that distinction.
A further consideration regarding any exemption is the implications for the implementation and enforcement of the regulations. People could have great fun deciding whether a bag was biodegradable or non-biodegradable. It would be open to a supplier to claim that his bags were biodegradable and exempt. The phrase used by an infamous English judge springs to mind, an appalling vista. We are trying for as reasonable a definition as possible. I commend the amendment to the House.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 7, line 8, after "a bag" to insert "supplied for the purposes of a waste management plan or".
I support action to reduce the use and proliferation of plastic bags but I am not convinced about how we will do that, specifically how this levy will work. I support the Minister's intention but hoped that he would ban them. We should start at that point and then move backwards towards allowing plastic bags for specific purposes such as hygiene in supermarkets or food outlets, where the Food Safety Authority might require them. On the Continent there are no plastic bags at supermarket checkouts. The customer is expected to bring a reusable bag. That should be our aim. I hope this levy will have that effect.
Some bags should not be levied. One is the heavy duty plastic bag which some supermarkets encourage and sell for 10p or 50p. They should not be seen in the same context as the ubiquitous plastic bag we want to get rid of. Their use should be encouraged.
This amendment is designed to ensure that the bag which consumers buy from local waste management companies for collection is not levied. The charges for these bin bags are increasing. It is largely single householders or old people, who do not generate huge amounts of waste and do not require a wheelie bin, who use this type of bag. They should not be levied because they are not the same as the plastic bags which litter the countryside causing a major problem.
While I support the Minister's intention and the spirit of the Bill in this regard, we must tease out how it will work in practice. I ask him to consider this amendment positively.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. The Minister's objective is excellent. We want fewer plastic bags. Senator O'Meara's amendment concerns a significant area of activity and would be useful. It will be absolutely impossible to collect the levy – it will be a nightmare for everybody. What is simplest is best, although I do not know what is the simplest thing to do. When I said that we should ban plastic bags I did not understand that the cost of producing paper bags was so high, as outlined by Senator Quinn. I would be happy to ban plastic bags, although it may not make sense as one wonders how the law might be applied. What the Minister said is good and constructive, but I am not happy with the mechanism proposed.
Comment on this
Senator O'Meara's amendment suggests that after the word "bags" we insert the words "supplied for the purposes of a waste management plan or". It will be very difficult to include such a provision in the Bill. The meat will be in the order made by the Minister, and while I understand exactly what the Senator is trying to do, namely, to exclude a certain type of bag, I could table 20 similar amendments. I have not done so, however, as the provision must be flexible enough to allow the Minister to make changes by order in order that he is not forced to return to the Oireachtas to introduce amending legislation. I have no problem supporting what is being suggested by the Senator. My problem is with including such details in legislation rather than ministerial orders.
I have often heard of the legislation pertaining to the muzzling of certain dogs introduced within hours or days of a crisis when a child was bitten by a dog. It was never enforced. The general tenor of the provision is to empower the Minister to make an order which can be adjusted over time. I doubt if matters will be exactly right from the outset, and I would hate to find that we have to return the legislation to the Oireachtas to cover other areas. If we start inserting details such as that proposed by the Senator, we could have an additional 20 amendments, but such detail should not form part of the Bill. The legislation will be more effective if it gives the Minister the ability to make orders which can be changed.
Comment on this
We are all in favour of what the Minister is trying to do, but it will be extraordinarily difficult. Senator Quinn has the most experience of dealing with plastic bags and is, probably, correct in saying the detail should be left to ministerial orders. We must change the philosophy in order that people do not look for plastic bags. On Second Stage Senator Dardis said that every Sunday morning he buys the newspapers and the same nice girl asks if he would like a plastic bag, to which he always says no. I would say that every Member has had the same experience. I tell people in shops not to offer plastic bags, that people should be made beg for them. I am told, however, that people ask for plastic bags, even for a packet of crisps. I have tabled an amendment to ensure that, at least, an attempt is made to charge people for bags. I do not know what we can do if we do not change the philosophy.
Senators have mentioned attitudes in other countries, particularly Germany where one is viewed as a Vandal or Goth if one looks for a plastic bag, even to carry some bread and a couple of slices of ham for a picnic. A huge effort is required about which the legislation may do something. What we must work on is the philosophy which is down to each of us.
Comment on this
The only manufacturer of plastic bags in Ireland is located in my constituency about four miles from where I live. The Minister will appreciate the pressure I am under, not only from the employees, but also from the distributors. The factory was called Europlast and owned by Údarás na Gaeltachta. It got into difficulty a number of years ago and was taken over by EPI, an Italian company. The employers maintain that the levy has been tried in other countries and proved unsuccessful – at least, that is what I am told. The employees are very concerned as there were over 50 employed in the company when owned by Údarás, a figure which has now been reduced to 24 or 25. This also concerns a number of distributors who travel the country selling the bags and who have also contacted me. The jobs are at risk as there have been difficulties. Raw material costs have increased by over 40% and the two other manufacturers in the country have closed. Perhaps in time no bags will be manufactured in Ireland, which would be a solution for the Minister.
The employees have asked me to raise the issue. The distributors are asking me who will be responsible for collecting the levy when introduced. I understand the shopkeeper will be responsible. From my experience in accountancy and dealing with shopkeepers who may not be as large or as well organised as Senator Quinn, there will be huge scope for malpractice in terms of collecting the money. I am not arguing that it should be collected at the manufacturing stage, which would, probably, ensure the levy was paid, but there will be huge practical issues.
Employees have also asked if the levy will be applied to all plastic bags. For example, will small plastic bags used for pick and mix carry a levy of 15p? Another issue is the choice of using a box or plastic bag. I prefer a bag as I find it easier to dispose of in a proper manner whereas a cardboard box could be thrown anywhere. Will people who provide cardboard boxes be charged? I accept that there is much pollution due to plastic bags, which can be seen on trees, along rivers, etc. The biggest source of litter pollution, however, is fast food take-aways as a result of the boxes and papers used for packaging. It will be unfair to charge shopkeepers for plastic bags while those who own take-aways will not have to pay for cardboard boxes, etc.
I ask the Minister to clarify a number of these issues. I raise the issue primarily on behalf of the employees of the Gaeltacht company concerned.
Comment on this
Despite what Senator Bonner said, I have no great philosophical opposition to the banning of plastic bags. We are, however, bound by EU law, including the packaging directive. We cannot ban packaging, which is consistent with that directive. Some countries have tried to ban different things resulting in matters coming before the European Court of Justice. That is the reason we took the route of imposing a levy to tackle the problem of plastic bags. We are talking about 1.2 billion plastic bags, about 350 plastic bags for every man, woman and child per annum.
I have noticed somewhat of a change in attitude. Shops almost throw plastic bags at customers. My daughter was working for a time in a service station and at the time there was a lot of publicity about the plastic bags levy. She said that it was remarkable that once the 10p levy was mentioned, many customers chose not to take a plastic bag for their purchases. It illustrated to me that if a ban is not possible, a monetary charge will make people aware of the problem.
Senator Quinn is correct in his points about this specific amendment. This has been a learning curve for all of us both in the Department and in other places such as the Revenue Commissioners. We have been trying to get this right and I do not think we will be totally successful on the first attempt. Initially, I thought the best way to collect this levy was at the distributor and manufacturer level. It was explained to us after much consultation with various groups that there would be a danger of abuse from the point of view of people importing from Northern Ireland or elsewhere. We are now back to the idea of the levy being charged at retail level. We think that the levy should be 15p because the collection of the levy by the Revenue Commissioners must also be paid for. We are unanimous in the spirit of this amendment because I believe the Senator wishes to exclude certain types of bags from the levy, such as the alternative bags offered by supermarkets. The regulations will deal with the size and composition of the bag and the exemptions. We will then have flexibility if that is needed. I accept the spirit of the amendment but I wish to deal with those issues in regulations.
I have every sympathy with Senator Bonner in relation to the points raised by him both today and over the past year. However, I must look at the broader picture even though I appreciate that the Senator must think about his local area. I would be concerned if any job losses were incurred but I am thinking of the greater good.
A charge for plastic bags operates in some countries – it operates very successfully in Denmark. I note that I was being blamed for the closure of a factory making plastic bags in County Clare. It closed down in anticipation of the 10p or 15p limit. I would regret if this measure had a serious effect on employment. We must think of alternatives to the plastic bag.
Cardboard is a recyclable material and is more biodegradable than plastic, and we do not intend to have charges on cardboard containers. I note the Senator's point about the materials used by take-away restaurants and this has become a significant cause of waste. There are provisions in the Litter Pollution Act which will have to be implemented. Plastic bags, aluminium beverage containers, plastic PET bottles and litter from take-aways are the most visible signs of litter, and action will have to be taken on them.
I have no illusions about the difficulties to be faced in implementing these measures. Apart from initial resistance, and once it is accepted that we will be introducing a levy, retailers and the Plastic Industries Association of Ireland have been extremely co-operative. I acknowledge that co-operation even though I know that many would have preferred if it was not introduced. I am aware there will be difficulties.
Comment on this
The regulations are not yet finalised, but it is not intended that smaller bags used within the store for meat or sweets would be taxed. VAT is included in the levy. I have secured an agreement with my colleague that the VAT charges will be reimbursed to the environment fund.
Comment on this
The purpose of this amendment is to provide that the proposed environment levy can in principle apply to the supply of plastic bags to a customer anywhere in the retail premises. This is another example of trying to anticipate different situations. It is simply to ensure that retailers would not offer plastic bags to customers as they enter the store and then not charge at the checkout. Anyone procuring a plastic bag in the store will have to pay the levy. That is the purpose of the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 8, to delete lines 12 to 16, and substitute the following:
"(e)requiring that the levy be charged as a billable item payable by the final consumer in such a manner as specified by the consumer,”.
I know that the Minister will agree to this amendment because his heart is in the right place about this. I do not mind if the Minister specifies how the levy should be payable. It is important that the person who gets the plastic bag pays. I do not agree with Senator Bonner's idea that it could be factored into the manufacturing price. How would the customer be aware of that? I am worried that the retailer will build it into their prices. Senator Quinn on Second Stage said that it would be too big a factor to build into retail prices, but I am not so sure that everyone would feel like this. We must change the attitude to the use of plastic bags. Some 350 bags per person per year are used. With any luck, until we get people to turn their minds to carrying Ugandan or Mexican baskets, as I do, the State could collect £50 per person per year.
We hear a great deal about the principle of making the polluter pay and Pigouvian taxes. The consumer of an article must be the one to pay the tax. I envisage one's bill being rung up on the supermarket till and the cashier saying, "and £1.50 for ten plastic bags." That would make quite a difference to one's bill. A customer in a service station who normally demands several bags for crisps and bars of chocolate and is charged an extra 45p for three plastic bags might be inclined to use fewer of them.
Senator Quinn expressed concern to me as to how my proposal would operate. Simply say, "20p for the bananas, 50p for three and 15p for the plastic bag." They will be collecting money for the Minister too. Unless, however, the last person is the one paying the levy, the measure will achieve nothing. The Minister may wish to reword my amendment, but I hope he will ensure the last person in the line knows he or she is paying the levy.
Comment on this
I do not always agree with the Senator, but in this case her heart and head are both in the right place. A tax paid by the person who demands and uses the plastic bag would have great benefits. The Minister hopes he will receive no money from this tax, but that the attitude of the public will change in order that they will refuse to pay 15p and stop using nasty, litter-bugging plastic bags. If that happens, the environmental fund will gain nothing, but the country will be cleared of a major element of litter. If we avoid using plastic bags, the benefit in the fight against inflation will be substantial. The cost of 350 bags per person is considerable. If we do not use any plastic bags, the cost to the nation will come down. Although Senator Bonner spoke of the factory in County Donegal which manufactures plastic bags, the vast majority are now imported.
How will the tax be collected? Senator Henry's proposal makes a great deal of sense. I am not sure how the price of a plastic bag would be written on the bottom of a receipt, as she proposes. How would the price be recorded for a plastic bag containing a few apples bought in Moore Street, where a receipt is not given? These are technicalities which the Minister must address.
The benefit of this measure in the fight against inflation is huge. On the other hand, it will be a great blow to our fight against inflation if the public pays this tax. A grocery bill will increase by 15p every time a plastic bag is used. If a customer uses ten plastic bags, the cost of his or her groceries will increase by £1.50. That would not be acceptable in the fight against inflation.
The Minister should consider the feasibility of accepting the amendment. I am aware Senator Henry's intention is good. I am not sure how the levy will be collected and do not think the Minister is fully sure either. I do not like the thought of returning to the old rate collection system whereby entrepreneurs would be appointed to collect taxes on behalf of the Government. The Minister appears to have something like this in mind. Unless the tax is collected in a way similar to that suggested by Senator Henry, it will not be collected easily. The Minister's original intention was to collect the levy at source. If that system were adopted, a large number of entrepreneurs would cross the Border, load the boots of their cars with plastic bags and no tax would ever be collected for them. The question of collection is of interest and one which we will be interested to hear the Minister clarify.
The concept of Senator Henry's amendment, that every customer who uses a plastic bag would be aware of how much he or she was paying for it, would be a huge disincentive to using plastic bags. For that reason it may achieve what the Minister wants and the tax will not yield a penny. If that happens we will have less litter and helped to reduce inflation by reducing the price of food.
The Minister referred to supermarkets, petrol service stations and other outlets. I have a fear the concentration will be in one area alone. Takeaway food outlets are a much greater source of litter, a matter we will discuss when we consider a later amendment. Our concern here is with changing the attitude of shoppers by having them pay for plastic bags.
I am a major polluter. Among the 18 shops which my company controls there is a huge difference in attitude. In some of my company's shops one customer in ten uses reusable bags and in others, not far away from them, almost nine in ten customers use them. When asked, the vast majority say that they have not got around to using reusable bags and would, probably, do so if forced. I believe it was President Roosevelt who said, "Speak softly but carry a big stick". The legislation contains a very large 15p stick. If this measure succeeds, the environmental fund will derive no income from the levy. Attitudes are more likely to be changed if Senator Henry's amendment, or something similar, is accepted and the final user is the one who is aware that he or she must pay.
Comment on this
The sentiments expressed in the amendment underscore the principle of making the polluter pay. If we could garner the same level of public support as has been shown in the fight against foot and mouth disease against the proliferation of litter, we would be taking a step in the right direction. This should be the objective of the Department and the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister is to be complimented on his initiative in introducing this charge. When one hears that 1.2 billion bags are used annually it is no wonder the countryside is strewn with torn plastic. The countryside is strewn with plastic bags although we are trying to keep it clean. I am sure that charging for them will be a deterrent against the use of plastic bags. I was surprised to find that only brown paper bags are issued in supermarkets in the United States. This also happens in chip shops in the UK and elsewhere. I do not know why they are no longer used here. Perhaps we need to educate people to bring the shopping bag back into use. I compliment the Minister on introducing this charge.
Comment on this
I agree with much of the debate which I have heard. There is a Drogheda retailer, who actually lives in the Minister's constituency in County Meath, who gives a 15 pence refund on goods when people bring in their own bags. He sells clothes and other such items which would cost more than a few pounds, and admits that while people laugh they are happy to take the money back.
I agree that education is critical. There is a degree of consensus on the issue of waste management. We can all work together on it. I believe it is possible to change people's minds through a campaign that is both national and local as well as targeting schools.
I agree with Senator Kiely. Before plastic bags we used paper or string bags. In that way recycling comes into play.
Comment on this
I thank the Senators for their support. I am not accepting Senator Henry's amendment because it is already in the Waste Management Act, 1996.
Comment on this
Section 29(4)(j) of the 1996 Act empowers the Minister by regulation to require the owner or manager of any specified sales outlet to impose a charge on a customer in respect of the provision by him or her to the customer of any bag, container or other such packaging.
I intend to make the regulations under section 29 of that Act, which is already in place, requiring that the retailers pass on the full amount of the proposed levy to customers. The enabling provision in the proposed section 8(6)(e) is intended to allow the Minister to require in regulations that the imposition of the levy in respect of the supply of plastic bags has to be clearly specified on the relevant till roll supplied to the customers.
I take the point that Senator Quinn made in relation to certain parts of the city and perhaps other cities as well. It is catered for. As the Senator would be aware, I have had some discussions with IBEC and retailers etc. They were concerned that this levy should not be seen as an imposition by them on their customers. I have no difficulty with retailers putting up signs beside their tills indicating that the 15p levy is for the environment fund. This addresses the concerns of retailers that they would be taking the blame for this. I seem to be blamed for much that is happening or not happening in this country, so I do not mind taking that on my shoulders as well.
The essential point is that everyone is aware that they are paying for the plastic bag, why they are paying for it and what the money is used for. Some Senators have called it an environmental tax and I would agree with that. It will be a function of the Revenue Commissioners to collect this levy. It will apply to all retailers, not just the larger multiples who might be considered an easy target.
There are various ways one can improve education and increase awareness. Putting up signs is one way and itemising it on receipts is another, as well as having direct action programmes. In Nova Scotia the emphasis on educating the public was very apparent. The efforts to make people aware of the issues appear to have paid off. It would be my intention to divert any potential income from the "plastic bags tax" from the environment fund into concentrated awareness-raising measures. That will help us all to reduce, re-use and recycle. I can assure Senator Henry that what is being sought in this amendment is already in place, and will be put in place by the regulations under section 29(4)(j).
Comment on this
It is not in the Bill. I thought for a moment I had missed something. I have a big star beside this area. This says quite clearly that the manager of the supermarket, service station or otherwise must impose a charge on a customer in respect of the provision by him or her to the customer of any bag.
I want it to be a billable item. Of course they can impose the charge, but it might get lost in all the other charges and be overlooked. When one looks at a bill one sees so much for VAT, so much for the service charge etc. I want plastic bag charge to be in the same category. The Minister would be wise to take my advice.
The imposition of a charge can be built into the price, but if it is a billable item such as £1.50 for ten plastic bags, would that not make one sit up? I want the person who is getting the plastic bag to be fully aware of it. All kinds of charges can be built in, such as charges for cleaning the floor etc. It is important to me that it be a billable item.
Comment on this
The Minister is far too young to remember a nasty item called turnover tax, from 1971 if I remember correctly. I had not thought this through until Senator Henry put this down. It was 2.5% and later became 5%. I think it was in 1972 that a bright entrepreneur named Pat Quinn announced that he would pay the turnover tax. While the rest of us showed the turnover tax at the end of the bill, he did not. He was out of business a couple of months later. He made this great play that he would pay this tax for people, that he did not charge turnover tax.
Senator Henry is saying that it is not enough to build in the charge, as there will always be someone to make the promise to pay that nasty tax for their customers. I support the Minister and I believe that Senator Henry is attempting to give him the power to help him to change attitudes and educate the public. I gave the example some time ago that many would be ashamed or unhappy to walk down Grafton Street in a fur coat because it is not acceptable behaviour. The same applies to those who still use, but are no longer happy to use plastic bags. We shall debate later which bags should be levied.
Senator Kiely referred to the use of brown paper bags in the United States. Brown paper bags are unacceptable as they would add to inflation, are more expensive and, more important, not environmentally acceptable. The only way we can win is to encourage people to use bags over and over again, not one trip bags. That is the Minister's objective. Whether the bag is plastic or paper, the fact that it is used only once does not achieve the objective. I support Senator Henry in that the person who buys the bag should pay for it. Her amendment is worthy of support.
Comment on this
We will be making regulations under both section 29, to ensure the charge is passed on, and under section 72(6)(e), as inserted by section 8, to ensure it is reflected in the till roll receipt. What will be done in the regulations will meet exactly what Senators are proposing. There is no difference between us on the matter, except that we propose to do it under section 29 and this section which will become section 72(6)(e) of the 1996 Act.
Comment on this
Yes, as inserted by section 8. The two matters the Senator desires, the separate charge—
Comment on this
Section 8 will become section 72 of the 1996 Act. The Senator's amendment is fully catered for.
Comment on this
I have already said that legislation is not the best way of dealing with this. However, I am concerned with the details and seek to influence the regulations when the Minister comes to make them. When will those regulations come into being? The Minister mentioned 1 January, which gives us time to take steps, but I am not sure if that is correct.
Some of the amendments have touched on my main point on the objective of the Bill, which is to change behaviour. If we are to change behaviour I want to make sure the Bill works when enacted. I do not want to find there are flaws in it, therefore our attitude should be that those who at present use plastic bags at the checkout for their goods cease doing so and switch their behaviour to using the same container, whether it is a box, shopping bag or carrier basket such as our grandparents used.
I know something of the bags used at our checkouts and a number of us are experimenting with new containers that will have many benefits. One of them is a heavy duty bag which costs 10p at present but those who buy it use it over and over again. It would be a shame if the legislation did not take into account the difference between that heavy duty bag which is used over and over and the flimsy light bag which ends up creating litter. I do not know how the Minister is to do that in regulations but it is important he does so.
There are three types of bags in a supermarket, although I know I should not just be talking about supermarkets, as take-aways and other types of shop also cause litter through plastic bags. The first type are the bags used at the checkout into which goods are put. The objective of this legislation is to stop such bags being used and to have something else take their place. The second type of bag is one into which, for example, one would place cooked ham to keep it separate from other foods, if only for food hygiene and safety reasons. It is essential that these bags are not taxed, even if they are plastic, because they are there for food safety. If we charge 15p for those bags the inflation cost will be huge. I know that is not the intention but we must make that clear.
The third type of bag used in supermarkets is not what is used for wet fresh foods but for other foods. If one buys half a dozen apples and half a dozen pears one needs some form of container to keep the apples separate from the pears and one probably uses a plastic bag for the six apples and six pears, as they must be kept separate if they are sold at different prices. It is important that these are not charged at 15p each also.
I do not know the solution to this but it may relate to the secondary bag. In other words, if a product is put in some sort of wrapping, whether it is a packet of crisps, as Senator Henry said, a few apples or some cooked ham, it already has a wrapper around it. It is the bag one then puts those into at the checkout which we aim to tackle with this measure.
I am not attempting to change the legislation but the regulations should take something like that into account. On that basis there would be no effect on inflation, we would achieve what we are setting out to do but we would also keep the challenge of food safety very high on the agenda. I am anxious to make sure the legislation works, as is the Minister, and we do not want it to fall down due to something we did not foresee like food safety. Between inflation and food safety there is a challenge and the answer may be in directing the regulations towards tackling the outer container. This may not be the occasion to solve the take-away problem because if one puts a hamburger into a piece of paper and then into another wrapper, the other wrapper will have a tax on it, whereas if one keeps it in one container it will not be taxed.
That may be the way to go and I suggest this not to influence the legislation but so that the Minister takes it into account when making the regulations.
Comment on this
This is a good section in that it taxes plastic bags. The attraction of the plastic bag is in its convenience but another factor contributes to the growth in use of plastic bags, they are very advertiser-friendly. The Minister should consider a regulation which would stop such bags being used for advertising but which would stipulate, on the contrary, that the bag would carry a message stating that use of the bag is ecologically unfriendly. I know that has not been very successful with cigarettes but it is part of education and awareness. If one took away the opportunity to avail of the bag – we are trying to discourage use of the bag given the difficulties with its disposal – one could not have an advertisement. A statement on the bag raising awareness of the problem would also help. This may not be the relevant section but such a provision would strengthen the purpose of the tax.
Comment on this
RG Data contacted Deputy Clune and she faxed me some of their questions, although most of them have been answered. What will happen when a consumer refuses to pay the levy for a plastic bag? What exemptions from the levy will apply, if any, and in what circumstances will refunds of the levy be repaid? Will there be exemptions for specific classes of retailers and, if so, on what basis will they be granted?
Comment on this
Most Senators, including Senator Quinn, have said that the primary pur pose of the legislation is to influence consumers to try to move away from the use of plastic bags. For that reason, the intention is that the charge for the bag will be separate and will appear on the Bill, as I said earlier. Senator Quinn also mentioned "bags for life" schemes which have been promoted by shops and retail outlets prior to the commencement of this scheme. It is not intended that bags that are consistently used should be affected by regulation. We are trying to deal with those bags that end up on trees and in bushes.
We realise that there are items that need to be protected for hygiene and food safety reasons. The Food Safety Authority has pointed out the need to separate what it calls wet foods in small bags. If we thought that people were trying to use this to evade the tax we would have to take it on board. I would not be as open to the Senator's suggestion to allow bags for apples and pears, as it is not intended that small bags be taxed at 15p. I disagree with the Senator as I think that apples and pears can be bought loose and put into shopping baskets and charged for on an individual basis. Such items have too much packaging and it is not a matter of hygiene.
I like the Senator's idea regarding the "secondary bag" which would be useful if we could come up with a tight definition of it. Senator Walsh and I recall that greaseproof paper was used extensively for goods until multiple retailers and multiple stores came on the scene. I also recall that it was once common to get one's chips wrapped in newspaper. Perhaps that is another good use for newspapers, a problem we discussed.
Comment on this
As regards the starting date, I want to give fair warning that it is our intention to start to collect the levy in the autumn, subject to being able to finalise details. I have told officials that they should make that known to people now. We have had talks in relation to this with retailers and IBEC and it is only fair that we allow the maximum possible lead-in time. The reference to 1 January next that a Senator asked about may be the specific mention to the Euro changeover, when the levy will be 19 cents. It is also intended that the landfill levy will start on 1 January 2002.
Senator Walsh asked about putting a message on the bag, but I am worried that a message saying that the consumer is paying a 15p charge for an environmental fund will make people think "this is wonderful, give me ten bags, keep the balance". Senator Quinn might confirm it was suggested when this tax was first proposed that my photograph be put on bags with a caption saying "This man is making consumers pay 15p". I am very disappointed that did not go ahead, particularly so close to a general election.
Senator O'Dowd asked a number of questions that I did not quite catch. His last question concerned exemptions for certain retailers, but there is no such provision whether the outlet is large or small. He also asked what happens if a customer refuses to pay for the bags. What happens if a customer refuses to pay for goods in a shop? The shopkeeper does not give them the goods, it is as straightforward as that.
Comment on this
My question was actually related to exemptions that may apply to the levy, but the Minister already said that there are none.
Comment on this
I assume the Senator refers to exemptions based on the type of bag and so on, which I have already dealt with.
Comment on this
If there is a loophole I am sure the Minister will close it before this Bill goes to the Dáil. It struck me when Senator Quinn was talking about apples and pears that such items are often carried in nets which may be made from plastic. I wonder if nets are covered within the scope of this Bill, as if they are not I can see creative people finding a way around the levy. If one creates a plastic bag with a lot of holes in it, suddenly it is not a plastic bag anymore.
I also have a question about subsection (6)(h) of this section, which enables the payment of the levy to be deferred by specified persons in specified circumstances. I wonder what specified person the Minister has in mind for this exemption. Senator Quinn's query about different sizes of bags is covered by paragraph (f) of the subsection which allows the Minister to designate certain sizes and composition of bags that would be unacceptable.
Comment on this
I welcome this section. In previous discussions with the Minister I suggested that he designate a national package-free day, similar to the national car-free day. I still hope he considers the idea, which came from a community member of the strategic policy committee in Galway. Before the tax on plastic bags is introduced, I hope that we run the national package-free day as a pilot scheme whereby anybody who goes to a supermarket or store would be encouraged to leave packaging behind. This would include plastic bags, packaging around apples, cardboard boxes around cornflakes and toothpaste as well as the other various wrappings used on a daily basis, particularly in supermarkets.
Following discussion at local council level and an endorsement of this by Galway Corporation, a constituent told me that manufacturers in Switzerland have changed the way they package goods as a result of changed consumer habits. Tubes of toothpaste are no longer surrounded by a plastic box and everything is much more environmentally friendly as a result of the elimination of waste. While I did not hear all Senator Quinn's address, I will tell him what happened when I was at the checkout of a supermarket while in Austria recently. Following the checking out of one's goods, if one picked up a plastic bag which was available an extra amount of money would have to be paid.
We pay such levies when abroad so I think we will do so here when we go to the supermarket. Just as we gave millennium candles to everybody in the country, perhaps we could distribute cloth bags for life sponsored by the Department of the Environment and Local Government. Such sponsorship would be a really nice initiative from the Minister at the launch of the campaign. Instead of putting his name on plastic bags, the Minister could put his Department's name on a cloth bag.
Comment on this
On Senator Cox's point about a national day, my company had a national day last year on 15 May and it worked very well. We charged 10p a bag for charity and a very large number of people were willing to participate because it was fun and there was much excitement. For those who were not willing to participate, we found a way of putting our hands in our pockets and saying that if they did not want to pay for it, we would pay for it. There were very few who would not participate. One can do that but there would be a need for a marketing effort behind it.
I know we are not talking about the Bill here and I am sorry for using it so that the Minister will understand the importance of my point. The point I want to get across about the bags is that there is no doubt about food hygiene because I am sure the Minister will not do anything which would suggest that we would not separate cooked meats from other meats.
I am talking about trying to do too much in this Bill. For instance, I made a point about apples and pears. When a supermarket customer wants to buy mushrooms, carrots, apples and pears, this does not pose a food safety problem, but the way that is done at present involves putting them in bags, weighing them and then paying for them at the checkout. It seems that if the Minister says that different produce should not be put in separate bags, that they should be all put together, that will not be an acceptable behaviour change to expect from the public. If the Minister wants to get people to change, he should not challenge the behaviour of people to such a great degree. There could be a reaction. It could be like what happened in the case of the dog muzzle.
The answer lies in primary and second packaging. Senator Cox talked about the way people behave at checkouts in other countries, but we are talking about the final packaging rather than individual packaging. We could go on about that too long. I believe that this legislation can work but perhaps we should not try to change everything. We certainly should not do something which has such an effect on inflation that there would be an outcry against it and it would not work as a result.
Comment on this
Senator Dardis raised the question of whether the use of nets or other ingenious means of trying to get around this levy would be catered for. We will obviously consider everything we possibly can when we are drafting the regulations. We probably will not think of everything because there is great ingenuity out there. I am aware of the kind of netted bags to which he referred but those would be more environmentally friendly, even if they are made of plastic, than ordinary plastic bags.
On the very good point the Senator raised regarding deferments of payment of the levy in specified circumstances, I mentioned that originally we envisaged that payment of the levy on plastic bags would be made by the distributors and manufacturers of plastic bags. In such circumstances they would need time to get the money in from the customers and, therefore, we provided for this built-in deferment period. We have changed the method of payment because it is the retailers who will pay the levy. We do not anticipate that there will be any deferment of payment of the levy but we are leaving it in as a contingency. It is a belt and braces approach.
We would have no problem with the idea of a package free day, as I said to Senator Cox when she raised this matter with me some time ago. I do not think that initially we will set about promoting such a day but if a local authority, using its initiative, introduced it on a pilot basis, we would be interested in seeing the reaction to it and whether it could work. It is part of a wider question to which the Senator referred, that is, the question of educating and-or creating awareness of these issues. Anything like that which we do can only be for the better.
On the proposal of a bag for life, we have received a proposal from An Taisce along the same lines. An Taisce has proposed that we would give out a bag at the launch of the levy to heighten awareness etc. and that is something which we are actively considering. It probably would be a good idea.
I want to make the general point again, because perhaps I took what Senator Quinn said about apples and pears too literally. We are trying to create an awareness of too much packaging in certain fruits. I accept what the Senator said about mushrooms and other such foods where it is not a food safety issue, but apples, pears, carrots and various other foods come in polystyrene trays, wrapped in plastic and perhaps wrapped again in something else. We are actively trying to ensure that there will be less of that and that people make the choices and decide to purchase loose produce as much as possible. I repeat that it is not our intention currently to go down the route of putting a levy on the primary packaging to which Senator Quinn referred.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 16 is a Government amendment. Amendment No. 17 is cognate. Therefore, amendments Nos. 16 and 17 may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
These are technical amendments for the avoidance of doubt and to ensure that the proposed landfill levy can be applied in respect of all landfill activity. Paragraph 1 of the Third Schedule of the 1996 Act, which specifies a range of waste disposal activities, relates to the deposit of waste "on, in or under land", including landfill. However, paragraph (v) of the Schedule specifies "Specially engineered landfill, including placement into lined discrete cells which are capped and isolated from one another and the environment". While landfill in such facilities may be taken as a sub-set of the activity specified in paragraph 1, reference should be made in the proposed section 72 to both paragraphs for the avoidance of doubt. It is a technical amendment.
Comment on this
The primary purpose of this amendment is the avoidance of doubt. It makes explicit the power to impose the proposed landfill levy at different rates in respect of landfill of different classes of waste or in respect of different types of landfill activity or both. This enabling power to specify different rates of levy is subject to subsection (3), which specifies the maximum initial amount of levy at £15, or 19. The purpose is to be careful to avoid doubt and to give us the power to do it at a later stage. There is no proposal at present that there will be different levels but it is prudent to provide that there may be different rates in the future.
Comment on this
While I welcome most of what is contained in section 10, I have a couple of questions. The landfill levy is to be posed locally. In other words, the local authority or whoever operates the facility will impose the levy. As I understand it, the money will be forwarded to the Exchequer. It is likely that the communities in the vicinity of the landfill sites will not be particularly happy because waste management facilities have an impact on the local environment.
If local authorities collect the tax, as they would in most cases, I urge the Minister to ensure a significant amount of the money raised locally, particularly by way of the landfill levy – I would not prescribe that it should be 40% or 50% and presume the Minister will ensure regulations are drawn up to deal with the matter – would be used locally to ameliorate the stress caused by the facility and support and improve environmental amenities within the county or town. If all the money raised locally by way of such a landfill levy was used nationally, an important benefit that could accrue to a local community would be lost forever. I have not read the detail on the imposition of a landfill levy in the United Kingdom, although I am aware that there were some incidences of fraud. Could that be a factor in the imposition of such a levy here and, if so, how would we deal with it?
Comment on this
I do not have a difficulty with the principle of imposing a levy. It is a sensible proposal. If we support the polluter pays principle, a levy should be imposed. Its imposition, however, would give rise to a potential difficulty. Illegal dumping presents a terrible problem in certain parts of my constituency. Some even dump material quite openly. It seems to take the local authority and the EPA a long time to deal with the problem in terms of the legal process that has to be gone through and eventually the stage may be reached where it is established that there is contempt. The long time taken to deal with such offenders is an encouragement to dump material illegally. Dumping presents a particular problem in the boglands in my constituency. It is practised by individuals rather than an organised offence.
To pick up on Senator O'Dowd's point, in which there is a good deal of merit, it would be useful if some of the moneys collected by way of such a levy were allocated to ensuring a local authority has the necessary manpower or resources to deal effectively with this activity which is being practised willy nilly and a blight on the landscape. There are two aspects to it, one of which is the ad hoc tipping of a skip in a bogland area. The other, which is more difficult to identify, is getting rid of other material in a large facility at which it is specified that only rubble should be dumped.
Comment on this
Senators raised some good points on the section. There is nothing to stop a local authority, as contained in the waste management policy document, Changing our Ways, including a charge or provision in the conditions covering a landfill to provide for a community relief or community fund, although I note the point made by Senator O'Dowd specifically in regard to a landfill levy.
On the question of fraud in the collection of such a tax, having read some of the material on this area, I recollect that the incidence of fraud made the imposition of a landfill levy ineffective in some parts of the United Kingdom. The possibility of fraud has been taken into account by the Department. It is some time since the Government agreed the principle of a landfill levy. We appointed consultants to advise us on international experience in this area. Their report is almost finalised. This one of the areas examined which ties in with a point made by Senator Dardis.
All of us would agree this an exercise of knocking local authorities, but one of the areas in which they have been weakest in the past, for good reason, is the enforcement of environmental legislation, as it is only since the late 1980s that environmental legislation has been up and running here, mainly because of the implementation of EU directives and so on. In a sense it has been the Cinderella service of the local authorities and the Cinderella element in the environmental area has been enforcement. Local authorities have not put the necessary resources into the enforcement of environmental legislation.
The only way to prevent fly tipping, which Senator O'Dowd raised, is by the active enforcement of the legislation by the local authorities. Without departing from the polluter pays principle, some of the money in the environment fund will be used to assist local authorities to implement their waste management plans and awareness programmes on environmental mat ters. Some of the money in that fund will be allocated to enforcing the legislation. I think that is something we will take on board. We indicated we would give that favourable consideration. I am not very much in favour of leaving that up to the local authority that collects the levy, as the aim of waste management policy is to reduce the number of landfills. Therefore, not every local authority will have one. There may be a case for a local authority that has a landfill being given a little more out the environment fund than one that does not have one. The money collected from the levy will go into the environment fund and it will be allocated to local authorities for environmental purposes. If a local authority has a landfill site, that should be taken into account in such allocations.
With regard to the experience of fraud in the collection of the levy in the UK, there will be one essential difference between the imposition of a landfill levy here and the levy in the UK. A considerable number of landfills in the UK are privately operated. Consequently, there is a greater opportunity for them not meeting their obligations than there would be here where most of them are operated by local authorities. We assume the local authorities would be in compliance with their obligations in relation to it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 12, line 3, to delete "may" and substitute "shall within three months of the passing of this Act.".
In this amendment I encourage the Minister to give himself a break, as he has a great deal to do. The Bill states that the Minister may by regulations delete the management and control of all or part of the environment fund. The Minister should ensure he deletes that control, as his life seems to be extremely busy. It appears initially that a good deal of money will flow into the environment fund, even though I agree with Senator Quinn, if we wanted to fade away as rapidly as possible from the plastic bag point of view, the matter of the levies on the tonnage going into the landfills may be a bit more difficult. The Minister should ensure that someone would be appointed to operate the environment fund as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept this amendment, as it places an imperative on the Minister to do something within three months of the passing of the Bill, in other words, to remove the proposed discretion the Minister would have to delegate the management and control of all or part of the environment fund and any of its related functions to a specified person. The pro posal here is simply an enabling provision. I have no proposals at this time to delegate the operation of the environment fund to any person or body.
I am currently trying to get the environment fund into operation. I hope it will provide assistance on a wide range of environmentally desirable initiatives. At this early stage, with the fund not even set up yet, it would be unwise for the Minister to begin delegating and I have not yet given much thought to that. It is possible that, in future, there could be a national waste management agency, or there might be an environmental awareness bureau, to which funds might be delegated. At this stage, however, I do not propose to let go of the fund before it is even established.
Comment on this
The idea of a national waste management agency cheers me up so much that I will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
No, I was simply putting forward a hypothesis that, if such a body were to be established, some funds might be delegated to it.
Comment on this
Amendments No. 20 and 21 are out of order, because they involve a potential charge on the Revenue. Amendment No. 22 is a Government amendment. Amendment No. 23 is an alternative. Therefore amendments Nos. 22 and 23 may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
The proposed section 74(9)(b) provides that the environment fund may be used, among other things, to assist the establishment and operation of waste recovery activities. Recovery, as defined in the 1996 Act, is very wide-ranging and includes the reclamation, reuse and recycling of waste, as well as energy recovery. I have recently received representations from the waste prevention working group of Comhar, the National Sustainable Development Partnership, requesting that the scope of this provision be limited to reuse and recycling only. In general terms, I intend that assistance from the fund will be directed to such activities which are high in the waste hierarchy and will not be used to support thermal treatment activities, such as municipal waste incineration.
However, I want to retain the option of providing assistance to projects entailing thermal treatment or energy recovery in relation to specific waste streams, where such activities are considered environmentally desirable. An example of such a project might be the application of gasification, as mentioned earlier in this debate, or porolysis to deal with used tyres, which we have to divert from landfill under the landfill directive. Another example would be anaerobic digestion of sludges or agricultural wastes, which generates energy in the form of methane. Waste treatment technologies are evolving and we should retain the flexibility to support the treatment of specific waste streams where that is environmentally desirable. The proposed amendment meets the essential concerns of the Comhar working group, while retaining the necessary flexibility. It is not necessary to specify 'reduction' in this amendment. Section 74(9)(a) provides that the environment fund may be used to assist programmes or schemes established for the prevention or reduction of waste.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 23 was based on the wording submitted by An Taisce – no doubt it circulated it to the Minister. I understand the Minister's comments and I do not agree with him, but I am not pressing it to a vote tonight. On the matter of used tyres, I understand that the recycling process in Nova Scotia involves grinding down the material. I cannot remember what the resulting product is used for but I can get the relevant information leaflet. However, the process certainly does not involve burning, in case that is what the Minister was concerned about.
Comment on this
This amendment is required both to amend an incorrect reference in section 11(9)(f) and to provide that moneys from the proposed environment fund may be used to support implementation of the forthcoming national hazardous waste management plan, as well as the local authority plans. Subsection (9)(f) provides that the environment fund may be used for the purpose of assisting the implementation of waste management plans within the meaning of Part III of the Act. Waste management planning is dealt with under Part II of the Act. The definition of waste management plan under Part II of the 1996 Act does not include the national hazardous waste management plan to be prepared by the EPA under section 26 of the Act. As it may well be desirable to be in a position to support the implementation of aspects of the forthcoming national plan, for example, in relation to measures for the collection of household hazardous wastes, it is proposed to make an appropriate amendment to subsection (9)(f).
Comment on this
Amendment No. 25 is a Government amendment. Amendment No. 26 is an alternative. Therefore, amendments Nos. 25 and 26 may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
These two amendments are alternatives and they have the same net effect. Obviously, I support the Government amendment, but I suggest that it encapsulates what Senator O'Dowd is proposing in his amendment. Amendment No. 25 is for the avoidance of doubt and to make it explicit that the proposed environment fund may be used, among other things, to assist appropriate activities undertaken by environmental NGOs. The proposed section 74(9)(l) provides that the environment fund may be used, among other things, to assist, support or promote initiatives undertaken by community groups, or other like persons, with respect to the protection of any aspect of the environment. I believe that is wide enough to cover what Senator O'Dowd intended in his amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 13, lines 29 and 30, to delete "the protection of the environment" and substitute "waste management".
I would have preferred if the environment fund had been called the waste fund. Waste management is probably the most serious issue which we are currently trying to deal with. I recently saw an advertisement for a guest lecture in UCD. Normally, the subject matter might be something like "the use of cobalt blue in impressionist paintings", but in this instance it was "waste management." I thought that was very indicative of how serious this issue is.
In advocating waste management support in my amendment, I am anxious to see that something is done about the landfill issue. The Minister and Senator Connor nearly came to blows earlier about what was happening in Roscommon.
Comment on this
Yes, the local authorities were not properly refurbishing landfill areas. On recycling, that industry should be supported. Perhaps Senator Bonner can encourage the people who he said were being put out of business in relation to plastic bags to set up a small industry in that area. The fund should not just be used for aspirational projects, however good they may be. I am delighted to see them all in this section. It is absolutely splendid but we must keep assisting, improving and educating people. We need to get down to brass tacks and that is why I put in the two amendments which were disallowed.
I put down this amendment because to talk about the protection of the environment is too nebulous. That could mean the protection of rare birds in Donegal or something like that. I want this fund used to deal with waste management. The Minister said that the national plan provided for £100 million in this area but with the amount of rubbish we have, that will go nowhere. That is why I would like the Minister to change the wording to "waste management". This is what the Bill is about. The environment is a very nice and friendly term and nobody likes talking about messy things like rubbish, dumps and waste, but that is really what we need to spend this money on. We should be more realistic. It is a splendid section and beautifully written but we should decide to use this money to deal with waste management.
Comment on this
I respectfully suggest that the Senator's amendment is not necessary. The section specifies on page 12 some of the things we will use the environment fund for. It specifies in paragraphs (a) to (l) the particular activities that may be supported. They largely but not exclusively relate to waste management. We have prevention and reduction programmes, waste recovery activities, support of research and development etc. It is better that we call it the environment fund because we would hope to add more money for a wider range of purposes rather than confining it to waste management. Stating it specifically for waste management would limit it too much.
Comment on this
This is an important amendment. The overall purpose of section 12 is to try to achieve a very clear and effective separation between IPC and waste licensing so that everyone involved, the EPA, the applicants, the licensees and the public, knows where they stand. This need for regulatory certainty applies both prospectively and retrospectively. This amendment addresses the retrospective aspect of it. Members who heard me speak on the Waste Management Bill, 1996, know that one of the particular areas in that Bill that I made a lot of was to do with processes that we were putting in place and the separate processes that were in place for planning. People would turn up to planning appeals to object to particular aspects of a development and be told it was a matter for the EPA and could not be discussed. This led to confusion, annoyance and frustration. I see this as a step in bringing clarity to these processes.
The proposed new subsections (3) and (4) are transitional provisions for the purpose of clarifying the position in relation to any activities which already have an IPC licence under the EPA Act, 1992, but which are really waste management activities and consistent with the principles followed in the section as a whole should be licensed under the Waste Management Act. The subsections will allow the agency, not earlier than three years after the passing of this Act, to require licensees in these circumstances to apply for a waste licence. The agency may make the transfer sooner provided it has the agreement of the licensee to do so. In the meantime, the status quo of regulation under the IPC regime remains in force. They are purely technical provisions to address the consequences of what we could have at the moment, duplicate licensing requirements, and ensure that the existing licensees are treated fairly in terms of transferring from an IPC licence to a waste licence. It would be unfair not to have that transition period.
Comment on this
This is a very important section of the Bill. I am not absolutely clear on what effectively is happening. At the moment a thermal treatment facility would require an IPC licence. If this amendment is passed the licence will come from the Waste Management Act, 1996, and therefore the burden of the IPC licence will no longer apply to the incinerating company. I have spoken to the EPA about this issue and they have assured me that the Waste Management Act, 1996, is a stronger, more effective Act. It defines that the financial circumstances of the company can be taken into account. This cannot be taken into account under the IPC system. That could mean, if this section is passed, that if a proposed incinerator is deemed to have a life of 30 years, the EPA could, in theory, identify a sum of money or satisfy itself that the company would be able to meet any legal actions due to ill health or other ill effect produced as a result of that incineration facility. That is a good thing.
The other important issue is that the EPA can regulate the waste stream. Under the IPC it cannot do so. Both of these issues must be considered. When I said that we were opposing the amendment I was referring to a document dealing with a meeting between the EPA and INDAVER where on 7 June 2000 INDAVER raised the issue of IPC and Waste Management Act licensing. The agency advised that with new regulations pending over the next few months a final decision might not be available. The most appropriate option was to indicate that whatever permits or licences were required would be applied for under the EPA Act and the Waste Management Act as appropriate. The next meeting was on 2 October 2000. The issues of the IPC and WMA licensing was raised again and the agency advised that as the amended Bill to the EPA Act had still not been published, let alone passed or enacted, the current situation was that an incineration facility as described required licensing under Schedule One of the EPA Act and any associated facilities would also be included in such an application. Non-associated facilities involving waste recycling etc. would require to be permitted under the WMA.
The agency also drew attention to requirements of the IPC directive which apply to new developments since October last. For an inciner ator company, the IPC is more lenient and I do not understand why they would be concerned about the WMA. I leave that as a question. While in theory we oppose this section, I raise these issues for the Dáil debate where they will be picked up. I am not satisfied that what the Minister is proposing is the best thing. I am happy that much of it is better but I am concerned why an incinerator company wanted this amendment.
I was told, as the Minister said, that they want clarity as to which was the licence they had to go for, the IPC or the WMA, so that there could be no legal challenge as to the regulations. Is there something in the IPC which would help those who are against the incineration facilities? The jury is out on that issue.
Earlier I raised the issue of licensing of waste transfer. Can the Minister respond now?
Comment on this
There is nothing sinister involved in this. This arose, I am told, because anyone applying for an IPC licence communicates with the EPA in advance, in pre-planning and so on. It arose that if it were a mixed facility, they would have to get two licences. It was a question of making the decision as to the most effective method. It is not reasonable to expect them to go through two similar licensing procedures.
From a legal point of view, if there is any room for doubt, lawyers could play off one act against another. The Senator has done his homework. My information is confirmed by the independent advice of Duncan Lawrence Environmental.
Comment on this
It makes it clear that the switch from the EPA Act to the Waste Management Act will not make the obtaining of approval for incinerators any easier. I will not delay the House by reading it as the Senator has it. It points out how much more stringent the Waste Management Act will be and how protective of long-term issues the licensing will be. Although it is the Senator's desire to prevent thermal treatment altogether, it is mine that thermal treatment plants operate to the highest standards. This is the way to ensure that.
Comment on this
I accept all that the Minister said. We are both getting that advice. My query is still why the incinerator company, when it has an easier vehicle in the IPC, wants the WMA. I do not understand that. It is the easier option for them.
Comment on this
I will get a thorough briefing note from officials. I hope that I am not wrong in surmising—
Comment on this
—that they went to the EPA as part of the IPC consultation process and discovered that they needed two licences, both IPC and waste management. The EPA thought that this was not a good way forward and recommended to us to change the procedures so that they would get one or the other. If I am right, and I beg the Senator's indulgence, we decided with the EPA that the Waste Management Act was more stringent and that was the route to go. If that is not so, the officials will provide the Senator with a brief.
Comment on this
I only half replied on the matter of transportation that the Senator raised but will supply him with a note on it. In general terms, the regulations referred to have direct application here. He asked if we could import waste. It can be imported for recycling or recovery but not for disposal.
Comment on this
This also arises from the EPA's discussion with the incinerator company. The UK can import waste for recovery and disposal only from Ireland and Portugal because they have no incinerating facility. If an incinerating company here, which will be possible under this Act – although, as the Minister pointed out, it could have happened under planning legislation – wished to import waste for recovery, it could be hazardous waste or anything. On 8 January 1999, Indover and Minchem, now both the same company, were concerned at the lack of consistency in applying disposal and recovery codes to activities across the EU. They felt one of two options should be adopted – no incineration process should be classified as recovery or a specific calorific value limit should apply. How will this legislation affect regulations which the Minister will make?
I referred this morning to F1149/98. I am raising these issues now because they are important. The Minister did not have prior notice. It is important, because we are moving into a new phase in national waste management, that we make absolutely sure that we keep the regulations as tight as possible. We both agree on that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 14, lines 31 and 32, to delete subsection (2).
The section effectively confirms regulations made in 1999. I presume the Minister is taking an opportunity to do this, but I wonder about the practice. Is it not an unusual provision? It appears to be a retrospective increase in the litter fine and perhaps the Minister will confirm this.
Comment on this
It is not a retrospective endorsement of an increase. The increase was introduced under the Litter Pollution Act, 1997, section 28 of which provides for on the spot fines of £25. This was increased by regulation under section 28(4) to £50 with effect from 3 January 2000. In examining this area in the context of preparing the litter action plan which was published last February we concluded there might be different interpretations of the power available to a Minister under the original Act to increase the fine under the section. Therefore, to avoid doubt, section 13(2) of the Bill clarifies the matter by confirming the 1999 regulations and the on the spot fine of £50. The rest of the section deals with increasing the fine beyond that level in future. It was felt that this clarification should be inserted in the Bill which is the first available opportunity to do so. There has been enough talk about litter and litter fines and I am sure the Senator is not opposing the principle of increasing it further. We shortly intend to increase the fine to £100.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 31 and 32 are consequential on amendment No. 30 and amendments Nos. 30, 31 and 32 may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
We have spent seven hours non-stop on Committee Stage. We have given it a very thorough examination and have had an excellent debate. However, in relation to the ordering of business, Committee Stage should have been taken over two days. It is not fair to the staff of the House, the Minister, his officials or anybody and it is no way to treat legislation. I know my views are shared by many Members. We are constantly raising the issue of how legislation is treated. We should not take Report Stage tonight. We should at least leave it until tomorrow and preferably leave it until another week. Legislation and the House should be treated with dignity. For that reason I do not agree with taking Report Stage now.
Comment on this
Business as ordered provided for a 15 minute break between Committee and Remaining Stages.
Comment on this
Can we amend the Order of Business and go straight to Report Stage as there are no amendments on Report Stage?
Comment on this
I compliment the Minister on this Bill. Senator O'Dowd referred to the diverse opinions expressed by Members from various parties. Nevertheless we all realise that the Minister faced a dilemma with regard to this issue. The question of waste management poses a challenge to national and local government. The Minister has tried to tackle the difficulties he faced in a manner which impacts as little as possible on the structure of local government. We hope his efforts will be fruitful.
The Minister must have regard to the European Union. The provisions to minimise the proliferation of plastic bags which have been a blight on our landscape and the disposal of which presents one of the most difficult aspects of waste management will stand the test of time. Despite minor differences on aspects of the Bill, the House supports the Minister in his efforts to encourage local authorities and the public to pursue progressive and environmentally friendly policies.
Comment on this
I thank you, a Chathaoirligh, and the acting chairmen who have chaired the debate for their patience and courtesy. I thank the Minister and Members for a very important and useful debate. We spend much time debating issues and statements on various subjects. This Bill merited twice the amount of time we gave it. It is not easy to debate legislation for seven consecutive hours but it is a challenge. Opposition Members do not shirk a challenge.
Bills such as this are of such national significance that we should give more time to debate them. We will debate other matters this week which are not half as important as those dealt with in this Bill. Waste management is an important issue and this debate has highlighted significant differences between the approach of the Government and the Opposition. Nevertheless the debate was an honest and honourable one which will continue. We have set the foundations for a good debate in Dáil Éireann. That is the job of the Seanad.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister and everyone concerned. The fullest time was afforded to debate this Bill. I thank the Minister for initiating this legislation in the Seanad. This is not the first time the Minister has initiated major legislation in the House. I hope many more Bills will be initiated here to be debated in the business-like manner in which Members carry out their duties, as they have done over recent days.
Comment on this
I thank Members for their kind remarks and their courtesy and co-operation during the course of a long debate. This is an important topic which deserves the attention it received in the House.
Despite our political differences most Members know my absolute commitment to the concept of local government and to local people taking responsibility and making decisions locally. It is a matter of regret that, in some cases, decisions were not taken locally in relation to waste management so that I was obliged to introduce legislation in the Oireachtas. I have a national responsibility and Ireland has obligations as a member of the European Union. It is for that reason that the Bill has been brought before the House.
Senators contributed to aspects of the Bill such as the environment fund and the landfill levy. These will be important in time to come and will lay the basis for a strong waste management regime firmly founded on the waste management hierarchy of prevention, minimisation, reuse, recycling, recovery and safe disposal of waste. We are all committed to that although our view may vary slightly as to how we will achieve it.
I thank you, a Chathaoirligh, acting chairmen, Senators who contributed to the debate and the staff of the House.