We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Pensions (Amendment) Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–149 of 285. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Pensions (Amendment) Bill 2001
Enacted

No. 45 of 2001 ›

I welcome the Minister to the House and ask for the indulgence of the Cathaoirleach to allow me to make a few comments which will, I hope, put the rest of the debate in context. This Bill was introduced on the first day of the last session. There has been a very long interval between the end of Second Stage debate and production of the amendments, which has caused a degree of frustration on this side of the House.

I realise the Bill has genuine all-party support. It is very much in the national interest and I am aware there has been a wide degree of consultation between the Minister's Department and the various professional bodies. The annoyance on this side of the House arose because the Bill was published without being fully ready and since then the Department has been catching up on sections and changing sections in consultation. I have no problem with consultation but it took a great deal of pressure from us to finally get the amendments and we have not had sufficient time for people who are non-experts to go through all the amendments. I want to be fully supportive of the Bill, however, and to co-operate in its speedy passage through the House.

I understand further major changes will be made on Report Stage, and the Minister will agree with me that bringing in major changes for the first time on Report Stage is not good parliamentary practice. I realise we are coming to the end of this Parliament and that those on all sides of the House would like to see this Bill on the Statute Book before the end of the Parliament. I will not be difficult today so as far as I possibly can I will help the Minister to get the Bill through the House. It will not be our fault, therefore, if it does not appear on the Statute Book before the end of the session.

Comment on this

The Minister will be aware that I caused a vote on a number of occasions because of the tardiness of the Bill coming through the House. More than most I recognise that the legislation is complex and I confirm that the levels of consultation on it are almost unprecedented. I compliment and thank the Minister and his officials on that because what has come forward has an enormous level of agreement at all levels. I am strongly of the view that this legislation should be enacted in the course of this Parliament and I do not intend to slow down the process in any way during the course of the day.

I have reservations about one or two issues which have been raised with the Minister in consultation with the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and others, but I wish to see the legislation go through the House as quickly as possible. I am concerned also about major changes on Report Stage, not just because of the practical difficulties but in case it raises new issues. However, I am supportive of getting the legislation through the House as quickly as possible.

Comment on this
Dermot Ahern Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs (Mr. D. Ahern) Fianna Fáil

I thank the Senators for their remarks. A commitment was made in the Programme for Prosperity and Fairness to publish this legislation within a certain timescale and while I was not part of the negotiations, I had some input in relation to it and we know now that the forecast for that timescale was probably too optimistic. This is probably one of the most complex legislative measures to come before this Dáil or previous Dálaí. I appreciate the difficulties Deputies experienced in terms of the amendments and I thank them for their forbearance. Some people will say the legislation was not totally ready but it was published in that way because the social partners put extreme pressure on us to show cause in relation to the commitments made in the PPF. We then undertook to release the Bill in various tranches. I am not blaming the parliamentary counsel's office but there was other urgent legislation that tended to take precedence from time to time.

The Government has always put a high priority on this legislation, however, and I thank the Deputies for their comments about getting it passed prior to the election on the basis that it has all-party agreement. It is unfortunate that some amendments will be brought forward on Report Stage. Many of those arose from further consultation that took place. When I published the original draft of the Bill I stated publicly on many occasions to all the partners involved that we would be willing to take on board representations for amendments to the Bill. It was stated that representations would be dealt with in an open manner and about 500 such representations were made as a result of the process. We endeavoured to explain as much as possible to the various groups that contacted us. I thank Senators for their sentiments.

Comment on this

This amendment proposes to insert the words "the relevant custodian account of" to make clear that payments under a personal retirement savings account contract are made to the relevant custodian account of the PRSA provider and not directly to the PRSA provider.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain why this is the case?

Comment on this

The amendment is necessary to make clear that payments will be made to the custodian account rather than directly to the PRSA provider. I am trying to ensure that there is clear water between the PRSA contract and the service provider.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

As amendments Nos. 3 to 6, inclusive, 20 to 22, inclusive, and 34 are related to amendment No. 2, all the amendments may be discussed together, by agreement.

Comment on this

The vast majority of these amendments relate to the euro changeover. The original Bill gave amounts in pounds and euro, whereas these amendments propose to give amounts in euro only. The exception is amendment No. 21, which constitutes a policy change in relation to PRSA contributions. The amendment will increase the minimum contribution to a PRSA from €6 to €10.

Comment on this

I wonder why it is necessary to make these amendments as I thought that enabling legislation was in place to change all pound references to euro automatically. The amendments are unnecessary if, as I understand it, they propose to change all pound references exactly to their euro equivalent. It is possible that I have missed the point, but the House needs to be informed. As £5 million is the same as €6.35 million, why are these amendments necessary?

Comment on this

The amendments are proposed to clean up the Bill and to take out references to pounds.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

As amendments Nos. 7 and 8 are related, they may be discussed together, by agreement.

Comment on this

These amendments are made to clarify the types of assets which must be held by a custodian. They also clarify the items, such as insurance policies, for which there is no such specific requirement, given the existing prudential requirements of entities that operate in those areas. The amendments are relatively technical.

Comment on this

This amendment will make it clear that no cash, security or other assets relating to a PRSA are ever remitted to, or held directly by, a PRSA provider.

Comment on this

The House should be given an explanation for these amendments. The Minister is just telling us what they do. What is the thinking behind them? I do not understand them and we are going through them quickly. Perhaps we can have the reason this is being done.

Comment on this

This amendment refers to the issue of a custodian account and the desire to ensure that there is a separation between the PRSA and other business in which the company is involved. This is an attempt to ensure that, in effect, they are two separate identities within the one company. The emphasis in this legislation is to try to set up a new system of pensions apart from existing systems. If, in the case of a service provider, there was a connection between the two, there could be an attempt to offset losses on one side against the other. That is the reason the legislation attempts to keep clear blue water between the two identities within a company.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 10 and 11 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

These amendments are similar to, and have the same effect as, amendments Nos. 8 and 9. Many of the Government amendments are technical in nature.

Comment on this

This amendment makes clear that the activities of an insurance undertaking in respect of PRSAs are limited to insurance business in line with existing legislation covering life companies.

Comment on this

Why is this amendment necessary?

Comment on this

I will not go through the entire section of the existing legislation, but it refers to the types of businesses regarding PRSAs. The amendment seeks to clarify that insurance business is separate from the existing position regarding PRSAs. The purpose of the amendment is to ensure that PRSAs will be separate from insurance business.

Comment on this

This amendment will delete the definition of permanent incapacity as it is no longer required on foot of other proposed amendments which will mean that certain events will be handled in tax legislation. On Report Stage I will introduce amendments regarding the tax treatment of PRSAs. Senators have been circulated with the main elements of the taxation changes we are making to give PRSAs the same tax treatment as existing pensions. This amendment deletes the definition of permanent incapacity as it is dealt with in changes which we will introduce later.

Comment on this

I do not understand what the Minister is talking about. He says he is deleting the definition of permanent incapacity in the context of amendments he will introduce later. Will he give us the details of the later amendments which necessitate the deletion of this definition? Otherwise we are blindly removing the definition.

Comment on this

As I said, when the Bill was first published we circulated a document about the tax treatment of PRSAs. It was originally intended to make changes in the Finance Acts with regard to PRSAs, but it was then agreed that we would introduce the amendments in this Bill. We will do that on Report Stage. In the original Bill there were references to such things as permanent incapacity, which we need to remove as we will be dealing with them later. I apologise for introducing these amendments, but we circulated what was in effect an explanatory memorandum of the proposed tax changes.

Comment on this

I still do not understand. Will the Minister tell us why we are taking this out and what are the amendments on Report Stage which will necessitate its removal? If he does not we will not know why it is being removed. Does the Minister see my point? He is asking us to take this out blindly on the assurance that on Report Stage there will be amendments which are at present unknown to us.

Comment on this

We gave the Senator a summary of the tax changes.

Comment on this

I know.

Comment on this

It referred to the type of tax treatment which will be introduced on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us the specific reason for the removal of these lines?

Comment on this

I can explain it no further. We are taking it out because all this will be dealt with later on Report Stage when we deal with the taxation issues.

Comment on this

On a point of order, a Chathaoirligh, is it normal for us to take lines out of a Bill conditional upon something about which we know nothing? I would have no problem with it if we knew what the Report Stage amendments would say, but we are being asked to take them out without knowing this.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The content of the amendments is a matter for the Minister. The House has no function—

Comment on this

Do you see the point I am making, a Chathaoirligh? Of course it is a matter for the Minister, but it would be very useful if we were given the reasons for the removal of these lines before they are removed. What are these measures, to be introduced on Report Stage, which necessitate this? We do not know what they are. Let us have a look at those amendments before we take this out. Presumably we could take it out on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

That is a question for the Minister, not for the Chair.

Comment on this

It is a question for the House.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no control over the Minister's response. The Minister has responded, but perhaps he may wish to add to his response.

Comment on this

I do not, other than to say that later in the Bill we will be removing other sections which relate to the treatment of PRSAs for tax purposes. We are doing that on the basis that we will be dealing with it comprehensively when we bring forward the amendments relating to tax treatment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

This is unsatisfactory procedure and I do not know whether there is a precedent.

Comment on this

As I said before the Senator came in, I appreciate that we have dealt with this legislation in different stages and some Senators may have found fault with the large time lag between Second and Committee Stages. However, we agreed with the offices of the House that we would do that to allow for the unprecedented consultation that has taken place. We did it on the basis that we would also give the Senators an opportunity to hear the views expressed by the various interests in this area. I accept there are difficulties and that many of the changes will have to be accepted at face value. However, there is nothing surreptitious about this. It is merely a technical amendment to clear up items which are rendered irrelevant by what we plan to do later.

Comment on this

I do not want to labour the point, but the Minister is assuming that what he plans to do later will actually happen. He is assuming that the House will pass the amendments he plans for Report Stage.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the House.

Comment on this

It is. We are being asked, however, to make what could be a very important deletion. We are doing it blind on the assurance of the Minister and on the assumption that the later amendments come through. It could have been done better, perhaps on Report Stage because they are dependent on each other. It is bad procedure. I know I will not win this point but it should be a marker of bad procedure.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am sure the Minister has heard what Senator Ross has said.

Comment on this

I have. I refer the Senator to amendment No. 26 because the words "permanent incapacity" are no longer required given the proposed amendment.

Comment on this

This is merely a technical amendment to clear a typographical error.

Comment on this

For clarification, is section 102 a section in the Bill? Has it been published already or will we see it on Report Stage?

Comment on this

It is a section in the primary Bill. What we are doing in section 3 of this Bill is putting in new sections to the original Bill. Section 3 of this Bill contains sections 91 to 125.

Comment on this

I am missing the point here.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Perhaps I could clarify the matter. In section 2 of this Bill the Senator will see that the principal Act means the Pensions Act, 1990.

Comment on this

It is section 102 of that Act. Thank you.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

That is what I understand. I hope I am correct.

Comment on this

No, section 2 in this Act is saying that the principal Act is the Pensions Act, 1990. What we are doing is inserting new sections into the principal Act and those are sections 91 to 125. That is where I get the reference to sections 101 and 102.

Comment on this

This is a technical amendment to correct a typographical error.

Comment on this

This is a technical amendment which will delete subsection (5). This is done because the reporting obligations of PRSA providers imposed by section 99 will apply equally to holders of licences or entities which are authorised by competent authorities of other member states.

Comment on this

This is, as the Minister says, confusing legislation. As this is the section of the Bill dealing with the approval of PRSA products, is this the appropriate time to ask a question? I understood that under the original proposal signed by the social partners there would simply be two types of pensions, occupational and PRSA pensions. Are there types of pensions envisaged other than those two? I have heard suggestions that there may be three or four types of pensions. Is it the case that no other types of pensions are envisaged?

Comment on this

Yes. Everything will be determined by the principal Act and this Bill now changing it which will bring in the PRSAs. There is no provision to allow other types of pensions.

Comment on this

This is another technical amendment which will delete subsection (9) in this section. This is done because the approval requirements of PRSA products provided by section 100 should apply equally to products which are provided by holders of licences and entities authorised by competent authorities of other member states.

Comment on this
Rory Kiely Acting Chairman (Mr. R. Kiely) Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 18 and 19 are related and will be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

This amendment will correct an incorrect reference. The reference to paragraph "(k)” of the Investment Intermediaries Act, 1995, will be replaced by reference to paragraph “(m)” of that Act. For that reason, the new paragraph being inserted into the Investment Intermediaries Act, 1995, will be styled “(n)”, that is rather than “(kk)”.

Comment on this

I have total clarity now.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments No. 23 to 25, inclusive, are related and will be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

These are technical amendments in relation to the security of contributions. These amendments will clarify that all payments under PRSA contracts must go directly to the PRSA account of the PRSA provider. It is similar to the first type of amendment we had to ensure that all payments go to the custodian account.

Comment on this

This is a simplifying technical amendment in relation to the payment of PRSA assets. This amendment deletes subsections (1) and (2) in section 109 as it is proposed that these issues should be dealt with in the Tax Consolidation Acts, amendments to which I will be proposing through this Bill on Report Stage. There is no proposed change in policy and PRSA assets will become available at the age of 60 or in the event of death or permanent incapacity. The amendment also clarifies that the contributor can request the payment of PRSA assets or that these can be offered by the PRSA provider where the particular circumstances outlined are met.

Comment on this

This is a simplifying amendment in relation to the binding nature of the contract. If contributions happen to be made and the contract is not binding these would have to be returned.

Comment on this

This is a technical amendment in relation to the regulations on charges or commissions. This amendment will have the effect that the Minister may, rather than shall, make regulations requiring a PRSA provider to make full disclosure of charges or commissions in respect of his or her PRSA activities. These regulations would not extend to charges or commissions under standard PRSAs which are already covered by the maximum charges, that is, 5% of contributions and 1% of asset value. It is considered best to await market developments before making regulations.

Comment on this

This amendment relates to statements of reasonable projection which are laid out in the legislation. The amendment will require PRSA providers to provide PRSA contributors with a printed paper copy of the statement of reasonable projection once a year. While statements may be given electronically in certain circumstances, this will ensure that the contributor gets a printed copy which is to his or her benefit.

Comment on this

What is a statement of reasonable projection?

Comment on this

It is a forecast of what return the pension will give over a period. Each provider will have to provide a reasonable projection under the legislation, although it will not be sacrosanct with regard to what ultimately might be the position.

Comment on this

What is the value of these statements of reasonable projection? They are based on certain assumptions which are, to say the least, questionable. What is the point of giving status in law to these statements?

Comment on this

The legislation will require that a statement of reasonable projection will have to be provided by actuaries, but that each contributor will also be entitled to a statement of the value of the assets they have at a particular time. This is looking into the future but the PRSA provider will also be obliged to provide a statement of the value of the assets that the person has in the pension.

Comment on this

The Minister should expand on this. When statements of reasonable projection, which are off the top of the head forecasts, are embodied in legislation, are they binding on anybody? Do they have any value in relation to the actuary? If statements of reasonable projection had been made three weeks ago, they would not look like statements of reasonable projection today, given the value of many assets. They are usually based on certain assumptions, one of which is that the value of assets goes up. I have never seen a statement of reasonable projection which does not assume that the value of assets of this sort, particularly pension assets, will rise in the long term.

Is there any point giving status to these statements when they do not seem to be of any value? Will the Minister tell us on what assumptions these statements will be based? Are we leaving them in the hands of actuaries whose accuracy at predicting the future is no better than mine, the Minister's or a man walking up a wall? What is the point of these things, what is their value and why are they being enshrined in legislation in this way?

I suspect that they are in many cases misleading. They give the impression that something is about to happen because they come from people who aspire to a science that does not exist, but they cannot reasonably bind anybody. In other words, these statements are meaningless because they are not binding on anybody in any sense. What is their value if they are not binding?

Comment on this

Unlike Senator Ross, I do not come from a financial background. However, this measure will give additional information to an individual with no direct knowledge of the PRSA and who would previously have handed over anything related to pensions to others. If those with pensions get regular information in lay man's terms and readable language, they will be better informed. That is what this amendment is about and I support it.

Comment on this

The amendment puts in place something that is not there at the moment in relation to reasonable projection. It is for the information of the contributor so that the contributor can see whether the amount of money they are putting into a pension will be sufficient to sustain them when they retire. They will be able to build on their contributions if that is required. I accept that the measure is not binding but it is a benefit to the contributor.

I refer Senator Ross to section 114, which I am proposing to insert as one of the group of sections I mentioned earlier. That section relates to general disclosure and says that a PRSA provider will give a statement of account in relation to a number of issues, including the total contributions credited to the contributor, a statement of account differentiating between the contributions paid by the employee and those paid by his or her employer and a statement of account in relation to the value of the PRSA on the date of publication of the statement, etc. There are significant disclosure obligations laid out in the legislation but this is an added look to the future measure for a contributor. It is a help rather than a hindrance for the contributor.

Comment on this

I am not clear about the point of this measure. I am in total agreement with the Minister about the benefits of transparency and of a valuation and facts being issued to a contributor any time he or she may want them. However, these statements of reasonable projection are dependent on the value of underlying assets. Is that not what we are talking about? One cannot make a reasonable projection unless one assumes that certain underlying assets will be worth something in the future. To put this in plain language, this relates to an estimate of the value of those assets in the future and the income that will come from them. That is what I am assuming although it is not clear from what the Minister said.

The Minister may correct me if I am wrong but there is a real danger that these statements of reasonable projection, enshrined in law and with credible sounding names or titles, will be utterly misleading and wrong. Far from giving facts, they may actually tell someone that they will get something in the future. That could be very misleading and I want to know the underlying assumptions made by the Minister in relation to this and what is seen as acceptable in terms of underlying assumptions and if those assumptions are wrong. It may not be deliberately misleading, but it will be misleading nonetheless.

We are talking about people who, as Senator Leonard rightly said, are not familiar with the movement of assets and financial dealings of this sort and people who will clutch at straws when they are told that they can expect something in the future. They will take such statements as gospel although the statements are just anybody's guess. If statements of reasonable projection had been made three weeks ago, they would be so wide of the mark now that people would claim they had been misled.

Perhaps the Minister will reassure me because making statements about the value of underlying assets is not an exact science; it is very dangerous. The Irish Stock Exchange is down 22% this year, but no one would have made a statement of reasonable projection forecasting that position. Every expert forecast that the assets would increase. Last year, the same market was down 5.7%. Any statement of reasonable projection would have suggested these assets would go up in that time, but they decreased by 25%. What will be done for the PRSA holder who is told a reasonable projection is a rise of 10% to 15%, but there is a fall of 25%? That is a difference of 40%. That is not a reasonable projection; it is haywire. How can these statements be of any value if they can be so wrong?

Comment on this

These are not in place at present. Most people are not conversant in this area so it will be of benefit to those investing money in a pension because they will be able to listen to what the experts are saying.

Comment on this

What experts? The experts are wrong.

Comment on this

A statement will be given on an annual basis so any divergence in the market could be well targeted from year to year. This will help people to see how they are performing, if they need to make further contributions to their pension, if they need to transfer it elsewhere or to make other arrangements because it is not making the desired return. It is not an exact science and never will be, but people will be more fully informed of how a pension is performing if a statement is given from year to year. Someone examining the topic over a longer period will have a better view of how the asset is performing.

Comment on this

In concrete terms, we are talking evaluation and forecasting. Forecasts are based on the value of the assets in which the pension fund invests. Is that right?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

We are talking about someone forecasting the future value of these assets.

Comment on this

The future value of their pension.

Comment on this

Can the Minister produce any evidence whatsoever that any of these experts have ever made any forecasts better than those of a complete amateur?

Comment on this

Actuaries are able, with some degree of accuracy, to—

Comment on this

Forecast the future?

Comment on this

—say if things perform the way people anticipate. That is not to say that events will not happen that could cause a downturn. I cannot understand why the Senator is being negative about giving more information to individuals so they can make their own decisions on their own contributions. If a statement of reasonable projection is given over a couple of years and it is obvious to the person that all these reasonable projections have not performed in the way forecast, then it would be up to him to change from that pension and make alternative arrangements. That is better than my experience of dealing with pensioners who put money aside, did not think about it until they retired and then found there was not enough money. Is it not better that they are given a year by year indication of how things are going so they will be able to make alternative arrangements or additional contributions?

Comment on this

The Minister is correct. It is better that they should be aware of the state of their funds and assets and if they should make further contributions. That is not the argument – perhaps the Minister is missing the point. That is the past. A person can look at it and say he has done badly and should put more money in, or that he has done well and does not need to put so much in, but the Minister has not provided evidence that these forecasters are any better than someone taking a random guess. He is giving these forecasters great status. "Actuaries" is a grand word. None of us has actuarial qualifications so we think they have some kind of mystique. There is no mystique. The evidence is the opposite.

Pension fund managers are consistently underperforming the market. It is absurd to give them this status. The Minister said "if the experts forecast. . .", but there are no experts in this market except self-appointed experts who fool everyone, including, unfortunately, the Minister, that somehow they have an expertise in a science which enables them to outperform anyone else. In effect we are giving status to underperformers.

Will the Minister help me by producing evidence that this expertise has, does and will assist people with their investments, that these people outperform the markets or have something to offer pensioners? Pension funds in Ireland fell over the past two years through bad investment. The forecasters said they would be up at the beginning of the year. Are these the people we are putting in charge of making forecasts in the new PRSA? Could I have the evidence that shows there is any benefit from giving these people any status of this sort?

Comment on this

The forecasters are often wrong but if a person sees the results on annual basis, a pattern will quickly materialise. It is the same with economists. Four economists in a room could not agree, but the man in the street can weigh up and, if necessary, transfer his PRSA after a couple of years. An amateur would see quickly if managers are not managing properly.

Comment on this

What would the person do about it?

Comment on this

He could see what else is available and transfer.

Comment on this

From one clown to another clown.

Comment on this

The Senator has a jaundiced view of actuaries and experts. I have some experience of dealing with actuaries and, generally, their forecasts are conservative. No one can foresee the future. We are trying to be of assistance to the consumer by giving some indication of what people who deal daily in this area have as regards their future. Obviously, the consumer does not have a clue and it is preferable for us to do something like this rather than leave it out. To delete it would mean in effect that, other than the normal disclosure, people would not get any indication of what they have in their pension fund.

As regards life policies, I like to see that what is being suggested will be the outcome. Sometimes it is the case that the outturn will not be as good as predicted, but these indications are not binding and are there only for the assistance of the consumer. It is better to have them included than not. This was specifically sought by the var ious interests in the national pensions policy initiative, including the social partners, who asked for this type of disclosure. I was fully in favour of those proposals.

Comment on this

I have great sympathy with the point being made by Senator Ross. There is a mystique surrounding many fund managers whose activities could do with far greater scrutiny that at present, given their performance. Wearing his other hat, Senator Ross may be able to help us achieve that. The Minister is living in the real world, however, and must deal with what is there.

I welcome greater openness but I would be happier if a group of fund managers engaged J.P. McManus or Dermot Desmond to advise them on future investments. Comparing the results of what they invested with what some of the fund managers invested I would feel more confident, if not quite as secure.

Comment on this

There is a warning on many advertisements for pension funds which states that "past performance is no guide to future return". Basically, that is saying one cannot tell anything from history in terms of fund management, and that is correct. I suppose one cannot foretell anything from history when one looks at it in an absolute sense. It is important to examine this science and ask questions in the light of recent events. The past few weeks have not been exceptional; such things have happened before.

There have been two particularly dramatic events on the Irish Stock Exchange. One was the complete collapse of the price of Elan, and the other was a mini collapse last week in the price of AIB, with which everyone is familiar. I will not go into the virtues of Elan as a stock but, for reasons which are not to their credit, it is my understanding that every single pension fund manger, bar one, was heavily into Elan. As a result of that everybody's pension fund has suffered – some considerably more than others. When one asks fund managers informally why these pension funds were in that particular stock, they say that Elan is the biggest company on the Irish Stock Exchange and therefore they have to invest in it to a greater extent. The reason is that they prefer to track the stock market and the Stock Exchange rather than make what they might consider bold, decisive, value investments. As a result we have a group of 16 or 17 so-called experts, in the Minister's word, running what are very close to tracker bonds. In other words, they are tracking the index by putting in pension money according to the weightings of those stocks. It is not absolutely true in the case of Elan because as a more recent development it has taken a while to get there.

The same would be exactly true of Allied Irish Banks, although I suggest that every single managed pension fund would have been in AIB because they would go for a stock not on what they considered its merits but because it is weighty and big. Roughly speaking, they all do it in about the same proportions; there is a variation but it is small. One can see the result in the performances of pension fund managers which are extraordinarily close over both short and long periods. The reason is that they all invest roughly the same amount of money in approximately the same stocks. There is no great skill or expertise in that. When things went wrong last week, people's pensions suffered to the extent of approximately 2%, which in pension terms is a big hit.

It is an inappropriate time for the Minister to talk with reverence about experts because pension funds have been over-invested in the wrong stocks at the wrong time. If there was any expertise involved, those people would not be in those stocks. I do not have that expertise and I am not sure if anyone does, but to suggest they do so is misleading. The evidence, which the Minister refuses to produce because there is none, suggests exactly the opposite – that these people invest for all the wrong reasons and not because of what they consider to be the merits of the stock. They invest primarily because a quarterly table is published showing who is top and who is bottom. Over a long period they still come in with devastatingly or spectacularly similar results because they are all doing the same thing at the same time, not in the interests of pensioners but in their own interests. Nobody dares to step out of line and take a risk in case they do not track the Irish Stock Exchange index, the ISEC. They measure themselves against that or, even worse, against themselves.

I will conclude with a minor example which is not facetious, although it may be funny. In the newspaper for which I work we conduct an experiment every year to see how fund mangers do against a monkey, that is, someone taking a random selection of assets.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator is making a Second Stage speech.

Comment on this

I am not. I am making a speech on this Bill and I am just coming to the end.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It amounts to a Second Stage speech.

Comment on this

I am trying to tell a quick story.

Comment on this

Let us hear the story anyway.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

There are a number of amendments to deal with.

Comment on this

Not before the punch line.

Comment on this

I am trying to illustrate an important point and the story illustrates it very well. Every year we ask someone to take a completely random look at the stock market and to pick six stocks and we also ask a complete amateur to do it. Then we pit them against four so-called experts. As far as I know, one expert in one year out of the last six has never beaten the monkey. Last year a punter – a reader who wrote in – was first, the monkey was second and the four experts came in third, fourth, fifth and sixth. This year, the punter and the monkey are so far ahead that I reckon they cannot be caught. Where were the experts? Every one of them was in Elan.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator has made his point.

Comment on this

I think I have.

Comment on this

Would the Senator be prepared to try the monkey test on some of his journalistic colleagues?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are straying completely from the Bill.

Comment on this

It is a very important point.

Comment on this

I wish to offer an explanation.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I think the Minister has explained it fully.

Comment on this

The Minister should be allowed to come back. If these so-called forecasters continue investing people's pensions in this way, we will get into a lot of trouble with pensions. We are also giving elevated status to forecasters when the evidence proves that they should have exactly the opposite status.

Comment on this

It is obvious listening to Senator Ross that the experts are in his newspaper rather than outside it, so perhaps we should take some advice from the experts in the Sunday Independent.

Comment on this

No, only from the monkey.

Comment on this

I am not making a political point but one of the hallmarks of what the Government has done over the last number of years in relation to pensions has been to try to give back to the ordinary person some independence and some ability to move their own money about in whatever way they see fit. That is the right way to go. It has been the case over the years that people's money has often been caught up in funds and non-accessible areas. From a taxation point of view and with a desire to implement an easier regime for people to handle, I would have thought Senator Ross would have been more complimentary. Like everything in life, even with expert advice, it is up to the consumer to decide finally on whether they wish to accept that advice.

I refer the Senator to section 116 which outlines what should be in the statement of reasonable value. Subsection (3) specifically refers to the health warning about which he is asking. It states: "The statement shall advise a potential or actual contributor of the importance of making adequate financial provision for retirement and of obtaining the appropriate financial advice in that respect." Subsection (2) states: ". . . shall contain such warnings as are prescribed for the benefit of a potential or actual contributor to a PRSA." The legislation is providing for a health warning in so far as it is possible.

Occasionally over the years I have read the Senator's articles in different newspapers. I compliment him because they are generally written in plainspeak which the average person can understand. I do not profess to have any particular expertise but, in relation to the investment of funds generally, the well-known old maxim of not putting all one's eggs in one basket applies equally in the higher echelons of investment. While there may have been some exposure in recent times in relation to the issues to which the Senator referred, I understand the position is that they operate on the principle of spreading the load over a number of funds and geographically throughout the world so that difficulties in one area of the world would not be replicated in another area. It is a question of swings and roundabouts.

Comment on this

Some 18% of Irish pension funds are in Ireland.

Comment on this

This all tends to be an inexact science. The amendment is intended to benefit consumers and not to hoodwink them. It will give the consumer some idea of how his or her pension is tracking over time.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendment No. 30 is consequential on amendment No. 31 and they may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

These amendments will insert the word "and" after paragraph (a) which is necessary due to the proposed deletion of paragraph (b) in section 112(2). On reflection it was considered that paragraph (b) was confusing and unnecessary given the other provisions and the fact that it is proposed that the Minister can make regulations generally in this area.

Comment on this

This amendment will allow the Minister to have the power by regulations to specify other events on the occurrence of which a statement of reasonable projection must be furnished. The position would be reviewed in the light of experience.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain what events he is talking about?

Comment on this

We are not aware at this moment but something might arise in the future.

Comment on this

I cannot think of any possibility in that regard. Will the Minister give an example of why it is necessary?

Comment on this

It could perhaps arise in relation to issues to do with the stock market. My advice is that if there was a downturn in the economy and if there were any significant events in any of the stock markets around the world, some power could be vested in the Minister to make regulations to specify the other events. That will leave it open in the future if it was felt that something should be included in the statement of projection.

Comment on this

This section does not seem to have any great point to it. It is very vague. Perhaps the Minister might look at it for Report Stage.

Comment on this

I will not press the amendment now. I will re-submit it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I will give further consideration to this subsection for Report Stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is it your wish that the amendment be withdrawn?

Comment on this

No, I am seeking to have the word "shall" replaced by the word "may" but I will undertake to review the entire section for Report Stage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain why the word "shall" is to be replaced by the word "may"?

Comment on this

On page 31, subsection (6) provides that a PRSA provider "may not impose a charge, not exceeding such amount as shall be prescribed, in respect of the furnishing by it of a Statement of Reasonable Projection under subsection (1)(b).” The substitution of the word “may” for “shall” will give more freedom to act.

Comment on this

What does subsection (1)(b) refer to?

Comment on this

The purpose of the amendment is to provide more discretion on the introduction of regulations. We may not be in a position to introduce them in the immediate future. The word "shall" would require us to introduce them immediately, whereas the word "may" gives us more scope in that regard.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendment No. 36 is related to amendment No. 35 and both should be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

These amendments will ensure that the power granted to the Minister to make regulations applies to the certificate referred to in subsection (1)(a) and the statement referred to in subsection (1)(b) of that section.

Comment on this

This technical amendment relates to disclosure before a transfer from a scheme to a PRSA. The amendment provides that regulations under subsection (4) will include a requirement that a person preparing the certificate and the statement referred to in subsection (1) has an appropriate level of professional indemnity insurance. There have been discussions about transfers from occupational pension schemes to PRSAs and it is important that a per son who transfers should have a certain level of protection.

PRSAs are being introduced as a pension vehicle to increase pension coverage. A large movement of people from good occupational pension schemes to PRSAs would be an unintended and undesirable outcome. I will monitor this area closely and will return to it on Report Stage in relation to the tax proposals of PRSAs. The amendment would ensure that only suitable people would be able to provide the relevant certificate and statement. I have not decided on a specific figure for the level of professional indemnity insurance but I hope it will be high.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 41 to 45, inclusive, are related to amendment No. 38 and all may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I intend to propose a specific definition of the word "furnish" on Report Stage.

Comment on this

What will the word "furnish" mean on Report Stage?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Allow the Minister to conclude.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 41, 42 and 43 will replace the word "furnished" with the word "given". Amendment No. 44 is a technical amendment to ensure that the report is furnished to the contributors. It is intended that, if possible, this can be furnished electronically to a contributor. Amendment No. 45 will delete subsection (5), as it is no longer necessary, given the other amendments. It will be possible in certain cases to supply information electronically and I propose to clarify this by a definition of the word "furnish" to be introduced on Report Stage. The intention in this regard is to ensure that the consumer is protected by receiving all the necessary information and reports from the PRSA provider but at the lowest possible cost.

Comment on this

Will there be a new definition of the word "furnish" on Report Stage?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Will that mean or include electronically furnished?

Comment on this

It will be to include electronically furnished.

Comment on this

What else will it mean?

Comment on this

To give it in whatever form is possible, I would expect.

Comment on this

Is that what it will mean?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it the case that it will have a very broad definition?

Comment on this

Yes, that is what we intend.

Comment on this

Why the need to provide a new definition?

Comment on this

It is to ensure that the recipient will get it in any form, electronically or otherwise.

Comment on this