Pharmacy Bill 2007: Committee and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 1–146 of 289. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 21 of 2007 ›
I have great respect and affection for the Minister for Health and Children but to be presented with 97 amendments at 9.30 a.m. today is not fair. Again, I do not blame anyone in particular; it is simply the way it is being done. To be presented with the groups of amendments at 12.30 p.m. today is not fair either. This House does its best to deal with legislation, particularly that introduced in it. This is not the way to do business. I am not trying to be obstructive but the timeframe within which we must operate in this case is not fair to Members who do not have the army of advisers the Minister has at her disposal.
Comment on this
I do not wish to be obstructive either but I share Senator Ryan's concern. This legislation is among the most important we have had for months. The wait for this Bill has, in some instances, been 130 odd years.
Comment on this
I agree with the previous speakers. Yesterday I telephoned the Bills Office numerous times and was told the amendments would be ready at 4 p.m. but they eventually arrived at 8.30 p.m. I am not being critical of the Bills Office but of the Government and the way it has handled this. It is very unfair that so many amendments have been tabled at the last minute and that they are all to be taken on the one day. I hope we can debate the amendments and that we get proper explanations. The Department of Health and Children tends to bamboozle us with amendments at times. I hope there will be detailed explanations for each amendment and that we will be allowed plenty of opportunity to query them.
Comment on this
I accept this is not the normal way we do business. This Bill has been in gestation for a considerable length of time. The amendments we propose have been informed by the response of the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland, the Irish Pharmaceutical Union and by the debate in the House on Second Stage. Some of the amendments are technical, some change the manner in which members of the society will be elected and the types of persons the bodies identified in the legislation will nominate to the position and some deal with conflict of interest situations, and many Senators were anxious that would be dealt with. As I said on Second Stage, we had intended to deal with it in a different way but on the legal advice of the Attorney General, we have had to deal with it by way of conflict of interest provisions.
I accept the timeframe is short. I can assure Senators it is short for me too. I only saw the amendments late yesterday and the small group of officials working on this Bill have been working all night preparing for this debate. I apologise to the House but the overriding concern is to have this legislation implemented as quickly as possible because of the length of time it has been gestation and the fact we, effectively, have no fitness to practice regime for pharmacists or pharmacies in Ireland.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 1, 9, 29 to 31, inclusive, 38, 44, 45, 61, 62 and 103 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed?
Comment on this
Some of the amendments that are at the core of what the Minister just mentioned when she very graciously dealt with our complaints, which I will not pursue any further, are hugely significant. I am not sure this is the wisest way to discuss amendments Nos. 61 and 62, in particular, both of which are two pages long. We will ramble all over the place with all these amendments being discussed together. However, I will not object if the House wishes to take them together.
Amendment No. 1 makes passing references to amendments Nos. 61 and 62. It is simply a technical necessity to deal with the others. However, amendments Nos. 61 and 62 are hugely significant amendments and are very welcome. I am not happy that we will suddenly launch into a discussion on what is the nub of the Government's amendments and group them all together. To a degree, I am alerting the House that we are either going to discuss the whole issue of conflict of interest now or not at all. I am not very happy with this grouping.
Comment on this
If the Senator is not happy, we will deal with amendments Nos. 61 and 62 separately. We will take amendments Nos. 1, 9, 29 to 31, inclusive, 38, 44, 45 and 103 together. The Senator expressed doubt in regard to amendments Nos. 61 and 62.
Comment on this
While I am uneasy about it, I will agree that the group of amendments be taken together. Taking those two amendments separate from the others is impossible as well. We need to be careful.
Comment on this
Is it agreed that we take amendments Nos. 1, 9, 29 to 31, inclusive, 38, 44, 45, 61, 62 and 103 together? Agreed.
Comment on this
As Senator Ryan has acknowledged, this group of amendments effectively relates to amendments Nos. 61 and 62. Amendment No. 1 is necessitated by the new provisions we are including in respect of conflict of interest. Amendment No. 61 deals with the prohibition of certain economic relationships between pharmacists and medical practitioners, namely, either party having a beneficial interest in the other's practice, including company or corporate relationships and a relationship by way of preferential leasing or tenancy arrangements.
Amendment No. 62 deals with pharmacy and medical practices using shared premises, the type of economic relationships it is considered necessary to prohibit and also the situation where the prescriber or dispenser recommends the other's practice to a patient. We are giving powers to the society and the Medical Council to deal with conflict of interest situations which arise by way of fitness to practice.
Essentially, a pharmacist can be charged only the normal market rent for a pharmacy. If true, the extraordinary stories one hears will be brought to an end under the provisions provided for the society, as well as those pertaining to the Medical Council.
Doctors cannot recommend a particular pharmacy. Obviously, a doctor may inform patients about the opening hours of pharmacies in a particular location and a pharmacist may inform a patient of a doctor's opening hours or location. However, they are not entitled to recommend each other and where there is co-location, there will be an obligation to have separate entrances to the individual facilities. Another issue brought to my attention recently concerned a clinic that was faxing prescriptions to a particular pharmacist. All such practices will be prohibited under the strong conflict of interest provisions I have introduced.
As I noted in my Second Stage debate, I had sought to deal with this issue in a different manner. However, the Attorney General strongly advised that this was not possible and that the proposal under discussion was the appropriate route to take. I have taken this advice, which explains why the substantial amendments are being made now rather than being included in the original Bill. I had envisaged doing this somewhat differently.
In addition to the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland, the Medical Council is also being given substantial powers regarding conflicts of interest that might arise in respect of medical practitioners. In the first instance, all of this is being done to ensure appropriate behaviour on the part of professionals and that economic interests will not influence what is asked of patients or the manner in which they are dealt with. This would not and cannot be acceptable.
Amendment No. 1 is simply a technical amendment to facilitate amendments Nos. 61 and 62.
Comment on this
I will restate some points I made during the Second Stage debate on the Bill. A prescription is valid nationwide; a prescription written by a doctor can be used in any pharmacy in Ireland. Is the HSE planning to have this stated clearly on prescriptions in the near future? I am aware it is drawing up guidelines in this regard. However, so doing would help remove any misconception or perception of misconduct.
Conflicts of interest are difficult. Previously, I made a point about the prospect of duty free pharmacies to the effect that patients should not be obliged to walk through a pharmacy to either enter or leave a primary care centre. This would be highly intimidating and would not offer choice to patients. There should be no beneficial or economic link between a general practitioner and a pharmacy based in the same premises. However, Members also live in the real world and it is next to impossible for a non-local arriving in Carlow to get an appointment to see a doctor. Moreover, there is a major problem regarding the number of patients per GP in north County Dublin, which I understand to be double the national average. It has been brought to my attention that the high cost of finding a building is a factor in this regard. Although I take the Minister's point, I am also aware that doctors are being told to expand their services, while pharmacists are being urged to have more consultation rooms, etc. While it is all well and good for Members to make such statements in the Chamber, they are not providing any help in this regard. Perhaps the Minister could announce the introduction of a grants package to enable general practitioners to set up in areas that currently lack them or to enable pharmacists to set up in an area or assist them in renovating their premises.
In some respects, Members are throwing out the baby with the bath water. Undoubtedly, there are some dodgy practices, with which no one is satisfied. However, patients should have access to doctors and pharmacists. In certain locations such as Cork city there are problems associated with the high cost of buildings and the increase in population. While one option is being ruled out, it does not appear that an alternative is being provided to incentivise people to become involved in either GP services or the pharmaceutical industry in areas that are crying out for them. In other sectors such as the hotel industry major tax breaks are given. However, nothing similar happens in this case.
Primary care are buzz words. Everyone is being told primary care is the future and that it is not desirable to have people in hospital beds or nursing homes. Although the option of remaining in one's home and community is being advocated, support to so do is not being provided. Although I have no difficulty in supporting the Minister's comments, I do not see how she is backing them up with alternatives.
Comment on this
The Minister has gone a long way towards addressing the concerns expressed by many Members during the Second Stage debate regarding both the enormous profits that can be made by individuals and public safety. As the Minister has recognised, it is essential to have a division between the prescriber and the dispenser. I am concerned as to whether the legislation will be retrospective, as a significant number of premises have already been built. For example, amendment No. 62 refers to "premises which, although separate ... are such that public access to the one is available only by way of the other, or ... share a common public entrance with each other". I know of several such arrangements. Will this provision cover them?
Key money, that is, money given to get close to health care centres in the first place, appears to have been a major issue. While it may be included in the Minister's amendment, I have not yet managed to pick it out. Key money appears to have cost between €1 million and €3 million. This would constitute a good start.
I was alarmed by a comment I read in an interview given by a former adviser to the chief executive of the Health Service Executive regarding the Touchstone project in Carlow, which Senator Browne has mentioned. He stated that in respect of the project, he was faced with the opportunity of being able to buy suites at a cost of 20% of their value. As an investment opportunity, it could not be matched by doing things privately. Who is paying the other 80%? Why are such suites being sold off so cheaply? There is no such thing as a free lunch. Such a development alarms me and I do not know whether the legislation covers it.
I am not being picky with the Minister regarding the lateness of the amendments. However, they are vitally important and at the nub of the issue. However, I cannot find a mention of either issue in them. Moreover, is it necessary to specify who will describe what constitutes reasonable rent in an area? Reasonable rent for a newsagent would not be the same as for a pharmacy, in which one stocks goods of a much higher value and so on and for which greater security is needed. This is of some concern to me.
The Minister has attempted to cover, to the best of her ability, the juxtaposition of pharmacists and doctors by getting their respective professional bodies to deal with them. However, I am concerned that the issue of key money does not appear to be covered and I am worried about the retrospective position. Who is paying for the suites being sold at such a cheap price? How will the issue of reasonable rent be worked out?
Comment on this
As for Senator Browne's query, I mentioned during the Second Stage debate that the HSE was preparing to ensure prescriptions would include a reference one's ability to go to any pharmacist. It is important for patients to have such information.
In respect of grants to doctors and pharmacies, there are special arrangements in disadvantaged areas for general practitioners. However, in both cases, these are professional entrepreneurs. In the case of pharmacy, approximately 80% of the business, sometimes more, is paid for by the taxpayer. The manner in which the State pays for the contract of service must be made attractive as otherwise, people would not be involved in the business in the first place. I certainly do not envisage grants.
Rising property values raise issues for health care facilities in terms of being able to compete in a market where it is lucrative to invest in residential, commercial or even industrial property. Recently, I spoke to a local authority on the need to designate by way of zoning particular portions of land for health related facilities, especially residential care. It is increasingly difficult in major urban centres for anybody who wants to provide private residential care to be able to purchase a property and make a reasonable return when the obvious temptation is to invest in residential apartments or housing or commercial activity. It is a major issue.
In the centre of Dublin it is difficult to encourage new entrants into the long-term care market. Most of the facilities built are on the fringe of the city where land values are cheaper. It raises issues and I would like to see it dealt with by way of specific zoning. The same may apply to other health facilities. Ultimately, patients and the health system must pay for the higher costs in attracting people into the business.
Regarding the points made by Senator Henry, the Bill cannot be retrospective in the context of what is already in place. Under the Bill the Medical Council and society will have specific powers to deal with ongoing behaviour. If a blatant economic attraction does not meet with market requirements, it will be a matter for the society to establish whether a normal relationship exists.
We will not prohibit doctors from owning pharmacy buildings or vice versa. We will not prohibit people’s rights to own properties. We seek to deal with conflicts of interest where economic misbehaviour takes place which affects the professionalism of either the pharmacist or the doctor. As Senator Henry stated, patient safety is put at risk in such a situation. To survive, a pharmacist requires a doctor to prescribe. If a patient who does not require a prescription receives one, it is a patient safety issue which is why it is dealt with through fitness to practice provisions, and this is the appropriate route.
Comment on this
The Minister has my sympathies if she received the list of amendments as late as the rest of us. It will be possible to have a pharmacy in the same premises as a medical practice but not with the same entrance. I am concerned not about medical aspects but about competition aspects. If one has a medical centre with a pharmacy in a country town, does its sheer accessibility not immediately threaten in terms of competition any other community pharmacies in the same town?
It is difficult to separate the belief in some type of competition. It may not be market-based competition. It may be quality of service or the fact people feel comfortable with one pharmacist more than another. It may be that women feel happier dealing with a female pharmacist about an issue and men feel more comfortable dealing with a male pharmacist. Is the Minister happy she will not introduce a major distortion in proper competition if functioning pharmacies are next door to a medical centre?
In country towns, an increasing tendency exists to have a single medical centre where all the GPs work. It is an improvement because it provides people with a range of services. However, a single pharmacy next door to it or beside it will have a negative effect on people's willingness to choose. If the number of other pharmacies declines, the long-term effect will be to create a quasi-monopoly. I do not need to tell the present Minister about the evils of monopolies. She made a good political career out of it.
Comment on this
I welcome what the Minister said and urge that prescription validity be written on prescriptions immediately. No reason exists to delay it. The sooner it is done the better and the matter can be solved quickly.
People are unhappy about the key money aspect and I cannot blame them. Perhaps the actions of the private sector are a reflection of the void which exists at present. During my 30 years on the planet, doctors have changed a great deal. We used to have one doctor in a surgery working on his or her own. Now they work in groups and have expanded services. Nationally, we encourage them to introduce other services such as physiotherapy, occupational therapy and speech and language therapy to have a one-stop shop. It is important we provide incentives and assistance.
The value of property has gone through the roof. In Carlow, even a basic small unit costs €500,000 if not more. A general practitioner starting off will have major costs and will pass these on to the patients. The advantage of a primary care team is that if three or four people go in together, it will lessen the financial burden which will be reflected in patients' fees.
Regarding the matter raised by Senator Henry, it is important to state the GPs planning to go into the Touchstone centre will have no economic link with the pharmacy. As far as I understand it, Touchstone will obtain the money directly from the pharmacy and other services in the area.
Comment on this
With regard to Senator Browne's final point I did not think an economic link would exist between the doctor and the pharmacist. I want to know why such generosity is shown by selling the suites at 20% of the market value. Somehow the other 80% will be paid. I support the Minister with regard to generic drugs. Senator Ryan is correct to state this may reduce competition enormously. From what the Minister stated, I feel she is not in a position to stop a pharmacy opening in the same building as a medical centre so that is that and there is nothing we can do about it.
I am also concerned about the fact that many medical centres are built on the fringes of towns because property is not so expensive there. We will have a situation whereby a pharmacy within a desirable medical centre will receive far more business due to convenience. The matter of allowing key money is very important.
Comment on this
I wish to follow up on a point made by Senator Browne on prescription validity and the point raised by Senator Henry. When a doctor prescribes a certain brand of drug, he or she should also write a note on the prescription to state if the particular brand is not available, another brand is to be used, possibly a generic drug. It would make it more economical, not for the pharmacist but certainly for the patient and for the State from the point of view of the General Medical Service.
I welcome the amendments on where a pharmacy can be situated, whether in a health centre or outside it. This is ground-breaking legislation and is new to all of us. It will settle down when it is implemented and we see it up and running. The ethical area will come into play. Pharmacists will be governed by their own ethical guide, as will doctors. If they are in breach of this ethical guide, they will face the rigours of a fitness to practise regime and, possibly, be found guilty of professional misconduct. Matters will settle down. Although I can understand the frustrations and worries expressed, when this new legislation pans out and is implemented, matters may not be as bad as we believe.
We have all heard the frightening stories of prescriptions being passed down a chute from a doctor's surgery to a pharmacy below. We have heard stories about patients being intimidated by being told that if they do not go to a certain pharmacy within a health unit, the doctor will not be able to get them a bed in a certain nursing home. These incidents occur but we do not condone them for one moment. They will be faced up to by doctors and pharmacists with their own regulatory authorities when such fitness to practise provisions are put in place.
Comment on this
I will not deal with a particular company because this legislation is not about a particular set of circumstances. We are not prohibiting co-location. For as long as I can remember, doctors and pharmacists have been in close proximity to each other. What we are seeking to ensure is that a doctor cannot have an interest in the pharmacy business and vice versa. We are also ensuring any rent paid must be at the normal rate. This may differ in areas, as it would perhaps be more expensive in the centre of Dublin than in Carlow or elsewhere. We are giving both regulatory bodies very strong powers in these matters. It will be professional misconduct to enter into an agreement where above normal market rent is being charged for a premises. For example, if it were the case that a doctor’s rent was subsidised and a pharmacist’s rent was hiked, I would have a significant number of concerns. The primary concern would be for the taxpayer, because as the purchaser of 80% of drugs, we would be paying for this. Nobody will do it on the basis of charity.
I have no philosophical or other objection to people making profits. As I stated the other evening, if people could not make profits, they would not be in business and if we did not have profit, we would not have much innovation in the provision of drugs, therapies and health care treatment. Most are funded by private providers rather than governments worldwide. We are looking to ensure patient safety will not be put at risk and that vulnerable cases will not be exploited using economic measures to blatantly discriminate against or favour one set of circumstances over another. That is not acceptable.
When I brought the Bill to the Cabinet, we sought to deal with the matter in a different fashion but we were strongly advised that we could not do so for constitutional and other legal reasons. The Attorney General advised us that this was the appropriate route and, on reflection, it is a good one because we are now giving powers not just to the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland but the Irish Medical Council also. I have written to the council about some of these matters, as under its existing powers, it is not in a position to deal with these issues. We are amending the Medical Practitioners Act 1978 through a new Bill before the other House which will be presented in this House shortly. We are including both bodies in these amendments, which is good.
I am a strong fan of competition which drives innovation and delivers better value for money for consumers. It has been argued that as the State pays every pharmacist in the country the same price for the same products, this may not be very competitive. Competition is not perfect by any means. My good friend Senator Minihan keeps me well informed about developments in the pharmacy business and tells me how difficult things are.
Comment on this
They could be much more difficult if we had a different system in place. I know a new contract with pharmacists is about to be negotiated and hope we will get even better value from the taxpayer's perspective, given the strong legislation we are introducing. I am sure we will get value.
In so far as I, or any Minister, can in legislation such as this, we are using the powers available to us in what I hope is an appropriate manner. The Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland and the Irish Medical Council will have powers to deal with these issues under the fitness to practise provisions. We are not being too prescriptive, indicating that certain elements are out. Clearly, each case will be considered on its own merits.
Comment on this
Provided the Bill goes through the Seanad today and will be before the Dáil tomorrow, when will it take effect? I presume it will go through Committee Stage in the Dáil next week.
Comment on this
We must bring forward regulations. I am informed that we will consult the organisations, but it will happen as quickly as possible. The Bill will be signed into law but, as with other primary legislation, will be implemented by way of regulations.
Comment on this
I wish to ask about the need to review the matter because it may not work out as we envisage. What will happen if a doctor and pharmacist are husband and wife? How will the Bill affect this?
Comment on this
What does the Senator mean by "it is allowed for"? We are certainly not prohibiting doctors from marrying pharmacists or vice versa. The provisions apply in all situations.
Comment on this
I am conscious that it can be difficult to trace companies. People may own property in the name of a company. Therefore, it could be difficult to trace who owns such a building.
Comment on this
As I stated, we are providing that a pharmacist has to be in charge of the corporate entity. A supervising pharmacist must be in charge of each retail community pharmacy. A person must also have overall responsibility for the chain for the reasons mentioned by the Senator such as the difficulties encountered in accessing corporate entities.
Comment on this
Before we move from this amendment, I look for clarification. I accept the Minister's comments on commercial rent, but can the provision be evaded by an arrangement prior to taking up occupancy via key money? The going rate for rent will be charged.
Comment on this
That is difficult enough, but can the provision be got around with a demand for a substantial key money payment in advance of taking over the premises?
Comment on this
I could say yes; the standard answer is that there will be constant reviews. The legislation has been awaited since 1875 and I know there were amendments in 1962. We should be realistic, as these are significant new powers and we must allow them to take their course. They will be broadly welcomed by both professions and certainly by the regulatory bodies.
Comment on this
I wish to discuss the definition of a retail pharmacy business. Am I clear in understanding a retail pharmacy business will cover hospitals?
Comment on this
No. We are not making hospitals retail pharmacy businesses. What we are covering is a situation where hospitals supply drugs to outpatients, as happens with certain drugs. A person has to come back to hospital for a certain anti-depressant drug called Clozaril, which requires the taking of a blood test every two weeks because it can be highly dangerous. This can only be done in a hospital environment. There are issues surrounding premises and the pharmacy in a hospital for which we are not legislating. It will be a major task, probably to be dealt with in the next Bill or perhaps through the licensing regime we hope to introduce for hospitals. A pharmacist practising anywhere is covered by the provisions of this legislation but we are not making hospital pharmacies into retail community pharmacies. Somebody asked me the other evening if that was the case; we have had the issue clarified and it is definitely not the case.
Comment on this
They must do so under this legislation. As I understand it, they notify the society but will now have to register.
Comment on this
It is important to clarify that hospitals have two types of pharmacies. For example, in St. James's Hospital, there is a public——
Comment on this
I accept that, but what of the hospital pharmacy? Pharmacists who work for hospitals are concerned and it is important to allay their fears regarding matters of fitness to practise and the creation of the public pharmacy as a separate identity, as arranged by the hospital. For example, it could be called St. James's Pharmacy and could be a limited company. Is it the recommendation of the Minister to public hospitals that they should register their pharmacies separately? There is a simple way to address the matter and to take hospital pharmacists' concerns into account.
I received a detailed submission that I will give to the Minister's officials. The concerns put forward about fitness to practise and buildings in which to work are sincere and genuine and I want to ensure pharmacists are satisfied in that regard.
Comment on this
I must be honest. I have a good and useful note and, rather than reading it, I will circulate it to Members. It is our latest clarification.
I acknowledge that hospital pharmacists comprise an important group of professionals in the health care system. They are highly qualified and, while I do not want to offend anyone, they earn much less than their retail counterparts.
Comment on this
We have met most of their concerns about the legislation, but there are issues relating to premises. Some of the hospital pharmacies I have seen are in pokey little places. If there were basements, that is where they would be. We are not addressing that issue in this legislation, but the jury is out on whether it should be dealt with in the second Bill or through the licensing regime for hospitals. Everyone should have appropriate facilities.
In terms of fitness to practise, the registration of the pharmacies and so on are required under this legislation. I understand that the majority of pharmacists notify the society, but they must register with the society from now on.
Comment on this
I also wish to voice my concern to the Minister. I welcome that these issues are being addressed by the Bill and that the Minister will deal further with hospital pharmacies and pharmacists in the second Bill. She was right to say those pharmacists comprise an important group of professionals. I can empathise with their belief that they have been forgotten in this debate because they are not the front or sexy end of the market. Rather, they are behind closed doors. If there were a basement in every hospital, the pharmacies would probably be found there instead of on the high street in big, shiny shops. However, they do an important job in acute hospitals.
Currently, 49 hospitals are registered. Like Senator Henry, I ask the Minister to keep pressure on the Health Service Executive to ensure those hospitals are registered. This must be done to ensure hospital pharmacists work within the remit of the Bill and within a safe parameter for everyone involved. All pharmacists will be covered by this Bill, but I look forward to the second Bill. Am I to understand that hospital pharmacists will be dealt with in this Bill in terms of fitness to practise?
Comment on this
Yes. As they supply drugs, they also fall under the same supply provisions as retail community pharmacies. From now on, all hospital pharmacies must be registered. I do not know how many of our 53 acute hospitals have pharmacy departments. While 49 of the 53 hospitals are registered and there are other settings with pharmacy departments, all such places must be registered under the Bill. I understand that the legal advice made available to us by hospital pharmacists in respect of these issues is the same as ours.
Comment on this
I remind Members of the limited period for Committee Stage. We will not reach many amendments because we are spending a considerable length of time on this amendment.
Comment on this
We are taking a majority of amendments. Will the Minister clarify whether there is a need for hospital pharmacists to register as retail pharmacy businesses and whether three years' retail pharmacy experience is necessary for a hospital pharmacist?
Comment on this
No. It is important to have a career structure in the hospital pharmacy sector. I understand that there are three levels. One must have three years of experience to go from the basic level to the next level and five years to go from the basic level of the supervisory level. I do not propose changing that good career structure. Instead of 70 graduates, there will be 160. This year, many pharmacists will qualify in Ireland and be available to the hospital sector and the pharmacy sector in general.
Comment on this
I will return to the matter of hospital pharmacists because there is a valid question to be raised. On this section——
Comment on this
To address Senator Browne, spouses are specifically mentioned in the amendment. In case the Senator is worried, we are not preventing them from marrying one another.
Comment on this
I want to clarify something in the definitions in section 2(2), which states: "References in this Act to the sale and supply or the sale or supply of a medicinal product include references to the keeping, preparing, compounding or dispensing of the medicinal product." I have no difficulty with the provision in respect of preparing, compounding and dispensing, but what of carers who give medicines to people who do not have their whole faculties? They are keeping medicines. I am not trying to be awkward. We are trying to maximise home help services. Home helpers ensure that medicines are kept out of the reach of elderly persons, for example.
Comment on this
It is in the context of pharmacists. We are not regulating home carers through the pharmacy society.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that, but I have enough experience to know events that are never the intention of those who draft legislation can occur. Before this legislation reaches the far end of the other House, I ask that the drafter be sure that he or she has not introduced a regulation to make life impossible for carers, home helpers and so on.
Comment on this
I misunderstood. I believed the Senator was suggesting that we should include those people. Someone must be conducting a business within the meaning of the Act to fall under these provisions. The people referred to by the Senator, whose opinion I share, would not be in that position.
Recently, I was told by a medical officer in my Department that half the people on blood pressure tablets should not be and half of the people who should be on them are not. It is a crazy statistic, but not just an Irish one. We have a great deal to learn about medication.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 9, lines 16 to 18, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:
"5.—(1) Notwithstanding the repeal by section 4 of the Pharmacy (Ireland) Act 1875, the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland shall continue in being subject to and as reconstituted by this Act.".
My eminent legal adviser is sceptical about the idea of dissolving the society and drawing a distinction between the old and new societies. I will say no more than that on it. I hope the Minister will assure me that there will not be a discontinuity.
Comment on this
We have provided for continuity. We are proposing some amendments on how the new people will be elected, etc., under the old society. I am advised that we have provided for continuity.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 9, subsection (2), line 19, after "as" to insert the following:
"Cumann Cógaiseoirí na hÉireann, or, in the English language,".
Tá sé mar nós ag Páirtí an Lucht Oibre consistency a lorg sa reachtaíocht. We have always looked for consistency in the naming of new bodies. They should have an official title in Irish. This is not a question of play-acting. In cases of conflict, the authoritative version of the basic document of this nation, Bunreacht na hÉireann, is the Irish language version. A good case can be made for including the Irish language in legislation in this way. When uncertainty exists, the Supreme Court is bound by the Irish language version of the Constitution. A thick document that describes the anomalies between the English and Irish versions of Bunreacht na hÉireann has been published. I have suggested that the official title of the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland under this legislation should be Cumann Cógaiseoirí na hÉireann. Similar provisions have been made when many other agencies have been established. I will not argue the point with the Minister. If she wants to refer it to the official translators, she can do so. I have outlined the principle that underpins this amendment.
Comment on this
Níl mo chuid Gaeilge chomh flúirseach is a bhí. I am happy to accept the point the Senator has made. I will consult the Office of the Chief Parliamentary Counsel to ensure the wording of the amendment is correct. If it is, I will revisit it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 10, subsection (1)(b), line 34, after “promote” to insert “and ensure”.
This is probably a quibble, but I am good at them. Section 7(1)(b) of the Bill states that one of the principal functions of the society will be “to promote a high standard of education and training for persons seeking to become pharmacists”. I think the society will have to do more than that. It will not simply promote high standards in the education of pharmacists; it will have a regulatory function to ensure that standards are maintained. I propose that the society will have “to promote and ensure a high standard of education”. In the case of engineering, which is my own profession, the role of Engineers Ireland in the accreditation of engineering degrees is not just to try to encourage people to be accredited, but also to choose a standard which people must meet before they can say they have been recognised as an engineer in this State. It is a question of ensuring that standards are upheld, as well as promoting those standards. I will not argue about the word, but I think the point needs to be made.
Comment on this
I think I can accept this amendment, subject to it being in order. The Senator has made a valid point. If there is a problem with it, we can change it later.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 11, subsection (2)(a)(iv), line 8, after “education” to insert “and training”.
I assume that the word "training" has been left out of this section of the Bill. The phrase "education and training" is used in several places in the Bill. I have looked for examples in the Bill of either the word "education" or the word "training" being left out, and tabled amendments to ensure that both words are included.
Comment on this
We should sort out the concepts of "education and training" for once and for all. We have never got our heads around the difference between them. That is why amendments of this nature are proposed all the time.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 11, subsection (2)(b), after line 45, to insert the following:
"(x) confer honorary fellowships.".
I am quite keen on this proposal. I once thought the Minister and I might get ourselves lined up for honorary fellowships some day.
Comment on this
When somebody told me an organisation intended to make me an honorary fellow, I thought I should get rid of its power to do so as quickly as possible. That is a joke. The society no longer wants to have that power. I did not have a problem with it.
Comment on this
The Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland is currently able to confer honorary fellowships.
Comment on this
That is right. Is it appropriate for a regulatory body to be able to do that? I will not go to war about this matter. I understand that the society no longer wants to have this power.
Comment on this
I am told that quite a long amendment would be required to make the change suggested by the Senator. Can I return to the matter on Report Stage?
Comment on this
I will confer with the members of the society who are in Leinster House as we speak.
Comment on this
I share the Minister's wariness about allowing a body with such an important regulatory function to confer honorary fellowships. It would be a good idea only if the fellowships amounted to no more than titles. I have heard stories over the years about people finding back doors into various bodies. It is obvious that none of the stories is entirely verifiable. It seems to me that a good case can be made for clarifying precisely what honorary fellowships might mean if they are to be allowed. They should not allow people to practise as pharmacists or imply that such people have some experience in the pharmacy sector.
Comment on this
As somebody who has been honoured with honorary doctorates, I am always amused when I see someone who has been given such an award referring to himself or herself as "Doctor".
Comment on this
I do not envisage that somebody with a fellowship from the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland will feel that the honour entitles him or her to practise as a pharmacist.
Comment on this
Perhaps I would be very happy to accept such an award if it entitled me to work in this area. I do not think it would bestow such benefits on me, however. I will speak to the representatives of the society. I have been informed that a major amendment would be required. If that is the case, we might not be able to include a provision of this nature. I will return to the matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister is quite right in the way she uses her honorary doctorates. Some people include them in their references to their qualifications. There was a time when doctors of philosophy, for example, did not use the title of "Doctor" other than when they were working in academia or something like that. There are doctors and professors in many spheres. I would not like people to start calling themselves "fellows" for the sake of aggrandisement. I am aware that the society has given honorary fellowships as accolades to those who have helped the pharmacy sector.
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 8, 19, 27 and 36 are related, they may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 11, after line 45, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) Without prejudice to the generality of subsection (2)(a)(ii), the Society’s duty under that provision shall include determining and applying criteria for registration which require compliance with any codes of conduct drawn up for pharmacists and undertakings to comply with such codes.”.
I think there is a need for a clearer and more explicit statement of the need for codes of conduct to apply to the profession. I accept that such codes are mentioned earlier in this section, but the reference should be somewhat more explicit. The determination of codes of conduct should be a clear part of the functions of the society. Section 7(2)(a)(iii) states that one of the duties of the society will be to “draw up codes of conduct for pharmacists”. I propose not only that such codes be “drawn up for pharmacists and undertakings” but also that those who will be bound by them will have to “comply” with them. I am somewhat wary of voluntary codes of conduct. I am well aware of the glorious joys of the operation of the drinks industry’s voluntary code of conduct in relation to the advertising of alcoholic drinks. I do not suggest that there are any similarities between the two industries. Codes of conduct should be enforceable.
Comment on this
The codes will not be voluntary. Section 12 outlines the manner in which codes of conduct will be given effect. I intend to ensure, subject to the agreement of the Competition Authority, that a code of conduct will not be used in a restrictive way, for example, as a barrier to entry. The Senator's proposal has already been covered in the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 11, after line 45, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) Without prejudice to the generality of subsection (2)(a)(iii), the Society’s duty under that provision shall include the drawing up of codes of conduct for pharmacists which make detailed provision for conflicts of interest, and, without limitation, for such conflicts as might arise as a result of certain relationships and arrangements between pharmacists and medical practitioners, or persons connected with them (including those relating to the letting of premises), and which require certain declarations and disclosures to be made in that regard.”.
Comment on this
I am a little intrigued by section 7(2)(b)(ii), which states that the society will have the power to “impose sanctions on pharmacists whom it finds (whether or not after an inquiry) to be unqualified or unfit to practise”. Is it consistent with natural justice to be able to punish a person without the holding of an inquiry? That is the only question I have on this section.
Comment on this
If a person knowingly contravenes a provision of a code or makes a declaration or disclosure to the society that is false and is proven subsequently to be false or misleading, what sanctions are in place to address that, or will such a contravention be deemed an offence?
Comment on this
It is an offence under the Act to give false or misleading information. It is probably dealt with under failure to comply with regulations under section 18.
I wish to seek clarification on the point made by Senator Ryan about it being possible to strike a person off the register without the holding of an inquiry.
Comment on this
On the point raised by Senator Ryan, from my experience of having been a member of the Medical Council, in regard to mediation or in the case of the Medical Council where there is a health committee, such a practitioner would not go before a fitness to practise committee but yet there would be genuine concerns about his or her practice which would render restrictions being imposed. In the case of a pharmacist, that might also follow suit. Is there provision for the establishment of a health committee for pharmacists?
Comment on this
The Bill provides for this in a case where, for example, a pharmacist would agree to a different process such as mediation rather than going before the fitness to practise committee. It provides for this as a result of the outcome of such a process.
Comment on this
The section provides that "The Minister may, by order (a) confer on the Society such additional functions, connected with those which it has, (b) make such provision ...”. There is no suggestion of consultation with the public or with the society. Perhaps I missed such a provision but as the section stands it provides that the Minister may by order confer additional functions. Much of this legislation is about transparency and providing for major improvement in that respect. Given that the attitude of the profession has been positive about the need for transparency, it seems extraordinary there would not be some process of consultation with the society and with the public in this regard.
Comment on this
It is understood. I note it is not explicitly stated and perhaps I can consider that for Report Stage. It is clearly understood that one would not send the society notice of a set of additional functions without having consulted and spoken to its members, checking if there is the necessary capacity and other related issues.
Comment on this
The Minister and I are long enough here to know common sense has nothing to do with legislation.
Comment on this
We do not want to be too prescriptive. Normal relationships can deal with some of these matters.
Comment on this
We are here to represent the public. How does one consult the public? Consultation is often an excuse to do nothing.
Comment on this
It could be addressed by providing wording to the effect that it is the intention of the Minister to add to the powers of the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland——
Comment on this
Let us not be so prescriptive. Clearly, any extension of functions, I imagine, would obviously be done after fairly wide consultation. I cannot anticipate off the top of my head a situation that could arise——
Comment on this
——where the members of the society would wake up one morning and suddenly have a host of new functions.
Comment on this
Subsection (2)(a)(i) states, “including the formulation and testing of experimental curricula”. Is that intended for pharmacists, pharmaceutical assistants or some other group? I am not clear about that.
Comment on this
It is the formulation and testing of experimental curricula. I am advised it is the education departments of universities that will be encompassed by that provision.
Comment on this
I hope it means the society will encourage universities to examine new ways of teaching and learning.
Comment on this
Wearing the hat of something of an academic, I point out that the days of boring old lecturers standing in front of even more bored students should be ending. There is a great deal of learning by doing and problem-based learning which seems, for a profession such as pharmacy or many other professions, an ideal and better way of learning. If we want to try new ways, we should not let legislation stand in the way of it. If that is what this provision means, I would welcome it.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 11 to 13, inclusive, and 18 are related to amendment No. 10 and amendment No. 14 is an alternative to amendments Nos. 13 and 15. Therefore, amendments No. 10 to 15, inclusive and 18 may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 12, subsection (2), lines 22 and 23, to delete "by the Minister" and substitute "or elected as set out in subsection (3)”.
We are discussing a number of amendments together. The Labour Party is unhappy with the fact that it is the Minister who appoints the council. The council should be appointed by following the legislation. That is the reason we suggest in amendment No. 10 that the council shall consist of 21 persons appointed or elected as set out in subsection (3). It is a self-governing profession to a considerable extent and I invite the Minister to examine another way of establishing the council other than the Minister being the appointer of the members. I believe that was included by accident. Some other people who have read the Bill, although they are not in the profession, see this as a sinister attempt to take over but I do not believe that is the case. The Minister has enough to do without taking over the pharmaceutical profession.
Comment on this
I do not like the idea of the members of the council being appointed by the Minister and I would like her to examine the suggestion in our amendment.
Our other amendment concerns the members of the society. It must be clear that the nine members must be elected and not selected by the council. The section provides that the council shall consist of nine members of the society who have been selected by its members but it ought to state who have been elected by its members.
Comment on this
Regarding the nine members, if that needs to be clarified, we must clarify it. It is the intention that they will be elected. In the event of only nine people putting themselves forward, obviously there would not be an election but I envisage more than nine will come forward. There is a good deal of interest in being involved with the society.
Regarding the issue of appointment by the Minister, that issue arose with the medical practitioners. We have a consistent approach whereby all regulatory bodies are appointed by the Minister. It is not the intention that the Minister would not accept the nine candidates put forward. I have given an undertaking that I will make that clear in the Medical Council legislation because some people were saying that if the Minister does not like the doctors elected, she will pick her own. That is not the case. It is automatic. Everybody will be appointed on the same basis and hopefully on the same day. It is to be consistent with all other regulatory bodies that we are doing it in this way. If there is any concern that the Minister would not appoint the people put forward by the society, I am happy to clarify that is not the intention.
On the question of the election of members, we will bring forward an amendment to clarify that it will be by election rather than selection. If only nine candidates come forward, I suppose it would still be an election.