Pharmacy Bill 2007: Committee and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 147–289 of 289. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 21 of 2007 ›
I want to make two points. It is unfortunate the legislation does not specify that representatives of patient advocacy groups will be included on the council. I have been involved with the group MRSA and Families which has done great work in promoting awareness of MRSA. It is important to acknowledge the role of the public and the patient advocacy groups and this could be specified in the legislation.
Members of the Oireachtas are debarred from being on such councils and this is the worst form of inequality but it does not appear to arise in this case. I am not suggesting Members should be on the council but neither should we be automatically debarred. I ask the Minister to clarify whether Members are entitled to be members of the council. I reiterate that I am not seeking to be nominated to the body. At times it appears to be an offence to be a Member of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Serving Members of the Oireachtas may not be members of the council of the society. I have strong opinions on this issue because I regard it as a conflict for a Member of the Oireachtas to be a member of a society. The first duty of a member of a society is to that society, whether that is the Medical Council or any other regulatory body and therefore the Schedule of the Act precludes Members of the Oireachtas from being members.
It is difficult to define patient groups as there are many of them and there is not a single group known as the patients' organisation which could then be written into legislation. The many different groups include Patient Focus, the Patients' Association, the group referred to by the Senator and a number of other groups including that focusing on organ retention. Those representing the wider public interest as opposed to the professional or educational interest have a role to play in these regulatory bodies. It would be the intention to appoint people with a particular perspective which they could bring to regulation which is being done in the public interest. This legislation is a regulation in the public interest and to protect patients and it is also to support the profession by having good and appropriate regulation and high standards of professionalism which is underlined in everything we seek to achieve.
Comment on this
Knowing that the Minister desired to have lay majorities on all the professional councils, I wish to inform her that the Medical Practitioners Bill does not have a provision for a lay majority on the Medical Council.
Comment on this
I acknowledge it has been rapidly rectified.
I have no problem with a lay majority. However, during the passage of the Veterinary Practice Bill it was discussed that one can run short of professionals to put on each of a number of committees. Even if committee membership is reduced to five members, which is a minimum number for any committee, a body will have run out of professionals by the time four committees have been set up.
Comment on this
To clarify the position for the Senator, it is the case with both this Bill and the Medical Practitioners Bill that a person does not need to be a member of the council to be on a committee. Members may be recruited.
Comment on this
The burden on members of a council such as this and the Medical Council, of which Senator Feeney has experience, is such that it is almost impossible to find either professional or lay people to participate. It was stated to me recently that no private sector employer would grant an employee time off to participate in some of these regulatory bodies because a fitness to practise hearing can run for quite a length of time. The power is being given to the society to recruit to committees people who are not on the council and this affords the kind of flexibility to fulfil their functions.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for clarifying the issue. It is a pity pharmacists who may have doctoral and bachelor of science degrees could be appointed but those with the qualification of MPSI cannot.
Comment on this
They could be appointed by one of the nominees but they are not specified in the legislation.
Comment on this
They are not specified but I think they could be appointed. The Minister might have more pharmacists appointed than she thinks.
Comment on this
I may have misunderstood the Senator. I thought the Senator was suggesting that the Bill should specify a medical practitioner.
Comment on this
No. The Bill states that a medical practitioner may be appointed to the health committee but I had not seen that one could appoint pharmacists to other committees, but it is obvious one can.
Comment on this
No, I mean the proposals in this Bill. I was concerned that with there being only nine pharmacists, unless pharmacists with bachelor of science degrees or doctoral degrees were appointed who were nominated by the various groups——
Comment on this
I am clear about that proposal now.
I was unenthusiastic about the nine members being selected. My amendment No. 18 is a thoughtful contribution and helped by the Bills Office is a transposition of the Minister for Agriculture and Food, Deputy Coughlan's and my methods of getting people elected to the first and subsequent veterinary councils and it has been considered by the vets as being successful. She and I put a lot of time and thought into that proposal.
Comment on this
I will reflect on the Senator's amendment No. 18 and introduce a Government amendment to specify all those points.
Comment on this
We have been informed by the Senator's very good amendment and we just need to clear it legally.
Comment on this
It is important to make it clear that such members are elected even if there are only nine because the word "selected" is not the ideal word.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated she is of the opinion that Oireachtas Members should be debarred from membership. I do not like a blanket ban and would prefer if people were considered on an individual basis. Senator Henry has a wealth of experience in the medical world which is not matched by any of us and Senator Feeney has a wealth of experience from the Medical Council. I am always concerned by these rules of general exclusion because the House likes to see equality observed. If an existing member of the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland were elected in a future election to either House, would he or she be required to step down?
Comment on this
There is a member in the other House and he is a Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children.
Comment on this
On the point made by Senator Browne, I am such a person in so far as I was not a Senator when I was appointed to the Medical Council in 1999. I was elected to the Seanad in 2002. My position was unique in that I was on the fitness to practise inquiry hearing into Dr. Michael Neary. This was an ongoing inquiry which had been running for 18 months. For practical and financial reasons and to accommodate both Dr. Neary and the patients involved, it was decided that I would remain on the council until the end of that inquiry. I agree with the Minister that there were times when as a Member of the Oireachtas I felt a little unwelcome in Lynn House, particularly during discussion of the Medical Practitioners Bill and I would have hand, act and part in the passing of that legislation. No one person in particular made me feel uncomfortable but it was a communal effort that made me feel a little uncomfortable at times.
To refer to Senator Browne's point, I am glad neither this legislation nor the Medical Practitioners Bill prohibits members of a local authority from being members. People from a community who have been elected to a local council have something to offer. From my own experience I do not believe it would work out successfully to have a Member of the Oireachtas as a member. I was perceived as being very close to the then Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin and whether that was a right or a wrong perception, I felt a little uncomfortable at times as a result.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 16 and 26 are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 13, subsection (3)(g)(i), line 14, to delete “pharmacy faculties” and substitute “Schools of Pharmacy”.
Comment on this
They are all known as schools of pharmacy, rather than pharmacy faculties. They are so touchy in the universities.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 13, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following subsection:
"(6) Not less than 40 per cent of the members of a Body shall be men and not less than 40 per cent shall be women.".
All I have ever asked for is consistency on the issue of a gender balance. I do not have an enormous issue with it, but governments insist on it in some places but not in others. The teaching staff in my place of work at CIT elect two members to the board of governors. We are instructed that one of them must be female. When this was first mooted, about 85% of the staff were male and it was difficult to find a woman who wanted to do it. However, it was public policy. If we believe it is appropriate, we should either make it universal or drop it. The suggestion in the amendment is that not less than 40% of the members of a body should be men and not less than 40% should be women, the joke being about what to do with the other 20%.
There should be an attempt made at striking a gender balance. Many of these professions are dominated by men. About 80% of the INTO membership are female, but not the executive. I am not sure it is enough to say women who are able will rise to the top. Conflicting demands impose more on women than on men. If institutional space is not created for them, these conflicting demands will not be met. If 40% of a body's membership are women, it will have a willingness to respond to the extra demands placed on women owing to domestic circumstances and so on. If there is no significant presence of women on the board of a body, the minority of women will have to put up with the male way of doing things.
Comment on this
This amendment is worthwhile. It is worthwhile promoting the involvement of women in their professional bodies. Sometimes they can be easier to deal with than men. I saw the figures for the political parties which have put forward candidates for the election to the Dáil and the Minister's party has done very well, as has the Labour Party. However, other parties have not done as well. It is worthwhile promoting the involvement of women. They will not get there, unless there is encouragement.
Comment on this
I am a strong fan of encouraging women to take up decision-making positions. If this was a council onto which the Minister was appointing all the members, I would probably accept the amendment. However, the members of the society will elect nine persons and it would be very prescriptive to tell them that four of them should be women. There are six Senators in this House representing the universities, only one of whom is female.
Comment on this
If we were to say to the universities that 40% of their candidates for seats in the Seanad had to be women, I do not know which of the male Senators here would have to give way. Half of the Dáil Deputies in my party are female.
I attend many health care conferences and there has been a complete transformation from my last job when I would look across the room to see if any woman was in the place. The opposite is now often the case because the health profession is dominated by women. I recently visited UCD where about 80% of the members of the medical society are female. That is the future. I do not know what is happening in pharmacy.
Comment on this
Much of it has to do with the points system. We all acknowledge that women are brighter than men.
Comment on this
We must be pragmatic and sensible. The argument was made when I brought forward the HIQA Bill that 70% of the members of the board would end up being female by virtue of the positions they held. Being over-prescriptive is not the way to go. I was in Norway last week. Eight of the 17 Ministers are female owing to the quota system. Therefore, a woman in the Norwegian Parliament has a great chance of becoming a Minister, as there is almost always a position in the Cabinet. There are wider cultural and societal issues as to why trade union representatives are often male in professions dominated by women. I am sure Mr. Liam Doran will not mind me mentioning the fact that he is secretary general of the Irish Nurses Organisation. Mr. Des Kavanagh is general secretary of the Irish Psychiatric Nursing Association. Women are in the majority in the electorate for these roles. In appointing members it would be my intention to strike a good gender balance in so far as possible.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Minister a question about section 10 that also relates to the Schedule. The duty of confidentiality of council members is clear. As an advocate of freedom of information, I am not happy about the idea that anything declared to be confidential must be confidential. Having said that, there is a clear obligation in respect of confidentiality. Will the Minister clarify that the person nominated by the Irish Medicines Board and the person nominated by the HSE will be bound by the same confidentiality clause and will not be able to report back to the Irish Medicines Board or the HSE on their activities? I asked this question on a previous occasion about another Bill and the relevant Minister said they could so report.
Civil servants are appointed to boards of public bodies which apply a confidentiality clause. Does that clause apply to them? There should be no exceptions. If we are to have a lay majority, it must be clear that their first commitment is to the success and proper running of the council. I would welcome it if the Minister would state those two people will be bound by the same confidentiality regulations as everyone else.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Ryan. However, it was normally the non-professional person on the board of which I was a member who insisted on maintaining confidentiality. The tendency to leak information always gives rise to problems. It is normally the professionals on boards, rather than lay members or those representing particular interest groups, who are most guilty of leaking information. I agree with the Senator that confidentiality is extremely important, particularly in the case of the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland or the Irish Medical Council. However, I do not know what we can do to ensure the confidentiality provisions will be so tight that leaks will not emerge.
Comment on this
When things began to go wrong for the former blood transfusion board, the Department of Health and Children's representative on it was severely criticised because, as far as I recall, she maintained confidentiality. People on various boards and those at the HSE have a difficult task at times.
Comment on this
Senator Henry is correct. During some of the inquiries under company law, great criticism was also levelled when members of the Central Bank did not report to Revenue. The confidentiality clause will apply to everyone. As stated in the section, however, it will not prohibit the making of reports to Ministers or whatever body to which the council might agree to make such a report. Confidentiality is paramount. Those on the council will not be present to represent the bodies of which they are members; they will be there because of the wider perspective they can bring. If a members believes there is anything untoward happening which should be brought to public attention, he or she would either be obliged to obtain the agreement of the council to release information in respect of it or resign.
As I stated on Second Stage, many asked me about the recent practitioners inquiry. When I informed them that I did not have a clue about what was happening, they were astonished. I have no right to know what is going on because confidentiality applies.
There have been breaches of confidentiality across a host of areas in recent years. The essence of a professional — be he or she a doctor, pharmacist, lawyer, politician or Minister — is that he or she should be able to maintain confidentiality. When I am asked to address schoolchildren, I am occasionally asked what advice I would give them. My reply is often that it is important to be somebody who can be trusted. I provide them with the example that if one tells one's best friend something and he or she betrays one's confidence, one will never trust him or her again. The same applies in respect of professionals. If one went to a doctor and discovered later that he or she had told someone else about one's health, one would naturally be furious as a result of this major breach of the doctor-patient relationship and the lapse in his or her professionalism. One would never return to that doctor's surgery. The same applies to many other professionals.
Those who will sit on the council will be bound by the same confidentiality rules, regardless of whether they are nominated by the HSE or the Irish Medicines Board or elected by the society. Their duty will be to the society in the first instance. The only opportunity they will have to bring matters to the attention of others will be through formal reports or a decision to be communicated by letter.
Comment on this
I do not believe in blanket confidentiality clauses. I am of the view that the basic principle regarding the exemptions which apply to freedom of information is that people should do their business in public, except where it needs to be done in private. This would enable those who have legitimate professional concerns of the type to which Senator Henry referred in respect of the blood transfusion board to raise them with the body by which they were appointed. Blanket confidentiality is an attempt to silence lay people. Many public servants on boards to a degree feel entitled to discuss with their managements matters about which the other members are unaware. On previous occasions when discussing similar confidentiality clauses with other Ministers, I was informed that civil servants must be in a position to inform their Departments about what they are doing on particular boards. My view is that the law states they cannot do so.
Comment on this
There are different situations. I am not providing in the legislation or in the Medical Practitioners Bill that there will be a representative of the Minister on the council. I gave consideration to that matter but ruled it out because, as is the case with other bodies, he or she would be there to represent the Minister. In my previous job the Minister had representatives on different boards and they reported to the Minister. The situation to which I refer is different from that which applies in this instance. The members of the council will not be representing the HSE or the IMB; they will be there in their own right by virtue of either their election, if they are members of the society, or their nomination. Their duty will be to the society.
At the press conference to launch the Bill I was asked why the council's meetings could not be held in public. Journalists would love everything to be held in public in order that they might report on matters of this nature. However, we must be pragmatic and sensible. Organisations must be able to do business in private. Could anyone run a business if all meetings involving boards of directors had to be held in public? Would it be possible to run political parties in such circumstances? We must be sensible in the way we legislate in these areas. We are discussing a regulatory body with enormous powers which will be in a position to effectively end people's careers and withdraw from them their livelihoods. The society must be able to operate in a professional way. We must be able to trust it and have confidence in those who will serve on it. I have no reason not to trust those individuals.
The society was handicapped because it was obliged to operate under extremely archaic legislation. As stated on a number of occasions, effectively there was no fitness to practise regime in place for pharmacists in Ireland. The Bill will provide the society with a modern regulatory framework and greatly enhance its authority and power to be able to intervene and initiate proceedings in the interests of both patients and the profession.
Comment on this
I understand what the Minister is concerned about in this section and agree with her. I refer to the idea that a body such as the council might use its powers to restrict entry to the profession. We are aware of at least one, if not two professions, that have done a remarkable job for 80 or 90 years. I look forward to the day when legislation stating the membership of the Bar Council will be appointed by the Minister will be introduced.
Comment on this
If I ever become Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, I would be delighted to introduce such legislation.
Comment on this
The disciplinary committee of the council has a lay majority but the council does not.
Comment on this
My sources, of which I have a few, inform me that the council has opted for a lay majority.
Comment on this
If the Competition Authority is dissatisfied with the code of conduct, will the matter ultimately be resolved by the council noting that fact and publicising it or do the authority's powers extend to being able to pursue the matter further? Will the authority be in a position to use its powers to change the code of conduct? Will there merely be a procedure that will involve the issuing of a notification to the effect that the authority is not satisfied with some aspect of the code of conduct?
I am wary of the Competition Authority. Some of its recent rulings have been quite daft. For instance, that the Health Service Executive cannot negotiate with the Irish Pharmaceutical Union is daft. It will place an enormous burden on the HSE and will not achieve anything in terms of value for money, either for the State or for consumers. However, that is a separate day's discussion.
Is there a residual power? What will happen afterwards? Will the Competition Authority effectively be able to pursue the council to change these? They can still publish and operate them. I take it the Minister understands my point.
Comment on this
I reiterate an earlier point about the need to review. The council will publish the code of conduct and lay it before both Houses of the Oireachtas, but I wonder could we insert a review on the operation of it on a two or three-year basis. Like much legislation which comes before this House, we all get enthusiastic and think it will work brilliantly and, unfortunately, a few months or years later, it may not work out exactly as planned. It would be helpful if a review was built into the legislation to allow all interested parties monitor and learn whether it is working as we and other bodies planned initially.
Comment on this
On reviews, I stated earlier that I have an ambition, following the general election when I hope to return to the Department of Health and Children, to establish in this Department — my officials are probably having heart attacks behind me — what we did in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment where we put a group together to examine company law and report every other year stating the need to modernise in certain areas, to do the work and, therefore, make the legislation easy.
On regulation, when we get the nurses and midwives modern legislation in place — the relevant legislation is 20 years old — and the dentists legislation, it would be no harm to have a group representing the different regulatory bodies who would look at it from time to time so that we do not wait. In the case of the Medical Practitioners Act, the legislation dates from 1978. In this case, the Acts date from 1875 and 1962, which is crazy. The nurses legislation is 20 years old, which is not so bad, but still a great deal has changed. We must have a more frequent way of being able to change and modernise legislation, and that would be a good day's work.
The code of conduct must have the consent of the Minister. The Minister must have the view of the Competition Authority and, therefore, it would be open to the Minister to state that he or she would not consent if he or she felt what was being suggested was not reasonable.
For clarity and accuracy, I say to Senator Ryan that when the negotiations were under way, it was the legal representative of the IPU who brought to the attention of the negotiators their legal advice that stated that the wholesalers cannot negotiate with us because it affects them as a third party. It was not the Competition Authority who highlighted that we must stop here. It was the lawyers for the IPU. When the Attorney General and the HSE's lawyers got it — I remember getting the advice of the Attorney General — they all agreed that the IPU was correct. That is what happened.
Comment on this
That was because of previous activity by the Competition Authority vis-à-vis actors.
Comment on this
It relates to competition law and is about price fixing. Clearly, we can negotiate the contract, what is included in the contract, the level of service, etc. and then there must be an objective adjudication of the price. I believe the mechanism being put in place can resolve the issue. It is a matter of being pragmatic and sensible, but clearly we cannot be in breach of the law.
The intention obviously would be that the code would be examined by the Competition Authority. The views of the Competition Authority, if it has views, would be attached when the Minister was consenting or, obviously, not consenting. The only reason the Minister would not consent is if there were something in the Competition Authority's view which the Minister felt was reasonable and which would lead to a period of discussion, or whatever, with the society.
Comment on this
On the point I raised, the Minister is agreeing with me but yet failing to put it in stone.
Comment on this
It is open to any Member of this House, including a Member of the Opposition, to table a Bill to amend any law if there is a deficiency in legislation. It rarely happens because generally legislation is made by Government for the good reason that it has available expertise and assistance and it has the majority to get legislation through. However, I do not want to be so prescriptive as to write into the Bill that every three years we will review this, that and the other merely for the sake of it, and have endless meetings of individuals and professionals going through a process that could be meaningless.
Comment on this
With respect to the Minister, following the previous general election, and no doubt the same will be the case following the next general election, there was a turnover of over one third of the Houses of the Oireachtas between Members retiring, Members who, unfortunately, will not get re-elected and new Members being elected. I speak not of a review every few years but that we agree to even one review. The Minister has admitted this is major legislation involving major changes.
Comment on this
The code could be reviewed every year. There is nothing in this Bill that prevents the society from changing or reviewing its code on an ongoing basis.
Comment on this
The point I make is that the Minister has admitted that it has taken many years for this Bill to come about in the first place, and no doubt her intentions are honourable in so far as she would, if she were re-elected and reappointed Minister for Health and Children, do as she stated. The danger is that she might not be reappointed as Minister and there could be a new Minister in place. In life, change is guaranteed. The danger is that a review could be lost in the process and not take place by 2012.
Comment on this
I doubt it. There is an advantage in providing on Report Stage an option of reviewing the entire procedure approximately three years from the date of enactment of the Bill. As it is major legislation, we would do everyone a service.
Comment on this
I do not know how workable Senator Browne's proposal would be. From the Medical Council's point of view, every time there was a query over something, the 27 year old legislation concerned would be taken out and read, and one was working continually on the legislation in place. It would be almost negative to provide in the Bill for a review in three years' time because one would not have determined all the workings of the Bill in that period. I cannot see where it would be helpful.
Comment on this
I made the point that we should not be wasting time and I do not want to keep repeating myself.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 15, lines 27 to 32, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:
"(2) The Council shall publish each register within 12 months of the setting up of the register and thereafter at intervals of not more than 12 months.".
The Minister has addressed this in amendment No. 21. She must have decided to share my anxieties. There is a vast trade in illegally prescribed drugs and it is depressing to learn of the amount of legalised drugs traded between drug addicts — analgesics, various anziolectics, steroids and the like. My concern was putting too much information on the Internet. Security lapses occur all too easily and such substances could be found too easily if a person were a keyholder for a pharmacy, for example. There would be a security risk for the person involved and also a risk to the security of the drugs.
I note that the Minister has provided, in amendment 21, that the duty should not extend to the home addresses, telephone numbers and e-mail addresses, etc. I would be grateful if I knew she had asked the Garda Commissioner about this because he gave a speech the other day about draft advice on security in pharmacies because it is a significant problem. I do not know that people really need that information on the Internet. It can be published somewhere but one would like to know who was looking at the information.
Perhaps the Minister might consider my point about the Internet. It is that which concerns me because it provides easy access to anyone to get a fair bit of information about someone who is in a position in which he or she has the security of supplies and the security of himself or herself and his or her family, to consider.
Comment on this
I share Senator Henry's concerns on that and especially her last point. They are in a position where they are housing drugs and cash. We live in a security conscious era. Even from a lesser point of view, Senators Henry, Browne and I have been receiving mail over the past two weeks from a certain Irish lobby group regarding the Medical Practitioners Bill 2007. I am glad the mail is being sent to my business address because when I was on the Medical Council, that kind of correspondence was sent to my home, along with nasty telephone calls, and it was not nice. There was no risk to my life at the time but the life of a pharmacist could be put at risk in this instance.
Comment on this
I share the views expressed by the Senators. The amendment seeks to ensure that home and e-mail addresses and telephone numbers will not be included. That is important.
With regard to the Medical Council, I am apparently going to overrule the Constitution with the Medical Practitioners Bill, such is the power I am giving myself. I have seen some of the correspondence to which Senator Feeney referred and there is no doubt that in the modern era, even without the Internet, people can dispense products such as drugs which can be very dangerous if taken in the wrong circumstances. They are vulnerable and we must ensure that open and transparent processes are in place for the council while not going so far that we aid and abet people in activities which are not helpful. My amendment gives the society the power to protect the security and privacy of individuals when deciding what is to be disclosed.
Comment on this
I want to make a suggestion to the Minister on the potential threat to the safety of pharmacists where too much information is disclosed and on the related issue of Internet sales of drugs. We have given the Garda and the Minister the right to oblige all companies to retain their records of traffic for three years. Every piece of spam concerning the Internet sale of drugs that lands in my in-box is in the possession of the authorities. The tedious job that is now required is tracking the sources of spam and demanding that whoever is making the offers be prosecuted by the authorities of the country in which he or she resides. There is no simple solution other than to pursue those who offer me God knows what medications at bargain prices. Our authorities should demand that either the ISP being used to send the e-mail or the authorities of the relevant jurisdiction deal with the offers.
The ability to purchase cheap drugs of dangerously bad quality over the Internet is going to become a significant threat to public health. It is already a major issue in countries less enlightened than our own, where people must pay large sums for necessary drugs. The fact that we have a fairly sensible drug payment assistance scheme is probably a guarantee that we will not follow that route. People in other countries are not buying these drugs for reasons of addiction but because they cannot afford the drugs prescribed for them. More vigour is needed on the part of our authorities in terms of finding out where the offers of cheap drugs are being made.
Comment on this
The sale of drugs by mail order is prohibited in Ireland. The issue arises with regard to procuring products over the Internet from sites outside the country. The Irish Medicines Board has reported to agencies and authorities in other countries and some sites have been closed down. The board has considerable powers, in so far as modern communications networks allow power in any single jurisdiction, and can communicate with enforcement agencies in other places with a view to having them take action on sites which sell in Ireland.
Controlling the Internet is a global challenge. People in certain places in the world do not care who locates there. The challenge arises not only in respect of medicine and drug sales but also in several other areas. I commend, for example, the wonderful work that has been done by enforcement agencies on child protection issues. It is encouraging that authorities in Europe and the United States have worked together to bring successful prosecutions, but we have a long way to go to ensure the Internet is used in a positive manner.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 16, subsection (2)(a)(ii), line 26, after “state” to insert “or in the State”.
I tabled this amendment because it appeared that if a person from outside the State was convicted in another State of an offence, the nature of which in the opinion of the council had a bearing on the person's fitness to practice, he or she would not be allowed to practice. However, it appears that a person is not excluded if he or she commits a crime in this State.
Comment on this
The issue raised by the Senator is addressed by section 14(1)(d), which is all-encompassing. The paragraph states: “satisfies the Council that the person is fit to be a registered pharmacist.”
Comment on this
I may have worded incorrectly a question I asked yesterday on existing pharmacists who lack the requisite qualifications. Section 14 requires that a pharmacist hold a qualification appropriate for his or her practice. I may have inadvertently claimed that hospital pharmacists are not qualified, which I certainly did not mean to imply, and I apologise for that mistake. I was trying to point out that the hospital and retail pharmacy sectors may employ people who have practised for many years and possess good records but who may hold different qualifications from modern pharmacists. How will such people be dealt with under the legislation? I presume they will be allowed to continue practising for as long as they wish. In her conclusion to yesterday's debate, the Minister acknowledged their role in the pharmaceutical trade.
Comment on this
One of the conditions set out in section 14 is that a person must satisfy the council that he or she is fit to be a registered pharmacist. That condition is additional to the requirements on qualifications. Does the council have to observe the tenets of the Equal Status Act 2000 in its determination of whether a person is fit to practise? I am simply trying to understand the meaning of this provision. The Irish Blood Transfusion Service will not accept blood donations from gay men simply because of their sexual orientation, which is of considerable annoyance to many gay men who know they are in perfect health. What is to prevent the council from deciding that having gay men working as pharmacists is too great a risk to take? Does the Equal Status Act apply?
Comment on this
I am sorry. I did not understand the point the Deputy was making. Clearly, the role of the society is to make sure the person who registers has the qualifications to practise pharmacy but their sexual orientation, marital status or political or religious beliefs are irrelevant. The Equal Status Act 2000 applies across the board in this State and one cannot be discriminated against.
The Senator raised a valid issue relating to blood, which Senator Norris asked me to examine two weeks ago. I have not had an opportunity to discuss this with the Blood Transfusion Service Board. The quality of the blood is paramount, as was highlighted by members of the hemochromatosis group. I recently met four sufferers, even though it is a very rare disease. They receive the highest quality blood and that is not accepted. Recently, I appointed a member of the voluntary group that represents them on the BTSB. She has come together with a group of patients who have a blood-related issue and given that the service is about blood, I appointed this lady to see if she could use her powers of persuasion on the board. This is a not a matter for the Minister because the board is an independent body and it is appropriate that its members make decisions based on expertise. However, the quality of the blood is paramount and I intend to examine this issue in consultation with my Department and the BTSB. Senator Norris attended a function recently during when he announced that of the 100 people present, 15 were gay. I was told by somebody in attendance that everybody was looking at each other.
Comment on this
On the law of averages, some pharmacists are gay but their sexual orientation does not matter. If they are able to do the job, the only concern is their qualifications.
Comment on this
Their sexual orientation cannot be an issue. They would have a great case if it was.
Comment on this
Under the section, the linguistic competence of nationals of other states is mentioned. Who will decide whether they are competent because there is no question of an examination being undertaken?
Comment on this
Linguistic competence is an increasing problem in our health service. For example, the linguistic ability of many nurses is not quite what it should be. I was asked by a nursing home, which had a problem recruiting staff from the Philippines, if I could try to point out to the recruits that they would be dealing with people with Alzheimer's. However, Poles who spoke no English had grave trouble communicating with patients who had serious trouble understanding anything. While the society will make decisions in this regard, will it be given guidance? Filling drug prescriptions and explaining how they should be taken is a serious business. This is again a public safety issue.
Comment on this
Under the section, a citizen of the State or another EU member state does not have to satisfy the linguistic test. Only non-EEA citizens will have to satisfy the council they have the linguistic competence. Does that mean, for example, somebody from Nigeria who speaks reasonably good English would have to undertake a linguistic test while somebody from Hungary, which is an accession state, would not? Is there a provision to preclude a citizen of Hungary, for example, who has the relevant qualifications and experience from working as a pharmacist in this State?
Comment on this
Senator Browne referred to the qualifications issue. Anyone who is registered under the current legislation can continue to practise and I am advised there is no issue regarding their qualifications.
The society, not the Minister, will decide the linguistic competency of an individual. I am sure the society will learn from the experience of other organisations such as An Bord Altranais and so on. International standards apply and our standard is higher than in many other countries.
Citizens of EU member states and EEA countries who are pharmacists must register and they will have a period within which they must fulfil the language competency. Citizens of non-EEA countries will only be registered when they fulfil both the language and qualifications requirements. That will be a matter for the society. I have not discussed this issue with the society but I presume it will inform itself regarding what happens in other organisations such as An Bord Altranais.
Senator Henry made a valid point about how distressing it is to try to establish what is wrong with a loved one when they have lost the power of speech following a stroke and so on. A number of years ago I visited a patient in a Dublin hospital and a Chinese woman was also a patient on the ward. Nobody spoke Chinese and she was clearly very distressed. It was an awful experience to observe this, although the nurses were very helpful and doctors were called but it was impossible. Aside from the need for health care professionals to be competent in English, given that the State is reliant on foreign nurses, more and more patients are from outside the State and some of them cannot communicate in English. This is a major issue and we are trying to be as practical as possible. The HSE provides translation services in certain situations, which is important.
With regard to the dispensing of drugs, I am always amazed pharmacists can read a doctor's prescription. I have not had a clue how to read any prescription I have ever seen. I suspect training will have to be provided to pharmacists on how to read a doctor's handwriting.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 23 and 24 are related and both may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
The amendment will further clarify the qualifications required. The section sets out the conditions which must be met to allow a person's qualifications be considered appropriate for practising pharmacy in the State. It deals with Irish, EU, EEA and non-EU qualifications. It gives the council the power to satisfy itself as to the appropriateness of any qualification and, if deemed necessary, to require the person to sit an examination or undergo such training as it may specify. These provisions do not interfere with the right of Irish and EU-EEA citizens to have their qualifications recognised under EU directives on qualifications and the free movement of professionals.
Comment on this
I referred to a little bugbear of mine on Second Stage. If EU directives are referred to in a section, they should be listed on the same page in the legislation. They are a major part of the legislative process and they should not be hidden in enabling legislation unless that is made clear. It is a minor issue, which could be addressed through a proper search.
I am glad the Minister has clarified who is entitled to work as a pharmacist in the State. However, many of us asked on Second Stage why there is no sign of a reciprocation in this regard by other states. The IPU told me a person who had qualified in the North could open a pharmacy in Dundalk but a person operating a pharmacy in Dundalk could not open one in Newry. Are other countries holding things up or is there an unwillingness on the part of the Commission to require countries to implement the directive?
Comment on this
To be frank, the answer is yes. Many EU countries use qualifications as a barrier to entry. That is why we have not achieved to create the single market. There is a derogation. It is a matter for member states to decide but that others do not do it is not a reason we should not. What motivates me mostly is the position of Irish people who graduated abroad. Under Irish law, one cannot distinguish between EU citizens. This is to help them. There was a time when the number of places in pharmacy was very restricted. Thankfully, we have moved from a figure of 70 to 160. Despite this, many more wish to become pharmacists. We will, however, have an adequate supply from the indigenous population. Other EU countries have not followed suit. As in the case of the smoking ban, it is no harm to be the trailblazer occasionally in matters which are good and worthwhile. The three year post-qualification requirement, before one can open a pharmacy, is reasonable. Many believed it was unreasonable but it is reasonable that one cannot open a pharmacy on the day one completes one's education. The requirement that one should have three years' experience is a good one.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 21, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) The Minister shall, prior to making any such regulations, consult with the Irish Pharmaceutical Union and with the Society, and with any other person or body the Minister considers, in his or her discretion, it would be desirable to consult in advance of making any regulations under this section.".
Out of the blue in the middle of legislation dealing with the profession, with outside assistance, regulating itself, section 18 states: "The Minister may, for the proposes of the health, safety and convenience of the public, make regulations about all or any of the following matters in respect of retail pharmacy businesses". Nobody would dispute the significance of this but there is no reference to the pharmaceutical society. The Minister will say there is no intention of producing regulations without consultation and I believe her because she is a reasonable woman most of the time. However, the amendment reads: "The Minister shall, prior to making any such regulations, consult with the Irish Pharmaceutical Union and with the Society, and with any other person or body the Minister considers, in his or her discretion, it would be desirable to consult in advance of making any regulations under this section". It seems rather bald to suddenly decide the Minister will do all this in isolation. There should be a formal consultation process.
Comment on this
I agree there should be consultation and give an undertaking that there will be. However, one should not prescribe that there should be consultation by way of legislation. That is overly prescriptive and unnecessary. I have probably met representatives of the pharmacy profession more often than any other group in the past two and a half years and I am always happy to do so because I have been well informed by the union and the society and it is my intention to consult both. I had this debate yesterday in regard to the Medical Practitioners Bill. The psychiatric training committee was mentioned and Deputies said they had never heard of it. It is the training body for psychiatrists. I was giving myself a transitional power because there was talk of a merger of the committee and the college in order that we would not have had to change the legislation when the body went out of existence and merged with another. I am not suggesting the IPU will go out of existence but it could well decide to become known by another name. One is overly prescriptive when one writes such provisions into legislation. It is my intention and, no doubt, that of my officials to consult widely before regulations are introduced. We need to consult because we do not have expertise.
Comment on this
I take it from the format of section 18 that enforcement of the regulations will be a matter for the Minister exclusively, not the pharmaceutical society.
Comment on this
I will not enforce the regulations. They will be enforced by the society. I do not yet have an enforcement wing at my disposal in my Department.
Comment on this
I do not see where it is stated in the section that the society will enforce the regulations but I take the Minister's word in that regard. I find it peculiar that a body would be required to enforce regulations which it did not draft.
Comment on this
The Minister informed us that half the people on blood pressure tablets should not be taking them and that half the people who were not on them, should be. She has spoken at length about the overuse of antibiotics, particularly at a time when she is in trouble over MRSA.
Comment on this
I would have liked to have brought Senator Browne to Scandinavia last week. If I had thought of it, I would have.
Comment on this
The Minister told me she would bring me to the Progressive Democrats party conference in Wexford too but she did not. I have received all these invitations after the event.
The Minister has talked a lot about the overuse of antibiotics, rightly so. I agree with her on the rise in the incidence of MRSA. However, I do not see any action being taken by her to combat it.
Comment on this
It is because the section refers to the disposal of medicinal products and the manner in which such products must be sold or supplied. Is there scope in the section to include guidelines on the appropriate use of antibiotics which the Minister has said on numerous occasions are overprescribed and overused and a factor in the rise in the incidence of MRSA?
Comment on this
I raised this issue on Second Stage. I refer to subsection (1)(k) on physical characteristics. A pharmacist must make arrangements in order that he or she can talk to patients in private, if necessary. This could be very onerous on those who run small pharmacies. I hope there will not be retrospective retribution against those who do not have a special section in which to people in private. In general, pharmacists do the very best they can to talk to people in private. I would not like to see those who run small shops and perhaps have inadequate facilities getting into trouble under this subsection.
Comment on this
I spoke about this matter on Second Stage. I had hoped those with pharmacies would not be penalised, unless they undertook refurbishment works or created space. Many family pharmacists work from small premises and give advice in private in a corner. I would be reassured if the Minister said they would not be compelled to implement the provisions of this subsection if they did not have the required space.
Comment on this
Senator Browne raised the issue of MRSA but we are not including provisions in that regard. As he knows, this is about empowering a regulatory body to regulate a profession.
In response to Senator Ryan, in section 19——
Comment on this
The regulations made by the Minister will be enforced by the society under section 19. Clearly, it is not the intention to close down anyone's business. I am the last person who would wish to so do as I am a strong believer in supporting those who take risks and open businesses. There will be transitional arrangements and there will be widespread consultations before regulations are made regarding private space. I believe that during the Second Stage debate, I mentioned the pharmacy my parents used while I was growing up. It was a very small establishment in which one handed in one's prescription, did one's shopping and returned to collect the medicine because the pharmacy could not accommodate more than three or four patients at any one time. The man in question provided a great service. I believe I noted that his County Galway roots were the main reason my parents went to him. It is as good a reason as any other, as he was qualified and so on.
Many excellent pharmacists practice in relatively small premises and one must be pragmatic and sensible. Consequently there will be widespread consultation and no one will be closed down. A distinction must be made between what exists at present and what will be required in future. The phrase, "grandfathering", is often used in legislation. While I am unsure exactly how this will pan out, there will be much consultation and, hopefully, agreement in respect of this matter.
Comment on this
Yes. There will be one set of circumstances for new pharmacists and presumably there will be time for others to meet the requirements. It may be that in some locations this will be extremely difficult. One must be pragmatic and sensible in the manner in which one seeks to apply this provision.
Comment on this
I did not receive a proper reply to my question. In the case of a pharmacy being aware of a doctor's over-prescription of antibiotics, is the onus on the pharmacists to inform on the doctor? Am I correct to assume there is no link between pharmacists and the Medical Council, which regulates doctors? Whenever the issue of MRSA is raised in this House, the abuse of antibiotics is discussed. However, I do not discern any joined-up thinking in this regard. It is more than likely that a pharmacist would spot over-prescription of antibiotics sooner than anyone else by virtue of observing the number of patients coming from a particular doctor. What should a pharmacist do in such a scenario? Should a report be made to the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland or is a mechanism in place to make a direct report to the Medical Council, which governs the general practitioners concerned?
Comment on this
The Senator's point is interesting. The Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland will regulate pharmacists rather than doctors. Consequently, there would be no point in reporting the activities of a doctor to the society. It would be an appropriate matter for the Medical Council and any citizen, pharmacists included, is free to make a complaint. There will be stronger powers in this regard under the new legislation.
I refer to the question of conflicts of interest that I dealt with earlier. I forgot to make the point that the legislation will require anyone who is aware of economic or financial arrangements that are not in line with market trends to report it.
Comment on this
It should be reported to the society in the case of a pharmacist. The requirement under the law as amended will be that those who are aware of such financial arrangements will have a duty to report them. It is important that this will not be simply voluntary; one will have a duty to do so in order that it can be investigated.
Doctors and pharmacists must work more closely together and the issue of MRSA and over-prescription is simply one such area. It will take considerable time to change the culture, habit and practice of patients in the first instance, as well as doctors and others. The public awareness campaign that began recently will include training, seminars and information for general practitioners and patients. It will take some time for it to sink in that looking for antibiotics for virtually all ailments is not a good thing. In fact it is both a bad and dangerous practice.
I held discussions last week in Scandinavia and it has never been the experience there that people sought antibiotics in the manner in which people in Ireland do. This is the main reason they have such a terrific record and they do not understand how Ireland has arrived at the point it has reached. Some people to whom I spoke suggested that it will probably take a long time to change practices in Ireland. This issue pertains to education and awareness. While calling it a module might sound over-prescriptive, this issue should be included in the training and education of doctors, particularly those who will work in general practice. Doctors have a major role in helping to inform patients, as do pharmacists.
Comment on this
I call Senator Browne. Members have almost exhausted this issue.
Comment on this
This is a significant point. Patients find it quite intimidating to query a decision by a doctor. In general they are glad to receive advice from doctors and tend to assume that the latter are acting in their best interests. I refer to patients with the courage to question such matters and bring them to the attention of a pharmacist who then brings them to the attention of the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland. It appears that such an action will come to a complete dead end and no joined-up thinking is discernible. What should the society do in such a case? It has no jurisdiction over GPs but a complaint has been received regarding the misuse of drugs. There should be some mechanism in place whereby the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland can pass on such concerns to the Medical Council. This issue must be raised.
Comment on this
The Minister's suggestions regarding education of the medical profession, patients and pharmacists must be followed in this instance. There is no standard dictating that one definitely prescribes penicillin in one instance and a different antibiotic in another. Pharmacists cannot state that a medical practitioner is doing something appalling by taking a particular course of action, or something good by taking another. It would take gross abuse of the use of antibiotics before any pharmacist would consider making a report. The route suggested by the Minister is the only one to take. There must be education for the profession and the public and we will continue from there. I agree with the Minister that this will take ages.
Comment on this
As is traditional, I wish to record my dislike of the phrase, "as soon as is practicable". I do not simply refer to this example, as this issue arises continually. Members should have reached the point whereby they can specify what constitutes a reasonable timeframe in which such matters should happen. While I hope it will not be an issue in this instance, I am not keen on this let-out phrase.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 28 and 37 are related and both may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 23, before section 25, but in Part 5, to insert the following new section:
25.—It shall be an offence for any person knowingly or recklessly to make any declaration or disclosure to the Society which is false, misleading or incomplete.".
This amendment is an attempt by the Labour Party to make it an offence for anyone who knowingly or recklessly makes any declaration or disclosure to the society that is false, misleading or incomplete. This is to deter malicious complaints. It ought to be clear that someone who knowingly makes a false declaration is committing an offence.
Comment on this
I will take advice on this amendment. I have made provision that the preliminary disciplinary proceedings committee can require a complainant to supply information by way of an affidavit. This is a good idea, if it believes it to be necessary rather than spending a lot of time on an issue that may not stand up or may be vexatious. Consequently, giving the committee the power to do this is appropriate. Somebody could genuine believe he or she has cause for complaint. I would like to take advice on the particular word used in the amendment. The same applies to medical practitioners and any professional body. Every profession takes complaints seriously. While we want people to complain when there is cause for complaint and to properly investigate those complaints we do not want people trying to destroy somebody's reputation, profession and livelihood by making vexatious or unwarranted complaints. It is a difficult issue.
If one wants to have an open and transparent mechanism by which complaints made are properly investigated by the regulatory body one cannot be too restrictive. Through preliminary proceedings, the health committee and mediation we have provided a range of mechanisms other than a full fitness to practice investigation which will deal with more serious issues.
When the Medical Practitioners Bill was discussed yesterday, the question was asked whether one could make a complaint if one did not like the doctor next door or had a problem with his or her planning permission or house. Those complaints cannot be dealt with by a regulatory body which will only deal with professional conduct.