Pharmacy Bill 2007: Committee Stage (Resumed) and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 1–136 of 271. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 21 of 2007 ›
Section 25(2) states:
"3 year minimum post-registration experience" means experience of at least 3 years of—
(a) practising whole-time as a registered pharmacist—
(i) in a retail pharmacy business,
(ii) before the commencement of this Act, in a shop kept open[.]
Does this preclude hospital pharmacists? Are they regarded as not having three years' minimum post-registration experience?
Comment on this
I am glad Senator Ryan raised this because this was why I asked about the reference to a retail pharmacy business when the first list of definitions was discussed earlier.
Comment on this
I would be concerned if that were the case because I do not wish to preclude anyone from starting his or her own business, but I am advised the dispensing role of a hospital pharmacist will count towards the three-year experience requirement.
Earlier this afternoon, I referred to legal advice the IPU had received regarding the contract negotiations, but I was in error. I am sorry if that caused to distress to the IPU officials in the Visitors Gallery. I do not know how I came to the view the advice was from the IPU's lawyers because it was the legal advice of the PDF, the wholesale group, that brought this to the attention of all concerned. I hope that clarifies the matter and that I am not accused of misleading the House. I also hope the IPU members who were very upset earlier will forgive me.
Comment on this
I will not accuse the Minister of misleading the House. However, I raised the definition of "retail pharmacy business" earlier because of the reference to it in this section. The Minister said the definition did not include hospital work.
Comment on this
I asked if the definition of "retail pharmacy business" on page 8 included hospital practices because that is vital under this section. The Minister replied that such practices were not included. Nobody would set up a hospital pharmacy business if they were not covered under this definition because they would not obtain credit for opening the business.
Comment on this
The Minister said earlier that the definition of "retail pharmacy business" did not include hospital pharmacies.
Comment on this
There is a little confusion. They are included in the context of their dispensing role to outpatients. The bulk of their work relates to patients in hospitals. However, earlier I listed a number of drugs dispensed by hospital pharmacists to outpatients and that is effectively the same as a retail pharmacy business.
Comment on this
No hospital pharmacy should only provide an inpatient service. That needs to be made very clear. Do all the hospitals we have discussed——
Comment on this
As the Minister has a few more bites of this cherry before the Bill is passed, will she review whether we need to be more specific and explicit about hospital pharmacies? There is a considerable amount of unease about it. As the Minister said, one does not want to push people into a blind alley career-wise against their wishes.
Comment on this
I will certainly ensure such people are covered because I would not want a situation to arise where somebody who has worked for 20 years in a hospital pharmacy is not able to open his or her own pharmacy if he or she chooses to do so. I will ensure that is certain.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 32 to 35, inclusive, and amendment No. 39 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 24, subsection (1)(a), line 33, after “person” to insert “being a registered pharmacist”.
The amendment states that the person should be a registered pharmacist. The business should be carried out by a "natural person", which is a lovely term in section 26, who is a registered pharmacists. Section 26 states:
A person carries on a retail pharmacy business in accordance with this section is the retail pharmacy business is registered and—
(a) where the business is carried on by a natural person[.]
Is it necessary to include that again?
Comment on this
Section 27 covers that situation. I have tabled amendment No. 39 to deal with the same situation.
Comment on this
I presume the response to my amendments will be the same in which case there is no point in me wasting time saying the same thing.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 40 to 42, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I refer to section 29(f) which states:
[T]hat—
(i) in the case where the event that gave rise to the appointment of the representative was the death of the registered pharmacist referred to in section 26(1)(c), not more than 5 years has elapsed since that death, and[.]
I do not wish to cause difficulties for people who are bereaved but is five years not a long time to have somebody other than a registered pharmacist in charge? Is there a logical explanation? I appreciate the slowness of the Probate Office.
Comment on this
Obviously, a supervising pharmacist must be in charge. There is no question of a pharmacy running for five years unsupervised. I do not know whether there would be an issue if we reduced it.
Comment on this
I will not make a big issue of it but it struck me as a long time. There could be two elections within that period.
Comment on this
It is not a big issue. I was just curious whether there was some important reason I did not know about.
Comment on this
Clearly, it would be an issue if nobody was in charge of the place and if the business was running for five years unsupervised. It took somebody Senator Minihan knows four and a half years to resolve issues around a pharmacy.
Comment on this
I understand some pharmacists may have had their General Medical Service contracts revoked last year because they were unable to recruit an Irish graduate despite the fact they advertised for several months. What happens in the case of such pharmacists? As far as I know, section 31 relates to that.
Comment on this
I am not aware of it. Perhaps the Senator will bring it to our attention. I do not believe it is provided for in this legislation.
Comment on this
Is there any point including section 32(5) and leaving a list of terms such as "pharmacy", "medical stores", "drug stores", "drug hall", etc. People who want to will think up new names not included in this subsection. It is an endless and fruitless chase. It would be an appropriate place to talk about Internet drugs, if we wanted to do so, but we will not go down that route as it is too late in the day. I do not see the point of including a list of names.
Comment on this
They were referred to in old Acts and it is to ensure people who are not pharmacists do not use these titles.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 29, subsection (8), line 33, after "committee" to insert the following:
"and a registered medical practitioner appointed under subsection (9)”.
The Labour Part Members had a concern in this regard. Section 34 pertains to the disciplinary committees and section 34(8) states that "members of a disciplinary committee have, as such, the same protections and immunities as a judge of the High Court". While no one would argue with that, it is unclear whether a registered medical practitioner who advises such a disciplinary committee would have the same privileges as the committee members. This amendment proposes that the members of the committee and a registered medical practitioner appointed under subsection (9) will have the same privileges in respect of protection from being sued.
Comment on this
My understanding is that such doctors are not present on the same basis as members of the committee. They are present purely in an advisory capacity. I must take advice and will have the matter checked.
Comment on this
While I do not wish to labour the point, it is unclear whether the doctor involved would be protected.
Comment on this
A doctor who gave bona fide advice to such a committee could be left wide open to being sued. I am glad the Minister will consider the issue.
Comment on this
I imagine the doctor would be paid. Does that make a difference? I assume the doctor would be paid.
Comment on this
The doctor would be present in an expert capacity. I imagine that doctors who give advice or are expert witnesses in court——
Comment on this
That is allowed. Does Senator Henry believe a distinction can be made in this regard?
Comment on this
I believe there is a difference when one acts as an expert witness. However I cannot recall the details.
Comment on this
Does the Senator mean that those who are paid are not protected? Does one's own private insurance or whatever offer protection?
Comment on this
I will check it. I want to ensure we make it easy to get such advice and avoid making it cumbersome or putting people in a vulnerable position.
Comment on this
I accept that section 34 does not state that membership of the committees is confined to members of the council. However, I would have preferred a more explicit statement that recruitment to the two committees in question was open to those who are not council members. Earlier the Minister commented on the burden of work that could be involved in respect of a preliminary professional conduct committee and a health committee. Moreover, given the prerequisite that a majority of the members of each committee should be registered pharmacists, resources may be overstretched. I understood the Minister to have stated that there would be an entitlement to have people on such committees other than members of the council. I would have preferred this to have been made explicit in the legislation.
Comment on this
This is included in paragraph 7(3) of Schedule 1 which states: "A committee may include persons who are not members of the Council."
Comment on this
Does this mean Members are in a position to move on?
Comment on this
If the Acting Chairman challenges me, I might make it impossible to move on. However, I will not.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 47, 48 and 50 to 52, inclusive, are cognate and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 29, subsection (1), line 41, after "pharmacist" to insert "or trainee pharmacist".
Trainee pharmacists should also be included. They have left the schools of pharmacy and are doing what could be described as their intern year. However, the registered pharmacist cannot have eyes in the back of his or her head. I would have thought there was an onus on the trainee pharmacist to abide by the rules and regulations of the society of which they aspire to become members.
Comment on this
The Senator makes the point that the supervisory pharmacist would be obliged to have eyes in the back of his or her head. I am trying to recall how the Medical Council legislation deals with interns. They are covered by the Medical Council legislation.
Comment on this
I will do so. I am uncertain whether it is reasonable to bring trainees before a fitness to practice committee. I will revert to the issue.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In page 30, subsection (2), lines 15 and 16, to delete "or, if not, in a form acceptable to the Council".
This amendment is quite important and pertains to the form of a complaint. At present, section 35(2) states: "A complaint must be in writing or, if not, in a form acceptable to the Council." I do not like the idea of the first half of a sentence using the word "must" when it is followed by the phrase "or, if not". It should be obligatory for a complaint of this nature to be in writing. While I am prepared to entertain arguments concerning those with disabilities and similar issues, the complaint must be in writing. This amendment suggests the deletion of "or, if not, in a form acceptable to the Council".
I am prepared to listen if a good reason can be put forward. In principle however, if a complaint is being made which could lead to anything from a reprimand to being struck off from the register of pharmacists, the least one can expect is a written record. The great advantage of written records is there is a clear record as to the nature of the complaint. This is not the case with either verbal or e-mailed complaints. E-mail is still an insufficiently secure or reliable method. I want to hear a reason for an exception because I cannot think of one.
For example, in the GAA one can do little in terms of appealing or complaining about anyone except in a written and prescribed form. Organisations recognise that without a written record, one enters dodgy territory. If there is a good reason, I am prepared to listen.
Comment on this
I support Senator Ryan in this regard. I could not think of another form that would be acceptable. Perhaps a form could be found that sounds reasonable.
Comment on this
It is hard to argue against the Senators' points. Much of this was done with a view to making it easy for people who wish to make a complaint from a patient safety perspective. However, I accept the need to be fair. Even a complaint that never ends up in a fitness to practice inquiry or that simply goes to a preliminary hearings committee can cause much upset. I will examine this matter.
Comment on this
I have a minor question in respect of section 35. While I do not wish to be awkward, this matter arose in a different context. I refer to section 35(3), which states: "A complaint may be made on behalf of any person or by the registrar." I am not being picky when I say this means that a person cannot make a complaint himself or herself. It can be made on behalf of any person or by the council. I suggest that a complaint can be made by, or on behalf or any person, or by the registrar. I ask the Minister to consider this. As it stands, it appears——
Comment on this
I refer to wording. Given the subsection's current wording, if I wished to complain about a pharmacist, such a complaint would have to be made on my behalf.
Comment on this
No. Section 35(3) states: "A complaint may be made on behalf of any person or by the registrar."
Comment on this
I had this debate with the Minister for Education and Science when discussing the Residential Institutions Redress Board in which a similar phrase was used. The form of drafting would have meant victims could not have appealed to the Ombudsman and would have needed someone to do it for them. This is why I noticed it here.
Comment on this
The eternal argument with the Parliamentary Counsel is once again raised in section 37(1) which states: "The council may devise guidelines about resolving complaints by mediation." Everybody believes resolving complaints by mediation is a most desirable way to do things. In my view it should state "shall" and not "may".
Comment on this
I do not disagree with the Senator and I will examine it. We want a mediation process and we must have guidelines on it. We will do "shall".
Comment on this
It should not be discretionary. The word "may" is appropriate in certain areas but "shall" should be used here.
Comment on this
I am delighted to see this section because frequently complaints can be fixed up through a mediation process.
Comment on this
I have some other questions and I do not believe they are trivial. The Acting Chairman has a wonderful way of looking at me to make me feel like I am wasting the House's time.
Comment on this
I wonder what would make the Senator think that.
Comment on this
Section 37(3) states:
No attempt may be made to resolve a complaint by mediation without the consent of the complainant and the registered pharmacist or pharmacy owner.
Should we insert the phrase "written consent" into this section? The purpose is to ensure everybody operates in the same way.
Comment on this
This is important. Agreeing to mediation is the start of a process and everybody should know what they agree to.
Comment on this
If they do not agree to mediation, it cannot take place. To mediate one must have both parties——
Comment on this
They might agree and then change their minds or be advised by a lawyer that they should not have agreed to it.
Comment on this
Many of us received representations from people in the profession and one argument put to me was that this is soft in terms of preference for all hearings to be in public. Section 42 states:
(1) A hearing before the professional conduct committee shall be held in public [This is a great start].
(2) But it shall be held in private if—
(a) the registered pharmacist or pharmacy owner or the complainant so requests, and
(b) the committee is satisfied that it would be appropriate to agree to that request.
I accept on occasion business must be conducted in private. Even the Houses of the Oireachtas have reserved the right to meet in private under certain circumstances. I do not think it has ever happened. The word "appropriate" is a bit weak. A stronger term such as "the greater good or public interest demands it" would be better. Bodies such as this should meet in public and complaints should be heard in public. The bodies are quasi-judicial and we have a strong tradition that all of our judicial activities take place in public.
Comment on this
I know we have a great desire to hold everything in public. However, I worry about the complainant far more than the professional when hearings are held in public. I frequently see court cases where patients have justified complaints against doctors but when they consider what would come out in court, the case falls apart. I would not like too much insistence on it being in public.
The professional would come out of it perfectly all right and he or she would almost certainly have the advice of the professional body and moral support. Frequently, a complainant is not used to publicity and is horrified to discover what may come out. While I understand the desire to hold everything in public, and it should be if everyone wants it, I have seen people dismayed.
I am sure the Minister saw in the High Court recently where a doctor tried to insist cases involving the most serious sexual abuse of adult patients were held in public. He knew the women would not continue with them if they were held in public. It took great courage on their part to go forward anonymously.
Comment on this
I have certain concerns. It is not unheard of for people to make baseless accusations against professional people, including pharmacists. The problem would be with the complainant. If it were held in public, we would have the old concept of no smoke without fire. It is covered sufficiently and a certain amount of reserved wisdom must apply in this case. I am concerned for any professional person. The merits of each case would have to be studied carefully and the legislation should provide for this.
Comment on this
I feel strongly about this issue. Senator Henry made valid points about the complainant and she is correct. Most people are terrified of authority, especially the courts. It is one of the reasons so few people come forward in rape and sexual offence cases. The few I met who did go forward stated the trial, court and adversarial system were terrifying and wondered whether they would go through it again. I do not state a fitness to practise inquiry is at the same level. However, we must make it easy for people to make legitimate complaints. The committee which will make the decision will have a non-pharmacy majority. It will not be a committee composed of pharmacists who will state it will be heard in private.
On the point made by Senator Glynn, I hope that with the new procedure, the preliminary hearings committee, dealing with mediation and health issues being dealt with by the health committee, this will mean only complaints of substance will go before a fitness to practise inquiry. These reasons include time and money and the fact that one does not want vexatious complaints getting past the preliminary inquiry. With all the good things happening in Ireland, I sometimes feel we have full-time complainers and whingers who love to complain about everybody and anything. I hope this legislation will not make it easy for vexatious complaints to be made about pharmacists, doctors or other health care professionals.
I believe we have the balance right. With regard to including the phrase "in the public interest", if the complainant has a wish to hold the hearing in private, it should be taken into account. Without the complainant we would not have a complaint and the matter would not arise in the first instance. Many people like to remain anonymous. The midwives in Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda eventually blew the whistle there and to the credit of the health board, it took the matter seriously. The person most responsible is now involved in the Pharmaceutical Society. Those people do not want to become public figures. Giving the decision to the committee is fair and reasonable under the circumstances.
Comment on this
Amendments 53 to 57, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
The Minister has an amendment tabled so let us move on. I will not move amendment No. 53.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 54 is a Government amendment but must be discussed with amendment No. 53. If the Minister wishes to speak on it, amendment No. 53 must be moved.
Comment on this
I apologise. I move amendment No. 53:
In page 34, subsection (1), line 32, after "the" where it firstly occurs to insert "High".
Comment on this
If the Minister wishes to comment on amendments Nos. 54 and 55, now is the time to do it.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 58 to 60, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
The amendment is self-explanatory. The provision would close the shop, but only on a High Court order, which would require the society to make a very strong case.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 60, I am glad the Minister took my advice. I thought it important there should be an immediate shutdown.
Comment on this
I thought it very important there should be an immediate shutdown if there was a really serious problem.
Comment on this
I have a comment on section 48(2), just to prove I read all this stuff. It states "The Council may not cancel the registration of a pharmacist or retail pharmacy business on the grounds of a conviction for an offence". I take it that is an offence unrelated to the nature of this Bill.
Comment on this
Yes. The Senator is reading from subsection (2), which states:
The Council may not cancel the registration of a pharmacist or retail pharmacy business on the grounds of a conviction for an offence unless in the Council's opinion, the nature of the offence or the circumstances in which it was committed are such that, were the pharmacist or pharmacy owner applying for registration, the Council would refuse the registration.
Comment on this
I am at least happy about the consistency that must apply the same test to cancelling as it would to refusing registration. Should there not be a little legislative guidance regarding the offences under consideration? It is undefined. Are we speaking about a drink-driving conviction or murder or rape? I presume we are speaking about serious offences.
This is only a thought but it may be the subject of enormous and lengthy discussion by the council before it would agree on what it is because it is so vague.
Comment on this
It is clearly concerned with fitness to practise. The council's role relates to the capacity of the individual to practise as a pharmacist.
Comment on this
If there is a breach of planning laws or some other road traffic incident, for example, it is not a reason for the council to act. It is in the context of the Bill and must be relevant, as the functions of the council would not allow it consider other issues. It must be in the context of professional conduct.
Comment on this
We discussed this earlier when I raised the equal status matter. I do not want to go off on that again.
Comment on this
No, there is no reason to go over that again. I believe it was a valid question but the Minister answered it satisfactorily and I am sorry for interrupting her. There is a clear statement here that people convicted of some undefined offences are not fit to practise. The matter could do with a little teasing out. It is only an opinion but the area could end up with enormous arguments. There is either a minimum penalty or an offence.
Comment on this
We will have it clarified by our legal advisers that it is foolproof to deal with just the issues I mentioned.
Comment on this
It is something councils must be very careful about. The term "moral turpitude" came up earlier. I do not know what it is but it sounds absolutely dreadful.
One must be very careful with professional people if their livelihood and profession are to be removed because of convictions in a totally unrelated area.
Comment on this
Of course the conviction cannot be of murder or something similar, as they would be in prison as a result. We should be very careful that we are not acting as some kind of moral supervisor for people——.
Comment on this
I brought up the term "of unsound mind" when we were discussing a Bill relevant to whether a person could run a gun shop. What is unsound mind? Is it somebody who is forgetful? There was no definition of the term. We would be taking away the person's livelihood and we should be very careful when making moral decisions about issues that will have such a serious effect. It may have nothing to do with a person's professional actions.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I will have that checked with the Parliamentary Counsel in case there is any doubt.
Comment on this
I am unsure whether it is the temerity or caution of the drafters but section 52(3) states "The High Court may but need not confirm the Council's decision." I am absolutely certain there was never any need to put into legislation that the High Court had the power to say no to anything.
Comment on this
I have never found it slow to say no. Subsection (3) is probably unnecessary as the High Court is more than capable of making up its own mind.
Comment on this
Perhaps we are entering into another discussion.
Comment on this
I will have to take legal advice but I take the point made by the Senator. We know the ultimate decision in these matters comes from the High Court.
Comment on this
I have made notes about sections 56 and 57 and decided to wait for the debate on section 57. When in God's name could it ever not be in the public interest to give public notice of any of the issues listed? What is the point of cancelling the registration of a pharmacist and not giving public notice? The same applies to restoration, suspension, expiry or attachment of conditions etc. These should clearly always be a public matter and it is entirely pointless to suggest there would ever be a reason not to give public notice.