Pharmacy Bill 2007: Committee Stage (Resumed) and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 137–271 of 271. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 21 of 2007 ›
The point concerns a public notice but will a sign go up in a pharmacy itself if, for example, a pharmacy was to be closed down? Would there be a newspaper advertisement?
Comment on this
The problem is if a pharmacy was to be closed down for a reason, the public might not be aware why it happened. It may have been closed for other reasons. Will a sign be clearly displayed in the pharmacy?
Comment on this
I am not certain there would be a sign. If we do what Senator Ryan is suggesting it would be a matter of public knowledge.
Comment on this
If a doctor is struck off we do not expect him or her to walk around with a sign indicating they have been struck off.
Comment on this
If it is closed down it will be shut. We can take Senator Ryan's comments into account and I could put the word "shall" in the section. I take the Senator's point of when it would not be in the public interest. Bad news usually makes big news anyway.
Comment on this
I refer back to the doctor and remind the Minister again of expert advice being given. This relates to defamation and whether we believe a doctor should be exempt from a defamation suit or not, we should at least make up our minds which side we are on. Expert witnesses in the High Court have qualified privilege. Unless they are proven to be acting in bad faith, they cannot be sued for the evidence they give. We must make the same true in this case.
Comment on this
This section relates to the cancellation of registration on request. In respect of the person applying for the cancellation, it states, "at the time of applying, the subject of a complaint", meaning the registration cannot be cancelled. What occurs in the case of a person who has cancelled his or her registration, but against whom a complaint is subsequently made? He or she cannot be struck off a register he or she is not on, but who will investigate the complaint? In such an instance, could the person apply to be re-registered two years later?
Comment on this
The complaint would need to be pursued at that point. I will clarify for the Senator, as I take his point.
Comment on this
As a perennial late payer, I want to protest. There are complicated procedures to go through to cancel a registration if a complaint is made against that person, but the Bill makes no reference to any court in the case of someone who loses his or her registration for failing to pay a retention fee. I would appeal to the council, if not to the Minister, to work out a procedure involving a few steps along the way to address such cases. A person's registration could be lost in the same way and with the same impact as is the case of someone accused of selling drugs to half of the city's addicts.
Comment on this
This is a self-financing organisation and we want to ensure funding. I have prohibited the council from charging trainee or student pharmacists.
Comment on this
Going to court would cost more than the fee and would not be a good idea. People will be given reminders.
Comment on this
Perhaps it should be like the Irish Turf Club, namely, always in credit.
Comment on this
I could not vote in elections or in ballots, but I would have the protection of my union, which would represent me if I had a problem.
Comment on this
On a point of clarification, the amendment states, "share a common public entrance with each other". Would it be helpful to insert a provision stating, "if, in the case of (a) or (b), there is an arrangement of the kind described in subsection (2)”? Does the current provision only apply to (b)?
Comment on this
Could we deal with it when we address the relevant section?
Comment on this
Unless we insert "in the case of (a) or (b)”, the proposed section 64(1)(b)(ii) would relate only to (b) and exclude same premises.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 63 and 64 are logical alternatives and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In page 41, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:
""premises" includes any aircraft, hovercraft, ship, stall, or vehicle;".
It is important to ensure the term "premises" is broadly defined. My definition is from the Irish Medicines Board (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2006.
There is a considerable problem with the smuggling of counterfeit drugs, a matter on which Senator Glynn has spoken frequently at the Joint Committee on Health and Children. It is important for the authorised officers to be in a position to examine any drug brought into the country and being sold here. For example, I saw pharmaceutical drugs being sold at a car boot sale in England, for which reason the word "stall" is relevant. I hope the Minister accepts my amendment.
Comment on this
I have no idea from where my amendment came, as I am not as well informed as Senator Henry, but the point has been made. The definition of "premises" must be clarified. Therefore, it would be no harm to include a broader definition.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 41, paragraph (a), line 37, before “a” to insert “computer data,”.
While the argument will always be that this provision is implied, we would suggest referring to computer data, disc, tape, soundtrack or other device on which to store information.
I will refer to a new way to do something on the Internet that has developed in the past three or four years. Google is an example. Instead of having documents on a computer, there are Google documents, Google spreadsheets, etc. Google guarantees privacy and presents a server through which one can work. Microsoft will do likewise. For further consideration, I suggest that this way of storing records is not covered by the Bill. I am not certain it would be covered by our amendment. The records would not be stored on the premises. Before being passed by the other House, it would be worthwhile to examine a definition encompassing new ways of storing data without a physical record on the premises or in the possession of the owner. The material is probably stored on a Google server in California.
Comment on this
I will clarify the matter, but I am advised that section 63(a) at the bottom of page 41, which refers to “a disc, tape, sound-track or other device in which information, sounds or signals are embodied so as to be capable (with or without the aid of some other instrument) of being reproduced in legible or audible form”, covers computer data. I will check for the Senator.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 66 to 70, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 42, paragraph (a), line 15, after “medicinal” to insert “or veterinary medicinal”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:
In page 42, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:
"(c) any veterinary medicinal product;”.
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 71 to 73, inclusive, are related, they may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 44, subsection (3)(n), line 15, after “facilities” to insert the following:
"or courier facilities or other means of transportation".
I will not argue with the Minister on this one. I proposed this amendment to ensure that forms of delivery other than the traditional forms of delivery are identified in the definitions. However, the Minister has tabled an amendment that includes the words "other means of delivery", thereby covering the issue I intended to raise, so I will withdraw my amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 44, subsection (3)(n), line 20, to delete “mail.” and substitute the following:
"mail, courier or other means of delivery or transportation.".
I understand that people sometimes seal their mailboxes to avoid getting things that can only be delivered by mail. Therefore, it is important to provide for other methods of delivery. Who would have thought that people would be so wicked?
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 74 and 75 are related, they may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
This amendment has been tabled to provide that the authorised officer can choose to be accompanied by people with "expertise relating to the relevant thing". I am surprised that the phrase "relevant thing" is being used in legislation.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister about a thought that has just struck me. Perhaps I should have raised it earlier in the debate, but I will try to sneak it in now. When a pharmacy is closed down, do its patients or customers have the right to access the information on their records?
Comment on this
I have been informed that such circumstances will be covered in the regulations we will make under section 18. We will engage in consultation before we draw up such regulations.
Comment on this
I am a little puzzled. I was curious when I saw that section 64(10) states that "a statement or admission made by a person pursuant to a requirement under subsection (3)(e) shall not be admissible”. When I consulted section 64(3)(e), I found that it states that an authorised officer may “require any person at the premises or the owner or person in charge of the premises and any person employed there to give to him or her such assistance and information and to produce to him or her such books, records or other documents ..... as he or she may reasonably require”. What type of “statement or admission” would be likely to be made by a person under section 64(3)(e)? Is this provision being introduced to ensure that people are not compelled to incriminate themselves?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 45, subsection (1)(b), line 41, after “separate” to insert “suitable”.
I am sure the Minister will find it hard to believe, but I remember pathological specimens that failed because they had been placed in totally unsuitable containers. Evidence that would have been valuable, not necessarily in court cases, was lost. People sometimes have to be reminded to be sensible. Therefore, I have suggested that authorised officers be required to place each part of the specimen in "separate" and "suitable" containers.
Comment on this
I will return to the Senator's proposal on Report Stage after I have checked it with the Office of the Chief Parliamentary Counsel. Senator Henry has made a valid point. One might assume that the container would be suitable, but we should specify that it should be.
Comment on this
Having read section 66(1) a few times, I am not sure whether there is a drafting error. Perhaps my brain is too slow to understand what is intended. I refer to the part of the section that begins:
In any proceedings for an offence under this Act, a certificate in the form specified in Schedule 3 to this Act signed by—
(a) either—
(i) the State Chemist, or
(ii) another chemist employed or engaged at the State Laboratory and authorised by the State Chemist to sign the certificate,
(b) either—
(i) a public analyst appointed under section 10 of the Sale of Food and Drugs Act 1875, or
(ii) another analyst authorised by such a public analyst to sign the certificate,
I wonder whether the word "or" should be included before (b) above. As it stands, it could mean that the certificate would have to be signed by one of the people mentioned in (a) and one of the people mentioned in (b). I am not being awkward. It seems to me that this section, as it is written, could mean that the certificate would have to be signed by both a chemist and an analyst, whereas I believe they are alternates.
Comment on this
The word "or" is used later in the section.
Comment on this
I have been told by my officials that the "or" is implied, but we should make it clear.
Comment on this
That is what the Office of the Chief Parliamentary Counsel is for. The officials behind the Minister are wonderful, but the draftsman always says that these things are implied.
Comment on this
As amendments No. 78 and 79 are alternatives to amendment No. 77, and amendment No. 80 is related to amendment No. 77, amendments Nos. 77 to 80, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 81 to 83, inclusive, are related, they may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:
In page 48, subsection (3), line 16, after "director," to insert the following:
"shadow director as defined in section 27 of the Companies Act 1990,".
I did not know there was such a person as a "shadow director" until I was told about his or her existence. We need to ensure that such people are included in the Bill. I will not delay the House if the Minister agrees it would be a good idea to make this change.
Comment on this
This section outlines the penalties for all the offences under this legislation. It provides that they will all be subject to the same spectrum of penalties. Are we sure that all the offences that could be committed under this Bill are of equivalent gravity, or has this section been drafted in this way as a convenient catch-all device? I do not want to delay the House, although we are doing reasonably well for time. It seems strange to me that every offence under this legislation will attract a penalty from the same spectrum.
Comment on this
It is clear that there is a standard distinction between summary conviction and indictment. What is the Senator suggesting?
Comment on this
If the Deputy could give an example of something that does not warrant the penalty proposed for it, I would be happy to consider that point.
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 84 and 97 to 102, inclusive, are related, they may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I must say that I am sorry to see the end of "Poths Hall", which was part of our student days. We were never quite sure what "Poths Hall" was, but we knew it was there somewhere. It entertained us enormously, although we were never quite sure what it did. I suppose, therefore, there is a certain feeling of nostalgia about it.
Comment on this
I can remember it very well. I was one of those who took part, as a junior, in the last examinations for Poths Hall, after which a Chinese gentleman threatened to kill one of the examiners. It was a very colourful outfit and while I am sorry it is no more, the standing of medicine and pharmacy in Ireland is better because of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 85:
In page 48, line 35, to delete subsection (2).
The lawyer from whom I take advice on these matters is a man of delicate sensitivities. He suggests subsection (2) is unnecessary because repeals are announced in section 4 and further stated in Schedule 4.
Comment on this
I am sure he is wonderful but I am obliged to take the advice of the Attorney General. I will ask the Parliamentary Counsel to examine the matter.
Comment on this
I am not trying to be awkward but to be helpful. This deals with an amendment to the Poisons Act. Subsection (1), in referring to section 18 of that Act, reads:
A person who . . . keeps open shop for the sale of poisons commits an offence.
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply in relation to the keeping of open shop by a person of a class specified in regulations under section 14 who is keeping open shop in accordance with those regulations.
(3) This subsection is complied with if—
(a) the person referred to in subsection (1) is—
(i) a registered pharmacist,
(ii) a registered druggist,
(iii) the personal representative ...
(iv) the Official Assignee ... or
(v) is a corporate body ...
I suggest the word "or" should be included after the reference to a registered pharmacist, a registered druggist and following the words "was lawfully keeping open shop for the sale of poisons". I do not believe a person must meet all those conditions, rather he or she must meet only one of them.
Comment on this
This amendment seeks to clarify legally what the section applies to. It includes previous references in the current section 72 reference.
Comment on this
Subsection (1) reads, "A code of conduct having effect under sections. . . and regulations made under section . . . shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas . . .”. That is a great idea and I have no problem with it. Subsection (2) reads, “If a resolution annulling these regulations . . . ”. Codes of conduct are not regulations; they are codes of conduct approved by the Minister. That is all they are. I have no problem with them being made known and available to the Houses of the Oireachtas. That is a good idea, but I doubt if they are regulations under any meaning of legislation I have heard.
Comment on this
The Senator is right but subsection (1) reads, "A code of conduct having effect under sections . . . and regulations . . .”. It is those regulations to which we are referring.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 87:
In page 51, paragraph 2, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:
"(2) A disqualification pursuant to an order of a court referred to in subparagraph (1)(a), (c), (d), (e) or (f) shall not take effect until the ordinary time for appealing against any such order has expired, or if an appeal is lodged within that time, until any such appeal, or a further appeal therefrom is determined.”.
This relates to a disqualification from office of the council. It is standard practice that where a person has been convicted and appealed, he or she cannot be punished until the matter is resolved that he or she is worthy, if that is the right word, of being punished. This would be a significant punishment. Somebody in that position would be well advised to resign but we should not provide for a situation where somebody who has been penalised and then cleared on appeal is punished by being disqualified.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 89 is a Government amendment. Amendment No. 90 is related, while amendment No. 91 is a logical alternative to amendment No. 89. Amendments Nos. 89 to 91, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister has agreed to this because it is important that the profession has confidence in the council. The general public must have confidence but the profession must also have confidence in it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 92:
In page 54, paragraph 9, after line 44, to insert the following:
"(8) A disclosure under this paragraph or paragraph 10 shall be recorded in a register together with particulars of any interest of members of the Authority or persons to whom paragraph 10 applies, and the register shall be available to public inspection during office hours.”.
This amendment is to ensure the interests, if so recorded, would be a matter of public record. Where members disclose interests, they should be a matter of public record.
Comment on this
I am not certain that is necessary but it is a matter for the council to decide. Members are covered by ethics in public office legislation. The council must keep a record.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 94:
In page 56, paragraph 12(2), line 9, after "surplus" to insert the following:
"including any surplus following the disposal of its assets".
This is to ensure that when the society is wound up, if it has any funds from the sale of assets, they would not go into the great maw of the Department of Health and Children.
Comment on this
I am advised that we need an amendment in this regard. I will arrange for it to be made.
Comment on this
The purpose of this amendment is to make the Bill gender friendly and include the word "herself" after "himself".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 96:
In page 58, after line 42, to insert the following:
"Accountability to Houses of the Oireachtas
22. When required by a committee of either or both Houses of the Oireachtas, the President of the Society shall appear before the committee to account for the general administration of the Society.".
A body which has the level and scale of responsibilities that the society will have ought to have a formal accountability role to the Oireachtas. I am happy to leave discussion of the details for a longer consideration but essentially these bodies are set up under legislation. Therefore, there ought to be a process to ensure that when they work, they are clearly aware of their obligations under the legislation. This appears to be the most efficient way to do this. However, I will not be hung on the amendment because I do not want them to be summoned every second week to discuss the price of drugs but there should be at least an annual reporting to the appropriate Oireachtas committee, presumably the Joint Committee on Health and Children. That would be a useful exercise.
Comment on this
I will examine that matter. I would like to do it. Obviously, it relates to their administration functions, not inquiries and so on, which issues they cannot deal with. I will have a look at the amendment and take advice. I agree it would be good if we could make that happen.
Comment on this
On the situation regarding connected relatives, this goes even further than the ethics in public office connections. I do not think brother and sister are included or the spouse of a child of the person.
Comment on this
I thought they were not because I thought I remembered the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources, Deputy Noel Dempsey, saying he would be unable to check up on his ten brothers.
Comment on this
The Senator makes a valid point and I will consider it. Sometimes brothers and sisters do not talk to each other.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Noel Dempsey has plenty of brothers and I remember him making that comment.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 102 is in the name of Senator Henry. It has already been discussed with amendment No. 84.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 102:
In page 62, between lines 9 and 10, to insert the following:
"
8 Edw.7.,55 | Poisons and Pharmacy Act 1908 | The whole Act
".
The Government has agreed to this amendment.
Comment on this
I was advised an Act had been omitted and I am grateful to the Government for having agreed the amendment.
Comment on this
In view of what the Minister has said and she accepted a great deal of our concerns, it would be very difficult for her officials to study them now, would it be agreeable to accept the Bill to go forward in that way?
Comment on this
The Minister plans to make changes to the Bill in the Dáil and will she return to this House then?
Comment on this
Many reasonable and useful points were made in this House which informed me and maybe my officials on some issues. We will discuss the points over the next day and it will be necessary to return to this House with further amendments. If the Bill is amended in the Dáil, I intend to take up some of the issues I mentioned here today and we will have to come back here with the amendments.
Comment on this
I will agree to this arrangement but it is not the ideal way to do business. It is a bit presumptuous to have the Bill in the Dáil tomorrow in an incomplete form. The Minister is proposing changes to the Bill even before it goes before the Dáil.
Comment on this
I accept it is not ideal but there are constraints of time.
I thank the Members for a very constructive and informative Committee Stage debate today. It is clear that Members did a considerable amount of work in a short period of time. I was impressed and we had a good debate. There is clearly much interest from the pharmacy profession in this Bill which has been sought for many years. Due to time constraints I am unable to return at this stage with the amendments I have agreed to consider but I will do so in due course.
I thank the Leader of the House for facilitating all Stages of the Bill this week. I thank my officials who are a small group of people sitting behind me. They have been up all night finalising the amendments because I placed a very short timeframe on the work. It is normal to have a longer period of time between Second and Committee Stages but because of time considerations and events that will happen in the summer of this year, time was not available to us.
I also thank the two parliamentary draftsmen who have been involved with this legislation and who will be involved in considering some of the very good amendments put forward. We have already accepted a number of them and the Bill is the stronger for that.
I will check the issue of brother and sister to ensure we are reasonable in what we do.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister and her officials. We support the Bill in general and we welcome the fitness to practise aspect of the Bill which we hope will ensure patient safety. Fine Gael is very keen to have a patient safety authority to cover all areas of medicine as there is a need for such a body. I do not envy the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland because it will have a lot of work to do when it is reformed and the legislation is somewhat vague in some areas. It will be its responsibility to decide on rules and codes of conduct. Pharmacies have changed in many ways and this Bill will enable them to change further and to meet the needs of patients. It is important that we follow the New Zealand and Northern Ireland example where pharmacies dispense drugs but will also ensure the patient is taking medication correctly.
I repeat my call that the pharmacists from the South would be permitted to work in the North and this is an issue which the Minister could take up with her European and Northern Ireland counterparts. The biggest threat we face is the growing sale of drugs on the Internet to which there is no easy solution but we must redouble our efforts.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister and her officials and the Members on all sides of the House who have contributed in a positive way to bringing forward this legislation which consigns the previous older legislation. I commend the IPU and the IPS and the hospital pharmacists, who are often forgotten, on their input. They have made a very positive contribution and lobbied in a realistic and responsible manner. I accept what the Minister has said. She has been forthcoming and accommodating.
When the Bill passes into law, the pharmaceutical profession and the general public will be the beneficiaries. I welcome what has been done. I am looking forward to seeing the Bill back in the House to endorse the amendments made.
Comment on this
This is a much needed Bill. I hope that when it is passed, it will last for 30 years. With the changes in pharmacy, we need something on which we can rely. It is a pity everything had to be rushed. We could have had a great time for weeks, just like when we dealt with the Bill relating to the Veterinary Council when we had really good sessions.
There is much interest in the House in legislation such as this. I am very grateful to the Irish Pharmaceutical Union, the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland, hospital pharmacists and individuals who all provided us with support and information. I look forward to seeing the Bill back in the House. I am sure the Minister will address all of our concerns when she brings it before the Dáil.
Comment on this
I compliment the Minister and her officials on bringing the Bill before the House. It was a long time coming, but the Minister made a commitment which has been honoured. The Bill is for the betterment of the profession and patients. The pharmaceutical profession and society can now move forward. The profession has been recognised as an integral part of the health service. Pharmacists can enter the profession and deal with patients on a sound legislative footing. I thank Members for their contributions and look forward to the early passage of the Bill in the Dáil before it is brought back before this House.
Comment on this
The Minister deserves compliments. This is a good Bill which is dreadfully overdue. It takes political will and clout to get the job done. There is limited political kudos for either the Minister or the Opposition in dealing with a Bill such as this. It is not the stuff that persuades the colourful writers in the Sunday newspapers to talk about it. If they do, they will state we spent a lot of time talking about it and will think that funny too.
It was a worthwhile debate. I thank the Leader of the House for allocating extra time which enabled us to go take Committee Stage in a reasonably civilised fashion. I thank the Minister for her responsiveness to the various amendments tabled by this side of the House. It was a positive engagement, as it usually is when the Minister comes before the House.
I compliment the representatives of the pharmaceutical profession who have shown a capacity to respond to rapidly changing events, given that the Bill and the amendments to it were quickly produced. I also thank them for their maturity. There is a campaign which suggests that a lay majority on a regulatory body marks the end of civilisation as we know it. It does not. It is one way of winning over the public to the belief that a self-regulating profession is also accountable to it and that it is there to serve it, not the self-interest of the profession. I hope other bodies will begin to listen and learn that a lay majority does not pose a threat, but is a way of advancing the cause of a profession.
I compliment the Minister and I look forward to seeing the long list of amendments that Dáil Éireann will have to deal with because of the diligence of Seanad Éireann.
Comment on this
I commend the Minister. It is always a pleasure to have her in the House. She gives of herself and engages with Senators. This is a fine Bill and the pharmaceutical profession will be well served by it. It is historic because it took so long to be brought forward, but the Minister did it, for which I congratulate her. We have been sitting after the Dáil adjourned. This is a legislative Chamber in which Bills are subject to great scrutiny. The Bill was subjected to terrific scrutiny, but the Dáil adjourned three hours ago.