We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Wildlife (Amendment) Bill 2010: Committee Stage

Contributions 1–129 of 262. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Wildlife (Amendment) Bill 2010
Enacted

No. 15 of 2010 ›

I welcome the belated arrival of the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government.

Comment on this
John Gormley Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government Green Party

I was detained in the other House.

Comment on this

I understand that, as I was watching the Minister performing there. I also understand that he was coursing through the halls of Leinster House to reach this Chamber to follow through. He has been very busy with his animal welfare legislation in recent days.

Comment on this

Yes. I also have been busy with the Planning and Development (Amendment) Bill and the Civil Partnership Bill.

Comment on this

That is correct——

Comment on this
Pat Moylan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

On section 3, please.

Comment on this

—— but the animal welfare legislation is high on the Minister's priorities and he has been busy in this regard. Obviously, the Minister has been late out of the traps in respect of much of this legislation. I understand the Dog Breeding Establishments Bill was held up for two or three months while Government Deputies and Senators wrestled with their consciences and much has been heard on that as well. As has been discussed at length on Second Stage here, as well as in the other House, Fine Gael opposes this Bill because it considers it to be the thin end of the wedge, to use a phrase that has been repeated so often. While the Minister may dismiss this as much as he wishes, can he put on the record of the House today a reassurance——

Comment on this

Can the Minister reassure the House——

Comment on this

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

—— that in his tenure as the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, he will not bring forth any legislation that will affect the hunting of foxes, coursing or any other shooting or hunting pursuits that are traditional in Ireland? Can he give a categorical assurance today that this will be an end to it? Serious concern exists in this regard and while I will not engage in a slagging match, because that does not achieve anything, the Minister and others have made allegations against the RISE! campaign. I have made clear in this Chamber that it was a properly organised lobby that engaged with all the stakeholders in rural Ireland, including those involved in the Ward Union Hunt, fox hunting, shooting, beagle hunting or whatever. The campaign engaged with those stakeholders, which is as it should be. All stakeholders should engage in a debate when new legislation is proposed that will have obvious consequences and impacts on their activities. This is all the RISE! campaign did and I do not see anything wrong with it. Consequently, that group should not be criticised for so doing.

As for the section under discussion, it proposes a prohibition on hunting deer with dogs. There is a contradiction in this Bill. I have heard the Minister and others speaking on radio and elsewhere to the effect that this is not only an animal welfare issue but a safety issue. This would be fine, were it not for a contradiction whereby the Bill allows for the hunting of deer with dogs by people on foot. I also consider that activity to be fine and the Minister allows for it. A deer being hunted by deer stalkers and which goes out on to the road is still a safety issue. One is not improving safety, per se, by introducing the legislation. In sport there are many safety implications for those directly involved and spectators and the public. A most unfortunate incident occurred in Donegal during a car rally. I do not use that example to attack the Minister. The response was not to ban the sport but to increase the safety regulations and monitoring. That is one example but I could give many others. If, as the Minister outlined previously, there are genuine concerns about safety, surely he could consider ways to enhance the safety and regulation of the Ward Union Hunt? Great strides have been made in that area in recent years and the hunt is subject to licence. The Minister has the power to ensure the enforcement of safety regulations.

I will not go over the entire animal welfare debate but the Minister has used the example of a deer jumping a ditch into a school yard. That is the one example we hear about all the time but not many other examples are given. If the Minister wishes to provide other examples, I would welcome that, but I do not believe there are many others. As is the case with car rallying, the one or two high profile cases constantly appear in the media. That is because the Minister is trying to put a spin on the issue to secure support for his position. We must take a fair and reasoned approach.

The Ward Union Hunt has been a responsible organisation in carrying out its pursuits and activities. It has always complied with regulations and the licensing conditions put on it. Much of its resources and those of the State were used to ensure it carried out its activities in a proper way. This seems to be an attempt by the Minister's party, which is a niche party that has high priorities and different policies, to get the legislation through. The Minister will hold up this legislation as a trophy to his members because that is how the party operates.

I am disappointed with the Fianna Fáil Members who support this Bill. The people that elected Fianna Fáil to be the largest party in the local authorities, although they are not any longer, and who elected them to be the largest party in the Dáil and in the Seanad are the people on whom it is turning its back. Fianna Fáil Members know I am being reasonable when I say this and moreover they are getting that sense from those who were lobbying them and the councillors and so on who have been in touch with them. Local authorities, including Fianna Fáil councillors, around the country are passing resolutions opposing the animal welfare legislation, yet when it comes to the national Parliament the party's representatives are doing the opposite.

I note that the Minister makes provision for deerstalkers to hunt on foot. Deerstalkers were concerned up to a very late stage on the Bill. Will the Minister outline the process of consultation with them? I accept they have been facilitated and that they will be allowed to continue their pursuit but I wonder why they were not consulted at an earlier stage given the implications the Bill would have had prior to the Minister bringing forward an amendment.

We oppose the section because we oppose the Bill. I do not wish to engage in a slagging match with the Minister but I am interested in hearing his views on the points I have raised.

Comment on this

I support the section because I support the Bill. I note Senator Coffey has employed a slightly more nuanced position with the reference to car rallying and health and safety. However, that gets away from the core focus which is animal welfare. I put on record the other day an account of a stag hunt in County Down on which the BBC reported in 2005.

Comment on this

That is a different jurisdiction.

Comment on this

The journalist presented a clear-eyed and vivid account of the animal welfare issues, the fact that the quarry of the stag was predicated on the stag running until exhausted and terrified. For me, animal welfare is the core issue. Nothing can distract from that. When there are adequate alternatives to pursuing live quarry, for instance, a drag hunt that in essence retains the activity, the exercise, the relationship between the horse and rider, access to the countryside and a range of other positive benefits that come from equine and country pursuits in general, I do not see why that option cannot be viewed by rational people as a decent alternative.

I took the trouble in recent days to look at various hunt websites in the United Kingdom in particular and in Northern Ireland to see whether the banning of hunting with packs of dogs following the 2004 Act closed down or compromised the economic value of the presence of a hunt in an area. I could find no such evidence. On the contrary, I found evidence of thriving hunt clubs not pursuing live animals but involved in a range of activities, including drag hunting and other diversification that is the lifeblood of any business. We must look at hunting in business terms too. Diversifying with the changing times is a critical element in any business model. It is one the Ward Union Hunt could usefully employ in this instance. I do not accept the notion therefore that this is the death knell of the Ward Union Hunt or that it will, necessarily, lead to the kind of job losses that have been spoken about. The evidence is contrary to that. With a bit of imagination and acceptance that this is an animal welfare issue with which we need to deal and that there is life beyond it, there is plenty of scope for the hunt to continue to thrive in a way that does not terrify and potentially injure or kill live quarry.

Comment on this

I have a simple question to ask before the Minister replies. I raised the point on Second Stage. Approximately 80 or 90 deer are killed in the Phoenix Park and in Muckross in the Killarney National Park every year. I would classify that as an animal welfare issue as well. Is it the intention of the Minister that in addition to dogs and everything else that he would ban vehicles in the Phoenix Park and the Killarney National Park because 100 more deer are killed per year on the roads in the national parks than were killed over many years in the Ward Union Hunt? The Minister should consider that to be an animal welfare issue as well.

Comment on this

The Minister is welcome. I have one point to make on the Bill, which is the point made by Senator Coffey. I declare an interest, as I did on Second Stage, in that I was a member of the Ward Union Hunt for many years. I am probably the only Member in that category. I found the members of the Ward Union Hunt to be very interested in animal welfare. They looked after the animals very well, both the hounds and the stags which they took out regularly. My one point is the same as that raised by Senator Coffey, whether it is possible that this is the thin end of the wedge.

One of the other sports in which I took pleasure was fishing. It seems to me that if animal welfare is a concern then one would have to include fishing. These are the types of steps about which people are concerned. Whatever about the Ward Union Hunt and the hunting of stags and deer, if we believe animal welfare is a concern then many other practices could be regarded as unacceptable. I wonder whether enough consideration was given to the fact that sometimes those who live in a city do not understand rural activities. Is it possible that we might have considered that each of those decisions could have been made at county council level? In other words, before one could hunt in counties Meath or Dublin, one would have to obtain permission to do so in those counties. It is quite likely that a decision in this regard would have enabled those who live in the country to make decisions about the country and those who live in the city to make decisions about the city.

With regard to animal welfare topics, one will find very often that those who live closer to the animals are very much aware of the need to look after them well. On that basis, the concerns that most Senators, including Senator Coffey, are expressing refer to the thin end of the wedge. Can the Minister assure us this is as far as he sees legislation in this area going?

Comment on this

I concur with most of what Senator Quinn said. I respect Senator Dearey's view, which he made quite cogently. We all need to respect each other's views. However, one could apply Senator Dearey's words on the Ward Union Hunt to fox hunting and coursing. This is the reason for our concern over the thin end of the wedge.

As we all know, the Green Party's stated policy is against fox hunting and coursing. This emphasises our concern. As an Opposition party that does not agree with the Green Party's point of view, Fine Gael is quite entitled to express its opinion as forcefully as it can without entering into a slagging match. Let us base our remarks on reasonable argument.

Senator Quinn made some very good points on how country people, be they farmers or chicken ranchers, feel about their animals. Animal husbandry is accorded very high priority by country people. One need only look at how farmers rear cattle, sheep and even deer. They look after them, they walk the fields and know them intimately. They know if an animal is sick just by looking at it. The Ward Union Hunt applies the same standard of husbandry to the rearing of the deer it hunts.

I have never hunted. I was never on horseback hunting but can understand why people would like to do so. I understand the hunters in the Ward Union Hunt rarely see the deer because it is so far ahead. It may be highly excited and scared, as any animal would be in the open countryside. Wildlife itself is very cruel. If a fox catches a rabbit in a field, the rabbit is scared and is literally torn asunder. However, we do not interfere with that; it is nature taking its course.

To return to the basic argument many of us have tried to make, based on ancient times and legend, man, as the priority being and species, has a basic instinct to hunt. We are trying to interfere with nature to a large degree. We can go into this debate as deeply as we want but we must realise that country people really understand what I am saying because they have been born and reared in this ethos and with this understanding. City people do not have the same understanding of the matter.

I am not trying to create an urban-rural divide in the debate but contend there must be understanding, and that nature itself is cruel. The Ward Union Hunt, however, is not cruel. Its animal husbandry is of the highest level, and it has conservation schemes in place for the deer it rears and hunts.

What will happen to the deer the Ward Union Hunt has in stock if this legislation is passed? Will they be put on show somewhere? Will they put into a zoo? The Green Party opposes zoos also.

Comment on this

That is ridiculous.

Comment on this

It does oppose zoos.

Comment on this

The Senator should read our policies.

Comment on this

I read out the Green Party's policy.

Comment on this

It opposes circuses; let us be honest about that.

Zoos are probably the places where young children are educated most about animals and where they see them at first hand.

Comment on this

I was there a month ago with my daughter.

Comment on this

I am only making my point and am entitled to do so.

Comment on this

The Senator is not allowed to misrepresent our party.

Comment on this
Pat Moylan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Senators will have an opportunity to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Senator Coffey had two opportunities.

Comment on this
Pat Moylan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am entitled to call any Member more than once and I expressed that clearly. The Chair is entitled to call a speaker a number of times on Committee Stage.

Comment on this

I accept the Cathaoirleach's point.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator and the Cathaoirleach.

This debate can be reasonable. Let us hear from both sides. I am putting the case clearly that what the Ward Union Hunt does is not a matter of animal welfare. While the deer is scared, the objective of the hunt is not to kill it. It is very rare that an animal is killed and, if it is, it is by accident in most cases. I still have not heard of such cases other than the high-profile case that has been in the media.

Senator Dearey has outlined what he picked up on the website based on events in County Down, Britain and other jurisdictions but we have not heard of examples in this State, except for the one high profile example, of where the Ward Union Hunt has been out of bounds or out of order.

With proper regulation and monitoring and with the co-operation of the Ward Union Hunt and all interested stakeholders, the Ward Union Hunt could continue to hunt in a very organised and fair fashion in the best interest of animal welfare and with a view to protecting the rural heritage that has always existed. I am interested in hearing the Minister's points on the matters I have raised.

Comment on this

As a member of the Green Party, which was referred to in this debate, I believe it is unfortunate that our policy is constantly misrepresented. It is unfortunate that the items in the programme for Government are constantly misrepresented.

I keep hearing about the thin end of wedge when in fact this is the thick end of the wedge. Anybody who has read the programme for Government will realise that this Bill, the Dog Breeding Establishments Bill and the fur farming Bill are the three Bills on animal welfare therein. There are no others.

With regard to fishing, Senator Quinn should note the Green Party's issue concerns hunting with hounds specifically. I certainly have never come across hunting fish with hounds. Nobody is suggesting the Green Party is against fishing. It is not in our policy and will not be, nor are we debating it because we are not interested in opposing fishing on the banks of our rivers. It has nothing to do with this Bill.

Senator Coffey is wrong in respect of there being one high profile incident. He obviously did not hear "Liveline" some days ago.

Comment on this

We are legislating according to "Liveline" now.

Comment on this

Many people outlined on the radio show incidents that happened in north County Dublin, which is now a suburban area. It is 150 years since the British army officers, not Cú Chulainn, formed the Ward Union Hunt. The hunt is not an Irish tradition.

Comment on this

Senator Coffey says hunting is a great Irish tradition. While hunting is an Irish tradition, I was amused and amazed at the various views of Senators this morning on the raucous behaviour of people outside the gates of Leinster House. The Senators were acting in a very patrician and civilised manner in saying raucous behaviour outside the gates was unacceptable. I totally agree. The reality is that we are now living in a civilised society. Senators are not going out with spears trying to catch their dinner. We have a nice canteen downstairs and a farming industry.

Comment on this

The deer is on your plate.

Comment on this

Fortunately we live in a more civilised society than people did in the time of Cú Chulainn. If Cú Chulainn, who was probably a great man, were to come in here, the gae bolga and other weapons he used would not be acceptable in this Chamber. We have moved on a bit since those days.

Comment on this

The Senator is missing the point.

Comment on this

To say everybody in rural areas is out hunting for his dinner is a misrepresentation of rural Ireland. I grew up in rural Ireland and really did not see guys out with spears wearing whatever they wore in hunts in days of old. We have moved on and we are a civilised society.

There is no question but that cruelty to animals is an important issue for the Green Party. I have been looking for Fine Gael's policy on animal welfare but cannot find it. Where is it? The Fine Gael Senators are very quick to criticise us.

If we are to have decent debates in this Chamber, it is incumbent on all parties to think about the very serious and real measures that are being introduced and which have the backing of the people rather than just criticising.

Comment on this

They have the backing of the Irish people all right.

Comment on this

We have a bigger mandate that the Green Party.

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the mandate of the Green Party.

Comment on this

Two per cent is quite a mandate.

Comment on this

It concerns the fact that public opinion has shown consistently that the hunt is opposed by the majority of the people.

Comment on this

Is this the public opinion poll that showed support for the Government? It is three years old.

Comment on this

In light of public opinion, it is only right and proper that the Minister has progressed this legislation. Fine Gael does not seem to be listening to the public but to a small group of well funded protestors. We are not sure from where the money is coming in some cases. A figure of €100,000 was mentioned for the RISE! campaign.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

I would like to know from where it is getting all of its funding.

Comment on this

Why does the Senator not ask it?

Comment on this

I did, but I have not received an answer.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Ó Brolcháin to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

He should meet RISE! and ask it.

Comment on this

Let us find out. We could go all over the place in this debate——

Comment on this

We surely have.

Comment on this

——but the reality is that the measure being introduced by the Minister is a simple one. I assure Senator Quinn that this is not the thin edge of the wedge in respect of fishing. I am sure the Minister will say likewise. There are three items in the programme for Government. This is an important one, but the matter has been blown out of all proportion. Some parties opposite are doing the people a disservice in spending so much time on this issue when they should be spending time on economic matters.

Comment on this

The Government orders business.

Comment on this

I primarily seek assurance from the Minister in the light of the ongoing debate in the Houses and nationally. I come from Drumshanbo, County Leitrim and live in what is known as the Leitrim lakeland region where outdoor pursuits have been engaged in for generations. We have relied heavily on pursuits such as gaming — many of my friends and neighbours are members of gun clubs — and coarse fishing.

I am sure the Minister, for whom I have the height of respect, will agree that in politics perception is everything. On this basis, while it may seem that this is a given, will he take the opportunity to highlight the fact that the Green Party's agenda in government is not to introduce legislation that will adversely affect outdoor pursuits? Not for one moment have I believed he is set on this agenda, but repeating this is important. Elements of this legislation are unpalatable to my colleagues in the parliamentary party, but we are loyal to our coalition partners. The safety of some Members who went through the lobbies in the Lower House was under threat and their families were being intimidated.

Comment on this

They are living in the heart of the area in question, but they believe in a higher duty. They were elected under the banner of the Fianna Fáil Party, took the party Whip and accepted what the Taoiseach, the leader of our party, had negotiated in good faith last autumn with his Cabinet colleagues in the renewed programme for Government. We can be accused of a lot, but we can never be accused of being disloyal or dishonourable in our dealings with any parliamentary party with which we have entered government.

Comment on this

Ask the Progressive Democrats.

Comment on this

Like many of those living near me, I am concerned. I have heard the same argument made on the other side of the House. When Senator Coffey and others enter government, they will face similar situations and wrestle with their consciences on issues agreed with their coalition partners. They will not like it, but they will have their day.

Comment on this

We will be well able for it.

Comment on this

It is ten years away.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mooney to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

The people involved in RISE! have not been the most helpful, certainly from a Fianna Fáil perspective, in raising the temperature across the country, but they are decent and honourable.

Comment on this

I am not sure about that.

Comment on this

Many around the country who engage in outdoor activities such as gaming and fishing are not members of RISE! or associated with it in any way. However, they and people within my party have a great deal of sympathy for the organisation. I am sure the same could be said of people in Fine Gael and other parties.

This is an important opportunity for the Green Party and, in particular, the Minister who is guiding the legislation through the House and which we are supporting as part of the programme for Government. We will honour our commitments in this House, as we did in the Lower House because more important issues must be addressed before the end of our term in office in 2012. Among other priorities, an economic challenge lies ahead——

Comment on this

——but this is a priority for the Green Party. As such, it included it in the programme for Government. In a spirit of compromise, which is what coalition government is about, we accept the Green Party's policy in this respect. In turn, it is accepting elements of our agenda. We are partners in government and nothing that will be stated on this side of the House will sunder that relationship before our mandate runs out.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Whip has lost one Deputy already.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to reassure the good, honourable and decent people of rural Ireland that just because he represents the leafy suburbs of Dublin 4 he is not in any way out of touch or lacking in empathy, sympathy and understanding of the importance of outdoor pursuits among the majority.

Comment on this

He must not have been to County Leitrim.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Has Senator Wilson indicated?

Comment on this

He is a heckler.

Comment on this

Fine Gael has its own.

Comment on this

I seek the Chair's protection from Senator Wilson.

Senator Mooney struck the nail on the head when he referred to this as being one of the Green Party's priorities in government. While I like Senator Ó Brolcháin, he is deluded on this issue. He keeps peddling the line that we should not be having this debate and that it is the Opposition's fault that we are spending so much time in discussing the issue. The Government orders business in this and the Lower House. The Green Party, as Senator Mooney outlined, wants to ensure this legislation is pushed through. That is the reason we are having this debate. Senator Mooney should spend more time speaking to people in rural Ireland if he believes they view the Minister, with all due respect to him, as having the interests of rural Ireland at heart. He should speak to councillors in County Leitrim about the planning and development Bill recently passed by the Lower House. They will tell a different story about the Minister's interest in protecting rural Ireland and its communities.

The proposed ban on stag hunting is the thin edge of the wedge because the Minister has already stated as much, given his comment on returning in the autumn with another animal welfare Bill. There will be further animal welfare legislation.

Comment on this

On fur farming.

Comment on this

It is included in the programme for Government.

Comment on this

Senator Quinn was right to raise the question, since the Minister has committed to making further changes. Obviously, the Government will introduce something else. It is committed to doing so, although I do not know what exactly it will do.

I am not hung up on the issue of stag hunting per se, but I am opposed to the idea of a small group inflicting their personal views on everyone else in respect of a traditional activity that has been carried on for many years in rural Ireland.

Comment on this

The Senator is discussing Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Even on its worst day, Fine Gael never represented less than one quarter of the population.

Comment on this

This legislation does not even have the entire support of the Green Party, only that of an internal clique. The genesis was not the renewed programme for Government but the NAMA legislation which the Green Party needed to pass at a specially convened conference. To get that legislation through, a former Green Party councillor went on the national airwaves to explain that certain animal welfare provisions would need to be included in the programme for Government. As Fianna Fáil needed to look after its friends in Anglo Irish Bank and seek other financial solutions, it allowed the Green Party its trophy legislation on stag hunting. That is the bare-faced——

Comment on this

The Senator is telling fairy stories.

Comment on this

Absolute fantasy.

Comment on this

That is the politics of the situation.

Comment on this

The Senator is good with fairy stories.

Comment on this

No, I will leave Cúchulainn and the Fianna to Senator Ó Brolcháin.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Phelan to continue without interruption. We are dealing with section 3. This discussion is not relevant to the Bill.

Comment on this

Section 3 is the core of the Bill. It deals with the ban on——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator should speak to the section.

Comment on this

I am dealing with section 3 and the root from which it comes is the decision of Members of the Government to have a cosy relationship between themselves. One part of the Government wants to help their developer friends, while the other wants to consolidate the most extreme element of support it has. My problem is that the people in the Green Party who propose legislation on animal rights have a far-reaching agenda when it comes to other activities in rural Ireland. I am not just talking about fox hunting, fishing, coursing or any of the blood sports, but rather about farming, agricultural practices. I am talking about people who do not want dairy farming, as we know it, to continue.

Comment on this

I am talking about a member of the Green Party. She was at its conference in Waterford when the RISE! protest was taking place outside.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We need to stick to section 3.

Comment on this

This is getting into the realms of fantasy.

Comment on this

I am on section 3.

Comment on this

Will we get the GAA as well?

Comment on this

I have nothing to do with the GAA at all.

Comment on this

What is the Senator against? Is he against motherhood?

Comment on this

No, the Green Party is against the people of rural Ireland.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Phelan, without interruption, and stick to section 3.

Comment on this

This is ridiculous, a Leas-Chathaoirligh, please.

Comment on this

I am finished, so if Senator Ó Brolcháin wishes to speak again, he will get his opportunity, I am sure.

Comment on this

Like Senator Mooney, I am a countryman living in a town, I know many decent people who have been and are involved in the RISE! campaign, and I have spoken to quite a number of them. I support this section, and the Bill, for the reasons stated by my colleague, Senator Mooney. There is a great deal of misinformation about this, no question, and this is mischievous to a large extent. This is in the programme for Government. Whether people like it or not, coalition is about partnership and an agreed agenda.

I am disappointed that Senator Phelan has referred to developers. I have always been a strong supporter of private enterprise, and I do not apologise to anybody for that. We are very pleased to have entrepreneurs in this Chamber such as Senator Quinn, who had the capacity and guts to take a chance in business and make it work. Where would we be without people such as that? Long may we have them.

Comment on this

Nobody is challenging that. Hear, hear to developers from the Green Party.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Glynn, please, without interruption.

Comment on this

Do not draw red herrings across the trail. It had nothing to do with this ——

Comment on this

I like Senator Quinn's stores. They are great stores.

Comment on this

Whether they like me saying it or not, people are being purely political. As Senator Mooney said, it is in the programme for Government. The Green Party as a participant party in Government is entitled to have legislation, as it sees fit. Being in Government is not about doing everything that one likes to do. People in business such as Senator Quinn and others in this Chamber have to take imperative managerial decisions, which they may not like doing, all the time, in the interests of good practice and good business.

Comment on this

Is this on section 3?

Comment on this

Yes, and whatever my views, I support it and this Bill, for the reasons stated. We have many issues to deal with. Our fish stocks are being decimated by mink.

Comment on this

Is this section 3?

Comment on this

I am talking about the whole concept of wildlife——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I do not believe any part of the debate has been on section 3.

Comment on this

Some people on the far side of the House never got as far as using the verb, so they make no sense.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

There will be no "Second Stage" speeches.

Comment on this

I will support this section and the Bill for the reasons eloquently stated by Senator Mooney.

Comment on this

I listened earlier to Senator Coffey and he made a few points on which I will elaborate. I respect the Minister and I take the point that we are in partnership. Whether the partnership is government or business, people have to work together. That is given. The place is in bits economically, there is high unemployment and here we are talking about stag hunting. I have asked whether a stag was ever ill treated or if cruelty was ever involved, and the answer I got was "No". There are more important issues we should consider.

In my constituency and throughout Dublin, as the Minister is aware — and we should concentrate on this rather than on the activities of rural people — there are hundreds of donkeys, ponies, dogs and cats that have to be put down week by week, since cruelty is widespread. Some dead animals are dumped in fields along roads, and nothing is being done about this. That is a valid point to make.

Could one say that greyhound racing is cruelty, or horse racing? The public perception, as I know from speaking to people, is to the effect, "Where is this going to end?" I am involved in setting up a fishing club at the moment. Is fishing going to be banned? Would that be regarded as cruelty? Senator Glynn, I believe, alluded to the largescale netting of fish throughout the country, destroying our tourism, and not a thing is being done about it. Stag hunting is not doing harm to anybody, and no one has been killed as a result. No child has been killed or injured despite the exaggeration as regards a stag running into a schoolyard, which was held to be a disaster. It was no such thing. I would like the Minister to confirm whether there is anything else in the pipeline in relation to country pursuits that are to be banned. That is the fear of the general public, and mine.

I know it is part of the programme for Government and there is a perception — although I cannot verify it — that this is being done to placate and satisfy a number of people within the Green Party who are not really representative of the general public.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister might like to reply to the "Second Stage" debates.

Comment on this

It was a "Second Stage" debate, with enormous latitude being given and that is the Leas-Chathaoirleach's choice. When people talk about wanting to get on to the main issues, however, I do not know why we stray and talk at length in a Second Stage manner, when we are supposed to address specific amendments.

There are major issues to be discussed. As far as I am concerned this is relatively minor legislation which can be got through very quickly. The Green Party is not making a big issue of this but rather Members of the Opposition who see this as a wonderful opportunity to have a go at the Green Party. People in the Labour Party, who are not here this afternoon, have done a complete U-turn because they see this as an opportunity, so it is blatant opportunism.

I have been asked by several speakers to clarify the position. I do not know why they are doing this because they know the position only too well. When people talk about "perception", why do they feed into that by even asking the question? Why do they do that when they know only too well that this is a small item of legislation dealing with one particular hunt, in County Meath? It has nothing to do with shooting, angling or anything else.

I grew up on the banks of the Shannon. When I was a kid I fished for perch, bream and eels, and as regards coarse fishing, I even caught a few pike in my time. Forget about this because there are very many people in my party who are involved in shooting and angling.

What I am trying to do as Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government and as a Green Party Member is to protect our habitats, ensure clean waters so fish can thrive and protect dwindling eel stocks.

However, politics enters into all of this. Senator Coffey can have his field day because no matter what I say here today he will still go to the public meeting in his constituency and put it out that this Bill is the thin end of the wedge.

Comment on this

It is the Minister's policy to ban all field sports.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister without interruption.

Comment on this

There we go again.

Comment on this

Is the Minister denying his policy?

Comment on this

I have just stated what the Bill is about and we have this and Senator Coffey's colleague's claims about zoos.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Coffey, allow the Minister without interruption.

Comment on this

Senator Coffey is smiling across there and saying this is great sport. Grand, but it is not the truth.

Comment on this