Wildlife (Amendment) Bill 2010: Committee Stage
Contributions 130–262 of 262. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 2010 ›
It is in the Green Party's policy documents.
Comment on this
Can Senator Coffey show it to us?
Comment on this
Reflecting on this in recent days, I have concluded the power of propaganda is amazing.
Comment on this
It always starts with the big lie.
Comment on this
One does not tell a porky, one tells the whopper — the big lie. One only has to go back to recent history to know who were the most successful propagandists.
Comment on this
Propaganda is a type of hypnotism.
Comment on this
I have seen it out there because they are immersed in this idea. The thing about hypnotism is that one must want to be hypnotised and want to believe it. People want to believe this nonsense. One can pick on the small parties and claim it is all their fault, which is too convenient by far.
It is slightly disillusioning when one thinks politics should be about rational debate on specific polices, not about the irrational. We talk about the human and animal species. Unfortunately, human beings are not always given to rational thought. Sometimes they want to believe in the propaganda put out by the other side.
Comment on this
What about the propaganda put out by the Minister's side? There are those on the Government side saying what we are saying.
Comment on this
Senator Coffey used an analogy of a motor rally in County Donegal. If a Minister had to give a licence for that rally and a serious accident occurred on it, I have no doubt the Minister would be held responsible, have to answer questions in the Dáil on it and calls would be made by the Opposition for his resignation.
Similarly with the Ward Union Hunt, which is licensed by the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, there are real difficulties around the issue of accidents. Senator Coffey referred to two incidents involving safety. As Senator Ó Brolcháin said, many more people in the area will recount incidents in which a stag came over a hedge into oncoming traffic and it was a close call.
Comment on this
The point is that it is not a licensed activity. The area covered by the Ward Union Hunt used to be in the heart of the countryside but is now a built-up area. It was over-zoned and, if Senators wish, I can go into all of the planning issues involved. I must also say the planning Bill referred to by Senator Coffey was progressive. He then brought in extraneous matters such as Anglo Irish Bank. I remind him it was his party and the Labour Party that appointed Mr. Lar Bradshaw of Anglo Irish Bank to the board of the Dublin Docklands Development Authority. The Greens had nothing to do with that.
Comment on this
The Minister should not even go there about the Dublin Docklands Development Authority.
Comment on this
The Minister should not start digging another hole.
Comment on this
The Minister better put the shovel away and stop digging.
Comment on this
Now that I have answered these questions, I will turn to section 3, the prohibition of deer hunting with dogs.
Section 3(1) redefines "deer" for the purposes of the legislation so that the term includes any deer which is not a wild animal. This expanded definition of deer has been incorporated into the Bill to ensure there is no argument and that the hunting of captive bred deer might not require a licence under the wildlife Acts. It must be remembered the deer used in the Ward Union Hunt is a domesticated animal. Would the Senators opposite like to see their pets hunted in that way? I do not believe they would.
Comment on this
No one spoke about someone's pets being hunted.
Comment on this
The Minister is using propaganda now.
Comment on this
What nonsense? Who is hunting pets? These are not pets we are talking about.
Comment on this
The Attorney General's advice in September 2007 was to the effect that section 26(1) of the Wildlife Act applied to all deer whether wild or domesticated. This advice was similar to the previous advice given by the Attorney General in February 1999.
Comment on this
Did the Minister listen to the Attorney General's advice on the Poolbeg incinerator?
Comment on this
In section 3(3) I have included a provision to ensure licensed deer stalkers may continue to use dogs where appropriate.
Comment on this
It is not unusual for a deer stalker to bring a dog out while hunting deer. In cases where several hunters were stalking deer on a property and each had a dog or if they were bringing two dogs for training purposes, it could be construed they were somehow breaking the law based on the original wording. It was never my intention that the Bill should place any restriction on lawful deer stalking.
Accordingly, the provision provides that it would not be an offence for people on foot stalking deer and with a deer licence under section 29 of the Wildlife Act or with permission under section 32 to have two or more dogs. More than 4,000 such licences were issued by my Department in the 2009-2010 season. The open season for most deer species extends from 1 September to the end of February. However, there is a 12-month hunting season for Muntjac deer as they are considered an invasive species which can cause much damage if allowed to spread.
Again, this gives the lie to this idea that we will stop shooting. I have given out more licences than any other previous Minister. I understand the necessity of doing this because of the number of deer causing destruction to habitat. I already said this in the Dáil. However, it will not be told out there because it is convenient to say the Greens want to stop all of this. That is arrant nonsense.
Section 42 permissions are issued outside of the open season and offer a facility whereby a person can obtain permission on a case-by-case basis to take action against a protected species including deer which can include the scaring, capturing or killing of the said species where serious damage is being caused to agricultural crops, forestry, and so on. There may be occasion when it may be necessary to bring dogs to assist moving deer. I am satisfied the provisions in section 3 will address the concerns of licensed deer hunters.
Comment on this
Thank you, a Leas-Chathaoirligh. I thought you were going to stop me from coming in on this.
Comment on this
I would not dare but we have had many Second Stage speeches on this section. We need to stick to the section.
Comment on this
I do not intend to make speeches. I just want to quote the Green Party's welfare policy:
The Green Party does not promote or support the live export of animals; campaigns for an end to the intensive rearing of cattle, sheep and poultry; campaigns for an end of the use of wild animals in circuses. When in government the Green party will introduce an end to bloodsports with heavy penalties——
Comment on this
On a point of order, that is totally irrelevant to the Bill. The Leas-Chathaoirleach should rule the Senator out of order.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order. I am trying to establish where Senator Cummins is coming from. Has this something to do with section 3?
Comment on this
It certainly has and it refers to several items which have been raised on this section to date whereby people are making incorrect assertions and comments.
Comment on this
Allow me to continue to quote. The Minister should read his own propaganda. I am giving it back to him and he does not like it.
Comment on this
As I stated last night, the Minister can give it but he cannot take it.
Comment on this
I will continue because I have only two lines left. It is not worth listening to the Green Party anyway which has only 2% of the vote. The party claims it will introduce an end to blood sports with heavy penalties for organisations and participants. It does not promote or support traditional zoos in the longer term and will continue to work towards a completion——
Comment on this
It answers some of the spurious comments made on the other side.
Comment on this
What is coming in the next wildlife Bill which the Minister proposes to introduce?
Comment on this
I am happy to answer that because there should be clarification. Senator Cummins is reading from a document which is 20 years old. If the Senator wishes to do so, that is fine.
Comment on this
The Minister has quoted the Attorney General from years ago.
Comment on this
As it happens, I am Leader of the party.
Comment on this
It is fair to say I would know what is in that document. The Senator is completely wrong.
Comment on this
I am only reading from it. Is the Minister suggesting the document from which I am reading is wrong?
Comment on this
I wish to answer Senator John Paul Phelan, who put a question. The animal welfare legislation to be introduced in the autumn will deal with animal welfare legislation dating back some time. It is a consolidation measure. One revision relates to the question of fur farming. In essence, that is what is contained in the legislation.
Comment on this
There will be higher penalties and it will address standards. It is not worth commenting further.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
There has not been much debate on this section which deals with the licensing of firearms and those who carry legally held shotguns. This is a serious matter.
Comment on this
Why would the Senator oppose this section?
Comment on this
When the firearms regime was amended in the Criminal Justice Act 2006 and the Criminal Justice (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2009, there was an omission in dealing with the law relating to the granting of licences under the wildlife Acts. The Minister will acknowledge that is the reason for the inclusion of this section. Separate from the criminal justice legislation dealing with firearms, section 29 of the Wildlife Act provided that, where an applicant made a declaration to a Garda superintendent that he or she would use the firearms to hunt exempted animals under the wildlife Acts, the superintendent was obliged to endorse the firearms certificate. This constituted a concurrent licensing regime for firearms. The criminal justice Acts amended the form of licences available and set out a new licensing regime. Licences would be granted by a superintendent and issued for three years instead of one, as is the case under the wildlife Acts.
The amendments had an effect in two ways. People who thought they had a licence to hunt birds during the last hunting season were acting legally because of a lacuna in law, about which the Government was made aware. They understood the licence and certificate were legal, but they were acting illegally in carrying a firearm. They were exposed because of this. The State did not inform them about the new regime and allowed them to continue under a misapprehension, despite having been warned there was this anomaly. In addition, the new licensing system is totally inconsistent, with each Garda superintendent effectively acting as an individual licensing authority. The effect of this is complete inconsistency in the issuing of licences for sporting purposes.
Will the Minister explain how this happened? Law abiding, hunting people understood they had certified legally held firearms but they were, in fact, not legal. This exposed them to the law. I understand a number of cases could come before the courts in this regard, which could result in serious exposure for the taxpayer. This lacuna or anomaly in the law dates back to the Criminal Justice Act following the shooting of Shane Geoghegan. That was rushed legislation to legislate for the possession of firearms. However, that rushed legislation led to this omission and seriously exposed people who were carrying firearms to hunt game. This could have serious repercussions for the State and the taxpayer, due to the costs that could accrue in future court cases. Will the Minister give his view on that?
Comment on this
I wish to express my amazement that this section is being opposed. We have an opportunity on Committee Stage to discuss each section and to put down——
Comment on this
According to the Order Paper it is being opposed. Every section is opposed.
Comment on this
We oppose the Bill. We will vote on that shortly.
Comment on this
A Chathaoirligh, this is my first contribution and I am speaking on section 4.
Comment on this
My point is that any Member is entitled to put down amendments to a section. That is their right. I want no interruption while the Senator is speaking.
Comment on this
I do not question the right of anybody to put down amendments but I question their sanity in making such an argument. That is the point of Committee Stage. The Members are saying they oppose a section that corrects an anomaly which they say exists.
Comment on this
This is opposition for the sake of opposition.
Comment on this
It will cost a fortune for the taxpayer. It is poor legislation.
Comment on this
This is at the heart of why Fine Gael is so badly suffering. If you believe——
Comment on this
If the Senator says we are suffering, the Green Party is dead on the bed.
Comment on this
——there is an anomaly, have it corrected.
Comment on this
If we are suffering, I do not know where you are.
Comment on this
If there is an anomaly to be corrected, it is corrected by the section in the Bill. It is that simple. It is legislation for dummies. If the Members wish to make a cod of the legislative process——
Comment on this
The Government made a mess of it, and it is trying to correct it now and at a huge cost to the taxpayer.
Comment on this
Senator Coffey, I want no interruptions. You will have an opportunity to intervene again if you wish.
Comment on this
We have had a Committee Stage debate that has been characterised by half truths, mistruths and utter lies. When I point out a truth and certainty that the Opposition is opposing a section that corrects an anomaly which it says should not exist, it is up in arms about it. I do not pardon the pun.
Comment on this
The Senator should relax. He is hyperventilating.
Comment on this
The Senator should not let himself get exercised by this Bill.
Comment on this
The Senator will take off in a minute.
Comment on this
Members can look at the transcript of the Second Stage and Committee Stage debate, as well as whatever Report Stage debate there will be——
Comment on this
The Senator interrupted and heckled everybody who spoke.
Comment on this
——and look at the number and length of the contributions. They will then see who has made this debate go on for an unnecessary length and who has made an unnecessary issue of this Bill. The finger will be pointed at Senator Coffey's party.
Comment on this
We will deal with it. We will deal with the Senator's party too at the next election.
Comment on this
I will conclude. I look forward to this point being argued further and having a vote on opposing a section that must be included to correct the anomaly.
Comment on this
We are not voting. We have more things to discuss.
Comment on this
That is the role the Opposition is playing. We are grateful as a Government for having such a circus voice that is called on to oppose.
Comment on this
You have been whipped in over the last few days.
Comment on this
The Senator's party is at 2% in the polls.
Comment on this
I welcome the amendments that were passed in the Dáil and I look forward to the Minister explaining this amendment for slow learners. The questions raised by the Senator regarding what he referred to as anomalies that might have some continuing cost for the taxpayer are plainly nonsense. I will explain some of the background and I hope the Minister will confirm and expand on it. Under the original legislation one received a paper certificate. This was endorsed on the reverse side, which gave one the right not only to hold the firearm or shotgun but also the right to hunt. Following changes last year, that piece of paper became a piece of plastic and it was impossible to put an endorsement on the back of a piece of plastic. I also understand, and the Minister will clarify this, that these changes took place under the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform.
I agree with the Senator that the lacuna he referred to is unacceptable on the face of it. There was a hiatus between the changes in the certificate's form and the introduction of the amending legislation. It meant that from last August some 100,000 people who hold firearm certificates that gave them the right to hunt were technically illegal. I do not believe any prosecutions have been taken since last August, and I cannot see any other reason that the Senator would suggest there is a financial imposition on the taxpayer. I will be interested to hear how he came to that conclusion. I am sure the Minister will clarify the matter.
The amending legislation has been passed by the Dáil and is part of the Bill before us. The regional game councils of Ireland, which were involved in this debate, welcome this legislation and the amendment, even though it is late in the day. They have no difficulty with the wording or the message contained in the amendment. Like Senator Boyle, I await with great interest the justification the Opposition will offer the House as to why it will oppose this enlightened amendment and section, which corrects a legal anomaly. It is now in a holding pattern that can continue up to 2015, even though the amendment states the licences can stand until 2012. Again, the Minister will clarify this.
If the new regime has not been put in place and new legislation is not introduced by August 2012, and I am confident that it will be, anybody who takes out a licence in July 2012 will continue to have the right to bear arms and to hunt for a further three years. There is a significant amount of time available to the Minister. Having corrected the legal anomaly, I am sure he will give an indication to the House, which I would welcome, of when he hopes to bring forward the amending legislation to ensure the new regime is permanent.
Comment on this
I will clarify why I raised this important matter. Can the Minister confirm if it is true that leave for judicial review has been granted against the Minister for this error in law? How many judicial review applications have been lodged with the Department with regard to this matter? It is a matter of concern that we have passed laws which contain lacunae and anomalies that could give rise to serious exposure for the taxpayer in the courts and which have also exposed those who carry licensed firearms.
It is extraordinary that Senator Boyle can get so exercised and hyperventilate over what he considers to be a minor Bill.
Comment on this
It is a pity we did not get the same passion from the Senator——
Comment on this
——on behalf of the old age pensioners, those on social welfare, the education cuts and all the other cuts he supported in Government. The Senator has not shown the same passion about that.
Comment on this
The Senator will take his medicine now.
Comment on this
I wish to express my utter astonishment that Fine Gael would oppose this section. I do not understand why it would wish to do so. The section makes sense and irons out an anomaly.
Comment on this
We are highlighting the Minister's errors.
Comment on this
I will try to answer the Senator's questions. I informed Senators during my Second Stage contribution on Wednesday that this provision addresses the issue that has arisen with regard to licences to shoot game during the open seasons. The Wildlife Act requires a hunter to have a licence to hunt certain birds such as wild fowl and hares, and I made provision that this would be obtained as an endorsement on the hunter's firearms certificate. Both the hunting licence and the firearms certificate were issued, as the Senator said, by the Garda Síochána in the form of a shotgun licence with the appropriate endorsement for hunting. However, when new computerised procedures were introduced in 2009 for issuing a three year firearms certificate, the facility for issuing the endorsement as a wildlife hunting licence was omitted. As a result, new firearms certificates do not provide for a hunting licence attachment and therefore do not meet the legal requirements of the existing Wildlife Acts. That is the factual position. Therefore, hunters who have the new firearms certificates would not be able to hunt legally. When this oversight was identified I understand it was not practicable to recall the certificates issued nor to change the licensing process in train. The Garda Síochána only started issuing the new licences last August and therefore the number of hunters affected in the 2009-10 season was very few. That is important to state.
My provision in this legislation provides for the amendment of section 29 of the Wildlife Act by the insertion of a new subsection (5)(a) to ensure that a firearms certificate issued for a shotgun between 1 August 2009 and 1 August 2012 will be deemed to be a hunting licence for game species such as wild fowl and hares. I should point out that this new amendment does not give hunters unrestricted permission to hunt protected birds and hares on a year-round basis. The hunting season for game birds under the open season is restricted for most wild fowl to a period from 1 September to the end of January, while the open season for hares is from the end of September to the end of February.
As I mentioned on Second Stage, arrangements will be made in the interim between my Department and the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform to revert to a position where the hunting licence is endorsed on the firearm certificate.
The Senator asked about judicial review. I understand that is on hold pending the passage of this Bill. It is important we understand that this is an anomaly that must be ironed out. It is encouraging that the Game Council of Ireland is supportive of this Minster trying to do his best for hunters throughout Ireland.
Comment on this
I can see the Minister is trying to do his best for hunters in one element but he is not doing his best in many other aspects of this legislation and many other laws he is bringing forward.
The Minister has not answered my question on the judicial review. Is it true that leave for judicial review has been granted against the Minister? He said it was on hold but I understand the Minister might be aware that over 100 applications for judicial review have been granted. Is that true? If it is true it has implications and we would like to hear about it.
Comment on this
I think I answered the question. Everything is on hold until we pass this Bill, so let us pass the Bill quickly.
Comment on this
Are there applications before the Minister?
Comment on this
A Chathaoirligh, we have tabled an amendment for Report Stage and we ask that time be taken to consider that.
Comment on this
Why not leave it till later? Why not deal with it next Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday?
Comment on this
I propose that the House be suspended for 30 minutes following which we will take Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Seanad divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I propose the suspension of the House until 4.30 p.m.