Social Welfare and Pensions Bill 2013: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–181 of 351. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 101 of 2013 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 6, line 21, after “income” to insert “in excess of €6,000”.
Comment on this
I will wait to hear the Minister.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 1 seeks to insert in page 6, line 21, after “income” the words “in excess of €6,000”. Similarly, amendment No. 2 seeks in page 6, line 29, after “income” to insert “in excess of €6,000”. I do not propose to accept these amendments.
The purpose of the section is to abolish the exemption from PRSI applying to employees and occupational pensioners under 66 years whose only other source of income is unearned. This unearned income will become liable to PRSI at the rate of 4% but only if the individual has sufficient income to be regarded by the Revenue Commissioners as a chargeable person.
A PRSI charge will not apply to PAYE taxpayers who have small amounts of unearned income that are subject to tax through the PAYE system. This is generally regarded as amounts not exceeding €3,174. In addition, people who have reached the State pension age of 66 are not liable to PRSI and therefore will not be affected.
Applying the charge to a higher level of unearned income, as proposed by Senator Mooney, would have the effect of excluding those with substantial levels of savings from the PRSI charge. For example, if the threshold for the charge was set at €6,000, as has been proposed, this would exclude those with savings of approximately €240,000 from the PRSI charge, assuming a rate of interest on such savings in the region of 2.5%. Obviously, given the current low interest rates, one is talking about far higher levels of savings.
In addition, as this PRSI charge is being collected by the Revenue Commissioners along with tax and the universal social charge, any change to the threshold at which the charge applies would cause difficulties in the assessment and collection of the charge by Revenue. As the Senator will appreciate, this is essentially a Revenue measure which we are carrying in the context of the social welfare Bill because PRSI is also a social welfare matter in terms of the Social Insurance Fund.
The exclusion of people with such significant levels of savings from this PRSI charge would significantly reduce the projected additional income to the Social Insurance Fund, which the measure is expected to yield. This section provides for the second of two measures which were announced by the Minister for Finance in December 2012, to broaden the income tax base on which PRSI is charged.
Earlier this year, in the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, I abolished the PRSI exemption for modified rate PRSI contributors who also have income from a trade or profession. The Senator will recall that regarding some people with very high incomes from the public service, such as consultants, there was an anomaly in the PRSI taxation base whereby their other income fell outside the PRSI catchment.
The significant shortfall in the Social Insurance Fund, which is being met by the Exchequer, will be above €1 billion this year. Given the measures we have introduced, and with the numbers of people going back to work, I confidently expect that the hole in the Social Insurance Fund will probably fall to about €700 million next year. That is important in terms of sustaining pensions for older people. We must have a broader PRSI base. The only alternative is to increase the levels of PRSI on people who are already paying PRSI.
This is a base-broadening measure to include a wider set of income sources than have been included up to now. As I have mentioned on a previous occasion in the Seanad, one of the priorities is to take steps to put the Social Insurance Fund on a sustainable financial footing. Yesterday I told Senators that we are spending an extra €190 million in this year's budget on pensions, contributory and non-contributory. Of the €20 billion spend we discussed, more than €6.5 billion goes on pensions. The sustainability of the Social Insurance Fund is critical to being able to maintain our rates of retirement pension for older people. To ensure this measure does not give rise to additional costs to the Social Insurance Fund, this new PRSI charge will apply without giving rise to entitlements to social insurance benefits. The majority of the individuals affected by this measure qualify separately for social insurance entitlement based on PRSI paid on other sources of income, for example, PRSI paid on income from their employment.
Comment on this
Am I right that the current threshold for unearned income is €3,174?
Comment on this
Therefore, there is nothing to stop the Government or any future one from reducing it to bring more people into the net, which seems to be the trend that is developing here.
Comment on this
The amount of administration needed would probably not justify going below the €3,000 threshold. I cannot give an absolute undertaking on that because other Ministers, other governments and other Seanaid might make different decisions, but the administration cost of going below the current amount would not be worthwhile. On the advice of the Revenue Commissioners, the current amount is an operable amount with which they can deal.
Comment on this
While many people may pay more PRSI, as the Minister has said, they will not accrue any additional benefits. Therefore, the self-employed will continue to remain outside the net in this regard. This has been an ongoing difficulty, particularly for those self-employed people who had worked for some time in the construction industry whose income in the past three or four years has been practically wiped out. Is any succour being given to those self-employed people or will they continue without getting any benefits?
Currently, people renting a spare room in their house are exempt from income tax on the rent received under the rent-a-room scheme. With the abolition of this provision, tens of thousands of people will now have additional income tax and PRSI liabilities. I understand that for savers it will mean a tax rate of 45% on deposit interest. The Minister referred to 2.5%, coming up with a figure of €240,000, which coincides with the reckonable unearned income of €6,000. I have not seen 2.5% anywhere. I believe the best rate available is approximately 1.8% or 1.9%. With the withdrawal in recent weeks of ACC Bank and Danske Bank leaving only the two pillar banks and Ulster Bank as a third, I have no doubt that the emerging duopoly will further reduce interest rates and make it even less attractive for savers. I know we can quibble over the figures the Minister has quoted, but ultimately on two levels this imposes a penal tax on those at a vulnerable stage in their lives and the self-employed will receive no additional benefit as a result of this abolition.
Comment on this
I commend Senator Mooney and agree with him in indicating some of the concerns I have, but I wish to add another one. What is unearned income? I do not know anybody who has not sweated and laboured for their money and then took a risk in putting it into stocks and shares, sometimes getting wiped out, or they may put it into prize bonds which are Government guaranteed and all the rest of it. To someone of my generation €240,000 seems like a vast sum of money. However, in the country's present situation, it is not such a vast sum of money and the Minister stated it only earns €6,000 a year. It actually does not because the rates are much lower. That is a tiny amount. The capital sum might seem big, but €6,000 to disqualify somebody is not right.
Comment on this
It should be €6,000 and should not be lower than that. The Minister said that any change like this would cause difficulty for the Revenue Commissioners. While I am sorry for them, they are the servants of the House and not the masters of the House. We establish the law and they administer it. I know there are very hard-working decent people in Revenue. They are overwhelmed by this rather unfortunate property tax and so on. That it would cause difficulty for Revenue is not sufficient reason not to do it. If it does, we will need to address that.
Comment on this
I applaud the Minister, who also said this was a question of reducing the deficit from €1 billion to €700 million because of pensions and all the rest of it. However, I am sure the Minister would probably tacitly agree with me that if the Government was serious about pensions, it should not have raided the pension fund to pay off the international financial institutions, the bankers, the bondholders and all these sorts of people. That was a disastrous mistake.
I am very glad that Senator Mooney mentioned the gross unfairness on self-employed people and people who create employment in small businesses. They are required to pay PRSI for their employees, but if their business goes bust, they have absolutely nothing except, perhaps, the €240,000 they had in the bank. If we want the economy to recover, we need to look after people who have the get up and go to start a business and employ other people, and we should not punish them for it. I know they do not for the most part at the moment make PRSI contributions, but they should be required to do so even if it is only a small amount that can be allowed to build up gradually. I certainly support Senator Mooney's amendments.
Comment on this
Does the Minister wish to clarify it before I call Senator Moloney or will I call Senator Moloney first?
Comment on this
I am sure Senator Moloney can clarify it.
Comment on this
No better woman. Senator Moloney should be sitting where the Minister is sitting, in case she gets incapacitated.
Comment on this
I want to make it absolutely clear that it is based on the interest earned on savings and not the way the Department of Social Protection assesses it. Based on how the Department assesses it, if a person being means tested had €100,000 in the bank, it would equate to €270 a week or €14,000 a year. If I ever had €100,000 and was about to be means tested, I would send my money to the Minister for Social Protection - whoever that might be - to invest it and try to get that rate of interest, which equates to about 14%. How the Department assesses capital is an absolute disgrace, but that is another day's work. I seek clarification that it is the actual interest that is being assessed and that it is not being done in the way the Department of Social Protection assesses it.
Comment on this
I support Senator Mooney's amendments. I want to speak about PRSI on rental income. The Bill as drafted would require people to pay PRSI on income and not profit. While capital expenditure, mortgage interest, etc. can be deducted for income tax purposes before paying the income tax aspect of it, I understand the PRSI will need to be paid on income.
Let us not forget that the vast majority of landlords in Ireland have only one property. In 2011, some 135,000 landlords had only one property, compared with just over 1,500 who had more than ten. In the current environment many of those are young couples who separately bought properties during the boom and have since got married, but cannot live in either apartment. They are therefore renting out a family home from somebody else and paying rent on it while getting rental income from their two separate apartments.
These are people who were forced into becoming, what is often termed, "accidental landlords". They certainly never intended to be landlords but have no other choice. Many of those people are losing a fortune on their properties. They cannot afford to sell them because the negative equity is so significant and yet the rent coming in is far less than the mortgage repayments. These people are making a loss on a rental property but are doing their best to hold on to it and just tread water. Now they will be required to pay PRSI on that loss. Nobody can dispute the tax to be paid on a profit, but it is scandalous to have to pay tax on a loss particularly for people bringing in very small amounts of income. Multinationals can write off all kinds of stuff in different tax years. They are not even required to write it off in the same tax year; they can write it off in other tax years. How can the Government turn around to couples who are struggling with one rental property and tell them it wants to add to that burden in addition to property taxes and everything else they are now paying on that home by expecting them to pay tax on a loss?
I believe it is incredibly unjust and I urge the Minister to change that provision. At the very least the Minister should accept Senator Mooney's amendment whereby the PRSI would only be paid on income over €6,000. A typical rental property in Dublin would yield €7,000, €8,000 or €10,000, which at least would cover some of the income for them. As a matter of principle, I object to the provision on the rental income side. If it applied to rental profit, it would be fair enough. Applying it to income is objectionable. However, before tabling a stronger amendment to change it from income to profit, I want to hear the Minister's response to establish if my understanding is correct. Unlike the income tax provisions which justifiably allow for deductibles, the provision as drafted does not and will apply to all income regardless of whether the person is making a loss after paying mortgage repayments, letting fees, the PRTB fee and general maintenance costs. Ultimately they will be taxed on that loss.
Comment on this
This is one of the few sections we support and we will oppose the Fianna Fáil amendments for good reason. I welcome that more income is being subjected to PRSI, which will help build up the Social Insurance Fund. The logic is to have enough money to pay the benefits people obviously need and get, as a consequence of paying into the Social Insurance Fund. I believe all income should be subjected to PRSI. However, there should be a quid pro quo. I understand that the income we are discussing will be disregarded when determining entitlement to social insurance contributions, which is unfair. If we are subjecting the income we are discussing to PRSI payment, then it should be taken into account for contributions paid, but based on my understanding of the Bill, this income is disregarded, which is unfair. I ask the Minister to respond to that aspect.
Comment on this
I was asked whether self-employed people benefit from PRSI. The benefits have been shown by the OECD and the recent actuarial review of the Social Insurance Fund by KPMG. This was not work by the Department of Social Protection or the Revenue Commissioners but was independently done. Given the benefits they acquire, which are broadly maternity benefit, widow's, survivor's and retirement pensions, the 4% contribution by self-employed people represents some of the best value that the social insurance system offers to any contributor.
Senator Mooney spoke about people who were formerly self-employed who may even have employed other people and paid employer PRSI contributions. The advisory group, chaired by the barrister, Ms Ita Mangan, did considerable research on this. What we found will be backed up by what many Senators, who have dealt with cases on the ground, will know. The advisory group report found that approximately 85% of the 20,000 self-employed people, who claimed the means-tested jobseeker's allowance during the worst three-year period of the crash following the bank guarantee in 2008 from the beginning of 2009 to 2011, actually got jobseeker's allowance. In other words, even though the self-employed do not pay a contribution of 14.75%, which employed people pay - 4% employee contribution and 10.75% employer's contribution - since I became Minister we have allowed self-employed persons or indeed farmers who have had a catastrophic fall in income to prepare accounts of their current financial position whereas with the previous Government they relied on previous years' accounts.
The crash really began in 2008 and accelerated particularly during 2009 and 2010. Many people in those days looking for some social welfare support did not qualify for jobseeker's allowance. Senators will recall the sad stories of such people who were broke having to go and get accountants to redo accounts. We have changed that, including for farmers, which was important in the context of the farming crisis experienced earlier this year and at the end of last year, to allow people to bring in current financial information. We do not require them to go off and get expensive accountants. They can go to their local social welfare office and bring their details there. The situation Senator Mooney has described no longer applies and we have the figures from the advisory committee showing that 85% of the 20,000 formerly self-employed people got jobseeker's allowance.
Why would a person not qualify? It might be because his or her spouse was in employment or had another occupation or business with income above the means-test limits. However, that particular situation was one of the terrible features we discussed with people during the 2011 general election campaign. I remember visiting Letterkenny and talking to people who had worked in construction and may have employed a few people. Some of them lived in big houses which needed to be heated and they were trying to pay the mortgage even though everything had crashed around them. I was very influenced by that and when I became Minister I was determined to make the change to allow them to be assessed on a current account basis, which is in effect as we speak.
Therefore, if I were to ask Senators, they would agree that they do not hear the level of distress experienced by people in those situations who try to get social welfare support. As I said, in some cases their spouses might have significant other means.
I shall return to another question on principles. The Revenue Commissioners administer a scheme that exempts the first €3,174 of income. People may say, in the context of interest, that the provision is not terribly significant. However, it is an important allowance. For instance, a person who earns an income from their employment, trade or profession pays PRSI on the gross amount. Why should somebody with an income from other sources, and in this case it is interest, be put in a more favourable position than somebody at work who pays PRSI on his or her gross income?
Yesterday, I listened very carefully to the Second Stage speeches and Senators emphasised repeatedly the importance of retirement pensions and those of widows and widowers. If we are to fund these, we must have a fund of money, and in Ireland that is the social Social Insurance Fund. It went into catastrophic deficit as a consequence of the crash, which is exactly what Senator Mooney talked about. We have now got the fund on a path to recovery and stability. If we grow and maintain the fund over the next period and right up to 2050, we will ensure every retired person in the country has an appropriate retirement pension. Not only that, it is one of the reasons that I, as a Minister, can tell older people who are retired that I can maintain - and have maintained - the basic weekly rate of retirement pension.
The amendment proposes the expansion of the PRSI base and will maintain the contributory pensions. I think I said to people yesterday that we must spend an extra €190 million this year due to an additional number of older people qualifying for retirement pensions. We must absorb that provision in our costs for this year and next year and, therefore, must increase the base. The amendment allows for a small and moderate increase in the base of the Social Insurance Fund.
Comment on this
The Minister did not respond to my question on PRSI contributions paid as part of income. I want them classed as contributions, thus providing an entitlement to social insurance contributions and benefits.
Comment on this
The Senator will have to take the matter up with the Minister for Finance when he attends here to debate the Finance Bill because he made the proposal. He stated it in the budget announcements of December 2012 which we are carrying into the Social Welfare and Pensions Bill because it affects PRSI.
My understanding of previous responses made by the Minister is as follows. Almost everybody who is subject to PRSI under the section has other sources of income or occupation and, therefore, has an entitlement to PRSI benefits. As Members of the House will know, there is only one other class of people who, by and large, do not qualify. Additional contributions made, for instance, by officeholders in the Dáil and Seanad do not qualify for additional benefits either.
Comment on this
I appreciate the flattering comments made by the Minister. She said that if we hung around until 2050, everybody would be straightened out. I might be here.
Comment on this
I wish to comment on the term "unearned". I have no time for extremely wealthy people such as billionaires who have funds of various kinds, but I do for somebody who is a landlord or has a small apartment to let. Senator Power said exactly the same and made the very good point that this is work and is not "unearned" income. How can it be "unearned"? A service is provided to the community and the property is maintained. One must ensure the electric lights, plumbing, sewerage, locks, burglar alarms and all of the rest are in working order. I do not think that is "unearned" income.
We must also take into account the fact that some people were prudent, saved and denied themselves all kinds of exotic pleasures such as foreign holidays and all of the rest. If they have €240,000 in a bank or somewhere, more power to them because they earned and saved the money. They paid tax on it and, therefore, have already paid tax.
I am very grateful to the Minister for displaying her usual courtesy by replying in considerable detail and clarity. She has been very helpful.
I wish to comment on individual employers such as people who have a small start-up business and employ people. Perhaps they will get a jobseeker's allowance but it is a very dicey business these days. I have a letter that will be relevant later on about a man who lost his job, has various entitlements but was told that they would all be stripped from him if he went into further education. There are all kinds of little traps here and there. Somebody who creates a small business employs other people and pays their PRSI, so an employer contributes in that sense. Without that employer those jobs and PRSI income would not exist. Those employers are entitled to more than just the odd ad misericordiam jump at a jobseeker's allowance. Sometimes the jobs they are told to seek are completely and utterly inappropriate. Those are the points that I wish to raise with the Minister.
Comment on this
I wish to respond to the point made by the Minister that PAYE is paid on employment income. I agree but I still think that is quite different from somebody who makes a loss on a rental property. At least with employment every euro one gets is extra and there is no question of losing money.
As I pointed out, what is being done in this provision is different from the existing code for income tax that rightly allows people to write off costs such as mortgage interest and similar items. This provision imposes a tax on a loss, which is extraordinary and is completely different from employment income. I ask the Minister to revisit the idea that this legislation could be changed to reflect rental profit.
I understand the points made by Senator Norris and others about charging people taxes on the interest they have made on savings or investments or when, for example, an elderly couple has their retirement income in a bank account and they are paying tax on the interest they earn from that. At least that is a tax on interest. The rental income provision is extraordinary because it is based on a loss. As I pointed out earlier, there are multinational companies in this county which make billions and yet write off all kinds of things to avoid paying tax. How could it possibly be right that somebody who has only one property and is losing money on it would have to pay PRSI on a loss? I genuinely believe that is different and I ask the Minister to revisit the provision between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
In respect of the reference to unearned income, which was raised by Senator Norris, I point out to him, given that he is a very distinguished Joycean scholar, that the definition for "unearned" dates back to before Joyce's time. Broadly, if I can remember my income tax law, there are categories of earnings from employment, trade or a profession where one carries on an activity and income streams arise from the activity. That is distinguished that from what would have been, in those days, largely income from rents, such as, for example, the income stream that flows from land, which is an asset. At the time people like Marx were very occupied with the idea as well, and income from capital sums lodged in banks were income streams. It is simply an old distinction but Senator Norris is possibly correct that the language should be changed.
It is something we inherited from the time of Joyce, and I am sure he made some references to it in terms of commercial operations in Dublin at the time.
Regarding Senator Power's points, the rates that apply in general to any source of income for taxation purposes also apply to income for the purposes of charging PRSI. It is the Minister for Finance who broadly deals with the charging of taxation, and the companion charge is PRSI. The income on which PRSI is applied, therefore, will in general be the same as that for the charging of taxation. The basis for general taxation, income tax or other forms of taxation that may apply to particular revenue streams is the same as that which applies to PRSI.
The point in our system, in terms of the Social Insurance Fund, is that there were areas of income that did not give rise to PRSI. In the rental example to which the Senator referred she is talking about a stream of rental income and if the stream of rental income is under €3,174 the PRSI charge would not apply. For somebody with a rental income - one property and so on as the Senator describes it - ultimately, it may be that over a long period of time and as the economy recovers those losses may be recovered. As the Senator rightly said, people in other lines of business such as banking have significant carry-forward loss provisions but people involved in renting also can do that in a more constrained way against those sources of income. However, that is a matter for the Minister for Finance.
In terms of social protection, what the Minister for Finance laid out in his budget provisions in December 2012 was to provide for wider streams of income to go into PRSI. I strongly support that because the Social Insurance Fund, which is the basis of our paying widow's pensions and retirement pensions, this year will be in deficit to the tune of approximately €1.5 billion. At the height of the crisis that went up to over €2 billion. If we want to continue paying the existing level of pensions to our pensioners and retired people, never mind increasing those in the future, we must have a replenished, strong Social Insurance Fund. That is the argument of the Minister for Finance regarding this broadening of the PRSI base.
Comment on this
If I may respond directly on that point before Senator Mooney asks about another issue, the crucial point is that the income will be subject to tax but the Minister is not providing for disregards from the PRSI liability in the way she does from income tax. That is the gap, and it is a huge gap because the reality is that somebody who does not pay any income tax on their rental property currently because their losses are so significant they do not have an income tax liability, having taken into account their expenditure, will now have to pay PRSI on that property. That is the difference. I agree the income is the same but not having the same disregards as the Minister has for the income tax side, the result is completely different. That is the reason it needs to be rephrased to ensure the legislation only refers to profits from rental properties. At the very least the Minister should provide the same disregards. The legislation should at least state that if the areas that would be discounted from rental income for the purpose of income tax, such as capital expenditure, repairs on a home, 75% of the mortgage interest and so on, logically they should also apply from the PRSI base as well, even using the argument the Minister just made about the need for the two systems - the income tax side and the PRSI side - to work in a similar way. I ask that the Minister would examine that and, if necessary, consult with the Minister for Finance on it between now and Report Stage. I thank the Minister for her engagement on it.
Comment on this
Can the Minister indicate the effect this proposal will have on the Social Insurance Fund? She spoke generally about the deficit in the Social Insurance Fund. What impact will this particular measure have or are there figures for that?
Comment on this
I do not think I have the figure with me but if I recall correctly it is a relatively modest amount. It is €14 million in 2014 and when it comes fully into effect over a period it should be €60 million in a full year. It is a small amount relative to the total PRSI take but the principle of taxation is that if everybody and all sources yield small amounts we will avoid very high rates, everybody will be a contributor and we will be able to continue paying the pensions.
Comment on this
Keeping in mind that the amount is modest, would the Minister not see some merit in the case put forward by Senator Power that there would be more clarification on the particular point she has made to ensure one could separate unearned income from actual loss, as she has illustrated?
Comment on this
I should say that the figure for the full year is €20 million; I want to correct the record in that respect. That is perhaps something to raise with the Minister for Finance because the rules on calculating profits and so on rest with the Revenue Commissioners, and that might be an issue to discuss with him.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Report Stage be taken tomorrow."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 6, line 29, after "income' " to insert "in excess of €6,000".
Comment on this
This section provides for an increase in the waiting period for entitlement to illness benefit from three days to six, with the change to take effect from January 2014. I understand this will result in a saving of some €22 million, but it also places another burden on small businesses by transferring the cost of sick pay onto them. There are 200,000 small businesses in Ireland employing more than 655,000 people. It is a key sector of the economy. Many of these jobs are in the retail and hospitality sectors, where employee costs account for more than 60% of total costs. These small companies do not have the flexibility to move staff around when one employee is out sick and, as such, this measure will act as a barrier to future employment in those areas.
The Minister has made comparisons with the systems in place in other jurisdictions to support her arguments, but some of those comparisons do not stand up to scrutiny. In the case of Northern Ireland, for example, while employers do make the initial sick pay payment, this can be offset against their PAYE tax bill at a later date. In addition, it has less of an immediate cashflow implication as the weekly payment is just £81.60 for 28 weeks, compared with €188 per week for two years in this State. As various representative groups have argued, extending the waiting period from three to six days means that people will be stretching their money and what limited funds they have to a point where it becomes an intolerable financial burden.
Comment on this
I am opposing this section. The first point to make is that we do not have a statutory sick pay scheme in this State, unlike in most other countries. What we are dealing with here is a crude, cost-cutting measure. It is true that most workers will not be affected by it - public sector workers will be covered, as will a majority of private sector workers because their employers will pick up the cost. However, a minority of workers - moreover, a growing minority - will not be covered. As we know, part-time work, precarious employment, zero-hour contracts, flexible contracts and so on are becoming an increasing feature of employment in this State. It is these types of workers who will be most affected by the cut in illness benefit entitlement of €112.80 which arises from the extension of the waiting period. The bottom line is that a significant section of people who have paid their PRSI and the universal social charge will now have less cover.
As Senator Mooney pointed out, the measure will also have an impact on employers, many of whom are struggling to meet the costs of business. Any additional cost or burden that is imposed on small business employers is a difficulty. Workers pay PRSI in the expectation that if they get sick they will be able to access illness benefit. Both employers and employees are paying more PRSI than ever before, in addition to which workers are paying a universal social charge, the purpose of which has never been properly explained. All people can see, in budget after budget, is fewer social insurance entitlements on the one hand and, on the other, more money being taken out of their wages.
This measure will impose a burden on many families and individuals. While the figure of €112.80 might seem small to the Minister, it will not be so for low-income individuals, in particular, who find themselves in a position where they are not covered and must take the hit themselves. Likewise, it is a significant burden for employers who decide to take the hit. I am opposing the section for all of these reasons.
Comment on this
Everything I intended to say has been said already by the previous two speakers, particularly Senator Cullinane. I have travelled around the country a good deal in recent years and seen the challenges facing the large number of small businesses, many of which employ only half a dozen people or fewer. Expecting them to bear the cost of this measure will be a major burden. We are hearing all the right sounds from the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, but not enough is being done to address the huge burden for small businesses. If we are to succeed in overcoming the jobs crisis, we must focus on positive initiatives. This particular measure is the very opposite of that and is the wrong way to proceed.
Comment on this
I echo what my colleague, Senator Quinn, has said. To reiterate the point I made on Second Stage, extending the waiting period from three to six days means that people will have to maintain a float, so to speak, to ensure they have a little protective padding in times of illness. The problem is that most of the people affected by this change will be in the lowest socioeconomic category and are living on such thin margins that they have the least possibility of being able to maintain that type of safety net. We heard this morning on the radio and in this House about people being forced to use loan sharks to make up payments of various types. The idea that somebody who is ill, and having been unable to save up the shortfall in illness benefit, would be forced to seek out a loan shark is very worrying. People in that situation are being very unjustly hit.
From the employer's point of view, it seems to be a case of the State attempting to transfer its own responsibility onto those who have created employment. Employers get nothing out of the situation at all because, unlike their employees, they do not benefit from PRSI payments. It is very unfair.
Senator Quinn is a very successful businessman, with an international reputation, and is somebody who has travelled around the country and has been successful in advising people on their businesses and so on. If he sees something wrong here, then it is time we sat up and took notice that it may have an effect on employment and on the welfare of small businesses. It is hitting vulnerable people in terms of their sickness benefit.
Comment on this
I want to support everything that has been said by my colleagues and echo the words of Senator Norris on the transfer of functions and social responsibility in this area from the Department to employers, very many of whom are defined as self-employed. Given that they make PRSI contributions to the State, they cannot avail of any social welfare transactions when they become unemployed themselves. There is a question here of going after people in a targeted manner. Small businesses, which are already struggling out there at the moment, will face additional pressures as a result of this move, but more importantly the employees concerned will have to ensure that they have a float of at least one week's wages saved before they become ill. That is grossly unreasonable. The message from this move is that it is okay to become ill, but one must have a week's worth of wages saved before one does so, or else the State will not provide support. What happens when the employers are not in a financial position to make any form of payment to individuals who are becoming ill or injured? This is wholly unreasonable and it will affect many people in a very disproportionate way.
While there are instances where people may be able to support themselves or employers could provide the support - the example was given of the public sector or multinationals - the smaller employers will find this measure very painful. In the event they are not able to fulfil the perceived obligation under the measure, the individual employee will suffer. That is unreasonable and it is why Senator Mooney is opposing this section. Even at this late stage, I ask the Minister to take on board what has been said here. At a time when somebody is either injured or ill and is not able to support himself or herself, the State has an obligation.
Comment on this
This measure was outlined and examined as part of the comprehensive review of expenditure carried out in 2011. Savings arising from this measure are just over €20 million and they will ease the pressure on the Social Insurance Fund, for which there was a deficit of €2 billion last year. This year we expect to have it down to €1.5 billion because people are going back to work. As more people move back into employment next year, we hope the deficit will fall to €700 million. That is still a huge shortfall, and we are committed to maintaining all of the weekly rates of social welfare payments, which we have managed to do.
This amendment will not affect primary rates of payment, rates of payment for dependents or duration of benefit for illness benefit claims. No existing customers of illness benefit will be affected by the measure, but from 6 January 2014 people who are coming into the illness benefit scheme will be affected by it.
It should be noted that there will still be continuity of payment for claimants transferring from jobseeker's benefit or allowance to illness benefit under the revised arrangements. In 2013, the Department will spend €662 million on illness benefit, which is one of the highest rates of payment in all the OECD countries. Many people will say that those figures are perhaps exceptionally high because of arrangements in the public sector which are currently undergoing changes. However, we have very high levels of claims in respect of illness benefit. The cost is €662 million, which is down by €111 million on the 2012 expenditure, partly due to the revised management of sick pay in the public sector, about which the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform has spoken to Senators. It is an issue that has come up in many European countries due to its cost, and we wish to concentrate the payments in respect of illness and disability on those who need them the most.
Many employees, including those in the public sector, receive their salaries when out sick where their employers have occupational sick pay arrangements in place. The employer then recoups the payment from the Social Insurance Fund, so the employees will not suffer any reduction in income as result of the measure. However, the employer, including public sector employers, will receive less in recoupment from the Department of Social Protection. Where employees are not covered by an occupational sick pay scheme, and they have an income need to cover the short period until illness benefit becomes available, they may have recourse to supplementary welfare allowances and to special needs payments. I wish to be clear about that.
There is no link between this measure and a statutory sick pay scheme which almost all European countries have introduced. There is no additional obligation, as a consequence of this measure, on employers. There is no element of compulsion on employers to pay employees for the duration of the new waiting day period, where they do not have an occupational sick pay arrangement already in place. Social insurance is not restricted to cover in respect of illness, as there is a range of other entitlements for people under social insurance.
This measure will reduce the overall social welfare bill in the Department in respect of illness by over €20 million per year. Much of that is paid in recouping money for employers, but if employers seek to limit their costs on these waiting days, then the management of initial early number of sick days will be with the employer. All of the evidence from people involved in management and ownership of businesses, and the experience from other countries, suggests that the closer sick leave is managed to the place of employment, the better the outcomes for the employer and the employee. One of the problems in social welfare systems is that if people build up fairly continuous sick leave arrangements and gradually begin to leave employment in some cases, the outcome can often be very bad for the individual. Most occupational medical experts will say that when somebody has an illness and later recovers, the best thing is to get back into the world of work if possible. That is very significant in assisting recovery.
Comment on this
For the record, last year the Minister indicated that she was reducing the statutory redundancy from 70% of two weeks per year to zero or increasing the sick pay leave, as in the Bill now. The Minister has now done both. From that point of view, some businesses that have been downsizing over recent years because of the economic recession are now caught on the double. This is an extra burden on business. In the circumstances, this initiative is not at all welcome.
Comment on this
The Minister spoke at length but, with respect, she did not address many of the core concerns articulated by a number of Senators. The first point I made in my contribution is that we do not have a statutory sick pay scheme. That presents problems for all workers. If this section is passed, it will mean that some employees will suffer and lose three days illness benefit and some employers will have to pick up the tab. I agree with Senators who spoke about this continuous shift of the burden from the State and the social insurance fund to employers. It is unfair. I supported the Minister earlier with regard to extending PRSI contributions to unearned, reckonable income. I have no difficulty with both employees and employers paying their fair share of PRSI. However, people expect to get a return. They expect that if they get sick, they will have an entitlement. They should not have to depend on an employer to pay them.
There is another problem if this is passed. Many businesses are struggling. They have contracts with their employees. How many of them will change the contracts when they come up for renewal or if they are taking on new employees? How many of them will cover sick pay into the future? I believe it will probably be fewer. They might not be able to pay it. The same happened with the redundancy benefit. In that case, the worker eventually loses. The worker would have received their statutory redundancy and because the employer was able to reclaim a sizeable portion of that from the State, they were able to give a top-up payment to the worker. Now the employer cannot do that because they must pay almost the full statutory redundancy. Ultimately, it is the workers and employees who will lose.
Unfortunately, employment is more precarious. The Mandate trade union produced a report on this quite recently, of which the Minister will be aware. More people are working part-time, there are more flexible contracts and zero hour contracts are creeping in. These workers will not have protections. My biggest fear is that genuine employers who wish to look after their staff and ensure they have good entitlements will be in a more difficult position and will be less inclined to give them cover such as this, because they will simply be unable to pay. While many of them in good faith paid their employees in the past on the basis that they would get the money back, at least some of them will be unable to do that in the future. That is my concern.
With respect, the Minister did not address many of the core concerns that were articulated to her. Perhaps she will take the opportunity to do that.
Comment on this
I will make a few remarks, but once Members have said what they wish to say we should move forward because there are a number of amendments to discuss. I wonder if, behind this, there is a feeling that there are malingerers. There are some - there are always a certain amount in any situation - but I believe it is a small proportion. I have heard people say, "I have five sick days left, so I can go on holiday". We certainly must change that attitude, but I do not believe it is widespread. What has become clear from this argument is the need for a statutory sickness scheme. The Government should act on that and be as helpful as possible to small business in establishing it.
The Minister is not going to move on this. She has made as good a case as possible and has been very helpful. However, when the supplementary welfare fund is dragged out again, I wonder how elastic it is. How much is in it? I have heard it produced to refer to a number of other issues, including the burial grant. One is told people can apply for the special supplementary welfare payment. That seems to be the mattress on which the Government is relying. If this is true, there will not be much of a saving. People will just be dislodged from one area of the bureaucracy to another.
If the proposers wish to call a vote, that is fine with me.
Comment on this
I can speak from experience as I have been in a small business for more than 25 years in which the average number of employees was four or five. It was never an issue. Any employer who has good staff would not consider telling them, "You will not be paid for three days, so hard luck". One does not create that type of relationship in a small business and expect to survive. We are moving towards the norms that exist in Europe, but from my experience of having staff for 25 to 27 years it does not cross an employer's mind to move on without paying their staff or by having staff out of pocket. All employers over the years have had staff who were off for various reasons but they have never been legalistic with them and told them they are not getting paid for missing certain days. An employer will be flexible with their employees. It also works the other way around. Many times employees are flexible with their employer, such as agreeing to come in on a Saturday even though they do not have to do so. It works both ways.
For a business to survive at present, this provision will not make or break it. What we need is confidence back in business. I spoke to other small employers in my local area and asked them what difference this provision would make. They said it would be very little. They said their job is to get people in the door to sell their products and to get to the end of the month and the end of the year. It is really about the relationship the employer has with the employee, and 99 out of 100 employers and employees alike will have had good experiences. Those businesses will not survive if the staff and the employer are not pulling together. Perhaps it is an issue in a large company, where there is lower, middle and senior management and there are ongoing staff issues. However, in the small local business that is struggling to survive, this is not a massive issue. It would be great if the system we have could continue all the time, but we are moving towards what is normal in Europe, as the Minister said. We cannot afford that luxury. From my perspective, having been in that sector for a long time, I do not consider this a game changer for any business.
Comment on this
I am glad Senator Norris raised the supplementary welfare allowance and how it can replace the payment on some occasions for some people. I was beginning to think nobody on that side of the House had heard what the Minister said. With regard to Senator Norris's question about the size of the supplementary welfare allowance budget, it is a demand led scheme so the money must be available for it. It is there to help needy people. For example, the victims of this new measure might be the bank manager's wife who goes out sick. I am sure the Senator is not here batting for wealthy people and to ensure that they get their share of it. We are looking after people who are in need and they will be looked after by the supplementary welfare scheme.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Kelly for his comments. Two schemes are commonly mentioned. One is the supplementary welfare allowance, which Senator Kelly referred to, which is a weekly payment of €2 or so less than the standard €188 per week. The second one, which we will probably discuss further later, is what is called a special needs payment or exceptional needs payment, ENP, in social welfare parlance. That is a fund for people who go to a community welfare officer when there is a particular need. We are spending between €46 million and €50 million per year on that.
As Senator Kelly said, the supplementary welfare allowance is an elastic amount because it depends on the number of people coming forward who will qualify. I emphasise to Senators that somebody who has a special need arising from this will qualify to seek a supplementary welfare allowance.
In the context of the work of the Department becoming a public employment service, I had the privilege of having a great deal of contact with employers around the country and on many occasions had an opportunity to discuss issues around illness. For some types of employment large amounts of employee sick leave is a significant cost, particularly so in parts of the public service. In this particular case the impact of this measure will be to give the public service type employer a very strong incentive to better manage short-term illnesses of employees. It is hoped the outcome of that will be less overall illness and also less development of a pattern of people having repeated and significant amounts of short-term illnesses. From what Members were saying, they are quite familiar with that. It is important that is managed at the level of the actual job. It is not possible for the Department of Social Protection to manage that in any detail. That is for the management of the employer. This will give an enhanced incentive to employers to manage it.
In terms of all the different illness payments, including disability and invalidity, as a country we are spending approximately €3 billion. That is about 16% of our payments whereas in Europe the average is about 10% or 11%. We have a problem in Ireland, therefore, with higher volumes of people on different types of disability benefit. This is precious money and in terms of social welfare provision we must ensure it is targeted at the people who have very serious illnesses and disabilities and who probably merit more support than they currently get because of the pervasiveness of and the larger number of illness claims here than is the norm in many other countries. Hence, many other countries have moved under statutory sick pay arrangements, including in the United Kingdom, to make employers responsible for all of the first four months. In the Netherlands, which once had such a problem when it was described as the sick man of Europe, such responsibility in respect of employers has moved to two years. We are not doing that. We are moving to a period of six days and I expect that will make a modest saving - it is about €20 million a year - but I hope it will result in a significant improvement in the management of short-term illnesses in employment.
I was told by IBEC that 75% of its members have statutory sick pay schemes. To refer to what Senator Harte said, around the country at the different forums which I addressed on getting people back to work, people said repeatedly that in their small firm all the employees know each other, the management know them and where somebody is ill and has to take time off, that is not a problem for the small employer employing a small number of people. Employees are very anxious to work but there is a problem in some organisations with the way this has evolved. Currently, it is costing us €661 million. This measure will achieve a modest but important saving.
Comment on this
In her helpful explanation of the various supplementary and other schemes, the Minister almost gave an impression that it was a panacea. I do not believe it is. I refer to a case that relates indirectly, and I hope the Minister will forgive me if it should have come up under a further part of the Bill but there is a question of illness involved because the man concerned who has worked consistently since he was a teenager and taken on extra jobs to try to get himself more education and so on, is talking about battling with depression and possible suicide. That is illness. It will have a catastrophic effect on his family if that happens. He stated in a letter that he decided to upskill recently by applying for a Master's course in the University of Limerick. He also stated that he was thrilled to receive a place on his chosen course. He further stated that at last there was some hope but no, he was told by social welfare that he would not be eligible for any supports if he was to take this course. He also stated he was shocked as this was in an area where there are great job prospects and chances are this time next year he would have been one less statistic for the Department to worry about.. He stated that as it is, he is struggling to survive. I wonder what is the position in a situation like that where a man is progressing towards ill health and gets a place in a university, and according to his evidence all supports are withdrawn. Could I send a copy of this letter to the Minister?
Comment on this
Yes. I am accompanied by some eminent officials who are expert in social protection. If the Senator gives us the details we will have a look at the case. I do not want to make a general comment on an individual case but we will be happy to do that.
Comment on this
I apologise for having had to leave the Chamber and perhaps this point has been discussed already. Does the six-day period apply to six working days or six days of a week? A person would work from Monday to Friday, which is five days and the next day is Saturday, therefore, would the six days include those five working days and the following Monday? I have been asked this question. Does the six-day period extend to the second week or only to the first week and include the Saturday? The Minister might clarify that.
Comment on this
I do not want to delay the debate on this issue because that are other important sections with which we need to deal. It is important to put on the record that I do not accept or consider it good enough for Senators or the Minister to point to the supplementary welfare allowance or the urgent needs payments as an alternative. That creates needless more bureaucracy for those involved. Either one is entitled to illness benefit or one is not. The Minister is saying that for six days a person will not be entitled to it but it is disingenuous to the people concerned to say that they can go here or there and get the money. The last thing a person who is sick needs to be told is that they have to work their way through the maze of the social welfare system. They should be able to get illness benefit. That is for what they pay their PRSI. It is not acceptable excuse. It is not that I was ignoring any of the Senators, I just do not accept it as a reason to cut benefit. That is what this is - a crude, cross-cutting measure.
Comment on this
I have every faith that there are alternatives. I am certain of one thing, namely, that if Senator Kelly was sitting where I am now in opposition, he would be opposing this measure.
Comment on this
I do not want to labour the point but north of the Border where the Senator's party has been in government for a long time, the period is 28 weeks. All I am saying is that this is a very modest extension. In the Netherlands it is two years and in the UK it is 28 weeks. The conditionality applying has become much tougher, as I am sure the Senator knows from his colleagues in government in the North. We have a very generous sick pay arrangement. We have very generous rates of payment, significantly in excess of anything in Newry, Belfast or Derry. We are a country where understandably all of the parties emphasise a compassionate and generous social welfare system but it is a system that has to be paid out of the taxation of everybody who is in work and their PRSI contributions. We have had an unprecedented collapse of our banks. We have to fund savings and find savings in the system while maintaining the integrity of its core base. In the jurisdiction in which the Senator's party has been in power for a long period of time, his party could have emphasised reforms in this area but it has been happy to stay with 28 weeks. I have never heard it say a word against it. Not only that, but I have spoken to employers in the North who support the Senator's party and they have told me they do not have a problem with 28 weeks because they consider that it assists the efficiency of the management by employers of problems relating to illnesses.
I offer that as an observation. We are doing this in a considered way. We are providing a backdrop for people who are in need of supplementary welfare assistance. That is an infinitely better situation than it is north of the Border with 28 weeks.
Comment on this
I want to make one point on this issue. As we make progress through the various sections, I am sure the Minister will refer to the position north of the Border on more than one occasion. She made the point that these rates are set in the United Kingdom. It is unfortunate that the North is still part of the United Kingdom and that these rates are set by-----
Comment on this
The poor Queen is at fault again. It is all her fault.
Comment on this
I find it amazing that I can sit here and listen to Senators from the Labour Party and the Minister without interrupting them, but they do not seem to be able to show me the same respect. The point I am making is that the Assembly in the North does not have the power to change what the Minister has been talking about.
Comment on this
Given that the rates are set by Westminster, perhaps she can explain how they might be changed by Sinn Féin or any party that is in government in the North. If we continue to have that debate, we will get sidetracked away from the real issue we are discussing here, namely, a Bill that will come into effect in this State and will affect people in this State. We should do the people who live here the courtesy of dealing with the issues that affect them. Our job and our responsibility is to deal with those matters, rather than pointing to the North as the Minister is continuing to do. No party in the North, including her sister party, the SDLP, has any hand, act or part in the issues to which she is pointing.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
Senators Mooney, Cullinane, van Turnhout and Zappone have said they wish to oppose this section.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil is strongly opposed to section 5. For the second year in a row, working mothers have been targeted for huge cuts in maternity benefit. Last year, the payment was taxed for the first time with the result that many women lost an incredible €2,700 over the course of one maternity leave period of 26 weeks. In this Bill, the payment is being cut by €32 per week for over 90% of claimants. Between budget 2013 and budget 2014, new mothers will have been hit for an astonishing €3,500. These are women who have worked and paid PRSI - it is a PRSI payment - so they have paid their social insurance. As the Minister pointed out earlier, it is one of the few payments that is available to self-employed women on the self-employed stamp. These are people who have worked and made their PRSI contributions. It is an incredibly expensive time in family life. Having infants is extremely expensive in terms of all the additional costs put on families. Now they are being hit for €3,500.
It is a savage cut. The National Women's Council described it as anti-women and anti-family while Barnardos described it as anti-parenting, callous and unsupportive. It was one of the worst cuts to target young mothers in this budget and the previous one. Many women simply will not be able to afford to take the full six months of paid maternity leave and will be forced to return to work early, which is bad not only for themselves, but also for their children. In terms of child care provision, the early years strategy and where we are trying to go in terms of prioritising investment in children at the youngest possible age, the first year is crucial. Ireland only has six months paid maternity leave when best practice internationally is to pay a year so that women can spend the crucial first year at home with their children. Not only do we only pay for the six-month period, we will now make it even harder for women to take that period.
Some women will be hit harder than others. Public sector employees will not be hit at all because the State will pick up the tab so female civil or public servants at least have some comfort in knowing that they will still get their full maternity pay when they are out on leave. A total of 75% of large companies pay top ups to ensure their female staff are able to get their full pay while on maternity leave. The number of companies doing this even among our largest employers has dropped considerably. Some surveys show it has dropped by 25% since 2008 because companies are cutting back in this area due to other financial pressures. In respect of women who work in small companies, only one quarter of SMEs pay top-up maternity pay so the majority of women who are in low-income employment or who work for small companies will not get any top ups so they will struggle financially as a result of these cuts.
It is crazy that this group is singled out in such a savage way by the Government. The Minister made the point about protecting core rates in all the budget commentary and in our earlier debate today. That is fine but I do not think there is any group that has not been cut for other ancillary payments at this stage. How can the Minister say that core payments to women on maternity leave have been protected when they have been cut by €3,500? It is an incredible cut that is really unfair, which is why we are opposing this section. I appeal to the Minister to look at it again because it is really savage. Over 45,000 women will be affected between last year's cut on the taxation side and this year's cut in payment. It is crazy to cut it by that amount.
Comment on this
I echo and agree with everything Senator Power said. I spoke about this on Second Stage yesterday so I will not repeat myself but I am concerned because I know part of the narrative is that the payment is going up for some people while it is going down for others. The payment is going down for 95% while it is going up for 5%.
Ms Orla O'Connor of the National Women's Council said a reduction of maternity benefit will force many women to go back to work earlier than they wish to. This is not in the best interests of women, their children or society as a whole. Senator Power has clearly outlined that some employers pay a top-up payment to women on maternity leave. In this case the employer may take a financial hit but some will not choose to take such a hit. We may see that significant classes and types of job will be directly cut by this reduction. Ms Tanya Ward of the Children's Rights Alliance has stated that Ireland is currently in the middle of a baby boom and to reduce maternity benefit at this time is economically counterproductive, counter-intuitive and will discourage women from having babies.
The difficulty is that the taxation measure came into effect from 1 July 2013, so it is beginning to hit now. That figure of €3,500 combined with this cut and the taxation measure sends out a damaging signal to women. I would like to see Ireland move to a combined system of maternity and paternity leave. In that way we could bring about greater gender equality because employers would regard men and women in the same way. However, it is a regressive step to reduce the amount.
It is not just NGOs who are warning about this. IBEC has also warned that some companies may have to review their maternity benefits as a result. Top-up payments to bring salaries up to normal levels during maternity leave are standard practice in most companies. For example, IBEC's head of HR development, Ms Mary Connaughton, said the change could cost the typical large employer with 12 employees on maternity leave an extra €10,000 a year. That is something they would have to consider. That is why I have tabled an amendment to oppose these cuts.
Comment on this
I also spoke against this section on Second Stage and indicated that I would oppose it on Committee Stage. The Minister will be aware of my party's opposition to this measure. The latest cut to maternity benefit comes on the back of reduced maternity benefits dating from 1 July this year. As the Minister knows, they were subject to tax. The majority of maternity benefit recipients will now see their weekly payment cut by €32, which is a significant amount. It amounts to a cut of €832 over their six months leave.
For many new mothers maternity benefit is their only income during that time. Other Senators have spoken about mothers who are fortunate enough to have their maternity benefit supplemented by their employers. However, the cumulative impact of this Government's cut and the tax measure could see the benefit shrink by as much as €126, which is a potential loss of up to €3,276. In a written response to my party, Barnardos described this cut as anti-parenting, callous and unsupportive. That was that charity's view of this cut. Barnardos also pointed out that Ireland lags behind many EU countries in only offering six months maternity leave. We still have no paid paternity leave, which is also a problem. All of this will exacerbate the financial pressures on women. It will unfortunately force more women back to work earlier than they want to, when they wish to be with their children and look after them as much as they possibly can.
I would like to read some e-mails I have received from constituents. I am sure the Minister has also received them. Their views reflect how this cut will impact upon them. Public representatives can give their views which may be interpreted by the Minister as being political. It does no harm to remind ourselves of how these cuts impact on people out in the real world.
One lady told me that the recent cut to maternity benefit, following as it does so closely behind the taxation of this benefit that came into play in July, can be interpreted in only one way: "You don't want working women to have families." She continued: "I have been in full-time tax-paying employment since I was 19 years old, so I have now been working almost half my life. I am the only source of income in my family as my husband has been unable to find employment and we are not in receipt of any social welfare benefit. I oppose this cut."
Another person wrote: "Although the HSE publicly states that babies should be breastfed exclusively for six months, most women have to return to work somewhere around the baby's fifth month. Maternity leave must be taken at 38 weeks at the latest, and 37 to 42 weeks is a normal term. The HSE also encourages continued breastfeeding for two years in line with World Health Organization guidelines, but there is no support in legislation beyond six months. If you want healthy future taxpayers, you need to rethink your fiscal policies."
Another lady wrote: "Before the benefit was taxed, some of us were able to save a bit so that we could avail of some unpaid leave to extend the time at home. After the tax, maybe some of us could beg or borrow enough to do that, but after this latest budget many families will struggle to survive the six months paid leave." The final e-mail states: "We have one son born before the cuts, and it has been a major financial struggle so I can't possibly see how we could have another with these cuts."
That gives a flavour of the hundreds of e-mails I got. I am sure all Senators have received them on this issue.
Comment on this
I can submit the e-mails to the Minister so that she will see them. If those Senators did not get them, people may have felt they were wasting their time lobbying Government representatives. We certainly got the e-mails, however, and I can forward them to the Minister. I am sure she got them also.
This is another cut that will impact on working mothers. It is wrong and I oppose it. I will be voting against the section.
Comment on this
In the Minister's response, she might indicate the level of saving her Department will generate from this specific change.
Comment on this
I will give Senators some background on this matter. I will start with what the Department is spending in this area. In 2005, which is roughly the period when the boom began, the expenditure by the Department on maternity benefit was €132 million. To emphasise the increase in payments that occurred after the boom, expenditure on maternity benefits in 2012 had risen to €303 million. One of the difficulties I have had in framing the budget is that during the boom the number of recipients for all the different social welfare schemes went up hugely. When the crash happened, as Senator Norris said earlier, that climbed even more because 250,000 jobs were lost.
As Minister, I am trying to maintain a social welfare system which is strongly supportive, but savings have to be made in certain areas. I was asked to prioritise child benefit in particular this year. Women who have had a baby receive child benefit immediately, which is an additional €130 per month.
Even after this reduction, maternity benefit payments in Ireland are among the highest in Europe. In most of Europe, including Britain and Northern Ireland, the vast bulk of maternity benefit payments are paid by employers in the same context as the sick pay issues we discussed on the last amendment. I pondered long and hard over making any reduction in social welfare for any category of people. I made very difficult decisions but we are trying to maintain the integrity of the social welfare system.
As to the shortfall in the Social Insurance Fund, expenditure more than doubled in the period in question. I do not contest Senators' remarks on the importance of good, paid maternity arrangements for mothers, fathers and, in particular, children. Our child benefit rate of €130 per month from the moment of the child's birth represents a significant payment, well in excess of many of our European neighbours, including our nearest neighbour and north of the Border.
I take issue with some of the comments of Senators. Compared internationally, we provide relatively generous maternity leave entitlements, currently at 42 weeks comprising 26 weeks of paid leave and a further 16 weeks of unpaid leave. This reflects one of the highest birth rates in Europe and a relatively high level of participation by women in the labour force. The 26-week duration is preserved in the budget. As a mother, I know how important that time is for families.
I accept Senator Power's statement on breast feeding. I strongly support breast feeding. Our maternity services should encourage it further, but that is probably a different issue.
Comment on this
Under European legislation, we are required to provide 14 weeks, but we provide 26 paid weeks. In the Netherlands and France, for example, only 16 weeks of maternity benefit is paid. This shows how good Ireland is. Sometimes, we undersell the strength of our agreed framework of social protection among all parties and none. As a country, we can be proud of it.
These savings are important. The people in receipt of the lowest levels of maternity benefit comprise a relatively small group, but they were identified as being in particular need of support, for example, people without full insurance cover or with relatively few hours of work or atypical arrangements and, therefore, who do not qualify. Their rate is being increased from €217 to €230.
I have some details on other countries. The rate in France is 16 weeks, comprising six weeks before confinement and ten weeks after. This is what France's public social insurance covers, although many of its employers pay in full. In France, the social insurance system is set up in an independent way. In Germany, the period is 14 weeks at €13 per day from social insurance, amounting to a payment of approximately €90 per week. Contrast this with our rate of €230.
Sufficient credit has not been given in this discussion to all of those employers who pay full wages to staff on maternity leave. Employers in Ireland have a good record in this respect. It is important that this be recognised. It can be more of a burden for smaller employers, but we have employers with a strong sense of responsibility. Our public sector probably has the most generous regime of maternity leave and support for parents of any country in Europe. This is done at significant cost, but we try to be family friendly through our social insurance system.
In the UK, including north of the Border, people receive €136 per week. Forgive me for comparing rates, as our situation is the most important issue, but we are a small, competitive economy that is maintaining comparatively positive rates of social protection in the teeth of difficulties imposed on the fund by an historic financial crisis.
Senator Bradford asked about this year's savings. They are in the order of €30 million, or €36 million in a full year. I hope that this information is helpful to Senators. Many of our employers strongly support their staff who are on maternity leave. I am happy to say that this is one of the best supportive situations for employees. Our payment amounts to €230 per week.
Senator Cullinane and others referred to a tax situation. In many cases, the principle adopted in the reform of social welfare is that social welfare payments should be subject to taxation in the same way that payment from employment is subject to taxation. One pays tax if one's income gives rise to a taxable income tax charge. Under the reform, all flows of income, including social welfare payments, are treated the same way for tax purposes. In fact, our system had an anomaly. Some people on maternity leave were being fully paid by their employers while also receiving maternity benefit payments, which were not subject to tax. They had an advantage over people in work who paid tax on all of their earnings. During the time of the previous Government, the Commission on Taxation recommended that this anomaly be rectified.
As the House knows, we are under the gaze of all sorts of interlocutors who want us to adopt the reforms recommended internally, for example, by the commission in approximately 2009. The Minister for Finance put this provision in place last year. I assure Senator Cullinane that its impact on low-income people is very limited, as many of our employers top up their employees' maternity entitlements to or nearly to their full salary rates. This is a particular feature of the Irish system.
We pay maternity benefit for 26 weeks whereas countries such as France and the Netherlands only pay for 16 weeks and the EU requirement is 14 weeks. I am happy to say that we have maintained the number of weeks. It should also be borne in mind that expenditure in this regard has increased from €132 million in 2005 to €303 million in 2012. From these figures, Senators can see the expenditure pressure on the Department.
Comment on this
I applaud the Minister for her comments following my colleague, Senator Power's contribution on breast feeding. They say that men should not engage in this debate, but it is a wider national health issue.
Comment on this
I fully support this concept. My wife breast fed all of our children and I understood from my late mother that I was also breast fed, as were all of her children.
Comment on this
That is why the Senator is so pink and healthy.
Comment on this
Perhaps that is the reason.
It obviously had some beneficial affect on my health in the long term, thankfully, and it will continue. Fewer than 50% of mothers in Ireland breast feed in the immediate days after birth. In the UK, which is our nearest comparator, the average is almost 80%. Anything that can be done by the Minister, as a woman and as head of a Department which deals with a huge cohort of young married women, to actively assist those bodies trying to encourage breast feeding is welcome. I do not know the reason so few women breast feed. Perhaps it is a cultural thing. I do not know the reason Ireland, which one would imagine to be a leader in this field, is not so. Anything that can be done in this regard by the hospitals or the Minister's Department is to be welcomed. I applaud the Minister for raising the issue.
Comment on this
I am sure the Leas-Chathaoirleach spent a long time thinking up that one. I take his point.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for her clarification. A saving of €36 million is a significant sum. It is difficult for any Minister in a pressing economic environment to find such a saving. One of the arguments that can be made in support of this measure is the introduction of free GP care for under fives, which should be of assistance to the mothers financially disadvantaged to the tune of €36 million. I am sure much thought has gone into this proposal and that the Minister is in some instances having to rob Peter to pay Paul and vice versa. Her choices are difficult. I do not envy her the task.
The Minister referred earlier to various reports and recommendations and comparisons with Europe. I agree with her that we sometimes flail ourself a little too strongly. We hear much about the Swedish, Finnish and other models, in respect of which everything is supposed to be perfect. The same is said about the Canadian, Australian and Dutch health insurance models. They are all marvellous until one examines them in detail and finds the starting point should be elsewhere.
I appreciate the reason the Minister must introduce these measures. It is hoped that over the next 12 months she will have an opportunity to engage in a more in-depth reform of the system. While many reports on the issue have been published, it is difficult to pick and choose. It must be within the Minister's capacity to secure enormous savings within her Department from an administrative perspective. I accept we will have further opportunity to speak more generally on the forthcoming social welfare Bill. We must look at how real savings in administration can be made, perhaps by way of reduction in some of the schemes via means testing and so on. I look forward to participating in that process.
I thank the Minister for defending what I know she and I always find difficult enough to defend. If times were better, we would be complaining that not enough of an increase was being given. None of us can be happy with measures which cost women, families and children. However, we must be realistic in terms of the times in which we live. If I were to propose that the Minister not introduce this measure she would be entitled to ask me from where would she get the saving required. Perhaps at some stage she will reflect on the suggestion made in the Dáil by Deputy Denis Naughten, namely, that approximately €100 million could be saved if we moved to a system of payment of child benefit based on school attendance, with obvious adjustments in respect of children who, owing to illness or otherwise, are not in a position to attend school. As I understand it, that such a scheme would save €100 million appears to stand up. No child in this country would be disadvantaged. Child benefit would not be paid in respect of children who do not attend school in this country. We will have to start considering proposals which could result in savings and no child being disadvantaged. I do not expect the Minister to respond now to that issue. It is perhaps one for ongoing dialogue.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned arrangements in other countries. I could provide a list of other countries in which there are preferential arrangements in relation to maternity and paternity benefits. I want the record to show that Ireland is not a leader in the world in respect of maternity benefits and leave.
Comment on this
Question put
Do you agree with this result?
The approach of the Department and the Minister to social welfare is characterised by a complete and utter lack of fairness and by targeting certain groups for disproportionate hits to their income. They have done this with maternity benefit and adoptive benefit. They have picked out groups and said, "We can get a lump out of them and we can say then that we have kept our promise not to cut social welfare rates by not technically cutting a broad swathe of recipients". However, at the same time, they are hurting categories of people who are in a minority but who could be in a difficult position. For instance, it could be mothers or the elderly who use telephones or adoptive parents who are affected by this section. They have been subject to particularly harsh cuts. Benefits such as the disability allowance or the bereavement grant are not paid out of the goodness of the Minister's heart; they are paid for by recipients who have accumulated stamps over the years. They are entitled to these benefits because they have been promised them and they have paid for them. They have a contract with the Department. These are not social assistance payments that the Minister or the Government of the day decide to dish out. There is a solemn contract between the State and the citizen. The citizen pays a price for the performance of the contract but that is being disregarded by the Minister as she slashes benefits. A great deal has been said about the actions of the previous Government but it adopted a simple approach whereby everybody paid a contribution. Those who could pay most paid most and those who could pay least paid the least. We did not pick out any group for heavy cuts apart from the wealthiest who were subject to higher tax and USC charges. The Minister has decided not to target the rich at all.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil cut the Christmas bonus.
Comment on this
The Christmas bonus equated to a 2% cut in social welfare payments at the time while the wealthiest civil servants were subject to double digit percentage pay cuts and higher earners had to pay much more tax. There was a fairness across society. People were hurt and they had to pay more but we did not target particular groups. The Labour Party is aware of this. We heard about the loaves and fishes yesterday. That is not the case in this instance because the Government is not bereft of resources unlike our Lord who conducted the miracle of the loaves and fishes and fed all the people. This is a reference to a comment by a Labour Party Senator yesterday. I do not criticise him personally because I compliment him on the motif but in that example everybody was treated fairly. The Labour Party is not doing that. It is picking out groups to target unfairly and hoping there will not be enough people to push back against the Government. However, groups have been hit, one of which is adoptive parents. This is also related to the maternity benefit cut as well. The Labour Party seems to have a thing against young families. It is supposed to be the party that represents them. It has not done so and it has allowed the rich to get away scot free. They can do what they like. They are the entrepreneurs and go getters to whom the party aspires while everyone else gets left behind. People are struggling with their mortgages and cannot afford to pay for funerals while pregnant women are struggling with families, trying to pay the bills the Minister is imposing on them.
Everybody would understand that she has a job to do with the troika if she did it fairly but the ESRI studies have consistently said that she has decided to do the job unfairly. That is mainly because she has been unable to tackle the influence of Fine Gael, which is putting out a line that the Labour Party is buying into that the Minister is dealing with scroungers on social welfare. The benefit covered by this section is for working people who have paid into a benefit scheme and because private sector companies generally cannot provide these services, the State has done so. The same applies to maternity benefit. The recipients are not scroungers; they are contributors to society. They receive benefits in return for the payments they make to the Exchequer and the Social Insurance Fund as the insurance need arises. This is a particularly vicious cut which is related to section 5 and it deserves to be opposed. It highlights the targeting of groups by this Labour Party Minister.
Comment on this
I will not rehearse the discussion we had on section 5 but I endorse it and it is related to this issue. Has the Minister given consideration to providing surrogacy leave? The Equality Authority has advised on this; I refer to the Ms Z case. A teacher with a rare medical condition preventing her from carrying a pregnancy, although she had healthy ovaries, arranged for a surrogate to give birth to herself and her husband's genetic child using IVF. The child was born in April 2010. The woman applied to the Department of Education and Skills for paid maternity leave and was refused. She was offered unpaid parental leave by her employers. She took a case to the Equality Tribunal and it ended up before the European Court of Justice. One of the court's advocate generals suggested that since adoptive parents are entitled to maternity leave under EU law, the national courts could assess whether it is illegal to apply different rules to adoptive parents and parents through surrogacy while another advocate general said that where surrogacy is allowed in a country, the mother taking care of the baby was entitled to leave to ensure the unhindered development of the mother-child relationship. The Equality Authority has advised the Minister for Justice and Equality to provide support to the small number of families availing of surrogacy similar to that provided to adoptive parents. Has that been considered?
Comment on this
The previous contribution shows what a complex area we are moving into in terms of human reproduction, which is outside the scope of the Bill. I hope the Government will address that issue because it has been left on the long finger for too long and a series of anomalous cases have arisen. I agree with some of what has been said but I do not agree with the party spin because the Government is in a difficult position. The Minister has made difficult choices. She has halved the demands that were made on her. Choices have to be made. They are awful and I would not want to make them but then I would not have started from there because the entire system should be pulled down. Unfortunately, this is what one gets with capitalism. This is where it leads. The financial system and everything else should be pulled down and the rights and welfare of people should be given primacy. I do not see any sign of that happening across Europe. We are in this situation and starting at the ideological position the Minister now does because there is little socialism around anywhere nowadays. However, I will ignore that aspect of the debate. This is not a time for point scoring. There are serious welfare issues because we are now at the point where it is about survival for people in this country.
I have one technical question.
The relevant subsection states, in respect of adoptive benefit, that the rate of payment will be "80 per cent of the reckonable weekly earnings, reckonable weekly emoluments or reckonable weekly income, as the case may be, of the woman to whom the benefit is payable in the income tax year prescribed for the purposes of this section". My concern here relates to the implications of this provision for gay and-or single men who have adopted a child. In the context of a specific reference to "the woman", are we to take it that they are they not being given any consideration at all? After the adjustments that I gather will be made, wisely and in the interests of the welfare of children, by the Minister for Justice and Equality, Deputy Alan Shatter - these adjustments might even come about prior to the introduction of same-sex marriage; if such is introduced, as I hope it will be - we could have a situation where two men have adopted a child. In that context, will the Minister consider changing "woman" to "person"?
Comment on this
This is an important section which reflects the genuine effort by the Minister to deal with what Senator David Norris rightly described as an extremely difficult situation. I would not necessarily disagree with the Senator when he attributes the difficulty to capitalism. We had a right-wing government in this country for 14 years and a particularly right-wing Administration for nine of those years. It was, however, a rather warped version of right-wing government in a context where, for instance, two year olds were being allocated a back to school clothing and footwear allowance. That was bizarre. How could anybody justify a system where parents were receiving a back to school allowance on behalf of their two year olds?
Comment on this
Should that allowance be withdrawn in all cases then? Is that what Senator Conway is saying?
Comment on this
I find it quite difficult to take on board lectures on this issue from Fianna Fáil Senators when such bizarre situations were permitted to arise under previous Administrations. I have given only one example of the types of anomalies that arose. At the same time, we have cases such as the 62 year old man who came to my office recently who, because his wife is a public servant and is still working, is not entitled to any type of benefit on his own account and does not qualify for any type of community employment scheme. He is at home tearing his hair out. I appeal to the Minister to seek to create a system where energetic, fit and healthy people aged 60 and over who want to contribute to society will have an opportunity to upskill. People might ask what the point of that is for older people-----
Comment on this
No, what I am saying is extremely relevant.
Comment on this
I have heard a great deal already that was not relevant, but there was no ruling from the Chair in those instances. I tend not to go off the point very much, and this is an extremely important point.
Comment on this
In response to Senator Thomas Byrne - I seem to recall he was not here for the discussion on the previous section - we have had very difficult decisions to make in regard to the social welfare budget. My Department's allocation stands at around the €20 billion mark, which is the highest spend of any Department. In 2005 - just as the boom was getting boomier, as a former Taoiseach described it - expenditure on maternity benefit was €132 million. By last year, four years into the most catastrophic collapse our economy has ever experienced, that expenditure had risen to €303 million. The measure in this Bill seeks to save €30 million under this heading in one year. Although it was indeed a difficult choice, we are standardising the maternity payment at €202 per week, which is among the highest level in Europe. People should not always be seeking to put Ireland down.
Comment on this
I am not putting Ireland down by standing up for the young mothers the Minister is targeting.
Comment on this
When Senator Thomas Byrne was in the other House and in committees, I recall that he was a great defender of everything to do with the banks that ruined this country.
Comment on this
Senator Byrne should have some manners and stop interrupting the Minister.
Comment on this
The Senator was a great defender of the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister has made a statement that I was a great defender in the Dáil of the banks. If she is making allegations like that, she should supply references from the Official Report.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that spending on maternity payments rose from €132 million at the beginning of the boom to €303 million in 2012. This was achieved in the teeth of the most difficult economic situation this country has ever faced, brought about by the collapse of the banks. Senator Byrne's party was very much closely involved in that terribly unfortunate collapse. I know he and his fellow party members did not want it to happen, but it did happen and it happened on their watch.
I had difficult choices to make in this budget. Any reduction in any element of social welfare provision is a difficult choice to make. This particular measure will give a modest saving of €30 million. Bear in mind, however, that somebody who has a baby, by either adoption or birth, will receive a child benefit payment of €130 per month, which I am happy to say is among the highest in Europe. In addition, in this budget we are finally providing for the roll-out next year and the following year of free GP care to families with children aged under five. In other words, there are benefits in this budget for families with children.
The suggestion that any party in the Oireachtas does not have great concern for families with children is a false charge. In light of the loss of 250,000 jobs in this country, we have done very well to maintain the social security system which all parties value. The two parties of government have sought to preserve that system in accordance with the advice I received from the various organisations, all of which asked me to prioritise child benefit this year. I did so and, in addition, the Government also extended medical care arrangements and doctor cards for children under five years of age. There are advances in this budget as well as difficulties.
As I said, I remember Senator Byrne's contributions in the Dáil-----
Comment on this
I made no contribution defending the banks. None whatsoever.
Comment on this
Given the Senator's general contributions in the Dáil in strong support of the former Minister for Finance, the late Brian Lenihan,-----
Comment on this
I supported him 100%. We were all in the front row at his funeral, Minister.
Comment on this
-----he would surely concede that-----
Comment on this
I know that. I remember the Senator supporting the late Minister and everything he did.
Comment on this
I gave him every support he needed in the teeth of vicious opposition from the Minister.
Comment on this
The bank guarantee was the wrong decision and cost the country an awful lot of money. Senator Byrne might have made that choice in good faith-----
Comment on this
Why did the Minister support the guarantee if it was the wrong decision?
Comment on this
She can talk out of both sides of her mouth for as long as she wants, but the question remains as to why she, in government, is supporting the guarantee if she thinks it is wrong?
Comment on this
Senators, please. Will the Minister confine herself to comment on the section under discussion?
Comment on this
Senator David Norris asked a very important question which I am happy to answer. Adoptive benefit is a very small scheme simply because the number of children adopted in this country is very small. It is a weekly payment made to an adopting employed or self-employed mother or single male who adopts a child and who meets the PRSI condition. That is set out in the primary legislation. I personally know a number of single people, both men and women, who have adopted children and been eligible for adoptive benefit since the time in the early 1990s when that developed as a practice.
Senators van Turnhout and Norris raised the surrogacy issue. The Minister for Justice and Equality brought a working paper before the Cabinet yesterday on legislative changes which will be made in respect of families and children. Medical technology is advancing in respect of surrogacy and various forms of assisted reproduction, and the law in Ireland needs to change. The Government is committed to making those changes. The Government agreed yesterday to put to the people a referendum on same-sex marriage. In that context, it will be necessary to introduce certain legal changes on adoption provisions as they affect same-sex couples. That legislation will be brought forward in due course by the Minister. There are difficult issues in respect of surrogacy because poor women in certain countries are being used in surrogacy arrangements. That issue must be addressed. The arrangement raised by Senator van Turnhout is quite different to that. The Department inherited that case from the previous Administration, but with the addressing of surrogacy issues in the proposed legislation, I would hope that we will be able to come to an arrangement for that case. However, there are still important issues with some surrogacy practices in some countries that we need to address.
Comment on this
The Minister made an allegation that I defended the banks. When I asked her to substantiate that, it boiled down to a defence of Brian Lenihan as Minister for Finance. I am very proud that I defended and supported him at the hour of his need and at the hour of this country's need.
Comment on this
I am very proud of it. If I could have given him more support, I would have been delighted to do so. I only wish the Minister and colleagues when in opposition would have given him the same sort of support. None of them is fit to lace his boots.
Comment on this
I ask that the Senator withdraw that remark immediately.
Comment on this
The Labour Party opposed 3% of the bank guarantee which relates to subordinated debt. None of that was paid on foot of the guarantee, so its objections to the bank guarantee are irrelevant.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I call on Senator Byrne to withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
I wish to continue on the section.
Comment on this
As my former, deceased colleague would have enunciated, cuts had to be made. I accept that cuts have to be made by this Government. My fundamental difficulty with what the Government is doing is that the Minister is saying it is only €30 million and so is a modest cut, but it has a disproportionate impact on certain sectors of society. There is not a whole lot to say, other than to point out that the ESRI and other such bodies acknowledged this as well. Instead of trying to spread it out as much as possible, there is a targeting that is going on.
Maternity benefit is increasing because of a baby boom. It is increasing because more people are paying into social insurance. This is not social security or social welfare; this is largely a social insurance scheme. People who are working have paid in to receive it. That is why there is more maternity benefit being paid out. It is not because the State has become more generous, but because more people have fulfilled the conditions required, which is to say that there has been a baby boom in this country. That is not a point of credit. The Minister is claiming credit for somehow not touching child benefit. She has broken her promise twice since the last election, when she had the figures that my former colleague, my deceased colleague Brian Lenihan would have given to her. His banking strategy has been continued by this Government. It has been enhanced and developed, but it has continued and there has not been a change to it.
Comment on this
I am glad of the acknowledgement that neither I nor my colleagues are fit enough to lick other people's shoes. I do not care who they are; shoe licking is not one of my habits and I do not regard as something that would be fitting for a man of my age. I remember Mr. Lenihan well. He was a good friend, a thoroughly decent man, highly intelligent, an excellent speaker, and very engaging. He made some terrible mistakes under strain. That is human. He is a figure of tragedy in my opinion. He was courageous, but I think he should be left out of the equation at the moment.
Comment on this
I would ask that the Acting Chairman rule on that matter. This has gone way off the point.
Comment on this
On a point of order, it was the Minister who brought Mr. Brian Lenihan's name into this debate.
Comment on this
Ruling on this is a pointless exercise. I remember in this House and in the other House Fine Gael supporting all the Government's daft measures with alacrity. Why do we in Ireland always have this background look? The short story writer Frank O'Connor used always complain about it. We should look to the future and make it better, however different our circumstances are now.
The Minister indicated that things were changing, that legislation on adoption would be introduced and so on, and this would cater for same-sex people. I notice that the section amends the principal Act, so we actually are instituting in law that only a woman can receive this. I wonder if it would not be timely to accept suggesting "person", which would be gender neutral, and then refer to "he-she". It may only be a small number of people and families involved, but each human situation has its own great pressures. I think we should make it neutral because it does not just deal with women. Of course it is the women who give birth. It is one of the many unique and wonderful things about women. I am not suggesting that men are desperately anxious to go through that process anyway. As the situation becomes more sophisticated and more complex, we will be facing many further problems. Since there are men who are adopting, I wonder if they should not be taken into account in this Bill, because it purports to amend the principal Act to which the Minister referred and which appeared to cater for men.
Comment on this
I endorse what the Minister said about surrogacy. The case I was citing to her is just one case, but we know there are other cases. I welcome the briefing note that we received on the Family Relationships and Children Bill 2013. I look forward to it being debated in this House.
Comment on this
I have consulted our legal experts and I would like to confirm to Senator Norris that the definition of an adopting parent under section 60 of the Act does include a single man. Obviously the primary references are to women, because it is a maternity for adoptive parents. However, the section specifies that this includes a man who is a single parent who is adopting.
Comment on this
It does not seem to reflect that in this legislation. It will be a comparatively simple matter to amend it, but it refers specifically and exclusively to "woman".
Comment on this
An adopting parent for adoptive benefit includes - this would be in the definition sections and in the arrangements in respect of the Act - a man in whose care a child is placed for adoption, including a foreign adoption, where the woman in whose care the child has been, or is to be placed, has died, or a man in whose sole care a child has been placed for adoption. That is the single male to which I referred and that is in the primary legislation. I can get a more comprehensive reply for the Senator and I will write to him. I understand that in scrutinising the Bill he has identified that, but the principal Act actually defines an adopting parent and that does include a single male.
The principal Act defines an adopting parent and that does include a single male.
Comment on this
I oppose the section and would like to hear the Minister's comments on it.
Comment on this
We dealt with this issue when dealing with section 4 which covered very similar points. It would not be helpful for any of us to re-hash the arguments. The Minister is aware of my position and that we oppose this section.
Comment on this
I raised tangentially a matter and I would like to express my gratitude to the Minister and her advisers for taking that matter on board. It included an element of the jobseeker's situation. Any reductions or constrictions are regrettable.
Comment on this
I just wanted to put on the record that the Minister and her advisers were very helpful in that instance.
Comment on this
This section is opposed by Senators Mooney and Cullinane. I call Senator Mooney to speak.
Comment on this
We discussed this matter on Second Stage in some detail, in respect of the withdrawal of the bereavement grant. There have been several submissions from various sources which are opposed to this Bill, not least the Irish Senior Citizens Parliament. I have already made the case for our opposition to this measure on Second Stage.
Comment on this
I also made this argument on Second Stage. The bereavement grant was only a small assistance to bereaved families towards the cost of funerals. It is for workers who have a solid contributions record which goes back to a point that many of us made when we read through this Bill, that most of these cuts affect people who pay into the social insurance fund, through their pay related social insurance, PRSI, and more recently, the universal social charge. They then expect to have some sort of social insurance protection at the other end. This is another example of people with solid contribution records being subject to this cut.
The Irish Association of Funeral Directors is on record as saying that the average cost of a funeral across the State is €4,000, possibly higher in Dublin and some other areas. The grant was a small contribution from the State to help families and this cut will have an impact on many families for that reason. Given that people pay into and provide for this grant this cut should not be implemented.
Comment on this
The biggest problem with the bereavement grant that existed until now was that it was a universal payment. People who had very generous pensions and had accumulated significant resources qualified for the funeral grant. It is important to point out that even today if somebody is in financial difficulty they can go to their community welfare officer and get a payment similar to the funeral grant. I oppose universal payments, whatever they are, whether child benefit, medical cards for the under-fives, or bereavement grants because I do not believe they serve the people who need them most. I have already said that we need an overall debate in society on universal payments because they have contributed to where we are today.
We all agree with what Senators Cullinane and Mooney have said in that regard. It is desperate for families to be faced with a bill for €4,000 or €5,000 when a loved one has passed away. I urge the Minister to ensure that community welfare officers are particularly sympathetic to people who find themselves in that situation. Senator Cullinane's points on this issue are well made but there is a better way to do it than the way in which it was done before now. I encourage the Minister to send a circular to community welfare officers urging them to treat people in that situation with sympathy and compassion.
Comment on this
Rituals such as weddings and First Holy Communions and everything else, are getting more and more expensive. People think that they benefit the person who should be the principal object of the ceremony. I am not sure that they do. I have ordered a wicker coffin. It is very nice and cheap.
In these circumstances we need a little bit of levity. I heard on the radio yesterday a piece about, I think, the Emperor Joseph II of Austria-Hungary among whose various inventions was the reusable coffin, the bottom of which had a spring. At the appropriate moment a button could be pushed, the corpse was deposited in the ground and the coffin recycled. There were immense protests in Vienna against this because it was seen as ruining a good party. The old people in the area near me would always save more enthusiastically for their funerals than for their Christmas turkeys but I believe that we should help the living and let the dead look after themselves, if they can.
Comment on this
Listening to Senator Norris I hope that he will not be using his coffin for many years to come.
Comment on this
I would say that is an offer the Senator will pass on.
Comment on this
I am not sure what correlation Senator Norris was making between the reusable coffin and the step that the Minister is taking here.
Comment on this
We all spoke on this issue yesterday and, to be fair to her, the Minister gave a measured response. The difficulty with universal payments is that very wealthy individuals who may not need it get the payment and other people at the bottom of the economic ladder, who are struggling, get the same payment although they might be meeting the same end cost. That is a difficulty that affects the social welfare system in general, whether it be child benefit or any other universal payments. The difficulty is that removing a universal payment has the same effect as giving one because the persons or families who are least well off are hit disproportionately more than the individual who is well off and can afford to take the hit. That is the difficulty that I see in this section.
The Minister said yesterday that there are alternative benefits, through the office of the community welfare officer, such as the exceptional need once-off payment. The difficulty I experience in dealing daily with that payment is that up to a few years ago that payment was available regularly, in other words, if an individual had an exceptional need they went to the social welfare office and were given a payment to meet the exceptional need. Now it is a once-off payment and one cannot have an exceptional need on a regular basis, such as every six months.
Community welfare officers are implementing that approach based on current Government policy. The Minister might address that issue, which was raised here in the context of that payment being used. No one can argue that a bereavement is not an exceptional need but the argument that a payment from the office of the community welfare officer or an exceptional needs payment is there to meet every ill does not hold up because a community welfare officer, on a practical basis, will tell a client that he or she cannot approve any more than one payment at present because of Government policy.
With regard to the other grants the Minister outlined yesterday, she mentioned that a grant of €6,000 was available. While we are aware of such grants, they are exceptionally difficult to obtain. She might outline the qualifying criteria for them.
The Minister said yesterday that there is a need to examine the cost of funerals. Why was that not examined, by way of a review or otherwise, by her Department in advance of bringing in this universal cut which will affect the least well off more disproportionately than the well off? That is where the difficulty arises with this payment, namely, that it is a universal payment that is being withdrawn. Instead of universally withdrawing the payment, could it not have been dealt with in a manner that would have protected the least well off in society? Could a measure not have been introduced in the budget to withdraw the €850 payment for those who can afford burials but to leave it in place for those who cannot afford them? The argument has been made that the money can be obtained through the other two grants but those two grants would have been available in addition in any event.
Comment on this
I am getting confused about this as I believe people do not understand the meaning of a universal payment. By no manner or means is the bereavement grant a universal payment. It is not paid to everybody who suffers a bereavement in this country. It is not paid to people with a lifelong disability or to small farmers who draw farm assist because they do not have the contributions. It is paid only to people with contributions.
Comment on this
It is paid to people with PRSI contributions.
Comment on this
It is certainly not a universal payment.
Second, as I said yesterday, and the Minister might elaborate on this, more than half, if not 60%, of bereavement grant payments have gone into estates and been paid to the beneficiaries. Regardless of whether they were left a big house or a number of properties or savings, they also got the bereavement grant. If we want to have a social welfare system where the least well off get it and those who are well off do not get it - that is what we strive for here every day when Members stand up in this Chamber and say that the least well off should be the ones who receive this type of payment - this is the only way we can do it. An exceptional needs payment grant of up to €2,000 is available which is far more substantial than this grant payment of €850.
I have dealt with this issue day in and day out, as I am sure every Senator has, because we all help the bereaved. Most of the people who have suffered a bereavement that I have helped out did not even know of the existence of this grant. As late as last week when I attended the funeral of a colleague of Deputy Ó Domhnaill, the late Denis Foley, and was standing in the queue with people in the church, they asked me what was this bereavement grant that they were all talking about. People did not even know it existed.
I regret that widows and children who need it will lose out on it, but they will get the exceptional needs grant and it is not a once off payment. I know of people who have received a number of payments for exceptional needs to cover the cost of heating and other costs. Perhaps different rules apply in different parts of the country but some people have got exceptional needs payments more than once. I will leave it to the Minister to elaborate on where the money is going.