We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Bill 2013: Committee Stage

Contributions 1–161 of 483. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Bill 2013
Enacted

No. 83 of 2013 ›

Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Kathleen Lynch, back to the House. She is a very frequent visitor.

Comment on this
Kathleen Lynch Minister of State at the Department of Justice and Equality Labour Party

I propose to delete the definition of "appointer". It is a consequential technical amendment that should have been made in tandem with an amendment made to the definition of "relevant person" on Report Stage in the Dáil. References to "appointer" were deleted from the definition of relevant person and, as such, a definition of "appointer" is no longer required in the general interpretation section.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

This seems to be a fairly technical matter. As I understand it, the word "appointer" has been deleted from the main text of the Bill. Is that correct?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Therefore, there is no need for a definition in the Bill for somebody who does not take part. That is fine. However, I will say this only once to the Minister of State. This whole Bill is dreadful in a sense. I do not blame the Minister of State. I blame the Department and the draftspeople. This is the third or fourth time we have had Government legislation with several hundred Government amendments after it has been passed by the Dáil. I never recall anything like this previously in nearly 30 years in Seanad Éireann. There is always a big rush coming up to Christmas, but I never remember anything like this.

There were more than 300 amendments to the Legal Services Regulation Bill, including amendments to amendments that were made a week previously. It is horrendously bad conduct of business. Here is another one with a couple of hundred Government amendments. I know that some of them just remove one word such as getting rid of "to" in "to appoint". For God's sake, those are such obvious drafting matters that they really should have been taken care of before the Bill was presented to the Dáil. If they were not, surely to God, they should have been amended in Dáil Éireann. However, on the other hand, of course, what a wonderful thing that we managed to preserve Seanad Éireann. Where would the Minister of State be without the Seanad? Where would her 200 and something amendments be? They would be floating around in mid-air and she would have to go back to the Dáil and do all kinds of high jumps and I do not know what else.

I am making a protest on behalf of doing good business. I ask the Minister of State to take it back to the draftspeople and her colleagues and all the rest of it. I see absolutely no reason for this Gadarene rush every single Christmas. That is bad enough, but to have three or four Bills with a couple of hundred Government amendments after being through the Dáil and, in the case of one of the others, through the Seanad and amended in committee to be followed by 300 Report Stage amendments is absolutely unheard of and scandalous.

That is all I shall say on the matter. I feel it very deeply. We should do our business in a proper and business-like manner that allows everybody participate and has the orderly progress of legislation through both Houses of the Oireachtas. I make it clear that I am not pinning personal responsibility on the Minister of State. It is a feature across Departments and seems to particularly hit the Department of Justice and Equality - for what reason I just do not know. I believe this is also a Department of Justice and Equality Bill. This is the third Bill we have had from the Department of Justice and Equality. I rest my case.

Comment on this

Senator David Norris has tabled some good amendments to the Bill. However, I want to approach this matter from the other side. He is saying that if people come with good ideas after a Bill is published, the Minister cannot listen to anything after it is passed in the Dáil, end of story. Having the Seanad leaves the Minister open to accepting good amendments when they come.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Nonsense.

Comment on this

That is a fact and I hope-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is not. Many of the amendments are drafting amendments.

Comment on this

I hope some of the Senator's amendments will be accepted.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are on amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

That is putting the other side of the story that the Minister listens and the drafters have to listen to the Minister.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is all fiction.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 2, 7, 19, 20, 69, 77, 143 to 146, inclusive, 148 and 170 to 193, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

No, it is not.

Comment on this

It is agreed.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is not agreed because how could we possibly deal with that number of amendments. How many are there? Can you count them? It is about 25 amendments.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

All of the amendments are related.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

They are related, but how-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

This is Committee Stage, not Report Stage. The Senator will be given ample time to contribute.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

We are still supposed to discuss them.

Comment on this

May I come in on one amendment?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Are we agreeing to discuss all of them together?

Comment on this
Senators

Agreed.

Comment on this

The Minister of State will speak on behalf of the Government. There is no need for the Senator to-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is it agreed?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

No, it is not.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Okay.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I want to have a vote on the issue.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We cannot have a vote on it.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

What?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We do not want to divide the House on the issue of whether we should discuss a number of amendments that are related.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Therefore, you are separating them now.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

If the House wishes to discuss all of them together, we will have to go with the wishes of the House.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Have you ascertained that the House wishes to do that?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That all of the amendments be discussed-----

Comment on this

Can you clarify something for me? I am a bit of a novice here and perhaps a slow learner. On Committee Stage, is it not still possible, even if amendments are grouped, for someone to speak to a specific amendment, if he or she so wishes?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator can come in and out as often as he wants.

Comment on this

As I said, perhaps I am a slow learner.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have made that case. Is it agreed that all of the amendments may be discussed together? Is Senator David Norris opposing that proposal?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I reserve my position. I will let it go, but it is utterly stupid to have so many amendments being discussed together.

Comment on this

I say to Senator David Norris that this is the Bill on which we have probably consulted the most widely. People in the Visitors Gallery will be conscious of that fact. It was a long time in drafting. It is reasonable to say it is an entirely different Bill from the one with which we started. It does not look anything like it did at the outset and even at this stage there are still amendments to be made. This legislation will affect each and every one of us in whatever position or circumstances we find ourselves at different stages of our lives and I hope it will be to our benefit.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am sure it will, but I would like to make a point.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator cannot come in.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

There is a series of amendments where the word "the" is deleted and "an" is introduced. This should have been obvious from day one in the drafting of the Bill.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator can make that point when he speaks to the amendment.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

There is a rake of amendments to delete the words "to advise" and substitute "advise". Those are things which should have been observed at a much earlier stage.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will the Senator, please, let the Minister of State respond?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am not having hogwash delivered all over me to try to persuade me that this is an appropriate Bill.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will the Senator, please, allow the Minister of State to respond?

Comment on this

There is no need for the Senator to talk about it at all.

Comment on this

In addressing amendments Nos. 2, 7,19 20, 69, 77, 143 to 145, inclusive, 148 and 170 to 193, inclusive, as outlined by the Cathaoirleach, I am proposing a suite of amendments to Part 7 of the Bill which provides for enduring powers of attorney. The provisions on enduring powers of attorney have remained for the most part untouched since the Bill was published in July 2013. Part 7 largely restates the provisions of Part 2 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1996. The proposed amendments are required to align the provisions with the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and current international best practice. The proposed amendments are also required for textual consistency and alignment with the rest of the Bill. The House will see that many of the proposed new sections mirror provisions already in other parts of the Bill.

The amendments will strengthen the safeguards against attorneys acting outside the authority given to them, address potential risks of abuse and exploitation of donors and increase protection for the rights of donors. The proposed amendments provide for attorneys to be accountable and held responsible for their actions. I am proposing to delete sections 50 to 64, inclusive, and replace them with a revised, simplified text and additional sections that provide for more detailed provision in relation to reports by attorneys, complaints against attorneys and offences relating to enduring powers of attorney.

Some of the new sections specify requirements such as notification requirements that would otherwise be left to regulations and were included in Schedules 1 and 2 to the Bill. Thus the main requirements for executing and registering enduring powers of attorney are now contained in primary legislation.

One of the main substantive changes to Part 7 is that the director will not register enduring powers which have been created under the 1996 Act but have yet to be registered. I have received legal advice stating it would not be possible for the director to register these enduring powers under this Bill. They will have to be registered under the 1996 Act by the Office of the Wards of Court, which is the current system. However, the attorneys appointed under these enduring powers and all other powers registered under the 1996 Act will be subject to the new complaints and offences provision I am proposing to insert by way of amendments Nos. 188 and 192. I believe the number of executed but not yet registered enduring powers under the 1996 Act will be small.

Amendment No. 2 revises the definition of "attorney" in line with the amendments to Part 7.

Amendment No. 7 is similar to amendment No. 2 in that it revises the definition of "enduring power of attorney" in line with the proposed amendment to Part 7. It also inserts a definition for "enduring power" under the 1996 Act which is now required as a result of the proposed amendment to Part 7.

Amendments Nos. 19 and 20 propose to delete the cross-references to Part 7 and Schedules 1 and 2. This is to enable jurisdiction for enduring powers of attorney to be transferred from the High Court to the Circuit Court. The proposal to transfer jurisdiction to the Circuit Court is intended to enable cases relating to enduring powers of attorney to have the benefit of the specialist judges who will be dealing with the majority of matters arising under this Bill. It is also intended to reduce costs for applicants in the interests of encouraging more people to draw up enduring powers of attorney. These remain a good means for the person to express his or her will and preference in terms of who should take decisions on his or her behalf if he or she subsequently loses capacity.

Amendment No. 69 clarifies that a co-decision making agreement will be null and void if there is an enduring power of attorney in force, registered either under the Bill's provisions or the 1996 Act.

Amendment No. 77 clarifies that the disqualification of a co-decision maker if he or she has an enduring power of attorney registered in respect of him or her includes enduring powers of attorney registered under the 1996 Act.

Amendments Nos. 143 to 146, inclusive, amend subsections (9) and (10) of section 33 which allow a person who is the subject of an application to be assisted in court by a court friend if he or she is not legally represented or does not have a decision-making assistant, co-decision maker, decision-making representative, attorney, designated health care representative or other person willing to assist him or her with the proceedings. The amendments clarify that the attorney can be appointed under the Bill or under the 1996 Act.

Amendment No. 148 proposes to delete subsection 34(3) which provides that the court cannot make a declaration as to whether a person lacks capacity to make or revoke an enduring power of attorney. This subsection was inserted in the Bill in order to avoid a person having to go to court routinely to get a declaration of capacity in respect of the making or revoking of an enduring power. A statement from a medical professional and another health care professional on the capacity of the donor is deemed sufficient. However, in drafting the new provisions on objections, complaints and offences under Part 7, it became apparent that the court may have to assess the donor’s capacity in order to investigate an objection, complaint or offence and it could not do so if subsection 34(3) remained in the Bill.

Amendment No. 170 inserts a new section 50. The current section 50 is being deleted and replaced by revised text as part of the overall amendment of the enduring powers of attorney provisions. The interpretation section of Part 7 has been streamlined and provides a definition of key terms in the revised sections of Part 7.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I just want to make the point again-----

Comment on this

As this will take a while, might I just-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

An tAire Stáit to conclude.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 171 inserts a new section 51. The new section 51 sets out what is an enduring power of attorney, who may appoint an attorney, what authority can be conferred in an enduring power and how the authority must be conferred. It reflects provisions in sections 52(2) and (5), 54(2) and 55(1) of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. Subsection (2) provides that an enduring power must be conferred in writing in an instrument which is compliant with the other provisions of the Part and regulations made by the Minister for that purpose. Subsection (3) provides that an attorney may, in the instrument creating the enduring power, appoint an alternate attorney should the original attorney die, be disqualified or is no longer able to carry out his or her duties as an attorney.

Subsection (4) provides that the enduring power will not come into force until the donor lacks capacity in one or more of the relevant decisions which are the subject of the power and the instrument that created the power is registered in accordance with new section 61. Subsection (5) equates to section 54(2) of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann and provides that where general authority is conferred by a donor on an attorney in respect of property and affairs, the attorney has the authority to do anything on behalf of the donor that the donor can lawfully do.

Subsection (6) sets out who is suitable for appointment. The attorney must be capable of performing the functions of attorney as specified in the enduring power of attorney.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

On a point of order, I think this section is grammatically inappropriate. The Minister of State actually said "capable of". In the amendment I have it reads that a person is suitable for appointment as an attorney if he or she is "able of performing". That is nonsense.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is not a point of order. The Senator can amend the wording on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Is capable of-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is capable of being amended on Report Stage.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am saying there is a mistake in the amendment. It is a technical mistake. I always thought that was covered by a point of order.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is not a point of order. The Senator can address the matter on Report Stage through an amendment.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I would be interested to hear the Minister of State's comment because the amendment states clearly "if he or she is able of performing". That is nonsense.

Comment on this

Subsection (6) sets out who is suitable for appointment. The attorney must be capable of performing the functions of attorney, as specified in the enduring power of attorney. The Senator's amendment has a different wording. but I assume mine is correct.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State is right. Why is it that the book of amendments submitted to us-----

Comment on this

As the Minister of State has read it, I imagine it should be-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Why are the amendments as submitted to us-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It can be amended on Report Stage.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Why are the amendments as submitted to us inappropriate?

Comment on this

The Minister of State has read the amendment.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 172 inserts a new section dealing with content of instrument creating an enduring power of attorney. The new section 52 sets out what has to be included in an instrument that creates an enduring power of attorney. Subsection (1) provides that the instrument must contain statements from the donor, a legal practitioner, a registered medical practitioner, a health care professional and the attorney in relation to various matters such as the capacity of the donor, that fraud of undue pressure was not used to create the enduring power and that the attorney is willing to undertake the functions of attorney under the power. The provisions were previously contained in section 52(4) which covered what might be included in regulations to be made by the Minister.

The new section 52 makes it obligatory to have such statements included in an instrument. It also provides for an additional safeguard by requiring statements by two different professionals as to the capacity of the donor to understand the implications of creating such an enduring power. One of the statements must be from a health care professional such as a social worker so as to not be too reliant on the medical assessment of capacity. Subsection (2) is a new provision specifying details that must be included in the instrument creating the enduring power of attorney that would otherwise be left to regulations.

Subsection (3) is a new provision which complements subsection (4). Subsections (3) and (4) mirror provisions introduced into the co-decision-making Part on Committee and Report Stages in the Dáil. The NDA advised that the Bill needed to provide for situations where, due to literacy issues, blindness, dexterity, etc., a person was unable to sign a document. The proposed provisions that will apply where a person cannot sign the document accords with advice that such a situation will require the combined input of the donor, the attorney, the substitute signatory and two witnesses.

Subsection (4) is a new provision which complements subsection (3). It tightens the provisions regarding the witnessing of an instrument creating an enduring power. Similar to section 14(7) in the co-decision-making Part, a further safeguard has been inserted which provides that an employee or agent of the attorney may not be a witness to an instrument creating an enduring power of attorney. It also requires that at least one of the witnesses not be an immediate family member of the donor or the attorney. The requirement that at least one witness not be an immediate family member is to provide an additional safeguard in order that an independent person must be involved as a witness. This is to reduce the risk of a donor being pushed by family members into conferring an enduring power of attorney against his or her wishes.

Subsection (5) is a new provision that requires a donor to specify in the instrument creating the enduring power if the attorney is to be paid for performing the functions of attorney, what functions he or she is to be paid for and how much he or she is to be paid.

For the purposes of clarity, subsection (6) provides a definition of immediate family member to include a spouse, civil partner, cohabitant, child, parent, step-parent, a grandparent, an aunt, uncle, nephew, niece or immediate in-laws of the appointer or co-decision-maker. The same definition is found in the corresponding subsections in Part 4 on co-decision-making and Part 8 on advance health care directives.

Amendment No 173 inserts a new section dealing with notice of execution of an enduring power of attorney. The new section 53 sets out the notification requirements in relation to the execution of an enduring power of attorney. It is a new provision that requires the donor to give notice of the execution of the power to all close family members such as a spouse and children over 18 years of age and any decision-making supporters that the donor may have such as a decision-making assistant or co-decision-maker. It also allows the donor to name two other persons whom he or she wishes to inform of the execution of the enduring power. The provisions in new section 53 specify requirements that would otherwise have been left to regulations.

Amendment No. 173 inserts a section dealing with scope of authority - personal welfare decisions.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is amendment No. 174.

Comment on this

I beg the Senator's pardon.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I point out that there are 24 pages of amendments. We have already been here for about ten minutes with the Minister of State explaining these sections. They are not all as closely related as people think. How can one possibly keep up-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are discussing amendments Nos. 170 to 193 together.

Comment on this

Once amendment No. 174-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

There are 24 pages of amendments all being discussed together. I have never come across this before.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

They are all related.

Comment on this

In fairness, we have never had legislation like this before and the Senator should take that into consideration.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

We had three examples last week.

Comment on this

It is legislation on which there has been extensive consultation. What we are doing is amending it again to make sure we get it right. Just because the Senator and I have not done it before does not mean that it is not the right thing to do.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes, but some of the amendments are grammatical amendments. It should have been utterly obvious whenever the thing was-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

On the amendments, please.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 174 inserts a section dealing with scope of authority - personal welfare decisions. The new section 54 replicates subsections (2) to (7), inclusive, of section 53 of the Bill as passed by the Dáil. It sets out the scope of authority of an enduring power of attorney in relation to personal welfare matters. Subsection (1) sets out the limited conditions where an attorney may restrain a donor. As with all other interveners restraint by attorneys is to be tightly regulated and only used in limited circumstances. The situation has to be an exceptional emergency in which there is an imminent risk of serious harm to the donor or to another person.

Subsection (2) defines ‘‘restrains’’ for the purposes of this section. It includes the definition of chemical restraint in that definition. Restraint is deemed to apply when a person administers a medication with the intention of modifying or controlling the relevant person’s behaviour in order that the person will become compliant. This amendment was inserted on Report Stage in the Dáil.

Subsection (3) requires that the restraint be immediately ceased when no longer necessary to prevent the imminent risk of serious harm to donor. Subsection (4) provides that subsections (1) to (3) shall not constrain the generality of section 69 of the Mental Health Act 2001 or of rules made under that section.

Subsection (5) prevents a donor from authorising an attorney from making a decision relating to the refusal of life-sustaining treatment or from making a decision that is the subject of an advance health care directive by the donor.

Subsection (6) provides that if an enduring power contains a relevant decision relating to the refusal of life-sustaining treatment or a decision that is the subject of an advance health care directive, the power is null and void to the extent that it relates to that decision.

Amendment No. 175 inserts a section dealing with the scope of authority relating to property and affairs. New section 55 replicates, with minor amendments, section 54(3) to (5), inclusive, of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. It sets out the scope of authority of an enduring power of attorney in relation to property and affairs. Subsection (1) provides that the attorney may, if specific provision to that effect is made in the power, act for his or her own benefit or that of any other person’s benefit to the extent provided for in the power. Subsections (2) and (3) cover the giving of gifts by the attorney on behalf of the donor. The donor must specify in the power that the attorney may give gifts, while subsection (3) limits these gifts to customary occasions and to persons, including the attorney, to whom the donor would have likely given gifts in the past. The value of the gifts must be reasonable, taking the circumstances of the donor into consideration.

Amendment No. 176 inserts a section dealing with the application of joint and joint several attorneys. New section 56 deals with the application of the Part to joint and several attorneys. The provisions in relation to joint and several attorneys were contained mainly in section 64 and the Second Schedule to the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. Subsection (1) allows a donor to appoint more than one attorney. The donor must specify in the enduring power of attorney whether such multiple appointments are made either jointly, jointly and severally, or jointly in some matters and severally in other matters.

Subsection (2) sets out what happens if one of the attorneys who was appointed to act jointly with another attorney is disqualified, dies or lacks capacity to carry out his or her duties as attorney. With regard to joint and several attorneys, where one dies, lacks capacity or is disqualified, the remaining attorney or attorneys may continue to act, unless the instrument creating the enduring power provides to the contrary.

Amendment No. 177 inserts a section dealing with persons who are not eligible to be attorneys. New section 57 equates to section 52(6) of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. Section 52 deals with a number of issues relating to the characteristics of an enduring power and who may be appointed as an attorney. Subsection (1) sets out who is not eligible for appointment as attorney and replicates similar provisions in assisted decision-making, co-decision-making and advance health care directives. Subsection (2) replaces section 52(7) and prevents financial issues such as bankruptcy from being a barrier to being an attorney in respect of personal welfare matters.

Amendment No. 178 inserts a section on the disqualification of an attorney. New section 58 equates to section 52(7), (8), (10), (11) and (12). For clarity and consistency with other Parts of the Bill, the provisions relating to disqualification have been brought together in one section.

Amendment No. 179 inserts a new section on the functions of the court prior to registration. New section 59 replicates section 56. It enables the court, before the registration of the enduring power, to exercise powers it would have been able to exercise once a power had been registered, if it has reason to believe the donor may lack or shortly may lack capacity. An application to the court under this section may be made by any interested party whether the attorney has made an application for registration of the instrument.

Amendment No. 180 inserts a new section on application for registration of an instrument creating an enduring power. New section 60 replicates the existing section 57 and incorporates Schedule 1 to the Bill. However, additional text has been added to incorporate provisions that were to be provided for by way of regulations and to strengthen the safeguards against the premature or fraudulent registration of an enduring power. It sets out the obligations placed on the attorney when he or she has reason to believe the donor lacks capacity in relation to one or more relevant decisions which are the subject of the enduring power. Subsection (1) provides that an attorney must make an application to register the instrument creating the power of attorney as soon as he or she believes the donor lacks capacity.

Subsection (2) provides that the application for registration shall be made in a form that is to be prescribed by the Minister. The fee to accompany the application shall also be prescribed in regulations. Subsection (3) requires the attorney to notify specified persons of the fact that he or she is applying to the director to register the enduring power of attorney. The list of those who have to be notified mirrors the list contained in new section 53 which lists those who have to be notified of the execution of an enduring power. Currently, section 57 and Schedule 1 to the Bill replicate the provisions of notification found in the 1996 Powers of Attorney Act. The provisions and the accompanying regulations have been a source of confusion and conflict in recent years. In order to simplify and to provide protection against premature or fraudulent registration, I propose that all close family members be notified by the attorney that he or she intends to register the enduring power. Those notified will then have the opportunity to object to the registration if they are of the opinion that the attorney is not suitable or that undue pressure was placed on the donor to choose the appointed attorney. The amended notification provisions in this new section, coupled with the new notification requirements at execution stage, should, I hope, ensure all of those who need to be informed of an enduring power of attorney are notified.

Subsection (4) replicates section 57(3). It provides that the attorney may, before applying to register the enduring power of attorney, apply to the court for a determination in relation to the validity of the power. Subsection (5) replicates section 55(2). It allows an attorney, once he or she has applied for registration, to take action under the enduring power to maintain the donor, to prevent loss to the donor’s estate, to maintain the attorney or other persons so far as the donor might be expected to do so or to make a personal welfare decision that cannot be reasonably deferred until the application has been determined.

Subsection (6) is a new provision that requires an attorney who has taken action under subsection (5) to report these actions to the director. Subsection (7) sets out what needs to accompany the application to register an instrument creating an enduring power. Similar to the requirement in relation to the execution of an enduring power of attorney, statements on the donor’s lack of capacity will now be required from two different professionals, one of whom must be a health care professional such as a social worker.

Comment on this

On a point of order, it is very difficult to hear the Minister of State. This is extremely important legislation.

Comment on this

We are trying to get agreement on holding votes.

Comment on this

I know, but the time for talking was before the debate began.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister of State should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

We will not say anything more.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister of State should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

This shows the difficulty in dealing with so many amendments in this way. I am trying to understand the legislation as it goes through the House and it is extremely difficult because we are referring to sections not included in the Bill, as it stands. There are further proposed hypothetical amendments. I am trying to understand the Bill in order that I can do a good job as a legislator. I am sorry if my whispering distressed Senator thingamajig.

Comment on this

To be fair, a Chathaoirligh, we almost had agreement.

Comment on this

Excuse me, Senator thingamajig has a name.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I could not remember it. Tell me what it is.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister of State should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Members can speak as often as they wish.

Comment on this

My point is that the discussions could have been held previously.

Comment on this

Subsection (8) sets out what will happen in relation to registration if more than one attorney is appointed under an enduring power of attorney.

To be of help to Senator David Norris, the entire section is about the enduring power of attorney.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, because there is a possibility it could be challenged, we have had to ensure there are safeguards in place. Because we will be moving to a new system, it is important we get it right in order that we will not face a challenge. Perhaps it might have been better to explain this at the outset.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I completely accept that and understand the good intentions of the Minister of State. However, there are so many matters involved and differences between them.

Comment on this

The entire section is about the enduring power of attorney.

Amendment No. 181 inserts a new section - registration of an instrument creating an enduring power of attorney. The new section 61 replicates section 58(1) of the Bill and provides in more detail for how the director shall review an application for registration. It also provides additional provisions incorporating an appeals mechanism in relation to the decisions of the director on the registration of an enduring power. Subsection (1) lists the criteria that the director must consider when reviewing an application to register an enduring power.

Subsection (2) provides that, subject to any objection received, where the director is satisfied that the application is in order, he or she shall register the instrument creating the power.

Subsection (3) provides that, where the director is not satisfied that all is in order with an application, he or she shall notify the attorney and the donor of his or her view and give the attorney and the donor the opportunity to respond. This is a new provision that allows the attorney or donor to provide further material or evidence to back up the application for registration because we cannot rule out the possibility of vexatious complaints about who is chosen.

Subsection (4) is complementary to the new subsection (3). Following the receipt of further information or material as provided for in subsection (3), the director can do one of two things - register the instrument if he or she if satisfied that the criteria listed in subsection (1) have been met or refuse to register the instrument because the criteria are not deemed to have been met.

Subsection (5) is a new provision. It provides for an appeals mechanism for an attorney whose application to register is refused. The attorney has 21 days from the time he or she is notified that the application has been refused to appeal the decision of the director to the court.

Subsection (6) is a new provision and complementary to subsection (5). It sets out what the court may do upon an appeal under subsection (5). It may require the director to register the instrument, or affirm the director’s decision to refuse to register it or make an order or declaration, as it considers appropriate.

Subsections (7) and (8) provide for the director to supply an authenticated copy of the instrument to the attorney and the donor. The copies authenticated by the director will be evidence of the contents of the instrument and the date it came into force. New section 60(3) provides that the attorney shall send them copies of the enduring power of attorney when notifying them of his or her intention to register the power.

Amendment No. 182 inserts a new section – effect and proof of registration. The new section 62 replicates section 59(1) and (2). Subsection (1) provides that once an instrument has been registered, a revocation of power will not be valid unless it is confirmed by the court. A disclaimer by the attorney will not be valid except on notice to the donor and with the consent of the court. Once registration has taken place, the donor cannot extend or restrict the power, nor can he or she give a valid consent or instruction by which the attorney will be bound. Subsection (2) provides that subsection (1) applies for so long as the instrument is registered, regardless of whether the donor lacks capacity for the time being.

Amendment No. 183 inserts a new section – objections to registration. The new section 63 replicates and expands on section 58(2), (3), (4) and (5) of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. It allows for objections to be made to the registration of an instrument creating an enduring power of attorney. It also provides for additional provisions that set out a mechanism by which the decisions of the director on whether an objection is well founded can be appealed to the court.

Subsection (2) sets out the grounds on which an objection to the registration of an instrument creating an enduring power of attorney may be made. It also allows for the possibility of a fee being charged which will help to filter out frivolous or vexatious objections. Section 46 of the Bill, as published, contains some similar provisions. Subsection (3) sets out the required actions of the director in regard to objections, while subsection (4) sets out the role of the courts in this regard. Subsection (5) provides that a person may appeal the decision of the director that his or her objection was not well founded to the court, while subsection (6) sets out the role of the court in this regard.

Amendment No. 184 inserts a new section – register of enduring powers. The new section 64 replicates section 60(1), (2) and (3) of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. It mirrors similar revised provisions in regard to other registers maintained by the director. Subsections (1) and (2) require the director to maintain, in such form as he or she considers appropriate, a register of enduring powers of attorney that have been registered by him or her.

Subsection (3) revises the current provision that provides for the register to be open to inspection by the public. With a view to the need for data protection, particularly as enduring powers of attorney are essentially private arrangements between individuals, it is not considered appropriate to make the register open to the general public. Where it is necessary for a person or a body to know of the existence of an enduring power or to have access to some or all of its contents, the director will allow the appropriate level of access.

Subsection (4) allows the director to issue an authenticated copy of an enduring power or part thereof to a body or class of persons that shall be designated by regulation. Subsection (5) provides for the maintaining of a record of those who have had access to the register or who have been sent an authenticated copy of an enduring power.

Amendment No. 185 inserts a new section – revocation and variation of enduring power. The new section 65 replicates and expands on the current section 62 of the Bill. Additional subsections provide for provisions that were to be provided for by regulation. Subsection (1) clarifies that where a donor has capacity, an enduring power of attorney may be varied or revoked anytime prior to its registration. Subsection (2) provides that the variation or revocation must be done in such form as prescribed by the Minister. Subsections (3) and (4) set out the administration requirements for the variation and revocation of an enduring power of attorney by a donor. It is not necessary for the donor to go to court to revoke an enduring power that has not been registered. Subsections (5) and (6) provide that a donor may revoke an enduring power that has been registered if he or she has the capacity to do so. However, the court must confirm the revocation for it to be valid.

Amendment No. 186 inserts a new section – disclaimer by attorney. The new section 66 replicates section 52(14). It provides that a disclaimer of an enduring power that has not been registered by the attorney will not be valid except on notice to the donor. A disclaimer of an enduring power that has been registered by the attorney will not be valid except with the consent of the court.

Amendment No. 187 inserts a new section – reports by attorneys. The new section 67 replicates and expands on section 60(4) of the Bill as passed by Dáil Éireann. It provides for greater oversight of attorneys by the director, especially in regard to the financial affairs of donors. Subsection (1) is a new provision that requires an attorney who has been given the authority by the donor to make decisions on his or her property and affairs to submit within three months of the registration of the enduring power a schedule of the donor’s assets and liabilities and projected statement of the donor’s income and expenditure to the director.

This is good practice on behalf of the attorney because he or she will need to be aware of the donor's incomings and outgoings in order to effectively manage the donor's property and affairs. It also ensures the director is made aware of any substantial estates that may require closer oversight.

Subsection (2) requires the attorney to keep proper accounts and that such accounts be available for inspection by the director or special visitor.

Subsection (3) requires the attorney under a registered enduring power to submit a report as to the performance of his or her functions under the enduring power to the director within 12 months. Subsection (4) provides that reports submitted by the attorney must be in a form to be prescribed by the Minister and must include details of all expenses and remuneration paid or to be claimed by the attorney.

Subsections (6) to (8), inclusive, are new provisions that set out what must happen when an attorney does not comply with his or her reporting obligations. This includes a provision that allows the court to determine that the attorney should no longer act as attorney for the donor concerned. Subsection (9) defines the term “relevant period”.

Subsections (10) and (11) are new provisions that apply the reporting obligations set out in this section to attorneys of enduring power that had been created under the 1996 Act but have not been registered yet.

Subsections (12) and (13) are also new provisions that provide that the functions of the director, the investigations of the director and the appointment of special and general visitors by the director in relation to the reporting obligations of an attorney include attorneys and owners under enduring powers created under the 1996 Act.

Amendment No. 188 inserts a new section 68 - complaints in relation to attorneys - into Part 7 of the Bill. The new section mirrors section 27 which deals with complaints against co-decision-makers. It sets out new provisions enabling complaints about the suitability or conduct of attorneys. Complaints against attorneys appointed under the Bill and attorneys appointed under the 1996 Act may be investigated by the director under this section. Provision is made here for the director, having satisfied himself or herself that a complaint is well founded, to apply to court for a determination. An additional safeguard is provided by allowing the director to investigate a matter and bring it to court notwithstanding that no complaint has been received.

Amendment No 189 inserts a new section 6 - applications to court. Subsection (1) sets out what the court may do where the director makes an application to it in relation to whether he or she should register an instrument creating an enduring power of attorney. Subsection (2) sets out the criteria that the court must take into consideration when determining if an attorney is suitable for appointment as an attorney.

Subsection (3) replicates section 61(2). The court can determine the meaning or effect of the instrument. The court may give directions with respect to the personal affairs and the management or disposal of the donor’s property or affairs. It can also decide on the rendering of accounts and the production of records kept by the attorney and the remuneration and expenses of the attorney and consent to a disclaimer by the attorney.

Subsection (4) replicates subsection (3) of section 61. It sets out the circumstances in which the court must notify the director of its directions, requirements, consent or authorisation made under subsection (3) and requires the director to monitor the giving of effect of such directions, requirements, etc., by the attorney.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I know the work the Minister of State has put into this, but why did we not receive a copy of her notes? It is very hard for her to read them and it is very hard for us to take in the provisions outlined because we did not get time to read them. I accept almost all of what the Minister of State is saying, but is there a reason we did not receive her notes beforehand?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It would not be normal practice on Committee Stage to circulate a Minister’s notes.

Comment on this

It would not be normal practice to relate 100 amendments.

Comment on this

It would make life easier, but I do not make the rules on these matters.

Comment on this

When the group goes over five or six amendments, we cannot take it in.

Comment on this

It is and we need to keep in mind that this is all on one particular issue but a very important one.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is not really. One could make an argument for separating out the amendment dealing with complaints about attorneys.

Comment on this

Perhaps we should have a rule that if a group includes more than a certain number of amendments, the notes should be circulated.

Comment on this

Amendment No 190 inserts a new section 70 - removal of instrument from the register. It mirrors provisions in section 26 that deal with the removal of co-decision-making agreements from the register following revocation. Subsection (1) sets out the circumstances in which the director shall remove from the register of enduring powers an instrument that has been revoked or where the attorney has been disqualified. Subsection (2) sets out what happens in regard to the register when there is more than one attorney appointed under the enduring power of attorney or where the donor has nominated an alternative attorney.

Amendment No 191 inserts a new section 71 - regulations. The new section pulls together in one section the matters that must be prescribed by the Minister. These are currently scattered throughout the Part.

Amendment No. 192 inserts a new section 72 - offences in regard to enduring powers of attorney. It mirrors similar sections in the co-decision-making and the advance health care directives parts. A person who uses fraud, coercion or undue influence to force another person to make, vary or revoke an enduring power will be guilty of an offence. A person who makes a statement in connection with the creation or registration of instrument creating an enduring power which he or she knows to be false will also be guilty of an offence. This is an important protection for a donor.

Amendment No. 193 inserts a new section - transitional provisions. The new section 73 provides for the transitional arrangements between the Bill and the Powers of Attorney Act 1996. It provides that, following the commencement of this Part, no further enduring powers of attorney may be created under the 1996 Act. That is straightforward.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am afraid I do not see any reason for applause. This is a bad evening’s work.

Comment on this

The Minister of State had to read through the amendments.

Comment on this

We applaud her endurance.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes, on a human level, but what about the endurance of the House? It is not to be applauded on a legislative level. As Senators demonstrated by their comments, the Minister of State showed some signs of physical stress in reading all this and one’s heart goes out to her. We have had nearly an hour of her. The amendments compose almost the heart of the entire Bill. They account for 22 pages out of 55. That is half the physical number of amendments. This is a huge swathe to take in one gulp. One could not really take it in. With the greatest respect, the Minister of State made a couple of errors in numbering and so on. What can we as ordinary Senators do about this? It is a real difficulty. I sincerely hope no legislation of this kind will be introduced again ever in the Seanad.

It is very important to consult people and it is welcome that the Bill has been amended in consultation, although not as fully as some of us would like, but there is no excuse for the kind of grammatical amendments being made two years later after it has been passed by the Dáil. They should have been spotted straightaway. It is a grotesque offence to Seanad Éireann that these kinds of drafting error are sustained in the Bill and have to be addressed at this stage.

I have some comments on the amendments as I followed them. I apologise to Senator Mary Moran if I interrupted her, but I was desperately trying to find out exactly where these things fitted in because some do not deal with sections in the Bill or the amendments.

They are all over the place and it is impossible to find out what section is qualifying another. I was trying to figure this out in order that I could do my job here.

Amendment No. 171 indicates "Subject to the provisions of this section ... a person who has attained the age of 18 years ... may appoint one or more suitable persons" to act as an attorney. What about people under that age? What about somebody who is 17 and a half yers, for example? Will the Minister of State reassure us that the guardian ad litem will be called into play for minors? They should certainly have some protection as they are more vulnerable than an adult. We are talking about people who have attained the age of 18 years but what about people who are under 18?

Amendment No. 184 deals with the register of enduring powers and subsection (2) indicates "The Register shall be in such form as the Director considers appropriate". I wonder what that means. Does it mean it should be in a ledger or in a computer? Does it give overwhelming power to the director to say that it can be done whatever way he or she likes? I would have thought that a register of enduring powers of attorney would be a factual matter. It is clear what it should include. I am not sure what it means by "in such form as the Director considers appropriate".

This is an enormous bulk of material to consider and it means that virtually half of the Bill is to be discussed in one go.

Comment on this

It is half the amendments.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes and they deal with a large swathe of the Bill. They could have been separated. For example, amendment No. 188 relates to complaints about attorneys. It seems there is a certain degree of separation in that issue and it deserves to be teased out separately. This is really pushing at the last minute to get legislation through. It is a very bad process as it minimises our capacity to concentrate our critical scrutiny on legislation and bring out points that need amending.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. I share the frustration of Senator David Norris. In fairness to him, we have had a number of Bills through the House in the past week and a half with hundreds of amendments coming at the last minute. As legislators, we can see amendments replacing sections and the discussion is on the new sections. It can be very confusing, especially as these numbered amendments only came to us at 11.59 p.m. last night. As none of us picked up our e-mails until this morning, it has been quite a challenge to try to get through the amendments.

I want to be specific about issues that have been raised, particularly with regard to advance health care directives. My understanding is these have been affected by the grouping of amendments to which we are speaking. They relate to changes to sections 59 and 60 of the Bill as passed by the Dáil. There are concerns being raised with me about advance health care directives and the provisions are causing a great deal of concern among mental health service users. They feel their human rights will not be respected on an equal basis with others if the treatment choices of those detained under mental health legislation are excluded from the Bill.

I note that the Minister of State is seeking to amend the mental health legislation around the issue of electro-convulsive therapy, ECT, and other harmful treatments, where people are found to be unable to consent, which is to be welcomed. It will only occur if there is a legally binding advance health care directive allowing patients to consent or refuse treatment in advance. It is believed the changes suggested may affect the issue around advance health care directives. I note that Dr. Fiona Morrissey from the National University of Ireland, Galway, has raised the issue and she states:

The impending legislative provisions discriminate against anyone who may experience mental distress. Given that one in four of us experiences some form of mental distress during our lifetime, any one of us could find ourselves in a position where we become emotionally overwhelmed due to some form of life event and end up in a crisis situation where we are excluded from making decisions in relation to our treatment under this legislation. The proposed legislation specifically excludes the use of legally binding advance health care directives for the treatment choices of those who may be subject to involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act 2001.

Dr. Morrissey believes this is clearly discriminatory under the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which the Government is planning to ratify in the near future. The use of differential standards in the legislation reinforces the notion that the preferences of individuals who may experience mental distress are not respected on an equal basis with others and reinforces stigma. In its general comment on Article 12, the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has stated state parties have an obligation to require all health and medical professionals, including psychiatric professionals, to obtain the free and informed consent of persons with disabilities prior to any treatment. She also argues that advance health care directives are legally binding during involuntary detention in a number of other jurisdictions, including Germany, and a number of US states and Canadian provinces. Advocacy organisations have urged that laws on advance directives for mental health treatment decisions should operate in exactly the same way as other directives, subject only to legitimate emergency situations, such as when there is an imminent threat to life or others.

The question is about seeking clarification. As Senator David Norris stated, with the grouping and gamut of amendments, we need specific discussion of this issue of advance health care directives. People are concerned that these are being specifically excluded. Will the Minister of State clarify this? Will they be omitted and, if so, what is the rationale for leaving them out in the light of this international opinion?

Comment on this

It is very hard not to share the concerns of my two colleagues, Senators David Norris and Trevor Ó Clochartaigh, with respect to the sheer volume of amendments. The grouping of amendments might need examination in the context of parliamentary reform. There is probably a logic in having a maximum number that may be discussed in one amendment grouping. That said, it appears that these amendments are related, diverse as they may be. They deal with wards of court and that has never been dealt with. Long before any of us were around here, in the 1800s, the legislation governing wards of court was in place. I do not follow the royal family in England, but it was probably Queen Victoria who was in charge. People who needed assistive capacity did not have any money, resources, rights or dignity. This is ensuring people who need assistive capacity have all those rights and their money is treated with respect. It is about ensuring their rights are not impugned in any way. It is welcome that we have substantial amendments, as they are to improve the legislation. I am sure many issues were identified, not just by colleagues in the Dáil but by officials and people drafting the Bill, as it is such pioneering and ground-breaking legislation. No Government in Irish history has made an effort to tackle it.

With colleagues such as Senators Ivana Bacik and Denis O'Donovan, among others, I was a member of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality that held exhaustive hearings and made significant recommendations in this area. The Minister of State is correct. I am a novice in the Seanad. Senator David Norris has been here for 20 years or longer.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is nearly 30 years.

Comment on this

In my very brief period I have not come across any legislation that has changed for the better, even in terms of language or the Title, more than this, with consultation with stakeholders and interested parties. We have seen an imperfect presentation tonight in terms of groupings and so on, but what we will have is legislation that is as close to perfect as is humanly possible to ensure dignity and rights are enshrined in law.

We all know that money is the root of all evil. With respect to people who need assisted decision making, we must make sure their money is protected and respected by the State as much as it is possible for it to do that. While it is not perfect, I sincerely hope this House will not divide on these issues of great importance to citizens who need our support and assistance.

Comment on this

I will be brief as it is important that we move on to deal with some of the very good amendments we want to ensure the Minister of State will accept.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are on the amendments.

Comment on this

I am referring to specific amendments and I hope many of them will be agreed.

Comment on this

I will be brief also. I agree with respect to the length of time involved. It is very difficult for everybody involved, but we are all here with a common aim to get this right. Like Senator Trevor Ó Clochartaigh, I read the article by Dr. Fiona Morrissey at the weekend and join in asking for clarification on some of the points made in it, particularly, as the Senator said, in regard to the mental health service users. I found it interesting that Dr. Morrissey reported that 60% of mental health service users felt that they had no control over future treatment. That is an important point. We are talking about a review in respect of wards of court and Part 6 of the Bill. I have had discussions with those involved in Inclusion Ireland who have expressed some concerns brought to their attention by family members. It is desirable we look at that category. It is always much better if the attorneys for wards of court are family members as opposed to a medical person. It is very important to ensure we do that.

Another aspect is funds for wards of court, even though this may not be the legislation under which to raise it. I do not know where that would come in, but with respect to funds in place for them that have been depleted as a result of the economic downturn, what is in place to ensure the people who were awarded money are not out of pocket?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Cáit Keane has indicated that she wants to speak again.

Comment on this

I have indicated again because I thought everybody was making a preamble, that everybody was going all over-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

No. Senators David Norris and Trevor Ó Clochartaigh spoke specifically to amendments.

Comment on this

I will speak specifically to amendment No. 27 because it is grouped with----

Comment on this

We are not on that amendment yet. That is why some of us are sitting here.

Comment on this

Will the Cathaoirleach specifically state which amendment we are on?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are dealing with the first group of amendments.

Comment on this

I am sorry, not everybody together, just the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are dealing with a group of amendments from amendment No. 2 together with the other amendments being discussed.

Comment on this

The Senator should sit down.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 2 and also amendments Nos. 7, 19, 20, 69, 77, as well as the others.

Comment on this

I have this awful feeling that we have got off on the wrong foot in dealing with this legislation which has been sought for 30 years. It is a difficult item of legislation to understand. I have been looking at it for two years and the officials have been working on it for even longer. I hope that we are not going to get off on the wrong foot and that this will head towards us doing something for people, including ourselves.

I point out to Senator David Norris that people under the age of 17 years cannot appoint an attorney. They have not reached the age of maturity. The Senator probably gathered that. Neither can they be a witness.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is under the age of 18 years.

Comment on this

It is important that we understand that. This is about adults.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes, but I was asking if the guardian ad litem would come into play.

Comment on this

No, because they are not at that point. They are not covered by the Bill. With respect to the register to be maintained, I believe that will be done electronically, but it will be very much up to the director. When we come to expand on what that director's duties and role are and where the office will be-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It should contain all the facts.

Comment on this

Yes. With respect to most of the amendments - I am sorry for racing through them but I was conscious that we did not want to be here until tomorrow morning-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

We did well.

Comment on this

-----the type of information that needs to be gathered, in the first instance, is extensive. When a complaint is made, it needs to be extensive. Therefore, it would cover all eventualities. I think the Senator will be happy enough with that. On the amendments we are proposing in regard to the enduring powers of attorney, we are simply aligning them with the reforms agreed by the Dáil, where there was exceptional co-operation around this area.

I advise Senator Trevor Ó Clochartaigh that we will be dealing with advance health care directives in Part 8 in which I believe his concerns will be dealt with.

Before I address Dr. Fiona Morrissey's article, I want to state we have met her. One of the meetings was with the officials and it was of three hours duration. I have also met her and she has put her case. It was an informal meeting. I do not want to mislead anyone; it was not the case that this was something we were discussing, but I knew her arguments because I had read her extensive e-mails on several occasions. I have explained to her and others - officials explained also in great detail during that three-hour meeting - that we intend to deal with the advance health care directives in regard to the mental health Bill when the general scheme is produced. We believe that is where it should be dealt with. As well as that, the expert group that has looked at the Mental Health Act for us has advised that is where we should deal with it. This legislation is about enabling people to make decisions and it relates to the general scheme of life events, but the specific area of mental health should be dealt with in the Mental Health Act. We are not opposed to that and have very much taken on board what Dr. Morrissey has said. She is very determined that this be stitched into this legislation, but we do not agree. That is the beauty of democracy. We have explained in great detail why it should be included in the Mental Health Act rather than this legislation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 10, between lines 24 and 25, to insert the following:

" "best interpretation" means the interpretation of the relevant person’s past and present communication (using all forms of communication, including, where relevant, total communication, augmented or alternative communication, and non-verbal communication, such as gestures and actions) that seems most reasonably justified in the circumstances;".

The Minister of State is extremely welcome. Before I speak to the amendment, I congratulate her on her work on the mental health (amendment) Bill which seeks to remove the use of coercion in the application of ECT. I acknowledge that a Bill was published by former Senator Dan Boyle, as she knows, and would particularly like to pay tribute to my cousin John McCarthy, God rest him. I can almost hear him using wonderfully colourful language and including the words "about time," but it is great that the Bill will be progressing. I say, "Well done," to the Minister of State.

In association with my colleague, Senator Katherine Zappone----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

And me.

Comment on this

-----I acknowledge the support of the NUIG Centre for Disability Law and Policy and Tallaght Trialogue. While most people simply require recognition of their legal capacity and support to express their will and preferences, there will still be a small minority of individuals who are not expressing a will and preference in a manner that others can understand. The Bill must establish the lawful response to such circumstances. However, I do not believe a functional assessment of a mental capacity and a subsequent denial of legal capacity is the correct response in these difficult situations. A person in a coma or a minimally conscious state, for example, will not be communicating his or her will and preferences to others and may not have made his or her wishes known in advance through an advance health care directive or granted a power of attorney to anyone for his or her relevant decision.

In these circumstances decision making assistants, co-decision makers, decision making representatives, attorneys or designated health care representatives may need to make a decision on the relevant person's behalf in accordance with their best interpretation of his or her will and preferences. While the Bill does require all interveners to respect the person's will and preferences as part of the guiding principles included in section 8, further reference to the concept of best interpretation of will and preferences is needed for the hard cases in which it is very difficult to tell what a person's wishes are. The term "best interpretation" needs to be defined in section 2 of the Bill to guide those in the supportive roles I have outlined. Best interpretation of a relevant person's will and preferences means taking into account past express preferences, where known, and includes knowledge gained from family and friends and other evidence available. Best interpretation can also be arrived at in seeking to communicate with the person in every possible way, including by using, where appropriate, assisted and augmentative communication, facilitated communication, signs, gestures and total communication, all of which are noted in the regulations and code of practice.

The use of best interpretation will rarely be an easy task. However, the best interest determinations used currently are similarly difficult in these circumstances. The provisions of Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities are merely shifting these difficult decisions from focusing on judgments existing outside the individual to the individual's own will and preferences. That is why I am trying to insert a definition of best interpretation. We do need to deal with the hard cases, too.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I support Senator Jillian van Turnhout's amendment. It seems important that we have a concept of best interpretation and a definition of it. It should take into account the history and past expressed wishes of a patient who may now no longer be in a position to express them. We should take into account assisted methods of communication, be it nodding, by squeezing a hand or whatever else. One has to be careful, however, about the way in which the family is included because not all families are perfect. We do not want to have families pushing an interpretation that suits them but not the patient.

I was interested to see that the Mental Health (Amendment) Bill 2008 had been introduced in the Dáil, a Bill I had seconded in this House. I remember discussing it with former Senator Dan Boyle and a very nice Progressive Democrats Senator whose name I cannot remember. That was before they dumped them. It was an important move to have the Bill discussed and I was surprised and pleased to see it being introduced in the Dáil on Tuesday.

Comment on this

I echo the support for the amendment which is very important and on which there has been a lot of very good work done. This is obviously an incredibly complex issue, but the express will of the relevant person is certainly paramount. Any mechanism or means that can be used to find out what it is should be used, no matter what state the person is in. There are questions about somebody making an advance health care directive, for example. If he or she decides in an advance health care directive that there are certain treatments he or she does not want to have, surely that must be taken into consideration. It is not just an issue of what he or she would like to happen, but also what treatments he or she would not like to receive.

I commend the Senators involved and the work of the academics who have been supporting it. I lend our support to the amendment.

Comment on this

I thank the Senators involved for bringing forward the amendment. As a practising solicitor, I have some concerns about it from my own experience which includes attending a nursing home to have a document granting power of attorney signed, only to find that the person concerned was not at all happy about signing it. I did not get it signed but two days later in my office I found a signed document granting power of attorney which had been witnessed by the matron of the nursing home. I can assure Senators that the document went into the shredder, which was the appropriate place for it. That is going back many years. I, therefore, have some concerns about how this provision will be interpreted in the sense that different people will give different interpretations to it and the intentions of the person concerned. While I accept that a lot of work has been done on this matter by the Senators concerned and that the issue needs to be looked at, I have concerns.

Comment on this

I did acknowledge Senator David Norris in the Dáil when we got the electro-convulsive therapy Bill through last evening. It will be taken in the Seanad on Thursday, 17 December. I acknowledged the Senator's involvement with that of former Senators Dan Boyle and Déirdre de Búrca. They were the three named Senators.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes. Deirdre de Búrca was her name.

Comment on this

I also acknowledged Mr. John McCarthy. I am not certain if he would agree with our interpretation of where he is now, but I am sure that if he was still around, he would, at least, be half happy.

On amendment No. 3, as Senator Colm Burke outlined, it is hugely important that we be very clear about the interpretation of someone's will and preferences. I fully acknowledge that we can never get it entirely right and that there will always be circumstances where we will get it wrong. Mr. John McCarthy's book which is on my shelf constantly reminds me of the human condition. We are human and will get it wrong. I do not know why we are ever that surprised by this.

Senators Jillian van Turnhout and Katherine Zappone have proposed amendment No. 3 to introduce a definition of "best interpretation". I cannot accept the amendment because my entire focus in the Bill is on ensuring people have the ability and are helped as much as possible to make decisions for themselves, sometimes in very difficult circumstances. Section 3 provides that where a person's capacity is being assessed, he or she can be deemed to have capacity if he or she can communicate his or her decision by talking, writing, using sign language, assistive technology or any other means, including by means of a third party who knows him or her well and knows what his or her will or preferences would be in the circumstances. Again, I am not certain people will always get it right, but they can only do their very best in the circumstances.

The provision in section 3(2) encompasses much of what the Senators are seeking to achieve. The proposed definition is somewhat unclear in terms of who would interpret it. One issue about which I have concerns is the idea that gestures and actions should be included, without proper safeguards, in a definition of best interpretation. The decisions which need to be made will often have serious legal consequences for the person concerned or another party. The sale of a house, for instance, may leave the person concerned without a home. It is crucial, given the seriousness of the decision, that his or her will and preferences be absolutely clear. Communication through gestures and actions could be misinterpreted if they were not clearly understood. As Senator Colm Burke says, they could be misinterpreted deliberately. In some cases, non-verbal communication will work. We all know people who are non-verbal but who can make their meaning very clear. We see this every day. In some cases, though, it may give rise to misunderstandings. Therefore, a general definition would need to be workable in all cases.

I suggest it would be more appropriate for the director to provide information on communication methods in a code of practice that would enable organisations to have clear information on how to approach communications which might involve the use of assistive technology or non-verbal communication. For these reasons, I cannot accept the amendment, while appreciating exactly what the Senators are seeking to do. I think we have covered as much as possible. The director will have a further part to play in terms of how non-verbal communication can be interpreted.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Minister of State's reply and her suggestion that the matter be included within a code of practice.

I am conscious dthat this legislation is historic and that we are jumping forward. My amendment proposes a framework for these hard cases because without it, there will no framework. As I appreciate what has been said about safeguards, I will withdraw my amendment. I will retable it on Report Stage and perhaps address some of the issues raised. We need a framework to deal with these hard cases in order that we do not have the situation Senator Colm Burke suggested. In the absence of a framework, who will make the interpretation? Where is the guidance for that interpretation? Perhaps it is within a code of practice. I need to consider how best that can be done.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 4, 6, 10, 11, 13, 16, 55, 75, 134 and 213 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this