We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Bill 2013: Committee Stage

Contributions 162–326 of 483. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Bill 2013
Enacted

No. 83 of 2013 ›

Amendments Nos. 4, 6, 10, 11, 13, 16, 55, 75, 134 and 213 propose to delete the current definitions in the Bill of an "approved nursing home", "care service", "relevant facility" and "nursing home or residential facility". Two new terms are proposed as more accurate terms to describe the facilities in which those encompassed by the Bill may be resident. The term "designated centre" is proposed to encompass residential facilities for older persons and persons with disabilities. It is a more accurate term than those currently included in the Bill. It is a term already defined in section 2 of the Health Act 2007. It is proposed that it will bring consistency to the terminology used in the Bill. The term "mental health facility" is retained to encompass residential facilities for persons with mental health illness.

It is not appropriate to retain terms, such as "approved nursing home", as they relate to the nursing home support scheme. The facilities encompassed by the Bill are broader than those which come under the nursing home support scheme. The change of terminology will require the consequential amendment of the definition of the "owner" of such facilities. Amendment No. 10 proposes a definition of "owner" which includes the new terms of "designated centre" and "mental health facility".

Amendments Nos. 55 and 75 are consequential on the streamlining of references to institutions. The references proposed are to "designated centres" to encompass nursing homes and residential facilities for people with disabilities and to "mental health facilities". The provision has been redrafted to make its intent clearer as our consultations with disability and mental health stakeholders have suggested the provision had created confusion. What is proposed is that an owner, a person living with the owner or an employee are automatically disqualified from acting as interveners under the Bill, that is, acting as a co-decision-maker. The exception is where any of them are the spouse, civil partner, cohabitant, parent, child or sibling of the relevant person.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendment No. 5 is in the names of Senators Denis O'Donovan, David Norris, Fidelma Healy Eames, Jillian van Turnhout and Katherine Zappone. Amendments Nos. 5 and 245 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 10, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:

“ “chemical restraint” is the intentional use of medication to control or modify a person’s behaviour or to ensure a patient is compliant or not capable of resistance, when no medically identified condition is being treated, where the treatment is not necessary for the condition, or the intended effect of the drug is to sedate the person for convenience or for disciplinary purposes;”.

I welcome the Minister of State. As this is very important and complex legislation, she has my support for the thrust of the Bill. I am glad that only two amendments - Nos. 5 and 245 - deal with chemical restraint. Accepting amendment No. 5 would really enhance the Bill. It states, "chemical restraint is the intentional use of medication to control or modify a person’s behaviour or to ensure a patient is compliant or not capable of resistance, when no medically identified condition is being treated, where the treatment is not necessary for the condition, or the intended effect of the drug is to sedate the person for convenience or for disciplinary purposes;".

In a nutshell, by accepting the amendment, we will improve the human rights and quality of treatment for a person. Before any drug is given to restrain a patient, a clinical assessment should be carried out which means that staff would have time for the patient. For example, giving a patient with dementia and who is agitated a drug will quieten him or her, but it does get to the root of the problem. Staff need time, skills and resources. This is humane and it is what I am asking of the Minister of State by accepting the amendment.

I have heard of cases where patients with dementia who have been agitated have been given drugs instead of receiving talk therapy to take them through the condition. I have heard of a stroke patient being drugged instead of being taken to the toilet. All she needed was to be physically brought to the toilet. It is undignified to use drugs in this way. I am not saying there is no need for drugs; there is a place for drugs but only after a clinical assessment has been carried out which deems use of them as being the best and last resort.

The same applies to children with autism. Instead of staff being trained to talk to children in a meltdown situation, Ritalin is often administered. I know that because there have been children in that state in my classroom. One is not dealing with the real person but a person in a zombie-like state who has been incapacitated. One is not dealing with the person with whom one could be dealing in order to get the best out of him or her. I strongly encourage the Minister of State to accept my amendment. Sage, the support and advocacy service for older people, is very appreciative and supportive of the amendment.

Amendment No. 245 reiterates what is in amendment No. 5 and states: "Nothing in this Act shall be construed as authorising any person to administer to a relevant person any medication for the purpose of controlling or modifying the relevant person’s behaviour or to ensure that a relevant person is compliant and not capable of resistance when no medically identified condition is being treated, where the treatment is not necessary for the condition, or the intended effect of the medication is to sedate the relevant person for convenience or for disciplinary purposes". This reminds me of what went on in that horrific case in Áras Attracta.

Comment on this

There were no drugs-----

Comment on this

In some cases, I understand there are. Amendment No. 245 further states: "Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (1), the appropriate use of drugs to reduce symptoms in the treatment of a medical condition does not constitute chemical restraint but the administration of such medication should be clearly documented on the relevant person's file and the reasons for the administration of such medication specified". In other words, there is a time and a place for medication but only after all of the appropriate human interventions, the face-to-face therapies and talking patients down and through the situation have been used.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The two amendments hang together clearly. The first one is a definition and I cannot see why it should be rejected. It states "chemical restraint" is the intentional use of medication to control or modify a person’s behaviour or to ensure a patient is compliant" - in other words, to dose them down. It is an emergency fire department response.

Importantly, the amendment also indicates that this is in a situation where the administration of these drugs is not to treat any condition, in other words, the drugs are not medically necessary and their usage is simply a form of restraint. We have to be very careful, in terms of people's human rights, when there is restraint.

The amendment also states "the intended effect of the drug is to sedate the person for convenience or for disciplinary purposes". It is shocking to think that when somebody behaves badly because he or she suffers from that, as punishment, drugs are administered to shut him or her up, keep him or her quiet and keep him or her down.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That would be dreadful.

I have experience from 30 or 40 years ago of visiting the then Central Mental Hospital in Dundrum, where I witnessed staff going around with trays of drugs and allowing people pick up handfuls of them. Those patients were zombies: they were out of their skulls. I do not think this practice continues and would be very surprised if it did. The amendments deal with the last vestiges of that system and would ensure drugs were not inappropriately used. Drugs are for a specific purpose and should not be used to punish people. The idea of using medication to punish a mentally ill person is absolutely repugnant.

Amendment No. 245 makes it perfectly clear, following the definition in amendment No. 5, that the Bill will not be interpreted in such a manner as to allow the administration of drugs or medicines in such a way - either to restrain or punish. However, it makes provision in subsection (2) for the medical administration of drugs. In other words, in cases where they are being administered to treat a particular medical condition, that is not to be considered as chemical restraint.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. I, too, was contacted by Mervyn Taylor of Sage, the support and advocacy service for older people, about this issue. Sage has noted the clear statement in the Department of Health policy document towards a restraint-free environment in nursing homes which unequivocally states, "Chemical restraint is always unacceptable". Chemical restraint is a violation of personal and bodily integrity. It constitutes inhumane and degrading treatment and in the experience of Sage, it is being used in certain circumstances to deprive people of their liberty rather than to address underlying clinical issues. As such, it is in breach of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and, therefore, should be prohibited.

It is health care professionals who are responsible for the administration of medicine to control behaviour, but rather than undertaking detailed clinical assessments to address the underlying reasons for agitation in some patients, for example, patients with dementia, they use chemical restraint as a first rather than a last resort. That is why I support the amendment and have put my name to it. We need to legislate and make it very clear that we should not normalise the issue of chemical restraint. It is a last resort and there should be an appropriate clinical assessment done if it is to be used.

Comment on this

The fact amendment No. 245 uses the words "chemical restraint" means that it is not unreasonable to ask for "chemical restraint" to be defined. We spoke about interpretation earlier and about how one interpretation could differ from another. Obviously, drugs must be prescribed by a medical practitioner, but there could be different interpretations regarding how they are used. Nursing homes have guidelines on how to deal with this matter, but would it be possible to address the problem raised here through the use of guidelines? I understand the concerns of other Senators about the widespread use or any use of chemical restraint in nursing homes without a requirement for medical intervention.

Comment on this

I understand perfectly the concerns of Senators. We are always under the impression that restraint is physical, but chemical restraint is much more subtle and, probably, far more effective. Apart from this Bill, there are other areas that are protected in terms of chemical restraint. For example, HIQA always insists on reading patients' records to ensure medication is appropriate for people and that the amount and frequency of medication administered is registered. This provision is always part of HIQA's reporting process. This is one of the mechanisms we have as a safeguard. Mention was made of Áras Attracta and that example shows we are human and things do go wrong. However, we must accept that the majority of people working in the care industry and medical professionals take this issue seriously and do not administer drugs that are of no benefit to the health of patients.

Amendments Nos. 5 and 245 would introduce a definition of chemical restraint into the Bill and insert a new section stipulating that persons would not be authorised by the Bill to use chemical restraint. We are all in agreement that chemical restraint should be used as little as possible. I have already responded to this concern and this is not the first time it has been raised. I am sure the Senators proposing the amendment have been lobbied on this area. I have already responded to this concern through the amendments I introduced in the Dáil on Report Stage. I introduced an amendment which stipulates that chemical restraint can be used or authorised only by decision-making representatives or by attorneys. This is a significant safeguard. They can use chemical restraint only in very limited circumstances, where there is an exceptional emergency situation which involves an imminent risk of serious harm to the relevant person or to another person. The use of such restraint must be proportionate to the likelihood of harm. Where chemical restraint is used or authorised, decision-making representatives and attorneys must include details of the use of restraint in their reports to the director of the decision support service.

My amendments give the strong message that chemical restraint should be used only as an exceptional measure. They are focused on instances in which individuals take decisions on behalf of a person with capacity difficulties as that is the focus of this Bill. The Bill is not intended to address all issues that may affect vulnerable people. Both HIQA and the medical profession have a role to play also.

On the issue of chemical restraint more broadly, the position is that chemical restraint is not currently defined in health legislation although, as previously stated, a definition is given in the national policy on the use of restraint in designated centres for older people - nursing homes. Regulations on designated centres for older people require that restraint only be used in accordance with that policy.

The Mental Health Act requires rules for the use of restraint to be drawn up by the Mental Health Commission. Rules have been in place since 2009. The recent review of the Mental Health Act has recommended that revised mental health legislation should be broadened to include all forms of seclusion and restraint, similar to in the capacity legislation. The group was satisfied that the details of how such policy should operate is best left to be provided for in rules and guidelines, which are to be revised by the Mental Health Commission when primary legislation is revised. At this point, it is intended that secondary legislation should include a provision ensuring that approved centres are obliged by law to follow national policy where seclusion and restraint are concerned.

Detailed provisions regarding the use of chemical restraint and other types of restraint are best set down in national policies and underpinned by secondary legislation. This has the advantage of allowing for changes to be made such as to improve safeguards, without the necessity of having to amend primary legislation. For this reason, while I sympathise with what the Senators are seeking to achieve and have considered the issues, I cannot accept the amendments. Again, we have included safeguards in this Bill in the context of who can authorise the administration of drugs and a reporting mechanism that should provide greater protection. There are times when that protection is needed.

The Mental Health Commission is also very active in this area. It is the HIQA of mental health services. In the context of older people and disability, HIQA is equally active in this area. I believe we have sufficient safeguards included in the Bill and further agreed definitions will be introduced in the revised Mental Health Act.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Am I correct in assuming that chemical restraint is referred to in the Bill, as it stands, even without these amendments?

Comment on this

I ask the Senator to repeat his question.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Am I correct in assuming that "chemical restraint" is provided for within the body of the Bill as a phrase?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is what I thought but it seems extraordinary that there is no definition for same. Whatever about amendments Nos. 2, 4 or 5, surely to goodness there should be the acceptance of a definition? If the Minister of State does not like our definition, she should present one of her own. It is astonishing that a major term employed in the Bill should not be defined. Everything else is defined. Decision includes "classes of decisions", for example. The Bill defines "decision", although many people believe they know what it means. Under the legislation, "Act of 1995" means the Civil Legal Act of 1995 and so on. There are so many definitions included. Why is there an absence of a definition in this instance? I would have thought that because chemical restraint was such a clear term, it would need a definition. The definition offered is: "the intentional use of medication to control, modify or a person’s behaviour or to ensure a patient is compliant or not capable of resistance when no medically identified condition is being treated, where the treatment is not necessary for the condition".

Comment on this

My apologies. I am listening to the Senator and did not mean to turn my back.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I do not mind at all. I have no problem with the Minister of State turning away and taking advice, although I know that other Senators do not like it. I firmly believe there must be a definition in the Bill. A definition is needed and I cannot emphasise that point enough.

Comment on this

I also believe a definition is vital because we must have agreement on what we are talking about. When Sage put its case to me, I had to ask what was meant by the term "chemical restraint" because I wanted to make sure we were talking about the same thing. The Bill, without a definition of chemical restraint, will not be strong enough to prevent the use of drugs to control behaviour for disciplinary or other purposes. The term must be defined and clearly understood throughout the text of the Bill. My thoughts go out to the poor, weak, vulnerable people who are being managed by drugs when talk therapy or other approaches would be more satisfactory.

I also ask the Minister of State to clarify what she means when she says chemical restraint should only be used in exceptional circumstances. I agree but ask where that assurance is laid out in the Bill.

Comment on this

That is what I was consulting the departmental official about because I knew I had read it somewhere. It is defined in the Bill and the definition is very similar to what is proposed in the amendment. It is covered in the section dealing with restrictions on decision-making representatives, namely, section 38. I will read the relevant-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I ask the Minister of State to give us the page number.

Comment on this

It is on page 53. However, I am worried that the version I have may not be the same as the one the Senator is using, which is why I am being cautious about it.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

What page and what line?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

If the Senators turn to page 53, section 38(9)(c). they will see the definition, which is very close to that proposed in the amendment. It reads as follows: "administers a medication, which is not necessary for a medically identified condition, with the intention of controlling or modifying the relevant person’s behaviour or ensuring that he or she is compliant or not capable of resistance".

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The difficulty with it is that it is not included in the definitions section.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It should be included in the definitions section and the definition provided for in the amendment is better. First, it is a definition. Second, it is very clear and, third, it introduces the fact that the drugs being administered are not necessary for a medical condition. That is absent from the subsection to which the Minister of State referred, which does not include a definition. I know that sometimes in Bills there are sections which contain definitions within them, in addition to the definitions in the first Part of the Bill. However, this-----

Comment on this

Perhaps we might take a little more time to read through this because the definition is actually included. The paragraph reads,"administers a medication, which is not necessary for a medically identified condition".

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this

The paragraph does not refer to chemical restraint.

Comment on this

Will the Senator repeat what he said, please?

Comment on this

The paragraph is not naming it as chemical restraint.

Comment on this

It does not need to name it as chemical restraint.

Comment on this

Let us examine what we are saying. For the purposes of the section, "a decision-making representative for a relevant person restrains the relevant person if he or she...". There are a number of points, including the one read by the Minister of State. Let us say, for the sake of argument, we are talking about a nurse or a care giver. Is he or she actually called a "decision-making representative"? A nurse or care giver may just be following someone's orders. I would not be convinced at all about this, given the potential impact on the patient, sufferer or vulnerable person. I would not be at all convinced that a person who is following instructions from a third party is a decision-making representative.

Comment on this

The Senator is making a different point entirely.

Comment on this

No, I am not because paragraph (c) of section 38(9) which the Minister of State read to reassure us is covered by the overarching opening sentence of the subsection which reads, "For the purpose of this section, a decision-making representative for a relevant person restrains the relevant person if he or she...". What I am trying determine is whether a care assistant, for example, is classed as a decision-making representative.

Comment on this

Yes, but that is not the point of the amendment. The point of the amendment is to define chemical restraint, but chemical restraint is covered in the Bill. If the Senator wants to propose an amendment relating to-----

Comment on this

It is only covered subject to the opening sentence which I have just read. A decision-making representative is not allowed to administer a medication, but I am asking if a care giver is a decision-making representative. Is a nurse, for example, a decision-making representative?

Comment on this

Then it does not work. It is not adequate.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are now dealing with two amendments.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I asked earlier if the phrase "chemical restraint" was used in the Bill. As it does not appear in this section, I assume it is used elsewhere in the Bill.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is the information I was given. The subsection does not refer to or define chemical restraint. I note that the Minister of State is nodding. Therefore, I am taking that to mean that the phrase does not appear elsewhere in the Bill. Her case is substantially weakened by virtue of the fact that subsection (9) of section 38 begins thus: "For the purposes of this section...". That limits it to this section, which means that it is not an adequate definition. It does not refer to chemical restraint as such. It gives a definition that approximates to chemical restraint, but it limits and confines it to this section. Therefore, where chemical restraint is mentioned elsewhere in the Bill, there is no definition.

Comment on this

If it is inclued in the Bill, it covers every part.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

No, that is not correct. What is the point in saying, "For the purposes of this section"? I know that it is a nicety, but legal points are niceties.

Comment on this

If it is included in the Bill, it forms part of the legislation.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Bill might be amended-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It states, "For the purposes of this section".

I do see a certain amount of agreement from the advisers. No, there is vigorous head-shaking.

Comment on this

They have minds of their own. I never interrupt them; they are well capable of making up their own minds.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Did Senator Martin Conway indicate?

Comment on this

I did, but the Minister of State clarified the point I was going to make.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State cannot get away from the fact that it states “for the purpose of this section”.

Comment on this

I believe the point made by Senator Fidelma Healy Eames concerns the chain of authority. Nowhere does the Bill authorise anyone else to medicate people for an identified medical problem. The Bill has taken a considerable time to draft. Do the Senators want to go into that level of detail to see what more we can add?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The points made by Senator David Norris are probably more relevant to the section, but the amendments are specific.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am being very specific.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The section deals with restraints and restrictions.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am being very specific because I am talking about a definition. I could not be more specific. I am talking about the language.

I have established that the words "chemical restraint" appear in other sections of the Bill. It would be very helpful if the Minister of State or her advisers could indicate where the words "chemical restraint" appear in the Bill. I know that is a bit of an “ask”, as they say, but I would be very grateful if she could. That might help us to tease out whether a definition is required.

Comment on this

I do understand the Minister of State is getting my point about the chain of authority. This is limited in two ways: first, the Government should amend the words "this section" because one could argue that it applies only in this section; second, a definition is vital and if the phrase “chemical restraint” appears elsewhere the Minister of State should give us the precise page references. Given that the Minister of State said a caregiver or a nurse would not be the decision-making representative prevented from administering a medication which is not necessary for a medically identified condition, who are the decision-making representatives? We need to know. Is it an attorney? About whom are we talking?

Comment on this

It is the whole point of Bill. Has the Senator not read it?

Comment on this

Of course I have.

Comment on this

It can be someone that the person chooses or who is appointed by the courts. Am I now to go back and explain to the Senator who these people are?

Comment on this

My question refers to a care setting.

Comment on this

It does not matter.

Comment on this

Is the Minister of State reassuring me that a doctor, nurse or caregiver can never administer drugs that are not necessary?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State used the words "in these circumstances".

Comment on this

It is used in exceptional circumstances where the person is in imminent danger of serious harm or someone else is in imminent danger of serious harm. I read it.

Comment on this

I was just checking.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Is it possible to give the reference? I want to tease this out.

Comment on this

We will find the other section of the Bill for the Senator, I promise.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State does not have it.

Comment on this

No. We are not that quick.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this

It is being pressed unless we know where we are going. We have to have a definition.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

We need to know where the words "chemical restraint" appears in the Bill. If they appear in the Bill, it needs a definition that is broader than just "for the purpose of the section".

Comment on this

It is also included in section 53 and it is exactly the same amendment.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Is that the only other place where it is used?

Comment on this

That is my information.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are not dealing with section 53 now.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is included in section 53(5)(c) but the words used are not actually “chemical restraint”.

Comment on this

Does the Senator accept that it is included by another name?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes. My point was that if the phrase “chemical restraint” was used in the legislation, as I was initially told, it needed a definition. It does not appear except in a section where it more or less defines itself.

Comment on this

I think we would have a serious difficulty if we were to include different types of definition. We would probably have five.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendment No. 6 was discussed with amendment No. 4.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I have made the point before that there is a huge number of amendments but when we come to an actual amendment, we are told it has already been discussed and that we cannot discuss it again.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We had a long discussion on that group of amendments.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I was misinformed by the Cathaoirleach because he said I could come in again.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Of course, the Senator can come in on the group of amendments being discussed.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Exactly, but I cannot come in when an amendment is before us. That is the point I was making and it is a very good and valid one.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

All of the amendments were related to the one subject.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Not necessarily.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 8, 48 to 50, inclusive, 56, 73, 76, 82, 95, 106, 107, 116, 131 and 232 are related. These are technical amendments that may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

No.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

They are only technical amendments.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I know. I am just being awkward.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is being very awkward.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I do not agree with all this. In this kind of circumstance where there are 21 or 22 pages of amendments which have all been grouped together in a big group and we can discuss them only as part of a huge, amorphous bulk, we do not have the opportunity to consider them where they are relevant in the Bill. We are told they have already been discussed with the other amendments. It should be possible to come in again at that point.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are not having a speech. Is the Senator agreeing to the proposal made?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am not agreeing to it, but that does not mean they are not being grouped.

Comment on this

I understand people are becoming a little jaded and frustrated by this.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State can go on. I do not care.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 8, 48 to 50, inclusive, 56, 73, 76, 82, 95, 106, 107, 116, 131 and 232 are technical amendments to correct cross-references or typographical errors. That will drive the Senator mad, but it has to be done.

Amendment No. 8 is a technical amendment to correct an incorrect cross-reference. Amendments Nos. 48 to 50 are technical amendments to specify the cross-reference more precisely. Amendment No. 56 is a technical amendment to include the necessary cross-references to all provisions relating to offences in the Bill. Amendment No. 73 is a technical amendment to provide for the correct reference to specific provisions in the Companies Act. Amendment No. 76 is similar to amendment No. 56 and a technical amendment to include the necessary cross-references to all provisions relating to offences in the Bill. Amendment No. 82 is a technical amendment to introduce the necessary cross-reference to the functions of a co-decision-maker as set out in section 16. Amendment No. 95 is a technical amendment that provides for the director, in reviewing a co-decision-making agreement, to check that the agreement is not null and void. Amendment No. 106 is a technical amendment to specify the correct cross-reference more precisely.

It proposes that the court would make a determination pursuant to an application under subsection (4)(b) which provides that the director can apply to the court to determine whether a person should continue to be a co-decision maker.

Amendment No. 106 is a technical amendment to specify that the application to register a co-decision-making agreement is subject to the requirement of section 14(6). This specifies that a co-decision-making agreement may be signed on behalf of an appointer by a third party. This is permitted where the appointer is unable to sign the agreement. However, the appointer must specify the third party who will sign on his or her behalf.

Amendment No. 107 is a technical amendment to describe more clearly the first grounds on which a complaint can be made against a co-decision maker. This is when the co-decision maker has acted or is proposing to act outside of the scope of the functions of the co-decision-making agreement and no change of policy is proposed.

Amendment No. 116 is a technical amendment to specify the cross-reference more precisely. The court will make a determination on an application by the director under subsection (2)(a) where the latter believes a complaint to be well founded.

Amendment No. 131 is a technical amendment to make clear the court's determination on applications on co-decision making is limited to matters arising from this part and to co-decision making.

Amendment No. 232 clarifies that in any application to the court on an advanced healthcare directive, the applicant should inform the court of any enduring power of attorney regardless of whether it was registered under the Bill or the 1996 Act.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Some of these amendments are generated by the text of the Bill and are necessary but others should have been picked up at an earlier stage. There is no excuse for that.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 9, 15, 18, 22, 24, 28, 46, 53, 54, 57, 59, 60, 66 to 68, inclusive, 70, 72, 74, 78 to 80, inclusive, 83 to 91, inclusive, 94, 96 to 104, inclusive, 109 to 115, inclusive, 119 to 130, inclusive, 133 and 147 are drafting amendments and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I will take this as slowly as possible because it is a huge group of amendments. I understand the Senator's frustration. We will do this as painlessly as possible.

Amendment No. 9 is intended to define intervention more accurately as the actions which directly have an impact on a relevant person. These can include an action by an intervener, a court order or a direction made by a court. It is not appropriate to include rules of court or ministerial regulations within the definition as their impact would be indirect in nature and would not be focused on an individual case. Accordingly, it is proposed to delete the references to rules of court or ministerial regulations from the definition of intervention.

Amendment No. 15 proposes to delete the words "in accordance with the provisions of this Act" from the definition of relevant person as the phrase is unnecessary to the meaning of the definition.

Amendment No. 18 proposes the deletion of a phrase which is unnecessary to the meaning of the provision. It is intended that the provisions of section 3 will apply for all of purposes of the Bill.

Amendments Nos. 22 and 24 propose to delete the word "relevant" from the provisions relating to the donation of an organ or the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment. Amendment No. 28 proposes to delete the word "relevant" from subsection (9) of section 8. This is because the phrase "relevant person" means someone who lacks capacity. As these provisions explicitly state they relate to a person who lacks capacity, the reference to "relevant" is unnecessary.

Amendment No. 46 is a technical amendment to introduce the necessary cross-reference to the criteria as set out in section 15 that make a person ineligible to be appointed as a co-decision maker. Amendment No. 53 ensures the definition of immediate family relates to both the appointer and the co-decision maker, not just the appointer who is a relevant person.

The purpose of amendment No. 54 is to correct a grammatical error. Amendment No. 57 is a technical amendment to make the provision more precise. Amendment No. 59 is a technical amendment that clarifies the intent of the provision that the functions of a co-decision maker shall be specified by the appointer in the co-decision-making agreement. Amendment No. 60 is a technical amendment that clarifies the intent of the provision that the co-decision-maker shall assist the appointer with communicating his or her will and preferences.

Amendments Nos. 67 and 70 are technical amendments to specify that a co-decision-making agreement will be null and void if any of the circumstances specified in subsections (1) or (2) occur, that is, that a marriage or civil partnership is dissolved or the couple separate. Amendment No. 68 is a technical amendment to clarify that the reference is to the co-decision-making agreement. Amendment No. 72 is a technical amendment to specify that subsection (6) relates to a co-decision-making agreement which becomes null and void post-registration of the agreement.

Amendment No. 74 is a technical amendment to specify that the cross-reference should be to Chapter 5 of Part 14 of the Companies Act 2014. Amendment No. 78 is a technical amendment to specify that the disqualification of a potential co-decision maker occurs when the court makes a declaration under section 34(1), that is, a declaration which declares the co-decision maker to lack capacity, unless assisted by a co-decision maker or even with the assistance of a co-decision maker. Amendments Nos. 79 and 80 are drafting amendments to make the intent of the provisions clearer. Amendment No. 83 corrects a grammatical error. Amendment No. 84 clarifies that the application for registration of a co-decision-making agreement must include a copy of any notice given to specified parties.

Amendment No. 85 is a technical amendment to specify that the director’s review of an application for a co-decision-making agreement will relate to establishing if the criteria set out in paragraphs (a) to (f) have been met. Amendment No. 86 is a technical amendment to specify that one of the criteria that needs to be fulfilled is that the co-decision-maker is eligible for appointment according to the eligibility grounds set out in section 15. Amendments Nos. 87 and 88 are technical amendments in the interests of consistency. They propose that specified actions will be taken where the director is of the view that criteria have been satisfied.

Amendments No. 89 and 90 are technical amendments to clarify that the capacity to make a decision is at issue rather than the decision in general. Amendment No. 91 is a technical amendment to specify more clearly that an objection can be made to registration of a co-decision-making agreement if the potential co-decision maker is not eligible on the grounds set out in section 15(1).

Amendment No. 94 is a technical amendment to specify more precisely that the director’s review of a co-decision-making agreement should be against the criteria set out in paragraphs (a) to (e). Amendments Nos. 100, 102 and 103 are related amendments which propose that the director’s view on the outcome of the review will be based on whether the criteria have been fulfilled.

The purpose of amendment No. 95 is to correct a typographical error. Amendments Nos. 96 and 97 propose to delete the word "effectively" as it is a subjective term and difficult for a director to assess. Amendment No. 98 is a technical amendment. Amendments Nos. 99 and 101 are related amendments which clarify that the director is forming a view that the necessary criteria do not apply at the time of his or her review of the co-decision-making agreement.

The director is not making an assessment as to whether the criteria applied in the past. Amendments Nos. 100, 102 and 103 are technical amendments that clarify the intent of the provision.

Amendment No. 104 is a technical amendment to replace the term "notice" with "notification". The term "notification" is a more correct term in the provision that sets out the director's right to apply to the court for a determination, having notified the co-decision maker that he or she has failed to submit a report or has submitted an incomplete report. The term "notice" relates more to the serving of notice to specified parties of the creation of an enduring power of attorney, for example.

Amendment No. 98 follows on from the change to the heading in the subsection. Amendments Nos. 109 to 112, inclusive, are technical amendments changing the word "the" to "and". The amendment is needed because a relevant person does not have the status of "the" appointer if a co-decision-making agreement is potentially null and void.

Amendment No. 113 is a technical amendment to make clear that the director's investigation will be on the matters that are the subject of the complaint. Amendment No. 114 proposes a time limit of 21 days for a person to appeal a decision of the director that a complaint is not well founded.

Amendment No. 115 is to correct a typographical error. Amendments Nos. 119 to 130, inclusive, are a series of technical amendments intended to make clearer the provisions of section 28. Amendment No. 133 is a technical amendment to specify that the person commits an offence when he or she uses fraud, coercion or undue influence to force another person to make, vary or revoke a co-decision-making agreement. Amendment No. 147 is a technical amendment to make clear that the decisions for which the person needs a co-decision-maker will be those set out in the court's declaration rather than in an application, potentially by a third party, to the court.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Quite a number of the amendments should have been picked up in the past two years and there is no excuse for not doing so. Will the Minister of State elucidate on amendment No. 63 which purports to delete on page 26, lines 19 to 26:

(3) A co-decision-maker shall not—

(a) attempt to obtain information that is not reasonably required for making a relevant decision, or

(b) use relevant information for a purpose other than in relation to making a relevant decision.

(4) A co-decision-maker shall take reasonable steps to ensure that relevant information—

(a) is kept secure from unauthorised access, use or disclosure, and-----

Comment on this

From what page is the Senator reading?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Page 26 of the Bill. I am curious as to why the Minister of State wants to delete a provision indicating that people should not attempt to obtain information that is not required. It would be utterly wrong to use information for a purpose that was not appropriate. The other provision is that a co-decision-maker should take reasonable steps to ensure the information is kept secure. As I am sure that is appropriate, I wonder why it is to be deleted.

Comment on this

We are trying to tidy up the Bill. As the Senator has stated, it is difficult enough to get our heads around it. All of the information on the obligations of co-decision-makers and others will be included in section 8. We are trying to tidy it up.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Is it included in section 8 or will that be included in section 8 after further amendment?

Comment on this

They will be grouped in section 8 after the amendments. We are trying to tidy up the Bill. The powers of attorney section will have all of the provisions together, which is why there are extensive-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I do not see anything in section 8 indicating that the people concerned "shall not obtain information" inappropriately or use it inappropriately, keeping it from unauthorised access. Is it included in section 8? I am sorry, but perhpas I am just being obtuse.

Comment on this

We have not yet come to that part, as the Senator might have gathered. It is page-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is page 14.

Comment on this

That is why there is a difference. My reference is to page 4. I want to be careful about the information I am giving. The amendment states:

In page 18, between lines 31 and 32, to insert the following:

“(10) The intervener, in making an intervention in respect of a relevant person—

(a) shall not attempt to obtain relevant information that is not reasonably required-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is an amendment.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is what I was asking. It is proposed to make an amendment to introduce that provision in another place.

Comment on this

It will be an amended section.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is now clear. I thank the Minister of State.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 14, 43, 63 and 240 to 243, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 14, 43, 63 and 240 to 243, inclusive, are intended to insert provisions to ensure information is sourced, used and stored correctly and in compliance with data protection obligations.

The proposed amendment No. 14 is intended to bring the Bill into compliance with the Data Protection Act by including a definition of "relevant information". This definition will enable interveners, such as decision-making assistants, for instance, to know the categories of information that they can and cannot access. Including the definition should also make clearer to an institution which categories of information can and cannot be given to an intervener.

Amendment No. 43 proposes to delete subsections (3) and (4) of section 16 as the obligations arising for co-decision-makers are now set out in section 8. The obligations now relate to all interveners rather than specifically to decision-making assistants. Similarly, amendment No. 63 proposes to delete subsections (2) and (3) of section 11 as the obligations arising for decision-making assistants are now set out in section 8.

Amendments Nos. 240 and 241 propose to introduce additional provisions to section 82 concerning the obligations that will apply to general visitors and special visitors if they seek records relating to a person with capacity difficulties as part of their role to support the director. They will need to have access to such records mainly when they are examining a complaint received by the director relating to a person with capacity difficulties. The proposed amendments retain the provision allowing them to examine and take copies of records.

It specifies that these can be health, personal welfare and financial records pertaining to the person with capacity difficulties. It also retains the provision for the general visitor or special visitor to interview the person.

The amendments propose a series of additional obligations to bring the provision into line with data protection obligations. It requires the general visitor or special visitor to seek the consent of the person with capacity difficulties prior to seeking the records in question. It proposes that the consent requirement can be dispensed with where the person has a decision-making representative or an attorney under an enduring power of attorney. This is for the reason that if the special visitor or general visitor is examining a complaint, it may often be against a decision-making representative or an attorney. It would not be appropriate, therefore, for the person against whom a complaint is potentially being made to have the possibility to refuse access by the special visitor or general visitor to the records in question.

The amendments would impose the following restrictions in terms of the records that can be sought. These are limited to the records needed for the purposes of carrying out the task required by the director. They would also require the special visitor or general visitor to keep the records secure from unauthorised access, use and disclosure. They would require the special visitor or general visitor to dispose of the records when no longer needed. To ensure these restrictions are complied with, they would require the director to carry out an annual check to ensure special visitors and general visitors are complying with these obligations.

Amendments Nos. 242 and 243 propose the same provisions and obligations on court friends as are specified in respect of general visitors or special visitors. They require the court friend to seek the consent of the person with capacity difficulties prior to seeking the records in question. They also propose that the consent requirement can be dispensed with where the person has a decision-making representative or an attorney under an enduring power of attorney. This is for the reason that if the court friend is supporting a person with capacity difficulties in a court hearing, the interests of the incapacitated person may be at odds with those of a decision-making representative or an attorney. It would not be appropriate to give them the power to refuse access to such records.

Comment on this

This is a technical amendment. It is considered good drafting practice for the legislation which is to be repealed to be included in the same section. No change of substance is involved. The Bill proposes to repeal, as previously agreed, the Marriage of Lunatics Act 1811, which seems so ridiculous now. The Lunacy Regulation (Ireland) Act 1871 will be repealed with the exception of the transitional arrangements of Part 6 to allow all adult wards to be discharged from wardship and-or migrated to the new options. That should get a round of applause.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 26, 27 and 29 and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 17, to delete line 30 and substitute the following:

"and to reside in the place of his or her choice in so far as that is practicable,".

Section 8 sets out the guiding principles, inherent in which is the minimisation of the restrictions on relevant persons. The principles include respect for the right to dignity, bodily integrity, privacy, autonomy and control of financial affairs. These are important rights but a fundamental right that should be included as a guiding principle is the right to reside in a place of one's own choice where that is practicable. This right for older persons is included in section 2 of the Council of Europe recommendations 2014 on the promotion of the human rights of older people and provides that older persons are entitled to lead their lives independently in a self-determined and autonomous manner. This encompasses, inter alia, the taking of independent decisions with regard to all issues which concern them, including those regarding their property, income, finances, place of residence, health, medical treatment or care. Older persons, in principle, should only be placed in a residential institution or psychiatric care with their free and informed consent and any exception to this principle must fulfil the requirements of Article 5.43 of the European Convention on Human Rights, in particular the right to liberty and security.

With regard to people with disabilities, the right to choose a place of residence is set out in Article 19(a) of the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities 2007, which provides, "Persons with disabilities have the opportunity to choose their place of residence and where and with whom they live on an equal basis with others and are not obliged to live in a particular living arrangement". Too often, current practice is not to afford the opportunity to a person to exercise his or her right to make a choice as to where he or she would like to reside and not to consider what options and support are available and could be put in place in respect of the choice being made. The spirit of the legislation requires us to do this and I would like the Minister of State to accept the amendment. The inclusion of this right in the guiding principles will at least prompt the interventor to consider this right before making arrangements that are contrary to the wishes and preferences of the relevant person. Each person's well-being and happiness, which we continually forget, should be the standard to which society aspires.

I know that the Minister of State understands this better than anybody, but we seem to think that as one gets older, one becomes a bigger economy. Although they are necessary and do good work, too many care and residential homes are being built and not enough is being done to keep people in their own homes if that is what they wish and if it is practicable. There is such a concept as the appropriateness of a home. More residential settings or residential beds for the elderly are not needed because we have enough. The Minister of State will be aware of residential institutions that are a home within a home all over Ireland. Older people have to be free and should never be incubated.

I mentioned the last time we discussed this topic in the House that if one left a dog on its own for three days, the ISPCA would be rapping on the door to find out why one had done that. Older people do not bark enough for attention, but we accept that they are deserving of more than one hour's human contact a day.

We should stop segregating them. There is a kind of apartheid in how we treat older people. That is why I tabled the amendment which I hope the Minister of State will accept. It proposes the inclusion of the words "to reside in the place of his or her choice in so far as that is practicable". It is not always medically practical or possible, but it should be a choice. We have the money to keep people in homes that cost a €1,000 a week for their care, but we do not have the same amount of money to keep them within the community. I do not understand this and that is the reason I tabled the amendment.

I know that the Minister of State understands this point, but the fair deal scheme should start in the home. People should be able to stay in their homes to which the fair deal scheme should apply. It should not only apply if people go into a care home or an institutionalised setting. The Minister of State is very aware of my views on this issue which has become very apparent to me. Sometimes things do not become apparent until they hit one right between the eyes with ageing parents. One of the findings from a small study I carried out recently of the Civil Service is that the mean age of the staff is 46 years and many of them spend a great deal of their lives caring for elderly parents. We will all do it and will all face our own mortality and grow old.

I would like the Minister of State to consider including this amendment. Inherent in that guiding principle section is the bodily integrity of the human being and the protection of finance, but we must protect people in their homes and their decision-making on the place in which they want to reside. This brings up the point other Senators made about ensuring people are not being cared for by strangers who make decisions on the hoof. I would like the Minister of State to consider this genuine amendment.

Comment on this

A word of advice-----

Comment on this

I am only speaking to that amendment.

Comment on this

The Senator is only speaking to one amendment, even though she is entitled to speak to the others.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, I am not speaking to the others. This is the only amendment in my name and it is the only one to which I am speaking.

Comment on this

That is fair enough. I call Senator Cáit Keane.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Acting Chairman-----

Comment on this

I saw the Senator indicating but Senator Cáit Keane indicated first.

Comment on this

I will speak only to amendment No. 26 which is a reasonable one and states "in so far as that is practicable". What it proposes is the direction in which the health service should be moving and what it should be aiming to do. Increasingly, more rather than less care should be given in the home. I will speak to amendment No. 27 after Senator David Norris has spoken, as it is his amendment.

Comment on this

It was my error. My apologies to Senator David Norris. Amendment No. 27 is in his name.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is no problem. I was called out of the Chamber to say hello to a group I had missed and which I was supposed to meet at 6.30 p.m. I apologise to the House.

Amendment No. 27 should not to be discussed with amendments Nos. 26 and 29, as it has not the remotest connection to either of them. There is no connection whatever. There is a reference in amendment No. 27 to section 121, but that section does not appear in the Bill, as it stands. It is amendment No. 244. Therefore, they could not have a clearer connection. As one amendment refers to the hypothetical new amendment, they should be grouped together, but amendment No. 27 should not be grouped with two amendments with which it is not related. The groupings are completely daft. I ask that we deal with amendments Nos. 26 and 29 now and that amendments Nos. 27, 239 and 244 be discussed together. That is the logical thing to do when the three amendments refer to each other.

Comment on this

I agree. Amendments Nos. 27, 239 and 244 refer to finances. If the Minister of State is agreeable, Senator Marie-Louise O'Donnell's amendment No. 26 should be discussed with amendment No. 29.

Comment on this

It is sitting there as it were.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is daft. I ask for the indulgence of the House.

Comment on this

I think we are all in agreement.

Comment on this

If there is not agreement on the groupings, the proposal falls, but we can discuss the amendments individually.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I suggest amendments Nos. 27, 239 and 244 be grouped.

Comment on this

That is agreed. We are dealing with amendment No. 26 now and that is all.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes. We will discuss amendments Nos. 27, 239 and 244 together.

Comment on this

That is agreed.

Comment on this

That is agreed.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

A victory for common sense.

Comment on this

I apologise for not being here for the taking of amendment No. 17 which I will resubmit on Report Stage. I am fully supportive of amendment No. 26 tabled by Senator Marie-Louise O'Donnell. The Minister of State is very aware that the Senator tabled a motion in recent months on this very issue, on which we had an excellent debate in the House. What the Senator is trying to achieve is the principle and the right of people to have such a choice. She has appropriately added the words "in so far as that is practicable". She has included a safeguard appropriately and I support her proposal.

Comment on this

While I am very sympathetic to Senator Marie-Louise O'Donnell's amendment, I have one concern which the Senator might address. Her amendment includes the words "in so far as that is practicable". I recall the turmoil of my elderly mother who wanted to live independently long after she was able to so do. At one stage, we had a nurse caring for her and over a period of six months, €54,000 was consumed. What caused us to make the final decision was finding her lying on the floor of her apartment, where she had been lying for several hours. We were confronted with the moral question as to whether we should make a decision for her. My mother was very lucid and was most of the time. It is that practical issue that I am trying to address. While I would like to support what the Senator said, I need that issue to be teased out a little more.

Comment on this

I want to clarify that we are discussing amendments Nos. 26 and 29 together.

Comment on this

I take Senator Gerard P. Craughwell's point. I am making a more general argument about the way we are "processing" older people. That is the word for it in the sense that we will not consider having the fair deal scheme applying to the home in the same way that it operates in care settings, but it would be helpful if could start there. In the Senator's case, it was not a practical option for his mother. Sometimes the decision is made. I have aged parents and there is nothing that teaches one how to proceed as quickly and as well as the human being in front of one. It is a more general look at how we should treat older people. We all talk about the dignity of protecting finances, bodily dignity and the dignity of the self, but people want to reside in their homes. This is not the only legislation which sought to bring this about, we are trying to do it from a community, social and health point of view. If I was standing in the next election for the Government, it would be an issue on which I would be standing, that people would have the right to stay in their home where it was practical and where it was medically and psychologically feasible. I understand the Senator's point, but I was talking about it as a generality. I believe that is the way we should be going. We should be looking at the home as the best place. I understand also that if the fair deal scheme applied in the home, the Senator might not have had to make the financial gift he had to make every week for care.

Comment on this

We would like to hear the Minister of State. The Senator has already made her case.

Comment on this

I apologise to the Minister of State.

Comment on this

I will speak first to amendment No. 29.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 26 and 29 are being discussed together.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 29 seeks to ensure the Bill complies with the Data Protection Acts - it is a technical amendment - by prescribing the data protection obligations that will arise for all interveners under section 8. All interveners will be obliged not to attempt to obtain or to use information acquired on a relevant person other than for the purposes of the decision. Interveners will also be required to ensure the relevant information is safely stored to prevent unauthorised access, use and disclosure. Furthermore, a requirement is proposed which would require an intervener to dispose of the information when that information is no longer required. I think that covers Senator David Norris's point on the deletion of text from another section; it is simply transposed and made stronger.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 26, tabled by Senator Marie-Louise O'Donnell, we have had this discussion over and over again and are at one about what should happen, but the difficulty is that this is the wrong legislation. As the Senator rightly pointed out, there are many pieces of legislation into which these types of safeguard on will and preference should be inserted. Unfortunately, this Bill is not the appropriate place because none of us has a right to decide where we are going to live or how we are going to live in many ways. Of course, we can decide if we have loads of money and that is possible, but the Senator's general point is that in the event that someone is already in situ in a home and they do not want to move from there, they should be afforded the opportunity to address that issue.

It is nothing to do with this Bill, it is to do with the fair deal scheme. We did look in the review at whether it was possible to offer the fair deal scheme in the home. What we discovered is that if one were to apply it to a home, while it would be beneficial in certain circumstances it would not suit other people who do not have family to contribute because the fair deal scheme is very much based on a contribution from the person. Despite the fact that one would be quite willing to make such a contribution for care, one would still have to heat one's home, eat and provide for all of the other needs. There must be a different mechanism for doing that. What we must do is build up community services. Most of the factors that keep us well in our own community are issues outside of the remit of the Department of Health and the Minister of State with responsibility for older people.

The next Government should create a new Department of social care, which would bring all of those related issues together to ensure that people at a later stage in their life who might need to dip in and out of services and require additional health care or support would be allowed to stay in their own homes. Equally, we need additional nursing home beds because there are people such as Senator Gerard P. Craughwell's mother who are at a particular stage in life and no matter what one would put in place they cannot safely stay in their own homes.

I accept Senator Marie-Louise O'Donnell's point, but, unfortunately, I cannot accept the amendment. I hope that in another piece of legislation we might be able to make a more reassuring and secure commitment to ensuring people can make choices about what they want. This Bill will allow people to make choices, but, first, there is a big learning curve to address in terms of telling people who need to make decisions now and for them to get those who agree with their point of view, which is important, to make decisions with them.

Comment on this

That is a very reasonable rebuttal. We spend €1,000 every week on one person in a nursing home.

Comment on this

That is cheap in some cases.

Comment on this

If families had that €1,000, under governance, would they not be prepared to provide care? Perhaps that is too creative. One could ask if there is a right place for legislative measures. I accept the point that the Bill concerns decision making and that if older people want to stay in their homes they cannot be forced out, if they have the capacity and wherewithal. However, where does one start with legislation? A measure such as the one I proposed should be enshrined in social, community, health and education legislation. I am in two minds as to whether to press the amendment. I appreciate the work that has been done on the Bill and that one cannot always have everything one wants.

Comment on this

I seek to reassure the Senator again. What we seriously need to do is start to create different types of community in order that one would not have circumstances whereby a person is in a home that is way too big for him or her, as a big house is difficult to heat and stairs are difficult to negotiate among other matters. Perhaps we need to start from the perspective of the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government in terms of creating different types of housing. I do not mean different types of community because I do not want people to be segregated. Members know my views in that regard. We must ensure we start to build more appropriate settings within communities for us as we age.

Comment on this

We continue all the time to create fragile environments and we put older people into them which makes them even more fragile. It is done in the name of health and safety, but, in fact, it is the closing down of their freedom. Some of them are so healthy and safe they are treated like babies and they are not allowed to think for themselves. In effect, their liberty is taken away from them, for example, because they broke their arm and there is nobody to make their dinner on a Saturday. I know the Minister has read the book by Atul Gawande, Being Mortal, and knows what we do to people when they get older. The model is outrageous. That is where politics should start - at the community level where people, if they want and can, stay in their towns and villages.

Comment on this