Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2015: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–185 of 376. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 79 of 2015 ›
Amendments Nos. 1, 2, 5 to 22, inclusive, 25, 46 and 47 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 6, line 14, to delete “child pornography” and substitute “child sexual abuse material”.
As set out during Second Stage in October, tackling child sexual abuse material on the Internet has been a consistent priority for me throughout my time in the Seanad. I firmly believe the proliferation of child sexual abuse material on the Internet is a stain on our moral conscience. A child sexual abuse image is a crime scene, a digital record of sexual abuse being perpetrated against a real child in the real world. I reiterate my disappointment that the decision was not taken to introduce a filtering system against online child sexual abuse material or to do so by statutory instrument. We continue to rely on the threat of this as a means to coerce ISPs into self-regulation and the Garda to develop a response.
The term "child pornography", as defined under section 2 of the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act 1998, is the same term used in this Bill. We should take the opportunity to replace the term "child pornography" with the more apt and reflective descriptor "child sexual abuse material". I have tabled amendments to this effect. I appreciate that the word pornography which first appeared in the English dictionary in the mid-19th century and the use of pornography have until relatively recently been associated with salaciousness and taboo and contrary to the morals of respectable society. Pornography was secretive, shameful and unacceptable. Against this backdrop, the term "child pornography" makes much more sense but attitudes towards pornography have changed significantly over the years. Pornographic material can now be purchased openly in newsagents and petrol stations throughout the country, where it is stored on the top shelves. "Pornography" is no longer a dirty word and its use is no longer an underground practice. As such, I really do not believe the seriousness and repugnant nature of depictions of children being raped, of incest or children being sadistically assaulted or tortured for the sexual gratification of paedophiles is adequately captured by the term "child pornography". Furthermore, I believe the term is misleading regarding the child's role or agency in his or her exploitation. The majority of law enforcement agencies working in this area, most notably Interpol and Europol, agree. According to Interpol, the world's largest policing organisation:
A sexual image of a child is “abuse” or “exploitation” and should never be described as “pornography”.
Pornography is a term used for adults engaging in consensual sexual acts distributed (mostly) legally to the general public for their sexual pleasure. Child abuse images are not. They involve children who cannot and would not consent and who are victims of a crime.
The child abuse images are documented evidence of a crime in progress – a child being sexually abused.
The Minister of State will be aware that I tabled an amendment similar to amendment No. 1 to the Children First Bill. The Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, Deputy James Reilly, agreed that the term "child pornography" is outdated and fails to reflect the full horror of sexual abuse involved. He stopped short of accepting my amendment on the basis that "child pornography" is still the language used in international instruments by which we are bound. He referred in particular to EU Directive 2011/93/EU which is to combat sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children and child pornography and the Lanzarote convention of the Council of Europe. I am not sure, however, whether it is strictly necessary as a matter of law to use the exact same language as used in the convention and elsewhere provided we give robust effect to the substance of the measure.
One of the methods of interpreting international treaties is the teleological or purposive approach which involves looking to the purpose of the international instrument and the broad intent motivating the enactment of the measure rather than its strict text. Notably, Article 41 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties states, "A treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose". Given that international treaties usually apply to multiple countries in many different languages and legal traditions, an excessively literal approach is often unhelpful. By analogy, it is submitted that, provided we address the substance of the relevant international and supra-national measures and achieve, in substance, the outcomes laid out in these instruments, the precise language we use to achieve these aims would not be of primary concern to the relevant monitoring bodies. The Council of Europe and the European Union are unlikely to be troubled if we use different language to achieve substantially the same outcome as set out in the relevant instruments.
The United Kingdom, our fellow European Union and Council of Europe partner, grappled with similar concerns over the inappropriateness and non-reflectiveness of the terms "child prostitution" and "child pornography". These are removed from its Sexual Offences Act 2003 through amendments in the Serious Crime Act 2015. The term for both phrases is now "sexual exploitation of a child".
Incidentally, the practice of updating the language used in criminal statutes to reflect modern understanding is not unknown in Irish law. In section 2 of the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act 1990, for instance, the offence of indecent assault upon any male person and of indecent assault upon any female person are effectively renamed as "sexual assault". It states, "The offence of indecent assault upon any male person and the offence of indecent assault upon any female person shall be known as sexual assault". I have used similar language in this amendment, the broad impact being that what was formerly known as "child pornography" should henceforth be known as "child sexual abuse material". I believe it is a case of when and not if other jurisdictions will follow suit. I am aware of concerted lobbying efforts by groups such as ECPAT in the United Kingdom and at EU and international level to have these terms removed from the directives and the conventions. We can and we should act now. We need to show leadership.
I wish to clarify that the second subsection, as it were, that I included in this grouping of amendments is designed to avoid the risk of a trial collapsing because of an inadvertent reference to the existing terminology. I have tried to ensure we protect it. I believe we should be taking this approach.
Comment on this
Senator Jillian van Turnhout has spoken on this issue previously in the Seanad. There is a great deal of sense in her point about the terminology used. It may not be possible to do it in this Bill and I accept that there are issues particularly around the international language used and particularly as the Bill is explicitly required to give effect to a directive on combatting sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children and child pornography. As the Senator said, there is an issue about the language used in EU and international treaties. We might look towards changing that culture where that language is used and rename it. I accept that would require a great deal of work in terms of education and so on, but it would be a good idea to rename it to reflect more accurately exactly what we are talking about.
Comment on this
I have always admired Senator Jillian van Turnhout's commitment to children and addressing the damage being done to them. She has outlined in a cogent, effective and convincing manner, the reasons the Minister of State should take her amendments on board.
We are living in a changing world. I am not sure that I totally agree with the reference to the fact that "pornography" has become muted or diluted. We all understand what pornography means, but in the context of children anything that would highlight to the general public, the awfulness of these crimes is to be welcomed.
I am concerned about a matter which the Minister of State might address in his response. The report Changing Policing in Ireland published during the week indicated that child pornography cases - let us use that term for the moment - are taking up to four years to be processed. That is scandalous. We, as a nation, cherish children and while we may not do it in the spirit of the 1916 Proclamation, we all have good intent in that regard and certainly where our own children are concerned, we will jealously guard and protect their rights.
It is unacceptable that the judicial system, the legal system or the Garda system is inhibited to such a degree in this day and age. That is only one of many flaws or inadequacies in the technology that has been provided to the Garda. It is unacceptable. It is a severe criticism of the Government and of the Department of Justice and Equality that this has been allowed to fester and continue. Particularly in the context of the amendments, having changed the language, done everything right and put in the structures, when it comes to being effective in fighting against this pernicious crime or series of crimes, the Garda is operating with one hand tied behind its back in this modern technological age.
The Taoiseach is constantly going around the world saying this is the best small country in the world in which to do business in and that it is modern and technologically advanced. I would not confine those remarks to the current Taoiseach but the previous Taoiseach, Mr. Bertie Ahern, in trying to introduce electronic voting, said he was fed up with the idea of a country that was so modern - this was ten years ago - using pencil and paper to count votes. Therefore, it is nothing new. This supposedly modern reformist Government that was elected in 2011 has done nothing.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. There was a discussion on the word "pornography". It comes from the Greeks who defined it as the writings of or about prostitutes and prostitution. It seems pornography is very widely accepted, apparently. I have not visited the petrol stations or the newsagents patronised by other Members of the House, or at least I have not seen this material openly on view, but I assume that they are correct in that it is. The phrase "child sexual abuse material" seems particularly appropriate in the light of the spread of pornographic, or sexually explicit or derogatory material on the Internet. Again, I have no personal direct knowledge of these things because I do not use a computer. I have never watched the Internet, if one can watch it and I do not know if one can. It seems to be something in the ether. I have never seen child sexual abuse material or child pornography, nor do I want to. It is pretty disgusting. For that reason, I strongly support Senator Jillian van Turnhout. She has done us a favour by raising this issue.
I understand from Senator Ivana Bacik that there may be some reasons in terms of the correlation between this law and international legal procedure that means we cannot do this, but I do not take that argument because I do not see why we should not lead the way. This country led the way in the marriage equality referendum. This was the first country in the world to vote this through on a national basis. I do not see any reason we should not lead the world again. Why should we be so backward in feeling we have to tie in with everybody else and that we have to use language that is not as explicit, that is not as clear and does not make the attitude of society as explicit simply because other countries have not yet caught up? We should be in the vanguard. We should be out front, leading proudly as Ireland, as a young progressive nation. I strongly support the substitution of "child sexual abuse material" for the phrase "child pornography".
People are now very chummy about pornography and seem to think it is a good thing and everybody openly discusses it on radio and television and all the rest of it. There seems to be something kind of warm and fuzzy and really sort of nice about pornography - there is the view that everybody does it and all this kind of stuff. Whatever about adults - I spoke on this many years ago in defence of people's access to explicit sexual material for learning purposes, instruction and titillation - I do not see anything wrong with it, but that is when it includes consenting adults. This is children and children are always in these circumstances the victims of exploitation. They are never consenting. They are never willing. They are frequently, I understand from reading about it, as I have never seen it, I would not watch it and I could not bear to watch it, abused physically, raped and, in some circumstances, I understand, even murdered for the pleasure of adults. It is really horrifying.
The nice chumminess where one sits down after one's Sunday roast beef or roast lamb and says we will switch on the television and see pornography is a very different thing from child sexual abuse material. That terminology seems to get it, it focuses it and it makes it clearer. I commend Senator Jillian van Turnhout for her amendment.
Comment on this
I support Senator Jillian van Turnhout in tabling this amendment. The terminology "child sexual abuse material" is still not strong enough. As Senator Ivana Bacik said, there should be a stronger terminology. What that is I do not know, but perhaps it should be child rape and abuse or something like that. The horrific acts carried out on young children are unimaginable. Thankfully, I have never experienced the viewing of it, but I have spoken to professionals who, during the course of investigations, have had to look at it and they have been physically and mentally sick and disturbed as a result of it. It is totally unacceptable. If we could think of a stronger term to use than that proposed, we should use it.
Comment on this
I got the term from the proposal of Interpol and Europol.
Comment on this
It is still not strong enough, but I would be supportive of the basis for it.
Comment on this
I support the amendment that every place in the Bill where the words "child pornography" are used, they would be substituted with the words "child sexual abuse material". Sadly, many young people do not know that child pornography is wrong. There is a normalising of pornography by society. It is the beginning of the ruination of many young people's lives. It is part of a grooming process being used and part of an acceptance culture. While the words may not be strong enough in the view of Senator Diarmuid Wilson, these are helpful words because they include the vital words "sexual abuse". I commend Senator Jillian van Turnhout for being perceptive in this area and identifying a useful change that I hope we all can support.
Comment on this
I thank Senators for their comments. When debating the Bill, we all are united in our attempts to tackle this most heinous of crimes. The Senator refers to explicit material. There is a deliberate attempt among commercial enterprises to sexualise young people and children, to shorten their childhood and to make them aware of their sexual power above any other power. It is quite disturbing. It is something that must be addressed because it is completely disempowering and is warping the young minds of boys and girls as early as possible for commercial benefit in the "legitimate" commercial and corporate sphere. This is something we may be able to return to between now and Report Stage because I am taken by the comments that have been made. I will give the technical response, but perhaps this is something on which we can work.
The effect of the amendments would be to substitute the term "child sexual abuse material" for "child pornography" throughout this Bill and other Acts in which it appears. As the Senator will be aware, the language used in the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act 1998 and this Bill reflects that contained in the EU directive to which the Bill, among other matters, is giving effect, as well as the Council of Europe Convention on Child Sexual Exploitation. It is also a term used in other EU instruments, including the Council decision to establish Europol. The amendments are proposed on the basis that the term "child sexual abuse material" more accurately reflects the horrific abuse involved and avoids the idea of some form of consent which may be implicit in the term "pornography".
In terms of the wording of the amendments put forward, there is a technical difficulty, which means that I would be unable to accept them. The term "child pornography" appears in the Statute Book outside the 1998 Act and any general amendment to that term throughout the Statute Book should be carefully made. I am advised that a general amending provision, as proposed by the Senator in amendment No. 25, would not suffice. Rather each provision in the Statute Book containing the term which it is proposed to amend should be individually identified. While it is not unusual to amend one form of words with another, it is done through individual identification of each instance. This is an important safeguard, particularly where the provisions relate to the criminal law.
The amendments proposed also raise other technical difficulties such as the effect on the Short Title of the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act 1998. I am advised it is not appropriate to amend the Short Title of an existing Act by an amendment in subsequent legislation. The Act should be substituted and repealed.
For these reasons, I am unable to accept the amendment on this occasion. The Minister would, however, fully support including the Senator's proposal in any future review of child pornography legislation. It is a technical reason. Perhaps we might look again to see if we can overcome this technical matter because the language the Senator has proposed is stronger and most likely to be more appropriate.
Comment on this
As I stated, the term has been proposed by Interpol and Europol which have to deal with this abhorrent and horrendous crime. I appreciate the Minister of State's response. The United Kingdom has managed to find the legislative way and has done it. We will not be the first but we should be taking the lead. This is not a case of if it will happen; it is when it will happen. It is about updating our laws to reflect the true seriousness of the crime. However, I withdraw the group of amendments. I want to get this right, but I also want to ensure we protect children and that we send a clear message that there is no consent, it is a crime scene, it is abhorrent and we will not tolerate it.
Comment on this
The purpose of amendment No. 3 is to allow the court to impose a fine instead of, or in addition to, a term of imprisonment on a person who is convicted on indictment of an offence under this section. A fine is already available as a penalty or part thereof for summary convictions under this section but was omitted in respect of convictions on indictment. It is unusual to provide for both a fine and a term of imprisonment in the available penalties, particularly where financial gain may be a motivation in the offence. This is consistent with the framing of other penalty provisions contained in the Bill.
Comment on this
My apologies for wanting to return to my earlier comments, but this Bill is as much about enforcement and here is a section dealing with fines. The report to which I referred and to which the Minister of State did not allude has indicated serious inadequacies in the manner in which child pornography crimes and sexual crimes against children are followed up. For example, there is no cybercrime unit in the Department of Justice and Equality. With respect to Senator David Norris's ignorance of the Internet, most of this awful traffic takes place on the Internet, yet there is no reference at all to what will happen following the enactment of a Bill which will include additional fines and more punitive measures against those perpetrating child pornography and child sexual crimes. The report which was not compiled by the Department but by Mr. Olson states quite clearly that we do not have a cybercrime unit in the Garda. I was gobsmacked when I read that.
I would like some response. I am not trying to make a political point, but this is a serious issue involving the Garda and we are passing a law that will put extra pressure on Garda resources in specific areas relating to cybercrime and child pornography, much of which takes place on the Internet with paedophile rings, etc. I would like a response because it is the earliest opportunity this House has had to raise this matter, following the publication of the report. For the information of the Minister of State, the Leader of the House indicated that the House will debate this report in the new year. I am basing my questions on newspaper reports rather than on anything emanating from the Department. My understanding is that the Minister, Deputy Frances Fitzgerald, has accepted the report in its entirety, which I welcome, but perhaps the Minister of State has some insight. I appreciate it may not be his main area of responsibility, but in the context of this legislation, he might be able give some indication.
Comment on this
With the Minister of State's amendment, we have ended up diluting what is in the Bill. Will he give us an explanation? The Bill, as published, stated, "on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years". We have diluted that to a fine or imprisonment. In other words, we are leaving it to the discretion of the Judiciary. I would be of a view that an offence under this section warrants mandatory imprisonment and it should not be discretionary.
The sexualisation of children is one matter, but the sexual exploitation of children is more serious. People should not be able to get away with a mere fine, which would not be related to the capacity to pay. It should be imprisonment, full stop. The term of imprisonment should be at the discretion of the judge. We should not remove mandatory imprisonment.
Comment on this
I share the Senator's concerns. Reducing the punishment to a fine or imprisonment dilutes the sanction for such a serious and heinous crime. Imprisonment at least offers some rehabilitation. Any imprisonment for sexual offences should be matched with rehabilitation. To leave the penalty at a fine gives an option for the offender to go scot free. It is not at all adequate. We are either serious about penalising sexual offences, knowing the effects on victims, or we are not.
Comment on this
This is standard legal practice, it is not unusual. To not do it would be an anomaly. The amendment is a standard framing of penalties in the State. A range of penalties are available for offences in the Bill and it is a standard in the drafting of penalties for offences. It is not in any way to suggest a fine in this area is an appropriate sentence, it is just the way that legislation in the State is framed across the Statute Book in every single circumstance.
Reference was made to the report of the Garda Inspectorate. The office of Internet safety within the Department provides a hotline service for the reporting of crime and the Minister has completely accepted the report and is examining it in detail. The prosecuting of child pornography is a technically difficult type of investigation which can involve different jurisdictions, unnamed people and unnamed vulnerable victims. As it is Internet based, it is particularly difficult to prosecute. However, there have been a number of recent sexual exploitation cases which were successfully prosecuted. It is given the highest priority, but in order to execute a conviction one must have a proper, robust investigation. Unfortunately, that can take time because of the complex nature of the offence.
Comment on this
I take the Minister of State's point that, in general, the option of "fine or imprisonment" applies right across all statutes. However, it is not universal within the Statute Book. If my memory serves me right there is mandatory imprisonment for offences regarding drug pushing. We have seen that sanction ignored by the Judiciary which, unfortunately, is a law unto itself when it comes to these issues and is not in any way accountable. In the past decade the Judiciary has successfully resisted the efforts of Administrations to establish a judicial council which operate in more progressive and democratic administrations.
We cannot compare the sexual exploitation of children which in many instances may have a lifelong impact on them with other offences on the Statute Book where this discretion is allowed. As legislators, we should collectively say this is an offence which is countenanced under no circumstances and that it is taken seriously. If a person engages in any way in this exploitation or encourages others, or engages in or encourages others to pay for or set up the exploitation - there is specific reference to the sexual exploitation of children - one pays the price. That price is imprisonment and the Judiciary would have discretion on the term of that imprisonment. A person who may be well off financially should not be able to get off purely by paying a fine. It might be a substantial fine but because of their own financial resources it would be insignificant to them and the sanction would be meaningless. This would not be acceptable and it is not prioritising the protection of children in the way that should be done. I feel strongly about this. I know that the amendment has gone through, but I appeal to the Minister of State to re-examine it in order that on Report Stage we could ensure this section reflected the graveness and seriousness of the offence of sexually exploiting children.
Comment on this
I will be brief in the context of the Government's proposals. I am at a loss to understand why this is happening. I appreciate the Minister of State has outlined that this is standard across various pieces of legislation. However, I refer to what has been happening with our nearest neighbour, the United Kingdom, with some very high profile cases relating to child pornography and Operation Yewtree. During the 1970s Gary Glitter was an icon to children and his hit records at the time conveyed this. Under his real name, Mr. Paul Gadd he was as a paedophile jailed in the United Kingdom and the Far East. Several other high profile celebrities, when they went before the courts and were convicted of child pornography would have had, as Senator Jim Walsh said, massive financial resources and would have easily met a fine no matter how high. Mr. Rolf Harris was a case in point and he was jailed. This amendment is sending the wrong message. It is saying the people concerned have a possibility of getting off with a fine, no matter how heinous the crime.
Comment on this
I know that in practice it is being left to the Judiciary to decide if it will be a fine or imprisonment, but as far as I am aware the amendment is changing the original sanction which was a mandatory jail term, unless the Minister of State can tell me otherwise. To delete "to the imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years" and substitute "to a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years, or both", means in plain English that the original version was imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years. Now it is changed and the Minister of State is not sending the right message at all. I do not know why this was drafted and why it went through the Cabinet considering all of the comments made in this House which would reflect the opinion of the population - that this is a heinous crime for which there will be no tolerance whatsoever.
Comment on this
I believe we are all agreed that this is a heinous crime and it is good to see it being defined and laid out in such detail in this important Bill about the sexual exploitation of children and adults. However, I wish to inject a small note of reality into the debate. The amendment which has already passed without contest simply allows for a fine to be included alongside imprisonment. It is a technical amendment. When one looks at subsection (5), the subsection into which the amendment is being made, one sees that it provides for the sentencing in standard fashion - "a person shall be liable on summary conviction to a class A fine or imprisonment, not exceeding 12 months, or both". It is not a mandatory sentence. A summary conviction is in the District Court which is where fines are imposed in more cases than in the Circuit Court. It is at conviction on indictment where one sees the sanction of imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years. If a person is being prosecuted on indictment in the Circuit Court on an offence under section 3, they are more likely to be subjected to a term of imprisonment than if they are being prosecuted in the District Court where fines are already imposed. It is simply technical that the words "fine or imprisonment" are always included. One would very rarely have fines imposed by way of penalty where there is a conviction on indictment in the Circuit Court for an offence of this seriousness.
I reassure colleagues that, as a matter of practice and reality, where one has an offence of this serious nature proceeding to prosecution on indictment, prison is the most likely outcome and much more likely than in the District Court. However, imprisonment is not mandatory in either case. The Bill uses the term "shall be liable". The point is that imprisonment is the maximum penalty.
Comment on this
Section 3(6) provides that a child "means a person under the age of 18 years". In section 4, child "means a person under the age of 15 years" and section 5 defines a child as "a person under the age of 17 years". In the space of three consecutive sections, the word "child" has three different meanings, namely, a person aged 18, 17 and 15 years, respectively. This is completely inconsistent. Why dither with the description of a child? The Minister of State may live in one of Dublin's leafy suburbs but I live in the north inner city where if one called a person of 18 years a child, one would get what is locally described as a poke in the snot. A person of 18 years is not a child, as I understand the word. The matter would be resolved by removing the word "child" and inserting the phrase "a person under the age of" followed by the prescribed age. Why not define the age in absolute terms instead of having this glaring inconsistency?
The age of consent is a troubled and difficult issue, although I have always agreed with the idea of an age of consent as a guideline. In this Bill it is illustrated by the inclusion of three greatly different ages - 18, 17 and 15 years - to define the same thing, namely, a child. I assume that in respect of section 4, somebody who is aged more than 15 years is not a child. If somebody of 16 years is not a child in section 4, why should a person be a child until the age of 18 years for the purposes of section 3? This is completely daft, but I am a humble, ordinary person. Humility is one of my most remarkable attributes, of which I have a great number.
Senator Paschal Mooney referred to Operation Yewtree, which was horrible. I do not know if Gary Glitter was caught up in that operation.
Comment on this
The entire episode was utterly revolting and shocking. In his autobiography Jimmy Saville drew attention to the fact that he was molesting children. He was brazen in the extreme and it was shocking that he was not prosecuted at the time. Senators should consider the case of Cliff Richard who is a decent man as far as I know. While I have never met him, I have always liked him and his music and I approve of his Christian beliefs and so on. As part of Operation Yewtree, his home was invaded by police who did not tell him what they had told television broadcasters and the tabloid press. The police have since had to withdraw the allegations. In this case, a person who was innocent of the allegations had his name trawled through the mud by the police, which is utterly shocking. While I agree with the legitimate prosecution of these types of offence, which have correctly been described as heinous, a certain degree of sensitivity is required. It is profoundly shocking that in cases where persons were being pursued on suspicion or on the word of an unnamed third party whose anonymity was protected, police handed out information to the media before subsequently being forced to withdraw the allegations. While I do not expect the Minister of State to comment on that matter, I would appreciate a comment on the business involving the meaning of a "child".
Would it not be more logical to replace the word "child" in section 3 with the words "a person under the age of 18 years"? This phrase is perfectly clear and does not lead to the contradiction in the very next section in which a child is defined as a person under the age of 15 years. One could just as easily insert the phrase "a person under the age of 15 years". In section 5, one would then use the phrase "a person under the age of 17 years". That is the logical approach, rather than having this nonsense about children being of different ages all over the place.
Comment on this
I will speak to the amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister of State indicated that it is standard legal practice to provide for the imposition of a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years. However, the amendment changed the meaning of the original text which provided for a sentence of imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years. Is the inclusion of that penalty not also standard practice?
I share the view expressed by previous speakers that we must ensure the penalty is a term of imprisonment and the imposition of a fine is not an option. The withdrawal of a person's freedom is the minimum that should be experienced by the perpetrator of this heinous crime. Victims groups are driven mad by the sentencing that involves fines. How many times, following the handing down of inappropriate sentences for serious sexual offences, have Senators argued that the punishment did not fit the crime? We are of one view on this issue. The Bill gives permission for fines to be imposed. I ask the Minister of State to revisit this issue. Why did the amendment reduce the sentence?
Comment on this
I bow to the greater expertise of Senator Ivana Bacik on legal matters. A little like Senator David Norris, I am a simple human being.
Comment on this
If one views the section in its entirety, it is not about individual crimes, that is, one individual exploiting a child, but about group paedophilia. It is about obtaining, providing, etc., a child for the purpose of sexual exploitation in which money changes hands. The section refers to obtaining a child for himself, herself or another person and provides for a sentence "on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years". The amendment changed this by providing that such persons may be fined. The original text is clear and does not provide for the imposition of a fine or a term of imprisonment. I cannot understand the reason the provision is being diluted.
I was very reluctant to go down the road Senator David Norris went down regarding Cliff Richard, but I concur with everything he said. I am a great fan of Cliff Richard whom I have met and believe what was done to him was outrageous. I did not want to go down this road because there is a case that is still unresolved and shows similar patterns much nearer to home. I refer to a person who has been accused in the public media without due process. My main focus in this matter is to ensure what the Minister of State is doing in the matter of convictions is the right thing and will not in any way allow people to get off.
Comment on this
To clarify one matter, I do not live in the leafy suburbs but in Ballybough, an area that has leaves.
Comment on this
Yes, although my house is not as big as the Senator's.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is much younger than I am. I did not have my house when I was his age.
Comment on this
I do not wish to diminish the seriousness of the topic we are discussing. On the issue of fines and mandatory prison sentences, mandatory imprisonment is limited to a small number of offences, namely, certain drugs and firearms offences. The sexual exploitation of a child is addressed in the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act 1998 and carries a penalty of a life sentence. We are dealing today with an offence that is in part financially motivated. Therefore, the addition of a fine, as provided for in the amendment, is appropriate. It should be noted, however, that the amendment has been passed.
It is a worthy debate, but we have work to do.
In terms of the sections, as outlined by Senator David Norris and on the apparent discrepancy in the definition of what constitutes a child, these are technical issues and relate to international law. Section 3 is an EU directive requirement and, therefore, the age is 18 years. Section 4 is a passive form of sexual assault and the age below which one cannot consent to an act which may amount to sexual assault is 15 years. Section 5 stipulates 17 years which reflects the age of consent in national law generally.
Comment on this
I understand what the Minister of State is saying to the effect that we are bringing these things into alignment with international law. On the other hand, there is nothing to prevent him from taking out the word "child" and putting in "a person of such and such", which would remove the apparent contradiction. It does look like a contradiction. If in international law one has a situation where children are defined differently all over the place, that is absurd also. Why not call it absurdity? It is not just absurdity if it occurs in this jurisdiction. If it occurs throughout Europe, it is even more absurd that children are classed as being such at different ages, depending on what section of the law at which one looks. A child is a child is a child just as a rose is a rose is a rose. It seems to be utterly daft to have different definitions of what a child is in terms of his or her age. If in one section a child is somebody under the age of 15 years, how can it be that somebody under the age of 18 years is a child in the next section? It seems to be absurd. I am not going to push the matter, but it is absolute nonsense.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for his reply and explanation but neither has fully reassured me. I can understand from where he is coming a little better. This section is about obtaining or providing a child for the purposes of sexual exploitation; therefore, there is an intent. I agree in terms of the section on summary convictions which would be dealt with in the District Court and I have not put forward fines as an alternative. However, if it is a conviction on indictment, obviously the matter has been regarded more seriously by the Garda and also by the Director of Public Prosecutions. Does it matter whether we take a view that we can depend on the Judiciary? I do not think it does. It comes down to what signal the Legislature sends to the Judiciary. Are we happy to send it legislation which says a fine is a satisfactory penalty or sanction for somebody who has obtained or endeavoured to obtain or who is providing a child for the purpose of sexual exploitation in circumstances where that is regarded a sufficiently serious offence to be subject to conviction on indictment? I certainly do not agree that it is sufficient. I accept what the Minister of State said about the section being passed. Unfortunately, I only spotted what we had done to the original text as I read the section. All I am asking is for the Minister of State to look at the matter. Will he give us an undertaking that he will look at the matter and come back to us on Report Stage when he has considered the points which we have made? Many people have spoken in favour of this point of view. From his comments, I do not think he has a fundamental objection with what has been said. I ask him to consider the matter between now and Report Stage.
The age of consent can be a difficult enough issue. I spent some time, probably ten years ago, on a children's committee. Two of the other members of that committee were the then Minister for Health and Children, the late Brian Lenihan, and the then Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, Mr Michael McDowell. It was an all-party committee and I think the parties had their own legal representation. We took a strong view on the age of consent. One of the suggestions that came from the committee which the Minister of State might consider, if not in the context of this Bill then perhaps in terms of another is that where two senior adolescents, for example, 16 or 17 year olds, engage in sexual activity, they should be treated differently and perhaps the law should reflect this. I think the Judiciary probably does so. It is different from a situation where-----
Comment on this
-----I am not saying what the Senator is saying is not of interest, but I really do not see what relevance his comments have to this section.
Comment on this
Let me explain. I am referring to section 3(6) which refers to the age of 18 years. All I am asking is that the Minister of State, perhaps in this legislation or, if not, a future Bill, consider providing for a situation where a case involving somebody aged 40 or 50 years would be regarded more seriously. The committee recommended that if there was a ten-year age gap, the offence should be regarded more seriously. I wanted to share with everyone that which the committee to which I refer came up. Its findings might be something that might be looked at with regard to the age of consent, adding to what Senator David Norris said on the matter.
Comment on this
I wish to comment on the definition of what constitutes a child. I believe different definitions are needed. Let us say two 17 year olds are doing a line. Section 4(1) states, "A person who, for sexual purposes, invites, induces, counsels or incites a child to touch". If a child, in that instance, is defined in the same manner as a child in an instance of paedophilia, that is different; therefore, we need a definition. The Minister of State should return to this matter because the legislation could deem all 17 year olds going out together to be criminals, particularly in the context of the phrase "inviting to touch". That is an issue.
Comment on this
I refer Senators to the comments I made previously. If further clarification is required on the issue of additional fines and imprisonment, we will be happy to provide it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I could not quite hear the Minister of State. Is he going to look at the definition of a child before Report Stage?
Comment on this
We can examine it in the context of providing clarification and I have no difficulty doing so. As Senators stated, the definition is a sensitive issue. It is also a difficult one because different instances require different responses. In order to ensure clarity, we have no difficult in doing, as I have outlined.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. I am not trying to change the offence. It would be a good idea to substitute the phrase "a person of 15, 17 or 18 years". That would remove the question of these conflicting definitions of a child which are repugnant to reason and leaving that definition of a child-----
Comment on this
No, we are not. We are taking Committee Stage which will be adjourned at 5.30 p.m. That is the order of the House.
Comment on this
I understand the definition of a child is 18 years, but in some cases it is 15 years and in others, 17 years. It is all perfectly logical.
Comment on this
The proceedings on Committee Stage shall be taken at the conclusion of the debate on Committee and Remaining Stages of the Courts Bill 2015 and shall be adjourned not later than 5.30 p.m., if not previously concluded.
Comment on this
No, that was the Courts Bill. It is Committee Stage only of this Bill which was to commence at the conclusion of Committee and Report Stages of the Courts Bill which is being taken. We have concluded all Stages of the Courts Bill.
Comment on this
This is Committee Stage of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2015. The proceedings on Committee Stage shall be taken at the conclusion of the debate on Committee and Remaining Stages of the Courts Bill.
Comment on this
Yes, it is Committee Stage only of this Bill that is being taken and the debate is to be adjourned at 5.30 p.m.
Comment on this
No. I want clarification. I am sorry, but because of Senator David Norris's contribution I do not know what the Minister of State said about fines and imprisonment in terms of the core of the argument we made on the section. Will the Minister of State repeat what he said?
Comment on this
I was interrupted by the confusion about the legislation.
Including the phrase "a person under the age of 18 years" does not change anything in the legislation. It also leaves us in a situation where this legislation can chime perfectly adequately with European legislation. It does not conflict with it.
Comment on this
The amendment has been passed.
Comment on this
The amendment has been passed and the justification for the amendment has been given. I have given an undertaking on the language provided in respect of the uncertainty of some Senators on the question of fines versus imprisonment, as well as in respect of the definition of a child. We are happy to return to this issue on Report Stage to allay whatever fears Senators have.
Comment on this
It may be appropriate to ask the Minister of State to look at this section. There is a name on the question of an age difference, although I cannot remember what it is. It could become part of the age of consent issue and how it is framed and adjudicated on by the Judiciary. I recall at committee meetings we had suggested a ten-year age gap.
Comment on this
I wish to make a point since we are on the age of consent. I know that it is an extremely troubling issue. When legislation was going through some years ago, I coined the phrase "the Romeo and Juliet syndrome". I pointed out that a sexually experienced 16 and a half year old girl could seduce a sexually inexperienced 14 year old boy and the 14 year old sexually inexperienced boy would be guilty of rape. That is an outrage to common sense. It is complete rubbish, but it is still the law of the land and it was passed through both Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
The issue in respect of age of consent is addressed in section 17. The proposed section 17 includes a new section 3(8) of the 2006 Act and provides for a proximity-of-age defence where a person is charged with an offence against a child between the ages of 15 and 17 years. It shall be a defence that where the child consented to the activity and the accused is younger or less than two years older than the child or the accused, he or she is not considered to be a person in authority or there is no intimidatory or exploitative element to the relationship. Effectively what I am saying is that the issue Senator Jim Walsh has raised is dealt with in section 17.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 4 brings additional clarification to section 8 which creates an offence where a person communicates by means of information and communications technology with another person for the purposes of facilitating the sexual exploitation of a child. The offence is committed whether the perpetrator contacts the child directly or contacts a third person to facilitate the sexual exploitation of the child. The purpose of the amendment is to clarify that the other person referred to in the provision includes the child, the victim. While implicit in the reference to "other person", the amendment makes it explicit.
Comment on this
Section 9 includes a new paragraph (a) with a definition of child pornography that includes any visual representation "that shows, or in the case of a document relates to, a person who is or is depicted as being a child". The reference to "the case of a document" seems a little odd to me. I presume this refers to a pornographic document. What happens in the case of Benny Hill dressing up as a child and engaging in frolics and so on? That is little nonsensical. In other words, what if we have someone who is an adult but dresses up in a pair of short trousers or a baby frock or whatever else, but he is plainly and obviously an adult? Is it really very significant to attack this kind of practice? It does not titillate me, I have to say, but it seems a little absurd. It is fine in the case of a person who is a child, but I am unsure about the provision for "a person who is depicted as being a child". It seems to be a little daft. Again, perhaps there is a cogent explanation.
Comment on this
Article 2 of the EU directive obliges member states to define child pornography as: "any material that visually depicts a child engaged in real or simulated sexually explicit conduct". In other words, it covers the case of any real depiction of a child. The definition also includes:
Any depiction of the sexual organs of a child for primarily sexual purposes; or
"any material that visually depicts any person appearing to be a child engaged in real or simulated sexually explicit conduct or any depiction of the sexual organs of any person appearing to be a child, for primarily sexual purposes; or
"realistic images of a child engaged in sexually explicit conduct or realistic images of the sexual organs of a child, regardless of the actual existence of such child, for primarily sexual purposes".
In this context, the term "a child or someone depicted as a child" is appropriate as determined by the EU directive.
Comment on this
That is rather silly. I do not care if it comes from the European Union. An absurd idea comes into my mind. What about dwarf pornography? I do not know if there is such a thing, but they look like children sometimes. Are we outlawing dwarf pornography?
Comment on this
This section deals with a person who "causes, incites or compels ... a child to participate in a pornographic performance". Again, this may be some kind of European thing. I am keen to ask the Minister of State because I do not know anything about it and believe the House would welcome the information. Is there any evidence of child pornographic material being produced in Ireland? I am not aware of it. It may happen. I am not a consumer of these products, but I am curious and interested to know whether we are dealing with a real situation. Is child pornography being produced here?
Comment on this
I have carired out some research in this area. I will outline how people get involved in child pornography. What happens is that they accidentally come across it on the Internet. They may be horrified and step away and decide it is awful. Often, however, they will go back within a week and start getting more involved in the imagery. In order to be king, they need to trade material. We have serious cases in Ireland. They can involve fathers, men or people making pornography in order to start trading.
Comment on this
It happens in Ireland, absolutely. It happens every day in every county in Ireland. I can guarantee Senator David Norris that this horrendous activity is happening.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 13, to delete line 5 and substitute the following:
“(c) a current or former step-parent of the child (‘step-parent’ shall include, for this purpose, a spouse, a civil partner (as defined by section 3 of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010) or a cohabitant (as defined by section 172 of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010) of the child’s parent),”.
For the purposes of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2006, a step-parent is treated as a person in authority. This means that he or she is subject to heightened maximum penalties on conviction of a sexual act with a stepchild. The traditional legal understanding of a step-parent has long been the spouse of a parent.
Notably, Murdoch's Dictionary of Irish Law defines "stepchild" as "a child of one spouse by a former union". Other legal sources suggest that a marriage is required to make a person a step-parent. For the specific purpose of tax law, however, the child of a civil partner is treated the same as the child of a spouse, but this is a result of a specific amendment to the Finance Acts 2011 and 2012. While the meaning of "step-parent" may well have evolved or evolve over time, it is not clear whether the civil partner or cohabitant of a parent is also a step-parent for the particular purpose we are discussing.
While a civil partner or cohabitant is likely to be treated as a person in loco parentis and, thus, a person in authority for this purpose, I remain concerned, since any ambiguity in legislation must be read in the favour of the accused. For instance, a civil partner could claim that he or she was not a step-parent and potentially escape liability, in particular if the civil partner is not for some reason in loco parentis. Arguably, he or she should be treated as a step-parent, but the point is unclear and the legislation would benefit from a wide definition of "step-parent" or a clear statement from the Minister of State that it was his intention that a current or former spouse, civil partner or cohabitant of a child's parent was a step-parent and, thus, a person in authority for the purposes of the Bill.
Comment on this
I endorse Senator Jillian van Turnhout's comments. The scientific research on all family types done in this regard shows that, by a significant degree, the highest at-risk situation for children is where a single mother cohabits. In such situations the child is substantially at risk of sexual exploitation and physical and fatal injury. It would be essential not to permit a lacuna in the law regarding such situations, as that would be to exclude the situation in which someone would be most at-risk.
Comment on this
I am in sympathy with what Senator Jillian van Turnhout stated, as it is revolting that someone in a position of authority should exploit a child for sexual purposes. However, it strikes me that paragraph (d) covers this matter adequately. It reads, "a current or former partner of a parent of the child". As such, the amendment is redundant and I see no necessity for it. I would, however, be interested in hearing the Minister of State on this point.
Comment on this
I have sympathy with the Senator's amendment. The evidence is that a great deal of the sexual abuse of children occurs within the family setting. This has been noted for a long time and was one of the bases on which the Stay Safe programme was introduced in the early 1990s. It is abuse in the most trusted of settings. I do not know what the legislation can do to prevent it. We have always addressed it from the point of view of empowering the child to know when there have been inappropriate approaches and touches, but it also depends on the culture of the family. Any legislative measure that we can put in place to protect the child or punish the offender is welcome, but, unfortunately, it is often too late for the child, as the offence has already taken place. This forms part of a wider discussion on the issue.
Comment on this
The Minister thanks Senator Jillian van Turnhout for this amendment and will re-examine the drafting of paragraphs (c) and (d) to ensure they cover comprehensively all persons who are or have been in a position of authority through a relationship with the parent of a child.
Comment on this
I hope there will be a statement on the matter on Report Stage so as to add clarity, which is what I am seeking in this provision. In that light, I will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
This addresses a concern about whether a reference to being charged with an offence should refer to a defendant being charged or a person being charged. Substituting the wording "Where, in proceedings for" removes this concern and is consistent with the approach already taken in section 17(4).
Comment on this
Amendment No. 27 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 26. Amendments Nos. 26 to 28, inclusive, and No. 30 are related and may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
On Second Stage the Minister informed the House that she would introduce amendments to Part 3 of the Bill relating to the purchase of sexual services that further decriminalised the women and men involved in prostitution by removing those who offered sexual services from the existing offences of soliciting and loitering for the purpose of prostitution. Amendment No. 26 makes the necessary provision, while amendment No. 30 ensures no inadvertent consequences may arise from it.
Section 7 of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1993 criminalises a person who, in a street or public place, solicits or importunes another person for the purposes of prostitution. Section 8 of that Act creates an offence where a person is loitering in order to solicit or importune another person for the purpose of prostitution and fails to leave that place when directed to do so by a garda. "Soliciting" is defined to include all parties whether male or female, prostitute or client or third party, such as pimp, and includes curb crawling.
There have been a number of calls, including from organisations associated with the Turn Off the Red Light campaign, for the removal of those selling sexual services from these offences. The effect of such a change will be that only those people who solicit the sexual services of others, that is, the buyers and pimps, will be prosecuted for the solicitation and loitering offences under the 1993 Act.
The primary rationale for decriminalising the sale of sexual services is that those offering the services involved in prostitution are highly vulnerable, often from impoverished backgrounds and frequently with addiction and other issues. It is often the case that those involved in on-street prostitution are among the most vulnerable and marginalised within an already vulnerable group. Retaining criminalisation for solicitation is to penalise this high-risk group. Decriminalisation will also allow people to report violence experienced on the street without fear of prosecution and encourage them to seek appropriate support services. The decriminalisation of on-street prostitution will bring the Irish approach further into line with that of Northern Ireland and the Nordic approach generally.
Amendment No. 26 deletes the current paragraph (a), which reads, "offers his or her services as a prostitute to another person", from the definition of "solicits or importunes for the purposes of prostitution" in section 1(2) of the 1993 Act. The effect of the amendment is to remove the persons offering sexual services from the offences under sections 7 and 8 of that Act of soliciting and loitering, respectively, in a public place for the purposes of prostitution. These offences will still apply to any person who solicits a prostitute, that is, the buyer or pimp, or any person who loiters in a public place for the purpose of soliciting a prostitute.
The inclusion of this amendment by itself gives rise to concerns that the Garda would be left with no means of combating any public nuisance if sexual offences were to be offered, for example, in a residential area. There is also a concern that the provision could be exploited by criminal gangs or others. Amendment No. 30 addresses these concerns. Section 8 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1994 provides that a garda may direct a person who is behaving in certain ways, for example, intoxicated, threatening or abusive, to stop behaving in that way or immediately leave the specific area. It is an offence under section 8 to fail to follow such a direction.
This amendment will add loitering for the purpose of offering services as a prostitute to the behaviours subject to a direction under section 8. The effect of the proposed amendments will be that on-street prostitution will not itself be an offence, but the Garda will still have the power to move on from a public place when necessary a person or persons offering sexual services. The remaining amendments in this group have been proposed by Senators and I will respond to them after they have been moved.
Comment on this
I welcome the Government's amendment. Our amendments were trying to achieve the same end. There has been a very long campaign to ensure we could decriminalise those who sell sexual services and I commend the people in the Visitors Gallery who have been campaigning on this issue for a very long time. The Turn Off the Red Light campaign has been very effective and very important because it has long been the case that many women have found themselves in the position of being turned into criminals in situations where they have been virtually powerless. In the light of the Government amendment which obviously crossed with us tabling amendments, we will not be pressing our amendments. We are achieving the same aim and I welcome the statement of the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I welcome amendment No. 26 which the Minister had flagged on Second Stage and which was requested by the Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality. I also welcome those in the Visitors Gallery who have been involved in moving forward this law reform, particularly the Immigrant Council of Ireland, Ruhama and the Turn Off the Red Light campaign. We debated the policy behind the provisions of sections 20 and 21 on Second Stage and they are very welcome to target demand and to criminalise the purchase but not the sale of sexual services. I see amendment No. 26 as very important in confirming that policy because, as the Minister of State said, it will decriminalise services as a prostitute by making that amendment to section 1 of the 1993 Act. That is very important. As the Minister said, it will bring this jurisdiction into line with the law in Northern Ireland and in Sweden and other Nordic countries that have taken a similar approach to tackling demand. To stress it again, the women and men engaged in prostitution and the sale of sexual services will be themselves decriminalised. Sometimes those who criticise the Nordic approach have suggested this is all about criminalising clients. Offences around the purchase of sex are already criminalised.
Comment on this
This approach decriminalises those engaged in prostitution, recognising the exploitation involved. In this regard, I understand why amendment No. 30 has been included. I have some concern that it may lead to harassment on the street of those engaged in selling sexual services, those women and men engaged in prostitution. While I understand that, as the Minister of State said, it does not criminalise prostitution which is now decriminalised, it does provide for the offence of failure to move on when directed to do so and specifically with reference to somebody who is loitering for the purpose of prostitution. I ask that some attention might be paid to this if we are going to put that amendment through. I understand the public order issue, but we might look at guidelines for An Garda Síochána as to how it operates that provision. Those of us from the Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality who travelled to Sweden and heard about how the law there is implemented were very impressed by the multi-agency approach and by the exit strategies with which the police and social services were all engaged. It was not just criminal justice.
Comment on this
It is, therefore, very important there be joined-up thinking and that the Garda not, on the one hand, be given a directive that it should be moving on women or men involved in selling sex on the street and, on the other hand, trying to work with them to ensure the criminalisation of clients and pimps. We need to be careful about this. I very much welcome amendment No. 26. It is welcome and very much in line with the request of the Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality. Perhaps the Minister of State might consider putting forward an amendment to section 13 of the 1993 Act on Report Stage in line with the overall policy objective of section 20. That would be to extend to section 7A, the new offence inserted by section 20 of the Bill, the power of arrest already present for section 7 offences. It is a power of arrest contingent on the new offence in section 7A-----
Comment on this
I can come back to it. I just wanted to save time by referring to it now.
Comment on this
I welcome the people from the Turn Off the Red Light campaign. I completely oppose their position and suspect their motivation. The information supply has been disastrous. Senator Ivana Bacik spoke about social workers in Sweden. Attempts were made to silence a considerable number of social workers in Sweden who have spoken out and given statements contradicting the position of the Turn Off the Red Light campaign. There is something incredibly patronising about people defining somebody as a victim, despite that they do not feel they are a victim. They have no right to say they are not a victim. I welcome the Cathaoirleach's guidance on the matter. As I am opposing the section, I presume I do not speak until it comes up for discussion.
Comment on this
Yes. I thank the Cathaoirleach. I welcome the partial decriminalisation of prostitution that is contained in this measure, but I deplore the criminalisation. It seems mad to take a unified transaction and criminalise half of it. It is absurd to decriminalise one half and criminalise the other half. There does not seem to be much logic in the Visitors Gallery today.
Comment on this
This is a momentous day and I hope we pass the Bill. It would be nice to have unanimity on it. I welcome the amendment. The women and young girls who comprise most of those involved in prostitution are vulnerable, marginalised and poor. I appreciate the work done and the information shared with us by Ruhama, the Turn Off the Red Light campaign and the HSE. They speak about the frame of mind women who have had to engage in prostitution to survive have to get into to go through these acts. On exiting it, for those who have been able to do so, one of the quotes was "It was a shit life". When that is the only way a person has to survive, it may be seen as consent, but I would question consent under that type of pressure. There is no such thing as safe prostitution. Sometimes people are battered to death, in the words of one rape crisis volunteer. The HSE has reported on the gang rape of women. The Internet is not helping. Prostitution is gender-based violence against women. We are right to take an ethical stance against buying another person, because that is what we are talking about. This is an exploitation issue. There are no safety or labour laws in the prostitution context. The Netherlands has tried and failed for ten years. The profits, on the other hand, are extraordinary. I read a quote from one young woman who said she did not have to pay any more than 50% to her pimp. One wonders who has to put up with all the pain and who gets all the gain. The hands of the Garda have been tied. That came out in the "Prime Time Investigates" programme.
Is the Swedish model enough? I would say it is a start. It is welcome that it makes it an offence for someone to purchase sex, but it is not the full solution for the woman who may be vulnerable and poor. We need very solid exit strategies and supports to help women rebuild their lives. It came across very well at a briefing we had in the audiovisual room recently that we had to bridge them into a new life. They have to be given holistic, psychological and financial support. One cannot leave people high and dry and on the breadline. They are also vulnerable to being enticed back. The best approach - there was consensus about this - is a more victim-centred one and the Garda would have to be trained and supported in that role. It needs support in legislation. Will the Minister of State say what extra Garda resources will be put into this?
Comment on this
It is all vital because we are bringing in new-----
Comment on this
I am talking about the amendment. We are bringing forward an amendment to decriminalise the women and men in some cases if they are involved in prostitution and to criminalise the buyers. What extra resources will be made available for that purpose?
I would like to flag another issue. Some of the women involved in prostitution have been trafficked here. Some of them do not have a visa status that supports them working here. If they make a report to the Garda, can we ensure they will not be criminalised for their visa status? Can we ensure the primary issue will be the health and well-being of the woman or man who involved in prostitution and wants to get out of it? A very important balance needs to be struck within a competing set of rights. We might come back to that point.
I welcome this legislation. I have been receiving e-mails from people in Galway and elsewhere in the country for at least two years, perhaps three or more years, looking for it to be introduced. I am glad that it is happening during the term of the Government and before Christmas.
Comment on this
I welcome any move which deals with the exploitation of vulnerable people. The people in question are women in the main, although some are men. I welcome any protection given to those who are trafficked, in particular. It is extraordinary that in this day and age we have moved back to a slavery trade that is probably more extensive than it has been at any time in history. It is appalling that this trade is even more extensive than it was in the 19th century. It has not been addressed by the international community as comprehensively and energetically as it needs to be. Anything that protects the women involved, in particular, is essential and I welcome it. I also welcome the steps being taken to protect women who are vulnerable by reason of drug addiction. The Minister of State has taken the particularly strong line that the criminal system is not the way to deal with drug addiction and the crime that flows consequently from it.
It is a mistake to say everybody involved in prostitution is being exploited or vulnerable. All the reports clearly show that a coterie of women participate in high-class escort agencies and charge very high fees for the sexual services they offer. I do not know to what extent this is the case. I agree with Senator David Norris that it is absurd that the purchaser is guilty of a criminal offence but the women who are selling the sex - it is a very lucrative business as far as they are concerned - are not guilty of such an offence. The Minister of State should look at that issue again. There is a danger associated with the manner in which this is being done. It is contingent on men, in the main, responding to the fact that they will be prosecuted criminally for what they do. That may not have the deterring effect that the Minister of State might expect or that any of us might expect. There are many laws on the books that are ignored by people.
I am concerned about vulnerable women, in particular. Some Senators referred to poor women who had resorted to prostitution as a means of getting some money. Poverty drives people into the sex trade. I am not sure the construction of this legislation will not have the opposite effect of increasing the number of women who participate in prostitution. That would be of some concern to me. I lived in an era when almost everybody was poor. We had nothing like the levels of crime we have today.
Comment on this
It is called exploitation now.
Comment on this
I do not think being poor should ever be regarded or accepted as a justification for resorting to any criminal activity.
I do not think this proposal should apply in certain situations. I refer to women who do this voluntarily. I am not speaking about those who do it out of financial necessity, because they are addicted to drugs, because they are being trafficked or because their pimps - boyfriends, in many instances - are forcing them to do it. It is absurd, as Senator David Norris said, that women would not be subject to a criminal offence in circumstances in which none of those things applied.
Comment on this
The purchaser is going to be criminalised.
Comment on this
This legislation is criminalising the purchaser. That is what I am saying. What is good for the goose is good for the gander. That is my opinion in this regard. I ask for it to be looked at again. It is not the same, but it is a little akin to saying the drug addict should be criminalised and brought to court for purchasing drugs but the drug pusher should in some way be decriminalised. I know that there is a significant difference.
Comment on this
We must keep a balance in the law, but we are not doing that in this instance. I can understand the intention of the amendment, which is to protect vulnerable women. That is something I fully support, but we have gone way beyond it in creating this new situation.
Comment on this
No, the Senator will not be brief. She does not know what the word "brief" means.
Comment on this
This is an historic day. I thank the Minister of State for bringing this amendment forward. I was not on the Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality. I thank Senator Ivana Bacik and her colleagues on the committee for all the work they have done. I was a member of committee D of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly in 2013 when it brought forward a report on human trafficking. I met representatives of Ruhama and Turn Off the Red Light at that time. This issue was discussed ad nauseam by the committee, which made a recommendation in this regard. It was under the chairmanship of Lord Dubs at the time. We have seen the Northern legislation on streamlining and know how trafficking works. There is no border when it comes to prostitution. This is a hugely significant day. Decriminalisation is most welcome.
The Minister of State has been sitting in the chair for four and a half hours. He was there when I was speaking on the previous Bill. He has not moved. Perhaps we might facilitate him by providing for a break of 20 minutes after we have dealt with this section.
Comment on this
I join others in commending the Turn Off the Red Light campaign for the manner in which it has approached and campaigned on this issue locally, nationally and internationally. This proposal is being made following an examination of the Swedish approach by the Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality. The Minister and I have deliberated on the matter with various interest groups in this area. The Swedish approach comes from a Parliament that is 45% female. The issue of gender equality in parliamentary representation is an important one. We should think about that when we discuss the issue of gender quotas also.
I accept Senator Ivana Bacik's well made point that we cannot take legislation from another jurisdiction without resourcing and funding it, providing for a process of training with regard to it and discussing with the Garda and others how it will be managed and how it will come into effect. I assure Senator Jim Walsh that we are not going to revisit this issue. I disagree with him and Senator David Norris. They are entitled to their opinion, but I disagree with it, as does the Government.
Comment on this
Arguments are always welcome. The argument for decriminalisation is that the seller is the vulnerable person. Prostitution is a demeaning, undermining and nasty industry. There is nothing glorious or glorified about it, contrary to what seems to have been suggested.
Comment on this
I am given to understand that in some circumstances the impression is almost being given that this is a liberating profession. It is an industry that undermines, devalues, dehumanises and demeans those involved in it, most of whom are women but some of whom are men.
Comment on this
In this amendment we are attempting to decriminalise these individuals to ensure they know they can approach the authorities, that help and support are available to them and that they are not criminals by virtue of having been lured or forced into the industry. The great majority of those involved in it are involved in it for reasons of poverty or addiction.
The amendment criminalises the buyer, which is an appropriate response. That enables the Garda to tackle the issue properly in a proactive and realistic fashion.
I thank the Senators who have spoken about this issue. While I appreciate that people have come to it with different perspectives, the issue of prostitution is one that has been with us for a very long time. To suggest we continue to approach it as we always have does not stand up to scrutiny any more. There are movements across the world to address the issue differently. The Swedish and Northern Irish approaches are being adopted here. As Senator Fidelma Healy Eames said, this is a good day.
Comment on this
I thank Senators for their support.
Comment on this
I suggest we take a break before we talk about the section because I will take quite a long time to go through the argument.
Comment on this
It is disingenuous of the Minister of State to try to give the impression that anybody suggested prostitution was a glorious career. Nobody I heard in the Chamber suggested that. Perhaps it is because he does not have a better argument to defend against the point that was being made to him, which he ignored. I support fully the view that a majority of women who decide to resort to prostitution are very vulnerable, often due to financial necessity, drug addiction, or human trafficking, which is heinous. However, there is a coterie of women for whom it is a choice. Anybody who has watched this on various programmes internationally or here, or who has read reports on it, knows that there are women who make considerable money from it and it is a choice. While I agree fully with criminalising and charging the purchasers right across the board, that coterie who do it as a choice and do not have the defence of being drug addicts, trafficked, pimped or coerced should face the same rigours of the law as the men. It can be the converse, too. It can be a gender-neutral situation because there are male prostitutes also. In those scenarios, it is wrong that one party participating is being charged with a criminal offence, while the other person is regarded as immune from any criminal prosecution. That is fundamentally wrong and borders on sexism.
Comment on this
I disagree. The intent is to end demand.
Comment on this
Our effort in order to tackle demand is to criminalise the purchaser and decriminalise the seller in an attempt to ensure the vulnerable seller of sexual services feels society takes a compassionate view of the situations in which they find themselves, that support services will be available to them, that they can approach gardaí without fear of criminal sanction, that they can find a pathway out of prostitution and that the resources of An Garda Síochána and the criminal justice system are channelled and funnelled toward the demand side of the equation. That is the purpose of the amendment.
Comment on this
I am ad idem with the Minister of State on reducing the level of prostitution and agree fully that one of the ways to do so is to tackle demand. However, the point I make is that if he is really serious about reducing it, why not tackle the supply side also where it is not being produced by women who are vulnerable in any of the categories I mentioned? There are women who do it as a career because it is very profitable. Why not take the same approach to them? I see no good reason the Minister of State would not. I do not disagree with tackling the demand side because he is correct, but for those who participate very willingly, have no qualms with regard to doing it, find it highly profitable and are not in any of the vulnerable categories that all of us would want to protect and not criminalise, why do we not make a distinction? That is the point I am making.
Comment on this
The Minister of State talks about demand and supply as if this was simply an economic situation, which it is not. Taking at a superficial level the question of tackling demand, there is nothing whatever to suggest demand has decreased as a result of this measure. Any purported statement that this is the situation have been completely undermined by Swedish academics. When the Minister of State was talking, I said: "What about prohibition? Did that work?" Worse than that, the Minister of State is not even suggesting prohibition. He is suggesting decriminalising the bootleggers and criminalising the drinkers. It is completely daft. I will have a great deal more to say about this when we get to discuss the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 17, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following:
“(3) The Minister shall collect data to review the operation of this offence and report to the Houses of the Oireachtas after this offence has been in effect for two years. In particular the report shall set out—
(a) information on the nature and extent of prostitution connected to human trafficking including numbers of arrests and convictions during the period covered by the report in connection with an offence under this section or section 2, 4 or 5 of the Criminal Law(Human Trafficking) Act 2008,
(b) the extent to which, in the opinion of the Minister, this section has operated to reduce human trafficking, and
(c) the impact of this section on the safety and well-being of prostitutes”.”.
My amendment would require section 20 of the Bill criminalising the purchase of sex to be reviewed and voted on again after two years by the Oireachtas. It is a very reasonable suggestion and, if it believes the law will result in a reduction in the number of people engaged in sex work and incidences of trafficking for sexual exploitation, I cannot see why the Government would oppose assessing its effectiveness in two years time. According to Amnesty International, the criminalisation of sex work is increasingly being recognised as a human rights concern. The United Nations special rapporteur on the right to health has called explicitly for the decriminalisation of sex work. The final report of the Global Commission on HIV and the Law, an independent body convened by the UN Development Programme on behalf of the joint UN Programme on HIV/AIDS, has made the same call. The commission deliberated over a two-year period, undertaking extensive analysis and research including seven regional dialogues on the links between legal frameworks, human rights and HIV.
Sex Workers Alliance Ireland, represented in the Visitors Gallery by Ms Kate McGrew, suggests two years would give an accurate picture of the impact of the legislation to assess it adequately. We must allow time for gardaí to be issued with guidelines on enforcement. A two-year period would provide the Garda with enough time to establish enforcement and the Government to commission an independent evaluation. There is zero evidence from Sweden that sex work has decreased since the introduction of the criminalisation of the purchase of sex, as there has been no consistent monitoring, independent research or evaluation of the legislation there. The Swedish Government's report evaluating criminalisation between 1999 and 2008 provided no data or evidence to prove that the levels of sex work had decreased or increased.
The report stated: “Altogether, this means that we can feel somewhat secure in the conclusion that prostitution as a whole has at least not increased in Sweden since 1999”. No data or evidence is provided to back up the statement in any way. As a result, the report is highly questionable. This is a highly complex policy area. We must ensure Ireland does not make the same mistake as Sweden and fail to monitor the outcomes and impacts of our laws adequately. That is why I propose the amendment to insert an operational review of section 20 into the Bill to ensure we have consistent, independent evaluation of this and other legislation related to sex work at regular intervals.
Sex workers tell us that where this law is implemented it makes their lives more difficult and they often have very poor relationships with the police and support services. HIV Ireland and the World Health Organization, WHO, have expressed serious concerns about the impact of such measures on health care access and HIV rates. Ireland's HIV rate increased by 11% last year. This is very serious and we need to do more to reduce HIV rates, not introduce laws which increase HIV rates, according to research by The Lancet and the WHO. We need this review of the legislation to ensure we monitor and assess the impact the law will have on health. It is a nonsense to criminalise the purchase of sex. It is a coalition between extreme feminists and right-wing fundamentalists. I am entitled to my opinion.
Comment on this
I do not think the Senator is right.
Comment on this
This section of this otherwise superb Bill is a nonsense.
Comment on this
Senator Mary White might be interested to know that the justice committee received unanimous support for the proposal to adopt the policy approach of decriminalising the sale and criminalising the purchase of sexual services.
Comment on this
No. It is my contribution on Senator Mary White's amendment.
Comment on this
It is not a point of information.
Comment on this
No. I asked to contribute in the same way any other colleague would.
Comment on this
The Senator is the key driver of it.
Comment on this
In fact, a number of members of the justice committee, from all parties and none, drove this. Senator White's Fianna Fáil colleagues fully endorsed the proposal.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I know Members in the Chamber who agree with me but who do not want to stand up and speak in public.
Comment on this
Senator Denis O'Donovan, Senator Mary White's colleague in Fianna Fáil, travelled with us as part of the justice committee delegation. We received unanimous, cross-party support on the justice committee for the recommendation which was subsequently developed by the Minister for Justice and Equality, Deputy Frances Fitzgerald, and the Minister of State, Deputy Aodhán Ó Ríordáin. It certainly is not a coalition of different views, as Senator Mary White suggested.
Comment on this
It represents an evidence-based approach to tackling a serious issue of exploitation.
Comment on this
If the Senator disagrees, I invite her to read the report of the justice committee which received cross-party support from members of all parties and none.
Comment on this
The justice committee turned its face against considerable evidence. The document, Research into Prostitution in Northern Ireland, prepared at the request of the Northern Ireland Department of Justice, is unequivocal, and the justice committee did not mention it. The objective, scientific realities were completely ignored. The Chairman of the justice committee, Deputy David Stanton, put a notice on his website fully endorsing the Swedish model before the committee had heard any evidence. This shows how open-minded he was. Senator Ivana Bacik is right that the committee does not represent a diverse group of opinion. That is the problem with it. All members are singing from the same hymn sheet.
Comment on this
The committee members are from Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin and the Labour Party.
Comment on this
The Senator would know all about interrupting.
Comment on this
I do. I practice it. It is a parliamentary skill in which the Senator is very well versed. I have much to say about the committee. Its members neglected to involve themselves with a series of people who proposed to talk to them. They omitted matters from the report.
Comment on this
Why were others allowed to discuss it? May I not even refer to it, while the other side can?
Comment on this
Yes, and I support the amendment, given that it is absolutely rational. If the Minister of State rejects it, he will be doing the House a favour by exposing the hypocrisy of the exercise. If the Minister of State is not prepared to accept the amendment, it is an utter disgrace and an affront to democracy. The amendment calls for a review of the operation of the legislation.
Comment on this
What have we got to be afraid of in a review of the operation of the legislation? The Minister of State does not want to know the facts. He has turned his face against them. The amendment provides that the Minister shall collect data to review the operation of this offence and report to the Houses of the Oireachtas. What is wrong with it? It is good parliamentary procedure. The Minister's report would include information on the nature and extent of prostitution connected to human trafficking. There has been a blurring of the division between prostitution and trafficking. It is a disgrace. It is a marketing exercise and a PR stunt by people who are radical feminists and ex-nuns. Some of them should be ashamed of themselves, given that they come from the order that operated the Magdalen laundries and are still trying to control people. The amendment provides that the Minister's report would include the extent to which, in the opinion of the Minister, the section has operated to reduce human trafficking. The Minister of State does not even want to know whether it will reduce trafficking. What is he afraid of? He is afraid of the truth, reality, objective facts on the ground. He will not face them. The amendment provides that the Minister also report on the impact of the section on the safety and well-being of prostitutes. All this humbug about talking to the women is all tripe if the Minister of State is not interested in their well-being. If he were really interested, he would want to know the impact on them. Of the women spoken to for the report commissioned by the Northern Ireland Assembly, 98% were against this model. The Minister of State does not speak on behalf of these people. I attended the briefing session and it was laughable. There were people there who were interpreting the minds of these women and speaking on their behalf with no permission to do so. Unless the Minister of State accepts the amendment, his hypocrisy is completely exposed. He does not give a damn about the safety and well-being of the women who are walking the streets and the spread of disease. It is all a middle-class pretence and a load of hypocrisy.
Comment on this
I do not support the amendment. Originally, we came to the issue by way of a motion tabled in the Seanad by the Independent group. Two motions were tabled, which led to the hearings by the justice committee. I carried out my own research, met many people across the spectrum on the issue and examined considerable evidence and fully support the Government's approach on the issue. The only question I have left is what category Senators Mary White and David Norris put me in, but I do not care because I support the amendment.
Comment on this
Debates are good and extremes of view are good. I hope we will arrive at an in-between position which is good for everybody. What is bad about decriminalising the person who has to engage in prostitution? What is bad about criminalising the buyer, the person who says, "There is a price on your body"? What is bad about criminalising a boyfriend who will force a girlfriend to go out to work? What is wrong with respecting the voices of people who work with the victims and who have heard the voices of the victims?
Comment on this
I ask those who support the amendment and who are against the Government proposal how many people they have spoken to who have said they feel safe while engaging in prostitution?
Comment on this
How many say this is their preferable position in life or that they do not always feel trapped? How many are willing to say this is the best career in which they could be involved? I have not heard that type of feedback.
Comment on this
I do not agree with the comments made by my colleague, Senator Mary White, when introducing amendment No. 29. I am perplexed as to why Senator Jillian van Turnhout is opposed to this amendment.