We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2015: Committee Stage

Contributions 186–376 of 376. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2015
Enacted

No. 79 of 2015 ›

The amendment is very simple. It is very clear and one to which I have no difficulty adding my support.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Good.

Comment on this

It is asking for three things.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Information.

Comment on this

It is looking for information on the nature and extent of prostitution connected to human trafficking, including the numbers of arrests and convictions during the period of the first two years. That is a matter in which every Member of this House should be interested. The second point looks for the extent to which, in the opinion of the Minister, this section has operated to reduce human trafficking. That is important because I presume one of the main objectives of the legislation is to reduce prostitution and, therefore, human trafficking and sex slavery. The third item is the impact of the section on the safety and well-being of prostitutes. Senator David Norris is correct in saying these requests for information are a barometer, or litmus test, of the genuineness of the legislation and the motivation behind it. I am not querying the motivation behind the legislation, but I accept that it is genuine. If it is genuine, I see no reason whatsoever the amendment would not be accepted and endorsed by the Minister of State. It would add to what has been stated as being the purpose of the Bill. It would provide for a check in order that the Department and Garda offices would be accountable. I hope the Minister of State will have no difficulty in accepting this and I divorce the amendment from the manner in which it was introduced. I do not agree with the comments made when the amendment was introduced, but I do agree with its wording and intent.

Comment on this

In case there is any ambiguity, Amnesty International does not suggest human trafficking, forced labour or the exploitation of children should be decriminalised. There is in this House a deliberate fudging of prostitution and trafficking, by which I am appalled. What the heck is wrong with Members that they cannot support a review?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Exactly.

Comment on this

I do not understand it. We have a professor of law who does not want a review of these matters. I regard Senator Ivana Bacik highly, but-----

Comment on this

I did not say that. I stated my opposition to the Senator's point that those in favour of section 20-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The record of the House will speak for itself. Senator Mary White to continue, without interruption.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 29 is about having a review in two years time.

Comment on this

I did not express a view on the Senator's amendment.

Comment on this

Is the Senator happy to have a review?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The record of the House will speak for itself.

Comment on this

I do not understand the logic of my colleagues. We are here to do the right thing for society. Why can we not have a review of the Bill in two years time? Those who do not support a review should not be here at all.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Perhaps the Minister of State might accept it.

Comment on this

I will outline for the House the organisations that have been involved in this campaign, which have been described as radical feminists and right-wing extremists. They include AkiDwA, Barnardos, the Children's Rights Alliance, Doras Luimní, the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, Focus Ireland, the Immigrant Council of Ireland, IMPACT trade union, the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation, my party, the Labour Party - perhaps we are radical feminists - One in Four, Pavee Point Traveller and Roma Centre, the Public Service Executive Union committee, Rape Crisis Network Ireland, SIPTU, Sport against Racism Ireland, Unite and Women's Aid.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The founder of One in Four is against it. The issue was never discussed with the membership of those organisations.

Comment on this

What about people who work in the industry? Do they have no say?

Comment on this

Rather than dismissing those groups of individuals who have come to this point of view-----

Comment on this

It is a populist view.

Comment on this

-----we should accept that they have come to this view because, like all in this House, they are trying to do what is best. I have only listed a number of organisations, but they should not be dismissed as having any motive apart from what is best for those who find themselves in a very vulnerable postion.

The amendment inserts a review provision into the Bill in respect of one section only, namely, section 20, which criminalises the purchase of sexual services. I assure the Senator that all the provisions in the Bill which, in addition to dealing with the exploitation associated with prostitution, address the sexual exploitation of children and protections for victims in the criminal process will be kept under continuous review. While I appreciate that there is a similar provision in the Northern Ireland legislation, the provisions in this Bill are too important not to be fully and properly implemented and I have no doubt it will be kept under review, with or without the proposed amendment.

It is also the case that the information sought should be available on request at any time without the need for a future review provision. Given the considerable debate on these provisions, I fully expect the information to be sought from my Department well in advance of a two-year review. In so far as the amendment sets out particular matters to be reviewed, since 2009 the anti-human trafficking unit of my Department has been providing annual reports on trafficking in human beings in Ireland. These annual reports are available on a dedicated anti-human trafficking website blueblindfold.gov.ie. Information on the extent of prostitution offences is available from the CSO and is regularly published.

I certainly expect issues impacting negatively on the safety and well-being of prostitutes to be addressed as they arise, but, as I have said and while there has been much discourse and narrative on this point, there is no substantive evidence showing a negative impact on the safety of those who provide sexual services in those jurisdictions where a similar approach has been implemented.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes, there is.

Comment on this

For these reasons and because of a minor drafting difficulty with the amendment, I am not in a position to accept it.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Will the Minister of State show the House where a review of the three areas to which Senator Mary White's amendment refers is made explicit? Will he indicate the point in the Bill where this is made explicit?

Comment on this

The Minister of State is ducking the matter. It is like saying all items of legislation are under review. Any Minister can say that, but we know in practice that it rarely, if ever, happens unless something occurs which highlights a lacuna. The Departments are not so proactive in monitoring what goes on in matters immediately under their control, not to mention previous legislation, which would probably be an impossible task. This is a specific request with regard to the issue of human trafficking and the Minister of State is doing himself an injustice.

He is exposing himself to giving credibility to some of the criticism that has been directed at him as to the motivation behind this. This is a very simple amendment. It would ensure that within two years - it would not be at the Minister's discretion, as it would be mandatory - such a report would be published on what are very germane matters concerning the outcomes of the legislation we are passing today. As somebody who has shown some degree of-----

Comment on this

I might not go that far, but as somebody who has shown some degree of ingenuity in the responsibilities he holds, the Minister of State should clearly exercise his right to accept the amendment. Too many Ministers of State who come to this House do not have any discretion, look over their shoulders for guidance and do not accept amendments. What distinguishes the good Ministers from the routine or run-of-the-mill Ministers is that they will exercise discretion in the House by accepting amendments that are sensible and enhance the legislation. That is the purpose of the amendment.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I have looked through the Bill and can find no explicit statement in any section which suggests there will be a review. I challenge the Minister of State to provide information on the precise page and line number in the Bill where this review is indicated. I do not believe it is available, but if the Minister of State can direct me to it, I will withdraw my allegation. Again, it is astonishing that he would turn his face against the collection of data and information on the nature and extent of prostitution connected with trafficking, the extent to which this is operated to reduce human trafficking and the impact of the section on the well-being of prostitutes. He might well say the legislation in its entirety is subject to review, but that is not stated in the Bill. That is a general piece of waffle. Will the Minister of State be kind enough to show me the precise page and line where a review of this legislation, in whole or in part, is provided for, because I do not see it?

Comment on this

I did not say that. I said all-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State implied it.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State implied it. It is the same thing.

Comment on this

I said all legislation was kept under constant review. With regard to this amendment, it clearly has been cut and pasted from the Northern Irish legislation.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

The word "Assembly" appears in the amendment and it would have to be amended before it could be considered.

Comment on this

I will give the people in the Chamber, including the very esteemed professor of law and the Minister of State, a chance to think about it further. What the heck is wrong with having a review of the legislation? Why should it be carved in stone? That is what happens with much of the legislation passed by the Oireachtas - it is carved in stone forever and nobody returns to it. I will not press the amendment, but I will retable it on Report Stage. I hope people will use their heads and the Government will provide for a review two years hence.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendment is withdrawn.

Comment on this

Yes, I am pushing it back to-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I wish to make a point before it is withdrawn. I hope this will be tabled on Report Stage. I would like if there were a vote on it today. It is important to expose the hypocrisy of the Minister.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendment has been withdrawn.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It has not been withdrawn yet.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Excuse me, Senator. It has been withdrawn.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Did Senator Mary White say it was withdrawn?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendment has been withdrawn.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I hope this goes to a vote on Report Stage and the hypocrisy of the Members on that side of the House is fully exposed.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendment is withdrawn by leave of the House.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes; I was right. It was not withdrawn.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It was withdrawn.

Comment on this

I understand how my colleague Senator David Norris feels and sympathise with him. However, I wish to give the benefit of the doubt to the Members who are present in the Chamber today. What is wrong with reviewing legislation?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendment is withdrawn.

Comment on this

What is wrong with it? I sincerely believe people who are not willing to have a review should not be here in the first place.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

As the Minister of State was seeking what is called a "comfort break," perhaps he should take it now because I will take some time. I would not like him to be agonised while I speak. Does the Minister of State wish to have a break now?

Comment on this

I am ready for the Senator. Bring it on.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

On his own bladder be it.

To challenge the question of the Swedish experience, I quote from a report of the Norwegian Ministry of Justice: "The Swedish street prostitutes experience a tougher time". That is the evidence. The Minister of State asked if there was evidence and said there was none. I have it with me. It is an official report from the Norwegian Ministry of Justice. It continues:

They are more frequently exposed to dangerous clients, while the serious clients are afraid of being arrested. Prohibition will never be able to stop the purchase and sale of sex. It could only make conditions worse for the prostitutes. They have less time to assess the client as the deal takes place very hurriedly due to fear on the part of the client. [The prostitutes] are exposed to violence and sexually transmitted diseases. If the client demands unprotected sex, many of the prostitutes cannot afford to say no. Harassment by the police has increased and the clients no longer provide tip-offs about pimps, for fear of being arrested themselves. The social workers working on the streets have problems reaching them. [The prostitutes] use pimps for protection.

In further support of this, I will quote from an interview in 2010 with a senior adviser regarding prostitution of the National Board of Health and Welfare of Sweden:

[You] put [them] in the same category, and you say that well, ultimately, it's all the same, it doesn't matter if you make €5,000 a month, you sell sex without intermediaries, independently ... you're in the same position as someone who is forced by third parties to, somebody who's underage and forced by third parties....

In other words, there is a complete blurring of the situation. I offer another quote from a social worker in Malmö's prostitution unit:

... [You are] not [included in the debate] unless you are a former sex [worker]. Or a former client [...]. If you ... give a picture [that's] painted in many colours, it's not okay. If you paint in black, it's okay. You can be listened to.

The senior adviser at the National Board of Health and Welfare for issues surrounding prostitution noted during an interview that a political consensus was formed by silencing discursive opposition, where Gunilla Ekberg and radical feminists working for the Social Democratic Women "really made an effort to control what people were saying, and then they, of course, did not invite those who were blacklisted, or on their shit list, they did not invite them to meetings, and of course you understood that your agency could not be considered for government grants ...". What is that if it is not bullying? Threatening to take away grants if one expresses a different opinion is a wonderful exercise in democracy. To quote an interview with a social worker in the Malmö prostitution unit in 2010:

...everyone must be on board. If you're not, if you say something bad about [the discourse], then you're against the whole law, you're against the whole thing. And then you're excluded...

I am quoting the National Board of Health and Welfare in Sweden. I am providing a series of quotes because I wish to be factual and clear. I wish to reply to what the Minister of State said about there being no qualifications in Sweden and about the results being clear, unambiguous and scientific. They are not. They are open to the most severe challenge. I refer to a 2007 report of the National Board of Health and Welfare in Sweden. That is quite official; it is a fairly authoritative voice. It states:

It is also difficult to discern any clear trend of development: has the extent of prostitution increased or decreased? We cannot give any unambiguous answer to that question. [How does the Minister respond to that?] At most, we can discern that street prostitution is slowly returning, after swiftly disappearing in the wake of the law against purchasing sexual services. But as said, that refers to street prostitution, which is the most obvious manifestation. With regard to increases and decreases in other areas of prostitution - the 'hidden prostitution' - we are even less able to make any statements.

The Minister of State does not want to have a review because he does not want to face these facts.

Women involved in prostitution say that criminalising clients will see more women being trafficked into Ireland. After all, pimps always have access to clients. The new law will cause sex workers to be much more secretive about their job and unlikely to reach out to agencies for help and support. This is the wonderful way in which the Minister of State is helping women. The Swedish National Police Board issued a press release in 2010, a decade or so after the new law was introduced in that country, which stated:

Serious organized crime, including prostitution and trafficking, has increased in strength, power and complexity during the past decade. It constitutes a serious social problem in Sweden and organised crime makes large amounts of money from the exploitation and trafficking of people under slave-like conditions.

That is the effect in another jurisdiction of the law the Minister of State proposes to introduce here. No wonder he does not want to learn about its effects. No wonder he does not want to have an examination or review of the provisions he has brought forward.

In a survey of sex workers in the United Kingdom, a roughly similar jurisdiction to ours with a very similar social make-up and so on, one of the key findings was that the large majority of interviewed migrant workers in the sex industry were not forced or trafficked into prostitution. In Northern Ireland, it was found that 98% of prostitutes interviewed were fully against the provisions the Government is introducing here. The UK study found that immigration status is by far the most important factor restricting sex workers' ability to exercise their rights in their professional and private lives. Working in the sex industry, it noted, is often a way for migrants to avoid the unrewarding and sometimes exploitative conditions they meet in non-sexual jobs.

I turn now to the negative consequences of the law, particularly the increased risk of violence. Although there is no reliable study on the issue, sex workers express fear of increased violence, as well as the conviction of an actual increase. Unlike speakers on the other side of the House, I am referring to actual research. Other speakers can only cite their jaunt to Sweden where they failed to engage with any of the groups working with prostitutes. They refused, for example, to meet representatives of the Rose Alliance and ignored the fact that when they were there, figures were released showing an enormous increase in prostitution and trafficking. I am referring to research conducted by Dodillet and Östergren in 2011, Scoular in 2010, Hubbard in 2008, the Norwegian Ministry of Justice in 2004 and Östergren in 2004. The Skarhed report of 2010 notes that a 2003 Swedish Government report referred to a heightened risk for sex workers because of greater competition among women for fewer clients. However, being a Swedish Government report, it concluded that this increase in violence was not the fault of the law but of the women themselves. As I said, the report by Queen's University, Belfast, noted that criminalisation of clients is not considered a useful policy measure by the vast majority of sex workers. Only 2% of the 171 workers who took part in its survey agreed that criminalising clients was a good idea. That is the level of support for these changes among sex workers.

In Sweden sex workers and researchers say the crackdown on street-based sex selling has forced women to move to more hidden and thus potentially dangerous locations. The men still on the streets are reportedly the more dangerous ones, while the nicer, safer clients have moved to the Internet. That is a factor of which no account seems to have been taken. Since the 1980s, there has been a significant drift from the street to the Internet, a reality that is not reflected in this law. As sex workers avail of more hidden locations to avoid the police, they may end up in the hands of third parties in an effort to stay out of the view of the police and secure clients. That is documented in the 2011 paper by Dodillet and Östergren, the Swedish National Board of Health and Welfare report of 2007 and the 2008 paper by Bernstein. Is the Minister of State prepared to deal with these facts? Will he indicate whether he or his advisers have read the Queen's University report, Research into Prostitution in Northern Ireland?

I take the opportunity to offer a number of comments by Irish sex workers. It is vital that their voices are not silenced.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is making a Second Stage speech.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

No, I am directly addressing my reasons for refusing to consent to the passage of this section. One Irish prostitute noted that the new law would make it more difficult to find apartments and hotels in which to work. She expressed concern that workers who were already established might find it easier as they already had a network, while new girls would be more likely to put themselves in danger as the industry went further underground. Another is convinced that many sex workers will be driven into poverty and have to rely on benefits. Since the Cathaoirleach does not want the voices of these women to be heard, I offer those comments by two women as a representative selection and will omit the comments of the other 12 or 14 women. If Members ever want to hear the other statements, I will be happy to show them.

I turn now to the marketing campaign surrounding the alleged success of the Swedish Sex Purchase Act. It is claimed the law has reduced prostitution and trafficking for sexual purposes, had a deterrent effect on clients and changed social attitudes. Those claims were most recently stated in the 2010 evaluation of the Act. At least an evaluation was made. Even the Swedes did that much, but the Minister of State is not prepared to do the same because he is afraid of what he might find.

The problem with these claims is that if they are carefully investigated, they do not appear to be supported by the available facts from research. As soon as the official evaluation was published, it was criticised from several directions, with that criticism focusing primarily on the lack of scientific rigour. The evaluation did not, it was noted, have an objective starting point since the terms of reference given were that the purchase of sex must continue to be illegal. There was no discussion of the facts. Illegality was the starting point and the facts had to be found to fit that or, rather, the facts had to be concealed and buried. There was not even a satisfying definition of prostitution.

The evaluation of the law did not take into account ideology, method, sources and possible confounding factors. There were inconsistencies, contradictions, haphazard referencing and irrelevant or flawed comparisons. According to the academic report by Dodillet and Östergren, the Sex Purchase Act "was introduced by feminist policymakers who argued that prostitution is a form of male violence against women". In other words, it was ideologically driven. The report by the Norwegian Ministry of Justice talks about a general problem with statistics from Sweden, describing them as "highly uncertain". This is one Government commenting upon another.

There is not the slightest scrap of international evidence that the so-called Swedish model has reduced trafficking into that country. In fact, the United Kingdom and Ireland scored better than Sweden in a recent survey on global slavery. To be clear, we are scoring better than Sweden on this marker after some ten years of the operation of the new law in that country. That tells us how effective it has been. The finding is somewhat odd given the claims made by the proponents of the Swedish model that it has reduced trafficking for sexual exploitation. In addition, there is a general ignoring of the New Zealand example, which has been successful.

Between 2009 and June 2014, the total number of suspected victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation encountered by the PSNI was 81. The number of confirmed victims was 26 during that five-year period.

This is serious and dreadful, but it is hardly the epidemic to justify this massive campaign.

I am a member of three unions and was never consulted. Not a single trade union consulted its general membership on this issue. This is the strength of it. It was a PR campaign railroaded through.

The Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality had a jaunt to Sweden and while it was there, the Swedish forum for human rights confirmed the trafficking of more than 166 children between 2008 and 2011 and confirmed the loss of 438 immigrant children in 2011 alone. Hello - is anybody listening? On the final day, sex workers were graciously permitted in but no transcript was made publicly available. Neither of the two sex workers, whose appearance at the very end of the meeting was sheer tokenism, requested their testimony to be excluded from the transcript, but the decision was made not to record their views. How balanced is this?

I wish to quote from a report from the press agency of the Rikspolisstyrelsen, the Swedish National Police Board. It has stated serious organised crime, including prostitution and trafficking, has increased in strength, power and complexity in the past decade, that it constitutes a serious social problem for Sweden and that organised crime makes large sums of money out of it. Why, when it was considering this, did the Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality neglect to examine a variety of social models and concentrate exclusively on the Swedish model? Why did it refuse specifically to liaise with the New Zealand authorities and the New Zealand Prostitutes' Collective, despite the well publicised success of full decriminalisation? Why did it refuse to invite the Swedish sex workers who expressed great dissatisfaction with the social model? At the Dublin conference in October Pye Jakobsson of the Swedish Rose Alliance spoke about the serious and various negative consequences experienced by sex workers under the Swedish model. Why did the delegation which visited Sweden in November refuse to meet the Swedish Rose Alliance? I have referred to the fact Deputy David Stanton put on his Facebook page a declaration about the situation before the committee had heard any evidence whatsoever.

In 2007, eight years after the law was implemented, the Government of Sweden conceded, according to an official Swedish Government document, that it could not give an unambiguous answer to the question on whether prostitution had increased or decreased. That is an interesting comment from the Swedish Government. Reporting from 2008 to 2010 showed an increase of trafficking in Sweden of 106%. The number of reported cases of sexual services sold went up by 569%. That is hardly a great tribute to the success of the Bill. A paper in The Lancet in July 2014 stated full decriminalisation would inhibit HIV transmission by up to 40%. Is nobody listening to these things? Is nobody concerned about the spread of disease? It is all very well to be comfortably ensconced here in our little middle-class environment and prate about life on the streets when very few people have real experience of it.

Amnesty International is a highly reputable body of international reputation. One in Four was instanced by the Minister of State as supporting it, and perhaps it is, but the founder of One in Four is the director of Amnesty International, which has fully endorsed the report. This should tell us something about diversity of views. There are all kinds of sensational charges laid about Amnesty International and against anybody who speaks out on behalf of this vulnerable minority. As I pointed out, 98% of prostitutes are against it, but 80% of the voters in Northern Ireland are in favour of it. That is why we have the unusual alliance between provisional Sinn Féin-IRA, on the one hand, and the Roman Catholic hierarchy, on the other, together with the Paisleyite Protestants. It is an interesting alliance. Amnesty International does not endorse or encourage sex work. It takes no position on this issue and is solely concerned with the protection of sex workers' human rights. Neither is Amnesty International's approach advocating any right to buy sex. Amnesty International states the moves to criminalise the purchase of sex run counter to increasing evidence that such an approach puts sex workers at risk and leads to human rights violations. This is Amnesty International stating it puts people at risk and leads to human rights violations, not a trade union or the Irish Countrywomen's Association, but the principal body dealing with human rights in this country.

Comment on this

Not all human rights, not the rights of the unborn child.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

For God's sake.

Comment on this

No, let us be clear.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Abortion once again-----

Comment on this

That is pathetic.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator David Norris to continue, without interruption.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The criminalisation of sex work is increasingly being recognised as a human rights concern. The UN special rapporteur on the right to health has explicitly called for the decriminalisation of sex work. The final report of the Global Commission on HIV and the Law, an independent body convened by the UN development programme on behalf of the joint United Nations programme on HIV-AIDS, has made the same call. The commission deliberated over a two-year period, undertaking extensive analysis and research, including seven regional dialogues on the links between legal frameworks, human rights and HIV. I apologise, as this information has been given by Senator Mary White in a very fine statement.

The UN AIDS advisory group on HIV and sex workers recommended that states move away from criminalising sex work or activities associated with it. It also recommended that the decriminalisation of sex work include removing criminal penalties for the purchase and sale of sex. It could not be any more unambiguous. This is the most reputable international body. It also recommended that the management of sex workers, brothels and other activities related to sex work, to the degree that states retain non-criminal administrative law regulations concerning sex work, be applied in ways that do not violate the workers' rights or dignity and ensure their enjoyment of due process of the law.

Now let us turn to the World Health Organization and the Minister of State can dismiss this any way he likes. It calls for countries to work towards the decriminalisation of sex work and the elimination of the unjust application of non-criminal laws and regulations against sex workers. The International Labour Organization has called on governments to recognise sex work as an economic sector and a legal occupation, with protection under the labour law, social security and health regulations. Human Rights Watch, Open Society Foundations and Anti-Slavery International, among other non-governmental groups, have also called for the decriminalisation of all sex work. A constellation of bodies is calling for the deletion of these two sections, which is my proposal. In Norway-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Deputy Leader wishes to propose an amendment to the Order of Business.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That we take a comfort break.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is fine as long as I can continue. I just have a few more points to make.

Comment on this

We can continue if the Senator has just a few more points. I am conscious of the need of the Minister of State for a break.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It might take perhaps up to five minutes.

Comment on this

That is fine. I just wanted to advise the Cathaoirleach that we needed to take a break shortly.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is why I was asking. The Minister of State still looks perfectly serene. I do not know how he can be in the light of the blistering account I have given him of all those organisations that have a completely contrary point of view and whose voice was silenced by the Turn Off the Red Light campaign.

My document states:

In Norway, leading academic researchers have cautioned that the reported decrease in sex work is limited by “substantial uncertainties”; expressing concerns that the authors of the evaluation failed to sufficiently explore their own findings that demonstrated that the market in Norway “may have changed because the people involved try to ‘stay under the radar’ and avoid arenas where they can be observed, and by implication, counted”.

In both Sweden and Norway, researchers have found evidence of increased risk-taking among sex workers in relation to their safety since the passage of the purchasing ban. [The Minister of State challenged me on this point so I am giving him the information.] Research in 2012 by Pro Sentret, Norway’s national centre of expertise on sex work policy, indicated that since the introduction of the prohibition on purchasing sex, some sex workers have reported seeing a decrease in ‘good clients’ and that the remaining ‘bad clients’ now make up a greater proportion of available options. The report indicates that sex workers are taking greater risks in their interactions with clients such as agreeing to visit their homes, concluding negotiations with clients more quickly or in secluded spaces that are safer for the client, and agreeing to take more dangerous clients. In Sweden, concern has been raised that this actually empowers those purchasers [and the pimps] who are willing to take risks as sex workers have less bargaining power and are potentially forced to sell sex cheaper and offer unprotected sex. [That is a wonderful way to address the problem of AIDS.] Research also indicates that this increase in risk is felt most acutely by the most vulnerable, resource-poor, street-based sex workers who cannot relocate indoors and now face increased competition for ‘bad’ clients, more pressure to conclude negotiations quickly and covertly, and reduced bargaining power.

Both the Swedish and Norwegian government evaluations reported that sex workers felt less safe since the passage of the purchasing ban.

The reality is that people feel less safe since the passage of the ban. Moreover, the document states:

For example, the Norwegian report stated that:

“[W]omen in the street market report to have a weaker bargaining position and more safety concerns now than before the law was introduced. At the indoors market, prostitutes express concerns for ‘out-door calls’. They prefer to have customers visiting them at their own apartment or own hotel room. The threshold for reporting a violent customer to the police also seems to be higher after the law. People in prostitution are afraid that such actions will come back to halt them at later stages.”

Of their discussion with current sex workers in Sweden, the authors of the evaluation reported that:

“They describe having chosen to prostitute themselves and do not consider themselves to be unwilling victims of anything. [It is the Government that is calling them victims.] This self-righteous campaign decided that these people who do not feel they are victims. It is the responsibility of the government to decide what other people are ... ."

It is also stated:

"Even if it is not forbidden to sell sex, they feel they are hunted by the police. They feel that they are being treated as incapacitated persons because their actions are tolerated but their wishes and choices are not respected. Moreover, they state that there is a difference between voluntary and forced prostitution."

[…]

The criminalisation of the purchase of sex has also reportedly impacted on HIV prevention and harm reduction. Condom distribution to sex workers and clients has been publicly criticised for ‘encouraging sex work’ and running contrary to the law and has been scaled back in at least one area of Sweden since the passage of the law.

When thinking about the human rights of prostitutes, we must note that not all of them regard themselves as unfortunate. Some of them are, however. Some of them, as a result of the operation of the law in Sweden, have been deprived not only of a large proportion of their income but also of their homes. I find it shameful that, in Norway, the police actively targeted the landlords of known prostitutes and called this excursion Operation Homeless. It is fairly cynical driving prostitutes out of their homes in a police operation described as Operation Homeless. This has led to the eviction of sex workers from their place of work and occupation. Is that what the Government wants? Does it want an increase in risk and damage to the safety of women? Does it want an increase in the risk to health and the risk of HIV infection, the dispossession of women from their homes, the harassment of women and their exposure to greater danger? I cannot believe this is what the Irish people want.

Comment on this

Sections 20 and 21 provide for two offences in the criminalisation of the purchase of sexual services. The first is a general offence of paying to engage in sexual activity with a prostitute and the second is the more serious offence of paying to engage in sexual activity with a trafficked person. These provisions are the result of considerable and extensive public consultation by the Department of Justice and Equality but primarily by the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality which recommended similar proposals in 2013. The matter has already been the subject of considerable debate both inside and outside these Houses and even beyond the State.

In deciding on these provisions the Minister considered all sides of the debate and the experience of those states that have introduced similar measures and those that have addressed prostitution in a different way. The purpose of introducing these provisions is primarily to target the trafficking and sexual exploitation of persons through prostitution. Both the Council of Europe and the European Parliament have recognised the effectiveness of the criminalisation of the purchase of sexual services as a tool in the fight against human trafficking. However, even to leave aside this unquestionable objective, there is undoubtedly evidence of wider exploitation of persons involved in prostitution outside those trafficked such as those coerced or otherwise forced through circumstances to engage in the activity.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Only 1% of the prostitutes in Northern Ireland said they were coerced.

Comment on this

The most direct way of combating this form of exploitation is to send a message to those who pay for these services and those who ignore the exploitation of the women and men that their behaviour is not acceptable and supports the exploitation of others.

Senator David Norris raised many aspects in the debate today. He raised issues about the impact of the provisions and the safety, health and well-being of those who work in prostitution. The Minister is well aware of the arguments and concerns. In deciding to put forward her proposals, she listened to all sides of the debate and is convinced that targeting the exploitation associated with prostitution requires targeting those who demand prostitutes.

Comment on this

I wish to comment on a point made by Senator David Norris and to correct the public record. Having listened to his opinions on these issues, I believe they are also grounded in an ideology. I wish to correct his comment on the justice committee, of which I am a member, and the evidence provided for its members by sex workers. I have checked with the secretariat and it has advised me that the evidence of former sex workers was, at their request, taken in private session before the committee in order to protect their identity. The secretariat has also advised and reminded us that similar arrangements were also requested by current sex workers to protect their identity and that we heard their evidence in private session. I am advised that if we hear evidence in private session, it is not normal procedure to produce a transcript of the meeting. I am informed that an initial examination of the records indicates there is no communication from any current or former sex workers of their evidence being omitted from the report.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I have information that what I say is the case; therefore, we will just have to differ on this. Let me make one final comment.

Comment on this

I am telling the Senator what is stated by the secretariat of the committee which will probably be recognised as evidence more than that to which the Senator is referring.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I accept that some of the sex workers wanted their evidence heard in private, but I do not believe that is universally the case.

Comment on this

Whether it is what the Senator believes, that is actually what happened. He has asked us to accept what he has indicated as evidence, but this is actually genuine evidence.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator has made her point. Senator David Norris to continue, without interruption.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I cannot hear a word she is saying; perhaps it is just as well.

In a review of the television programme “Sex For Sale” by RTE Investigates - that well known, reputable group - Emmanuel Kehoe in The Sunday Business Post stated:

Viewers might be forgiven for wondering whether, when gangs can operate so successfully and openly in Ireland despite current legislation, a new law, if weakly enforced, will prove a real deterrent. Is it not likely that a few punters will get prosecuted in the full glare of tabloid publicity while the thugs remain at large, adapting their operations to the prevailing circumstance?

I do not just have compassion and interest in the welfare of the women involved. I also think of the men involved. What about the tabloid exploitation of the tiny and unrepresentative arbitrary number of people caught up in this thing? I can see suicides taking place as a result of this. It is perfectly lamentable.

Comment on this

It is useful that Senator Katherine Zappone has given the information she has to the House. I did not get it all because there was much shouting and covering up of voices. As I am not on the justice committee, can I have it confirmed that what the Senator has said is that the voices of sex workers were taken into the account?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The record of the House will speak for itself.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Some.

Comment on this

I just want to finish. Is their evidence built into the recommendation?

Comment on this

I am very pleased to hear that because we do need to hear the diversity of voices. We have had so much talk that I am not sure if there is a review built into the legislation. Will the Minister of State confirm that is the case?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State said "No."

Comment on this

We are on section 20.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The Minister of State can speak for himself.

Comment on this

I have the floor.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Fidelma Healy Eames to continue, without interruption.

Comment on this

I am happy with the legislation the Minister of State has proposed. However, we need to measure the impact of all new legislation into the future and how it pans out in reality. It would be wise if, on Report Stage, the Minister of State considered providing for a review of the overall legislation and its impact of practices in Ireland in this field.

Comment on this

The Minister of State has referred to the large number of organisations which support this provision. He should ask them if they would have a problem with having a review of it. No sensible person would have a problem with having a review of the legislation in two years time. I cannot believe what is happening. There should be a consensus of common sense that this legislation should be reviewed in two years time. I will withdraw the amendment and hope the Minister of State will use common sense on this matter to do himself justice on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the question, "That section 20, as amended, stand part of the Bill," agreed to?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

No. Vótáil.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

On the question, "That section 20, as amended, stand part of the Bill," a division has been challenged. However, in the absence of two Tellers on the Níl side, the division cannot proceed. I, therefore, declare the question carried.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I thank the Cathaoirleach for his advice. It is a sad day for Seanad Éireann and democracy that I am the only voice that stands out on this issue.

Comment on this

I propose a suspension of the sitting until 4.40 p.m.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I notice there are only three Members in the Seanad. Can the Cathaoirleach assure me that we have a quorum?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the Senator calling for a quorum?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:

In page 17, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following:

“21. Section 9 of the Act of 1993 is amended—

(a) in subparagraph (i) by the substitution of “€10,000” for “£1,000”,

(b) in subparagraph (ii) by the substitution of “€50,000” for “£10,000”.”.

This amendment proposes to bring the figures up to date as they appear to be out of date at this stage. We are in the era of the euro as opposed to pounds.

Comment on this

I thank the Senators for the amendment. It proposes to increase the penalty for the organisation of prostitution. The Minister supports the aim of the Senators' proposal. There have been calls to review the existing penalties for offences relating to prostitution. The Minister has concerns about some penalties in this area, for example, the maximum penalty for living on the earnings of prostitution of another person, pimping, is only a maximum of six months imprisonment. The Minister has asked for a review of the penalties for all offences relating to prostitution. On Report Stage she will be increasing the penalty for loitering and will bring forward other amendments where a forum is appropriate.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for that intervention. We will reserve the right to retable this amendment on Report Stage if we see the Government has not brought forward an amendment of its own.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 33:

In page 17, between lines 17 and 18, to insert the following:

“22. The Act of 1908 is amended by the substitution of the following section for section 1 and 2:

“1. Any person of or above the age of 17 years who has carnal knowledge of a person, who to his or her knowledge is his or her parent, child, brother, sister, grandparent or grandchild shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for life or a lesser term of imprisonment.”.”.

This amendment applies to two sections which deal with the same issue.

It proposes to make the offence gender neutral. The offence is split by gender, assigning a dominant role to the male and a passive role to the female. The penalties are much lighter for female offenders, but they are being equalised now. The problem is that males may be tried for incest from the age of 12 years and females from 17 years. As such, it appears that males and females are not treated equally regarding their intentional capacity under the Bill. We just wanted to point out this anomaly to the Minister of State. It needs to be addressed. If that is not done here, it could be challenged at a later stage.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. The Minister appreciates the purpose behind the proposed amendment, but she has initial misgivings about it. The purpose of the provisions in sections 22 and 23 is to remove the existing gender anomaly relating to the penalty for incest by a male as opposed to by a female. Otherwise, they reflect the provisions of the Punishment of Incest Act 1908. When offences of this nature occur, generally an adult and child are involved. The 1908 provisions were undoubtedly intended to protect children within the family, but they were also motivated by the potentially adverse effects on any children born out of such relationships and eugenic considerations generally. For this reason, the Act and the amended provisions proposed in the Bill limit the offence to an act between persons where pregnancy is most likely.

The Senator's amendment would broaden the offence in this respect. For instance, the current offence of incest by a male includes a male who has carnal knowledge of his granddaughter but not a male who has carnal knowledge of his grandmother. Equally, in so far as there is an offence of incest by a female, it may occur where there is carnal knowledge with her grandfather but not her grandson. Obviously, where a person engages in a sexual act with a child under the age of 17 years, the existing defilement offences under the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2006 will apply. However, where it is an offence of incest, the relationships within which the offence may arise are limited to those most likely to result in pregnancy. Therefore, the Minister wants to examine this aspect of the amendment to ensure that it does not unnecessarily extend the offence of incest. The amendment would limit the offence to persons over the age of 17 years where currently that limit only applies to females and not to males. The amendment would exempt males under 17 years of age from the offence, thus restricting its scope while expanding its extent by unifying the categories of prohibited relationships for both sexes. We must be careful not to bring about unintended or unnecessary consequences.

The Supreme Court has adjudicated that the Oireachtas is entitled to protect girls under the age of 17 years from the risk of pregnancy because a girl potentially carries a greater burden from the act physically and emotionally should she become pregnant. The Minister is concerned that accepting the amendment may preclude, where appropriate, the prosecution of a male of, for example, 16 years of age.

The amendment also would delete subsection (2) from the offence of incest by a male. Under subsection (2), a male cannot rely on the consent of a female as a defence to a charge of incest. While there is no similar provision in the offence by a female, it would not be correct to suggest that the offence by a female can be defended by the consent of the male. The nature of the offence by the female is different than that committed by a male. The offence by a female is committed where she permits a specified male relative to have carnal knowledge of her. Consent on the part of both parties is, therefore, implied and an element of the offence. Relying on the defence of consent on the part of the male would not arise. The offence by a male is committed where he has carnal knowledge of the female. A provision clarifying that consent of the female is not a defence is, therefore, required and brings it into line with the offence by a female. Removing this provision from the offence by a male would mean a male could rely on consent as a defence but a female could not. For these reasons, we cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for his detailed response which we would like to study. We are probably coming from a similar perspective, but we want to be sure before making any amendment. I understand that the Minister of State is considering the matter as well and may table a Report Stage amendment on it. We will take what he stated on board and study it and we might revert on this matter on Report Stage. I will withdraw the amendment, by leave of the House.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I would like to tease out a few issues. This section relates to incest. Can incest take place between two males? There is an exclusion of male-to-male sexual activity from the Bill. I am curious as to why. I am not advocating that it should be included, but I am curious to know why this particular form of behaviour is not covered by the Bill.

Regarding the line "Any female person of or above the age of 17 years" in section 23, what about someone who is 16 and a half years of age? Does the world dramatically change on a 17th birthday? Is it perfectly legal for a girl of 16 and a half or 16 and three quarters years of age to have sex with her grandfather, father, brother or son? The provision reads, "knowing him to be her grandfather, father, brother or son". There was a tragic case in Germany in the past ten years of a brother and sister who were separated at birth, did not know each other and went to different families. I am not sure whether they went to different towns. They met casually, fell in love, started a relationship and, as far as I remember, had children. They applied to get married.

Imprisonment for life is a harsh term. I am not in any sense encouraging incest but imprisonment for life is putting it on the same level as murder. I would be interested in the Minister of State's response.

Comment on this

It is a difficult discussion to have and I understand that it can cause great upset to people who have been victims of this offence or affected by it. In a technical sense, the offence of incest is limited to those relationships that may result in pregnancy. On that basis, sexual intercourse between two brothers would not be considered to be incest.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is not considered to be incest. That is very interesting. I made the same point in an interview and was publicly pilloried for it, but the Minister of State has put the fact on record. That is what I said, but I was publicly humiliated and held up as some kind of libertarian rascal.

The Minister of State has not answered my question about a girl of 16 and three quarters years of age. Does she commit no offence?

Comment on this

No, the Senator is right. A female under the age of 17 years cannot commit an offence. Someone who is 16 and three quarters years of age would not be committing an offence.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is very interesting. That satisfies the Lolita syndrome merchants. Here we are again. The question of consent and so on is interesting. This time, it operates in a different way. A girl of 16 and three quarters can have sex with her father, grandfather, mother, brother or whomever else - actually, it does not include the mother - until three months later. What if she is 16 years and 11 months old or 16 years, 11 months and 29 days old?

Comment on this

I find this discussion nonsensical. We are dealing with serious issues that affect people. In this serious legislation, to have an almost humorous debate on whether someone is one month older or younger than another and whether that is an offence does a significant disservice to victims throughout the country. I would appreciate it if we could stick to the Bill-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Does the Senator see a smile on my face, or did she? Was I trying to be humorous? I am trying to project a hypothetical case and demonstrate that arbitrary lines like this have an element of folly. I did not smile once. How the Senator could construe my remarks as humorous, I simply do not know.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Senator has said he is not attempting to be humorous, but I still stand over my point that this discussion is almost nonsensical at this point.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this

If we could stick to the very serious-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I completely agree. I am highlighting the nonsensical aspects of the Bill.

Comment on this

In any legislation dealing with an age limit, this matter will always arise. One could say it is nonsensical for somebody who is 17 years and 364 days old not to be able to vote, but that is the reality of our current arrangement. It features in this legislation also. It is the Supreme Court adjudication that the Oireachtas is entitled to protect girls under the age of 17 years from the risk of pregnancy as a girl would potentially carry a greater burden from the legislation physically and emotionally should she become pregnant.

The Minister is concerned that accepting the Senator's amendment may preclude, where appropriate, the prosecution of a male of, say, 16 years. While I can understand the Senator's examples, the law draws a line in the sand when it comes to somebody's age. That is the way it has been and the way it always will be.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am sorry if Senator Máiría Cahill believes I am being humorous. I am certainly not being humorous but I am teasing this matter out as I am required to do as an elected Member of Seanad Éireann.

The Minister has confused matters further by introducing a High Court or Supreme Court ruling on the question of pregnancy. Is the Minister of State suggesting somebody under the age of 17 years cannot get pregnant? People get pregnant at quite early ages. It may be very regrettable, but it is a fact. At what age can people be married?

Comment on this

Sixteen years with permission.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

People can get married at 16 years. Senator Máiría Cahill should note these are the anomalies in the law. As with the Code Napoléon, we need to codify laws in a coherent and sensible manner in order that we are all treated in the same way. When the Minister introduces the notion of pregnancy, it seems almost to imply that somebody under the age of 17 years cannot get pregnant. Quite plainly, she can and, therefore, the argument does not-----

Comment on this

We are not saying that.

Comment on this

That is not what we are saying.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is what I understood the Minister of State to have said.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

He introduced the notion of pregnancy.

Comment on this

Again, the language is quite clear. The legislation refers to protecting girls from the risk of pregnancy. The Oireachtas has a responsibility to protect girls from the risk of pregnancy. We are not in any way suggesting that somebody under 17 years cannot become pregnant. Such a suggestion would be preposterous. The Supreme Court adjudication dates from 2006.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Again, what I said is perfectly sensible. The reference to protecting girls from the risk of pregnancy is quite clear. I am suggesting tthe Minister of State is implying there is no risk of pregnancy under the age of 17 years. I do not accept that. When the Minister of State spoke about the risk of pregnancy, perhaps there was something I did not understand. He says the age is over 17 years because of the risk of pregnancy and so on. What about people under 17 years? Are they not at risk of pregnancy?

Comment on this

That is why we are protecting them. My point has been made. It is our responsibility as legislators to protect a girl under the age of 17 years from a risk of pregnancy through a sexual violation, sexual assault, rape or incest. That is what we are dealing with. In a manner, we are dancing on the head of a pin, but essentially the point has been made.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I believe I now understand what the Minister of State is saying. Is he suggesting the matter is covered by other legislation?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It was a very roundabout way of saying it.

Comment on this

Taking on board what the Minister of State said about section 22, we are going to analyse this again. We will not oppose the section at this stage.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I notice that there are fewer Members in the House than would constitute a quorum. Will the Cathaoirleach reassure me that the House is quorate?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the Senator calling for a quorum?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 35 to 43, inclusive, are related. Amendment No. 38 is a physical alternative to No. 37. They may all be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Does Senator Trevor Ó Clochartaigh have permission to move amendment No. 35?

Comment on this

Yes, I have been asked by Senator Jillian van Turnhout to move her amendment.

I move amendment No. 35:

In page 22, line 27, after “in this section” to insert “and in section 19B”.

The purpose of amendment No. 36 in my name is to restrict the availability of therapy notes in criminal proceedings to those which have a direct bearing on the offence in question. We have raised issues around this on different Stages. Therapy, following from sexual abuse, is not solely concerned with discussing that experience. According to representations from the CARI Foundation, the Children’s University Hospital, Temple Street, and Our Lady’s Children’s Hospital, Crumlin, therapy often covers a range of family and relationship issues which are often not relevant to proceedings. Without a definition of relevance, there is a risk that defence representatives would cast a deliberately wide net, seeking sensitive information which does not contain reference to the actual offence.

Amendment No. 38 is to ensure therapy records do not provide an indication of whether or not a complainant has an ability to testify at trial. Such notes do not capture the current developmental, verbal or emotional competencies of a complainant or, in any way, assess a complainant’s capabilities to participate in the criminal justice system.

The purpose of amendment No. 39 is to ensure therapy records do not provide an indication of whether a complainant has an ability to testify at trial.

Amendment No. 41 is to ensure vulnerable people such as children are protected from re-traumatisation. It is the opinion of special care units that the risk of harm, psychological harm in this context, which could be caused to the victim by unnecessary disclosure should be included as a factor. This is consistent with EU directives which describe that child witnesses should be protected from further victimisation and re-traumatisation within the criminal justice system.

To put it in a nutshell, we are concerned by the way therapy notes could be misused by unscrupulous legal representatives and how they could possibly drag up many issues which people might not like to have discussed in a public or other court. This could be a deterrent to some people taking cases. We know these cases are difficult to prosecute in any sense. I imagine the Minister of State is coming from a similar type of perspective to ourselves on this. I hope he will consider these amendments helpful and take them on board.

Comment on this

Section 33 regulates the disclosure of the content of third-party counselling or therapy records in sexual offence trials. The disclosure of counselling or therapy records in the context of criminal proceedings, especially with regard to sexual violence, touches on several sensitive issues and balancing of rights. The right to a fair trial for an accused must be respected. However, so too does the right of the victim not to feel further violated in the criminal justice process. This section establishes a process for the disclosure of such records, where appropriate.

Since the publication of the Bill, the Minister for Justice and Equality has received several submissions proposing changes to this section. Notably, submissions from the Ombudsman for Children, Rape Crisis Network Ireland and Q4, representing the child sexual assault units in Temple Street and Crumlin children’s hospitals, are being considered by officials in the Department of Justice and Equality. The necessary balancing of fundamental rights involved in the disclosure of sensitive personal records requires careful consideration from both a legal and operational perspective. The Minister expects to be in a position to address several concerns raised about this section by way of amendment as the Bill progresses through the Houses. For example, the Minister intends to accept one proposal raised in the submissions of Q4 and Rape Crisis Network Ireland, namely, the removal of all references to the competence of the complainant or witness to testify, as she is persuaded that counselling records are not relevant to competence.

With regard to the specific amendments proposed, I thank Senators Jillian van Turnhout, Denis O’Donovan, David Cullinane, Trevor Ó Clochartaigh and Kathryn Reilly for their amendments. The Minister fully appreciates the points they have made.

Senator Jillian van Turnhout’s amendments Nos. 35 and 43 propose a separate disclosure regime to apply to children. The Minister is concerned that difficulties would arise in applying two regimes simultaneously but will consider the particular protections applying to children as part of the review of this section.

As to amendment No. 36, there are several difficulties with the definition of “relevant record” proposed. The proposed amendment deletes the reference to the prosecutor having sight or knowledge of the record, making it almost impossible to identify which records would be subject to a disclosure application and pre-trial hearing. Requiring, by definition, that the record has some probative or evidential value also raises the question of how this can be determined in advance of a pre-trial hearing and may create a presumption in favour of the disclosure of the record at a hearing. These are matters appropriate to the hearing.

Amendments Nos. 37 to 41, inclusive, seek changes to the list of assertions in section 33(4) which, on their own, will not establish the relevance of a record, and the factors in section 33(9) which the court must consider in determining whether to disclose a record. These are issues which have also been raised in the submissions the Minister has received and the two subsections in particular are being reviewed.

The Minister is minded to take on board some of the changes proposed. However, it is important to emphasise again that a careful balancing of rights is involved to ensure the disclosure provisions are constitutionally sound.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister of State’s contribution. It is important these issues are taken on board. We will take the Minister of State at his word that amendments will be introduced on Report Stage. As we tend to get amendment lists quite late, would it be possible to get these amendments at an earlier stage after they have been drafted to ensure we can get sight if they cover the issues we are addressing?

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for his response. I was one of the Senators who contacted the Minister for Justice and Equality about various points concerning section 33 and on ways in which the disclosure regime could be strengthened, as well as the rights of victims protected. I look forward to the Report Stage debate on this issue.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

These are quite important amendments and I appreciate the Minister of State has addressed them. I note, for example, that amendment No. 36 is in the names of Senator Denis O’Donovan and the Sinn Féin Senators. I presume this is as a result of extensive lobbying by groups interested in this area.

One does not want records disclosed all over the place willy-nilly. The amendment certainly seems to have merit in that it should be a “record that has some probative or evidential value to the alleged sexual offences that is or are the subject of the criminal proceedings”. We all know the ways of lawyers, pace Senator Professor Dr. Bacik.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am sorry; the Senator was blowing her nose. I said we all knew the ways of lawyers, pace Senator Dr. Professor Bacik. I am excusing her from the practice of lawyers.

Comment on this

I am sorry; I could not hear the Senator.

Comment on this

I will not excuse Senator David Norris for that comment, however.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

We also know the way in criminal trials how counsel is often inclined to draw in red herrings and smear one side or the other. For that reason, this is a very well argued and reasonable amendment. I will certainly support it. Although it has been withdrawn, I hope some version of it will be put back on Report Stage.

Comment on this

We understand the Minister will come forward with a similar amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Excellent. If not, I am sure the Senator will be watching.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Amendment No. 40 is about the impact of such disclosures. Amendment No. 41 deals with the risk of harm to the person to whom the record relates. These are sensitive matters concerning the personal medical and therapeutic records of people giving evidence in a criminal case. They need to be treated with the greatest possible sensitivity. For that reason, I welcome the fact the Minister of State has indicated he will look at these for Report Stage and bring amendments to the House in that regard.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 44 and 45 form a composite proposal and may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:

In page 27, after line 41, to insert the following:

"PART 7

CONSENT

Choice of Individual to Consent

39. An individual consents if he or she agrees by choice and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.".

I withdraw my amendment, but I would like to hear what the Minister of State has to say.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator for bringing forward these amendments. This question of introducing a statutory definition of consent has been raised by a number of groups, in particular those who work with and support the victims of sexual offences and also by the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality in terms of domestic and sexual violence. Moreover, this is an issue which does not appear to have received any significant consideration since Law Reform Commission's proposals in 1988. I know that the Minister is of the view that the question of providing a statutory definition of consent is overdue for review and that she has directed officials within her Department to undertake that work.

There is a clear understanding of the arguments favouring a statutory definition, including the clarity and understanding it will bring, as well as the assistance it could offer jurors, particularly in cases that may be difficult to adjudicate. However, there are also concerns that a statutory definition of consent may mean the flexibility of the common law system would be lost.

Aside from whether there should be a statutory definition of consent and if the answer is "Yes", what that definition should be, there are also a number of other questions which must be considered. Other common law jurisdictions have adopted different approaches to what is or is not consent. For instance, in the United Kingdom consent is defined with the addition of listing both evidential and conclusive presumptions about consent. While not defining consent itself, the New Zealand approach is to list the circumstances under which allowing sexual activity does not amount to consent. The Canadian model defines consent, as well as setting out those circumstances where no consent is obtained and those circumstances under which a defendant's belief that consent was given would not be a defence.

While other jurisdictions share a number of similarities in their approach to the question of consent to a sexual act, there are differences, and Ireland should adopt a model appropriate to this jurisdiction. That is a complex matter which warrants a comprehensive review and appropriate consultation with those involved in the investigation and prosecution of sexual offences. While that process is ongoing, the Minister is currently unable to accommodate Senator Denis O'Donovan's amendments today but, again, I thank him. The approach adopted in these amendments will also form part of the further consideration of this issue.

Comment on this

It is regrettable that the Minister of State is not taking on board the relevant points made by Senator Denis O'Donovan in his amendments. Amendment No. 45 refers to the "non-consent of sexual activity" which formed the basis of a case recently. The amendment continued:

(f) the complainant was asleep or otherwise unconscious at the time of the relevant act;

(g) the complainant was too affected by alcohol or drugs to freely agree to sexual activity;

(i) the complainant having originally consented to engage in sexual activity expresses by words or conduct a lack of agreement to continue to engage in the activity;

(j) the complainant submits to sexual activity because of the abuse of a position of authority or trust.".

These are very real situations in which people are abused every day. It would add quite appreciably to the Bill to have those definitions included, if one can call them definitions. They would assist juries by quite a lot to reach judgments that assist the victim.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Two of the amendments deal with the question of consent. Amendment No. 44 reads, "An individual consents if he or she agrees by choice and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice". That seems to be a reasonable definition of consent. I have not thought deeply about the matter, but it seems to be a fairly commonsense view of the question of consent.

Do the amendments propose new sections because I can see that the headline reads "Consent"? I presume that means it is an entire new section.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendments propose the insertion of new sections.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

They propose to the insertion of new sections, yes, but that is not actually stated. The Cathaoirleach has been helpful and I thank him very much. I notice that the provision comes in at the end of the Bill. The amendment does not state it is a new section after line 41 on page 27 of the Bill, after the end of a short two paragraph statement on double jeopardy. The section does not really talk about consent at all. Section 38 reads:

(1) Where a person has been acquitted of an offence in a place other than the State, he or she shall not be proceeded against for an offence under this Act consisting of the alleged act or acts constituting the first-mentioned offence.

(2) Where a person has been convicted of an offence in a place other than the State, he or she shall not be proceeded against for an offence under this Act consisting of the act or acts constituting the first-mentioned offence.

I do not see any connection whatever there with consent. It is unusual that amendment No. 44 states, "In page 27, after line 41."

Amendment No. 45 states:

An individual is to be taken not to have consented to sexual activity where:

(a) the defendant intentionally deceived the complainant as to the nature or purpose of sexual activity.

I am not sure what that provision means. Perhaps I might get some further information from the proposer. Does that mean that the defendant says, "We're just having sex not for pleasure but in order to produce children"?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am serious. What does "deceived the complainant as to the nature or purpose of sexual activity" mean? I do not understand it. Perhaps I might sit down and continue later if the Senator can explain to me what it means. I do not follow it.

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendments but shall resubmit them on Report Stage.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Does that mean I am not able to talk to the amendment? I was in the middle of talking.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator can speak to the section.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

All right. I shall speak to the section.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

As I was saying, I do not understand what the phrase meant. I know that the amendment has been withdrawn, but it shall be put forward on Report Stage. Therefore, it is still meat for discussion. I do not understand paragraph (a) in amendment No. 45. Paragraph (b) states, "the defendant intentionally induced the complainant to consent to sexual activity by impersonating a person known personally to the complainant". Again, I would counsel that if this amendment comes back on Report Stage, such a line be removed because how on earth would one do so? Such a scenario beggars and stretches belief. People talk about things being ludicrous and frivolous. I mean if somebody presents himself or herself in front of someone, one can see him or her and one knows who he or she is.

Comment on this

It could be a twin.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Come on.

Comment on this

On a point of information, recently there has been a very lengthy court case in Britain on this issue.

Comment on this

It was found that this scenario had happened. A person impersonated somebody else and the defendant won the case.

Comment on this

It was based on-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Wow.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I will not delay the House, but I am interested in hearing more about the case.

Comment on this

We will give the Senator the salacious details later.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I thank the Senator. The amendment continued, "(c) the complainant submits to sexual activity as a result of violence or threats". That is a perfectly reasonable provision and anybody can understand it-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Ivana Bacik just indicated to the Chair.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I thought she wanted me to stop.

Comment on this

No, I indicated that I wanted to speak next.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I am sorry. I shall be as quick as I can.

Comment on this

The Senator does not have to answer Senator Ivana Bacik.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I do. I am sorry, that was frivolous and lighthearted. I must not smile as this is a grim Chamber, the star Chamber of Seanad Éireann. The amendment continued, "(d) the complainant was, and the defendant was not, unlawfully detained at the time of the relevant act". Again, the provision is perfectly reasonable. If, for example, one was imprisoned-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

In keeping with the order of the House, we have to report progress.

Comment on this