Judicial Appointments Commission Bill 2017: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 138–280 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 71 of 2017 ›
Senator Bacik now has the agreement of the House and I am grateful to her because she has explained it.
Comment on this
Did the Senator want to call a vote on it?
Comment on this
Just to put the record straight on a point of order, I am not simply withdrawing an amendment unilaterally. We had quite an extensive discussion.
Comment on this
We had a discussion and I explained the basis of its withdrawal. I would take issue with any suggestion, and I do not think Senator McDowell intended it-----
Comment on this
-----that I am withdrawing it without any due consideration.
Comment on this
I am merely saying that the Minister seems to think that any Member can table an amendment and withdraw it and just pull the rug out from under a debate without the leave of the House. That is not true.
Comment on this
We all know that we have been discussing this for an hour. There is no question of pulling the rug from under the debate.
Comment on this
That is superfluous. We have the agreement of the House. We are moving on. Amendment No. 77 is in the names of Senators Bacik, Humphreys, Nash and Ó Ríordáin. Is Senator Bacik moving that amendment?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:
In page 24, to delete lines 34 to 41 and substitute the following:
“(6) In this section ‘educational establishment’ means a university to which the Universities Act 1997 applies, and in computing, for the purposes of this section, any period that a person must have served as a legal academic, successive employment of the person by 2 or more of any of the foregoing educational establishments shall suffice.”.
With some trepidation I am applying for leave to withdraw it again on the basis of the earlier debate that we have had and the very strong reasons offered as to why it should not be accepted and on reflection I think I was wrong to put it in. I have said that and I am seeking to withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
There was no amendment down to remove the first few lines of this section which is about the eligibility of a District Court judge after two years' service to be "qualified for appointment as a judge of the High Court". I am against that proposition for the reasons I have already explained and I am not going to repeat them now. I do not want to delay the House unnecessarily. I am against that provision.
I note Senator Bacik has rightly been persuaded that her amendment would have been unduly restrictive to subsection (6) but in subsection (6) we are dealing with a university to which the Universities Act 1997 applies. Can the Minister tell the House one way or the other whether the technological universities which, as I understand it, are about to come into existence will be covered? Are they universities to which the 1997 Act applies or are they under a separate statute?
Comment on this
I will check that point on the basis that the Senator says he understands this is something that may happen at some stage in the future. At that stage we will consider it. My understanding is that these colleges are not covered under the Universities Act. They may well be at some stage in the future. As of now my understanding is otherwise.
Comment on this
I have not been following the debate exactly but I have the impression that the Oireachtas has already passed legislation for the technological universities.
Comment on this
If that is the case they are covered.
Comment on this
Are they? Does the 1997 Act apply to them?
Comment on this
I do not believe that the technological universities are encompassed in the 1997 Act. The Act was amended during the debate on the technological universities legislation. This legislation is in fact flawed.
Comment on this
Has the other legislation been passed?
Comment on this
It has been passed. The Dublin Institute of Technology and the institutes of technology at Blanchardstown and Tallaght are rapidly moving towards their new campus in Grangegorman. Technological universities and the institutes of technology have delivered some fine legal courses down through the years and have some fine legal academics working in them. We need to amend this legislation before it goes forward.
Comment on this
It had occurred to me before Senator McDowell raised this issue that the technological universities might be covered. Certainly there are excellent law faculties and departments in very many of them, so that is an important point. It relates to a point I made earlier in respect of the in-house lawyers and the relationship between this Bill and the other legislation such as the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015 and the Courts and Court Officers (Amendment) Act 2007. It is important that the legislation is future-proofed to take account of changes such as the change in university status for the institutes of technology and the other institutions. We just need to check that to ensure that this legislation is properly mindful of other changes that are happening in parallel.
Comment on this
I am not trying to be troublesome but I believe the legislation is already enacted for those technological universities.
Comment on this
If we do not change this we may miss the bus on this definition of a university.
Comment on this
We can certainly do it in the context of further discussion on the amendments as put forward and withdrawn by Senator Bacik but with a view to coming back on Report Stage. My understanding is that the Bill has been enacted.
Comment on this
It was signed into law by the President on 19 March of this year. Unless there is a deeming provision that the provisions of the Universities Act also apply to the technological universities it would be necessary to make provision for it in this Act.
Comment on this
Under Standing Order 62(3)(b) I request that the division be taken again other than by electronic means.
Comment on this
That is not allowed as the Senator is not a teller. If the Senator can get five Members to stand in support I can accept the request.
Comment on this
Question again put
Do you agree with this result?
This is the first section in Chapter 2 of Part 6 of the Bill. We are now getting to a crucial portion of this proposed legislation. Chapter 2 is concerned with eligibility and preconditions for appointment to the relevant judicial offices. What I have a major problem with is that section 34(1) states: "Nothing in this Chapter shall be construed as being applicable to a judicial office to which section 44 applies."
This is, in other words, part of a legislative scheme which includes section 44. Section 44, as the Bill currently stands, is an entirely separate chapter of the legislation on appointments to the position of Chief Justice, President of the Court of Appeal and President of the High Court. The exclusion in section 34(1) is to say that the divisions of this chapter will not be applicable to appointments as Chief Justice, President of the Court of Appeal and President of the High Court but will be applicable to all other judicial appointments. That is where, among other places, for the purposes of this discussion, I part company with the legislation.
This chapter provides that: "In addition to the requirement of sections 7 and 36 and subsection (2) and (where it applies) subsection (3), the Commission shall not recommend the name of a person to the Minister unless it is satisfied that the requirements of the relevant provisions are complied with in relation to the person." It then states: "In the taking of steps that result in a recommendation of a person's name to the Minister, the Commission shall ensure that the requirements in the published statement are complied with."
We will come back to that in a moment when we can deal with that in more detail on section 35. Section 35(3) states:
In the case of an appointment to the office of—
(a) ordinary judge of the Supreme Court,
(b) ordinary judge of the Court of Appeal, or
(c) ordinary judge of the High Court,
the Commission shall not recommend the name of a person to the Minister unless, in the opinion of the Commission, the person has—
(i) an appropriate knowledge of the decisions, and
(ii) an appropriate knowledge and appropriate experience of the practice and procedure,
of the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal and the High Court.
The problem with all of this is that if ordinary judges of the High Court and the Court of Appeal, those two categories of people, are to be appointed or considered for a recommendation by the commission, the commission is going to have to ask itself about the candidates appropriate knowledge of the decision and appropriate experience of the practice and procedure of the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal and the High Court.
To take an example, let us go back to what we were discussing earlier, namely, a District Court judge. A District Court judge, on the Minister's version of section 33, is to be eligible. We are now going to have a situation where the commission is going to have to carry out an inquiry as to whether the District Court judge has appropriate experience of the practice and procedure of the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal and the High Court. That is an extraordinary thing to do.
It is even more extraordinary that an existing Circuit Court or High Court judge would have to go through that test, that is an existing High Court judge be effectively required to prove his or her experience of the Supreme Court in order to be appointed to the Supreme Court. Once one is a judge of the superior courts, namely, the High Court, the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court, one should be eligible, ipso facto, to be appointed and one is, in statute, eligible to any more senior position in those three courts. Asking existing members of those courts to apply to the commission for its approval and their shortlisting for a position is entirely unjustifiable. I will come back to that at a later stage and will not elaborate now because I do not want to be repetitive.
I utterly disagree with the procedure laid down in section 44 and therefore I cannot agree with the provisions of section 34-----
Comment on this
That is my point, a Leas-Chathaoirligh, I was just going to point that out. I therefore cannot agree with what is provided in section 34(1), which refers to that. I am opposed completely to the procedure set out in section 44. When this Bill started off, there was to be a fast-track for those positions which did not involve a visit to the judicial appointments commission. It was amended I believe in Dáil Éireann so as to abolish the fast-track and require everybody who wanted to be appointed to the Supreme Court or whatever, to make an application to the judicial appointments commission, and to be either on or off a shortlist as the case may be. I am utterly opposed to that in principle. It is wrong. Sitting judges in the superior courts should never have to go before the judicial appointments commission to see whether they are suitable for appointment to the Court of Appeal or to the Supreme Court.
I will elaborate later on this but my strong view is that when the Government comes to decide what person it should or should not appoint to the Supreme Court, it operates on the basis of its own criteria as to what kind of Supreme Court it wants to establish - what kind of philosophical balance, balance of legal outlook, what kind of balance in terms of liberalism and conservatism, being pro-European less pro-European or whatever. These are issues which only the Government is entitled to decide upon and which the Constitution gives to the Government as its own function to make its own mind up on.
Asking judges in the High Court to submit their names to the judicial appointments commission with a view to determining as to whether they should be on a shortlist to be considered by the Government is in my view not merely invidious, but it strikes at the heart of what the Government's prerogative, function and duty is, namely, to make up its own mind on this issue. It can of course take advice from whoever it likes. It can set up an institution which can tender advice. In this case we are making it an offence for anybody to canvass for his or her appointment to the Supreme Court and we are also, as I have pointed out on another occasion, making it an offence for the Attorney General to tell the Government who the unsuccessful applicants for promotion, who were not shortlisted, actually were.
A combination of all these factors makes this an unconstitutional provision. I also believe that it seriously infringes the independence of the Judiciary that they should undergo an evaluation process the same as somebody who is not a judge just because they want to be seriously considered by the Government for promotion from the Court of Appeal to an ordinary member of the Supreme Court. That is not right and is wrong in principle.
I would be reassured if the Minister would tell me that he has been reconsidering the provision that the Attorney General should commit a criminal offence if he or she discloses to the Government who the unsuccessful applicants for promotion were. If the Minister was to even tell me that he was reconsidering the stance he has taken on that in the course of this legislation I would feel some sense of reassurance. In the absence of that I cannot agree to the section 44 procedure existing at all.
Comment on this
Chapter 2 of Part 6 states: "In this Chapter 'legal academic' means a legal academic within the meaning of section 45A" and so on. We have quite a lengthy section in section 33 dealing with the definition of a legal academic and so on. I am not sure why it is necessary to rehearse it at this point because it seems to me a legal academic has already been satisfactorily defined in the legislation. One assumes the provisions and terms of the Bill would apply in all cases to legal academic as so defined in the Bill. I am wondering why this subsection is included.
Comment on this
I want to make one point. I see the point. I am sorry.
Comment on this
I will make one point before I deal with the Bill. There has been some suggestion that we are trying to filibuster this.
Comment on this
We are on section 34, with respect.
Comment on this
I would like to deal with it now if I could. There has been some suggestion that we are deliberately filibustering this Bill. Our job is to scrutinise the Bill and put it through its paces. I am a layman. That is all I am. I am not a legal expert but at this stage I cannot for the life of me see why we are still talking about this Bill and why it has not been withdrawn altogether. It is seriously flawed. We are talking about setting up a commission that we do not-----
Comment on this
With respect, we are on section 34. The Chair has already ruled on the question of filibustering. We are monitoring the debate to ensure-----
Comment on this
I am attempting to deal with the section.
Comment on this
When we are talking about learned judges having to go through some sort of a test in order to find themselves short-listed, I cannot, for the life of me, understand or believe any judge would subject himself or herself to that sort of treatment. If this Bill goes through and if it were to be enacted in the morning, members of the Judiciary or Bar would be out of their minds to consider going forward for a position. Why would they want to do that? Why would they want to have people with no legal knowledge assessing their legal knowledge? Why would they do that? For the life of me, I cannot understand it and it needs to be put on the record at every section.
Comment on this
It is flawed. That is my view. I am only a layman. One should look at any of the media reports from over the weekend and read what they are saying. They are saying the Bill is flawed and they support-----
Comment on this
That is a point of principle more suited to a Second Stage debate. We are on Committee Stage now.
Comment on this
I will leave it at that. I will not upset the Leas-Chathaoirleach anymore.
Comment on this
Yes. All the points Senator McDowell raised are valid but they are issues that are more particular to the later sections rather than section 34. For ease of debate, it might be desirable that we proceed in accordance with the accepted practice of going through the Bill on a line-by-line basis. The points raised by Senator McDowell, although they are all valid, are more appropriate to a later discussion, with particular reference to an amendment Senator McDowell has submitted.
Dealing with Chapter 2 of Part 6, what we have here in section 34 is a technical amendment cross-referencing what is being inserted into section 33 by the Seanad. It is merely an appropriate, desirable and, dare I say, necessary drafting provision. I do not have anything further to say on the section but I acknowledge the importance of what Senator McDowell has said. He stated he is parting company with the Bill. I have been here for 42 hours. I did not see him in company with the Bill at any stage but under Chapter 2 he now indicates he is parting company with the Bill. I invite him to wait until we have an opportunity to discuss the substance of his amendments. I think I might be in a position to engage in interesting discourse on some of the points that Senator McDowell will make. I do not think they will be made today.
I will not be provoked into a response to Senator Craughwell. I do not think I could respond to him and remain within the rules of the Standing Orders of the House.
Comment on this
The Minister is signalling we will not reach the amendments on which this great discourse he is promising is going to happen today.
Comment on this
In view of that concession by the Minister, it is probably a good idea to put this section to a vote and we will deal with the matter on the next day.
Comment on this
That should not be seen to be in some way a response to something I said because Senator McDowell has been so disposed right during the course of this debate.
Comment on this
Question put
Do you agree with this result?
Amendments Nos. 78, 79, 90 and 91 are related. Amendment No. 91 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 90. These amendments may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78:
In page 25, to delete lines 25 to 34 and substitute the following:
"(3) In the case of an appointment to the office of ordinary member of the High Court, the Commission shall not recommend the name of a person to the Minister unless in the opinion of the Commission the person has—
(a) an appropriate knowledge of the decisions, and
(b) an appropriate knowledge and appropriate experience of the practice and procedure, of the High Court.".
The amendment provides for the-----
Comment on this
Those Members speaking on the phone in the Chamber should leave. This matter is taking a lot of time. They should allow Senator McDowell to make his contribution without interruption.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment is to underline our opposition to the idea that sitting members of the superior courts should be under any obligation to submit to legal experience and qualification evaluation by the commission at all. We are opposed to the idea that sitting judges should be asked to submit their names to the commission for appointment to the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. This may appear to some people to be a matter of less importance than I feel it is. The reason I say this is that at present, when the judges of the High Court, Court of Appeal and ordinary members of the Supreme Court carry out their duties, they are required to be impartial and hard-working in upholding their constitutional declaration and they are required to discharge the functions of a High Court, Court of Appeal or Supreme Court judge as the case may be, which involves the evaluation of cases purely as matters of law and not by reference to other criteria. To uphold the Constitution and the laws in their decisions impartially requires them to function clearly independently from public opinion going one way or the other on issues. It is about standing up for the rights of an individual citizen at law and under the Constitution, however popular or unpopular the position of that individual citizen may be.
Under the JAAB procedure at present, no member of the High Court, the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court is required to, enabled to or in any sense eligible to submit an application to that body for its determination as to his or her suitability. A judge of the High Court cannot apply to be evaluated or declared suitable by the board for promotion to the Supreme Court. There are very good reasons for this. It is not the business of the current members of the board to start ferreting around among the existing High Court Judiciary and saying so-and-so is suitable and so-and-so is not suitable to be on the Court of Appeal. It is a matter for the Government to make this decision, and it is a matter for the Government to take the advice of the Attorney General and, usually, the advice of the Minister for Justice and Equality and make up its mind as to who among the existing Judiciary in the superior courts should be promoted to the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court.
Currently, of course, the Attorney General or the Minister for Justice and Equality might well confer with the president of either of those courts if it were for a position as an ordinary member of either of those courts for his or her view as to whether there was anybody whom he or she thought would be particularly useful or appropriate to be included in a court to supply a vacancy in that court. The Government does not ask all members of the Judiciary to engage in a beauty parade before an institution that is independent of them for evaluation or shortlisting.
I am interested to know whether any common law jurisdiction requires existing members of its court of appeal to be vetted by a lay commission as to whether they should be made members of the supreme court of that jurisdiction. I do not claim to be an expert but I would be surprised if it were the case that the members of the court of appeal in London would have to submit to a full-scale evaluation by a majority group of lay people to make a recommendation as to whether they should be appointed to the English supreme court. I very much doubt this is the case. Even if the English were so minded to do it, they are not living in the world of a written constitution. The written Constitution we have states such an appointment is a matter for the Government.
I indicated earlier the outline of my view on this matter but in this context I have to reiterate it because we are now getting to the point where it is directly an issue in the amendments, section 35 and succeeding sections. The decision as to whether a High Court judge or a Court of Appeal judge is appointed to the Supreme Court is a matter exclusively for determination by the Government. The Government is free to take advice, soundings or whatever it likes in any quarter on this matter by whatever means it chooses but it is not constitutionally competent for the Oireachtas to tell it that it must operate in a state of legislatively imposed ignorance as to who wants to be appointed and who is available to be appointed to the Supreme Court, and certainly not in a context where the Attorney General of the day, who sits at the table when the Government is making its deliberations and traditionally has always been available to express his or her views as to the desirability of one nominee rather than another, should be committing a criminal offence if he or she discloses to the Government at a meeting to consider the matter that one particular person has shown an interest and has applied once or on a number of occasions to the commission but has not been shortlisted.
The desire to keep the Government in ignorance as to who are the unsuccessful would-be appointees - by unsuccessful I mean the people who have failed to make the shortlist to be sent forward by the judicial appointments commission - is, in my submission, absolutely indefensible. There is no possible reason a Government in a situation where eight members of the High Court and two members of the Court of Appeal have expressed a wish to be appointed to a vacancy in the Supreme Court, should be told it cannot find out who of those ten people had expressed an interest in the appointment and may only be informed, on pain of the commission of a criminal offence, of the identity of the three people the commission has shortlisted. That proposition, and the desire to have that situation in place, runs counter to the function of the Government under the Constitution.
As I said earlier, if the Minister was to tell me he had been listening to the debate in this House - I know he is listening, I am not suggesting he is not, and he has very little choice in the matter-----
Comment on this
-----and has reconsidered the notion of making it a criminal offence for the Attorney General to inform the Cabinet as to who the applicants - the non-shortlisted applicants - were and is now open to amending the statute to allow for such information to be given to the Cabinet by the Attorney General, who ex officio is to be a member of this commission, at least part of my worries would be addressed here. The Minister should signal now, one way or the other, whether I am wasting my time here, not that it will deter me from continuing to make the point, I hasten to add-----
Comment on this
I would never make such a suggestion.
Comment on this
I would like know whether I am wasting my time and playing handball against a ministerial and governmental haystack in respect of the obligation this Bill proposes to put on all existing members of the superior courts to effectively engage in a competitive process to be shortlisted to be among the three names to be sent forward for consideration by the Cabinet. If I was told the Minister is now reconsidering that position I would be greatly relieved and feel we were making some progress in this debate. However, if I am told that is not the intention of the Government and that it will not yield on that issue, then I am equally obdurately opposed to the passage of this legislation and equally convinced that it is constitutionally infirm.
Section 35(1) states: "In addition to the requirement of sections 7 and 36 and subsection (2) [of section 35] and (where it applies ) subsection (3), the Commission shall not recommend the name of a person to the Minister unless it is satisfied that the requirements of the relevant provisions are complied with in relation to that person." The relevant provisions are set out in subsection (6) of the section.
Section (7) is referenced in subsection (1) and, as have already debated it, I will not go into it great length. Section (7) states, "A decision to recommend" and a fortiori a decision to include somebody on a shortlist of three "shall be based on merit". It further states: "Subject to subsection (1), where the function, under this Act, of selecting and recommending persons for appointment to a judicial office falls to be performed, regard shall be had to ... the objective that the membership of the judiciary should comprise equal numbers of men and women." That is the first proposal, that there should be numerical equality between men and women as far as possible. Second, the section also states "the objective that the membership of the judiciary should, to the extent feasible and practicable, reflect the diversity within the population as a whole". Third, it states. "the objective that, consistent with the written statement most recently provided under section 53(7) to the Procedures Committee concerning the needs of the users of the courts in that regard, the membership of the judiciary should include persons with a proficiency in the Irish language".
This shortlisting process has statutory criteria which are blended in a strange way with the idea of merit. When we read section 7(1) and 7(2) it is not clear whether it is based purely on these being the three best people full stop, or that these are the three best people having regard to the need for the numerical equality of men and women in the Supreme Court. It makes one wonder. Supposing it were the case that the judicial appointments commission was confronted with a Supreme Court which had of nine members, seven male and two female members, in comprising its shortlist is it to attempt to ensure that the position is secured by a woman? If it is to do that, how is it to do it? Is it to ensure that the majority of the shortlist of three should be women or that all three of them should be women and leave the Government with a choice of the top three women, bearing in mind the existing imbalance in the Supreme Court?
These are the kinds of matters the commission will be driven to considering in its procedures, whereas what happens at Government is something totally different. What happens at Government is a consideration as to whether Mr. Justice Michael McDowell is a person who is a liberal or a conservative on social issues. That is an issue curiously which the commission is not allowed to take into account. Those are not the criteria that it is allowed to take into account. It is strange that the Government is obliged to take into account criteria in respect of which the commission is supposed to compose a short list for the Government that the commission is excluded, by the terms of this Act, from considering.
That emphasises the fundamental error of applying the terms of this statute to promotional appointments within the Judiciary. If the Government of the day wants to make the Supreme Court more liberal or more conservative, as it may well wish to do for perfectly good reasons, or, as I said earlier, more pro-European or less pro-European or more generous on the subject of personal compensation or less generous on that subject, and to make decisions along those lines, not merely is it perfectly entitled to do so, it is duty bound to do so, if it considers that is in the national interest. Yet the body that composes the shortlist for consideration by the Government is not entitled to look to those very questions. It is supposed to come up with a shortlist by reference to different criteria. That is what I find so incongruous about this legislation, that a group of outsiders are being asked to make a shortlist decision by reference to criteria that the Government is not merely not concerned with but that it has a much bigger priority to make its own decision unencumbered by, say, for instance, the gender balance on any particular occasion.
It may be far more important for the Government to select Mr. Justice David Norris for appointment to the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
It may be far more important for the Government to appoint David Norris on the basis of his liberal outlook or whatever rather than-----
Comment on this
Exactly. It may be far more important for the Government to make that appointment than to have regard to gender balance-----
Comment on this
I refer to having regard to his social background-----
Comment on this
-----diversity, or lack of diversity, or where he stands in the spectrum of social diversity in Ireland. Those things may not be of interest to them and yet those are the criteria which we are saying must be the basis of him being, or not being, on the shortlist.
I asked the Minister to inform me whether it is a central pillar of Government policy that existing members of the High Court must apply to the judicial appointments commission to be considered by the Cabinet for promotion to the Supreme Court, and whether that is a cornerstone of this legislation on which the Minister and Government will not budge.
I asked the Minister to indicate again whether he is open to reconsidering whether the Attorney General should be in a position to inform the Cabinet of those ready and willing to be appointed even though they have not been shortlisted - in other words, the people who have been applicants, have displayed an interest in appointment to a particular office and who have not been shortlisted for consideration by the Government. On those two points the constitutionality of this legislation depends. If the Government goes down the road of forcing existing judges to submit themselves to an evaluation by a group of people other than a government, one is not merely on the thinnest of ice but one is up to one's ears in constitutional water. Likewise, if one maintains the proposition that the Government cannot know who among the existing Judiciary is ready and willing to serve but has not been shortlisted, then one is, equally, up to one's ears in constitutional water. We are not allowed know the inner workings of the Cabinet and we are not allowed to know the inner workings of individual Ministers' minds on this issue. Unless there is some willingness to engage on those two issues, then this legislation is fundamentally flawed from a constitutional perspective.
Comment on this
I would like to address one point, through the Chair, concerning Senator McDowell's amendment No. 90.
Comment on this
Senator Norris pointed out a typographical error in subsection (2) in amendment No. 90.
Comment on this
The amendment states that the Minister shall request that the judicial appointments commission furnish a report "of the Government". I want to change the word "of" to "to" so that the amendment reads "to the Government."
Comment on this
That is exactly point I was making. One cannot simply use the word "request" because, grammatically, one must request something. Senator McDowell has now made the change.
Comment on this
I will apply the change and amend the amendment.
Comment on this
I accept the unimportant point that Senator Norris has made.
Comment on this
The typographical error has been accepted by Senator McDowell.
Comment on this
Senator McDowell is right insofar as he suggests that we are now dealing with the heart of the Bill. I am not, a Chathaoirligh, going to go back over ground that has already been covered, with particular reference to the role or, indeed, the disposition of the Attorney General at any given point.
I have carefully listened to this debate in its entirety. I am not indicating that I am going to unravel any aspects of the Bill that have already been concluded on Committee Stage. Rather, I would now like to deal with the amendments before us which are amendments Nos. 78, 79, 90 and 91, all of which are important.
In the first instance, Senator McDowell suggested that this legislation is unique insofar as it deals with a form of assessment of candidates. He used the word "vetting".
Comment on this
In the Supreme Court but among the existing Judiciary.
Comment on this
I think in these circumstances the use of the word "vetting"-----
Comment on this
-----is not appropriate. I understand that serving judges are assessed in other jurisdictions for promotion. I have already mentioned at an earlier Stage the situation in the neighbouring island, both in Wales and in Scotland. I would be happy to address the point by way of sending a note to Senator McDowell with a particular reference to the point that he makes, not about suggesting names for appointment but suggesting names for what we can describe as elevation or promotion from one rank of the Bench to another. I reject the term "vetting" which, in the circumstances, I do not believe to be appropriate.
Senator McDowell is right when he says that currently the Judicial Appointments Advisory Board does not vet the suitability of candidates for the High Court, Court of Appeal or, indeed, the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
I could live with the word "assess".
Comment on this
This is precisely because the Courts and Court Officers Acts do not allow for such vetting, or even assessment.
To answer Senator McDowell question, yes, this is one of the fundamental pillars of this Bill. This is one of the changes in that the commission will assess the suitability of serving judges for such appointment. This is in response to the public consultation that was undertaken prior to this Bill having even been drafted.
Certainly, I am enlightened as to the direction of Senator McDowell in terms of his opposition to the Bill when he repeatedly used the word "outsiders". He said that outsiders are assessing, that outsiders are involved and that outsiders are a part of the process.
Comment on this
This is telling in the matter of the fundamentals of the commission, with particular reference to its status as having a non-legal majority and a non-legal chair, but that is not to describe the commission as comprising outsiders. Again, I was very careful in the context of the Bill, both in this House and the other House, to reassure people who felt that there was an imbalance here that there would be the active involvement, in the membership of the commission, of the Presidents of the Courts, all of whom I expect to be members of the commission because of their importance, expertise and experience. I invite Senator McDowell, in particular, to accept that point because I believe that they have a very important role to play in bringing a level of expertise and a high degree of experience and being in a position to strongly influence the names that ultimately go forward to Government for nomination to the President for appointment.
Senator McDowell's amendment No. 78, as he freely admitted, would significantly narrow the scope of the section to relate only to:
(a) an appropriate knowledge of the decisions, and
(b) an appropriate knowledge and appropriate experience of the practice and procedure, of the High Court.
This would again serve to reflect the Senator's intentions with regard to amendment No. 90, which is an important amendment.
The scope of the section does not relate to appointments to the position of Chief Justice, President of the Court of Appeal or President of the High Court. I acknowledge that the Senator's amendment observes that clear distinction which is important.
Amendment No. 90 would introduce a senior judicial appointments committee to deal with not just those three positions of leadership, the Chief Justice, the President of the Court of Appeal and the President of the High Court, but all appointments to the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. I assume, therefore, that the Senator makes the section relevant only to those appointments that will remain within the ambit of the commission under this amendment.
As I indicated previously, I am giving further consideration to the amendment on the establishment of a senior judicial appointments commission. I am not sure if we can dispose of it in its entirety now, but I would be happy to continue to engage with Senators on the issue. On the conclusion of Committee Stage, I would be happy to reflect further.
Amendment No. 79 again narrows considerably reference to provisions under the section. It would require that the commission would accord with the Senator's intentions regarding the proposed committee under section 90. I am minded to acknowledge the importance of the senior appointments committee or group for the three appointments we mentioned. However, I am not sure about extending that further across the entire range of appointments the Senator wishes to encompass. This would reduce the import of the Bill in a way that is not reflective of Government policy.
I need to preserve the Government's policy in this regard, which is to construct a senior judicial appointments advisory committee but only for the top three positions as mentioned - Chief Justice, President of the Court of Appeal and President of the High Court. The Bill originally provided for that, but a Dáil committee did not favour this provision during its deliberations and it was replaced by an amendment, which, to all intents and purposes, moves the work required to recommend persons for appointment to these posts to the commission itself. I am still not satisfied with that approach. An amendment to that effect which I moved on Report Stage in the Dáil was defeated. However, I am minded to revisit the concept of a senior committee for precisely the reasons the Senator has outlined.
I still have a number of issues with the amendment. There appears to be no lay involvement from the new commission in this arrangement. I accept that a TLAC representative is provided for. Under the Senator's view of the commission, there would be no lay chair at that point. The question, therefore, of a lay chair being part of the new committee would not arise under this scheme. No lay involvement whatever from the commission is somewhat challenging and problematic.
The senior judicial appointments advisory committee contained in the Government Bill as published, which did not find favour with the Dáil, was to comprise the Chief Justice, the lay chair of the commission and the Attorney General. Perhaps the Senator might like to comment on that composition of a high-level senior appointments group. I acknowledge the success of such a group in the context of recent appointments to senior positions. I invite the Senator to explore possibilities of the Seanad further examining a high-level group with a view to reaching agreement, but acknowledging my disposition not to depart from what all Senators know - whatever about agreeing with - is Government policy.
While we can take the composition of the committee in the first instance, amendment No. 90 broadens considerably the posts to which the committee would make recommendations. I accept the importance and the differentiation of the three top judicial posts - Chief Justice, President of the Court of Appeal and President of the High Court - as distinct from ordinary members of the High Court or other judges, albeit that they are senior in office.
The Senator wishes to broaden the scope of these recommendations to cover all appointments to the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.
Having regard to the importance of these positions, they would be relatively few as a proportion of total appointments, but they are important. On Second Stage I referred to the reduction to just three names in the number of recommendations the Minister receives and to the fact that the legislation will cover the matter of the elevation or movement of a serving judge to a higher court. These are important issues which we must not lose sight of and which might not necessarily be catered for fully in the Senator's amendment, if I was disposed to accept it. I am not indicating that I will accept it but that there are aspects of these amendments which I am minded to subject to further exploration. That is why I am pleased to have the opportunity to listen to the points the Senator has made.
Under his arrangement, much of the original Bill will be lost, as it was the intention of the Government that ordinary judicial appointments to the two most senior courts would be for the commission to recommend. That would not survive the Senator's amendment. Not all appointments to the Court of Appeal or to the Supreme Court are serving judges. Some have been appointed straight from practice and I am sure that will continue, for good reason. Ultimately, I am not convinced that we should scuttle the reforming aspects of this Bill by leaving important appointments to the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court and the elevation of serving judges outside the remit of the new commission. I am prepared to give the matter further consideration and to take further advice on it. I would be happy to hear the views of other Senators on this.
Subsection (7) of the Senator's amendment provides that not just all members of the superior courts may be informed of a relevant vacancy but that this extends to other persons as well. Other provisions provide for a maximum of three recommendations but not in any order of preference, the stipulation being that the Government shall first consider for appointment what will be described as recommended persons. I will continue to listen to the Senators on that. I will come back on Report Stage with considered amendments that will seek to address the concerns about senior level judicial appointments. At the same time, however, I cannot have a situation where the import of the Bill is, in effect, emasculated.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 90 is a more substantial and significant amendment than the other amendments in this group and I am at a loss as to why my amendment, No. 91, is included.
Comment on this
I did not realise amendment No. 91 was in this group.
Comment on this
I am quite happy that it would not be dealt with in this group because while it is a proposed amendment to section 44, which is also the subject of amendment-----
Comment on this
It has been agreed that they will be discussed together. We can deal with them and the Minister can come back to it.
Comment on this
If Senator Bacik wishes to separate it, I do not have a difficulty with that, subject to the agreement of the House.
Comment on this
Okay. We will deal with the other three amendments. Is it agreed that amendment No. 91 will be dealt with separately from amendments Nos. 78, 79 and 90? Agreed. It should not make any difference to the overall situation.
Comment on this
Yes, it does not make any difference. Amendment No. 91 is better dealt with along with amendments Nos. 86 and 87, both of which refer to gender balance in appointments. That appears to be the more appropriate grouping.
Comment on this
I will discuss amendment No. 91 when we reach amendments Nos. 86 and 87.
On amendment No. 90, the Minister has indicated a willingness to move on this given that there was provision for a similar senior level judicial appointments committee in the original version of the Bill. That is welcome. If Senator McDowell's amendment or some variation of it was accepted, our amendment No. 91 does not arise as it simply becomes a different type of procedure. I support Senator McDowell's amendment. Amendment No. 91 deals with a separate issue and can be discussed with amendments Nos. 86 and 87.
Comment on this
I support amendment No. 78. The objective is to narrow the focus and scope of the Bill at this point and, in the case of an appointment of an ordinary member of the High Court, to ensure the person has an appropriate knowledge of the decisions and "an appropriate knowledge and appropriate experience of the practice and procedure, of the High Court". Curiously, the Bill refers to an appropriate knowledge and so forth as I just said, but it refers to the Supreme Court first. It refers to the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal and the High Court. The High Court, where this person will be officiating, is put last, almost as an addendum. Senator McDowell's refocusing of attention on the practice and experience of the High Court is appropriate.
I also support him regarding Attorney General being prohibited by law, under the sword of Damocles of committing a criminal offence, from informing the Government of the long list. That seems to be quite extraordinary. It would deprive the Government of critical information. The Government will be deprived of critical information about this appointment and will surrender its rights to a body where the majority of the members may not have any great knowledge or expertise in this area at all. I strongly support Senator McDowell on this.
There is another matter on which I support him. The Minister referred to seeking expressions of interest on the part of eligible persons who wish to be considered for appointment to that office. How do they know that they wish to be considered for this office? How can the commission tell from whom expressions of interest should be sought?
Subsection (7) of Senator McDowell's proposed new section states:
The Committee shall, for the purposes of making a report under subsection (2)—
(a) inform all members of the Superior Courts of the vacancy and invite any such member to express an interest in being appointed to the judicial office mentioned in subsection (2),
(b) publish any circular or advertisement as it considers appropriate inviting any other person eligible for appointment to the judicial office mentioned in subsection (2) to notify the Committee expressing an interest in such an appointment.
That is the way to do it. First, all the members of the superior courts are informed. As an addendum, I used the word "demean". It was slightly mischievous but when one is talking about superior courts, one is talking about superiority, and if one is going down, one is demeaning oneself. It seems that if one is seeking to attract the interest of people, one should first inform the members of the superior courts. They are the individuals who are critically and principally involved. Second, one should "publish any circular or advertisement as it considers appropriate". That is the way to attract people, rather than using some vague means of contacting individuals who, as far as I can understand it, have a wish that has not yet been expressed.
Comment on this
The Minister referred to the reforming aspects of the Bill. He picked up quickly on Senator McDowell's word, "outsiders", and chose to put his own slant on it. The Senator had a different slant so language is clearly important.
If there is a vacancy and ten or 15 people apply, they have to be assessed to progress through the selection process. We have no idea how they will be assessed or who will assess them. Three recommendations are to be brought before the Cabinet, which is to make the appointment. The Cabinet does not have to accept any one of the three. If the Attorney General's hands are tied, as was the case in respect of section 27, he or she will have no input whatsoever into the appointment. If we untie the Attorney General's hands and the Cabinet says it is not happy with any of the three applicants and asks the Attorney General for an opinion and, on receiving it, makes an appointment, what in God's name is transparent about any of the process? The public will never know who applied. They will never know how the applicants were assessed and short-listed, that the three on the short-list were rejected by the Cabinet, or the reason for that. We will end up with the system we currently use to appoint judges. I cannot see anything reforming in this. The more we go through this Bill, the more I despair over it. Why are we pursuing it at all? It is deeply flawed. My colleague Senator McDowell, who is an expert in the area, says he believes it is unconstitutional. I said when discussing this with the Minister some weeks ago that if no one tests this in the Supreme Court if and when it is passed, I am mindful to test it myself. I do not believe the President will sign it anyway.
Comment on this
I refer the House to the proposed section 44 in our amendment. May I explain the context?
Comment on this
If I heard the Minister correctly, he is prepared to get further advice and rethink some of the points raised before Report Stage. I would like the Senator to bear that in mind.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but I want to make one point very clear to the Cathaoirleach. Committee Stage is where this has to be thrashed out. When we get to Report Stage, it will be a speech for and a speech against, followed by a speech for and a speech against, and that will be it.
Comment on this
Unless it reverts to Committee Stage, there is no real engagement, just speeches for and against.
Comment on this
I am not using this as a device. I accept what the Senator said and I invite him to proceed.
Comment on this
I am very cautious of the Report Stage procedure. I do not like it at all. I realise one can recommit to Committee Stage but I would prefer to address all the principles-----
Comment on this
I do not have a difficulty with that. The Senator and I are around here a long time. I will not engage in any sharp practice, if that is what he is implying.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but, on the other hand, I am not willing to let go the lead of the dog-----
Comment on this
That is what the Senator is entitled to do. Whatever about other amendments-----
Comment on this
Whatever about my disposition as far as other amendments are concerned, I assure the Senator that I am keen to engage with him on these amendments. Given his experience and expertise, I am keen to listen on these amendments because they are of great importance in the context of the Bill. Whatever about anything I might have said on previous occasions about the length of the Bill or the length of the debate, I am keen to engage here. I am not in any way anxious to curtail or stymie debate on these amendments. It is not that I would be allowed to do so in any event.
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Minister has indicated a degree of openness of mind on this issue. It is clearly understandable in the context that he ended up leaving the Dáil with a provision in this respect with which he did not enter the Dáil.
Subsection (8) of our proposed section 44 refers to the committee constituted by the section for all senior promotional appointments within the superior courts:
The Committee shall as soon as practicable make a report to the Government when requested by the Minister in accordance with subsection (2), and shall include in its report—
(a) the names of such persons as have expressed an interest in appointment to the judicial office mentioned in subsection (2), and
(b) the names of any such person or persons (not exceeding three in any case) whom the Committee recommends for such appointment.
Subsection (9) of the proposed new section states: "In advising the President in relation to the appointment of a person to a judicial office to which this section applies, the Government shall first consider for appointment those persons whose names have been recommended to the Government by the Committee in a report furnished to the Government under the provisions of this section." This was, and is, an effort to create visibility for the Government regarding what it is doing in the context of a senior appointment. First, it re-enacts the JAAB procedure whereby the Government should first consider the recommended list. That is probably as close as one can sail to the constitutional wind in asking the Government to pay attention to the report of the body. What we have in mind is that the names of persons who have expressed an interest should be the subject of knowledge of the Cabinet.
Let me make a point that I do not believe is widely understood. On a good day, if everybody became enthusiastic, a large number of people - perhaps 30 to 60 - could express an interest in being appointed as an ordinary member of the High Court. My experience was that when vacancies in the Supreme Court were advertised, the number of practitioners who expressed an interest was tiny. They were countable on one hand, or none. Few people would waste their time filling out the forms unless they were serious contenders. Of course, a few nutcases put in applications from time to time but, ignoring them for the time being, only a handful of serious contenders would have asked the JAAB to be considered.