Criminal Justice (Incitement to Violence or Hatred and Hate Offences) Bill 2022: Committee and Remaining Stages
Contributions 1–128 of 253. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 105 of 2022 ›
Amendments Nos. 1, 97, 102, 110, 112, 115, 117 to 119, inclusive, 121, 122, 126 to 128, inclusive, and 134 to 173, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
All these amendments aim to do two things: first, to remove all the incitement to violence or hatred provisions from the Bill; and second, to deal with the consequential amendments arising from enactment of the Criminal Justice (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2023. I will deal with these separately and will start with the first tranche.
As Senators are aware, the Bill originally aimed to achieve two objectives which were to update and modernise our existing incitement to hatred laws, and to introduce hate crime provisions for the first time in this State. Regrettably, while there was significant consensus in the Dáil for incitement to violence or hatred provisions, including opposition, that consensus was lost in proposals to expand the law further. This led to my announcement last month that I would be proposing a series of Committee Stage amendments to remove the parts of the Bill which deal with incitement to violence or hatred and to proceed only with the elements that deal with hate crime. Government endorsed this decision on 26 September so that the much-needed protections against hate crime could be progressed to enactment.
The core purpose of this hate crime legislation is to publicly recognise the harm that is caused by criminal conduct motivated by hatred and to make clear that this will not be tolerated. Hate-aggravated offences have been criminalised in most western nations. Hate crimes challenge our societies by directly undermining a sense of belonging and place which is central to inclusive communities. We must do everything we can to protect people from being targeted just because of who they are, particularly in the current climate of increasing intolerance, hatred and violence towards vulnerable and marginalised communities.
These are the first of many amendments that give effect to this decision. I recall comments by certain Senators in this House last year to the effect that this Bill would get through in a heartbeat if the hate crime elements were separated out. I am delighted that we are here and will be passing it. This is what I am proposing to do. Almost half of the Government amendments I will move this evening are to remove the incitement to violence or hatred provisions entirely from this Bill so that we can progress this important element of legislation and send a very clear message that hatred and violence are not tolerated in our society. I have said very publicly that I believe we need to update our 1989 Acts. I absolutely believe this needs to be next on our agenda.
I will outline the changes as they have been grouped and as they arise in the sections of the Bill. To begin with, I am moving amendments to the Short Title of the Act as provided for in section 1. Subsection 1 will be amended to provide for the Short Title to be changed to the Criminal Justice (Hate Offences) Act 2024. Subsequent amendments will involve the deletion of sections 6 to 16 which make up Part 2 of the Bill and references elsewhere to incitement to violence or hatred and to the EU framework decision on combating racism and xenophobia. The Prohibition of Incitement to Hatred Act 1989 will no longer need to be repealed. Section 4, which provides for the repeal, will also be deleted. Specifically, amendments Nos. 1, 97, 102 and 110 remove references to incitement to violence or hatred. Amendments Nos. 112, 115, 117 to 119 and 121, 122, 126 to 128 are minor technical amendments that are required in order to update the references to this legislation that are being inserted into other Acts to create new hate aggravated offences. These arise from the removal of the incitement to violence or hatred provisions in part 2 from the Bill. Amendments Nos. 134 and 135 are technical amendments that also result from the removal of the incitement to violence or hatred provisions.
The second tranche of technical amendments, from amendments Nos. 135 to 173, inclusive, result from the insertion of new offences into the 1997 Act for the Criminal Justice (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2023 enacted last year. The relevant sections of that Act were commenced on 31 October 2023. These amendments will update section numbers and references to the new hate aggravated offences in the 1997 Act that were changed by the 2023 Act so that the legislative logic of this enactment is maintained.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister to the House and I thank her for taking on board, in part at least, the criticisms of the Bill that were made in this House. It is fair to say that if it was not for the Seanad, we would not be in the place we are in today. The Government has taken on board, at least temporarily, the serious concerns people had about this legislation in its original form, as passed by the Dáil, and its implications for legitimate freedom of expression on important issues of controversy.
That is not to say the Bill did not attempt various protections for freedom of expression and I have always acknowledged that. It is also not to deny there were categories of communication that the Bill sought to protect. However, as was pointed out to the Minister at the time, those protections did not go far enough. In fact, it was all about the context. I previously said to the Minister what seems like a long time ago now, when we had the Second Stage debate on this Bill, that our society is in the middle of a cancel culture. People attempt to weaponise taking offence at other people's communication in order to close down the expression of opinions and ideas they disagree with and believe should not be allowed. Such a culture is of course toxic to any free society. It was pointed out to the Minister, and I again acknowledge what cannot be denied, that were it not for some people on the Government side who accepted there were problems with the Bill as previously cast - insofar as they related to incitement to hatred in particular, the non-definition of hatred in the Bill, the problematic definition of gender in the Bill and the potential for something that was designed to ostensibly protect people from hate-related speech which could endanger them - the Bill could have in fact gone much further and been used to close down the legitimate exchange of ideas on controversial issues.
To the extent that the Government has, as I put it earlier, pulled in its horns on the incitement to violence or hatred, that is welcome. However, I can give it only a partial welcome. First, I put on the record that I would have had no problem supporting an update of the 1989 legislation so far as the prohibition on the incitement of hatred or violence is concerned. What we should be dealing with today are Government-sponsored amendments to that legislation to deal with the legitimate concerns the Minister took on board. I do not understand why the Government's response was simply to cut that out of the Bill. My suspicion is that it is just parking it for another day and that when the members of the Government get back into government, they will come back with it and use their majority to push it through without ever engaging with the concerns people had about how far these provisions on incitement to violence or hatred went. As the Minister knows, I have the greatest of respect and goodwill towards her personally, but I am disappointed that no attempt has been made to seek out those who expressed concerns about the Bill and to see whether we could work together to address those concerns in a way that would meet the objective of updating the Prohibition of Incitement to Hatred Act, if that was necessary. I am concerned by the lack of communication that has taken place and what that means in regard to the Government's true intentions, which we must try to discern. That is my first point.
Second, it has been said, rather casually and sometimes glibly, that the 1989 legislation is not fit for purpose and is out of date. My friend and colleague, Senator Ward, mentioned in a prerecorded Newstalk interview we did earlier today that this Bill is to take account of the new digital space, which is not covered by the 1989 Act. I am not sure that is the case. In advance of the European and local elections, helpful documentation was produced by the Electoral Commission to enable politicians to protect themselves and keep themselves safe in the context of the election campaigning. It is interesting, if I recall correctly, that among the legislation invoked as being of assistance was that 1989 legislation. I am not sure there has been careful and honest scrutiny of how the 1989 Act could have been tweaked, if necessary at all, to transfer over what that legislation does in regard to traditional modes of communication and media to ensure, for the avoidance of doubt, that it would also cover anything expressed in the digital and online space.
Of course, as we know, the Government has expressed the desire to secure more prosecutions in this area. That is why we had the strange situation on Second Stage of the Minister, if I recall correctly, using language like "stir up" and talking about how the legislation was intended to prevent people from stirring up hatred, when, in fact, that language was not in the Bill. A lower threshold was being established, which bolstered our concerns that this could be used to close down legitimate freedom of expression. As I said, the Minister has dealt with that temporarily by simply pulling the whole thing out of the Bill. I have concerns about that approach as opposed to a more studied and consultative set of amendments that would allow us to agree on how to cast legislation for this era dealing with incitement to violence or hatred.
The Minister also mentioned, and she is right, that it was said that this legislation would pass in a heartbeat if it contained only the hate crimes element. I think I am the party who spoke in that respect. It is true in that I have much less concern about the hate offences part of the Bill than I had about the implications for the free expression of ideas contained in the incitement to violence or hatred portion. In the same way, I had much less concern about the section of the Bill, which has not been removed, to do with genocide, Holocaust denial and so on. That is not to say I have no concerns. I remember, before any of this legislation came to the House, taking part in an online briefing with Department of Justice officials. I put on record my concern then and I put it on the record again today. I understand the argument for identifying certain groups of people in society in respect of whom if crimes of violence or assault on their property or person take place, and if such crimes are motivated by hatred towards them because of the particular characteristics they might have, that may have a chilling effect on them as a community and there is a particular damage that is done. I can imagine a scenario, for example, where there is a small minority-ethnic group in a particular community and they are being subject to a series of attacks motivated by hatred towards them. I get how that would have a frightening effect not just on the person who is attacked but on the small group as a whole. It is not that there is no argument for selecting particular groups whereby if hatred is shown towards them in the context of a crime committed against them, it is especially grave. I accept that argument.
There is an argument against it, however, to which the Government has not faced up. That argument is that in a society that is already polarised and divided, it is dangerous to go creating different tiers of victimhood in respect of the same crime. It is dangerous to go beyond the point where judges already have a certain amount of latitude and leeway to have regard to the particular circumstances of a crime committed, including not just the mentality of hatred that might underline the crime but other circumstances that would make a given offence particularly egregious in a particular set of circumstances. That discretion and latitude is already there for the courts. It is best left there, even as I acknowledge that there may be, as I said, cases and categories where certain crimes are particularly harmful. It is best left to the courts to take all of that into account in the context of sentencing.
Why do I say that? I do so because, as I said, in a society that is, sadly, polarised and, it seems, more polarised than it used to be, where people are very quick to sense that they are being left behind or are uncared for, anything that suggests that, in the eyes of the State, a crime against X is less serious than a crime against Y is potentially damaging to the common good. I gave the example in my debate with my friend and colleague, Senator Ward, earlier today that if somebody assaults a child because there is a hatred towards that child's parent or just because the attacker is being malicious on a given day, to that child and to that family, the offence is just as serious and grave and deserves the same level of seriousness from the State as if the offence were an offence committed against that child because he or she is a member of a particular ethnic group. It really is for judges to decide what is going on in a particular case. An underlying attitude of hatred towards a particular community or group is just one of the issues a judge should take into account.
On balance, if I were asked, níorbh é an cloch ba mhó ar mo phaidrín, mar a deir siad i gConamara. This was not my biggest concern. However, I do have a concern about the tiering of victimhood. When we tier victims, we also tier offenders. Treating one offender's offence as more serious because it is motivated by a mentality towards a particular group is a dangerous road to go. The solidarity we need to promote in society demands a constant reinforcement that we are all equal in the eyes of the law. That is a fundamental constitutional principle which I should not have to restate. There is something about the hate offences section of the Bill that subtracts somewhat from the principle that we are all equal in the eyes of the law. However, as I said earlier, I was happy to live with that.
One of the reasons I am happy to live with it is because when you are talking about hate offences, you are talking about people who have committed a crime anyway. While they might deserve incarceration that is designed not just to punish them but to rehabilitate them, my sympathy towards them does not go very far. Where we are talking about a criminal act, one can make an argument that there is already a level of punishment that is deserved and it may still be that even if the crime is upgraded because of a hate motivation towards people with a protected characteristic, there are still other issues judges may take into account in the sentencing in individual cases. That makes me think there will be no real difference, in practice, to the actual discretion judges might have in a given situation. I am very interested in hearing what the Minister has to say to that and indeed, what my colleagues Senator Ward and Senator McDowell might have to say that to that idea when they come in.
The point I made at the time to the officials from the Department of Justice is that the problem here is a tiering of victimhood that makes me nervous. I will park that, however, and not oppose the Bill today on that ground alone. I will express my concern and move on. There are other, more serious issues with the Bill. I will go further and say that the failure to define hatred, while less serious because the prohibition of incitement to violence or hatred will be removed from the Bill temporarily anyway, remains nonetheless problematic. That is all I will say about that for the moment because I will propose my own amendments, with Senator Keogan, which will offer different alternatives as to how hatred might be appropriately defined having regard to international instruments.
For me, the big challenge remains that a strange, anomalous, innovative, weird and dangerous definition of gender has been left in this Bill. I urge the Minister to change course on that. Let us recall that this Bill grew out of a European framework decision of 2008 and 2009 that put the onus on member states to take actions in order to combat racism and xenophobia, as we all know. The concepts we were asked to deal with as member states, with latitude given in various respects, were all about race, colour, religion, descent, or national or ethnic origin. This Bill clearly goes much further than that. It is worth recalling that is what this framework decision was about. The reference to religion is required to cover at least conduct that would be a pretext for directing acts against a group of persons or a member of such group defined by reference to race, colour, descent, or national or ethnic origin. Clearly, the issue underlying the framework decision was racial harmony. It was about racism and xenophobia. The framework decision required each member state to take measures necessary to ensure that certain types of conduct would be punishable, such as publicly inciting violence or hatred directed against a group of persons or a member of such group defined by reference to race, colour, religion, descent, or national or ethnic origin. Clearly, there is a requirement on foot of the framework decision with regard to certain kinds of incitement to violence or hatred. Obviously, that is not addressed in today's Bill so this work remains unfinished from the perspective of the decision. It requires thinking about it in terms of groups defined by reference to race, colour, religion, descent, or national or ethnic origin.
To the extent that we see the framework decision as binding, it is clear that the Minister has to think in terms of the groups in the legislation that she is casting here to implement that decision. This does not mean that the route of greatly widening the list of groups by reference to protected characteristics needed to be travelled in the way it was. It would be possible - indeed, I have amendments that seek to do this - to achieve a hate offences provision that has regard to hatred but widens the groups' possibilities, as the framework decision entitles the Minister to do. The Minister could take account of hatred aimed at individuals or at individuals by reference to their group status, and such group status could include their family membership. I refer to circumstances in which a person is a member of a particular family, and a child is targeted because they are from that family. I argue and have argued here in my amendments for including people's political opinions as entitling them to be considered in terms of group characteristics. If somebody is attacked because of their connection with a person who has particular political opinions or affiliations, or indeed because of their own political affiliations, I see that level of victimisation as just as serious. I think the Minister should seek to secure that in the context of what she is doing around hate offences.
As regards the troubling issue of gender, and I will return to this in my amendments, it is clear to me-----
Comment on this
Can we leave it until that stage so we can move on with the Bill? Would that be possible?
Comment on this
Let me sum it up. The Minister has spoken about what she is taking out. She has said we should be satisfied with what she is leaving in. The definition of "gender" confuses gender, which is objective and has to deal with the male-female binary, and gender identity and expression, which you might also see fit to include as a basis for protecting a group. Confusing them and redefining them all as being part of "gender" is an unprecedented step. That should not go into the statute law of our country. It should certainly not go into the statute law of our country if it is her intention to proceed at a later date, if she is the Minister, with incitement to violence or hatred legislation. In such circumstances, we would be back to the same problem of cancelling people's views and closing them down because they dare to say if you are a man you are a man and you cannot be a woman, except if you choose to have a preferred gender under the 2015 legislation. You certainly cannot be both a man and a woman and you cannot be one of the amazingly increasing number of genders. That takes us into "Alice in Wonderland" territory and the Minister should not do this in this legislation.
It does not need to be done in order to protect people who might feel vulnerable or may be vulnerable. Senator Ward reminded me today that there is evidence - I have not seen that much of it but I am willing to accept it is there - that shows that people are being targeted in a particular way because of their gender identity or expression. I do not mind why people are being targeted; it is wrong. If gender identity and expression - that subjective state where a person believes themselves to be a particular gender, set of genders, no gender or some gender nobody has ever heard of before now - is to be included, that is fine. It can be put in, but it should not be confused with the true meaning of words which we have had right up until this point in Irish legislation, which is that "gender" refers to male or female, because to do so would have implications for future laws. We know the way legislation piggybacks on previous legislation and uses definitions from previous legislation. It cannot be anything other than ideological. I am not saying it is the personal ideology of the Minister, but it is the ideology of people who have access to the Government.
The confusing and highly intentional new definition of gender has implications for women's spaces, children's safety and many issues down the line, as I will make clear when it comes to the amendments.
The Minister is right. If it was only about the hate offences, the Bill would pass in a heartbeat - let us say a rather slow heartbeat - though not without objections. Certainly, while that definition of gender remains in this Bill we are in the same dangerous, toxic and irresponsible place we always were.
We should not be deciding this. We gave the Government pause in the Seanad. Many people lobbied the Government on social media inside and outside of this country. Insofar as the dialogue and contributions were respectful, I endorse them wholeheartedly, but it is no response to such responsible use of our parliamentary time to raise important issues to then propose that this entire issue be wrapped up in one session here today. Is there any reality to my ability, or that of Senator Keogan or anybody else here, to convince the Minister about the merits of an amendment we might have tabled on Committee Stage if there will not even be time to re-table that amendment on Report Stage or for the Minister to consider the issues with her officials? There is cynicism at the heart of the timetabling and organisation of the remaining Stages of this Bill.
Comment on this
Of course. I always take a point from the Senator, though I might not agree with it.
Comment on this
Perhaps there would be time if the Senator had not spent half an hour making what is, in essence, a Second Stage speech-----
Comment on this
-----that does not really refer to any of the amendments that have been tabled.
Comment on this
That is a classic tactical point that Government Senators repeatedly make. What I have noticed in the past here is that other Senators might come in and set out. I have not repeated myself hardly once in the context of what I have set out. I cannot believe that my colleague and friend, Senator Ward, said what he said. Here we are for the first time in more than year since we last discussed this issue and we have not been consulted with even once by Government. We have raised issues. We persuaded the media, mainstream and others, to take our points seriously to the point that the Minister and others representing the Government rightly had to answer hard questions. The Minister might have acceded, to some extent, to the validity of our concerns by withdrawing parts of the Bill here today. For my colleague, Senator Ward, to get up on his hind legs and offer a point of information - sorry, Barry, you only have two legs and I am not trying to suggest anything by that; I really am sorry and I did not mean it in the way it came out - to get up on his two legs and take issue with the fact that I remind this House of all the problems with this legislation and of the problems that remain after a gap of one year really beggars belief. It is suggestive of a governmental attitude that is not only not interested in the free exchange of ideas, but not interested in engaging with the real concerns that people have and have expressed. We should never use the guillotine in this House, especially not in the Seanad, except in cases of extreme emergency.
The Seanad exists to be the second eye on legislation going through the Oireachtas. Insofar as this hate-related legislation is concerned, the Seanad had done its job well. This is one of the occasions that we can point to where the Government was given pause by issues that were raised in the Seanad that were not properly ventilated in the Dáil. Please, Senator Ward and others, do not take umbrage or try to close down the debate by reference to the fact that I set out the issues again after a gap of a year or more. These issues have to be talked through properly. Let me hear it from the Senator that he will not support the ramming through of this legislation here today, and that he will not support the conflation of the important Committee Stage and the vital Report Stage of this legislation in the Seanad.
Comment on this
The Order of Business has been accepted by the House today.
Comment on this
That I accept. Using the Government's majority.
Comment on this
When Senator Ward tells me he is uncomfortable about the use of the guillotine, I will listen with more eagerness to what he has to say about the relative length of speeches. This is one speech that has to be made, however, because there is a lot that is still wrong with the Bill.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat, a Cathaoirleach Gníomhach. I will start by addressing that issue. This Bill has been discussed to an extraordinary extent on Committee Stage. Yes, it was a while ago and the reason for that is because the Minister took away-----
Comment on this
The Senator said "Committee Stage". Can I offer the Senator a point of information?
Comment on this
Senator Mullen had his turn to speak. Let Senator Ward speak.
Comment on this
Through the Chair, Senator Flynn. The Senator will have her opportunity to speak in a moment; she is next.
Comment on this
It is the least the Senator could do. Senator Ward said “Committee Stage”. We have not had discussion on Committee Stage. Everybody had one speech on Second Stage in the Seanad and this is Committee Stage.
Comment on this
Yes. The Bill has been discussed. I may have misspoken in respect of Committee Stage. The Bill has been discussed extensively in this House. It has been discussed at the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Justice as well. There is no lack of discussion on this subject. Senator Mullen and I have shared platforms in respect of this on a number of occasions. We have been in the media on this on a vast number of occasions - far too many, some might say. There is no lack of discussion on this Bill. The Bill has been scheduled for four and a half hours of discussion today. We have now spent 35 minutes of those four and a half hours listening to Senator Mullen telling us about the issues that have to be talked through properly. The Senator should understand that talking through issues does not mean a monologue from one Senator with one perspective.
This is a debate where amendments have been tabled. Each amendment should be discussed and debated with regard to the amendments themselves. What we actually heard from the Senator was an extensive Second Stage speech in which he set out all the issues he has with this Bill, including aspects of the Bill that the Minister is withdrawing from the House. If that is not a waste of some of the time that this House has, then I do not know what is.
I will not spend a lot of time talking about this but I want to address a couple of issues raised by Senator Mullen. He expressed a view that the difference between an offence committed against a child because somebody hates their parent and an offence committed against a child because of the ethnicity or race of that child is naught . That is to fundamentally misunderstand the effect on a person of an offence that is motivated by hatred because of, for example, ethnicity or race. There is ample academic literature to back this up but it is perfectly commonsense that when somebody is targeted because of who they are in terms of their being, not what they have chosen to be, it has a deep effect on them. If a child, for example, who is not Irish and maybe is ethnically different is assaulted on the street, let us say, the message that child takes is that they are not welcome, that they are different, that they are othered and that they are not safe or welcome in this community. That has a deep-seated psychological impact on that child. That is something that is recognised in the courts as an aggravating factor at sentence. It is widely recognised in our criminal courts. In fact, I have never heard that fact being disputed before. The notion that somebody-----
Comment on this
Will Senator Ward take a point of information? I did not dispute that view today that judges have latitude in this area.
Comment on this
No, what the Senator disputed is that there is no difference between, let us say, a child born in Africa who is ethnically African and comes to this country and is assaulted in the course of a hate crime, called names, othered and essentially told they are not welcome, and a child who is assaulted because somebody does not like that child's father. There is a fundamental difference between those two things. It is so fundamental that this House and the other House have spent a great deal of time passing an extensive piece of legislation to recognise the fact that that offence is markedly different in character, and perhaps most importantly, in the effect that it has on the victim of that crime. I have never heard anybody in the law courts or in these Houses actually dispute that fact, other than Senator Mullen when he stood up today and essentially said the same thing.
He talked about the fact that there is a tiering of victimhood. I have news for Senator Mullen: every single crime is different, every offender is different and every victim is different. The effect on every one of them is different, so of course there are tiers. If, for example, a person is a victim of domestic violence and assault at home by a partner, that is completely different from somebody who is randomly assaulted on the street by a person coming out of a pub. They are different. The Senator can call them tiers or differences, but it is entirely appropriate that the law would recognise that one is more serious than the other because it has a more profound effect on the victim. That is the reality of the criminal law and the way the courts approach it. The reality of what we are doing in this law is trying to recognise the fact that crimes do have different effects on people, which is something that must be taken into consideration.
By the way, we already do this in law. We recognise the fact that, for example, murder of an individual is different from capital murder of a garda in the course of his or her duty. We have already put through legislation in this House to recognise the difference between assault on an individual and assault on an ambulance crew who are trying to help somebody or a fire crew who are trying to stop a fire from burning down a home. These are different crimes and they deserve different recognition in law.
It most certainly does not affect the doctrine that everybody is equal in the eyes of the law. That is not what this is about. It is exactly this kind of mischaracterisation that has polluted the well-founded concepts behind this Bill. It is the muddying of the waters by Senator Mullen and others in this House, who have suggested that there is somehow a nefarious ideological agenda here - that is not here - but instead it has caused people to lose faith in aspects of the Bill and resulted in us having to come back here.
Comment on this
When we look at the percentage of the vote and support that you enjoy, Senator Mullen-----
Comment on this
Senator Ward should speak through the Chair.
Comment on this
-----relative to what is enjoyed by the Government, then you can start assessing who the people have confidence in.
Comment on this
Senator Ward should please speak through the Chair.
Comment on this
The second issue Senator Mullen raised was the definition of gender. Again, I have raised it in this House on a number of occasions. There is an expansive, extensive and broad definition of gender in section 3. It is there for a very good reason - because the very people who fall outside the traditional norms of gender in this society are the same people who are repeatedly targeted for harassment and criminal activity due to them being non-gender normative. That is the reason the definition is so wide. That is one point, but let us park it for a moment.
Senator Mullen then takes that and decides this is somehow going to leach into every other active Bill that has been passed by these Houses, without any basis for making such a statement. The definition of gender in section 3 can only apply when the Bill becomes law. It can never apply to any other piece of legislation because it is specific to this legislative measure. That does not stop Senator Mullen suggesting to us that there is somehow an attempt by the Government to create a new definition of gender.
Comment on this
There is no basis whatsoever for that accusation. The definitions in this Bill specifically relate to the matters that are dealt with in this Bill. Different words are defined differently in various pieces of legislation because they are approached differently. They do not always mean the same thing in different contexts. That is a normal part of legislative practice. It is not unusual. I could give Senator Mullen a list of other words that apply differently in various pieces of legislation – from "public place" to "mechanically propelled vehicle" to "tax". Every one of them has different meanings. Let us not try to muddy the waters further.
Ironically, Senator Mullen talked about cancel culture, and how this Bill is somehow going to promote that. Once again, this is a complete and utter misconception that he has perpetrated time and time again. The Bill is not about being offended or taking offence. The Bill does not outlaw people being offensive.
Comment on this
I congratulate Senator Mullen on that because he has an opportunity to continue to be offensive after this legislation passes. It is not about Senator Mullen and people being offended, giving offence or taking offence; it is about a legal framework to protect people who have repeatedly been the subject of abuse, harassment and crime in this community. It is about saying to them: we recognise the impact of these criminal actions against them, and we are willing to recognise the fact that it has a deep-seated impact on them, not just personally but on their community – and on the other people who are within that characteristic and, most importantly, their ability as a citizen or resident of this State to peaceably enjoy the environment the same as the rest of us. That is what this is about. Let us not talk about cancel culture as if it is something any of us approves of. I am totally opposed to cancel culture.
Comment on this
That is not what the Bill is about. It does not outlaw giving offence or taking offence. After this legislation passes, even without the hate speech elements of it, it will still be permissible to say things that are offensive. It was never going to be any other way, but Senator Mullen repeatedly suggests that in an attempt to include in his army of misinformation things that are simply not in the Bill. I absolutely reject that.
It is important that we talk about these issues but, most important, when we pass this Bill, that we set down a rule for a case when someone is about to target a group that is vulnerable. It is not about majority groups, equality before the law, or saying all crimes are the same, because none of those things applies in regard to this Bill; it is about saying what will happen if you want to commit a crime against somebody and you target that person because of their ethnicity, religious belief, sexuality or gender. We can talk about what gender means if you want, but gender is actually a grammatical construct – sex is the word we should use if you want to go down that road. Everybody understands what-----
Comment on this
I would be delighted if you went back to it. You have been manipulating gender very conveniently for years.
Comment on this
That is why there is a definition in section 3.
Comment on this
Once again, you have managed to be offensive without actually contributing to the debate. It is about saying that if a person is part of a group that is repeatedly targeted, we recognise that is a serious matter. It is an aggravating factor and is a crime all of its own. It is appropriate for these Houses to recognise the impact that has on those individuals and to say, if you are going to do that, you will suffer greater consequences before the courts. I do not have a problem with any of that. I have no concerns about this legislation. I certainly have no concerns about the semantics that the Senator finds to try to satisfy the very limited cohort of people who have concerns about this, many of whom have emailed me and with whom I have engaged. I do not have concerns. This is an entirely proportionate and reasonable piece of legislation.
I recognise what the Minister has done in taking on board the concerns expressed on Second Stage in this House, in saying she will slim it down to satisfy those people. I do hope it is something we can revisit in the next session of these Houses, whenever that is. I acknowledge what the Minister has done. I put on record my admiration for the fact that she has taken the concerns on board and resolved those issues. Despite the fact that she has done that, Senator Mullen and his cronies still come in here and find a way to complain about it. Let us please get on with passing an important piece of legislation.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Ward. Before I call on Senator Flynn, I welcome visitors to the House who are guests of our colleague, Senator Lombard. We have Liam Condon, Gerard Crowley, Seamus Walsh and James Kilduff. I hope they enjoy the hospitality and entertainment that Senator Lombard will provide later.
Comment on this
I do not know what rock Senator Mullen has been living under for the past five years because the Coalition Against Hate Crime Ireland has worked with the Minister, other Senators, TDs, and the Department to have robust hate crime legislation. In my early days, I remember speaking with Members of the Oireachtas about this piece of legislation. I also remember that Senator O'Loughlin brought in a piece of legislation. We want a piece of hate crime legislation that is fit for purpose. That is what Senator Mullen has said himself as well.
I did not agree with scrapping the hate speech part of the Bill. I put my hands up to that. I have tabled amendments on it. I have to say: a good start is half the battle. I am absolutely delighted for people from minority groups to feel heard and seen within Irish society. That is thanks the Minister and to the coalition beside me. I have worked very closely with Dr. Seamus Taylor in the last five years. He also worked on hate crime in England. We have got the best people around us. I know that from the Coalition Against Hate Crime Ireland and the amount of work it has done in the past five years, but also for decades.
From 1989 to 2017 there were only five prosecutions for hate crime. It is not that we are going to be locking people up and throwing away the key or anything of the sort. It is about minority groups. It is not acceptable that my child, or children within my community, can be targeted because they are members of the Traveller community. That is not in the Bill. I do not know where Senator Mullen got that from, and why he is even speaking about children. Unfortunately, if you are born as a member of the Traveller community, a person of colour or born into another family, you are automatically seen as different within Irish society. Likewise, if you are a child with a disability, you are automatically seen as different within Irish society.
Instead of looking at people being all the same within the justice system, we have to look at differences within all of our systems. We must celebrate differences. I do not pretend to be the same as anybody here in these Houses. I am unique. I am okay with being unique. I am the first ever member of the Traveller community in these Houses. I bring pride and dignity to that. I am okay with being different. Do not insult me for my identity when I walk down the street. Do not insult a person walking down the street or burn a person's home because of the colour of their skin, their identity, sexuality or gender.
It would be great for all minority groups in the country if we were to pass this legislation. I know at least two Senators will talk and talk and feed into a minority view. It is a smaller minority than my community. There are 40,000 Travellers in Ireland and we would not even fill up Croke Park; we would only need a little section of it. The support Senator Mullen has is an extremely small community. It is a bit loud but we can all be a wee bit loud, if you want.
I credit the Minister from the bottom of my heart on behalf of all minority groups in the country and people who are different, be they trans or a person with a disability. This legislation is not ideal. I get that. I am disappointed at the scrapping of the hate speech element.
Our amendments address the report of how the process is going. The amendments from the Civil Engagement Group come not from me or Senator Higgins; they come from the coalition, the people from minority groups who are impacted most.
I look forward to discussing our amendments and urge Senators to be mindful. As the Minister said in the early days of this discussion, people still have the right to be offensive. It is unfortunate we have public representatives who still want to be offensive and to insult people who are othered in Irish society. I thank the Minister and welcome the coalition here again today. Senators should be mindful the Gallery is full of supporters of this legislation. We have two Members in the House this evening who are not supporting it. That is fine. They are entitled to freedom of speech and expression and all that jazz, but they should be mindful that people in the Gallery support the legislation.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin raised a number of flaws in this legislation in the last term, especially in the hate speech elements, as it proceeded through both Houses of the Oireachtas. These concerns included the definitions of "hate" and "hatred", or lack thereof, and still remain, as well as the over-reaching grounds for searches of phones and other personal devices, and freedom of speech issues.
While the Bill has been in the process of passing, we have seen the genocidal actions of Israel take place in Gaza and now Lebanon. An unprecedented mobilisation against genocide and in solidarity with the Palestinian people has taken place here and across Europe. Hate speech laws have been used to remove legitimate symbols of expression, such as the Palestinian national flag, during protests. In Britain, one woman faced arrest and was prosecuted for a poster of the then UK Prime Minister, using a term which academics testified at her trial was not a racial slur. Nevertheless, she faced personal and professional ruin when she had, in reality, no case to answer.
Unfortunately, the Government has pressed ahead bullishly without taking on board any of the concerns raised by Sinn Féin. It is for that reason we voted against the legislation in this House in June and it is for that reason we now propose, as the Government does, to delete the relevant sections. We support the amendments to delete these sections.
Comment on this
I join Senator Flynn in calling for us to press on with this legislation at this stage. Many hours have been dedicated to this Bill. There have been issues, particularly with regard to definitions, but ultimately we in the Labour Party are supportive of the Bill and what it is trying to do, particularly when we see a rise in the number of reports of attacks driven by racism, homophobia and transphobia. To us, this Bill is all the more necessary now. It is with some disappointment we see the Minister deleting the update, effectively, to the 1989 Act. It is regrettable she is shying away from that. I think she is being overly cautious. We believe an upgrade is required to that Act.
There is a fundamental challenge in the Bill as it will be amended by Government amendments. We will have two different definitions of "protected characteristics". Under the 1989 Act there are seven protected characteristics, while under this Bill there are ten. It is not entirely clear, if the 1989 Act is not repealed, whether the ten or the seven protected characteristics apply to the incitement to hatred laws. We firmly believe the list of ten protected characteristics that applies to Part 3 of the Bill must also apply to the incitement to hatred laws.
We have received much correspondence in recent days urging us to vote down this Bill. People have raised their concerns that this is an attempt to silence or to ram one set of views about gender down the throat of others. I could not disagree more with many of the comments we have received. I find it sad that people feel so threatened by people saying there is something other than biological male and female. Any of us with life experience in this House should recognise that while our world is still built around the binary male-female order of things, there are a small but real number of people who believe they are born in the wrong body and do not fit into the male-female definition. We need to listen to and respect them, ensure health and other social supports are there and show empathy.
The critical thing is the Bill does not create any new legal status. It is not about creating a new list of genders. It is about ensuring if somebody wants to project their hate or distaste onto another person just because of what or who they are, and does so with the use of physical or verbal violence, that is not acceptable and should be met with the force of the law. That is why the Bill is really important.
We cannot deny the increase in appalling attacks, particularly in the past 12 months. I am thinking particularly of one young man I know, Patrick, who, in broad daylight on a Saturday afternoon outside a Luas stop, was beaten up just because of how he dressed and how he presented to the world. That is not the kind of Ireland I want my kids or anybody else's to grow up in.
Our amendment to standardise or provide clarity on the list of protected characteristics was unfortunately ruled out of order because the Minister is amending the Bill to delete section 4. We believe clarity is now required as to whether the list of ten protected characteristics will apply to the 1989 legislation.
Comment on this
I am surprised by the personalised approach taken by Senators Ward, Flynn and, to a lesser but somewhat existent extent, Sherlock to attacking our concerns.
Those of us who have concerns about this Bill have set them out very carefully. The difference between Senator Ward and me is that I acknowledged the point of view that the other side had. I expressed, for example, why I could see the argument that a particular person who was a victim of a particular crime coming from a particular group-----
Comment on this
I ask the Senator to speak to the Chair, not to the Senator.
Comment on this
I am just looking at him; I am speaking to the Acting Chair. He is a beauty to behold, no more than myself.
I accept the argument but my point is simply this: on balance, it is dangerous to go tiering victims and it is best left to courts to make rulings in sentencing having regard to all of the circumstances in the case of an offence, including a hatred motivation. I should be allowed to say that without being demonised by Senator Ward, Senator Flynn or others. The more strident and dogmatic they are in insisting that people like me have come out from under a rock, the more the listening public hears people who are simply ad hominem in their arguments, as opposed to people who are honestly grappling with the issues. I would have a lot more respect if Senator Ward said that he sees my point of view but thinks I am mistaken because of X, Y or Z. On the suggestion of reassuring me that I will be able to "continue to be offensive", I would be horrified to think that I was ever deliberately or even accidentally offensive. I do not think that kind of trademark, old-style, political jibing is what is called for as we scrutinise this legislation. There is no need for it. Disagree with me all you will and show me why you think I am wrong but do not suggest that I am looking for an excuse to be offensive. Nothing could be further from the truth.
I believe there is an element of sleight of hand on the part of the Government - I point at no person - in maintaining this new definition of "gender", which is without precedent. I would say there is no reason to do that. I will point out to the Minister in a moment why the victim of crimes legislation in 2017 gets it right. It refers to "gender", which relates to the objective situation of whether a person is male or female, including a person who is male but who has elected under the 2015 legislation to be designated as female, and to the more subjective reality that is a person's perception of their own "gender identity or expression". I do not see how Senators Flynn or Ward can have a problem. I may be concerned about this kind of tiering of victims in the context of hate crimes, as I see it, but I have said that I will live with it. I do not see how anybody can have a problem with what I am saying, which is that the hatred that underlies an act making it into a more serious crime should or could refer to characteristics of the victim, including their age, communications difficulties, colour, disability, family connections, health, nationality, national status, gender, gender identity or expression, ethnicity, political views or affiliation, religion, race, sex characteristics or sexual orientation. I am the one who is being inclusive here. You guys are the ones who are being exclusive by forcing people to take on board that gender no longer means a male or female, and also by excluding certain categories of people from protection. I put it to the Senators again: if a child is attacked because they are a member of a political family-----
Comment on this
On a point of order, we are debating the first grouping of amendments, all of which are technical in nature and deal primarily with the name of the Bill. We are now having a rehash of the speech that Senator Mullen made earlier. It is not in order, it does not relate to the amendments that are being discussed and it is repetitive.
Comment on this
I will simply reply by saying that I am responding to particular things that Senator Ward chose to say.
Comment on this
If he chose to say them and it was in order, then it is in order for me to reply at this point. I will conclude by saying that everything that is being proposed here today leaves open the possibility that people will be protected against crimes based on hateful motivation. I will put it to the Senators again - we are here in this House as politicians - that if someone is attacked because they are a child of a political family, and that has a chilling effect on them ever getting involved in politics, that is serious and is deserving of consideration in the same way as if the hatred is based on the ethnicity or other protected characteristics of a person. It in no way denigrates anybody or any minority that you simply make room to take into account that hatred can be based on characteristics other than those the Government is proposing. I ask the Minister to take that on board and to take it seriously.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Mullen. Does anyone else want to come in on these amendments? The Minister can come back in.
Comment on this
Very briefly on this again, I will refer back to what exactly we are trying to achieve here. The amendments we are speaking to are technical in nature and remove quite a significant part of this legislation. I genuinely regret that this is where we are at now. For a lot of legislation, you will not always reach a consensus but for the most part, you need to have a consensus and that was not there in this instance. I accept that. The next Dáil and the next Seanad, whenever they come into being, will need to find a way forward because the 1989 Act needs to be updated. We can see that clearly, particularly in the changes we are experiencing in our society at the moment and the fact that a greater level of hatred is being displayed and communicated in every type of platform. I fundamentally believe we need to update our 1989 Act. I regret we are not doing it here now but I also fundamentally believe we need to have hate crime laws in place. We do not have them at the moment. We are the only country in Europe, and indeed probably the western world, that does not have hate crime legislation. I will touch on many of the points that have been raised in some of the amendments but I want to make the point that no country has hate crime legislation that defines hate. Again, we will touch on that. Many people in this House have suggested that we are doing something weird, wacky or different from everybody else by defining it in the way that is being proposed, that we will be completely out of kilter and that it will render this Bill completely unusable. I will get into that again but we are not going off kilter here. We are looking at what other countries have done in making sure we get this right.
With regard to the characteristics, the reason we chose these specific characteristics is based on consultation and facts, including the fact that there are people who are more likely to be targeted and are already victims of crime simply because of who they are. I am not aware of a significant number of children who are being attacked because their parents or others are politicians. What I do know, however, is that if you are under the age of 25 and you are transgender, you are significantly more likely to be a victim of a crime or to be attacked than any other younger person. That is a fact. It is based on fact, and not just reports that have been done but you only have to look at reports from An Garda Síochána. I will outline a few, and continue to outline these throughout the evening. On 29 June 2004 in Dublin, a female was on the way to a market with two friends and was physically attacked by a man. He threw his body at her with all of his strength. She asked him what was happening, and he began insulting her saying that she was "nothing more than a trans". He repeated several times that she was nothing more than a man. On 8 August 2023, a transgender person was with a group of friends when three to five individuals began intimidating just that person, not the others. They attempted to evade these individuals. They were pursued, punched three times to the face and pushed to the ground. Their runners and hoodies were taken. Third, on 27 April last year in the north west, a transgender person was walking from a shop and was followed out of the shop by an individual who punched them in the back of the head simply because they were transgender. These are real people, real Garda reports and real issues. They are not made up or airy-fairy.
Comment on this
They are real crimes but these are real people who are more likely to be targeted because of the fact they are transgender. Senator Mullen's amendments and his objective here would mean that these people are not protected.
Comment on this
No, they are protected. Of course they are protected under criminal law.
Comment on this
I would like to hear from Senators throughout this debate. If the objective of this Bill relates to people who are targeted simply because of who they are - we can clearly see this, and the reason we have chosen these characteristics is because we know these people are more likely to be targeted - why would Senators not include in this Bill people who are more likely to be targeted than others? The objective of this Bill is to protect those who are more vulnerable, and these are vulnerable people. We need to understand why the Senator would not protect the people I have just mentioned here. They are real people who have been physically assaulted and attacked.
Comment on this
That is a misrepresentation. I want them all to be protected.
Comment on this
In a court of law their perpetrator would not get a higher sentence compared to somebody who was attacked because of the colour of their skin, where they came from, their religion or any other characteristic, disability or otherwise. They would not be protected. They would have to produce a certificate.
Should I have to produce a certificate if I am attacked because I am a woman? Should the Senator have to produce a certificate if he is physically attacked? That is what he is asking. This definition of gender is for this Bill alone. It recognises that there are people who are targeted because of who they are. There are many examples of where we have different definitions. The 2017 sexual offences Act has three different definitions of "child" in the one Act. It is not to say this is a Trojan Horse and this will change the definition of gender. There is one piece of legislation that has three definitions of a child in the one Act. We can discuss all of this but it is important we acknowledge what we are trying to do here. We are acknowledging that there are people in our society who are being targeted, assaulted and are victims of crime simply because of who they are. We know that because it is there. It is in black and white. I have just read it out. What is being proposed by many of these amendments would mean these people do not fall under this Bill and we do not recognise them. I fundamentally disagree that that is the approach we should take.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 2 to 13, inclusive, 36 to 38, inclusive, and 175 to 181, inclusive, are related. Amendment No. 8 is a logical alternative to amendment No. 4; amendments Nos. 6 to 8, inclusive, are physical alternatives to amendment No. 5; amendment No. 36 is a logical alternative to amendment No. 11; amendment No. 176 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 175; and amendments Nos. 179 and 180 are physical alternatives to amendment No. 178. Amendments Nos. 2 to 13, inclusive, 36 to 38, inclusive, and 175 to 181, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 2 and 13 are required because of the removal of the Schedule to the Bill, which itself is due to the proposed removal of Part 2. The provisions in Part 2 were intended to address most of our outstanding obligations to full transposition of Council Framework Decision 2008/913/JHA of 28 November 2008 on combating certain forms and expressions of racism and xenophobia by means of criminal law. This is why it is referenced in the Bill. With the deletion of the incitement to violence or hatred provisions, we will no longer be transposing the framework decision. This will be progressed separately in due course. Reference to the framework decision in sections 2(1) and (2) are to be removed.
Amendments Nos. 175, 177, 178 and 180 remove the references to incitement to violence or hatred from the Long Title, along with references to the Prohibition of Incitement to Hatred Act 1989, given that these provisions have been deleted throughout the Bill. I cannot accept Senators Keogan’s and Mullen’s amendments to the Title as the amendments I move have been expressly drafted by the Office of Parliamentary Counsel to the Government.
I propose to take amendments Nos. 3, 4, 5, 6, 8 and 10 together as they all deal with the definition of "hatred". One of the key criticisms of this legislation is that hatred has not been defined in the Bill. I wish to again explain to the House why this is the case. When drafting new legislation, a comparative exercise is undertaken to examine how other jurisdictions have legislated for a particular topic. This exercise was undertaken in developing this Bill at great length, I must add, given that Ireland is one of the last countries in western Europe and the western world to provide to hate crime laws, as I mentioned. There is, therefore, a great body of comparative legislation available worldwide. No other jurisdictions have defined hatred - none; zero. Similarly, legislation from many different jurisdictions around the world has been examined and hatred is not defined in any of them. Some jurisdictions use synonyms for hatred such as “hostility”, “ill will” and “malice”, such as England and Scotland, but again these terms are not defined. In addition, the framework decision of 2008 on combating racism and xenophobia, the one Ireland is required to transpose and which I referred to earlier, does not define hatred. It states, “‘Hatred’ should be understood as referring to hatred based on race, colour, religion, descent or national or ethnic origin.” This is exactly in line with the approach being taken in this Bill.
The definitions of hatred proposed by Senators Clonan, Gavan, Keogan, Mullen and Warfield are based on a European Commission against Racism and Intolerance definition of hatred, which is used for policy and advocacy purposes, not legislation. I stress to Senators that I expressly contacted the ECRI, which confirmed it was never intended for inclusion in criminal legislation. On the contrary, the ECRI made very clear that this definition is only intended to inform policy and offer guidance to member states. I have been strongly advised by the current and former Attorney General against using the ECRI definition on the basis that attaching different words to the definition of the explanation of hatred would then require the explanation of each of these constituting words. The Senators used the terms “opprobrium”, “enmity” and “detestation”. These are not commonly understood concepts in the same way that hatred is. These terms do not provide any additional precision. In fact, they just confuse things even more. They could leave the legislation vulnerable to constitutional challenge on the basis that the offences become excessively broad, vague, uncertain and inconsistent with the rule of law. The Attorney General also advises that it is not possible or appropriate to provide exhaustive definitions of every term in the legislation. Additionally, if the amendments were accepted, each of the proposed terms would have to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt in court to secure a conviction. Think of this. This would mean that on top of proving that the person committed the crime, it would have to be proven that the individual concerned demonstrated opprobrium, enmity and detestation, that they were biased, that there was prejudice, that they held contempt or that they were hostile and bigoted. This would place an almost impossible burden on the prosecution. That is what is being asked here. That is what is being proposed to put into this Bill. In essence, I believe that for the purpose of this legislation, many of the terms proposed to define hatred are simply more obscure words which are more likely to confuse a jury in the course of a criminal prosecution than what is a widely understood term - hatred. This is the view also shared by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
The definition of hatred as currently set out in the Bill represents the word’s ordinary and everyday meaning. The person who attacks a person leaving a gay club for no reason other than they hate gay people can be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law and be labelled the hate criminal they are. The person who attacks a person simply because of the colour of their skin can be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law and be labelled the hate criminal they are. There will be no legal uncertainty as to what constitutes a hate offence, as hatred will have its ordinary and everyday meaning. This reflects the rules of statutory interpretation, which the Supreme Court has consistently upheld. For these reasons, I cannot accept these amendments.
Senators Keogan’s and Mullen’s amendments dealing with the definition of “incitement” will be overtaken by the Government proposal to delete Part 2 from the Bill, which contains all of the provisions for incitement to violence or hatred as well as those definitions that are required only for the purposes of Part 2, so I cannot accept these amendments. To Senator Keogan, for the avoidance of doubt, we are not progressing with hate speech. Despite the many social media posts over the weekend and otherwise, we are not progressing with the hate speech element of it. Similarly, I cannot accept amendments Nos. 36, 37 and 38, as this section is to be removed.
I propose to speak to amendments Nos. 9 and 12 together. The definition of “gender” contained in this legislation is confined to this legislation. It does not affect the Gender Recognition Act. This is not a gender recognition Act; it is a hate crime Act. It does not affect the Civil Registration Act - this is not a civil registration Act - or any other Act on the Statute Book. I want to be very clear on this and I want to ensure everyone in this House understands this. The definition of "gender" provided for in this Bill is specific for the purpose of this Bill, and that is to protect our citizens from hate crime. That is the only reason for this. We know members of the LGBTQI communities experience a disproportionate amount of harassment and abuse and a disproportionate level of violence. We know members are targeted for the way they look, the way they dress, the way they identify and the people they love. We know it is precisely the people who do not fit into conventional ideas of gender and sexuality who are most vulnerable to this kind of victimisation.
This legislation is vital and long overdue. Our statistics on hate crime and hate-related incidents have risen year on year. I have just given an example of some of the recent crimes that have taken place in the past year. The Council of Europe has noted a marked increase in hate speech and hate crime, targeting people and organisations based on sexual orientation, gender identity and sex characteristics. This has also been documented by the EU’s Fundamental Rights Agency. Its 2024 survey of more than 100,000 LGBTQI people across Europe gives us a clear snapshot of the scale of discrimination, bullying, harassment and violence that members of this community face. More than half of surveyed respondents were victims of hate-motivated harassment - half of the 100,000 people.
Ireland's statistics are no different. Over half the respondents in the EU survey said prejudice and intolerance in Ireland have increased, while two in three said violence in Ireland has increased. In the year before the EU survey, more than half of those surveyed had been harassed. One in 20 had been attacked. We need to think about these figures when we are talking about definitions and what we are trying to achieve here. The numbers illustrate the scale of the problem but do not adequately convey the impact of the incidents on the victims themselves and the broader LGBTQI community.
I received a phone call about two weeks ago – I will not get into the details – about a person who was attacked simply because of who they were. It was a mother who called me. It was devastating for the individual attacked, the mother and the entire family that the individual was singled out because of who they were. The idea that it would be one of my two boys in the future, for whatever characteristic is represented here, is unthinkable. It is heartbreaking to think people are still being targeted because of who they are. These incidents send a message that people in communities are unsafe because of who they are. The physical and psychological impacts of hate crime are much deeper than those of regular crime. Hate crime dehumanises and goes to the heart of a person's identity. It damages their dignity and forces people to change their behaviour and hide who they are.
The objective of this legislation is to provide protection to victims of hate crime on the basis of personal identity characteristics. These protected characteristics include gender, sex characteristics and sexual orientation. This approach is deliberately inclusive to ensure we are adequately capturing the individuals and communities targeted by such crimes. Acknowledging that LGBTQI people are under increasing attack in Europe, the Council of Europe has called on member states to ensure a strong legal framework is in place to prevent and combat hate-motivated offences based on sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression and sex characteristics.
Gender, as set out in the legislation, means "the gender of a person or the gender which a person expresses as the person's preferred gender or with which the person identifies and includes transgender and a gender other than those of male and female". This broad definition of gender ensures protection for transgender people, as well as non-binary persons and others who do not identify with any of the terms expressly included in the definition. Why would we leave these people out when we know they are more likely to be victims of an attack, an assault or a crime? Inclusion of this broader meaning was on foot of recommendations from civil society organisations representing vulnerable minority groups, including the Coalition Against Hate Crime, which I acknowledge and thank for its work in supporting minority groups. The broad definition of gender ensures protection for transgender persons as well as non-binary persons and others who do not identify with the terms expressly included in the definition. It is also included because the Garda has said very clearly that it needs stronger laws and to ensure the people it sees and engages with daily are included in the legislation. Inclusion of the broader meaning was recommended by the civil society organisations, as well as An Garda and many others. Transgender and non-binary persons experience extraordinary violence – physical, sexual, social, emotional and psychological – daily, often because they do not fit societal gender norms and stereotypes.
The EU survey found that more than one third of transgender and non-binary respondents had been physically or sexually attacked in the preceding five years. Furthermore, transgender and non-binary people were much more likely to have been attacked several times, with almost a quarter indicating they were attacked at least twice. Over half of transgender, non-binary and gender-diverse people say they have suicidal thoughts. We must protect these vulnerable members of our society. This is not just my view; it is the view of the vast majority of Irish people. An all-island national survey undertaken last year showed that 82% of Irish people believe transgender people should be protected by hate crime legislation. Not a single amendment from the Senators in this House would protect a transgender person.
Comment on this
Not true. Has the Minister read my amendments?
Comment on this
Has the Minister read my amendments?
Comment on this
I have read them and I understand-----
Comment on this
I have read and understand the intention behind the Senator's amendment, but it does not protect-----
Comment on this
It is precisely these people who are at risk of being victimised due to their gender identity. Protection cannot, and should not, be limited to binary gender identities of male and female. Let me be abundantly clear: this legislation has nothing to do with a victim's legal status. The definition of gender set out in this legislation-----
Comment on this
-----applies only in the context of hate crime.
Comment on this
The Minister has said something that is untrue. I ask her, given that we are talking about the Government and its responsibilities regarding truthfulness, to take a pause and read amendment No. 100. I ask her to withdraw the assertion that there is nothing in my amendment and indeed those of others that would protect a transgender person.
Comment on this
I do not share the same ideological ground as Senator Mullen. My amendment relates to the categories of citizens set out in the legislation. It includes all those referred to.
Comment on this
What the Minister said may have been unintentional but she should clarify the record because, with respect, my amendment seeks explicitly to protect that category of citizens in question.
Comment on this
The definition of "gender" set out in this legislation applies only in the context of hate crime. We need a broad and inclusive definition of gender because we are, by and large, a broad and inclusive society that encompasses these diverse gender identities.
Comment on this
The Minister is simply continuing; she has not corrected the record. I ask the Chair to direct the following question to the Minister: does she intend to correct the record or does she stand by her assertion that there is nothing in my amendment that would seek to protect all the categories of citizens as set out by her and her drafters? I have explicitly referred to protecting them.
Comment on this
I was not referring to the Senator's amendment, so-----
Comment on this
Will the Minister correct the record?
Comment on this
I was not referring to the Senator's amendment. He has not spoken yet.
Comment on this
She said none of the amendments submitted by any of the Senators would protect a transgender person. I have the greatest of respect for the Minister; this is not personal.
Comment on this
I stand corrected on the Senator's point.
Comment on this
Has the Minister even read my amendment?
Comment on this
Could she read amendment No. 100, please?
Comment on this
There is no heckling. We are asking for basic respect.
Comment on this
Disagree with me if you will, but do not misrepresent-----
Comment on this
Twenty-two amendments are being discussed together at the moment. I will allow the Minister to continue, and every Senator who wants to discuss them will be allowed to do so. Of the amendments, 14 relate to Senators Mullen and Keogan and six relate to the Government. Senator Clonan has one and Sinn Féin has one. Everyone will have an opportunity to speak and everyone should be allowed to speak.
Comment on this
We can speak to the Senator's point. He said earlier he does not intend to be offensive. He has already referred to the definition of gender as weird, strange and dangerous-----
Comment on this
We have very different views on this.
It is important to remember that a hate crime is a criminal offence, whether it is harassment, assault, vandalism or any other crime. It is a crime aggravated by hatred. An attacker's perception of somebody's gender identity becomes a reason to victimise them. Where a person is targeted based on their gender, where they are harassed or attacked or where their property is vandalised or stolen, a hate crime has been committed. The purpose of this legislation is to ensure the perpetrators of hate crime offences are punished appropriately. For the reasons outlined, I cannot accept any of these amendments.
Comment on this
The Minister is very welcome to the Chamber again. I do not have any objection whatsoever to the intentions and principles that underpin this Bill. It is sometimes said that perfection is the enemy of the good, but one small imperfection in this Bill is the enemy of the good intentions of the Minister and the Government. With regard to the definition of hate I have submitted in my amendment – it is my only amendment – I want to be clear. The citing of the lack of a definition of hatred in other jurisdictions as a reason not to attempt to define hatred is an a priori position; it is not an intellectual position. What if you were to go back to the 17th century and question why, because no jurisdiction in the world gives women suffrage, it should be done here? Just because something has not been attempted elsewhere does not mean we should not incorporate it into legislation like this. We should at least make an attempt.
Much has been made of the language in my amendment, particularly the words "emotions of opprobrium, enmity, and detestation rooted in bias, prejudice or hostility". I got those words from the glossary of terms of the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance, the ECRI. It was an attempt to clarify and elaborate. It was not an attempt to deflect or cause confusion. This is the Upper House. I was elected by Trinity College graduates. If there is a problem with the use of language, if we decide to censor certain words because some people have a difficulty with them, that is Orwellian. I am not addressing that to the Minister.
I seek to address the lack of clarity in the definition of "hate" and of the threshold in the context of the intention of a person by incorporating into the wording the following:
Any interpretation of hate or hatred under this Act shall be required to meet the definition and threshold set out by the UN Rabat Plan of Action including all six parts of the threshold which accounts for context, speaker’s status, intent, content and form, extent of the speech act, and the likelihood including imminence to inciting a crime towards a group. Any interpretation of hate under this Act must also be in keeping with the European Convention of Human Rights;
The Minister is not accepting my amendment. In light of what I am going to say, however, I ask her and her officials to consider it and, if they have any discretion, to include some of what it contains in the Bill. The amendment is an exhortation to bring this legislation into line with the aspirations as set out by our European partners and the United Nations. This legislation in the wrong hands and with this definition has the potential to be an oppressive instrument. What do I mean by that? Let us consider what freedom of speech means. The closest definition I could find in Irish legislation is the Universities Act of 1997. Section 14 (2) of the latter deals with academic freedom and provides that "A member of the academic staff of a university shall have the freedom, within the law, in his or her teaching, research and any other activities either in or outside the university, to question and test received wisdom ...", to test the hegemonic views of the majority, to test the group-think or Gleichschaltung of a society. I think of the ethical and intellectual failures of the Celtic tiger, when nobody could put his or hand up and say that none of what was happening made any sense without risking ridicule and opprobrium. To test and question received wisdom is a fundamental right, as set out in the Universities Act. Furthermore, it is a right to put forward new ideas and to state controversial or unpopular opinions. Imagine, that people would have the right to state unpopular or controversial opinions and "not be disadvantaged, or subject to less favourable treatment ... for the exercise of that freedom".
The reason I am so exercised about this is that as a young man and an army officer, I served my country in the service of peace in the Middle East in circumstances not unlike today, coming under direct and indirect fire to protect the lives of my fellow citizens in Lebanon. When I returned to Ireland, I did a PhD in Dublin City University in which looked at the experiences of my female colleagues in the Defence Forces. That research uncovered shockingly high levels of bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, sexual assault and rape of my female colleagues. I remind the House of the right to put forward new ideas, challenge received thinking and state controversial or unpopular opinions. One can make an ethical rationale for theft in order to feed one's children so that they do not starve. One can make an ethical argument or rationale for lying to protect oneself. One can even come up with a rationale for killing in self-defence or for defending one's comrades' lives. The one thing for which there is no ethical defence is the rape, abuse or sexual abuse of another human being. That is the one thing, as a species, for which there is no defence and that is what I spoke to. I spoke truth to power of a beloved, august institution and what was the consequence? I was exposed to hatred. I experienced reprisal. That reprisal consisted of physical assault in front of my infant children, not for who I am but for what I said. If it is an offence in this country to speak out against rape, sexual assault or sexual harassment, then hang me from the nearest apple tree. I am guilty. Some people might find it funny, but when one has experienced opprobrium, public denunciation, enmity, detestation rooted in toxic masculinity, bias, prejudice and hostility, one knows that those words are not ambiguous.
I want to be really clear. When I did my PhD, contributed to knowledge and introduced new ideas, I experienced reprisal. This was not 100 years ago. This was 24 years ago. Ireland is a very conservative country and this type of legislation, without the proper definitions and protections, represents an oppressive instrument. Senator Ward, for whom I have the greatest respect as a colleague, a friend and someone who will probably be my local representative after the next election - and I wish him every good fortune in that - said that this Bill is not about cancel culture. I agree with him; it is not about that. However, one of the things I was threatened with by the military authorities was that I had breached the Official Secrets Act in my research, which was a criminal offence, that a file would be sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions, that I would be charged, arrested and if found guilty, I could be imprisoned. The Official Secrets Act was not designed to be a feature of cancel culture but in the wrong hands and at the wrong time that is precisely what it was used for. All the king's horses and all the king's men participated in the reprisal to which I refer. The military authorities, the Department of Defence and, might I say, the university remained completely silent. Not once did the university state that my PhD had been internally and externally examined. Not only that, it had been sent to the solicitors on retainer with the university and had been subject to all of the ethical, oversight and governance requirements.
I can tell the House from personal experience that bringing forth unpopular or controversial views that threaten the hegemonic, received views of the majority in this country can be a forlorn exercise at best, and perilous at worst. My experience was described by Transparency International Ireland as a textbook case of whistleblower reprisal. It included character assassination, denunciation and reprisal which continues to this day and which was reanimated by the emergence of the Women of Honour and their disclosures, by the publication of the findings of the independent review group and, again, on the establishment of a judge-led inquiry into the culture of our armed forces. Make no mistake about it - Ireland is not some sort of benign, neutral environment when it comes to freedom of speech and ideas around what is appropriate or not appropriate. Since I was elected to this House, I have witnessed the coercive use of power by Government to try to curb freedom of speech.
I will give an example. During the referendum campaigns, a Minister told NGOs that if they disagreed with the Government line on the care referendum, they would have to defend or set out their position because of Government funding. There is an inherent conservative arc towards coercion in Irish society. I experienced that as I was growing up in the sixties and seventies when Ireland was full of nuns and priests. They had their own cancel culture and their own coercive, autocratic, authoritarian form of a priori truth. Theirs was the ultimate form of cancellation; it was called excommunication. Within this Bill, there is the prescription for excommunication. We got rid of the last crowd of coercive, authoritarian excommunicators. I do not want to empower or embolden a new generation of high priests and high priestess of political correctness who will seek to suppress alternative views and disagreement. I go back to moral philosophy and Socrates and Aristotle. They all agree that disagreement is the most powerful engine for arriving at the truth. Disagreement is important. I welcome disagreement because without it and without dialogue, we cannot move forward. The lack of a proper definition in this Bill is the enemy of the good. I support this legislation and I ask the Minister to do the right thing on this.
There should be no impulse to censor or excommunicate in our society. I believe, notwithstanding those deletions that have been incorporated by the Government, there is the potential for this legislation to be used as an oppressive instrument in the wrong hands. The Minister might think that will never happen but it has happened to me, not because I was being offensive, being provocative or trying to rock the boat but because I was calling out the most heinous crimes against my female colleagues. Do not think it cannot happen. I have seen the coercive tendency in this Government through its warning of NGOs funded by it that they must toe the Government line. Thankfully, notwithstanding the fact that all the Government parties and all the Opposition parties, bar one, supported the Government line, the Irish people saw the truth and resoundingly voted "No" against the proposed wording of the care referendum. That is something for which I am very grateful.
While this Bill it is not about cancel culture, without the proper definition it could be mobilised to cancel dissent. I value freedom of speech in our society and our culture. We are so lucky and privileged to have it. Do not give something to a future Government or a future Minister that could be used as an instrument of oppression. I want the record to show I am warning the Minister that this contains within it the potential for that abuse. I ask the Minister and her officials to consider some broadening of the definition and some remedy because, in the wrong hands, the opportunity will exist for somebody to use this legislation as an instrument of cancellation or excommunication.
I apologise for being a little bit emotional about this but I have experienced reprisal and excommunication. I have lived with it and the risk it poses to my family, because they too have been targeted in this way recently. Why should my children need to have that conversation in our family kitchen? It all arises from speaking truth to power and holding a controversial view, in the eyes of some, no matter how worthy or how compelling that view is. As colleagues, and I include the Minister in that as I am not just referring to Senators, I ask the Government to please consider remedying the defect and the lack of precision in the definition.
Comment on this
I will speak on amendments Nos. 5, 7 and 9 to 11, inclusive. I will come back in later on amendments Nos. 36 and 38.
Comment on this
They are all being discussed together but I have quite a long list of amendments so I want to try to get in as many as I can. On amendment No. 5, the current definition of "hatred" that exists is too loose. The current definition gives too much power to the gardaí, the DPP and the Judiciary. If it came to something like the trans issue, a person could be convicted whether they are favourably disposed to transgender views or opposed to them. A rigorous definition of the concept of "hatred", as utilised in this Bill, is essential for the sake of public interest and legislative clarity. The burden of proof for "hate" refers to the legal standard or threshold that must be met to prove that an act was motivated by hatred in cases involving hate crimes, hate speech or hate-related offences.
This burden of proof is a crucial aspect of law enforcement and judicial processes as it determines whether the accused can be held legally responsible for actions deemed to be motivated by hate. Key aspects of the burden of proof in hate crimes or hate speech include, but are not limited to, proving motivation. One of the main challenges in hate crime or hate speech cases is proving that the motivation behind the act was hate based on characteristics like race, religion, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation or disability that distinguishes the act from regular criminal activity. The prosecution must show that the defendant's actions were not just illegal in cases like assault, vandalism or verbal abuse, but were explicitly motivated by bias or prejudice against a protected characteristic of the victim.
The burden of proof in criminal cases, including hate crimes, is typically beyond a reasonable doubt. This means the prosecution must convince the court or jury that the accused committed the crime and it was motivated by hate to a very high degree of certainty. In civil cases, such as cases involving discrimination or hate speech, the standard of proof is often on the balance of probabilities. This lower standard requires that it is more likely than not that the action was motivated by hate. However, this poses a dangerous threat to fairness in our justice system. Evaluating the probability that a statement is defined as hate speech injects an arbitrary and opinionated procedure into our courts as the Government has chosen not to define the meaning of hatred for the purpose of this Bill.
In order to meet the burden of proof in hate crime cases, prosecutors must present evidence showing the act was motivated by hate or bias. This can include direct evidence such as statements made by the perpetrator during or before the crime, such as the use of racial slurs, homophobic language or symbols associated with hate. It can also include circumstantial evidence, which is evidence that suggests crime was motivated by hate such as targeting a place of worship, a specific ethnic group or an LGBTQ+ establishment. The accused's history of behaviour may also be taken into account. If the accused has a documented history of bias, hate speech or participation in hate groups, this may be presented as evidence of motivation.
When it comes to proving hate in court, courts often require clear and convincing evidence that bias or hatred was a substantial motivating factor behind the defendant's action. Intent is critical. Hate crimes are considered crimes of intent, meaning the prosecution must show the accused intentionally targeted the victim based on a characteristic such as race, religion or sexual orientation. There are challenges in proving hate and subjectivity of motive. It can be difficult to definitively prove what was going on in the perpetrator's mind when they committed the offence, especially if there was no overt statement or symbol of hate.
There are also mixed motives in some cases. The accused may have multiple motivations for their actions, not all of which involve hate. For example, a robbery that also involved racial slurs might raise questions about whether the hate component was a primary motivating factor.
Regarding free speech protections in hate speech cases, the burden of proof must also balance legal protections for freedom of expression. Courts may require a high threshold of proof to determine the speech was incitement to violence or hatred rather than merely offensive or controversial. The burden of proof for hate crimes in demonstrating the accused's actions were motivated by hate, bias or prejudice against a protected characteristic can involve proving intent through direct statements, historical behaviour or other circumstantial evidence.
The standard of proof in criminal cases beyond a reasonable doubt is quite high, making these cases challenging, especially in determining motivation. Adopting a precisely crafted and transparent definition of hate for the purpose of this legislation is essential to minimise and prevent improper convictions of people who have not called for physical harm to others but whose comments could be punished unjustly by this law. The Government must not merely proclaim protected characteristics, as is done so vaguely in this law, as necessary for State protection, while obscuring from the public any definition of what actions are considered criminal under this legislation. The State ought to provide an extensive list for each protected characteristic and outline sample statements and hypothetical cases in which it is extremely clear to the public what kinds of statements are to be criminalised under this Bill.
Regarding amendment No. 7, this Bill lacks a definition of hate as well as what incitement to hatred or violence actually is.
Comment on this
The Senator is giving speaking on an amendment that is being removed from the Bill.
Comment on this
I have already tabled my amendments so I am afraid the Minister is going to have to listen to this. The amendment aimed to address this issue and ensure there is a threshold------
Comment on this
For everybody's benefit, including the Senator's, if the section is already being opposed, there is no need to speak on it.
Comment on this
I am speaking on amendment No. 7, which is included in this section.
Comment on this
It has not yet been deleted yet. I did not interrupt anybody in any of the earlier contributions.