We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Criminal Justice (Incitement to Violence or Hatred and Hate Offences) Bill 2022: Committee and Remaining Stages

Contributions 129–253 of 253. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Criminal Justice (Hate Offences) Bill 2022
Enacted

No. 105 of 2022 ›

The Bill currently lacks a clear definition of hate and incitement to hate or violence, which are central to its purpose. By leaving these terms undefined, the legislation risks creating ambiguity in its application, leading to potential challenges in enforcement, interpretation and legal scrutiny. This amendment seeks to address this gap by providing a clear and precise definition of incitement of violence or hatred as conduct specifically intended to cause physical violence or to create intense or irrational emotions of opprobrium, extreme enmity, hostility, detestation or deep hate towards a person or group. Incorporating these thresholds ensures the legislation targets conduct that goes beyond mere expressions of disagreement or distaste and focuses on speech or actions that genuinely aim to incite harmful emotions or actions against others. It protects the fundamental rights to freedom of expression while drawing a firm line around behaviours that threaten societal peace and individual safety.

Incitement refers to encouraging or provoking someone to commit a crime or act unlawfully. In the context of this Bill, incitement to violence or hatred involves actively commanding or encouraging others to commit violent acts or to develop a strong, unjustifiable bias or hatred towards individuals or groups based on characteristics like race, religion, sexual orientation or gender identity. The inclusion of this definition sets an important legal standard that can help distinguish between legally protected forms of speech and conduct that seeks to provoke violence or irrational hostility, ensuring the law is both effective and proportionate.

Globally, many legal frameworks include clear and well defined parameters for what constitutes incitement to hatred, ensuring legislation can be applied consistently and fairly. For example, article 20 section 2 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, ICCPR, defines incitement to hatred as speech that advocates for "national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence". The ICCPR's guidance stresses that restrictions on speech must be necessary and proportionate to prevent overreach.

The Council of Europe's additional protocol to the Convention on Cybercrime in 2003 defines incitement to hatred as the act of spreading racist and xenophobic material motivated by hostility or prejudice and likely to incite violence or discrimination. The European Union framework decision of 2008 on combating racism and xenophobia also defines incitement to hatred as the public dissemination of a message that incites violence or hatred based on race, colour, religion or dissent, again focusing on clear intent and specific targeting.

These international legal standards provide robust, narrow definitions to prevent both misuse of the laws and the risk of infringing on freedom of expression. They also emphasise that incitement laws must address speech or conduct that genuinely threatens public safety or leads to real world harm, ensuring laws focus on actions with clear intent to incite violence or hatred. The current Bill, however, lacks any such clear or precise definition of what constitutes incitement to hatred or incitement to violence. Without a concrete framework, the legal threshold for conviction may be uncertain, leaving critical questions unanswered. What level of conduct or speech would trigger an accusation or conviction? How will the courts distinguish between heated or offensive speech and speech that actually incites violence or hatred? This absence of clarity may lead to subjective interpretations of what constitutes incitement, increasing the risk of inconsistent enforcement.

The lack of an explicit definition creates potential for overreach, where individuals may be prosecuted for speech that, while offensive or controversial, does not rise to the level of incitement under international human rights standards. Without a clear legal definition of incitement, individuals could be wrongly convicted based on misinterpretation of their speech or intent where provocative, controversial or critical statements are seen as incitement, even when they fall short of encouraging actual violence or hatred. Vague or subjective standards, where authorities or courts apply inconsistent criteria, could potentially lead to the prosecution of speech that is merely offensive, distasteful or dissenting rather than incitement. For example, an artist, journalist or activist expressing views critical of a political group or religious ideology could be charged with incitement to hatred under a broad or ambiguous law despite having no intent to provoke violence or irrational hostility. This would have a chilling effect on free speech and would discourage individuals from expressing legitimate, though controversial, opinions. Moreover, the lack of definition may cause disproportionate enforcement against minority groups, dissidents or marginalised communities who may be more vulnerable to accusations of incitement due to cultural misunderstandings of political bias.

In its current form, the Bill risks violating international norms of free expression by failing to provide clear definitions of incitement to hatred or incitement to violence.

The proposed amendments seek to introduce a clear and specific threshold for incitement, ensuring that only conduct with the intent to provoke violence or irrational hatred is criminalised. This would protect the fundamental right to free speech while ensuring the law effectively addresses harmful conduct aimed at inciting violence or hatred. By drawing on international legal standards, this amendment ensures the Bill aligns with best practice, maintaining a balance between the right to freedom of expression and the need to protect individuals from genuine threats of violence and hate.

The absence of a clear definition for incitement to hate in the Bill also poses broader implications for legal certainty. Internationally, legal certainty is a fundamental principle of the rule of law, ensuring that individuals can understand what actions are prohibited and adjust their behaviour accordingly. By failing to provide precise language around what constitutes incitement to hatred or violence, this Bill risks creating ambiguity in its enforcement. Without a clear definition, ordinary citizens may not know when their words or actions cross the line into criminal conduct. This creates an atmosphere of fear and uncertainty around the boundaries of permissible speech. As seen in other jurisdictions, such uncertainty can result in censorship where individuals avoid expressing opinions that, while lawful, could be perceived as incitement. This disproportionately affects public discourse on controversial issues, especially political, religious or social matters. Law enforcement agencies tasked with applying the law may struggle with how to interpret vague provisions, leading to inconsistent or biased enforcement. This can result in selective prosecutions or targeting of individuals or groups based on subjective judgments rather than objective legal standards. As demonstrated in jurisdictions where similar laws lack clear thresholds, officers may find themselves uncertain about what exactly constitutes incitement to hatred versus offensive or provocative language that remains protected under the rights to free expression.

The courts may be burdened with the complex task of interpreting these vague provisions, leading to varying judgments across different cases. This can create legal inconsistencies as different judges could apply the law based on their personal interpretation or societal attitudes. A lack of clear criteria could open the door to broad judicial discretion which increases the risk of legal rulings being influenced by political or cultural biases, further complicating matters of free speech and protection against genuine incitement.

International law cases demonstrate that minorities and marginalised groups may be disproportionately affected by hate crime legislation that lacks specificity. These groups may be unfairly targeted or accused of incitement when expressing views that challenge the majority, leading to a skewed application of justice. In countries where a broad or ill-defined incitement laws exist, activists from minority communities have often found themselves criminalised for raising critical or uncomfortable discussions about social injustices, despite having no intent to incite violence or hatred.

The proposed amendment seeks to prevent wrongful convictions by demanding a clear threshold for what constitutes incitement to hatred or violence. When the law is not clear, it opens the door to misinterpretation and misuse, particularly in cases where speech is misunderstood or misrepresented by others. This is especially true in highly charged social or political contexts where emotions run high and legitimate criticisms or dissent can be misconstrued as hateful or violent incitement. Without specific definitions and legal criteria, individuals could face charges based on subjective interpretations of their intent or statements. For example, a public figure or speaker engaging in controversial political debate could be prosecuted if his or her statements are seen as hostile, even if they were not intended to incite violence or hatred. Satirical speech or artistic expression, which often use exaggeration or provocation to highlight societal issues, could be wrongly viewed as incitement due to the subjective reactions of audiences. The lack of a clear intent requirement also leaves the law vulnerable to being weaponised against individuals or groups for reasons unrelated to genuine incitement. This could lead to a chilling effect, particularly in the context of sensitive or polarising topics such as religion, gender identity or ethnic relations where accusations of hatred or violence may arise from misunderstandings rather than actual malice.

The proposed amendment aims to bring the Bill in line with international standards, which typically include clear intent and specific harm as necessary components of any hate speech or incitement law. For example, the Rabat plan of action, which is a 2012 report of the UN High Commissioner of Human Rights, outlines six key factors to consider when determining whether speech constitutes incitement, including intent, context and likelihood of harm. These guidelines underscore the need for a high threshold to ensure restrictions on free speech do not exceed what is necessary to prevent violence or discrimination. The European Court of Human Rights has consistently ruled that restrictions on free speech must be carefully balanced to ensure they do not infringe on the rights of freedom of expression. This includes a focus on whether speech directly incites violence or discrimination. By introducing a clear and specific definition of incitement to hatred and violence, the amendment would ensure the Bill meets these international recognised standards, reducing the risk of overreach or misapplication.

The proposed amendment is critical to ensure the Bill provides clear definitions and a high threshold for what constitutes incitement to hatred or violence. Without such clarity, the Bill risks creating legal uncertainty, chilling free expression and leading to wrongful convictions based on vague or subjective interpretations of intent. By aligning with international norms and providing specific guidance on incitement, this amendment would help safeguard both public safety and the fundamental right to free expression.

The definition of amendment No. 9 aligns the definition with Irish law. If we are to accept the Government’s definition, however, this would mean there would be at least 72 genders, including, but not limited to, agender, abimegender, adamasgender, aerogender, aesthetgender, affectugender, agenderflux, alexigender, aliusgender, amaregender, ambigender, ambonec, amicagender, amorgender, androgyne, androgynflux, anesigender, angeligender, anogender, anongender, anteisgender, anxiegender, apagender, apconsugender, apertusgender, aposgender, aquagender, aquariusgender, archaegender, argogender, aristogender, aritgender, artistigender, astroflux, astralgender, atmosgender, atturgender, autigender, autogender, axigender, axiogender, azuregender-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does Senator Ward have a point of order?

Comment on this

The God-help-us gender.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thought Senator Ward was raising a point of order.

Comment on this

-----bafflegender, bakeragender, biogender, blizzgender, blurgender, boggender, bordragender, boyflux, brevigender, burstgender, cadensgender, caelgender, cancegender, canisgender, cantogender, caprigender, cartogender,

cassflux, cavusgender, ceasgenger, celestgender, cendgender, centrigender, cervugender, chaosgender, circgender, circumgender, clarigender, cloudegender, clowngender, codegender, cogitogender, coldgender, collgender, comfgender, compgender, composgender, congruogender, constellgender, contigender, contingender, corugender, cosmigender, cosmicgender, cumulogender, cyangender, cyclogender - please forgive me if I pronounce some of these incorrectly; they are quite extensive and if I do offend anybody reading this out and making mistakes, I apologise.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will stop you for one second to give you a breather. I welcome our former colleague and friend, iar-Sheanadóir Niall Ó Brolcháin, to the Gallery. It is good to see you. You are very welcome to Leinster House. Thank you for being here. Céad míle fáilte.

Comment on this

It also includes dahlgender, dampgender, dazegender, deltagender, demigender, demifluid, demiboy, demigirl, demienby, demiflux, demosgender, denatigender, dentrogender, depressogender, deservgender, desigender, devisgender, divigender, diminugender, dreamgender, dulcigender, dustgender, dysporiagender, edafogender, egogender, egender, ecliptgender, effloragender, eldrigender, elegender, elementgender, elixgender, elusigender, embergender, emptgender, engypgender, englobgender, enigender, enthugender, endromogender, eonogender, epicgender, epigender, equilibrigender, evaporgender, evokegender, exgender, expansgender, expecgender, extergender, extragender, fabricagender, facetgender, fadingender, faegender, fawngender, faunagender, fazogender, felisgender, femfluid, femgender, fenesgender, feugender, fictigender, firegender, flamgender, flashgender, fleursgender, flexigender, flickergender, flingender, flowgender, fluidgeterogender, fluidgeterosexual, fluigender, fluxfluid, fluxgender, fluxiongender, foamgender, folgender, fontgender, forgender, fornogender, fragagender, fraggender, frangender, frictgender, frigidgender, frondgender, frostgender, fugigender, fugugender,galactigender, galegender, gallugender, gallopgender, genderflux, genderfluid, genderlight, gendersatyr, gendersea, genderwood, generagender, genicgender, geogender, geologender, gerangender, gigglegender, glaciagender, glistenogender, glitchgender, gloomgender, glossogender, glowgender, gluemgender, gringender, gritgender, guarigender, guasgogender, gullgender, gunigender, gustgender, gynefluid, gynogender, gypsgender, hagigender, haigender, hallgender, halogender, haplogender, hasragender, havogender, healgender, heartgender, hedgegender, heligender, hermetigender, hexagender, hidrogender, himagender, hipogender, hoarigender, hollowgender, hornagender, horsgender, hostgender, hubgender, hurricangender, hydrogengender, hygender, hypegender, hypergender, hypogender, imbergender, immogender, impulsigender, inagender, indagender, indiogender, infinitigender, insigender, intellagender, intergender, intraflux, irascgender, irisgender, isogender, itergender, itinogender, itzigender, januagender, jentagender, jocusgender, jorgender, junggender, junipergender, justgender, kaleidogender, kaleidoflux, kallogender, keplergender, kerfuffleflux, kinetigender, kissgender, koloragender, kolorgender, kryptogender, kurogender, laconicgender, laggender, lamellgender, lampadgender, lamposgender, latigg, latensgender, lavendergender, lentesgender, leogender, lepigender, lissgender, lividgender, locustgender, logigender, longegender, loopgender, loticgender, lownessgender, luggender, lumigender, lunalogender, lunargender, lurgigender, lusterogender, luxgender, macrogender, magogender, magpiegender, magnogender, majestigender, magogender, malugender, maplegender, marengender, marigrugender, marvelogender, mascgender, maskgender, masonagender, matkigender, maxigender, meandgender, mechagender, medigender, medleygender, melanchogender, melegender, melodigender, memigender, mentegender, mercurialgender, messogender, metamorphogender, microgender, midasgender, miegender, migragender, mimogender, moltgender-----

Comment on this

Is the Senator trying to make the point that the number of genders is infinite? In which case, we may be here for a very long time.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you.

Comment on this

I think there is-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is not a point of order, but it is a relevant question at the same time. Thank you for raising the matter.

Comment on this

It is important that we know what the term "gender" means. Does it mean these particular genders? I think it is important to read them into the record of the House.

Comment on this

That is not a very good use of time-----

Comment on this

It may not be, but-----

Comment on this

In the context of-----

Comment on this

-----this is a really important piece of legislation.

Comment on this

I know it is. In the context of the guillotine-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Warfield, thank you. Could we address our remarks through the Chair and keep our remarks relevant to the Bill, the amendment and the issues being raised? I remind Members that in the context of the amendment we are on, the relevance of the amendment is about the definition-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Let us stick to that, please.

Comment on this

With respect to the Senator, it is not a comprehensive list because all of humanity is infinite and varietal. All difference is to be celebrated. To read-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is really not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is a finite list, so it cannot purport to represent the infinite variety of all human beings which, as I said, should be celebrated.

Comment on this

The list includes microgender, midasgender, miegender, migragender, mimogender, moltgender, momentigender, monegencer, mooncangender, morphogender,

mossgender, motigender, mountainogender, movender, multigender, mundagender, mungender, muragender, muscisgender, mutaegender, mythogender, napgender, narritogender, nebulagender, nefasgender, negogender, neligender, nemergender, neptunegender, nervigender, netergender, nexgender, nicogender, nightgender, nimbusgender, nocgender, nomigender, non-binary, non-genegender, non-gegender, novagender, nullgender, numerigender, nuxgender, nyctogender, oasgender, obliquesgender, obnuvigender, oculogender, odorgender, offgender, omegagender, ominogender, omnisgender, omniverigender, onimogender, onirigender, ontogender, oobgender, opacigender, opalusgender, opengender, oppigender, opulengender, opusgender, orbisgender, orchegender, orchigender, oreogender, orgagender, oscilligender, osmagender, overcastgender, ovogender, oxgender, oxtongender, ozgender, pacigender, pagender, paleogender, pampaflux, pampogender, panarcticgender, pandanagender, pangegender, pantasexgender, paragender, parallogender, parasolgender, parchgender, particgender, pastgender, patagender, pegasgender, peligender, perennialgender, perigender, perimmonogender, permagender, perrigender, persecutogender, persephonogender, petrolgender, phantasmgender, phlegmagender, photogender, phototropogender, phtorogender, pianogender, pictgender, pietagender, pigeongender, pinkgender, piogender, piscigender, plasmagender, plathgender, platogender, pleasgender, ploidgender, plutogender, poetrigender, polargender, polarisgender, posifluxgender, positivogender, possgender, potegender, prairiegender, precarigender, precipigender, primgender, prismagender, privagender, probabiligender, prodigender, prodromgender, profectgender, progenigender, proliflux, propagender, prospicgender, protogender, purgogender, pyrogender, quartzgender, quasigender, questgender, quietgender, quindrigender, quinxgender, radgender, radiantgender, rainflux, rainogender, raptorgender, ravengender, raygender, rayongender, readygender, realmgender, recurrigender, reflectogender, regender, regigender, reinigender, relicgender, religender, renitentgender, repentagender, respigender, restitugender, retrogender, revigender, revivagender, rexgender, rhythmgender, rimegender, riptidegender, rishigender, rivenergender, rivergender, roangender, robotgender, rocciagender, rockygender, rogender, romanticgender, rosagender, rosegender, rotundgender, rubygender, runegender, rustgender, rushgender, sablegender, sacralgender, safegender, sagittgender, sagittariusgender, salvogender, sammagender, sandalwoodgender, sandgender, sangagender, sanctigender, sapflux, sapgender, sapphgender, saturagender, scenogender, scentergender, scutgender, seagender, secludogender, sedatagender, selfigender, sensorgender, sentiogender, sepiagender, sequiogender, serenogender, shapgender, shardgender, shattergender, shifgender, shiftfluid, shiftgender, shimmergender, shipgender, shoalrogender, shoegender, shygender, siamgender, sibligender, sickgender, sidegender, sigmagender, silangender, silicogender, silkgender, simulagender, singender, singularity gender, sinistergender, sirengender, sixgender, skategender, skeingender, skygender, skylargender, sleepgender, slidegender, sloggender, slushgender, smarogender, smilegender, smoggender, smokegender, snowgender, softgender, solaragender, solemgender, solidgender, solilogender, solivagender, solugender, somnigender, sonargender, sonicgender, soragender, soupgender, soundgender, speedgender, spheregender, spicgender, spillagender, spiritogender, splashgender, splendorgender, spookgender, spraygender, springgender, spritegender, spritzgender, spurgender, squallgender, squawkgender, squeegender, stadiogender, stagegender, stalactigender, stalagmitgender, starlightgender, stargender, staticgender, stellargender, stelligender, sterngender, stillgender, stormgender, stovagender, stratagender, streamgender, streetgender, strigender, strobeogender, struggender, subflu, subgender, subjugender, subrigender, subterrangender, successogender, sungender, sunrisegender, sunsetgender, supergender, superflux, supinegender, supperogender, surfigender, surprisgender, surreogender, swamgender, sweltergender, switchgender, swordgender, sybylgender, synergigender, synodgender, syrengender, systegender, tabogender, tadpolegender, tailorgender, tantalumgender, tartargender, tasselgender, techfluid, techgender, tempestgender, temporalflux, temporalgender, tenebrogender, tensiongender, tentgender, terggender, terragender, tesseragender, testigender, texturegender, thalassogender, thawgender, themoflux, themogender, thistlegender, thorogender, thoughtgender, threadgender, thrilligender, thrumgender, thunderogender, tidalgender, tidegender, tierogender, tigender, tigerogender, tiltgender, timegender, tornadogender, touchgender, towergender, tracegender, trafectgender, transgender, transgenderqueer, transientgender, transitgender, trianglegender, tricousgender, tridensgender, triformgender, trilixgender, troughgender, troubadorgender, trowgender, trumpetgender, truxgender, tsunamigender, turbogender, turntablegender, tutelgender, twingender, twirlgender,

twittergender, twilightgender, twinkleflux, twinklegender, typgender, typogender, tyrogender, ultragender, umbragender, umbramalgender, unabigender, unarrowgender, unbinary, unblurrgender, unclogender, underflux, underogender, unfogender, uniformgender, unigonogender, uniquefluid, uniquender, unknogender, unogender, unsegender, unsungender, unumgender, updraftgender, upliftgender, upperogender, uranogender, urgogender, urnanogender, urnogender, ursaegender, usherogender, utapendragender, utensigender, utopiangender, vacatgender, vaggender, vagabondgender, vaguegender, valencygender, valleygender, valorgender, vangender, variegender, veilgender, velocitygender, veldgender, vellumgender, velvetgender, vendergender, vengeogender, venusgender, verbflu, verbgender, versatogender, vespgender, vibragender, victorygender, viergegender, viletendergender, villagender, vinegender, violaflux, violagender, virtuegender, visiongender, vitagender, vitalgender, voidgender, volatogender, voltigender, voyagegender, vulcangender, wailgender, wargender, watergender, wavegender, waxgender, weathergender, webgender, wedgender, welcomegender, whispergender, whistgender, wightgender, willowgender, windgender, windowgender, windyflux, wintegender, wintergender, withergender, wobblegender, woodgender, woolgender, workgender, wovengender, wrathgender, wrenogender, wringergender, xagender, xemeogender, xenogender, xerographgender, xestergender, xilogender, xylogender, yarnogender, yawnogender, yearninggender, yellowgender, yeldgender, yoigender, younggender, youthgender, ytterbigender, zephyrogender, zeroesgender, zigzaggender, zodigender, zoegender, zonogender, zoomgender, zygender, and zyrenogender. It is worth noting that if the Minister were to accept our amendments today, she might avoid the possibility of a constitutional referendum down the road.

Amendment No. 10 proposes a specific definition of "hate" to be inserted into the Bill, framing it as a malicious attempt to victimise an individual or group based on their protected characteristics. This victimisation must be likely to entice another person to commit an act of discrimination or violence. The current draft of the Bill lacks such a definition, which creates significant concerns regarding legal certainty and clarity in its enforcement. As noted in the Minister, Deputy McEntee’s statement, it is implied we all know what hate is. Without a concrete and legal definition of hate in this Bill, however, there is a risk that both law enforcement and the courts will struggle to apply the legislation consistently. This could lead to uncertainty and arbitrary enforcement where accusations of hate are made based on subjective interpretations or social context rather than clearly defined legal standards. The proposed definition ensures a threshold is established for what constitutes hate by specifying that hate must involve malicious intent to target individuals or groups based on their protected characteristics. This definition sets standards of what type of behaviour or speech qualifies as hate and requires a clear connection between the hateful act and its capacity to entice discrimination or violence. This would ensure only actions or expressions with real-world harmful consequences would be subject to legal consequences, protecting free expression while addressing genuine harm.

Globally, incitement laws must balance freedom of speech with the need to prevent violence and discrimination. Several international legal frameworks and instruments have addressed the threshold for incitement. The European Court of Human Rights has emphasised that speech restrictions must be narrowly defined and only enforced where there is a clear intention to incite violence or hatred that leads to discrimination. In cases where speech merely offends or shocks, it is protected under free expression rights.

The United Nations Rabat Plan of Action outlines a high threshold for what constitutes incitement, requiring that the speech in question be directed at the audience, have intent to incite and be likely to lead to imminent harm, such as discrimination or violence. This approach seeks to distinguish between lawful speech, even if provocative, and unlawful incitement. By providing a definition of hate, this amendment aligns with these international principles, ensuring the law only targets behaviour or speech that is genuinely harmful.

Without a specific definition, there is a risk of wrongful convictions under this Bill. Speech that is critical, controversial or uncomfortable could be wrongly perceived as hateful, even when it does not meet the criteria of inciting discrimination or violence. A vague or overly broad understanding of hate could lead to individuals being wrongly prosecuted for expressing views that, while unpopular, do not constitute hate speech under international norms. The proposed amendment protects against this by limiting hate to malicious acts aimed at incitement, meaning opinions, discussions, or debates that do not meet this threshold do not fall under its purview.

In societies with robust free speech protections, such as Canada or Germany, courts have consistently ruled that incitement laws must differentiate between offensive or harmful speech and speech that directly leads to acts of violence or discrimination. This ensures minority views, satire or unpopular opinions are not stifled.

The proposed amendment provides much clarity to the Bill by defining hate as a malicious act aimed at inciting others to discriminate or inciting violence based on a person’s protected characteristic. This definition establishes a clear threshold for legal action, aligning with international standards and ensuring the Bill targets genuine harm while safeguarding free expression. The lack of a definition in the current Bill leaves the door open to misinterpretation and inconsistent application, which could lead to wrongful convictions and chilled public discourse. The amendment strengthens the Bill by providing legal certainty and ensuring incitement is clearly defined.

I come to amendment No. 11. I am nearly finished, Members will be delighted to know.

Comment on this

The Senator can take her time.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 11, there is no standard definition of incitement. The fact that hate, incitement and incitement to violence or hatred is ambiguous is a major problem with this Bill. This definition should be robust enough to ensure no one is unfairly convicted. The emphasis on irrational creates a great burden of proof. This amendment introduces a clear and standardised definition of "incitement" to be included in the Bill, which is currently lacking. The proposed definition frames incitement as behaviour or communications about a person or group that creates a serious risk of discrimination, hostility or violence towards them based on their protected characteristics.

By doing so, it aims to establish a robust legal threshold that ensures individuals are not unfairly convicted for incitement while addressing harmful behaviours that genuinely threaten the well-being of others.

One of the major shortcomings of the Bill is the absence of clear definitions of "hate", "incitement" and "incitement to violence or hatred". This creates significant challenges when it comes to the interpretation and enforcement of the law. Without clear guidance law enforcement and the Judiciary are left to interpret these terms, potentially leading to inconsistent applications and an increased risk of wrongful convictions. The absence of a definition of "incitement" leaves a grey area regarding what kinds of speech or behaviour are legally punishable. This could potentially criminalise legitimate speech, including criticism, debate and dissent, which should be protected under free expression.

Ambiguous legal terms also make it difficult for individuals to know what constitutes lawful or unlawful conduct, which can chill free speech by creating fear of persecution or expressing opinions. The proposed definition is designed to be specific and robust, focusing on behaviour or communications that create a serious risk or harmful outcome such as discrimination, hostility or violence. This sets a high threshold that ensures only genuine harmful acts which are likely to lead to real-world consequences will be criminalised. By introducing the concept of a serious risk the amendment prevents overreach and ensures the incitement laws do not criminalise speech that is merely offensive or provocative. Instead they will target individuals that pose a genuine danger to individuals or groups. The definition covers direct and indirect actions, including communications about a person or a group and thereby ensuring the harmful stereotyping misinformation or dangerous rhetoric that leads to real harm is addressed.

International standards offer guidance on the meaning of incitement and the thresholds that should be applied. The European Court of Human Rights has consistently ruled that incitement must be clearly linked to a likelihood of imminent violence or serious harm. In cases like Erbakan v. Turkey, the European Court of Human Rights emphasised that offensive speech alone does not constitute incitement unless it directly leads to violence or discrimination. The UN’s Rabat plan of action sets a high threshold for incitement, requiring the speech or behaviour in question be directed at a specific audience, having intent and be likely to lead to imminent harm. This approach is designed to safeguard free speech while addressing dangerous conduct. Countries like Germany and Canada have also introduced similar thresholds in their hate speech and incitement laws to ensure only speech that leads to tangible harms is penalised. For example, Germany’s criminal code includes provisions that punish incitement to hatred, but only when it is aimed at disrupting public peace or inciting violence. By adopting a definition aligned with these international standards, the amendment ensures that Ireland’s legislation remains in line with global human rights norms, especially in balancing the protection of individuals from hate speech and violence with the preservation of free speech.

The emphasis on irrational emotion, opprobrium, enmity, and detestation found elsewhere in the Bill creates a high burden of proof and could lead to difficulties in prosecution. While it is important to distinguish between rational criticism and irrational hatred, the absence of a clear threshold for incitement increases the likelihood individuals could be convicted for expressing views that do not actually incite violence or hatred. The proposed definition seeks to protect individuals from unfair conviction by ensuring only actions or communications that create a serious risk or harm would qualify as it as incitement. This introduces greater legal certainty and prevents over-criminalisation. By focusing on actions that lead to a serious risk of discrimination, hostility or violence, the definition ensures laws do not disproportionately target minority voices, satire or political dissent. These forms of expression often provoke strong reactions but do not necessarily incite harm. Inclusion of a standard definition of "incitement" is crucial for the Bill’s clarity and enforceability. The proposed definition establishes a clear threshold for what constitutes incitement to ensure only behaviour or communication that creates a serious risk of discrimination, hostility or violence based on a person’s protected characteristics are criminalised. This amendment aligns with international legal standards and protects against unjust prosecutions while addressing genuine harm, offering a more balanced approach to incitement laws.

I will come in on my other amendments later.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Seanadór. She might facilitate the parliamentary reporter with the list of names she read out. To be fair, they would need the Senator's assistance, because I am sure some of the words and phrases were-----

Comment on this

They would be new to most people.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It was not that they were new to most people-----

Comment on this

They were new to me.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

-----it is that they were badly mangled. I am aware that it is Committee Stage. I have been here since 6 p.m., and Senator Keogan, as is her right, has spoken for 45 minutes or more. We are due to conclude at 8.30 p.m. and five Members have indicated that they wish to speak. I am asking people to be conscious of that. I appreciate that there are different views on the handling of the Bill. I call Senator McDowell.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister. When it became apparent to the Members of this House precisely what the Minister was intending to do with her amendments, the scene in relation to this Bill changed rather dramatically. We now know the hate offences section is now not proposed by the Minister to become law at this stage. We also know the provisions in the Bill to introduce the framework decision of 2008 is not being preceded with, provided the Minister’s amendments are accepted.

I have a couple of things to say about procedure. This Bill, in its present form, with all of those things in it which are now apparently not to be preceded with, got through Dáil Éireann and has come to this House for further consideration. Between Second Stage and the guillotined Third, Fourth and Fifth Stages we are dealing with today, there has been a major public debate because this House exists. If this House did not exist, the Bill would have become law without any amendment whatsoever.

Comment on this

When people criticise Seanad Éireann, they should reflect on the fact this House is a revising Chamber. It is a Chamber where we are tolerant and not abusive towards each other, not hostile to each other and where reflective debate and serious consideration of legislation takes place. It has on this occasion had very significant effects.

The second thing I wanted to say is the fact this Bill is being guillotined this evening means there will not be a Report Stage because the way things are panning out now, it means that the Members of this House had to table amendments without seeing the Government’s amendments, with a common deadline for both. Some of the amendments, therefore, may seem redundant in the light of what the Government is proposing to now. On that procedure itself, we normally allow amendments to amendments and we allow on Report Stage reaction arising out of the debate which occurred on Committee Stage. All that has been swept aside by the Minister’s action in seeking to have this debate abridged and to have Third, Fourth and Fifth Stages disposed of by 8:30 p.m.

That is the effect of the guillotine. Every Member of this House who wanted to put in amendments had to do so on the blind, not knowing precisely what the Government was suggesting. They find themselves in a situation where they are not even in a position to amend the Government's amendments or to reflect on what the Government is saying and be able to make proposals for consequential amendments to the Bill. All of that is swept aside. The Minister is obviously very anxious to get this done before the general election. I accept that. The Minister has also come in here and said that violence against people by virtue of their protected characteristics is terrible and the consequences for individuals who fear it or who suffer it and for their families is life-changing for the psychology and well-being of many people. I accept all of that, so I am not saying there is nothing urgent about the issue of hatred in Ireland.

The public order legislation currently in place is not sufficient in some respects. For example, people can upload onto the Internet material which is grossly inflammatory. Under the present public order legislation, this does not constitute an offence because a kind of pre-Internet conceptual framework exists at the moment. There will have to be amendment to ensure that people do not use the Internet to achieve what they could not do if they took a loudhailer outside this building and spewed out incitement and violence-inducing rhetoric. If it is wrong to do it on a street, it must be wrong to do it from the privacy of a keyboard. What I find fascinating about Internet hatred is that it is done by cowards who hide behind anonymity to spew out their falsehoods and threats.

What we are now left with is legislation which effectively is increasing the penalties for existing offences, which are punishable by law. We do not have a proper explanatory memorandum of the Minister's amendments and we do not have a comprehensive speech explaining the entirety of the amendments and the individual consequences. As far as I have been able to detect, what is happening here is that for many offences, an extra two years is being added to indictable offences. This means increasing penalties from five years to seven years, and from ten years to 12 years and the like. That is what the Bill is now doing, in cases where the motivation for the offence is found to be hatred of persons by reason of their protected characteristics. We could have achieved this much more easily if we had just said that in sentencing, if it appears to a court that hatred is established, the court should have regard to that.

From my own experience, we now have a criminal justice system that is under serious stress. Increasing maximum sentences at this stage is probably not going to bring about increased sentences for people who engage in hate crime because the Judiciary is bending over backwards to keep the prison system from clogging up completely with people serving sentences. In yesterday's newspapers, one could see the extent to which the criminal justice system is creaking at the moment simply by virtue of overcrowding of our prisons and longer prison sentences being imposed. I do not really think that thugs who use violence against other people are going to be affected by the knowledge that, if convicted, they would serve a maximum of two years more than the current sentence. Everybody is against hatred and everybody wants to be seen to be against it, but in large measure let us be truthful with ourselves. Increasing the maximum sentences for a series of offences is unlikely to have any significant deterrent effect. People who are going to beat someone up because they are black or gay or whatever are not going to think that they should be more careful because the five-year sentence for landing a person with a black eye - actual bodily harm - is now increasing to seven years. I do not think it will have significant behavioural effects. However, that is what we are doing now and I accept that the Minister's proposed set of amendments is intended to achieve that.

In that context, I notice a number of criminal enactments which are set out in the sections that are to remain in the Bill. The Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997, which is the major non-homicidal violence statute, is now to be amended by the insertion of definitions referring to what will be the remains of this Bill. I note that "hatred" will have the meaning given in the 2023 Act and "protected characteristics" will have the meaning it has in section 2 of this Act. This is a point I want to address seriously. We are saying that "protected characteristics" has a meaning in all of those statutes for the purpose of determining what hatred is, by reference to the definitions set out in section 3, as they are proposed to be. I am very clear that violence and the threat of it, harassment and the destruction of property belonging to any person, by reason of their sex or sexual orientation, or the way in which they express themselves sexually, or portray themselves to society, is fundamentally wrong. I have no difficulty with that proposition. In that context, I have no difficulty with the notion of protecting people who are transgender. However, in the context of legislating for what "gender" is and what "transgender" is, I want clarity. This Bill does not offer a clear definition of "gender" and it does not offer a clear definition of what is meant by the term "transgender". I think I know what is involved. I think we are talking about people who psychologically prefer to be seen as neither male nor female but as having a different identity - if I may use that kind of phraseology about it - or people who are genuinely suffering from the medical condition of dysphoria, or people who live the life of a gender which they did not have at birth, or people who alternate between different views of themselves and follow different behaviour patterns.

That is what I presume is meant by transgender, and I have no problem with protecting them from hatred. I note that Senator Mullen's amendment would do the same. He extends protection to them in his amendment. The point I am making, however, is that the definition of "gender" that has been offered, which I oppose, is "the gender of a person or the gender which a person expresses as the person's preferred gender or with which the person identifies and includes transgender and a gender other than those of male and female". The Minister has been at pains to say this definition applies only in this Bill, but it does not because we are already extending it by the criminal justice amendments in the other sections. We are extending that definition to the broad range of criminal justice statutes which are affected by it. Therefore, it is not just for this Bill; we are, in a number of statutes, stating that there are genders other than those of male and female and which do not amount to transgender. That is what we are saying now with this definition. I want to know - and I have never had an explanation from anybody - what thing other than transgender is a gender other than those of male and female. What are we actually saying? What are we actually legislating for? Why are we amending the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act by changing the protected characteristics, etc., in that legislation in this way?

I do not accept the proposition, in all good faith. I have personal experience of people with dysphoria and people who have gone through gender-transforming surgery - decent, kind people - and I have the utmost sympathy for them in the sense that they feel vulnerable and the utmost sense of supporting them if that is the way they choose to live their lives. I have no problem whatsoever with and am deeply empathic towards them and supportive of them, and I think they should be protected. Let us not in any sense distort what we think other people are saying by seeking to amend this definition.

It is notable that the former Leader of this House, when she was Leader, went to the Scottish Parliament on 22 June 2022 to give evidence before one of its committees on this very issue of gender. She is now an MEP, and I do not want to attack her behind her back in any possible way. She chose to give those in attendance the background to the Irish gender recognition legislation and the plans of the Government, of which she was a significant member as Leader of this House at the time, in respect of gender and developing Irish law on gender in order that the Scottish Parliament could consider what we were doing here and what she was proposing we could do here. She shared her wisdom with them on this subject. She said, and this is in column 8 of the report of the debate:

Generations ago, there were two genders and two sexes. There still are two sexes, but today we probably have around nine genders, and that does not diminish any other gender in the gender identity set. That is a conversation that we need to have with people, particularly with women. That does not make them more or less at risk, but saying that a trans female cannot access the same spaces as other women certainly does not protect them. If we believe that men were going to go to the extent of dressing up as women and changing their gender to get access to and be violent towards women, we have a far greater problem than the male violence that we have in our cultures and jurisdictions.

That passage stands out as a statement by a serving member of the Government apparatus who was appointed by the then Taoiseach to be the leader of the Government parties in this House as to what she considered to be involved with the term "gender". She said solemnly - this was not an after-dinner speech but evidence to a Scottish committee - that there were nine genders and probably more. I can take the proposition, as I said earlier, that we should protect people by reference to two genders or transgender people who do not identify, whether permanently or impermanently, with either gender, male or female. I can fully see that there is a case for protecting them from hate, but we are being asked to say there are genders other than male and female and transgender. We are being asked to put a proposition that there are genders of that kind, a multiplicity of genders, into criminal statutes, not simply in this Bill for its purpose but into our general criminal laws. The Department of Justice has not explained - and cannot, apparently, explain - what is meant by the definition it is offering. The best it can do is to say that it wants this legislation to be open to development in this area.

I should also tell the House that Ms Doherty spoke at great length about prisoners and their gender and said:

We had a debate a number of months ago about a number of prisoners in Limerick prison, in the south-west of our country, who are in a female prison and who identified as female after they had been arrested and charged. The law is that they can change their gender if that is what they want to do, but any prison warden or officer who is running an institution or a congregated setting has to mitigate all risks, and if a patron of a prisoner facility is a threat or a risk, mitigating circumstances have to be put in place to protect all the other prisoners ...

That happened in Ireland. I will not mention the name of the individual involved - or there were two, I think - but it also happened in Scotland. When it happened in Scotland, it spelled disaster for the Scottish National Party, and the gender legislation then provoked a crisis between Edinburgh and Westminster as regards the approval, the giving of royal assent, to that legislation.

There is another layer to this whole debate. I do not want to distract us too much, but there is a movement in Ireland, and groups like TENI are part of it, which seeks to educate children that there are a multiplicity of genders.

That is a fact. I am not inventing that.

Comment on this

We now have syllabus texts and teacher training that goes down that road. I have a strong view that the Constitution provides for parents not merely the right but the duty to determine the moral formation and the social formation of their children. It is written into our Constitution that parents have that primary function. Activist people who want to project a different view have decided to change the very vocabulary of our common speech by using their concepts to educate children in textbooks and the like. I believe that all of these things are related.

When former Senator Regina Doherty was in Edinburgh she talked about how we were amending legislation to talk about pregnant people rather than pregnant women. She spoke enthusiastically about that and told the Scottish Parliament that Ireland was an example of progressive thought in these matters. It may be right or it may be wrong. One could be conservative or one can be "progressive" but when it comes to this legislation I had to put in an amendment not knowing whether the Minister was going to put in an amendment to her definition of gender. I had intended to propose taking out the definition of gender and the reference to gender and to put it back in on Report Stage when the Minister had come to this House and explained precisely what is meant by genders other than transgender, male and female, and when the Minister had an opportunity to say here are five examples. One does not have to go to Senator Keogan's list - I lost count and I lost the will to live as well.

Comment on this
Mary Seery Kearney Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Didn't we all?

Comment on this

I lost count but one does not have to go to those lengths to simply ask if the former Senator, Regina Doherty, is right that there are nine definitions, for starters, and would somebody kindly enumerate them for us so that we can see what we are actually putting into criminal statutes such as: the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act; the Criminal Damage Act; the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1991; the various other statutes that will be amended including the Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Act; by inference the Bail Act; the Criminal Justice (Safety of United Nations Workers) Act; the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 2003; and the schedule of the Criminal Justice (Terrorist Offences) Act 2005, among others. If we are going to say that for the purpose of those statutes "hatred" means hatred on the basis of protected characteristics, and if we are going to say that protected characteristics for the purpose of those Acts now involves importing into those statutes by indirect reference the notion that there are, as a matter of Irish law, genders other than male, female and transgender, and that there are other things out there we are now saying are part of the official law of Ireland, part of our criminal law and recognised by law, then what are we talking about?

Does the Minister, Deputy McEntee, agree with the former Senator, MEP Regina Doherty who, on behalf of the Minister's party, went to Edinburgh and said there are nine genders and possibly more? The Minister owes this House an explanation as to what is in fact meant by genders other than those of male and female that are not transgender. What is the Minister actually saying? I could not understand most of Senator Keogan's list but I do not know what most of those labels apparently referred to. I do not even have an idea what the former Senator's nine genders are. I have no idea and I do not see why we in this House should be asked to bring into Irish law the concept that there are unspecified genders, maybe nine in number, which are different from transgender, different from male and different from female but nobody will tell us what they are. That to me is bad legislation. We should at least know what we are actually doing when we amend our criminal law in this way.

We are asking criminal judges to look at that definition as well. This goes back to a little thing that happened in the two referenda that the Minister may remember. Are we saying that judges will decide what it means? Are we just putting it up there and they will decide, in their independence and their wisdom, what a gender that is not transgender, male or female actually can be and is? Is it anything that somebody claims about himself or herself, or themselves to use the new phraseology? I just want to know and I believe we deserve a bit of honesty on this. It is all very well for the Minister to come in here - and I fully support her - to say the victims of hate who are assaulted, harassed, and had their property, families, privacy and their whole lives wrecked are entitled to protection. I agree with that but I also say that if the Minister wants me to change the criminal law of Ireland and introduce a concept of hate based by inference on the existence of genders other than male, female and transgender then the Minister must please tell me what she is talking about. That is not a huge demand to make. It is not a huge demand to make and it is not reactionary to ask what it is she is talking about. Be frank with us. Will the Minister give us three, four or five things that the she says are genders that she believes will be protected in the future by reference to this legislation, but maybe not the full nine as referred to by the former Senator, Regina Doherty, in Edinburgh?

It is not reactionary and it is not divisive to ask that the Minister would please just say what she is talking about and explain her own legislation. I ask the Minister to justify the proposition whereby the definition of gender in the Bill "means the gender of a person or the gender which a person expresses as the person’s preferred gender or with which the person identifies and includes transgender...", which I understand and if it stopped there it would be fine but it goes on to say "... and a gender other than those of male and female,", in addition to transgender. No explanation has been given to this House as to what the Minister means. When the present Taoiseach was holding the Minister's position temporarily I did inquire what was meant by this. I got no satisfactory reply. If the Minister is going to rush this Bill into law and deem it to have been passed by this House, even though we will not have had an opportunity to consider any reply the Minister makes to my speech now, or put amendments down to deal with it because there will be no Report Stage, we are entitled to a straight and honest answer now.

The question I am putting to the Minister is whether there are genders other than male, female and transgender to which this Bill is going to apply. What are they? How many of them are there? Will the Minister name any of the genders we are being asked to say exist as a matter of Irish law in this Bill? When this Bill becomes law, it will affect a variety of different criminal law statutes, including the Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Act.

I do not know how temporary the decision to drop the Council framework decision aspect of this legislation is but the House should know what is involved in it. It is said that it does not prevent a member state from adopting provisions in national law that extend Articles 1(1)(c) and 1(1)(d), which deal with genocide and the results of the Nuremburg trials, to crimes directed against a group of persons defined by criteria other than race, colour, religion, descent or national or ethnic origin such as social status or political convictions. It is said that the objective of the framework decision is to ensure that racist and xenophobic offences are sanctioned in all member states by at least a minimum level of effective, proportionate and dissuasive criminal penalties and that, for the purpose of judicial co-operation between member states, there should be a common understanding of these terms. We should be conscious of what we are doing here. People will be the subject of justice and home affairs, JHA, European arrest warrants in respect of the offences it is proposed to standardise. Irish citizens will face trial in other jurisdictions based on those jurisdictions' interpretation of what the term "hate" actually amounts to. We have to be very clear that this is what is intended by this legislation. All that was asked for was that each member state would:

take the measures necessary to ensure that the following intentional conduct is punishable:

(a) publicly inciting to violence or hatred directed against a group of persons or a member of such a group defined by reference to race, colour, religion, descent or national or ethnic origin;

(b) the commission of an act referred to in point (a) by public dissemination or distribution of tracts, pictures or other material;

I reiterate my point about the Internet. We have to do something about that. Article 3 of this framework decision says that:

1. Each Member State shall take the necessary measures to ensure that the conduct referred to in Articles 1 and 2 is punishable by effective, proportionate and dissuasive criminal penalties.

2. Each Member State shall take the necessary measures to ensure that the conduct referred to in Article 1 is punishable by criminal penalties of a maximum of at least between 1 and 3 years of imprisonment.

That is very easily achieved. Apart from a common assault or something like that, there is practically nothing that is not punishable in such a way under Irish law. Article 4 provides that:

For offences other than those referred to in Articles 1 and 2, Member States shall take the necessary measures to ensure that racist and xenophobic motivation is considered an aggravating circumstance, or, alternatively that such motivation may be taken into consideration by the courts in the determination of the penalties.

Let us be truthful; of course, this can be taken into consideration. That is already the law in Ireland. Does anybody seriously think that, when imposing a sentence, an Irish judge cannot take into account that there was racism or xenophobia involved? Do we want to approximate laws across Europe for the purpose of having a common understanding of what hatred is without providing any definition in our own law as to what it amounts to?

The Minister has referred to the advice of two successive Attorneys General. She may not have done herself justice on the last occasion she was here. She said that they had advised her that it would make it more difficult to secure convictions if what is meant by "hatred" and so on was defined in the legislation, which it certainly would. Allowing that their advice to the Minister was somewhat more sophisticated than what was suggested, it seems that the whole purpose of this legislation in its new truncated form is a mere illusion. Nearly every serious offence I can think of that involves damage to people, threats to kill people and all of the other things that are to be considered new offences where hate is a motivation are already punishable by very severe sentences. Nobody has complained that they are not. We are mirroring many offences such as making death threats with offences such as making death threats where hate is an element and we are providing that people can be prosecuted under the new offence with a heavier sentence. At the end of the day, if the jury finds that it has doubt about the hate element, people can nonetheless be convicted of the original offence. Is a judge to say that, because the jury had doubts about the hate element even though that judge is clear in his or her mind that an offence was xenophobic or racist, he or she is not allowed to take that into account when imposing a sentence? These are the kinds of issues that are going to arise. We are tinkering with our criminal law for visual effect.

The serious thing the Minister or her successor must do is to address the need to look at the Internet and its potential to disseminate hatred and to build up threats against people based on protected characteristics. That is the big priority and we are not doing it with this Bill as it is proposed to be amended. We are not going to get an opportunity at the end of this Committee Stage debate to have Report Stage amendments through which we could try to embody the fruit of Committee Stage because a decision has been made that all of this must be guillotined through tonight. Why could it not have been given another week? Is the election so imminent that the Bill has to be rushed through this House so that it can get to the Dáil, in whatever amended state it is in, to be rushed through there so as to create the impression that the Government did not completely back down in the face of legitimate criticism of the Bill as originally intended?

I will reiterate that the procedure whereby the Members of this House were asked to submit amendments on the blind and whereby we are not in a position to amend the Minister's amendment in any shape or form is a shameful procedure to deploy. It was not necessary. Even if the Minister said that she wanted to do this before she goes to the people in November or whenever it is, she could at least have allowed this House to have two bites of the cherry, to see what she was actually proposing and to see whether we wanted to amend what she was intent on doing by way of amendment.

The revising function of this House is being short-circuited, deliberately I am afraid, for purposes that are unnecessary, which lack the degree of urgency that they must be done in the next few days. We could have had a better debate and a better Bill if the guillotine had not been imposed.

Comment on this

The Minister's articulation of her concern for the experience of trans people in our city and country is commendable. I share those concerns. I wish her Government partners and colleague also shared those concerns, given that transgender healthcare in Ireland is the worst in Europe. I will speak to amendments Nos. 6 and 14.

Amendment No. 6 is Sinn Féin's proposal on a definition of "hate" which is based in part on the work of the Irish Council for Civil Liberties when it first made a submission. It is also based on work done by the party with others. It proposes that "hate" would include bias, prejudice, contempt, hostility and bigotry. It proposes that "hatred" would be defined as, "a state of mind characterised as intense and irrational emotions of enmity or detestation against a person or a group of persons in the State or elsewhere on account of their membership or presumed membership of a group defined by reference to protected characteristics". The amendment provides separate definitions for "hate" and "hatred", whereas the current definition of "hate" defines it as hatred. The Minister made a case against it but I feel that is circular. Sinn Féin and I do not think that is acceptable. We submitted this amendment previously and one of the subjects of debate today and one of the main concerns throughout this Bill's progress in both Houses has been the lack of definition of "hate" and "hatred". The Government's amendment still provides that hate is hatred even though there are multiple well-researched and internationally accepted definitions. Accordingly, I will be pressing that amendment. I do not think it is beyond the ability of the Attorney General to give us a definition, and that is our proposal.

I turn to amendment No. 14, in which we propose a definition of "protected characteristic". I think it is part of this grouping. We propose that the definition of "protected characteristic" be in accordance with the Equal Status Act. We feel this would give the Bill legal and definitional certainty while being inclusive enough to cover all cases. Various amendments are trying to delete references to religion, for example, and the original Government one expanded the definition of gender. We do not want the Bill to be at risk of legal challenge and legal uncertainty, which would be unacceptable given how long people have been waiting for these protections.

I note with regard to the Equal Status Act that in 2021 the Department of children initiated a review of the various equality Acts. All that has thus far been published in this term, unfortunately, is a summary of the submissions. That is an extraordinary omission by the Government. It is not the only omission. We have seen delay and stalling on conversion therapy. We have seen delay and stalling with the disregard of convictions. These are difficult issues in the current climate but responsibilities should not be shied away from.

We believe plain language should be used to ensure public support for the legislation, but also to give legal certainty and prevent legal challenges. Too many people have waited too long for these protections for the Government to risk those protections. Our amendment is not perfect, particularly in light of the failure to review the equality Acts, but there is an abundance of case law. It speaks to the need for definitional certainty across legislation. In Sinn Féin's view, the current definition does not help to do that.

I will make another point as I may not be able to come back in before the end. There are some persons, perhaps a minority of people in targeted communities, who are re-evaluating the response of increased imprisonment and considering potential alternatives. I make a personal point that we need to see more social, economic and educational initiatives to prevent hate crimes happening in the first place. There should be targeted support and funding for communities affected by hate crimes to address the community harms that exist. We should also be thinking about how we can support victims through compensation, professional support, free mental health support and greater use of restorative justice. I am in favour of a scenario where a select number of hate crime cases can be diverted away from traditional prosecution and sentencing and towards restorative justice programmes instead. Those actions would help to support communities, help to break down cultural and social barriers between offenders and victims, prevent hate crimes happening in the first place and reduce the likelihood of a person re-offending.

Comment on this

I pick up where Senator Warfield finished, which was on education. Concerns have been expressed in the House about education. One of the key tools is education that reflects the experiences of minorities in the State and the fact that there is gender, sexuality and ethnic diversity, as well as all the other categories discussed in terms of protected characteristics. That understanding and acceptance from an early day and it not being treated as something frightening is a matter of reality about the people who are here. This is not an ideological piece. It is about who is here, who is part of our society and the fact there is diversity in our society. Early education that continues throughout life in public education is one of the key ways we challenge these issues.

Within this group there are some useful suggestions. There is a general valid point that it would be better if there were greater clarity on some of the definitions. Some of the concerns expressed have been overstated, however, to the point that there is almost a suggestion that we should not include these matters as they are. There are some constructive points. One of the key differences in the definition put forward by Senator Warfield and others is that it does not just talk about hatred in the context of emotion or enmity. Crucially, it speaks to how it is addressed towards persons as part of their membership or presumed membership of a group defined by related or protected characteristics.

While there have been strong inputs in this House regarding the appalling treatment of whistleblowers, the hostility with which those who have taken a stand on an issue of principle or difference of opinion have been treated, and suggestions regarding other categories of persons, the key thing in relation to all of these views is that it is not hatred based on your membership or presumed membership of a group of people. It is not hatred addressed towards you simply because of who you are or who you are presumed to be. It is not appropriate to create an equivalence between extraordinarily poor behaviour and abuse, which has been named as abuse and so forth, towards individuals in a situation related to their actions and the kinds of hatred we are talking about here, where actions are directed towards a person simply because of their existence and who they are.

We heard a long list of purported genders earlier. The one word that came to me was not "gender" but "disingenuous", because I believe it is disingenuous to suggest that this will somehow be so wide and confusing, we should almost stay away from it. That is one of the ways in which you silence people, by saying, "Let's make this issue too difficult to touch; let's take it off the table." Let us be clear about the reality. The known fact now is that those who would benefit from protection and indeed who need protection by the State from the hatred and violence they experience regarding gender are predominantly transgender people. Women and men can also experience discrimination but transgender people experience extraordinary abuse, real levels of violence and extraordinary levels of silencing in this State. I think skelligogender was suggested, which I presume is a very small number of persons given that is an uninhabited island, but to be frank, the idea or suggestion is that the danger we might accidentally protect somebody else would somehow warn us off proceeding with legislation that protects a known vulnerable minority of transgender people who experience some of the worst abuse and worst violence that is addressed towards anybody and who have experienced that, not since 2015 but who have seen that intensified in recent years, largely emboldened by the fact there are so many new figures in public life who are willing to create fear around the existence of transgender people and what that might mean. We need to be very clear and honest. There was a call for clarity. Let us also be clear and honest about who actually needs protection and should be protected under this.

I know we are coming towards the end of the debate. Some of my own amendments are unlikely to be discussed. I regret the guillotining of the legislation, as others have said. As has been noted and outlined, the fact is Ireland needs to comply with Council Framework Decision 2008/913/JHA. I have been asking the Minister for a report on it. In the absence of that, if we are removing those sections from the Bill - had they remained, I, along with others, would probably have been looking to amend further and adjust them as I think they could have been better drafted, and I will come to some of the areas that need to be considered in any new attempt - will the Minister in her reply to the debate say what the plans are regarding the framework directive, because we need to see a clear arrow and signal of them? What comes next? As we know, infringement proceedings are being talked about. I suggest we need to know what the plan is to address what was said in terms of expressions of racism and xenophobia and how they should be appropriately tackled.

I would suggest a couple of areas in which there should be learning from the debate on all sides regarding areas that need to be addressed when we come to address these issues. The principles of equality, fairness, proportionality and justice are important. Proportionality was, of course, one of the key tests that IHREC signalled needs to be applied. Power dynamics is one of the key pieces missing from the legislation, since it does not really address power imbalances. I will look at this in two separate ways that need to be addressed. One has been touched on by other speakers but another has been neglected. Crucially, we need to look at the power imbalances in terms of the context, such as situations of employment where somebody is in a position of authority over you or where someone has financial resources, for example, if you are a major tech multibillionaire and are more in a position than others to take action and have impact. Those factors of power imbalances need to be addressed, both in the circumstances whereby you look to someone who is in a vulnerable position in a specific context and how their words are taken, and to the situation where it is particularly difficult for somebody who is receiving abuse or hatred from somebody who is in a position of authority over them to take action on it. There are a couple of ways in which that needs to be considered. Those are the specific circumstances. Some of that contextual piece has been talked about.

There is also the piece, which has been missing from some of the contributions of other Senators, which is the other part of context. We have heard a lot about the context and how it might be taken. Another part of the context is the historical power imbalances, the fact we have a deeply unequal society, and the fact there are those categories of persons, exactly those who were attempted to be listed here, who have experienced higher levels of abuse and violence historically, who have had less power regarding some of the situations they are facing, and who need the State to signal to society that it is not acceptable that there are groups of people in society who can be punched and kicked down at, treated as lesser, marginalised and be subject to the kinds of pressure to silence them and keep them in the margins that we see. That is why it is important, when we talk about it being named in court cases, that it is not simply about the individual. It is important to society to have racism, xenophobia and hatred recognised as aggravating factors because it sends a signal to society by saying you are damaging our society by making it a less equal, less inclusive place, and one in which all are not being treated equally and there are whole categories of persons living in fear and being placed into fear.

It is important when there is incitement to hatred that it is recognised. I disagree with the other contributors who say it is a minor issue in the sentencing. The signal that it sends is actually very important. The power imbalance historically needs to be addressed. That is part of the context too. That is why there is a need for legislation that at least attempts to address this, even though I would be clear that I do not believe this legislation, as is, is perfect. One of the issues regarding power is, for example, the imbalance of economic power, the fact that those with significant corporate power should not be more protected from or less vulnerable to prosecution under this Bill than the individual who says something. One of the other things the Minister, or the next Minister, when coming back to address this, as is required under the Council framework directive, needs to look to is addressing the question of the amplification, including the commercial amplification, of expressions of racism and xenophobia, those who profit from and promote racism and xenophobia for financial interest. That is not solely about the individual who makes the expression; it is that person who profiteers from the amplification of it.

That needs to be addressed. It is part of the fundamental problem.

There was a discussion of inclusive and democratic participation and its importance. We need to look at that democratic participation and fair political criticism, which is important. Part of looking at that is ensuring that there is an inclusive public sphere in which people are not literally intimidated from participation in the public sphere, be it political or elsewhere, because of the simple fact of who they are, even before they open their mouths for what they say. All the people who are afraid they will be judged for what they say were spoken about. Simply stepping forward and existing in the public space may make them a target of hatred. That is a problem we need to address. It is one reason we need to tackle these issues.

The EU context has been mentioned. Sadly, there are concerns around some of the transposition in some other EU states. Ireland, rather than aligning with that, should look to avoid those mistakes. It is important that there is no equivalence between political criticism of a state and any other form of hatred. Explicitly, we need to make sure that the protection of the right to criticise any government or state and its actions is protected and that it is not falsely equivalised with any other issue. It is appropriate that denunciation of the crime of genocide or any other human rights crimes, or denial of them, should be addressed but it is also important that we have the right to critique any state and its actions. That must be maintained. This is not the end of the road on this discussion. We have a next stage to come. I hope that there is deep learning from this debate and these categories and that some of those important issues of power and context are better addressed.

Comment on this

Senator Higgins warned against creating fear around the existence of transgender people. I think that is a concern that everybody can share. Everybody should be against any creation of fear around transgender people. Senator McDowell, who spoke eloquently, put his finger on it when he said that the important word is "empathic". There is a different thing when we talk about the activity of trans activists and the implications of that activity for child protection, in particular, and for the protection of women's safety and privacy. That is a live issue in our society thanks to the ideology that has access to the Government and is not opposed by the Minister as long she goes with this controversial definition of "gender".

I would like to remind the Minister of something in passing. Some people here may be familiar with the crime novels of Michael Connelly and the character of Hieronymus Bosch, otherwise known as Harry Bosch. He has a phrase he resorts to in these novels: "Everyone counts or nobody counts". That expresses my concern about the exclusivity.

I endorse everything Senator McDowell has said about the capacity of the courts to take hatred into account in whatever form it manifests itself. It seems, having listened to what he said, that there is no actual substance in this Bill in terms of what it will change in practice other than one thing - the radical definition of "gender". I draw the Minister's attention to that because of what she said earlier about the lack of concern for protection. People are protected in the law as it stands if they are attacked, regardless of whatever category of person they are. As we heard, judges are in a position to take into account the particular circumstances, including hatred against a minority group. Let us not pretend it is a free-for-all against minorities in our society at the moment as far as crime goes. There are regular prosecutions, and rightfully so. We know the number of hate-related crimes. It is about 600 or 700 according to the last year's statistics from the Garda. They are a small percentage of the crime, criminality and attacks on persons that take place in our society. I think there were something like 22,000 assaults in 2022. The Government could stand accused of virtue signalling in relation to one category of crime where redress is available, including redress that takes account of a hate motive, and failing to do enough in relation to a vastly greater number of victims of crime and attack.

I draw the Minister's attention to my amendment No. 100 which, accepting the principle that there will be groups who will have particular protection in this area, is based on the idea that if the Government is going to do that, it should be as inclusive as possible. The amendment refers to "hatred towards a group of persons on account of the group being defined by reference to characteristics common to the group, whether age, communication difficulties, colour, disability, family connections, health, nationality, national status, [here are the key words] gender, gender identity or expression, ethnicity, political views or affiliation [that counts too], religion, race, sex characteristics or sexual orientation". That is what I have said in my amendment, and the Minister should acknowledge that I am not proposing the exclusion of people who have gender identity issues, however they express themselves.

I must draw the Minister's attention to the Criminal Justice (Victims of Crime) Act 2017, which gets it right. It refers to "gender" and "gender identity or expression" as a basis for victimising people. To make this controversy go away, all the Minister needs to do is say that she will think about this and she will make that change. I defy her to tell me - certainly, Senator Ward was not able to tell me on Newstalk today - how that would lessen in any way the protection she wants to give to people who may be victims of crime based on hatred towards their gender identity or expression. It is because she is redefining "gender" that she is doing a serious disservice. As the Minister knows, I have personal respect for her and her family, which will continue, but I must say in all seriousness - I am not grandstanding - that when she faces the electorate in a few weeks, she will not deserve the vote of any parent of schoolgoing children-----

Comment on this

That is not fair.

Comment on this

-----if she does not change this definition of gender. It is as serious as this - there is serious endangerment of children in our schools based around a gender politics.

Comment on this

Excuse me, that is quite a significant accusation to make. Earlier, there was reference to particular organisations and their engagement in school training.

Comment on this

That was not an accusation.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

He was offering a point of view.

Comment on this

It was a statement of opinion about the seriousness-----

Comment on this

He is personalising it.

Comment on this

-----of this issue. I assure those who might think that Senators McDowell and Keogan and I are standing up here for the good of our health because we found a kind of argument to make that it is a lot more serious than that. There is no rational basis for not separating gender and gender identity as two separate characteristic groups in the list of characteristics. Lesbian, gay and bisexual people want this separation. Let us be clear - it is the BeLonG To organisation, and nobody else, that wants to change the definition of "gender". It is its submission that the Minister has chosen to hear. It is an example of the groups - Senator McDowell mentioned TENI - that are pushing the idea of the gender spectrum, the idea that people may be neither male nor female. That attitude, that politics and that unscientific, non-evidence-based ideology is proving toxic to children not just in Ireland but all over the western world.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with the amendments, Chair.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator, please do not intervene.

Comment on this

That is why this issue-----

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Flynn is next to speak. She can have her say then.

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the amendments.

Comment on this

For the assistance of Senator Flynn, it relates to Senator Keogan's amendment.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I ask the Senator to give me the floor for a minute. At this stage, it would be easier for me sitting in the Chair if each Senator could reference the amendments they are speaking to. This is moving into a general discussion rather than speaking to the amendments. Will Senators from now on identify what amendment in the group they are speaking to?

Comment on this

I am speaking to amendment No. 9 from Senator Keogan, seconded by me. It was BeLonG To that wanted the change in this definition of "gender". This new definition of "gender" is about causing confusion in the law. It lays the basis for changes to other gender-related legislation. Nobody knows what the new definition means but it achieves a specific aim which is to create an oppression of those who stand by the gender binary.

I accept in the context of this Bill that it relates to this Bill, which has to do with hate offences. Senator McDowell showed all the other legislation that is being impacted. However, the Minister is setting down a precedent. I am about to call the Minister out on something. She said we need not worry; it is only about a Bill that has to do with hate offences. However, I have evidence that her thinking is otherwise. I want to refer to an email reply to Deputy Richard Bruton who brought a concern to the Minister from a constituent.

Comment on this

Is this on the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes, it relates to gender. Do not be afraid of ideas.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen, the debate-----

Comment on this

What is the Senator afraid of?

Comment on this

I am afraid that children will be harmed as a result of the ideology that is influencing the Government. Is é sin an rud atá ag déanamh buartha dom.

Comment on this

God help my two boys-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I remind Senator Mullen the debate is not about gender-----

Comment on this

The Minister's two boys are lucky to have great parents. Let us not bring that into it. There are many other vulnerable children in this country.

Comment on this
A Senator

This is getting very personal.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am happy to have assistance in chairing the proceedings. I remind Senator Mullen that this is not about gender.

Comment on this

It is. It is to Senator Keogan's amendment which relates to the definition of "gender" and I am following up on what Senator McDowell said and what everybody is talking about. This will not take long but it is very revealing.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Everybody needs to show respect to the Chair in terms of addressing their remarks through the Chair, and not to the Minister directly.

Comment on this

The Minister said to Senator Bruton, "as you will be aware, transgender and non-binary people, domestically and internationally, are unfortunately and increasingly targeted by hate crime offenders. The meaning of gender for the purposes of this legislation therefore has to recognise that offenders target individuals based on non-conforming gender identities like non-binary, in addition to binary gender identities such as male or female." That is not true because the distinctive terms "gender and gender identity or expression" could be used in order to address the concern there in the first line. The Minister goes on to say, "The hate crime Bill is concerned with offenders' behavior and not the victim's legal status etc." There no issue there. She goes on to say: "Inclusion of the broader meaning of gender in the Bill to include transgender and non-binary persons was on foot of recommendations from civil society organisations representing a vulnerable and minority group, including the coalition against hate crime, as part of the pre-legislative scrutiny process." She does not mention Belong To. We are talking here about activist groups that have had access to the ear of the Government. The Government has not, in the 15 months or so since the Second Stage-----

Comment on this

It is not groups; it is organisations.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is that a point of order?

Comment on this

Yes, there are 23 representative organisations behind this.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

What is the point of order? Senator might stand up, thank you.

Comment on this

To ensure that everybody knows, the collective group against hate crime is made up of LGBTQI+ organisations as well and-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is not a point of order but thank you.

Comment on this

Adam Long, who is a gay man, is actually in the room. I want to make that point of order.

Comment on this

Everybody is welcome to this. However, as I said during the surrogacy legislation, it would be a sad day if we had to exclude certain points that we are making here as elected representatives because of who might be sitting in the Public Gallery. Everybody deserves respect but those in the Public Gallery are here to listen to what the parliamentarians have to say, not the other way around. We hear them when they are lobbying and then we come in to legislate, if we get a chance.

My point is that the Government has not been consulting. The Minister may correct me if I am wrong but I saw a report in recent days that, when asked about what she was going to do on the gender definition, she said we will wait to see what is brought in. The Minister may correct me if she did not say that. Clearly, to my knowledge at least, she has made no attempt to deal with any of the people who expressed concerns in this Chamber on Second Stage about the problem with the gender issue.

On that occasion, I did not mention the 2017 victim of crimes Act and the distinction between gender and gender identity and expression. I do not know whether the Minister had a chance to give that consideration. Having regard to what Senator McDowell was saying, she should take that on board and say that there is a precedent here that we can use without victimising anybody. In that way, a great deal of controversy is removed and the concerns of parents are allayed because this stuff influences what is going to happen in schools. This is the next point I want to make to illustrate why that is the case.

The short email to Deputy Bruton concludes by stating, "An Garda Síochána's diversity and integration strategy and PULSE systems contain similar concepts of gender in its discriminatory motives. We cannot be in a situation whereby, operationally, the Garda has a wide, so-called progressive" - I am saying "so-called" - "understanding of a concept such as gender but the legislation dealing with offences against a protected group of persons is far more restrictive." What the Minister is saying is that because the Garda has chosen to be expansive about what gender means and to confuse gender expression and identity which is subjective, somehow the law must follow. It is supposed to be the other way around. The Legislature is supposed to set the rules and the Garda is supposed to implement the law.

The Minister also mentioned, by the way, that the Garda says it is necessary. I would be grateful for her help on that matter. Where has it been said by the Garda that this definition of gender is necessary in the law? It is for the legislature, for Oireachtas Éireann, to set the tone for what the Garda must do and must implement.

Here is the giveaway. The Minister says that this has nothing to do with other pieces of legislation. She says, "Following a review of the Equality Act that is currently being undertaken by the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth, definitions used in the Bill may be reconsidered to ensure consistency in definitions across the Statute Book." To me, this sounds as though the Minister is saying, "Yes, we intend to revisit all these definitions of gender across the Statute Book." It sounds as though she is admitting there that she is laying the groundwork for this and this is the first shot of the gun. The Minister cannot tell us here that there is nothing to see here, that this only applies to this legislation, when she is telling people in her own party that this is part of a wider revisiting of the meaning of gender. Correct me if I am wrong but that has blown the gaff on her. The concern people have is that there is this agenda going on. We saw this in the referendums as well. The Minister mentioned the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth. We had the same problem in the referendums with ideological language leading to a badly-worded amendment that was roundly rejected by the people. That ideological language was rooted in this agenda to redefine gender.

If gender is redefined, this puts pressure on the system. It puts pressure on the curriculum. It bolsters those who want to imbue in children from an early age that if they are not comfortable in their gender identity that they may actually be a different gender. That has many medical professionals worried. The Minister knows about the controversies in relation to puberty blockers-----

Comment on this

That is way off the topic.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Flynn, it is not off the topic. To be fair, Senator Mullen, despite Senator Flynn's views, is entitled to his view. I ask all Members to allow people to speak without interruption. Senator Flynn will get a chance to speak next. I am conscious that we are due to conclude at 8.30 p.m. I ask Members to stick to the relevance of the amendments that are discussing please.

Comment on this

I am near the end of my comments to the Minister. In its submission, which I do not have to hand, it was Belong To that sought this new expansive definition of gender. It wants to replace the binary with the spectrum and wants to harness all laws built around the binary to apply to the spectrum. That, as I said, is the work that was going on in the background with regard to the equality Acts by the Minister for Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth, the same ministry that was so misleading on the referendums. I am reminded of the phrase, "Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me".

There is controversy between LGB and trans activists about gender identity, its impact on women's security, women's spaces, lesbians and so on.

That is real, but the possible implications of this on child protection should be at the top of our tree of concern. That is my sincere concern. The Minister, Senator Ward and others may think I am mistaken, but many people do not think so. Many people wonder why the hell this strange new definition of gender is being smuggled in with this Bill, under the cloak of having listened to objections and having taken out whole swathes of the Bill that actually had merit. We have the worst of both worlds in a sense. We are getting nothing new on incitement to violence or hatred to update the law on the matter in the way Senator McDowell rightly said is desirable and necessary.

There are two views on how the 1989 legislation might work. I am happy to accept and support amendments at any stage that make sure that what applies to what people do in mainstream and traditional media would also apply to combatting hatred in the digital online space. However, we are not getting that because the Minister has taken that away, but she has left in a toxic definition of gender. There is no reason for her to have done that other than that the Government is caving in to an element in the Government or to certain NGOs, which I have named, who have a highly politicised view of gender. This is not about protecting people from being assaulted in the streets at all. It is about mainstreaming an idea that people are not born male or female, but rather as a combination of genders, no gender or somewhere on that new spectrum that is having a negative impact on children who encounter this ideology. You only have to ask some of the medical professionals who have been vocal in recent times about how we need to move much more carefully and more slowly on this. That is why I am on the record as saying that school boards of management need to do a risk assessment from a child protection point of view on aspects of the social, personal and health education, SPHE, curriculum. The Minister needs to do a risk assessment of this definition of gender. It lays the groundwork. It is not evidence based. It inappropriately conflates the reality of one's gender, be it male or female, and one's gender expression or identity which may vary according to the person.

Everyone deserves respect and empathy and all these people deserve to be protected against crimes motivated by hatred against them individually or as a group. The Minister has the solution to the problem. It was offered to her here, to accept a new definition of gender or at least to split, in whatever way she chooses - she has the time to do it if she wishes - gender from gender identity and expression. In so doing, following the precedent of the 2017 legislation, she will have solved the problem. She will get rid of this definition of gender and make it clear. Everything would be covered by the word "gender". People know what it is: male and female, including people availing of a preferred gender under the 2015 legislation, and everyone else under the sun who has a gender identity or expression issue and deserves the protection the Minister wants for them can be covered by using that phrase. The problem is solved.

If the Minister does not accept that solution to the problem, no one can be fooled, but that there is an ideological reason. Perhaps the Minister does not personally subscribe to it, but it has her in its grip because she is a member of a Government that has chosen to cave in to it. That has child protection implications, I have to tell her sincerely and in all honesty. That is why I say the Minister and her Government colleagues must be answerable to the electorate if they take a risk on this when they do not need to. The novelty in this is coming from the Minister and the rest of the Government. We have law that distinguishes gender and gender identity and expression. We have precedents in legislation that extend protection in this area to include all people. Why not go for it?

Comment on this

We have spent more than two hours making fun and games of a very important Bill for people from minority groups, including transgender people. We are saying "transgender issues". Transgender people do not have issues. The issue is society and people who are anti-trans. It is very sad to see public representatives using this platform - the Houses of the Oireachtas - to spread lies and misinformation.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator should not use that language and she should withdraw it.

Comment on this

Okay, I will withdraw it. Misinformation is being spread when we could have focused on education elements of the Bill.

It is regrettable that the Government will not accept our amendment - due to a charge on the Exchequer - around education for people in fourth year in secondary schools on what a hate crime and hate speech are. When we know better, we do better and prevention is better than intervention. My colleagues, Senators Ward and Higgins, and I do not want to tell people they have committed a hate crime and lock them up. It is about education and learning from one another within Irish society. I will put my hands up and say this legislation is not ideal and we could do more on definitions and so forth.

I want people to be aware that the part on hate speech has been removed from the Bill. Even though some people spent hours talking about hate speech in the Chamber this evening, hate speech has been removed from the Bill. Section 29 deals with social media and multitech companies. I have been a victim many times of hate crime on social media where I have been called names because of my identity. I was spat at walking down the street almost two years ago, not because I am a politician, but because of my identity. There are no protections for people from the Traveller community, people of colour or transgender people in Irish society. Therefore, a half loaf of bread is better than no loaf of bread. This is not ideal legislation and it needs a lot more work, but as I said earlier, I welcome it.

On the fun and games, when we have guests in the Public Gallery who represent organisations and they are being insulted, it is not fair. While I am a proud Member of this House, it makes me a little bit disappointed in the behaviour of some of our Senators. It is regrettable that Senator Higgins and I could not speak on our amendments on the definition and education. The Coalition Against Hate Crime has asked for a report on whether this legislation is working and to have adequate information on the impact of hate crime in our society.

It has to be proved. It is like any other crime; it must be proved that a crime was a hate crime, motivated by hatred. Everyone knows that. I want to put people at ease about this legislation, that it is not just that people will be told they committed a hate crime. As the Minister said and anyone can read in the Bill, it has to be proved that a person committed a hate crime. I do not want people to be scared.

As a mother of two little girls, I absolutely welcome as much education as possible in our education system around gender. To use children as a weapon, as has been done in this House this evening, is absolutely appalling. I say that as a mother of two children. I am a member of the Traveller community. We have different cultural beliefs than people from the general population. Still, within our community there are a lot of barriers for Traveller women.

Traveller women rarely speak openly about issues that impact them - menopause, CervicalCheck, etc. We still tend to keep many things private in the Traveller community. We are a very Catholic, religious community.

I say as a Traveller mother of two children that I welcome education of our children in schools and regret Senator Mullen using a lot of his time to speak about how we are educating our children. Education is the key for our kids and we have to keep embedding education in our children. So what if we are talking about stuff that is not very comfortable in a Catholic sense or in the sense of the Traveller community? I will include my own community as well. It is important we educate our children. What these people are making out-----

Comment on this

Excuse me, I am speaking. What these people are making out-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senators, sorry. Can we just-----

Comment on this

Just let me make my last point and I will finish then.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Sure. That is perfect. Thank you.

Comment on this

What these people are making out in the Chamber this evening is that we are looking to brainwash. We have seen the protests against our libraries and stoking up hatred over the last few months. It is an absolute sin that public representatives can come in here for two hours, waste everyone's time and make a mockery of an important piece of legislation.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

In fairness, no matter one's political viewpoint on a Bill, a Member of the House is entitled to come in and express and articulate that viewpoint, no matter who that Member is.

I will call the Minister because she has not spoken yet. Senator Keogan had 46 minutes when I was in the Chair earlier.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

You did, yes - uninterrupted nearly.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

If there is time, I will bring you back in after the Minister.

Comment on this

Thank you very much.

Comment on this

I am trying to gather my thoughts. Again I need to go back to what we are trying to achieve. What is the objective of the legislation? This is not a gender recognition Bill. The pages and pages Senator Keogan read from whoever sent them to her could perhaps be kept for a gender recognition (amendment) Bill. It has no relevance to what we are talking about. I will never apologise for wanting to make sure that in our law people who are a minority, are victimised or are most vulnerable are protected, recognised and acknowledged, and if they are victims of a criminal act, that is recognised too. This is not, as Senator McDowell said, tinkering around the edges for effect. That is a huge insult to anybody who has been victim of a hate crime or physically assaulted because of the colour of their skin, who they identity as, where they come from or what religion they are. It is an insult to say we are tinkering around the edges for the sake of it. We are saying clearly that if a person commits a crime against another person simply because of who they are, we will acknowledge it and make sure the person who perpetrates it faces a harsher sentence. We are the only country across Europe and the western world that does not have this law.

In terms of the definition, it is not that we are sheep and following everybody. There is a reason nobody else defines the word "hate". In the UK, it is "hatred"; it is the ordinary meaning. In Northern Ireland law, it is "hatred"; it is the ordinary meaning. In German law, it is "hatred"; it is the ordinary meaning. In Spanish law, it is "hatred"; it is the ordinary meaning. In our existing law from 1989, it is "hatred"; it is the ordinary meaning. In EU law, it is "hatred"; it is the ordinary meaning. If we introduce a law, we need to make sure it is effective. Can anybody tell me "opprobrium", "enmity" or "detestation" is easier to explain or prove in a court of law than "hatred"? We all know what "hatred" means. It is the examples I gave earlier. A gang of males threatened to assault a gay man, made homophobic slurs and threatened to kill him. Gardaí attended the location but the suspects were gone on arrival. That is hatred of a person because of who they are. A female was on the way to a market with two friends and was physically attacked by a man who threw his body at her with all his strength. The female asked what was happening and he began insulting her, saying she was nothing more than a trans. He repeated several times that she was nothing more than a man. On 8 August 2023, a transgender person was with a group of friends when a group of three to five individuals began intimidating that person. The person attempted to evade them and was pursued, punched three times in the face and pushed to the ground. I challenge anybody to say that is not hatred. It is understood by our courts, our gardaí and the DPP. It is how it is currently in law and that is why we are keeping the definition as it currently stands.

In terms of gender, this is not a back door into anything. This is specific to this legislation. It has been made clear that the LGBTQI community in Ireland and across the world is more at risk of harm. I will speak to a 2024 report. Being LGBTQI+ in Ireland is a research project involving over 2,800 LGBTQI+ people, aimed at examining the mental health and well-being of those people in the Republic of Ireland and investigating public attitudes towards LGBTQI+ people. It was carried out by a group of researchers led by Professor Agnes Higgins of Trinity College in collaboration with Belong To. Key findings of the study indicate mental health and well-being have declined among the population since 2016, with significant challenges experienced by younger age groups and transgender and gender non-conforming communities. We do not need to define that: "gender non-conforming communities". The study finds LGBTQI+ people in Ireland continue to face high levels of self-harm and suicidality, with increased levels of depression, anxiety and stress. It is particularly upsetting concerning two cohorts: under-25s and trans individuals. They face more stigma, isolation and discrimination in society than other cohorts. As a result, they have worse mental health outcomes than peers. It finds they face higher levels of harassment and violence. These are people; this is not an ideology or a theoretical debate or discussion. These are people in our country who are feeling vulnerable. The legislation is being put in place to recognise that and say that if you are targeted because you do not conform to what other people think you should conform to, we will protect you insofar as is possible and we will recognise that crime. We are not trying to change anything else. The definition as it refers to the various Criminal Law Acts is specific to the hate crime Act.

For those saying they support transgender people or those who are non-conforming and have shown such support - yes, Senators Mullen and Keogan have tabled amendments Nos. 100, 106, 113, 114 and 132, and they refer to gender expression and identity, but they also include a number of other elements that will never be accepted: health, communications difficulties, political ideologies. They put such references in those amendments, knowing they will never be accepted. Every other amendment they or Senator McDowell have tabled either removes gender completely, leaving no protection for somebody who is transgender, non-binary or non-conforming, or else clearly removes the protection they say they have for people. I have not heard them say a single thing in relation to transgender, non-binary or non-gender-conforming people that shows they support or protect them. Instead, they talk about child protection issues and protecting women.

Comment on this

What about the 2017 Act? I gave the Minister a way out.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the definition here? I genuinely do not understand what people are concerned about.

Comment on this

It redefines gender.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Sorry, Senator Mullen. The Minister without interruption, please. Thank you.

Comment on this

It redefines gender. That is what is wrong with it. The Minister does not need to do it.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Sorry, Senator Mullen, you had-----

Comment on this

The Minister asked me a question.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

She did not ask you a question.

Comment on this

She asked what is wrong-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen, please.

Comment on this

She looked at me.

Comment on this

Sorry, I will talk through the Chair.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister without interruption, please.

Comment on this

We are trying to set out a gender definition that ensures nobody is left out. We are making sure those who are most vulnerable are protected under this legislation. It is for the purpose of this legislation. The various-----

Comment on this

You are leaving out-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen, please stop.

Comment on this

Various Bills are amended, whether with regard to assault; non-fatal offences against the person; assault causing harm; assault causing serious harm; threats to kill; coercion; harassment; endangerment; damaging property; threatening, abusive or insulting behaviour; distribution or display in a public place of material which is threatening, abusive or insulting; entering a building with an intent to commit an offence; or assault with intent to cause harm.

The changes are for the purpose of this legislation. We are talking about hate crimes. We are talking about people who are physically being assaulted, who are being victimised, who are the victims of crime because of who they are. The characteristics that we have chosen will make sure that those who are most vulnerable, based on the facts and the evidence that we have, are protected under this legislation. That is the objective here.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It has now reached the time of 8.30 p.m.

Comment on this

Chair, we asked for an extension.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senators may ask for an extension but it is not in my gift to give it because the House has already voted on the Order of Business today.

As it is now 8.30 p.m. I am required to put the following question in accordance with the Order of the Seanad of this day: "That amendment No. 2 is hereby agreed to in Committee; the Government amendments undisposed of are hereby made to the Bill; in respect of each of the sections undisposed of, other than sections 4, 6 to 16, inclusive, and 29, which are hereby deleted, the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to in Committee; the Schedule is hereby deleted in Committee; the Title, as amended, is hereby agreed to in Committee; the Bill, as amended, is accordingly reported to the House; Fourth Stage is hereby completed; the Bill is hereby received for final consideration; and the Bill is hereby passed." Is that agreed?

Comment on this

It is not agreed. It is shameful.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will the Senators claiming a division please rise?

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

As fewer than five Members have risen, I declare the question carried. In accordance with Standing Order 61, the names of the Senators dissenting will be recorded in the Official Report and the Journal of the Proceedings of the Seanad.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I welcome Sheena Burke to the Public Gallery. She gave many great years’ service in Leinster House. Sheena is welcome. It is good to see her again and her friend who is accompanying her. Céad míle fáilte.

I ask the Leader when is it proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

At 9.30 a.m. tomorrow.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this